HomeMy WebLinkAboutSDP 2022-0018; 725 ARBUCKLE; HISTORICAL STUDY; 2023-05-05State of California -The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREA TlON
PRlMARY RECORD
Other Listings
Primary#
Trinomial
HRI #
NRHP Status Code
Review Code Reviewer
1
Date
Page 1 of 25 *Resource Name or#: 725 Arbuckle Pl APN#: 203-110-20-00
P1. Other Identifier: 725 Arbuckle Pl
*P2. Location: □ Not for Publication ■ Unrestricted *a. County: San Diego
and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a Location Map as necessary.)
*b. USGS 7.5' Quad: Date: T : R 1/, of ¼ of Sec
M.D. 8.M.
c. Address: 725 Arbuckle Pl City: San Diego Zip: 92008
d. UTM: Zone: , mE/ mN (G.P.S.) 33.16347, -117.34838
e. Other Locational Data: (e.g., parcel#, directions to resource, elevation, etc., as appropriate)
*P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements. Include design, materials, condition, alterations, size,
setting, and boundaries).
Architectural Description.
This house was most likely originally designed in the craftsman style. The single-story home was built in 1928 as seen
on the Residential Building Record. The property includes a prefabricated barn back house as well as a garage that
has since been extended that was likely constructed after the original house structure. Changes to the home are
extensive and include a series of additions, enclosure of the original front porch, resurfaced siding, and encased eaves.
Eave fascia boards are visible around various parts of the house where additions were built, which displays the different
periods of additions. The wood siding on some sections of the house was resurfaced sometime in the 1940's or 50's
and that 1950's transite now covers the original masonry and horizontal wood siding. The windows that originally stood
proud are now flushed by the protruding siding that was built around them. The exposed eaves, a defining feature of
the craftsman style, were encased.
*P3b. Resource Attributes: (List attributes and codes} Single-family residence
*P4. Resources Present: ■Building □Structure □Object □Site □District Element□ of District Other□
*P9. Date Recorded: May 5, 2023
DDDDDDDDDDP5b. Description of Photo:
(View, date, accession#)
0 0 0 0 DD ODD D Photo of front of house facing
southwest. Taken May 5, 2023 by Steph
LeBlanc
DDDDOOOOOO•ps, Date Constructed/Age and
Sources:
□■ 000000000Historic Prehistoric Both
*P7. Owner and Address:
Angela Klein
725 Arbuckle Place
Carlsbad, CA 92008 OCT 11 2a23
*P10. Survey Type: (Describe) Preliminary Resource Review
*P11. Report Citation: (Cite survey report and other sources, or enter "none.") None
Preliminary historic review of 725 Arbuckle Pl, San Diego, California, for the City of San Diego, Historical Resources
Board, by Steph LeBlanc
*Attachments:□ ■Location Map lsketch Map □Continuation Sheet ■Building, Structure, and Object Record D
Archaeological Record □District Record □Linear Feature Record □Milling Station Record □Rock Art Record □
Artifact Record □Photograph Record □ Other (List):
2
State of California -The Resources Agency Primary# _____________ _
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # _____________ _
BUILDING, STRUCTURE. AND OBJECT RECORD
Page 2 of 25 *Resource Name or#: 725 Arbuckle Pt
*Recorded by: Kiley Wallace & Steph LeBlanc *Date: May 5, 2023 !SJ Continuation D Update
*P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements. Include design, materials, condition,
alterations, size, setting, and boundaries) (Continued): (See Attachment D, Photographs)
The home's style appears to be in the craftsman architectural style with several critical additions and
alterations over time. The central section of the house, which includes the main living area, the kitchen, and
a bathroom, is likely the only remaining original portion of the structure. There is an entrance to the east
side of the north fai;:ade with a large window to the west. As seen in analysis of historic photos and the
residential building record (attached), that entryway and window were once an open porch, a characteristic
feature of craftsman design. The porch was enclosed some time following the residential building record
photographs from 1971. On the east fa<;:ade of the house, there is a visible change from the enclosed porch
area to what might be the only remaining original exterior of the house. The original construction could be
characterized by horizontal wooden paneling over a masonry foundation. At some point, many sections of
the house were faced with transite meant to imitate the appearance of large wooden shingles. Rounding
the corner to the original section of the house on the east side, the transitive materials in one area were
broken and horizontal wooden paneling is visible underneath.
The south fac;:ade of the house shows an additional doorway that appears to have been of the original
structure. To the west on the south fac;:ade, an addition that connects to the bedroom addition is apparent
from examining the vergeboard that remains from the original footprint of the gable roof. Where the two
additions meet on the west fac;:ade, the siding returns from horizontal wood that is meant to imitate the
original facade converges with the transite siding on the bedroom addition. The west facade was
constructed less than two feet from the garage, displaying their varying dates of construction.
On the north facade, the section of the house to the east can be distinguished from an addition to the west
by the varying roof gables and !ack of material continuity. The additional bedroom that was later built to the
west is faced with transite meant to imitate the appearance of large wooden shingles.
Each side of the house is composed of varying surface materials, sloppily combining original horizontal
wooden paneling, imitation horizontal wooden paneling of a different width, and large transite shingles. The
convergence of these stylistic elements both falsely imitate original construction practices and create a lack
of continuity between alterations.
Craftsman Style. The Craftsman style, also sometimes referred to as the American Arts and Crafts style,
became popular in the early 1900's from about 1905-1930, especially in California. While the style shared
an appreciation of hand craftsmanship and organic detailing with its European counterpart The style is
usually differentiated from the English Arts and Crafts style (which highly influenced it) by its extensive use
of wood, low pitched rooflines, and sometimes Asian inspiration. The American version grew to become an
independent western movement in American architecture and quickly spread nationwide by way of
magazines and plan pattern books.
Many important architects and designers of the style, like Pasadena architects Greene and Greene, and
designer and furniture maker Gustav Stickley, showed their appreciation of natural materials like wood, tile,
brick and stone while utilizing human craftsmanship to create designs in direct opposition to the mass
production and machine made designs of the recent Industrial Revolution. Craftsman style homes often
used natural earth-tone colors. Wooden details were very important In the creation of Craftsman homes
which usually included built in wooden furniture, doors and stairs in the same highly detailed natural wood
aesthetic.
State of California -The Resources Agency Primary # _____________ _
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS ANO RECREATION HRI #==~=~----------
BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD
3
Page 3 of 25 *Resource Name or#: 725 Arbuckle Pl
*Recorded by: Kiley Wallace & Steph LeBlanc *Date: May 5, 2023 ~ Continuation D Update
*P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements. Include design, materials, condition,
alterations, size, setting, and boundaries) (Continued): (See Attachment D, Photographs)
The following are architectural changes that cause architectural integrity loss:
• Material change. The house was resurfaced with a material that was meant to look like wooden
shingles. This alteration detracts from the fundamental wooden material elements that are
characteristic of the Craftsman style.
• Front porch enctosure. Open front porches are essential elements to the Craftsman style.
• Eave encasement. A crucial element of the Craftsman style is open eaves. Encasing them
diminishes the integrity of the previous design of the house.
• Window flushing. When the exterior of the house was resurfaced, the new material protruded from
the original wooden shingles and encroaches on windows that would normally stand proud.
• Series of additions. The western section of the house, garage, and ADU were all later additions
that attempt to mimic the architectural design of the original house, but instead draw from the
historic integrity of the property.
State of California_ The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
CONTINUATION SHEET
Primary#
HRI#
Trinomial
Page 4 of 25 *Resource Name or#: 725 Arbuckle Pl
*Recorded by: Kiley Wallace & Steph LeBlanc *Date: May 5, 2023 1:8] Continuation D Update
B1. Historic Name: 725 Arbuckle Pl 82. Common Name: 725 Arbuckle Pl
83. Original Use: Single-family residence
84. Present Use: Single-family residence
*B5. Architectural Style: Craftsman
*B6. Construction History: (Construction date, alterations, and date of alterations)
Construction date. The subject resource is a residential home constructed
Additions and alterations. The multiple extensions, additions, and alterations to the home's integrity compromise
the characteristis of a typical craftsman design and leave an inconsistent jumbled collection of construction.
*87. Moved? ■No □Yes □Unknown Date:
*88. Related Features:
89a. Architect:
*810. Significance: none Theme: Residential architecture
Original Location:
b. Builder:
Area:
Period of Significance: 1920's Property Type: Residential Applicable Criteria: None
4
(Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope.
Also address integrity.)
*B10. Significance: Criterion A.
Criterion A: Exemplifies or reflects special elements of the City's. a community's, or a neighborhood's historical,
archaeological, cultural, social, economic, political, aesthetic, engineering, landscaping or architectural development.
725 Arbuckle Place was not found to rise to the level of exemplifying special elements of the community's
historical, archaeological, cultural, social, economic, political, aesthetic, engineering, landscaping or
architectural development. No Information came to light to determine that the resource rose to a level of
significance to quaUfy for designation under Criterion A. The following information provides the background
for that conclusion.
1920s Carlsbad: Building Foundations
Carlsbad in the 1920s was a town setting its foundations. With an emerging sense of community, institutions like
churches, theaters, and newspapers began taking root. Sally Troutman and Marion Holmes spearheaded a Sunday
school in 1922, evolving into the Carlsbad Union Church. Another milestone was the Carlsbad Theater's inauguration
in 1927, with its murals encapsulating the region's essence. Religious establishments such as Saint Patrick's Mission
Church and Adventist Christian Church also emerged. The Carlsbad Champion newspaper, launched in 1925,
chronicled the town's life. But challenges came too-fires ravaged businesses, and the 1929stock market crash loomed
large. Despite this, the California Carlsbad Mineral Spring Hotel was unveiled in 1930, adding a touch of luxury.
1930s: Facing the Depression
The 1930s painted a contrasting picture. The economic depression touched Carlsbad, leading to the First National
Bank's closure. While many novice farmers, lured by the Avocado Day Festival, failed, seasoned ones survived despite
challenges. Government programs, like the Works Progress Administration, provided relief, resulting in infrastructural
improvements. The Army and Navy Academy's relocation in 1936 bolstered the economy. Signs of revival were evident
by the decade's end, highlighted by W. C. Garrett's floral ventures attracting attention.
1940s: War and Transformation
World War II cast a shadow over the 1940s. The loss of local heroes like Lee Ruse during Pearl Harbor deeply affected
Carlsbad. Camp Pendleton's establishment in 1942 significantly impacted the economy, causing a housing boom.
Carlsbad actively supported the war effort, with the Carlsbad Hotel serving recovering soldiers and local areas utilized
for military needs, Hollywood's influence grew, with Bing Crosby's Carlsbad Properties leading to the Royal Palms
Hotel's construction emnhasizina Carlsbad's shift to tourism
State of California _ The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
CONTINUATION SHEET
Page 5 of 25 *Resource Name or#: 725 Arbuckle Pl
Primary#
HRI#
Trinomial
*Recorded by: Kiley Wallace & Steph leBlanc *Date: May 5, 2023 Continuation Update
Post-War Era: Towards Independence
5
The post~war period saw Carlsbad's economic boom. But growth brought challenges-strained resources and
dissatisfaction with San Diego County's governance. The Chamber of Commerce, initially Carlsbad's informal
governing body, found it challenging to manage rising civic responsibilities. Key events, such as San Diego Gas and
Electric's decision to establish a power plant in 1948 and a devastating house fire in 1952, highlighted the town's needs.
These challenges combined with potential revenue sources and community sentiments catalyzed Carlsbad's push for
cityhood and autonomy.
Conclusion: The 1928 residential home does not sufficiently reflect the city's early development and was not
found to qualify under Criterion A. The structure does not reflect special elements of the city's development to
a greater extent than other typical structures of this era. Insufficient information was found to determine the
subject home qualifies under Criterion A.
Criterion B. No significant associations or connections with historical persons were found. An occupancy list and
biography of owners and builders is provided. Insufficient information was found to determine the subject
structure qualifies under Criterion 8.
Criterion C. The home does not represent a good examp!e of the craftsman style due to lack of original integrity
and material continuity. The home is not Significant under Criterion C and fails to embody the Craftsman architectural
style due to a series of alterations, additions, and material change.
Criterion D. The building is not under Criterion Das representative of the notable work of an architect. No architect
has been notably identified and is therefore not likely to be a recognized Master Architect or Master Builder. This
home would not qualify it's builder to be considered as a Master Architect or Master Builder.
B 11. Additional Resource Attributes: (List attributes and codes): None
*812. References: see attached works cited
B 13. Remarks: none
*B14. Evaluator: Steph LeBlanc
*Date of Evaluation: May 2023
(This space reserved for official comments.)
State of California _ The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
CONTINUATION SHEET
Page 6 of 25 *Resource Name or#: 725 Arbuckle Pl
Primary#
HRI#
Trinomial
*Recorded by: Kiley Wallace & Steph LeBlanc *Date: !Z] Continuation O Update
*P3a. Criterion C -Integrity Analysis. The home overall displays poor architectural integrity due to a
series of alterations and additions. The modifications to the home are extensive and include additions in
(dates). The changes have made a substantial and critical impact on the building's integrity as it relates to
the 1928 of construction and period of significance.
The extent and cumulative effect of the additions and alterations on the home's integrity is grave and
alters every critical character defining feature of the home's presumed original craftsman style. The
alterations greatly impact the design, materials, workmanship, feeling and association aspects of integrity,
leaving only the home's original integrity of setting relatively intact.
In addition, many of these alterations are readily visible and broadly mimic the materials and architectural
detailing of the original home. For example, the exterior was resurfaced to mimic wooden shingles that
would be key characteristics of a quintessential craftsman design, but now detracts from the historic integrity
of the house with its material change. These additions and alterations are not consistent with the U.S.
Secretary of the Interior Standards and overall create a false sense of history.
The building therefore fails to qualify under Criterion C due to the lack of original architectural
integrity. This lack of integrity is due to extensive changes to all character defining features creating
a false sense of history. The home fails to convey architectural significance or sufficient original
architectural integrity to be considered for historic designation.
*P3a. Criterion D -Work of a Master Architect. The subject home fails to qualify under Criterion D as
the notable work of a Master Architect or Builder. No architect has been notably identified and is therefore
not likely to be a recognized Master Architect or Master Builder. Furthermore, this home does not represent
his work due to its extensive changes and alterations. Even if the work was performed by an established
Master Architect, the home as we see it today does not reflect the original design of that work and
the extensive alterations shows the home does not sufficiently reflect its original architectural
design for consideration under Criterion D.
Attachment A
Building Information
A. 1 Residential Building Record
!-.. (;01:J!ilY .U~E,.~OA
$A-Ill 01~GO"CO-CA1,.IF0ANIA
A--J~
n..,i.. ' • "R
1/H iDH ...
' " • ~-· I -··--~-·~ , ,_., ·-,w.,:..,, -· -~
RESIDENTIAL BUILOING.RECORD
... , ..... . -.. .
7.1:s
-,.
/< ,.,.,..·-~
' ""''' ' CONSTRUCTIONRECOffD
ff.C.L-/lO
•-11 8-H
.... .,-,/,f()-' ~
/~J'. ,;t,b
.,, /t:11
/,S,
,
-
,o.
•
,-
A.3 Site Plan with Footprint
...,.,.:;.,,,_
-. ,
, .. .
'
<o
.)
• ' ,., • '
7
"'" /,trtlf/011 ,ilf/lH
"""' c..-_'!., P. ' -
UEt:IAL ,~ATUflH ,,,.,.,.,.
""--··--
• •
8
Taken from Residential Building Record (1971)
9
Attachment B
Ownership and Occupant Information
8.1 -Chain of Title
8.2 -Directory Search of Occupants
B.1 Chain of Title
Through the research of this house, its historic elements. documentation, and past occupants, a Chain of
Title was not considered necessary to determine the historic integrity of this house. It was determined that
if any association existed to a historically significant person that the home no longer retains sufficient
architectural integrity for the time period of that associated person.
B.2 Directory Search of Occupants
1928 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1929-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1930-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1931 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1932-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1933 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1934-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1935 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1936 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1937 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1938 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1939 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1940 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1941 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1942-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1943 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Rub)' Milholland (Housewife)
1944 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1945 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1946 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1947 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1948 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1949-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1950 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
Otillia Carpenter (Mother in Law)
1951 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1952-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1953 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1954-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1955 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1956-Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1957 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1958 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1959 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1960 -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
196! -Bert Milholland (Laborer) & Ruby Milholland (Housewife)
1962 -Unknown
1963 -Unknown
1964 -Unknown
1965 -Unknown
1966 -Unknown
1967 -Unknown
1968 -Unknown
1969 -Unknown
1970-Unknown
1971 -Unknown
1972 -Patrick J Manifesta
1973 -Patrick J Manifesta
1974 -Patrick J Manifesta
1975 -Patrick J Manifesta
1976 -Patrick J Manifesta
1977 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1978 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1979 -Tara D. Tauriainen; Leslie Ann Landreth: Patrick J Manifesta
1980 -Jake R Tauriainen; Leslie Ann Landreth: Patrick J Manifesta
1981 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1982 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1983 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1984 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1985 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1986 -Leslie Ann Landreth: Patrick J Manifesta
Mary Kapsalis
1987 -Leslie Ann Landreth; Patrick J Manifesta
1988 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth: Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses: Patrick J
Manifesta
1989 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta
! 990 -Richard S Landreth: Leslie Ann Landreth: Ricky Leo Defosses: Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta
1991 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta
1992 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta
1993 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses: Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta
1994 -Contruction Landreth; Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina
Alba Defosses; Patrick J Manifesta
! 995 -Leslie A Landreth; Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth: Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba
11
Defosses; Patrick J Manifesta
1996 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Arm Landreth: Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta
1997 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta
1998 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Patrick J
Manifesta; Paul Clement Manifesta
1999 -Richard S Landreth; Leslie Ann Landreth; Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Paul
Clement Manifesta
2000-Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Paul Clement Manifesta
2001 -Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses; Paul Clement Manifesta
2002 -Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses;
2003 -Ricky Leo Defosses; Sabrina Alba Defosses
2004 -Dean Mack; Ricky Leo Defosses; Tara D Tauriainen; Jake Richard Tauriainen
2005 -Sarah J Njaa (Second Residence); Sierra Brie Pitts; Tara D Tauriainen; Sonia Y Ruiz; Jake
Richard Tauriainen
2006 -Tara D Tauriainen; Sonia Y Ruiz; Jake Richard Tauriainen
2007 -Jessica J Ruiz (Third Residence); Tara D Tauriainen; Sonia Y Ruiz
2008 -Jessica J Ruiz (Third Residence); Tara D Tauriainen; Sonia Y Ruiz
2009 -Jessica J Ruiz (Third Residence); Tara D Tauriainen; Sonia Y Ruiz
20 IO -Jessica J Ruiz (Third Residence); Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; Tara D Tauriainen; Sonia Y Ruiz
2011 -Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; Tara D Tauriainen
2012-Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; Beatrice Virginia Robinson; John P Robinson
2013 -Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; John P Robinson
2014 -Connor Robinson; Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; John P Robinson
2015 -Connor Robinson; Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; John P Robinson
2016-Connor Robinson; Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; John P Robinson
2017 -Connor Robinson; Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; John P Robinson
2018-Connor Robinson; Gwen E!iz.abeth Robinson; John P Robinson
2019. -Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; John P Robinson
2020 -Gwen Elizabeth Robinson; John P Robinson
Attachment C
Maps
C.1 -Historic Maps
C.1 Historic Maps -
US Department of Interior Geological Survey Map ( 1949) -Arbuckle Pl. outlined in blue
Map from Carlsbad Historic Resources Survey (1990) -Property outlined in red
12
Attachment D
Photographs
D.1 -Historical/ Transitional Photographs
D.2 -Current Photographs
D.1 Historical Photographs
Exterior from Residential Building Record (1971)
13
14
D.1 Transitional Photographs
Google Maps (2019)
Google Maps (2016)
15
Google Maps (2011 )
Google Maps (2009)
16
D.2 Current Photographs
North Far;:ade and Front Entrance of House
17
North & WestFa9ade of House with View of Garage Addition to West
East Fa9ade of House Facing South
18
South Fa9ade of House
Siding on East Fayade With Original Wood Visible Underneath
19
South & West Fa9ade of House Showing
Vergeboard on South Fa9ade of House Showing Addition
20
East Fa<,ade of ADU
North Fa<;:ade of ADU
South Fai;:ade of Garage Addition
Attachment E
HRB Criteria
Supplemental Documentation
21
E.1 -Criterion A
E.2 -Criterion 8
E.3 -Criterion C
E.4 -Criterion D
E.5 -Criterion E
E.6 -Criterion F
E.2 Criterion 8 -Historic Person
22
Research did not return any evidence that 725 Arbuckle Place, Carlsbad CA was associated with
the lives of persons significant in our past.
Newspaper clipping from The Daily Times -Advocate (1956) -Resident, Ruby Milholland
,. -------.,,-.-,.. New Officen Installed By Native Daughters--r
NA1'1\'F. U.\l'GHTER~ or tht Golden West Las Flom dtl Mar Parlor 301 Friday,,,.
ninir installed new orrinrs al a r.o-hoat dinner held al lht MJaioo 8o11 I, OttJ1nsid,.
From left, Maltd, art lllarian Trotter. president; .\ttlnr Deputy Grand Prtsldtnt Dor-
olby <'hen,,. iru.tallinr orticer: se.cond row, Eni~ Bnvtr, lna.sltt: l,ola Cooch1ln. lru,-.
l«: \'ushli Papworlh. OJX • rtl'llden • ostlla I
Wolfe. 1 hird I itt prftiident: Eliui-
belh Salis bury. recording Sttrtlary; Dorothy . . rtr: n rec , lrus•
ttt: .\litt Whilthead, marshal; Caroll Guidotti. financial secretary: FrJMff! Webltr.
~l prtsidtnl, and Annett, Vartiklan, inside se.ntin,1. •
Newspaper clipping from North County Times (1995) -Family name not mentioned
23
Works Cited
E.1 -Provide a list of works cited
(bibliography)
24
25
E.1 Bibliography
Books
California Office of Historic Preservation
1996 The California Register of Historic Resources: Regulations for Nomination of Historic Properties.
State of California, The Resources Agency, Department of Parks and Recreation
Hartmann, Glenn D.
1977 Architectural Description Guide: Developed for Use in Preparing Nominations for State and
National Registers of Historic Places. Office of Archaeology and Historic Preservation,
Washington State Parks & Recreation Commission, Olympia, Washington
McAlester, Virginia
2013 Field Guide to American Houses. New York: Alfred A Knopf, Inc.
National Archives
1992 National Register of Historic Places Registration Form: Carlsbad Santa Fe Depot
United States Department of Interior, National Park Service
National Park Service
1985 Historic American Building Survey Guidelines for Preparing Written and Historical Descriptive
Data. Division of National Register Programs, Western Regional Office, San Francisco, California
Smith, G.E. Kidder
1996 Source Book of American Architecture. New York: Princeton Architectural Press
Government Documents
City of San Diego Historical Resources Board
2009 Historical Resource Research Report Guidelines and Requirements, Land Development Manual,
Historical Resources Guidelines, Appendix E, Part 1.1, Adopted by the Historical Resources
Board November 30, 2006, Updated January 24, 2008 and February 9, 2009.
Internet
Ancestry.com, www.ancestry.com {US. Census 1880, 1890, 1900, 1910, 1920, 1930, 1940; California
Death Index; Social Security Death Index; genealogical files)
Newspaper
Daily Times~ Advocate
North County Times
San Diego Union~ Tribune
Other Resources
Previous Wallace Historic and/or Landmark Historic research documentation