HomeMy WebLinkAboutSan Diego Gas and Electric; 2017-08-25;City of Carlsbad
SOG&E Customer Name
405 Oak Avenue
Mailing Address
Steve Didier
Customer Contact Name
(760) 602-7539
Contact Telephone Number
PAYEE INFORMATION
Carlsbad
City
Contact Fax Number
CA
State
Municipal Projects Manager
Title
92008
Zip
steven.didier@carlsbadca.gov
Email
Tax Identification Type (select ONLY one)• Federal Tax ID Employer ID Number (EIN) Social Security Number Tax Identification Number.
Tax Status (select ONLY one) Corporation Non-Corporation Individual • Exempt 95-6004793
City of Carlsbad (760) 602-2751
Payee
1635 Faraday Avenue
Mailing Address
Elaine Lukey
Contact Name
PROJECT INFORMATION
10379010
Enrollment Number
Pine Avenue Park Community Center
Project Name
799 Pine Avenue
Project Site Address
Telephone Number Fax Number
Carlsbad CA 92008
City State Zip
Public Works Director elaine.lukey@carlsbadca.gov
Title Email
11/14/2017
Estimated Completion Date
Carlsbad, CA 92008
City/State Zip Code
Elaine Lukey Public Works Director
Contact Name
(760) 602-2751
Contact Telephone Number
ENERGY CALCULATION METHOD
I!) Whole Building Approach
Contact Fax Number
Attached Documentation:
I!) WBA Title 24 Report
0 Engineering Cales
Title
PROPOSED DESIGN AND INCENTIVE ESTIMATE
Description kW kWh
Whole Building Incentive
Overall Building Performance 4.2 86,866
10% End Use Monitoring Incentive
Other Systems Processes
TOTALS: 4.2 86,866
#7~ Digitally signed by Ernie Rincon
Date: 2017.06.27 06:36:12 -07'00'
Signature Date
elaine.lukey@carlsbadca.gov
Email
PROJECT TYPE:
I!} New Construction
D Renovation/Remodel
Therms $Amount
733 $27,214
733
Estimated Incentive:
$27,214.00
~sOG&r reftrs to SJin Diego Gai; and Electrk Company. a subsidiary of Sempra Energy Corporation. 0 2017 San Diego Gas and Electric Company. All rights reserved. These offtrings are funded by California utility customers and ~mlnlstered
by SDG&E under the auspices of the California Public Utillti!S Commlssk>n. Janua,y2017 WSOA-2017-0011 of3
2017 Savings By Des ign Owner Agreement: Whole Building Approach
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Th is Agreement is entered into by San Diego Gas & Electric (hereafter referred to as "SDG&E"} and the Owner (as indicated herein}.
This Agreement is a one-time offer to provide design assistance and a financial incentive to the Owner for participation in the
Savings By Design Program ("Program"} pursuant to the terms and conditions outlined herein and in the Savings By Design
Program Documents ("Program Documents"). The Program Documents are incorporated into this Agreement by reference and
include t he 1} Savings By Design brochure, and the 2) 2017 Savings By Design Participant Handbook, which have been provided
to the Owner. Funding approved for this Program is limited and will be paid on a first-come, first-served basis to qualified
applica nts. Funds will only be reserved upon SDG&E's execution of this Agreement. This incentive offer is subject to the
availability of authorized funds. This Agreement is valid for forty-eight (48} months from the date SDG&E executes this
Agreement. SDG&E will deliver an executed copy of this Agreement to the Owner after acceptance and execution by SDG&E.
INCENTIVE
This incentive offer is an estimate and is subject to the availability of authorized funds. SDG&E reserves the right to modify or
cancel t he incentive offer if the actual system(s} installed differs from the proposed installation.
Additionally, self-generation systems (such as photovoltaics, fuel cells, micro turbines, and cogeneration systems) are not
eligible for incentives. This project may be subject to a significant reduction in incentives, up to and including zero
incentives p~id if it is discovered at the time of inspection that a self-generation system or device has been installed at
the project site to reduce the quantity of electricity purchased from SDG&E. Furthermore, the energy purchased for the
project site must be purchased from SDG&E under a tariff that collects Public Purpose Programs funds. .lni1lillQ
SDG&E reserves the right to modify or discontinue this Program without prior notice at its discretion, a~cknowledge
or by order of the CPUC. Payment of authorized incentives shall be made to the Owner only after all program .
requirements are met and upon verification of installation by an SDG&E Savings By Design Program Representative.
ELIGIBILITY
•Tobe eligible for incentives under this Program, Owner's project must be nonresidential new construction or renovation/
remodel located within SDG&E's service territory.
• Owner must install the energy-efficient equipment or system(s} specified in the "Proposed Design and Incentive Estimate"
section of this agreement (the "Proposed Design"} which at minimum exceeds Title 24 standards or a generally-accepted
industry standard for energy efficiency.
• Installation of any energy-efficient equipment required for compliance with Title 24 will not qualify for incentives under this
Program.
• Energy savings, and incentives based on those savings, will be based on energy efficiency improvements beyond the minimum,
currently in effect, Title 24 requirements, where applicable.
• Specific Restrictions apply to each energy efficiency system, as outlined in the Program Documents.
•Tobe eligible for incentives under this Program, Owner agrees that they will not apply for or receive incentives offered by local
or state entities or other utilities for measures covered under this Agreement.
OWNER AGREES TO:
• Install and operate the Proposed Design in accordance with applicable laws, safety standards, and existing governmental
regulations or orders.
• Provide SDG&E with Title 24 compliance documentation plus any other document ation needed to establish the performance of
systems selected. Owner agrees to provide SDG&E with all documentation necessary for verification of installation and
performance of energy efficient systems qualifying for incentives.
• Provide manufacturer's specification sheets to SDG&E prior to the payment of the incentive. Also, upon request, Owner agrees to
submit vendor and/or contractor invoice(s} to verify that incentive payments will not exceed 75 percent of the incremental costs
associated with the purchase/installation of the energy efficient technologies.
• Accept as final authority, SDG&E's determination of the incentive amount.
• Allow SDG&E and California Public Utilities Commission ("CPUC"} representatives reasonable access to Owner's project site to
inspect and verify installation and operation. Owner understands that said inspection and verification is not an electrical safety
inspection.
"'SOG&E'" refers to San Diego Gas and Electric Company, a subsidiary of Sempra EnergyCorporc1tion. 0 2017 San Diego Gu and Elect1lc Company. All lights reserved. These offerings are funded by California utility customers and administered
by SDG&E und•r th• ausplcos of the calirornla Public Utillti•s Commission. Janua,y 2017 W80A-lOl7•001 2 of 3
2017 Savings By Design Owner Agreement: Whole Building Approach
OWNER AGREES TO (CONTINUED):
• Participate in measurement and evaluation studies, if selected. These studies are used to analyze current program
performance and improve future program designs. Owner agrees to fully cooperate with the study team if asked to
participate.
• Owner shall indemnify, defend, and hold harmless SDG&E, its affiliates, subsidiaries, parent company, officers, directors, agents,
and employees from and against all claims, losses, damages, costs, expenses, and liability arising from or connected with Owner's
participation in the Program. Owner shall, at SDG&E's request, provide a defense against any claim covered by this indemnity.
• In no instance shall SDG&E be liable for any incidental, special, or consequential damages as a result of this Agreement.
• Owner understands that SDG&E makes no representations and warranties as to proper installation, product endorsement,
technical feasibility, operational capability, and/or reliability of equipment for which incentives are paid. Owner agrees not to
make any such representations and warranties to third parties and agrees to indemnify SDG&E in the event said representation
and warranties are made to third parties. Owner further acknowledges that any incentive paid is funded through Public Goods
Charges from California ratepayers and that said incentives are intended for the benefit of customers of California utilities.
• Owner consents to SDG&E's assignment, in its discretion, all of SDG&E's rights, duties, and obligations under this Agreement
("Duties'1 to the CPUC or its designee. Such assignment shall relieve SDG&E of all duties arising under this Agreement. Other than
such assignment by SDG&E, neither party shall assign its right or delegate its duties without the prior written consent of the other
party, except in connection with the sale or merger of a substantial portion of its properties. Consent to assignment shall not be
unreasonably withheld. If an assignment is requested, Owner may be required to provide additional information if requested by
SDG&E.
• Owner agrees that SDG&E will receive the energy benefit for which the Owner incentive is paid, for a period of not less than five
(S) years or the rated life of the equipment if that is less than five (5) years. Owner agrees that if 1) Owner does not provide Utility
with 100 percent of the related benefits specified in the application, for a period of five years from the receipt of the incentive, or
2) the energy benefit to SDG&E ceases (for example, if Owner' stops using the equipment or no longer pays the Public Goods
Charge (PGC),) Owner will return to SDG&E the prorated portion of the Owner Incentive dollars based on the actual period of time
for which Owner failed to provide the energy benefit.
TAX LIABILITY
• Incentives may be taxable and will be reported by SDG&E to the IRS unless Owner qualifies under an exempt status. SDG&E will
report the incentive as income to Owner on IRS Form 1099 unless Owner has established that it qualifies for an exempt tax status
as indicated on this Agreement. Owner is urged to consult a tax advisor concerning the taxability of incentives. SDG&E is not
responsible for any taxes that may be imposed due to incentive payments.
• SDG&E MAKES NO WARRANTY, WHETHER STATUTORY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ANY WARRANTIES
REGARDING THE DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, EQUIPMENT, OR INSTALLATION OF ANY PROJECT OR PARTS REFERRED TO HEREIN, OR
THE BENEFITS TO BE DERIVED FROM THE INSTALLATION, OPERATION, AND USE OF SUCH EQUIPMENT, OR ANY WARRANTY OF
MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PARTICULAR USE OR APPLICATION. NO AGENT, EMPLOYEE, OR REPRESENTATIVE OF
SDG&E HAS AUTHORITY TO BIND SDG&E TO ANY AFFIRMATION, REPRESENTATION, OR WARRANTY UNLESS EXPRESSLY MADE AND
AGREED TO IN WRITING BY SDG&E.
• By execution of this Agreement, Owner certifies that Owner meets all the program eligibility requirements and that the
information supplied on this Agreement is true and correct. Owner certifies that Owner has read and understands the Program
Documents and agrees to abide by Program rules and requirements set forth in the Program Documents. To be valid, this
Agreement must be signed by all parties prior to December 31, 2017.
In witness whereof, the parties have executed this Agreement as of the date last set forth below.
ff~ ---
Signature ~ \}.;;ature
Elaine Lukey Michelle Costello
Owner's Representative (Print Name From Above)
Public Works Director t5.Z.<-f ' / l
SDG&E REPRESENTATIVE (Print Name From Above) d
EE Non-Res Programs MGR <J\u'::J t l 1
Title Date Title Date
"SOG&E· r"fe,s to San Diego Gas and EIKblc Company, a subsidiary of Sempra EnergyCorpo,ation. 0 2017 Scln Diego Gas and Electric Company. All righU reserved. lhe.se offerings are fundl!d by California utility customer.sand •dministe,ed
by SOG&E under the auspkes of the Califomla Public Utilities Commis.s1on. January 2017 WBOA-2017·001 3 of 3
Savings By Design
10379010 -Pine Ave Park Community Center (5001256512)
Summary of Energy Savings and Incentives
% better Owner
Building Description kW kWh Therms than T24 Sq Ft. Incentive
Community Center 0.0 93,749 733 32.3% 17,050 $31,014.00
Preliminary Savings & Incentive (prior to PV reduction) 0.0 93,749 733 $31,014.00
PV Adjustment to Calculations
!Preliminary Energy Saving & Incentive 92.63% 0.0 93,749 733 $31,014.00i
! PV Savings & Incentive Adjustments: 7.37% 4.2 (6,883) 0.0 $ (3,800.00) !
I I •-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------~
% better Owner
FINAL PROJECT ENERGY SAVINGS & INCENTIVE kW kWh Therms than T24 Sq Ft. Incentive
FINAL PROJECT ENERGY SAVINGS & INCENTIVE: 4.2 86,866 733 32.3% 17,050 $27,214.00
., "' I!" :, -:1 .. ., :em be 10379010 Pine Ave Park Community Center (5001256512) Run No. AD E1 E2 E3 E4 ES E6 EP v6.7.0.4 CZ7 E. nerav t::rrtctenc Building sq-ft" Measure As Designed See Note AD below for model Information Notes: AE: Craig Bullock Modeled By: T Squared Engineen: v Measures ;:;,ummarv 17,050 Total Building Average Average 2pm-5pm Annual Annual 2pm-5pm %Better Peak Electricity Therms Peak than T24 Demand Consumed Consumed Demand Usa0<> Savt!!<!• lkW/vr\ lkWh/vr\ ltherm<ivr\ lkW/vrl 32.3% . 287,513 . ( -• -: ·,. --' ' -AO Edited provided EnergyPro model: Includes Ken's Ltg evaluation E1 E2 E3 E4 ES E6 Annual Electricity Saved• lkWhlvrl 93,740 ' -I ;ii -,, ' --' -Annual Owner Therms Incentive Saved• ($) Ctherms/vrl 733 $31.014 . ... ' ----. -. Reviewed: James G. RoclH. SDG&E Incentive 10% End Use Moitoring Parking Annual Combined Incentive Incentive .. Lighting Savings• ($) 1$\ $/sn-ft l~h,r\ $31,014 $ 1.82 s 9,838 so s -,1 $0 $ .• $0 $ . so s -so $ -$0 $ -'Compared to As Designed .,To qualify for the End Use Monitoring or Enhanced Commislonlng Incentives, please see the guidelines in the Savings by Design Participant Handbook •••This •rough order of magn~ude' estimate of IMC is based on RS Means or Cost Estimators reports or Industry Standard Practice. It is reliable, however no cost is guarenteed; Customers are encouraged to double check these values, and/or provide their own. Incremental Measure Cost % Better than T24 (IMC)" ... 1$\ 0% 5% 10% 15% s 1,066 '!';", ~ ·-·-~· }/\ I '.' \\nas-cp1 a\data2WKTGISHAREICPS\0Tl\SBO lnfo\Olgllal_Pl'Ojoct_Flles\SBOIProject_Oireetory\02_ YNauta\1037901 O_PinoAvePari<comrmmityCenter_ YNIOJ_E><Ante\03.2_ CUSTSELC\03.2.1_SLFGEN\5001256512_PineAvoPar1<_EEM_Summa,y.Jdsx 20%
1
2
Savings By Design I UTILITY INCENTIVE WORKSHEET UTIL-1
3 10379010 Pine Ave Park Community Center -SolarPV
ANNUAL TDV ENERGY USE (kBtu/sqft-yr)
Standard Proposed Margin
7 Space Heating 36.94 9.74 27.20
8 Space Cooling 221.04 99.29 121.75
9 Indoor Fans 24.06 36.88 -12.82
10 Heat Rejection 0.00 0.00 0.00
11 Pumps 1.27 0.00 1.27
12 Domestic Hot Water 68.34 70.63 -2.29
13 Lighting 81.51 42.83 38.68
14 Receptacle 104.80 104.80 0.00
15 Process 2.33 2.33 0.00
16 Process Lighting 0.00 0.00 0.00
17 Totals: 540.29 366.50 173.79
ANNUAL SITE ENERGY USE
19 Average 2pm -5pm Standard Proposed Margin
20 Peak Demand (kW) 83.5 79.3 4.2
21 Standard Proposed
22 ENERGY COMPONENT Electricity Nat. Gas Electricity Nat. Gas
23 (kWh) (therms) (kWh) (therms)
24 Space Heating 0 733 11,485
25 Space Cooling 137,679 0 42,273
26 Indoor Fans 15,367 0 28,682
27 Heat Rejection 0 0 0
28 Pumps 415 0 0
29 Domestic Hot Water 98,541 0 101,841
30 Lighting 54,900 0 28,847
31 Receptacle 72,459 0 72,459
32 Process 1,999 0 1,999
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3/16/2017
PERCENT BELOW TITLE-24
Adjusted TDV Energy Use
(Exdudes Process Energy)
Standard Proposed
Design Design Margin
540.291 -1 366.501 =I 113.791
Standard %Below
Margin Design Title-24
173.791" 537.961 =I 32.3%1
Conditioned Floor Area (sq.ft.): 17,050 sq.ft.
The values below are results from an EnergyPro
"Noncompliance" energy analysis.
Margin Qualifying Margin
Electricity Nat. Gas Adjustment
(kWh) (therms) 0.9263
-10,639 733 eligible / gross
88,377 0
-12,335 0
0 0
384 0
-3,057 0
24,134 0
0 0
0 0
33 Process Lighting 0 0 0 0 0 0 .,_ ___ ...
34 Totals: ~~ m m~ o ¾~ m
POTENTIAL OWNER INCENTIVE CALCULATION -ADJUSTEDFOR PV GENERATION
36
37
38
39
40
Electricity (kWh)
41 Electricity (kW)
42 A~ Sempra Energy utiutV-
43
44 Natural Gas (therms)
45 These results are for Self-Generation projects with 8760
46 annual hour analysis showing hours in which measure is
"purchasing" energy. Hours of over production
47 ("selling") are not eligible for incentives, and these
48 results have been adjusted to reflect this.
s r um
B C
% Be owT-24
(from step 2)
Incentive
Rate
30.o I xi I 30.0%1:Ja---·L __ _
C/kWh
100.oolx!
$/kW
100.oi xi
C/therm
!Owner Incentive
D E F
Savings
(from step 3) Subtotal
86,8661 =I $26,0601
kWh
4.21 =I $421 1
kW
7331 =I $733 1
therms 100.0%
27,214
-1 $27,2141
($150,000 max)
G H
SUMMARY
Self-Generation -PV Report
10379010 Pine Ave Park Community Center -SolarPV Date:
3/16/2017 FIie: 10379010 PineAveParkCtr PV Calc.xlsx
Eligible Savings, kWh/yr: 86,865.6 Margin, kW: 4.21
Photo-Voltaic Analysis -Procedure to Establish Eligibility & Incentive
PV Reduction: 3.9" Climate Zone: 7
PROCEDURES
Steps:
1. Run EnergyPro model in T-24 Compliance mode and Non-compliance mode.
2. Save output from parametric runs in "StandardNC.csv" and "ProposedNC.csv" for the
Non-compliance mode.
3. Print UTIL-1 and ECON-1 for Compliance mode; Print ECON-1 for Non-compliance
mode.
4. Go to PV Watts website, input PV system, using zip code, and select TMY3 data.
http://pvwatts.nrel.gov/
5. Save output as "hourly" data to "*.csv"
Save or Print "inputs and assumptions" into this spreadsheet.
6. Copy and Paste Non-compliance "StandardNC.csv" and "ProposedNC.csv" data into
this spreadsheet in appropriate tabs.
7. Copy and Paste PV-Watts "* .csv" data output into this spreadsheet.
8. Manually edit the "Energy Components" for both "Standard" and "Proposed" columns
in the "STEP-1" area of UTIL-1 tab (cells C7 .. C16 and E7 .. E16).
9. Standard -Proposed is "Margin" or Savings. This is compared to PV generation each
hour of the year. Qualifying Margin = minimum of "Purchase or Gross Margin".
10. Print UTIL 1, Non Compliance Runs, and Instructions Tabs below, for report.
Compile printed record/Report:
>UTIL-1 (w/ECON-1) SOG&E calculator;
>PV results tab; ,
11. >UTIL-1, ECON-1 from EnergyPro, for compliance and non;
>Summary & Procedures (instructions tab);
>PV documents and drawings;
>Backup documents, emails, etc.;
103 79010_P/neAveParkCtr_ PV_ Ca/c.xlsx Instructions Printed: 3/16/2017 5:57 PM
10379010 Pine Ave Park Community Center (5001256512)
EP v6.7.0.4 AE: Craig Bullock
Modeled by: T Squared Enginee El M t # ec. e er : _________________ _
17,050 sf CZ7 Gas Meter#: ______________ _
Electrical Inspector
Allowed Actual Checkoff
Lighting Power Density (watts/sf) 0.963 0.506 47.5% D
better than T-24
Mechanical
COOLING
Split System No. of Manf. Model No. Tons Cooling EER Economizer I Notes Units
FC/CU-1, 3, 5, 6 4 Carrier 25HCD3 60 5.0 1.0 y D
FC/CU-2 1 Carrier 25HCD3 30 2-1/2 2.0 N
FC/CU-4 1 Carrier 25HCD3 48 4.0 3.0 N
FC/CU-7, 8, 9 3 Carrier 38MAQB 18 1-1/2 4.0 N
Packaged AJC Unit No.of Mani. Model No. Tons Cooling EER Economizer ~ Notes Units
RTU-1, 2 2 Carrier 50TCQD 14 12.0 11.6 SEER y
DOMESTIC HOT WATER
Water Heater/Boiler I ~~1,~
1 I Mani. Model No. 1a~r.:..1 Efficiency I
WH-1 Rheem Rheem 82VR30-2 15,533 0.90% Electric B
Envelo e
Glazing Manufacturer Description WlnlerU-SHGC Overhangs Factor
PPG Solarban 70XL 0.28 0.27 D
Roof U-Factor R-Value Joint App IV Ref
R-30 WOOD ROOF 0.035 28.6 JA4.2.2-A 17 B R-30 ROOF ATTIC 0.031 32.3 JA4.2.1-A20
Cool Roof A~ed Solar Reflectance I Therm Emltt I
Johns Manville JM TPO 0.1 0.85 D
Wall U-Factor · R=value Joint App IV Ref
R-19 Metal Stud 0.074 13.50 JA4.3.1-A5 D
Owner understands that changes to the Proposed Building Measures and Inspection Checklist, Including, alterations, D
substitutions, additions, or omissions will result In a project energy performance reconclliatlon review and may result In a
lower or higher energy efficiency Incentive payment.
J/1612017
Customer
Initials
Date
5001256512_PineAvePar1<_EEM_Summory.,cisx