HomeMy WebLinkAboutCUP 99-30; CANNON COURT; HYDROLOGY AND HYDRAULIC CALCULATIONS; 1999-12-08I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
• •
•
Hydrology and Hydraulic Calclations
Cannon Court #210-010-38
MSxxxxu
Date: December 8, 1999 .
Prepared for:
West Development, Inc.
Prepared by:
O'Day Consultants, Inc.
5900 Pasteur Court Suit 100
Carlsbad, California 92008
Prepared By: TG
Checked By: MC
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
• •
Introduction/Methodology
R1111-off Coefficients
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Time of Concentration Nomograph
Intensity-Duration Chart/lsopluvials
Rational Method Calculations & Exhibits
1
2
3
S-7
App.
I
I
• • I
• • • I
• I
I
I
I
I
I
I
• •
44Jii i;ZP sea ; "
INTRODUCTION
The following Hydrology study was prepared to support the Tentative Parcel Map/Site
Development plan for Cannon Court APN# 210-010-38.
EXISTING CONDITION
Presently, the site is vacant and slopes gently from east to west. The site currently
receives drainage from the parcel to the north, and a 24" RCP drainage outlet pipe @ the
CalTrans right-of-way. The flow from the CalTrans pipe is conveyed across the property
via a drainage swale and a shallow steel pipe. The entire site (and off-site contributing)
drains to a S'x S' railroad tie culvert at the AT&SF railroad.
PROPOSED CONDITION
The development plan proposes commercial/tourist site which will cover most of the lot
with buildings and A/C paving. The drainage will be connected to the existing outlet via
a series of pipes/inlets as shown on the site plan (attached).
HYDROLOGY
The run-off was calcualted using the rational method as outlined in the San Diego County
Hydrology Manual .
The following criteria was used:
• 100-year storm event .
• Time of concentration {Tc) calculated using appendix X-C (see page 3).
• "C" values of .45 for existing, and .9 for proposed (see page 2).
• Intensity "I" was calculated using the Intensity-duration Charts (see pages 5-7).
I
I
I
I
I
1:
II
I
I· .~
I'
I
I
11---
1
I
I
I
I
-!!,-
RU~OFF COEFFICIENTS (RATIONAL MEnlOD)
LAND USE
Undeveloped
Residen~ial:
!tural
Single Faaily
Multi-Units
Mobile Homes (2)
..
Comercial (2)
80\ Impervious
Industrial (2)
90\ lmpenious
NOTES:
Coefficient, C
Soil Group 01
A 8 C
.30 .35 .40
.30 .li .40
.40 .4S .so
.4S . so •. 60
.45 . so .s~
. iO . 7S .80
.so .as .90
ra
•. 6i
.35
(-'1!
. 95
(1) Obtain soil group from ■aps on fit;• with the Deparaent of Sanitat::.on
and Flood.Control. -
(2) Where actual conditions deviate sipificantly from the tabulated
imperviousness values of 80\ or 90\, the values 1iven for coefficien~
C, m.ay be revised by aultiplying 80\ or 90\ by the ratio of actual
mpeniousness to the tabulated iapeniousness·. However. in no case
shall the final coefficient be less than 0.50. For example: Cons.:Jer
ccmmercial property on D soil group. .
---------· ------· · ----------··-· ----·-··---------------------·-~c'tua.1-ilaperviousness ---=--SO\ --------·-·----· ---·---------
Tabulated illlper-viousness = 80%
Revised C = i8, X 0.85 = 0.53
APPENOI:c !X
1:
1·
I
1:
I:
I
1:
1:
I:
.
Ii
'
••
I
I
1--
I
I
I
I
I
-"""'L 61111!11. 11:a-a•s■: :■.t■z ■0111:111;iaH111111••·11111J11111!1J11"!!0""!"·-'·
llR&fPH ~RE/J.S t:JVERI.ANO TIME OF Fi.lJHI tt9URVES'
. .S411 O:CC:4!.. .
~._.,.....~ •I • I I , I • ■
' ++-..•-+-•
.
I
·•·
.
• I
I
..
. . .. .
I • •
i.A
.
. ...
. '
.... ~ I
I
•
. ,,.
-· .
. I -• ...
.
I ~ ;. ~ • • &
-. • -~ -• • . ...,.::__;i 41 . ~ : .-:•. . • -: ---a
I --••-~
-I :.·5.a~---~
•..:. . ----• -= • -~
.-
·-. -,.
··-·• .... Ex..amp/"'~-L-----·-·--··---·------·•-------·---·----·-··-----··---···---·-. --··--------------• ··-------·---· ----
G,wrn : L ~19.>'h 4" F/ow • Jt)O h.
Slop~ • /. tJ %
coe,Ac,~A,,: ~/ Run~,'_ C •. 50
R~ad: ~,-1,m; /nJwl,;,,, r/.? Al/nu~~,
SAN DI EGO COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF SPECIAL DISTRICT SERVICES
I APPROVED ~·; ~--' ~:. ,-~~~~~;~---
URBAN AREAS OVERLAND TIMI
OF FLOW CURV~S
I DATE It /I/! f AP0 ENDIX
..
·,,BuTSKO e
"JI UTILITY DESIGN, INC.
May 31, 2000
Planning Systems
Dennis Cunningham
1530 Faraday Ave #100
Carlsbad, Ca. 92009
Re: Cannon Court
Dear Mr. Cunningham:
Butsko Utility Design, Inc. has reviewed the above-mentioned site to determine if there is a potential to
relocate the transmission corridor and substation. Based upon this preliminary analysis and
information gathering, please find below a listing of existing utility constraints and what we believe to be
the critical constraints, and summary.
I. EXISTING UTILITY CONSTRAINTS
1. Encina Power Plant
The Encina Power Plant provides the feed to the Cannon substation and the
transmission corridor that extends east across Interstate 5. If the Encina Power Plant
were to be relocated to the proposed site to the north, it is unlikely that the substation
and transmission lines would be relocated from their present location. With the Agua
Hedionda Lagoon on both sides of the proposed site, there is not an acceptable
location for a new transmission corridor. The transmission lines would need to extend
south from the proposed power plant location to the existing transmission corridor to
maintain the alignment across Interstate 5. The Cannon substation would need to be
within the alignment of the transmission corridor and accessible to the new power
plant location.
The relocation of the power plant would be contingent upon SDG&E being able to
acquire the necessary private property, easements, permits, and satisfying state and
local requirements for the realignment of the transmission corridor.
2. Cannon Substation
Cannon substation currently occupies 160 feet by 275 feet (approximately}. In order
to relocate a substation, SDGE would require an acceptable alternative site location.
The new site location would need to be accessible from the Encina Power Plant or the
proposed location in order to maintain the feed to the Cannon substation.
The relocation of the substation would have a significant impact on the existing 12KV
distribution lines that leave the substation. There is an existing overhead and
underground distribution line. These lines would need to be extended to maintain the
circuits. State Highway and Railroad Permits would be required for any new highway
and railroad crossing locations.
The cost to relocate a substation is estimated at $10-15 million. This estimate is
based upon historical data, but varies due to site-specific issues.
2. Transmission Unes
There are multiple transmission lines that run east from the Encina Power Plant on the
west side of the railroad tracks to the Cannon substation. The transmission corridor
I 70G'i Via Del Campo • Suite ..'ilO • San Diq.:o • CA • ')..' 127 • S'iS.67(i.'J700 • FAX S'i8 676 977-i
\\'1th OHlcc:-. in _l,;,rn D1c,~n • Or,11\L:;C Coumy • InLu1d Empire • Centr.d Ct,a~c
• Page2 May 31, 2000
continues east from the Encina Power Plant, crosses the railroad tracks and the
freeway. The width of the transmission easement is 400 feet.
The location of the transmission corridor is dictated by the location of the Encina
Power Plant, the ocean and the freeway. The relocation would be contingent upon
SDGE being able to acquire the necessary easements and satisfying state and local
requirements for the proposed route. According to SDG&E, relocation of the
transmission lines would be virtually impossible unless the Encina Power Plant were
to be relocated.
Relocation of transmission poles is estimated at $200,000 per pole.
3. Overhead and Underground12kv Distribution Lines
There is an existing overhead distribution line that extends out of the Cannon
substation on the north and continues east and west. There is an existing
underground distribution line that extends south to Cannon Rd and continues east
and west on Cannon Rd. Relocation of the substation would require the relocation of
all distribution lines. The acquisition of new easements would be required for the new
alignment as well as highway permits and railroad permits.
The estimated cost for relocation of the distribution poles is $12,000 per pole. The
estimated cost for relocation of the underground distribution system is $200.00 per
foot.
5. Gas
As a note, there is an existing 12" gas transmission line that runs north and south
along the westerly property line.
II. ADDITIONAL CONSTRAINTS
1. An Environmental impact report will be required per State of California, General Order
131 D. The review and approval process historically takes 2-3 years.
2. Impact on the power grid, which is controlled by the power exchange. Any
modifications would be subject to state approval and schedule.
3. Successful acquisition of private property for new corridor site.
4. Successful acquisition of all necessary easements.
4. Project Schedule as it relates to the process schedule.
5. Costs
6. Subject to Coastal Commission review and approval
In addition to our review, we contacted John Hernandez, Sempra Transmission Property Manager to
discuss the project. John acknowledged that our assumptions were consistent with Sempra/SDG&E's
position.
In summary, we have found that the relocation of the Encina Power Plant, transmission corridor and the
Cannon substation to be highly improbable based on the elements above.
Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call Gregg Butsko or me at (858) 676-9700
~'-BUTSKO il:411 UTILilY DESIGN, INC.
' .: ., .
• Page 3 May 31, 2000
Or you may call to schedule a follow-up meeting to discuss these issues in more detail. Thank you for
providing Butsko Utility Design with the opportunity to be of service.
~sL
Martha Smith
Project Manager
Cc: John Hernandez
Cc: John Buza
~~BUTSKO
·~ UTILITY DESIGN, INC.
•••••••••••••••••••• ! I
lNTEHSITr~ouAATlON DESJGn CHART
I I
I
""--.-......... 1'""1 ••• -· rtrnmml·a n-,, .. , .. 111 .. 111 ....... ,,nr-, , • '• 1 1.1:..un-,nmrhr.1 • · ·-645 Equation:\ I .... 7,44 P 6 D •
I ! I • Intensity (ln./Hr.)
I i p6 • 6 Hr, Precipitation (In.)
I
I•, I
\ I ~ j1r, I .. ,. ,.:
D1rect1ons for Application:
1) From prec1pitatton ~aps detenn1ne 6 hr. and 24 hr. amounts for the selected frequency. •
These maps are printed in the County Hydro ..
Manual (10, 50 and 100 yr. maps tntluded tn~
Design and Procedure Hanual).
t) Adjust 6 hr. precipitation (if necessary) so
that it is within the range of 45,: to 651 of
the 24 hr. precipitation. (Not aprlicable
to Desert)
~ ~ ' 3) Pl~t 6 hr. precipitation on the rioht side
•11• ;::. a= of the chart. -.Z ~I~ l~f;'., C: ~ lili i::: 1 ! 4) Draw a 11ne through the point parallel to the ::: ~1 i~l!ll ~ plotted lines.
vi, • II • -u ---a -5 ·· · . ~ 5) This line 1s the intensity-duration curve for
-~-"
7
~.J--. 6.0 ~ the location being analyzed. -ss-
>I ,9 ·-'· ... •.. --, .. .,,_, s:o g • +" I . -.. --4 5 1------------------1 .,.... ... . ---. ~ ;i .-•.. ·= . 4.0 ~ . App1 icat1on Form:
!t .a • :· • • .. "'-... •I-+ ~•◄1-nu,,Hi-+++'NlJ-H+.t.+t+lt ~+i-'N 3•5 g. ' • O) Selected Frequency • /Oo Yr,
C -· • 30 11
-• • J.....&,.&+1-1;-l+l+H+l+l.ffl+IIIH+irtltttth'1 ~!iii.-M-l+i-r'N 111 , .s ~ • 1-~-: .. • _. 1) P6 • -z.<o to .• P24• 4.}
.. · I . ~~l+H+tH+tl • 5 ~ .
.;:. : ~~Hf ==~l,.~:PFf~i+.i+Nit. .o' ,3 • : : '
* I p6 • '°·' I*
7ii°4
2) Adjusted *Pt __ -z._._Co ___ 1.n.
3) tc • _____ min,
4) I • ____ in/hr.
*Not Appltcable to Desert Region
-< .!....I -L..J.-J-,.I-L-1,...&..U~..u.J.U.Wl,f,LWWU&jl"""'""~l,lf,U, ..... ., .
AnDal.1nTY YT
-----~-------------
--:io VI
j
I I I
I J
• COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO \
DEPARTMENT OF ·sANITAfION '·
FLOOO CONTROL !
! !
100-VEAR 24-HOllR PRECIPITATION
r20✓1SOPLUVIALS. Or 100 -VEAR 24-HOUR
PRECIPITATION ltl EHTHS OF AH .lfJCH
30'
15 1
' . : I·
~-~ --: ~
-, ' !
i ,--1 ;
.. ,.p .. 11 ~'
4
U.S. DEPARTAtEN I' OF COMMERCE
NATIONAL OCt:A~IC AND Al", OlitllllllC ADMINUITRATIOH
SPECIAl. STUDIES BHAN CU, Ot"l'ICK OP II UNp&.OGY, NATIONI\L, waATIIIE8 S&ICYIC:& ;
I
30•
..... 11: I I I 1• lat; I I,: I I It.•
-------------------
,II
:D p.. --~
1,1'1
'
cou,rrv OF SAN DIEGO '
DEPARTMENT OF SANITAtllON,
FLOOD CONTROL . 1 OD-YEAR 6-HOU
r20✓ ISOPLUVIAL
, . r
45 I -+-!---lfol~~~~':.in~'-1\..-'
i
!
• i
• 1
l I
30 I '-++!-------~~--•
I
I
PRECIPITATIOr~
F 100-YEAR 6-HOUR
15' ~· i--------i1------"1~~'----w~:::liif~~f,;;,~~..t;!2::~~:l'ltffl~~c:f::::====l===--t-
' i Prepa •d br I U.S. DEPARTMEN r OF COMMERCE
NATIONAL OCEANIC AND AT OSPllliRIC ADMINIITRAflON
SPECIAL STUDIES BRANCH, OFFICE or II D¥LOOY, NATIONAL WEATHER IIRVICI
!
I
30 1 ;--:---;----+---+-~--.f----~1---~1-----1----,1..
! .. ".: I.,-I .. ,,.. . ... la.Cl IC:I
I
I
I
II·
11·
111
I
11:-
1:
' 1'
1:1
II I
II
I\
.. .,,,,_ .. ....._.,•u•t t•s:;•1 Siliii!Oiii14jiii: ~·-~7 • ______ __,,,,.....,.,..,..,,..~---,----~
RATIONAL METHOD CALCULATIONS
AND
EXHIBITS
, ,_. -·· --···
I
Ii
lJ
lJ
•
I
I
• • • • • • • • • • I
• I
• • • •
•• 4 f AU I ¥ . JUE I!$! t c A" •
!
A, : \Mt>il~ l,)f'Ll~1·lo\'J S.. ·, ..
,. : ffttt]Ul,06'"( cA C..CUL,,A;=rl~? ~12-tff'-{;Jrrt ~
. '; ~tJ\ C,~t.-.,.-,Z. ,br,-.J ~
;,W l<t) .. WA~ ~\l~/>,1~ wAO Cftwl.,+£P uf,1~&--nf-e
:! 14\'r(o,JJtc.v ?vte-n+·o,J:
fJ ~c1A .. l'c.o
?vt>-t;-iA~ Arie>-e, A« £;!-ltw~ A-r ~!1,1e,1r A ('1, ~
MO /:,.. ~ q,5 Ac+ 11.o ,Ac=-1.o,6 Au
1\h'::: ~~'i>,'?~ ~ 1\.0 i\fi\:t, ()~ Ai£~&_;, I ·fAVt?P ~ fj.,,:/ft:/,Al1!lf(,,1(11J/,
1o 1 -Ac-f >-..tv A{Le A ~ 1. , Ac.. = '"i r-) , nt c ::-o. 'r5
o~fZ----('7,4 A-c..,, -,~z C0111-\ c. =-6,+.;
~ c ~ o,1c;C"Jis) + , +s ( .ts) -0.1;?
: : J. :::-1, 44 '~ fl -• "'4 6
t,,~:: ,z,,,
l1/1a~
1"'-' : o\/0-1.,PJ? t:aF.~)q :Jv r~ i .. :,t> 'f'J ! )I ~ l,=--110 1 ,:X~ :::-'2.S ~
C ::;. 0,4">
1\->,~¥t-VA ~~ (\'.) °'" e~ r~ ~t).,\v ~ o':?~{">-~J --fc., ; }.. e.t,·1~ .(\J.1lJ.1.., ~ lo 1M
+ c., • ,i, \ ·1',\~ -=) I ,., t:;
~ =-(, t A "' O. 6 "'=> ( "l ,1) (_'I<·.~;") 7 ~S q-J
·./
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
~l"°JT\t-J<r ~~)frf•:~ .. \> ( !,A1N r .·tr?)
1,,. otf-f.>~ f. ~ Act-r~ fll~l i._·~.)ft..ff\ L 'i·-tt t;,<.11 t t.n t~-·)
q::; (.I;&.
ct:, o,~
·i ""7-# ri -t-c, -• t,t1-~ __ A¼,,,\: 1--c. •·:-~ w-;.,.
J ::.--7 .44 {·z. ,.) rs·, -.i"'", .;;,-t,. 1 •1/tr
~ ~ c., A· ~ (..', 4-S·{' f) { l.1) ~ 4 I{) 4 /
~ I c; AC. ( ~ ~ {(.. ;:. s 11A j.,\~
. ~ := o. 45 ( b .if) (e,. <\) • 'lo t';)
i,. ~ tA½!L),1:.0\.)S oN ~l~
C (>)l L-L 0\-\~1-.J<&s[. ,..IU O "c.l
~ .! C I A ;:; D ~ '1 o ( b , c/) ( £. ~ ) :: 4<J ~'L
OffSI~ i'lff' 1l C, Jl. \,Jiu.,, ,-k\D I •
7"0 ·➔ lr,JPU1 ft,t~ -t .. ti ''--,,_ i ~_\ , 1. s i. l (. r,1-~ -f J~,)
~~-~s + .'fs(i.11(1.,")+ . ~(,z_:,) (b.S)~ ?Zc(s
'r'
t,f 'f6)1f;..
\.",~ G,
t1
I·
I
I
::;•:t:{~~ :J, /flittit~iJJ,5 ti
. '
• !~ :_.:: 1~~:-:·: :-~
-.. :;'-~~ \;~;f\it1
..,"'?,__:~ ;f. t..,;.~ \: .•
r ~-:~;>~i;.,
I
I
I
I,
I
~ ~I~ .fluM >-'? ~ : l":ir-100'
---
I
.~ 4:~! !~·!5!tf~ :·,:,.~•-_../~-~. •: T .,
:-------..:.. __ --_~ .;.---_:;'_:~ .. ~:_f~ ..... :'._.,_::_:.;.:·_~;_~·t.:~_!_~ f ~11¥ p,;
..
.. ,._ ··~;-.:·.-.;~:-·
:--· ◄-.. -:.
--... ·-••
~---,....,_.,-
.. ----------
•. ·;:.;.
f ,
, .. i .. -....
0) -tr•
J
~ • r-~~,
.. :~~~,,.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I,
I
I
I.
---------------
I
.. ,..,..,.-----
/
///
/
! .. {
i J
HYDROLOGY MAP
£XISTIN(J CfJNIJ/T/ON
~· -&.---,--" ~ -~:s;,~11~ \ --1--~--~--,. --' .. , \ .. ~ ~-..... ---: . . --~ ~~----------:,,,":. _..-; -,·_ ':-'"'..--:-=:~:--
&.,. ..,..· -------
, I _,
~-/-
r.
\
5800 ,.,__ taurt N T S ~ s.a. ,oo c-.. v ~-
• CCIIWomlo t20DI Pion..... "'V
laG--931-7100 ----_,,,..
11
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
...
~..---:;::..:-:::.--------C " • , :::--j/_ .. ,,-; -: • ---• --"" --. . -,_,_.. ~~----::-----.... -~----;/ .--:, -----~=-1..../ --------------• -;;c---, , _,.. ----~ -_,,,,.--
. _ __., ·c -~-....-----• ~-------=" ,. /----'.'-:::.------.----'\:--~ >'~~~::::::~-_ _.,., --~ ____ ___.--_,,,_,, _ __,-\ I ::::=:----:x---"-.. . --~ ---,.-_~)' \~'-''.'..'\ -__. __----I • ,, 1',. '· •
. . ~ . ---·-'--' 'l!\i-
.. ,---~ d •
'---._ -_____ l_-------;i --_ __,, --i \ '. ~'< I l ,,,,-~~~:;;::• --~~~~:;!:z:=::i=~:;~~ --_--~ \_.:, • i· Ii, ,;;~~ ·--.st. ~-_,-=j==-::f~~~~~~~;;;:::~ • • ..,.._ -~ -~-~ .... --""=s,;,;..lf?!:::::----.,..L-:::::..-/ -----·--' • ... : ' • -··
--~a~I~ i
-~ •• • ---/,.
/----✓------
/ /
.. ' .
I
I / y-~, "/ ~ ~v-\
\ \ ; )
\ \ • \
i -• !
\ \ \ \\ . -_} ~ \ ', _..,,.,. .. \ 1t !._ ~ . . . _.-------
\_-\ ~!;,. \ \ . . --~✓::;;;,---••
. \) ----. --i-· -__ ,.. .--· --j
~➔-_ _...:,::.-l . .---· . _.:,:;:,:.,-::;_
.... · -~-'!~=::.
! / t
\_ :;&.,~
•\ __ . ',\ ·;
\ '. . ~~
·, \ 1~~-·-'\_ ~-=
\'Ji \ . • . :--~.:;