Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-06-09; City Council; 14; Options for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements ProjectCA Review TL Meeting Date: To: From: Staff Contact: tom.frank@carlsbadca.gov, 442-339-2766 Subject: District: Recommended Action 1)Adopt a resolution directing the City Manager to proceed with final design, environmental review and permitting for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project to include road resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard and to consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement is completed; or 2)Adopt a resolution directing the City Manager to proceed with final design, environmental review and permitting for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project to include road resurfacing and restriping and construction of a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard. Executive Summary The Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project was initially planned to include a roundabout at Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road, lane reductions on Cannon Road west of the railroad tracks and a traffic signal at Cerezo Drive. Following community feedback against the roundabout, the City Council re-evaluated the project scope and, on Oct. 28, 2025, approved a smaller-scale project, which could include sidewalks, street resurfacing and restriping. At that meeting, staff told the City Council they would return with conceptual designs and public input so that the City Council could decide upon the placement of the sidewalk on Carlsbad Boulevard. Consistent with the City Council’s action, staff have since prepared conceptual designs with options for sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard. Based on the conceptual layout, adding sidewalks would result in a loss of up to half of the parking spaces on Carlsbad Boulevard within the project area. Installing sidewalks on only one side of the street would preserve parking on the other side of the street, while proceeding with no sidewalks at this time would avoid impacts on parking. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 1 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 In March and April 2026, staff gathered hundreds of comments from community members on the placement of sidewalks and related parking impacts. Feedback was split, with just over half of responses in an online input form saying they were opposed to new sidewalks in the area, with parking impacts cited as a common concern. Additional public input was received at the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission meeting on April 6, 2026, when staff presented options for improvements in the project area. The commissioners recommended that the City Council: •Proceed with resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard •Consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement1 with Cabrillo Power I LLC (a subsidiary of NRG Energy) and San Diego Gas & Electric is completed •Evaluate other parking opportunities with State Parks on the bluff area The City Council is now being asked to decide whether to include a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard as part of the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project. Explanation & Analysis Project area The project area covers about one mile of Carlsbad Boulevard, the main coastal road and scenic byway through the city, between Tierra Del Oro Street and Manzano Drive, and a quarter mile of Cannon Road between Carlsbad Boulevard and Avenida Encinas. The stretch of Carlsbad Boulevard within the project area is a two-lane road without sidewalks or designated parking. The road presents a unique challenge in that it is the only way to access the coastline between Cannon Road and Palomar Airport Road, making it heavily traveled. It is also flanked by homes on both sides, with driveway access directly onto the roadway. 1 The Seaside Transaction Agreement is a final negotiated settlement agreement between the city, Cabrillo Power I LLC and San Diego Gas & Electric that includes a land transfer to the city for an area north of Cannon Road on the east side of Carlsbad Boulevard, immediately north and east of the Terramar project area. The approval process and fulfillment of the obligations of this agreement is expected to take about five to seven years after the effective date of the agreement, which was April 16, 2025. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 2 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 City plans In 2015, an update of the General Plan’s Mobility Element, the element that covers transportation, changed the designation of this roadway to a “Coastal Street,” a designation that provides for a wider array of options for meeting traffic, safety and overall mobility needs in the area. The Sustainable Mobility Plan has also identified the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project area as requiring enhanced pedestrian and bicycle facilities. The plan also recognized the two project corridors of Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road as “transformative corridors” with the goal of establishing a multimodal backbone network, one designed for all modes of travel, comprising high-quality bikeways, pedestrian facilities and transit services. Road volume • Carlsbad Boulevard is a major north-south coastal route through the city with an average traffic volume of 13,000 vehicles per day. • Cannon Road is a major east-west connector route through the central portion of the city with an average traffic volume of 7,400 vehicles per day. Carlsbad Boulevard ranks as the most-used corridor for bicycle travel out of all the streets in the city. The table below provides a summary of the bicyclist and pedestrian daily volumes on Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road. Bicyclists and pedestrians’ average daily traffic Location / type of day Bicyclists Pedestrians Carlsbad Boulevard - Weekday 786 402 Carlsbad Boulevard - Weekend 1,853 780 Cannon Road - Weekday 203 129 Cannon Road - Weekend 305 168 Source: Carlsbad Active Transportation Monitoring Report Year 3 Data collected in September 2024 Issues project is to address The Terramar project area has several mobility, beach access, shoreline protection and resident quality of life issues that need to be addressed: • Lack of sidewalks results in walkers, bicyclists, joggers, strollers and other users competing to share the roadway shoulder or use the street • Beachgoers often park on neighborhood streets, limiting parking for residents The Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project includes the following goals: • Create a balanced road for vehicles, bicyclists and pedestrians • Maintain traffic flow with vehicle speeds compatible with a residential neighborhood • Improve access to the coast and create an enhanced connection between the beach and the community June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 3 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Collision data There was a total of 40 reported collisions on Carlsbad Boulevard between Tierra Del Oro Street and Manzano Drive over the five-year period from 2021 through 2025 according to the city database of collisions maintained by the Police Department. Of these, 35 were injury collisions, and none was fatal. No pedestrian‑involved collisions occurred during this period. There were 10 bicyclist‑involved collisions, including four bike‑only incidents in which no vehicles were involved. Timeline Following several years of community involvement, the City Council has considered designs intended to improve access, safety and operations for all modes of travel including vehicles, pedestrians, bicyclists and transit riders. Oct. 15, 2013 The City Council directed staff to pursue livable streets2 improvements on Carlsbad Boulevard and expand the area in which improvement projects should be initiated to include the area from the north city limit to the south city limit. Nov. 27, 2018 The City Council selected a preferred project alternative, which included a roundabout at Cannon Road and a traffic signal at Cerezo Drive, and authorized staff to move forward with the environmental review, permitting and final engineering. Oct. 28, 2025 The City Council revisited the project scope and approved a smaller-scale project to include sidewalks and street resurfacing and restriping, without a roundabout. At this meeting, staff stated that the conceptual designs would be brought back to the City Council in the spring of 2026 for further direction on sidewalk placement and with updated community input. The related Carlsbad Boulevard Water and Sewer Improvements at Terramar Project, Capital Improvement Program Project Nos. 5048 and 5503-20, was completed in March 2026. The utilities work in that project was previously included in the original scope of work presented to the City Council in November 2018. Public engagement In March and April 2026, following the change in project scope, staff gathered input to help guide decisions about potential improvements. Community members were invited to provide input through three channels: •Completing an online input form •Emailing the Transportation Department •Attending the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission meeting on April 6, 2026 It’s important to note that the online form was not a scientific or statistically significant survey. It should be considered with the same weight as an email or public comment. 2 Livable streets, also known as "complete streets," are roadways designed to be safe, convenient and accessible for all users — not just drivers — including pedestrians, cyclists, transit riders and people of all ages and abilities. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 4 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Nearly 350 responses were received through the online form, from Terramar residents and people who live in other areas and visit Terramar frequently. The community input summary and all verbatim comments received are included as Exhibit 3. Summary of responses: • 67% of responses indicated they live elsewhere and visit the area frequently. The remaining 33% indicated they live and/or own property in the Terramar area. • 52% did not support any new sidewalks. • Of those that supported sidewalks, most indicated a preference for sidewalks on both sides of the street or the west side only; 10% favored sidewalks on the east side only. • This sentiment was consistent among both Terramar residents and those who live in other areas and visit Terramar frequently. Several common themes were noted from the community input, including: • Pavement condition concerns • A desire to maintain neighborhood characteristics, including vegetation • Preference for natural pathway instead of paved sidewalk • Parking concerns, impacts on neighborhood streets • Lack of pedestrian demand on the east side • Need for safety improvements for pedestrians • Safety concerns at Cerezo Drive intersection • Privacy concerns • Pedestrian visibility concerns with the existing conditions Additional information about the community engagement process and the feedback provided is included in the community input summary, Exhibit 3. The city shared information about the input opportunity through a variety of channels, including: • Terramar Association meeting (March 12, 2026) • Postcard mailer to Terramar residents and property owners • Information in the City Manager’s Update newsletter • Social media posts • Emails to people who expressed interest in the project • Website updates Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission recommendation Staff presented the public feedback and possible options for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project to the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission to get its feedback and recommended option. Staff reminded the commission that it could provide recommendations on any other improvements to the project area. The commissioners recommended that the City Council: • Proceed with resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard • Consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement is completed • Evaluate other parking opportunities with State Parks on the bluff area June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 5 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 The staff report presented to the commission is provided as Exhibit 4 and the meeting minutes are provided as Exhibit 5. Fiscal Analysis The Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project, Capital Improvement Program Project No. 6054, has received prior appropriations of $12.1 million from traffic impact fees, General Capital Construction funds, TransNet funds and public facilities fees.3 Approximately $2.5 million has been expended to date, leaving an unspent balance of about $9.6 million. Sufficient funding is available for either Option 1 or Option 2. With the smaller-scale project approved by the City Council on Oct. 28, 2025, the forecasted construction phase budget of $7.2 million for fiscal year, or FY, 2026-27 will not be needed and can be used for other projects. Staff also propose to return a portion of appropriated funding in FY 2026-27. The table below provides more details. Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project Capital Improvement Program Project No. 6054 Total appropriation to date $12,100,000 Total expenditures and encumbrances to date -$2,458,847 Return appropriated funding – Transnet transportation tax -$1,000,000 Return appropriated funding – General Capital Construction fund -$998,151 Return appropriated funding – Traffic impact fees -$2,600,000 Total available balance after funding is returned $5,043,002 Options Option 1: Adopt a resolution directing the City Manager to proceed with the final design, environmental review and permitting for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project to include road resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard and to consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Agreement Transaction is completed. (Exhibit 1) This option is estimated to cost $1.5 million and could take about two years to complete the design, bidding and construction. Sidewalks could be reconsidered at a future date when the Seaside Transaction Agreement is completed, the land use at the NRG site north of Cannon Park at the intersection of Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road is better defined and other parking opportunities are identified. Road resurfacing and restriping are needed because construction has been completed for the Carlsbad Boulevard Water and Sewer Improvements at Terramar Project and to maintain the existing pavement infrastructure. If this option is selected, staff would target returning to the City Council to request adoption of plans, specifications and contract documents and award of a construction contract for only the road resurfacing and restriping as part of the pavement management program in 2027. Staff 3 TransNet is a countywide sales tax collected to fund regional transportation projects. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 6 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 will also consider a secondary project in the future when other parking opportunities have been identified as well as coordinating with State Parks on the bluff area. Pros • Addresses the strongest signal of support resulting from the community outreach conducted March–April 2026 • This is the least costly option that is needed after completion of the water and sewer improvements construction in early 2026 and to maintain the pavement. • Excess funding could be returned to respective funding sources for use on other projects • Quickest to complete, minimizes immediate disruption to residents and businesses • Maintains on-street parking on both sides of Carlsbad Boulevard • The city could revisit the need for additional street and mobility improvements later Cons • Pedestrians would continue to use the roadway shoulder for walking and coastal access since sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard would not be considered until a later date Option 2: Adopt a resolution directing the City Manager to proceed with the final design, environmental review and permitting for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project to include road resurfacing and restriping and construction of a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard (Exhibit 2). This option would include road resurfacing and restriping and construction of a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard from Tierra Del Oro Street to Cerezo Drive. This option is estimated to cost approximately $3 to $4 million and could take about two to three years to complete. If this option is selected, staff would complete the final design, environmental studies and permitting and target returning to the City Council to request adoption of plans, specifications and contract documents and award of a construction contract in mid-2028. Pros • Provides Americans with Disabilities Act-compliant pedestrian access with new sidewalks along the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard from Tierra Del Oro Street to Cerezo Drive • Serves the primary pedestrian destination, South Carlsbad State Beach, by providing a sidewalk on the ocean-facing or west side of Carlsbad Boulevard • Preserves available parking on the east side of Carlsbad Boulevard Cons • Removes about 23 shoulder parking spots • A sidewalk gap would remain on the east side of Carlsbad Boulevard • Sidewalk improvements on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard would inconvenience adjacent property owners and the public during construction June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 7 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Next Steps Staff will proceed with the selected option and work on the final design, environmental review and permitting. Staff will return to the City Council at a future date for adoption of plans, specifications and contract documents and award of a construction contract. Environmental Evaluation The proposed action is not a “project” as defined by California Environmental Quality Act, or CEQA, Section 21065 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(b)(5) and does not require environmental review under CEQA Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3) and 15061(b)(3), because the proposed action of the City Council providing direction on improvements within the project area is an organizational or administrative government activity that does not involve any commitment to any specific project which may result in a potentially significant physical impact on the environment. Any subsequent action or direction stemming from the proposed action may require preparation of an environmental document in accordance with CEQA or the CEQA Guidelines. Exhibits 1. City Council resolution – Option 1 2. City Council resolution – Option 2 3. Community Input Summary and Input Form Responses 4. Staff report from April 6, 2026, Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission Meeting (on file in the Office of the City Clerk) 5. Minutes from April 6, 2026, Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission meeting (on file in the Office of the City Clerk) June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 8 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Exhibit 1 RESOLUTION NO. 2026-113 . A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, DIRECTING THE CITY MANAGER TO PROCEED WITH FINAL DESIGN, ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW AND PERMITTING FOR THE TERRAMAR AREA COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT TO INCLUDE ROAD RESURFACING AND RESTRIPING WITH NO SIDEWALKS ON CARLSBAD BOULEVARD AND TO CONSIDER A POTENTIAL SECONDARY PROJECT FOR THIS AREA AFTER THE SEASIDE TRANSACTION AGREEMENT IS COMPLETED WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California has determined that it is necessary, desirable, and in the public interest to make improvements on Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road within the limits of the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project, Capital Improvement Program, Project No. 6054; and WHEREAS, on Oct. 28, 2025, the City Council reviewed three options and selected the option to proceed with a smaller-scale project consisting of certain roadway and sidewalk improvements with resurfacing and restriping on Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road within the project limits, and no roundabout and no lane reductions for the project; and WHEREAS, consistent with the City Council’s action, staff prepared conceptual designs and conducted public engagement from mid-March to early April 2026 to invite community feedback on the proposed sidewalk, pavement, parking and striping improvements within the project area; and WHEREAS, hundreds of community members participated in the process; and WHEREAS, conceptual design options for the project were presented to the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission for its feedback and recommendations on April 6, 2026; and WHEREAS, the commission recommended that the City Council proceed with resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard and consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement with Cabrillo I LLC (a subsidiary of NRG Energy) and San Diego Gas & Electric is completed; and WHEREAS, the Seaside Transaction Agreement is a final negotiated settlement agreement that includes a land transfer to the city for the area north of Cannon Road on the east side of Carlsbad Boulevard, immediately north of the Terramar project area. The approval process and fulfillment of the obligations of this agreement is expected to take approximately five to seven years after the effective date of the agreement, April 16, 2025; and June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 9 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 WHEREAS, on June 9, 2026, the City Council reviewed options for sidewalks, pavement, parking and striping improvements in the project area and selected the option to direct the City Manager to proceed with final design, environmental review and permitting for the project that will include road resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard and consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement is completed; and WHEREAS, sufficient funding has been appropriated in the project account. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California, as follows: 1.That the above recitations are true and correct. 2.That the City Council has determined that the proposed action is not a “project” as defined by the California Environmental Quality Act, or CEQA, Section 21065 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(b)(5) and does not require environmental review under CEQA Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3) and 15061(b)(3), because the proposed action of the City Council providing direction on improvements within the project area is an administrative government activity that does not involve any commitment to any specific project which may result in a potentially significant physical impact on the environment. Any subsequent action or direction stemming from the proposed action may require preparation of an environmental document in accordance with CEQA or the CEQA Guidelines. 3.That the City Council directs the City Manager to proceed with final design, environmental review and permitting for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project, CIP Project No. 6054 to include road resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard and consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement is completed. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 10 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of Carlsbad on the 9th day of June, 2026, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: Blackburn, Burkholder, Shin. NAYS: Bhat-Patel, Acosta. ABSTAIN: ABSENT: ______________________________________ KEITH BLACKBURN, Mayor ______________________________________ SHERRY FREISINGER, City Clerk (SEAL) June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 11 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Exhibit 2 RESOLUTION NO. . A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, DIRECTING THE CITY MANAGER TO PROCEED WITH FINAL DESIGN, ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW AND PERMITTING FOR THE TERRAMAR AREA COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT TO INCLUDE ROAD RESURFACING AND RESTRIPING AND CONSTRUCTION OF A SIDEWALK ON THE WEST SIDE OF CARLSBAD BOULEVARD WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California has determined that it is necessary, desirable, and in the public interest to construct a smaller-scale project consisting of certain roadway and sidewalk improvements with resurfacing and restriping on Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road within the limits of the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project, Capital Improvement Program, or CIP, Project No. 6054, or Project; and WHEREAS, on Oct. 28, 2025, the City Council reviewed three options and selected the option to proceed with a smaller scale project consisting of certain roadway and sidewalk improvements with resurfacing and restriping on Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road within the Project limits, and no roundabout and no lane reductions for the Project; and WHEREAS, consistent with the City Council’s action, staff prepared conceptual designs and conducted public engagement from mid-March to early April 2026 to invite community feedback on the proposed resurfacing and restriping improvements and the placement of sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard within the project area; and WHEREAS, hundreds of community members participated in the process; and WHEREAS, the conceptual design options for the Project were presented to the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission, or TS&MC, for its feedback and recommendations on April 6, 2026; and WHEREAS, the TS&MC recommended that the City Council proceed with resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard and consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement with Cabrillo I LLC (a subsidiary of NRG Energy) and San Diego Gas & Electric is completed, with a vote of 5/0/0/2 with two absences (Commissioners Newlands and Schuck); and WHEREAS, the Seaside Transaction Agreement is a final negotiated settlement agreement that includes a land transfer to the city for the area north of Cannon Road on the east side of Carlsbad Boulevard, immediately north of the Terramar project area. The approval process and fulfillment of the June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 12 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 obligations of this agreement is expected to take approximately five to seven years after the effective date of the agreement, April 16, 2025; and WHEREAS, on June 9, 2026, the City Council reviewed options for pavement, sidewalks, parking and striping improvements in the Project area and selected the option to direct the City Manager to proceed with final design, environmental review and permitting for the Project that will include road resurfacing and restriping and construction of a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard; and WHEREAS, sufficient funding has been appropriated in the project account. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California, as follows: 1. That the above recitations are true and correct. 2. That the City Council has determined that the proposed action is not a “project” as defined by the California Environmental Quality Act, or CEQA, Section 21065 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(b)(5) and does not require environmental review under CEQA Guidelines Section 15060(c)(3) and 15061(b)(3), because the proposed action of the City Council providing direction on improvements within the project area is an administrative government activity that does not involve any commitment to any specific project which may result in a potentially significant physical impact on the environment. Any subsequent action or direction stemming from the proposed action may require preparation of an environmental document in accordance with CEQA or the CEQA Guidelines. 3. That the City Council directs the City Manager to proceed with final design, environmental review and permitting for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project, CIP Project No. 6054, to include road resurfacing and restriping and construction of a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 13 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of Carlsbad on the __ day of ________, 2026, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NAYS: ABSTAIN: ABSENT: ______________________________________ KEITH BLACKBURN, Mayor ______________________________________ SHERRY FREISINGER, City Clerk (SEAL) June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 14 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Area Street Improvements Community Input Summary About the project The City of Carlsbad is developing a project to address long-standing traffic and safety concerns in the Terramar neighborhood, along Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road. A large-scale project was previously planned for the area, which included a roundabout at Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road, lane reductions on Cannon Road west of the railroad tracks and a traffic signal at Cerezo Drive. Following community feedback regarding roundabouts, the City Council re-evaluated the project scope and in October 2025, directed staff to explore a smaller-scale project. In March and April 2026, the city gathered input to help guide decisions about potential improvements, including: •New sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard on one or both sides of the street •Resurfacing and restriping Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road Parking impacts If new sidewalks are installed, some of the parking currently available off the shoulder of Carlsbad Boulevard would need to be removed. On the west side of the street, new parking spots could be added near the southern end of the new sidewalk to help offset parking loss further north. Here is how parking in the area could be impacted if sidewalks are installed: •Westside sidewalk only: Reduced by 23 spots •Eastside sidewalk only: Reduced by 11 spots •Sidewalks on both sides: Reduced by 34 spots How we engaged Community members were invited to provide input through three channels: •Completing an online input form •Emailing traffic@carlsbadca.gov •Attending the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission meeting on April 6, 2026 Additionally, city staff attended a Terramar Association meeting on Thursday, March 12, to discuss options with Terramar residents and property owners, and to raise awareness of the input opportunity. Exhibit 3 June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 15 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 2 Online input form Available March 10-25, 2026 Responses: 347 June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 16 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 3 How the opportunities were promoted The city shared information about the input opportunity through a variety of channels, including: • Attending a Terramar Association meeting on March 12, 2026 • Postcard mailer sent to Terramar residents and property owners • Information in the City Manager’s Update newsletter • Social media posts • Emails to project interest lists • Website updates What we heard Comments and survey responses have been categorized into overall themes and topics below. Readers are strongly encouraged to review the verbatim comments in Appendix A to get a better understanding of specific ideas, priorities and concerns expressed. It is important to note that the online form was not a scientific or statistically significant survey. It should be considered with the same weight as an email to a commission or a public comment. The city received input from Terramar residents and people who live in other areas and visit the area frequently. 33%67%Terramar residents and/or property owners Live elsewhere and visit the area June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 17 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 4 Feedback on potential sidewalks was split fairly evenly, with about 52% of responses opposed to sidewalks, with parking impacts cited as a common concern. About 47% of responses supported sidewalks on one or both sides of the street. This sentiment was consistent among both Terramar residents and those who live in other areas and visit Terramar frequently. 47%52% 1%Yes sidewalks No sidewalks No response 52%47% 1% Sidewalk preference (Terramar residents) No sidewalks Yes sidewalks Did not respond June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 18 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 5 Among all respondents who favor adding sidewalks, most indicated a preference for sidewalks on both sides or the west side of the street (about 90%). 53%47% Sidewalk preference (non-residents) No sidewalks Yes sidewalks 52% 38% 10% Preferred sidewalk placement (those who favor sidewalks) Sidewalks on both sides Sidewalks on west Sidewalks on east June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 19 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 6 Key themes summary (online input form) This section provides a summary of common feedback provided through the online input form, divided up based on key themes and the respondents’ preferences for sidewalks in the area. This summary does not include verbatim comments, which are available in Appendix A. Responses not in favor of sidewalks (52%) • • Installing sidewalks that reduce existing parking would change how residents use the area because the coastal parking is a critical access point. These spaces are used for surfing, fishing and beach recreation, often carrying boards and gear. • Installing sidewalks would reduce parking in the area, reduce public access to the coast and take away important parking for residents. • It's already difficult to find parking. • Not in favor of reducing parking for existing homeowners. The loss of parking spaces would outweigh any potential improvement. • Removing parking would limit beach access for residents with disabilities. • Sidewalks would be great, but not if parking is lost. • Street parking is more important than sidewalks. More cars now use the area than people walking. • Taking away parking for beachgoers would push them into the neighborhoods. • There is currently not enough parking for Terramar break surfers. Pedestrian impacts • bike lane. Currently, they run close to the homes, which is deemed better. • If the city installs a sidewalk, a slightly wider “trail” on the west side for walkers/runners would be preferred. • Skepticism that sidewalks on the east side would be utilized by the public. Runners and walkers now use the west side of the street to enjoy coastal views. • Some respondents would use the sidewalk, but they don’t have a problem running on the asphalt currently. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 20 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 7 • However the parking is a more important issue, and Cannon Park needs its own parking. • reducing parking. • Installing sidewalks could increase traffic congestion due to less character impacts • Adding sidewalks would reduce the scenic nature of the current dirt shoulder. • Preference for dirt paths over concrete sidewalks. • Sidewalks would diminish the natural beauty of the area. Responses in favor of installing sidewalks (47%) Parking impacts • Sidewalk improvements may help reduce these impacts. • Adding sidewalks would be wonderful, however if it can't connect all the way to the beach entrance, then the positive impact would be minimal. Especially if residents can't find parking to get out of their cars to walk on the sidewalk. • I don't use parking on the west side. Parking on the east side is used for residents and short-term rental guests, not coastal visitors. • Improve access while minimally impacting parking. • Installing sidewalks on one side only will improve pedestrian access to the coast while limiting parking impacts to neighborhoods that are already impacted by beachgoers. • It's already hard to park. Taking away spaces would make the problem much worse. • Parking should be reduced. Currently, there is insufficient sight distance to avoid hitting vehicles, bicycles and e-bikes. • Removing parking on the West side would not impact me. There is plenty of parking along Carlsbad Blvd. north of Terramar along the seawall, on Cannon and the Palomar dirt lot. • Removing parking will greatly impact the community by reducing access to the tide pools, surfing and coast. • Removing parking would make it safer for cyclists by preventing "dooring" while cycling. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 21 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 8 • park in the neighborhoods. • Respondents reported varied views of reducing parking. • Respondents would not be able to use the street to park by their house, but it would be safer for pedestrians. • Suggestions to consider garage parking like Laguna Beach with Hearing HERO signage to remind drivers of hearing-impaired residents. • The city might consider using some of the property at the old Power Plant site for paid parking like Newport where parking is scarce as a potential revenue source. • Traffic would flow more smoothly through the area without motorists circling and stopping suddenly to park. impacts • A paved path is preferred over gravel or dirt access for pedestrians and dog walkers. The current terrain is rocky and uneven. • A sidewalk would improve access for people with strollers, canes or difficulty walking. • Adding curbs to separate traffic from pedestrians would be an improvement. • It is currently dangerous with parked cars, runners, walkers and dogs darting in and out dodging bikes and cars. • Improve pedestrian safety by making it safer to walk in the area. • It would clean up the area, provide a better surface for walking and provide a clear understanding of where and how to park in only available spaces. • It would create a safe, continuous path for walking in both directions and avoid forcing people to cross the street or walk in traffic. Sidewalks on both sides would make the neighborhood safer, more accessible and more usable for daily walking. • It would improve safety for pedestrians and cyclists that have a hearing impairment. Currently, one resident has had "near misses" with cars. • Paved sidewalks would make it easier to walk, including when it’s rainy and muddy. • Sidewalks on both sides would help prevent jaywalking and relieve congestion by not confining it to the west side only. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 22 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 9 • Sidewalks would improve ADA access to the coast. • West side is preferred for sidewalks. East side is preferred for resident parking and accessing driveways. • Would encourage leisurely walks and not having to worry about the congestion on the west side and safety on the east side. • Would improve access from the end of the seawall sidewalk to the Terramar area. • Would make it safer for residents who live on the east side of the street to walk to the beach. • Would support the way travelers currently use the area, with most pedestrians using the west side. • • Would make the bike lane safer. Currently, pedestrians, runners and bikers are all using the skinny bike lane. • 101. • Motorists would feel safer knowing that pedestrians, strollers and individuals with limited mobility have a designated and unobstructed path. • Would make driving safer because it would help motorists see pedestrians when driving. Note: 1% of respondents did not answer the question “Should the city install sidewalks in this area?” Key themes summary (email correspondence) The city received more than a dozen emails related to the project before the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission meeting on April 6, 2026. A compilation of all emails received is available in the meeting materials on the city’s website. Key themes from email correspondence included: • Concerns about pavement condition • Importance of maintaining neighborhood characteristics, including vegetation June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 23 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 10 • Preference for natural pathway instead of paved sidewalk • Parking concerns and potential impacts on neighborhood streets • Lack of pedestrians on the east side • Need for safety improvements for pedestrians • Safety concerns at Cerezo Drive intersection • Privacy concerns • Pedestrian visibility concerns with existing conditions Public comments at the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission Meeting Twelve residents provided public comments at the Carlsbad Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission Meeting on April 6, 2026, during agenda item 3. Options for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project. A summary of public comments received during the commission meeting is available in the meeting minutes from the April 6, 2026. After reviewing community input, the Carlsbad Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission recommended that the City Council: • Proceed with resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard • Consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement1 with Cabrillo Power I LLC (a subsidiary of NRG Energy) and San Diego Gas & Electric is completed • Evaluate other parking opportunities with State Parks on the bluff area Next steps The City Council will consider the commission’s recommendation, along with community feedback at an upcoming meeting in June 2026. Following the City Council meeting, staff will develop the final engineering design and conduct environmental review and permitting consistent with the option approved by the City Council. Staff will then return to the City Council at a future date to award a construction contract. Sign up to receive email updates on this project. 1 The Seaside Transaction Agreement is a final negotiated settlement agreement between the city, Cabrillo Power I LLC and San Diego Gas & Electric that includes a land transfer to the city for an area north of Cannon Road on the east side of Carlsbad Boulevard, immediately north and east of the Terramar project area. The approval process and fulfillment of the obligations of this agreement is expected to take approximately five to seven years after the effective date of the agreement, April 16, 2025. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 24 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 11 Appendix A Input Form Responses Total Responses: 347 How would you describe yourself? How do you typically use the streets in the Terramar area? When you use street parking in this area, what is the primary reason for the city install sidewalks in this area? How would installing new sidewalks change how you use the street? How would removing parking affect you? elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here an issue for locals visiting or with the homeowners. Could also increase congestion in the elsewhere run or use a mobility both sides area for people to walk me directly June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 25 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 12 elsewhere and visit the area frequently don't park the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and change that would affect the bike lanes. would make it safer for cyclists; no door zones elsewhere and visit the area frequently transit; Walk, run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street on the east side. Both east and west are ideal. The dirt path on west side is okay for now and many use that path daily. The east side is not usable as a pedestrian so a side walk is welcomed! Plus east side is not used for parking. Overall, this is long overdue and thank you for considering this impact me personally. I ride my bike and walk / run Terramar. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here reduce parking at the coast? That is reducing public access to the beach. Placing side walks would likely cause the center lane to be removed which would increase safety concerns. Residents could not access their homes without stopping traffic, fire dept wouldn't have a lane to use to respond to emergencies. Sidewalks on the Eastside would require the taxpayers to pay for new driveways because the grade of the driveways will be impacted. The safety would be less parking to access the coast. Which is in conflict with the Coastal Act, and is someones pipe dream. Spend the money to save our beaches which we're losing to sea level rise. Waste of money - spend it on removing the southbound land of Carlsbad Blvd and leave us with a sandy beach. Please publish ALL the comments for full disclosure. We don't need another cherry June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 26 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 13 reason. the City. Please listen to the residents of Terra elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore beaches terramar reef elsewhere and visit the area frequently both sides of the street cyclists from pedestrians, primarily on west side. It also make the street safer and more inviting to potential "dooring" while cycling. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Other: Parking!!! coast think sidewalks should be installed here frequently. I have never heard anyone express the need for a sidewalk here. The loss of parking spaces far outweighs any potential improvement. It's already hard enough to elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore help keep runners and walkers out of the bike lanes, improving safety for all. sidewalks will reduce parking... cars are currently parking parallel to the roadway. elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street there. I prefer to have sidewalks for my walks somewhere else elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed without sidewalks in Carlsbad & this is not a good place to mess around. Leave the Carlsbad drive by there almost every day bc I go to the beach to walk there. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 27 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 14 Resurface the roads bc they need it. take away parking, the people will push into Terramar neighborhoods, parking there, which I'm sure the people who live there will not appreciate. We have many streets in Olde Carlsbad w no sidewalks. You can't put sidewalks everywhere due to how it's already built. Put the $$ into speed monitoring signs on Carlsbad Blvd & along the hill down towards north elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore lanes safer park on Cerezo elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore currently pedestrians, runners and bikers are all using the skinny bike lane harder to start my walk from that area elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore more frequently to walk along the coast harder to park during peak times elsewhere and visit mobility device like a walker or coast both sides of the bikers, etc have a hearing impairment. I personal feel there should be garage June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 28 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 15 frequently comes behind me and have had several near misses in the area due to this lost sense. Hearing HERO signage up to remind others that those with the hearing loss disability have issues hearing and hopefully it will help elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and total nightmare! owners on the east side should welcome a sidewalk. They would be able to remove the no parking signs and have nicer curb elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here sidewalks in this area, and I especially think that sidewalks on the eastern side of the street would not be utilized by the public. Everybody is on the west side of the street so they can access the coastal views on their on the west side of the street would make it harder to access the coast near terramar elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here going to add to anything it will take away from the properties values and the natural coastal feel of the neighborhood, and the money would better served elsewhere and visit the area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street enough parking, I will use my bike. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 29 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 16 the area wheelchair street walking a hazard. elsewhere and visit the area both sides of the street how I use the street. me as I simply drive past the area regularly. elsewhere and visit the area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street not be walking in the streets & be safer for everyone. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here traffic lanes causing hazards and seem to reduce parking. There are bigger issues with eroding bluffs and pedestrian use of these areas and accessing the access for visitors. This is already an issue elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed parking situation even worse. access to the coast. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) improve access from the end of the seawall sidewalk to the Terramar area. parking would be removed, there is plenty of parking along Carlsbad Blvd north of Terramar (along the seawall), on Cannon, and the elsewhere and visit the area frequently Cannon Park the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore not change how I use the street. would not impact me. elsewhere and visit run or use a mobility device like a walker both sides of the and running in the area. would make the area safer for June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 30 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 17 elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore area. I park further north. elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street walks in a much safer way elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore comfortable walking in the area with a dedicated sidewalk inconvenience elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed sidewalk, but I don't have a problem running on the asphalt currently. locals out of parking, taking parking away from non local visitors. elsewhere and visit the area frequently Walk, run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here decrease the parking. There are many visitors to the area for the beaches. The area is used mainly by runners/walkers besides people parking. Adding a sidewalk will push runners further into traffic. Currently they run close to the homes which is better. You'll also have more runners in a "bike lane" competing for space. elsewhere run or use a mobility coast think more dangerous by access to the beach June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 31 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 18 frequently or wheelchair installed here would remove parking reducing access to the beach for surfing. It would reduce access during construction. It would reduce the scenic nature of the current dirt shoulder. the street which has proven dangerous (e.g., Canon). It would shift the parking burden onto residential areas. It would increase traffic while people elsewhere and visit the area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street walking on a sidewalk. Also, there is less worry about mud and puddles elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street likely to walk between Cannon and Palomar. lot at Tamarack, along PCH across from old power plant, or on Cannon, elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed for us to visit the beach here because of less parking spots. to visit the beach here. We love visiting here when we can. We live in elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore safer as a pedestrian because people speed up going south on Carlsbad after Cannon. parking on the west side. The east side is primarily used by residents and short term rental guests, not coastal visitors. elsewhere and visit use a mobility device like a walker both sides of the run in this area and it would be safer. about the parking. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 32 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 19 frequently gutters, which would help with safety and elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed I walk harder to find a spot to park elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair think sidewalks should be installed in adjacent neighborhood streets. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair on Carlsbad Blvd think sidewalks should be installed here sidewalk was needed when I walk or run on Carlsbad Blvd. And driving through I've never felt like walkers/runners interfered. If you do put a sidewalk in I'd prefer a slightly wider "trail" on the west side for walkers/runners to use that side. I never walk elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here pedestrians fumbled all onto a sidewalk poor decision for accessing the beach and ocean. Many folks park on Carlsbad Blvd to get to Terramar public elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore and walkers a dedicated safe space. me at all. elsewhere use a mobility coast think CBAD and the coast June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 33 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 20 frequently or wheelchair installed here livable and why we have such a high elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here parking as it is to enjoy the beautiful cliff side trail, and the beach. You will be forcing people to use dangerous crossings. would you reduce parking in a place that has extremely limited parking as it is? There are two very important coastal access points. There are both the trail at the cliff and the beach below and you're taking like 30 spots out of it. Why would elsewhere and visit the area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street people who frequent the area. It's currently not safe without the elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore would make it much safer for biking and running. all. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair Recreation bike or walk and use PAR by bike or drive to avoid the I-5 by bike use of the street me. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra for runners and walkers in the area June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 34 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 21 elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here frequently due to lack of parking. Parking is already difficult enough in this area. Removing more than half of the parking to add sidewalks to a small stretch of road that will eventually turn back to dirt or merge back into the road is just plain dumb. Show us the statistics that indicate there is a need for sidewalks here, including past injuries suck. This is very popular area, especially for surfers. Parking is already difficult to nearly impossible. Removing more than half of the sidewalks would make a bad problem worse and limit access to this area. elsewhere and visit the area frequently transit; Walk, run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street driving through the area knowing that pedestrians, strollers, and individuals with limited mobility have a designated and more smoothly through the area without people circling and stopping suddenly to park. elsewhere and visit the area coast both sides of the street of those who are walking. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and walk in the area. typically park in this area. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street greater sense of safety in having even surfaces, which would be appropriately separated from parking and bike walking/running and biking surfaces and enhance the safety of performing those activities. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 35 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 22 elsewhere and visit the area frequently the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore me. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street congestion of walkers, cyclists, runners and strollers all sharing the road primarily on the west side. It would encourage me and others to go for more leisurely walks and not worry about the congestion on the west side and the safety on negative effect on me, and would be a positive. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) walking down the coast, it will connect later with trail without having to cross the street the west side sidewalk - if visitors to the houses on that side use the parking it may be hard for them. If its just visitors to the area, that's okay. Also, with the renovation of Cannon Park - perhaps there will be more spots elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Bike; Drive coast think sidewalks should be installed here reduce existing parking would change how my family uses this area because the coastal parking is a critical access point. We regularly use these spaces for surfing, fishing, and beach recreation, often carrying boards and Terramar would reduce practical coastal access. I use this parking almost daily for surfing, fishing, and recreation with my kids, and many users carry boards or gear that require nearby parking. Under the June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 36 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 23 significantly limit our ability to access the beach and could discourage us from using this location. must protect and maximize public access to the shoreline. Eliminating long- standing beach access parking would effectively reduce the public's ability to reach and elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently the beach; Walk, run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore walk on the west side of the street. A sidewalk would be especially nice for people with strollers, canes, or difficulty walking. up going to the beach in summer as it is impossible to park. Less parking spaces will mean giving up the beach elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore while walking in that area. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair don't park in this area the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore coast but it doesn't feel as safe without a sidewalk. It would be great to have walking path all the way to the south end of Carlsbad. here elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed more difficult June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 37 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 24 elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street way to Palomar elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed parking. enough parking. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here surf spot and changing parking will make visiting the beach more difficult for all. harder time finding parking, riding my bike, and I think it would potentially make the area more crowded. With the rising sea level, Terramar is not a safe beach for an inexperienced swimmer, and there are no lifeguards on site. I worry that parking will lead to more unaware tourists thinking the break is safe, leading to potential safety elsewhere and visit the area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street frequently than I park elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and visiting west side see above elsewhere and visit mobility device like a walker or the west side only Sidewalks on both sides would be optimum but more safely walk the area instead of June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 38 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 25 frequently Del Oro and Shore Drive) should be on the west side because that is where the majority of walkers & runners use the area. If sidewalks are only installed on the east, walkers & runners will have to cross the busy street to have access to the sidewalk. Most likely will not do so, meaning they will still be using the unsafe west side, having to dodge parked cars, while avoiding traffic and bikes. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair Parking to walk the coast. the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore to walk the coast. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore sidewalks for older adults are better. elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed find parking why not a parking lot on east side of PCH where the dirt lot is now? across PCH more cars stopping to find parking elsewhere and visit coast the east side only to provide ADA access to the coast. It's odd access to the tide pools and walking June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 39 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 26 frequently Cannon, Cerezo and Manzano) area. However, removing parking will greatly impact the community by reducing access to the tide pools, surfing, and general enjoyment of our exercise. elsewhere and visit the area coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here sidewalks. I prefer the look and feel of dirt trails. Please no more concrete. to park in the area. This would cause more people to park in the neighborhood in front of people's elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Drive; Other: Park for beach access. Surf. coast both sides of the street stop for pedestrians and never pay attention to the red light crosswalk. I've seen too many accidents and red light runners at the Cerezo intersection. That intersection has no pedestrian protection, sidewalks, safe crosswalks bc Carlsbad Blvd invites rubbernecking and folks speed through and or are looking at the view pedestrians and runners. Bicyclists are a problem as much as vehicles. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street safer for pedestrians and cars. It could be on either side, but either way we need a bit more safety for all of the parking scarcer, but I never rely on parking there anyway. Encourage more walking! elsewhere and visit run or use a mobility device like a walker coast think sidewalks I use the area, but would perhaps make already parking impacted area even June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 40 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 27 frequently here already a wide bike lane, so it really isn't a huge issue most of the alternative parking (at the old power plant?) put in place. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair Don't park here. Just roll by. think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently think sidewalks should be installed here people I see there are runners and a lot of runners there run in bike lanes even where there is sidewalk available north or south of the area mean more cars waiting for parking spots blocking the bike lane. I think it would be more dangerous for cyclists as they would either have to wait for parking cars or merge into traffic lanes to go around cars waiting for elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here parking and this would make it way worse. I walk and bike there with no issues. There is actually plenty of room of the parking to the nearby neighborhoods and be farther away from the beach elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast both sides of the street same. Sidewalks will provide a much needed safe area for pedestrians, runners who use this area because of the designated area for pedestrians. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair think sidewalks should be installed parking and it already gets hard to park park. Don't take away parking! elsewhere and visit run or use a mobility device like a walker coast the west side only to walk farther from wherever I park, if I June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 41 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 28 frequently Del Oro and Shore elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and one of the most overcrowded beaches in north county park on the neighborhood and ruin their parking. Less access to the beach and people parking poorly elsewhere elsewhere and visit the area frequently beach coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore improve safety for pedestrians and bicyclists elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed parking is already difficult. People walk around the parked cars with no problems now parking to surf. More cars will park on los robles upsetting those elsewhere and visit mobility device like a walker or Cannon Park both sides of the more. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 42 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 29 elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently driving coast think sidewalks should be installed into the neighborhood. for parking in the neighborhoods elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed I use the area. how I use the area. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here the east side of the road to walk, nobody does. When I come to this area I either walk along the coastal trail which I really enjoy as is or jog along the blvd in a pre- existing bike lane force me to park in the neighborhood. there already is impacted parking in the neighborhood and I feel bad for them on nice days with good surf and elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here install sidewalks here. I'm a disabled surfer and need to park right in front of the stairs at Terramar. It would hinder my access to the beach and ocean. I lost my Achilles on my L foot and cannot walk very far. Thank you for your and need to park as close to the Terramar stairs as possible. Plus the neighbors in this area would be greatly disappointed to have a ton of more cars from surfers in front of June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 43 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 30 elsewhere and visit the area frequently for surfing coast think sidewalks should be installed key parking that had provided locals easy access to surf, NO ONE WANTS THIS!!! harder, would visit less frequently elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore from the Village to Cannon. Adding sidewalks to the west side of the road would make a lot of sense. more cars to park north of Cannon would impact where I sometimes park elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) more enjoyable so I don't need to work around parked cars or get gravel in my shoes. It would make way for people to pass each other without going into me - I park further north and walk south and then back north again. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street safer walk to the beach area to find parking in this area, even adding/improving the Palomar dirt lot would help offset elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed to quickly pull over to enjoy the coast right there. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street think I would feel much safer walking on sidewalks than on dirt with the cars passing constantly. I always feel a little uncomfortable so close to passing traffic and no curb elsewhere coast think Terramar almost daily me because I ride June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 44 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 31 frequently installed here affect me much. I don't think they are necessary. There is plenty of space for both bikes and walker/runners in the bike lane. Parking can sometimes be an issue for cars. If lines were added so that folks would park diagonally, it would allow quite a devastating for anyone visiting the beach. elsewhere and visit the area coast both sides of the street much, but would feel safer while walking. park. Taking away spaces would make the problem much elsewhere and visit the area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street the road and into a safe area elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and harder to access coast for surfing. makes it harder to access coast for surfing. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair not park here the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore feel much safer. The terrain in that area is rocky & uneven, and the traffic is right next to you. there. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 45 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 32 the area frequently should be installed here exists. If these were taken away, parking would overflow into the neighborhoods causing more congestion and traffic. walkers. They all share the bike lane and areas of the shoulder that are still vacant, even with a parked car. The area functions well as is. There is plenty of space in the bike lanes for all. Installing sidewalks would greatly affect the local surf community while not having much of an impact on the rest of the population. Most people veer onto the cliff trail once they are able. Such a short area of sidewalk is a waste elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Drive coast think sidewalks should be installed here park, forced to park in neighborhood nearby where parking is already limited 3x a week. I always park on the west side of the street. Implementing sidewalks would force me and others to park in the neighborhood. This would limit the parking for residents as well due to the high volume of surfers this beach attracts. I also have elderly friends, some with injuries who have to carry their heavy boards. Forcing them to park further away is inhumane and ignorant to those June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 46 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 33 would reduce parking for residents elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed being able to access the coast, since I drive there. inside the cerezo/los robles neighborhood elsewhere and visit the area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street peak hours. So, I can usually find parking. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here would not visit because there would be no parking there as much. I mean, if there's no parking, I'm just not going to visit there. Maybe in the winter when it's more elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and crowded I will avoid going south on 101. possibly. Loss of parking will drive surfers to other parking spots I currently use. elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area coast the west side only (adjacent visit no matter what. I prefer sidewalks on the west side because June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 47 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 34 and Shore side isn't as scary on a elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here traffic worse and the street less safe and others to park in the neighborhood and disturb the peace and cross the street putting me at elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here more difficult. already gets extremely busy and removing parking will make it even more difficult to find elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here for visitors to find parking. They will crowd the surrounding neighborhoods making them less safe. not Terramar. I enjoy visiting the coastal area. This change will make it harder for carlsbad residents to enjoy elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here access. I've been surfing at TerraMar for 17 years and it is already congested trying to find spots access nearly impossible. I already park in the neighborhoods sometimes far away. I am friends with the TerraMar residents and they don't want June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 48 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 35 the area frequently should be installed abundant parking. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here in an area that is already at capacity during summer months, weekends, and holidays. on the West side would drive myself, and others, to park in the Terramar neighborhood, inconveniencing elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here the residents, and natural patterns of use in the area. Construction would ruin our beautiful coastline and the livelihoods of surfers and community members alike. Keep impossible to enjoy our beaches the way we do now. Already crowded enough! elsewhere and visit the area frequently surfing coast think sidewalks should be installed Parked cars stretch well South of terramar. Cutting out additional spots will further crowd difficult and need more time to find a space. elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here amount of public parking that is accessible to Tamar and force more parking into the neighborhoods, aggravating the neighbors further eventually to stop enjoying the area that I pay taxes for and enjoy, and I've grown up for the last 20 years, taking my kids and teaching them to elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be accessibility to the coast. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 49 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 36 elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed more difficult to access the coast elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here the current spots will force people to park in the neighborhood which would negatively affect homeowners who live there. further complicates being a surfer in Carlsbad. The volleyball courts by warm water jetties have eliminated tons of parking spots and the proposal to remove or reduce Terramar spots will have the same effect, basically forcing surfers to park in surrounding elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed character of the Terramar area. parking in the neighborhood of terramar which is already congested elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Drive coast think sidewalks should be installed here parking somewhere else in the neighborhoods, which already are crowded. Less parking means my handicapped mom cannot easily walk from the current parking spots to the coast if she doesn't get that is already overcrowded. Makes it look ugly too. Removes parking from one of the best beaches. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 50 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 37 elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed a bike lane now that's used. the Terramar neighborhood to be way too congested. elsewhere and visit the area frequently think sidewalks should be installed center of the traffic lane to avoid runners and pedestrians in the bike lane safer pathway for cyclists and pedestrians elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here back up on the already very busy coast highway. also adding ugly side walks would ruin terra mar and add more stress to our cause more back up and would be hard for surfers and beach goers to enjoy the area elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here area if sidewalks were put in. Such a waste of resources and time. Use the funds to fix the potholes elsewhere and clean the beaches!!! area because of the congestion, lack of available spots, and more likelihood of accidents because of the select number of elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here anything at all. There's plenty of safe walking areas & it's a classic coastal spot. Installing sidewalks wouldn't benefit anyone. tremendously! This is a classic spot that everyone loves! The parking is the beauty of this spot & it would ruin it for a lot of surfers and people! DON'T INSTALL elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed inaccessible elsewhere and visit Walk, run or use a mobility device like coast the east side only however if they can't connect all the way to will limit my access to the coast June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 51 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 38 frequently wheelchair Cannon, Cerezo and Manzano) little impact on me. Especially if I can't find parking to even get myself out of the car and walking on the sidewalk. accessing parking here, while a sidewalk would be nice for when I walk in the area it wouldn't make much difference if I couldn't park to access the coast. I can only walk a small distance before my chronic pain becomes an issue, less spots means I'll have to find parking even further away than I do now and therefore eliminate my ability to access the coast. Please reconsider how to elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed from the cliffs and nature. elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here from visiting the beach that i surf at daily. Parking would clog neighborhoods, prevent people from surfing and enjoying the coast. devastating as it is my favorite beach to surf and spend time at and I would not be able to find parking. Parking in California is already horrible. This would devastate me personally and my friends and community who frequent this beach. I got engaged at this beach. Removing parking would be horrifying. There is June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 52 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 39 elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here broken. The traffic isn't bad. Removing the parking would make for surfers to park in the neighborhood and potentially cause distress to homeowners considering no parking easy access to the beach tend to end up on this road because of how accessible it is for them. Don't fix what's not broken. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here more congestion during construction periods, and reduce the amount of parking available to north county san diego citizens that visit the terramar beaches one or both sides of the street would take away my chances of getting parking to one of my favorite beaches in carlsbad elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here to park and surf at the most beautiful local surf break in san diego. It would make more traffic and ruin the natural beauty of the already eroding bluffs. the natural beauty of the local area, prevent local surfers like myself from having access to the break, further damage already eroding cliffs, increase foot traffic marring one of the few local beaches with concrete and is a waste of resources that nobody in the area is interested in implementing in the first place. Leave elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed provide any added benefit and would be a waste of funds parking so I'd be less inclined to visit elsewhere coast think June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 53 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 40 frequently installed elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair think sidewalks should be installed street traffic and remove parking for visiting my family and the beach elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here the likely displacement of vehicles to nearby residential streets, specifically Los Robles Drive and El Arbol Drive. If parking near the beach becomes limited due to sidewalk construction, surfers and beachgoers will be forced to seek alternative parking in these neighborhoods. This shift would create congestion, reduce available parking for residents, and potentially lead to increased traffic and safety concerns within these quiet residential the surfing community of Carlsbad for a well known surf location causing surfers to commute further alone road sides with their boards congesting a quiet neighborhood. It also affects those who have disabilities who aren't able to make that walk from being pushed inland to find parking. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed access less access elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Bike; Drive coast think sidewalks should be installed surf spot and tide pool area. it would make accessibility much more difficult elsewhere and visit the area coast think sidewalks should be people from coming here if the parking was reduced that much. (and negatively) affect the Carlsbad surfing community June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 54 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 41 elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore walking along this area. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Drive; Other: Park to go to the beach coast think sidewalks should be installed here would restrict access to the beach. Beach goers would be forced to park in the neighborhood to the east of Coast Hwy which would greatly impact the access to the public beach. elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here area. I often cycle the area. I also park occasionally. Most of the free street parking is taken early in the morning by motor homes. We need to save all the parking that elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and the east side of the street with walkers and bikers having to share the road with cars. limited parking in the area and I'd have to park in the neighborhood more often if spots were taken away on coast highway. elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here park in the neighborhood which will create increased risk of accidents between cars and also pedestrians as there are no sidewalks in the June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 55 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 42 the area frequently or wheelchair should be installed here during summer months, weekends, and holidays. and others, to park in the Terramar neighborhood, inconveniencing elsewhere and visit the area frequently and enjoy the beach coast think sidewalks should be installed here for coastal enjoyment, already limited parking. I'll assume once the old power plant is open to the public then we would have plenty of parking. Though, maybe wait till then to place elsewhere and visit the area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and sidewalks on the West side as I would not be able to visit this area anymore able to visit and support the area if you ruin it with sidewalks on the west side elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore in the area parking when I visit elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed parking areas. parking for this area is tough. elsewhere and visit the area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be parking it has. Don't do this. We live 2 miles away but it's too take my family to our favorite beach as often. Right now June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 56 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 43 here kids. Don't take away more ocean accessibility just to add sidewalks in an area where no one has asked for them. This is just a measure to remove parking, mostly residents and locals park here, not outsiders. This money would be better spent it is too dangerous for us to ride down on our bikes with our kids from Aviara. Make this area accessible for the families east of the 5 if you're going to take our parking. elsewhere and visit the area frequently surf break coast think sidewalks should be installed here challenge. taking away parking spaces is going to negatively impact the ability to visit the beach. On crowded days even the neighborhoods are my ability to enjoy the ocean elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here shortage of parking. Sidewalks would be nice, but not if it reduces places to park. walk on a sidewalk, but the lack of parking would harm the area more than a sidewalk would elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) runners do. Space is shared with runners walkers and cyclists. The sidewalk needs to be asphalt. Runners will not run on cement and there needs to be elsewhere and visit the area coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed near the ocean, very few people walk this stretch, we need the parking! are both seniors and enjoy going to the beach and walking the bluff along the June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 57 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 44 elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore and running that's connected to the other beach sidewalks from Tamarack areas elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore the area elsewhere and visit the area coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair walk there from my house, don't need street both sides of the street double wide from here to tamarack or further north to accommodate two way traffic and strollers and dogs elsewhere and visit the area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street would make walking here a lot safer. in this area, I'll continue to look for somewhere along elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra have a sidewalk. Right now we just have to randomly walk on the side of the road and is not great but the benefit of having a sidewalk far outweighs a few June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 58 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 45 elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore pedestrian safe areas especially by the beach more elsewhere and visit the area Cannon Park both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street this area and would feel welcome to use it. This area has been treated as an extension of the homeowners property in Terramar and has not been treated like the public right of way that elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here important here than sidewalks. We usually either walk south of this area or north, but this is not an area that we parking problems north of Cannon elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here and enjoy being able to run on the dirt. Sidewalks not the best for running. Sidewalks may actually move some runners into the street. Don't put Sidewalks but reclaim dirt shoulder on the east side that resident's have claimed for private parking and/or extension of their June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 59 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 46 the area frequently or wheelchair should be installed slammed for parking elsewhere and visit the area coast both sides of the street elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Other: Frequent the area to coast think sidewalks should be installed reducing the wildness of this area are two things I don't want to see happen and reducing the wildness of this area are two things I don't want to see elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here guess it would be nice if it was flat and smooth. But it would not affect my usage. suck as parking is already limited. If you had to do it, I would definitely say West side only. I imagine the people in the neighborhoods would not love it elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) place for pedestrians to walk. Those of us who walk have to walk around parked cars, many times having to walk where traffic is whizzing by, bikes and e-bikes. We need a sidewalk so all people, with families, children, old and young alike can walk or run safely. side of Carlsbad Blvd even north of Cannon, rarely has many people walking there. I've seen most people walking on the west side. So, I don't believe taking valuable parking away from the east side of Carlsbad Blvd in the Terramar area, would be elsewhere and visit the area frequently transit; Walk, run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street safer to walk and bike with families. I've seen and experienced cars driving by and veering into the dirt area due to parking more challenging, I would rather have the walking and biking area and increased June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 60 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 47 elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here unbearable and increase in pedestrian traffic right on coast highway would be dangerous for all. would be more dangerous with increased pedestrians to nowhere. Where would residents and elsewhere and visit the area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street walking and running through the area. safer for walking, running, and bicycling in the area. elsewhere and visit the area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair Cannon Park both sides of the street sidewalks along Garfield above lagoon overdue elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street along the road without having to stumble through people's dirty yards and/or worry about getting hit by cars or bikes. And when on bike, not have to worry about hitting people who are walking in the bike lane because there me at all. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore I walk there with my children. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street sidewalks for pedestrians and surfers to safely travel through the terramar area. It would also keep people walking with surfboards out of the bike lanes. would be a safer way to get people up and down this heavily used area. Do Not let residents who have been resisting sidewalks in the area for years continue to drive June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 61 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 48 HUMANS, and THE PUBLIC need elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street access to the coast easier and safer since access is limited in the area to Terramar and the south end of the promenade. negative impact to access since access to the coast is limited in the area to Terramar and the south end of the elsewhere and visit the area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street safety elsewhere and visit the area frequently use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair above think sidewalks should be installed beaches, more crowded streets elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed force me/others to park in adjacent neighborhoods, and cause excessive elsewhere use a mobility coast think our family spot very longer be able to lug June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 62 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 49 frequently or wheelchair installed beach to surf elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here parking. parking there is already at a premium. Why do you have to mess with a good thing? While you're at it why don't you add some roundabouts and back in parking elsewhere and visit the area frequently Surfing think sidewalks should be installed residential areas when I surf. I am sure the residents might not be too happy about that. elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street in Carlsbad to the beach to access the large sidewalk past this area and it feels very unsafe to walk through this walk a little more to access the stairway to the beach elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed natural feeling of the environment. Too much concrete elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed neighbors in the area to see an increase in unwanted public traffic difficult elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed here improve anything because there are very wide usable walking paths in this entire area to begin with impact many visitors and the residents here. There are many people who benefit from being able to park directly near the beach, especially June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 63 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 50 know several surfers with disabilities who need to access the streetside parking on a regular basis. You'd also be forcing more people to park inside the neighborhood which will anger the residents if visitors accidentally park elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here more difficult than it is now. It will also push bicyclists farther out into the busy road. Furthermore, it will decrease the charm of the old Carlsbad area. harder, and moving parking further into the street because of the sidewalk will only cause more issues with traffic stopping when cars elsewhere and visit the area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street walk/run/bike there more frequently and other pedestrians feel safer elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast think sidewalks should be installed at a spot that already has reduced parking because of the frequent surfers and beach goers to park there and surf there elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and Manzano) west side, never on east side of the street, so sidewalks on the east side would not affect me. However, sidewalks on the west side would make parking more difficult and push more users who surf like myself to the south or into the eastern neighborhoods, on one or both sides of the street would significantly impact parking in the area and push surfer parking even further into the neighborhoods on the east side. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 64 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 51 elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed density. Putting in sidewalks will further lower density for visitor elsewhere and visit the area frequently mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore residents homes and I feel that you should leave it so that there is more parking. elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here needed parking spots and we don't really need sidewalks to be able to run and walk there, it's perfectly fine as it is. us park further back in the neighborhood, making for a longer walk to the beach and more crowded neighborhood elsewhere and visit the area frequently run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here effect on parking by removing the dirt strip we use every morning. congest the neighborhood and increase speeds on Carlsbad Blvd since it will widen the elsewhere and visit the area frequently coast both sides of the street currently have to use the bike lanes as sidewalks. They would be safer on an actual sidewalk. It would make my daily commute by elsewhere and visit the area frequently; I live in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here would make the coastal area too crowded and create an even larger crowd that cannot handle the parking, nor can the beach hold that big a capacity. inhibit ability to park near the surf break, along with effecting many of my friends who use the close parking because they cannot walk far June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 65 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 52 elsewhere and visit the area frequently; I own property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here east side would dramatically affect those trying to access their homes as they would have to contend with people walking in sidewalks in addition to the non stop cars and bicycles that already would be less convenient for residents/service vehicles/and visitors Terramar area surfing; Walk, run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and have to park in neighborhood east side... Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair don't use street parking in this area. the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore beach it would be more convenient (I don't like walking on dirt/unpacked surfaces). live on different streets. Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed homeowners would be reduced too greatly would move to adjacent streets Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here installed, this will cause more traffic congestion due to less parking spaces available and it's already a problem for entire neighborhood since it will cause more traffic looking for parking spots. Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street area, provide a better surface for walking and provide a clear understanding of where reduce parking further. At the moment, there is insufficient sight June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 66 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 53 available spaces. bicycles and especially e-bikes. If you fail to create a clear line of sight to pull out of a driveway then you are creating a dangerous impact Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker both sides of the walking and riding my bike. me. Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) Tierra Del Oro to Manzano on west side of Cbad Blvd only - Leave east side alone on west side of Carlsbad Blvd and installing sidewalks on west side would keep us safe - Negative impact if Sidewalk on west Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here how I use Carlsbad Blvd 34 parking spaces on Carlsbad Boulevard. All of those cars that would normally park there would filter onto My St., Los Robles. We already have a disaster on our street on the weekends and this would create a bigger problem. We don't even have room for guests to park on our street on the weekends. I am very much against eliminating parking spaces on Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be I currently use the street on carlsbad blvd and cannon, but it will parking spaces will be a disaster for park and beach June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 67 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 54 here and own a home, Los Robles Drive doesn't have enough parking with the multiple ADUs and homes that have been allowed to build without garages and room to park on property, forcing residents to park on the street daily. Currently we don't even have the space for guests to park in front of our house, let alone the weekends are a nightmare with the parking. I am very much opposed to removing any Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Terramar area coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore impact the biking. I currently bike here 3-4 times a week and several times almost collide with pedestrians. Please take bike paths bike paths Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore pedestrian traffic and a curb would separate vehicle and pedestrian traffic. me. Terramar Cannon both sides June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 68 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 55 Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair neighbors think sidewalks should be installed here bike lanes and walkers on sidewalks, however the parking is an overriding issue, Cannon Park needs its the area for everyone, the parking will then go to Los Robles and El Arbol Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed parking availability in front of my home more difficult for me Terramar area Bike ride the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore side. Everyone walks in the bike path on west side. We need a sidewalk or walking path for walkers and runners to keep them Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore the pedestrians when I'm driving. It would give pedestrians a designated place to be. It would make me feel safer when I am the me. Terramar area both sides of the street with parked cars runners walkers dogs darting in and out Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair Cannon Park think sidewalks should be installed here great, but not if we lose parking. will push the parking into the neighborhood. I wish there was a safe way to walk without being pushed into traffic, but we can't lose Terramar use a mobility home think June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 69 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 56 or wheelchair installed Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair don't the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore a runner or a kid Terramar area Cannon Park both sides of the on the sidewalks instead of being in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker coast both sides of the foremost Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair think sidewalks should be installed here the south side of Cerezo would be a great idea if you are concerned with public safety. Either there should be no parking allowed there or there needs to be sidewalks. It is a very dangerous situation daily with people walking in the street with surfboards into traffic turning right from would likely add to parking in the Terramar neighborhood, where beach parking is already a big problem for us residents Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street improve walkability - providing an even surface - and safety overflow to adjacent streets Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street young children could actually safely walk and bike on Carlsbad Blvd. parking might push cars on to Los Robles where we Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker home both sides of the use the street to park by my house, but it would the ability for me to park in front of my June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 70 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 57 Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here access the beach nearby. Continue to make it easy for people to park and access the beach. We live in a beach town. Parking nearby the beach is Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed for beach goers and pushes them into the neighborhood. for the long time owners Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair think sidewalks should be installed here residential streets in the area. There are days already on holidays and hot days where there is no room to park. I am unable to park in front of my own home or have company with somewhere to park. Creates traffic problems for home Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore West side of the street. East side sidewalk is not scenic, and would encourage littering on my property would not be desirable for surfers and beach utilization Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker home both sides of the neighborhoods with my grandchildren. Much and have a garage Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed every time I drove past probably as I surf here every day and already struggle to find parking June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 71 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 58 Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Bike; Drive coast think sidewalks should be installed the world!? Stop overdeveloping carlsbad. For who?? obviously Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair my own garage both sides of the street when we have company and our grandchildren who don't realize how dangerous the streets Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed the area. Parking spaces are more important than installing new sidewalks from being able to park and access the area Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here away from the accessibility to the area. It's nice for a long stop to enjoy the beaches or a quick stop to enjoy lunch, or views, or take a deep breath Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here perfect for walking and parking. I'm not sure what problem this is solving. Walking on the trails is great along the coast. Parking there is just about perfect. What is the purpose of this? to beach - we live right next to Poinsettia Park and already have issues accessing the coast by anything other than car because of the terrible bike access over the 5. Because of the danger to our children riding bikes down PAR or Poinsettia we must drive to our favorite beach even though it is well within biking distance. Instead we must June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 72 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 59 fix bike access from east of the 5 to this area before you take Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed stop creating traffic its already so bad. Seriously what are you doing stretch of coast into unusable congested tourist slop Terramar area coast think sidewalks should be installed here of the residents living in terramar want sidewalks put in. enough to find parking and you guys are crowding the town with more residents. That's one of the main reasons I moved to Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here way I use the area very drastically other than walking on a sidewalk versus an easy to walk on trail. I walk here frequently and there is plenty of room to walk and access to the trail along the coast to walk on. It just feels like a major waste of tax here as frequently. I live in the area but I enjoy driving over and parking if I have my surfboard. It's already hard to find a spot here to park and if there were less, it'd be a nightmare. Please don't remove the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here the Cannon Park offers not enough parking for the sports they have on the weekends and they overflow into our neighborhood. Creating noise and congestion. Then we have the beach goers who take up parking and blocking fire hydrants. We June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 73 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 60 Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here walking, cycling. It would negatively affect parking. affected by beachgoer parking. Our driveway is often partially blocked. Removing another 31 spots would make this unsustainable. This area has gotten more popular since COVID and social media, there seem to be notices of low tides that bring a very high number of Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street both sides of the street would significantly improve how I use this area. It would create a safe, continuous path for walking in both directions and avoid forcing people to cross the street or walk in traffic. Sidewalks on both sides would make the neighborhood much safer, more accessible, and more usable for would affect me less than continuing to have no sidewalks. Parking convenience is secondary to pedestrian safety. If some parking must be removed to install sidewalks on both sides, that is a reasonable tradeoff to prevent residents and visitors from being forced to walk Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street use it to walk to the beach. I want it on both sides so people don't only walk on the West parking more difficult but that is OK, I can use driveway and Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street constantly along the coast and having sidewalks would make it me, I park in driveway of my home. Terramar run or use a mobility home think how we use the area. Robles and there are June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 74 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 61 or wheelchair installed here Terramar neighborhood to walk to the beach. Cerezo is not wide enough (and has no sidewalks) to accommodate pedestrians. There are real safety concerns with this issue, along with a 3 way intersection where people constantly run to park at our house. By reducing the parking by half on Carlsbad Blvd. the parking in the Terramar neighborhood will become very challenging for guests, homeowners, service workers, etc. Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair Visit daughter's home. Visit home I rent out. the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore impossible. there impossible. Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street cleaner and upgraded in appearance. It depends on if you are leaving the bike lane and the center lane. These are both necessary for safety. many guests would be able to park. I am not sure your parking calculations are correct. On the east side there is parking in front of many homes. Since this is not a detailed drawing I would be concerned if that parking will be removed. If so this could be a problem for both residents Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and Manzano) side would provide safer walking and biking on this side. The roadway is too close to traffic and not really safe to walk. much more traffic pushed into the Terramar neighborhood. I live on Los Robles and we already have too much traffic cutting in our June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 75 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 62 from out of the area parking on our street causing issues with our tenants finding a parking spot in front of our Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here Del Oro behind the bougainvillea where Cannon ends. If the bougainvillea is cut down, trimmed or removed to put in a sidewalk, my backyard will be visible from waist height to anyone using the sidewalk. My backyard will lose all privacy and will not be secure. The bougainvillea is the barrier that protects my access to Tierra Del Oro for various events (Marathon, etc) I will have to park my car further if the parking is removed from Carlsbad Blvd Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker home both sides of the Terramar area home think sidewalks should be installed here for residents a real problem Blvd would be parking on my street, Shore Dr, which would then make parking for the residents on Shore even tougher than it Terramar area coast think sidewalks should be to the coast and Beach. There are already a small amount of areas access to the coast and Beach. There are already a small June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 76 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 63 here would complicate the area and make it more congested unneeded sidewalks would complicate the area and make it Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed we can get to avoid overflow on El Arbol and Los Robles Terramar area coast think sidewalks should be installed needs a sidewalk on the north side OR the south side. This is not a city hiking trail. to park to access the shore for coastal use (surfing, fishing) for no benefit Terramar area coast think sidewalks should be installed more safety for pedestrians Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street would make it safer for pedestrians. There are vacation rentals on the east side of Carlsbad Blvd in Terramar and I see families with young children struggling over the rocks, dirt, parked cars in the parkway. They are trying to get to the crosswalk at Cannon Rd. would push drivers to park on adjacent streets like Shore Dr, Los Robles, and El Arbol. These streets are already impacted on weekends and summer vacation months, and with use of nearby Cannon Park. Perhaps when the city purchases the old power plant property more parking can be Terramar area; I own property in the run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street and mother of two young children, I am very concerned about the lack of safe pedestrian routes along parking would not affect me personally because I park at my home. Even so, I believe there are June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 77 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 64 area area is heavily used by walkers/joggers/cyclists, including myself and my family and neighbors, and we are constantly having to dodge around parked cars and avoid heavily speeding traffic along the Blvd. Sidewalks would provide a safe path for runners/walkers and also serve to slow down car traffic that speeds parking places for the public to use in the area and that sidewalks on both side of the street would benefit the public and residents by slowing down traffic and providing safer routes for pedestrians and bicyclists that are sorely lacking at the moment. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast both sides of the street the proposed areas would allow my family to walk safely rather than being forced into the street. With cars parked along the dirt shoulders, there is often no clear place to walk or push a stroller. As a parent of a toddler, sidewalks would significantly improve safety and make it much more comfortable to walk through the on one side of the street in key areas would not meaningfully affect me. There is plenty of parking available throughout the neighborhood, and improving pedestrian safety should be the priority. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here use the street, and I expect it will cause more problems (for pedestrians too) given the reduction in parking. Robles and already have parking issues due to beach and park traffic, as well as the fact that there are lots that June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 78 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 65 lot) without stipulation for Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here affect the parking on El Arbol and Los Robles Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore west side of blvd; hence less impact to residents. No need for 8 ft sidewalk, not enough pedestrian traffic. go into neighborhood for parking. Note Terramar has both beach goers and park goers. Major Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here difficult and to take away parking. However I see the safety benefits of a sidewalk. Isn't there a way to keep the parking and put a sidewalk on the west side using an easement where there is currently neighborhood making the street less safe for children and walking residents. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area think sidewalks should be installed here negative about the Blvd as it is now and has been. There are no pedestrian or bike incidents. Leave it alone and spend your money elsewhere. traverse Cerezo, a very narrow street with pedestrians walking in the middle of the street. Parking will impact all the residents on El Arbol, Los Robles, Shore, Cerezo. Residents will have no place in front of their house. Trash and loud voices will Terramar use a mobility home the west People park down June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 79 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 66 property in the Terramar or wheelchair to Tierra Del Oro and Shore there would be impacted. It is a tough call Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair think sidewalks should be installed here how I use the area. People can already walk alongside road cars onto the back streets of the Terramar community Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here it's already OK to walk. Robles is already packed with cars so to lose parking would bring even more cars to our street Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Bike; Drive; Other: Access to residence on BLVD. home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) my home. Sidewalks would improve safety of those on foot. However, could cause unsafe issues with the numerous other Blvd users (surfers, strollers with babies & dogs, rollerbladers, skateboarders, joggers, etc.) competing for space. At times the Blvd seems to be a mini Demolition Derby with Cars, Motorcycles, Bikes, Club Bikers, Golf Carts, Electric Bikes, Electric Balls, Electric Skateboards, Unicycles, etc. all competing for space. It is not Safe as oncoming traffic (foot or motorized) when exiting residence. Would improve Safety of all concerned. Must back out into oncoming Blvd traffic. Terramar area; I own use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be be installed if parking is NOT lost. Removing parking will push surfers be parking in the neighborhood on Robles Dr and El June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 80 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 67 Terramar here congested occasion, blocking Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street both sides of the street is essential for safe and equitable access. My grandmother uses a wheelchair and currently faces unsafe conditions due to the lack of continuous, accessible pathways. Sidewalks on both sides would provide ADA- compliant mobility, reduce the need to travel in the roadway, and allow her, and others with disabilities, seniors, and families, to move safely and independently. parking may be an inconvenience, it should not outweigh the need for safe, ADA-compliant access. For residents with mobility impairments, the absence of sidewalks creates a significant safety risk and limits basic access. Ensuring continuous sidewalks on both sides is a matter of accessibility and public safety, and should be prioritized over on-street Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area transit home think sidewalks should be installed here west side of Carlsbad blvd are zoned allowing 2+ units per lot, street parking is essentially necessary. Removing available parking areas on the west side would adversely impact owners/tenants who live here (my property included) & create new parking problems in the tenants with 3 cars & 1 tenant has to park in front of our neighboring lots who also need the available parking areas in front of their units Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair both sides of the street accessibility and safety. (I avoid walking down there at night, I've nearly gotten ran over multiple times as cars drift over the line onto the dirt siding). There are way too many me personally as I have enough driveway parking but it will impact others/visitors. Vast majority of the traffic/safety violations are due to June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 81 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 68 afternoon, two directions walk, fast walking, running and then passing. Regularly 6-8 people wide, with people spilling into bike lane trying to pass and then bike lane runners spilling out into street trying to pass them. Make a wide promenade and remove the handful of parking spots that are there, just get rid of them except for the handful of houses that only have street parking & be permit only. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here anything. park in front of my house because boulevard parking will be eliminated and the overflow will impact my street, which is Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street and hopefully slow down traffic. It's insanely unsafe right now with motorcycles often speeding down the bike/walk lanes illegally to avoid traffic jams and drivers regularly speed on that route. safety in the area for all pedestrians, local and visitors but also negatively impacts neighborhood parking during busy visitor time. Please keep the bike lanes as well they are not mentioned so I'd like to know they will Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here sidewalks. New sidewalks would not change how I use the streets. detrimental to the neighborhood. It would push more people to park in the neighborhood. We already have limited parking due to the vacation rentals and the new buildings that do not have adequate parking June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 82 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 69 idea. Do not put in sidewalks and remove parking on the Blvd. We need to keep all of the Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here Del Oro to Cannon Road, where there is currently gravel would be great so that we could get to the stoplight without walking in the dirt. Going south from Cannon Road to the south end of Shore Drive. We can just walk on Shore Drive and there is no need to take away parking on either side of the boulevard from N Shore down to the South end of Shore Dr. Then, a sidewalk from South Shore Drive down past Manzano a sidewalk & parking to access public stairs by problem throughout the area. Removing street parking from the homes on Carlsbad Boulevard between Cannon Road going south towards Cerezo would just spill more traffic onto surrounding Terramar streets Shore Drive, Los Robles and Tierra Del Oro... In my opinion, it makes more sense to add parking south of Cerezo and in the lot where SDGE white building currently exists. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here take away parking on either side of the street from Cannon Road down to Cerezo. That would just increase the already parking problem on Los Robles, Tierra Del Oro and Shore Dr. And make it difficult for homeowners to access their homes. Sidewalk is only needed where gravel exists now.. from TDO to No. Shore Dr, then walkers can travel on Shore to So Shore our street during events at Cannon Park and any good beach day or holiday. There is plenty of room to put a small parking structure or large lot where the white SDGE office building currently is, and that would help people going to the park and the beach without affecting the residents in the June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 83 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 70 for people to access public Cerezo stairs /+ PLS widen sidewalk So already are. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here create a parking nightmare our streets looking for parking where we already have no available parking Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Bike; Drive; Other: Park home think sidewalks should be installed here to find parking near my home for myself and visitors. So less likely to invite friends to Cannon Park and the beach. and myself to park, more competition for less parking spots. Less parking for friends to come visit for surfing and Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar transit; Walk, run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast think sidewalks should be installed here good. We already have parking issues. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street dangers of traffic. Help improve the landscaping and eliminate rat infested tree and shrubs on west side between Shore and often find a parking spot near my home. Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here impact our neighborhood and street parking and traffic congestion on our street in front of our houses Terramar area; I use a mobility device like a walker home think sidewalks would park in front of people's houses. treating terramar like bressi ranch. We June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 84 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 71 in the Terramar here beachgoers Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here amount of parking spaces would affect the number of cars parking on streets east of Carlsbad Blvd and remove spaces for many homeowners on Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here cars parking on our residential streets, El Arbol and Los Robles which would be hard on the homeowners Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Bike; Drive; Ride transit; Other: Parking, neighborhood events/camaraderie. home think sidewalks should be installed here Nowhere"...I have difficulty understanding the rationale for these "improvements." Why is the City contemplating sacrificing much needed and desired coastal parking for sections of unnecessary sidewalk that end nowhere? Whose idea? What's the benefit/ROI? Shouldn't the City prioritize the need for such capital improvements? Shouldn't the City consider the negative side effects of such projects? The unintended consequences. Less parking on the coast impacts the adjacent neighborhoods. limited parking along the coast will simply move beach goers into the adjacent neighborhoods, which will create more inconvenience for the beach goers and create less parking, more congestion, noise and mess in the surrounding neighborhoods. This project is unnecessary, unwarranted and unwanted. Its questionable benefits pale in comparison to its unintended negative consequences. Please use some June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 85 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 72 spending on projects & purposes that are Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area coast think sidewalks should be installed here parking left, Residents don't want to deal with another year of loud noises and backed up traffic on their street! access only pushes people to park in neighborhoods more instead of along the coast. We just got done with construction to the road which caused loud noises and terrible traffic for over a year. The road is just fine without sidewalks it Terramar area; I own property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here against Carlsbad blvd and the yard would be vulnerable to foot traffic without any privacy or security. The plants there now provide a barrier. already gets lots of parking traffic. Now limiting the parking spots will cause a bigger issue on my street. We have trouble now with cars blocking our property in the Terramar mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street both sides will avoid a lot of "J Walking" and relieve walking congestion by not confining it to west side of street. It will also help in getting in and out of our driveway especially in the summer when pedestrian and car traffic is heavier. Parking, as it exists now moved over farther on east side of the street I do not think it would affect parking but if parking is removed people park elsewhere. Could be a problem on side streets. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 86 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 73 the line of sight pulling out of our driveway and hinders our ability to "time" our exit so as to avoid bikes, traffic and property in the Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street response consider using some of the property at the old Power Plant site for paid parking like Newport where parking is scarce. Could be a source of revenue and provide property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here drive and park on Los Robles Drive, where I own property and visit frequently. This would make the street more dangerous for pedestrians and children, as well as make the current challenging parking situation more property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore dodging cars and bikes more often. property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) the west side of Carlsbad Blvd. would not change the way I use the street. I commonly walk on the west side, as it is closest to the ocean and allows properties between Cerezo and Manzano are unique in SD County, they have views across a two-lane road to CA State property and June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 87 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 74 Installing a sidewalk on the east side of the street between Cerezo and Manzano defeats the point of a walk at the beach or along the bluff and it serves no Terramar- or field- access purpose not served directly by Cerezo. street's west side, most days folks are drinking, smoking pot, and frequently misbehaving in or on their vehicles, most of which we hear, see, and smell. The road keeps most of the misconduct on the west side and putting sidewalks on the east side only invites imposition of more intrusion in the lives of property in the Terramar run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street privacy on our property. property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here parking for residents, there has never been parking there in the past and there is parking both North and South so I don't see the need. More and more of the houses here have ADUs or are turning into single resident homes into duplexes, we need residents on coast high, thus impacting parking on El Arbol, Cannon, and Los Robles property in the Terramar area run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed here important than sidewalks. More cars are using the area than people walking. Congestion and use of our property would be impacted. When the weather is good as in summer, every available spot is usually taken for hardscape is better. Keep the cool vibe it has in its natural state. Leave the pathways as they are. June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 88 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 75 property in the Terramar run or use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street are a necessity. property in the Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair; Drive; Other: Surf there/park home the east side only (adjacent to Cannon, Cerezo and from my house to the beach. I live on the east side of the street when friends visit to have enough parking especially at high beach season property in the Terramar area home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) only makes sense since pedestrians along Carlsbad blvd are accessing the beach. If sidewalks are installed on both sides it would impact parking for homeowners and guests. Where would our guests park when they come over? On Shore Dr. Those homeowners are already impacted by on east side would negatively impact my home and all the homes. There would literally be no where to park. property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore property in the Terramar use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair Street parking is for our both sides of the street to Cerezo without fearing for my life. Carlsbad Blvd is like a challenging for our visitors. property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra the east side needs parking to access their property park June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 89 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 76 property in the Terramar area mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore come into Terramar to park on Los Robles, El Arbol, Manzano, and Cerezo. property in the Terramar area home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore side would likely make my driveway steep and hard to pull into if there was more pedestrian traffic. East side sidewalks are not used side will cause more street crossings, more accidents and make my driveway steeper. property in the Terramar area home the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore property in the Terramar use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street walking property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home both sides of the street take walks if there were sidewalks. The parking would be more organized and more accessible for property in the Terramar area home think sidewalks should be installed here of my home block up my street and block my driveway which already happens during warm weekends and property mobility device like coast think park in the area. When I June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 90 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 77 area Drive; Other: Park installed here lose the "protected" area I currently have. If you narrow the road to provide safety zone, traffic flow will be property in the Terramar area use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair home think sidewalks should be installed adjacent to my property line and back fence. The fence would need to be extended upwards. City more crowded with tourists if PCH parking is removed live in Carlsbad but surf Terramar Terramar coast think sidewalks should be installed parking for the many folks that come to surf the beautiful Terramar break. Any reduction in in South Carlsbad. Would love to walk in area but don't due to lack of use a mobility device like a walker or wheelchair don't park here the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore Drive) frequently. Currently it's not comfortable to walk without feeling endangered by cars. Visit and park for surfing coast the west side only (adjacent to Tierra Del Oro and Shore surf? worried about the cost. think sidewalks should be installed it all alone. Don't spend the money. Watch your pocket book. daughter is disabled and surfs need car both sides of the street who surfs June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 91 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Terramar Improvements Community Input Summary Spring 2026 78 coast think sidewalks should be installed here area. There are already walking spots along the coast in this area. Leave the parking as is! upset! This is a date spot where a lot of people park to enjoy the sunset. Leave it as is and don't ruin it like you guys have ruined the streets with all the bike June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 92 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Exhibit 4 Staff report from April 6, 2026, Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission Meeting (on file in the Office of the City Clerk) June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 93 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 Exhibit 5 Minutes from April 6, 2026, Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission meeting (on file in the Office of the City Clerk) June 9, 2026 Item #14 Page 94 of 94 Docusign Envelope ID: 40B9F863-E851-8902-83BA-0AA952684A94 From:Nina Eaton To:City Clerk Subject:June 9 Council mtg Date:Sunday, June 7, 2026 5:37:29 PM TERRAMAR COAST HWY IMPROVEMENTS: 1. Constructing sidewalks and LOOSING ANY PARKING spaces is unimaginable in this public beach area, with a public staircase located in that exact area. 2. If the City had done their homework, they’re see nobody walks on the EAST side of the hwy. The beach is on the WEST side, and is the only side that should be considered for a sidewalk. But we don’t need the sidewalk. We need the PARKING. 3. IF the City attempts to sidewalk the EAST side, the MITIGATION for existing, steep driveways is unfathomable. We don’t need the bluff beautification at the expense of public access and public parking. Consider putting the $$ into a multi- level PARKING GARAGE, as discussed for decades! These wasteful beautification projects have unintentional consequences. Please stop. Use our tax dollars for the benefit of Carlsbadians. Respectfully Nina Eaton Tierra Del Oro Terramar Sent from my iPhone CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. All Receive - Agenda Item #_____ For the Information of the: CITY COUCNIL Date: ___________ CA ____ CC____ CM ____ ACM ____ DCM (3) ____ 14 6/8/2026 x x x x x From:Robert Pritchard To:City Clerk Cc:Kevin Shin; Tom Frank Subject:Support of Carlsbad Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission"s Recommendation * June 9, 2026 Date:Sunday, June 7, 2026 7:21:50 PM Council Member Shin and City Council Members: As a Terramar Resident we are in support of the the Carlsbad Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission's recommended for the City Council:         • Proceed with resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks or reduction of parking on Carlsbad Boulevard            (Please include better water drainage from Carlsbad Blvd to the ocean along Shore Drive)        • Consider a potential secondary project for this area after the Seaside Transaction Agreement1 with Cabrillo Power I LLC (a subsidiary of NRG Energy) and          San Diego Gas & Electric is completed        • Evaluate other parking opportunities with State Parks on the bluff area Respectfully, Bob and Cathy Pritchard 5098 Shore Drive CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. 1 Adriana Trujillo From:Lovelynne Magalued Sent:Monday, June 8, 2026 3:17 PM To:City Clerk Subject:FW: ➡ Next steps for Terramar street improvements From: Bill Arsenault <billarsenault1@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, June 5, 2026 11:53 AM To: Communications <communications@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Re: Next steps for Terramar street improvements Dear City Council, I am writing to provide public comment regarding the potential street improvements for Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road. The current configuration does not provide adequate safety for cyclists, runners, or surfers. The existing narrow bike lane is insufficient, and the unmaintained dirt parking areas are messy and poorly managed. I strongly support the installation of sidewalks, specifically on at least the west side of the street. To address parking concerns, I suggest reclaiming city easements and exploring the addition of parking on the east side of the street to offset any loss of shoulder parking. And most importantly are Senior park as no areas to use handicap assisted equipment wheelchairs etc. The street is not safe not feasible. Thank you for considering these improvements for the Terramar area. Best regards, 6507 Friendly Pl Carlsbad 92011 Bill Arsenault On Fri, Jun 5, 2026 at 9:15 AM City of Carlsbad <communications@carlsbadca.gov> wrote: Learn more about improvements being considered for Carlsbad Blvd and Cannon Rd View this email in your web browser All Receive - Agenda Item #_____ For the Information of the: CITY COUCNIL Date: ___________ CA ____ CC____ CM ____ ACM ____ DCM (3) ____ 14 6/9/2026 x x x x x 2 To address traffic and safety concerns in the Terramar area, the City of Carlsbad is exploring potential street improvements, including: • New sidewalks on one or both sides of Carlsbad Boulevard • Resurfacing and restriping Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road in this area The Carlsbad City Council is scheduled to discuss potential improvements during its meeting on Tuesday, June 9. City Council meeting Tuesday, June 9, 5 p.m. City Council Chamber 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive View the agenda and staff report. How to participate • Attend the meeting in person and provide a public comment • Email comments to clerk@carlsbadca.gov by 2 p.m. on Tuesday, June 9 • Watch the livestream on the city’s website 3 Background A project that was previously planned for the area included a roundabout at Carlsbad Boulevard and Cannon Road, lane reductions on Cannon Road west of the railroad tracks and a traffic signal at Cerezo Drive. Following community feedback regarding roundabouts, the City Council re-evaluated the project scope in October 2025 and directed staff to explore a smaller-scale project. If new sidewalks are installed, some of the parking currently available off the shoulder of Carlsbad Boulevard would need to be removed. On the west side of the street, parking spaces could be retained near the southern end of the new sidewalk to minimize the parking loss. This spring, the city asked the community to weigh in on potential improvements through: • Completing an online form • Emailing traffic@carlsbadca.gov • Attending the Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission meeting on April 6 View the community input summary. Learn more. 4 Questions? We’re here to help traffic@carlsbadca.gov City of Carlsbad | Website City of Carlsbad | 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive | Carlsbad, CA 92008 US Unsubscribe | Update Profile | Constant Contact Data Notice CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Traffic To:City Clerk Subject:FW: east side sidewalks Date:Monday, June 8, 2026 3:22:04 PM From: Carol Scurlock <cascurlock@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, June 5, 2026 9:37 AM To: Traffic <traffic@CarlsbadCA.gov> Subject: east side sidewalks These have already been deleted from the project. Please don't give new consideration in your emails. carol scurlock CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Diana A To:City Clerk; Priya Bhat-Patel Subject:Agenda #14 Support Sidewalks for Terramar Area Coastal Improvements (CIP No. 6054) Date:Tuesday, June 9, 2026 8:15:49 AM Dear Mayor and City Council Members, I strongly urge you to choose Option 2 and include construction of a sidewalk on the west sideof Carlsbad Boulevard as part of the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project (CIP No. 6054). Reasons to support the sidewalk:- Public access: A continuous sidewalk between La Costa Ave and Cannon will provide safe, reliable access to the beach and coastal trail for residents and visitors of all ages and abilities. - Pedestrian safety: Sidewalks reduce conflicts between people walking and vehicles, lowering the risk of crashes—especially where driveways and crossings are frequent. - Equity and inclusion: Sidewalks serve people who cannot drive, including seniors, children, people with disabilities, and low-income residents; public right-of-way improvements shouldprioritize community access over individual driveway preferences. - Connectivity and active transportation: A sidewalk connects neighborhoods to transit stops,businesses, and the coastal trail, encouraging walking and reducing short car trips. - Long-term value: Building the sidewalk now prevents more costly retrofits later anddemonstrates commitment to safe, walkable streets near our coast. I recognize some nearby homeowners oppose a sidewalk in front of their properties. However, this stretch is a public corridor used by many: the broader community’s need for safe access tothe coast should take precedence. If the Council is concerned about design impacts, please direct staff to minimize landscaping disruptions and use context-sensitive design whilekeeping the sidewalk continuous and accessible. Please vote to proceed with final design, environmental review, permitting, and construction of the sidewalk (Option 2). Thank you for prioritizing safe, equitable public access to ourcoast. Sincerely, Diana Aguirre, MBA, PMP®, LSSBB (District 3)City of Carlsbad Citizen Academy Graduate CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Chih-Wu Chang To:City Clerk; Keith Blackburn; Priya Bhat-Patel; Teresa Acosta; Melanie Burkholder; Kevin Shin Subject:Support Option 2 of Agenda Item #14 Date:Tuesday, June 9, 2026 11:24:08 AM Dear Mayor Blackburn, Mayor Pro Tem, and Honorable City Council Members, I am writing to express my support for Option 2 of Agenda Item #14, which would authorize the construction of the proposed sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard as part of the Terramar Area Coastal Improvement Project (CIP Project No. 6054). I recognize that this decision involves balancing neighborhood concerns, costs, and competing priorities. However, I believe Option 2 best reflects Carlsbad's commitment to public safety, accessibility, and long-term community well-being. Pedestrians should not have to walk in the street because basic infrastructure is missing. Sidewalks minimize conflicts between pedestrians and vehicles and help prevent avoidable injuries. While preserving the status quo may seem less disruptive in the short term, the absence of sidewalks places the burden of that choice on those who are most vulnerable. A community that values safety and inclusion should ensure that all residents can move through their neighborhoods without unnecessary risk. I understand that some residents may have concerns about parking, aesthetics, or construction impacts. Those concerns deserve thoughtful consideration. Nevertheless, I believe that the broader public benefits of improved pedestrian safety and accessibility outweigh the inconveniences associated with construction. Future generations of Carlsbad residents and visitors will benefit from a safer and more accessible coastal experience because of the decision made today. For these reasons, I urge the City Council to approve Option 2 of Agenda Item #14 and move forward with the construction of the sidewalk. All Receive - Agenda Item #_____ For the Information of the: CITY COUCNIL Date: ___________ CA ____ CC____ CM ____ ACM ____ DCM (3) ____ 14 6/9/2026 x x x x x I appreciate your service to our community and for your commitment to making Carlsbad a safer and more accessible city for everyone. Chih-Wu Chang Carlsbad Resident “We are all here on earth to help others.” CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Sam Ward To:City Clerk Subject:Agenda item 14 Date:Tuesday, June 9, 2026 11:33:24 AM Dear Mayor and Councilmembers: I write to encourage the City Council to adopt Option 2 and issue a resolution including a sidewalk on the West side of Carlsbad Boulevard in the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project. Building a continuous sidewalk will greatly aid costal access and provide additional pedestrian safety on an increasingly busy portion of Carlsbad Boulevard. Thank you. Sam Ward District 1 resident Sent from my iPhone CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Vanessa Forsythe To:City Clerk; Teresa Acosta Subject:Agenda #14 Support Sidewalks for Terramar Area Coastal Improvements (CIP No. 6054) Date:Tuesday, June 9, 2026 11:55:11 AM Dear Mayor and City Council Members As a senior citizen, walkability and safe sidewalks where I can enjoy our beautifulocean view is increasingly important. For myself and other seniors, safe sidewalks are important for our mental and physical health. The continuation of a sidewalk is also important for families and visitors - so that they are not forced to walk in the road and be at risk of injury from cars and other vehicles.I request that you vote in support of Option 2 and include construction of a sidewalkon the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard as part of the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project (CIP No. 6054). Please vote to proceed with final design, environmental review, permitting, andconstruction of the sidewalk (Option 2). Thank you for prioritizing safe, equitablepublic access to our coast. Sincerely, Vanessa Vanessa Forsythe RN MSN 2177 Vista La Nisa Carlsbad CA 92009 CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. 1 Morgen Fry From:Jason Fackler <jason@sockguy.com> Sent:Tuesday, June 9, 2026 2:40 PM To:City Clerk Subject:Support Option 2 — Build Sidewalk on Carlsbad Blvd (CIP No. 6054) Dear Mayor and Council, Please choose Option 2 and include a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard for the Terramar Area Coastal Improvements Project (CIP No. 6054). A continuous sidewalk between La Costa Ave and Cannon will improve public access to the beach, increase pedestrian safety, and connect neighborhoods to transit and the coastal trail. Sidewalks serve seniors, children, people with disabilities, and others who don’t drive. Building it now avoids costlier retrofits later. Thank you for protecting safe, equitable access to our coast. Sincerely, Jason Fackler CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. All Receive - Agenda Item #_____ For the Information of the: CITY COUCNIL Date: ___________ CA ____ CC____ CM ____ ACM ____ DCM (3) ____ 14 6/10/2026 x x x x x Tom Frank, Transportation Director/City Engineer June 9, 2026 Terramar Area Sidewalk Options 1 Nov. 27, 2018 City Council selects preferred option 2018 - Present Environmental analysis, permitting and design Fall 2024 Construction began on water and sewer improvements Oct. 28, 2025 City Council approved a smaller-scale project including repaving, restriping and potentially new sidewalks 2015 Public input on needs, priorities and design considerations 2015 - 2018 Develop initial concepts and gather community input ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS Oct. 15, 2013 City Council direction to pursue complete streets improvements on Carlsbad Blvd Late 2025 - Early 2026 Staff analysis of new sidewalks and parking impacts March 2026 Community input 2 April 6, 2026 Traffic Safety & Mobility Commission Potential sidewalks Resurface and restripe 3 4 ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS Bicyclists Vehicles Carlsbad Boulevard Weekday 786 402 12,711 Weekend 1,853 780 14,021 Cannon Road Weekday 203 129 5,923 Weekend 305 168 6,000 4 DAILY TRAFFIC VOLUMES 5 ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 5 PARKING IMPACTS ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 6 PARKING IMPACTS •Terramar Association meeting on March 12 •Postcard mailer to Terramar residents •City Manager’s Update newsletters •Social media posts •Emails to project interest lists •Website updates ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 7 COMMUNITY INPUT Online form (347 responses received) Email Commission meeting ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 8 COMMUNITY INPUT ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 33%67%Terramar residents and/or property owners Live elsewhere and visit the area 9 WHAT WE HEARD ONLINE INPUT FORM 47%52% 1% Yes sidewalks No sidewalks No response ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 10 WHAT WE HEARD ONLINE INPUT FORM 47%52% 1% ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 11 WHAT WE HEARD ONLINE INPUT FORM Preferred sidewalk location •84 responses: Sidewalks on both sides •62 responses: West side only •17 responses: East side only ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS WHAT WE HEARD EMAIL AND IN-PERSON •Pavement condition •Maintain neighborhood characteristics, including vegetation •Preference for natural pathway instead of paved sidewalk •Parking concerns, impacts on neighborhood streets •Lack of pedestrians on the east side •Need for safety improvements for pedestrians •Safety concerns at Cerezo Drive intersection •Privacy concerns •Pedestrian visibility concerns with existing conditions 12 ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION •Proceed with resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks on Carlsbad Boulevard o Consider a secondary project for parking north of Cannon Road after the Seaside Transaction Agreement is complete o Consider coordinating with State Parks on the coastal bluffs 13 OPTIONS 1.Road resurfacing and restriping with no sidewalks 2.Road resurfacing and restriping, and construction of a sidewalk on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard 3.Other direction as provided ITEM 14: TERRAMAR COASTAL IMPROVEMENTS 14 Conceptual with sidewalk on both sides 18 Conceptual with sidewalk on west side 19