The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About; |COASTAL CONSERVANCY|Constantino, Ben V & Joan C|; 88-266867; Easement0. -w 2189 a:,,. 2 5 6 -8 q; 7 "_ . Recording Requested by and When Recorded Mail To: City Clerk City of Carisbad 1200 Elm Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 1 ... . I. . . j -.. . .- i . " I - .- -,ii __._ *. i i;. . i . : -..: ., .I+. :.: .2<:;!::::, . , . . I' :.., . : . ~: : , :: :t< T < . . .. - .-.:. i".c.." I -. F '2 r; :: > ri.?r , :. -g: j13J IC. : i .%>%s. =:s:.: L" q; i 1 ; . : ~, i 'I" - .. .. . ... .I. "_^,_. $-;-.ji ;' .: ::: { F::.:':- I-! 1 i ui?%::. , .__ :., .,..:, ~ ;; ; L r.:: - ~ .. CERTIFICATE OF ACCEPTANCE This is to certify that the City of Carlsbad hereby accepts the Offer to Dedicate for Permit No. F-9505 Executed by: Ben V. Constantino and Joan C. Constantino on January 26 , 19% and recorded on February 10, 1981 As Instrument No. 81-041445 of the Official Records in the Office of the Recorder of San Dieqo County. May 26, 1988 BY dLL i 62& AELTHA L. RAUTENKRANZ, City [Clerk Dated For The City of Carlsbad -1 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF 1 On May 26, 1988 , before the undersigned, a Notary Public, personally appeared Aletha L. Rautenkranz ? 15s /x/ personally known to me / / pxved to me on the hzsis ~f satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) who executed the within instrument as City Clerk of the corporation/agency therein named and acknowledged to me that thc corporation/agency executed it. * .............................. OFFICIAL. SE,+t t * NOTARY PUBLC-CAtiFeRRiA :: :: * SAN DIEGO COUNTY * * MY Comm. Ex*. SCUI. 27. 1999 2 ****+******+**********.**+**** KAREN 8. KUNOTZ 8 * I Noyy Pub1 idi n pid fordaid County and State 7 i /( E p "._ L _." _"""_._C_" --"-~~------ ." # mi i94 e, FjLf;? .. 'C;F 81441 ''7 Id. '7 /& C2lG f I! !I I' 1; zeturn CriqiZA 'ZC EX^ 1' Reca*SicG Er.;L&s t.ed 3y: ; < -cy I : .. ". I. - :, , , : nr,-- -. -.. REC":Z:,: i.L.~.,_2~ c:~ il 'I. fit+ f, Pi., SAl, f 4 1 ,; state cf Califorr.ia kB 10 io. js il{ 'L i f. 11 Californis coastal rom.issicn . -. .. 3 11 031 Eoward Street, 4ch Flcor -4 ui<' i OFFICII,L ;.:~RDs . !i Sari Irilaciscc;, cslifcrz<z 941r)~ %AH DEW c:.gvTy, CA, 3 !I .VERA L. LYLE I/ &A8 : RECORDER 'i El 9 2 15'81 - "i 6 I Ii?RFiCCADLE: OFFER TO CZ3TCAT i ''1 :* ~U-SEREAS, (I)& U: &23+dn/,nc. i J~I~, L: &7~ AmJ/Os. . 8 I tfie record o.vr.er(s) , tereinzfter referred ta as "cwner (s) ", of the rei 31'* ~roger:y located zt (2) &&d7 flQrr& Dc' f Qrb, &W/!Xb&( -fde \ 16 1 - 11, I 12 Califoraia, le?s11y described as partiav.lzrly sa.? forth in attacked ? m:hijit A hereby i?corI;orated by reference, and hereinafter refsrred l.3 /r cas&j ect progert-y" ; ar.3 14 , 11. t v,,cFsAsI the Caltfcrnia Coastal com~ssiop., (:ai Sn o/e2 15 !I Cozst Regional Ccmission, hereiriafter referred to as "the Codssion II 16 17 acting on behalf of the People of the State of California; and 111. TXXZFZASI the Pecple of the State. of Caiir'cr-ia have a legal i1 IS 1 z 11 on The scbject p,pezty4td I ir! th2 lands seawar3 cf the nwan 'nigh tiee line; end 19 ,\ IV= \rizm, pursuant 20 tks Caiifornir Cazstai Act of 1975, kke < ~n 1 a$iec? to t.:?e c&mi.ssioT: for a coastal developent Fernit fgr (4!& '" 1 21 i OK 3doo -%, 4. S,/79/€ -L.k/v /Y,'d:niP 6./cc4&' ASFfldd4 7+ 9 21 1 1 v. >ZE&S, a coastal ~evelo~ment permit no. (s>f 9305 vas gr I on 6- &rdflL b&zc n / Ad< z5 I (6) Daefldbpv /9 , 14;. I by the Comlission in accc .. $ -.* z6 1 tk _r;rovisions sf the Stafi RecomenSation and Findisgs (7) "" Exhibir ' i i ST." 0- c*-.rJ..(t* Ii 27 1 // COL'RT PkPES ~10 *:3 .rev o f:. a&: jj I /. '.*. *. W( " '1 / / 1 1' Etttz.Chfd hereto and here& incorp-lrated by reference, Subject tG the fallDwj 2 record the following restriction against the subject property: 5 conz:.tion: (3) I I - That p?h%kro transmittal ok th permit, the permittee shali" - 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 I1 12 13 14 I 1. I Pennittee agrees to irrevocably offer to dedicate to a public agency or private association approved by the Executive Director, of the San Diego Coast Regional Commission or its successor in interest, an easement for public access and recreaticn on that portion of the pernittee's property seaward of the toe cf the bluff. This easement shall be free of prior liens an2 encun- brances except for tex liens. In no case shall this easemeat be construed to allow the public to climb upon the bluff or to , use that portion of the permittee's property easterly of the toe of the bluff. The irrevocable offer shall be binding on the permittee's successors in interest and any subsequent .purchasers of any portion of the real property, " VX. h"riEIzEX, the subject SroTerty is a parcel located betveen the first 15 1 pblic road and the shoreline; utd 16 // 'LE. WHZRkS, uder the Folicies of Sections 30210 through 30212 of the 17 18 I California Coastal Act of 1976, pblic access to the shoreline and aloilg; 20 VIII. KEELS, the Ccripnission f0ur.d that but for the imposition of the ab07 jetween L\e first public road and the shorelhe shall be provized; and 19 the coast is tc! be maximized, an5 in all new development projects located. 1.. j/ 2= // conlir;ion, the prtposed de-rciopnen: cvriid r-ut be fsuiiC consi~~er.: witii Lhe 22 a 2e";nlt could not be have been granted; 24 Coastal Act of 1976 and that therefore in the sbsence of such a condition, 23 I peblic access policies of Section 3C210 through 30212 of tho- Califcrnia 25 I // 26! // I 1 27 COURT P.\PEQ 5'" 1 13 # scv 3 'PI STAlt GT '-\-!?ORNIA OL- i I i ! 1 // -2- <;-. .\ I ':, \ fs1 .. ~. I ._ .( e! 1436 1 NOW TSZREFGFE, in consideration of the granting of pernit no. 2 ( 9 If- YZ75 " to the owner (s) by che Commission, the owner(s) hereby 3 to dedicate to the Pesple of California an easenent in peqetuity for 4 purposes of (10) 5 L. PYA4 L c&z?Cfsr &,?//' f/&-"&. x. .-/, " 6 1:- ? located on the subject property (11) U " - 9 &Afw/4Gf? 0-4 74 <'. -4C.e oi 4.4 &+g I 3 I and as specifically set forth by axacned Exhibit C (3.2) i-iereby inm: I / lo 1 by refzrexe. 11 This offer of dedication shall be irrevocable for a pericd of 12 the local government in whose jurisdiction the schject property lies, 16 15 i shall accept, tkis offer thrcugh the (13) 14 the scrSject property Sescribed a33cve. The People cf the State of Cal: 13lbinding upon the owner(s1, their heirs, assigns, or successors in ina cne (21) years, measured foward fron the date .of recordatim, and shi , I *' Ir I/ /fi n24#& 17 I a pcblic agency or a private association ,acceptable to the Executive 1 18 1 of the Conrmissicn or its successor in interest. I 20 l9 /I ,I // // 21 1 //t 22 // 23 24 25 26 27 ll ji ii '/ 1 // i // I // COURT F4PER I ST^ \13 .REV. 6.72. liTl.7L OP CAC.?OI'<I4 II 0.2 . H -3- *, - .'H*. e( 14'3'9W, 1 0 I, 3 4 5 6 7 8 .3 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 * 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 2e 27 "_ . COURT PAPER STD. 113 I~LV. e..'zl C'TLTC CC 3ALl~OWwlA e.- I Acceptance of tk offer is sukject to a covenmt which runs with the 1- land, providing that the first offerez to accept the easement may not zbandon it but mucc instezd offer the easener?t to other public agencies or private associatigns acceptabie to the Executive Girector of the Commission for ths ' Zuration of the term of the origina.1 offer to dedicate. The graat of easema once made shall run with the lane and shall be binding on the ovners? their heirs? an8 assigns. I Executed on this 26th day of January , 1g81 , in the City o f couiity of Los. Angeles " .. .. I Date& " ... Signed d' I ,~~/~~~~/< (OWNZR) HEN Vo CONSTANTINO ,.-I .I I .i L. .:,/%-.v ./ L i' &;-I -6 ' p& L'JoAN c. cdsm~No OWtJER STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES On Januarv 26. 1981 , before the ur,dersignet, a Not,?ry FuSlis and for said State, personally appeared ***BEN V COSTANTINO AND JOAN c .. .> . . . ... . I/ INO* f * * * , whose name(s) are subsczibee td tha .. . .. within instrument, ad acknowicdge that they exczuted tk same- N6taq Pul$i/c in anc far said County and 5 I II ;; j " ~ar4 LOU Iman MARY LOtJ IMAN WQTARY WBUC - CALIFORNIA Los AWOELES Ooum PRINCIPAL OFFICE tN My CommMon Expires June 7,1984 ( .. /',-, ' I ' " \ i, I/ - -4- - - . - ..""._.. - .~ .. -. - " _." - " -- . ._ ., r . ._ I (a 1-4 5 8 a 1 I1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1G I 1 I 11 12 13 14 15 3.6 17 18 l9 I P. 2o ! &I. 1 This is to cerrify t5st the offer or' erdicstion set forth above 81 , znd signed by & 0, &'j-j&'L , owner (SI, is hereby ackr,owledged by tl undersigned officer on behalf of the California Coastal Conmission pu: tc authority cor?ferred by the California Coastal Commission when it g: v .I9& h c JiPanchKr /7 HL7 - Cozstel Development Pernit No. F 95'0 5 on-, 19, J. / ym California Coastal Commission consents to recordation thereof by its c authorized officer. Cats5 : &A,+/ d7y /sa/ / , eYXl7jlKA k t" fcc,C&(:~~@ California Coastal Conmission STATE OF CALIFORNIA CdbXTY OF SAN FRANCISCO on zm~d a, /r/ , befcre L?e undersigned, a Notzry 31: and for said State, personally zp_neared {%4 K' Adfly I knsm to me to be the -'n(ff. /- NSXLG of the California Coastal Commission and known to me to be the persor executed the within instment on behalf of said Commission, and ackr to me that such Conmission executed the same. 'rJitaess my hzad ad uEficial saal. 22 23 24 25 26 27 CSURT PAPER s+crc or CIC:?CRN~I 5:'~ I 13 <wcv a.711 nw I I i 1 ! I I 1 i " -5 - .."- . . ". __ .. . . _.-.. .. , .. " r- ** . .* 5rA;i a:. =A~;~;~:.J,/,-~AI~:~!<!A CDP.SIXL c.- A " u U"S __.__". €iYAUN3 G. ~ "" iF.G\'<P """" jR , Gu.. s&< !.j:;.a;'j cL.Ad,t i<~.::~,~.,~,~ (I~;~rl+:~*..ava\ jy XL-; C'yiL!, a,p:c$H;& p2;2p - :r; (?: ?! 283"?? _" """___ "" .. .". "". "" """" _""""""""" -" "." --..- . """ _."_ " ""_ - - "_. - ..F.: ,-,vc- --->cr?r8;' ~~Mr~F~fl.*f)'; &!>4 #.,f:%g t'l:?3;;E ram, X!K 222 ( E"&,&- Fi F5_ICOIfiEidDAT'iON AXD TIEJDIKL'GS """" COXli'H3;, fi'o : FS505 23PFL;CALi';' : Ben V. and Soar; C, corstaatino 2896 Pinelewrl Drivz ~a Crescerlta, Cli 92174 LnST I.?&:' FG? DATE 07 PUBLIC AC'1'10:: : Dece!r&xx 26, 1930 ECAGIIX: Decenber 5, 1'330 VGT& XE:2! JIiiX? : Majority of Com',sslcn mc-nlbexs present at meeting ~7i.tk: ii q~ ner;cssary ;ror actlo-? ('r ~om~issioners ccnsrikutc a quorirmj . C!~!.~.!IE~I.C;.IEfiS -7ESz:l;'i' AT PUXiLlC ?ILAIAIICG : Eckert, Francis, Galimon, Gotch (portion of hearin,?), IIedgeccck f (XHERS WI3 SPOEI: OR OTRERS STJBNITTINC WRITTEN p?cISTZpzp yc, spE,m C3SUmCS AT OR PF3'3R TO AT ?UBL'iC €EEI',RIGG : .. PUBLIC IIZAXING : Anne Omsted'& Joan Jackson (Sierra club) PROJECT LcXATi 01J : 5009 Tierr2 del Oro, ne= Carlsbad Blvd./Canxn RGzd - intersection, CarlsFJad (APN 210-020-171 PE.OSECT DESCRIPTION: .. Construction of a 3,600 sq. ft. single-family residence, (includes basemalt and garage) on a vacant beachfront lot. Lot area Building coverage Paved area. coverace Landscape coverage & cobhly hczch Parking Zoning Gelieral plan Project density Hg ::. abv . svg . grak 13,400 sq.ft. .. 2,65S sq.ft. (20%) 600 SQ.ft. { 4%) /' 10,142 sq.ft. (76%) h L R-1 - Low-mcd. Residential . 0-4 du/ac ' 3.25 du/ac 20' .- i%IlDiTI3IP.L SUBSTANTl'JE FILS DOCUIvikNTS: Letter from Siang Tax, Div. Mines aI;d. GcolPgY. ,, z 6 -3L.J "- "" "_""""._ -.- RECO~~,~f:NL~A'rIr):.: : - , "._ ...- .-.. - . \ s.f;sfi- rccoimcnd-; ti?at t11;: su ~icgo cozst: neqional.'.~~issio,? ISSW a . .. ~cv-:.cl~.~~l?: p.:.>li t. f~r t:;e ~TQI:o.c.;~~ prcjcc.t .cnSject to.kJc- fo&lqwias srJdLcinl. con2i.tions: 12-12-8( (Spccicil Conditions conti ;lucd next page) TE : am 0 ( 0 .. .. R&corrmendation and Findings F9505 Page 2 1501 SPECIAL C,3Y.TD'I "IONS : "- ^"" 1. (a) - That prior to transmittal of the pennit, the permittee shall record the followingarestriction against the subject property FCXIIIittee agrees to irrevocably offer to dedicate to a public agency cr >r!.::?t'.e assoziati.on approved by the Ex$cutivc ~.',rec Of ihc Ssn Diqo Coast Regicaal Commission or its ~~~c~s~<~~ F: interest, an easemernt for public access and recreation on t)-,s portion of the pernittee's property seaward of the toe of thle bluff. This easement shall be free of prior liens and encwo- ~X&LLC.L~S KCCrp-i; ZGlZ tdY iieils. In 110 CdsC snaii this easement he construed to allow the pcblic to climb upon the bluff 01- t, use that portion of the permittee's property easterly of the toe of the bluff. The irrevocable offer shall be binding on the prmittec's successars ir? interest and any subsec;uent purchasers of any portion of the real property. (bj - "Prior tc; the transmittal of a coastal developnent permit, th applicant-shall submit to the Executive Director a tied re- ; " striction for r-ecordinq, free of prior liens except for tar. liens, thzt binds the applicant any any successors in interes The folT.nl and content of the deed restriction shall 5~ sukject to the review and approval of the Executj.ve Director. The deed' restriction shall .j-rGvide (a) that the applicants under- stand that the sit? may -. 6e'subject - - to extraordi.nary kszard from erosion and lacdsiides caused by waves from storms, an2 the applicants sssune the liaSility frcm those hazards; (b) the applicants onccnditivnally waive any claim of liability on thepart of the Commission or any oth'er regulatory agency . for my damage from such hazards; and (c) the applicants unde stand that construction in the face of i:hese probable hazards may mke them ineligible for public disaster funds or loans for repir, replacenent, or rehabilitztion of the property j.3 the event of 's~onns er,d landslides. (c) - That prior to transmittal of a building pemit fron the City of CarlsLad, the applicant shall have the buildinc plans for the proposed project (irxluding a foundation planj reviewed by the Division of Mines and Geology. This official Cmmcnt from ths Division of Mines and Geology shall be sdxnfitt~d with the buildirq permit application for subsecpent Zeview by tha Citry of Carlsbad Building Department. -7, c W( Rccom.eAdation and Findlngs 1582 F9505 Page 3 FlNDINGS : "" 1. Confcmi-ty witl: t.hc Provisions of Chaptar 3 of the Czltfoznic Coastal Act of 1076 - Section 36xG4 (a) of the California Coastal Act of 197G requires that the Regional Commission find, prior to issuance of a permit, that the pro- posed development is consistent with the provisions of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. The Commission finds that this proposed development, as conditioned, is consistent with the Chapter 3 policies. Additional consistency finds are made below. "- A. Public Access - The Coastal Act states: . +tior! 30210 - In carrying out the requirement of Section 4 of the Article X of the California Constitution, maximum access, which shall be conspicu0usi.y posted, and recraation opportunities shall be pro- . vided for all the people consistent with public safety needs and the' need to prp'tect public rights, rights of private property owners, and * natural resource areas fron overuse. Section 30211 - DeVelOFmnt shall not interfere with the public's right of access to the sea where acquired thrcugh use, custom, or legislative authorization, including, but not limited to, the use of dry sand and rocky coastal beaches to the first line of ter- restial vegetaion. SsctiGz 3G212 - 2uBli.c access fr-or;. tLe nearcst public r~zdway to the shoreline and along the coast shall be provided in new development project; except, where (1) it is inconsistent with public safety, military securitqr needs, or the ?rote-ticn of fxagile coastal re- sources, (2; irdc-q?u~l:e acces: exists LcarSy, or (3) agriculture would be adversely affected. Dedicated accessway shall 'not be required to be opened to pubilc use until a public agency or private association agrees to acdept responsibility for maintenance ar.d liability Of t.he accessway.. An existing path on the subject site suggested that project site nay have heen -:sed 3q the public for vertical access to the teach from Tierri: d?l Cro. The ~.. scbjcet propcrcy 2nd tnc \racailt lot to the south arc both fenced off from 'rierra del Oro or1 the biuf f top. \ -3- '. Recomncndatior~ rind Findi * .. ' F9505 * ,. Paqe 1 IS93 e The applica:lt nas stated that the path has not been used recently by the pul and that the existing path has resulted prinarily fro3 private use . Acce! to the. Leach fron Carlsbad Blvd. is 1;tatc.d ~~~.~~r;j~~in~~~~~~.~ L5C feet to +:lie nc %he Comr!issicn finds that approval cf prcposed project is not e>:pected to ii VertiCal public; aCCeSS to the teach dr;e to the nearby public access to the Special coniitj-on 1 (a) I which reqllires the public deeication of the beach a (west of the tcje of the bluff) , would ensure that lateral public access wou be nainthined. Tnus, the Comission finds that proposed project, as condit is consistent-. with Secrr."ons 3G212, 3221.1, a!-d 36212 :chich detail the ma.intc: of public ZCCCLE: to tile shgxi:linz. .. .\ ." . E. 31-.Cj.i?<:l In;. Ct~*,~t?.I.c?psnJi a~c? Al.t.er~ttion of Landforms- - Section 30251 " 2- - "_ the C03S"Ci A,Z% StotES: ." " The scenic and visual qualities of coastal areas shall be considered and Frotecteci as a xes3uTcc Of public importance. Permitted development shall be sited and designed to protect views to and along the ocean and scenic coastal areas, io rnin!.nize the alteration of natural land forms, 'to be visually conpatible wi.th the character of surrounding areas, in vi&ual.ly degraded areas. . and, where fezsible, to restore acd enhance visual quality On residentfal .T;~velop:+mts along the coastline, the Commission considers t orientation of a pxopqsed structure in relation to existing dwellings on ei side. Tho propas&! residence is set back far emugh to conforn with the ex ing string line. - The prcposed project will require,a "cut" into the slope of approximately 3 cubic yards. The bluff in this area was used as a dcmp area for the old hi some years ago. The Commission finds that the ncut"Iwhich is minor in scal would involve renoval of previous fill material, would not rqxcsent alters of a natural 'land form, Thus, the Cormission fin2s tha5 the proposed prcjsct is consistent with Sec 30253. of the Act, since the hcuse is set back far enough to'conform with th stringlinc: and 110 signir'j cm-t ;!l.teraLion of a land fo-m will occur. C. Ezard from ITavs Ai.t.uc!: - Scction 30253 of the Coastal Act states: "New development shall: .(i) Minimize risks to life znd property ic areas of high geologic, flood, arid fire hazard; (2) Assure stabil slid structural integrity, and neither create nor contribute signif to erosion, geologic instability, Gr destruction of tile site or su rounding area or in any way require the construction cf protective devices that would substantially alter natural landforms along blc and clifi's: """ The apFlicani: suhitted a geoloyy report, which states the following in ref to hazards from erosion: -4- * ? 1304 m ReccmmendaL:ion and Findings F9505 Page 5 . "It is believed that the house is located far enough from the beach and to2 of the slope that erosion will not present a problem. It is assumed that the neighbors would cocpcrac2 to line the toe of the slope with riprap should the front change for the worse in the future.'' DLe to the. extensive erosion that has occurred to the beach profile in the recent past, and because residents to the south heve deemed it necessary to ir.- stall and repair rip-rap,. staff seeked additional input from the Division of Elinos axi Gealccjy regarding any hazards from erosion resulting from wave atta.l=k. Mr. 8hr;; S. Tm, fl-ox1 the Santa A-qa off ice of the Divisioa oi Xi zes and ~C.c~i~~*~ visited the sitc on December 8, 1980 (letter attached) . He states that the site and adjacent areas appear to have a history of increased wave erosion. The mean high tide line has moved inland approximately 100 feet since 1953. 52 I He further indicztes that if no protective devices are installed, the anticipated amount of wave erosion should be considered in the engineering design of the proposed dwelling. Condition 1 (C) requires the zpplicant to have the foundation plans reviewed and com.-?ntcd on by the Civision of Mines and Geology, prior to submitting an applicat with. the City of Carlsbzil for a bcilding permit. The Division of Mines and Geolog has requested additional information needed j.c order to complete a geotechnical ir vestigation of the-proposed site. It is thuc suggesteS that the applicant submit a geotcchnical report (in addition to revised foundation plaris) which indicates', . bct not lilnite6 to, the following: -. ;.l) An accurate topographic map of the site with cross-section(s). (2) A slope stability analysis of the sea bluff based on results of a shear (3) Calculation of the rate of sea wave erosion or anticipated amount of test of saturated (soaked) native material remolded to native conditions. erosion during the life span of the proposed building. '2 ,.P L. C7om.igsion finds that this condition w.i.11 help ensure that the Carlsbad Build' DzpariLqeiik has received amsle information 2nd recommendations needed for their ravi.cw a2 the proposed project. ' In a4ditim the Commissiol; finds that condition l(b), a waiver of liability, . will ensure that the applicant is aware of pc,ssibI.c hzzzrls and that the Conunissi wiil not Se held res~or;sibl.s for any future disa.stcrs. The Commission finds that the proposed project, as conditiond, is consistent witf Section 30253 of the Act, which requires the Conmission to minimize risks to life and propesty, and to assure stability and structltral integrity of any. new devclop:r,;m t . . .- 2. Preparation of Local Coastal Program - Section 30604(a) also requires "" "."" thclt a coastal developrn2nt permit shall. be issued only if the Regional Corn;nissiol - - finds that tJtc permitted devcI.opment will llot prejudice the ability Of thL? local yovcrmnent to prepare F. local coastal program (LCP) in confomi.ty v1it.h tllc pro- visions of Cha1:ter 3 of tile Coastal. lict. Construction of a singl~-family msi- dence in this area of Carlsbad will not prt.judice thc ;tloption of the C'lr] shad r .1 b ?. e- *( 1505 Recommendation and Findings F9505 Page 6 3. Feasible Alternative or Mitigation Measures - Under the terms~of the California Envirolunental Quality Act, the Commission m1JSt review any feasihlc alternatives or mitigation measures which would avoid any potentially signifj cant adverse environmental impacts associated with development, With the attached sp'ecial conditions, the proposed project will not create any substal impacts on the environment. Therefore, no additional alternatives or mitigai measures are proposed. - ROTLF, 'JO )-?T'L'T?$.:?i' ".- jG9 (X"j23 lT!ZD3ST9 P"R.LSOfiS: Color s'iides pertair?ing to this project, may be shoprn tc the Co,.,. 7i7fiSSj a time of the Fix21 Vote, Those tkshing to see these slides, as well as otl makerial recleivtd pursuat to- tPis application, are welcone to do so at tl Co,n"ssionss offices prior to the day of the Codssion meeting. DPORTIJITT : 1ill 'appedls of Regional Comission decisions must be received Fn tl Codssion office not later tha 10 wrking, dzys fmk 'thc date of thc Reg: Comnission's decision, Appeal foms art: avaihklie at the Fcgional CczrLs -6- . P.ZCC)M~YEN~A'LJ UL'J & f II\uIILb> . PAdX ' 7 w - k' 9505 I 1Sij6 mI - IU'OTICE to Al-rT.TZ;iJTS : All psrmits granted by the San Diego Coast Regional Commission aresubjectto the following st3,ndard terms and conditions and standard provisions : A. STI\!JEARD TI3LYS .%Nil C3NDITIOMS: 1. That the applicant agrees to adhere strictly to the current plms for the prcject as approved by the -F:egional Commission. 2. That the applizaht agrees to notify the Regional Commission (or State Cornnission if there is no Regional Commission) of any changes in the project . 3. That the applicant will nect all the local code reqniremcnts and ardinmces and obtai:: all necessary permits from State and Federal Agencies. 4, That the abl;licant screes to conform to the permit rules and regula- tions of the CaliforRia Coastal Ccnmission. 5. That the applicant agrees that the Connission staff may make site inspections of the project during construction and upon completion. " Term and Conditions are to rr?n with the land. These terms and condi- * tions ,shall be perpetual and it is the intention of the parties to bind all fkture owners and possessors of the subject prol;erty to said terms and conditions, B. STANDARD PROVISIONS: 1. STRICT COWLIANCE: ?ermi.ttee is under obligation to Conform strictly to permit under penalties established by California Coastal Act of 1976. 2. TIIJELY DEVELOPi4ENI' AND CCMPLETi@N: Pe-mittee slpEl~L..C&gunenc.e. devclo3- ment withj? two years follcwi.nganal approy;tlof the project .by the San Diego fi~glnnal"~ommission, Construction shall be pursued in a diligent ma-w~ sad completed within a reasonable period of time. "- - ""-e. h,::,". * "-- 3. ~ZQUEST FOR FYTENSIONS: Permittee may request an extension of time for t!?? commencerent. of ccns'iruction Frovided the request is qslied for prior to expiration of the _cermlt, - 4. ASSIGNhBILiTY OF PEEMTT: This permit is not assignable unlcss the per- mittee's obligations under the permit are assumed by assignee in writing witill orryc-ar and a copy of the required assumption agreemnt delivered to thc Regio Commission or State Commission if there is no Regional Conmission. 5. APPEAL - Unless appcaled to the State Commission withill tcn (13) worki - days follo!ding final accion hy the San Diego Coast Segional- Commission, all tc and conditions shall bc final. 6. " D1SCLAfMI:K: " The permit is in :IO way intended to affect the riqhts ani 0hliga:ioiis hcrctoiore existinq under private agreements nor to affect thc CY.j ing regulations of other public bodies. --- 7. PI?.IYlITTET: TO I?Yi'I.lPN .COPY: This permit sh;tIl not bc. valid un1c:;s wit]: ,k:' - ten ( I.(\) workirlcl tl,xy<; pc:a1ittx:c rctur;ls a signed CO~))' c\~kn~wIt?dgi.r;~~. cci;tsl:tS ""__ """ ' i, San ni.ccJo CGarit rct.>qicmul Cctmrrlisr; ion. .. -7- , . .. -. .. .( ISU7 :I I . . _." "_ ." ST-IE Or CXlIC)RNlA, -- THC PELOUECES AGFNCY . "____ EDMUND G. 6RO .- - I?FI'AI;lMFNr OF CC!i![RVAT!Otl ~- ""._ ____." -" DiVISI9'N CJF I.!riNES AND GEOLQGY CC>S ANSELES CiSTRICT OFFtCE /3l 107 SSUTH B?.OAC'+VAY, ROOM 1065 . LDS ANSEES, CX P30:Z (Phone 313620.356Oj , From: Siang S. Tan 28 Civic Center Plaza, Room 64 Sxta Ana, CA. 92731 . Phone: (73.4) 558-4187 ATSS: 657-4167 ,. ,.I fi@l( $3; \;I\ jL2 \ .:,>,, . ( ../ ;.:,.- pr c 1 ( December 9, 1980 . c. . Phone: (73.4) 558-4187 ATSS: 657-4167 ,. ,.I fi@l( $3; \;I\ jL2 \ .:,>,, . ( ../ ;.:,.- pr c 1 ( December 9, 1980 . c. ._ , . C$\T. CQF! 38 bid Fir. ThOiitkS IiUf flmn San Diego Coast Regional Corrunission 6154 Mission Gorse mad, Suite 220 San Die.go, California 92120 Subject: Control No. F9505, Proposed Dwelling at 5009 Tierra del Oro Street, Carlsbad, CA. . Dcar Mr. Huf fman: Pur'suant to our phone conversation and your request for 01 surroundings on December 8, 1980 and have the followi.ng comments : . I To complete our geotechnical evaluation of the site, more specific and detailed information are needed, among other: (1) an accurate topographic map of the site with cross- section(s); (2) 2 slope stability analysis of the sea bluff based on results of shear test of saturated (soaked) native material or rexolded to nztive conditions; (3) rate of sea wave erosion or anticipated amount of erosion during the lifespar! of the proposed buildiny. It; seems that the site arid adjacent areas have a history of increased wave erosion. Based on or,e of the maps in- cluded in ycur "pro ject suirxmry" report of December 1 , 1980, the mean high tide line in 1978 seems to have moved approxiamtely 1.00 feet inland from the mean high tidelinc position in 1953 or 25 years earlier. A landward shift of the high tide line in the amount of 100 feet within a erosion. During my recent visit, there seemed Lo be indicaticns that the toe of the unprotected seabluff at the site may be located about 19 to 15 feet more inland than the position of the adjacent po~rl-ion of the sea bluff t:ilich is protected by rip rap rcvctn!cnts constructed about 10 years ago. This conditiol: my also be indicative of review of thz &QVE applicaticx, I visited the site a;:d period ot 25 years is a very significant rate of shoreline .. .( 1308 @: To: T. Huffman; From: S. Tan; 12/9/80; P2 .. significant wave erosion at the site. 1: no protective device is proposed for the site, the anti2ipated amount of wave erosioa should therefore be seriously considered in the engineering design of the proposed dwelling. The Sluff face in the area which consists of terrace deposits shows soae water seepage which has an adverse efzect on the stability of the slope and shoulii therefore be considere2 in the stability analysis of the bluff. COIJCLUS ION : To complete our evaluation of the geotechnical aspects of the proposed dwelling, an accurate topographic map and cross-section of the site, a slope stability ana1ysj.s of saturated native material (in native soils condition), and the anticipated amount of wave erosion during the lifespan of the proposed building are necessary in order to recom- mend proper geotechnical design criteria. for the foundation and other engineering aspects of the proposed dwelling. If y& have any further questions, please contact me at our Santa Ana off.ice. Sincerely, , Sli+ .Ti. Siang S. Tan Geologist APPROVED : - Zmes F.Davis, State Geolcgist SST:JPD:bb cc: Perry Y. kmimoto Cliff H. Gray, Jr. ,a * I. . *. a( is09 e, ~. \~KT~IT:J CG~I~\l~i<'!'~> '.'O!:F.l - _"" "" !' _1 < T' )c cr ruT;r,Ic 1;l.:p,RItx: I 3 - 5 - 8 0 ~PTLIC;Yi'TON cO1:Ti:oL :::' q 5'0 s - 9. -" Dit PLAN[?JNG I':ATTCR i.:; jsG!:~i TS I:\'I'I:::.:L>;~'~ FCR USE: BY TIIOSir: L?![a ATri'CI,!i) j, PuikLIc ]\~~~~?~~~~ ?)SI3 T\!X U::AP?,i~; i. !<iTS!I "1t3 SP!:.:LI:. !ZY CO:.!PL,C'I'T!!G X!II SUS:.i>TTIKL'C; '!?!IS r"Q!Y.l AT l7IE "I'TEIE OF 'l'i!E PL!~I J ,?LC ~~~~'~'.~~r,i~;~{I~!l~~ Yar;T< ELIGII3ILI'i'Y FOS Si')EI\KIKrJ 0:j 'i'!{lS i.;,31".?i.;lt Til' TIiS 'i'?>.li: (]I.' r 1'15 AN3 k'02 i',!'l":~X~..lXC l'!ic IXGIONAL Cr)?',S'Til!, (70:.?I\l.'LSSION'S l,ECISIO!J 0i.I TIIlS I'!'I!,?: :'<I :r,',;IS:T3;:. CC?I:.3 O? YOUR CO;L\!E;!fS biIidTA I52 FHL?VIT)2D TO 'I'lLi: CO:3iI.CSIC);.!i;:1~S p??@]: t ZY VCTZ (LJXIXSS T!IE Crj?.i"41SST.CN VOTES GN 1TIE SI'.!,!E D.%Y AS 'PHIS l.'C!FS IS Y.!.~CI~lIT7i.:~) a'\"" art 1.11.0 : 0-4 2. \, Y=.@"L\9& - "3V-l Rd a AEURESf; : &U -4 .faJ ' h Ch 7x32"s . 0 Y- SU-wfy+- .P79 *<A= 06 PiiONz ~\~uP~~~r\:- ares Code x\q) 75 3 - ~57 0 7 $9 - 3s L 1 * REi'EESZKTINC; : 5kL.e- U' (Group 01: Self') .. !,EASE IIIDICZiTk RLLO\*I WkiY YOU SUPPORT I: OR OPPOSE -K TXIS YL~TT " 1IEi3' GiVE TK2 POI'J.! 'TO' A C@P!I*IZSSICB .STZhFF I*IE!.LE3ER, . -.%a -e "$hQ." & .Q m-;> 2-L &cJp--" ah -LA; &&x&+Luc.w. d 1 30&\-0 ,YO&\\ 3LLO\& &' 3035'3 f", 4& CG &J> . p.. *&L"" c r p, GT-y .. V& (4T- & LC+"@ ALL- I. '9" . !J& hLep- &'3L '5 "F O-\ Y *F ' , 4 I. ' SUnMITTED AT SDCRC PU1:L 13EAlliNC: 12. s*.@ I_ - \hie 0 0 c \ 0 .( c e 0 _. I'l,1*:!2sl' Ko'I-ra: (:!ll~l~;l~l'l,l,Y Tl!l*: :\l~lI,I'l'~ l:NC:l,1:SIC)NS ..\XI) l,Id1]'1 ,\'l.]()XS .\\I) 5l'l~;(:ll~l(: :\sS1'I~,?N(:l~:S ~\l~l~'ol~l~l':l~ IlY 'I'IIIS ~;~'~\l~~\~'l'l~;l~:. 11: yol; \\;Is11 !ll)l)l'l'] 1.1 \l~ll,l'l~~* ()I{ Assvl; \h(:la3 o'l~lll~:l< '1.11 \x \s ~:oN'l~~\l&l~:l~ lll~:l~l~:~~, l'l,l*:\,<l~; (:()\ l'ili~~ (:OllI'.\NY l.'Ol< l~'\'l{'I'IiI*;I{ ISI.'OI<,!l:\'I'ION ,\S 'I,() 'I'llIq: ,\\'~\~~,~\~i~~,~'I'~ ,\SI) r~~~~~~~ ( GUARASTlX C-619343 RO.".. " LIAHII,I?'Y $ 6,000.00 E'E13 $ 60.00 SAFECO TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY a corporation, herein called the Company, GUARANTEES CALIFORNIA COASTAL cOI.PIISSION hereirl called the Assured, against actual loss not exceeding the liability amount stated above which the As shall sustain by reason of any incorrectness in the assurances set forth in Schedule A. LIABILITY EXCLUSIONS AND LIMITATIONS 1. No guarantee is given nor liability assumed with respect to the identity of any party named or referred to in Schedule A or with respect to the validity, legal effect or priority of any matter shown therein. 2. The Company's liability hereunder shall be limited to the amount of actual loss sustained by the Assured because of reliance upon the assurances herein set forth, but in no eyent shall the Company's liability exceed the liability amount set forth above. Dated : March 27, 1981 &-%E Sccrctory .>..-..%x- ",\',I\ 2.. .\52 R4 +. 'I,, ..-,'.;,.......*i" -.. ' 8:: r r, *as f: ;;,, ;' *,$~P,',. 4 I r !! 1 //-;:.,. f, qi i\ .I.>**-' . *. .!> 'I!, 13: \ 1 :: / _. , a,; .. -1 . r ,,;. I, . .I :. ; *. ;.$,j /i/ ;/ !,, \'it> ' ;,:.. c 4, .. :* -... .*.. .. . ti,, !:'I; / j PLJ': .?.p ''b ,.L ,,,.. - ./ .A a, I!, ,r *-, .' x. I . ., f * 1. . -. W#& PIC! An Authorized Signature CLTA Guarantee Face Page (Re\.. 68-71) W m SCHEDULE A KO. C-619343 The assurances referred to on the lace page are: That, acrorcling to tftosc 1)uhlic rerods wlticll, un&r Ihc rwordiug laws. itnlmrl cw1strurtivc notice of matters relating to the interest, if ally, whit.11 was BEN V. COSTANTINO AND JOAN C. COSTANTINO, husband and wife as community property. pursuant to a in and to the land described as follows: Lot 17 of Tierra del Oro, in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to the Map thereof No. 3052, Grant Deed of Record - filed in the Office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, . February 4, 1954. EXCEPTING therefrom that portion now or heretofore lying below the mean high tide line of the Pacific Ocean. Only the following matters appear in such records subsequent to March 10, 1977 ~. . . - - 1. A Full Reconveyance recorded June 5, 1978 as File No. 78-231439. 2. A Agreement Imposing Restrictions On Real Property, recorded December 31, 1980 as File No. 80-440268. 3. A Irrevocable Offer To Dedicate, recorded February 10, 1981 as File NO. 81-041445. I. . . .. 'I'his Guururttcc docs rtot c'ovcr: 1. Taxes. assessments and matters related thereto. ' 2. Instruments, proceedings or other matters which do not specifically describe said land. CHAIN OF TITLE GUARANTEE CLTA Guarantee Form No. 6 (Rev. 9-12-68) P-238 (G S 1 -I I e 0 " -" rv _. i 4 "This plat is for #Our aid in locating Your land with reference io Streets and other parcels. While this plat is believed to be correct, the Company assumes no liability for any loss occurring by reawn of reliance thereon.'' TERRA DEL OR0 I *".79 kl3 CARLSBAD BOULEVARu "." --- " - - "".. .-- - "." -" I I \ a