Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
CDP 16-42; SAFETY FENCING AT SEA CAVE; Coastal Development Permit (CDP)
(City of LAND USE REVIEW Development Services Planning Division Carlsbad APPLICATION 1635 Faraday Avenue P-1 (760) 602-4610 www.carlsbadca.gov APPLICATIONS APPLIED FOR:(CHECK BOXES) Development Permits (FOR DEPT. USE ONLY)Legislative Permits (FOR DEPT. USE ONLY) O Coastal Development Permit El Minor COP111014 General Plan Amendment O Conditional Use Permit 0 Minor 0 Extension D Local Coastal Program Amendment 0 Day Care (Large)0 Master Plan 0 Amendment 0 Environmental Impact Assessment 0 Specific Plan 0 Amendment O Habitat Management Permit 0 Minor 0 Zone Change O Hillside Development Permit 0 Minor 0 Zone Code Amendment O Nonconforming Construction Permit South Carlsbad Coastal Review Area Permits O Planned Development Permit 0 Minor 0 Review Permit 0 Residential 0 Non-Residential Administrative 0 Minor Major O Planning Commission Determination O Reasonable Accommodation Village Review Area Permits O Site Development Plan 0 Minor 0 Review Permit O Special Use Permit 0 Administrative Minor 0 Major O Tentative Parcel Map (Minor Subdivision) O Tentative Tract Map (Major Subdivision) O Variance El Minor NOTE: A PROPOSED PROJECT REQUIRING MULTIPLE APPLICATIONS MUST BE SUBMITTED PRIOR TO 3:30 P.M.A PROPOSED PROJECT REQUIRING ONLY ONE APPLICATION MUST BE SUBMITTED PRIOR TO 4:00 P.M. ASSESSOR PARCEL NO(S).:210-120-29 PROJECT NAME:Safety Fencing at Sea Cave Natural Feature BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:Instal 4' chain link fencing to reroute the pedestrian trail off the roof of the sea cave. PROJECT VALUE ESTIMATED COMPLETION DATE(SITE IMPROVEMENTS) LOCATION OF PROJECT:5400 Block of Carlsbad Blvd. STREET ADDRESS ON THE:West SIDE OF Carlsbad Blvd. (NORTH, SOUTH, EAST, WEST)(NAME OF STREET) BETWEEN Cerezo Drive AND Palomar Airport Road (NAME OF STREET)(NAME OF STREET) P-1 Page 1 of 6 Revised 09/16 • OWNER NAME (Print):Lisa Urbach rd./ago:re APPLICANT NAME (Print):Lisa Urbach lath "(Wag MAILING ADDRESS:2680 Carlsbad Blvd.MAILING ADDRESS:2680 Carlsbad Blvd. CITY, STATE, ZIP:Carlsbad, CA 92008 CITY, STATE, ZIP:Carlsbad, CA 92008 TELEPHONE:760-720-7001 TELEPHONE:760-720-7001 EMAIL ADDRESS:lisa.urbach©parks.ca.gov EMAIL ADDRESS: I CERTIFY THAT I AM THE LEGAL OWNER AND THAT ALL THE ABOVE I CERTIFY THAT I AM THE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE OWNER INFORMATION IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF MY AND THAT ALL THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO KNOWLEDGE.I CERTIFY AS LEGAL OWNER THAT THE APPLICANT AS THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE. SET FORTH HE IN I MY AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE FOR PU P ES OFT AP TI I 011412.0a.101L/17016 SIGNATURE DATE SIG ATURE DATE APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE (Print): MAILING ADDRESS: CITY, STATE, ZIP: TELEPHONE: EMAIL ADDRESS: I CERTIFY THAT I AM THE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE APPLICANT FOR PURPOSES OF THIS APPLICATION AND THAT ALL THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF MY KNO DGE. fr SI NATURE DATE IN THE PROCESS OF REVIEWING THIS APPLICATION IT MAY BE NECESSARY FOR MEMBERS OF CITY STAFF,PLANNING COMMISSIONERS OR CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS TO INSPECT AND ENTER THE PROPERTY THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THIS APPLICATION.I/WE CONSENT TO ENTRY FOR THIS PURPOSE. NOTICE OF RESTRICTION:PROPERTY OWNER ACKNOWLEDGES AND CONSENTS TO A NOTICE OF RESTRICTION BEING RECORDED ON THE TITLE TO HIS PROPERTY IF CONDITIONED FOR THE APPLICANT.NOTICE OF RESTRICTIONS RUN WITH THE LAND AND BIND ANY SUCCESSORS IN INTEREST. PROPERTY OWNER SIGNATURE FOR CITY USE ONLY RECEIVED OCT 0 4 2016 CITY OF CARLSBAD PLANNING DIVISION DATE STAMP APPLICATION RECEIVED RECEIVED BY: P-1 Page 2 of 6 Revised 09/16 Development Services City of DISCLOSURE STATEMENT Planning Division Carlsbad P-1(A)1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-4610 www.carlsbadca.gov Applicant's statement or disclosure of certain ownership interests on all applications which will require discretionary action on the part of the City Council or any appointed Board, Commission or Committee. The following information MUST be disclosed at the time of application submittal.Your project cannot be reviewed until this information is completed. Please print. Note: Person is defined as "Any individual, firm, co-partnership, joint venture, association, social club, fraternal organization, corporation, estate, trust, receiver, syndicate, in this and any other county, city and county, city municipality, district or other political subdivision or any other group or combination acting as a unit." Agents may sign this document; however, the legal name and entity of the applicant and property owner must be provided below. 1.APPLICANT (Not the applicant's agent) Provide the COMPLETE,LEGAL names and addresses of ALL persons having a financial interest in the application. If the applicant includes a corporation or partnership, include the names,titles,addresses of all individuals owning more than 10%of the shares.IF NO INDIVIDUALS OWN MORE THAN 10%OF THE SHARES,PLEASE INDICATE NON-APPLICABLE (N/A)IN THE SPACE BELOW.If a publicly-owned corporation,include the names,titles,and addresses of the corporate officers.(A separate page may be attached if necessary.) Person Corp/Part Title Title Address Address 2.OWNER (Not the owner's agent) Provide the COMPLETE,LEGAL names and addresses of ALL persons having any ownership interest in the property involved.Also,provide the nature of the legal ownership (i.e.,partnership,tenants in common,non -profit,corporation,etc.).If the ownership includes a corporation or partnership, include the names, titles, addresses of all individuals owning more than 10% of the shares.IF NO INDIVIDUALS OWN MORE THAN 10%OF THE SHARES,PLEASE INDICATE NON-APPLICABLE (N/A)IN THE SPACE BELOW.If a publicly-owned corporation,include the names,titles,and addresses of the corporate officers.(A separate page may be attached if necessary.) Person Corp/Part State of California Title Title Department of Parks & Recreation Address Address San Diego Coast District 4477 Pacific Hwy. San Diego, CA 92110 P-1(A)Page 1 of 2 Revised 07/10 11111.11101111 Illibouweirmilitiiiiirowa.....~.4411111111111.1111 0 3.NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATION OR TRUST If any person identified pursuant to (1) or (2) above is a nonprofit organization or a trust, list the names and addresses of ANY person serving as an officer or director of the non- profit organization or as trustee or beneficiary of the. Non. Profit/Trust N/A Non Profit/Trust Title Title Address Address 4.Have you had more than $500 worth of business transacted with any member of City staff,Boards,Commissions,Committees and/or Council within the past twelve (12) months? I=1 Yes ID No If yes, please indicate person(s): NOTE:Attach additional sheets if necessary. I certify that all the above information is true and correct to the best of my knowledge. iP‘44L (1)61"-1in-l7o16 va.614.t.L)//2_/zotco Signature of owner/date Signature of applicant/date 4•46644beehreitate-Par44-Sidiaerintendelltiti.LSk 142 4(11 /PS EEC Print or type name of owner Print or type name of applicant Signature of owner/applicant's agent if applicable/date Print or type name of owner/applicant's agent P-1(A)Page 2 of 2 Revised 07/10 1111111111110111 impowiNiomimaid1151111111 CP CC o•ity f PROJECT DESCRIPTION Development Services Planning Division Carlsbad P-1(B)1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-4610 www.carlsbadca.gov PROJECT NAME:Safety Fencing at Sea Cave Natural Feature APPLICANT NAME:Department of Parks and Recreation Please describe fully the proposed project by application type.Include any details necessary to adequately explain the scope and/or operation of the proposed project.You may also include any background information and supporting statements regarding the reasons for,or appropriateness of, the application.Use an addendum sheet if necessary. Description/Explanation: See attached documents. This project will replace temporary orange fencing, currently surrounding a naturally formed sea cave, with a chain link fence.The sea cave is located approximately 350 feet north of Manzano Drive, on the bluff face, in Carlsbad at the Terramar Bluffs.The foot print of the fencing is 40 foot by 110 foot, encompassing the entire cave and the surrounding area to keep people at a safe distance. The fence will match existing fence at 4' tall. The sea cave, measured on April 11, 2016, was approximately 30 feet wide, 18 feet deep and 28 feet high. The roof thickness was about 5 feet thick at the front face and about 4 feet thick at the apex of the roof. Currently, the sea cave has expanded to approximately 50 feet wide. For the public safety, we hope to keep fencing away from sides of cave at 110 feet. This project will entail a total of 23 posts for the fencing to attach to.There will be one-two foot deep hole dug at each corner and additional posts every 10 feet.Each of the four corner posts will have two bags of concrete to secure the terminal posts.All remaining posts (19) will each have one bag of concrete to secure the post.The fencing will only be placed from the existing fence-to the east, away from the bluff face.There is an unauthorized foot trail west of the bluff face, also currently marked off with temporary fencing, that we will not be replacing with chain link fence. The goal of this project is to keep the public safely out of the sea cave area and post signs on the fencing alerting the public to the dangerous bluffs. P-1(B)Page 1 of 1 Revised 07/10 111111110011.111011011110111111.11111111 0 HAZARDOUS WASTE Development Services(City of AND SUBSTANCES Planning Division Carlsbad STATEMENT 1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-4610P-1(C)www.carlsbadca.gov Consultation of Lists of Sites Related to Hazardous Wastes (Certification of Compliance with Government Code Section 65962.5) Pursuant to State of California Government Code Section 65962.5,I have consulted the Hazardous Waste and Substances Sites List compiled by the California Environmental Protection Agency and hereby certify that (check one): El The development project and any alternatives proposed in this application are not contained on the lists compiled pursuant to Section 65962.5 of the State Government Code. The development project and any alternatives proposed in this application are contained on the lists compiled pursuant to Section 65962.5 of the State Government Code. APPLICANT PROPERTY OWNER Name:Name: Same as disclosure statement Address:Address: Phone Number:Phone Number:760-720-7001 Address of Site:5400 block of Carlsbad Blvd. Local Agency (City and County):Carlsbad, San Diego Assessor's book, page, and parcel number:2 I 0 2-0 Specify list(s): Regulatory Identification Number: Date of List: SAS -I 21-4 V p.nt -u.a ure/Date (a)C.)Property Owner Signature/Date The Hazardous Waste and Substances Sites List (Cortese List)is used by the State,local agencies and developers to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act requirements in providing information about the location of hazardous materials release sites. P-1(C)Page 1 of 2 Revised 02/13 MINOR Development Services(City of COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT/Planning DivisionSINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCECarlsbadAPPLICATION 1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-4610 P-6 www.carlsbadca.gov A proposed project requiring multiple applications must be submitted prior to 3:30 p.m.A proposed project requiring only one application must be submitted prior to 4:00 p.m. All joint application exhibits, i.e. Tentative Map and Planned Development Site Plan should be prepared at the same scale.(Use a scale no smaller than 1" =40'.) I.GENERAL BACKGROUND A.Estimated Cost of Development: Development costing $60,000 or more does not qualify as a Minor Coastal Development Permit. The City Planner shall make the final determination regarding a project's cost of development. The primary basis for determining cost of development will be the application of dollar costs per square foot for different types of residential construction.These costs are set by the International Conference of Building Officials (ICBO) and are applied throughout San Diego County. Please complete the following information to assist in the determination of this project's cost of development (Contractor proposals may also be submitted for consideration by the City Planner).Please refer to the current fee schedule for the appropriate $/square foot fee rate. New Residential Square Footage: square feet x $/sq. ft. =$ Residential Addition Square Footage: square feet x $/sq. ft. =$ Any Garage Square Footage: square feet x $/sq. ft. =$ Residential Conversion Square Footage: square feet x $/sq. ft. =$ Please contact the City of Carlsbad Building Division for current fee rate for Non- Residential uses (i.e. Retail/Store; Restaurants; Office; and Manufacturing/Warehouse uses.) square feet x $/sq. ft.=$ COST OF DEVELOPMENT ESTIMATE: $Uhaer &D 000 . B.Do you wish to apply for: 1.A Minor Coastal Development Permit (Under $60,000 cost estimate)E 2.A Coastal Development Permit ($60,000 or more cost estimate) C.Street address of proposed development 5400 block of Carlsbad Blvd. P-6 Page 1 of 6 Revised 08/16 INIMINSIONWSONNWil 111111MINIMMOINOwisoftwiarsiewommill 11111101moreramass"iiiiiillin 0 D.Assessor's Parcel Number of proposed development 2101202900 E.Development Description: Briefly describe project:Install chain link safety fencing to reroute the pedestrian trail off the roof of the sea cave. F.Describe the present land uses (i.e. vacant land, single family homes, apartments, offices, etc.) that surround the proposed development to the: North:open space South:open space East:open space open spaceWest: G.Is project located within a 100-year flood plain? Yes E No II.PRESENT USE OF PROPERTY A.Are there existing structures on the property? Yes E No If yes, please describe. B.Will any existing structure be removed/demolished?O Yes g No If yes to either question, describe the extent of the demolition or removal, including the relocation site, if applicable (also show on plans). III.LOT COVERAGE A.Existing and Proposed Existing Proposed Total Building Coverage sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.0/0 Landscaped Area sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft. Hardscape Area sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft. Unimproved Area (Left Natural)sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft. 1 P-6 Page 2 of 6 Revised 08/16 111110011WINSINSMINIMI B.Parking:Number of existing spaces Number of new spaces proposed Existing/Proposed TOTAL: Number of total spaces required Number of covered spaces Number of uncovered spaces Number of standard spaces Number of compact spaces Is tandem parking existing?I=1 Yes #El No Is tandem parking proposed? Yes #El No C.Grade Alteration: Is any grading proposed?EJ Yes ID No If yes, please complete the following: 1.Amount of cut cu. yds. 2.Amount of fill cu. yds. 3.Maximum height of fill slope feet 4.Maximum height of cut slope feet 5.Amount of import or export cu. yds. 6.Location of borrow or disposal site • P-6 Page 3 of 6 Revised 08/16 I r -STORM WATER STANDARDS Development Services Citv of QUESTIONNAIRE Land Development Engineering Carlsbad E -34 1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-2750 www.ca rlsbadca.gov INSTRUCTIONS: To address post-development pollutants that may be generated from development projects,the city requires that new development and significant redevelopment priority projects incorporate Permanent Storm Water Best Management Practices (BMPs) into the project design per Carlsbad BMP Design Manual (BMP Manual).To view the BMP Manual, refer to the Engineering Standards (Volume 5). This questionnaire must be completed by the applicant in advance of submitting for a development application (subdivision,discretionary permits and/or construction permits).The results of the questionnaire determine the level of storm water standards that must be applied to a proposed development or redevelopment project.Depending on the outcome,your project will either be subject to 'STANDARD PROJECT'requirements or be subject to 'PRIORITY DEVELOPMENT PROJECT' (PDP) requirements. Your responses to the questionnaire represent an initial assessment of the proposed project conditions and impacts.City staff has responsibility for making the final assessment after submission of the development application.If staff determines that the questionnaire was incorrectly filled out and is subject to more stringent storm water standards than initially assessed by you, this will result in the return of the development application as incomplete.In this case,please make the changes to the questionnaire and resubmit to the city. If you are unsure about the meaning of a question or need help in determining how to respond to one or more of the questions, please seek assistance from Land Development Engineering staff. A completed and signed questionnaire must be submitted with each development project application.Only one completed and signed questionnaire is required when multiple development applications for the same project are submitted concurrently. PROJECT INFORMATION PROJECT NAME:Safety Fencing PROJECT ID: ADDRESS:5400 Block of Carlsbad Blvd.APN:210-120-29 The project is (check one): New Development Redevelopment The total proposed disturbed area is:4400 ft2 (0.101 )acres 1010.The total proposed newly created and/or replaced impervious area is:4400 ft2 ()acres If your project is covered by an approved SWQMP as part of a larger development project, provide the project ID and the SWQMP # of the larger development project: Project ID N/A SWQMP #: Then,go to Step 1 and follow the instructions.When completed,sign the form at the end and submit this with your application to the city. E-34 Page 1 of 4 REV 02/16 1.4) • STEP 1 TO BE COMPLETED FOR ALL PROJECTS To determine if your project is a "development project", please answer the following question: YES NO Is your project LIMITED TO routine maintenance activity and/or repair/improvements to an existing building or structure that do not alter the size (See Section 1.3 of the BMP Design Manual for guidance)? If you answered "yes" to the above question, provide justification below then go to Step 5,mark the third box stating "my project is not a 'development project'and not subject to the requirements of the BMP manual" and complete applicant information. Justification/discussion: (e.g. the project includes only interior remodels within an existing building): If you answered "no" to the above question, the project is a 'development project', go to Step 2. STEP 2 TO BE COMPLETED FOR ALL DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS To determine if your project is exempt from PDP requirements pursuant to MS4 Permit Provision E.3.b.(3), please answer the following questions: Is your project LIMITED to one or more of the following: YES NO 1.Constructing new or retrofitting paved sidewalks, bicycle lanes or trails that meet the following criteria: a)Designed and constructed to direct storm water runoff to adjacent vegetated areas, or other non- erodible permeable areas; b)Designed and constructed to be hydraulically disconnected from paved streets or roads; c)Designed and constructed with permeable pavements or surfaces in accordance with USEPA Green Streets guidance? 2.Retrofitting or redeveloping existing paved alleys, streets, or roads that are designed and constructed in accordance with the USEPA Green Streets guidance? 3.Ground Mounted Solar Array that meets the criteria provided in section 1.4.2 of the BMP manual? If you answered "yes" to one or more of the above questions, provide discussion/justification below, then go to Step 5, mark the second box stating "my project is EXEMPT from PDP ..." and complete applicant information. Discussion to justify exemption (e.g. the project redeveloping existing road designed and constructed in accordance with the USEPA Green Street guidance): If you answered "no" to the above questions, your project is not exempt from PDP, go to Step 3. E-34 Page 2 of 4 REV 02/16 STEP 3 TO BE COMPLETED FOR ALL NE1t•11 OR REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS To determine if your project is a PDP, please answer the following questions (MS4 Permit Provision E.3.b.(1)): YES NO 1.Is your project a new development that creates 10,000 square feet or more of impervious surfaces collectively over the entire project site?This includes commercial,industrial,residential,mixed-use, and public development projects on public or private land. 2.Is your project a redevelopment project creating and/or replacing 5,000 square feet or more of impervious surface collectively over the entire project site on an existing site of 10,000 square feet or more of impervious surface?This includes commercial,industrial,residential,mixed-use,and public development projects on public or private land. 3.Is your project a new or redevelopment project that creates and/or replaces 5,000 square feet or more of impervious surface collectively over the entire project site and supports a restaurant?A restaurant is a facility that sells prepared foods and drinks for consumption, including stationary lunch counters and refreshment stands selling prepared foods and drinks for immediate consumption (Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) code 5812). 4.Is your project a new or redevelopment project that creates 5,000 square feet or more of impervious surface collectively over the entire project site and supports a hillside development project?A hillside development project includes development on any natural slope that is twenty-five percent or greater. 5.Is your project a new or redevelopment project that creates and/or replaces 5,000 square feet or more of impervious surface collectively over the entire project site and supports a parking lot? A parking lot is a land area or facility for the temporary parking or storage of motor vehicles used personally for business or for commerce. 6.Is your project a new or redevelopment project that creates and/or replaces 5,000 square feet or more of impervious surface collectively over the entire project site and supports a street,road,highway freeway or driveway?A street,road,highway,freeway or driveway is any paved impervious surface used for the transportation of automobiles, trucks, motorcycles, and other vehicles. 7.Is your project a new or redevelopment project that creates and/or replaces 2,500 square feet or more of impervious surface collectively over the entire site,and discharges directly to an Environmentally Sensitive Area (ESA)?"Discharging Directly to" includes flow that is conveyed overland a distance of 200 feet or less from the project to the ESA, or conveyed in a pipe or open channel any distance as an isolated flow from the project to the ESA (i.e. not commingled with flows from adjacent lands).* 8.Is your project a new development or redevelopment project that creates and/or replaces 5,000 square feet or more of impervious surface that supports an automotive repair shop?An automotive repair shop is a facility that is categorized in any one of the following Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) codes: 5013, 5014, 5541,7532-7534, or 7536-7539. 9.Is your project a new development or redevelopment project that creates and/or replaces 5,000 square feet or more of impervious area that supports a retail gasoline outlet (RGO)?This category includes RGO's that meet the following criteria:(a)5,000 square feet or more or (b)a project Average Daily Traffic (ADT)of 100 or more vehicles per day. 10.Is your project a new or redevelopment project that results in the disturbance of one or more acres of land and are expected to generate pollutants post construction? 11.Is your project located within 200 feet of the Pacific Ocean and (1) creates 2,500 square feet or more of impervious surface or (2)increases impervious surface on the property by more than 10%?(CMC 21.203.040) If you answered "yes" to one or more of the above questions, your project is a PDP.If your project is a redevelopment project, go to step 4.If your project is a new project, go to step 5,check the first box stating "My project is a PDP ..." and complete applicant information. If you answered "no" to all of the above questions, your project is a 'STANDARD PROJECT.'Go to step 5,check the second box stating "My project is a 'STANDARD PROJECT'..." and complete applicant information. E-34 Page 3 of 4 REV 02/16 ik STEP 4 TO BE COMPLETED FOR REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS THAT ARE PRIORITY DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS (PDP) ONLY Complete the questions below regarding your redevelopment project (MS4 Permit Provision E.3.b.(2)): YES NO Does the redevelopment project result in the creation or replacement of impervious surface in an amount of less than 50%of the surface area of the previously existing development?Complete the percent impervious calculation below: Existing impervious area (A)=sq. ft.CI El Total proposed newly created or replaced impervious area (B)=sq. ft. Percent impervious area created or replaced (B/A)*100 =% If you answered "yes",the structural BMPs required for PDP apply only to the creation or replacement of impervious surface and not the entire development.Go to step 5, check the first box stating "My project is a PDP ..." and complete applicant information. If you answered "no," the structural BMP's required for PDP apply to the entire development.Go to step 5, check the check the first box stating "My project is a PDP ..." and complete applicant information. STEP 5 CHECK THE APPROPRIATE BOX AND COMPLETE APPLICANT INFORMATION O My project is a PDP and must comply with PDP stormwater requirements of the BMP Manual.I understand I must prepare a Storm Water Quality Management Plan (SWQMP) for submittal at time of application. O My project is a 'STANDARD PROJECT' OR EXEMPT from PDP and must only comply with 'STANDARD PROJECT' stormwater requirements of the BMP Manual.As part of these requirements,I will submit a "Standard Project Requirement Checklist Form E-36" and incorporate low impact development strategies throughout my project. Note:For projects that are close to meeting the PDP threshold, staff may require detailed impervious area calculations and exhibits to verify if 'STANDARD PROJECT' stormwater requirements apply. E My Project is NOT a 'development project'and is not subject to the requirements of the BMP Manual. Applicant Information and Signature Box Applicant Name:Lk --(A.4." te)CL-C..("._Applicant Title:Sir&Park—Superstr-fac(roc. Applicant Signature:A/dOL?__A_c..(i.4 i Date:I 0 /44/2Z I *Environmentally Sensitive Areas include but are not limited to all Clean Water Act Section 303(d) impaired water bodies; areas designated as Areas of Special Biological Significance by the State Water Resources Control Board (Water Quality Control Plan for the San Diego Basin (1994) and amendments); water bodies designated with the RARE beneficial use by the State Water Resources Control Board (Water Quality Control Plan for the San Diego Basin (1994)and amendments); areas designated as preserves or their equivalent under the Multi Species Conservation Program within the Cities and County of San Diego; Habitat Management Plan; and any other equivalent environmentally sensitive areas which have been identified by the City. This Box for City Use Only YES NO City Concurrence:0 0 By: Date: Project ID: E-34 Page 4 of 4 REV 02/16 di NM City of Carlsbad 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad CA 92008 1111111111111111111111111 Applicant:STATE OF CALIFORNIA PARK Description Amount CDP16042 884.22 Receipt Number:R0120615 Transaction ID:R0120615 Transaction Date:10/04/2016 Pay Type Method Description Amount Payment Check 214338 884.22 Transaction Amount:884.22 0\ri 4111 .• City of Carlsbad Faraday Center Faraday Cashiering 001 1627801 -2 10/04/2016 149 Tue,Oct 04,2016 11:42 AM Receipt Ref Nbr:R1627801 -2/0023 PERMITS -PERMITS Tran Ref Nbr:162780102 0023 0027 Trans/Rcpt#:R0120615 SET #:CDP16042 Amount:1 L $884.22 Item Subtotal:$884.22 Item Total:$884.22 1 ITEM(S)TOTAL:$884.22 Check (Chk#366)$884.22 Total Received:$884.22 Have a nice day! **************CUSTOMER copy************* ,,n State of California —The Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION CEQA PROJECT COMPLETION VERIFICATION TO:Project Manager: Vince Kraft DATE: July 27, 2016 District PM: Lisa Urbach FROM:Cindy Krimmel, District Environmental Coordinator (DEC) 619-278-3771 Luke Sema, Service Center Environmental Coordinator (SCEC) 619-221-7068 PROJECT TITLE: Safety Fencing at Sea Cave Natural Feature (16/17-SD-02) PARK UNIT: Carlsbad State Beach DISTRICT: San Diego Coast This project is approved to proceed with the following measures incorporated and/or comments considered: Service Center Environmental Coordinator (Luke Sema: 619-221-7068) 1.Please include within the PEF and/or SLR worksheet that the sea cave has formed as a result of wave uprush and began to form approximately 7-9 months ago. This information could be used to assess whether further collapse may occur and if any other precautions would be warranted.Geological evaluation during a site visit determined that the receding cliffs are limestone. 2.Coordination with the Coastal Commission should take place to keep them aware of the sea cave's condition as well as CSPs efforts to place fencing above it to protect the public.CCC may have recommendations for continuing public access while maintaining visitor safety. Biological Resources (Cara Stafford: 619-718-7868) 1.None Water Quality Protection Measures 1.None Archaeological Resource Protection Measures (Nicole Turner: 619-933-9013) 1.Given the lack of ground visibility, as a result of ice plant vegetation, it is recommended that an initial spot check by an archaeologist during posthole excavation be conducted at onset of project. Please contact District Archaeologist Nicole Turner to schedule an archaeological monitor. Historical Resource Protection Measures (Alex Bevil: 619-221-7041) 1.None As the Project Manager, you are responsible for ensuring that all project requirements, restrictions, or mitigations are adhered to. This includes reviewing all comments, briefing any staff and contractors who may work on the project, and coordinating the on-site presence of specialist staff, if required. Please take pictures both before and after work is complete for inclusion with the project file. Please send the pictures to both the DEC and SCEC. You are also responsible for verifying project completion. When the project is complete, please sign and date this form and return it to the DEC. Please note any problems or comments you may have concerning the project. If the project is cancelled or postponed for a significant period of time, please inform the DEC as soon as possible. PROJECT MANAGER CERTIFICATION I certify that this project haS been completed in compliance with the above conditions. PROJECT MANAGER SIGNATURE DATE COMMENTS: DPR 510 (New 4/2003)(Excel 2/11/2005 State of California Environmental Review Memorandum Date :July 27, 2016 Attached Please Find: To Vince Kraft El Project Evaluation Form's: Dept.of Parks and Recreation ®For Signature (Final)0San Diego Coast District For Review and Comment0For Redesign/Modification/Resubmittal05024 Review Forms:Cindy Krimmel Dept. of Parks and Recreation 0 For Signature and Return (Final)• San Diego Coast District 0 For Review (Contact Reviewing Specialist) Notice/s of Exemption 15303 Project's :Carlsbad State Beach —Safety Fencing at Sea Cave Natural 0 Other: Feature —(16/17-SD-02) Please Note:0 Additional Information Requested (see Comments section below) Eg Project Modification/s or Condition/s (see Comments section below) El See Archaeological Site 5024 Review Form (Section/s: El See Historic Facility 5024 Review Form (Section/s: See Archaeologist's Comments on PEF El See Historian's Comments on PEF El See Resource Ecologist's Comments on PEF El See Maintenance Chief's Comments on PEF Comments: Service Center Environmental Coordinator (Luke Serna: 619-221-7068) 1.Please include within the PEF and/or SLR worksheet that the sea cave has formed as a result of wave uprush and began to form approximately 7-9 months ago. This information could be used to assess whether further collapse may occur and if any other precautions would be warranted. Geological evaluation during a site visit determined that the receding cliffs are limestone. 2.Coordination with the Coastal Commission should take place to keep them aware of the sea cave's condition as well as CSPs efforts to place fencing above it to protect the public. CCC may have recommendations for continuing public access while maintaining visitor safety. Biological Resources (Cara Stafford: 619-718-7868) 1.None Water Quality Protection Measures 1.None Archaeological Resource Protection Measures (Nicole Turner: 619-933-9013) 1.Given the lack of ground visibility, as a result of ice plant vegetation, it is recommended that an initial spot check by an archaeologist during posthole excavation be conducted at onset of project. Please contact District Archaeologist Nicole Turner to schedule an archaeological monitor. Historical Resource Protection Measures (Alex Bevil: 619-221-7041) 1.None If project is constructed as described, it is exempt from CEQA. Please return the signed CEQA Project Completion Verification with the before and after photographs. Sincerely, c/R- 66a/ "VitA() Cindy Krimmel Environmental Coordinator, San Diego Coast District, (619) 278-3771, E-mail: Cindy.Krimmel@parks.ca.gov 0 .• • •-••Stale of California —Tiie Resource •.*Agency'1"- ••- • DEPARTMENT OF PARKS•.)-E NOTICE OF EXEMPTIO.N. •20 6 0 78 557 TO:'.Office of Planning .and Research 1400 Tenth Street, Room 222 FROM :Department of Parks Recreation 1416 Ninth Street ••• RO. 5.0.)00.44 P0 Box 94296 . Sacramento.. CA 15814 :Sacramento.•CA:042•9......... .. PROJECT TITLE:'SafetyPeriding at Sea Cave Natural Feature (46117-SD-02) 1.4CATION:Carlabad•State Beach :CoONTY;San 0.10:00. -- DESCRIPTION OF THE NATURE AND PURPOSE OF PROjEcT:. This project will .replace temporary fencing with a permanent:chainlin151ente on the bluff above Carlsbad State Beach The fence blocks the previous :trait that goes over the roof of the cave vid. reroutes footitaffiCOn solid ground,:protet pUbliO nealtharid safety'.- • PUBLIC AGENCY APPROVING THE PROJEOT:.Clffornia Department ofParksand Recreation: NAME OF OW-15PN OR DISTRICT CARRYING OUT PROJECT :6•Ardaregtoatt oovipToriro*• D Nelarecl Emergent y(sectiOli 15269ka)). O Emergency Project (Section 15269(b) and leD OStatutory Exemption • ElCategorical Exemption • •• 0/004:a .500ti-o.69):15303 • REASONS WHY PROJECT IS EXEMPT:No potential.for significant impact to the environment is anticipated in compliance with CEQA §15300 2 if the pipet is implemented as indicated within the project description including conditions provided by CDPRishadallata. then It is exempt under§1'$.5a-New Constryctipn. The action falls under the Departmental List ofExempt attivitieS •according to: OE0A 0:1•004.4 'Constructiongr installation of park facilities ;$4e.nee fencing.$.iono....''''1:0100$ CONTACT;Cindy •Krimmel •PHONE; '.(010.)2164771 District Environmental Coordinator EMAIL: cindy.krimmel@parks.Qa.gov California Department of Parks& Recreation San Diego Coast District Headquarters 44:77•PadifIc Highway ..„..... San Die:go. GA 9211p GovemetsOfficeofPlannino&Research JUL 21 2016 •STATECLEARINGHOUSE ene District Sup rinton,drit,.-Sar) Diego Coast .District 24 •'Date •' DPR 508:(Rikt 4/2003)rord 4/4/2003 ty U C4 --11.64 - 1AAck R61.11AAJL e S Ito 117-51) —02 Routing Slip for CEQA/PEF Review PLEASE INITIAL, DATE & RETURN TO CINDY KRIMMEL (619) 278-3771 USE BLUE INK 'Visit& Date received Deferred maintenance Copy in CEQA file Environmental Coordinator 0.1Cindy Krimmel . District Superintendent Robin Greene 9 Sector Superintendent LAitArrL.ci.„Vv•-a711cliG. District Services Manager Darren Smith Environmental Scientist Cara Stafford 31111( Maintenance Chief Susan Kosek-Kelly Archaeologist ..Nicole Turner -E I i Historian ..Alex Bevil a._//97;10 12-i(" Tribal Liaison ..Nicole Turner 7 //1/Lo Accessibility -7/0.-7/240 Other Cindy Krimmel Service Center Robin Greene Cindy Krimmel Needs Fire Marshall review State of California —Natural Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. PROJECT CONCEPT PROJECT TITLE PARK UNIT NAME Safety Fencing at Sea Cave Natural Feature Carlsbad State Beach DISTRICT NAME FACILITY NO. San Diego Coast 612 PROJECT MANAGER PHONE NO.EMAIL Vince Kraft 760-438-5021 Vince.Kraft@parks.ca.gov DISTRICT PROJECT MANAGER PHONE NO.EMAIL Lisa Urbach 760-331-9178 Lisa.Urbach@parks.ca.gov PROJECT BID DATE CONSTRUCTION START DATE FUNDING SOURCE Staff Project July 25, 2016 Home Base PROJECT DESCRIPTION Identify the scope of the project in detail, including its purpose, location, and potential impacts.Ifthe ground is to be disturbed, describe the depth and extent of excavation.Describe the existing site conditions, including previous development.Note ifwork will impact or extend beyond park property. Indicate if work will be done in conjunction with, or as part of, other projects. (Use additional pages ifnecessary.) This project will replace temporary orange fencing, currently surrounding a naturally formed sea cave, with a chain link fence.The sea cave is located approximately 350 feet north of Manzano Drive, on the bluff face,in Carlsbad at the Terramar Bluffs.The foot print of the fencing is 40 foot by 170 foot, encompassing the entire cave and the surrounding area to keep people at a safe distance. The sea cave, measured on April 11, 2016,is approximately 30 feet wide,18 feet deep and 28 feet high.The roof thickness is about 5 feet thick at the front face and about 4 feet thick at the apex of the roof. This project will entail a total of 23 posts for the fencing to attach to.There will be one-two foot deep hole dug at each corner and additional posts every 10 feet.Each of the four corner posts will have two bags of concrete to secure the terminal posts.All remaining posts (19) will each have one bag of concrete to secure the post.The fencing will only be placed from the existing fence-to the east, away from the bluff face.There is an unauthorized foot trail west of the bluff face, also currently marked off with temporary fencing, that we will not be replacing with chain link fence. The goal of this project is to keep the public safely out of the sea cave area and post signs on the fencing alerting the public to the dangerous bluffs. DOCUMENTS ATTACHED El 7.5 minute (quad) map of project area (Required) Site Map (Required -Scale should show relationship to existing buildings, roads, landscape features, etc.)Z DPR 727 Accessibility Review and Comment Sheet (Required—Attach DPR 727 or emailed project exemption from the Accessibility Section.) El Sea-level Rise Worksheet (for coastal park units)Z Graphics (Specify -photos, diagrams, drawings, cross-sections, etc.):photos Other (Specify): DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)1 r.... %we 0 Project ID No.1 6/1 7-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS IS AN APPLICATION, PERMIT, OR CONSULTATION REQUIRED?YES MAYBE NO CONTACT Coastal Development Permit 0 0 N 0 DFG Stream Alteration Permit 0 0 N 0 State & Federal Endangered Species Consultation 0 0 N 0 Corps of Engineers 404 Permit 0 0 N 0 RWQCB or NPDES Permit 0 0 N 0 DPR Right to Enter or Temporary Use Permit 0 0 N 0 PRC 5024 Review El El 0 0 Stormwater Management Plan 0 0 N 0 Encroachment Permit (Specify Agency):0 0 N 0 Native American Consultation 0 N 0 0 Other (Specify):0 0 0 0 COMMENTS: DEPARTMENT POLICY COMPLIANCE YES NO HAS A GENERAL PLAN BEEN APPROVED FOR THE UNIT?El 0 If YES, is the project consistent with the GP?El 0 If NO, what is the project justification? Is it a temporary facility?(No permanent resource commitment)0 0 Health and Safety?0 0 Is it a Resource Management Project?0 0 Is it repairing, replacing, or rehabilitating an existing facility?0 0 IS THE PROJECT WITHIN A CLASSIFIED SUBUNIT? Natural Preserve 0 N Cultural Preserve 0 N State Wilderness El N IS THE PROJECT CONSISTENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT'S CULTURAL N 0 RESOURCE MANAGEMENT DIRECTIVES? IS THE PROJECT CONSISTENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT'S OPERATIONS 0 MANUAL CHAPTER 0300? COMMENTS: 411SUPERINTENDE —1%44 CONC APPR•VAL OR DESIGNEE TITLE DATE r District Superintendent 7/Iir iia DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)2 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. RESOURCES Explain all 'Yes' or 'Maybe' answers in the "Evaluation and Comments" section (reference by letter and number).Attach additional pages,if necessary. YES MAYBE NO A.EARTH -WILL THE PROJECT: Z 1.Create unstable soil or geologic conditions? Z 2.Adversely affect topographic features? 0 3.Adversely affect any unusual or significant geologic features? Z 4.Increase wind or water erosion? Z 5.Adversely affect sand deposition or erosion of a sand beach? Z 6.Expose people, property, or facilities to geologic hazards or hazardous waste? 0 7.Adversely affect any paleontological resource? YES MAYBE NO B.AIR -WILL THE PROJECT: Z 1.Adversely affect general air quality or climatic patterns? 0 2.Introduce airborne pollutants that may affect plant or animal vigor or viability? El 3.Increase levels of dust or smoke? Z 4.Adversely affect visibility? YES MAYBE NO C.WATER -WILL THE PROJECT: Z 1.Change or adversely affect movement in marine or fresh waters? Z 2.Change or adversely affect drainage patterns or sediment transportation rates? 0 3.Adversely affect the quantity or quality of groundwater? 0 4.Adversely affect the quantity or quality of surface waters? Z 5.Expose people or property to flood waters? Z 6.Adversely affect existing or potential aquatic habitat(s)? YES MAYBE NO D.PLANT LIFE -WILL THE PROJECT: Z 1.Adversely affect any native plant community? Z 2.Adversely affect any unique, rare, endangered, or protected plant species? Z 3.Introduce a new species of plant to the area? Z 4.Adversely affect agricultural production? 0 5.Adversely affect the vigor or structure of any tree? El 6.Encourage the growth or spread of alien (non-native) species? Z 7.Interfere with established fire management plans or practices? YES MAYBE NO E.ANIMAL LIFE -WILL THE PROJECT: El 1.Adversely affect any native or naturalized animal population? El 2.Adversely affect any unusual, rare, endangered, or protected species? Z 3.Adversely affect any animal habitat? Z 4.Introduce or encourage the proliferation of any non-native species? YES MAYBE.NO F.CULTURAL RESOURCES -WILL THE PROJECT: Z 1.Adversely affect a prehistoric or historic archeological site, or tribal cultural resource? Z 2.Adversely affect a prehistoric or historic building, structure, or object? Z 3.Cause an adverse physical or aesthetic effect on an eligible or contributing building, structure, object, or cultural landscape? Z 4.Diminish the informational or research potential of a cultural resource? El 5.Increase the potential for vandalism or looting? Z 6.Disturb any human remains? Z 7.Restrict access to a sacred site or inhibit the traditional religious practice of a Native American community? DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)3 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. YES MAYBE NO G.AESTHETIC RESOURCES —WILL THE PROJECT: 1.Adversely affect a scenic vista or view? 2.Significantly increase noise levels? 3.Adversely affect the quality of the scenic resources in the immediate area or park-wide? 4.Create a visually offensive site? El 5.Be incompatible with the park design established for this unit or diminish the intended sense of "a special park quality" for the visitor? YES MAYBE NO H.RECREATIONAL RESOURCES —WILL THE PROJECT: 1.Be in a public use area? 2.Have an adverse effect on the quality of the intended visitor experience? 3.Have an adverse effect on the quality or quantity of existing or future recreational opportunities or facilities? 4.Have an adverse effect on the accessibility of recreational facilities (e.g., ADA requirements)? YES MAYBE NO I.SEA-LEVEL RISE AND EXTREME EVENTS (COASTAL UNITS ONLY): 1.Has this project been evaluated for potential impacts from sea-level rise, coastal storm surge, and other extreme events, using the Department's Sea-Level Rise and Extreme Events Guidance Document or an equivalent process?Please attach the Sea-Level Rise Worksheet (provided in the guidance document) or other detailed evaluation. 2.Based on the evaluation described above, will the project be adversely impacted by frequent flooding or permanent inundation during its expected lifetime? Non-coastal unit EVALUATION AND COMMENTS DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 913/2015)4 Project ID No.16117-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW To Be Completed by Qualified Specialist(s) ONLY. Attach additional reviews or continuation pages, as necessary. TRIBAL LIAISON COMMENTS AND SIGNATURE (REQUIRED FOR ALL FINDINGS) E Reviewer is Designated District/Service Center/Division Tribal Liaison or Designee NAHC Listed Tribe(s) contacted (attach correspondence record for contact and findings) Findings: ED Project action does not have potential to affect "tribal cultural" resources (explain) Check more than one box iftribes provide differing responses, and describe all consultations below. El Tribe(s) did not respond Tribe(s)approved project as written Tribe(s)approved project with treatments or conditions El Tribe(s) and DPR unable to reach mutual agreement on project treatments or conditions Explain There are no documented tribal cultural resources at this location.The project as written does not have the potential to impact tribal cultural resources. SIGNATURE PRINTED NAME Nicole Turner TITLE DATE District Tribal Liaison "7 /1/20 / ARCHEOLOGIST COMMENTS AND SIGNATURE (REQUIRED FOR ALL FINDINGS) Findings:•No PRC 5024 necessary (provide justification) PRC 5024 attached; project approved as written PRC 5024 attached, conditions necessary PRC 5024 attached, mitigations and/or potential significant impacts Explain There are no documented cultural resources at this location. A recent field visit by DPR Archaeologist Nicole Turner did not observe any cultural resources at the project location or in the profile of the ongoing eroding cliff edge.Given the lack of ground visibility, as a result of ice plant, vegetation it is recommended that an initial spot check by an archaeologist during post hole excavation be conducted at onset of project.Please contact District Archaeologist Nicole Turner 619-933-9013 to schedule an ar -haeological monitor. SIGNATURE PRINTED NAME Nicole Turner TITLE DATE Associate State Archaeologist 7A "1/2 °t ' DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)5 roN, Nur'0 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. HISTORIAN COMMENTS AND SIGNATURE (REQUIRED FOR ALL FINDINGS) Findings: El No PRC 5024 necessary (provide iustification) PRC 5024 attached, project approved as written O PRC 5024 attached, conditions necessary O PRC 5024 attached, mitigations and/or potential significant impacts Explain There are no recorded or potentially significant historical resources located within or immediately adjacent to the Proposed Project's A.P.E. SIGNATURE &•PRINTED NAME Alexander D. Bevil TITLE DATE Historian II,So. Service Center 21 July 2016 DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)6 CtiP 0 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENTIST COMMENTS AND SIGNATURE (REQUIRED FOR ALL FINDINGS) Findings: tio Impact Impact(s), see conditions/mitigations below or on attached page(s) 0 Potential Significant Impact Explain No iraeaci5 a 41 c-( pect -+-.64) --P-trice riff]S t1-11(661•1 CA ?Oh ofuS. SIGNArkg i PRINTED NAME Cara Stafford TITLE DATE Environmental Sciel 7/7.//(6) MAINTENANCE CHIEF/SUPERVISOR (REQUIRED FOR ALL FINDINGS) COMMENTS: 66194.L. SIGNATURE v4t4L....10).}..„, PRINTED NAME ,.Susan Kosek-Kelly TITLE DATE Maintenance Chief i`I 1 -7'16 DISTRICT SERVICES MANAGER Comments: TAie--t 13el-W-ie tf -41Wie-Riorra C oferigb, SIGN v..../(6511.........„ PRINTED NAMELDarrenSmith TITLE JJDistrict Services Manager DATE 1.7_.1 / (6. DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 913/2015)7 %me ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. SSC ENVIRONMENTAL COORDINATOR Please include within the PEF and/or SLR worksheet that the sea cave has formed as a result of wave uprush and began to form approximately 7-9 months ago. This information could be used to assess whether further collapse may occur and if any other precautions would be warranted. Geological evaluation during a site visit determined that the receding cliffs are limestone. Coordination with the Coastal Commission should take place to keep them aware of the sea cave's condition as well as CSPs efforts to place fencing above it to protect the public. CCC may have recommendations for continuing public access while maintaining visitor safety. SIGNATURE PRINTED NAME Luke Serna TITLE DATE Associate Park & Recreation Specialist July 20, 2016 DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)8 Krimmel, Cindy@Parks From:Urbach, Lisa@Parks Sent Thursday, July 21, 2016 8:16 PM To:Serna, Lucas@Parks Cc Krimmel, Cindy@Parks; Urbach, Lisa@Parks Subject:Sea Cave-2006 Photo .,, -4 ill '.4.•' r ' re•..,••74.,'' ....‘t '1.•I '- • Figure 1.Sea cave in September 2006 just starting to form. 1 State of California —Natural Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION ACCESSIBILITY SECTION --ACQUISITION AND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW Et COMMENT SHEET Project: Safety Fencing at Sea Cave Natural Feature Design Entity: San Diego Coast District Location: Carlsbad SB Project Manager: Vince Kraft Review Date: July 22, 2016 [Reviewer: Shawn Smith Project Phase:PEF Phone: 916-445-8932 This review and comment does not authorize any omissions or deviations from applicable regulations.The intent of this review is for general conformance with applicable parts of Americans with Disabilities Act Standard's for Accessible Design (ADASAD),California Code of Regulations Title 24 -access compliance, and the Department of Parks and Recreation's (DPR)California State Parks Accessibility Guidelines (CSPAG).Plans were reviewed solely on the items submitted to the Accessibility Section as it relates to standards in design and construction of accessibility features for individuals with disabilities.All construction must comply with the Latest Editions of the California Building Code (CBC), California Mechanical Code (CMC), California Plumbing Code (CPC), California Electrical code (CEC), California Fire Code (CFC), current editions of the Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) and all other prevailing state and federal regulations. GENERAL COMMENTS Accessibility Section has completed review of this PEF, determined that there are no accessibility requirements and the project is exempt. Unless the scope of work changes, no further review is required. END OF COMMENTS DPR 727 (New 2/2014)(Word 2/18/2014)Page 1 of 1 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. • ENVIRONMENTAL COORDINATOR REVIEW YES MAYBE NO CUMULATIVE IMPACTS O IZI 1.Will the project be conducted in conjunction with or at the same time as other projects at the park? O 0 2.Will the project be part of a series of inter-related projects? O 0 El 3.Are there any other projects that must be completed for any part of this project to become operational?0 0 4.Are there any other projects (including deferred maintenance) that have been completed or any probable future projects that could contribute to the cumulative impacts of this project? O 0 5.Are any of the projects that relate to the proposed work outside the General Plan? COMMENTS: RECOMMENDATION: O Not a project for the purposes of CEQA compliance. O Project is De Minimus; register in logbook [g]The project is exempt.File a Notice of Exemption.0 A Negative Declaration should be prepared. O A Mitigated Negative Declaration should be prepared. O An EIR should be prepared. SIGNATURE NMI 14 PRINTED NAME is Cindy Krimmel TITLE DATE c::?fvtfbd._ Z-1/ bEnvironmental Coordinator DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT REVIEW COMMENTS: I acknowledge any constraints placed on the project as a result of the specialists' comments above and recommend the project proceed. DISTRICT SUPERINTE T PROVAL SIGNATURE TITLE DATE —District Superintendent 2.off6 DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/312015)9 0 •411. 'ER 11864 .•Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. •v.-. --'it -.'"7 .'7.4..,---"1„"--'''--- ....: -•.i'.:7.7,7"*:77-_,.':4',-...''.;:,-••-•!--,..'',i'4•:::,''4.r.-1 .4:'-'1:.:,'..!...••\'• '''•---,44.4 .'lc --IR''11E,::"" '•'''.-''-,°'-'''-*/!1-'-_..f \--'•;'.. •\‘.'•'''---•:74!7.4 ': -./•- •-ii.'.-.',..1..-. --.......:..'. -.'";"'' --..."-.„•- ..`...:....,‘-1 --"......?.• .. ...-' -•,•:'!',.-ti.--7 '`.-..''A ."''-.'."...!`.'Y li ?'X . .. - -0 - '',f4t. ....••....._........ .,., ...‘,.•'kiSv.,,T:.:,';., • ' .• - ...,:' - '•'• - h!l'.---..-";'.rs's?..,..,., .........e.....1 4....._.1.10 •....."-_.......,.....;.-1 .c....-.t 4.•-•-., ,.•..\-v7'''•1.."-:._.. - , -'''';;••••••4:1•'-./•-•; .7,. . -\- ..4,:\i -Ot '',A,t :'J''''r:---''''''i.'-'•''.',-,T.`....-.,‘.-4 i '- .4...,A.4'.' "•,....i • -.''et i- •f......Ti•..:.'--•-.......3 -.4. ,\.. .t.l... ''..--'''.A ..4...f.„*2.4 . ,„„6....;•-•....i.i.'":;.'-k‹ - .:,,.7 ,ri......:ef,- .7%r'l 'r.C,' -•'- .•'_c -...''.-•'')t....r.,..•...--:;;.'., -. .......,....'. ''..,...i.1-••.e.e.-''it.....J.-....-.:. ,j•,,*.:•.•'.-•+...0.istri.'.'....;.-*.-."....-•— .':*'f 1 eiii•.-74r-#.-...1..!...'/7', -.>,::'.•;)•:.-e::--r'Q-..... ,:-....P.'14 jt-:./..ft.v.i:1 ......••:'•! - ..'.;;' : ' .'r;g - '':•1'...7. -":.-ii.Z.:3::'.i.;;T.F.,iiiii44 - :::;:;:i1. - :;4.-i -..?t.'.:.t '.1;'.)...4;1;.-:'.4.:;..-''- ' -'' .:, --1..,'•:, - .-':,,--'-1\- ''..;--.--:"..'''!"-7:74N.2--.,',.......'."-(0';.-..,.„:' ..,- ---T''''-, -'It-: i •...\‘.--'''--. .c .1"`Ir-••....... 4-il..::(447.Z:.;:;.,,........ t.• ?,,,,,/'• .j.. ''','-' .-\.'.*.':',..•..,..--•••''',",... --.i__..A .. .v....,,......'t..•-'-'.;'.'..\4.-4K...:*•!.'"-....-.4--•h --' ...i-t --;•*--..V..---'i.4-'`',',.. ..we •--. N-.... ---.'4-f''". '-'•-•:-..""*"'.‘..c.i...A '....---,- k,;.IT.P •,-,4 %•' ,4.1...,4- i..4seir.---...is,'.-••- 301.111!AW... - !„ -.- -.• -.--..-Aik :.\.#;-.•`,-• " ••••-•I i i'l....-• •"gm"-4 1...._...._._..._...._.' •--'----'•'- ''.-, -NI -. --se4: -.'"rj-lef.-.. --- -_.-el ..•.-4 .'.`..;,, .-'' . --'-'7'''...i..7•T - h 16.,____,...-';.7.;.;.-0..N.:.•k - •....\It'•7•A'','"c•- •-,,.',..I.- .s'•.... - 1'......•••.$• .\ •-211,:,',t..%-•.t . Ls %•:?...,):,\c'..i.,.-i \''','!..—.v;T: t•i -7)'"':...1 - % 4*- 11.:‘'). •--—.•'—: Ai '''4.c..i.:.7..7.t.:.t•.\.-•.:-".'..**... ,4,i.k :'Ci-'•• •-,-••'•ii...:::;•:;.t....).,\1.1.-- '-'.„‘-'-\--'4: -..:•-:::/'',,...,....•,1 '•.. -V ('.,;.'...\:.f.c....' -.4 k.,I,..,,, • '.\. . ‘.N7..•.•i ......•• :1.„....../4.:....• •••••1 • .';J:i .111raftssapi:.....A4 1.;St':1.47-.4,..al. ..„1;:;„:;! -•1 ........c .1',\i ..',.1 .-'.:.A.1 '...,' LI . 'i i 1(•.''• ....'."—%'l'i.•.- ,,,t 1 t.\._-,_.,.•\-•IA.-1- ',,.''..j ,,,:.,•?, '''''2.1 :... •lk\. .'it'1 - -."''•:''''.14':- .::.,4.., ,- s.•le:.•'?•....A.....•,•,_s-........1- I..4 .. • `.. • :7k '7 -\- -*''r" .. r .•i ;'...1i.':;^4'-'-...• •2 -.i.%,' • .-....!;' - ':,..'1. ,.,.,.,..•..• •---- ‘,...,•\••,. ••.111 .Park Boundary .. .. ...,• ,.-•• •'''t..,..4.NI '-i4.'.'...1 7 „.p. - • ';---.•'-,-i'.”;,.•-n ..... u:....-`.'wt.'.....-..1.....15•i:„A • • Figure 1.Project Location -Feet Alk01,1502,300 4,600 6,900 9,200 Carlsbad State Beach NO \\CT it \ ,.. 1 ,.. - : ......1.... - ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF) ,pcANo. Photo of Area with Pro'ect Lines .,. : --‘16-..........: ..aVir . .....'4 -'' YIP` se- '4 ' .; .4?:;-1111he'4.'II yp ....\ ..4.1. -Ilill-''' It -_--. - 1..1-'.-1 .,....,•. " "•S:-..?:..'-'‘7.-*""t • •i......1-:..i.-;-c4 ...r,ooms 1 -_,..1*-:-...... 4ot II 11 1..- .,.,...44"g„ •. ..- , ..1 IN —t/t`##4_.__--•\-..,.tea.---- ,• ,, 1 4......_ •e _ 1...wirs _ I to 4 . ..,..4".1010.•*44T'2.1., .."Eil l y. e ........, ,,•,.i I , '.-4 -..-I \...-...- 4 . • , f.".Lir\Z;1!.5*-_.c7i DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)12 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. Temporary Orange Fencing / South Boundary-to be replaced with permanent fencing up to existing ,,..4 chain link fence line. wti ., ---^ 1 = Gt' r//jzzes!...7._94.111vaair.Irtaii -ii _ . ...-..- --,M14110•08Stimeti/-.------ imer.volartassror _- 011111111111iiiiaanitit '".--- ....•Pr---7 ‘C. CIai I '107 ,1 a ^.`. "- r T• r..,°41."_., .—.., __- ( DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)13 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. •Clr-,*Temporary Orange Fencing / North Boundary-to be replaced with permanent fencing up to existing chain link fence line. •, ..„. •r •is*. kilt`•11:1 ••'• • - • • .r- -•'•• .- • .-e .•-•-_ „. • ••• Ito TIP imo• •r • .4e DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)14 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. Temporary Fencing blocking access from old path/ South of Sea Cave *Permanent fencing is NOT Scheduled west of the existing chain link fence line. -• • _ _44./4-10$-----• --- 7 _- 4'^ DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)15 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. Temporary Fencing blocking pathway / North of Sea Cave *Permanent fencing is NOT Scheduled west of the existing chain link fence line. ,_A6 -irivei0P/5 -40Aiiii444 - e cY 4.0-•••,••,•t ••.•••" -le";,•t'1•, -: ., •. S s _ "-* DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)16 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. • /t !10, - /#1 411.4440%. •6fAt Alnir •--.46.•//.4*41111 41114111111111Mar— '34,40 .74.0N4p. 41;Til"311. 4411111Pr f:`:••••7.; _ rr. •• 0"'.441:•• ' --—46001111111*-"*„..-V• Sea Cave-View from beach DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)17 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. • 114„.;‘.4. )11/41A.•, 4.4-••.1114.14 Sto 4111r ,„ - -y •}0., *ha • • • •••••;51...• 74.•:••:.J•"%*.'••••• •'4'10 •.t4A•44"1 -hiv_4404 s'‘ 4 _• Sea Cave from Beach DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)18 ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. • -,:t_,i .it r.-.,-,-- •--1.-4- ,•',-....!“---•.,4.-t ,^ 4:--..7-'114.'-.: '"i '...r.-411HeS.44 ,...,.. -'''.:..4•:'7.I •.-...74...-...:;-i _-;:,..---,'-,;:-,se .,...-.,,,„•....+14."-'...-,•Ir '''''.1.''Sr4'-'-'.e.t. P:':4.''41-t7V-4°'--,ri" -. -.6.4 '•'..-'."'4r.•-••• --st...:'.4 . -1...P -..::$'-..‘_;•- _41-z.--4.7 •'•.,'-.;,*' .„.,. ...,,---.•..•-- ,'-'• '.'- '''''' .i.';__4Aceorf•s, ----,•_...?.. -..•-.._..... .......ixf....... -„lip .1-. ----•--..•-....y!.•-•-41.... -.....--.....,...,---._ .....it..•.-.._,...-..i...-..•,.. .---...,...--._ !. -:-...-__•..„,-• -lic.4 .°gL:.• dif; 2....„......:..:....A....r....._0 z.f.. ...-- .?'-.---7.--7.:--'.-40..4....4;:.......•''''• $ ,:iti.. ...„ -.- ?:...c'...41.177e...I.,.: -•_'....:7:'....-...r'.44"..: otik - _____:....,,i...:: ....1:::...,'............4., t .7/•••:-....... '\-.,A.•.--.-:1.--.• '---"7- , .,.„..,.,.,„,. .,....*......,....______.„.. ...... .e...,. _ ..:..il .- • ..,.. .,..,-•_.,..,. •),.... . - ..1.,•.....ir ...e-•A.-. ...461 U1tS7/.9LEtCLIFFS ..4..7...,.. 44 STAY '74, 7 :. BACK A - •„_ '...arr,di 71-r . •. ,.• ....'•-... .'..'•''- '''''•'.. '...b•;%;7:. ' '....'4'. '. '.'--*.'1”. '''.--.''.)1 ..v.-.••,s'.•se-''.--,--; '• •t .... 5.1 r ..•10#•, ' J ''•:,444..o...411.',..`.N,. :••••,k-71•7 ..•H.7-.;_,:4 -.•--.4.-..-..,•_--' .,."'•-i ••,-'.'. 'N.1.-.. ..d •4.- , t _........ .,„...... •1.'-..•-....l*i '14110...t , . . 1'4....,eti...:'........ ....14.--•. -• .-''-: ' . Sea Cave Close Up-With Graffiti • DPR 18 ..,. ER 11864 Project ID No.16/17-SD-02 PROJECT EVALUATION (PEF)PCA No. .,...•- ., • , ill. ..-'t . ' .1-1., *-''•2 tpp-., •.-‘•i ..44.' V e•1 fl'A;k.,.- ikt .--..:. or -1 -.*......—-....e.-'1),&.4.N4 .:,1.%-*j.• ...--'- r...... ...,,lif -'4 '. ......,....•''7W.'..*r4I,...,,,,, 4 NV'.;.21.•....,.1 '' t .'st.,...i -h - ..t •', -••r .:;47......-.. .d _.I..!•..4.',if -' ''-.A '-•-r.'".. , •. ...,. .../ar•, •,Jrhi%_,..,',..1..,•,—.,..in' 44 •,-•' '. ,44.:::,,,,130104.;7.,,...ID 4-0.-'. 'it '•'„' .... ,... ..'.•,4 •'''':' I aEr -4 4 iIIi•.'., L 4 i ' ..t'• lir•...1.•4 .0..„,I • It 4.4.•,4 i • 4..4. 111 ...c...-c. c 1..0446w . ' :4 A:At*Irk.-:....i..---...c0.41i.410 -4-0Ler.1.'-''..e.1. -- -..',..-..-- ":-'It4tli'11-7 .;$-"•- -4.- February 10, 2016-First reported. DPR 183 (Rev. 9/2015)(Word 9/3/2015)20 Sea-level Rise Worksheet This worksheet refers to concepts and processes described in the Department's Sea-level Rise and Extreme Events Guidance. Please visit http://isearch.parks.ca.ciovisea-level-rise for more information. Sea-level Rise & Extreme Event Worksheet PROJECT/RESOURCE TITLE:Safety Fencing at Sea Cave Natural Feature DATE:July 21, 2016 DISTRICT NAME:San Diego Coast PARK UNIT NAME:Carlsbad State Beach PROJECT/RESOURCE EVALUATOR:PHONE NO.EMAIL: Cindy Krimmel (619) 278-3771 Cindy.Krimmel@parks.ca.gov 1. DEFINE PROJECT OR RESOURCE CHARACTERISTICS A. Describe the Resource or Project objectives: Archaeological exploration to determine the absence/presence of archaeological deposits within the construction footprint of the proposed Moonlight State Beach Marine Safety Center. B.Is the location:Upland Near Shoreline Uncertain C. What is the expected lifetime?20 years D. Is there history of past damage due to erosion, waves,Yes No Uncertain flooding, or inundation? E.Are the resources involved:Significant Critical Representative None CJ F.Is the location experiencing:Uplift Subsidence Uncertain El Revised 03/03/14 2. ASSESS VULNERABILITY a.Exposure Resource is located in an area that is already a flood zone or has experienced impacts from extreme events Yes No Uncertain High Exposure Is Resource projected to be in MSLR zones within project lifetime? Yes No Depends on Projection Describe MSLR projections used and extent and timing of exposure (e.g., within likely storm surges or within likely inundation zones).In addition, identify any other local factors that may be relevant (e.g. tectonics, nearby seawalls or development). This fence will be on the bluff, approximately 50 feet above sea level. b.Sensitivity.Is this project or resource sensitive? Examples of sensitive resources include: •A rare plant or animal that cannot tolerate flooding, inundation, or a change in salinity •An archeological resource that will be exposed due to erosion •A facility that will have its structure or function compromised by seawater •Soil is contaminated or prone to erosion either onsite or nearby. •A particularly important point for public access. Describe the sensitivity of this resource. Consult natural or cultural staff as appropriate: This is not a sensitive resource 2 \two'*NS c.Adaptive Capacity. Check boxes as appropriate. Yes No Can the project be easily moved upland to avoid MSLR and extreme events? Can the project be easily raised or reinforced to prevent damage from flooding or inundation?Yes No Describe how this project or resource can be modified to tolerate MSLR and extreme events: d.Discuss Overall Vulnerability: The sea cave is a natural feature that was created by erosive forces and is vulnerable to further change, but the fence to prevent people from walking over the top of the cave is not vulnerable. 3. IDENTIFY CONSEQUENCES Infrastructure. Will overall parking, restrooms, campsites, first-aid stations, interpretive Yes No centers, or utilities be affected? Natural resources. Will the loss of this resource reduce biological diversity? Will it affect Yes No ecological processes or significant resources (e.g., representative or outstanding resources)? Cultural resources. Will archeological sites, historic structures, or other cultural resources be Yes No affected? Visitors.Is this a project that affects resources which attract a lot of visitors?Yes No Recreation Areas. Will hiking, biking, horseback riding, OHV sites, or other recreation that Yes No attracts visitors be affected? Personnel. Will MSLR necessitate additional maintenance? How much effort will be required Yes No to maintain the resource in a functional state? Overall cost. Will additional costs be incurred over the project lifetime due to flooding,Yes No inundation, and extreme events? Explanation: 4. MAKE RECOMMENDATION.Attach photographs and maps if appropriate. This project should be approved for public safety. e- 'send SSC ENVIRONMENTAL COORDINATOR Please include within the PEF andfor SLR worksheet that the sea cave has formed as a result of wave uprush and began to form approximately 7-9 months ago. This information could be used to assess whether further collapse may occur and ifany other precautions would be warranted. Geological evaluation during a site visit determined that the rececing cliffs are limestone. Coordination with the Coastal Commission should take place to keep them awareof the sea cave's condition as well as CSPs efforts to place fencing shove it to protect the public. CCC may have recommendations for continuing public access while maintaining visitor safety_ SIGNATURE PRINTED NAME Luke Serna UTLE DATE Associate Park & Recreation Specialist July 20, 2016 http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2016/jul/14/sea-cave-to-get-permanent- fence-signs/a11/?print Sea cave to get permanent fence, signs High tides, big waves created Carlsbad hazard this year S By Phil Diehl I 4:40 p.m. July 14, 2016 I Updated, 4:43 p.m. 41°"400.P. DO NOT ENTER 44/00o. __• A man walks near a cave that has formed on a section of beach bluff that has eroded in Carlsbad. Hayne Palmour IV CARLSBAD — A huge sea cave that opened up this winter at a Carlsbad beach won't be torn down, but new warning signs and a permanent fence will be installed to keep people away from it, state parks officials said this week. The narrow state beach along Carlsbad Boulevard near the foot of Cerezo Drive is one of many areas where North County bluffs were badly eroded this year by high tides and powerful waves. Just this week, part of a 100 -foot cliff collapsed in Del Mar, prompting immediate fears that people had been trapped under the debris. Searchers with dogs turned up nothing. r r mansiSMINSIONI 01111111111111110111m........os•rrrrrr MI 0 0 In Carlsbad, warning signs and a temporary orange plastic fence were erected in March after high tides and big surf enlarged the cave that had been there for several years. The cavity chewed deep into the bluff and beneath a trail frequently used by joggers, tourists and dog walkers. State parks and city officials had discussed the possibility of intentionally collapsing the cave to remove the hazard, perhaps with explosives or high-pressure fire hoses, but recently decided against messing with Mother Nature. "We've had some scientific evaluations of the cave" that showed it could collapse at any time or stick around for years, state parks Superintendent Robin Greene said Thursday. "We're treating it as a natural formation," state parks Supervising Ranger Lisa Urbach said this week at a meeting of Carlsbad's Beach Preservation Commission. Still, people often ignore the warnings and risk their lives by walking on the seaward side of the fence, Greene and Urbach said. "Tons of people do it," Greene said. Despite more warning signs on the beach 50 feet below the bluff, vandals sometimes enter the cave to carve their initials or other graffiti into the soft sandstone walls. Park rangers patrol the area and often ask people to stay away from the cave, which is not in an area protected by lifeguards. Also, Greene said, they have requested a "superintendent's order" that will allow rangers to issue tickets to people caught in the cave. "We'll contact parents where that's appropriate," she said, and that should help spread the word that the cave is dangerous. The new fence will be the same type of low, plastic-coated chain-link fence already used in the area, she said, and it should be installed by the end of the month. The barrier is designed to stop small children or runaway pets, but not an adult determined to cross it. The Carlsbad Fire Department, which provides emergency medical services to all seven miles of state beach in the city, helped erect the temporary fencing and signs, and supports the state's handling of the cave, Fire Chief Mike Davis said Thursday. "We're there to lend a hand," Davis said. "That's what we're trying to do." philip. diehl@sdunion tribune. corn © Copyright 2016 The San Diego Union-Tribune. All rights reserved. ......._ Ir 1119.(Y-65.2, 'f0 -cin.A.-Joi. S lb. -•1219 ' 73 -1:082580 FILE/PAGE NO._ BOOK 1913 D°C.0103V.ma RECORDED REQUEST OF--.........._...... -._......._... WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO •-• I %Qin INSURANCE AND TRUST CO2Pitt • MAR i 3 37 PM PieFSTATEOFCALIFORNIA7 . DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SERVICES OFFICIAL RECORDS REAL ESTATE SERVICES DIVISION SAN DIEGO COUNTY. CALIF. 650 Howe Avenue HARLEY F;81.004 RECORDERSacramento,CA 95825 NO FEE 1 _J • SPACE *DOVES THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE .Agency%Parke and Recreation Grant Deed Project South Carlsbad Beach S.P. • PARCEL 19000-210-120-'t :hru22 ..-_ Parcel'2869 DOCUMENTARY TRANSFER TM S NONE 41473 7/6 •-City of Carlsbad PAUL ECICE and MAGDALENA ECKE,husband and wife • hereby GRANTS to THE STATE OP CALIFORNIA, the following described real property in the County of San Diego .State of California: I PARCEL 1:•' tote 2 through 22 inclusive,of Poineetta Beach Unit No.1,in the City of Carlsbad,in the County of San Diego,State of California,according to Hap thereof No.3897 filed in the Office of County Recorder of San . •Diego County.:'. - • •,....•, . ••-• I I .., • •NO CHARGE ON THIS DOCUMENT FOR THE BENEFIT OF ,• •State of California , Affix IRS 7 / Datedt-s..Sti /ey ../9-7.-- .,*VA."„..c..,'PAUL E k .... Subscribing Witness;,)(•-e_a -/Cat--11.4f-eire17(9V P -MAGDALENA 0.6 ,v . PD-167 nti SA 13n3 ,...7 2.3 5 9 9 MINIM PINS 11111.1111/1111111 • •• ..•. GRANTOR(S)SUBSCRIBING WITNESS STATE OF CALIFORNIA ..TE OF CALIFORNIA U.• COUNTY OF COI).7 • Oa _19_before me,•.On.—,19 /./..before me, the undersigned,a Notary Public in and for the State of .the undersign s,a Notary Public in and for the State of California,.appeared_----/-------, _known to me to the person whose name h subscribed to_the within ins lu What! thedert who, being by me duly swom,deposed •.el snide that •was present and saw known to me to be the person—. whose naine...—. subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged that.executed the same. personally known to him •4.the person....described in WITNESS my hand and official seal and whose name--—.Incribed to the within in- -strument, execute the e;an.that &lima subscribed ht.! name thereto as a wito.-.to said .•ecution. WITNESS my ban•and official seal. .• Narhe (Typed or Printed)Name (Typed or Printed) Notary Public in and for !be Stair of Califorti4 biota -Public in and for the Slate of Celifonia •)..'• ,• '•.:"1...,;r'5i -.;I -•-.... •." •1 •15 .• I"...•al a;1.lit •••• ,.1.- r.••••J I • • •••••• I I • .r •I si .0'1T:s;r4) 4 •." •0111111111s err 91/1 1221 'krExhibit"V" ofminutes •State Public Works Board January January 30,1978. • RESOLUTION OF STATE PUBLIC WORKS BOARD AMENDING LEGAL DESCRIPTION AND APPROVING ACQUISITION OF REAL PROPERTY UNDER SECTION 15654 OF THE GOVERNMENT CODE (Parcel 2869 -South Carlsbad State Beach) WHEREAS,this Board adopted a resolution on February 2,1976(see Exhibit "Q".minutes of that date),selecting site and authorizing acquisition of five parcels of real property in the County of Sonoma, State of California,for use of the Department of Parks and Recreation; and • Is WHEREAS,it is desired that the legal description set out in Parcel 2869 in said resolution be amended to delete certain land;and WHEREAS,the owners of the hereinafter identified parcel of real property have agreed to sell said parcel to the State for the con- sideration set forth in the hereinafter identified agreement,subject to the terms and conditions contained therein; NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED.that said resolution dated February 2,1976,is hereby amended by deleting the description of Parcel 2869 presently contained therein,and in lieu thereof inserting the following description:• PARCEL 2869 Lots 2 through 22.inclusive,of Poinsetta Beach Unit No.1,in the City of Carlsbad,in the County of San Diego,State of California,accordingatomapthereofNo.3897 filed in the Office of County Recorder of San Diego County. In all other respects,the original resolution shall remain infullforceandeffect,and all of its provisions and recitals shall he applicable hereto. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED,the State Public Works Board by unani- mous vote hereby determines the consideration set forth in the herein- after identified agreement is fair and reasonable for the purchase of certain property in the County of San Diego,State of California,as more particularly described in that certain resolution adopted by this Board on February 2,1976,designated as Exhibit "Q"of the minutes of that date,as amended herein,and acquisition by condemnation is not necessary. Page 1 of 2 MS a I11 STATE OF CALIFORNIA (511P 1/1111111* COUNTY OF SACRAMENTO ) ss. SUBSCRIBING WITNESS . 1220 . On February 7 ,192.before me,the undersigned,a Notary Public in and for the State of California,personally appeared Robert L.Bangs known to me to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument as a witness thereto,who,being by me duly sworn,deposed and said:that he was present and saw Paul Ecke and Magdalena Ecke personally known to him to be the persons described in and whose name n .are subscribed to the within Instrument,execute the same;and that affiant subscribed his name thereto as a witness to said execution. WITNESS my hand and official seal. i OFFICIAL SEALltriCONSTANCEK.OKINO F7.),N NOIARY PUBLIC -CA.IFOSSILA 1..e.:... Principal Office In Sacramento County 1?My Commission Expires fob.29,1980 ent4 -es-)ck ArL4 CONSTANCE K.OKINO Notary Public in and for the State of California .. ,- -• 111111SIIM I •411. /t/cf"-gra .• fttoft47 TITLE INSURANCE AND TRUST • ATICOR COMPANY Policy of Tdle Insurance • SUBJECT TO SCHEDULE B AND THE CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS HEREOF, TITLE INSURANCE AND TRUST COMPANY,a California corporation, herein called the Company, insures the insured,as of Date of Policy shown in Schedule A, against loss or damage, not exceeding the amount of insurance stated in Schedule A, and costs, attorneys' fees and expenses which the Company may become obligated to pay hereunder, sustained or incurred by said insured by reason of: • 1.Title to the estate or interest described in Schedule A being vested other than as stated therein; 2.Any defect in or lien or encumbrance on such title; 3.Unmarketability of such title; or 4.Any lack of the ordinary right of an abutting owner for access to at least one physically open street or highway if the land, in fact, abuts upon one or more such streets or highways; and in addition, as to an insured lender only; 5.Invalidity of the lien of the insured mortgage upon said estate or interest except to the extent that such invalidity, or claim thereof, arises out of the transaction evidenced by the insured mortgage and is based upon .. a.usury,Or b.any consumer credit protection or truth in lending law; 6.Priority of any lien or encumbrance over the lien of the insured mortgage, said mortgage being shown in Schedule B in the order of its priority; or 7.Invalidity of any assignment of the insured mortgage, provided such assignment is shown in Schedule B. Title Insurance anclaTiWdOrnpanysc.s- it.Ca";;,"&eriby• .zre p Ati.Y;11.:5tPresident1"-6;"sas-r.1.Cf --"\ t11409Sia.-:•/6."X.44;f-171 triCopy of prPol icy c.)%. erns644.•• No additional liatillitce'assoffilsr.c • •in‘A\c.....:r • 72 3599 70 1012 71-7 (10-75) California Land Title Association Standard Coverage Policy-1973 MI IS 111 IIIMINIMIlli NIONMINi .mmililliflINII •C 'O.Schedule B Part I 1.Taxes or assessments which are not shown as existing liens by the records of any taxing authority that levies taxes or assessments on real property or by the public records.-•-• Proceedings by a public agency which may result in taxes or assessments, or notices of such proceedings, whether or not shown by the records of such agency or by the public records. 2.Any facts.rights,interests or claims which are not shown by the public records but which could be ascertained by an inspection of the land or by making inquiry of persons in possession thereof. 3.Easements, liens or encumbrances, or claims thereof, which are not shown by the public records. 4.Discrepancies, conflicts in boundary lines, shortage In area, encroachments, or any other facts which a correct survey would disclose, and which are not shown by the public records. • 5.(a) Unpatented mining claims; (b) reservations or exceptions in patents or in Acts authorizing the issuance •thereof; (c) water rights, claims or title to water... .• 6.Any right, title, interest, estate or easement in land beyond the lines of the area specifically described or referred to in Schedule C,or in abutting streets,roads,avenues,alleys, lanes, ways or waterways, but nothing in this paragraph shall modify or limit the extent to which the ordinary right of an abutting owner for access to a physically open street or highway is insured by this policy. 7.Any law, ordinance or governmental regulation (including but not limited to building and zoning ordinances) restricting or regulating or prohibiting the occupancy, use or enjoyment of the land, or regulating the character, dimensions or location of any improvement now or hereafter erected on the land, or prohibiting a separation in ownership or a reduction in the dimensions or area of the land, or the effect of any violation of any such law, ordinance or governmental regulation. 8.Rights of eminent doniain or governmental rights of police power unless notice of the exercise of such rights appears in the public records. .. 9.Defects, liens, encumbrances. adverse claims, or other matters (a) created, suffered, assumed or agreed to by the insured claimant; (b) not shown by the public records and not otherwise excluded from coverage but known to the insured claimant either at Date of Policy or at the date such claimant acquired an estate or interest insured by this policy or acquired the insured mortgage and not disclosed in writing by the insured claimant to the Company prior to the date such insured claimant became an insured hereunder; (c) resulting in no loss or damage to the insured' claimant; (d) attaching or created subsequent to Date of Policy; or (e) resulting in loss or damage which would not have been sustained if the insured claimant had been a purchaser or encumbrancer for value without knowledge. 10.Any facts,rights,interests or claims which are not shown by the public records but which could be ascertained by making inquiry of the lessors in the lease or leases described or referred to in Schedule A. 11.The effect of any failure to comply with the terms, covenants and conditions of the lease or leases described or referred to in Schedule A. Conditions and Stipulations 1.Definition of Terms ignated in paragraph 2(a) of these Conditions and Stipulations. 1 The following terms when used in this policy mean;(b.) "insured claimant":an insured claiming loss or damage (a.)"insured": the insured named in Schedule A, and, subject to hereunder. any rights Or defenses the Company may have had against the (c.) "Insured lender": the owner of an insured mortgage. named insured. those who succeed to the interest of such insured by •(d.) "insured mortgage":a mortgage shown in Schedule B, the operation of law as distinguished from purchase including. but not owner of which is named as an insured in Schedule A. limited to, heirs. distributees. devisees, survivors, personal repro-(e.)"knowledge": actual knowledge. not constructive knowledge sentatives, next of kin, or corporate or fiduciary successors. The •or notice which may be imputed to an insured by reason of any term "insured" also includes (i) the owner of the indebtedness public records. secured by the insured mortgage and each successor in ownership of (f.)"land": the land described specifically or by reference in such indebtedness (reserving, however, all rights and defenses as to Schedule C, and improvements affixed thereto which by law con- any such successor who acquires the indebtedness by operation of .stitute real property: provided, however, the term "land" does not taw as described in the first sentence of this subparagraph (a) that include any area excluded by Paragraph No. 6 of Part I of Schedule the Company would have had against the successor's transferor),B of this Policy. and further includes (ii) any governmental agency or Instrumentality (g.) "mortgage": mortgage, deed of trust, trust *deed,or other t"' which is an insurer or guarantor under an insurance contract or guar-security instrument. any insuring or guaranteeing said indebtedness, or any part thereof.(h.)"public records": those records which by law impart con•' whether named as an insu'red herein or not,.and (iii) the parties des•structive notice of matters relating to the land... (CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS Continued on the inside of the Last Page of This Polley)'I IC.• 1,,,‘.L , f c k.,i.s tit+ .. V..t,., 1 '•O., CALIFORNIA LAND TITLE ASSOCIATION STANDARD COVERAGE POLICY -1973 SCHEDULE A POLICY NO.:993716 AMOUNT :$1.200.000.00 CHARGE :52.011.88 EFFECTIVE DATE:MARCH 1.1978 AT 8:30 A.M. I.NAME OF INSURED THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 2.THE ESTATE OR INTEREST IN THE LAND DESCRIBED HEREIN ANC WHICH [S COVERED BY THIS POLICY IS A FEE. 3.THE ESTATE OR INTEREST REFERRED TO HEREIN IS AT DATE OF POLICY VESTED IN: THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA SCHECULE B THIS POLICY DOES NOT INSURE AGAINST LOSS OR DAMAGE.NCR AGAINST COSTS.ATTORNEY'S FEES OR EXPENSES.ANY OR ALL OF WHICH ARISE BY REASCN OF THE FOLLOWING. PART I ALL MATTERS SET FORTH IN PARAGRAPHS NUMBERED 1 (ONE)TO 11 (ELEVEN) INCLUSIVE ON THE INSIDE COVER SHEET OF THIS POLICY UNDER THE HEADING OF SCHEDULE 9 PART I. PART II I.GENERAL AND SPECIAL COUNTY ANO CITY TAXES FOR THE FISCAL YEAR :1978-79 A LIEN NOT YET PAYABLE. 2.GENERAL AND SPECIAL COUNTY AND CITY TAXES FOR THE FISCAL YEAR :1977-78 SECOND INSTALLMENT :NOW DUE AND PAYABLE 3.ANY ADVERSE CLAIM BASED UPON THE ASSERTION THAT SOME PORTION OF SAID LAND IS TIDE OR SUBMERGED LANDS.OR HAS BEEN CREATED BY ARTIFICIAL MEANS OR HAS ACCRETED TO SUCH PCRTION SO CREATED. 4.THE RIGHT TO EXTEND AND MAINTAIN DRAINAGE STRUCTURES AND EXCAVATION AND EMBANKMENT SLOPES BEYOND THE LIMITS OF THE RIGHT 993716 PAGE e OMMEM miuMMO Wm OF WAY GRANTED THEREIN WHERE REQUIRED FCR CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE GR4NTEO TO :STATE OF CALIFORNIA RECORDED :AUGUST 30.1935 IN BOOK 432.PAGE 60 OF OFFICIAL RECORDS AFFECTS:BETWEEN THE FOLLOWING ENGINEER'S STATIONS OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORK'S SURVEY ROAD XI-SD-2-8: FROM ENGINEER'S STATION 296 PLUS 50 TO ENGINEER'S STATION 300 PLUS 00; FROM ENGINEER'S STATION 301 PLUS 50 TO ENGINEER'S STATION 303 PLUS 50: FROM ENGINEER'S STATION 306 PLUS 50 TO ENGINEER'S STATION 308 PLUS 50: FROM ENGINEER'S STATION 310 PLUS 50 TO ENGINEER'S STATION 312 PLUS 50; FROM ENGINEER'S STATION 370 PLUS 00 TO ENGINEER'S STATION 372 PLUS 50: FROM ENGINEER'S STATION 390 PLUS 50 TO ENGINEER'S STATION 393 PLUS 00; FROM ENGINEER'S STATION 397 PLUS 00 TO ENGINEER'S STATION 399 PLUS 50. 993716 PAGE 2 MIMS Sinaisi SCHEDULE C THE LAND REFERREC TO IN THIS POLICY IS SITUATED IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.COUNTY CF SAN DIEGO.ANO IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: LOTS 2 THROUGH 22 INCLUSIVE.CF POINSETTA BEACH UNIT NO.1.IN THE CITY OF CARLSBAD.IN THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO.STATE OF CALIFORNIA. ACCORDING TO MAP THEREOF NO.3897 FILED IN THE OFFICE OF COUNTY RECORDER OF SAN DIEGO COUNTY. 993716 PAGE 3 r Sr S •.,0 .,,.•• .. t % .This is not a survey of the land,but is • •compiled for information only,nor is it a part of the report or policy to rich \it may be attached. TITLE INSURANCE AND TRUST\220 "A"Street\\_„.\San Dior California 92101 ie•\\\\\\\ \ci.7414.5E777.4 BEACH\$c•\L/AerrA6 /t•/Plates 46 .4997"1 00 ti.\f 1 -.\0110"...---".0.3 t \.. \ a \•\\-'.\.\\-1411.1r1 559/16 ,,.6\\ . 1 \ •.\ •,I_•\\• 1. .10115 \. ._\• \. •• \\\• \. \•gra 400 \\ .....„\ clotto0.\.•\7\'‘\\T tl zi C.1..)\ T.1..114 \ m ...'CI \en ..• `....,\t 0 11 \\04 \ [..\ .. —-. .-,•--,,,._ ,,. (CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS Continued From Reverse Side of Policy Face) 2.(a.) Continuation of Insurance after Acquisition of Title by ecuting or defending such action or proceeding. and (2) in any Insured Lender other act which in the opinion of the Company may be necessary or desirable to establish the title to the estate ol. Interest' or the lien ofIf this policy insures the owner of the indebtedness secured by the insured mortgage, this policy shall continue in force as of Date of the insured mortgage, as insured, including but not limited to Policy in favor of such insured who acquires all or any part of said executing corrective or other documents. estate or interest in the land described In Schedule C by foreclosure,4.Proof of Loss or Damage —Limitation of Action trustee's sale, conveyance in lieu of foreclosure. or other legal man-In addition to the notices required under Paragraph 3(b) of thesener which discharges the lien of the insured mortgage. and if such Conditions and Stipulations,a proof of loss or damage, signed andinsured is a corporation, its transferee of the estate or interest so sworn to by the Insured claimant shall be furnished to the Companyacquired. provided the transferee is the parent or wholly owned within 90 days after the.insured claimant shall ascertain or deter-subsidiary of such insured; and in favor of any governmental agency mine the facts giving rise to such loss or damage. Such proof of lossor instrumentality which acquires all or any part of the estate or or damage shall describe the defect in, or Ilen or encumbrance onInterest pursuant to a contract of insurance or guaranty insuring or the title, or other matter insured against by this policy which con-guaranteeing the indebtedness secured by the insured mortgage.stitutes the basis of loss or damage, and. when appropriate, state theAfter any such acquisition the amount of insurance hereunder,basis of calculating the amount of such loss or damage.exclusive of costs, attorneys' fees and expenses which the Company .. may be obligated to pay, shall not exceed the least of:Should such proof of loss or damage fail to,state facts sufficient to . (I)the amount of insurance stated in Schedule A;enable thetompany to determine its liability hereunder, insured (ii) the amount of the unpaid principal of the indebtedness plus claimant, at the written request of the Company, shall furnish such interest thereon. as determined under paragraph 6(a)(Hi) hereof,additional information as may reasonably be necessary to make such expenses of foreclosure and amounts advanced to protect the lien of determination. the insured mortgage and secured by said insured mortgage at the NO right of action shall accrue to insured claimant until 30 daystime of acquisition Cl such estate or interest in the land; or after such proof of loss or damage shall have been furnished.(Hi)the amount paid by any governmental agency or instrumentality. if such agency or instrumentality is the insured claimant,In Failure to furnish such proof of loss or damage shall terminate any acquisition of such estate or Interest in satisfaction of its insurance liability of the Company under this policy as to such loss or damage. contract or guaranty.5.Options to Pay or Otherwise Settle Claims and Options to (b.) Continuation of Insurance After Conveyance of Title Purchase Indebtedness The coverage of this policy shall continue in force as of Date of The Company shall have the option to pay or otherwise settle for or Policy, in favor of an Insured so long as such insured retains an in the name of an insured claimant any claim insured against, or to estate or interest in the land. or owns an indebtedness secured by a •terminate all liability and obligations of the Company hereunder by purchase money mortgage given by a purchaser from such insured,paying or tendering payment of the amount of insurance under this or so long as such insured shall have liability by reason of covenants policy together with any costs, attorneys' fees and expenses of warranty made by such insured in any transfer or conveyance of Incurred up tothe lime of such payment or lender of payment by such estate or interest: provided. however, this policy shall not the insured claimant and authorized by the Company. In case loss or continue in force in favor of any purchaser from such insured of damage is claimed under this policy by the owner of the Indebted-either said estate or interest or the indebtedness secured by a ness secured by theinsured mortgage, the Company shall have the purchase money mortgage given to such insured.further option to purchase such indebtedness for the amount owing 3.Defense and Prosecution of Actions —Notice of Claim to be thereon together with all costs, attorneys' fees and expenses which Given by an Insured Claimant .the Company is obligated hereunder to pay. If the Company offers (a.) The Company, at Its own cost and without undue delay. shall to purchase said indebtedness as herein provided, the owner of suchindebtedness shall transfer and assign said indebtedness and'the provide for the defense of an insured in litigation to the extent that mortgage and any collateral securing the same to the Company uponsuch litigation involves an alleged defect, lien. encumbrance or other payment therefor as herein provided. Upon such offer being madematter insured against by this policy.by the Company. all liability and obligations of the Company here- (b.) The insured shall notify the Company promptly in writing (i) in under to the owner of the indebtedness secured by said Insured case of any litigation as set forth In (a) above, (ii) M case knowledge mortgage. other than the obligation to purchase said indebtedness shall come lo an insured hereunder of any claim of title or Interest pursuant to this paragraph, are terminated. which is adverse to the title to the estate or interest or the lien of • the Insured mortgage, as Insured, and which might cause loss or 6.Determination and Payment of Loss damage for which the Company may be liable by virtue of this (a.) The liability of the Company under this policy shall in no case policy, or (iii) if title to the estate or interest or the lien of the exceed the least of . insured mortgage.as insured, is rejected as unmarketable. If such (i) the actual loss of the insured claimant; orprompt notice shall not be given to the Company, then as.to such (ii) the amount of insurance stated in Schedule A, or, if applicable,insured all liability 01 the Company shalt cease and terminate in the amount of insurance as defined In paragraph 2(a) hereof; or regard to the matter or matters for which such prompt notice is (Hi)if this policy insures the owner of the indebtedness secured byrequired; provided. however, that failure to notify shall in no case the insured mortgage, and provided said owner is the insured claim- Prejudice the rights of any such insured under this policy unless the ant, the amount of the unpaid principal of said indebtedness. plus Company shall be prejudiced by such failure and then only to the interest thereon, provided such amount shall'not include any addi-extent of such prejudice.tional principal indebtedness created subsequent to Date of Policy. (c.) The Company shall have the right at its own cost to'inslitute except as to amounts advanced to protect the lien of the insured and without undue delay prosecute any action or proceeding or to mortgage and secured thereby. do any other act which in Its opinion may beneCessary or desirable (b.) The Company will pay,in addition to any loss insured against to establish the title to the estate or interest or the lien of the by this policy, all costs imposed upon an insured in litigation carried insured mortgage, as insured; and the Company may take any appro-on by the Company for such Insured. and all costs, attorneys' fees • oriole action, whether or not it shall be liable under the terms of and expenses in litigation carried on by such insured with thethis policy. and shall not thereby concede liability or waive any • written authorization of the Company.provision of this policy.(c.) When the amount of loss or damage has been definitely fixed in(d.) Whenever the Company shall have brought any action or inter-accordance with the conditions of this policy, the loss or damageposed a defense as required or permitted by the provisions of this shall be payable within 30 days thereafter.policy, the Company may pursue any such litigation to final deter- mination by a court of competent jurisdiction and expressly reserves 7.Limitation of Liability the right, in Its sole discretion, to appeal from any adverse judgment No claim shall arise or be'maintainable under this policy (a) if the • or order.Company, after having received notice of an alleged defect, lien or (e.) In all cases where this policy permits or requires the Company encumbrance insured against hereunder, by litigation or otherwise, to prosecute or provide for the defense of any action or proceeding.removes such defect, lien or encumbrance or establishes the title, or the Insured hereunder shall secure to the Company the right to so the lien of the insured mortgage, as insured. within a reasonable prosecute or provide defense in such action or proceeding, and all lime after receipt of such notice; (b)In the event of litigation until appeals therein, and permit the Company to use. at its option, the there has been a final determination by a court of competent juris- name of such insured for such purpose. Whenever requested by the diction, and disposition of all appeals therefrom. adverse to the title Company, such insured shall give the Company, at the Company's or to the lien of the Insured mortgage, as insured, as provided in expense. all reasonable aid (1) in any such action or proceeding in paragraph 3 hereof; or (c) for liability voluntarily admitted or effecting settlement, securing evidence, obtaining witnesses, or pros-assumed by an insured without prior written consent of the Company. (CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS Continued and Concluded on Reverse Side of This Pagel a NMI Nall1111111Mingil -Mina IIIIINIMMIN C r 1 0 ••-.t.-, (CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS Continued and Concluded From Reverse Side of This Page).. 8.Reduction of Insurance; Termination of Liability priority of the lien of the insured mortgage and does not result in All payments under this policy, except payment made for costs,any loss of priority of the lien of the insured mortgage. The Company attorneys' fees and expenses. shall reduce the amount of the insur-shall be subrogated to and be entitled to all rights and remedies ante pro tanto; provided, however, if the owner of the indebtedness which such insured claimant would have had against any person secured by the insured mortgage is an insured hereunder, then such or property in respect to such Claim had this policy not been issued, payments, prior to the acquisition of title to said estate or interest and the Company is hereby authorized and empowered to sue, com- as provided in paragraph 2(a) of these Conditions and Stipulations,promise or settle in its name or in the name of the insured to the shall not reduce pro tanto the amount of the insurance afforded full extent of the loss sustained by the Company. If requested by hereunder as to any such insured, except to the extent that such the Company, the insured shall execute any and all documents to payments reduce the amount of the indebtedness secured by such evidence the within subrogation.If the payment does not cover the mortgage.loss of such Insured claimant, the Company shall be subrogated to such rights and remedies in the proportion which said payment Payment in full by any person or voluntary satisfaction or release of bears to the amount of said loss, but such subrogation shall be in the insured mortgage shall terminate all liability of the Company to subordination to an insured mortgage. If loss should result from any an insured owner of the indebtedness secured by the insured more-act of such insured claimant, such act shall not void this policy. but gage, except as provided in paragraph 2(a) hereof.the Company, In that event, shall as to such insured claimant be required to pay only that part of any losses insured against here- 9.Liability Noncumulative under which shall exceed the amount, if any, lost to the Company It is expressly understood that the amount of insurance under this by reason of the impairment of the right of subrogation. policy as to the insured owner of the estate or interest covered by this policy, shall be reduced by any amount the Company may pay 11.Liability Limited to this Policy under any policy insuring (a) a mortgage shown or referred to in This instrument together with all endorsements and other Instru- Schedule Et hereof which is a lien on the estate or interest covered ments, if any, attached hereto by the Company is the entire policyby this policy. or (b)a mortgage hereafter executed by an insured and contract between the insured and the Company. Any claim ofwhich is a charge or lien on the estate or interest described or referred loss or damage. whether or not based on negligence, and whichto in Schedule A, and the amount so paid shall be deemed a payment arises out of the status of the lien of the insured mortgage or of theunder this policy. The Company shall have the option to apply to title to the estate or interest covered hereby. or any action assertingthe payment of any such mortgage any amount that otherwise would such claim, shall be restricted to the provisions and Conditions andbe payable hereunder to the insured owner of the estate or interest Stipulations of this policy. covered by this policy and the amount so paid shall be deemed a payment under this policy to said Insured owner.No amendment of or endorsement to this policy can be made except by writing endorsed hereon or attached hereto signed by eitherThe provisions of this paragraph 9 shall not apply to an owner of the President, a Vice President, the Secretary, an Assistant Secretary,the indebtedness secured by the insured mortgage. unless such or validating officer or authorized signatory of the Company.Insured acquires title to said estate or interest in satisfaction of said indebtedness or any part thereof.No payment shall be made without producing this policy for endorsement of such payment unless the policy be lost or destroyed, 10.Subrogation Upon Payment or Settlement in which case proof of such loss or destruction shall be furnished Whenever the Company shall have paid or settled a claim under this to the satisfaction of the Company. policy, all right of subrogation shall vest in the Company unaffected by any act of the insured claimant, except that the owner of the 12.Notices, Where Sent indebtedness secured by the insured mortgage may release or substi-All notices required to be given the Company and any statement in Lute the personal liability of any debtor or guarantor, or extend or writing required to be furnished the Company shall be addressed to otherwise modify the terms of payment, or release a portion of the it at the office which issued this policy or to its Home Office. 433 estate or interest from the lien of the insured mortgage, or release South Spring Street, P.O. Box 2586. Los Angeles, California 90051. any collateral security for the indebtedness, provided such act occurs prior to receipt by such insured of notice of any claim of 13.THE PREMIUM SPECIFIED IN SCHEDULE A IS THE ENTIRE title or interest adverse to the title to the estate or interest or the CHARGE FOR TITLE SEARCH,TITLE EXAMINATION ANDTITLEINSURANCE. g cs) fl_ Ica.," on >n 20n fi ITI>4 Z iliti tik 0 —i 32 . C 4 i vs . •. . .. .. ........•f..•.4 •.4 .lip..•;..:.,..:. • 0 Star-6rd al Hernia •.----it/91 7—6 CA. State and Consumer Services Agency Memorandum tent. 7441/47 Dote :November 13,1978 File No.:DBP-402 To :Office of the Director Subject :TRANSFER OF JURISDICTION Department of Parks and Recreation Parks and Recreation 1416 Ninth Street,14th Floor South Carlsbad State Beach Sacramento,CA 95814 Parcel 2869 •Attention Jack Harrison,Chief Acquisitions Division From :Department of General Services —Real Estate Services Division 650 Howe Avenue,Sacramento 95825 By resolution dated January 30,1978,the State Public Works Board authorized the acquisition of subject parcel of real property required for the above—referenced project. The Department of Parks and Recreation having determined that the subject parcel is needed for the purpose for which acquired as of the date hereof,the Director of General Services,acting pursuant to the Property Acquisition Law,transfers jurisdiction of the subject parcel of real property to the Department of Parks and Recreation as of such date. Copies of the recorded instrument of conveyance and policy of title insurance for the parcel being transferred are enclosed for your use. Originals of these documents have been sent to the Proprietary Land Index for forwarding and permanent filing in the Office of the Secretary of State. Taxes on this parcel have been handled pursuant to Section 4986,et seq., Revenue and Taxation Code. Attached are two copies of this letter which we request be acknowledged on behalf of the Department of Parks and Recreation.The original may be retained for your records.After so signing;please return the two copies to this office. DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SE ICES CICSeig7 THOMAS F.RMAN Supervising Land Agent Receipt of this communication with enclosures mentioned is hereby acknowledged. DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION .a .dq DATE )t'1s r PC-30 -.4 le 1111111M11111111.1111 OMMOIMOOM • 4799.--4(4";.% • ("101••••Attz. •Aft4/aAgencytaLT:ks and Recreation le Project South Carlsbad Beach ,State Park •Pateel(s)2869 • PROPERTY ACQUISITION AGREEMENT • Deed Dated January 17,1978 Title Company Title Insurance and Trust Company County San Diego Address 220 A Street San Diego,CA 92112 • Escrow No.99371 6 • The parties to this agreement arc the undersigned grantor(s), hereinafter referred to as grantor, and the State of California, acting by and through the State Public Works Board, hereinafter referred to as State. The parties agree as follows: I.Grantor agrees to grant to State certain property, located in the above County, and more particularly described in the above deed, which is herewith handed to State's Land Agent, subject to the terms and conditions hereof. 2.The State agrees to pay S 1.2200..000.00into said escrow at the above title company for the account of grantor, mind it'OA on thjo.Roperty'vesiiiig inState, free and cle.ar of all liens,leases,-eneurnbrances, assessments, easements,of record of bttterwisand of taxes, extept:•;.;""•":7 •4:Z (a)Taxes for the fiscal year in which this escrow closes,a portion of which may be collectible against the grantor as--••-• provided by. Section 4980.of theRevenue and Taxation Code, it being expressly understood that the State is not liable,for paythent of any taxes which.Wave beend•are paid or piYable bYllid grantor:..'.••r••• r:T••"."••:".:-:!'.rx:T.•-c t.—2;1. (b)Easement or•rightiorway•Ofrecord for public roadsor publith dtilities;if ally . (c)Exceptions Numbers 2,3 and 7. .•• .• •. ..• •,. THE PROVISIONS ON TILE REVERSE. SIDE I IEREOF CONSTITUTE A PART OF THIS AGREEMENT Dated •Grantors At _ PAUL ECKE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, State PublicWorks Board By••fg;i4e:'0"1/267:-/Liel.-11--'s Administrative •- MAGgLENA ECKE DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SERVICES Dilectot by Chief I and Agent Approval Hi:corium:tided `I::"H.•••;1E511 Rev.3/11)'land Agent • • ?••.#yif.F-‘5'A . . •.No : 1 ... --1 . • t .I o.•1; •. W fA."..."‘„)..........,..„„tistillitlit' .0 t•'-1 #4.'iv 0 E.c ., .....; • iE. •. 4'7 . i... ----1----1-- -- .....,,,c„:„..1.7,.:—„ - - - 1 - -.' - ) -------------- 1.„.• AY /•vr • I 1._____— -.li -Arc...400w,--ro441.4-4-7.--gi II _— -- 5-.. 1•SOUTH CARLSBAD STATE BEACH ...-----1 ....--../-.... ft? ! '''b. oi- :.ol__.0 . --_.•- 13 AO".••••4......nr...r.1-.M.!..".........../C: . . 0.,......../de...................•••‘!..'••••e0....re'''.___......,.. .....°4441•4444•44_ 4. 0 T...•••••.... '''. •-7 e"" —......e.a .-..•'---AARLiDAD /:-_••'*••,...r. .i .•; •..-.-----"--77:-. -;?.47 ';::1 i . t•1 i 41.44H....' "7t.41.1itt+"t 1 1 6 • •%. 1 g 2 ,,...- I .cie Ar-2 a <p)A C I P I C 0 C ti'A _ 1 1.'i:.•' m o • O !• ..1 •i/..' • •\.CIA 14. 1.-4.AU 2 .,e-... ./ .,. ... s•- 'ETC-//O4 rool /L 11 osa1..ol Ari. 1 . A,4 '''••44.:rs.0 11.efre••4 ':—. ---'---.----..-------'-.----.------- .- --.'--'--- ----s. -•-.- -----.-- .f ..---.—.-.."---:-----4'3 7 --;,...... --.------_.---7---.-:-.-.....,__,------_____....---•-• 3 A‘i to UR Oileo *Z Z . •rr)---.,. •-.• U . --.,--..---....• ._,.....- ca. - .,...........................'*"..'..*SOUTH ---..........cARI SBAD....._.-.STATE..'4.....BP'AcH---""--.. -; ......._..;_„..... ------ ......i..... ....•,....._ .•_ co _1 —.--...........„.._...,0_...„............._:- ....,............_.... ow.'"lAJ '""....www.A....................................- AAP...".....4 V) a. ' .0 0, ::Ec .. ........."'''.••••Z0 .--eTEAAA.CD............,Ul l'' ioliaosoc.P A C 1 7 ..._ ...._...........,...... cr 1011 /WM/ 0 . _A-A .o ..._____ ---- 1 21 LEUCADIA m.AT B'TATE BEACH 0u) -qui LEGEND ------STATE BEACH BOUNDARY Ilis...,'\, OWNERSHIP SCHEDULE-;1 --.......-ACQUISITION BOUNDARY OWNER •GSESSOR'S PCL.NO.SECTION, TOWN9Nlir, RANGE DOCUMENT ACREAGE clqt,..v44.....• PARCEL NO.)..j 0 ACQUISITION PARCEL NO.L.-t Ecke Pool 9.0* 2 Eck'Paul ----3.04 _. DRAWING No.3 Zonakst.Willirmk _____,. SOUTH CAOLsitAD ....."..""""' 4 Lake Arrowhead Crearowejal Co.. .6.1fL___.14437 STATE BEACH •el•sksr,fji,--7 .301•5 Lake arrowhead Cackarrocial 04 ----- •1 %/4.-wt...-. .1\-:.Skitil.r).00 ' • 00 400....101.....j..40 -.• . Aware*J--i INv2:01' Mrfynari:;IT.k Waal-Candler Bldg.Co 1. —.-----'3 22 j SNEET No. 014 01100 :-ici..r .P..ACE1 .• I• •I . .•e.. ••••at so...11............0.•!• _- •1 (5 .. 1 .1 • ., w TI2 S RAW SBM u g -4 `J.L .a 42i.i 11 I . 1 4 SAN DIEGO COUNTY ne a) Or /(j°......441141111414....... u 0-;al ,i. GINIENINNEEMITIEo.ea.0 0RANCHOAQUAHEDI ONDA .e7 I k.*-,,,0.•., .D./*t• 11;.... • 4/ a 4.04 1 2 •.-:At (.;i i *440 t „,+.7.../p;t t x eo4.0 /o•4 ..II:w ...-o .• ;7:• 60 :*LOT N 0it1.41.z.44,.c.pien.c „._.....,.0 .--C7Rwer E S Ai r.(E13)44.j.,,,.g ...'V i'..zir .-IIVtTH/C. 'k ) V e.-\----..f ar)LIRE SEWER v tota....c„coicxe_se.Estur.,___ __sAss..•ga.-------------_--_-I LA COSTA DOWNS 0 0ON Mb Mil Oprin••••••••iM•I/INO 4•Ir MS ... ...iM 4.1.41.111•11•11041.7. ...UNIT Nal --- ...,......1 w ts•AA w FAL so.4 PAR NILS „.. ......./... /I PAUL ECKE R A.MORTON 1.---W.LINE R.R.142`t _____________4 _________...._I c' rii.*.x....4 Vilz::,7Rte{-ow ad w .; r.nit Tatrar****11r11.4417k .I.R.*a•ara.„,_,..3.).tentta.444 --74A \t .....•.Oh I-,.1110ddis4 _ AE Lia•I°:_g.....551151:__ 117"%*--Q •o.El 00LOTIL.T 2 •es I to •cot4 4..MT •*AARE [LINO.TO CT •----__ .....2 --1.-___.1 __1 2 to -fadPtTENNANIAN1ITENN/MAR D.- i4.0 7 /...>•Xl-h0-2-8 'MR 0 ir 0-tf.V.•UNIT NOS i UNIT Na 6 t•I01a5.11 -- %awl STATE NWT.PARCEL a Cr 1 /74- .___________ 4:___-----DI 000'DIf...A.-S ROL&30 STNI.OP LA •i if 0 le T.C..e •ii g ilf,.........t :.-_-.IT*PANCEL 1%.4 t ;will I ....IL--ex td:wire=.....%.„...........„.„.„„Vj..AL Witte" (14 8.1 1 --it ,e -_-•-__•1 --- "Ei .......11....*'.............""'.7PAI'.11.NO. I 1(60 el Y.iii a.firw-Wig or LIM PAL 0 I PAIL10 0 31...414: .4 •. •. _.__;-_________________-s Istra---tut mum..--------Nom a.- ./in Ir ---crams.AD NIL I .•......EASENENTS 04__________--------*---------- -------------------- . .• i_I---rt seilliellal slillalridri .r.1.1.......___,I 1 ...----WEAN woe nor Lin ...........j ___________---41Faii ZIMESTOEXTEINIIPAIIESSWEETT-3-11410I 1 I *PrI11141 I II"------011:.NO.11 ..............------------- ll C4111 I i 114A --'mum •sewn '-0Iij_...-------CAUL(STATION 1004.1101.••i-.1AerRox. AREAtI3•••so,SEE 00008(17 PILE 411LS)I _.--------0 ___._.--.."----------- Bean.' Nwaisi-IMEIJT LEASE ,------"--PACIFIC OCEAN te I.; CI aZtoOt<4 to 4lez ci:I- WTI2SR4WSBM2u. 111 1-• 0...i .:7 1 s...."--------..., _,SAN DIEGO COUNTY 4...„,,-§z 40ILIto .1.•:i 0.4 •2 *c..0 ,/I I.ce o./a:y , ,................„...z.s.. /.i /-:..- o 's.".""es'"liIlli"IMIIIIIIIIIIICTIONIII AS PER L.4111:401WATitiana COTESpEoDY:sT1.%482.0 A.. iti D.1"<a"a ; - t I ----- ......4 /- ATCH E 3 ON TOPEKA a-71--47X....1....N TA FE--...‹ -- /R11.- - LOT zt / _--- TAT - E -2f1" -WW1ili ...".1%,„,",',xjs::s...o:;:lliv_.1:7:::°:::...1 - ic 2 -I•/&LOT 3 4:37 •Vs -•L-- ...-:.... - ............__on -___t -LOT 2. ---......---. :::. LOT 4 A/----------------if S 2/ -----------•-fu--,q -------_ _ _2X LOT 4 /0 /..GI-Cr/.1...s.----.‹..-,.?!..IV ./,14.1 43) (Asc..-•-•low Acacia LOT 6 ___twog_...-.=- 0../ 0OPERMII41)0 DERCEL I'*---- ••••••....ffil). -17-71.".. .4........'42 ,.......:-..,. .....-•-------LOT 13 .*-13A1701.11TOS ....ick.savitT. C.P. ........... eV C.)0 30ACCESS E.3 ,-----LO T 1 ••••-...............s•.,,fez I)i. 1.1:1111-4 : ez Houma.vg 210 ACCE _2094 Tr OPIIIIIIES >,,,,i4i .EE W(7)pAICEL °""1"7 NW•f„•f _T'4 if .,.i pre DIX 40 ROAD SE.0"----'......•(Th ::Plif 1.0•31*0 AAA fr ,.....,"1.•113.0.'310.13T.0.00101...PAIL.16.1 LOACI.SEA BLUFF .ILI• ----_______) ;••-.....9-4.ri'.--iti LANE N kf I.-CL------p,,,,.„,,,,,,,•••.0.1:.;......•A Yit.,.i 41 .....__(SEAN MOM TIDE LIES %_,_,"...„,..,7174 ------------_______men i ,t.,-"1-Imums31.11tvEy 1-11-1144)--\11011-ExCL SIVE in*,p,ACCESS"CO_________---/-------___ .....111111111111111111111.1NIENINIiiiimiimi.4• 1.33 .7 OE•311sENTVICINITY(MAP CO ---------.2.'cc.0,PACIFIC OCEAN CAM FOR DOAT aCCEI --- T11 -------------,..l'I._.!OYER C-----LS IVNICIS .9 w \\‘`,1k\ NAT OE CONSTRUCTEDIN 0 I:3T 421I 11/0 POO WATERPIPE(UOLOCAT031 Z 0ESCoNCIDO 0---„,SCHEDULE OF ENCUMBRANCES t-\\\\,sa CARLSBAD SCHEDULE OF ACQUISITION = -12 \.STATE BEACH RES No PCL . NO GRANTOR TYPE OF RECORDING saoa a me afriCELt TOTALDOCUMENTDATEACREAGE Mull-_INuNCE GRANTEE _2 1 STATE OF CALM.Div OF Hank TYPE OP TERAGNATION Docuwepsy RECORDING eook a „AuDOCumENTDATEDATEDATE0110peRiPeTuAL2-a -35 a-so -3a 432 OR SO 0 400 1 SOOI 0 0E0 ECUS IN PEET Z.13.11 I Dm OF HIGHWAYS t C F.11-11 -49 3391 OM 322 ,14.22•11. £3.a ••a •a EASE.5 -1 -53 6 -18 -53 4454 On 443ca..1...?, --9-2$-SI up •38._117? E -24 CITY Of CAnLSIAD e •4-24 -GI Ilf.c.FILE 110701N..•••10-s• ii4 F Pt14;2343 3.SGE..*••ft L '4-28 -41 •-lasso LEGEND --I485TITLEINSuRANCEaTRUST CO.OM GRANT 1 -22-74 74-016291 23.4o00.Es WPM N._EINISK et II MO ...1NOEFINITE (2-7-34 .!-3 -sa 8486 ON 20 ••••••••••-•• ..•••••••.. STATE PARK 8DRYc-$2778 6 WILLIAM MASKER 3-3 -74 74 -042079 4.00 ET MAW ••8-54-65 1 -12 -SG REC.Famosselin-3-68-ta/1.••2775 7 60181 CASCADE HOMED LANO cowl •RABBDWZDC_LAKE COADIEMCIAL CO.--y'•II -It -GS ••2043904-15 -74 74 -127564 10.00 _3-IS -WI 78 -082580 a 07 Mai N_MI110-.,AinflaBlea •II -10-GS 11 -12 -64 --W839I 0 PARCEL NUMBER •)1 2569 5 PAUL &MAGDALENA [CAE427419COUNTYofSANMeGo fit.•futtitmu ie.Allms ...tux_. 0.C. °EEO 7-17 -78 76 -2 31r299 0. .Z./4RAAJr-,!!1-/G.-BS ,s3•39to 0.40G-. I ; • *.Istr eillail clAIMERCtAL CO. .-•.• , ,if -5-58 II -IS -EN'•*IOTA3-4 -G15 I -14 -NI ..•8 12 2 -14-44 2-17 -so -*mit /0 ENCUMBRANCE - DRAWING NC. 7.1 111*I/SERIES 6, 8K 199 2..•EXCEPTING WATER,1 Es Vo4i:1111511210:no 0.time co.EASE.•It-13 -50 -•14505.17579.•1 (17 1..SERIES 2,8X.1961 FILE NO H19958 Ooc NO 126621 OA.a NUMERAL RIGHTS I 9 CO MILTON It,Mat 0. vs•.••• --4 -27 -76 4-29 -74 •-79427343ataillzra7b_*a-1M LAND a WATER CONSERVATION - ( +•dam_ N 0(110 .n._s.E-P..co,.e. EP9-.B ,g •38a 3 3)...-7 --."Eil 'EDINA&60912RNMENT 212 oAGREDIET -'LAM:WATERC VISTA sANiTATIoN DiCITY-CAPLSGA0 AGREEMENT •'CLT Y DF riaR.LSESA D I I.6.4-64 saw FIM Ni. 429.6 :/-/2-act ti_-/-89 IfIR-4.740f45 Set-0312.3 ,----, AGREEMENT BDRY.sHEET NO- 1 OF ,,,,\IN iiiiit -I IlD I r'ISPOSAt-PA kce-L.‘../\\- ALE NI "MIS '----- ACREAGES MAY BE ADJUSTED BY SUBSEQUENT SURvEYS .______2 1 i i 1 2.-4