The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutMP 88-01A; Arroyo La Costa; Master Plan (MP) (2)City of arlsbad LAND USE REVIEW APPLICATION P-1 Development Services Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-4610 www.carlsbadca.gov APPLICATIONS APPLIED FOR: (CHECK BOXES) Develooment Permits I I Coastal Development Permit (*) Q Minor I I Conditional Use Permit (*) n Minor n Extension • Day Care (Large) I I Environmental Impact Assessment I I Habitat Management Permit Q Minor I I Hillside Development Permit (*) \Z} Minor I I Nonconforming Construction Permit I I Planned Development Permit [Z\ Minor I I Residential d] Non-Residential I I Planning Commission Determination [^^^'te Deveiopment Plan O Minor I I Speciai Use Permit I I Tentative Parcel Map (Minor Subdivision) Tentative Tract Map (Major Subdivision) (FOR DEPT. USE ONLY) Legislative Permits I I General Plan Amendment (FOR DEPT. USE ONLY) ariance VI ...iiior I I Local Coastal Program Amendment (*) ^[^Master Plan MlU()fl2^Amendment I I Specific Plan [H Amendment n Zone Change (*) I I Zone Code Amendment South Carlsbad Coastal Review Area Permits I I Review Permit I I Administrative Q Minor D Major Villaae Review Area Permits I I Review Permit I I Administrative CH Minor [H Major (*) = eligible for 25% discount NOTE: A PROPOSED PROJECT REQUIRING MULTIPLE APPUCATIONS MUST BE SUBMITTED PRIOR TO 3:30 P.M. A PROPOSED PROJECT REQUIRING ONLY ONE APPUCATION MUST BE SUBMITTED PRIOR TO 4:00 P.M. ASSESSOR PARCEL NO(S).: PROJECT NAME: BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT ^ 5D-DD / BRIEF LEGAL DESCRIPTION: -^y^c^ ^NM-D^A 0.V^ UoPr lof b^ftWA W^^^^ LOCATION OF PROJECT: tjTf^ ^i?-VvOge(-) IQn QLAA. l^S) ?aS^O FVV^O STREET ADDRESS ONJTiE: f SIDE OF fefTdO f> O (NORTH, SOUTH, EASTl^WEST^ (NAME OF STREET) BETWEEN OfNOL. AND (NAME OF STREET) (FJAMEW (NAME">dF STREET) iWNERNAr^E (Print): Lg, fo^^ \'^^W mfkc 'MAIUNG ADDRESS: .'^qsO Loo ^{Vt ^^SD CITY. STATe. ZIP: Q]^nl^l?^c^, OA ^^01^ TELEPHONE: -?>^Q t- EMAILADDPESS: cks^rA g ^m\^rneV. APPLICANT NAME (Print): yj^J^,^,'^ (Aulj/ak-^A MAIUNG ADDRESS: CITY, STATE, ZIP: TELEPHONE: EMAIL ADDRESS: I CERTIFY THAT | AM THE LEGAL OWNER AND THAT ALL THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE. ^NATURE DATE I CERTIFY THAT I AM THE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE OWNER AND THAT ALL THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO TRUEST OF MY KNIOWLEDGE. , / SIGNATURE J DAtE ' APPLICANTS REPRESENTATIVE (Print): \jAWrt^ .) 11 C 1. ^ A ^/l^ ( T^r^^i.^A.^U \r..,^ MAILING ADDRESS: ^^ St> Loo ^.r^oe. ^.'^H <^ CITY. STATE. ZIP: QrVvl^U^, QiV 9^0^ TELEPHONE: 7(^T> ^\%^%bS^ EMAILADDRESS: •4 I CERTIFY THAT I AM THE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE APPLICANT AND THAT ALL THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE. ^WGNA GNATURE J IN THE PROCESS OF REVIEWING THIS APPLICATION IT MAY BE NECESSARY FOR MEMBERS OF CITY STAFF. PLANNING COMMISSIONERS OR CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS TO INSPECT AND ENTER THE PROPERTY THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THIS APPUCATION. lAWE CONSENT TO ENTRY FOR THIS PURPOSE. NOTICE OF RESTRICTION: PROPERTY OWNER ACKNOWLEDGES AND CONSENTS TO A NOTICE OF RESTRICTION BEiNG RECORDED ON THE TITLE TO HIS PROPERTY IF CONDITIONED FOR THE APPLICANT. NOTICE OF RESTRICTIONS RUN WITH THE LAND ANDNBIND ANY SUCCESSORSJN INTEREST. FOR CiTY USE ONLY FEB 0 3 2015 DATE STAMP APPLICATION RECEIVED RECEIVED BY: f^- Development Services ^ City of DISCLOSURE STATEMENT planning Division Carlsbad P""«(A) 1535 Faradav Avenue (760) 602-4610 www.carlsbadca.gov Applicant's statement or disclosure of certain ownership interests on all applications which will require discretionary action on the part of the City Council or any appointed Board, Commission or Committee. The following information MUST be disclosed at the time of application submittal. Your project cannot be reviewed until this information is completed. Please print. Note: Person is defined as "Any individual, firm, co-partnership, joint venture, association, social club, fratemal organization, corporation, estate, trust, receiver, syndicate, in this and any other county, city and county, city municipality, district or other political subdivision or any olher group or combination acting as a unit" Agents may sign this document; however, the legal name and entity of the applicant and property owner must be provided below. 1. APPLICANT (Not the applicant's agent) Provide the COMPLETE. LEGAL names and addresses of ALL persons having a financial interest in the application. If the applicant includes a corporation or partnership, include the names, titles, addresses of ail individuals owning more than 10% of the shares. IF NO INDIVIDUALS OWN MORE THAN 10% OF THE SHARES, PLEASE INDICATE NON-APPLICABLE (N/A) IN THE SPACE BELOW. If a publiclv-owned corporation, include the names, titles, and addresses of the corporate officers. (A separate page may be attached if necessary.) Person /VA Corp/Part A^/P Title Title Address Address 2. OWNER (Not the owner's agent) Provide the COMPLETE. LEGAL names and addresses of ALL persons having any ownership interest in the property involved. Also, provide the nature of the legal ownership (i.e., partnership, tenants in common, non-profit, corporation, etc.). If the ownership includes a corporation or partnership, include the names, titles, addresses of all individuals owning more than 10% of the shares. IF NO INDIVIDUALS OWN MORE THAN 10% OF THE SHARES, PLEASE INDICATE NON-APPLICABLE (N/A) IN THE SPACE BELOW. If a publiclv-owned corporation, include the names, titles, and addresses of the corporate officers. (A separate page may be attached if necessary.) Person A'^/^ Corp/Part Za. /^Dbh VaJIxij f0l3^h(^ Title Title ' Address Address p-1 (A) Page lof 2 Revised 07/10 NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATION OR TRUST If any person identified pursuant to (1) or (2) above is a nonprofit organization or a trust, list the names and addresses of ANY person serving as an officer or director of the non- pro^t_organization or as trustee or beneficiary of the. ^on Prdij)Trust TAc^a^ A^ryn/Z'J^/ (JonProf^T rust PlrirJr^Q^ PUi I Title yr^5/'^/>/;/, Title Taot^urer Address 7^5"g Shho A^/^pfro Address J^^/ ^i^hu 4. Have you had more than $500 worth of business transacted with any member of City staff, Boards, Commissions, Committees and/or Council within the past twelve (12) months? ^ I I Yes No If yes, please indicate person(s): NOTE: Attach additional sheets if necessary. 1 certify that all the above information is true and correct to the best of my knowledge. of applicant/date ^ Signature of owner/date Signature of applicant/dat Print or type name of owner Print or type name of applicant / >'^^ . , , Signature of owner/^^^cant's agent if applicable/date of^ o\ Print or type name of owner/applicant's agent P-1 (A) Page 2 of 2 Revised 07/10 8 ^C^Cityof Carlsbad PROJECT DESCRIPTION Development Services ry ^ /p\ Planning Division '^'*\°) 1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-4610 www.carlsbadca.gov PROJECTNAME: ^.^7^ 1^//^ W^f^T^^r ,^-^^^7^^/? {^^^ KY ^nc< APPLICANTNAME: "^laWn'c^ GiuWlck&^rv Please describe fully the proposed project by application type. Include any details necessary to adequately explain the scope and/or operation of the proposed project. You may also include any background information and supporting statements regarding the reasons for, or appropriateness of. the application. Use an addendum sheet if necessary. Description/Explanation: Please, ^sJri.^ 4o otAWalvdl isW-^^rv^e^V o-OcL O^^laCtO^ u3fDticl-ejA ^ovl-^ u:)H-A_ m-ef^sj. 39 P-1 (B) Page 1 of 1 Revised 07/10 7A pcmintemet.com AN ASSOCIA COMPANV January 12, 2015 City of Carlsbad 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 Re: Case: CE-14-1180 We are formally responding to the courtesy notice provided to La Costa Valley Master HOA for failure to obtain a building permit. After meeting with members of the City it was decided that that we would submit an application to amend the original fencing plan for the community, thereby allowing the 7 foot fencing topped with barbed wire to enclose the storage facility located off of Paseo Aliso within La Costa Valley Master Association. Our request to amend the plan is to allow for adequate fencing around the Recreation Storage Facility in an effort to maintain health, safety and the better welfare for the community. Additional fencing is required due to deterioration of existing fencing and demands from renters of storage facility to upgrade the fence due to the existing height and materials allowing individuals easy access which has resulted in loss and damage to vehicles. Enclosed is historical information outlying the thefts that have occurred in the last four years. In addition, to these reports of theft, complaints have also been made to the City of Carlsbad Police department of illegal drug use in this area. A sampling of homeowner requests for action appears for your reference. 40 pcmintemet.com AN ASSOCIA COMPANY The Board of Directors upon notification of these events acted in the best interest of the community which in comprised of 1072 residences by seeking opinions from: police and legal counsel on appropriate action to secure the facility. The Board investigated additional lighting, security systems, security patrol and fencing options. Great care and consideration was given to the resolution of escalating criminal activity which also affected neighboring homes. As part of the investigation a survey and visit to local Homeowner's Association Recreation Storage facilities was performed. These findings were that chain link fencing and barbed was the standard material of choice. We hereby request that an amendment be granted to allow for a 7 foot chain link, barbed wire fence and automated entry gate to secure this area. Sincerely, Valerie Gullicksen, CCAM Sr. Community Manager On Behalf of the La Costa Valley Master Association Board of Directors. 41 I Tte 4 MuioscF OS-8 \ V^STA Design Criteria LEGEND ' • » TraB Refined Slopes * » Village Boundcuy !HHi Rrpject Boundary BWBir 47 227 i—"1 -PrDpDs'inc^', LEGEND VILLAGE WALL • ••••SoOd PROJECT FENCING •••••I Standard Tte L^^STA Wail / Fence Location O.S.- 8 BCHBir 48 228 All community walls shall be landscaped in accordance with the comiaunity landscape plan. Whenever possible, mounding and landscaping shajl be utilized to soften the appearance of walls and fences. Where necessary, the wall types will be modified to accommodate views and noise attenuation. Note that along Calle Barcelona the community wall varies in its setback, thus creating a variety of special landscape experiences along the street. 2. VILLAGE WALLS These walls are of similar materials as the community walls except that the pilasters are six feet, wall height is five feet, and wall decorations are not used. All Village walls shall be landscaped in accordance with the community landscape plan. Whenever possible, mounding and landscaping shall be utilized to soften the appearance of walls and fences. WTiere necessary, this wall type will be modified to accommodate views and noise attenuation. The Village wall detaUs are shown on Exhibit 32 on page 74. 3. PRODUCTION FENCING The production fences are of wood construction, and used to separate private residence boundaries. This fence type has an upgraded version where it borders on public areas, as well as a view fence (see Exhibit 33, page 75). All fence heights shall be coordinated such that there is a smooth transition ^ between side and fi-ont yard production fences (see Exhibit 34 on page 76). H. VIEWS^^ '^^in^ T^rc\r^ -V) W 1 M CUIA linK 4ofJ>€cl Maintaining quality views is important in the overall image of the Villages of La Costa. Interior view potential should be maximized by carefiil siting of buildings (especially two-story) and taU trees. Outward views should be framed with tree and shrub massing. This planting will also serve to soften views of the houses visible to surrounding areas (see Exhibit 35 on page 77). Views into the riparian area should be maintained (Exhibit 36 on page 78), >vhile views which look down fi'om residential areas into the recreation center and the school yards should be controlled (see Exhibit 37 on page 79). This provides a feeling of privacy and seclusion for those who use these fadlities, and still maintains a view corridor for medium and long-range views. The treatment of edges between differing land uses is an important consideration in maintaining continuity in conununity design. Site plaiming and landscape design should make a smooth and logical transition from one area to the other without leaving hard edges or abrupt changes. The three areas of greatest concem are the riparian-open space/residential interface, the special use/residential interface and the easement/residential interface. 73 53 • 6' NEIGHBORHOOD PILASTER VINE ACCENT LIGHT STUCCO FINISH VILLAGE THEME WALL NOTE: PILASTER LOCATIONS ARE AT BEGINNING AND ENDS OF WALLS AS WELL AS AT SIGNIFICANT HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL CHANGES. 6-NEIGHBORHOOD PILASTER TUBULAR STEEL FENCING VINE ACCENT PLANTING • VILLAGE THEME VIEW FENCE THE VlllAGESOF LACCKTA Village Theme Walls ARROYO LA COSTA EXHIBIT 54 74 'frDf>ose-. (JP K LdDDcL 4or rc\t=h^ 4d ahoLr^c^ STANDARD PRODUCTION FENCE f 2X4 RAIL TOP AND BOTTOM ^-BLACK VINYL CHAINUNK 6X6 WOOD POST y PRODUCTION VIEW FENCE 2X6 CAP 2X4flAIL \ f1 X a CBDAR BOARD 6 X 6 WOOD POST—, UPGRADED PRODUCTION FENCE VllUCESOF LACQSTA Production Fencing ARROYO LA COSTA EXHIBIT 55 75 ^ HAZARDOUS WASTE Development Services \^ City of AND SUBSTANCES Planning Division Carlsbad STATEMENT 1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-4610 P-1 (C) www.carlsbadca.gov Consultation of Lists of Sites Related to Hazardous Wastes (Certification of Compliance with Government Code Section 65962.5) Pursuant to State of California Government Code Section 65962.5, 1 have consulted the Hazardous Waste and Substances Sites List compiled by the California Environmental Protection Agency and hereby certify that (check one): lists compiled pursuant to Section 65962.5 of the State Government Code. I I The development project and any alternatives proposed in this application are contained on the lists compiled pursuant to Section 65962.5 of the State Government Code. APPLICANT PROPERTY OWNER Name: Name: Address: ^9ST) PUr^g^ 0^. ^^,i/.^SO Address: Phone Number: 7 (rO Ql ?0 Phone Number:. Address of SWe:/nJ><^A-<l^p/"L. V9^ 7 7^a6^ o /^/I'sp Local Agency (City and Countv): /^/^A/zi^ CUJn-h^<^ Assessor's book, page, and parcel number: <^.^S'- c^S'J — SD-/^ T^ Specify list(s): /KA Regulatory Identification Number: /VA Date of List: Property Owner Signature/Date ' The Hazardous Waste and Substances Sites List (Cortese List) is used by the State, local agencies and developers to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act requirements in providing information about the location of hazardous materials release sites. p-1 (C) Page 1 of 2 Revised 02/13 99 o o LA COSTA VALLEY ASSOCIATION MAINTENANCE AREAS PIAN ^ EIA INFORMATION Development Services < r FORM Planning Division CITY OF P-1fD^ 1635 Faraday Avenue r"ARI ^RAD "'V^/ (760)602 4610 V-./%r\L_»jD/AL-/ www.carlsbadca.gov INSTRUCTION SHEET FOR COMPLETING AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT INFORMATION FORM This Environmental Information Form will be used to assist staff in determining what type of environmental documentation (i.e., Environmental Impact Report, Mitigated Negative Declaration, Negative Declaration or Exemption) will be required to be prepared for your application, per the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and Title 19 of Carlsbad's Municipal Code. The clarity and accuracy of the information you provide is critical for purposes of quickly determining the specific environmental effects of your project. Any environmental studies (i.e., biological, cultural resource, traffic, noise) that are necessary to substantiate a "no impact" or "yes impact" determination should be submitted as an attachment to this Environmental Information Form. This is especially important when a Negative Declaration is being sought. The more information provided in this form, the easier and quicker it will be for staff to complete the Environmental Impact Assessment Form - Initial Study. P-1(D) Page lof 4 Revised 07/10 ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION FORM (To be Completed by Applicant) Date Filed: (To be completed by City) Application Number(s): General Information 1. Name of project: Name of developer or project sponsor: Address: City, State, Zip Code: Phone Number: 3. Name of person to be contacted concerning this project: Vfli^ri'f. f-inWl C.\t<^ Address: ,^9,gZ? Ja "Plaro . 5<c^/)6- 2SD City, State, Zip Code: Phone Number: ^(eO ^1^- 4. Address of Project: inLe-h^-ce^fX^ 79^7 ar)J 79^/ 7^5^6) Msd Assessor's Parcel Number: J^S — t^S~/ ~~ -5~3 — 5. List and describe any other related permits and other public approvals required for this project, including those required by city, regional, state and federal agencies: 6. Existing General Plan Land Use Designation: /p-h 7. Existing zoning district: 8. Existing land use(s): Ut/^ T^V Jn-h 9. Proposed use of site (Project for which this form is filed): /ID Q hos-ir^Q^ — ^5^11 Project Description 10. Site size: 11. Proposed Building square footage: 12: Number of floors of construction: 13. Amount of off-street parking provided: 14. Associated projects: p-1 (D) Page 2 of 4 Revised 07/10 15. If residential, include the number of units and schedule of unit sizes: ?f V 16. If commercial, indicate the type, whether neighborhood, city or regionally oriented, square footage of sales area, and loading facilities: 17. If industrial, indicate type, estimated employment per shift, and loading facilities: 18. If institutional, indicate the major function, estimated employment per shift, estimated occupancy, loading facilities, and community benefits to be derived from the project: 19. If the project involves a variance, conditional use or rezoning applications, state this and indicate clearly why the application is required: 5 P-1 (D) Page 3 of 4 Revised 07/10 Are the following items applicable to the project or its effects? Discuss all items cfiecked yes (attach additional sheets as necessary). Yes No. 20. Change in existing features of any bays, tidelands, beaches, or hills, or substantial • CE^ alteration of ground contours. 21. Change in scenic views or vistas from existing residential areas or public lands or • roads. 22. Change in pattern, scale or character of general area of project. 23. Significant amounts of solid waste or litter. 24. Change in dust, ash, smoke, fumes or odors in vicinity. • • 0^ • 0^ 25. Change in ocean, bay, lake, stream or ground water quality or quantity, or alteration of existing drainage patterns. 26. Substantial change in existing noise or vibration levels in the vicinity. 27. Site on filled land or on slope of 10 percent or more. • • • • • 28. Use of disposal of potentially hazardous materials, such as toxic substances, flammables or explosives. 29. Substantial change in demand for municipal services (police, fire, water, sewage, etc.). 30. Substantially increase fossil fuel consumption (electricity, oil, natural gas, etc.). 31. Relationship to a larger project or series of projects. Environmental Setting Attach sheets that include a response to the following questions: 32. Describe the project site as it exists before the project, including information on topography, soil stability, plants and animals, and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects. Describe any existing structures on the site, and the use of the structures. Attach photographs of the site. Snapshots or Polaroid photos will be accepted. 33. Describe the surrounding properties, including information on plants and animals and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects. Indicate the type of land use (residential, commercial, etc.), intensity of land use (one-family, apartment houses, shops, department stores, etc.), and scale of development (height, frontage, set-back, rear yard, etc.). Attach photographs of the vicinity. Snapshots or polaroid photos will be accepted. Certification I hereby certify that the statements furnished above and in the attached exhibits present the data and information required for this initial evaluation to the best of my ability, and that the facts, statements, and information presented are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. Date: )S' Signature: floljlA^. ^^^Jiu jJj/^ AAOJJ For: ^ (Mi Valhf VrViy^ 3^ P-1 (D) Page 4 of 4 Revised 07/10 City of Carlsbad Faraday Center Faraday Cashiering 001 1503401-2 02/03/2015 149 Tue, Feb 03, 2015 03:35 PM Receipt Ref Nbr: R1503401-2/0037 PERMITS - PERMITS Tran Ref Nbr: 150340102 0037 0041 Trans/Rcpt#: ROI06974 SET #: MP00149V Amount: 1 @ $1,668.00 Item Subtotal: $1,668.00 Item Total: $1,668.00 1 ITEM(S) TOTAL: $1,668.00 Check (Chk# 022254) $1,668.00 Total Received: $1,668.00 Have a nice day! **************CUST0MER COPY************* City of Carlsbad 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad CA 9200! Applicant: PROFESSIONAL COMMUNITY MANAGEMENT/GULLICKSEN VAL Description Amount MP00149V 1,668.00 Receipt Number: R0106974 Transaction ID: R0106974 Transaction Date: 02/03/2015 Pay Type Method Description Amount Payment Check 1,668.00 Transaction Amount: 1,668.00 AS Valerie Gullicksen bject: FW: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights From: Lise Zondler [mailto:lzondler@qmail.coml Sent: Tuesday, November 11, 2014 4:22 PM To: PCM Info Subject: Re: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights Due to illness we will not be able to attend the La Costa Valley HOA meeting tonight. I am sending photos of one of the numerous incidences that has happened to our property before the new fence was put up. For the record, We are in opposition to the fence around the RV lot to be tom down and reverted to the old design. We are directly across from the driveway entrance into the RV lot. Our home is on the comer of Paseo Aliso and Corte Limon. Before the current changes to the fence we were constantly burdened with malicious and dangerous elements in and around the RV lot and felt overflow activities around our home and property. We were in contact with the police far too much, for an area that is supposed to be safe and secure. These activities are very frightening as well. We have experienced property damage also. Since the fence was changed, there has been a remarkable improvement in unsavory and dangerous elements in our area. We are devastated to fmd out that there is potential for our area to become an unsafe place once again. We appreciate and understand some of the residents concem, but when community safety and security is the price that is paid to have a better ew of Walmart, it is of great concem. hank you for your consideration. Lise Zondler lzondler(g) gmail.com 2176 Corte Limon Carlsbad, Ca ^1 86 mmi CO , INC 1314 vv MfSSION«DAD ESCONDIDO. CA 0! P (760) 745-6609 F 760, 745-3CSe§ frontierfencecoincvfsfecsitofea; ne* PROPOSAL TO ^ Oosta Valley- Masters Asso. c/o PCM BILLING ADDRESS. JOB ADDRESS__JLl2L c/o Valerie DATE... Dec. 17, 13 . PHDMP 760 918 8053 {Bus.}. 760 809 1655 H6«sw i-K;- SHT"--—^ rop Ran I Bo«>m Rsi! Gauge • Miwf' ^ Bfac* ^ If' Ul O z Ul fteplace iron wi1:h chain- TF^ror ribbon ••^re^-oy.ecjl 1419' 25-bottcin fillers 10' 1 7/8 10' 2'- 1 3/8 2" 1 3/8 Wooc Cham Uf * (A O a. Corner 2 3/8ss20 < Ersd F>os!s Gate Posts colams - Type - Single Doybie Sfyte WkJth ' H»ght ' Frame double iron 26« 2" Gucirdian style Specifications Z i Picks! I ^oc Rail i Bottom ftaii T '~{,^ - -^~..r^f^a%-iicj^wiQn ^ ^^^^ II 'j^^ .,111,1.1.1 2" + 2"+ : 3/4 4" Pant 8! Pnme Vi O u CC H z < o UJ 0. Vi Corn iif.H r"i 'n JBCK na^n^^^!f .pfRazof ?'£>l3cn Diagram Guardian iron over tlie 2 gate oolurais 1- pipe grate 2- key pads Safety loop KTKJX 2-CSW24V operators (HOA t^o provide the power) We run the power across the road Pour Tpout ^\or 4o ^l^cfACaJ flMS: NET CASH UPOh COMPLETION. Taxes, if any, to vmicti this sate may &e sgbjed are induded tn, contract pnce, •env owned by: -,- - - - .., CEPTANGE This proposal, signed ifiis ot., „,., 20., becomes a contract wfien accepted by the setter, suDiect to the priniecj conditions or? tne reverse side hereof, and *« not suijject to cancellatton. •rrwAI ^ 49571.00 Prices sjuoted domot include buildirig permit fee / » V/ Salesperson's Sig.. CUSTOMER'S SIG TOTAL Down Payment 'Ck, No BALANCE DUE 7.2 Residential Area Improvements. 7.2.1 Residence. No Residential Lot shaii be improved except with one Residence (unless additionai Residences are permitted by the ordinances ofihe City) designed to accommodate no more than a single family (unless the ordinances of the City permit use by more than a single family) and its servants and occasional guests, plus a garage, fencing and such other improvements as are necessary or customarily incident lo a single-famiiy residence. Subject to applicable requirements of any Governmental Agency having jurisdiction over the Residential Lot or any planned unit deveiopment permits affecting the Property, no part of the construction on any Residential Lot shall exceed two (2) stories sn height above the finished pad. Chimneys, railings, vent stacks, pediments and similar architectural features of normal size, height and distribution may rise above the two (2) story construction limit. No projections of any type shall be placed or permitted to remain above the roof of any building within the Residential Lot, except chimneys, railings, vent stacks, pediments and similar architectural features. Anything contained in this Section to the contrary notwithstanding, any stmcture constructed on a Residentiai Lot shall be subject to the ordinances of the City regulating the height of stractures. No wiring or air conditioning fixture, water softeners or other devices (other than solar heating devices approved b}' the Architectural Committee) shall be installed on the e.x:terior of a Residence or be allowed to protrude through the wails or roof ofthe Residence with the exception of those items installed during the original constraction ofthe Residence). 7.2.2 Utilities. All utility, storage areas or structures and pool and spa equipment installed or constracted after the conveyance of a Residentiai Lot to an Owner by Declarant or a Merchant Builder must be (i) completely concealed from the view of any other Residential Lot or street, or (ii) constructed of such design, materials, configuration and in such location as to be compatible with the Residence and other Improvements on the Residential Lot. 7.2.3 Accessory Stractures. Patios and accessory stractures not exceeding six feet in height (including peaked roof) within rear yards ofthe Residential'Lots shall be allowed up to five feet from the rear property line of the Residential Lot. 7.2.4 Fences. All fences installed within the Property shall be in conformance with the fencing plan for La Costa Valley adopted by the City Planning Department. No fence within a Lot or the Association Property shall be constracted or altered as to type or height without the approval ofthe City Planning Department and the Architectural Committee. In the event fencing withia the Property requires replacement, the replacement fencing shali be substantially identical to La Costa Valley 40 the fencing being replaced, unless other rep!ace.meni fencing !.s approved by the City Planning Department and the A_rchitectural Committee. Fencing on those Lots designated Lots 573 through 583 and Lots 808 through 825 of Unit No. 3 shali be located only at the northeriy property line of 57 the Lots. The fencing shall be six (6) feet in height and constructed of wood. No stracture taller than six (6) feet in height shall be constracted in the northerly ten (10) feet of Lots 573 through 583 2942 AVENIDA PIMENTERA ARCHITECTURAL COMMITTEE MEETING NOVEMBER 17, 2014 PAGE 2 directed Management to call homeowner to a December hearing for Board review. Application was submitted at the direction of the Committee, for landscape changes in the back yard, which has been completed. A neighbor brought to the Committee's attention, that 10 Japanese Blueberry Trees were planted in close proximity of the shared fence. Homeowner stated via correspondence that Podocarpus shrubs were planted and all meet the 3 foot set back requirement. Committee noted that these shrubs can be tree like since they can get to be 40-100 feet tall. Committee directed Management to contact Jim Taylor of Lightfoot Planning Group for his input on whether there is anything to be concerned about. Management to report back to the Committee via email for further direction. 2857 SEGOVIA WAY |2166 VISTA LA 'NISA Application also requested approval for a solar system. Committee did not receive specification on the solar system. As such, directed Management to request the homeowner submit a new application with plans and specifications. Application was received for a roof mounted solar system. Application was approved with the condition that the solar panels be flush with the plane ofthe roof line and that the conduit be painted to match the home. Application was received for a roof mounted solar system. Committee felt there was not enough detail on the system and has directed Management to obtain more informafion. 2881 SEGOVIA WAY NOC's RV LOT FENCE Application was received for backyard landscape renovations and Installation of a spa and small pool. Application was approved to be forwarded to The Lightfoot Planning Group for further review. Notice of Completions were received and will be verified as followed: Susan will verify 2880 Vista Acedera for a roof mounted solar system; Mike will verify 2158 Vista La Nisa for exterior painting; Ken will verify 2168 Avenida Toronja for a roof mounted solar system; and Chris will verify 8002 Calle Pinon for exterior painting. The Committee discussed and approved plans to keep the existing 7 foot chain link fence around the La Costa Valley RV lot, and the addition of 3 strands of barbed wire. 7835 SITIO COCO Application was received for front yard landscape improvements, installation of 3 foot high stone walls, one on each side of the property and installation of a trellis near the front entry. Committee approved the landscape improvements. However, the Committee was not certain the trellis should be reviewed by the Lightfoot Planning Group. There was also a question as to how close to the property lines the walls would be and how they would be secured so as to not tip over. Management is to obtain this information and report back to the Committee for further direction. 2956 CAMINO SERBAL Approval application from The Lightfoot Planning Group was reviewed. 58 LOCATION LA COSTA VALLEY MASTER ASSOCIATION ARCHITECTURAL COMMITTEE MEETING NOVEMBER 17, 2014 The Architectural Committee Meeting of the La Costa Valley Master Association was held Monday, November 17, 2014 at 2280 Calle Barcelona, Carlsbad, CA 92009 in the Multi-Purpose Room ofthe Valley Club. CALL TO ORDER 5:45 PM Committee Members Present: Members Absent: Representing PCM: Others Present: Susan Mendes Dave Brennan Mike Zientek Ken Gross Chris Morrison Sandra Arguelles, Administrative Assistant 1 Guest ARTIFICIAL TURF 8015 PASEO lALMENDRO In an effort to be educated in the matter the Committee invited Eric Shepard from Tierra Verde Resources Inc., who has worked in the landscape industry for 35 years, to speak with the Committee and answer questions regarding artificial turf. Eric stated that artificial grass has improved in appearance in recent years acknowledging that artificial turf no longer looks like a shiny green carpet but more like actual grass. Also, techniques in installation have improved, where now sand is used underneath instead of tire shreds, which would be tracked into homes and/or wash away. It was noted that although there is about a 50% savings in water usage, artificial turf requires regular maintenance and at times requires the use of cleaning chemicals to ensure it remains clean and free of bacteria. The Committee is concerned that this will result in run off into the storm drains. Also, waste, such as animal feces, should be picked up and area washed immediately to avoid bacteria growth, which, if not cleaned properly could cause adults or kids sitting/playing on the turf to contract an infection. It was also noted that the process of installing artificial turf is almost irreversible, as chemicals are used to kill anything living, such as, grass, pests, and good bacteria in the soil. Bringing the soil back from a dead state requires a lot of work and could take years. This could create a problem if homeowner sells the home. At this point, the Committee is not prepared to allow artificial turf in the front yard. Committee would like to schedule more meetings In an effort to continue educate themselves on artificial turf and the impact it can have on the community. Management has been directed to contact an environmentalist, an artificial turf manufacturer as well as someone who installs it, and someone who has removed it. It was reported that homeowner has made front yard alterations, including Installation of artificial turf, without approval of the Architectural Committee. It was noted that this homeowner was given approval in March of 2014 for backyard renovations and was asked to resubmit an application with specifications to front yard improvements, which has not yet been received- Correspondence has been mailed to the owner earlier this month requesting a? response from the owner concerning the above information. Committee REPORTED RV LOT THEFTS/VANDALIZED ITEMS YEAR VICTIM PROPERTY/THEFT June 2008 December 2008 January 2009 2009-12 2010 March -May 2012 Gallucci Association Association Gene Ma Valley Crest N/A New Boat Motor/Mounts RV Lot Padlock RV Lot Gate Dates unclear/Reports at least 3 thefts between these years Golf Cart Stolen Drag paraphernalia and suspected illegal teen activity in and around resident RV. Multiple calls to Police to investigate. April 2012 Unclear Unclear (Police re( June 2012 Valley Crest Golf Cart June 2012 Association Fence August 2012 Survey to renters N/A January 2013 Capps Trailer/Misc. May 2013 Vierrg Outboard Motor May 2013 Vierrg Boat Cover May 2013 Universal Protection Board Members Security Meeting July 2013 Beraus Golf Cart August 2013 Bemus Tools/Equipment September 2013 Gene Ma Tires//Wheels September 2013 Jacob Spolestra Tarp September 2013 Association RV Lot Gate September 2013 Universal Protection Guard Lock Box January 2014 Association Padlock stolen Febraary 2014 Mizock Broken window Febmary 2014 Chemus Tarp 60 Febraary 2014 Steffemo Ransacked FENCE INSTALLED FEBRURAY March 2014 Gene Ma Unclear August 2014 Gene Ma ATV August 2014 Association Fence 61 Ja Valerie Gullicksen rom: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Wednesday, May ll'T^^UffW^ Valerie Gullicksen; lacostavalleyclub@gmail.com David Vieregg RV Lot Theft Hi Valerie and Nancy, 1 lease spot #15 at the La Costa Valley RV Storage lot for my camper trailer. 1 allow my neighbor Dave Vieregg to store his boat in the same spot (you have all insurance and registration documents on file). Yesterday aftemoon we went to remove Dave's boat and my trailer had been moved aside and his boat's motor, steering, and navigation had been stolen. He estimates the value of the motor at about $5000. He filed a police report last night. We are not sure when this happened as the last time we were there was about a month or so ago. It was after the last break in as I checked on things after that and this was the first 1 had been there since the rekey. ^^an you please let us know how to proceed? It would be good to also notify the RV lot resident email ^Plt to let everyone know what happened to raise awareness. The motor was large and Dave suspects it would have taken at least two people and at least an hour to unbolt, etc. Pl ease a dvise. Thanks, Steve Isachsen 62 Sandra Ar guelles^ om: Alan Wiliingham Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 8:29 PM To: Sandra Arguelles Subject: FW: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importance: High Sandra, This has been an ongoing problem for years? Are there any plans to add better security precautions to reduce the risk and damages to our property? Cameras, barb wire and much better signage are some easy additions. The fences are way too easy to climb and lift things over the 5'-6' height. Please forward this to the members of the board to address this ongoing problem for us. Thanks Alan Wiliingham Regional Vice President - Purchasing Southern California STANDARD PACIFIC HOMES www.standardpaciflchomes,com | Making You Right At Home® m Please consider the environment before printing a copy of this email, jiis e-mail and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use ofthe individual or entity to which they are addressed and all rmation is legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, or a person responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that disclosure, copying, dissemination, or use of information contained in or attached to this transmission is strictly prohibited. Note: that any views or opinions presented in this e-mail are solely those ofthe author and do not necessarily represent those of Standard Pacific Homes, Standard Pacific Homes tal^es every precaution to protect e-mail recipients, but recipients are responsible for checking any e-mail and attachments for the possible presence of viruses. Standard Pacific Homes or the author accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by e-mail. From: 'runner.com] Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 5:51 PM To: Alan Wiliingham Subject: Fwd: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importance: High Sent from my HTC JEorwarded message^- From: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles(a),pcmintemet.com> Date: Mon, Aug 5, 2013 5:48 pm Subject: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In To: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles@pcmintemet.com> Dear Homeowner: \ease be advised that the RV lot was connpromised on 8/4/13 and the Landscape Company's tools were stolen. Please check your RV or Boat and ensure that your items are secure. 63 Sandra Arguelles bm: Kim Blok Sent: Tuesday, August 06, 2013 8:01 AM To: Sandra Arguelles Subject: Re: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Ron & i were there picking up our RV around 11:00 am. We have the spot right next to the shed. The shed was wide open and the Beamus golf cart was partially behind our RV. We pushed it out of the way. It was weird but we just thought a worker must be attending to something in LCV & that he left the shed open. I was going to complain about the state of things but now i realize it was a break-in. Ron thinks we need barbed wire on top of fences, i think we need a better lock system, since i can barely unlock the gates by myself. We both think that Beamus needs a separate area for their equipment ( outside the RV lot) because the space is so tight & too many people are going in & out. The workers have never scratched our RV & they seem to be very careful, but its still too close to our RV for comfort. Anyway, maybe this info will help w/the timeline of what happened. Kim & Ron Blok, space 34. Sent from my iPhone On Aug 5, 2013, at 5:48 PM, Sandra Arguelles Dear Homeowner: Please be advised that the RV lot was compromised on 8/4/13 and the Landscape Company's tools were stolen. Please check your RV or Boat and ensure that your items are secure. If you have any stolen or damaged property, the La Costa Valley Board of Directors encourage you to file a Police Report. Also, if you have any information on the person(s) responsible for this fraudulent activity, please report it to the Carlsbad Police Department at 760-931-2100. Finally, if you have any questions regarding this notice, please let me know. Sincerely, Sandra Arguelles Administrative Assistant Professional Community Management of California, Inc. (PCM) An Associa® Company 5950 La Place Court, Suite 250, Carlsbad, CA 92008 Direct: 760-918-8055 Main: 760-918-8040 Toll Free: 800-599-9151 sarRuelles(5) pcminternet.com Associa'^ - Delivering unsurpassed management and lifestyle services to communities worldwide. Learn more at v\/vi/w.pcminternet.com / Follow us at www.facebook.com/professionalcommunitvmanagement 64 Valerie Gullicksen tf om: Sent: Wednesday, September 18, 2013 10:53 PM To: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RV lot theft Ms Gullicksen, This past weekend my trailer was once again, for the 4th time, vandalized. This time my trailer wheels and tires stolen and my trailer left on cinder blocks on the drum brakes/axle assembly. A police report was filed, case number 13-05964. At this time I would like to ask if the association carries any insurance at the property to reimburse the expenses I continue to incur as a result of repetitive incidents. I have tried to be reasonable and have approached the board to consider security cameras in the past. I would request that the board consider that as an action item once and for all. I understand that this was supposedly considered by a recent poll of the lot renters and there was a lack of interest, but I have been advised that an organization having been noticed of security concems who fail to act responsibly to protect the members remains liable. As I have said before, I am not interested in involving counsel. It just isn't my approach, as evidence by the 3 prior notifications of the association and my subsequent willingness to allow the board and management company to respond as they see fit. But please understand that at this point, after 3 prior acts of vandalism, I have just had it. The police officer who responded was surprised, to say the least, at the lack of security prevalent at the site, which he indicated was simply an invitation for vandalism at an unsecured RV lot. I would appreciate a timely response indicating the plan moving forward. ^^ncerely, ^Hbne Ma Carlsbad 65 Sandra Arguelles tf bm: Alan Wiliingham Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 8:29 PM To: Sandra Arguelles Subject: FW: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importance: High Sandra, This has been an ongoing problem for years? Are there any plans to add better security precautions to reduce the risk and damages to our property? Cameras, barb wire and much better signage are some easy additions. The fences are way too easy to climb and lift things over the 5'-6' height. Please forward this to the members ofthe board to address this ongoing problem for us. Thanks Alan Wiliingham Regional Vice President - Purchasing Southern California STANDARD PACIFIC HOMES wvwv.standardpacifichomes com | Making You Right At Home® Please consider the environment before printing a copy of this email, is e-maii and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individuai or entity to which they are addressed and all nmation is legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, or a person responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that disclosure, copying, dissemination, or use of information contained in or attached to this transmission is strictly prohibited. Note; that any views or opinions presented in this e-mail are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of Standard Pacific Homes, Standard Pacific Homes takes every precaution to protect e-mail recipients, but recipients are responsible for checking any e-mail and attachments forthe possible presence of viruses. Standard Pacific Homes or the author accepts no liability for any damage caused by any vinjs transmitted by e-mail. tf From: 'runner.com] Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 5:51 PM To: Alan Wiliingham Subject: Fwd: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importance: High Sent from my HTC Earwardedanessag^ From: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles(g!pcminternet.com> Date: Mon, Aug 5, 2013 5:48 pm Subject: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In To: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles@pcmintemet.com> Dear Homeowner: ^^ase be advised that the RV lot was compromised on 8/4/13 and the Landscape Company's tools were stolen. Please check your RV or Boat and ensure that your items are secure. 66 13S Valerie Gullicksen tf rom: Phyllis Mischke Sent: Thursday, September 19, 2013 2:23 PM To: Alan Wiliingham' Cc: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RE: Thank you for your e-mail Alan. I will pass it on for consideration. PAy///5 mischke Office Manager Professional Community Management of California, Inc. (PCM) An Associa® Company 5950 La Place Court, Ste. 250, Carlsbad, CA 92008 Direct: 760-918-8044; Main: 760-918-8040 Toll Free: 800-599-9151; Direct Fax: 949-206-2352 pmischke@pcminternet.com Associa® - Delivering unsurpassed management and lifestyle services to communities worldwide. Learn more at www.pcminternet.com / Follow us at www.facebook.com/professionalcommunitvmanagement ^Bom: Alan Willinghan^ 3ent: Thursday, SeptemE >ent: Thursday, September 19, 2013 2:14 PM To: Phyllis Mischke Subject: Phyllis, I recall that the board sent out a survey earlier in the year, or even late last year about improving the security at the RV lot and nothing other than 2 new locks every came of the survey/notice. The continued vandalism over the years is only increasing and it is truly time that action is taken to reduce the risk of theft and vandalism. I know that it wili never be 100% safe, but reducing the risk will reduce the number of occurrence's that seem to be growing. I sent a message in right after the last occurrence last month and still have not heard anything back from anyone. Will you please forward this message to the board and ask for their consideration to at least take "some" action to reduce the risk, doing nothing to mitigate the vandalism is not helping to reducing the risk. Just a few ideas: Barb Wire (24" barrel roll) added to the top section of the current fencing? Security Cameras, even fake camera wiil reduce risk Really good signage, large and posted per state law for no trespassing regulations (every 100') Much taller fencing 8', in some areas the current fencing is not much higher than 4' kank you for your consideration From: Phyllis Mischke' ^^^^^ Sent: Thursday, SepterriBer 19, 2013 10:25 AM 67 /OSS Sandr^Arguelle^ rom: Sent: To: Subject: Gary Endres(fc|||^ Tuesday, December 03, 2013 12:00 PM Sandra Arguelles Re: RV Lot Break-in Sorry to say it ...but you need to get the landscape people out of there...so this is about #5 or #6 incidents...Ive had a spot for my boat since early 2000's...I had my trailer license...battery...sound system stolen...hoa needs to take action... On Dec 3, 2013 11:29 AM, "Sandra Arguelles" Good moming. This email serves as a notice that on a recent RV lot inspection it was noted that a section of the fence had been detached and was laying on the grown. Although it was evident that the piece of fence was forcefiilly removed, it did not appear that anything else at the RV lot was out of order. However, PCM and the La Costa Valley Board of Directors do encourage you to inspect your property to ensure nothing was stolen or damaged. would like to add that, during the RV lot inspection, management met with a fence company to discuss the addition of a 6 foot chain link fence with the added razor wire on top. Please know that the La Costa Valley Board is researching several different options for added security measures. Further communication on what measures will be taken will be communicated in the months to follow. If you have any questions or concems, please let me know. Thank you. Sandra Arguelles Administrative Assistant W PROFESSIONAL COMMUNITY MANAGEMENT *N ASSOCIA COMPANV 68 Valerie Gullicksen tf bject: FW: RV lot questions There are two Recreational Vehicle (RV) storage areas in the Community. RV Lot A: • 338 parking spaces • 6' chain link perimeter fence topped with 3 strands of barbed wire • Member identification card activated electric rolling gate • CCTV pan, tilt and zoom camera monitored by Security RV Lot B: • 79 parking spaces • 6' chain link perimeter fence topped with 3 strands of barbed wire • Manual operated hinged swinging gate secured with chain and keyed padlock The RV Lots are patrolled 24/7 by PCM Security Patrol; there is no history of vandalism or theft in the lots. Jerry C. Storage, BSCE, MBA, CCAM®, CMCA®, AMS®, PCAM® Senior VP and General Manager 69 Valerie Gullicksen ^om: Neal C Dundas <neal@ncdundas.com> "Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 12:26 PM To: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RE: La Costa Valley Valerie: This confirms our conversation regarding the fence the Association wants to install. I have a number of Associations with RV lots. ALL have at least 8 foot high chain link fences with barbed wire or razor wire. I think there is a greater chance of the Association being sued for "lack of reasonable care" in protecting the member's RV equipment than having someone trying to get into the RV lot and getting injured. Remember, that type of person would be considered a trespasser and subject to county trespassing laws which protect the owner of the property. I would, therefore, highly recommend that the Association board go through with installing a chain link fence with barbed or razor wire. No RV owner could later come back and accuse the board of not using the care necessary to protect his or her RV unit. Hopefully, this helps the board make the right decision on this. Best regards, Neal Dundas, V.P. Commercial Division Direct Line: (949) 489-0214 Fax: (949) 340-7154 ^mail: neal@ncdundas.com neald@hoa-insurance.com License #: 0583884 Labarre/Oksnee Insurance 30 Enterprise, Suite 180 Aliso Viejo, California 92656 (949) 588-0711 (800) 698-0711 From: Valerie Gullicksen [mailto:vgullicksen@pcminternet.com1 Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:47 AM To: 'neal@ncdundas.com' Subject: La Costa Valley Dear Neal, Thank you for taking the time to speak with me regarding installation of fencing to include barbed and razor wire around the association RV lot. Best Regards, <Val&t£e. ^iMcAAen, CCAM Senior Community Manager 70 Sandra Arquelles tf ^wn m: Nancy Wright fent: Wednesday, September 25, 2013 12:31 PM To: 'Susan Mendes'; 'Thomas Krynicki' Cc: 'Thomas Normoyle'; 'Brad Westcott'; 'Scott W.'; Sandra Arguelles; Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RE: razor fencing I did call the City of Carlsbad on Valerie's request last week and they said there is no city rule regarding barbed or razor wire. Nancy From: Susan Mendes^ Sent: Wednesday, September 25, 2013 12:21 PM To: Thomas Krynicki Cc: Thomas Normoyle; Brad Westcott; Scott W.; Nancy Wright; Sandra Arguelles; Valerie Gullicksen Subject: Re: razor fencing I must agree, kids getting hurt trying to climb over a barbed fence into private property don't get my sympathy and I don't think we would have any liability. I think we need to know if there is a city rule about using barbed fence (I don't know). I think adding this to our existing fencing could be best use of resources to add efficient (long-term) security to this area. Susan n Sep 25, 2013, at 7:16 AM, Thomas Krynicki wrote: Gday All, I like the idea of a more secure entry gate but it also appears the thieves gain entrance and exit over the fence....I saw a barbed wire fence in Fallbrook last week on top of a similar ornate fence of about 4-5 ft tall that would seem to work as a great entrance deterrent....if a kid tries to use plywood etc to straddle and gets hurt than they win the Darwin award and I do not believe we would incur any added liability.... should weigh the cost of a new fence verses adding barbed/razor to existing... from reserve study still 8 years of life remaining: not sure we should replace too soon Metal Fencing - Common/RV 22 8 14 $95,500 $52,537 $4,341 $60,773 ($8,236) ($7.68) Component Service Life (a) Remaining Life (b) Years in Service (c) Current ^K)lacement ^Ost (d) Projected Reserve 71 the Board wants confirmation or your opinion that they are not opening themselves up for "more" liability by using this material. From: Thomas Normoyle Sent: Wednesday, SeptembSP 2b, 2U13 /: To: Valerie Gullicksen Cc: Thomas Krynicki; Susan Mendes; Brad Westcott; Scott W.; Nancy Wright; Sandra Arguelles Subject: Re: razor fencing We need to look more closely at use of barbed and razor wire on existing fence. 1 walked utility-path side of RV storage today and the 5-foot fence dips down to 4-foot elevations depending on grading. I would expect HOA to be sued in a scenario where there were serious injuries to children attempting to climb fence to retrieve kite, model airplane, whatever. More to the point, we need to understand zoning classification of this area. Both county and city prohibit use of barb wire on fences less than 6 feet in a variety of zoning classifications. I reviewed this with the Building Division at City of Carlsbad this aftemoon. They identified the following references and advised us to review the code and zoning with the Planning Department. I am waiting for a retum call. http://librarv.municode.com/index.aspx?clientId=l 5184 http://www.co.san-diego.ca.us/pds/docs/DPLU070.pdf We need to identify 2 to 3 fence contractors that can assist with questions on automated gate, use of barbed wire, and installation of 6 to 8 foot security fence. On Wed, Sep 25, 2013 at 5:42 PM, Valerie Gullicksen wrote: Shall I obtain 3 proposals to add barbed wire to the existing fence? Best Regards, Valerie Gvllicksen, CCAM Senior Community Manager Professional Community Management of California, Inc. (PCM), An Associa® Company 5950 La Place Court, Suite 250, Carlsbad, 92008 . Phone: 760-918-8040 . Fax: 949- 206-2356 . - 72 w FARMERS INSURANCE "It is a strange anomaly that men could be careful to insure their houses, their ships, their merchandise and yet neglect to insure their LIVES - surely the most important of all to their families, and more subject to loss." - Benjamin Franklin Original Message Received: 06:56 AM PDT From: Thomas Norm To: Susan Mendes < Cc: Brad Westco "Scott 'ject: Re: razor fencing How tall was fence? Agreed at committee meeting that modifying existing architectural fence with razor wire, at 4 to 6 feet with sloping elevations, is a safety issue. Tempting for kids to try to straddle with plywood, etc. Intend to move forward as quickly as possible with motion sensor surveillance and increased patrols. Need to answer question of integrating gate lock with security key fob. Low cost solution is two-step entry using key fob with existing key lock. At same time need to evaluate use of existing fence reserves to install 8 to 10 foot chain link fence with barb wire. Details to follow. On Tue, Sep 24, 2013 at 7:02 PM, Susan Mendes <susanmendes8@gmail.com> wrote: I spent last weekend in Bonsall at a horse ranch. Driving there I passed many groves that were fenced with the barbed wire/razor wire we have mentioned (like in the picture below). The grove fencing I passed, like in the picture, was not objectionable at all. I would like to know what the cost would be of installing this around our RV lot above our existing fencing. I would imagine that the city would need to approve of this if we chose to make this change. 73 I like this idea very much for a few reasons: (1) one-time cost solution (2) extremely effective for the level of vandalization/theft we are experiencing (3) not really visible because our RV lot is in an area that is not very visible. Susan Thomas Normoyle This e-mail message and any documents accompanying this transmission may contain confidential information and are intended solely for the addressee (s) named above. If you are not the intended addressee/recipient, any use of, disclosure, copying, distribution, or reliance on the contents of this e- mail information is strictly prohibited. Please reply to the sender advising of the ertor in transmission and immediately delete/destroy the message and any accompanying documents. 74 9q Valerie Gullicksen ibject: FW: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights Dear La Costa Valley HOA... I om not sure I con attend the meeting although I would like to share my thoughts and experiences ...I om on original owner of a La Costa Valley home since 2002...I am also an original RV Lot space renter. I have had 3 different vandal experiences with my parked boot... one incident was the theft ofthe stereo in my boot..another wos the theft of my boot trailer's vehicle license and the third wos the theft of my boot battery... all 3 instances I reported the theft to the HOA...on each occasion I was told thot 'the HOA was not responsible ond to report the theft to the City of Corlsbod... Each year when renewing the agreement to rent the space I was and om required to sign a document stating I am self-insured for my property on the site... I hove communicated to the HOA numerous times that my belief was the possibility of acquaintances ofthe landscaping company employees may have something to do with what's been happening... I am not pointing my finger buy when one starts to look ot the possibilities of who has entry to the space this is an obvious group thot has no vested interest. I om referring to the individual employees not the landscape company, am sure Bemis mokes every attempt to monitor and screen its employees. I om sure I have mode no friends with the company expressing my thoughts. My intention is only to create awareness and not pass judgment or blame. ter many years of issues the HOA has finally taken measures to secure the lot, hich I applaud, am not sure but I also believe the HOA hod taken ''by the book' 77 4 measures before spending any home owner reserve funds and storting any mproved security measures. The home owners who ore effected surely have a voice. Some thoughts that come to mind in this area ore....l) the RVIot hos always been there. VJhen one buys a home future changes regording common property must be considered...2) I om sure the HOA ha announced its intentions, sent letters and hos given the community ond the local home owners affected a chance to express their concerns 3) I am hopeful something can be done to mitigate the affected homeowners., .ie trees, aesthetic decor or something to soften any unsightly views 4) depending on how many homeowners are affected, a great number of La Costa Volley home owner recreational vehicles now hove greoter security. Something thot has been needed. I vote to try ond accommodate the affected home owners by continually trying improve the affected area that is on the HOA common property...Home owners own their own property and do have the ability to plant trees ond create screens to Ip improve a situation. tf There con always be changes made to the Master Plon. Things change ond chonge is necessary. Sending any HOA reserve funds to remove the new fence would be totally a waste of money, redundantly, after what's been spent... I am not sure how many homeowners ore affected but do the math...if 5 are upset...there are probably 50 who ore happier... Gory End res Celll-760-473-4423 78 Valerie Gullicksen c bject: FW: FwdiEmail SUPPLEMENTAL FOR BOARD PACKAGE Forwarded message From: Isachsen <sbisachsen(a)gmail.com> Date: Mon, Nov 10, 2014 at 10:02 AM Subject: Re: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights - - To: La Costa Valley <lacostavallevclub(a),Rmail.com> Hi, I am unable to attend the meeting tomorrow night, but do have direct experience with the following (please print and share with the Board): 5/21/13: Spot #15 had a boat's motor, steering, and navigation stolen (loss estimated to be $5000+). Police report was filed. The police estimated the crime took several hours to perform and a truck had to be backed in to lift and haul away the motor, which was several hundred pounds in weight. Approximately a month later, the thieves retumed to steal various other parts related specifically to the operation of the motor (additional bolts, fuel lines, steering mechanisms, etc). Since the new security fence has been installed no further thefts have ^|een reported in spot #15. 1 strongly support leaving the new fence in place, along with adding user-specific gate electronic codes. 1 also would support the gardeners no longer using the RV storage lot for their vehicles, lunches, etc as this creates additional opportunities for crime, not from the gardeners themselves but from the gate opening and closing throughout the day as they drive in and out. Please let me know if any questions. Thanks, Bjom Isachsen 2949 Avenida Castana 760-271-0983 On Thu, Nov 6, 2014 at 3:43 PM, Website Update <info@pcmintemet.com> wrote: LA COSTA VALLEY RESIDENTS: In an attempt to keep our residents informed with upcoming topics that may directly impact homeowners, we will be sending agenda updates when necessary: This email is sent on behalf of the La Costa Valley Master Association Board of Directors to advise you that concems regarding the new RV lot security fence have been raised by homeowners who border the RV lot area to the Carlsbad City Planning/Code Departments. The Good News is that the replacement fence has shown to have had a positive impact on increased security for the RVs, as well as the homes n the vicinity of the RV lot. Costa Valley HOA is currently working with the City for a solution. It appears the replacement fence may not conform to the fence in the Master Plan the developer submitted to the City many years ago. These homeowners are asking the City to have the HOA remove the fence completely and revert back to the original fence which is in a state of disrepair. „ _ jmail - Fwd: HOA Meeting Agenda Higjilights https://inail.google.com/]jU(u/0/?ui=2&ik=4e4a4ebe53&view=pt&sea.. La Costa Valley <lacostavalleyclub@gmail.com> Fwd: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights 2 messages Andrea Beyer Green <andie@hollysgidfriend.com> To: La Costa Valley <lacostavalleyclub@gmail.com> Hi Nancy, Below is the email I sent last week. I'm sorry we can't make it this evening. Thank you. Andie Beyer Green M: 619.895.6992 Begin fonwarded message: Tue, Nov 11. 2014 at 5:02 PM From: Andrea Beyer Green <andie.green@jaginteractive.com> Subject: Fwd: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights Date: November 6, 2014 at 5:33:16 PM PST To: lacostavalley@gmail.com Cc: John Green <johng92009@gmail.com> Hi Nancy, Thank you for sending this note out to the community. I wish John and I could be there on Tuesday night. I'm sorry to hear that the residents nearby don't care for the fence, but we really appreciate the reductions of break-ins and vandalization of the RVs, lot and nearby homes. The RV lot has been secure and we haven't experienced any trouble since we moved our RV into it last May. Best of luck and many thanks to the board in figuring this out. My hope is that between considering the residents' concerns, master plan, budget for the fence, and the Carlsbad Police crime reports before and after the fence, the board can figure out the best solution for the community. Best, Andie and John Green Andie Beyer Green M: 619.895.6992 Begin forwarded message: From: Website Update <info@pcmintemet,com> Subject: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights Date: November 6, 2014 at 3:43:39 PM PST To: Andrea Green <andie.green@jaginteractive.com> LA COSTA VALLEY RESIDENTS: In an attempt to keep our residents informed with upcoming topics that may directly impact homeowners, we will be sending agenda updates when necessary: 80 of2 11/11/2014 5:04 PM jinail - RV lot https://mail.google.conVrnail/ii/0/?ui=2&ik==4e4a4ebe53&vievv==pt&search=all&th=149al97... GM ii La Costa Valley <lacostavalleyclub@gmail.com> RVIot 1 message Julie Caines <julie@clarkecaines.com> Tue, Nov 11, 2014 at 5:21 PM To: "lacostavalleyclub@gmail.com" <lacostavalleyclub@gmail.com> To whom it may concern, Our boat is in the tv lot and had gas syphoned out during the time the old gate was in place. We are in favor of keeping the lot with the wire and security in place. Julie and Clarke Caines Sent from my iPhone 00 „fi 11/11/om/I <:.TO D^;^ Vandalism to Maxum Boat at La Costa Valley Storage Area February/2010 Vandals removed the rear section of all three covers and took the entire navigational system, ship to shore radio, stereo system, power amp and speaker system. In the process, they pried the entire dashboard apart causing severe damage. The previous fence surrounding the perimeter was sub-standard and could easily be climbed over by anyone. It is imperative that the current barbed wire replacement fence stay in place so as to prevent further vandalism to our property. The Willinghams 3025 Corte Baldre Carlsbad, CA 92009 82 00 u> 00 oo cn 1 1^ "L r \ \ rr w" _ -rr. \ \ mmm^m i'"a!( • .1'— < ( AA AAAA- A A X /: A /A^ A A A ..^"^ 1^,,,.- -A' K ,< . A 11 // •* 'III 'A!' A m AAm NOTICE OF EXEIVIPTION [F D [L 1 © Kmest .1 Dronenburg, ,ir, Kwor^er Cmmli tirk To: SD County Clerk Attn: James Scott 1600 Pacific Highway, Suite 260 PO Box 121750 San Diego, CA 92101 From: CITY OF CARLSBAD Planning Division "7' ' / ^T^'t/i^i ^ 1635 Faraday Avenue ^_nyy]bfr Carlsbad, CA 92008 (760) 602-4600 JUN 1 7 2015 Subject: Filing of this Notice of Exemption is in compliance with Section 21152b of the Public Resources Code (California Environmental Quality Act). Project Number and Title: MP 88-OlA - Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Amendment Project Location - Specific: RV Storage lot in between 7947 Paseo Aliso and 7951 Paseo Aliso Project Location - City: Carlsbad Project Location - County: San DieRO Description of Project: Amendment to Arroyo La Costa Master Plan to allow a change to the fencing which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire that has already been constructed and to change the production view fence by replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts. Name of Public Agency Approving Project: Citv of Carlsbad Name of Person or Agency Carrying Out Project: Austin Silva Name of Applicant: Valerie Gullickson Applicant's Address: 5950 La Place Court #250. Carlsbad. CA 92008 Applicant's Telephone Number: 760-918-8053 Exempt Status: (Chec/c One) • Ministerial (Section 21080(b)(1); 15268); • Declared Emergency (Section 21080(b)(3); 15269(a)); • Emergency Project (Section 21080(b)(4); 15269 (b)(c)); ^ Categorical Exemption - State type and section number: Section 15311 - Accessorv Structures • Statutory Exemptions - State code number: • General rule (Section 15061(b)(3)) Reasons why project is exempt: Proiect involves the construction of a fence with now environmental impacts. Lead Agency Contact Person: Austin Silva Telephone: 760-602-4631 DON NEU, City Planner Date received for filing at OPR: FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNT/ CLERK SanD^Coun^on_JLlli?L_^ Pnsted JUN 11 2015 Removed JUL W 2015 Retumed to agency on J^'^- 1'^ ^^^^ n>pdY z^La/ Date Revised 05/13 NOTICE OF EXEMPTION To: SDCountyClerk From: CITYOFCARLSBAD Attn: James Scott Planning Division 1600 Pacific Highway, Suite 260 1635 Faraday Avenue PO Box 121750 Carlsbad, CA 92008 San Diego, CA 92101 (760) 602-4600 FILE Subject: Filing of this Notice of Exemption is in compliance with Section 21152b of the Public Resources Code (California Environmental Quality Act). Project Number and Title: MP 88-OlA - Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Amendment Project Location - Specific: RV Storage lot in between 7947 Paseo Aliso and 7951 Paseo Aliso Project Location - City: Carlsbad Project Location - County: San Diego Description of Project: Amendment to Arroyo La Costa Master Plan to allow a change to the fencing which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire that has already been constructed and to change the production view fence bv replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts. Name of Public Agency Approving Project: City of Carlsbad • Name of Person or Agency Carrying Out Project: Austin Silva Name of Applicant: Valerie Gullickson Applicant's Address: 5950 La Place Court #250, Carlsbad. CA 92008 Applicant's Telephone Number: 760-918-8053 Exempt Status: [Check One) • Ministerial (Section 21080(b)(1); 15268); • Declared Emergency (Section 21080(b)(3); 15269(a)); • Emergency Project (Section 21080(b)(4); 15269 (b)(c)); ^ Categorical Exemption - State type and section number: Section 15311 - Accessory Structures n Statutory Exemptions - State code number: • General rule (Section 15061(b)(3)) Reasons why project is exempt: Proiect involves the construction of a fence with now environmental impacts. Lead Agency Contact Person: Austin Silva Telephone: 760-602-4631 DON NEU, City Planner Date Date received for filing at OPR: Revised 05/13 • FILE Ccityof Carlsbad NOTICE OF AN ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING SCHEDULED FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT An Administrative Master Plan Amendment (MP 149V) has been applied for to allow a change to the fencing plan that was approved as part ofthe Arroyo La Costa Master Plan, which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire that has already been constructed and to change the production view fence by replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts on property located east of El Camino Real and west of Paseo Aliso, generally known as the RV and Boat storage lot, and more particularly described as: Lot 124, of Carlsbad Tract No. 88-03-1, Arroyo La Costa, Unit 1, (Villages I), in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to map thereof no. 13385, filed in the office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, December 20,1996. Pursuant to Carlsbad Municipal Code Title 21, Section 21.54.060 B.2. An administrative hearing shall take place if a request to be heard is filed within ten (10) calendar days of the date ofthe notice. A request for an administrative hearing was submitted within 10 calendar days after the Notice of Request for an Administrative Master Plan Amendment was mailed out. This notice is hereby given to inform the requestor(s) and the applicant of the administrative hearing date, time and location as noted below. Please contact Austin Silva at 760-602-4631 or by email at austin.silva@carlsbadca.gov if you have any questions. ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING SCHEDULE HEARING DATE: HEARING TIME: April 29, 2015 5:30 P.M. HEARING LOCATION: 1635 Faraday Avenue, Room 173A, Carlsbad, CA 92008 CASE NO.: MP 149V CASE NAME: Arroyo La Costa Master Plan DATE NOTICE MAILED: April 13, 2015 CITYOFCARLSBAD PLANNING DiVISION Community & Economic Development Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue I Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-4600 I 760-602-8560 fax AM3AV-O9-008-1 UI03-Aj8Ae-/VUMM } vudn-dod pioqai a| jei^A^j 0 ap suas ®09I.S ®A>I3AV lueqeb 3| Z9S\\\m J3|ad f sa|iDe^ sananbpa Property Owner 7925 Grado El Tupelo Carlsbad, CA 92009 Jim & Cathy Miller 7959 Paseo Aliso Carlsbad, CA 92009 Tim Gallagher 7995 Paseo Aliso Carlsbad, CA 92009 Richard Schneeberger & Susan Gorman 7963 Paseo Aliso Carlsbad, CA 92009 Tammy Atherton 2192 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 Rania Amin & Sherif Abdalla 2177 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 Mark & Michelle Chaffee 7951 Paseo Aliso Carlsbad, CA 92009 David Daughters 2185 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 Alley Residence 7994 Via Hoja Carlsbad, CA 92009 Patrick R. Foley 2246 Vista La Nisa Carlsbad, CA 92009 Lise Zondler 2176 Corte Limon Carlsbad, CA 92009 Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 A notice has been mailed to all property owners/occupants listed herein. Date: Signature I 909kS ®AfciaAV laBpa dn-dod asodxa bl au|| Buo|e puaa ®091S aieidmai ®^l^AV asn FIL^ C City of Carlsbad NOTICE OF REQUEST FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT Notice is hereby given that an Administrative Master Plan Amendment has been applied for to allow a change to the fencing plan that was approved as part of Arroyo La Costa Master Plan, which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire and to change the production view fence by replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts on property generally located east of El Camino Real and west of Paseo Aliso in Carlsbad, California, and more particularly described as: Lot 124, of Carlsbad Tract No. 88-03-1, Arroyo La Costa, Unit 1, (Villages I), in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to map thereof no. 13385, filed in the office ofthe County Recorder of San Diego County, December 20,1996. If you have any objections to the granting of this Master Plan Amendment or wish to have an administrative hearing to discuss the requested Master Plan Amendment, please notify the Planning Division, 1635 Faraday Avenue, Carlsbad, California 92008, in writing within 10 calendar days ofthe date of this notice. If you have any questions, please call Austin Silva in the Planning Division at (760) 602-4631. CASE NO.: MP 149V CASE NAME: ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN DATE: March 17, 2015 CITY OF CARLSBAD PLANNING DIVISION Community & Economic Development Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue I Carlsbad, CA92008 I 760-602-4600 I 760-602-8560fax 091-8/09 tSo^JS/^V 8|q|}Bduioo luui Z9 x aiui gg IBLUJOI gp enanbig 091.8/^p) '^JSAV miM gjqiiBduJOO .,8/9 2 x „ j. am \3(\e\ 88030 2 00000000411-411108S GREGORY & JANELL TIBBITS 8066 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111084 WILLIAM & JOANNE RANDOLPH 8 0 67 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110977 DANIEL MILLER 8 069 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111085 JEREMY CURTIS 18070 VIA ARCE ICARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110959 MICHAEL P GOKHALE 8 072 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110976 ROBERT & KAREN SHUFF 8073 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110960 THE LOWE FAMILY TRST 8076 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110975 DAVE & DEBORA DEMAREST 8077 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110961 MARK BRUMER 8080 PASEO ARRAYAN CARL'SBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110974 GREGORY SAVRAN 8 081 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110962 NAOMI SPECTOR 8084 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110973 KEVIN & BOONSEON GUDMUNDSON 8085 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110963 MICHAEL & JtlLIA REYNOSA 8088 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110972 RONALD & DONNA THOMPSON 808 9 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110964 VICTOR & PAULA GALLISON 8092 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110971 KIAN T COLESTOCK 8 093 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110965 SANJAY & MEENAKSHI BHANOT 8094 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110970 JOHN QUART & DEBORAH CASHER 8095 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110966 ANTHONY & ALISON CASCIANO 8096 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110969 KIRSTEN DIANE BERGER RAMSEY 8 097 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110967 JENNIFER LEIGH EICHENMtJLLER 8098 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110968 ARNOLD Sc CHARLOTTE TUB IS 8099 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 Total Labels 1,075 Association 411 Label Type On-Site A notice has been mailed to all property owners/occupants listed herein. Date.- Signature:. label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 l^tlquette de fomiat 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery ®5160/8160 091.8/09 ts® AJ9AV 08AB 8|qpdaioo luui Z9 x luui gg IBUIJOJ. ep ettenbia 091.8/^||^ 'tisAV miM eiqpduiOD „8/g S x „ j. ezjS laqej 88030 2 00000000411-4110912 MICHAEL & SUE WEBB 8 044 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111009 KEVIN & JENNIFER BLAKEBOR 8045 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110982 HtlNG-CHAO & JULIA TAI 8045 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111070 MICHAEL & REBECCA MCINNIS 8045 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110952 CHRISTOPHER & CORDELIA MANIS 8 04 6 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111078 JAMES E SMITH 8046 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111001 JOHN & SHERRI WALKER 804 8 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110913 JAMES FOLEY & LINDA PERSHING 8 048 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111010 SCOTT LOEBIG 804 9 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110981 MICHAEL R GEROE 804 9 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111071 EDWARD & ELEANOR WHITE 8 049 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110953 MARIA E NIXON 8 050 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111080 RAYMOND Sc DOMINIQUE TECOTZKY 8051 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111000 HERBERT CHEUNG & ANN ONG 8052 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111072 ARDESHIR ADI DABESTANI 8053 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111076 SHISHIR SINHA/MARGARET HELLER 8054 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111089 KEITH & ANNE KEATING 8054 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111081 NELSON G COSTA 8055 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110999 RA Sc JEANNE VAN DER BIE 8056 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110980 THE HARRIS FAMILY TRUST 8057 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111073 TERRELL L THISTLETHWAITE 8057 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111075 DENNIS Sc CYNTHIA MORRIS 8058 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111088 IAN SCOTT SPECTOR 8058 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111082 ALEXANDER & CARMELINA MEROLA 8059 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110998 MATTHEW & NICOLE LOPICCOLO 8060 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110979 MICHAEL & MARCI MULVEHILL 8061 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111074 ALAN WASKIN 8062 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111087 BARRY HIRSCHBERG 8062 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110997 VICTOR SHAFOR 8 064 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110978 FRANK Sc. SANDRA SILVA 8065 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery ®5160/8160 0918/091-9® Ali 09 'ifKL 08AB giqjjBdulOo uiui Z9 x luui gg jBiujoi ep euanbjig^ AJ8AV L|i|M 8|q|}BdLU03 ,,9/9 2 X „ j. ezis jsqBi 88030 2 00000000411-4110931 SCOTT Sc REBECCA HARRINGTON 802 8 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110908 PAUL Sc MARISA ACOSTA 8028 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111033 MARC D RUDICH 8028 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110986 STEPHEN Sc HEATHER HILLIAR 8029 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111092 AMY R GARCIA 8029 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111017 DOUGLAS Sc DENISE NOVAK 803 0 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110923 PETER Sc JODI SCEPANOVIC 8031 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111032 SANDRA L SCHAFER 8031 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111005 RICHARD & KAYLEEN HUFFMAN 8 032 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110909 DAVID ARTIS 8032 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110921 JORGE SOROKIN 8 033 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111006 STEVEN Sc MAUREEN DUFF 8033 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110985 MARK Sc TRUDIE STRLTMWASSER 8 033 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111091 ALAN KENNY & JENNY HUANG 8033 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110949 JOHN Sc LAURIE ALTENBERN 8034 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110922 RANDY LANG 8035 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111004 R TODD STICHLER 8036 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110920 LINDA BEREZNY & JOEL ZUIEBACK 8037 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110984 PAUL Sc VERONICA RE JTO 8037 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111068 DOREEN KIRKPATRICK 8037 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110950 DAVID P RAUSCHE 8 03 8 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111003 THOMAS III & PATRICIA WOOD TT 804 0 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110911 LOUIS & SHEILA TRUNFIO 8040 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110919 GENE Sc KELLY MA 8041 CALLE PINON CARLSEiAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111008 JACK Sc NANCY CABRAL 8 041 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110983 HUNG HUYNH & NANCY SEN 8 041 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111069 KENNETH SIGEMAN 8041 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110951 MICHAEL & YESSIKA STRINGF 8 042 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111079 WILLIAM & tJRSULA BERMAN 8042 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111002 PHILLIP Sc RACHEL BAIRLEY 8044 CORTE SASAFRAS CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 label size 1" X 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery ®5160/8160 09t8/09tS® Ai^ 09AB ejqjiBduioo uiiu Z9 x luiu gg JBUIJO^ ep ettanbj}^^ 09 |.8ML) f^SKi mm eiqiiBdiuoo ,,8/g g x „ i. ezjs jeqej |^ 88030 2 00000000411-4110930 NARBNDRA KANJI & NALINI PATEL 8015 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110038 DAVID D TATAR JR 8015 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110927 ROBERT C & CRYSTAL D 8015 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111028 BRIAN Sc STACEY WADA 8015 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110989 BRIAN ZHANG & LILY HAN 8 017 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110946 MARY PATRICIA ZETTERBERG 8 018 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111020 VASILIOS Sc RUTH ZIKAKIS 8 018 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111100 EMIL TORKAR 8018 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110039 OSCAR & FIORELLA GIRALDO 8019 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110926 DIEGO Sc ANGELA VILLAMIZAR 8019 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111029 SAMER KABBANI 8019 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110041 GONZALO C & PURITA L SY-QUIA 802 0 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110933 SCOTT E GICKING 802 0 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111035 RANDY Sc STACEY PETERSON 802 0 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110988 PHILLIP LEWIS COLLA 8021 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111094 CARL MOSTERT 8021 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110947 JESSICA GOOD WOLTERS 8022 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111101 BRIAN & CATHERINE BOVENIZ 8 022 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110925 JEFFREY & DEBORAH DUNN 8023 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111030 DANIEL EGOROFF 8023 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111066 PAUL Sc LIZBETH GEITNER 8023 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110040 ALLAN OYAMA 8024 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110932 BRIAN & LORRAINE tJTSLER 8024 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111034 ERNEST MENDES 8024 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110987 RANDALL & CYNTHIA ERMERT 8025 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111093 ROBERT LOWELL 8025 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111018 HARRY R SMITH 8026 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110924 DAVID Sc NASRIN BROWN 802 7 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111031 14 LLI AM Sc MAGADALINI KARN 8027 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111067 PHILLIP H KENNEY 8027 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Aveiy ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Aven^ ®5160/8160 091-8/091-9® Aia^V 08AB eiquBdiuoo luiu Z9 x luui gg imioi ep eiienbig^ 09 l-8/HiL AJ8AV qtiM ajqiiBdiuoo ..g/g g x „ j. azjs |8qB| 88030 2 00000000411-4110047 DOUGLAS Sc CATHERINE DITTRICH 7996 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110094 MARK & KAREN SWANSON 7996 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110884 CRAIG & DEBORAH JOHNSON 7998 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110034 GREGORY & KAREN MESSNER 7999 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110046 ERIK KOLBERG 80 00 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111040 HARRY T TAYLOR 8000 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110942 JOHN D Sc BRENDA L BUSHER 80 02 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111024 MATTHEW Sc VIOLET LEHRER TTEES 8 002 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111025 HARIS ECONOMUS 80 03 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110045 KAVEN & ABRASEH& KAMBIZ KOHAN 80 04 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111039 YUHUAN TONG Sc YIBING ZHANG 8 0 04 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110992 GLEN Sc CAROL S MCGEARY 8005 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110943 DR Sc MRS JOHN ALLEN RAMEY 80 06 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111023 RAJESH KRISHNAN 8006 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110928 MARK Sc SUE DtJNN SCHAFFER 8007 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110036 JORGE BEAUMONT 80 07 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111038 PETER GAMERDINGER 8 008 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110991 MEHMOOD Sc JtlLIA MANJI 80 09 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110944 MARY LOU SCIARRILLO 8010 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111022 MARK & DANA ISAACS 8 010 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110929 CHERYL FELDMAN 8011 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110037 DIANE LEMOS 8011 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111027 JAMES L KAMBESTAD 8011 SITIO CAUCHO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110043 SAMUEL Sc KORRI BALL 8 012 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111037 JENNIFER M & STEVEN J FULSTON 8012 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110990 ALBERT Sc DONNA ROSA 8 013 PASEO ARRAYAN CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111096 JEFF M HALL 8013 PASEO AVELLANO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 WEI CHEN 8014 CALLE PINON CARLSBAD CA 00000000411-4110945 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111021 KEVIN Sc VIRGINIA KELLY 8014 SITION CAUCHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111099 KARLHEINZ & tJRSULA PULLMANN 8014 VIA ARCE CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery ®5160/8160 09118 08AB 9|q|lBdlJU00 lUUI Z9 X UllU gg IBlUJOi 8P 9H9nb|J3^ ytiSAV qilM 9|qiiBduioo „8/9 2 x „ j. azjs laqei 88030 2 00000000411-4110018 DAVID Sc IRENE HATTMAN 7971 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110053 WAYDE & JULIE GILLIAM 7972 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110090 FRANK & ELENA SUN 7 973 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110890 MONICA WESTERMYER 7973 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110052 MARYAM SEDGHI 7976 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110091 RICHARD Sc CLAUDIA SALZAR 7977 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110889 RON Sc KIM BLOK 7977 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110020 MARK D ROWEN 7979 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110051 FRANK Sc JENNIFER MERCHAT 7980 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110098 DARCY BRANDON 7980 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110092 JEFFREY STUMBO & CYNTHIA BOND 7 981 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110888 ANTOINE & PAOLA ASSIOUN 7981 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110880 DOUG Sc GLENNA DARLIN 7982 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110021 KENNETH T & ALBERTA A GILES 7983 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110050 WILLIAM Sc CHRISTINA HAMILL 7984 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110097 GREGORY LOWE 7984 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110093 THOMAS W Sc DELILAH A WARD 7985 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110887 LEROI Sc MARY JEAN FARLOW 7985 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110022 L ESQtJENAZI & C HOFFMAN 7987 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110049 SUSAN LOVELL-STERN 7 98 8 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110096 DANA MENDEL & DANIEL NEIPRIS 7 98 8 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110886 LILY Sc ALICE MENG 7989 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110882 PHILIP E SMITH 7990 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110023 JAMES VANONI 7991 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110048 ROZELYN NALIBOFF 7992 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110095 tJMESH & SUDHA KUMAR 7992 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110024 WILLIAM Sc CHRISTINE DUNFEY 7993 VIA HOJA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110883 WILLIAM TIEP 7 994 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110032 ROBERT Sc LINDA TALLEY 7994 VIA HOJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110033 TIMOTHY Sc PATRICIA GALLAGHER 7995 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec kiery ®5160/8160 0918/0919®^ 0918/ AjaiWD 1^ D8AB aiqpdiuoo UIUJ /g x UJUJ gg JBUIJOI ap epnb!}; AJ8AV miM aiqiiBduioo „8/9 g x.,azjs laqB] 88030 2 00000000411-4110084 ANDREW OLAH 7949 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110854 BRIAN Sc KIMARA SOLOMON 7 949 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110771 JAIME Sc MEREDITH GARCIA 7949 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110776 THOMAS KRYNICKI 7950 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110013 MARK Sc MICHELLE CHAFFEE 7951 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110058 BARENT Sc NANCY MYNDERSE 7952 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110110 BRYAN MARCUS 7952 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110761 DANIEL Sc MACHELLE MCCARTH 7952 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110085 MARK & STACY HVASTA 7953 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110853 HAROLD Sc NANCY SNOWDEN 7953 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110775 WARREN ROWLANDS 7 954 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110014 CHRISTOPHER FRITZ 7955 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110057 BRIAN ASKARI 7956 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110109 ROBERT Sc JILLIAN LOMBARD 7956 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110086 ARVIN MIROW & BARBARA CASEY 7 957 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110852 JOHN R Sc LAN SHAtILL 7957 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110774 LORI RYAN 7958 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110015 JAMES Sc CATHY MILLER 7959 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110056 CLINTON M GROSSER 7960 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110087 RICHETTE LOCK ESPIRITU 7961 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110893 GEORGE Sc LAURA FREESE 7 961 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110773 ROBERT/SHELLY/NANCY/ERIN 7962 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110016 RICHARD SCHNEEBERGER 7963 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110055 FRANCIS RIGDON CURRIE 7964 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110088 WAH KIN Sc YUK FAN CHEW 7965 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110892 JANET SUTTON 7965 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110772 DAVID & PATRICIA HOFFMAST 7966 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110017 VIJAY PALSANIA 7967 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110054 PRUDENCIO PERERA 7968 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110891 MARK & ANNETTE FARABAUGH 7969 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 091-8/0919® 0918J AJaAVO 09AB aiqiiBduioo UJUI zg x oiuj gg IBUJJOI ap aiianbii^ yti8Av qiim aiqiiBduioo „8/g g x „{. azjs laqBj 88030 2 00000000411-4110711 JAMES & JOAN COCHRAN 7936 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110081 RICHARD Sc VERONICA GILLETTE 7937 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110857 SHERRI N WAITE 7937 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110768 KRISTEN MORRISON 7937 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110709 EDWARD A & CHERYL H DUNBAR 7937 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110722 MERLAN & LISA MARTING 7938 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110779 CHRISTINE COCHRANE-ELIAS 7938 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110010 ROBERT Sc NANCY ERHARDT 793 9 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110758 WILLIAM KROMYDAS 7939 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110719 ERIK L WILLIAMSON 793 9 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110061 JORDAN Sc JOLYNN SHAPIRO 7940 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110764 JONATHAN CHANG & DORIS LIN 794 0 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110082 ANTHONY YOKOYAMA 7941 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110856 STEVEN Sc TRACEY BOGERT 7941 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110769 THOMAS GEORGE/PREETHA ALtJMKAL 7941 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110710 IRINA Sc YILMAZ OZGUR CANTEZ 7941 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110721 RAMON G Sc CORRIE M SAMANIEGO 7 942 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110778 THOMAS Sc KATHLEEN WHITE 7942 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110011 THOMAS GRAY 7943 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110759 MATTHEW BERGER & KAMARA GEORG 7943 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110720 ALAN PASION 7943 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110060 HEIDI M WAGNER 7944 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110763 STEVEN Sc DAYNA HAFERKAMP 7 944 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110083 KAREN DANIELS-RATTA 7945 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110855 LISA JAYNES 7945 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110770 PHILIP Sc CHRISTINE KOPP 7945 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110777 LISA L Sc KEVIN D FREEMAN-COOK 7946 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110760 DUSTIN R HACKER 7947 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110059 GREG PROVENZANO 7948 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110762 GORDON Sc WENDY CROSBY 794 8 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Averv ®5160/8160 09t8/09l-9®^ 0918 oaAB sjqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x UJUJ gg IBUJJOJ ap aiianbiq AjaAv qiim siqiiBdujoo „8/g g x ..t azis |aqB| 88030 2 00000000411-4110716 SUSAN KRAUSE 7927 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110648 TOM Sc BEATRICE SEVERSON 7927 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110074 RACHEL Sc ANTHONY PARSONS 7928 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110868 R TEICHMAN & L TALAMINI 7928 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110753 MARK Sc NANCY KULIK 7928 SITIO ABRIDOR CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110713 WALKER FAMILY TRUST 7928 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110079 ERIC & KAREN EDWARDS 792 9 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110859 SCOTT D DRUMMOND 7929 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411,-4110707 JOHN HISAYOSHI KtTRATA 7929 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 JIAN MA 7930 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD CA 0 0000 000411-4110724 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110008 GARY Sc JAMIE NG 7931 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110756 ROBERT Sc MICHELLE CHRISTEN 7931 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110717 PAXIL A SCOTT/JENNIFER S FRIEN 7 931 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110073 KAREN BtJRROWS 7932 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110869 STEVEN Sc ANDREA SUFFICOOL 7932 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110752 LEONARD Sc DANI STEINBERG 7932 SITIO ABRIDOR CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110766 DALE Sc MARINA HENRY 7932 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110712 LINDA WEBB 7932 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110080 IRA Sc LINDA ABRAMS 7 93 3 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110858 JOHN H SORENSON 7 933 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110751 JOEL & VALERIE ALTSHUL 7933 SITIO ABRIDOR CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110767 ROBERT RICH 7933 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110708 CHARLES Sc ANGELA BROWN 7933 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110723 MARK Sc JOANN HAYDEN 7934 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110780 BARBRA PLANTE/MICKY MCKINLEY 7934 SITIO NISPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110009 SAMUEL Sc KAREN GORDON 7935 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110757 BHUPEN Sc AMITA SHAH 7935 SITIO BANIANO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110718 BRIAN Sc LINDA FRIEND 7935 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110062 MICRAEL Sc JANELLE FINE 793 6 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110870 ERIC DASSO 7 936 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 0918/0919® 0918] OBAB aiqiiBduioo aim Z9 x uiiu gg iBuuoi ap aiianbig AjaAV qi|M aiqiiBduioo „8/g g x j az|s jaqBi 88030 2 00000000411-4110744 STEVEN C NOVOTNY 7915 VISTA NUEZ CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110645 DEREK JOHN PRESTON 7915 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110865 HELEN MARLIN 7916 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110663 FERNANDO Sc KAREN BELTRAN 7916 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110736 JACOBS FAMILY TRUST 7916 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110659 DONALD & JtJLIE ALEXANDER 7917 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110734 BRIAN A GILMORE 7917 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110651 THOMAS F EVANS 7 918 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110005 YU LIANG HUANG & HONG JIN 7919 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110646 JAMES Sc DEBBIE TKACH 7919 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110076 KAMBIZ Sc LAtJRA KOHANI 7 92 0 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110866 DARREN Sc CHARLENE LAZARUS 792 0 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110662 MARK Sc CHRISTINE BROWN 7920 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110077 ALAN HOCKNELL 7 921 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110748 PATRICK Sc ROBIN KEEGAN 7921 SITIO ABRIDOR CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110660 JOHN LEVIEUX 7921 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110735 ROBERT Sc DEBORAH HEYER 7 921 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110726 TIMOTHY J Sc MAGDA CORVI 7922 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110650 MELANIE BIERD 7922 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110006 HAO Sc SHUPING JIN 7923 PASEO ALISO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110715 RONALD & CAROLYN ZOLLAR 7 92 3 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110647 THOMAS & YING JONES 7923 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110075 STEVEN JACK COOK 7924 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110867 J SIMON & VANITA CRAW 7924 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110754 EDGAR Sc GABRIELLE NIELD 7924 SITIO ABRIDOR CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110714 BRENT NEWBY Sc LISA PUZO 7924 SITIO PERAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110078 SCOTT S Sc CRISTEN K MORRIS 7925 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110860 DONALD Sc RENEE SANSHU 7925 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110725 BRIAN Sc AMY HANLON 7926 SITIO GRANADO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110649 DAVID & COLLEEN BRENNAN 792 6 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 0918/091.9® 0918 yy^o OBAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap aiianbig AiaAv mm aiqiiBduioo „8/g g x „|. azjS laqBj 88030 2 00000000411-4110640 IAN KIRKWOOD 7904 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110666 OSCAR Sc MIRTHA CEPERO 7904 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110636 SAMUEL & LORRAINE STODDER 7905 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110656 JOHN B VANCE 7905 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110731 RICHARD Sc JAMIE EUCKER 7905 VISTA GtlYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110747 PAUL Sc ANNA CORTEZ 7906 VISTA NUEZ CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110654 CHAD & JULIA PUTNAM 7905 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110142 XIAODONG YAN & MEILING XU 7907 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110742 CARYL MARSHALL 7907 VISTA NUEZ CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110643 CLIFFORD F CHO & YOUNA CHOtJNG 7907 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110639 M KARIMI Sc S GHAMATY 7 908 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110665 CHRIS Sc EMILY KUO 7908 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110738 MICHAEL D OSGOOD 7908 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110637 KEVIN Sc CARRIE BISHOP 7 909 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110657 LARRY Sc SUSAN MARSHALL 7909 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110732 MICHAEL Sc MICHELLE BUNJE 7909 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110746 MICHAEL J SCHMITZ 7910 VISTA NUEZ CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110653 F HALE & S CORTELLESSA 7910 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110141 STEPHEN Sc KATHERINE ARMAN 7911 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110743 SCOTT VIGIL 7911 VISTA NUEZ CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110644 DAVID Sc KATHREN GILMETTE 7 911 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110638 DEWEY LEDERER & DIANA WOLKEN 7912 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110664 CHRISTOPHER F YUNKERScJULIE RI 7912 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110737 JASON Sc STEPHANIE RICHARDS 7912 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110863 GREGORY/KIMBERLY VAN LEEUWEN 7913 PASEO MEMBRILLO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110658 WILLIAM R SHERMAN/AMY RODERIC 7 913 VISTA CANELA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110733 CtTRT Sc MARLENA NOLAND 7913 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110745 DWIGHT L Sc DAWN K NAVIS 7914 VISTA NUEZ CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110652 TIMOTHY Sc JULIE THOMPSON 7 914 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110140 STANTON Sc CINDY ROBERTS 7915 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 0918/09tS® 091-1 08AB diqiiBdulOO UIUI Z9 X UIUI gg IBUIJOI ap aiianbjij i®yti8AV m|/w aiqiiBduioo „8/9 g x „|. azjs jaqBi 88030 2 00000000411-4110601 BRAD ANTHONY RAMBUR 7887 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110838 THOMAS & DENISE ENGEL 7887 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110796 ANTHONY Sc HELEN ADRASFAY 7888 SITIO MIRTO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110834 RICHARD D Sc TAMELA K NAGY 7888 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110632 MICHAEL R Sc GLENDA J MCCLURG 7889 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110791 DAVID Sc CHRISTINE CODELLI 7889 SITIO MIRTO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110851 B MCMURREY Sc F TRIFILETTI 78 90 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110595 KEITH A FORKIN 7890 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110146 AMIR ETEZADI Sc F TAHMASSBI 7891 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110837 JASON D VANCE 78 91 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110795 RANDY Sc KIMBERLY GARLAND 78 92 SITIO MIRTO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110835 STEPHEN YtJE Sc POLLY YU 7892 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110633 C WELSH Sc J SHELBY 78 93 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110792 GARY Sc ILEESE SCHNEIR 7893 SITIO MIRTO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110145 ROBERT A LUCAS 7895 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110599 HAIG & HELEN BOZIGIAN 78 95 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110836 CHRISTOPHER Sc STEPANIE FINCH 7 895 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110794 JAMES & DEBORAH LAVIN 7896 SITIO MIRTO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110634 TAO WU Sc WAN NI 7897 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110793 JAY & JULIA SARNO 7897 SITIO MIRTO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110597 LEE MAESTAS 7898 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110144 DURANT FAMILY TRUST 78 99 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110598 MICHAEL P DE LUCA 7899 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110641 SALVATORE Sc DIANNE PROVEN 7900 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110740 JEFFREY Sc SARAH GIVENS 790 0 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110635 MICHAEL P Sc AMY NANGEL 7901 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110730 RAGAN G Sc LESLIE M REEVES 7901 VISTA GUYABA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110655 ROBERT MORTON Sc LISA FRANK 7902 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110741 RANDY Sc DAWN GROSSMAN 7903 VISTA NUEZ CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110642 ROBERT Sc MARYAN LENNICK 7903 VISTA PALMA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 foiauette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Averv ®5160/8160 0918/0919, 09 H ;^AV oaAB aiqiiBdujoo UJUI Z9 x UJUI gg IBUIJOJ ap ananb ;® AJ8AV qiiM aiqiiBduioo „8/9 g x „t az|s |aqB| 88030 2 00000000411-4110591 DANILO Sc RHONDA HINCAPIE 7874 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110604 ALEXANDER Sc CHRISTINE MONKO 7875 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110798 MARCELO & KAREN SZTRAICHE 7875 SITIO OLMO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110841 PUGMIRE-PINGREE FAMILY TRUST 7875 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110802 J SOLOMON 7876 SITIO OLMO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110375 JAMES G Sc ANNA M HOLTEN 7876 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110831 TONY LO Sc SUSAN TUEY 7876 VISTA HIGtJERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110629 MARK D RIGBY 7877 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110805 DON ANDRUS 7877 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110848 MARK Sc MARY DURFEE 7878 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110592 TERRY Sc CAROLE ZANELLA 7878 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110149 KYUN Sc WON KIM 7879 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110603 S WALLACE Sc C PORTILLO 7879 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110840 TIMOTHY Sc JENNIFER GRANICH 7879 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110801 ROBERT Sc REBECCA MOORE 7880 SITIO OLMO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110376 CHRISTOPHER Sc LESLIE DUDECK 78 8 0 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110832 DAVID BOMSHTEYN 788 0 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110630 ELIZABETH M AGUIAR 7881 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110849 JOHN Sc MARTHA KOHUT 7882 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110593 WILLIAM L HOLLINGSWORTH 7882 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110148 JAMSHID PEZESHK 7883 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110602 YU CHUAN LIN Sc YU FANG CHANG 7883 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110800 JOHN Sc SUSAN MORGAN 7883 SITIO OLMO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110839 DAVID Sc LYNDA WENNERSTROM 7883 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110833 FRANK A SUNDELL 7884 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110631 RICHARD Sc COLLEEN SMITH 7885 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110807 JAMES & KATHLEEN STACY 7885 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110790 MR Sc MRS DANIEL PETERS 7885 SITIO MIRTO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110850 MARK Sc JOAN STEM 7886 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110147 ROBERT BABBIT Sc HEIDI JANZEN 7887 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 0918/0919® 091-1 8ip® oaAB aiqiiBduioo UJUI Z9 X UIUI gg IBUIJOJ. ap ananbji^ ytiOAV qiiAA aiqiiBduioo „8/9 2 x „|. azjs laqEj 88030 2 00000000411-4110504 DEVIN T FOREMAN 7865 SITIO FRESNO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110367 RICARDO M Sc SILVIA C REYES 7 865 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110393 DANIEL Sc BARBARA NESS 7865 VIA COSCOJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110511 DEREK NOBLE 7865 VIA TECA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110540 BRIAN Si JANE REYNOLDS 7866 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110506 WILLIAM Sc MARGARET GINTY 7866 SITIO FRESNO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 AZEVEDO 7866 VIA COSCOJA CARLSBAD CA 00000000411-4110410 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110378 EBON SMITH 7867 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110606 PHIL SAMBAZIS 7867 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110385 TERRY Sc PAMELA ODONNELL 7868 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110373 PHILLIP Sc KATHRYN SPENCER 7868 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110485 TAN M NGUYEN 7868 VIA TECA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110531 MICHEAL Sc KAREN MILLER 78 69 CALLE OLIVIA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 CAROLAN 7 869 SITIO FRESNO CARLSBAD, CA 00 00 00 0 0411-4110505 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110392 SHANNON M PARRA 7869 VIA COSCOJA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110512 YOUE-KONG SHUE Sc LIANG-YU WEI 7869 VIA TECA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110541 JACK F BUTLER 787 0 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110590 THE BIASI FAMILY TRUST 78 70 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110411 JENNIFER JEWELL TOKATYAN 7870 VIA COSCOJA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110377 MELISSA CLAASSEN 7871 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110605 CHRISTOPHER J PASCALE 7871 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110386 LINDA LIMA TTEE 7 872 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110465 RANDALL RlZm 7872 PASEO TtJLIPERO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110803 JOHN TIMPANI 7872 SITIO OLMO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110374 STEPHEN Sc LAURA MCKENERY 7872 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111102 THE WHEELER LIV TRS 02/28/200 7872 VIA TECA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110830 DAVID Sc ALLIE SATODA 7872 VISTA HIGUERA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110530 SHAUN Sc AUDREY MC LAURIN 7873 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110804 JOHN Sc KAREN WALSH 7873 PASEO ALMENDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110513 J BLAZEVICH Sc A VARZOS 7873 VIA TECA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 EtiauettB rifi fnrmat 25 mm x 67 mm nnmnatihifi aver. Avsrv ®R1fin/ft1fin 0918/0919, 091 r^^M/ 39AB aiqiiBduJOO UIUJ Z9 X UIUI gg iBUiJOl ap aiianbiu^ lIHb® A18AV qij/A diqiiBduioo „8/g g x „ j. 8Z|S |8qB| 88030 2 00000000411-4110399 ALAN FRANK 7851 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110460 JAMES H Sc MARGARET M OIUMET 7852 PASEO TtJLIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110489 JOHN Sc JOAN PYLE 7852 VIA TECA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110537 KENNETH & WENDY COLSON 7854 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110381 EMERY Sc LOIS ERDELYI 7855 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110398 THOMAS W Sc JULIE H OVERTON 7855 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110382 JOHN Sc ANDREA GREEN 7856 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110461 MICHAEL MADEIRA 7856 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110370 PIETRO TARANTINO 7856 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110488 VICTORIA FABRY Sc DAVID CROCKE 7856 VIA TECA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110534 JAMES ROBERT WOOD 7857 CALLE OLIVIA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110369 BERNARD A BASKIN 7857 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110538 PAUL CASTOR 7858 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110380 KURT & JEANELL BAUSBACK 7859 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110397 RUSSELL Sc DARCIE JOHNSTON 7859 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110371 TODD S NOBLE 7860 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110487 JAMES SINCLAIR 7 860 VIA TECA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110533 SADAHARU Sc EMI NISHIO 7861 CALLE OLIVIA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110503 EDWARD Sc MELANI OBRIAN 7861 SITIO FRESNO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110368 BRIAN BRACKIN 7861 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110539 T TODD DONAHUE 7 862 CALLE OLIVA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110507 EDEN D WESTGARTH 7862 SITIO FRESNO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110379 DANIEL Sc RANDI YUTER 7863 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110607 BRANDEN FRAZIER 7863 SITIO ABETO CARLSBAD 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110396 MARY ENGEN 7863 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110384 PETER Sc CHRISTINA RICE 7864 GRADO CIPRESO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110463 HAOYUN AN & ZHENGMING YAN 7864 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110372 KENNETH R KING 7864 VIA ADELFA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110486 JOHN Sc GENE KIRKLAND 7864 VIA TECA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110532 MICHAEL Sc FELIZABEL BANNACH 7865 CALLE OLIVIA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 EtIniJfittfi rifi fnrmat mm x R7 mm nnmnatihifi avfin Avprv ®fi1fin/R1fin 0918/0919® 0918/ oaAB aiqpduioo uiui Z9 x UJUI gg IBUUO; ap aiianbjt^ AjaAV mm aiqiiBduioo „8/9 g x „t az|s jaqBj 88030 2 00000000411-4110295 KEVIN & KATHLEEN MCCLAIN 7812 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110423 CHRISTIAN Sc BRANKA BILLANTE 7813 VIA OPUNTIA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110325 STANLEY Sc DONNA POEY 7814 VIA OPUNTIA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110422 DONALD Sc JOYCE MIZOCK 7817 VIA OPtJNTIA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110326 LEOR MATALON 7818 VIA OPtJNTIA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110297 CONTI FAMILY LIVING TRUST 7820 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110176 THOMAS Sc NANCY GAFFNEY 7821 SITIO TEJO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110298 GREG Sc CATALINA tJHLER 7824 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110177 KEVIN Sc CHERI HOFFMAN 7824 SITIO TEJO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110175 SCOTT Sc RENEE MYERS 7825 SITIO TEJO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110263 JOHN tJNIKEWICZ 7827 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110178 MICHAEL Sc CATHERINE PALOCHKO 7828 SITIO TEJO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110404 MICHAEL & MELISSA MtJRRAY 7830 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110262 HONGJIANG Sc VIVIAN WU 7831 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110300 MICHAEL BROWN 7832 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110179 BRIAN Sc MICHELLE LAWRENCE 7832 SITIO TEJO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110173 RICHARD Sc ELEANOR SMITH 7833 SITIO TEJO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110405 MELISSA JOCHEM 7834 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110403 ROGER Sc GAIL PETTY 7835 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110406 C Sc V MCCARTHY 783 8 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110402 BRIAN & MANDIE THEODORE 783 9 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110160 JOHN MCFADDEN 7 841 PASEO TtlLIPERO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110407 MERED Sc MARY OREN 7842 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110401 JACOB Sc TANYA G SPOELSTRA 7843 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110458 RICHARD Sc SUSAN LAVER 7844 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110408 KERRY GUINN 7846 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110400 MARK DAVIS & STACY WILE 7847 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110459 THOMAS MCMILLAN DODSON 7848 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110158 LISA RUDLOFF/COLLEEN KNUTSON 7849 PASEO TULIPERO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110394 MONICA KAISER 7850 SITIO COCO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiaiifittfi rifi fnrmat 25 mm x fi? mm nnmnatihifi avfin Avfirv ®51fifl/S1Rn 09i8/09ig® 0918, • oaAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x UJUJ gg IBUIJOI ap aiianbji^^ J, AJ8AV Vim Biqpduioo „8/g g x „ t azis laqBi 88030 2 00000000411-4110819 LORENE HENDERSON 3 028 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110941 SETH GROSSMAN 3 02 8 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110843 RONALD Sc CRISTA FONTAINE 3 02 9 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110901 RICHARD Sc TAMARA GILDERSLEEVE 3 030 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110820 CRAIG Sc JULIE LEIGH 3 032 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110842 ANTHONY Sc BRENDA PANETTI 3 033 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110821 JEFFERY REICHUBER 3 036 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110822 CHARLES W CHESNEY 3 04 0 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110879 GEORGE & AMY WILLETT 3 041 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110823 BRIAN Sc KATHRYN STEVENS 3 044 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110871 ARTHUR Sc JOANNE RODRIGUEZ 3 044 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110878 JOHN Sc MELANIE GILL 3045 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110829 ELIE Sc AGNES COHEN 3047 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110824 JAY B SLEIGH 3048 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110872 ROGER & BARBARA LEHMAN 3048 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110877 BARRY Sc DEBRA CONSTANTINE 304 9 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110828 JERROLD A/BARBARA J LITWILLER 3 051 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110825 MATTHEW C STRAWN TRUSTEE 3 052 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110873 R DOUGLAS Sc CATHY PARTIE 3 052 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110876 JACOB W STAVANA 3 053 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110827 WESLEY SHIH 3 055 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110826 STEPHEN & KARYN DUNN 3 056 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110874 ELAINE KING TTEE 3 056 VIA ROMAZA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110292 MERRICK MARK MATRICARDI 7800 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110293 HARALD Sc DEBORA FREY 7804 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110425 BRIAN & LUCILE LYNCH 7805 VIA OPUNTIA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110323 KENNETH WILLS & JACQUELINE AV 7806 VIA OPUNTIA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110294 EDWARD Sc FE WATT 7 8 08 CALLE PINABETE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110424 HOWARD DRESKIN/PHYLLIS LEVINE 7809 VIA OPUNTIA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110324 ALAN R HEBERT 7810 VIA OPUNTIA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Averv ®5160/81fin 0918/09 IS OS! 'tsJmi 09AB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOI ap auanb^^ llBlS® ^9AV mm aiqiiBduioo ,,8/g g x „ j. 8Z|s jaqB] 88030 2 00000000411-4110785 JOHN Sc RINA NASTOPKA 3012 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110916 THE POPE FAMILY TRUST 3012 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110815 COREY Sc TERRH KLINKE 3 012 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110937 JAMIE HOULIHAN 3012 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110905 MARK Sc JEANETTE KAGAN 3013 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110897 BRIAN Sc CHERIE HEID 3014 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110957 THEODORE Sc MARY WILLIAMS 3 015 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110934 KENNETH & BONNIE KRAEMER 3 015 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110784 DAVID & MARY ELAINE MIGDAL 3 016 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110917 CAROL CHANG 3 016 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110816 TOM HARRISON 3 016 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110938 L JESS Sc JENNIFER ROPER 3 016 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110846 ALLAN P FRANKEL 3017 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110904 TERRILL Sc KARRI SMITH 3 017 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110898 JAMES E Sc KAREN AUSTIN 3 018 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110956 SUNG Sc KYUNG MOON 3019 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110783 SHULING GUO 3 02 0 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110817 NOLAN ALEXANDER 3 02 0 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110939 BRIAN Sc ROSHANAK CLUNE 3020 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110845 MELISSA F TOMLINSON 3021 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110899 KNtJTE Sc PATRICIA SYVRUD 3022 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110955 GUY BRADLEY 3 023 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110782 JOAN DOYLE 3024 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110818 MICHEL Sc FADWA MASHNI 3 024 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110940 JOSEPH Sc LINDA FERRARA 3 024 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110844 LEWIS A Sc VICTORIA K BLOISE 3 025 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110902 JON Sc DOROTHY WILLINGHAM 3025 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110900 RICARDO CAMACHO 3 026 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110954 JOHN BECCARI Sc JUSTIE REIMANN 3027 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110781 SEAN C SEIBEL 302 8 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiniifittfi rifi fnrmat 25 mm x 67 mm nnmnatihifi avfin Avfirw ®FiARmiRO 0918/091-9® 0918, oaAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui g2 iBuuoi ap aiianbn^ AJ8AV qil/vi aiqiiBduioo ,.8/g 2 x „t az|S |8qB| 88030 2 00000000411-4110581 JON Sc ANN VAN WINKLE 2968 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110588 JAMES Sc STEPHANIE CLtlXTON 2 971 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110702 MYUNG HUI MOON 2 972 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110582 BRIAN MCCLOSKEY 2972 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110587 PHIL MICKELSON 2 975 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110703 DANIEL Sc SUZANNE DI PENTI 2 976 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110583 MICHAEL LUCAS 2 976 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110586 LON Sc CHERYL BARR 2979 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110704 GERARD Sc MARLA DAVANZO 2 98 0 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110808 JAMES Si RISA LAUTH 2982 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110705 RONALD Sc MONICA CHERNUS 2 984 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110809 MYLES F SUER Sc SUE E PRETZER 2 984 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110584 ROBERT B FESSINGER 2987 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110706 JOSEPH Sc ANN MARIE GABALDON 2 988 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110810 ROBERT Si LINDA CHEMALY 2988 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110811 BERTHA DUPLER 2992 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110789 SOCRATES SUSIM 2 996 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110812 NEIL Sc TERI MILLER 2 996 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110788 JEFFREY Si JULIA GARCIA 3 000 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110813 TERRI L MAGUIRE 3000 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110787 HUI LI Si XIAOWEN XI 3 0 04 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110914 W DRENNEN Sc M STRAYER 3004 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110814 EARL R DOWDY 3 004 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110895 LIU Sc LU LIU 3 006 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110786 GLEN L SALLEE 30 08 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110915 MU-YUE Sc MONA HSIAO 3 008 CALLE ALHENA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110936 JENNIFER BETTIS 3 008 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110906 WILLIAM SAMUEL Si MARY MEYERS 3009 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 90029 88030 2 00000000411-4110896 STEPHEN Si LORI WHALEN 3 010 CORTE BALDRE CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110935 ASHLIN S Sc ASHA J WILBUN 3 011 CORTE TILO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comnatlblfi aven AVRH/ 60/8160 0918/0919, 0911 i,a^tV OSA" aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap aii8nbij|^ ^^^5® AJ9AV qil'w aiqiiBduioo „8/9 2 x.. t azjs laqBj ^ 88030 2 00000000411-4110996 ROBERT Sc DEBORAH SYLVESTE 2930 AVENIDA PIMENTERA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110609 DANIEL Sc MONIQUE OMALL 2 931 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110573 CHARLES CUNO, III 2932 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110688 JOSEPH Sc VALERIE DIVITA 2 934 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110995 GIAN CARLO SAGGESE 2 934 AVENIDA PIMENTERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110608 MITCHELL Sc ALISON TRUELOC 2935 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110574 JOSEPH Si MELISSA BARBANO 2936 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110698 LUKE Si JILL WILLIAMS 2 937 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110689 NORINE PIGGOTT 2938 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110994 DAN Sc DIANA HALVORSON 2938 AVENIDA PIMENTERA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110575 DANIEL RITCHEY CHEVALLARD 2940 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110697 CAROLYN EDWARDS 2 941 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110690 STEVEN Sc TIFFANY FISHER 2942 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110993 LAURENCE Sc LAURA GREENE 2 942 AVENIDA PIMENTERA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110576 GEORGE Si JANA MANE 2944 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110691 JOHN Si ELISE CHO 2946 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110577 L HARRIS, R Sc S SHADDLE 2 948 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110695 STEPHEN Sc COLLETTE ISACHSEN 294 9 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110692 MARK S Sc DEBORAH S DERVAES 295 0 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110727 JUDITH M JOHNSON 2951 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110578 ROBERT Si KATHRYN WINSHIP 2 952 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110694 P Si D TARRICONE TTEES 2 953 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110693 RONALD Sc SARA GOLDBLtIM 2 954 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110728 CHRISTOPHER & DELAYNE WIL 2 955 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110579 DAVID GEIER SiJANET HOWARD TTE 2 956 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110729 ROBERT Si SHEILA GRAUL 2 959 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110699 JASON D Si BECKY B STUEMPFIG 2 962 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110580 MATTHEW Si HEATHER VIOTTO 2 964 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110589 LARRY Sc LESLIE NARITELLI 2 967 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92006 88030 2 00000000411-4110701 CLAUDE TRUDEL 2968 AVENIDA CIRUELA CARLSBAD CA 920 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Ihtlniifittft rifi fnrmat PR mm v fi7 mm nnmnatihifi a\(fin AwfirM ®S1Rn/R1fin 09t8/091.9®, 091 g, Amy 08AB aiqiiBduioo uiui zg x uiui gg IBUIJOI ap aiianbiu^ .^Bk® AiaAV qi!/«\ eiqiieduioo .,8/9 g x „ t azis jaqB) 88030 2 00000000411-4110490 A CHAVE Si C SEMENIUK 2 8 98 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110616 JOHN Sc MARY MOCK 2899 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 006 88030 2 00000000411-4110566 VIVIAN CHARTSSA KERR 2900 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110518 DAVID Si AMY SAVIAGE 2901 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110681 EDWARD Si ANNA MONOSOV 2902 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110615 SCOTT P HAVRANEK 2903 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111016 JAMES Si CAROL PEARSON 2 904 AVE PIMENTERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110567 ROBERT W GILES JR. 2904 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110517 AtlBREY Si NANCY WOODROOF 2905 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110614 BRUCE Sc LISA ANN BISHOP 2907 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111015 LYNN OBLIGADO 2908 AVE PIMENTERA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110516 MONICA DUNWELL 290 9 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110683 THOMAS Si LISA BUCKLEY 2 910 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111014 WILLIAM T ECKHOLM 2912 AVE PIMENTERA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110515 STEVEN STRYDER THOMPKINS 2 913 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110613 HO G PHAN Sc HA T TRAN 2 915 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111013 WAYNE CHEUNG 2 916 AVENIDA PIMENTERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110570 WILLIAM PETER STAMATIS JR 2916 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110514 JERRY Sc JANE CASS 2917 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110684 ERIC P GAVAMI 2 918 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110612 JAKE ZOLDAN 2919 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111012 JAMES Sc MAUREEN KASSELMAN 292 0 AVENIDA PIMENTERA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110571 SCOTT L WHITE 2 920 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110685 RANDY HSIAO 2922 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110611 MICHAEL M FOGLER Sc HUI YANG 2923 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111011 STEPHAN Si ALANA PEJOUAN 2924 AVENIDA PIMENTERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110686 JULIE FREDRICKS TTEE 292 6 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110610 STEVEN Sc MARYEV LYNN BETTERLY 2927 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110572 KEITH Si CYNTHIA WHITE 292 8 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110687 STEVEN P MARTINEZ 293 0 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 091-8/0919® 091- g, Am/ oaAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOI ap aiianb!U|^ .gfjm® AiaAV mm siqpduioo .,8/9 2 x A ezjs |3qB| 88030 2 00000000411-4111042 GARY Sc MAUREEN BOROSKY 2876 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110524 MATT Sc CHRIS CRAVETS 28 77 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110621 ART MONTGOMERY 2879 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110561 VNDREW MERRILL TERRY 2880 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111041 JOHN Si KAREN LUDLOW 28 80 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110523 MICHAEL Si MARILYN PEDICINI 2881 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110494 STEPHEN Sc MARGARET SCHMITTER 28 82 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110620 DEAN STAMOS Sc JUSTINE M FIORE 2 883 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110502 TAMARA FRANCIS 2883 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110562 THE CODIGA FAMILY TRUST 2884 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110522 MATTHEW Sc VIOLET LEHRER 2885 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110677 AARON D/CAROL A GERRAUGHTY 2886 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110493 B CARRUTHERS Si G BtJRBERY 28 86 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110619 KEVIN JAMES GLAZIER 2887 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110508 C.MATTHEW Si LISA KENDALL 2887 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110563 DAVID Si ABBY FISHER 2888 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110521 NEAL Sc JEANNE BORNHOFT 2889 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110678 PHILIP Si JENIFER BUCKLEY 2890 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110492 BRIAN FAULSTICH 2890 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD CA • 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110618 MR Sc MRS ALFRED SPADA 2891 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110509 E JA2TOSZK0 Si T RADOSEVIC 28 91 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110564 ANTHONY Si MICHELLE BURZO 2 892 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110520 GARY Sc SUSAN GOTO 2 893 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110679 BRUCE Si CHARIE OMAN 2894 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110491 PETER T Si ANITA L LAIRD 28 94 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110617 WILLIAM Si LAURIE MOSELLE 2895 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110510 FRANK Sc SABRINA GLYNN 2 8 95 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110565 REID Sc ROBIN CONANT 2896 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110519 R ASPERSLAG Sc K OBRZUT 2897 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110680 FREDRICK Sc NANCY ROCKER 2898 AVENIDA CASTANA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 ftiniiettP rifi fnrmat mm Y R7 mm rnmnatihio a\ior A\(en/ ®R1fin/81Rn 09t8/09l-9®, 091 a^Mf oaAB aiqiiBduioo uiui zg x uiui 92 IBUIJOI ap apnbia^ .j^P^g, AjaAV qi|W\ aiqiiBduioo .,8/9 2 x,. 18Z|S |aqB| 88030 2 00000000411-4110546 KERRI HOFFMAN 2859 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111056 PHILLIP BERKOVITZ 2 859 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110556 JOSEPH Sc TRACEY RUDMAN 2860 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111046 ERIC Si AMY RINGDAHL 2860 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110528 LARRY Sc DEBORAH OSBURN 2 861 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110672 WILLIAM F MC GOVERN 2862 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110545 GREGG Sc TERRY SONKEN 28 63 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110557 TIMOTHY SUTTON 2 864 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111045 JAY VARON 2864 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110527 JOHN CHATLANI Sc RATNA DtTBE 2 865 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110673 AZZEDINE Si BETH TOUZNI 2 866 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110544 ROBERT Si MELLISSA StJMMERS 2867 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110498 BRIAN MALEWICZ 2 867 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111098 PATRICK J COLLINS 2867 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110558 ALBERT Sc ELEANOR FELDMAN 2868 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111044 THOMAS Si SARAH O'CONNOR 28 68 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110526 JOSE Sc ELISA FREGOSO 2869 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110674 ERIN DUFFEY Sc JACKSON LONG 2870 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110497 JAMES Sc ELISE HAAR 2870 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110623 ROBERT Sc REBECCA MANES 2871 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110499 ERIC VENNEMEYER 2871 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111097 ANDREW Sc CANDICE I VERS 28 71 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110559 RIEM E Sc MAGDY E BADR 2872 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111043 MICHAEL D Si LAURA L WARNOCK 2 872 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110525 WILLIAM Sc VERA KOLE 2 873 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110675 CANDACE L SAGE TTEE 2874 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110496 ROBERT E SCHMIDT 2874 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110622 RANDALL Sc NANCY OLSEN 2 875 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110500 THOMAS Si JACALYN HARTMAN 2875 CORTE MORERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110560 STEVEN DILAURO 2876 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible aven Aven/ ©"jlRO/Slfin 0918/0915® 091- ® AJ^ 09AE aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IEUIJOJ ap ausnbuj^ isfll® AiaAV ijiiffl aiqiiBduioo „8/g g x „|. az|S laqB] 88030 2 00000000411-4110550 JEFFREY M Si DEBRA M COLTON 2 843 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111052 THOMAS Si NANCY WELBORN 2843 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110543 KIP Sc PATRICIA PUTERBAUGH 2844 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110552 ROBERT Sc MELISSA PORTER 2 844 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111050 KEVIN Si CORA CARMODY 2 844 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110627 A J JR RASSEY Si L ANDRESEN 2,845 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111065 WERNER Sc DONNA STEFFEN 2 845 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110668 ANTHONY Sc CATHERINE SELINKA 2 846 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111060 CHAR-YEN Si SERENA LEE 2846 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110549 CHRISTINE OGRADY 2847 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111053 THOMAS Sc CHIU GALLAGHER 284 7 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110553 DENIS JR Sc SARA SULLIVAN TTEE 2848 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111049 PAtIL K BINGHAM 2848 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110626 MATTHEW Sc DEVERY CAVANAUGH 284 9 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110669 DANIEL PENCAK 2850 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111059 MARCOS E Si MARIA A MILLA 2 850 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110548 CURTIS Sc SUSAN SHAFER 2851 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111054 BRIAN Si COREEN BAKER 2851 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110554 WILLIAM W PARKES 2852 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111048 DANIEL Si MICHELLE BOTHE 2852 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110625 CHARLES STEVEN EVENDORFF 2853 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110670 DOUGLAS J MACHON 2854 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD CA 92006 88030 2 00000000411-4111058 MICHAEL L JIMMINK 2854 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111055 GREGORY F Si ERIKA J BRUCIA 2855 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110555 SADEGH M Sc DEBORAH A RADVAR 28 56 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111047 LEONARD Sc JERYL BADOUR 2856 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110624 WILLIAM Sc JULIE GAGE 2857 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110529 ANT IA Sc MARK GOULD 2857 SEGOVIA WAY CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110671 PATRICK F Sc LEELA M MAGOSIN 2858 AVENIDA CEREZA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4111057 MICHAEL Sc DEBRA JEAN SHAN 2858 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiniifittfi rifi fnrmat 9R mm x fi7 mm nnmnatihifi awfin Asifir\/ ®Fi1fin/R1fin 09t8/09l.g® 091 oaAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOI ap aiisnbuj^ .^^m® AjdAV mm aiqiiBduioo .,8/g g x „ t azjs laqBj fl^ 88030 2 00000000411-4110338 DAN Sc NANCY JO PES 23 31 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110319 DOUGLAS Sc JANINE NAKAMA 2 332 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110413 TIMOTHY CLARK TRUSTEES 2332 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110337 JOEL VANN 23 35 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110320 GREGG Sc LORI HAGGART 2336 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110414 MICHAEL ISRAEL Si JULIE HOPPER 2336 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110336 FRANK CARLSON Si EVELYN CARLSO 23 39 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110415 LAURA R GOIKE 234 0 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110335 ELIZABETH JOHNSTONE 2343 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110321 JAMES ANDREW MOEDER 2344 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110334 BAMBI L COWELL 2347 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110322 STEVEN W Sc MEREDITH T DENZLER 234 8 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110417 CHANCE D TROMBETTI 234 8 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110333 ELISE REED 2351 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110418 MICHAEL A Sc HEATHER S ZIENTEK 2352 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110419 MICHAEL Si JAMIE SCHLEHUBER 23 60 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110420 DAVID Sc LYNNE BAUM 2364 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110421 WENDY PIEL 2368 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110332 FREDERICK B Sc ELYSE COLE 23 69 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110331 LEONARD DODSON 2373 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110330 YUJOO ITO 2377 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110329 JOSEPH STINE Si PHYLLIS SABOUR 23 81 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110327 HUEI-CHUN YUAN/SHtJEH-CHING LI 2389 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111062 LANCE S KURATA 283 8 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110551 STEPHEN Sc JENNIFER SEDLOC 283 9 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111051 DOUGLAS Sc DEBRA HANSEN 283 9 VISTA ACEDERA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110542 LOUISE WATKINS 284 0 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110628 KEVIN M Sc CHRISTY A WHALEN 2841 AVENIDA HELECHO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111064 ROBERT Si ANASTACIA SCOTT 2841 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4111061 CHIHLtMG CHAO 2 842 CORTE PAPAYA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 0918/0919® 0918, oaAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap eHanbn^ AiaAV qiiM aiqiiBduioo ,.8/9 2 x „|. azjs jaqEj 88030 2 00000000411-4110432 FRANK MANGANO 22 79 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110306 SALLY BARR 228 0 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110230 THOMAS Sc KIMBERY STRATTON 2281 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110390 EDWARD T COOPER 22 82 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110349 JOHN R O'DONNELL 2283 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110307 GAIL BOUGHNER Sc MARGARET HAHN 2284 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110229 JOHN MONAHAN 22 85 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110391 JONAH SONNENSHEIN 2286 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110347 SAMUEL Sc FRANCES GELBART 22 91 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110309 SHIJIE HUANG 22 92 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110346 GERALD Si OONAGH SHIELS 2295 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110310 FRED Sc JANET WORTHY 2296 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110345 ALAN Sc LYDIA CLARK 22 99 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110311 STEPHEN DENT 23 00 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110344 EVERETT Sc CHRISTINE RING 2 303 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110312 JOSEPH Sc MARIANNE ZAGARA 23 04 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110343 CURRIE HAMBRIGHT 23 07 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110430 JOHN Si JANICE JACKSON 230 9 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110314 CHARLES E CARR 2312 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110429 APURBA ROY 2 313 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110342 FREDA BUNTING 2 315 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110315 KENNETH Si TERESA EMMINGER 2316 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110428 JEFFREY Sc GENE HERSH 2317 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110341 JAMES BROWN, JR Si 2319 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110316 ROBERT Si CHAtlNCY NOBLE 2320 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110427 MICHAEL Sc TRACEY WEINGARTEN 2 321 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110340 RONALD WOERPEL 2323 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110317 THOMAS RUST GODDARD 2324 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110318 WILLIAM Sc MARY BARRY 232 8 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110412 MICHAEL Si BARBARA FRANCIS 232 8 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Ptiniiettp HP fnrmat 9R mm v R7 mm rnmnatihio a\(pr Awpnf ®Rifin/filRn 0918/0919® 0918 08AB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap ajianbiq AiaAV mm aiqiiBduioo ,,8/g g x „|. az|s laqBj 88030 2 00000000411-4110291 KELLY ALBERTS 2252 CORTE CICtn'A CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110236 ROCKY LE BLANC 2253 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110225 MICHAEL Si LISA WALSH 2254 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110438 STEPHEN THOMAS TAGGART 22 55 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110355 MARIANNE RETHWISCH 2255 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBM, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110235 J M GORLOW Si E RAMELLA-GORLOW 2257 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110226 ANGELO Si PARRY KOROS TTEES 22 58 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110437 MATTHEW LEHRER 2259 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110354 JASON E YATES 2259 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110301 GtTY Sc SHERLYN SHARP 22 60 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110234 MICHAEL Sc LORI BARNETT 2261 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110227 JOE ECKER 2262 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110436 MITCHELL Si ELVA ARAN JO 22 63 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110302 GAIL MCALLISTER 2264 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110233 CHRIS Sc JEAN SMITH 2265 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110435 SHANA OSBORN 22 67 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110303 JOHN R WINN 22 68 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110232 THOMAS W NORMOYLE 2269 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110387 PHILLIP Sc MONICA MAR 2270 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110228 WILLIAM Sc MARYJANE BAGBY 2270 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110434 ROBERT Sc CARRIE BRUCE 2271 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110352 ROBERT A KREGER 22 71 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110304 WILLIAM J PINNELL 2272 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110231 JAMES Si ELINOR WALDAL 2273 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110388 DMITRY Sc OLGA FARBEROV 22 74 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110433 MIGUEL MOTTA 2275 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110351 WILLIAM L HOYE 2275 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 02 00000000411-411DAYC CYNTHIA Sc HARRY CESENA 22 76 CALLE BARCELONA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110305 STUART HEPBURN 22 76 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110389 BO SUN Si WEN WANG 2278 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 ftlniifittft rifi fnrmat 9.R mm Y fi7 mm nnmnatihifi a<mn Awfin/ ©.RIRn/RIRn 0918/0919® A^f OBAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui 92 JBUIJOJ ap ananbit^ 0918/^b ^3AV mm 8|q|iBduioo ..8/9 g x., j. azjs jaqEj 88030 2 00000000411-4110276 CLINTON Sc CHRISTINA GILE 2231 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110361 RAY S Si AMY CATHERINE BURNETT 2231 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110266 ERIC Si ALISON REYNOLDS 2232 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110286 MICHAEL Sc JOVIE PADUS 2232 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110260 WILLIAM Sc NANCY PATTERSON 2233 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110240 JEFF Sc PAULA MOODY 2233 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110220 EDWARD P Si ROBIN A HERMANN 2234 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110442 PETER Si VALERIA PALLAI 2235 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110275 JOHN Sc CATHY DONADIO 2235 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110360 BRAD Sc STACI WESTCOTT 2235 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110265 DOUGLAS Si TINA ROBINSON 223 6 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110287 DAVID MILLS 2236 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110261 DAVID Si JILL STEIGERWALD 2237 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110221 JOHN Si PAMELA KEFFER 223 8 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110274 HARRY J Si JANICE S PROCTOR 223 9 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110359 ALAN B Si JILL A COLE 223 9 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110288 CLARKE Sc JULIA CAINES 2240 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110239 ANDREAS Sc MARY PLEIL 2241 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110222 BONNIE L LEAR, TRUSTEE 2242 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110441 DAVID Sc MAUREN QUESSENBERRY 2243 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110273 JONATHAN Sc SHARON HEE 2243 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110358 ANDREW MEURER 2243 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110289 DAVID Si DELANE HINKLE 2244 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110238 PATRICK Sc JILL WARD 2245 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110223 PATRICK R Si CHRISTINE L FOLEY 2246 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110440 CHRISTOPHER Sc JULIA AMES 2247 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110357 RICHARD Si CYNTHIA JOHNSON 2247 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110237 RICHARD Si SHARON FORBER 2249 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110439 JOHN Sc DONNA MASON 2251 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110271 THOMAS Si STEPHANIE BOWMAN 2251 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 label size 1" X 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Ftinrifittp rip fnrmat 9R mm Y fi? mm nnmnatlhip a\mr. Awpr\/ ®R1fin/R1Rn 09t8/091S®Ai 0918, A^wo 08AE aiqiiBduioo uiui zg x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap diianbig AiaAV mm 8iq|}Bdujoo ,,8/g g x „ j. azjs laqBj 88030 2 00000000411-4110216 RANDALL Sc LAUREL HICKOK TTEES 2218 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110446 DONALD C WILCOXSON 2219 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110279 TIMOTHY Si ELIZABETH RIIS 2219 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110364 DOUGLAS Si STEPHANIE LEWIS 2219 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110064 JOSEPH M Sc BROOK L LARIOS 2219 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110269 COLIN CHAMBERS 2220 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110283 MARK Sc AILEEN HERRERA 222 0 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110257 THE BOOHER FAMILY 2221 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110243 NATHAN Sc JENNIFER HAMLER 2221 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110067 BRIAN BAKER 2222 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110217 MADELEINE LAVALLEE 2222 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110445 SATISH IYER 2223 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110278 DAVID ESTRIN 2223 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110363 MICHAEL Sc HEATHER LOPEZ TTEE 2223 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110065 KIM SIMSBY 2223 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110268 RICHARD Sc CATHLEEN FOX 2224 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110284 GLENN Sc JULIE STILL 2224 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110258 THOMAS' Sc TINA JACKSE 2225 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110242 ARETE REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS 2225 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110066 C Sc C HERGESHEIMER 222 6 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110218 VAL Sc JUDITH BUONAIUTO 2226 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110444 ATHOLL A V Sc EDNA M GIBSON 2227 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110277 MANUEL CORPUS 2227 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110362 RASHID MEHIN 2227 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110267 PAUL Sc CHERYL BREEN 2228 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110285 ROBERT Sc DENISE PLANTE 222 8 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110259 STEVEN Sc LAtJRA PRZESMICKI 2229 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110241 TODD SERAFIN 2229 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110219 TIM Sc LUCI ROMERO SERLET 2230 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110443 GARY MARTIN 2231 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etinufittfi rifi fnrmat 25 mm x 67 mm nnmnatihifi avfin Avfirv ®R160/81 RO 091.8/0915® 0918 , AjM/03AB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x UJUJ gg IBUIJOJ ap aiianbii^^ jjflL AJ8AV mm eiqiJBduioo ,.8/g g x., j. azis laqBj 88030 2 00000000411-4110115 KAY STEFFERNO 2196 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110249 MICHAEL Sc RtraY CALLIHAN 2197 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110103 JAMES Sc JENNIFER THOMAS 2198 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110211 JOHN CAPRARA 2198 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110449 MATTHEW TURNER 2199 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110185 DAVID Si RONIT BARACH 2199 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110254 SUSAN Sc PETER REYNOLDS 22 00 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110248 DANIEL Sc LORI ASKEW 2201 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110184 JOHN C Si JOCELYN A GOLDEN 2203 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110072 DAVID HUANG Sc YANMIN SUN 2203 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110255 RUSSELL Sc JODI WALLIS 2204 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110247 JACK DAVID CARNES 2205 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110213 KEVIN Si MIA CRUFF 22 06 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110183 LARRY Sc SUSAN KAISER 22 07 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110071 BIAO YUAN Sc YAN PANG 2207 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110256 DANNY ALLAN FORD 22 08 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 9-2 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110246 MARTIN J SZtlMSKI 2209 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110070 R SCHNEIDER Sc C CATALDO 2210 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110214 BHASKAR Si ANSUYA BOSE 2210 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110448 DAVID ZITKO TTEE 2211 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110281 ATUL PATEL 2212 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110245 ROBERT Sc DIANA PAXTON 2213 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110215 THE SLOCUM TRUST 2214 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110447 CATHERINE MCDONALD 2215 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110280 ,ARK Si DEBORAH GRAS SI 2215 CORTE CICUTA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110365 THOMAS Sc JOANNE HEAVILAND 2215 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110063 FRED CHYTRAUS Sc SHERRI TAMS 2215 VISTA CHAPARRAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110270 MARK E Sc MICHELLE M TROSTLER 2217 CORTE ANANAS CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110244 CHARLES Si LYNETTE BOWMAN 2217 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110366 DOUGLAS Sc LINDA JOHNSON 2218 PASEO SAUCEDAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiniifittfi rifi fnrmat 9R mm Y R7 mm nnmnatihifi avfln Avnrv ®R1fin/R1Rn 0918/0915® 0918, AJ^OSAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap aiianbii^ AJ8AV qi|M aiqiiBduioo „8/g 2 x ..j azis laqBj 88030 2 00000000411-4110028 DAVID Si SUSAN DAUGHTERS 2185 CORTE ARBOLES CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110112 C KLOCK Sc L ROSENBERG 2185 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110190 PO HSIN WU Si ETSUKO OKUNO 2185 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110130 KIEN Sc CHRISTINA LUONG 2186 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110106 FREDERICK S Sc KELLY S 2186 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110209 HUGH Sc ANNE O ' DONNELL 2186 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110188 KENNETH & DEBORAH RAUSCHE 2187 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110100 S PARTHASARATHY Sc L GANESAN 2187 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110251 EUGENE Si STEPHANIE LEWIS 218 8 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110031 GUILLERMO OBLIGADO 2188 CORTE ARBOLES CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110117 ERNEST Si DANA HAUSER 2188 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110029 SIDNEY Si ELSIE SCHULMAN 2189 CORTE ARBOLES CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110113 PETER Sc SUSAN GUST 218 9 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110189 SEAN M KABO 2189 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110182 DAN MCGREGOR 2190 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110129 IAN HEIDT 2190 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110105 PEDRO BENUR BOHRER 2190 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110451 KHUSHROW P Sc HILLA K MA 2191 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110187 RONALD Sc MICHELLE CAPPS 2191 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110101 ROBERT Sc JEAN MAXWELL 2191 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110252 MELVIN Sc BRENDA BROWN 2192 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110030 CHRISTOPHER ATHERTON 2192 CORTE ARBOLES CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110116 KELLY Si ANDREA REVELL 2192 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110114 SOTERO Si ESPERANZA FRANCHI-AL 2193 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110250 WILLIAM A Sc JULIE R FLETCHER 2193 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110104 CHARLES E GOLDEN 2194 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110450 JOSEPH A DE SANTIS 2195 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110186 GLORIA HO 2195 CAMINO ROBELDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110102 TIMOTHY Sc KAREN COOK 2195 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110253 MARK D Sc WILLOW H lATAROLA 2196 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etlnuette rie format 25 mm x 67 mm nnmnatihifi aven Avfirv ®R160/8160 091-8/09I-S® Ajafitf oaftE ajqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiuj gg JBUIJOJ ap awanbii^ l/mk, AJ8AV qilM aiqiiBduioo ..8/9 2 x „j 8Z|S jaqei 0918/1 88030 2 00000000411-4110135 MICHAEL GELLER 2165 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110195 CHRISTOPHER DANIEL LEGERE 2165 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110204 SHARON A JAYNES 2166 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110457 ANTHONY Si PATRICIA JORDAN 2167 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110170 MARK D Si JENNIFER LEE STACKLE 2168 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110134 CLAY BOWLAND 2169 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD, CA 92029 88030 2 00000000411-4110194 CHENG Sc CHEN-CHEN LIN 2169 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110205 DAVID NEIL VIEREGG 217 0 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110456 KEVIN Sc CAROLYN SCARSKI 2171 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110133 SUZANNE LEHMER 2173 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110206 ROBERT MEADE 2174 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110455 ERIC Sc MEGAN AARNAES 2175 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110172 THOMAS Si AVA EIDENSCHINK 2176 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110025 STEPHEN CILURZO 2176 CORTE ARBOLES CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110120 WILLIAM ZONDLER 217 6 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110132 JOSH JENKINS-ROBBINS 2177 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110026 SHERIF Sc RANIA ABDALLA 217 7 CORTE ARBOLES CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110192 DAVID Si VANESSA FORSYTHE 2177 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110108 THOMAS MOSES 2178 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110207 BRADLEY Sc CYNTHIA LARSEN 2178 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110454 WESLEY Sc CATHRINE NICHOLS 2179 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110119 EAMON GALLAGHER Sc MONICA LEWI 2180 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110027 JOHN RYAN KIMMEL 2181 CORTE ARBOLES CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110111 CELINE POWER 2181 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110191 TSUONG CHEN Si CHRISTINA LEE 2181 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110107 MICHELLE TEMPLIN 2182 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110208 RODNEY Sc PAMELA KEILLOR 2182 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110453 T TIEN Sc T CHU Sc C CHANG 2183 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110099 WANDERLEY DIEHL 2183 CORTE MANGO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110118 KURT P. WATSON AND 2184 CORTE LIMON CARLSBAD, CA 920 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiniifittfi rifi fnrmat 25 mm x 67 mm nnmnatihifi avnn Avfirv ®R1Rn/R1Rn 0918/091-9® /^Mf 03AB aiqiiBduioD uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUJJOJ ap aHanbii^^ 0918/^Pb AJBAV qn* aiqiiBduioo ,.8/9 2 x „ 1 az|s |8qE| 88030 2 00000000411-4110153 GRETCHEN B HILL 2141 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110004 MEHRDAD G Sc AKRAM BARHAGHI 2145 CORTE CIDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110152 SEAN M DONAHUE 2145 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110154 MICHAEL RICHARDS 2146 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110164 CHAD PAGNI 2147 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110165 HARRIS Si KAREN HAUPTMAN 2148 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110139 CYNTHIA M MCCLURE 2149 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110151 MICHAEL DALZELL 2149 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD, CA 920 0 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110199 JOHN Sc ANNE BURNS 2149 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110003 DEREK G FRITTS 2150 CORTE CIDRO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110155 HERMAN Sc TAMMY SOTOMAYER 2150 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD, CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110200 ANN LABE 2150 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110163 MICHAEL Sc DEBRA CALIGIURI 2151 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110166 RONALDO Sc RICHETTE ESPIRITU 2152 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110150 GARY D SAGUNSKY 2153 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110198 MYRON VAYNSHTEYN 2153 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110002 GREG Sc REGINA HESTER 2154 CORTE CIDRO CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110156 RONALD WHITEHEAD 2154 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110162 DAVID HARRIMAN Si BARBARA BELL 2155 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110167 RICHARD DOZBABA 2156 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110137 BRYAN M Si PEGGY K MATSUYOSHI 2157 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110197 KEVIN WALTER COLLINS 2157 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110001 AZADEH KARIMI 2158 CORTE CIDRO CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110157 DANIEL Si FLORENCE TULLIO 2158 CORTE MORAL CARLSBAD, CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110202 MASOUD SHAHRI 2158 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110168 CHRISTOPHER Si CANDIS MORELLO 2160 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD, CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110136 SCOTT SCHWARTE 2161 CORTE ACEBO CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110196 JOE DEE TIPTON JR 2161 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110203 KEISUKE Sc MICHIKO YAGI 2162 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD, CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110169 BENNETT G Sc MARIAN A SINGER 2164 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 92009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 091-8/0915® AJ^OOAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui 92 IBUIJOJ ap ajianbn^^ 0918/fl|) AJ8AV qi|M aiqiiBduioo „8/9 Z x ..J az|S jaqB| 88030 2 00000000411-4111077 88030 2 00000000411-4111090 88030 2 00000000411-4111083 AHMAD SHAMSHIRIAN BRIAN Sc CAROL LYLE JAY Sc MARITA COPLAN 1029 W RIVERSIDE WAY 155 PHOEBE ST C/O SPEEDPRESS SAN JOSE CA 95129 ENCINITAS CA 92024 2270 CAMINO VIDA ROBLE #H CARLSBAD CA 92 009 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 09t8/091S® 09 ta Aj^oaAB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap ananbn^^ '^k) f^ms} mm aiqiiBduioo „8/9 g x „ t azts laqei 88030 2 00000000411-4110797 DENNIS F Sc REINA ROBERTS 50375 VISTA MONTANA LA QUINTA CA 92253 88030 2 00000000411-4110594 LONG VALLEY, LLC C/O DANIEL GETZINGER 674 VIA DE LA VALLE STE 2 02 SOLANA BEACH CA 92 075 88030 2 00000000411-4110600 ALI Sc FATEMEH SAMI I 1947 CAMINO VIDA ROBLE STE 10 CARLSBAD CA 92 008 88030 2 00000000411-4110596 CALEB WILLIS NANCY WILLIS 2719 LOKER VIEW AVE W CARLSBAD CA 92010 88030 2 00000000411-4110143 NEAL Si JENNIFER MCPARLANE 7668 EL CAMINO REAL CARLSBAD,CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110739 DRAGAN D NEBRIGIC MICHELLE A NEBRIGIC 2331 GAMAY COMMON LIVERMORE CA 94 55 0 88030 2 00000000411-4110864 PAIGE LEPINSKI 1212 LAURENT ST SANTA CRUZ CA 95060 88030 2 00000000411-4110862 ANDREW M Si LARA HEILMAN 1260 TROPICAL AVE PASADENA CA 91107 88030 2 00000000411-4110755 ROBERT Sc TRACIE KULAKOWSK PO BOX 471 RANCHO SANTA FE CA 92 067 88030 2 00000000411-4110861 FRANK Sc ROSE MOSER PO BOX 231475 ENCINITAS CA 92023 88030 2 00000000411-4110749 MARION DAVIS PO BOX 130442 CARLSBAD CA 92 013 88030 2 00000000411-4110661 CHRISTOPHER Sc BRIDGET GATE P.O. BOX 130445 CARLSBAD CA 92 013 88030 2 00000000411-4110007 ALI Sc MELINDA POURTASH 7211 COZYCROFT AVE #43 WINNETKA CA 913 06 88030 2 00000000411-4110750 DANIEL C Sc STACEY F WRIGHT 792 9 SITIO ABRIDOR CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110765 HELMUT ALEXANDER TOROK MARY ANN Sc CHRISTINE L TOROK 764 3 FORRESTAL RD SAN DIEGO CA 9212 0 88030 2 00000000411-4110089 KHOSRO KHATIBI Si MITRA RAHMAN 2605 LA GRAN VIA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110019 CHAD Sc MIYONA PAGNI 2147 AVENIDA TORONJA CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110881 VIKRAM YASHPAL BOX 02353407 SIOUX FALLS ID 57186 88030 2 00000000411-4110885 SEAN J O'LEARY REGINA BRIDGET O'LEARY 7947 SITIO SOLANA CARLSBAD CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110035 MIKE WANG Sc NANCY LIU C/O THE RENTAL XPERTS 533 SECOND ST # 110 ENCINITAS CA 92024 88030 2 00000000411-4111026 NAOMI L Si OCTAVIO F DELGADO P.O. BOX 230548 ENCINITAS CA 92 023 88030 2 00000000411-4110044 MICHAEL WINTERS 13644 BOQUITA DR DEL MAR CA 92014 88030 2 00000000411-4110042 SHANA SILVERMAN OSBORN TRUSTE 2267 CAMINO ROBLEDO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4111036 MATRUBtJTHAM/ THIAGARAJAN C/O CHAMBERLAIN PROP MGMT 2 653 ROOSEVELT ST #D CARLSBAD CA 92008 88030 2 00000000411-4111095 EDWARD ATTIX Si VALERIE CASKEY 7964 SITIO FRESCANO CARLSBAD CA 920 09 88030 2 00000000411-4111019 BRERETON Sc SANDRA BISSELL LINDA BELL 13715 POWAY RD #A POWAY CA 92064 88030 2 00000000411-4110948 ROBERT H BAKER, LLC A CALIFORNIA LLC 591 CAMINO DE LA REINA #1100 SAN DIEGO, CA 92108 88030 2 00000000411-4110910 JIM M Sc SANDRA J SAMUELS 182 NEPTUNE AVE ENCINITAS CA 92 024 88030 2 00000000411-4111007 DEBORAH LONDON 29324 QUAILWOOD DR. RAN PALOS VERDES CA 90275 88030 2 00000000411-4110918 MATTHEW Si KRISTIE GRISAFE 6928 SANDPIPER PLACE CARLSBAD CA 920 09 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 0918/09ig®AJi 0918/1 \j^o 08A6 aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap ajianbn^ AiBAV mm aiqiJBduioo ,,8/g 2 x „|. 8Z|S jaqEj 88030 2 00000000411-4110667 ROGER L Sc JONNA DE LEON 1699A STEVENS PL LOS ALTOS CA 94024 88030 2 00000000411-4110547 JOHN OHARA Sc ANGELA LOCKHART 2 855 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD, CA 92009 88030 2 00000000411-4110676 JAMES R Sc MARIA D BARBIER 1218 YORK DR VISTA CA 92 084 88030 2 00000000411-4110495 DAVID Sc SUZANNE RICCI 7396 SITIO LIMA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110501 GREGORY JASENOVEC TTEE JASENOVEC FAM TRST DTD 8/15/1 10531 4S COMMONS DR #459 SAN DIEGO CA 9212 7 88030 2 00000000411-4110682 JAMES Si JOANN STRICKLIN CO-TT STRICKLIN FAMILY TRUST 1415 STRAFFORD CT DEL MAR CA 92 014 88030 2 00000000411-4110568 OWB REO LLC ONE WEST BANK NA 888 E WALNUT ST PASADENA CA 91101 88030 2 00000000411-4110569 DAVID Sc JULIA ROMAINE BOX 01976261 SIOUX FALLS, SD 57186 88030 2 00000000411-4110696 DAVID N Si TINA M VIEREGG 2170 VISTA LA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110700 MICHAEL B Sc KERRY C KLE IMAN PO BOX 6789 LONGMONT CO 8 0501 88030 2 00000000411-4110585 SIEU TRUONG Si DAVID CHENG 1709 ARYANA DR ENCINITAS CA 92 024 88030 2 00000000411-4110894 TOMMIE CHANG 4751 TOWPATH LANE SYLVANIA OH 43 560 88030 2 00000000411-4110907 VINCENT Sc PATRICIA HWANG 24 781 CLARINGTON DR LAGUNA HILLS CA 92653 88030 2 00000000411-4110958 IRFAN GHAFOOR Sc MtJNAZZA IRFAN 910 ORANGEWOOD DR BREA CA 92 821 88030 2 00000000411-4110903 MARK Sc DIANA COOPER 243 N HWY 101 STE 22 SOLANA BEACH CA 92 075 88030 2 00000000411-4110875 JAMES PATTERSON 72 98 CALLE CONIFERA CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110296 MICHAEL FOGLER 2 92 3 CAMINO SERBAL N CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110299 MIKE Sc GLORIA ALASANTRO 1723 SOMERSET AVE CARDIFF CA 92 0 07 88030 2 00000000411-4110174 TIRANDAZ GOSHTASBI 12241 RANCH HOUSE ROAD SAN DIEGO CA 92128 88030 2 00000000411-4110159 BLAIR A NICHOLAS C/O BLUE DIAMOND RENTALS 7704 CAMINITO LEON #101 CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110536 MICHAEL Sc LESLIE KNYSH PO BOX 231003 ENCINITAS CA 92 023 88030 2 00000000411-4110535 MICHAEL Si LESLIE KNYSH PO BOX 231003 ENCINITAS CA 92023 88030 2 00000000411-4110395 GARY LEE BROWN JR JACQUELYN ELIZABETH BROWN 525 S DITMAR ST OCEANSIDE CA 92 054 88030 2 00000000411-4110383 WILLIAM Si CHRIS BRAUN 22038 E RIDGE TRAIL DR AtJRORA CO 80016 88030 2 00000000411-4110462 MYRON Sc LYDIA VAYNSHTEYN 2153 VISTA NISA CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110409 BO PI Si TZER-WEI CHOU 13557 OLD EL CAMINO REAL SAN DIEGO, CA 92130 88030 2 00000000411-4110464 KEVIN GADDY 112 8 HAMPTON COURT ENCINITAS CA 92 024 88030 2 00000000411-4110847 GARY Si BETSY ENDRES C/O STIFEL NICOLAUS 5780 FLEET ST STE 250 CARLSBAMIA. 92008 88030 2 00000000411-4110799 ROBERT Sc NANCY MCALLISTER PO BOX 785 SOLANA BEACH CA 92 075 88030 2 00000000411-4110806 DANIEL Sc MARY MORILAK PO BOX 702 8 RANCHO SANTA FE CA 92 0 67 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Aven/ ®5160/8160 0918/0919® AJJAV 09AB aiqiiBduioo uiui Z9 x uiui gg IBUIJOJ ap auanbu^^ 09 l-8^k> AiaAV mm aiqiiBduioo ,,8/9 g x., j. 8Z|S laqej XXXXX 00000000411-411RV99 FAIRWAYS HOMEOWNERS ASOC. CtJRTIS MGMT/PHIL GLORIOSO 5050 AVENIDA ENCINAS STE 160 CARLSBAD CA 92 0 08 88030 2 00000000411-4110138 DAVID SIMPSON 3436 FEDERAL AVE LOS ANGELES CA 90066 88030 2 00000000411-4110201 ROBERT Sc PAMELA REGNERY 3372 CALLE MARGARITA ENCINITAS CA 92 024 88030 2 00000000411-4110161 THOMAS ACUNA TTEE STELLA ACUNA TTEE 34 6 VIA LINDA DEL SUR ENCINITAS CA 92024 88030 2 00000000411-4110171 RENE Sc VIRGINIE RAFFRAY 3754 SHASTA ST APT E SAN DIEGO CA 92109 88030 2 00000000411-4110193 TOM ROBBINS MEGAN ROBBINS 5580 LA JOLLA BLVD #446 LA JOLLA CA 92 037 88030 2 00000000411-4110131 KEVIN L EVARTS GINA L EVARTS 6612 SITIO SAGO CARLSBAD CA 92 011 88030 2 00000000411-4110180 GIUSEPPE DESTITO MELISSA CALLAHAN 1827 PARLIAMENT RD ENCINITAS CA 92024 88030 2 00000000411-4110181 JOSEPH Sc ELISE QUINN 7835 SE 73RD PL MERCER ISLAND WA 98 04 0 88030 2 00000000411-4110452 THOMAS Sc PAULETTE MORENO 165-16 CHAPIN PKY JAMAICA NY 11432 88030 2 00000000411-4110128 ANDREW O'BOYLE C/O D ADLARD - PROPERTY MGR 6994 EL CAMINO REAL #209 CARLSBAD CA 92 00 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110210 BRUNO F PAUL FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST PO BOX 181487 NISA CORONADO CA 92118 88030 2 00000000411-4110212 JOHN Sc JEANNE CHANG PO BOX 131342 CARLSBAD CA 92013 88030 2 00000000411-4110282 MARCUS Si DOUGLAS CHANG 7105 ALICANTE RD CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110264 THOMAS Sc SUSAN BROWN 1805 ALTAMIRA PL SAN DIEGO CA 92103 88030 2 00000000411-4110272 IVAN Si FIONA STRASHOON 3830 VALLEY CTR DR #705-225 SAN DIEGO CA 92130 88030 2 00000000411-4110290 JAMES Sc RISA LAUTH 2982 CAMINO SERBAL CARLSBAD CA 9200 9 88030 2 00000000411-4110224 KAREN BtJRROWS 7 932 GRADO EL TUPELO CARLSBAD CA 92 0 09 88030 2 00000000411-4110356 IVAN Sc FIONA STRASHOON 3830 VALLEY CTR DR #705-225 SAN DIEGO CA 9213 0 88030 2 00000000411-4110353 IVAN Sc FIONA STRASHOON 3830 VALLEY CTR DR #705-225 SAN DIEGO CA 92130 88030 2 00000000411-4110350 RUI-FANG SHI Si HONG YAO 19842 PORTAL PLAZA CUPERTINO CA 95014 88030 2 00000000411-4110348 EMILIE MANLEY 484 E CARMEL DR # 167 CARMEL IN 46032 88030 2 00000000411-4110308 PAUL PULLIN MONICA H PULLIN 4 607 HINCHINGHAM LN LOTHIAN MD 20711 88030 2 00000000411-4110431 SALVATORE Si DORIE GALLUCCI 7353 CORTE TOMILLO CARLSBAD CA 92 009 88030 2 00000000411-4110313 MARA I WEINBERG 350 IITH AVENUE tJNIT 23 0 SAN DIEGO CA 92101 88030 2 00000000411-4110426 MELVIN EUGENE TAUNT JUDITH LOUISE TAtJNT PO BOX 122 0 PINEDALE AZ 85934 88030 2 00000000411-4110339 RANCHO CARLTON PROPERTIES, LL 692 9 N HAYDEN STE C4 PMB 626 SCOTTSDALE AZ 85250 88030 2 00000000411-4110416 THEODORE/SANDRA H GOETZ, TTEE SANDRA H GOETZ 1106 2ND ST #640 ENCINITAS _CA 92 024 88030 2 00000000411-4110328 ANNIE YEO PO BOX 130002 CARLSBAD CA 92 013 88030 2 00000000411-4111063 MATTHEW HEINDEL 29749 MELLOW WIND FAIR OAKS RANCH TX 78 015 label size 1" x 2 5/8" compatible with Avery ®5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery ®5160/8160 Carlsbad May 11, 2015 Professional Community Management Attn: Valerie Gullickson 5950 La Place Ct., Ste. 250 Carlsbad, CA 92008 SUBJECT: MP 88-01(A) - ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN The City Planner has completed a review of your application for a Minor Master Plan Amendment MP 88'01(A), to allow for an eight foot tall tube steel entry gate and a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire surrounding the recreational vehicle storage lot and to change the production view fence by replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts. A notice was sent to property owners within the La Costa Valley Master Association requesting comments regarding the above request. Comments were received and a request for an Administrative Hearing was filed. On April 27, 2015, the City Planner held an Administrative Hearing to consider said request. Public testimony was given. After careful consideration ofthe evidence presented at the Administrative Hearing, the City Planner has determined that the findings required for granting a Minor Master Plan Amendment can be made and therefore, APPROVES this request based on the following findings and conditions. Findings: 1. The City Planner finds that the project, as conditioned herein, is in conformance with the Elements of the City's General Plan in that the proposed chain link fence topped with barbed wire will assist in providing better security and safety of the recreational vehicle storage lot by minimizing the damage to property resulting from crime consistent with Crime Hazards Goal "A" of the Public Safety Element. Additionally, the existing recreational vehicle storage lot is consistent with the Open Space (OS) General Plan designation. 2. That the residential and open space portions of the community will constitute an environment of sustained desirability and stability, and that it will be in harmony with or provide compatible variety to the character of the surrounding area, and that the sites proposed for public facilities, such as schools, playgrounds and parks are adequate to serve the anticipated population and appear acceptable to the public authorities having jurisdiction thereof, in that views of the recreational vehicle storage lot and surrounding fence with barbed wire are minimal. The character of the area will not be compromised as there is existing RV fencing and existing transmission poles, wires, and utilities within the SDG&E easement. Furthermore, the proposed chain link fence with barbed wire is similar to fences that are in use at other recreational vehicle storage areas in master planned communities. 3. That the proposed Minor Master Plan Amendment strengthens the unity and vitality of the community's design in that the recreational vehicle storage lot and surrounding fence is located in an isolated area within the community that is only visible to a few homes that are adjacent to the SDG&E transmission easement. The fencing material is light in color, is minimally visible and consists of the least possible structure to serve the intended purpose as compared to other alternative designs. Community & Economic Development Planning Division 11635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbacl, CA 92008-7314 j 760-602-4660 j 760-602-8560 f | www.carlsbadca.gov ^me^ IB., 2Cff5 ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN ,2ci5 Page 2 4. Landscape screening was considered but because of the location of the SDG&E easement, landscaping was not required. Additionally, landscaping would block visibility of the site negatively impacting the security of the recreational vehicle storage lot. 5. Extending the height of the wrought iron fence and topping it with iron spikes was considered as an alternative but rejected as having a higher level of visibility due to the size and color of the material. 6. That the project qualifies as a Minor Master Plan Amendment in that the project includes proposed changes to design features identified in Chapter IV, Community Development Standards, of the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. 7. That the City Planner has determined that the project is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per Section 15303 (New Construction of Small Structures) of the State CEQA Guidelines and will not have any adverse significant impact on the environment. This decision may be appealed by you or any member of the public to the Planning Commission within ten (10) days of receipt of this letter. Appeals must be submitted in writing to the Planning Commission at 1635 Faraday Avenue in Carlsbad, along with a payment of $661.00. The filing of such appeal within such time limit shall stay the effective date of the order of the City Planner until such time as a final decision on the appeal is reached. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact Austin Silva at (760) 602-4631. Sincerely, DON NEU, AlCP City Planner DN:AS:bd c: Steve Cilurzo, 2176 Corte Arboles, Carlsbad CA 92009 Patrick Foley, 2246 Vista La Nisa, Carlsbad CA 92009 Thomas Krynicki, 7950 Sitio Nispero, Carlsbad CA 92009 Interested Parties List (via email) Van Lynch Michele Masterson, Senior Management Analyst Data Entry DMS File Copy Date 3'^("15^ ^'ty of Carlsbad City Of Carlsbad Planning Division ^ ^ ^^^^ 1635 Faraday Ave. Planning Division Carlsbad, CA 92008 I am opposed to Case MP 149V, ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN. I object to this proposed Master Plan Amendnnent, because it's not aesthetically pleasing or in harmony with our community. I hereby request an administrative hearing. SincereiN City of Carlsbad Date MAR 2 5 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 I am opposed to Case MP 149V, ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN. I object to this proposed Master Plan Amendment, because it's not aesthetically pleasing or in harmony with our community. I hereby request an administrative hearing. Sincerely, City of Carlsbad Date S^A)A )A. MAR 2 3 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Planning Division Carlsbad, CA 92008 I am opposed to Case MP 149V, ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN. I object to this proposed Master Plan Amendment, because it's not aesthetically pleasing or in harmonv with our community. I hereby request an administrative hearing. Sincerely Date City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 I am opposed to Case MP 149V, ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN. I object to this proposed Master Plan Amendment, because it'.s not aesfrhetir^lly plea.sing or in harmonv with our communitv. I hereby request an administrative hearing. City of Carlsbad Sincerely, Jf'iH-V//^ i^^M MAR 2 3 2015 D rr^ / ^ Planning Division Your name Your address CJty of Carlsbad Date 7-2^-/^ MAR 23 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 I am opposed to Case MP 149V, ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN. I object to this proposed Master Plan Amendment, because it's not aesthetically pleasing or in harmony with our community. I hereby request an administrative hearing. Sincerely, City of Carlsbad MAR 2 3 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 3/17/15 Ref: Case # MP 149V We are writing In reference to the Anroyo La Costa Master Plan amendment request made by the La Costa Valley Home Owners Association (HOA). We are homeowners in La Costa Valley and are directly impacted by this amendment request. The La Costa Valley HOA is making the amendment request because they have installed a fence that is In violation of the Carlsbad Master Fence Plan. They took this action without a permit or approval from the City, without consulting the homeowners affected by it, and without using the process for such construction as outlined in our OCRs. This chain link and barb-wire fence is not consistent with the community aesthetic and, frankly, is well suited for a prison. I have asked a professional appraiser for an opinion on what this fence does to my property value and he said that it reduces the values of nearby homes from $5,000 to $10,000 because of the impact on the view from our backyards and in our houses. Further, this fence is visible from El Camino Real, Olivenhain Rd. and the nearby shopping centers. This is not acceptable. We chose to live in Carlsbad because of the beautiful neighborhoods. The La Costa Valley HOA does not have the authority to arbitrarily destroy property values within Carisbad. Many homeowners have been attending the HOA meetings to plead with the Board to provide a reasonable altemative and they have refused. We now must rely on the City to help us protect our property values. We request that the City deny the request for an amendment to Administrative Master Plan. We also request that an administrative hearing be held, if needed. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this monstrosity. ''^'AA A Mark and Michele Chaffee 7951 Paseo Aliso FEBRUARY 2014 CHRONOLOGY OF MUNICIPAL CODE VIOLATION (CASE: CE-14-1180) ILLEGAL 7FT HIGH CHAIN LINK FENCE TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE TRANSITION TO ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT MP149V La Costa Valley HOA approves and has installed a 7 ft. high chain link fence topped with barbed wire installed with without proper or prior notice to the adjacent residents in violation of the City's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. The residents in the area were outraged, the installation of the 7 ft. high chain link fence topped with barbed wire was installed without proper notification and they vehemently objected to it at numerous HOA board monthly meetings to no avail. As a result, a frustrated resident contacted Code Enforcement. SEPTEMBER 25,2014 NOVEMBER 6,2014 Code Enforcement issues a Notice of Violation citing section CMC18.04.015 - Building Permit Required: No building or structure regulated by this code shall be constructed unless a permit for each has been obtained. Not only is the 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire a violation of the municipal code it is also a flagrant violation of the fencing plan contained in the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. Principal Planner, Chris DeCerbo sent an email to the resident who initiated the complaint relating to the 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire. In the email he states the following: I met with Mr. Krynicki (President of the HOA) and Ms. Gullicksen (PCM Sr. Community Manager) on Monday, November 3, 2014 and informed them tiiat the HOA must apply for a Minor Master Flan Amendment (MPA), pursuant to Section 21.54.06(B) of the Carlsbad Municipal Code, to propose an alternative fence type that is currently allowed by the La Costa Valley Master Plan. They were provided with the application forms and indicated that they would first meet with the surrounding homeowners to attempt to achieve concurrence on a fence design prior to submitting the application. He goes on to state: As Mr. Rudinger (code enforcement officer), has responded, they are working toward a resolution to the issue and are committing to submit a Minor MPA application; therefore no citations will be assessed. A Minor MPA is an administrative permit that could allow the City Planner the discretion to approve an alternative type of fence. (Based on his previous statement in the email that would be an alternative fence type that is currently allowed by the La Costa Valley Master Plan.) ATTACHMENT 1 email from Principal Planner, Chris DeCerbo. DECEMBER 18, 2014 Since the HOA Board did not submit the application for a Minor MPA nor did the HOA board meet with the surrounding residents to achieve concurrence on an alternative fence design prior to submitting the Minor MPA, code enforcement on December 18, 2014 issued a Final Notice of Violation. Shortly After the Final Notice of Violation is issued by Code Enforcement, City Planner Don Nue informs code enforcement not to issue a citation. The City Planner allows the HOA board an additional 47 days, to submit the Minor MPA application to planning and the application is received by planning on February 3,2015. MARCH 17,2015 NOTICE OF REQUEST FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT IS ISSUED ON MARCH 17, 2015 The notice reads as follows: Notice is hereby given that an Administrative Master Plan Amendment (MP 149V) has been applied for to allow a change to the fencing plan that was approved as part of Arroyo La Costa Master Plan, which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire on property generally located east of El Camino Real and west of Paseo Aliso in Carlsbad. (ATTACHMENT 2 MARCH 17,2015 NOTICE) The Notice is misleading since the 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire has already been installed and it does not state in la3mian's terms where the exact location is for this installation. APRIL 7,2015 In light of the fact that the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan clearly states: " One of the most dominate visual elements for a community is its fencing. It is essential for this element to be AESTHETICALLY PLEASING and provide continuity in design to unify the various architectural styles within individual neighborhoods into a single community theme." One has to wonder why planning would even consider a 7 ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire for a minor master plan amendment that is such a gross travesty of the Master Plan's fencing plan which states fencing is to be ASETHETICALLY PLEASING. Residents of La Costa Valley made presentations to the City Council on the installation of an illegal 7 ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire in violation of the city's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. The illegal fence topped with barbed wire makes the residents feel as if they are in a prison camp walled in by a 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire. The meeting is covered by the local media news stations and City Planner Don Nue; emphatically states in front of the cameras that the issue of the 7ft chain link fence topped with barbed wire will not be mediated. The application for the administrative master plan amendment to allow a 7ft tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire will be considered at an administrative hearing to be schedule soon. (Attachment 3 - DVD of Local Media Coverage of the April 7*^^ meeting and discussion with Don Nue outside the council chambers). APRIL 13, 2015 NOTICE OF AN ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING SCHEDULED FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT IS SCHEDULED FOR APRIL 29, 2015 AT 5:30 PM AT 1635 FARADAYAVENUE The notice states: "An Administrative Master Plan Amendment (MP 149V) has been applied for to allow a change to the fencing plan that was approved as part of the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan, which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire that has already been constructed located east of El Camino Real and west of Paseo Aliso, generally known as the RV and Boat storage lot..." The purpose of the administrative hearing was clearly and specifically stated in the public notice issued on April 13, 2015 to allow a change to the fencing plan ...which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire that has already been constructed. ATTACHMENT 4 NOTICE OF AN ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING SCHEDULED FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT At the administrative hearing on April 29*' the proponents restated all the reasons for the amendment to allow the 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire that were contained in their application. The opponents stated all their reasons for opposing the 7ft tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire that had already been provided to planning in emails, phone calls and signed petitions adamantly opposing any amendment to the master plan that would allow a chain link fence topped with barbed wire. Neither the proponents nor the opponents expressed a desire for or wanted a comprise decision or mediation. The issue before the City Planner Don Nue, is either approve the proposed amendment to the Master Plan and allow a 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire or deny the proposed amendment to the master plan amendment and not allow the 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire. At the conclusion ofthe hearing those in attendance were told a decision will be made early next week and depending on the decision either side may appeal the City Planner's decision to the Planning Commission. APRIL 30, 2015 Patrick Foley received an email from Housing and Neighborhood Services Director, Debbie Fountain the day after the Administrative hearing on April 30th that states: " Thanks for your inquiry. Our office did check with the City Planner, Project Planner, and the Community and Economic Development Director. The RV gate is being considered as part of the same violation for the fence. The entire project is one; they are not being considered as separate issues. Therefore, we have included the gate as part of the original code complaint that was made on the fence itself If the City Planner determines that the fence and gate are not permitted and no variance is granted, we will continue in our code enforcement effort to have both (fence and gate) removed or modified within 14-21 days, depending on the direction from the City Planner. If an alternate decision is made, we will follow up from code enforcement as instructed by the City Planner and Community and Economic Development Director." How did the proposed Administrative Master Plan Amendment (MP 149V) which was the reason for an administrative hearing on April 29, 2015 to allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire go back to being a code enforcement issue? Proponents of the amendment and opponents of the amendment want the City Planner to make a decision on whether or not the 7ft tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire is approved or denied. NO one is asking for a variance and no one is asking planning to come up with any alternative decision. It is either Yes the proposed amendment is approved or NO the proposed amendment is not approved. The City Planner acting on his own volition has turned an egregious Municipal code violation that was being handled appropriately by code enforcement on December 18, 2015 into a convoluted calamity. Your prior City Manager, Steve Sarkozy stated in the press that " He and the city staff were not in complete alignment, which is why he is moving on." The installation of a 7ft high chain link fence topped with barbed wire is a flagrant violation of the municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan and should have been resolved long ago by code enforcement without any interference from the Planning Department. Your planning department is clearly not in alignment with the Housing and Neighborhood Services Department. Municipal code violations need to be handled in a judicious and timely manner and if necessary in a coordinate manner between departments not in a manner in which one department is clearly at odds with the other. Patrick Foley ATTACHMENT 1 From: Steve Cilurzo <cilurzo@att.net> Sent: Wednesday, April 1, 2015 10:53 AM To: Patrick Foley Subject: Fwd: CE14-1180 - La Costa Valley RV Lot Fence Begin forwarded message: From: Chris DeCerbo <Chris.DeCerbo@carisbadca.qov> Subject: RE: CE14-1180 - La Costa Vailey RV Lot Fence Date: November 6, 2014 8:10:26 AM PST To: Steve Cilurzo <cilurzo(S),att.net>. Sandra Arguelles <sarquelles(S),pcminternet.com>. "vgullicksen(5).pcminternet.com" <vgullicksen@pcminternet.com> Cc: Scott Rudinger <Scott.Rudinger(5).carlsbadca.gov>. Chris DeCerbo <Chrls.DeCerbo(a)carlsbadca.gov>. Don Neu <Don.Neu(S),carlsbadca.aov>. Gina Ruiz <Gina.Ruiz(g)carlsbadca.gov>, Glen Van Peski <Glen.VanPeski@carlsbadca.gov> Hi Mr. Cilurzo, I met with Mr. Krynicki and Ms. Gullicksen on Monday November 3, 2014 and informed them that the HOA must apply for a Minor Master Plan Amendment (MPA), pursuant to Section 21.54.060(B) ofthe Carlsbad Municipal Code, to propose an alternative fence type than is currently allowed by the La Costa Valley Master Plan. They were provided with application forms and indicated that they would first meet with the surrounding homeowners to attempt to achieve concurrence on a fence design prior to submitting the application. As Mr. Rudinger has responded, they are working toward a resolution to the issue and are committing to submit a Minor MPA application; therefore no citations will be assessed. A Minor MPA is an administrative permit that could allow the City Planner the discretion to approve an alternative type of fence. The Minor MPA procedure would require a 10 day public notice to property owners within a radius of the subject property. Please contact me if you have any questions regarding this. Thank You, Chris Ccityof Carlsbad ATTACHMENT 2 Ccityof Carlsbad NOTICE OF REQUEST FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT Notice is hereby given that an Administrative Master Plan Amendment has been applied for to allow a change to the fencing plan that was approved as part of Arroyo La Costa Master Plan^ which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wir^ dhd to change the production view fence by replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts on property generally located east of El Camino Real and west of Paseo Aliso in Carlsbad, California, and more particularly described as: Lot 124, of Carlsbad Tract No. 88-03-1, Arroyo La Costa, Unit 1, (Villages I), in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to map thereof no. 13385, filed in the office of the County Recorder of San Dlego County, December 20,1996. If you have any objections to the granting of this Master Plan Amendment or wish to have an administrative hearing to discuss the requested Master Plan Amendment, please notify the Planning Division, 1635 Faraday Avenue, Carlsbad, California 92008, in writing within 10 calendar days of the date of this notice, if you have any questions, please call Austin Silva in the Planning Division at (760) 602-4631. CASE NO.: MP 149V CASE NAME: ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PU\N DATE: March 17, 2015 CITY OF CARLSBAD PLANNING DIVISION Community & Economic Dwelopment Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue I Carlsbad, CA92008 I 760-602-4600 I 760-602-8560fax ATTACHMENT 4 CACity of Carlsbad NOTICE OF AN ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING SCHEDULED FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT An Administrative Master Plan Amendment (MP 149V) has been applied for to allow a change to the fencing plan that was approved as part ofthe Arroyo La Costa Master Plan, which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire that has already been constructed and to change the production view fence by replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts on property located east of El Camino Real and west of Paseo Aliso, generally known as the RV and Boat storage lot, and more particularly described as: Lot 124, of Carlsbad Tract No. 88-03-1, Arroyo La Costa, Unit 1, (Villages I), in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to map thereof no. 13385, filed in the office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, December 20,1996. Pursuant to Carlsbad Municipal Code Title 21, Section 21.54.060 B.2. An administrative hearing shall take place if a request to be heard is filed within ten (10) calendar days ofthe date ofthe notice. A request for an administrative hearing was submitted within 10 calendar days after the Notice of Request for an Administrative Master Plan Amendment was mailed out. This notice is hereby given to inform the requestor(s) and the applicant of the administrative hearing date, time and location ss noted below. Piease contact Austin Silva at 760-602-4631 or by email at austin.silv8fi>carisb8dca.gov if you have any questions. ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING SCHEDULE HEARING DATE: April 29, 2015 HEARING TiME: 5:30 P.M. HEARING LOCATION: 1635 Faraday Avenue, Room 173A, Carisbad, CA 92008 CASE NO.: MP 149V CASENAME: Arroyo La Costa Master Plan DATE NOTICE MAILED: April 13, 2015 CITYOFCARLSBAD PLANNING DIVISION Comn-jiinsty & Scfttiorr/in Davefc-pmsnt Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue I Carisbad, CA 92008 j 760-602-4600 I 760-602-8560 fax April 11, 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, California 92008 Subject: Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Reference: Case NO: MP 149V, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan My name is James Miller. My wife and I reside in Arroyo La Costa. We are unfortunately unable to attend the administrative hearing in person on the scheduled date. We object to the Amendment to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan that was proposed to allow an already constructed seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire. This change is not aesthetically consistent with the Master Plan for our neighborhood or the City of Carlsbad community. We are directly affected as this fence is visible from our home. It is directly behind our house and we see the fence from our bedrooms. Equally important, it is visible from public areas west of our community, including the highways and popular shopping areas. The fence makes our community look like a prison to these public areas. It is unappealing and not consistent with other community fencing. It also violates the governing Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. Although the HOA published meetings minutes generally describing a six foot fence. It was constructed without confirming notification of immediately affected residents or the community residents. The HOA requires residents to provide specific designs and description of additions and modifications to property within the Arroyo La Costa community for approval. This process requires signature of all adjacent and affected residents as part of the request process. That the HOA would not follow their own required process for fence additions and modifications is beyond comprehension. Several of my neighbors and I have attended multiple HOA meetings to address our concerns, but have not been satisfied. We do understand and appreciate the concern for RV lot security. We have suggested alternatives including; cameras, motions sensors. Increased patrols by existing HOA security and/or moving parts of the fence out of view of residents and neighboring public areas. Although the HOA indicates they considered such alternatives, our requests to see documentation of studies. quotes or evaluations have been rejected. It appears that the suggested alternatives were never seriously considered or carefully evaluated. The topping razor wire was removed, however the unsightly, prison-style fence is still visible to residents and the community. We request rejection of the proposed amendment to the master fence plan and immediate removal ofthe fence. Sincerely, m arid Catfiy Miller 7959 Paseo Aliso Ca/lsbad, Ca 92009 City of Carisbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carisbad, CA 92008 3/17/15 Ref: Case # MP 149V We are writing in reference to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan amendment request made by the La Costa Valley Home Owners Association (HOA). We are homeowners in La Costa Valley and are directly impacted by this amendment request. The La Costa Valley HOA is making the amendment request because they have installed a fence that is in violation of the Carisbad Master Fence Plan. They took this action without a permit or approval from the City, without consulting the homeowners affected by it, and without using the process for such construction as outlined in our CCRs. This chain link and barb-wire fence is not consistent with the community aesthetic and, frankly, is well suited for a prison. I have asked a professional appraiser for an opinion on what this fence does to my property value and he said that it reduces the values of nearby homes from $5,000 to $10,000 because of the impact on the view from our backyards and in our houses. Further, this fence is visible from El Camino Real, Olivenhain Rd. and the nearby shopping centers. This is not acceptable. We chose to live in Carisbad because of the beautiful neighborhoods. The La Costa Valley HOA does not have the authority to arbitrarily destroy property values within Carisbad. Many homeowners have been attending the HOA meetings to plead with the Board to provide a reasonable alternative and they have refused. We now must rely on the City to help us protect our property values. We request that the City deny the request for an amendment to Administrative Master Plan. We also request that an administrative hearing be held, if needed. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this monstrosity. Mark and Michele Chaffee 7951 Paseo Aliso We live adjacent to the fence next to the RV gate and can view it from both the upstairs and the downstairs rooms of our home - including the kitchen, dining room, family room, downstairs bedroom and, of course, from the backyard. Last year at this time we wanted to put our home on the market and had some very interested potential buyers come over for a showing. They were in the backyard looking at the pool and beautiful landscaping and spotted the ugly 9-foot tall - barbed wire - prison-style fence. The wife exclaimed "what is that...What is back there?" I could hear the alarm in her voice - what is so dangerous as to necessitate such a structure? What horrible thing must I worry about keeping my children away from? They did not make an offer. The fence has a negative financial impact on the value of my home and all homes in La Costa Valley. The irony is that it wasn't forced upon us by a utility or government entity - but by our own homeowners association who chose to build it. The very people we PAY to care for and beautify our neighborhood. The very people whose charter and mission is to PROTECT HOME VALUES - as reflected in the numerous policies and processes we homeowners must abide by. I ask - how can this association justify, in any way, the continued presence of this prison-style fence in beautiful La Costa Valley? 1 fear that many people are now looking at the fence from the Forum, from the Target Center, from El Camino Real and asking "What is that - what is behind that fence?" It is blight on our neighborhood and our city, it doesn't have it be there - it has to come down. Michele Chaffee 7951 Paseo Aliso Statement From Gary Ng 4-27-15 Administrative Hearing MP 149V To the Carlsbad Planning Department: One of the things that first attracted me to Carlsbad was the attention to detail when it came to planning and enforcing the architectural elements of our city. I moved here from East County where the planning was not so strict and watched my neighborhood deteriorate as decisions were made that were not in the best interest of the community. As a resident on Paseo Allso whose home buts up the the open area, I was dismayed and disappointed to see the chain link fence topped with barbed wire installed. Was this the same community that required me to turn in a plan for every shrub I planted in my front yard? By now you have seen the fence and have heard the comparisons to a prison yard and I echo these sentiments. The fence is an eyesore and needs to be removed. I openly admit that I was not at the HOA meetings where it was "approved" but I wonder how many residents who are negatively Impacted would have voted for it had we been notified. Surely It would have been in everyones best interest to openly disclose the plans to those who live on the street prior to its installation. Is it fair that the aesthetics of our neighborhood are sacrificed to keep the owners of the RVs, none who appear to live on our street, happy? Thank you for your time and I hope you agree that there is a better solution than lining this area with a barbed wired fence. Gary and Jamie Ng 7931 Paseo Aliso March 24, 2014 City Of Carlsbad City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. MAR 2 7 2015 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Planning Division Subject: Artoyo La Costa Master Plan Reference: Case Number MP 149V, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan We reside in Arroyo La Costa and oppose the proposed amendment to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan that would allow for a chain link fence surrounding the RV lot with or without barbed wire / concertina wire for the foUovying reasons: 1) This is not in keeping vyith the current CC&R's for very good reason. It is not esthetically pleasing and is not in keeping vyith the surrounding community. Where in any community would it be OK to have a seven foot high fence topped with barbed wire? 2) It serves no useful purpose. The current structure / gating is such that any person of reasonable physical capability can use the existing gate structure to enter the lot with very little effort. 3) Changing CC&R's after the fact is bad policy given one and two above. 4) The association without regard for its own mles regarding sign ofPs, made what any reasonable person can conclude is a major change vyithout getting sign offs. 5) There are other methodologies that could be employed to keep the RV lot secured (like having a gate that is lockable, and not easy to climb over). 6) There are many altematives to this type of fence, and the location. a. The fence could be moved down the bank, hiding it from view b. The existing rod iron fence could have been made taller, vyith an electronic sensing vyire. I hereby ask that the request to amend the CC&R's be refused, and or an administrative hearing be scheduled. Sinp^rely, . "--^^ / / Frank & Jeimifer Merchat 7980 Grado El Tupelo Carlsbad, CA. 92009 Phone 760-635-3497 March 24, 2015 City Of Carlsbad MAR 2 7 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Planning Division Carisbad, CA 92008 We are opposed to Case MP 149V, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. We object to this proposed Master Plan Amendment because it's diminishing the living experiences of current homeowners and their future home appreciation. It also negatively impacts neighborhood aesthetics and perceived property value for other La Costa homeowners. I request an administrative hearing regarding this matter. Sincerely, William "Liam" and Clyfi^tine Dunfey 7993 Via Hoja Carisbad, CA 92009 City of Carlsbad WAR 2 7 Planning Division March 24, 2014 City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 Subject: Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Reference: Case Number MP 149V, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan We reside in Arroyo La Costa and oppose the proposed amendment to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan that would allow the already constructed seven tall chain link fence, located directly behind our home, with barbed wire to remain. The fence is not aesthetically pleasing or in harmony with our community. I hereby request an administrative hearing. Sincerely, ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN ^ „. , /i^*:"'^'. ... ^ ^ ' /' Chris and Annie Fritz 7955 Paseo Aliso Carlsbad, CA 92009 w pLMi;m(- OBpr Patrick Foley From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Patrick Foley Tuesday, March 31, 2015 10:31 AM Vgullicksen@pcminternet.com' FW: City of Carlsbad Code Enforcement Case CE-14-1180 memo to President and Board Members of the La Cos CE-14-1180.pdf HOA.doc; Case Notes From: Patrick Foley <pfolev845(aigmail.com> Subject: City of Carlsbad Code Enforcement Case CE-14-1180 Date: March 30,2015 at 9:00:30 PM PDT To: vgullicksen@pcmintemet.com Valerie: I am formally requesting that the attached documents: Memo to the President and Board Members dated April 8, 2015 and the City of Carlsbad, Code Enforcement Case: CE-14-1180 Case Notes be included on the Board's April 8,2015 Agenda for discussion and action to remove the barbed vyire and lower the chain link fence to the 6 foot height limit in compliance with the City's municipal code. I will not be attending the April 8th board meeting. I and many other residents will be attending the administrative hearing on the proposed administrative master plan amendment when it is scheduled by the planning dept. If you have any questions conceming my formal request to have the code enforcement case CE-14-1180 and the attached documents placed on the Board's April 8,2015 agenda, you can express your concems in an email to me at: pfolev845(a)gmail.com Patrick Foley 2246 Vista La Nisa Memo TO: President and Board Members of the La Costa Valley HOA FROM: Patrick Foley, 2246 Vista La Nis£ DATE: April 8, 2015 Subject: City of Carlsbad Code Enforcement Case: CE-14-1180 The reckless act of the HOA board to approve and have installed a 7 foot high chain linked fence topped with barbed wire is an egregious violation of the City's municipal code. As a result of your action, the president of the board was issued a Notice of Violation by registered mail on September 25, 2014 by the City of Carlsbad's code enforcement officer. In response, the board on October 21, 2014 sent an email to the Code Enforcement officer stating that the board will lower the fence to the 6 foot height limit. The HOA board failed to act and wantonly continued to violate the City's municipal code. In light of this continued violation, the code enforcement officer issued a Final Notice of Violation to the president of the board on December 18, 2014 by registered mail. As symptomatic ofan irresponsible board, on January 20, 2015 the City of Carlsbad received the Final Notice of Violation back in the mail as UNCLAIMED. (See attached Code Enforcement Case CE-14-1180, case notes). The blatant and willful ongoing violation of the Carlsbad Municipal Code by the board exposes the HOA and the residents of La Costa Valley to indefensible liability claims that could result in the millions of dollars if anyone is seriously injured by the barbed wire. The sole purpose of barbed wire is to inflict bodily harm to anyone it ensnares. This irresponsible act by the board clearly demonstrates its inability to comprehend the seriousness of intentionally violating the City's municipal code and the consequences that could result. A personal injury lawsuit usually results when the injury is the result of negligence. I would not want to be in the place of a board member on the witness stand being aggressively interrogated by a wily and seasoned personal injury litigator in full view of a jury. The unjustifiable action of the board in violation of the City's municipal code reflects poorly on the professionalism of the PCM staff for their failure to advise the board that installing a 7 foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire is a flagrant violation of the City's municipal code and will expose the HOA and residents of La Costa Valley to the potential of duly filed legal claims of liability. If the president and board members believe that the proposed administrative master plan amendment and subsequent administrative hearing to amend the Arroyo La Costa Mater plan, to legitimize the egregious violation of the City's municipal code, is going to be approved, you are delusional. The board is going to face a firestorm of vehement opposition to this proposed amendment fi"om La Costa Valley residents who don't live anywhere near the barbed wire installation. They are appalled at board's wanton disregard for the Carlsbad municipal code and the board's distain for the City's (2) Notices of Violation. They are adamantly opposed to any amendment that would allow the installation of a 7 foot high chain linked fence topped with barbed wire anywhere in the La Costa Valley Master Planned Community. At the April 8, 2015 Board meeting, the president and board members will have the opportunity to take the necessary action to demonstrate your integrity by honoring your commitment to the City's Code Enforcement Officer made in your October 21, 2014 email and remove the barbed wire and lower the chain link fence to the 6 foot high limit. Remember that the board represents all the residents of the Master Planned Community of La Costa Valley and not just the limited number of residents who park their recreational vehicles in the RV lot. Attachment: Code Enforcement Case: 14-1180 Cc: Carlsbad City Planner Don Nue Deputy City Clerk Sherry Freisinger, public records Scott Rudinger, Carlsbad Code Enforcement Officer Print Code Enforcement Case Page 1 of3 Code Enforcement Case: CE-14-1180 Entered on: 09/15/2014 4:33 PM Printedon: 03/25/2015 Topic: 2k»ning Due Date: 03/26/15 Initiated by: Neighbor Hearing Date: Status: Open Assigned To: Scott Rudinger Area#: (Select) Hearing Time: Permit Permit #: Business name: License #: Property Location Occupant Name: LA COSTA VALLEY MASTER HOA Address: 5950 LA PLACE CT. # 250, 92008 Phone: APN : 255-251-50-00 Cell #: Owner Information Owner Name: KRYNICKI, THOMAS ILCA. PRESIDENT Address: 5950 LA PLACE CT. CARLSBAD, CA 92008 Phone: Cell #: Actions Action Compiaint Case Notes inspection Phone Call ~ Courtesy Noffce Inspection Case Notes Caie Notes inspection Phone Call Inspection Case Notes Case Notes Patti CrescentI Date Time Note/Observalion Patti CrescentI "Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott ' Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger ScSt Rudinger ~ Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger 09/15/2014 4:33 pm THEY HAVE ERECTED A CHAIN UNK FENCE OVER 6 FEET HIGH AROUND THE R.V. PARK AT LA COSTA VALLEY MASTER HOA. YOU CAN CALL COMPLAINANT TO GET ACCESS. HE _ _ LIVES NEXT DOOR. _ 09/22/2014 2:28 pm RECEIVED A LETTER FHOM^^^^^^H SEE BELOW. 09/24/2014 ¥9/25/2014' "oa'25A2014~ iO/6l/2014 10/03/2014 10/08/2014 fd/09/2014 10/16/2014 10/17^014 Site visit.. Complaint is valid... But 1 don't see why the containing party would have any concems... 7 foot fenoe with Bathed wire on lop js suiTOuncHng the RV lot ....•I will conlact complaining party, Phone call to CP brielsd on findings... He does waril me to have the H .O.A. tower the fence to 6 foot maximum... I will send H.O.A. a . notice gf violafion. _ Send to (dwner.Propsrty Location) V.M from H.O. A. secratury (Sandra) requesting a call back to discuss N O.v.... I left her a retum message..., _ Phone call to H.O. A receptionist (Sandra) Brief on my iiotfce of violation... She wili bring it up with the president.! sent the president a notice o( violation as well. _ Emaiffrom cornpiaining'party... Email attached..,phone callfrom " Valerie on the H.O.A....wanted to discuss nolice of _ violation ..^briefed _ V.M. from Valery from the H.6.A...she requested a call back to discuss „..I left herj return y.M _ ReUirn "frfjone irail toVaterie ifrom Lacosta Valley H.O.A.' ... She is requesting more time to collect papenvork to give to planning to appeal their overhight fence violation Re-Check. 10/17/14 E-h/iail from planning (Chris D.) he requested more info and photos from my case files...sent a responqe...^ planningChris D In planning... Email Chris the requested infomation for his review Re-Check. 10^^3/14....E-Mail from Valery from the H.O.A...she said they applied for a permit on Friday...E-Mall attached... "~E4Aai\ from C/P. -^ps appealliig to planning not to give fiie H.O A a perrnit for the ovemight fence^...E4j/!lail attached.... http://user.govoutreach.com/carlsbadca/ceprintrequest.php?curld=846533&type=0 03/25/2015 Print Code Enforcement Case Page 2 of3 Inspection Scott Rudinger 10/21/2014 E-Ma'l from H.OA....they sakl they will lower the fance to the 6 foot hiaht limlt....E-Mail attadied.... Case Notes Scott Rudinger ^OI23t2D^4 Eman from plannb^... Chris 0... He ts review^ ttm papenwcHlc sent in tw the H .OA to make sure the fence is coniristent witti the viliase Of Lacosta master plan.... Re-Check. 11-4/14 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/04/2014 Email ttie planning department... Chris D... Requesting any information on any dedskms made on ttie Illegal fencing Issues wilh the La Costa Valley HOA Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/05/2014 Email from plannii^ department... Chris D... Tlie Lacosta Valley H 0 A met wHh Chris laM week and they are woridng wtth the towards compllanoe at ttiis time... EmaN attached... Redieck 11/19/14 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/06/2014 E-lMaH from C/P requ^'ng an update from myasif and the pianning dept..E-Mail and my responcs attached Case Notee Scott Rudinger 11/19/2014 Email planning dep«tment... Chris D... For an upctole on any progress towards compfianos at this ttme... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/20/2014 Email from planning... Chris 0... He says ttie HOA has no applk^tksn submitted as of yet... He requested we give them more time... Email attached. Re-Check 12/17/14 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 12/17/2014 E-Mail to planning Oept ..Chris D tor an update on anyjMogtess towards compliance on non confomiing fencing at LA COSTA Valley H.OA. Case Notes Scott Rudinger 12/18C014 Email from planntng...Chris D No comfrfianoe... 1 wnn send the HOA a fnial nottce of violation....E-Mail attached Notice of Vtotatfon-Rnal Scott Rudinger 12/18^014 Send to (Property Locatk>n,Complalnant • STEVE CILURZO) Phone Call Scott Rudir^er 12/22/2014 P.C from Valerie at P.C.M...she requested a rail bade to discuss their final N.0.V...Left her a retum V.M... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 12/30/2014 E-Mail from Valerie at P.C.M. for La Coste valley.„( Attached) They plan to submit for the application for ttiere perrTdL..They are vralting for ttie preliminan/ titte report at this ttme... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 01/05/2015 HOA is woridng on plans to submit to ttie planning department tfiis week... They are waiting for a preliminary titfe report at ttils time... Recheck 1/21/15 Case Notes Soott Rudinger 01/13/2015 Email from Valerie at PCM for La Costa Valley (stttached) she went to submit plans yesterday but needed mors papenvoric... She sakl she wilt resubmit plans next week... Case Notes Paw CrescentI 01/^015 RECEIVED FiNAL NOTICE BACK II^E MAIL AS UNCLAIMED. • • Case Notes Scott Rudinger 0iei/2015 Email to Valerie with Lacosta Valley H OA... Reque^ an update on application submittal for ovemnht fence Case Notes Scott Rudinger 01/22/2015 Email from Valerie from Lacosta Vailey HOA... She is out of flie state due to a family emergency... She requested more ttme to get the plans submitted...,Reclieck 2/5/15 Phone Call Scott Rudinger 02/020015 V.M. from Valerie. ..she sakl she VAU submit the master plan amendment and aoolication tomorrow... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 02/03/2015 E-Mail firom Valerie...she has submitted her appBcatton this aflemoon...Gina R..has verified that ttie plans have been subndtted...E-Mail attached Phone Call Scott Rudinger ozmizois P.C. toC/P ...brief on update from planning. Recheck 2/19/15 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 02/19/2015 Property owner is sutxnitting required paperworit to iirianning... i will contact plannina for an update Case Notes Scott Rudinger 02/20/2015 Emait fromplamting... Austin S... Property owner dkl si^mit paperwori( for master pl«i amendment to allow ttmn to ctwigB the fencing materiai...plannitHJ vvill study and req3oiid....eniiril attached... Recheck 3/5/15 Case Notes Soott Rudinger 03W5/201S E-Mail Austin In planning requesting an update on the HOA appltoatton status.... Case Notes Soott Rudinger 03/06/2015 Email fitim planning... Austin S he sakl they were going to send the complete leUsr to ttie appltoant... Sounds Rke they are gdng to ai^ve the requested changes suggested firom ttie HOA. ..E-maH attached. Recheck 3/25/15 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 03/25/2015 Email to planning... Austtn S... Requested an update on the progress ofthe ap^^nts status on ttie revision of the master plan for the new fencing?/ http://user.govoutreach.coin/c»rlsbadca/cepintreqiiestphp?curld=846533&type=0 03/25/2015 Print Code Enforcement Case Page 3 of3 Case Notes Robbie 03/25/2015 Hickerson A NEW C/P WOULD LIKE TO BE CONTACTED A>ND CfTY ALLOWING THE HOA TO KEEP THE FENCE AND BARBWIRE UP THIS LONG AND NOT CITING THEM EITHER. IS! Violatton Type .J Building - Permit Required Corrections Required: Obtain a valid pennit. Violations Due Date _Status _ Open Closed Date Additional Addresses Address Tvpe:Comi Nama Address' Phom Address Type:Coniplainant Name Address:, PhcMie" Inspection Notes Date: Time: Findings:. http://user,govoutreach.com/carlsbadca/ceprintrequest.php?curld=846533&type=0 03/25/2015 March 31, 2015 Don Nue City Plarmer CityofCarlsbad 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 Don: I am formally requesting that the attached letter and the signed petitions ftom the 40 residents of La Costa Valley be included in the case file for Code Enforcement Case CE- 14-1118 and also the file for the proposed administrative master plan amendment MP 149V. The attached letter and signed petitions are to be included in the record for the administrative hearing when it is scheduled. I will be attending the administrative hearing to convey the strong feelings of the residents who signed the petition. They are appalled by the reckless action of the HOA board resulting in the installation of a 7 foot high chain link fence topped by barbed wire and wanted to know why the City's plarming and code enforcement staff have not taken further action to abate this egregious violation of the City's municipal code after sending the HOA a notice of violation on Sept 25, 2014 and a final notice of violation on December 12, 2014? I told them they could pose that question to the staff at the administrative hearing to be scheduled and conducted by the Planning Department. Based on the input I received from talking to a wide variety of residents in La Costa Valley and the attached signed petitions, on their behalf, I insist that you as the City Plarmer direct the staff to send a Notice/Letter registered mail to the President of the La Costa Valley HOA stating: " tliat the 7 foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire is in violation of the City's municipal code. The barbed wire must be removed and the chain link fence reduced in height to 6 feet. If full compliance is not achieved within number of calendar days from the date of the Notice/letter, the City of Carlsbad will take enforcement action including but not limited to, the issuance of administrative citations and civil fines. " Planning staff must act now to correct this blatant violation of the municipal code and ensure compliance by the HOA. The rights of the residents of La Costa Valley must be honored by the HOA board and protected by the City through enforcement of the municipal code. I am formally requesting that this letter also be included in the case file for Code Enforcement Case CE-14-1118 and the file for the proposed administrative master plan amendment MP 149V . ^oley 2246 Vista La Nisa ^^^^^ isaL/ Cc Scott Rudinger, Code Enforcement Officer Sherry Freisinger, Deputy City Clerk, public records Patrick Foley 2246 Vista La Nisa Carlsbad, CA 92009 (760) 473-6408 March 27, 2015 Don Nue City Planner CityofCarlsbad 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 RE: Code Enforcement Case: CE-14-1180 Dear Mr. Nue: It is unfortunate that the perpetrated code violation committed by the La Costa Valley HOA board of directors occurred almost a year ago when it approved and had installed a 7 foot high chain link fence topped with barbed v\ire in a residential area of La Costa Valley. No proper notice was given to the residents living adjacent to the installation and they complained vociferously to the board of directors for months but to no avail. The City's code compliance office was finally contacted by a fiiistrated resident and a formal complaint was submitted. The Code Enforcement officer reviewed the installation and confirmed it was a violation of the city's municipal code. The president of the homeowners association received a Notice of Violation by registered mail on September 25, 2014. In response, on October 21, 2014, the HOA in an email to code enforcement stated they will lower the fence to the (6) foot high limit. Nothing was done by the HOA and a Final Notice of Violation was mailed registered mail to the president of the HOA on December 18, 2014. As symptomatic of an arrogant board of directors, on January 20, 2015, the City received the Final Notice of Violation in the mail as "unclaimed." As you can plainly see, the board of the HOA did nothing in response to the City's Code Enforcement's 2 notifications of a code violation. The unresolved violation was finally given to the City's Planning Department for resolution. Today if the Plaiming staff does not hold the La Costa Valley HOA board of directors accountable for intentionally and willfully violating the City's municipal code and the Board is not required to remove the barbed wire and lower the chain link fence to 6 feet, it will continue to demonstrably symbolize the arrogance and hubris of the board of directors and showcase to the residents of the area, impacted by this barbed wire travesty, that the City appears to be incapable of enforcing its own municipal code regulations when they are wantonly violated by an HOA. (See the attached code enforcement Case CE-14-1180, case notes.) I certainly hope this is not the impression the Plarming staff wants to convey to its residents but what reason does the City have to allow this brazenly obvious and overt violation of its municipal code to continue unabated? The residents of La Costa Valley have a right to insist that the City of Carlsbad take immediate and decisive action to enforce its municipal code and take legal action if necessary against the HOA board of directors to ensure that the 7 foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire is removed within an expeditiously designated period of time. The installation of a 7 foot high chain link fence topped with barbed vnre adjacent to residential homes is an egregious violation of the City's municipal code and should not have be tolerated by the residents of the area or the City. This deplorable violation poses a health and safety risk every day it remains imabated, exposes the HOA and the City to indefensible liability and subjects the homeowners to an unwarranted and intrusive violation of their quality of life guaranteed by the conditions of the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. The residents of La Costa Valley and the City of Carlsbad caimot afford to allow this blatant and willful violation of the City's municipal code and the City's approved conditions for the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan to continue unabated throughout the administrative master plan process. No resident should have to endure the visual and negative impacts of this unjustifiable barbed wire installation one more day. On behalf of the residents of La Costa Valley who were forced to suffer the indignities of viewing this barbed wire structure for almost a year, I respectfully and emphatically request that the Planning staff take the appropriate actions to ensure that the La Costa Valley HOA board brings the fence into full compliance within 7 calendar days or other appropriate time frame firom the date of a Final Notice of Violation. If full compliance is not achieved within the time franie, code enforcement must issue administrative citations and civil fines. To continue to allow this reckless act of the HOA board to continue one more day is unconscionable. The Planning staff must act now to correct this blatant violation and ensure that the City's municipal code is enforced, the rights ofthe residents are honored by the HOA and protected by the mimicipal code. Respectfully Submitted, Attachments: Code Enforcement Case: CE-14-1180 Print Code Enforcement Case Page 1 of 3 Code Enforcement Case: CE-14-1180 Entered on: 09/15/2014 4:33 PM Printed on: 03/25/2015 Topic: Zoning Due Date: 03/26/15 Initiated by: Neighbor Hearing Date: Status: Open Assigned To: Scott Rudinger Area#: (Select) Hearing Time: Permit Pennit #: Business name; License #: Property Location Occupant Name: LA COSTA VALLEY MASTER HOA Address: 5950 LA PLACE CT. # 250,92008 Phone: APN : 255-251-50-00 Cell #: Owner Information Owner Name: KRYNICKI, THOMAS H.O.A. PRESIDENT Address: 5950 LA PLACE CT. CARLSBAD, CA 92008 Phone: CeU #: Actions Action Complaint Case Notes inspection Phone Cili ~ Courtesy Nottce Inspection Case Notes Case Notes Inspectton Phone Call Inspection Case Notes Case Notes _ By_ . Patti CrescentI Patti CrescentI '"Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Date Time Note/Observation Scott Rudinger ~ Scott Rudinger Soott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger Scott Rudinger 09/15/2014 4:33 pm THEY HAVE ERECTED A CHAIN LINK FENCE OVER 6 FEET HIGH AROUND THE R.V. PARK AT LA COSTA VALLEY MASTER HOA. YOU CAN CALL COMPLAINANT TO GET ACCESS. HE LIVES NEXT DOOR. _ 09/22/2014 2:28 pm RECEIVED A LETTER FROM ^^^^^^B SEE BELOW. 09/24/2014 09/25/2614' 09^5^014" 10/01/2014 woi/iou' 10^)3^4' •I0/08G014 10/16/2014 10/17/2014 "10/20/2014" Site Vistt... Complaint is valid... But) d(»i't see why the complaining party vyould have any concems... 7 foot fence wltti Barbed wire on '9?J!' llllByM,"!;! *5L?0!'t?5^^^^^ I'hone call to CP briefed on flridings... He does warit rne to have the H .O.A. tower the fence to 6 foot maximum... I will send H.O.A. a notice of violation. _ Send to (dvmer.Properily Location) V.M from H.O.A. secratury (Sandra) requesting a call back to discuss N O.v.... I left her a retum message.... „_ Phone call to H.O.A receptionist (Sandra) Brief on my notfce of violation... She will bring It up with the presidentl sent the president a notice of violation as welL ,_ _ Emaiffrom compiaining party... Email atlached..,phone call from " Valerie on the H.O.A....wanted to discuss notice of violatioTi ....briefed V.M. fnan Vaieiy from the H.6.A.. .she requested a call back to discuss „..l lefthwa returny.M...... Return phone" call to Valerie from Lacosta Valley H.Q.A.... She is requesting more time to collect papenvork to give to planning to appeal their overhight fence violation Re-Check. 10/17/14 E-Mail from planning (Chris D.) he requested rnore info and photos from my case fijes...sent a responce... planningChris 5 In planning... imaii Chris the requested informafion for his review Re-Check. 10/23/14....E-Mali from Valery from the H.O.A..,she said they applied for a permit on Friday...E-Mail attached... "E-Mail from CIP..^/ms appealing to ptenning not to give ttie H.bX a pemiit for ttie ovSriight fwice^...E4!«aa attadied.... _ http://user.govoutreach,com/carlsbadca/ceprintrequest.php?curld=846533&type=0 03/25/2015 Print Code Enforcement Case Page 2 of3 Inspection Scott Rudinger 1QC1/2014 E-Mail from H.OA....tti^ sakl Oiey wW lower the fisnce to the 6 fbot bight limlt....E-Maii attectied.... Case Notes Scott Rudinger ^o/23/2a^4 Email from planning... Chris D... He is reviev^ ttie paperwork sent in by the H .0.A to make sure ttie tence is consistent witti ttie ViHage of Lacosta master plan.... Re-Check. 11-4/14 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/04/2014 Email the planning department... Chris D... Requesfii^ any informatton on any dedsions made on ttie 111^ fendng issues wiUi the La Coste Valley HOA Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/05/2014 Email firom plarmir^ department... Civte D... The Lacosta VaHi^ H 0 A met with Chris last week and ttiey are woridng witti tiie city towards compUanoe at ttiis ttme... Emafl sXtadnati... Ftecheck 11/18/14 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/08/2014 E-Mail from C/P requesOng an update from myself and the planning dwt..E-Mail and my responce attached Case Notes Scott Rudinger 11/102014 Email planning department... Chris D... For an update on any progress towards compSanoe at tfiis time... Case Notes Soott Rudinger 11/20/2014 Email from planning... Chrfe D... He says ttie HOA has no appltoatton submitted as of yet... He requested we ^e ttiem more ttme... Eman attached. Re-Check 12/17/14 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 12/17/2014 E-Mail to planning Dept ..Chris D for an update on any progress towards complianoe on non confomiing fendng at LA COSTA VaO^ KOA. Case Notes Scott Rudinger 12/18/2014 Eman from planning...Chris D No compliance... 1 WiH send flie HOA a final nottt» of \rtolation....E-Maii att^ed Nofice of Vtotation - Final Scott Rudinger 12/18/2014 Send to (Property Loi»fon,Complainant - STEVC CILURZO) Phone CaU Scott Rudinger 12/22/2014 P.C from Vaterie at P.C.M...she requested a call back to discuss ttieir final N.0.V..ljeft her a retum V.M... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 12/30^014 E-Mail ftom Valerie at P.C.M. for La Costa valtey...( Attached) They plan to submit iior ttie appfication fbr ttiere pemiiL..They are vraittng for ttie preliminarv titte report at this ttme... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 01/05/2016 HOA is woridng on plans to submit to the planning department ttiis week... They are waiting for a preliminary tttte report at ttiis time... Recheck 1/21/15 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 01/13/2015 Email fit>m Valerie at PCM for La Costa Vailey (attached) she went to submit plans yesterday but needed more papeiworit... She said she will resubmit plans next week... Case Notes Patti Crescent! 01/20^015 RECEIVED FINAL NOTICE BACK IhkSHE MAIL AS UNCLAIMED. Case Notes Scott Rudinger 01/21/2015 Email to Vaterie with Lacoste Valley H OA... Requrat^ an update on application submutlal fbr ovemiotit fence Case Notes Scott Rudinger 01/22/2015 Email from Vaterie from Lacoste Vall^ HOA... She is out of the stete due to a family emergency... She requested more ttme to get ttie plans submined„..Recheck 2/5/15 Phone Call Scott Rudinger 02/02/2015 V.M. from Valerie...8he sakl she will submit the master plan amendment and aiwlicatton tomorrow... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 02/03/2015 E-Mail firom Valerie...she has submitted her appOcatton ttiis afiemoon...Gina R..has verified ttiat the plans have been submltted...E-Mail attached Phone Call Scott Rudinger 02/04^015 P.C. to C/P ...brief on update from ptenning. Recheck 2/19/15 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 02/19/2015 Property owner is submitting required papenvoric to ptenning... 1 w^ll contact planning for an update Case Notes Scott Rudinger 02/20/2015 EmaH frcnn ptenning... Austtn S... Property owner did submit papefworic for ma^ plan amendment to altow ttimt lb change the feridng material. ..planning wUI study and respond....eniall attached... Recheck 3/5/15 Case Notes Soott Rudinger 03^)5/2015 E-Mail Austtn In planning requesting an update on the HOA appllcatton status.... Case Notes Scott Rudinger 03/08/2015 Email firom planning... Austin S he sakl ttiey were going to send the complete letter to ttie applicant.. Sounds like they are going to approve the requested dianges suggested from ttie HOA ...E-mail attached. Recheck 3^/15 Case Notes Scott Rudinger 03/25/2015 EmaH to ptenning... Austtn S... Requested an update on flie progress ofthe apii^nts status on ttie revision of ttie master plan fbr ttie new tencingfT http-7/user.govQutreach.com/carlsbadca/ceprintrequest.php?curId=846533&type=0 03/25/2015 Print Code Enforcement Case Page 3 of 3 Case Notes Robbie 03/26/2015 Hickerson A NEW C/P WOULD LIKE TO BE CONTACTED/^D GIVE UPDATES ABOUT THIS CASE. •••••••USTAI' TO THE POTJMER. COUNCIL AND MAYOR ASKING WHY IS THE CITY /VLLOWING THE HOA TO KEEP THE FENCE AND BARBWIRE UP THIS LONG AND NOT CITING THEM EFfHER. Violations d Violation Type _ _DueDate ._Status^_ _ _ Closed Date ^ auilding - Permit Required Open Corrections Required:Obtain a valid pemiit. Additional Addresses Address Type: Name; Address) Phom Address Type:Conriplainant Name: Address:; Phone Inspection Notes Date: Time: Findings; http://user.govoutreach.com/carlsbadca/ceprintrequest.php?curld=846533&type=0 03/25/2015 WE THE UNDERSIGNED RESIDENTS OF LA COSTA VALLEY ADMANTLY OPPOSE THE INSTALLATION OF BARBED WIRE IN OUR MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY AND WANT THIS PETITION INCLUDED IN THE RECORD FOR THE ADMISTRATIVE HEARING FOR THE PROPOSED MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT TO ALLOW A 7 FOOT HIGH CHAIN LINK FENCE TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE. ADDRESS I-" —)— • IIOCJ*^ \0]fA^ (/^Ml cA (rMj fYi.'c^or. 7^J7 l :<.4^ A.^rA7 r^hn 94 (^/zfe 7AJA>Z. CmJ} Ocwh YOf\ \^o^OfAA c^^ck} 723$ i//5^ CM M/.^ ^l3oq A-^\ C^... j>ij^s^ \'^A A<A- WE THE UNDERSIGNED RESIDENTS OF LA COSTA VALLEY ADMANTLY OPPOSE THE INSTALLATION OF BARBED WIRE IN OUR MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY AND WANT THIS PETITION INCLUDED IN THE RECORD FORTHE ADMISTRATIVE HEARING FORTHE PROPOSED MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT TO ALLOW A 7 FOOT HIGH CHAIN LINK FENCE TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE. NAME APDRESS TA^^S \I>A2'^ L^I^A^, (5c^V^ oA HOy^AiAAtil^ (//s^ U ( i iU imA VA. uA/^ d.yi^.A 6^ ^^^-^ )^^^A2y"A^'^ f 7 yA^^(Ay WE THE UNDERSIGNED RESIDENTS OF LA COSTA VALLEY ADMANTLY OPPOSE THE INSTALLATION OF BARBED WIRE IN OUR MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY AND WANT THIS PETITION INCLUDED IN THE RECORD FOR THE ADMISTRATIVE HEARING FOR THE PROPOSED MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT TO ALLOW A 7 FOOT HIGH CHAIN LINK FENCE TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE. NAME Ciarut, Co I wes ADPRESS Julie CaU'lcs 7,7.3 i (*6 Are dfcoi GA^^ ^'>C>4 WE THE UNDERSIGNED RESIDENTS OF LA COSTA VALLEY ADMANTLY OPPOSE THE INSTALLATION OF BARBED WIRE IN OUR MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY AND WANT THIS PETITION INCLUDED IN THE RECORD FOR THE ADMISTRATIVE HEARING FOR THE PROPOSED MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT TO ALLOW A 7 FOOT HIGH CHAIN LINK FENCE TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE. ADDRESS ^3 V?. iJmA U /u/s/h 1 LD^l&/^>fvdi c3 tLO-rv S rrvl'f'in ;i^u5 Visfo^ Lou MiscL. WE THE UNDERSIGNED RESIDENTS OF LA COSTA VALLEY ADMANTLY OPPOSE THE INSTALLATION OF BARBED WIRE IN OUR MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY AND WANT THIS PETITION INCLUDED IN THE RECORD FOR THE ADMISTRATIVE HEARING FOR THE PROPOSED MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT TO ALLOW A 7 FOOT HIGH CHAIN LINK FENCE TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE. NAME MSfe Ary\ ADQBESS Uv\!!tc>.>vup ij^, ^fj- ^liP 7^0^ Cr...., .Wk,l \^^^%^ ^o(,A I'^A^M] A<4^ Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 760-436-8788 March 26, 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 RE: Case - MP 149V - Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Enclosed are two letters from La Costa Valley homeowner, Mr. Patrick Foley. His comments were sent to Mayor Matt Hall and Members of the City Council, City Attorney, Celia A Brewer and Director of Community & Economic Development. I completely agree with his comments, and wish to submit the attached letters [dated March 20 and March 24) to the Planning Division, for further consideration on this matter. The letters speak for themselves. Furthermore, please incorporate these letters [enclosed), along with my continued adamant opposition to this proposed Administrative Master Plan Amendment. RespectfuHy^ubmitted, Steve Cilurzo :2 letters attachments March 20,2015 Patrick R. Foley 2246 Vista La Nisa Carlsbad, CA 92009 Mayor Matt Hall ^d Members of the City Council 1200 Carlsbad Village Eh-ive Carlsbad, CA 92008 RE: Case No: MP 149V Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Case Name: Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Amendment Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Councii: On March 18, 2015, 1 received the attached Notice of Request For An Administrative Master Plan Amendmeiit to allow the following: • A seven foot tall chain Unk fence topped by barbed wire • Change the production view fence by replacing 6" X 6" wooden posts with metal posts I have no issue with the second item to replace 6" X 6" wooden posts with metal posts, however the use of barbed wire in Carlsbad's residential communities and especially a master planned community is ludicrous. If the use of barbed wire in Carlsbad's residential areas is not banned by the City's zoning code it should be without exception. Most if not all cities in Califomia ban the use of bailed wh-e or similar sharp materials in residential areas. I am adamantly opposed to this ridiculous request to amend the Master Plan for Arroyo La Costa and should be denied by the planning staff immediately for non- compliance with the approved Master Plan for Arroyo La Costa. Case no: MP 149V. This so called administrative master plan amendment if approved could have community wide ramifications relating to the use of barbed wire in residential areas of the City and according to the City's municipal code Section 21.38.120 any minor master plan amendment should be consideiisd by the planning commission at a noticed public hearing not an informal administrative hearing for residents opposed to the administrative master plan amendment to allow a (7) foot chain link fence topped with barbed wire. The use of barbed wire, especially in a residential area, gives the impression that the area is blighted and subject to a high rate of crime. This is not an image I or the residents of Carlsbad want to convey to tiie general public. There are other residential compatible options for security fencing. One option would be to use decorative spear tipped iron fencing intertwined with thorny bougainviUea plants. I am sure the City's planners can come up with additional community compatible options for security fencing in residential areas without the use of barbed wire. I also would like the following issues addressed by the City staff: According to the Carlsbad Mimicipal Code Section 21.38.120 -Amendment of Master Plan it states under subsection A 2. Minor Master Plan Amendments (a) "Master plan amendments, which are determined by the city planner to be minor in nature, may be approved, conditionally approved or denied by the planning commission at a public hearing noticed in accordance with Chapter 21.54 of this title. How can the proposed Arroyo La Costa Administrative Master Plan Amendment be defined by the "city planner" as other than a minor master plan amendment and the intent to install a (7) seven foot chain link fence topped with barbed wire circumvent review by the City's planning commission at a notice public hearing. I respectfiilly request that the Mayor and City Council direct the planning staff to schedule this proposed amendment to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan for a noticed public hearing before the City's planning commission or deny the request outri^t for non-compliance with the Mater Plan. Respectfully Submitted, Patrick R. Foley Attached: Notice of Request for an Administrative Master Plan Amendment CC: Mayor Matt Hall and Members ofthe City Coimcil City Attomey, Celia A. Brewer Patrick Foley 2246 Vista La Nisa Carlsbad, CA 92009 (760) 473-6408 March 24,2015 Honorable Mayor Matt Hall And Member ofthe City Council Carlsbad City Hall 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Dear Mayor and Members of the City Council; The La Costa Valley Home Owners Association Board of Directors has charted a misguided approach to resolve what they seem to perceive as a major crime wave in our master planned conmiunity. However, the Board of Directors are not exempt from complying with the City's municipal code. The Board of Directors approved and had installed a seven (7) foot chain linked fence topped with barbed wire in a residential area of the La Costa Valley Master Planned Community, This is in blatant disregard for the City's municipal code section 21.38.120- Amendment of the Master Plan. Their action is an onerous affront to the residents whose homes are adjacent to this instillation. The residents in the immediate area were never given proper notification or provided an opportunity to express their concems before the chain link fence and barbed wire were installed. I respectfully request and urgently implore, the Mayor and City Council to direct the appropriate city staff to require the La Costa Valley Home Owners Association Board of Directors to comply with the City's municipal code and immediately begin the process for removal of the 7 foot chain link fence topped with barbed wire. After this violation has been rectified, if the HOA board of directors would like to proceed with a master plan amendment for Arroyo La Costa to consider allowing a 7 foot chain link fence topped with barbed wire, it should go through a noticed public hearing before the City's Plarming Commission as required by the City's mimicipal code section 21.38.120 Amendmenl of the Master Plan. This will ensure that all the residents of the City of Carlsbad including the residents of La Costa Valley are given an opportunity to express their concems with the proposed amendment in a proper open and fair public hearing process. Respectfully Submitted, Patrick Foley Cc: City Attomey Director of Conununity & Economic Development La Costa Valley Home Owners Association Board of Directors Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 760-436-8788 March 26, 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 RE: MP 149V - Arroyo La Costa Master Plan As an addendum to my previously filed objections, I wish to submit the following photographs ofthe automatic gate that is a part of this misguided project I recently discovered that automatic gate does not have any locking mechanism, and it frequently is not closed all the way. Please see the photos below. If security is such a concern to the HOA, then I submit that it's only a matter of time before thieves discover they can pull and push on the gate to easily gain access. Page 2 shows the automatic gate entrance to the RV Storage Lot [which was constructed as part of this project illegally). Page 3 shows the gap at the gate, where it doesn't stay closed or locked. Page 4 shows how I can further pull the gate open. If I put my camera phone down, I could push on the other side [at the same time) and squeeze through the opening. As you can see, it's very easy for almost anyone to gain access to the RV Lot. That 7 foot chain linked with barbed wire is not going to deter any unauthorized activity from entering the area. Thank you for your time and opportunity to be heard on this matter. Respectfully submitted. Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 TO: Don Nue, Planning Director Deborah K. Fountain, Director of Housing & Neighborhood Services FROM: Patrick Foley, Resident of La Costa Valley DATE: April 29,2015 SUBIECT: APRIL 25, 2015 ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING ON A PROPOSAL TO AMEND THE ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN'S FENCING PLAN TO ALLOW AN EXISTING ILLEGALLY INSTALLED 7 FOOT HIGH CHAIN LINK FENCE TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE IN VIOLATION OF THE CITY'S MUNICIPAL CODE AND THE ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN. Request for A Master Plan Amendment Valerie Gulhcksen in her letter dated lanuary 12,2015 regarding Re: CE- 14-1180, which she submitted on behalf of the HOA, states the following reason why a master plan amendment should be granted in order to legitimize an illegally installed 7 foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire: 1. "Our request to amend the plan is to allow for adequate fencing around the Recreation Storage Facility in an effort to maintain health, safety and the better welfare for the community." RESPONSE: Installing an illegal 7 foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire does not maintain health, safety and the better welfare for the community. Rather this egregious violation of the City's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master plan poses a health and safety risk every day it remains unabated, exposes the HOA and the City to indefensible liability and subjects the homeowners to an unwarranted and intmsive violation of their quality of life guaranteed by the conditions of the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. The installation of an illegal 7foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire around the 63 space RV lot is not for the better welfare of the community which is comprised of 1,073 residential units. The vast majority of the residents in La Costa Valley as documented by the petitions, emails, phone calls and correspondence submitted to planning are in vehement opposition to this installation that is in violation of the city's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. Valerie Gullicksen in her letter dated January 12, 2015 goes on to state: "Additional fencing is required due to the deterioration of existing fencing and demands from renters of storage facility to upgrade the fence due to the existing height and materials allowing individuals easy access which has resulted in damage to vehicles." RESPONSE: In her letter on behalf of the HOA, Valerie states: "A sampling of homeowner requests for action appears for your reference." She is referring to the emails from RV owners that were attached to their application for a Master Plan amendment to allow an illegally installed 7foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire in violation of the city's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master plan as justification for approval of their proposed amendment by City Planner, Don Nue. The HOA included 7 emails from RV owners who had vehicles in the RV lot and expressed their concerns about the RV lot security. A summary of their emails follows: [1) Email dated May 22. 2013 from Steve Isachsen. [PCM notify RV owners of theft) Steve allowed his neighbor Dave Vieregg to store his boat on his lease space #15 and the motor on Dave's boat was stolen. Dave valued the motor at $5,000. Neither Dave nor Steve were sure when the theft occurred because they had not been to the lot for over a month. The motor was large and the owner Dave suspects it would have taken at least two people and at least an hour to unbolt etc. "It would be good to also notify the RV lot resident email list to let everyone know what happened to raise awareness." [2) Email dated August 5. 2013 from Alan Wiliingham. Regional Vice President-Purchasing Southern California Standard Pacific Homes [Cameras, barbed wire and better signage) Alan in his email is suggesting better security precautions to reduce the risk and damages to our property. He suggests: "Cameras, barbed wire and much better signage are some easy additions." [3) Email dated August 6. 2013 from Kim Block [Bemus out of the RV Lot) Mrs. Block stated that she and Ron were picking up their RV around 11 am. They have the spot right next to the shed. "The shed was wide open and the Bemus golf cart was partially behind our RV. We pushed it out of the way. I was going to complain about the state of things but now I realize it was a break in. Ron thinks we need barbed wire on top of fences, I think we need a better lock system, since I can barely unlock the gates by myself " We both think that Bemus needs a separate area for their equipment [outside the RV lot) because the space is so tight & too many people are going in & out" [4) Email dated September 18. 2013 from Gene Ma [Security Cameras) " I have tried to be reasonable and have approached the board to consider security cameras in the past I would request that the board consider that as an action item once and for all." [5) Email dated September 19. 2013 from Alan WiUiams. Regional Vice President - Purchasing Southern California Standard Pacific Homes (Barbed wire, Security Cameras, Good Signage, Much taller fencing 8'J " I recall that the board sent out a survey earlier in the year, or even late last year about improving the security at the RV lot and nothing other than 2 new locks ever came of the survey/notice." "Just a few ideas: • Barb wire [24" barrel roll) added to the top section of the current fencing? • Security cameras, even fake camera will reduce risk • Really good signage, large and posted per state law for no trespassing regulations [every 100') • Much taller fencing 8', in some areas the current fencing is not much higher than 4'." [6) Email dated December 3, 2013 from Gary Endres (Get landscape people out of there) "Sorry to say it....but you need to get the landscape people out of there....so this is about the #5 or #6 incidents ....Ive had a spot for my boat since early 2000s ....I had my trailer license....battery sound system stolen hoa needs to take action...." [7) Email from Jerry Storage. Senior VP and General Manager, the date of the email was obviously covered so it would not show when it was copied. Email Subject: FW: RV lot questions [None of the questions are shown in the email) Jerry Storage is the General Manager for Laguna Woods Village in Orange County, whom I know personally. The Village is a private gated community of 12,000 residents. It has 3 different HOA boards and two RV lots. One RV lot has 338 spaces and the other has 79 spaces. As stated in his email, the RV lots have the following types of security: • 6' chain link perimeter fence topped with 3 strands of Barbed wire • CCTV pan, tilt and zoom cameras monitored by security • member identification card activated electric rolling gate • the RV lots are patrolled 24/7 by PCM Security Patrol: there is no history of vandalism or theft in the lots. Conclusion The La Costa Valley RV lot's illegal 7foot high chain link fence is the least effective of the 3 types of security measures mentioned by Jerry Storage in his email. This is evidenced by the fact that after the illegal 7 foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire was installed [February 2014) in August 2014 a whole section of the fence was cut out and removed and an ATV was driven out through the opening in the fence. Yet in her letter dated January 12, 2015, Valerie Gullicksen with PCM states the following: " The Board of Directors upon notification of these events acted in the best interest of the community which "in" comprised of 1072 residents by seeking opinions from: police and legal counsel on appropriate action to secure the facility. The Board investigated additional lighting, security systems, security patrol and fencing options. Great care and consideration was given to the resolution of escalating criminal activity which also affected neighboring homes." "As part of the investigation a survey and visit to local Homeowner's Association Recreation Storage facilities was performed. These findings were that chain link fencing and barbed wire was the standard material of choice." It is ludicrous to believe that installing an illegal 7foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire is acting in the best interest of a community comprised of 1,072 residents. It is also inconceivable that the Carlsbad Police department would have informed the HOA board that a 7foot high chain like fence topped with barbed wire was the most effective security measure they could take. In my recent conversations with Jody Fasway of the Carlsbad Police Department's Crime Prevention unit she mentioned cameras as one of the more effective deterrents to vandalism and theft along with increased security patrols. Recommendation On behalf of the residents who signed the petitions adamantly opposing any change to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan and the residents of Paseo Aliso, I strongly recommend that Planning deny the HOA's application for a master plan amendment in its entirety and that Code Enforcement take immediate action to ensure that the 7foot high chain link fence topped with barbed wire is completely removed in compliance with the City's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan; that Planning direct the HOA board to meet with the residents of La Costa Valley and Paseo Aliso to achieve consensus on security measures that can be implemented in the RV lot that are cost effective and in compliance with the City's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan including but not limited to security cameras, increased security patrols inside the RV lot motion sensors and motion activated lighting, and the permanent removal of all landscaping vehicles, equipment, and landscape planting materials and supplies from the RV lot. ATTACHMENTS 1. Letter from Valerie Gullicksen, PCM, on behalf of the La Costa Valley Master Association Board of Directors 2. Reported RV Lot Theft/Vandalized Items 3. Emails from Residents with lease space in the RV Lot Expressing concerns about security 4. DVD of Local News Media Coverage of April 7, 2015 Carlsbad Council meeting showing residents adamantly opposed to the HOA's illegally Installed 7foot high chain Unk fence topped with barbed wire in violation of the city's municipal code and the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. pcminternet.com January 12, 2015 CityofCarlsbad 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 Re: Case: CE-14-1180 We are formally responding to the courtesy notice provided to La Costa Valley Master HOA for failure to obtain a building permit. After meeting with mcmber-s ofthe City it was decided lhat lhat we vsould .submit an application to amend the original fencing plan forthe connniinit>", thereby allowing the 7 foot fencing topped with barbed wire to enclose the storage facility located off of Paseo Aliso within La Costa Valley Master Association. Our request to amend the plan is to allow for adequate fencing around the Recreation Storage Facilily in an effort to maintain health, safety and the better welfare for the community. Additional fencing is required due to deterioration of existing fencing and demands from renters of storage facilits' to upgrade the fence due to the existing height and materials allow ing individuals easy access which has resulted in loss and damage lo vehicles. Enclosed is historical information outlying the thefts that have occurred in the last four years. In addition, to these reports of theft, complaints have also been made to the Cits- of Carlsbad Police department of illegal drug use in this area. A sampling of homeowner requests for action appears for your reference. 40 pcminternet.com AN ASSOCi* COMPANY The Board of Directors upon notification of these events acted in the best interest of the connnimit>' \vhich in comprised of 1072 residences by seeking opinions from: police and legal counsel on appropriate action to secure the facility. The Board investigated additional lighting, security systems, security patrol and fencing options. Great care and consideration was given to the resolution of escalating criminal activity which also affected neighboring homes. As part of die in\ cstigation a survey and visit to local Homeowner's Association Recreation Storage facilities was performed. These findings were that chain link fencing and barbed was the standard material of choice. We hereby request that an amendment be granted to allow for a 7 foot chain Unk, barbed wire fence and automated entry gate to secure this area. Sincerely, Valerie GulUcksen, CCAM Sr. Community Manager On Behalf of the La Costa Valley Master Association Board of Directors. 41 REPORTED RV LOT THEFTS/VANDALIZED ITEMS YEAR VICTIM PROPERTY/THEFT June 2008 ^December 2008 jjjS January 2009 2009-12 2010 March-May 2012 Gallucci Association ( Association q^. Gene Ma New Boat Motor/Mounts RV Lot Padlock RV Lot Gate Dates unclear/Reports at least 3 thefts between these years Golf Cart Stolen Drug paraphernalia and suspected iliegai teen activity in and around resident RV. Multiple calls to Police to investigate. April 2012 Unclear Unclear (Police rec June 2012 Valley Crest L\ Golf Cart June 2012 Association 'f Fence August 2012 Survey to renters N/A .,=^-~ January 2013 Capps Trailer/Misc. May 2013 Vierrg Outboard Motor May 2013 Vierrg Boat Cover May 2013 Universal Protection Board Members Security Meeting ^ July 2013 Golf Cart ^August 2013 Bemus Tools/Equipment September 2013 Gene Ma Tires/ZWheels September 2013 Jacob Spolestra Tarp September 2013 Association ^ RV Lot Gate September 2013 Universal Protection /9 Guard Lock Box January 2014 Association Padlock stolen Febraary 2014 Mizock Broken window Febraary 2014 Chemus Tarp 60 Febraary 2014 Steffemo Ransacked FENCE INSTALLED FEBRURAY March 2014 Gene Ma Unclear August 2014 Gene Ma ATV ||-August2014 Association |> Fence 61 Valerie Gullicksen tmm: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Wednesday, May 22, iSf^S^WT' Valerie Gullicksen; lacostavalleyclub@gmail.conn David Vieregg RV Lot Theft Hi Valerie and Nancy, 1 lease spot #15 at the La Costa Vall^ RV Storage lot for my camper trailer. 1 allow my neighbor Dave Vieregg to store his boat in the same spot (you have all insurance and registration documents on file). Yesterday aftemoon we went to remove Dave's boat and my trailer had been moved aside and his boat's motor, steering, and navigation had been stolen. He estimates the value ofthe motor at about $5000. He filed a police report last night. We are not sure when this happened as the last time we were there was about a month or so ago. It was after the last break in as 1 checked on things after that and this was the first 1 had been there since the rekey. <^an you please let us know how to proceed? It would be good to also notify the RV lot resident email V ^st to let everyone know what happened to raise awareness. The motor was large and Dave suspects it would have taken at least two people and at least an hour to unbolt, etc. Please acJvise. Thanks, Steve Isachsen 62 Sandra .Arguelles ( 1 .(•om: Alan Wiliingham Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 8:29 PM To: Sandra Arguelles ^-A Subject: FW: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importance: High Sandra, This has t>een an ongoing problem for years? Are there any plans to add better security precautions to reduce the risk and damages to our property? Cameras, barb wire and much better signage are some easy additions. The fences are way too e asy to climb and lift things over the 5'-6' height. Please forward this to the members of the board to address this ongoi ng problem for us. Thanks Alan Willir^gham Regional Vice President - Purchasing Southern Caiifornia STANDARD PACIFIC HOMES www.standardpacifichomes.com j Making You Right At Home Please consider the environment before printing a copy of this email. JDlis e-mail and ary dies liansmitted with it are can'iaenlial and 'inencied soiely fc !'ie JSC ol the iiidi\.idi;.3i or entily !c •.vHicr Vio.y are acc-^s-sec dnc) all f pnmation is legally pnviieged If you are nol tt^e irterded ler.ipie-H.Or a person respo-isitle <or deliverii^c it x- tlie irite-saed re-cipient, you a-e hereDy notified that V } disclosure :;ociyirig dissDn'.ination, or use ol inforr-.at.o'- .-.o'-'s r^ar. in cr artacrec to t'liS transnvssion <. st^'Cfv D'oi;fcileo Nc;e ;-.3l any vews ot ocinions 'presented in tins e-ciai: s.?. solely those ofthe author aic do "ct necessarily reorescni fiose of Standsrc Haaf,c hcnes Sianilafd Pacific Honnes takes every precaution to protect e-mail recipients, but recipients are responsible for checlcng ariy e-n^an and aUactiif>e^ts for fie possioie !:iesence ot vLMses Siandard Pacific Homes or the author accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by e-mail. From: runner.comi Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 5:51 PM To: Alan Wiliingham Subject: Fwd: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importartce: High Sent from my HTC Forvi/arded message From: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles@pcmintemet.com> Date: Moxi, Aug 5, 2013 5:48 pm Subject: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In To: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles(fl),pcmintemet.com> Dear Homeowner: (^.ease be advised that the RV lot was compromised on 8/4/13 and the Landscape Company's tools were stolen. Please check your RV or Boat and ensure that your items are secure. 63 Sandra Arguelles om: Kim Blok Sent: Tuesday, August 06, 2013 8:01 AM To: Sandra Arguelles Subject: Re; La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Ron & i were there picking up our RV around 11:00 am. We have the spot right next to the shed. The shed was wide open and the Beamus golf cart was partially behind our RV. We pushed it out ofthe way. It was weird but we just thought a worker must be attending to something in LCV & that he left the shed open. I was going to complain about the state of things but now i realize it was a break-in. Ron thinks we need barbed wire on top offences, i think we need a better lock system, since i can barely unlock the gates by myself. We both think that Beamus needs a separate area for their equipment (outside the RV lot) because the space is so tight & too many people are going in & out. The workers have never scratched our RV & they seem to be very careful, but its still too close to our RV for comfort. Anyway, maybe this info will help wAhe timeline of what happened. Kim & Ron Blok, space 34. Sent from my iPhone On Aug 5, 2013, at 5:48 PM, Sandra Arguelles Dear Homeowner: Please be advised that the RV lot was compromised on 8/4/13 and the Landscape Company's tools were stolen. Please check your RV or Boat and ensure that your items are secure. If you have any stolen or damaged property, the La Costa Valley Board of Directors encourage you to file a Police Report. Also, if you have any information on the person(s) responsible for this fraudulent acfivity, please report it to the Carlsbad Police Department at 780-931-2100. Finally, if you have any questions regarding this notice, please let me know. Sincerely, Sandra Arguelles Administrative Assistant Professional Community Management of Califomia, Inc. (PCM) An Associa* Company 5950 La Place Court, Suite 250, Carlsbad, CA 92008 Di reet: 760-918-8055 M ain: 760-918-8040 Toll Free: 800-599-9151 sa reuelle5@pcminternet.com Associa* - Delivering unsurpassed management and lifestyle services to communities worldwide. Learn more at www.pcminternet.com / Foiiow us at vtfww.facebook.com/professionalcommunitvmanaeement 64 Valerie Gullicksen . rom: Sent: Wednesday, September 18, 2013 10:53 PM To: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RV lot theft Ms Gulli cksen. This past weekend my trailer was once again, for the 4th time, vandalized. This time my trailer wheels and tires stolen and my trailer left on cinder blocks on the dnmi brakes/axle assembly. A police report was filed, case niunber 13-05964. At this time I would like to ask if the association carries any insurance at the property to reimburse the expenses I continue to incur as a result of repetitive incidents. have tried to be reasonable and have approached the board to consider security cameras in the past. I would request that the board consider that as an action item once and for all. I understand that this was supposedly considered by a recent poll of the lot renters and there was a lack of interest, but I have been advised that an organization having been noticed of security concems who fail to act responsibly to protect the members remains liable. As I have said before, I am not interested in involving counsel. It just isn't my approach, as evidence by the 3 prior notifications of the association and my subsequent willingness to allow tiie board and manageinent company to respond as they see fit. But please understand that at this point, after 3 prior acts of vandalism, I have just had it. The police officer who responded was surprised, to say the least, at the lack of security prevalent at the site, which he indicated was simply an invitation for vandalism at an imsecured RV lot. I would appreciate a timely response indicating the plan moving forward. Sincerely, ( 'sne Ma Carlsbad 65 Sandra >Vrguelles . om: Alan Wiliingham Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 8:29 PM To: Sandra Arguelles Subject: FW; La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importance: High Sandra, This has been an ongoing problem for years? Are there any plans to add better security precautions to reduce the risk and damages to our property? Cameras, barb wire and much better signage are some easy additions. The fences are way too easy to climb and lift things over the 5'-6' height. Please forward this to the members ofthe board to address this ongoing problem for us. Thanks Alan Wiliingham Regional Vice President - Purchasing Southem California STANDARD PACIFIC HOMES vvww.standardDacifichomes.com | Making You Right At Home* ( Please consider the environment before printing a copy of this email. Itjis e-mail and any files transmitted with it are conf.dentia' at-.d r-ito'iaea so.ely for the use cf tne mdiv.dua. 21 entity to wtucn they ara acaressed and atl »fmation 'S legacy rnvi egeu If you are not the ntended r-scipiei't. or a tie'so- rescons'bie for nelive'inc -.i ;o tht intGnaec rectrieni you are --ereDy not.fied that ,/ disclosure, capying dissemination, or use of infofmatior: ,-:cr't3i'iGa in or attaclied to this t'a"s:-isscn is s!t:ot;y rjrrt-i&iied -Mete ti-al a-y v:ews jr ;)pinions presented in this e-mai. are sciely those ofthe autha- anc ao not necessan^y -earesent trose cf Stancarc Pacr'ic r-omes Standard Pacf'C i-nmes taKes every precaution to protect e-mail recipients, but recipients are responsible for checlting any e-niai: anc attachments -or the r:cs.>;:bie presence of v r..ses Standard Pacific Homes or the author accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by e-mail. From: 'runner.comi Sent: Monday, August 05, 2013 5:51 PM To: Alan Wiliingham Subject: Fwd: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In Importance: High Sent firom my HTC -—Forwiuded-message ~ - From: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles@pcmintemet.com> Date: Moxi, Aug 5,2013 5:48 pm Subject: La Costa Valley RV Lot Break In To: "Sandra Arguelles" <sarguelles(g>pcmintemet.com> Dear Homeowner: ease be advised that the RV lot was compromised on 8/4/13 and the Landscape Company's tools were stolen. Please check your RV or Boat and ensure that your items are secure. 66 1 -^fi Valerie Gullicksen Y-rom: Phyllis Mischke Sent: Thursday, September 19, 2013 2:23 PM To: 'Alan Wiliingham' Cc: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RE: Thank you for your e-mali Alan. I will pass it on for consideration. PAy///s /yiischke Office Ma nager Professional Community Management of California, Inc. (PCM) An Associa * Company 5950 La Place Court, Ste. 250, Carlsbad, CA 92008 Direct; 760-918-8044; Main: 760-918-8040 Toll Free: 800-599-9151; Direct Fax: 949-206-2352 pmischke<S)pcminternet.com Associa® — Delivering unsurpassed management and lifestyle services to communities worldwide. Learn more at www.pcminternet.com / Foiiow us at www.facebool<.com/profes5ionalcommunitvmanaeement om: Alan WillinghanW" Sent: Thursday, September 19, 20.15 2: i4 PM To: Phyllis Mischke Subject: Phyllis, I recall that the board sent out a survey earlier In the year, or even late last year about improving the security at the RV lot and nothing other than 2 new locks every came of the survey/notice. The continued vandalism over the years is only increasing and it is truly time that action is taken to reduce the risk of theft and vandalism. I know that it will never be lOOo/o safe, but reducing the risk will reduce the number of occurrence's that seem to be growing. I sent a message in right after the last occurrence last month and still have not heard anything back from anyone. Will you please forward this message to the board and ask fbr their consideration to at least take "some" action to reduce the risk, doing nothing to mitigate the vandalism is not helping to reducing the risk. Just a few ideas: Barb Wire (24" barrel roll) added to the top section of the current fencing? Security Cameras, even fake camera wiil reduce risk Really good signage, large and posted per state law for no trespassing regulations (every 100') Much taller fencing 8', in some areas the current fencing is not much higher than 4' lank you for your consideration From: Phyllis Mischke^ Sent: Thursday, SeptemBer 19, 2013 10:25 AM 67 Jo Sandra Arguelles Sent: To: Subject: Gary Endres^|§, Tuesday, December 03, 2013 12:00 PM Sandra Arguelles Re: RV Lot Break-in Sorry to say it ...but you need to get the landscape people out of there...so this is about #5 or #6 incidents...Ive had a spot for my boat since early 2000's...I had my trailer license...battery...sound system stolen...hoa needs to take action... On Dec 3,2013 11 ;29 AM, "Sandra Arguelles" Good morning. This email serves as a notice that on a recent RV lot inspection it was noted that a section of the fence had been detached and was laying on the grown. Although it was evident that the piece of fence was forcefiilly removed, it did not appear that anything else at the RV lot was out of order. However, PCM and the La Costa Valley Board of Directors do encourage you to inspect your property to ensure nothing was stolen or damaged. fwould like to add that, during the RV lot inspection, management met with a fence company to discuss the addition of a 6 foot chain link fence with the added razor wire on top. Please know that the La Costa Valley Board is researching several different options for added security measures. Further conununication on what measures will be taken will be communicated in the months to follow. If you have any questions or concems, please let me know. Thank you, Sandra Arguelles Administrative Assistant •PPOr ES51CNAL - J COMMUNiTY AN ASiOCIA COHPAKY 68 Valerie ^Gullicksen jbject: FW: RV lot questions There are two Recreational Vehicle (RV) storage areas in the Community. RV Lot A: • 338 parking spaces • 6' chain link perimeter fence topped with 3 strands of barbed wire • Member identification card activated electric rolling gate • CCTV pan, tilt and zoom camera monitored by Security RV Lot B: • 79 parking spaces • 6' chain link perimeter fence topped with 3 strands of barbed wire • Manual operated hinged swinging gate secured with chain and keyed padlock The RV Lots are patrolled 24/7 by PCM Security Patrol; there is no history of vandalism or theft in the lots. Jerry C. Storage, BSCE, MBA, CCAM®, CMCA®, AMS®, PCAM® Senior VP and General Manager i 69 March 23,2015 ^'^^^^^d City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue CaHsbad, California 92008 Subject: Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Reference: Case NO: MP 149V, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan, Planning Division Letter dated March 17, 2015 We reside in Arroyo La Costa and we do object to the Amendment to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan that was proposed to allow an already constructed seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire. This change is not aesthetically consistent with the Master Plan for our neighborhood or the City of Carlsbad community. We are directly affected as this fence is visible from our home. It is directly behind our house and we see the fence from our bedrooms. Equally important, it is visible from public areas west of our community, including the highways and popular shopping areas. The fence makes our community look like a prison to these public areas. It is unappealing and not consistent with other community fencing, let alone the governing Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. We have attended multiple HOA meetings to address our concerns, but have not been satisfied. We understand that the motivation for the fence is increased security for the RV storage area, however we believe that alternatives exist that have not been seriously investigated. We request an administrative hearing. Sincerely, 'lim and Cathy Miller 7959 Paseo Aliso Carlsbad, Ca 92009 City of Carlsbad RE: Case No: MP 149V, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan 03/22/2015 ^ ^ ^^^^ Planning Division I am writing in regard to my concern about the potential revision of plans, removal/replacement of the chain link and razor wire fence located surrounding the RV parking lot in the La Costa Valley development. Simply, I am concerned for the safety and security of my family, neighborhood and surrounding community if the current fence is deemed not to code or the code and plan is changed and thusly the current fence torn down and replaced with a less secure more "attractive" alternative. I live directly across the street from the driveway that is the entrance and exit for the RV parking lot onto Paseo Aliso. I have experienced first hand the unsafe environment before the razor wire fence install. The reduction in unsavory and illegal activities after the razor fence was installed was felt immediately. The nuisance of loud late nights and no sleep, RVs being broken into, people jumping the fence to score drugs and then shooting up in front of our home were too numerous to count before the current fence was installed. The occurrences of vandalism before the razor wire fence was installed were most unsettling. Please see attached photographs. The photographs are of the wall on our property and were taken after one incidence of vandalism, shocking and unsettling to say the least. Since the installation of the razor wire fence, there has been a considerable decrease in these frightening and dangerous happenings surrounding the RV lot. I understand that there is much swirl concerning the original plans and permits from the onset of our planned community, what is currently the case and how it came to be. Recently, we have been contacted by some neighbors with concern over the installation of the current fencing. These neighbors are using certain planning arguments to push an agenda that is actually based on whether or not the current fencing is pleasing to them aesthetically. My concern is for the safe and secure environment that our community and the city of Carlsbad wish to maintain. It is difficult to feel a sense of safety when you wake up to find that "F.. da Police" in letters 3 feet tall has been painted of your wall and every neighbor child on their way to school that morning wants to know what those words mean. I am grateful for the opportunity to write you this letter and ask that it will be taken into consideration. I am proud to be a resident of the fine city of Carlsbad and I believe that at the end of the day the safety and security of its residents are the most important factor when considering these matters. Please feel free to contact me regarding this matter. Respectfully, LisofZondler 2176 Corte Limon Carlsbad, Ca 92009 760-753-4690 Ccityof Carlsbad NOTICE OF REQUEST FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT Notice is hereby given that an Administrative Master Plan Amendment has been applied for to allow a change to the fencing plan that was approved as part of Arroyo La Costa Master Plan, which would allow for a seven foot tall chain link fence topped with barbed wire and to change the production view fence by replacing 6" x 6" wooden posts with metal posts on property generally located east of El Camino Real and west of Paseo Aliso in Carisbad, California, and more particularly described as: Lot 124, of Carlsbad Tract No. 88-03-1, Arroyo La Costa, Unit 1, (Villages I), in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to map thereof no. 13385, filed in the office ofthe County Recorder of San Diego County, December 20,1996. If you have any objections to the granting of this Master Plan Amendment or wish to have an administrative hearing to discuss the requested Master Plan Amendment, please notify the Planning Division, 1635 Faraday Avenue, Carisbad, California 92008, in writing within 10 calendar days ofthe date of this notice. If you have any questions, please call Austin Silva in the Planning Division at (760) 602-4631. CASE NO.: MP 149V CASE NAME: ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN DATE: March 17, 2015 CITY OF CARLSBAD PLANNING DIVISION Community & Economic Development Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue I Carlsbad, CA 92008 I 760-602-4600 I 760-602-8560 fax March 20,2015 Patrick R. Foley 2246 Vista La Nisa Carlsbad, CA 92009 Austin Silva Planning Division City of Carlsbad 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 RE: Case No: MP 149V Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Case Name: Arroyo La Costa Master Plan Amendment Dear Mr. Silva: On March 18, 2015, I received the attached Notice of Request For An Administrative Master Plan Amendment to allow the following: • A seven foot tall chain link fence topped by barbed wire • Change the production view fence by replacing 6" X 6" wooden posts with metal posts I have no issue with the second item to replace 6" X 6" wooden posts with metal posts, however the use of barbed wire in Carlsbad's residential communities and especially a master planned community is ludicrous. If the use of barbed wire in Carlsbad's residential areas is not banned by the City's zoning code it should be without exception. Most if not all cities in Califomia ban the use of barbed wire or similar sharp materials in residential areas. I am adamantly opposed to this ridiculous request to amend the Master Plan for Arroyo La Costa and it should be denied by the planning staff immediately for non- compliance with the approved Master Plan for Arroyo La Costa. Case no: MP 149V. This so called administrative master plan amendment if approved could have community wide ramifications relating to the use of barbed wire in residential areas of the City and according to the City's municipal code Section 21.38.120 any minor master plan amendment should be considered by the planning commission at a noticed public hearing not an informal administrative hearing for residents opposed to the administrative master plan amendment to allow a (7) foot chain link fence topped with barbed wire. The use of barbed wire, especially in a residential area, gives the impression that the area is blighted and subject to a high rate of crime. This is not an image I or the residents of Carlsbad want to convey to the general public. There are other residential compatible options for security fencing. One option would be to use decorative spear tipped iron fencing intertwined with thorny bougainviUea plants. I am sure the City's planners can come up with additional community compatible options for security fencing in residential areas without the use of barbed wire. I also would like the following issues addressed by the City staff: According to the Carlsbad Municipal Code Section 21.38.120 -Amendment of Master Plan it states under subsection A 2. Minor Master Plan Amendments (a) "Master plan amendments, which are determined by the city planner to be minor in nature, may be approved, conditionally approved or denied by the planning commission at a public hearing noticed in accordance with Chapter 21.54 of this title. How can the proposed Arroyo La Costa Administrative Master Plan Amendment be defined by the "city planner" as other than a minor master plan amendment and the intent to install a (7) seven foot chain link fence topped with barbed wire circumvent review by the City's planning commission at a notice public hearing ? I respectfully request that the Mayor and City Council direct the plaiming staff to schedule this amendment to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan for a noticed public hearing before the City's planning commission or deny the request outright for non-compliance with the Mater Plan. Respectfully Submitted Patrick R. F( Attached: NoK<jeof|{^quest for an Administrative Master Plan Amendment CC: Mayor Matt Hall and Members of the City Council City Attomey, Celia A. Brewer Valerie Gullicksen From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Theresa Gray <theresa_m_flynn@yahoo.com> Tuesday, April 28, 2015 8:05 PM austin.silva@carisbadca.gov Valerie Gullicksen; Eric Gray La Costa HOA fencing issue Hello, My husband and 1 live at 7943 Paseo Aliso, within the La Costa Valley development. Our home is adjacent to the driveway to enter the RV storage lot, and we can see the fence in question from our windows. We understand that there is a public meeting tomorrow night, but we will not be able to attend. 1 wanted to submit our opinion that the benefits from the increased security to the RV storage area outweigh the unsightliness of the chain link and barb wire. In a perfect world, we wouldn't need night time security or a need for fences and gates - but we all know that is not our world. Because we are so close to the RV storage, we can hear very well what is happening inside the area after hours. There used to be many more 'people' goofing off in the area after hours. 1 think that by making it hard to get inside we are eliminating an easy location to be acting inappropriately. 1 sympathize with the people who are backed up to the lot who don't like the aesthetics, but honestly, it's not any worse than the high voltage lines that we (those along this side of Paseo Aliso) have right behind our house. You just leam to ignore it and appreciate the pretty things that you can see! (This same thing applies the the eyesore that is 'Walmart' - that we can easily see) I just wanted to present our side of the issue. Thank you, Theresa & Eric Gray (760) 943-7780 Valerie Gullicksen From: Steve McKenery <smckenery@yahoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, April 29, 2015 12:49 AM To: austin.silva@carsbadca.gov Cc: Valerie Gullicksen; Laura McKenery Subject: La Costa RV Fence Dear Mr. Silva, It has come to our attention that there is a hearing this evening regarding the fence around the RV storage area in our La Costa Valley neighborhood. A quick internet search reveals the details. My wife and I are unable to attend the hearing this evening but wanted to share our opinion as we are original homeowners in La Costa Valley (16 years) and have a boat stored in the RV area. We understand the issues raised by some of the homeowners, and it sounds as though the HOA should have applied for a permit before constructing the fence. Mistakes happen, and it sounds as though the HOA has now filed the appropriate documentation to amend the master plan. The comments raised by the vocal homeowners that the chain-link fence looks like a "prison" are ridiculous. El Camino Creek School which sits right in the middle of our neighborhood has a tall chain- link fence around it, and it is clearly visible from many streets. Our La Costa Valley clubhouse tennis courts have tall chain link fences and they are clearly visible from main streets. The RV storage area is hidden around behind houses under high-voltage SDG&E power lines and is NOT visible from any streets. The lot has 64 large RVs and boats and has been there since the community was built over 16 years ago. Given the very unsightly high-voltage transmission lines, various RVs and boats and the beautiful view of the Target parking lot across El Camino Real street, I find the addition of a chain link fence inconsequential. The chain link fence was built for a reason ....constant, continued delinquent and criminal activity occurring in the RV lot by vandals. Our boat cover was vandalized 3 years ago, and we have read about and seen damage occur on dozens of occasions to other vehicles over the past many years. Since this taller fence with barbed wire was installed, we have not experienced any thefts or damage and I understand the criminal activity has stopped or been greatly reduced. There is a reason the local school (ECC) has a tall chain link fence rather than a 4' tall ornamental fence .... it helps prevent vandalism. I would think those complaining homeowners would be glad that they no longer have a bunch of criminal activity occurring right below their homes. They should be glad the new fencing is in place. We strongly urge you to keep the new fence in place and approve the appropriate Master Plan update and the necessary documentation being submitted by the La Costa Valley HOA. Thank you for your consideration. Best regards, Steve and Laura McKenery (homeowners and RV yard occupants) 7872 Via Adelfa Sandra Ar IgueJMes^ From: Dottie Wiliingham <willinghams@roadrunner.com> Sent: Wednesday, April 29, 2015 7:46 AM To: Sandra Arguelles Subject: FW: La Costa Valley - RV Lot Fence (Resolution Idea) Attachments: Fence in Irvine.jpg; DSCN0073.JPG; bougain.jpg fyi From: Alan Wiliingham [mailto:AWilling@stanpac.com] Sent: Tuesday, April 28, 2015 9:31 PM To: austin.silva@carlsbadca.qov Cc: Dottie Wiliingham Subject: La Costa Valley - RV Lot Fence (Resolution Idea) Austin, I am writing in favor of finding a resolution to this conflict, I understand both sides and I happen to be in favor of the current fence since it has proven to help protect our RVs and I feel that our HOA has an obligation to respond to the past vandalism and theft and I believe that the HOA did do the right thing. It is unfortunate that there are a "select" few that feel that they have been impacted by the fence for reasons that are not clearly understood by me. I am writing in case I am unable to make the meeting tomorrow and I would like my "idea" below to be considered and I feel that it should satisfy both sides and will still provide the protection to our property that we pay to have stored within "our" common area property. I am sure that this has been considered, but my thoughts are that the HOA can plant a fast growing vine species (see attached photos) on the easterly side of the RV lot fence that will provide a very pleasing landscape barrier that will not only help to address the concerns with silver fencing, it will also help to provide those concerned neighbor's with a nice landscape barrier so they don't have to look at all of the RVs in the lot any longer as they have for the last 15 years. It will definitely provide them with a more pleasing view then they have ever had in the past. I think that a few minor adjustment to the spray pattern on the existing irrigation system in the RV lot will provide enough water to these new vines. I feel that this is a very reasonable alternative to address the concerns and Is a win for all of parties involved and will still provide us with a safe barrier to protect our property in the RV lot. I don't feel that having a chain link fence around a RV lot is an abnormal or unreasonable thing to expect. I actually think that this is the most common application/barrier used in other RV lots around the city. I appreciate your understanding and consideration. Thank You Alan Wiliingham Regional Vice President - Purchasing Standard Pacific Homes, Southern California 15360 Barranca Parkway Irvine, Ca 92618 Valerie Gullicksen From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Dan O'Malley <domalleyl4@gmail.com> Tuesday, April 28, 2015 4:50 PM austin.silva@carlsbadca.gov Valerie Gullicksen La Costa Valley Fence Mr. Silva, 1 am a homeowner in La Costa Valley and am writing to express my strong support for taking measures to enable the retention of the security fence that has been installed at the RV lot area. The fence provides a level of security, is not unattractive, and is commonly seen throughout Carlsbad. It is reasonable that a fence of this type is used to help deter crime and vandalism to vehicles and trailers parked at the facility. It is my understanding that the new fence has resulted in less instances of vandalism and theft. 1 hope to attend the meeting tomorrow, but want to express my opinion in case 1 cannot. 1 strongly support the fence and feel it protects an important asset at the La Costa Valley Community. Thank you for your consideration. Dan O'Malley 2931 Camino Serbal Sandra Arguelles From: Doug Dittrich <doug.dittrich@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, April 23, 2015 2:28 PM To: austin.silva@carlsbadca.gov Cc: Sandra Arguelles Subject: La Costa Valley RV lot fence Austin, I won't be able to attend the Carlsbad City Council meeting next week when the fence for the La Costa Valley RV lot fence will be discussed, but I wanted to share my viewpoint with you. I think that anyone who pays a monthly fee to store a boat, RV, or trailer in the lot deserves adequate security to protect their personal property. There were many reported break ins to items stored in the lot prior to the new fence being erected. As a cost effect security measure, I think the new fence has proven to be a prudent deterrent. Aesthetically, the new fence does not look very attractive; however after walking the power line access road I can't really understand what the issue is. There are 4-6 houses that back up to the fence and the only way you could see the barbed wire fence would be if you were in the upstairs of said houses and looked over the top of the existing back yard wooden fence. I do keep a utility trailer in the lot, so I have a vested interest in this decision. It would be cost prohibitive to have a full time security guard at the lot and intermittent security checks ever night would be ineffective. While no security measure can prevent a determined criminal, I think the razor wire 7 foot fence is an effective deterrent for the opportunistic bad guy. One solution would be to move new chain link fence inside the old fence and further down the slope. This would only apply to the section of fence that is adjacent to the power line access road closest to the houses. This would still maintain the security aspect ofthe fence while removing it from the sight line of the affected houses. By eliminating the RV lot as an easy theft target, it also lessens the attractiveness ofthe adjacent houses as targets as well. I hope my comments and others both pro and con are made public at the meeting. Thank you. Regards, Doug Dittrich 7996 Grado El Tupelo Carlsbad, CA 92009 Join me on my passive income joumey at freedom595.com Valerie Gullicksen From: Sandra Arguelles Sent: Thursday, March 27, 2014 3:47 PM To: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: FW: Landscape Request - La Costa Valley (Wiliingham Residence 3025Corte Baldre) Attachments: Gate.jpg; gate l.jpg From: Alan Wiliingham [mailto:AWilling@stanpac.com] Sent: Thursday, March 27, 2014 10:51 AM To: Sandra Arguelles Cc: Alan Wiliingham Subject: RE: Landscape Request - La Costa Valley (Wiliingham Residence 3025Corte Baldre) Sandra, Thank you again for ail of your help, everything has been handled and I would like you to know how impressed we are with PCM and your responsiveness. You guys do a great job... On another subject, the RV lot and newly installed fencing and gate system. Could you pass along to the board our thanks for responding to the need to reduce the risk of break in's by adding the taller fencing and more importantly the razor wire. I am confident that this will truly deter many culprits in the future and greatly assist in protecting our property, what a great enhancement to our facility. It is so nice to know that the board is listening to the homeowners when there are issues that need to be addressed in our neighborhood. I have a couple of simple suggestions for the board to consider in regards to the final installation of the new fencing and gate system at the RV lot. This is more of a future maintenance/cost issue and a bit of a security risk that I see from my professional opinion (See Below), i hope that this does sound like a criticism in any way for the wonderful job that has already been done with the new fencing. I have attached a few photos to represent my suggestions. 1) Automatic/Iron Gate area, since the gate is hinged to the adjacent block pilasters (see attached image) and the iron gate system just has a simple angled spike on the top of the gate and adjacent fence panel it makes it very simple to just jump upon top of the block pilaster on the outside and just step over the iron panel onto the pilaster on the inside and easily get over the fencing. The entire lot is very secure now and this one small area appears to be a very vulnerable and the weak link to a great fencing system. My suggestion would be to extend the rolled razor wire that is on the adjacent chain link fencing across the top the small gate panel and the top ofthe iron gates to eliminate this weak link in the entire security fencing that would be the first place that an intruder would focus on if they were trying to get over the fencing system. Again, I don't want this to come across as a criticism in anyway, just a suggestion... 2) Automatic Gate, I happen to be in the development business and have a lot of experience with automated entry gate systems, mostly in new community developments. It has been my experience in the past that security gates like these require a (heavy) magnetic latching system that securely latches the two gates together in the center once they close. These latching systems operate automatically when the motors are engaged to secure and release the gates from each other. Without the latching system on the gates the gate motors, gears and arms are very susceptible to damage by simply pushing on the gates in the center with moderate force. The cost involved in replacing the damaged motors or parts the first time that this occurs could be close to the cost to add the magnetic latching system to the gate that should reduce the risk of this ever happening. Just a suggestion from someone that has paid for gate motor repairs many times in the past... Valerie Gullicksen From: La Costa Valley <lacostavalleyclub@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, November 10, 2014 10:09 AM To: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: Fwd:Email SUPPLEMENTAL FOR BOARD PACKAGE Please include, thanks Respectfully, Nancy Wright Director of Recreation The VaUey Club 2280 Calle Barcelona Caflsbad, Ca. 92009 760-635-8633 — Forwarded message From: Isachsen <sbisachsen(5),gmail.com> Date: Mon, Nov 10, 2014 at 10:02 AM Subject: Re: HOA Meeting Agenda Highlights - - To; La Costa Valley <lacostavalleyclub(g),gmail.com> Hi, I am unable to attend the meeting tomorrow night, but do have direct experience with the following (please print and share with the Board); 5/21/13: Spot #15 had a boat's motor, steering, and navigation stolen (loss estimated to be $5000+). Police report was filed. The police estimated the crime took several hours to perform and a truck had to be backed in to lift and haul away the motor, which was several hundred pounds in weight. Approximately a month later, the thieves retumed to steal various other parts related specifically to the operation of the motor (additional bolts, fuel lines, steering mechanisms, etc). Since the new security fence has been installed no further thefts have been reported in spot #15. I strongly support leaving the new fence in place, along with adding user-specific gate electronic codes. I also would support the gardeners no longer using the RV storage lot for their vehicles, lunches, etc as this creates additional opportunities for crime, not from the gardeners themselves but from the gate opening and closing throughout the day as they drive in and out. Please let me know if any questions. Thanks, Bjom Isachsen 2949 Avenida Castana 760-271-0983 Valerie Gullicksen From: Gene Ma <genemal@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 18, 2013 10:53 PM To: Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RV lot theft Ms Gullicksen, This past weekend my trailer was once again, for the 4th time, vandalized. This time my trailer wheels and tires stolen and my trailer left on cinder blocks on the drum brakes/axle assembly. A police report was filed, case number 13-05964. At this time I would like to ask if the association carries any insurance at the property to reimburse the expenses I continue to incur as a result of repetitive incidents. I have tried to be reasonable and have approached the board to consider security cameras in the past. I would request that the board consider that as an action item once and for all. I understand that this was supposedly considered by a recent poll of the lot renters and there was a lack of interest, but I have been advised that an organization having been noticed of security concems who fail to act responsibly to protect the members remains liable. As I have said before, I am not interested in involving counsel. It just isn't my approach, as evidence by the 3 prior notifications of the association and my subsequent willingness to allow the board and management company to respond as they see fit. But please understand that at this point, after 3 prior acts of vandalism, I have just had it. The police officer who responded was surprised, to say the least, at the lack of security prevalent at the site, which he indicated was simply an invitation for vandalism at an unsecured RV lot. I would appreciate a timely response indicating the plan moving forward. Sincerely, Gene Ma 8041 Calle Pinon Carlsbad REPORTED RV LOT THEFTS/VANDALIZED ITEMS YEAR VICTIM PROPERTY/THEFT June 2008 December 2008 January 2009 2009-12 2010 March -May 2012 Gallucci Association Association Gene Ma Valley Crest N/A New Boat Motor/Mounts RV Lot Padlock RV Lot Gate Dates unclear/Reports at least 3 thefts between these years Golf Cart Stolen Drug paraphernalia and suspected illegal teen activity in and around resident RV. Multiple calls to Police to investigate. April 2012 Unclear Unclear (Police rec June 2012 Valley Crest Golf Cart June 2012 Association Fence August 2012 Survey to renters N/A January 2013 Capps Trailer/Misc. May 2013 Vierrg Outboard Motor May 2013 Vierrg Boat Cover May 2013 Universal Protection Board Members Security Meeting July 2013 Bemus Golf Cart August 2013 Bemus Tools/Equipment September 2013 Gene Ma Tires/ZWheels September 2013 Jacob Spolestra Tarp September 2013 Association RV Lot Gate September 2013 Universal Protection Guard Lock Box January 2014 Association Padlock stolen Febmary 2014 Mizock Broken window Febmary 2014 Chemus Tarp Febmary 2014 Steffemo FENCE INSTALLED FEBRURAY March 2014 August 2014 August 2014 Gene Ma Gene Ma Association Ransacked Unclear ATV Fence Valerie Gullicksen Subject: FW: RV lot status Original Message From: Lauren ToshefF [mailto:lauren(a)tosheff'.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 22, 2012 12:56 PM To: Brad W.; Susan Mendes; Thomas Krynicki; Thomas Normoyle; Nancy Wright; Valerie Gullicksen Subject: RV lot status Good Moming, The "gathering information" portion of this project is complete, here's what we have: 1. A homeowner (Lady X) spoke to Nancy confidentially to inform her that Lady X has hear rumors that kids are using the RV lot to use dmgs. 2. A homeowner (Gene Ma) wrote to the board about vandalism occurring in the RV lot. 3. Nancy observed 7 different kids entering the RV lot after school hours (between 2:50 and 3:10)on several different days. 4. Nancy, Valerie, Sara and 1 all have noticed and documented RV in space #8 accumulating trash over the last several days including broken beer bottle glass, broken cement blocks, matches, cigarette packages, food wrappers, empty mbbing alcohol bottle, empty sudafed bottle, tubing, matches, champagne bottle, paintball gun and more random trash. The trash is strewn over the hill about 3 spaces long, and today's new find was a mixing bowl upside down in the bushes with human waste in it. 5. Nancy observed one of the same boys (Boy Y) jumping the fence and entering RV in space #8. We know the family on record of ownership has an 8th grade boy. The address of the family on record is a house that(a friend of mine who is a few doors up neighbor from the family told me) has a history of police surveillance and a heroine arrest by the high school aged son.(heroine was found in the house, he was arrested for dealing heroine) The police were working cooperatively with the neighborhood to arrest the oldest son. The parents are going through a divorce and dad is not around (according to the neighbor). When 1 called the Carlsbad police station, he said the items found under and around the RV are commonly used to make Meth amphetamines. He suggested if a resident observes Boy Y jumping the fence, or entering the RV, we should call the 911 number and then meet them at the gate with the key to allow them access, so they can deal with the situation and get it sorted out. Here are our options: This moming Valerie, Sara and 1 did the quarterly walk through to look for violations. The lot #8 has many violations, as well as outdated registration and all the trash. Option 1. Send violation letter We use our security company to do what the police suggested- observe, call 911 and open the gate to allow access. This would require adding some time and money to this, since they usually don't start until 7pm. Option 2. hire heritage for extra time As a homeowner and resident, 1 can observe activity and call the police, then use my RV lot key to allow access. This would be as a RESIDENT and Boat owner. NOT AS A BOARD MEMBER. Option 3- 1 do the observing etc. Also as RESIDENTS and neighbors, if any ONE of us feels so compelled, we could contact the family. The BOARD would not recommend this ever. It's not the boards place to do it. Looking for feedback. I'm afraid this situation is more serious than just regular violations because of the content of the trash, and because I'm informed of what kids can do/make/use with that trash. Also as a boat owner 1 am concemed about my property being vandalized if there is opportunity to do so. Thoughts? Lauren March 25, 2015 City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 Ref: Case # MP 149V We are writing in reference to the Arroyo La Costa Master Plan amendment request made by the La Costa Valley Home Owners Association (HOA). We are home owners in the La Costa Valley HOA and are directly impacted by the amendment request; that is, we live within 100 feet ofthe fence in question and the fence is visible from multiple windows. The HOA is asking for a minor amendment to the master plan for this fence because they installed a 7 foot fence, topped with 3 wires of barbed wire and razor concertina wire. This was done without following established La Costa Valley HOA CC&R protocols. In addition, the HOA failed to obtain a permit from the city to proceed for making changes to and installing the fence. Moreover, the HOA disregarded the City's municipal code section 21.38.120-Amendment of the Master Plan, which reads as follows: 21.38.^20 - Amendment of master plan. A. An approved master plan may be amended pursuant to the following: 1. An application to amend a master plan shall be submitted in accordance with Section Ijl.ii.OSO of this chapter, or may be initiated by city council motion. 2. Minor IVIaster Plan Amendments. a. Master plan amendments, which are determined by the city planner to be minor in nature, may be approved, conditionally approved or denied by the planning commission at a public hearing noticed in accordance with Chapter Z|.54 of this title. i. A minor amendment shall not change the densities or boundaries of the subject property, or involve an addition of a new use or group of uses not shown on the original master plan, or the rearrangement of uses within the master plan. 3. Master Plan Amendments. a. Master plan amendments that are not minor in nature shall be processed in accordance with Section 21 S4.125 of this title. We are extremely disappointed that the HOA did not go through the proper CC&R protocol and city permitting process. Furthermore, the HOA did not solicit input from all stakeholders, especially the neighbors adjacent to the RV iot. To determine whether we were just "out of the loop" with respect to knowing about the plans to install this type of new fence, we conducted a survey ofthe neighborhood and found that no one in the neighborhood adjoining the location of the RV lot had detailed knowledge or direct notification about the plans for installing a new fence and most were shocked that there was no direct notification. Based on this reaction we rapidly collected 28 signatures to inform the HOA of our displeasure and to ask them to move a portion of the fence out of view of nearby homes (petition attached). This petition was presented to the HOA and neighbors attended multiple HOA meetings to implore the HOA committee to consider options for mitigating the harsh prison-type appearance of the new fence. While the HOA wisely decided to remove the razor wire, they have not been willing to address the issue of a non-conforming fence and consistently refuse to consider alternatives to the March 25, 2015 chain link barbed wire fence. Perhaps more importantly, the HOA has consistently minimalized the impact that the fence has on the views of the adjacent homeowners and its impact on property values. When we purchased our home, we were specifically interested in living in a City of Carlsbad Master Planned Community because we thought there was a rigorous process in place for evaluating changes to community Master Plans to protect home values. This HOA's actions will set a precedent for further modifications to La Costa Valley and could well serve as precedent for other HOA Master Plans that are not in keeping with the Carlsbad communities' aesthetic qualities. This could easily have deleterious effects on property values. Therefore my spouse and I request that the city deny the La Costa Valley HOA's requested amendment to the master plan and, if required, request an administrative hearing to be held. ^ IOI u -.v^ii'ieeberger and 7963 Paseo Aliso Carlsbad CA. 92009 city of Carlsbad „ uooom^ MAR 2 6 2015 March 23,2015 I To; Carlsbad Planning Commission Planning Division Re: Arroyo La Costa Valley Masterplan Amendment As a resident of La Costa Valley, I oppose a masterplan amendment to allow for the barbed wired fence around the RV parking area. If you have not seen it, the fence is unsightly and is probably more suited for a prison facility than a nice neighborhood. The fence is visible from outside the community and destroys the views of the bluffs when walkmg on the trail. Considering how strict the HOA has been on other community issues 1 am surprised and disappointed that this fence was allowed and request that it be removed and other security options explored. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Gary and Jamie Ng 7931 Paseo AUso Carisbad, CA 92009 Jennifer Hamler . _ , , , 2221 Vista La Nisa Carlsbad Carisbad, CA 92009 760-402-1015 MAR 2 6 2015 March 21,2015 Planning Division City of Carlsbad Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave Carisbad, CA 92008 Dear Sir: We received a letter dated March 17,2015 from the City of Carlsbad Planning Division regarding a change in the master plan (lot 124 of Carlsbad Tract No. 88-03- 1, ArroyaLa Costa, Unit 1. We are writing to object to this change. This fence is already up without a change in the plan and without the consent of the homeowners. Thank you for your consideration. Jen Hamler, resident of La Costa Valley City of Carlsbad MAR 2 5 2015 Plannir^ Division 2369 Avenida Helecho Carlsbad, CA March 23, 2015 Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA, 92008 Dear Sir/Madam: We are writing to voice our strong objections to the Administrative Master Plan Amendment, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. We are vehemently opposed to a 7 foot chain link fence topped by barbed wire that would change our beautiful neighborhood into an industrial park. So much effort has been taken to make this neighborhood beautiful, and a chain link fence topped with barbed wire would ruin that. It would encroach on the neighborhood, and degrade the beauty ofthe houses in the immediate vicinity. The people who wrote the original Master Plan had in mind a more beautiful neighborhood. It would be a shame for all of us to see their vision eroded through this action. We hope that this Master Plan Amendment will be defeated. Best regards. Elyse and Fred Cole 760 650 6801 City of Carlsbad MAR 2 3 2015 March 20, 2015 Planning Division City of Carlsbacl Planning Division 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 I am a resident of Arroyo La Costa and I would like to have documented my opposition to Case MP 149V, Arroyo La Costa Master Plan. I object to this proposed Master Plan amendment, because it is NOT aesthetically pleasing or in harmony with our community. We live in close proximity to the chain linked "barbed wire" fence that was installed around the RV/boat storage area in our community of La Costa Valley. Due to the extreme unappealing appearance of the fence, my family and I were under the impression it had to have been installed temporarily. Obviously we were wrong. We live in the cul de sac which faces the canyon where the barbed wire fence has been installed. We have the displeasure of seeing it from our driveway and bedrooms. The fence is comparable to a high security state prison fence. Not something we would have ever imagined being installed in our lovely neighborhood. I hereby request an administrative hearing. Sincerely, Tammy Atherton 2192 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 760-436-8788 March 23,2015 CityofCarlsbad Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 RE: MP 149V - Arroyo La Costa Master Plan I hereby strongly object to the granting of this Master Plan Amendment. My numerous objections (to this after the fact proposal) have already been documented to the City of Carlsbad Planning Department. I request that all of my letters, emails, photographs and any other complaints I've filed with the City regarding this matter, be included in your consideration. In addition to those comments, I object based on the following: • Chain Link fence topped with barbwire is not aesthetically pleasing, nor is it in harmony with the community. • HOA should provide an alternative to chain link/barbed wire, something that is more inline with the original look and feel of our community and the city of Carlsbad. • HOA has the burden of proof to prove that no other fencing material will provide the same level of security as chain link and barbwire. • The proposed application (which is already built] causes an undesirable change to scenic views or vistas from existing residential areas, public lands and roads. • The HOA does not have the scope of authority to ignore the CC&R's nor the City regulations. They should have notified the homeowners adjacent to the RV lot. They failed to do this or follow their own rules. • The CC&R's clearly indicate what fence t5^es or alterations are allowed without City Planning Department approval (see Section 7.2,4). The City of Carlsbad has found this to be a violation with the City "Master Fence" plan. • HOA illegally constructed this fence last year in February 2014. Shortly after that, a Petition To Relocate The RV Fence Topped With Barbed Wire And Razor Wire was signed by 36 residences, to relocate the fence to a lower elevation where it can't be seen by homeowners (see enclosed Petition). This was denied by the HOA. • Furthermore, the issue of security (according to our own security patrol) - had more to do with the old RV Lot gate not being closed or locked. Since an automatic gate with keypad entrance has been installed, unauthorized access has been solved. However, the HOA will have you believe crime is down due to the fence installation, but I maintain the automatic gate is the main reason why. • In August 2014, on a Saturday morning both the chain link fence, and existing (original) tubular steel fence was cut thru and a major theft occurred. An off-road ATV quad type vehicle was driven through that large opening and stolen. Proof that the chain link fence does not prevent crime. • Since the chain link/barbwire fence was installed, another break in occurred when someone climbed a tree, and jumped onto the Bemus landscape storage shed. • Bemus Landscape uses the RV lot as a maintenance yard for storing tools and equipment, as well as a large trash container. The constant traffic from Bemus employees is a disturbance to adjacent property owners. From approximately 6 AM to 3:30 PM on weekdays, Bemus' frequent trips in and out ofthe RV storage lot is providing access that is not in our best security interests. The automatic gate stays open for along time after any authorized user passes through. • According to our CC&R's and the City's Master Plan for this community, the use ofthe RV lot is intended only for Recreational Vehicle Storage. There are no provisions for Bemus (or any landscape company) to use the RV Storage Lot for other purposes. [Please see City Master Plan, Page 225 - #2 Use Allocation Use]. • Furthermore, Site planning and landscaping for this area shall provide adequate buffer to adjacent residences, in the form of berming and landscaping, from light and noise created by the RV parking use. Notice it says RV parking use, not landscape workers going in and out all day, further exposing the possibility for vandalism. [Please see City Master Plan, Page 226] • And that section goes on to say Landscaping and berming shall be provided on the west side of the Recreational Vehicle lot to ensure that the light and aesthetic impacts ofthe lot are sufficiently screened from development to the west as well as automobiles on El Camlno Real. This 7 plus foot chain link barbwire fence is even more visible than the original fence. Which is not in a state of disrepair, as the association maintains. • "One of the most dominant visual elements of a community is its fencing. It is essential for this element to be aesthetically pleasing [emphasis added] and provide continuity in design to unify the various architectural styles within individual neighborhoods into a single community theme". [Please see City Master Fence Plan, Page 69, Section G. Fencing] This project is far from aesthetically pleasing! For the reasons stated here (and others) I respectfully request that the City of Carlsbad deny this Master Plan Amendment. Therefore, I request an administrative hearing (if necessary) and the opportunity to present further evidence on this matter. Please let me know if there is any other information I can provide. I work from home, and would be happy to direct the City to all the public areas where I (and others) have identified where this unsightly mess can be seen. Thank you for your time. Respectfully submitted. feve Cilurzo :enclosures 3/18/2014 Petition To Relocate RV Fence Topped With Barbed Wire And Razor Wire We, the undersigned homeowners in La Costa Valley, adamantly request that the HOA of La Costa Valley move a portion ofthe fence topped with barbed wire and razor wire that surrounds the RV parking lot from its current position to the edge of the paved portion of the east side ofthe RV lot. This fence is currently visible from the street and from a number of homes in the neighborhood. This reduces home values and is not in keeping with the aesthetics of our community. We realize that security measures must be taken In view ofthe ongoing vandalism to the vehicles stored in the lot and the reports of under-age drinking and drug use there. The solution to this problem, however, should not detract from home values or compromise the beauty ofthe neighborhood surroundings. The La Costa Valley CC&Rs establish Architectural Control in Article 6 and the La Costa Valley Architectural Guidelines state "All of these elements shall be designed in harmony with the architectural style, color and proportionate to the residence to which it is associated." Furthermore, any architectural modification requires the signature of all affected, adjoining and neighboring residents on the application to assure awareness and allow each to express concerns over the modification. It is incomprehensible that he board did not follow the same process in addressing the security improvement solutions for the RV lot. The HOA must be aware that the reduction in property value this causes will be felt by all households in the La Costa Valley community. It is commonplace for a realtor to provide a client "comps" showing the sale prices of other nearby homes as a starting point for buy-price negotiations. Consequently, the reduction in value of one home in the community affects many homes. Because the purpose of the HOA is to protect home values, we adamantly request that the HOA take immediate and positive action to relocate the fence. Name Address 7963 Paseo Aliso lost ?as^ f\h&o CD cr: 3/18/2014 <4;^V^=^' ^VV--— i'?^^ P'Lu, Ms, ^7 • ' w^ A 6>^/-iL /V^ncf' _ ______ J CAAAiLi^^^jli-^ AAA iVs.-'A(..<30 t^M^ k^O /Wl^ Aczu p/)S,t C> Ac-/yj 2A Z. AiS^^^S 3/18/2014 <A' ' siTs^j^ — 2/77 Co^7£ /I fLDL^s 'jA-^ljA'^ 7*^"^/ P^-^"> 7fs'Z. P/Hi-^^ /U/^^ 7^^1 l^-^5e^ AtA-Sc ^A^A-•^/tA Z.^*-^ AAAA (24AA<8PA^ 9^/;',og \AAh Co-^-t Vv^^^J^A Ceivi^Z. Ah 92^ ~A<^3A <^'So Steve Cilurzo <cilurzo@att.net><^ October 19, 2014 8:31 PM To; Don Neu <Don.Neu@carlsbadca.gov> Cc: Chris DeCerbo <Chris.DeCerbo@carlsbadca.gov>, Van Lynch <Van.Lynch@carlsbaclca.gov>, Scott Rudinger <Scott.Rudinger@carlsbadca.gov> Re: La Costa Valley Master HOA RV Lot Fence 3 Attachments, 417 KB Dear Mr. Neu, We understand that the La Costa Valley Master Home Owners Association is appealing the Notice of Violation, issued by the City of Carlsbad on September 25, 2014 for violation of the CC&R's and the City of Carlsbad Zoning Ordinance, for constructing a fence without the proper permits or variance from the City. I would like to express to the City, that there is no argument they can make, that would excuse this blatant disregard for the CC&R's (the very Rules that we look for them to uphold in our community). This egregious action by the HOA, has been met with strong opposition from the property owners near and adjacent to the illegally constructed prison style fence. Homeowners have been attending the monthly Board Meetings, expressing our views, since the erection of the fence in late February of 2014. So if I seem rather zealous in my pursuit of this issue, it's because weVe become frustrated, with more than 8 months of trying to reason with them. Only to be told they will do nothing. Now that the City is involved, we took to you to hold them accountable and enforce the rules and procedures, that will allow us to comment directly to the City on this issue. At the October 14th HOA meeting, they told us they didnt think they need a permit for the fence on Association Property. However, I pointed out that the CC&R's Section 7.2.4 Fences clearly states: "No fence within a lot or the Association Property shall be constructed or altered as to type or height without approval ofthe City Planning Department..." It couldn't be anymore clearly stated. Yet, they seem to think the CC&R's don't apply to them. Please hold them to the same standards we all have to abide by. Scott Rudinger visited the site and verified that the fence type and height had been changed. Not to mention the offensive razor ribbon wire, that the City likes to discourage being used. He has seen it first hand, and then issued the Notice of Violation. Since a picture is worth a thousand words... here are a few to give you a better idea of what I am so irate about. You can see, it's a second fence. There is nothing wrong with the existing fence, that is harmonious with the community, and has been there over 16 years. It is a perfectly adequate fence, that is in good condition and blends in with the community. Ultimately, we want the fence removed, or moved out of sight. Property owners here agree that the fence has a negative impact on our property values, is unsightly and not in harmony with our community and the City of Carlsbad. Please do not grant the La Costa Valley Master HOA any appeal on the Notice of Violation. The City of Carlsbad is our only hope to get just resolution to this issue... that we have to live with everyday! Thank you for your time and help. Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 760-436-8788 Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 760-436-8788 September 22,2014 City of Carlsbad Code Enforcement Housing & Neighborhood Services 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Attention: Mr. Scott Rudinger RE: La Costa Valley Master HOA - RV Lot (Parcel # 255-251-50-00) Dear Mr. Rudinger, For the past 16 years, I have resided at 2176 Corte Arboles, Carlsbad, CA 92009, property located within the La Costa Valley Master Home Owners Association. My property is adjacent to the SDG&E easement road and Parcel #255-251-50-00, herein referred to as the RV Lot This letter shall serve as my formal complaint, that the La Costa Valley Master HOA has erected a second fence around the RV Lot, in direct violation of CC&R's, City of Carlsbad Zoning Ordinances, City Planning Department and the Architectural Committee. They constructed this illegal fence without obtaining the necessaiy building permits or prior approval of the City, nor did they notify and contact the adjacent property owners, prior to erecting a new fence as required by the CC&R's. According to the CC&R's: 7.2.4 Fences. All fences installed within the Property shall be in conformance with the fencing plan for La Costa Valley adopted by the City Planning Department. No fence within a Lot or the Association Property shall be constructed or altered as to type or height without the approval of the City Planning Department and the Architectural Committee. In the event fencing within the Property requires replacement, the replacement fence shall be substantially identical to the fence being replaced, unless other replacement fencing is approved by the City Planning Department and the Architectural Committee. This new chain link fence is seven (7) feet tall, topped with barb wire and razor ribbon wire, is in direct violation of that section of the CC&R's on four (4) counts. Plus it's contrary to the City of Carlsbad's own policy to discourage the use of razor wire. 1. This fence is not "in conformance with the fencing plan for La Costa Valley adopted by the City Planning Department". 2. This fence within the Association Property was constructed illegally in a manner which alters the "type or height without the approval ofthe City Planning Department". The fence type (specifically chain link, barb wire, and razor wire) has been changed, and the height has been altered. The chain link portion alone is in excess of 6 feet, and therefore requires approval and permits from the City of Carlsbad. 3. Further CC&R's section 7.2.4 states: "In the event fencing within the Property requires replacement, the replacement fence shall be substantially identical to the fence being replaced". This was not a replacement to the existing fence; it is new additional illegal construction, in violation of 7.2.4. 4. Furthermore, La Costa Valley Master HOA failed to get any approval by the City Planning Department to alter the Fencing Plan already in place for La Costa Valley. The La Costa Valley Master HOA constructed this fence in February of 2014, without consulting the adjacent homeowners or the City of Carlsbad. At subsequent board meetings, residents expressed concern for the appearance ofthe fence, and the adverse effect on property values. In May 2014, a "Petition" signed by 33 property owners, expressing our desire for the removal or relocation of the fence out of view (see attached copy) was submitted to the HOA. The "Petition" conveys the sentiment of residents who agree that the fence has a negative effect on homeowner's property values. However, the La Costa Valley Master Association has rejected any ideas submitted and decUned move or eliminate the unsightly and objectionable fence. As property owners, we wish to preserve our property values and the Master Plan for this community. During the June 2014, home owners association meeting, I specifically asked if all the proper permits were obtained for constructing this prison type of fence, and I was told: "yes, we have everything". Now I have come to learn that a neighbor asked this same question at a previous board meeting and she was told the same thing. Apparently, nothing could be further from the truth. On September 15,2014,1 spoke with Mr. Van Lynch in the Carlsbad Planning Department, who confirmed that fencing taller than six (6) feet would require approval of the City Planning Department Upon searching Parcel # 255-251-50-00 (the RV Lot), he confirmed that no such permit had been issued and referred me to you, Mr. Rudinger in the Code Enforcement department Mr. Lynch also expressed that the City likes to "discourage the use of razor wire" in particular. After confirming measurements on the chain link portion of the fence, I called your office and verbally filed a complaint This letter shall serve as my formal complaint and request that the City of Carlsbad enforce this blatant code violation to the full extent of the law, including but not limited to removal ofthe chain link fence, barbwire, and razor wire. For 16 years, there has been an existing approved fence surrounding the RV Lot For whatever perceived security reason, the La Costa Valley HOA has ignored if s own CC&R's and the City of Carlsbad, constructing a second fence illegally. Since this action, I believe if s just brought more attention to the RV Lot I respectfully request that the City of Carlsbad require the La Costa Valley Master Home Owners Association to remove the illegally constructed fence and comply with the Master Plan and City Zoning Ordinances. Finally, 1 would Uke to request that I (and other property owners) be kept informed of any request for a zoning ordinance change, or building permits requested in connection with the subject property and fence issue. We would also appreciate a response on how the City plans to address this issue with the HOA. Thank you for your time and help. Sincerel Steve Cilurzo cc: Mr. Van Lynch, City of Carlsbad Planning Department it PROFESSIONAL COMMUNITY HANAGEMENT m ASSOCIA COMPANY Better Living. Maintainetl 5950 La Place Court, Suite #250 I Carlsbad I CA 92008 Direct (760) 918-8055 I Main (760) 918-8040 IToll Free (800) 599-9151 sarguelles(ajpcminternet.com • www.pcminternet.com Associa® - Delivering unsurpassed management and lifestyle services to communities woridwide. Connect f * '5 From: Chris DeCerbo [mailto:Chris.DeCerbo@carlsbadca.qov] Sent: Thursday, October 23, 2014 3:51 PM To: Sandra Arguelles Cc: Chris DeCerbo; Don Neu; Glen Van Peski; Gina Ruiz; Van Lynch Subject: La Costa Valley HOA Fence Dear Sandra, I am a Principal Planner for the City of Carlsbad. I spoke with Valerie Gullickson from your office last week regarding the La Costa Valley HOA illegal RV Lot fence and told her that I would let her know what she needed to do after I completed research into the specifics of the issue. It is my recommendation that the La Costa Valley HOA apply to the City of Carlsbad for a Consistency Determination to construct any other type of fence around the RV Lot than is currently allowed by the La Costa Valley IVIaster Plan (see attachment). A Consistency Determination is an administrative policy that could allow the City Planner the discretion to approve an alternative type offence provided the applicable findings can be made (see attachment). Please contact me if you have any questions regarding this. Sincerely, Chris Ccityof Csrlsbsd Chris DeCerbo Principal Planner City of Carlsbad 1635 FaradayAvenue Carlsbad, CA. 92008-7314 (760) 602-4611 chris.decerbo@carlsbadca.gov PCM is an Associa Member Company- The nation's leader in community association management. Notice: This e-mail message is for the sole use of the intended recipient{S) and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are nof the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-rnail and destroy ali copies ofthe original message. Please virus check all attachments to prevent widespread contamination and corruption of files and operating systems. The unauthorized access, use, disclosure, or distribution of this email may constitute a violation of the Federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 and similar stale laws. This corrirminication does not reflect an intention by the sender or the sender's client or principal to conduct a transaction or make any agreement by electronic 2 Chris DeCerbo From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Chris DeCerbo Friday, October 24, 2014 10:03 AM 'Sandra Arguelles' Glen Van Peski; Don Neu; Van Lynch; Chris DeCerbo; Gina Ruiz RE: La Costa Valley HOA Fence Hi Sandra, I would strongly encourage that the La Costa Valley HOA take some time to share fence ideas with and achieve some general consensus with the surrounding La Costa Valley homeowners prior to making a submittal of a security fence design for a Consistency Determination. In my communications with one ofthe residents, the point was made that perhaps a security fence located down the slope of the RV parking lot could achieve the same security objectives while not compromising the aesthetics of the community. Thank You, Chris C City of Carisbad Chris DeCerbo Principal Planner City of Carlsbad 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA. 92008-7314 (760) 602-4611 chris.decerbo(a)carlsbadca.gov From: Sandra Arguelles [mailto:sarguelles@pcminternet.com] Sent: Friday, October 24, 2014 9:30 AM To: Chris DeCerbo Cc: Don Neu; Glen Van Peski; Gina Ruiz; Van Lynch Subject: RE: La Costa Valley HOA Fence Got it, thank you for the information. Best regards, Sandra Arguelles Administrative Assistant SEP 2 2 2014 Steve Cilurzo 2176 Corte Arboles Carlsbad, CA 92009 760-436-8788 September 22,2014 City of Carlsbad Code Enforcement Housing & Neighborhood Services 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Attention: Mr. Scott Rudinger RE: La Costa Valley Master HOA - RV Lot (Parcel # 255-251-50-00) Dear Mr. Rudinger, For the past 16 years, I have resided at 2176 Corte Arboles, Carlsbad, CA 92009, property located within the La Costa Valley Master Home Owners Association. My property is adjacent to the SDG&E easement road and Parcel #255-251-50-00, herein referred to as the RV Lot This letter shall serve as my formal complaint that the La Costa Valley Master HOA has erected a second fence around the RV Lot in direct violation of CC&R's, City of Carlsbad Zoning Ordinances, City Planning Department and the Architectural Committee. They constructed this illegal fence without obtaining the necessary building permits or prior approval ofthe City, nor did they notify and contact the adjacent property owners, prior to erecting a new fence as required by the CC&R's. According to the CC&R's: 7.2.4 Fences. All fences installed within the Property shall be in conformance with the fencing plan for La Costa Valley adopted by the City Planning Department No fence within a Lot or the Association Property shall be constructed or altered as to type or height without the approval ofthe City Planning Department and the Architectural Committee. In the event fencing within the Property requires replacement the replacement fence shall be substantially identical to the fence being replaced, unless other replacement fencing is approved by the City Planning Department and the Architectural Committee. This new chain link fence is seven (7) feet tall, topped with barb wire and razor ribbon wire, is in direct violation ofthat section of the CC&R's on four (4) counts. Plus if s contrary to the City of Carlsbad's own policy to discourage the use of razor wire. 1. This fence is not "in conformance with the fencing plan for La Costa Valley adopted by the City Planning Departmenf'. 2. This fence within the Association Property was constructed illegally in a manner which alters the "type or height without the approval of the City Planning Departmenf. The fence tj^e (specifically chain link, barb wire, and razor wire) has been changed, and the height has been altered. The chain link portion alone is in excess of 6 feet and therefore requires approval and permits from the City of Carlsbad. 3. Further CC&R's section 7.2.4 states: "In the event fencing within the Property requires replacement the replacement fence shall be substantially identical to the fence being replaced". This was not a replacement to the existing fence; it is new additional illegal construction, in violation of 7.2.4. 4. Furthermore, La Costa Valley Master HOA failed to get any approval by the City Planning Department to alter the Fencing Plan already in place for La Costa Valley. The La Costa Valley Master HOA constructed this fence in February of 2014, without consulting the adjacent homeowners or the City of Carlsbad. At subsequent board meetings, residents expressed concern for the appearance of the fence, and the adverse effect on property values. In May 2014, a "Petition" signed by 33 property owners, expressing our desire for the removal or relocation the fence out of view (see attached copy) was submitted to the HOA. The "Petition" conveys the sentiment of residents who agree that the fence has a negative effect on homeowner's property values. However, the La Costa Valley Master Association has rejected any ideas submitted and declined move or eliminate the unsightly and objectionable fence. As property owners, we wish to preserve our property values and the Master Plan for this community. During the June 2014, home owners association meeting, I specifically asked if all the proper permits were obtained for constructing this prison type of fence, and I was told: "yes, we have everything". Now I have come to learn that a neighbor asked this same question at a previous board meeting and she was told the same thing. Apparently, nothing could be further from the truth. On September 15,2014,1 spoke with Mr. Van Lynch in the Carlsbad Planning Department who confirmed that fencing taller than six (6) feet would require approval of the City Planning Department Upon searching Parcel # 255-251-50-00 (the RV Lot), he confirmed that no such permit had been issued and referred me to you, Mr. Rudinger in the Code Enforcement department Mr. Lynch also expressed that the City likes to "discourage the use of razor wire" in particular. After confirming measurements on the chain link portion of the fence, I called your office and verbally filed a complaint This letter shall serve as my formal complaint and request that the City of Carlsbad enforce this blatant code violation to the full extent of the law, including but not limited to removal ofthe chain link fence, barbwire, and razor wire. For 16 years, there has been an existing approved fence surrounding the RV Lot For whatever perceived security reason, the La Costa Valley HOA has ignored if s own CC&R's and the City of Carlsbad, constructing a second fence illegally. Since this action, I believe if s just brought more attention to the RV Lot I respectfully request that the City of Carlsbad require the La Costa Valley Master Home Owners Association to remove the illegally constructed fence and comply with the Master Plan and City Zoning Ordinances. Finally, 1 would like to request that I (and other property owners) be kept informed of any request for a zoning ordinance change, or building permits requested in connection with the subject property and fence issue. We would also appreciate a response on how the City plans to address this issue with the HOA. Thank you for your time and help. Sincerely^ Steve Cilurzo 'xc: Mr. Van Lynch, City of Carlsbad Planning Department 3/18/2014 Petition To Relocate RV Fence Topped With Barbed Wire And Razor Wire We, the undersigned homeowners in La Costa Valley, adamantly request that the HOA of La Costa Valley move a portion of the fence topped with barbed wire and razor wire that surrounds the RV parking lot from its current position to the edge of the paved portion of the east side of the RV lot. This fence is currently visible from the street and from a number of homes in the neighborhood. This reduces home values and is not in keeping with the aesthetics of our community. We realize that security measures must be taken in view of the ongoing vandalism to the vehicles stored in the lot and the reports of under-age drinking and drug use there. The solution to this problem, however, should not detract from home values or compromise the beauty ofthe neighborhood surroundings. The La Costa Valley CC&Rs establish Architectural Control in Article 6 and the La Costa Valley Architectural Guidelines state "All of these elements shall be designed in harmony with the architectural style, color and proportionate to the residence to which it is associated." Furthermore, any architectural modification requires the signature of all affected, adjoining and neighboring residents on the application to assure awareness and allow each to express concerns over the modification. It is incomprehensible that he board did not follow the same process in addressing the security improvement solutions for the RV lot. The HOA must be aware that the reduction in property value this causes will be felt by all households in the La Costa Valley community. It is commonplace for a realtor to provide a client "comps" showing the sale prices of other nearby homes as a starting point for buy-price negotiations. Consequently, the reduction in value of one home in the community affects many homes. Because the purpose of the HOA is to protect home values, we adamantly request that the HOA take immediate and positive action to relocate the fence. AP 7963 Paseo Aliso 3/18/2014 \Av^ iAA/^ dxJl l'?^^ /i^^, /^J(/ Ai ^j,.,^. A Cii^ ... <^^Aui. [A • Kt^^^w-^ (AAAIU^^AI''^ AAA ?<;^S.-'A(.,.-(50 AA ^^^^ AAAikA tiVi^ ?a^^o f\l)^ f^iiAmtA •———~ * ' • ^ r— /^•-Zd.. A/?<,AC> /^^N 0 212- •iO'MB A)24S0^S 3/18/2014 2/77 Co/^7B AfLDl^s '' A^.y (A 'Tz^o^'x Aim fcis-^> Auso l<f^'L PMi^r^ 'MJ<^O <^^-<^ cA°\ T_oo^ ' _AJAA^ (2^AA'^ 'BPhd ^/yL ckA<UZAf\ 92^}^ V (CARLSBAD riLC Comnnunity & Economic Development www.carlsbadca.gov March 25, 2015 Valerie Gullickson Professional Community Management Suite 250 5950 La Place Court Carlsbad, CA 92008 SUBJECT: MP 149V - ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN - CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT (CEQA) APPLICABILITY/PROCESS OETERMINATION AND TARGET DECISION DATE CEQA Determination: This is to advise you that after reviewing the application for the project referenced above, the City has determined that the following environmental review process (pursuant to CEQA) will be required for the project: The project is exempt from the provisions of CEQA, pursuant to CEQA Categorical Exemption for Accessory Structures (Section 15311). No environmental review is required for the project. A Notice of Exemption will be filed after approval of the project with the San Diego County Clerk's Office which involves a filing fee. Please submit a check to the project planner in the amount of $50.00 made out to the San Diego County Clerk. The check should be submitted approximately one week prior to the City Planner decision date. Target Decision Date: In the interest of expeditiously processing your application consistent with the State Permit Streamlining Act (California Government Code Section 65950), an administrative decision to approve or deny the project should be determined by May 22, 2015. For additional information related to this CEQA applicability/process determination or should you have any questions regarding an application extension or would like to withdraw your application, please contact Austin Silva at (760) 602-4631 or by email at austin.silva@carlsbadca.gov. Sincerely, DON NEU, AlCP City Planner DN:AS:fn c; Chris DeCerbo, Principal Planner Michele Masterson, Senior Management Analyst File Copy Data Entry Planning Division 1635 FaradayAvenue, Carlsbad, CA 92008-7314 T 760-602-4600 F 760-602-8559 A • • W\qiW3/^i/r CITY OF tru C Community & Economic Development www.carlsbadca.gov March 5, 2015 1^ Valerie Gullickson Professional Community Management Suite 250 5950 La Place Court Carlsbad, CA 92008 SUBJECT: 1st REVIEW FOR MP 14-9V - ARROYO LA COSTA MASTER PLAN Thank you for applying for Land Use Permits in the City of Carlsbad. The Planning Division ha: reviewed your Master Plan Amendment, application no. MP 14-9V, as to its completeness for processing. The application is complete, as submitted. Although the initial processing of your application may have already begun, the technical acceptance date is acknowledged by the date of this communication. The City may, in the course of processing the application, request that you clarify, amplify, correct or otherwise supplement the basic information required for the application. The Planning Division will begin processing your application as of the date of this communication. In order to expedite the processing of your application, you are strongly encouraged to contact your Staff Planner, Austin Silva, at (760) 602-4631, to discuss or to schedule a meeting to discuss your application and to completely understand this letter. Sincerely, CHRIS DeCERBO Principal Planner CD:AS:fn c: Don Neu, City Planner Chris DeCerbo, Principal Planner IVIichele Masterson, Senior Management Analyst File Copy Data Entry Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue. Carlsbad, CA 92008-7314 T 760-602-4600 F 760-602-8559 0 Planning Di^^ion Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name: /T^^ m A^ A/A^ Name: Address: ^^AA ^^^^ AUAA>y^<^ P<rrni\r d^m^L -F^TCKL C«J>^S Planning Di^Aion Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name: / Name: Address A9AI Pa^co A^/Ao Planning Divrsion Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name: A-rf>nCA(^ Name: Address : T^5~/ /^.^-Tf-Q /^^^ ^6 Planning Dii^ion Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name ( I. Name: Address: A ooo Planning Division Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name: M" (_.^JS~ Name: /C^ Address: CA^.^. AU Akk) A ^ RV tA \cA . S^<^<^o-tM issue 'i [oh o\ ' ^ Planning Division Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name:. Name Address: P^A€^ IAM ' . -.-w.- ^^^^^ r'^^ Planning Division Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name: Name Address: S^lAl QjmX< O^^v^oca^/ 0»^n^\aA^^ . ..W^c -lot. r ' r\ts^^^ I'T ^ r - Planning Division Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name:_ Name: Address: 7^^^ P^<.^ MlCP . C^^^^ ^'"^ ' l>H«^ Planning Division Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name:_ Name: Address: Project Name: Planning Division Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Name: AA A^^^ Address: ^/Al-^ \ kj^O lAkgJ^^ * Lc^ AirY\^ (rc:^t=i«^ N UAA for .z^cz^ien ' , ^ A of cn^osorc Planning Division Pfozi'^c Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip -for- \o,s>-^ Project Name:. Name: Address: HO A I h ^ ^P'V^*^'^ V 6c>(tci {jo^ii os^ nc^Af-fe * ehc^oS^r-*^ /Sofe^-(^) chain ^ Planning Division Administrative Hearing Speaker Slip Project Name:. Name: Address 7 ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING on APRIL 29, 2015 SIGN IN SHEET NAME ADDRESS EMAILADDRESS 2/7^ <c^/&r(^ A'^Ae<. Oj^otj^z^eAT^A^tj^ A n A 7M 4 imr/(e J^lSl\ \A1\ 14.. D)A^-^ Se^-L] fes-^ AfK^ V ,C#»^ Hou\c^ Ki^'\1)CrL 7S5^5>Tlo ^2oot.' Cc<,<3 NAME ADDRESS EMAILADDRESS C\(Ar^ (^a(<AicA z'7^0 Ac>t7\d/^A.