HomeMy WebLinkAbout3190; Rancho Sante Fe Road Bridge Replacement; Rancho Sante Fe Road Bridge Replacement; 2005-03-01PREPARED FOR:
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carlsbad, CA 92008
PREPARED BY:
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
605 Third Street
Encinitas, CA 92024
I
C 2004
i ANNUAL MilTIGATION ACTIVITT
: REPORT
r
k
z
r
m k
k
[
r
Rancho Santa Te Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project
Prepared for:
. City of Carisbad
li 1635 Faraday Avenue
Carlsbad, California 92008
L Contact: Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Tel: (760) 602-2746
Prepared by:
DUDEK
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
Pro^Hlorud Ttamt fot Complex Prt^eett
605 Third Street
Encinitas, California 92024
Comact: Kam Muri
Tel: (760) 479-4292
Mlarch 2005
fm
m
c
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project
TABLE or CONTENTS
Section Page No.
1.0 INTRODUCTION 1
2.0 COASTAL CALIFORNIA GNATCATCHER MITIGATION ITEMS 1
2.1 Avoidance of Breeding Season 1
2.2 Avoidance of Noise Impacts 4
2.3 Nest Ske Protection 4
2.4 Employee Education Program 4
3.0 BIOLOGICAL MONITORING 5
3.1 Construction Activities 5
3.2 Monitoring Activities 9
3.3 Monthly Monkorkig Reports 9
4.0 HABITAT ACQUISITION & ENDOWMENT FUND 9
5.0 WETLANDS HABITAT MITIGATION ITEMS 10
Listof rfgures
Figure 1 Regional Map 2
Figure 2 Vicinity Map 2
Figure 3 Site Photographs 6
^ Figure 4 Site Photographs 7
Figure 5 Site Photographs 8
Appendix A Employee Education Program Informational Handout
Appendk B Rainy Season Action
Appendix C Monthly Monitoring
4186-01
1^:^-^—'March 8. 2005
z
L
[
I
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project
1.0 INTRODUCTION
This annual report summarizes the progress and completion of various mitigation activities
associated wkh the Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project
(Project) in 2004, in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Biological Opinion
issued bythe U.S. Fish and WildUfe Service (USFWS) on January 23,2002. The Project affects
a subset of the area covered by the Habitat Conservation Plan/Ongoing Multi-species Plan
for Properties in the Southeast Quadrant of the City of Carisbad, CaUforna (HCP) (City of
Cadsbad 1995) (Figures 1 and 2). Construction of the project is occurring in two phases.
^ Phase 1 of the project includes the roadway realignment between the La Costa Avenue
^ intersection in the south to approximately the intersection of Rancho Santa Fe Road and San
Elijo Road in the north. Construction of Phase 1 began in 2002 and the new roadway opened
to traffic on June 21, 2004. Phase 2 of the project includes construction of the new bridge at
San Marcos Creek, demoUtion of the existing bridge and roadway construction of the
realigned Rancho Santa Fe Road between San Elijo Road and Melrose Drive. Initial
vegetation clearing for Phase 2 began in January 2004 and construction was initiated in May
2004.
Mitigation activities conducted in 2004 consisted of on-going biological monitoring of
construction activities to ensure compliance with various resource permits including the
completion of specific monitoring measures related to the protection of the federaUy-listed
threatened coastal California gnatcatcher (Polioptila californica californica; gnatcatcher). In
addkion, mitigation activkies included on-going preparation, design and implementation of
the wetlands mitigation program for impacts to wetlands. The discussion below provides
documentation for each of these activities.
2.0 COASTAL CAUFORNIA GNATCATCHER MITIGATION ITEMS
f 2.1 Avoidance of Breeding Season
IM
E Vegetation clearing for Phase 2 of the project was completed in February 2004, prior to the
start of the gnatcatcher breeding season (February 15 - August 31). Coastal sage scrub and
scrub oak chaparral vegetation was cleared within the Phase 2 project limits along the west
P side of the existing Rancho Santa Fe Road between San Elijo Road and Melrose Avenue.
mmm SlASSOCIATES, INC.
4186-01
March 8, 2005
Orange
County
r-SMiles
San Diego
Imperial
Beach ™ OtayMesaVL—_
Tijuana Mexico
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment & Bridge Replacement Project
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Regional Map
FIGURE
;
'Mm \
\Li:u' /':i..'l^ ^ifc
Sancj and Gravel - ^ ^ ^
SM I76,f I
Rancho Santa Fe Rd Phase 1 Project Liniits
Rancho Santa Fe Rd Phase 2 Project Limits
BASE MAP SOURCE: USGS, 7.5 Minute Series, Rancho Santa Fe Quadrangle
2000
Scale in Feet
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment & Bridge Replacement Project
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Vicinity Map
FIGURE
r
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project
Focused USFWS protocol-level surveys for gnatcatcher were conducted by Dudek wUdUfe
biologist Anita Hayworth, Ph.D. (TE-781084) in suitable habitat wkhin 500 feet of the Phase
2 project limits prior to the start of construction activities in May 2004. Results of the
surveys were negative and were submitted to USFWS in a survey report dated May 25,2004.
2.2 Avoidance of Noise Impacts
As discussed above in Section 2.1, focused surveys for gnatcatcher conducted throughout
sukable habitat wkhin 500 feet of the Phase 2 project limits were negative. Therefore,
gnatcatcher monitoring activities and the implementation of noise mitigation measures was
not required.
2.3 Nest Site Protection
ll Vegetation clearing activities in 2004 were limked to the Phase 2 project area and were
completed in February 2004 prior to the start of the gnatcatcher breeding season. No clearing
^ or grading activkies took place wkhin habitat occupied by gnatcatcher during the gnatcatcher
breeding season. All vegetation clearing associated with Phase 1 of the project was completed
g in February 2002 prior to the start of the breedkig season.
p 2.4 Employee Education Program
h
In accordance with the requirements of the USFWS Biological Opinion, Dudek biologisk
r Kamarul Muri conducted an employee education meeting onsite for new construction crews
associated with Phase 2 on May 24, 2004. Dudek identified native habitat areas adjacent to
E the project and highlighted senskive biological resources associated with the project includmg
the federally-listed threatened coastal CaUfornia gnatcatcher and wetlands regulated by the
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the California Regional Water QuaUty Control Board
E (RWOCB) and the California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG). An informational
brochure prepared by Dudek was also provided to all in attendance at the meeting to provide
E general information regarding biological resources in the area and to provide guidelines for
avoiding impacts to adjacent native habitat areas (Appendix A).
DUDEK 4186-01
& ASSOCIATES, INC. ,, . „ ofinc
^P^i^T^^c^e^ March 8. 2005
I
E
Z
Z
Z
c
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project
3.0 BIOLOGICAL MONITORING
3.1 Construction Activities
The Biological Opinion issued by USFWS requires that a qualified biologist be onsite when
construction activities are taking place adjacent to sensitive habitat areas. Sensitive habitat
areas adjacent to the Phase 2 project include coastal sage scrub and southern mixed chaparral
located to the west of the project and wetlands associated with San Marcos Creek in the
northern portion of Phase 2.
Beginning with initial vegetation clearing activkies in January 2004, Dudek biologists have
maintained a periodic schedule of daUy or weekly biological monkoring as necessary based
upon the location and extent of construction activities. Construction activities in 2004
included installation of perimeter fencing and construction ske Best Management Practicies
(BMPs), vegetation clearing, installation of temporary stream diversion culverts, excavation
and construction of bridge piers, construction of bridge spans and associated false-work, mass
grading and associated earth work including rock crushing and screenkig, and the
construction of subsurface storm drain facUities.
Temporary Diversion of San Marcos Creek
The natural fiow of San Marcos Creek through the bridge ske in Phase 2 was redirected
through a temporary stream diversion culvert constructed at the start of Phase 2 construction
in May 2004 (Figurt3). The temporary stream diversion culvert was designed to carry stream
flow during low fiow conditions and wUl remain in place untU the completion of project
construction. The diversion of San Marcos Creek through the bridge site was necessary to
allow construction activity to occur at the bridge ske wkhout working directly wkhin the
flowing portions of the creek.
The temporary stream diversion culverts were constructed using three 20-inch steel pipes
placed at approximately 10 to 12 inches below the existing grade of the creek bottom and
extend approximately 280 linear feet between the upstream and downstream Umks of the
project (Figure 4). Creek flows were redirected into the temporary culverts by manually
constructing an earthen berm across the natural fiow channel of the creek. At the
downstream limits of the project, the culvert was constructed to outlet into an existing
DUDEK
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
4186-01
March 8,2005
?rJOTO 4
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment & Bridge Replacement Project - 2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Site Photographs
FIGURE
PHOTO 6
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment & Bridge Replacement Project
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Site Photographs
FIGURE
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment & Bridge Replacement Project
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Site Photographs
FIGURE
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
^ Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project
L secondary channel of San Marcos Creek (Figurt 5). The culvert outlet area was stabUized by
placement of smaU rip-rap in the channel bed and bank. Prior to backfilling the onsite portion
of the creek, an effort was made to identify aquatic species remaining within the channel to
determine if translocation would be necessary. However, only non-native species were
identified including non-native fish species, bullfrog (Rana cattsbiana) and signal crayfish
(Pacifastacus leniusculs).
Excavation and Construction of Bridge Piers
Due to their location within San Marcos Creek, the excavation and construction of the bridge
piers required the management of surface water associated with the creek as weU as ground
water. As described above, surface flows associated with San Marcos Creek were redirected
through temporary stream diversion culverts that outiet into a secondary channel along the
downstream project limits. Due to the presence of groundwater within excavated pits, the
excavation and construction of the bridge piers required the temporary extraction and storage
of groundwater onsite. During pier construction, ground water was extracted from the active
excavation and pumped into adjacent pier excavations and an onsite storage tank for
temporary storage. Some of the ground water stored onsite was used to supply water trucks
onsite for dust control. Pier excavations used to store groundwater were backfiUed once
construction of the bridge piers was complete.
Flooding of San Marcos Creek
FoUowing the completion of the bridge piers in September 2004, the entire bridge site was
lined with rock to provide a solid foundation for false work installation and as a protective
measure to prevent soUs being washed downstream during winter flooding events. All
construction equipment and materials were promptly removed from the bridge site prior to
forecasted rain events, and no construction occurred within ponded or flowing portions of
the creek.
Rainy Season Action Plan
IP
An action plan identifying specific site BMPs that are to be updated and deployed prior to
^ forecasted rain events was prepared by the contractor and construction management at the
start of the rainy season. The plan describes existing the condition of existing BMPs to
r DUDEK & ASSOCIATES. INC.
4186-01
March 8, 2005
k
f k
Z
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project
throughout the site and the appropriate action to be taken in the even of forecasted rain
(Appendix B).
3.2 Monitoring Activities
Beginning with initial Phase 2 vegetation clearing activities in Januar/ 2004, Dudek biologists
^ maintained a periodic schedule of daily and weekly biological monitoring as necessary based
L upon the location and extent of construction activities. Construction activities were
monitored to ensure that no impacts to adjacent conservation areas occurred and that
^ adequate measures were in place to minimize potential indirect impacts, such as dust, runoff,
etc.
^ In addition to regular monitoring of construction activities, the inlet and outlet of the stream
^ diversion culverts were checked regularly by Dudek for signs of erosion or sedimentation.
^ Downstream portions of the creek adjacent to the project were also monitored to determine
if existing habitat was being adversely affected by the redirected creek flows and groundwater
*^ extraction activities. Dudek also performed monitoring of perimeter fencing and erosion
control and water quality-related BMPs. Orange perimeter fencing and ske BMPs were
checked and construction management was notified immediately if maintenance or repairs
^ were necessary.
^ 3.3 Monthly Reports
In accordance wkh the BO, monthly reports were submkted to the City and USFWS
^ summarizing ongoing monitoring activities carried out by Dudek. Monthly reports from
pp» 2004 are included as Appendix C of this report.
4.0 HABITAT ACQUISITION AND ENDOWMENT FUND
In accordance wkh the requirements of the HCP adopted in the Biological Opinion for the
project, over 622 acres of native lands have been transferred as onsite mitigation for several
individual projects including the City's Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge
Replacement Project. A Conservation Easement was recorded in favor of the California
Department of Fish and Game (CDFG) on January 11, 2002. In addition, an endowment in
DUDEK SASSOCIAimiNC.
4186-01
Pttfttilmd •Omnt Cl 111(11 ir Prttttf March 8.2005 10
c
E
2004 Annual Mitigation Activity Report
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project
U the amount of $891,962 was provided to the Center for Natural Lands Management for the
long-term management of the preserved habitat.
^ 5.0 WETLANDS HABITAT MITIGATION ITEMS
Wetlands mitigation for the Rancho Santa Fe Road project is being implemented in two
^ phases: an onsite revegetation/restoration effort at the location of the existing Rancho Santa
b Fe Road bridge at San Marcos Creek and around the margins of the new bridge, and an offsite
mitigation/revegetation effort located within the University Commons project along
upstream portions of San Marcos Creek. The offsite mitigation program for the Rancho
Santa Fe Road project wUl be located adjacent to separately planned mitigation/revegetation
areas being implemented by Brookfield Homes, Inc. (Brookfield) as mitigation for the
b University Commons project. The Brookfield and City mitigation programs are contiguous
^ to one another but are being implemented as separate installation and
^ maintenance/monitoring projects.
In 2004, planning for the onsite and offsite wetlands mitigation programs of the Rancho
Santa Fe Road project included finaUzing the revegetation construction documents (i.e. plans
and specifications) for each project. Both sets of plans were revised in 2004 and are pending
future implementation by the City in 2005/2006.
The implementation of the onsite wetlands restoration work at the existing Rancho Santa
Fe Road bridge site is contingent upon the completion of the new bridge and demolition of
the old bridge. The restoration work cannot be instaUed untU the new bridge is buUt and
opened and the old bridge has been removed. The onsite restoration work occurs at the
existing bridge site and within the limits of construction boundaries for the new bridge.
Final revegetation grading plans for the offsite wetland mitigation program at University
Commons were prepared by O'Day Consultants in late 2004/early 2005, and are currently
pending final approval by the City of San Marcos. Revegetation grading and instaUation of
the Brookfield portion of the wetlands mitigation at University Commons was implemented
in the Fall of 2004 and wUl be completed sometime in 2005 pending weather delays.
Implementation of the Rancho Santa Fe Road offsite wetlands mitigation portion at
University Commons wiU likely foUow completion of the Brookfield portion. Coordination
will be required between Brookfield and the City of Carlsbad in order to avoid impacts to
previously installed portions.
DUDEK 4186-01
I& ASSOCIATES, INC. I March 8. 2005 11
I.
r
APPENDIX A
c
^ Employee Education Program Informational Handout
r
r
ito
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment &
Bridge Replacement Project, Phase 2
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, Phase 2
The City of Carlsbad's Rancho
Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement
Project is located adjacent to
sensitive native habitat. More than
260 native plant and wildlife species
inhabit the areas adjacent to the
project and much of the habitat has
been set aside for long-term
preservation to protect native plants
and wildlife. Importantly, this
project has been approved under
state and federal environmental laws
that set forth certain restrictions during construction of the project
in order to protect sensitive biological resources.
California Gnatcatcher
Federally-listed Threatened Species
California Species of Concern
The Califomia gnatcatcher is a small blue-gray songbird that
inhabits native coastal sage scrub habitat. Gnatcatchers eat
insects and nest during the spring and summer from February
through August. Gnatcatchers are
highly territorial and very sensitive
to disturbances. As a federally-
listed threatened species, it is
protected under the federal
Endangered Species Act by the
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and
as a species of concem by the
Califomia Department of Fish and
Game.
NATIVE HABITAT
San Marcos Creek/Riparian Habitat
San Marcos Creek and the associated native
vegetation are considered sensitive
biological resources. Native vegetation in
the area includes southem willow scrub and
freshwater marsh which provide important
habitat for native plants and wildlife. Even
the existing bridge provides important
nesting habitat for bats and swallows.
Maintaining the water quality of San Marcos
Creek is also essential to protecting the use
of valuable water resources in the region.
The creek and associated vegetation are
sensitive to impacts from dust, erosion, litter
and runoff containing oils and other
chemicals associated with construction.
Uplands Habitat
Upland areas next to the project include native coastal sage scrub
and chaparral vegetation. These areas provide important habitat
for native plants and animals, including the federally-listed
Califomia gnatcatcher. Upland habitat areas are most sensitive
to impacts from dust, erosion, litter and intrusion by domestic
pets.
AGENCIES AND REGULATIONS
The Resource Agencies
This project is authorized by statc and
federal agencies responsible for
regulating activities under the federal
Endangered Species Act, the federal
Clean Water Act and the Califomia
Fish and Game Code. These
agencies have primary authority over
regulated activities and may visit or
enter the project site at any time.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Seirice - federal Endangered Species Act
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers - federal Clean Water Act
Califomia Regional Water Quality Control Board - federal Clean Water Act
Califomia Department of Fish and Game - Califomia Fish and Game Code
Guidelines
• Do not cross barriers or enter native habitat.
• Do not disturb or remove orange environmental fencing.
• LMaintain silt fences and other BMPs to prevent erosion and
siltation of adjacent habitat.
• Do not litter or dump waste into habitat areas.
• Do not refuel or change oil where spills can wash into adjacent
habitat.
• Do not remove any plants or animals from habitat areas.
• Do not injure or kill wildlife.
• Do not bring pets to the jobsite.
Penalties
Violation of statc and federal laws
protecting native plants, wildlife and
habitat can result in severe penalties,
including:
• Habitat restoration responsibilities costing up
to hundreds of thousands of dollars.
• Large fines and substantial project delays.
• Arrest and imprisonment may result from
serious violations.
r
JM
APPENDIX B
Rainy Season Plan
PI
m k
m
k z
[
k
k
City ofCarlsbad
Rainy Season Action Plan for Construction Sites
Action Plans are to be in place by October 1, 2003 and UPDATED prior to each rain event.
Project Name: Rancho Santa Fe Road, Phase 2 Date: November 16, 2004
Project Address: 1645 S. Rancho Santa Fe Road, Suite 202
San Marcos, CA 92078
Contractor: FCI Constructors Project Manager: Roy Bartlett
FCI Contacts: Paul Mignone Jon Krause
Cell: 760-497-2926 Cell: 619-666-3579
Home: 619-300-3107 Home: 760-740-9498
Inspector Name & Title: Mark Plotnikiewicz, Resident Engineer
Inspector Signature:
z
k
p
Existine Condition Action Plan
Erosion Control:
Silt fence placed at toe-of-slopes, fiber roll
placed on slopes, large stockpile near San Elijo
has been sprayed with BFM, slope on west side
of existing RSF is covered with visquin
Additional silt fence, fiber rolls, gravel bags,
and visquin are on site in the event of a storm
and existing measures become inadequate.
Gravel bag check dams and silt fence will be
installed on the graded portions ofthe new road
to slow dovm storm water flow and prevent
erosion.
Sediment Controls:
Silt fence, gravel bag check dams, and visquin
are on the slopes leading to and adjacent to the
creek.
The access road between the bridges will be
blocked off and gravel bag check dams and silt
fence will be placed on the access road slopes
adjacent to the creek. A de-silting basin will be
constructed on the south side ofthe bridge just
south of the final slope leading to the creek.
The access road slopes adjacent to the creek
will be covered with visquin prior to a major
storm event.
Materials and Wastes:
Trash dumpsters are on site; concrete washout
areas are constructed; hazardous materials are
stored in spill containment area
Stockpiles of materials will be covered /
sprayed with BFM prior to a storm;
construction materials and equipment will be
removed fi^om creek bottom and floodplain
prior to a storm event
P
tai
r
p
te
te
z
p
Existine Condition Action Plan
Discharge Locations:
Existing San Marcos Creek flows through 3 -
20" culverts dunng normal flow. During high
flow, the creek overtops the culverts and flows
through the creek floodplain. The bottom of
the existing creek bed and floodplain has been
covered with rock to control silt and erosion.
The rock has been graded to direct flow
between the falsework bents,
Prior to a storm event, all equipment and
material will be removed from the creek bed
and the floodplain. BMP's will be constructed
on the access roads approaching the creek.
Finished Slope Protection:
N/A at this time Slopes will be stabilized with fiber rolls, BFM,
and visquin until the permanent hydro-seeding
is placed
Unfinished Slope Protection:
All inactive slopes are stabilized Active slopes will be stabilized when they
become inactive
Construction Entrance/Exit:
Construction entrances / exits are in place near
San Elijo, La Costa Meadows, and Melrose
Drive
Additional 3" minus rock is on site for
maintenance
Inlet Protection:
Gravel bags are placed at inlets Additional gravel bags are on site in the event
that they are needed
Other:
p
k
p
li
p
k
p
k
P k
p
k
p
c
APPENDIX C
Monthly Monitoring Reports
z
z
z
p
te
Professional Trams for Complex Projects
Engineering, Planning,
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporale Office;
605 Third Street
Encinitas, California 92024
760.942.5H7
Fax 760,632.0164
February 12, 2004 3912-01
k
p
ito
m
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Senior CivU Engineer
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carlsbad, California 92008
Re: Monthly Monttoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road ReaUgnment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlshad, California
Dear Ms. Loya-Smalley:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
weekly visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Ongoing Construction Activity
In January 2004, Dudek biologists made periodic visits to the project site to conduct biological
monitoring of ongoing construction activities. During this time, activity within Phase 1 of
the project has been limited to the construction of the wildUfe tunnel corridor and the
associated portions of the roadway.
During each site visit, the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion control
measures was checked and the contractor was notified if maintenance repairs were found to
be necessary. Construction activities were monitored to ensure that no impacts to adjacent
conservation areas occurred and that adequate measures were in place to minimize potential
indirect impacts, such as dust, runoff, etc.
m
m
p
i
te
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Projec t, City of Carlsbad, California
r Phase 2
te
^ Permit Compliance
Dudek attended project team meetings with City and project staff in October 2003 to review
r resource permit restrictions relative to Phase 2 of the project, and specifically m anticipation
of the start of vegetation clearing in January 2004. Timing restrictions, monitoring
requirements, appropnate construction practices and the implementation of project
conservation design elements were identified and appropriate strategies for ensuring
compliance with resource permits were discussed. With respect to construction activity
associated with San Marcos Creek, the following methods and restrictions were agreed upon:
vegetation clearing would be completed without the construction of temporary crossings,
^ equipment or machinery wouid not be permitted within the creek, equipment or machinery
te would not be permitted to cross the creek, and vegetation within the creek would be removed
^ by hand. At the request of the City, a summary of permit conditions (attached) was prepared
^ by Dudek to facilitate compliance with permits held from the Califorma Department of Fish
and Game, USFWS, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Regional Water Quality Control
Board.
p. Requirements of project California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and National
^ Environmental Protection Act (NEPA) documents have conflicting timing restrictions with
regard to bridge demolition and construction. The Biological Resources Technical Report
(November 2000) adopted by the City during the CEQA approval process requires that the
^ existing bridge is demolished between September 15 and February 15 to avoid impacts to
^ nesting swaUows. The Environmental Assessment (December 2001) prepared for the NEPA
k process requires that in order to minimize water quality degradation by sedimentation of the
river channel during construction, construction of the new bridge piers and demolition of
existing piers shall be limited to the dry season (March to October). As bridge demolition is
anticipated to occur in AprU 2005 after the completion of the new bridge, preclusionary
netting will be instaUed beneath the existing bridge prior to February 15 in order to avoid
te impacting nesting swallows. If the USFWS has recommendations regarding the use of
preclusionary devices or alternative methods for avoiding impacts to nesting swallows, please
contact Kam Muri at (760) 479-4292.
p
z
r te
3912-01
^ASSOCIATES,INC.; February 12, 2004
^ Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
^ Project, Chy of Carlsbad, CaUfornia ^
r Grading activities in Phase 2 are not expected to begin until April 2004. Given the lack of
^ grading operations between February 15 and April 1, coastal CaUfornia gnatcatcher {Polioptila
californica californica; gnatcatcher) monitoring within suitable habitat adjacent to the project
area wiU not be initiated until approximately March 20, subject to the start of Phase 2 grading.
r
te
Monitoring of Vegetation Clearing Activity
Vegetation clearing and tree removal activities within Phase 2 of the project were initiated on
January 6, 2004. Prior to the start of vegetation clearing, Dudek checked and confirmed the
accuracy of staking and flagging identifying the limits of the Phase 2 project area. Dudek also
r checked and confirmed that no raptor nests were present within trees prior to their removal.
^ A red-tailed hawk {Buteo jamaicensis) pair was observed carrying nesting materials to a nest
m site adjacent to the project area; however, the pair was unaffected by activity onsite and is
li using the nest site in spite of the exposure to existing traffic nosie from nearby Rancho Santa
Fe Road and Melrose Drive.
p
Orange environmental fencing was instaUed along the project limits as portions ofthe project
^ were cleared. Erosion control measures instaUed in cleared areas throughout the site include
te fiber rolls, gravel bags, silt fencing and the application of bonded fiber matrix (BFM).
Remaining work is expected to be completed in the next few days, mcluding the instaUation
of site fencing and erosion controls. In accordance with permit requirements, vegetation
within the project area was removed prior to the February 15 start of the gnatcatcher breeding
^ season, and the March 15 start of the breeding season for riparian species. Additional clearing
^ necessary for future Phase 2 construction activities is anticipated to occur in FaU 2004 after the
^ August 31 end of the gnatcatcher breeding season.
AU vegetation clearing and tree removal work was monitored by City inspectors and Dudek
biologists. However, upon arriving onsite to monitor ongoing clearing activity on January 27,
Dudek observed that an excavator had crossed to the south side of the creek to remove
PI vegetation along the bank and crossed back to the north side shortly after. The disturbance
ll to the stream channel occurred within the project Hmits but caused a temporary increase in
turbidity which subsided approximately 45 minutes after the impact. Dudek immediately
notified the contractor of the incident and reiterated that equipment or machinery was not
permitted within the creek. Dudek reported the incident in its daily report of monitoring
activities and recommended remedial action including the manual removal of any debris
k remaining within the creek.
.:• : 3912-01
P
P
z & ASSOCb\TES, INC.- February 12, 2004
r..n/<....™niN.-^f'.rC..-.f
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City of Carlsbad, CaUfornia _——^==^=^=^=
With the exception of the incident described above, the Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment
and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed in compliance with all environmental
requirements and permit regulations. If you have any questions or concerns please contact me
at (760) 479-4292.
r
te Very truly yours.
P
te
p
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
P
k
p
te
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmentai Sciences Division
aii: Summary of Environmenial Permit Restrictions
cc: John Marlin, U.S- Fisk and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming, Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek Associates, Inc.
Vipul Joshi, Dudek Associaies, Inc.
Anita Hayworth, Dudek Associates, Inc.
m
k 3912-01
&ASSOClATfcS, INC; February 12. 2004
RANCHO SANTA FE ROAD PROJECT PHASE 2
Summary of Environmental Perniit Restrictions
City of Carlsbad
12/2/2003
Item No. Condition/Restriction Source
TIMING I iFSTRICTIONS
1
All work will be conducted during the daytime hours; night lighling shall not occur
except in an emergency situation.
USFWS 4, EA/NEPA
2
The Operator shall not remove vegetation within the stream from March 15 to July
31 to avoid impacts fo nesting birds.
CDFG 6
3
Vegetation removal lhat is needed to accomplish the proposed project shall be
conducted between September 15 and February 14 immediately prior to construction.
USFWS 3
4
The existing bridge over San Marcos Creek will be demolished between 15
September and 15 February to avoid impacts to nesting swallows. Prior to
demolition, all potentially occurring bats and swallows will be flushed from under the
bridge by a qualified biologist.
BIO/CEQA
5
To minimize water quality degradation by sedimentafion ofthe river channe) during
construction, construction of the new bridge piers and demolilion of existing piers
shall be limited to fhe dry season (March to October).
RWQCB, NEPA
CONSTRI JCTION PRACTICES - WATER QUALITY AND CREEK RELATED
6
Installation of bridges, culverts, or other slRictures shall be such that water flow is
not impaired. Bottoms of lemporary culverts shall be placed at stream channel grade;
bottoms of permanent culverts shall be placed at or below stream channel grade.
CDFG 10
7
Preparafion shall be made so that runoff from steep, erodible surfaces will be diverted
into stable areas with litfle erosion potential. Frequent water checks shall be placed
on dirt roads, cat tracks, or other work trails fo control erosion.
CDFG 11
8
Staging/storage areas for equipment and materials shall be located outside ofthe
stream.
CDFG 15
9
Spoil sites shall not be located within a stream/lake, where spoil shall be washed back
into a sfream/lake, or where il will cover aquatic or riparian vegetation.
CDFG 22
10
The permitee shall employ all standard BMPs fo ensure that toxic material, silt,
debris or excessive erosion do not enter San Marcos Creek during project
construction.
ACOE 5
11
Water containing mud, silt or olher pollutants from aggregate washing or other
activities shall not be allowed lo enter a lake or flowing stream or placed in locations
thai may be subjected lo high storm flows.
CDFG 12
12 No equipment shall be operated in ponded or flowing areas. CDFG 8
13
Structures and associated materials not designed to withstand high seasonal flows
shall be removed to areas above the high water mark before such flows occur.
CDFG 13
14
During construction of the bridge and removal of the exisfing bridge within San
Marcos Creek, an area approximately 3 meters (10 feet) wide and 3 meters high, with
dry substrate, that has visual access from end to end, will be maintained to allow
wildlife movement-
USFWS 5, EA/NEPA
15
Disturbed slope areas in the vicinity of any jurisdictional waters of the US shall be
stabilized using jute netting or other appropriate means, and revegaleated with native
vegetation prior to the onset ofthe first winter rains following construction, so as to
minimize sedimenataion and related impacts to the drainage.
ACOE 9
1 of2
p
te
RANCHO SANTA FE ROAD PROJECT PHASE 2
Summary of Environmental Permit Restrictions
City of Carlsbad
12/2/2003
P
te
P
ib
z
p
k
Item No. Condition/Restriction Source
rnNs:TRi!rTiON PRACTICES - GENERAL
16
The Operator shall have a qualified biologist onsite daily during any impacts to
vegetation forthe purpose of monitoring and enforcing condition numbers 6, 9, 14,
and 21 ofthis agreement.
CDFG 7
17
Disturbance or removal of vegetation shall occur only wilhin the limits of work. Any
disturbed areas outside the limits of work shall be restored.
CDFG 9
18
The perimeter ofthe work site shall be adequately flagged to prevent damage to
adjacent riparian habitat.
CDFG 14
19
The Operator shall comply with all litter and pollution laws. All contractors,
subcontractors and employees shall also obey these laws and it shall be the
responsibility of the operator to ensure compliance.
CDFG 16
20 Access lo the work site shall be via existing roads and access ramps. CDFG 21
21
Prior to commencement of clearing or grading activities, fencing shall be installed to
delmeate lhe limits of work, including designated access and staging/stockpiling
areas. The construction crew must be informed ofthe sensitivityof adjacent
conserved habitat.
USFWS 8
22
All constaiction activity, including storage, staging and stockpiling, shall be kept
within the limits of work and kept as far as possible from conserved habitat.
USFWS 9
23
The project she shall be kept as free as possible of trash, refuse, discarded food
wrappers, and other waste that might attract small predators that prey on gnalcatcher.
Trash conlainers wilh animal-resistant lids will be provided on the site during
construction.
USFWS 9
24
Erosion control devices will be monitored during the rainy season lo ensure that dirt
topsoil, and ofher materials are not washing into adjacenf habitat areas. If at any
fime significant amounts of dust or maferial are determined fo be impacting
conserved habitat, corrective measures will be taken immediately.
USFWS 10
25
During grading and construction adjacent to conserved habitat, a biologist will
monitor the adjacent habitat for excessive accumulation of dust or other disturbance.
USFWS 10
26
The permitee shall remove all excess fill and/or construction debris, temporary fill or
structures used for access and dewatering for construction purposes, and equipment
from the site immediately upon completion of construction.
ACOE 7
27
The permittee shall ensure that all vehicles maintenance, staging, storage and
dispensing of fuel occurs in designated upland areas. The permittee shall ensure thaf
these designated upland areas are located in such a manner as to prevent any runoff
from entering waters of the US.
ACOE 6
28
Landscaping and erosion control will not use species listed as noxious weeds
(Execufive Order on Invasive Species EO i 3112). In the San Marcos Creek area,
extra precaution will be taken if invasive species are found in or adjacent lo
conslruclion areas, including inspection/cleaning of construction equipmenl and
eradication strategies should an invasion occur.
EA/NEPA
p
[
p
k 2 of 2
P
k
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
Pro/'i's-wnol Team^ ,-""r Coniph-i Projects
Engineering, Planning,
Corporate Offtce:
Envirnnmental Sciences and ^^.^^^ ^^^^^^ 760.942.5147
Management Services Encinitas, California 92024 Fax 760.632.0164
March 2, 2004 3912-01
Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
P Senior Civil Engineer
• City of Carlsbad
_ 1635 Faraday Avenue
^ Carlsbad, California 92008
P
L
te
Ke; Monthly Monitoring Report^ Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project^ City of Carlsbad, California
Dear Ms. Loya-Smalley:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compUance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
weekly visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Ongoing Construction Activity
p In February 2004, Dudek biologists made periodic visits to the project site to conduct biological
li monitoring of ongoing construction activities. During this time, activity within Phase 1 of the
project has been limited to ongoing road construction including finish grading and gravel
laying.
E During each site visit, the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion control
measures was checked and the contractor was notified if maintenance repairs were found to
be necessary. Construction activities were monitored to ensure that no impacts to adjacent
^ conservation areas occurred and that adequate measures were in place to minimize potential
indirect impacts, such as dust, runoff, etc.
m
te
p
te
p
te
p
p
k
p
p
te
te
c
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge
Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
Gnatcatcher Monitoring Program
In accordance with the USFWS Biological Opinion, the City of Carlsbad is required to
implement a monitoring program for the federaUy-listed threatened coastal CaUfornia
gnatcatcher {Polioptila californica californica; gnatcatcher) during the breeding season (February
15 through August 31) to avoid indirect impacts to the species. A protocol-level focused survey
is being conducted to determine if gnatcatcher are present in suitable habitat within 500 feet
k of project areas currently under construction. If present, weekly monitoring wUI be
conducted to determine nesting status and noise calculations wiU be made as needed based on
construction activity and nest iocation.
Phase 2
Site Monitoring
Dudek biologists made weekly visits to monitor site conditions in Phase 2 of the project
following the completion of vegetation clearing and the installation of erosion control measures
in February 2004. During each site visit, the condition of existing environmental fencing and
erosion control measures was checked and the contractor was notified if maintenance repairs
were found to be necessary.
The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
in compliance with all environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
Very truly yours,
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmental Sciences Division
& ASSOCIATES. INC. ^^grch 2, 2004
3912-01
p
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge
Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
r
te
cc:
te
P
John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek Associates, Inc.
Vipul Joshi, Dudek (S2 Associates, Inc.
Anita Hayworth, Dudek Associates, Inc.
m
k
k
p
k
p k
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
3912-01
March 2, 2004
p
W Engineering, Planning.
g ^afi 5»ia aafl WM Kai Corporate Office:
Environmental Sciences and ^^.^^ 3^^^^^ 760.942,5147
'profe..,..a,Teo.,..forCon,pU-.Proj.c>l Management SetvicBS Encmitas. California 92024 Fax 760.632.0164
AprU 16, 2004 3912-01
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
r Senior CivU Engineer
^ City of Carlsbad
pa 1635 Faraday Avenue
^ Cadsbad, Califorma 92008
te
r k
k
p
k
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
Dear Ms. Loya-Smalley:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
weekly visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Ongoing Construction Activity
In March 2004, Dudek biologists made periodic visits to the project site to conduct biological
monitoring of ongoing construction activities. During this time, activity within Phase 1 of the
project has been limited to ongoing road construction including finish grading and gravel
laying.
During each site visit, the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion control
measures was checked and construction management was notified if maintenance repairs
were found to be necessary. Construction activities were monitored to ensure that no impacts
to adjacent conservation areas occurred and that adequate measures were in place to minimize
potential indirect impacts, such as dust, runoff, etc.
k
k
Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
P Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge
Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, Califomia
k Gnatcatcher Monitoring Program
In accordance with the USFWS Biological Opinion, the City of Carlsbad is required to
implement a monitoring program for the federally-Usted threatened coastal California
P gnatcatcher (Polioptila californica californica; gnatcatcher) during the breeding season (February
te 15 through August 31) to avoid indirect impacts to the species. A protocol-level focused survey
^ was conducted to determine if gnatcatcher are present in suitable habitat within 500 feet of
''^ Phase 1 projectareascurrentlyunderconstructionbutnognatcatcherweredetected. Because
gnatcatcher are not present adjacent to the project, gnatcatcher monitoring activities wUl not
^ be required,
te
^ Phase 2
te
Site Monitoring
m
k Dudek biologists made weekly visits to monitor site conditions in Phase 2 of the project
C foUowing the completion of vegetation clearing and the instaUation of erosion control measures
in February 2004. During each site visit, the condition of existing environmental fencing and
erosion control measures was checked and construction management was notified if
P maintenance repairs were found to be necessary. As construction for Phase 2 of the project
^ has yet to begin, no construction activities occurred within the Phase 2 area.
E
hi
k
P
m
The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
in compUance with aU environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
Very truly yours,
Dudek &c Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmental Sciences Division
3912-01
& ASSOCIATE. INC. I ^p^ji 10 2004
z
z
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realigtmient and Bridge
Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
CC:
P
i
te
John Marlin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
Vipul Joshi, Dudek Associaies, Inc.
Anita Hayworth, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
r
L
p
k
p
k
3912-01
& ASSOCIATES, INCi ^p^i, ^g, 2004
z
z
z
r
L
r
DUDEK
& ASSOCIATES, INC
Professional Teams for Complex Projects
Engineering. Planning,
Corporate Office:
Environmental Sciences and ^^.^^^ ^^^^^^ 760.942.5147
Management Services Encinitas, California 92024 Fax 760.632.0164
May 10, 2004 3912-01
Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
Senior CivU Engineer
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Cadsbad, California 92008
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Ref^lacement Project, City ofCarlsbad, California
Dear Ms. Loya-SmaUey:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
L weekly visits during construction.
r Phase 1 te
F-" Biological Monitoring of Ongoing Construction Activity
k
In AprU 2004, Dudek biologists made periodic visits to the project site to conduct biological
r monitoring of ongoing construction activities. During this time, activities within Phase 1 of
the project has been Umited to paving, curb construction and landscaping work.
C During each site visit, the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion control
measures was checked and construction management was notified if maintenance repairs
P were found to be necessary. Construction activities were monitored to ensure that no
impacts to adjacent conservation areas occurred and that adequate measures were in place
•I to minimize potential indirect impacts, such as dust, runoff, etc.
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
m Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacemem Project,
te City of Carlsbad, California
z
P
k
Phase 2
Site Monitoring
In April 2004, Dudek biologists made periodic visits to monitor site conditions in Phase 2 of
C the project following the completion of vegetation clearing and the instaUation of erosion
control measures in February 2004. During each site visit, the condition of existing
• • environmental fencing and erosion control measures was checked and construction
k management was notified if maintenance repairs were found to be necessary.
C Construction activity in Phase 2 was initiated on May 5,2004 with limited pot holing efforts
to locate existing subsurface utiUties in the vicinity of San Marcos Creek. A subsequent
• monthly report for the month of May will cover the initiation of Phase 2 construction.
k
Gnatcatcher Monitoring Program
^ In accordance with the USFWS Biological Opinion, the City of Cadsbad is required to
m implement a monitoring program for the federaUy-listed threatened coastal California
C gnatcatcher (Polioptila californica californica; gnatcatcher) during the breeding season (February
15 through August 31) to avoid indirect impacts to the species. Results of a protocol-level
r focused survey conducted in suitable habitat within 500 feet of the Phase 2 project area were
^ negative. Because gnatcatcher are not present adjacent to the project, gnatcatcher
monitoring activities wUl not be required.
^ The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Proj ect is being constructed
in compliance with aU environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
P
te Very truly yours,
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist.
Environmental Sciences Division
3912-01
May 10. 2004 I&ASSOCIATES, INa
z
p
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project,
City of Carlsbad, CaUfornia
z
r
te
CC: John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek Associaies, Inc.
Mark Plotnikiewicz, Simon Wong Engineering
Vipul Joshi, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
Anita Hayworth, Dudek Associates, Inc.
i.
P
L
r
L
te
p
ll
DUDEK |& ASSOCIATES, INC j May 10. 2004
3912-01
Professional Teams fnr Co'nple.i Projects
Engineering, Planning,
Corporate Office:
Environmental Sciences and ^^.^^ ^^^^^^ 760.942 5147
Management Services Encinitas, California 92024 Fax 760.632.0164
P
C
July 2, 2004 3912-01
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
p Senior CivU Engineer
te City of Cadsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
r Cadsbad, California 92008
Re: Monthly Monitoring Rep^ort, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlshad, Califomia
Dear Ms. Loya-Smalley:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compUance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
Phase 1 te
F Biological Monitoring of Ongoing Construction Activity
_ In May 2004, Dudek biologists made a brief visit to the project site to monitor the status of
£ ongoing construction activities. During this time, activity within Phase 1 of the project has
been limited to landscaping and other minor work along the roadway. The Phase 1 roadway
C between La Costa avenue and San Elijo Road was opened to traffic on June 21, 2004. With
the completion of this portion of the Phase 1 roadway, limited portions of orange
environmental fencing have been removed. AU existing sUt fencing and other erosion controls
L remain in place. Remaining construction in Phase 1 involves the re-alignment of the La Costa
Avenue intersection and is expected to take approximately 2 to 3 months to complete.
Dudek wiU continue to monitor the condition of existmg environmentai fencing and erosion
controls in Phase 1 with periodic inspections and notify construction management if
maintenance repairs are found to be necessary.
p
te
k
p
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Ft Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City of Carlsbad, California
Phase 2
Biological Monitoring of Construcfion
Phase 2 construction began on May 5, 2004. The work conducted in May involved the
diversion of San Marcos Creek, excavation and ongoing construction of footings for two piers
under the westerly bridge and grading for the new roadway alignment. To aUow the
excavation and construction of the piers for the new bridge, the fiow of San Marcos Creek
onsite has been temporarUy redirected through three 20-mch diameter steel pipe culverts that
extend approximately 250 linear feet and outlet into an existing secondary channel within
the project limits. The culvert inlets are located beneath the existing Rancho Santa Fe Road
bridge.
Diversion of San Marcos Creek
A trench was excavated to place three steel pipe culverts approximately 10 to 12 inches beiow
the existing stream bed. The main fiow channel was bermed and diverted into the 3 pipe
culverts by using hand labor to shift existing soils and place plastic tarps at a narrow point
beneath the existing bridge. Upon diverting the creek, the downstream limit of the main
channel was bermed and silt fencing installed to prevent sedimentation of downstream
portions of the creek. The culvert outlet area was stabUized by placement of smaU rip-rap
in the channel bed and bank extending approximately 4 feet from the outlet. An effort was
made to identify the species that remained in the channel to determine if translocation would
'k be necessary. However, only non-native species were identified, including non-native fish
species, bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) and signal crayfish (Pacifastacus Itniusculus). The main
E creek channel was then backfiUed starting at the upstream end.
r
te
p
z
z
z
The iniet and outlet of the culverts are checked regularly by Dudek and no signs of
sedimentation within the creek have been observed. Downstream portions of the creek
adjacent to the project are also being monitored to determine if existing habitat is being
affected by the redirected creek fiows.
Pier Excavation and Groundwater Removal
Once the main channel was backfUled, gradmg was initiated to levei the site to begin
excavation for construction of the piers for the new bridge. There are currently two
excavations onsite, one for each of the piers associated with the westerly bridge that wUl
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 3912-01 EDUDEK
p
1^ Water levels in the main channel immediately downstream of the project and upstream of
the stream diversion outlet appear to be affected by groundwater extraction in the Pier 2
excavation. Water levels in the adjacent main charmel appear to remain stable when the Pier
2 excavation is fiUed and used as a holding basin. FFowever, water in the main channel
appears to be percolating down when the Pier 2 excavation is pumped dry for construction
due to the draw down of groundwater levels. This situation is being monitored by Dudek
to ensure that reduced water levels in the main channel do not cause impacts to adjacent
vegetation.
Avoidance of Impacts to Nesting Birds
Two nesting bird locations were identified onsite. A kiUdeer (Charadrius vociferus) nest with
four eggs was found within the mulch on the ground beneath the VaUeeitos Water District
signboard at the southwest corner of La Costa Meadows and Rancho Santa Fe Road. The
nest was protected in place by staking and flagging untU nesting was complete and the nest
abandoned. The second nesting location involves a wiUow snag along the western boundary
of the project being used by a northern flicker pair (Colaptts auratus). Tree swaUow
(Tachycineta bicolor) have also been observed using the snag, however they do not appear to
be actively nesting. The snag has been protected in place by orange environmentai fencing.
Employee Education Program
In accordance with the requirements of the USFWS Biological Opinion, Dudek conducted an
employee education meeting onsite for new construction crews associated with Phase 2 on
May 24, 2004. Dudek identified native habitat areas adjacent to the project and highlighted
sensitive biological resources associated with the project including the federally-Usted
threatened coastal CaUfornia gnatcatcher (Polioptila californica californica; gnatcatcher) and
wetlands regulated by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the CaUfornia Regional Water
Ouaiity Control Board and the CaUfornia Department of Fish and Game. An informational
brochure prepared by Dudek (attached) was also provided to aU in attendance at the meeting
to provide general information regarding biological resources in the area and to provide
guidelines for avoiding impacts to adjacent native habitat areas. The program wUl be
r k
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
k Project, City of Carlsbad, California
carry northbound traffic. Currently, one excavation is used as a temporary holding basin for
extracted groundwater while pier construction in the second excavation takes place.
Extracted groundwater is also being stored in a water tank onsite for dust control use. No
groundwater is being discharged to the creek.
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 3912-01
& ASSOCIATES, INC. I UDEK!
July 2, 2004
p
k
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
m Re: Monthly Monitoring Rtport, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
te Projtct, City of Carlsbad, California
^ repeated as necessary during the remainder of Phase 2 construction for new contractors,
subcontractors and crew.
p
k Gnatcatcher Monitoring Program
^ In accordance with the USFWS Biological Opinion, the City of Cadsbad is required to
implement a monitoring program for the federally-listed threatened coastal California
C gnatcatcher during the breeding season (February 15 through August 31) to avoid indirect
impacts to the species. Results of a protocol-level focused survey conducted in suitable
habitat within 500 feet of the Phase 2 project area were negative. Because gnatcatcher are
^ not present adjacent to the project, gnatcatcher monitoring activities wUl not be required.
A survey report dated May 25, 2004, has been submitted to USFWS by Anita Hayworth,
r Ph.D, TE-781084. te
^ The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
^ in compliance with aU environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
m
Very truly yours,
p
^ Dudek & Associates, Inc.
P
li
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmental Sciences Division
cc: John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
k Mark Plotnikiewicz, Simon Wong Engineering
Vipul Joshi, Dudek (^Associates, Inc.
Anita Hayworth, Dudek d2 Associates, Inc.
att. Employee Education Brochure
liMJOilCi Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
& ASSOCIATES, mc
3912-01
July 2.2004
te
DUDEK
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
Professional Teams for Complex Projects
Engineering, Planning,
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporate Office:
605 Third Street
Encinitas, California 92024
760.942.5147
Fax 760.632.0164
k July 15,2004 4186-01
p
te Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
Senior Civil Engineer
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Cadsbad, California 92008
P
te
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlshad, Califomia
p
L
Dear Ms. Loya-SmaUey:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Construction
Construction on the final segment of the southbound lanes near the La Costa Avenue
intersection started foUowing the opening of the Phase 1 roadway between La Costa Avenue
and San Elijo Road on June 21, 2004. Construction currently involves grading and work
associated with underground utUities. Due to the lack of sensitive resources associated with
the current construction activity in Phase 1, biological monitoring is not required. However,
Dudek wUl continue to monitor the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion
controls in Phase 1 with periodic inspections and wUI notify construction management if
maintenance or repairs are found to be necessary.
p
ll
p
te
p
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
F Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
^ Projtct, City of Carlsbad, California
p
k Phase 2
Biological Monitoring of Construction
In June, construction in Phase 2 involved ongoing work with pier construction at the bridge
site and grading along the roadway alignment. Pier construction currently involves
construction of the columns and both excavations for Pier 2 and Pier 3 remain open for the
time being. One of the pier excavations continues to be used as a temporary holding basin
for extracted groundwater whUe construction takes place in the second excavation. The
majority of grading is currently taking place to the south of San Marcos Creek. Over-
excavation is taking place in portions of the alignment where it is necessary to remove
unsuitable fUl materials.
The irUet and outlet of the stream diversion culverts are checked regularly by Dudek and no
signs of sedimentation within the creek have been observed. Downstream portions of the
creek adjacent to the project are also being monitored to determme if existing habitat is being
affected by the redirected creek flows. Water levels in the main channel immediately
P downstream of the project continue to fluctuate as groundwater levels in the vicinity are
affected by temporary de-watering activities at the bridge site. Mature sycamore trees
^ (Platanus racemosa) in the creek area near the westem boundary of the project are showing
te signs of water stress and beginning to drop some leaves. This appears to be a result of the
draw-down of the water table and temporary de-watering activities at the bridge site. These
^ trees should recover when de-watering activities in the area cease and the water table is
aUowed to rise back up.
C Gnatcatcher Monitoring Program
r In accordance with the USFWS Biological Opinion, the City of Cadsbad is required to
implement a monitoring program for the federally-Usted threatened coastal California
Pk gnatcatcher during the breeding season (February 15 through August 31) to avoid indirect
li impacts to the species. Results of a protocol-level focused survey conducted in suitable
habitat within 500 feet of the Phase 2 project area were negative. Because gnatcatcher are
P not present adjacent to the project, gnatcatcher morutoring activities wiU not be required.
A survey report dated May 25, 2004, has been submitted to USFWS by Anita Hayworth,
p Ph.D, TE-781084.
k
p
k
p
te
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
& ASSOCIATES. INa
l^fmljinntjPMfar CuM^tai Projtin July 15,2004
m
te
p
te
p
te
te
te
p
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Ft Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City of Carlsbad, California
The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Proj ect is being constructed
in compliance with all environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
p Very truly yours,
te
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
H
• Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
1^ Environmental Sciences Division
m cc: John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
te C)oug Helming Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
^ Mark Plotnikiewicz, Simon Wong Engineering
^ Vipul Joshi, Dudek d2 Associates, Inc.
Anita Hayworth, Dudek di Associates, inc.
\ BjliM Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Repiacement 4186-01
& ASSOCIATES, INC July 15. 2004
P
hi
p
k Professional Teams for Complex Priyjects
Engineering. Planning.
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporale Office:
605 Third Street
Encinitas, California 92024
760.942.5147
Fax 760.632.0164
P
te
k
p
te
August 19, 2004 4186-01
Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
Senior CivU Engineer
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Cadsbad, Cahfornia 92008
Re: Monthly Motiitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
m
te
k
p
k
te
k
p
k
Dear Ms. Loya-SmaUey:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdhfe Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Construction
Construction on the final segment of the southbound lanes near the La Costa Avenue
intersection started following the opening of the Phase 1 roadway between La Costa Avenue
and San Elij o Road on June 21,2004. Due to the lack of sensitive resources associated with the
current construction activity in Phase 1, biological morutoring is not required. However,
Dudek wiU continue to monitor the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion
controls in Phase 1 with periodic inspections and wiU notify construction management if
maintenance or repairs are found to be necessary.
P
te
m
te
P
te
P
te
P
ii
M
m
te
p
p
te
p
p
te
te
p
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City ofCarlsbad, California
Phase 2
p Biological Monitoring of Construction
te
In July, Phase 2 construction involved ongoing excavation and construction of the bridge piers
and embankment waUs. De-watering activities are ongoing with the existing pier excavations
being used as temporary holding basins for extracted groundwater. Grading operations
continue within upland portions of the site to the south of San Marcos Creek. A water truck
continues to make regular trips around the site to mimmize dust. Orange environmental
fencing and silt fencing throughout the site were checked and construction management
notified if maintenance or repairs were necessary.
The inlet and outlet of the stream diversion culverts are checked regularly by Dudek and no
signs of sedimentation witiiin the creek have been observed. Downstream portions of the
creek adjacent to the project are also being monitored to determine if existing habitat is bemg
affected by the redirected creek flows. Water levels in the main channel downstream of the
project do not appear to be fluctuating as widely and have been observed within
approximately 12 to 18 inches of pre-construction levels.
PR Gnatcatcher Monitoring Program
te
In accordance with the USFWS Biological Opinion, the City of Carlsbad is required to
implement a monitoring program for the federally-listed threatened coastal California
gnatcatcher during the breeding season (February 15 through August 31) to avoid indirect
impacts to the species. Results of a protocol-level focused survey conducted in suitable habitat
k within 500 feet of the Phase 2 project area were negative. Because gnatcatcher are not present
adjacent to the project, gnatcatcher monitoring activities wiU not be required. A survey report
dated May 25, 2004, has been submitted to USFWS by Anita Hayworth, Ph.D, TE-781084.
The Rancho Santa Fe Road ReaUgnment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
in compUance with aU environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
PR
te
m
P
te
mi
p
k
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Projtct, City of Carlsbad, California
Very truly yours,
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
te
m
te Environmental Sciences Division
CC: John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming, Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
Mark Plotnikiewicz, Simon Wong Engineering
Vipul Joshi, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
Anita Hayworth, Dudek Associaies, Inc.
mmm Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
|&ASSOCIATES, INC.[ ^—— p™to««(TB™h..c™pi„p™,«u August 19, 2004
te
DUDEK
& ASSOCIATES. INC.
Professional Teams for Camples Projects
Engineering, Planning,
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporate Office:
605 Third Street
Encinitas, California 92024
760.942.5147
Fax 760.632.0164
October 12, 2004 4186-01
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Senior CivU Engineer
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carisbad, California 92008
P
p
m
k
m
k
P
te
p
te
p
te
m
te
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City ofCarlsbad, Califomia
Dear Ms. Loya-Smalley:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Construction
Construction on the final segment of the southbound lanes near the La Costa Avenue
intersection started following the opening of the Phase 1 roadway between La Costa Avenue
and San Elijo Road on June 21, 2004. Due to the lack of sensitive resources associated with
the current construction activity in Phase 1, biological monitoring is not required. However,
Dudek wiU continue to monitor the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion
controls in Phase 1 with periodic inspections and wiU notify construction management if
maintenance or repairs are found to be necessary.
p
k
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road ReaUgnment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City of Carlsbad, CaUfornia
Phase 2
Biological Monitoring of Construction
In August, Phase 2 construction involved ongoing grading activity, ongoing construction of the
bridge piers and embankments and vegetation clearing on the east of the existing bridge. The
majority of grading activity is taking place to the south of San Marcos Creek and generally
involves excavation and the separation of suitable and unsuitable fiU material. Approxunately
400 feet of the old Rancho Santa Fe Road south of the San Elijo Road intersection is being used
as a stockpiling area. Orange fencing has been installed along the west side of the stockpiling
area to prevent encroachment into adjacent habitat. De-watering activities associated with
IP construction at the bridge site continue to use existing pier excavations as temporary holding
iiii basins for extracted groundwater. A portion of the extracted groundwater is being stored
onsite and used for dust controi. Orange environmental fencing and sUt fencing throughout
2 the site were checked and construction management notified if maintenance or repairs were
necessary.
P
* In accordance with timing restrictions in the Section 1601 Streambed Alteration Agreement
from the California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG), vegetation clearing within San
Marcos Creek commenced following the end of the breeding season for riparian birds on July
31'^ Dudek verified the staked limits of work using a Global Positioning System (GPS) back-
pack unit, met with construction crews prior to the start of clearing and conducted dady
monitoring of clearing activities. Vegetation clearing was done manually using chainsaws. A
backhoe was used to haul cut slash and logs out of the creek area but did not enter the creek
itself. Orange environmental fencing was instaUed along the limits of work immediately
foUowing the start of clearing activities. WhUe vegetation to the north of the creek has been
completely cleared, limited vegetation remains to the south of the creek. This vegetation wUl
be cleared at a later date due to it's proximity to north-bound traffic on Rancho Santa Fe
Road.
p
k
P
P
il
P k
p
te
The inlet and outlet of the stream diversion culverts associated with the bridge construction
are checked regularly by Dudek and no signs of sedimentation within the creek have been
observed. Downstream portions of the creek adjacent to the project are also being monitored
to determine if existing habitat is being affected by the redirected creek flows. Water leveis
in the main channel downstream of the project were observed to be near pre-construction
levels.
DUDEK |& ASSOCIATES. INa I —— rt.(«i«n««iwc-*i«p«*«. October 12, 2004
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
^ Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City of Carlsbad, California
f* _ . ____
k A break in a reclaimed water hne belonging to the VaUeeitos Water District (VWD) under
Melrose Avenue occurred on August 9,2004. Although unrelated to Phase 2 project activities,
surface flows from the break entered the Phase 2 project site near the Melrose Avenue
intersection along Rancho Santa Fe Road. Runoff from the water entering the site managed
to travel beneath a portion of the sUt fencing around the concrete-lined channel onsite. To
prevent sUted runoff that may have entered the channel from flowing downstream into San
Marcos Creek, VWD crews temporarily blocked off the pipe culverts beneath La Costa
Meadows. The contractor and VWD crews worked together to immediately block additional
water from entering the site. As a result, only a Umited amount of water actually entered the
site and runoff into adjacent habitat areas did not occur.
Gnatcatcher IVIonitoring Program
te
p
te
m
r
k
p
te
P
te
F k
In accordance with the USFWS Biological Opinion, the City of Carlsbad is required to
implement a monitoring program for the federally-listed threatened coastal California
gnatcatcher during the breeding season (February 15 through August 31) to avoid indirect
impacts to the species. Results of a protocol-level focused survey conducted in suitable habitat
within 500 feet of the Phase 2 project area were negative. Results also indicated that habitat
within 500 feet of the new stockpihng area on old Rancho Santa Fe Road south of the San EUjo
Road intersection is unoccupied. Because gnatcatcher are not present adjacent to the project,
gnatcatcher monitoring activities wiU not be required. A survey report dated May 25, 2004,
has been submitted to USFWS by Anita Hayworth, Ph.D, TE-781084.
The Rancho Santa Fe Road ReaUgnment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
in compUance with all environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
Very truly yours,
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmental Sciences Division
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
& ASSOCIATES, INC. .
Bto^ 7i~lW C«*IB PrifRU October 12, 2004
k
k
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City of Carlsbad, California
John Marlin, US. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming, Helming Engineering, Inc.
George Litzinger, Dtidek d2 Associates, Inc.
Mark Phwikiewicz, Simon Wong Engineering
Vipul Joshi, Dudek Associates, Inc.
P
k
P
te
p
te
te
P
iDUDEK
I&ASSOCIATES, INC. „ ^
isA»wT»»fc,c<».^p»»., October 12, 2004
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
te Professional Teams for Complex Projects
Engineering, Planning,
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporate Office:
605 Third Street
Encinitas, California 92024
760.942.5147
Fax 760.632.0164
November 15, 2004 4186-01
Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
Senior Civil Engineer
City ofCarlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carisbad, Califomia 92008
P
te
k
z
p
te
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
Dear Ms. Loya-Smalley:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WildUfe Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists irom Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Construction
Construction on the final segment of the southbound lanes near the La Costa Avenue intersection
started following the opening of the Phase 1 roadway between La Costa Avenue and San Elijo
Road on June 21, 2004. Due to the lack of sensitive resources associated with the current
construction activity in Phase 1, biological monitoring is not required. However, Dudek will
continue to monitor the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion controls in
Phase 1 with periodic inspections and will notify construction management if maintenance or
repairs are found to be necessary.
P
te
jj^ Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
p» Project, City of Carlsbad, CaUfornia
^ Phase 2
p
k Biological Monitoring of Construction
^ In September, Phase 2 construction involved ongoing grading and earth work, ongoing
^ constmction associated with the bridge piers and embankment walls, and the start of false work
P installation for construction of the bridge spans. Grading and earth work is taking place to the
L south of San Marcos Creek and generally involves excavation and the separation of suitable and
unsuitable fill material. Work on the bridge piers was completed this month, but construction
associated with the embankment walls is ongoing. Following the completion ofthe bridge piers,
the pier excavations were backfUled and the bridge site prepared for the instailation of false work
C for construction ofthe bridge spans. The entire bridge site was lined with rock to provide a solid
foundation for the false work and to prevent soils being washed downstream during winter
flooding events. A water truck continues to make regular trips around the site to minimize dust.
Orange environmental fencing and silt fencing throughout the site were checked and construction
management notified if maintenance or repairs were necessary.
P k
p
te
p
^ The inlet and outlet of the stream diversion culverts associated with the bridge construction are
checked regulariy by Dudek and no signs of sedimentation within the creek have been observed.
As pier constmction is now complete and the pier excavations backfilled, de-watering activities
have ceased and the water level in the stream channel immediateiy downstream ofthe project site
^ has retumed to pre-construction levels.
i
The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed in
compliance with all environmental requirements and pemiit regulations. If you have any
^ questions or concems please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
^ Very truly yours,
^ Dudek & Associates, Inc.
c
te
P
i
te
c
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
te Environmental Sciences Division
P cc; John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming, Helming Engineering, Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek & Associates, Inc.
Mark Plotnikiewicz, Simon Wong Engineering
Vipul Joshi, Dudek & Associates, Inc.
4186-01
& ASSOCIATES, INC. November 2004
Prci/cuiundt Ttam* for CamfAai Pn^ccb
p
L DUDEK
Professional Teams for Complex Projects
Engineering, Planning,
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporate Office:
605 Third Street
Encinitas. California 92024
760.942.5147
Fax 760.632.0164
December 1, 2004 4186-01
P
L
Ms. Carrie Loya-SmaUey
Senior CivU Engineer
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carisbad, CaUfornia 92008
Re; Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, CityofCarlsbad, California
P
L
r te
Dear Ms. Loya-Smalley:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
P
te
P
ii
p
k
te
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Construction
Construction on the final segment of the southbound lanes near the La Costa Avenue
intersection was completed in October. Two out of three southbound lanes are now open to
traffic. The third lane remains closed for a portion of Rancho Santa Fe Road south of Camino
Junipero as landscaping and other minor construction continues adjacent to the roadway.
Due to the lack of sensitive resources associated with current activity in Phase 1, biological
monitoring is not required. However, Dudek wUl continue to monitor the condition of existing
environmental fencing and erosion controls in Phase 1 with periodic inspections and wiU notify
construction management if maintenance or repairs are found to be necessary.
p
L
p
te
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road ReaUgnment and Bridge Replacement
p» Project, City of Carlsbad, California
te
Phase 2
p
te
Biological Monitoring of Construction
P
<i
te In October, Phase 2 construction involved ongoing grading and earth work in the southern
portion of the site and ongoing construction associated with the bridge and embankment
waUs. Soils from sorting activities to the south of San Marcos Creek are being hauled to the
stockpile in the northern portion of the site near the intersection of Rancho Santa Fe Road and
F Melrose Avenue. Soils are also stockpUed on the abandoned portion of old Rancho Santa Fe
^ Road that is immediately south of the San EUjo Road intersection. However, this stockpile is
not actively being used. Extensive work was also done prior to anticipated rain events to
In deploy appropriate weather-triggered BMPs and following rain events to clean up the site and
repair existing BMPs.
^ The entire bridge site along San Marcos Creek was inundated with flood waters on several
r» occasions during the heavy rainstorms that occurred in October. However, the construction
te management team and the contractor have been proactive and responsive in dealing with
forecasted storms and have effectively minimized the risk of construction-related impacts to
r* the creek and adjacent areas. As mentioned above, extensive work was carried out throughout
the site prior to and following rain events to ensure that water quality and creek-related
^ protection measures are in place and functioning. The attached rainy season action plan
te details the existing site conditions and lists the corresponding BMPs that are updated prior to
each rain event.
z As flooding has severely damaged orange fencing and overtopped sUt fencing along the
E upstream and downstream limits of the project corridor, orange fencing and sUt fencing have
been temporarily removed from the flood zone of the creek. Orange fencing and silt fencing
located above flood levels are maintained in place and continue to be checked by Dudek. To
1^ date, the only creek-related incident to note involved two small wooden bins that were washed
downstream of the site during the first storm in mid-October However, both bms were
F immediately retrieved and secured onsite without causing impacts to downstream areas.
F
p
te
The inlet and outlet of the stream diversion culverts associated with bridge construction
continue to be checked regularly by Dudek. During storm events, the culverts are inundated
as the creek floods and flows directly across the entire bridge site. Limited scour has exposed
a small portion of the stream diversion culvert at the downstream end. The exposed portion
of the outlet culvert wUl be monitored and secured in place by the contractor if necessary.
Rancfio Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
ASSOCLATES, INC.! December 1, 2004
i
te
p
te
r te
p
L
p
te
P
te
p
te
A45. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Project, City of Carlsbad, California
The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
in compliance with aU environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
Very truly yours,
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmental Sciences Division
all: Rainy Season Action Plan
CC: John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming, Helming Engineering, Inc.
Gecrge Litzinger, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
Mark Plotnikiewicz, Simon Wong Bngineering
Vipul Joshi, Dudek d2 Associates, Inc.
|&ASSOCI.\TES. INC.
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
December 1, 2004 3
p
k City ofCarlsbad
Rainy Season Action Plan for Construction Sites
Action Plans are to be in place by October 1, 2003 and UPDATED prior to each rain event.
Project Name: Rancho Santa Fe Road, Phase 2 Date: November 16, 2004
Project Address: 1645 S. Rancho Santa Fe Road, Suite 202
San Marcos, CA 92078
Contractor: FCI Constructors Project Manager: Roy Bartlett
FCI Contacts: Paul Mignone Jon Krause
Cell: 760-497-2926 Cell: 619-666-3579
Home: 619-300-3107 Home: 760-740-9498
Inspector Name & Title: Mark Plotnikiewicz, Resident Engineer
Inspector Signature:
P
k
P
k
k
p
k
p
p
i
te
Existine Condition Action Plan
Erosion Control:
Silt fence placed at toe-of-slopes, fiber roll
placed on slopes, large stockpile near San Elijo
has been sprayed with BFM, slope on west side
of existing RSF is covered with visquin
Additional silt fence, fiber roils, gravel bags,
and visquin are on site in the event ofa storm
and existing measures become inadequate.
Gravel bag check dams and silt fence will be
installed on the graded portions ofthe new road
to slow down storm water flow and prevent
erosion.
Sediment Controls:
Silt fence, gravel bag check dams, and visquin
are on the slopes leading to and adjacent to the
creek.
The access road between the bridges will be
blocked off and gravel bag check dams and silt
fence will be placed on the access road slopes
adjacent to the creek. A de-silting basin will be
constructed on the south side of the bridge just
south of the final slope leading to the creek.
The access road slopes adjacent to the creek
will be covered with visquin prior to a major
storm event.
Materials and Wastes:
Trash dumpsters are on site; concrete washout
areas are constructed; hazardous materials are
stored in spill containment area
Stockpiles of materials will be covered /
sprayed with BFM prior to a storm;
construction materials and equipment will be
removed from creek bottom and floodplain
prior to a storm event
p
te
te
p
ii
te
in
p
k
p
L
p
k
p L
Existine Condition Action Plan
Discharf»e Locations:
Exisling San Marcos Creek flows through 3 -
20" culverts dunng normal flow. During high
flow, the creek overtops the culverts and flows
through the creek Hoodplam. The bottom of
the existing creek bed and fioodplain has been
covered with rock to control silt and erosion.
The rock has been graded to direct fiow
between the falsework bents.
Prior to a storm event, all equipment and
material will be removed from the creek bed
and the fioodplain. BMP's will be constructed
on the access roads approaching the creek.
Finished Slope Protection:
N/A at this time Slopes will be stabilized with fiber rolls, BFM,
and visquin until the permanent hydro-seeding
is placed
Tlnfini.shed Slooe Protection:
All inactive slopes are stabilized Active slopes will be stabilized when they
become inactive
Con.sfruction Entrance/Exit:
Construction entrances / exits are in place near
San Elijo, La Costa Meadows, and Melrose
Drive
Additional 3" minus rock is on site for
maintenance
Inlet Protection:
Grave! bags are placed at inlets Additional gravel bags are on site in the event
that they are needed
Other:
p
li
f
te
te
te
te
Professional Teams for Complex Projecis
December 20, 2004
Engineering, Planning,
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporate Office:
605 Tfiird Street
Encinitas, California 92024
760,942.5147
Fax 760.632.0164
4186-01
k
P
P
k
z
P
k
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Senior CivU Engineer
City of Carlsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carisbad, California 92008
Re: Monthly Monttoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and
Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlshad, California
Dear Ms. Loya-SmaUey:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Construction
Roadway construction on the final segment of the southbound lanes near the La Costa
Avenue intersection was completed in October. Ongoing activity at the south end of Phase
1 at La Costa Avenue is limited to landscaping, guard raU and median work. Due to the lack
of sensitive resources associated with the current activity in Phase 1, biological monitoring
is not required. However, Dudek wiU continue to monitor the condition of existing
environmental fencing and erosion controls in Phase 1 with periodic inspections and wiU
notify construction management if maintenance or repairs are found to be necessary. All
Phase 1 activities are expected to be completed in the next few months.
p
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road ReaUgnment and Bridge Replacement
^ Project, City of Carlsbad, California
k =====^==================
Phase 2
p
k
Biological Monitoring of Construction
p
k In November, Phase 2 construction involved ongoing grading and earth work and ongoing
construction of the bridge spans. Grading and earth work is taking place to the south of San
Marcos Creek and generally involves excavation, rock crushing activities and the separation
of suitable and unsuitable fiU material. Work on the bridge spans is ongoing. A water truck
continues to make regular trips around the site to minimize dust.
The contractor is currently working to eUminate ponding that occurs in portions of the bridge
site once flood levels have receded. The ponded areas tend to drain slowly into the creek, and
can carry high levels of sUt due to the long settling time for such fine-grained material. Minor
grading and the placement of rock for soU protection is planned in the northeastern portion
of the bridge site where ponding has been the most prevalent. Once the minor grading and
placement of rock is completed, drainage through the site during and after flood events
should be improved and the potential for erosion and siltation wiU be minimized. P
te
p As flooding in October severely damaged orange fencing and overtopped sUt fencing along
k the upstream and downstream Umits of the project corridor, orange fencing and sUt fencing
^ have been temporarily removed from the flood zone of the creek. If work is expected to
^ occur near the project limits in the creek area, orange fencing or some other means of clearly
identifying the limits of work wUl be in place and a biologist present to monitor construction.
^ Orange fencing and sUt fencing located above flood levels and throughout the remainder of
^ the Phase 2 project are maintained in place and continue to be inspected by Dudek.
Construction management is notified immediately if maintenance or repairs are necessary.
L
The inlet and outlet of the stream diversion culverts are inspected regularly by Dudek. The
^ final segment of the outlet pipe culvert has been exposed by scouring during flood events, but
^ the situation is being monitored and the pipe wiU be secured if necessary to ensure that it is
^ not washed downstream during future flood events.
p
The Rancho SantaFe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
^ in compliance with aU environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
te questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
F I O S C'l ^^"'^ Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01
te |& ASSOOATTS. INC. I September 28, 2004
p
te
p
te
p
k
te
p
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Projtct, City of Carlsbad, California
Very truly yours,
Dudek 8z Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmental Sciences Division
te
P
k
te
cc: John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek d^ Associaies, Inc.
Mark Plotnikiewicz, Simon Wong Engineering
Vipul Joshi, Dudek d^ Associaies, Inc.
DUDEK & ASSOCIATES, INC.
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Repiacement 4186-01
December 20, 2004
p
te
DUDEK
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
Professional Teams fnr Comple.r Projecis
Engineering, Planning,
Environmental Sciences and
Management Services
Corporate Office:
605 Third Street
Encinitas, California 92024
760.942.5147
Fax 760.632.0164
te February 7, 2005 4186-01
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Senior CivU Engineer
City of Cadsbad
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carisbad, California 92008
Re: December 2004 Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road
Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project City of Carlshad, California
k
P
k
Dear Ms. Loya-SmaUey:
In accordance with the requirements of the Biological Opinion issued by the U.S. Fish and
WUdUfe Service (USFWS), this monthly letter report summarizes biological monitoring
activities and reports on compliance with permit regulations. Biological monitoring of the
project is being conducted by biologists from Dudek and Associates, Inc. (Dudek) through
periodic visits during construction.
Phase 1
Biological Monitoring of Construction
Roadway construction on the final segment of the southbound lanes near the La Costa
Avenue intersection was completed in October. Ongoing activity at the south end of Phase
1 at La Costa Avenue is limited to landscaping, guard raU and median work. Due to the lack
of sensitive resources associated with the current activity in Phase 1, biological monitoring
of construction activity is not required. However, Dudek has been and wUl continue to
monitor the condition of existing environmental fencing and erosion controls in Phase 1 with
periodic inspections and wiU notify construction management if maintenance or repairs are
found to be necessary. No adverse impacts have been observed in the Phase 1 project area.
AU Phase 1 activities are expected to be completed in the next few months.
P
te
F
k
te
p
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: December 2004 Monthly Monitoring Report, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge
^ Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
Phase 2
Biological Monitoring of Construction
In December, Phase 2 construction involved ongoing grading and earth work in the upland
areas to the south of San Marcos Creek and ongoing construction associated with the south-
bound bridge. Grading and earth work to the south of San Marcos Creek generally involves
excavation and rock crushing activities, as well as excavation for storm drain construction
within the roadway. The bridge spans along the south-bound bridge have been compieted.
Current work involves construction and placement of utUities within the bridge cells.
Construction activity in the northern portion of the project site near Melrose Avenue is
limited with most of the area being used for staging.
k The bridge site continues to be flooded by high water levels in San Marcos Creek foUowing
_ rain events. The three stream diversion culverts remain in place and continue to convey flow
through the bridge site. When the creek is flooded however, flows overtop the culverts and
flow directly across the bridge site. The final pipeline segment of the outlet culvert on the
downstream side of the site has been exposed by scouring during repeated flood events; the
situation continues to be monitored to ensure that the pipeline segment is not dislodged and
washed downstream. No construction activity has been conducted within the flooded areas.
Rock StockpUed along the eastern embankment wall on the north side of the creek has yet
to be removed from the creek area as recommended in the previous monthly report. As the
bridge site continues to be flooded foUowing periodic rain events, there has been little
opportunity for work to occur at the bridge site throughout the month of December.
As flooding in San Marcos Creek from the rains in October severely damaged orange fencing
and overtopped sUt fencing along the upstream and downstream hmits of the project
corridor, orange fencing and sUt fencing have been temporarily removed from the flood zone
of the creek. If work is expected to occur near the project limits in the creek area, orange
fencing or some other means of clearly identifying the limits of work will be in place and a
biologist present to monitor construction. Orange fencing and erosion control measures
located above flood levels and throughout the remainder of the Phase 2 project are
maintained in place and continue to be inspected by Dudek.
la ASSOCIATES, INC.
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement
Febmary 2005
z p
k
k
te
F k
Ms. Carrie Loya-Smalley
Re: December 2004 Monthly Monitoring Rtport, Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge
Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, California
Erosion control measures currently in place throughout the site include sUt fencing, fiber
rolls, bonded fiber matrix (BFM) and visquin. SUt fencing, gravel bag check dams, visquin and
temporary catchment basins are also in place adjacent to the creek in order to minimize
runoff and sedimentation into the creek. Dudek continues to monitor the condition of
construction site BMPs and construction management is notified immediately if maintenance
or repairs are necessary.
The Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement Project is being constructed
in compliance with aU environmental requirements and permit regulations. If you have any
questions or concerns please contact me at (760) 479-4292.
Very truly yours.
P
k
Dudek & Associates, Inc.
Kam Muri
Monitoring Biologist
Environmental Sciences Division
pi
te
p
k
cc: John Martin, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Doug Helming Helming Engineering Inc.
George Litzinger, Dudek di Associates, Inc.
Jason Linsdau, Dudek d^ Associates, Inc.
Vipul Joshi, Dudek d2 Associates, Inc.
te
c & ASSOCIATES, INC I ivrf»rt~rT™./-c—»i=p~j-t. February 7, 2005
Rancho Santa Fe Road Realignment and Bridge Replacement 4186-01