HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-04-02; Arts Commission; 03; Chestnut Underpass Public Art Final Design Vote Meeting Date: April 2, 2026
To: Arts Commission
From: Krystal Roa, Program Manager
Staff Contact: Krystal Roa, Program Manager
krystal.roa@carlsbadca.gov, 442-339-5611
Subject: Chestnut Underpass Public Art Final Design Vote
District: All
Recommended Action
Receive a presentation from artist team, Greenmeme and vote to approve final art design.
Executive Summary
The artist team, Greenmeme, will present a revised design concept which has been reshaped
following community feedback. Based on the feedback gathered the following key themes
emerged:
• Appreciation for adding color and visual interest: Respondents generally supported the
artwork, saying it would add color, beauty, and a more welcoming feel to an otherwise
concrete-heavy underpass.
• Interest in stronger connections to Carlsbad: Many participants wanted the design to
include recognizable local elements—such as native plants, the Flower Fields, or the bird of
paradise—to better reflect Carlsbad’s identity.
• Reflects the ocean: Several respondents felt the ocean theme was unclear and suggested
adding visual elements like waves, coastal colors, or marine life.
• Desire for stronger representation of Barrio history and culture: Some participants
expressed that the design does not clearly reflect Barrio culture or history and
recommended incorporating more culturally relevant imagery.
• Suggestions for specific plants or design refinements: Respondents offered detailed ideas
for improvement, including adding specific regional plants, refining colors and scale, and
enhancing overall design cohesion.
ARTS COMMISSION
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 1 of 49
Explanation & Analysis
The Chestnut Avenue Interstate 5 underpass will be the first permanent public art installation
within a freeway underpass in Carlsbad. The site serves as a key gateway to the Barrio, linking
neighborhoods surrounding Holiday Park on the east with the Barrio community on the west.
On Jan. 4, 2024, the Public Art Advisory Subcommittee reviewed artist presentations and
interviewed two individual artists and one artist team as part of the initial artist selection
process, which included consideration of early community engagement approaches. Following
this review, Greenmeme was selected as the project artist.
Greenmeme presented two preliminary design concepts for the Chestnut Avenue underpass at
the Arts Commission meeting on Sept. 4, 2025. Following the presentation, the city conducted a
community outreach effort through an online feedback form, available from Sept. 11 through
Oct. 2, 2025. A total of 238 completed surveys were received, and all verbatim responses were
provided to the artist team.
A revised design concept was subsequently presented to the Arts Commission on Feb. 5, 2026.
Following this presentation, the city again solicited community input through an online survey
conducted from Feb. 10 through Feb. 27, 2026. The survey received 321 responses, and all
submitted comments were shared with the artist team to inform further refinement of the
design. The collected feedback is included in Exhibit 1.
Community Engagement
The community is invited to provide feedback on the revised design concepts. Public comments
will be accepted via email. The feedback will be utilized in the finalized design concept.
Fiscal Analysis
A total appropriation of $400,000 has been approved to fund permanent public art for the
Chestnut Avenue Community Enhancement Project (Capital Improvement Program, Project No.
6098).
Options
None.
Next Steps
Upon approval of the final design concept, the artist or artist team will present the proposal to
the City Council. The city will submit a Transportation Art Proposal and Transportation Art
Maintenance Plan Pending approval, the artist will enter a contract for the fabrication phase,
and installation contract(s) will subsequently be initiated.
Environmental Evaluation
The proposed action is not a “project” as defined by CEQA Section 21065 and CEQA Guidelines
Section 15378(b)(5) and does not require environment review under CEQA Guidelines Section
15060(c)(3) and 15061(b)(3), because the proposed action to report on Chestnut Avenue I-5
Underpass Public Art concepts is an organizational or administrative government activity that
does not involve any commitment to any specific project which may result in a potentially
significant physical impact on the environment. Any subsequent action or direction stemming
from the proposed action may require preparation of an environmental document in accordance
with CEQA or CEQA Guidelines.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 2 of 49
Exhibits
1.Public Input Summary
2.Greenmeme Public Art Renderings
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 3 of 49
Chestnut Underpass Public Art
Phase 4 Community Input Summary
March 2026
The City of Carlsbad is planning a public art project at the Chestnut Avenue I-5 underpass, which will be
the first permanent public art at a freeway underpass in Carlsbad. The undercrossing serves as one of
the main entrances to the Barrio and links the neighborhoods around Holiday Park on the east side of
the freeway and the city’s Barrio community on the west.
Carlsbad Municipal Code 2.18.110 requires that a minimum of 1% of the cost of certain construction
projects be dedicated to public art. For this project, the City Council has designated $400,000 for
permanent public art in the underpass.
Community engagement approach
The city involved the community during the initial stages of the project’s development, which included
soliciting input on artist selection and working with the selected artist team to ensure the new artwork
captures the community’s values related to this key neighborhood transition point.
Following community input on initial design concepts presented in fall 2025, city staff and the artist
team revisited the design approach. Feedback from the community and the Arts Commission indicated
interest in a concept that more clearly reflected the project’s themes and the surrounding neighborhood
context. At the same time, additional technical review identified site considerations and maintenance
concerns related to the art's location within the Caltrans right-of-way.
Based on this input and analysis, the artist team developed an updated design concept that uses plant
and floral forms inspired by Carlsbad’s landscape and the Barrio’s layered history. The revised concept
focuses on vegetation associated with different periods of the area’s ecological and cultural history and
uses color and form to illustrate change across the landscape over time.
This report summarizes the input received during Phase 4 of engagement.
Below are the phases of engagement:
Phase 1: Selection of artist (Winter 2024)
•Which of the artists seems like the best choice for this public art project?
Phase 2: Artist collaboration (Spring 2025)
•How can the proposed public art design best reflect the values and culture of the surrounding
communities?
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 4 of 49
Exhibit 1
Phase 3: Feedback on the proposed artwork (Fall 2025)
• How well does this public art reflect the priorities identified in phases 1 and 2?
Phase 4: Feedback on revised concept (Winter 2026)
• How clearly does the updated design concept reflect the themes identified by the community?
• What elements of the design work well and what could be improved?
Level of engagement
The International Association of Public Participation’s spectrum of public participation illustrates a
variety of approaches to involving the public in decision making. The Veterans Memorial Park public art
input process falls between “consult” and “involve.”
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 5 of 49
How to consider the input
The input in this report is qualitative in nature and was
obtained through a convenience sample. This means the
city focused on gaining an in-depth understanding of
community member perspectives, and the results
cannot be generalized to the entire population of the
city within a defined margin of error.
That’s why the input in this report should be considered with a similar weight as other forms of
feedback that have always been part of the city’s decision-making process, such as comments made at
City Council meetings or emails sent to the city expressing an opinion.
Caltrans guidance for public art
The Chestnut Underpass public art project is located within Caltrans’ right-of-way and must adhere to
requirements set by Caltrans. The City of Carlsbad and the selected artist for this project, Greenmeme,
have worked closely with Caltrans to ensure the artwork concepts proposed follow all of the
requirements, including:
Design & Aesthetics
• Reflect history, resources or character of the area
• Scaled to surroundings
• Incorporate durable, non-reflective materials
• No text, logos, flags or symbols
Safety & Function
• Avoid traffic-control colors
• Not create a distraction or glare for drivers
• Not include moving, flashing or kinetic elements
• Maintain sight distance and airspace
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 6 of 49
Revised design concept
Following feedback on the initial artwork concepts presented in fall 2025, the artist team revisited the
design approach and developed a revised concept for the Chestnut Underpass public art installation.
The updated concept draws inspiration from Carlsbad’s natural landscape and the layered history of the
surrounding Barrio community. Rather than depicting specific people or objects, the revised design uses
plant and floral forms to represent different periods of ecological and cultural change in the area.
The design contrasts vegetation associated with different eras and influences across the landscape.
Native plants and cultivated flowers represent the ways Carlsbad’s environment and neighborhoods
have evolved over time through migration, settlement and community growth.
The concept is designed to visually frame the entrances to the underpass and create a welcoming
gateway between neighborhoods on either side of Interstate 5. The artwork would be installed on the
four exterior corners of the underpass using powder-coated steel panels mounted slightly off the wall
for durability and ease of maintenance.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 7 of 49
Design elements
The revised concept proposes different plant imagery on each side of the underpass:
West side of the underpass
• Mirrored designs on the north and south walls featuring native and cultivated flowers
• Examples shown in the concept include yellow cholla and red freesia
East side of the underpass
• Mirrored designs on the north and south walls featuring prehistoric plant forms
• Examples shown in the concept include pines, aspens and oaks
Through color and form, the design illustrates a visual transition across the landscape—from earlier
ecological forms to more recent cultivated plants—reflecting how the area’s natural environment and
community have changed over time.
Phase 4 input opportunity
The revised design concept for the Chestnut Underpass public art project was presented to the Arts
Commission during its Feb. 5, 2026 meeting. Following that discussion, the city invited community
members to review the updated concept and share feedback through an online survey.
The survey was available from Feb. 10 to 27, and received 321 responses. All comments submitted
through the survey were shared with the artist team to help inform further refinement of the design.
Online survey
The online survey was designed to gather input on how well the revised design concept reflects the
themes identified during earlier engagement phases. The survey included a combination of multiple-
choice and open-ended questions to better understand community perspectives on the design.
Participants were asked to review the design renderings and respond to questions, including:
• How familiar are you with the Chestnut Underpass public art project?
• Based on the renderings, how clearly does the overall concept come across?
• To what extent do you agree that this design reflects each of the following themes identified by
the community?
• Which theme(s) could be better reflected, and how?
The survey also provided an opportunity for respondents to share additional comments or suggestions
related to the design.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 8 of 49
Promotion
The city promoted the opportunity to provide input on the revised design concept through several
communication channels to help reach residents, nearby neighborhoods and community members
interested in public art and the Barrio.
The input opportunity was promoted through the following:
• Social media and Nextdoor posts
• Emails to public art and Barrio interest lists on Feb. 10 and Feb. 23
• City Manager’s Update email newsletter on Feb. 12
• Email outreach to the Carlsbad Village Association for distribution to its network
• A newsroom post featured on the city website home page
• Updates to the project webpage with the revised design concept and survey link
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 9 of 49
Key themes
The feedback from the online survey was reviewed and grouped into several common themes based on
patterns in the responses and comments submitted by participants. While individual responses varied,
several consistent perspectives emerged.
Representative survey comments are included below to illustrate common perspectives expressed by
respondents. Readers are encouraged to review the verbatim comments in Appendix A for additional
context and specific suggestions shared by respondents.
Appreciation for adding color and visual interest
Many respondents expressed support for adding artwork to the underpass and appreciated the idea of
introducing color and visual interest to a space that is currently dominated by concrete infrastructure.
Some said the proposed plant imagery would help create a more welcoming gateway between
neighborhoods and improve the overall character of the area.
Examples from the comments include:
• “The design is pleasing to the eye and will be enjoyed, I think, by most viewers.”
• “The bold florals feel welcoming and expressive, especially for the barrio.”
• “The Flowers are gorgeous.”
Interest in stronger connections to Carlsbad
A common theme in the comments was the desire for the artwork to reflect elements that are clearly
associated with Carlsbad. Many respondents suggested incorporating plants or imagery that people
would readily recognize from the city, such as species associated with the Flower Fields, the city’s official
flower (the bird of paradise) or native coastal vegetation. Some respondents also recommended
including wildlife or other natural elements that reflect the area’s environment.
Examples from the comments include:
• “If you are going to do flowers rinunculas would be a better choice to represent the flower
fields.”
• “To strengthen it even more, I would suggest incorporating plants that are clearly associated
with Carlsbad — like the Bird of Paradise, so the artwork feels more rooted in our city and
identity.”
• “As a child Carlsbad was Pea Soup Andersens, the smokestack, Poinsettias, Bird of Paradise, and
the organic wild growth of native sea bush with purple flowers, and red apple pickle weed.”
• “Should include plants that represent Carlsbad.”
• “Native plants would give it deeper meaning and accurate representation.”
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 10 of 49
Questions about how the design reflects the ocean
Some respondents noted that while the design clearly reflects nature, the connection to the ocean was
less apparent. Many comments suggested incorporating visual references to the coast, waves or marine
life to better reflect Carlsbad’s coastal identity.
Examples from the comments include:
• “I see no water or ocean. why not add something related to our beaches.”
• “Ocean: there are no longer any colors or shapes reflecting ocean. Add waves, ocean textures.”
• “Where’s the part of the ocean theme?”
• “It would be nice if you could also incorporate a bit of the ocean in this beautiful mural!”
Desire for stronger representation of Barrio history and culture
Some participants said they would like the design to more clearly reflect the history and cultural identity
of the Barrio neighborhood. Suggestions included incorporating imagery connected to the community’s
history, culture or long-standing traditions.
Other respondents felt the plant-based concept could still reflect the neighborhood if the selected
vegetation more clearly referenced plants commonly found in the area.
Examples from the comments include:
• “The barrio theme keeps getting mentioned but I just don’t see it.”
• “I don’t see anything that conveys a sense of the barrio or its culture.”
• “I would love to see more representation for Latinos in Carlsbad.”
• “Barrio history for sure, the designs dont offer any reflection to Barrio history.”
Suggestions for specific plants or design refinements
Many respondents provided detailed suggestions for how the design could be refined. These included
recommending specific plants associated with Carlsbad or Southern California, adjusting the scale or
color of elements and increasing visual continuity across the underpass.
Several comments also expressed preferences between the flower imagery and the prehistoric plant
forms shown in the concept renderings.
Examples from the comments include:
• “Movement and connection coulld be better relected by using similar colors on both ends.”
• “The green side with Pine, Aspen, and Oak, is unclear.”
• “The plants are nice but the size of the plant images are unrealistic.”
• “I also agree to add maybe bees, butterflies, and ladybugs.”
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 11 of 49
Input summary
The city received 321 survey responses from community members who reviewed the revised design
concept and shared feedback. The survey included a combination of multiple-choice questions and
open-ended responses.
Familiarity with the project
Respondents had varying levels of familiarity with the Chestnut Underpass public art project:
• 46% said they had seen updates about the project but had not previously participated in the
engagement process
• 30% said they had provided input earlier in the process
• 24% said this was the first time they had heard about the project
These responses indicate that this phase of engagement reached both community members who had
previously participated in the project and others who were learning about it for the first time.
Clarity of the design concept
Participants were asked how clearly the overall concept came across based on the renderings.
• 45% said the concept was very clear
• 34% said it was somewhat clear
• 19% said it was not very clear
• 2% said they were not sure
Overall, about 79% of respondents said the concept was either very or somewhat clear.
Alignment with community themes
Respondents were also asked to what extent the design reflects the themes identified during earlier
engagement phases, including nature, Barrio history and culture, community connection, movement
through the corridor and community pride.
Responses varied across these themes. Feedback generally indicated stronger recognition of the
design’s connection to nature and landscape, while comments suggested that connections to the ocean
and Barrio history were less immediately apparent to some respondents.
Additional insights about these perspectives are reflected in the key themes summarized in the previous
section.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 12 of 49
Next steps
City staff and the artist team will review the feedback received through the online survey and the
discussion from the Feb. 5 Arts Commission meeting. This input will help inform refinements to the
proposed design.
A refined design concept is expected to be presented to the Arts Commission for review at its meeting
on April 2, 2026. If the Arts Commission recommends the design for approval, the final concept will be
presented to the City Council at a future meeting for consideration.
If approved, the project will move forward with final design development, fabrication and installation in
coordination with Caltrans.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 13 of 49
APPENDIX A
1. How familiar are you with the Chestnut Underpass public art project?
Answered: 316 Skipped: 5
Answer choices Percentage Respondents
This is my first time hearing about it 24.05% 76
I’ve seen some updates but haven’t participated 46.20% 146
I provided input earlier in the process 29.75% 94
Total: 316
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 14 of 49
2.Based on the renderings, how clearly does the overall concept come across
to you?
Answered: 314 Skipped: 7
Answer choices Percentage Respondents
Very clear 44.90% 141
Somewhat clear 33.76% 106
Not so clear 19.43% 61
Not sure 1.91% 6
Total: 314
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 15 of 49
3. To what extent do you agree that this design reflects each of the following
themes identified by the community?
Answered: 318 Skipped: 3
Theme
1 -
Strongly
disagree
2 3 4
5 -
Strongly
agree
Weighted Average
Celebrate nature and the
ocean 12.93% 17.03% 23.34% 25.87% 20.82% 3.25
Honor Barrio history and
culture 23.81% 20.32% 22.86% 18.41% 14.60% 2.8
Encourages reflection and
respect 15.77% 17.67% 25.87% 22.40% 18.30% 3.1
Foster community
connection and inclusivity 20.63% 19.37% 25.71% 18.10% 16.19% 2.9
Reflect movement and
important access link 17.72% 12.97% 25.63% 22.15% 21.52% 3.17
Inspire community pride
and hope 15.19% 16.14% 19.94% 23.42% 25.32% 3.28
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 16 of 49
4. Which theme(s) could be better reflected, and how?
Answered: 189 Skipped: 132
More color on the prehistoric side
Movement and connection coulld be better relected by using similar colors on both ends, but
with different intensities (splashy & bold vs. subdued & smaller flowers). Represents current
nature better, for those who love our trails.
This flower design is my favorite so far. It is welcoming, impactful, colorful, and it relates to
Carlsbad popular farming of flowers (Flower fields and Ecke Pointsettias). Although we can go
with other themes (Barrio, Sea Life or other), this one seems to also reflect another known
history of Carlsbad. So it can work as well.
They all are ugly and out of scale. Doesn’t even look good. Try again!
The barrio theme keeps getting mentioned but I just don’t see it
The green side with Pine, Aspen, and Oak, is unclear. The Pine is shown, but overall looks
more like green blobs than anything else. Also, the sides should be flipped. Why is the side
closer to what's left of the historic barrio not with the "prehistoric" plants. Speaking of,
where is the sage, the buckwheat, truly important native species of the area. The flower
selections barely feel California, let alone southern California.
celebrate nature and ocean
I do not see a coastal theme or colors here. It does reflect the Barrio flower colors.
I think the carlsbad flowers should be painted on their
I like the use of native plants and representative colors in this proposal over anything I've
seen to date. I would love to see this.
The art proposed will reduce visibility of on coming traffic needed for bike and pedestrian
crossings. It is too large. A floral motif could fit with the community character if the flowers
include jacaranda, ranunculus, bird of paradise & poinsettia - similar to the art in Pine park
and found naturally in Holiday park, and the flower fields. An illuminated mosaic pattern
should be designed and installed at the upper blank band of the retaining walls with lighting.
This will enhance bike and pedestrian crossing visibility while adding much needed lighting in
the tunnel.
None
Not seeing ocean represented.
Greenhouses sunflowers
Why in the world would we incorporate flowers that have nothing to do with the city of
Carlsbad or the county of San Diego or the state of California? And how could you possibly
say that this design is inclusive or something... What a ridiculous and meaningless piece of
art.
Prehistoric plants design less obtrusive
Inclusivity of people, not just natures beauty.
This is very ugly and I don't want it in my town
I think there is no better because it depends which demographic you ask. I think the current
design is neutral to reflect various demographics and cultures. That’s a good thing.
more emphasis on the Barrio's Mexican heritage
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 17 of 49
How does it honor the Barrio history and culture?
I see no water or ocean. why not add something related to our beaches
The history of the Carlsbad Barrio.
I truly appreciate the proposed design. It beautifully shows how gardens are living reflections
of culture and migration, while also complementing and enhancing the natural character of
the local surroundings.
Should include plants that represent Carlsbad.
Nature is well-represented, but I don't think the greenery on the East side reflects ancient
plant material. It seems too abstract to me. I like the west side; maybe make the East side
more like the West side.
Even if every theme isn’t totally reflected, I think the artist team did a good job. I wonder if
the quotes are included in actual art.
Ocean - how does this reflect the ocean? Add an ocean element on the west side.
Barrio history and culture - Nothing! Look at Lola’s market for ideas.
Inclusivity???
Reflect movement - maybe with an ocean design
Inspire pride and hope - need more suggestions of the Barrio culture.
As a resident, I feel the bouquet concept better reflects the vibrancy and pride of our
community. The bold florals feel welcoming and expressive, especially for the barrio.
To strengthen it even more, I would suggest incorporating plants that are clearly associated
with Carlsbad — like the Bird of Paradise, so the artwork feels more rooted in our city and
identity.
I don’t see anything that conveys a sense of the barrio or its culture.
Designs that represent the flora, herbs, plant life of this beautiful town is a great idea. It is
relaxing to reflect on the vegetation of the area that all people regardless of their personal
life can thoroughly enjoy. It is a good decision to showcase natural beauty. It is a good
decision to refrain from overwhelming children especially as well as all other North County
citizens with anything that would reflect sexual, malevolent, or politically themed imagery.
Coastal Culture and actually San Diego native plants
Smaller and more colourful. Not just acent art. Also doesn’t say anything about the ocean,
doesn’t need to but the question asked.
I like the flowers design better than the plants.
Something with people, maybe the wall silhouette figures applied to the corners
If you are going with the nature or flower theme then you can honor the Latinx barrio
community with more traditional Mexican floral designs. This would reflect the barrio better
and inspire more community pride
Less plants and more people
The design is beautiful, but does not reflect 'ocean', as stated 'nature & ocean'. Either way it
is absolutely beautiful even without 'ocean' depicted.
I don't see ocean or Barrio reflected at all. Need different drawing representing all.
neither, where are the illustrations of the people? The community? This new direction feels
so generic. And "safe"
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 18 of 49
Add an ocean element to theme one and native flowers only.
I don't know what part os the Barrio history and culture people want to reflect on, so I can't
speak to that. I can say that I see flowers and succulents all throughout the Barrio and Olde
Carlsbad.
I can the flowers and how they would celebrate. Don't see anything really reflecting the
ocean
More people drive on the road than walk. Attention should be on driving, not looking at art.
There is no "ocean" in flower rendering.
The design is pleasing to the eye and will be enjoyed, I think, by most viewers. On the other
hand, it does not, in my opinion, particularly relate to the themes of ocean, inclusivity,
movement and access, and pride/hope.
Celebrate the ocean.
The Flowers are gorgeous.
Bottom line it needs to be aesthetically pleasing to those viewing it everyday while also
preventing homeless populations from settling there.
The use of native California flowers and birds.
I'm missing the ocean part. I only see flowers, which are great but I don't see a water
element.
I really like the flower concept and agree with commission comments about adding color at
both ends and incorporating bird of paradise and ranunculus. This definitely needs words--
either a title on the piece or a signage/description-- to connect the history to the
flowers/plants. Please, please no pinata -- keep the connection to the barrio through native
plants.
It would be nice if you could also incorporate a bit of the ocean in this beautiful mural!
Ocean themes
This seems to want to represent the Barrio and not with any ocean themes which is fine. If
that is the case, I would include people with the flowers as part of the community. DIversity is
key.
They are beautiful designs and clearly convey what they are (flowers and other plants), but
unless one has read the background for choosing that design, they will not understand why
those plants are depicted. Is it a big deal- I don't think so because it does add visual interest
to the area. Sometimes things can be created just to be beautiful, they don't necessarily need
a deeper theme.
Cover the whole underside with paint! Just a couple flowers at each end is kinda
underwhelming. Its the Carlsbad flower fields it should be super floral!
the design is boring and mundane, and the underpass would be fine without it and lots of
money would be saved. the design says nothing about Carlsbad, the ocean, or the barrio.
I don't understand how this honors Barrio history & culture.
As much as I love nature, I feel this design isn't an improvement over earlier ones.
I want to thank the team involved with the project as it’s not an easy undertaking to try and
please the public. If the artwork is limited to agriculture i would prefer to see an intimate
reflection of the City of Carlsbad limited to maybe the last 50 years rather then history of
bush and flowers of southern California. As a child Carlsbad was Pea Soup Andersens, the
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 19 of 49
smoke stack, Poinsettias, Bird of Paradise, and the organic wild growth of native sea bush
with purple flowers, and red apple pickle weed. That assortment remains along with the
current World Renowned Ranunculus in which we’re very proud . The color palate of those
flowers are all within the allotted number of colors. My vote keep it simple. It reflects
Carlsbad and all cultures. I also agree to add maybe bees, butterflies, and ladybugs. May
sound boring but that reflects intimate Carlsbad and its draw of visitors. Can’t wait till we get
to the beach factor. Thank you for asking resident’s opinion.
marine life, kids sports
The barrio and/or ocean themes .
I like the local flora concept. I don't think it represents the above items, but I still like the
proposal
the west side made reference to Carlasbad colors...and it is happy
The barrio neighborhood has beautiful greenery, plants and flowers in front of the homes, so
a garden theme on the murals is in place.
This entire project is a waste of money.
I just think this art project would be better appreciated at an intersection where you exit the
5 freeway so more people see it. I have never been at this underpass as it’s not a freeway
exit.
Anything more subtle. This seems to be within the uncanny valley. Too much color, too big.
Distracting. I don’t like it AT all. Creepy.
A welcome sign/banner on the east side as you are entering the barrio. Above the tunnel
entrance.
Nature and ocean
Ocean: there are no longer any colors or shapes reflecting ocean. Add waves, ocean
textures./Community: plant life chosen not easily identified with Carlsbad barrio or any part
of Carlsbad community. Use plants grown by local farmers like birds of paradise.
I see nothing that ties it with anything Barrio.
Way to busy looking,
Just pain the ocean on the wall.
That is such a waist of money that could go to more important things
More of an ocean vibe and it’s way too vibrant and will get very boring to look at over time
imo
I’ve seen overpasses like this that had the name of neighborhood painted on the overpass
with historical imagery.
One side could say “Barrio Carlsbad,” the other could say “Olde Carlsbad.”
Ocean
Ocean and marine life
An ocean or wave scene.
I feel like a beach/ocean theme would be more appropriate. But if you're only going with
flowers representing the barrio, it should have marigolds.
The plants are nice but the size of the plant images are unrealistic. Staying true to size of
plants would be more realistic. Also have the in more places similar to landscape like on a hill
I feel honoring the Barrio's history and culture could be better reflected. I've seen the past
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 20 of 49
renderings of silhouettes of people, and I feel I liked that one a bit more than these flowers.
In all honesty I grown up in the Barrio of Carlsbad and this has always felt like home to me
because of the Latino culture. Places like Lola's and El Torito being walking distance from
where I used to live are things I remember most and what I love about the Barrio. I don't feel
the flowers are enough representation of the history and culture, I didn't even know what
flowers those were. I would love to see more representation for Latinos in Carlsbad.
Tile murals reflecting barrio, ocean, rannuculas
We live on the coast where we have palm trees, ocean and blooming succulents- I am not
sure the proposed design reflects our environment or heritage
I like the flower one the most
Our Pacific Ocean due west a mile away.
Barrio history mural like other cities have.
Bienvenidos & Communidad!
How about life in Carlsbad, especially the barrio?
I don't understand the theme that is being expressed here.
I love the concept of adding art to the underpass, but less enthused about the choices. Feels
like a missed opportunity to honor the Barrio community. The floral elements are pretty but
bland.
Barrio and Espanic Heritage
the entry/exit flower concept seems out of place and doesn't capture any of themes. The
painted wall idea tried to incorporate themes and has a nicer flow through the underpass.
The rain maintenance issue could be handled I'm sure as there are murals everywhere that
are in the rain/snow throughout the country. Seems the current design would be a
maintenance problem also and possible vandalism. These big bouquets at the entries seem
unusual, distracting, and out of place to me.
The west side is almost monochromatic. It needs some color.
Maybe we're going back too far. Why don't we highlight the flowers that were kmown to the
first human inhabitants...native plants have colorful flowers. Monkey flower, prickly pear
flowers, seaside daisies, etc. Take a look at the local Calochortus varieties...the colors will
amaze you.
East side could reflect the flowers that have arrived since the Spaniards first visited.
Poinsettias and Ranunculus are good choices. As a reflection of agricultural flowers, use
avocado flowers (yeah, boring) or whatever else was here before commercial flowers.
I like the nature/flower scheme, but where is the Bird of Paradise?
Ocean bird; Bird of Paradise
I love the flower design. Not so keen on the greenery
The Barrio history; Latino culture and members that are still part of the Carlsbad community ;
those that have worked the land building up Carlsbad for what it is today. I think a mural can
best represent that and if this is a sculpture, maybe layer that on top to compliment the
artwork. $400,000 is a large investment to in the end not represent the Barrio history that
also helped build Carlsbad. That would be a big miss for the goals set out in this project.
I don't see how the ocean has been brought into the art.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 21 of 49
I don’t see any link to the barrio and history, but using pictures of flowers. I feel like we are
being tricked into seeing pretty, and no historical context. Is the artist Latino heritage at
least?
It's just flowers and greenery. The themes are reading way too. much into simple flowers and
greenery. Geeze...
The only theme reflected is nature. There is no oceanfront Barrio history/culture or overall
sense on community.
I appreciate the creativity and concept but would prefer native plants be represented alone. I
am not sure why cultivated plants are reflected in the work. Native plants would give it
deeper meaning and accurate representation.
Unsure of how it ties in to the history of the Barrio, but would be excited to learn.
Although this rendering is better than the last ones, where is the ocean? I'd like to see our
local wildlife included as well as, perhaps hawks, seagulls or coyotes? The current offering
doesn't provide much of a connection to nature or the barrio at all.
I’m don’t understand how these flowers represent the people of the barrio neighborhood or
the movement along this street. Are those flowers around in peoples gardens or in the
park.will there be greenery add to the dirt slope underneath freeway?
Is there room for a beach scene?
While the art is beautiful, I am not sure it easily translates into sharing the community
culture, ocean, or speaks to inclusivity.
I don’t see how this artwork reflects anything about the ocean. I think that should be
included in this project.
Prehistoric fauna does not resonate. Nothing here is oceanic in reflection. The character of
both Olde Carlsbad and (especially) the Barrio inextricably linked to proximity to the beach
and ocean. I cannot see any such influence that would be apparent to the majority of
passers-by.
It’s basically ugly. We don’t need funeral flowers on the overpass. Need a new concept.
leaves & flowers only represent nature to me nothing seems representative of the Ocean.
Ocean
Cultured flowers represent gardens and nurseries which I do not associate with the Barrio.
What about poinsettias? More natives that cultured preferred.
Ocean, general color schemes, community parks
Keep it grey… Offend no one and stop wasting tax payers time and money
I think the designs are fine as they are.
it's art, it's pretty. But it doesn't "foster" or 'honor" anything.
I like this theme so much better than the hats or people that were presented before.
Ocean scenes
Where’s the part of the ocean theme?
Where’s the Barrio theme? The cultivated flower part?
Not that clear/obvious of a connection to the Barrio
I don’t see ocean theme. Colorful flowers are nice.
Better to use native plants, flower fields and colors that are repeated to create continuity as
you move through the tunnel.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 22 of 49
Barrio history
All
The Ocean is really nowhere. I think the flowers are nice, but feel the trees should be waves
or something more reflective of the ocean you would be heading towards.
Barrio history for sure, the designs dont offer any reflection to Barrio history and Carlsbads
initial incorporation. We already have the Flower Fields 5 minutes south, so I dont feel
flowers are necessarily needed again. We have the old pine trees literally across the street at
Holiday Park, I dont necessarily feel its needed on a mural 50 feet away.
Floral designs, to me, are more for space fillers to avoid graffiti or blankness in an area. If you
want Barrio history and community connection, then here are my suggestions. First, research
more what Carlsbad used to be like when the Barrio was created. Since the city is quickly
turning into Newport Beach 2.0, then preserve that history through mural before we lose all
of Carlsbads history to this gentrification project. Second, if you want plants/nature, then
look at the agave and cactus that go with Barrio culture. Third, try and find a local artist who
either grew up in Carlsbad or lives in Carlsbad so that there is local ties to it
What happened to the colored stratification that represented the flower fields to the beach
& ocean. I rode mtn bikes in Carlbad for years and have never once seen the type of flower
represented in nature here. No reference to ocean. Doesn’t make sense for carlsbad at all.
Flowers
The art is pretty neutral, not tending to offend anyone since it is only plants. It does not
reflect movement. How does it "foster commmunity connection and inclusivity?" I don't see
the ocean anywhere either. Don't know where you got "inclusivity" from a bunch of plants!
But that's ok - the artwork is pretty, even striking, and it is attractive to have on a here-to-
fore dull and dark underpass.
It would help tremendously to actually see what the designs would look like. To hear some
speak of this it sounds like they are wanting a contemplative zen garden. Sorry, it's an
underpass and you're not going to zone out. It's going to be more of a quick, drive-by feel
good. And there's nothing wrong with that.
Celebrate nature and the ocean.
These are all bad designs. Please come back with something better. Ocean themed will be
more widely appealing.
Where's the history and cultural diversity of the Barrio? Plants and flowers makes it pretty
however, for anyone just passing by, there's no history.
The ocean is not reflected in the art. Would be nice to see that in the "ocean side" design.
I mean, how does one try to explain - with a straight face - that this someone fosters
inclusion? It’s a beautiful piece of proposed art, but it’s some flowers lol. Don’t overthink it.
Ocean is not included. Should it be?
Would love if I'm it was continuous - more than either end.
Not Hispanic at all.
It’s just plants. Not very creative and the green blob is odd.
As much native plant representation as possible to connect to Barrio history
It’s unclear that the designs reflect the themes except for nature. I like them except for that
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 23 of 49
If you are going to do flowers rinunculas would be a better choice to represent the flower
fields. The other green plants have nothing to do with Carlsbad. I have said before and I 'll say
it again, -please do something with beach/ocean theme which would be a much better fit.
Work with a local artist who knows the area.
I don’t think it’s realistic to expect all of those themes to be reflected in one area.
Perhaps the materiality could respond to the Barrio's culture better. What flowers were
cultivated in the area? The scale does not encourage reflection it seems to give precedence
to vehicles.
The proposed designs are beautiful. I particularly like the flowers, as the colors are brighter
and more cheerful. Brighter colors will also show better in the shaded underpass. I don't
really see any of the themes reflected in the art however.
Honor Barrio history and culture by including historical faces, experiences and photos of the
Barrio area.
It doesn't reflect the Barrio culture and I think having it mirrored on either side is a little
boring. I think there is a lot of room for improvement on the design. Also, how do prehistoric
plants, or plants in general, represent the culture and community of the area?
Put some people in it.
This does not reflect the ocean or the neighborhood at all.
More blues and greens would be better. Being a coastal town, I would like to see more of an
ocean theme here.
I think artist has done as well as possible to include all themes.
Although beautiful - I would prefer the use of actual plants/trees/ocean that are native to our
area - those don't seem to be reflected well -Pines? Aspens? not sure what the flowers
depicted are - there is no ocean at all. Representation of the actual length of the spaces
seems off.
I didn't connect with the black and white native plant image. I am not familiar with the
depicted plants, written explanations would be helpful.
Honestly not sure
It doesn't represent Carlsbad
Something that actually tells the history of the area in art that shows the area, the people,
nature, and the ocean.
"Village by the sea" ocean inspired - waves, etc.
Focus on southern California native plants
no ocean is reflected in this art work. green trees and natural scrub would better reflect
greenery in our area. The green element is not vivid.
People and the ocean. San Diego is not know for flowers and vegetations, especially the
barrio.
Just Flowers
I don’t see anything with the ocean and I don’t like the trees
There was nothing to suggest the ocean in the art renderings. Many people moved to
Carlsbad for its proximity to the beach and the ocean. Carlsbad is definitely a beach town.
We respect and don’t waste the peoples’ money in Carlsbad would be good themes.
Encourages reflection and respect. Perhaps a plaque explaining which flowers and plants
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 24 of 49
were used, their origin and connection to the area.
Ridiculous. Leave most of the underpass as bare concrete.
There’s no OCEAN theme included! I like the native plant concept and the colorful flower
side, but the PREHISTORIC TREES idea throws me for loop. I don’t like the design at all! It’s
monotone and I don’t see a connection at all! It should be all Carlsbad barrio theme, based
on photos and Carlsbad’s origins, and/or adding in an ocean theme as well. Get rid of that all
green concept at the East side. Plus, why the budget for this is $400K, I’m not so sure I get
that!?!?!
A local artist would surely be proud to be the one to do this artwork commission for much
less!!!!!
Ocean . Something blue would help
Barrio history including agriculture and Hispanic community. Also, I’m not sure how/if the
sculpture will intrude into the sidewalk? Seems like an odd medium for that location.
This is a key passageway into the Barrio, a culturally rich area of Carlsbad that is slowly being
erased — the under passage should reflect the community that resides there. I’m sure there
a great way to blend Barrio culture and history with nature/ocean. The current design is nice
flowers but you all can really do better. This feels lazy.
The native fan palm and some cactus images would be nice in the middle of the underpass.
The ocean, perhaps on the horizon. The beach sand.
There is little to nothing reflecting the Barrio history and culture.
all of the above which are totally missing, picking a few plant, enlarging them and plastering
on a wall with no connection to the surrounding, is not art. It is just an expensive uselles
canvas that will be covered with graffiti (which hopefully will make it better)
I feel it could do more to honor the history of the barrio. Also, the colors aren’t
representative of the coastal plants or architecture in the area.
Ocean theme (waves, sun, pelicans, seagulls,..), Bird of Paradise,… No historic plants.
I think it’s a very attractive design.
I don't see the Ocean represented here at all. Good colors for Nature, but would have liked to
see some waves (blue) represented in the designs you've chosen also.
Ocean citrus avocados hispanic culture
I don’t understand how this celebrates the barrio. Maybe an item (pottery) that reflects
Mexican heritage?
The ocean and Carlsbad's proximity to the shore could definitely be better represented. The
flowers have a cultural connection and are attractive, but I'd prefer ocean emphasis.
Floral or color representation of our Latin roots. Add a bee like in previous design or
hummingbird both represent pollination and migration
All themes except "celebrate nature" could be better reflected.
I think more of a surfing theme would be more appropriate.
Some reflection on the history of Carlsbad. Pointsettias Ranunculus? waves? even some
tomatoes and strawberries would be nice.
It looks fine right now. As it is. Why spend more money. Use the money elsewhere.
these flower images I don't see are very recognizable to those plants gown in Carlsbad
commercially
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 25 of 49
I don't see anything ocean related or community related
Love the plant idea but do trees and plants native to the area. Like eucalyptus and avocado.
Ocean? This design has no ocean. Barrio? My family has been here for over 100 years. It was
farm land with farmers horses gardens. Show that
Why not save money and put it towards Boys and Girls club?
This is nice and cheerful, but I would have preferred an ocean theme, myself.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 26 of 49
5. Based on the current design, how do you think the artwork would affect your
experience at the underpass? (select all that apply)
Answered: 317 Skipped: 4
Answer choices Percentage Respondents
Adds visual interest to the area 62.15% 197
Creates a welcoming and memorable entry 47.00% 149
Feels disconnected from the space 23.03% 73
Not sure 11.04% 35
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 27 of 49
6. How do the colors in the current design feel to you? (select all that apply)
Answered: 314 Skipped: 7
Answer choices Percentage Respondents
Feel like a good fit for the space 61.46% 193
Feel too bold 13.69% 43
Feel too muted 4.14% 13
Not sure 10.51% 33
Other (please specify) 23.25% 73
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 28 of 49
Question 6 – Other (please specify)
The red one is really good, but the green needs a bit more color
The greens are too light - need more dark for chaparral. The colors on the other end are
good, happy.
I love it!
Why are the cultivated plants colorful and the ancient ones only green? Real native history of
southern California plants is incredibly colorful and painting them all washed green feels
utterly like erasure of the native history and beauty of the area.
Prefer greens/blues=coastal
Love the richness and vibrancy.
Colorful is good. include jacaranda, ranunculus, bird of paradise & poinsettia.
waste of money
Panis flowers?
Does not fit.
The colors of the flowers are vibrant but not sure about the green selections.
Feels too muted on the East side
Colors are good. Like that they are vibrant!
Depending on the lighting throughout the day, colors can look bold or muted. Would suggest
painting a sample to see how bold to make the design. On a white background, that we see, it
looks very bold; but it will not be seen this way in reality
Lose the red colored flowers, keep the yellow coreopsis and add an ocean element which
would make a nice contrast. ***That bold red color on the existing design could ignite gang
activity.
This is not Art—
Love the bold colors! Fits the Barrio.
Too red and the wrong shade of green
needs more color at east end
Needs some blues (the ocean) included in ADDITION to original design!! :)
Color pallet fits the are but bit the plants
I love the design; it’s just odd to me that this is the chosen locations other higher visibility
locations.
I look at it and think- what an absolute waste of money
One side color too warm, other side all green too blah
Nothing Barrio
To bold, to loud
The red design is attractive but the green monochrome is confusing
the bold colors of the flowers are a great fit. The other pre-historic plants I feel are too muted
and plain and are not an attractive design for the underpass.
Not representative
Color is great but with environment native to our region that looks like our vicinity
Barrio mural with ocean waves
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 29 of 49
native flowers, incorporate ocean theme,
Need more color on the west side.
See #4
See comment above
Would like to see more color on the prehistoric side.
See comment above
I love bright colors! Especially by the dull concrete jungle above
They feel more tropical than coastal
While colors are nice, with little/no blue the ocean doesn’t seem to be reflected in design
West-facing side makes sense. East-facing prehistoric flora seems drab and uninspiring.
Ugly funeral flowers
The flowers are a good mix of colors however the leaves just seem a mass of green
Rediculous…wasting time and money fix the roads
the underpass is dark. bright colors are needed
I LIKE IT.
too bold and fake but may be software program limitation.
Needs more
Flowers good, greens should be ocean blue
It doesnt feel like it doesnt fit
Not representative of natural flowers anywhere in Carlsbad.
Feels appropriate for the subjects
Will the actual art look like a poorly vectorized image like this? If so, I don’t like it.
Feels basic.
Some red or yellow to tie in the very green end
Makes no sense
Seems like it would distracting for drivers & red. Maybe some more muted colors that
wouldnt fade
I feel like is a lazy, boring, and uninspired idea, exactly like the art on the Arenal/El Camino
Fire Station.
Blues and greens are more calming
would like some of the ocean feel incorporated -
Don't like the green
Depends on the surrounding plants
Need some blues for the ocean
scale makes no sense
The side w/ the flowers is much more appealing than the all green side. I don’t get why one
would be all green and the other side very colorful artwork!?!?!
Too much orange
The colors are ok. Would like to see the entire underpass illustrated.
missing blue balance
We are a seaside town so please use a seaside theme. No historic plants.
I feel it's too oversized in scope. Why is it taller than the tunnel?
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 30 of 49
I would like to see the yellow flowers as a more stylized/abstract representation
these colors would only reflect a seasonal aspect for the area- totally miss the ethnobotany
of the area
bold and cheerful
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 31 of 49
7. How do you feel about the plant and flower species proposed in the design?
Answered: 309 Skipped: 12
Answer choices Percentage Respondents
I like the species proposed 50.16% 155
I like the general approach, but would suggest different species 19.74% 61
I would suggest additional species 15.53% 48
Not sure 14.56% 45
Total: 309
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 32 of 49
8. If you have suggestions for different or additional plant or flower species,
please share them and explain what makes them meaningful to you.
Answered: 137 Skipped: 184
No
More native plants that have same colors as the splashy ones, but are more sparse: Salvia
clevelandii (sage) or yellow mustard (was brought on Junipero Serra expedition), Indian
Paintbrush (makes me think of indigenous) or monkeyflower (orange-red), maybe add some
blue like Sea Lavender (grows along ocean bluffs), lupine, phacelia (appears after wildfire).
The blue suggests ocean. Using same colors on both ends gives cohesion/community unity,
just use different intensities.
I like the ones showing but can't tell what they are. My only suggestions would be to use the
popular flowers from the Flower Fields (Giant Tecolote Ranunculus) and/or Pointsettias (any
color). Some of the other designs appear to be more for an urban setting.
Bird of paradise and palms. Reflect carlsbad instead of some giant monstrosity
If we add local flowers from our area would be cool option!
Buckwheat, California Holly (Toyon), Sages, Manzanita, Yucca, Elderberry, just to name a few.
These are the indigenous plants of the area used by those in the past. The use of oak and
pine and aspen is great, but they are not clear in their design as of this moment, the green
looks utterly unidentifiable. And even the red side doesn't feel like the area. So much of the
visual space is dedicated to two plants, mostly because they are bright and pretty no because
they have real significance to the area. Also get rid of poinsettia, its everywhere already. No
bird of paradise either please get creative and just use the actual important plants of the
area.
I always consider the Bird of Paradise being a very coastal influence (although not native) and
the Ranunculus being "Carlsbad." But the ones proposed are more specific to the Barrio so
they fit better.
None
Include jacaranda, ranunculus, bird of paradise, poinsettia & possibly monarch butterflies.
Similar to the mosaic totems in Pine park and Rachel Rodi Mosaics.
https://www.rachelrodi.com/blog/2019/11/10/glass-flowers-mosaic-mural-installed
The California Poppy should be featured
Ranunculus Flowers
Sunflowers
Incorporate only native species, mix it with beach waves and sunset to flow with the entire
beach community vibes. Maybe adding some of our local Beach birds as well.
Cactus and cactus blossoms only
Flowers are entirely wrong for this location
Bird of paradise is nice but this one is already so pretty
more cactus and succulent species
im wondering what the costs are and how that is being funded
palm trees
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 33 of 49
Species that are unique to our indigenous plant life
It is beautiful just as it is.
Ranunculus should be represented.
Plants that are more clearly defined; perhaps with ocean in the background. Pines, they don't
look like aspen to me. Plants that have a similar uplift to the West side.
I would suggest adding a Bird of Paradise to each entrance-side bouquet. The Bird of Paradise
is widely recognized as a symbol of Carlsbad and Southern California. It reflects our coastal
landscape and horticultural identity, and its bold form would complement the existing
flowers while adding vertical movement and visual strength.
Prehistoric plants make no sense to me. If only 2 designs, mirror east / west not N / S.
Because of the Carlsbad Flower Fields, would be nice to see a ranunculus plant. Because of
Carlsbad and the State of California, I REALLY LOVE seeing a poppy plant. Because of the
Batiquitos Lagoon, I like seeing the Bush Sunflower. Would love to see the addition of few of
these of these radiant blossoms.
Id focus on native plant to San Diego Ancient Coulter Pine, Western Prickly Pear (Yellow),
Spiny Redberry or Bush Monkeyflower (Red), Arroyo Willow (whites), Fiesta Flower(purple)
The plant design is too monochromatic.
Not a fan of the flower option
The floral colors/flowers are stunning, very cheerful love it
I can't tell what any of these are.
Put the people back into the illustration. This could be anywhere in the world.
I don’t understand the choice of prehistoric plants and why all four corner are not the same.
Carlsbad is palm trees, birds of paradise, etc.
I like the native yellow coreopsis, lose the red flower (gang color) and add an ocean element
in s blue-green so that gang color are not associated.
I see succulents everywhere around town, it would be great to see them reflected in the
design.
I can’t ID the flower species on the design, trees are more clear
PALM TREES
Desert mallow or maybe San Diego Monkey Flower
bougainvillea, ranunculus
Sea lavender (Limonium californicum)
Include several native California species of different colors and shapes so it feels like a
wildflower prairie.
Bird of Paradise?
see above
Are there any purple and blue (indigo, turquoise??) flowers that are local to our area? It
would add additional beauty to the already excellent mural your artists have created.
I fail to see the local connection of most of the chosen plants. Aspen only grow in the
mountains above 5,000 ft elevation. The Torrey Pine is the only native pine, and their cones
are shorter and fatter than the cone in the design. The description mentions an oak, but none
of the leaves in the design look like any of the native oak leaves. Also the species of cholla in
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 34 of 49
the design (California Cholla) is not native to Carlsbad (it grows further inland) but Coastal
Cholla is native.
Would love to see actual native plants on one side, and cultivars (plants and produce)
connected to our local heritage on the other. Perhaps cultivars as you enter the Barrio
(entering the cultural center), and natives as you leave (entering what was historically the
backcountry)?
I think poinsettia's were also another flower in our area besides ranunculus. The eucalyptus
trees and elm trees are central to our cities history.
N/A
More more more!
difficult for the average person to understand and relate it to the community.
All native species would be suggested
Use natives
Reasoning was Answered above.
Pointsettias, Bird of Paradise, Ranunculas,
native plants, california poppy, succulents
I don’t like the look of the green prehistoric plants
N/A
I’d like all 4 sides to be floral
Birds of paradise. There were formerly many fields of them grown in the neighborhood (e. g.
on Magnolia, on Park)
Walk thru the Barrio, lots of fruit trees, birds of paradise, passion fruit
Paint the strawberry fields or the pumpkin fields or the ocean
Your choices are way over the top big, loud, bold and dramatic for under a bridge.
I love a matilija poppy and I think it goes with the barrio theme very well plus they are natural
in this area and so whimsy
Kelp
Kelp, sea shells, fish
I feel like if they are trying to connect to the history of barrio they should include marigolds.
Also palm trees. The Bougainvillea look kind of like Hibiscus.
Maybe Encelia californica, sticking to native species in the coastal sage scrub community.
Instead of a huge mural mimic how plants occur on a hill
Again, I would love to see more representation for Latinos especially in the barrio where
Latinos made up that community. If were focusing on plants I would love to see things like
Nopales, or Cactus, and maybe some Agave or Marigolds. These plants are meaningful to me
because it's something a lot of Latinos grow up eating. It's sold at the bodega in the Barrio. I
understand that the flowers are native and are supposed to represent the Barrio, but I don't
feel it does and I've lived there for 21 years.
Rannuculas and gladiolus for the flower fields. Palm trees
Ocean background with pelicans, palm trees, bird of paradise, blooming succulents
Bougavilla
Birds of Paradise
Ocean kelp
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 35 of 49
Waves Dolphins etc.
More native plants
Were the cholla and freesias requested by the Barrio/old Carlsbad community? They seem
disjointed together. I know that freesias were grown by the Frazee family back in the day, but
will there be explanations for people walking by?
There are no aspens in Carlsbad since they only grow above about 5000 feet, so they seem an
odd choice. Why not all local native trees like Sycamores and Oaks and Toyons?
I wish the colorful elements were carried across the entire underpass, even if in some small
way. Think you need explanations for your choices posted because they may make sense, but
it isn't clear to this lifetime Carlsbad resident and lover of plants and history - so likely lost on
others, as well.
more native flowers and foliage and colors that blend in and flow better as the underpass.
these flower bouquets seem out of place at those locations and seem too grandiose for an
underpass.
See my answer to question 4.
If you know where to look, you can still find beautiful native flowers blooming within the city
limits. Check out calscape.org, which lets you search for natives by ZIP code.
I like the nod that poinsettias give to the Barrio's history. Maybe also marigolds? Not sure if
those were ever grown here commercially.
See above
Ocean bird; Bird of Paradise
If the prehistoric plants are/were native to the Carlsbad area, that would be perfect.
I don't recognize the flowers. If they are to represent CBAD I would recommend bird of
paradise or ranunculus as better fits. Bird of Paradise is on our City Seal and ranunculas are
from our Flower Fields.
I am not a native plants expert but I would like to see native plants exclusively represented.
The California Poppy and palm trees are an obvious choice. How about some desert natives
since we are a coastal desert?
Sea lavender, sage, yucca
Native flora & fauna from the coastal southern CA landscape.
Palms, cycads, succulents, cacti. They may not be historically native, but they are an
important part of our landscape and reflect a particular aesthetic that reflects "coastal
SoCal".
Plants consistent with seaside areas.
toyon and elderberry could be added to tree side
Flowers that are at Carlsbad flower fields, strawberries to represent strawberry field picking
in Carlsbad
More native plants and if use cultured, what about poinsettias.
Poppy or something else local
Object to project
shouldn't bird of paradise be included?
Agave.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 36 of 49
Suggestion: Insert a small hint of the Pacific Ocean at the base of the concrete wall, splashing
upwards, midway between the opposite ends of what's there. Tips of waves, peeking through
the sideway, in the direction of traffic, on both sides.
Blue Centheous, California poppy. Both natives local to us with nice contrasting colors.
Use native coastal plants with red and yellow in them to complement flower field flowers -
maybe Poinsettia too
Agave, Cactus, Manzanita
Runnuculas are the “flower” associated with Carlsbad.
Bird of paradise would add a nice touch of artistry as well of color
Isn't Carlsbad known for ranunculus?
Don’t do plants. This is ugly.
It's not memorable.
The pre-Historic plants are not so familiar to me or representative of Carlsbad. I'd
recommend others that are more obviously associated with the area.
I’m guessing these flowers grow well in Carlsbad.
Please use native plants and flowers only
Love all
I'd rather they use our native endemic species rather than common garden flowers found
everywhere in the world. They have nothing to do with Carlsbad.
I'd love to see the California Poppy featured, as it is native to both the United States and
Mexico, same with the California buckwheat which has beautiful flowers as well.
Rinunculus which are the flower grown at the Flower Fields would make more sense. The
other green plants have nothing to do with Carlsbad.
The freesia seems random. Was there a local freesia grower in the area historically? If there
was not a symbolic grower/species, I would suggest natives like the California Fuchsia or
Mimulus aurantiacus. They historically grew native to the location but have similar color and
growth to the freesia.
Study the history of cultivation of flowers in the area and add those. I remember fields of
gladiolus, freesias and tomatoes. (I imagine tomatoes have flowers.) Ranunculus would give a
nod to the present.
We’d love to see an approach that leans into material, texture, and pattern rather than
illustrative objects—something that feels rooted, calm, and enduring, and that still
communicates movement, nature, and cultural history without needing frequent upkeep or
be possibly distracting
I like the current floral design, but it would be pretty to incorporate the Bird of Paradise that
we have in the Carlsbad logo, with the current design option
Our official city flower, the bird of paradise.
I think instead of prehistoric plants it should include plants we see in the neighborhood, like
Agave, succulents, bougainvillea, etc. If it must be plants at all, it should be something we as a
community have an actual familiarity with, not what existed here 1000s of years before we
did.
I think this should either be all native species, or if you want cultivated species, use
ranunculus and poinsettias. It could also be ocean and kelp.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 37 of 49
Elm - leaves/branch at least, not sure if the red are poppies? lilac or sagebrush -CA fuchsia,
something that represents local trees, flowering bushes - plants
I dont think a plant or flower species is a good idea. How about an ocean scene instead
California native plant species indigenous to local microclimate
birds of paradise would be colorful and reflect our area. cactus flowers. flowering trees.
succulents.
Succulents, Native to Southern, California
Just flowers as shown above
I think the tree should be more realistic
Bird of paradise and avocado
If the flower are native plants to Carlsbad, that’s all good. I’d suggest the other side be
SUCCULENTS…..AND, incorporate native birds and an ocean/beach theme to either/both
sides as well.
Add flower field and sea lavender
Ranunculus flowers occupy the Carlsbad Flower fields but it was originally poinsettias that
grew here. Also, the city flower is the bird of paradise.
Cacti
cannot even see what these humongous things are. does not add or mean anything.
Salvia, sage, sea lavender, and island morning glory. They grow along our coast and are
familiar to those who enjoy visiting the local beaches.
We are a sea side town so use a seaside theme! It’s a main entrance to the village. Bird of
Paradise is the most iconic image with ocean, sun, pelicans, seagulls,…
Bird of Paradise plants are uniquely colorful and would fit well with what has been planned.
Palms, birds of paradise, avocado, citrus, lowquats plants we saw here in the 70’s - current
I’d recommend that entry flowers are not identical. More visually interesting if the flowers
are slightly different in position/arrangement.
I'd like to see more blues and greens emphasizing the ocean and seagrass.
Bird of paradise,
Something native to the beach area.
Pointsettias Ranunculus? waves? even some tomatoes and strawberries
Why not add all the varieties of Carlsbad commercial growing, as well as native plant
material. This seems very superficial
Eucalyptus and avocado. Poinsettias gardens Torrey Pines
Add a splash of purple statice. One of the reasons I moved to this area. I saw it growing wild
here, and it's my favorite flower.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 38 of 49
9. What else would you like the artist team or city staff to consider as the final
design is developed?
Answered: 147 Skipped: 174
The prehistoric side needs more color.
Please measure the space again. The aspect ratio of the rendering seems off. When I drive by
on Pio Pico, the underpass doesn't seem as long as it appears in the design.
In my opinion, it is important for the underpass to provide a walkway where one feels safe
crossing it. In general underpasses tend to feel a bit scary when no one else is around. Also,
the use of materials that repel graffiti paint, may be helpful--just in case.
Scale it way back. It’s ridiculously way too large and I’m a professional licensed architect.
Scale is way off!
To achieve the Barrio aesthetic I think the artist should Aztec patterns in the flowers! And
maybe even add a traditional Mexican “Calavera”! I don’t think we gotta change anything just
add to it!
The barrio is historic, and southern California in general has rich indigenous history and
biodiversity. If we are claiming this art is some great look of area and plants, they actually use
the space to show a variety and the diversity you are saying it shows.
The art shouldn't be distracting, but blend into the underpass. All of the car parked under the
underpass along with such a large art piece will look cluttered. Can the city spend $400,000
on the betterment of making the city parking lot signs and wood signs in the village more
appealing. I am curious where the idea of this art came from, is it necessary? The freeway
exits and entrance to our street from the freeway need better curb appeal.
More coastal vibes please
I like the change to the entrances and exits rather than the entire passage as that often feels
too "chamber of commerce" like.
The proposed art should not compete with the safety of our community. The super scale
proposed is a safety concern and appropriate if viewed from the freeway, not Chestnut.
Pedestrians should not have to compete with the art for visibility within this dark underpass.
Clear visibility for on coming traffic is needed for bike and pedestrian crossings. The art
should be reduced in size and illuminated to enhance the experience for more than just
vehicles. An illuminated mosaic pattern should be designed and installed at the upper blank
band of the retaining walls with lighting. Another precedent for lighting includes the Pardall
Light Tunnel on the campus of UC Santa Barbara. Redesign will enhance bike and pedestrian
crossing visibility while adding much needed lighting within the tunnel. Thanks for
considering these revisions.
Add the state bird or a bird that is native to the Carlsbad area
discourage homeless from camping there
Incorporate greenhouses
Underwater Ocean theme
These flowers have nothing truly to do with our community. I was born and raised in North
County and still have hopes of retiring in Carlsbad when I can finally afford a home there. But
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 39 of 49
it is my heart and soul. This artwork does not pull at your heartstrings and make you feel like
you are part of the community... It doesn't say anything about the people who live here.
Incorporate the native species, The colors of nature of the water of the sunset of the hiking
trails and the kayaking and all the opportunities that Carlsbad has to offer!
Keep colors muted
Ocean. Ocean. Ocean.
I think you can’t cater to everyone. As a Hispanic woman, I think this is classy, appealing and
represent a variety of people.
please consult with local gatekeepers and stewards of the Barrio community, such as Connie
and Henry at Lola's market.
I go on this underpass multiple times a day. I want to be sure that there is a provision in the
budget for maintence and repair because I think it will be vandalized and look worse. I do like
the new concrete work that was done. Lighting would be a big plus.
To be more clear and obvious about honoring Barrio's history.
I had hoped that the art would reflect the culture of the Carlsbad Barrio. Sadly, plants do not
meet that reality.
It is beautiful just as it is.
Is there any way of including the ocean in the background? I think it would tie better to the
community--that's the primary reason so many people are here...blue sky and ocean
As a Carlsbad resident, I strongly believe the Bird of Paradise should be included in this piece.
It is such a recognizable symbol of our city and the Southern California landscape. When
people see it, they immediately associate it with home. Including it would make the artwork
feel rooted in Carlsbad, not just decorative, but meaningful.
Especially in the barrio, where there is so much history, culture, and pride, the Bird of
Paradise feels like a symbol of strength and growth. Its upward form adds energy and
optimism to the space, helping transform the underpass into something welcoming and
vibrant rather than just a pass-through.
To me, it adds more than visual balance, it adds identity. It makes the piece feel like it truly
belongs to this community.
Maybe ocean birds as you approach from the east. More Hispanic looking designs.
Would be nice if the design has a certain organic FLOW to it...an undulating arrangement...so
it doesn't look like it is static. The ocean flows in Carlsbad.
Too busy of a design or live plants that require upkeep could make the tunnel feel too dense
and hard to navigate as a pedestrian.
What to do with the blanks spots
I do not get an ocean community feel with either design.i preferred the original design of
blues, tans, etc.
Local community, kids sports, gateway should represent these.
Reflect the barrio community more
Possibly words of welcome or kindness? I think the design team did a beautiful job with the
plants.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 40 of 49
Keep it clean and I like the designs presented
A building representing the Barrio are, rannuculas, bird of paradise & ocean
include People? Represent the Bario, not a a generic floral or greenery arrangement that
could be anywhere in the world.
The year the city was incorporated.
Nothing to add.
WATER FEATURE
Some Ocean landscape is always good
Incorporate an image of ocean bluffs
Prevention of homeless settlements there please. Is local artist Sean Dominguez involved? He
grew up right there. His input would be valuable.
Please collaborate with the California Native Plants Society for this and all future city
landscaping and art projects.
title/word incorporated
Maybe add some palm trees (rich shades of green?) so that the mural is a little more colorful
and representative of Carlsbad's coast?
Love the plant idea, but would love to see the final design be an artist's
impression/interpretation of the plants as opposed to the current design which features
photos put through a filter
some sort of community people in the background. Even if it was a shadow of people in the
background.
Please note that as you show in the design of shifting plants species, the city and its people
shift. What one culture is there today may not be tomorrow and so your proposal of plants is
neutral ground- it likely will continue to be appealing through shifts of culture and populace.
Tons of flowers!! More!
make the entire underpass visual interesting and not so dull
Nit an easy job… Good Luck and Thank you.m
marine life
It needs some connection to the barrio and/or the ocean. The underpass is the gateway to
both of those areas.
Pop of color on the all green prehistoric side
Please don’t waste $ on this.
I didn't see any reference to the ocean or Beach but that would be good to incorporate
I’m glad it’s not people pictured. This is inclusive.
The east side entrance handles a lot of different kinds traffic; ebikes, pedestrians, buses,
autos etc. These designs would distract people's attention and make the intersection less
safe.
The cost
This design is completely different from the previous renderings. These oversized florals are
not inviting or inspiring in any way.
Please, start over. Who wants to drive next to flowers that are bigger than your truck. Not
the right area for flowers, sorry just being honest because I go underneath that bridge daily
This underpass is my favorite project in Carlsbad in a long time and to really not settle!!!
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 41 of 49
When I first saw the green monochrome design I thought it was a two boxers in a ring, one
having just thrown a punch and the other reeling from it. I still don't understand it except for
the pine needles.
Some sort of water or wave theme
Yes this honors nature but not the ocean. Personally would have enjoyed a beach mural with
the ocean & maybe grey whales & dolphins. Or something dating back to the original creation
of the barrio's history.
The culture. Things like the Plaetero Man, El Torito, the history of Lolas and how it used to be
a market, the parks and soccer fields, the community center and Jefferson, Harding St. before
new development. These things are what matter to me as a Mexican American from Carlsbad
and I know you can't put all that in the underpass but Marigolds and Monarch butterflies
would be beautiful and I feel they do a good job of representing our culture because they
mean so much to us yet also representing lost loved ones and movement to the future. I
enjoy the vibrant colors, but I would love to see a more inclusive design.
Something representing the barrio
More ocean & Barrio mural.
Michas Gracias!
More artwork between the two entrances
Consider where this art will appear.
If this is meant to welcome you to the Barrio, why doesn't it have any of the culture and
history of the neighborhood?
Why "prehistoric" plants (an odd term)?
I also don't feel like the two ends of the art speak to each other very well, or it is lost on me
what the message is.
Not sure. seems pretty far down the road to make major changes at this point. I think the
painted mural wall concept is better. Or downscale the flower bouquets somehow and better
incorporate other themes that the community input provided.
Don't let Andrea Blum anywhere near this project! ;-)
Could you add an interpretive plaque so that casual passersby can understand the flower
choices?
It’s a pity about the rain runoff but it would still be nice to have some color in there. While a
colorful entry into the tunnel is nice, it would make the tunnel itself even drabber and
dingier. Perhaps some colorful lighting (like we’ve seen at the Botanical Garden light festival).
Again, the Latino and cultural history of the Barrio need to be included somehow. Especially
in this location.
Barrio heritage!
Not a good idea to have parts sticking out above the wall. Just asking for crap to be hung on
them.
I love the vision. Very uplifting! Please celebrate our many native plants that the Luseno
people once walked amongst and used in their daily lives. More than celebrating the Barrio I
think it would be meaningful to celebrate the people who once inhabited this land for
thousands of years.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 42 of 49
If the goals listed above are considered, this design misses the mark. It could be so much
better!
Community and inclusivity don’t seem to be addressed- or at least understandable without a
sign describing art piece.
Somehow the presence of the ocean in our lives should be included. Perhaps some low waves
rolling toward the flowers.
Consider an ocean and sky theme
It doesn’t have to be big and bold just warm and welcoming with ties to locals
Fix roads instead
as noted above, the underpass is dark and any art work needs to brighten
Much better and nature focused thank you!
See 8.
The pines seem very subdued compared to the colorful plants.
The choice of color will be very important and a sample should be reviewed before
installation.
As above, ocean theme on east side as you enter.
Really talk to those who 1) live in the Barrio for actual Barrio history 2) talk to those who have
lived in Carlsbad for 30+ years for true community aspect and feel
Don’t like this theme at all. Completely missed the connection of bringing the neighborhood
of Olde Carlbad to Barrio and eventually Beach when Chestnut train overpass or track
trenching occurs. Misses the mark completely.
Don't understand the question
Give us an actual image of what this is going to look like. The pictures I'm seeing here are
surely not what they will actually look like.
I hope the final artwork is more refined in style. The mockup looks like a poor quality vector.
Ocean themes.
The greens on one side seem incongruent with the bright floral on the other ... I like
DIFFERENT art on each side, but less green and some other color on the pre-Historic plants
side.
Not wasting city resources (time or money) on discussing ways to make this art represent
inclusion. I’m all about inclusion, btw. But give me a break! Just paint the dang thing and
move on!
I don’t really have much of an opinion as I don’t live near there. I live in Calavera Hills.
Consider adding a blue waves element to represent the ocean
Relatively new to area and first impression and continued opinion is how bad it looks with the
parked cars.
Please make the plants recognizable! Right now it looks very much like some photographs of
plants with photoshop filters on them. I honestly could have put something together in an
afternoon that would be more visually appealing. I wouldn't say it's "the bars" all over again
but it also is not good.
It could be beautiful to also include some homage to pollinators (bees, butterflies, etc.) To
further explore the ideas of migration. I don't recommend including the ranunculus or
pointsettia, as they are widely represented throught the city already, including right at the
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 43 of 49
corner of Pine Ave. While those flowers are a crucial part of the city's symbolism, but with a
focus on the barrio, I think going in the direction of other native flowers, especially those
native to Mexico as well, would be even better!
Should be something with beach/ocean theme.
I’m not convinced the aspen is historically relevant for Carlsbad. There are lots of other
prehistoric species that are, so double check the species are located regionally. (specific to
carlsbad and this neighborhood).
Consider the surface treatment of the wall as built with. Have the art work with the vertical
texture or grooves and change as it moves to the top flatter area. The wall and art work don't
seem to work well together. Make the scale work for pedestrians too.
There are so many other issues to spend time on, like the multi-story buildings going up
everywhere, that no doubt have insufficient parking. Just pick one of the beautiful designs
and go with it. No need to drag an underpass art project out any longer.
would be nice to be able to upload a visual
I love the big, bold, beautiful forals! Add a bird of paradise and it will be perfect
It's not clear that the green depicts prehistoric plants
Update the flowers to bird of paradise, include faces of former Barrio residents and sights.
Consider more how this represents the community, the neighborhood it is proposed in, and
how interesting it will actually be. The design feels so lazy as is, and there are many other
options to feature that represent our neighborhood and area.
More coastal asthetic.
I think I understand the color pallet of the flowers as a tie to the Barrio's culture, history, but
also think there is a miss not using the Ca poppy, and maybe a miss not using the purples of
the purple/grey greens that could compliment the ocean feel. Not completely sure of all the
materials - but seem some mixed texture would be nice as well.
Cultural heritage and history of the barrio
Add in some of our wildlife. I see hummingbirds, owls, coyotes, and crows everyday in
Carlsbad. They are residents too.
"Coastal", "Village by the sea", "Ocean"
Better plant landscaping: native species
paint the entire wall, not just the corners
People in the Ocean
The ocean!
Is this the best proposal staff has found?
Waves instead of plants
Mineral water
back light the shapes as a silhouette in same colors
*Colorful Native flowers and plants!
*Ocean/Beach/Sun/Waves theme.
*ArtWork 2 Celebrate the Barrio, Mexican history of that specific area of Carlsbad.
Blue waves
It would be great to see the entire underpass illustrated instead of just the entrances. Also,
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 44 of 49
I’m not sure about sculptures in a narrow dimly lit area, doesn’t seem like the right medium
for that location.
Saguaros
Please bring in a connection to the Barrio/Latino culture. The underpass is a literal bridge
connecting two communities. The design should include aspects of both communities. Or at
least, find some commonalities.
do something else, waste of money. Not art, totally meaningless, any moron can put together
a drawing of a bunch of plants. would have been better to let people in the barrio do their
own design or have a contest at the schools
When I look at the current color scheme I think tropical. I don’t feel that it reflects the village
and the more coastal vibe of the city.
A flower and historic plants everyone does not recognize is out of place. Please change the
theme to one we and visitors all relate to.
What happened to our ocean concepts? Perhaps add seagulls?
How easily the art will be maintained if damaged or graffiti. Liability if someone is hurt
climbing it.
Safety of leaves that stick up. Kids will probably climb, right?
If this is supposed to be an entrance to the barrio, then the red and yellow seem culturally
relevant. But is it only leading to the barrio? I think not. I associate the whole of Carlsbad with
a varied color theme.
Bees hummingbirds and colors representative of Latino culture
This design is at least recognizable but is just a safe non-political design that hardly reflects
the stated themes.
I would like to see more of a beach theme.
Maybe more ocean inclusion
The cultural aspect of the barrio and Carlsbad by the SEA!
If the representation of the person next to the sculpture is accurate, the design appears to be
huge. Given its apparent very large display the colors look like they will be so bold as to be
overwhelming to the viewer.
All the vast variety of plant material all the way to the ocean with items such as sea lavender
An ocean element would be good as the ocean and beach are big element of Carlsbad
identity
Ocean
Personally, I would have gone with ocean waves and ocean life, but I always like flowers, too.
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 45 of 49
10.Please tell us where you live.
Answered: 319 Skipped: 2
Answer choices Percentage Respondents
Under 18 0.00% 0
18-24 0.95% 3
25-34 6.94% 22
35-44 12.30% 39
45-54 15.14% 48
55-64 24.29% 77
65+ 40.38% 128
Total: 317
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 46 of 49
11. What is your age range?
Answered: 317 Skipped: 4
Answer choices Percentage Respondents
92008 50.47% 161
92009 14.11% 45
92010 15.67% 50
92011 12.23% 39
I don't live in Carlsbad, but I work in Carlsbad 4.39% 14
I don't live in Carlsbad, but I like to visit 3.13% 10
Total: 319
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 47 of 49
Exhibit 2: I-5 Chestnut Underpass Public Art
EAST WALL ELEVATION
WEST WALL ELEVATION
Florals Pictured: Poinsettia, Ranunculus, California Poppy, and Freesia
,
Florals Pictured: Birds of Paradise, Matilija Poppy, White Sage and Opuntia April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 48 of 49
Exhibit 2
PROCESS
The two images show how we transform our photographs into three-dimensional sculptural panels.
NORTH WALL ELEVATION
SOUTH WALLS TO MIRROR IMAGE
April 2, 2026 Item #3 Page 49 of 49
Chestnut Underpass
Public Art Update
Krystal Roa, Program Manager
Library & Cultural Arts Department
April 2, 2026
1
3 2
Caltrans & City of Carlsbad
$400,000 CIP Project No. 6098
Subcommittee Jan. 4, 2024
Community Input (In-Person & Virtual)
Early Design Concepts
Community Input (In-Person & Virtual)
PROJECT OVERVIEW
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
3
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Phase 1: Selection of artist (Winter 2024)
•Which of the artists seems like the best choice for this public art
project?
Phase 2: Artist collaboration (Spring 2025)
•How can the proposed public art design best reflect the values and
culture of the surrounding communities?
Phase 3: Feedback on the proposed artwork (Fall 2025)
•How well does this public art reflect the priorities identified in
phases 1 and 2?
4
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
INITIAL ARTWORK CONCEPT 1:
COMMUNITY SILHOUETTES
5
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
6
INITIAL ARTWORK CONCEPT 2:
COMMUNITY HATS
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
7
INITIAL ARTWORK CONCEPT 2:
COMMUNITY HATS
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
IMAGE:Sculptural “Bouquet”of both native and
cultivated flowers at Western entrance to the Underpass
IMAGE:Sculptural “Bouquet”of both Pre-Historic plants including Pines, Aspens and Oaks.
IMAGE:
North Elevation 8
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
REVISED DESIGN CONCEPT
PHASE 4 COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
•How familiar are you with the Chestnut Underpass public art
project?
•Based on the renderings, how clearly does the overall concept
come across?
•To what extent do you agree that this design reflects each of the
following themes identified by the community?
•Which theme(s) could be better reflected, and how?
•The survey also provided an opportunity for respondents to share
additional comments or suggestions related to the design.
9
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
KEY THEMES
Appreciation for adding color and visual interest
Interest in stronger connections to Carlsbad
Questions about how the design reflects the ocean
Desire for stronger representation of Barrio history and culture
Suggestions for specific plants or design refinements
10
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
QUOTES FROM THE COMMUNITY
11
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
“The bold florals feel welcoming and expressive, especially for the barrio.”
“To strengthen it even more, I would suggest incorporating plants that are
clearly associated with Carlsbad —like the Bird of Paradise, so the artwork
feels more rooted in our city and identity.”
“Ocean: there are no longer any colors or shapes reflecting ocean. Add waves,
ocean textures.”
“I don’t see anything that conveys a sense of the barrio or its culture.”
ARTWORK REFINEMENTS
12
I T E M 3 : C H E S T N U T U N D E R PA S S
Integration of community-suggested
plants.
•Birds of Paradise•Ranunculus
•Prickly Pear•Sea Lavender
•Native Succulents
Stronger connection to the ocean.Florals and symbolism used should be
connected to
Carlsbad’s community and Barrio
neighborhood.
Implement more variety of colors –
community referred to
the monochromatic design.
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ART UPDATE
Carlsbad, CA
Date: 04/02/2026
“Gardens are always produced by the interaction between plant, nature and culture.
“Gardens are always produced by the
interaction between plant, nature and culture.
Because of its conscious cultivation, every form of
garden embodies both pleasure and power, but a
constant defining feature of California, is the
significance of migration. Migration culture and
aspirations have shaped the gardens here since
the eighteenth century. In turn, the gardens have
influenced the society that has formed here.”
Paradise Transplanted: Migration and the Making of California Gardens
USC sociologist Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
FLOWER FIELDS
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
COASTAL VEGETATION AND COLOR STORY
“Gardens are deceptive. They are
seemingly place bound, enclosed,
and immobile patches of earth with
plants, yet they are products of
movement and migration”
Paradise Transplanted: Migration and the Making of California
Gardens
USC sociologist Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
FLOWER PHOTOGRAPH LIBRARY
Origin story of selected flowers. These flowers were
suggested by the Carlsbad public.
SPECIES: Poinsettia
Indigenous Roots in Mexico.
The plant we now call the poinsettia is native to Mexico, where it was known by the Aztecs as “Cuetlaxochitl.” The Aztecs used it for: Dye (from
its red bracts) and Medicine (to treat fevers)The
poinsettia is named after Joel Roberts Poinsett, the
first U.S. ambassador to Mexico.In the 1820s, he discovered the plant growing wild. He brought cuttings back to the United States and propagated
them.
SPECIES:Ranunculus
Indigenous Roots in Mediterranean region,
Southwest Asia and parts of Europe.Ranunculus seeds were brought to Carlsbad by flower grower named Luther Gage in the
early 1920’s, but it was grower Edwin Frazee
who cultivated the single petalled flowers into
full layered blooms we see in the flower fields today.
SPECIES: Mekechaa (Tongva) California
Poppy
Native for USA and Mexico. An important
plant relative to the Luiseno. Mekechaa is both food, medicine and ancestry to native people.
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
SPECIES: Bird Of ParadiseIndigenous to South Africa. The plant was likely brought to California by Europeans. It is now the
City Flower of Carlsbad. This is a great example of
how a plant from another continent can become
part of a region’s visual identity.
SPECIES:White and Black Sage, Salvia. Native to California and Mexico. It is resistant to fire and is a pollinator plant.
Used by tribes for medicine. It relieves pain.
SPECIES: Matilija PoppyNative to the California and Southern Baja chaparral and coastal scrub .The name is said
to come from the Chumash leader, Chief
Matilija. The plant has said to have medicinal
properties.
Origin story of selected flowers. These flowers were
suggested by the Carlsbad public.
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
SPECIES: Opuntia. Navut
Cacti native to the Americas. Opuntia is
commonly known as prickly pear. Its fruit
and “leaves” are edible.
SPECIES: Sea Lavender
Native to California and Mexico.
Origin story of selected flowers. These flowers were
suggested by the Carlsbad public.
SPECIES: Sea Kelp
Macrocystis pyrifera
Found along coast near Carlsbad.
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
EAST WALL
BOUQUET
ARRANGEMENT TESTS
PROCESS
The two images show how we transform our
photographs into three dimensional sculptural
panels.
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
CHESTNUT UNDERPASSPUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSALCHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
PROCESS
Metal petal panels are layered on top of
eachother. These will be bolted to each other
and the wall.
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
EAST WALL
ELEVATION
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
WEST WALL
BOUQUET
ARRANGEMENT TESTS
CHESTNUT UNDERPASS
PUBLIC ARTWORK PROPOSAL
WEST WALL
ELEVATION
29
From: Millie Paul <mbpaul444@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, March 31, 2026 5:16 PM
To: Calendar Arts <arts@carlsbadca.gov>
Subject: Updated Proposed Design for Underpass
To Whom It May Concern,
I like this updated version a lot! Thank you to the artists for
being willing to make changes--the plants have more
clarity, vibrancy and overall impact. Please vote for this
design. Thank you
Millie Paul
3421 Ann Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and
know the content is safe.
From: Kimberly Mcinerney <info@btvstudio.com>
Sent: Tuesday, March 31, 2026 5:36 PM
To: Calendar Arts <arts@carlsbadca.gov>
Subject: Chestnut underpass clarification
HI,
I really like how the design has developed.
Just to be clear, the east side will NOT have both sides the same, correct?
For example, the south east side will have Poinsettia, Ranunculus, California Poppy, and Freesia and the
northeast side will have Birds of Paradise, Matilija Poppy, White Sage and Opuntia and the southwest
side would have Birds of Paradise, Matilija Poppy, White Sage and Opuntia across from the northwest
side Poinsettia, Ranunculus, California Poppy, and Freesia.
The designs should be kitty corner.
The idea of having a mirror image is disgusting.
Thanks,
Kimberly McInerney
4216 Isle Drive
08
CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the
content is safe.
From: ROBERT R CLOSE <motcon@aol.com>
Sent: Tuesday, March 31, 2026 9:59 PM
To: Calendar Arts <arts@carlsbadca.gov>
Subject: Chestnut. Art
Not a Ranunculi or Bird of Paradise in the works!
Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS
CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and
know the content is safe.
From: Gayle Cadwallader <gjcadwallader@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, April 1, 2026 9:48 PM
To: Calendar Arts <arts@carlsbadca.gov>
Subject: Comments on Chestnut Underpass Art
The flowers are lovely. The colors are bright and hopeful, remind me of Latin celebrations,
and Carlsbad.
As someone who has photographed 770 of the species native to San Diego County, I do not
recognise the orange and salmon flowers in the lower right of the artwork for the east side. I
viewed the updated design concept, but only four of the five flowers depicted on the east
side are identified. It reminds me of a passion flower, but has the wrong number of petals -
6 vs 5 petals and 5 sepals. Likewise, a hibiscus has 5 petals, not 6, and rose species have
multiples of 5 petals. From the description of the Process, I can't tell how many petals the
photo has, but they all look like they are the same color, not alternating orange and salmon
like the transformation has. Also, the transformation looks cartoonish - too flat and
symmetrical, not even hinting at natural. The yellow in the center, representing the
reproductive parts, also looks too stylized, and the number (7) looks off - usually flowers
have the same number of stamens as petals, or a multiple. Please revisit this one. It will
bother me every time I pass by if I can identify only 9 of the 10 flowers depicted.
I don't see the "sea kelp" nor "ocean-inspired tones" that were allegedly added. I don't see
green stems and leaves as kelp, nor ocean-inspired.
Gayle Cadwallader
92010
CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and
know the content is safe.