HomeMy WebLinkAbout1973-03-20; City Council; 1083; Repairs to Storm Drain-Carlsbad Blvd. at Pine Ave.Agenda Sill Plo. /dq3 Date: March 20, 1973
Referred To:
Subj ect: Submitted By:
Repairs to Storm Drain-Carlsbad Blvd. at Pine Ave. Public Works
Contract 101 7 D i rector
Statement of the Matter
The storm drain crossing Carlsbad Blvd. at Pine Ave. has deteriorated
;a the point where it is no longer functional and must be replaced.
Cdrl~bad Blvd. floods all northbound lanes each time it rains.
This department originally planned to do the work under informal contract.
Informal bids were received as follows:
1) Don Hubbard Contracting Co., Encinitas $5,935 25 2) K. Construction Co. Carlsbad $6,195.44 5) S.K. Construction Co. 'Seal Beach $6,682.06 4) Castillo & Son, Sari Marcos $1 0,252 .OO
The low bid exceeds the limit for informal bidding for Public Works
contracts.
Norma 1 1 y we wou 1 d re-advert i se following the formal bidding
procedure'. However, in this case, we have an emergency situation where
immediate action should be taken to protect the safety of motorists on
Carlsbad Blvd. Exhibit A shows the extent of the flooding during this
morning's rain.
It is doubtful that re-advertising would result in a significant cost
reduction. The low bidder can begin work this week and immediately
1 correct the floodSny problem.
Exhibit
''A'' Photographs of f 1 oodi ng taken 3-20-73
& 3.897 cLcc/w&-' &~Z(U;z"
I 7-
St3ff Recommendations
Adopt a r~so1~~:!~!1 1) declaring that the Public interest and necessity
dmand the imizdiate expenditure of Pub1 ic money to safeguard 1 ife,
!-.:-le low bidder for- a price of $5,935.25 for the replacement of the
Pine Ave. storri drain.
' . . I 'Z - ; '- -.!, 2,. and pi-'opzi-ty9 and 2) authorizing the award of a contract with
(Note: this re3~1u:iion will require a 4/5 vote)
*
0, fl
na NU.
#
Date: March 20, 1973
..
City Manayer's Recommendation
Concur.
.-
Co unci 1 Ac ti o R
3 -20-73 Resolution #3097 was adopted, declaring that Public interest and necessity demand the immediate expenditure of pub1 ic money to
safeguard life, health and property,awarding the contract to the
low bidder and authorizing the' expenditure of funds in the amount
of $5,935.25.
.. .. -
,(
t
__ . . . .. .- .- --.
-2-
-.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
21
28
29
30
31
32
RESOLUTION NO. 3097
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING THAT THE PUBLIC ItITEREST AND NECESSITY DEMAND THE IPlT4EDIATE EXPENDITURE OF PUBLIC MONEY TO SAFEGUARD LIFE, HEALTH AND PROPERTY A3D AUTHORIZING THE AWARD OF A CONTRACT TO
OF $5,935.25 FOR THE REPLACEMENT OF THE PINE AVEUUE STORM DRAIN.
Dot4 HUBBARD CONTRACTING CO. IN THE AE-10UNT
WHEREAS, the California Government Code and the Carlsbad
Municipal Code, provide for a waiver of normal formal bidding
requirements in regard to public works contracts in certain
emergency situations; and
WHEREAS, the Pine Avenue storm drain has collapsed
.resulting in a flooding of Carlsbad Boulevard and created
an emergency situation requiring immediate action to protect
private property in the area and to insure the safety of
motorists using said roads; and
WHEREAS, the City has received informal bids from four
contractors for the work necessary to repair said condition; and
WHEREAS, the Don Hubbard Contracting Company of Encinitas
has submitted the low bid of $5,935-25;
NOW, TrlEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council of
the City of Carlsbad as follows:
1. That the above recitations are true and correct.
2. That the public interest and necessity demand the
immediate expenditure of public money to safeguard life, health,
and property in the City of Carlsbad by repairing the Pine
Avenue storm drain.
3. The Public Works Director is hereby authorized to
accept the bid of Don HuDbard Contracting Company for the
performance of said bid and is autnorized to execute a
///
///
///
1.
0.
. '1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
25
29
30
31
32
contract for the same in the amount of $5,935.25.
PASSED, APPROVE3 AND ADOPTED by the City Council of th2
City of Carlsbad at a regular meeting held March 20, 1973,
by the following vote, to wit:
AYES; . .Councilmen Dunne, McComas, Lewis and Frazee.
NOES : None.
ABSENT: Councilman Chase.
City of Carlsbad, California
ATTEST:
(SEAL)
2.
Supplement No. 1 to
AB NO. 765 c
Date: August 15, 1972
Some action must be taken to avoid loss of grant funds. The following table
capsulizes the pros and cons of the al'ternatives aviilable:
Alke r na t e
a) Leave rate structure
as is
b) Raise rates for major
industrial users to
18$/100 cubic feet.
c) Raise rates for major
industrial users to
- 12C/100 cubic feet.
d) Raise rates for all
industry as in (b)
__
It is the feeling of your
Con ..
L Pro - Least affect on 1. Inequitable distribu-
industrial users tion of expenses among users
2. Loss of Grant funds - 1. Allocates expenses
in relation with bene- duction in attraction to
fits received industry.
1. Possible'femporary re-
2. Puts major industry
on same basis *as resi-
dential use
3. Qualifies for Grant Funds
1. Possibly qualifies .lo Leaves portion of in-
for Grant Funds dustrial expense with non-
2, Spreads ultimate
increase to industry
ove r se ve r a 1 ye a r s
industrial user
1. Puts all industrial 1. See (b)
and residential use on
s ame bas is 2.. Complete analysis of
2. Qualifies for Grant industries not complete
Funds
sewer usage for individual
staff that alternate (b) is the most equitable way
to proceed considering both residents and industry. A review of rates
is being made and a recommendation regarding all residential and industrial
rates will be submitted for your consideration in the fall.
Exhibit .
Agenda Bill 765 with Exhibits (1)-(2)
(3) County letter dated July 11, 1972 recommending rates for industry
(4) County letter dated March 17,' 1972
(5) Capital cost and operating cost allocation-Carlsbad portion of EWPCF
(6) Synopsis revenue. program guidelines
S t a-f f Re commend at ions .. *
1. Adopt Ordinance 7040 establishing method' of promolgating rates.
2. Adopt Resolution 2025 setting sewer service charges. (Specify alternate
des ireU)
City Manaqer's Recommendations ,
Either alternate 'lb" or "c" is acceptable. As a possible compromise, this office would suggest a' rate of 12$/100 cubic feet be established
for the remainder of this fiscal year and a rate of 18$/100 cubic feet be established as of July 1, 1973.
t I i
I
-2-
THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALI FORNIA
Agenda Bill No. 765 - Date: June 7, 1972
Referred To:
Sub j ect: Submitted By:
A recommended change to commercial sewer .service rates
and an accompanying concurrent change to the Method Public Works Dir.
of promulgating all sewer service rates.
Statement of the Matter
1. Current commercial sewer service rates, for industries whose
primary commodity is water, do not generate revenues which
reflect their relative use of the Encina Water Pollution Control
Facility. An increase from 6c/100 cu. ft. of water used to 18C/100
cu. ft. is necessary to derive sufficient income to support
industry allocated expenses.
2.
3.
The rate changes recommended result from operating and capital costs
increases related to Phase II expansion of the Encina Facility.
This expansion, part of a five-year plan, is partially funded by
an 80% grant from the State Water Resources Control Board under
a Clean Water Projects program. For the City of Carlsbad to
continue to qualify for the 80% grant, two conditions must be met:
a) Each user should pay in accordance with demand imposed-on system.
b) Industrial waste dischargers should contribute revenues to pay
their share of expenses, allocated on a relative use basis.
The recommended i ncrease fu 1 f i 1 1 s these requ i rements.
Sewer service rates will require frequent review and updating as
the costs of operation and facility expansion continue to rise. A change in method of promulgating these rates is recommended. At
present, rates are stated in the Carlsbad Municipal Code, Section 13.12.020. To facilitate Council action on rate changes, it is
recommended rates be promulgated by resolution hereafter.
Exhibit
1. Ordinance No. FJf(? to amend Section 13.12.020, Carlsbad Municipal
Code.
~ 2. Resolution No.Sd& /L to promulgate Sewer Service Charges.
Staff Recommendations
1. Adopt Y/J */) / Ordinance No. i- c-
2. Adopt Resolution No. ,‘&/Lgar-sett ing sewer service charges.
,. .. .T H E CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALI FORNIA
Supplement No. 1 to
Agenda Bi 71 'No. 765
Referred To:
Date: August 15, 1972
--- Subj ect: Submitted By:
Changes to Sewer Service Rates Public Works Director
Statement of the Matter
The Council requested that the Staff have the County reanalyze the Industrial
sewer service charges and to report back on their findings. The results are
contained in the County's letter dated July 11th (Exhibit 3) . They recommend
that the rate for Burroughs & Culligan be increased to 18C per 100 cubic feet
of watG used. They further recommend that this rate ''be extended to all
industries in the City". General information regarding Clean Water Grants is
---.
,,"included in Exhibit (6) .
A review of the charges by other members of the Encina Joint Sewerage Agency
shows Vista and Buena Sanitation Districts currently charge on the basis of
flow recommended by the County. San Marcos County Water District charges 20e
per 100 cubic feet. They all recover industry's share of capital and operat-
ing expenses from industrial sewer service charges. The City of Oceanside
rate is 4.8C/100 cubic feet. This has not yet been modified in accordance
with State regulations.
Industry's annual expense in Carlsbad is $31,600. (See Exhibit (5)). Burroughs
share is 96% or $30,000f, plus costs of monitoring their industrial waste
which could run around $2,000. Estimated revenue from Burroughs @ 18$/100
cubic feet, using their anticipated water usage, is $32,200. The current rate
for the City of Carlsbad is 6C/100 cubic feet.
Discussions have been held with both Burroughs & Culligan, regarding the re-
quired increase which must be imposed. Culligan is planning to ultimately
recycle waste water and is not strongly opposed to the recommended increase.
- Burroughs on the. other hand, requests that any increase be spread over a
number of years. They have expressed agreement with an increase to 12C per
100 cubic feet . This would generate approximately $23,000 in revenue, leaving
a deficit in excess of $7,000.
I
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO
PUBLIC WORKS AGENCY
DeDm-tment of Smitation @ Flood Control A C. J. HOUSON Director
.I
County Operations Center, 5555 Overland Avenue, San Diego, California 92123 . . . . . Telephone: 278-9200
11 July 1972
City of Carlsbad
1200 Elm Avenue
Carlsbad, California 92008
Attention: Mr. Hunter T. Cook, City Engineer
.I .
SUBJECT: Sewer Service Charges
As stated in our letter of 13 March, in order to meet the requirements of
the State Water Resources Control Board for grant recipients, it is neces-
sary for industry to pay its share of the capital and operating expenses
related to sewer service. Consequently, the sewer service charges for in-
dustries operating in the City of Carlsbad must be increased.
According to the State guidelines, no credit can be given to industry for
economies of scale. Computations of the industrial sewer charges should
therefore be on the following basis:
Residential charge is $2 a month.
a day for each equivalent dwelling unit (EDU), the residential
cost is 18c per 100 cubic feet,
Based on a flow of 280 gallons
The present charge to Burroughs and Culligan is 6c per 100 cubic
feet. It is therefore recommended that the charge to these two
industries be increased to 18c per 100 cubic feet for 1972-73,
The foregoing analysis will satisfy the requirements of the State Water
Resources Control Board. In the future, it is recommended that Carlsbad
establish sewer charges on the basis of equivalent dwelling units as pre-
viously outlined in our letter of 13 March. The charge per dwelling unit
should be based on the revenue requirements, taking into consideration
collection, transportation, treatment and disposal costs, A careful
analytical study should be made of the basis for assessing industrial sewer
charges (i.e., flow and strength).
termining sewer charges, but they do not meet the State Board requirements.
There are several other methods of de-
City of Carlsbad
Page 2
11 July 1972
As you know, the final payment of the grant for the Encina Phase I
Enlargement will not be paid until an equitable method of applying
sewer service charges to industry is adopted by Carlsbad, as well as
San Harcos and Vista.
In order to be equitable, the proposed increase in flow charges to the
two maior industries in Carlsbad from 6t to 18e per 100 cubic feet should