Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-12-06; City Council; 5262; CLAIM AGAINST CITY - ZENY WARDSubject: -- . , CLAIM AGAINST THE CITY ZENY WARD M , .. :,` „. :: r Statement of the Matter. } ,',I:- , �� ''' o- .. ', ,, .- rq� , W.�`, .. ,, .�, .. ... - k. �� ' A claim has been filed against the City of Carlsbad by . ::y ,,A .-;Zeny Ward in the amount of $608.02. �'.trs. -Ward- alleges r. " ,, ... -damage to her ear's 'finish due to tar splatterings while " �$ -.driving on Elm Street. ,* , .,. - a_. , . =: , _, ,, s a, .. r - IIIIW f, iJ )I' .s � Exhiba t - a���� .yi9/* k rk 1" t u { Resolution No , G denying claiz , 3 $�4, Claim for Damages Form filed by claimant'� _ f . Y"rJ S - f t r'} 9 - } y �T, a'K r j �9 _­ ' rj 3 I { %" t° i x , Recommendation ' P r<t°' A % 7 3 '. , The; City'Council: ado= t P. Resolution No. deny_ng the claim anddrectngrthe City°,Attorney to refer the matter ,° to the Citys insurance carrier, :Y L. ,, ' �'k ^ ## i P# ,«' 1 #. 1 r A S 1 O JP t A `k k � 'f Y 'f`':F� Z t 2 XS" _. v P } k, lk [ ­ ,,I' - � �� ,�, I�_ 4-,�,',­-y--'II ,' �I, �, _1N,i.I, ,"�''I�a" i,,, ��IIT, p, __"�,,,,,A_" , ��. " , ,,, ,�---, ,1 ,�`'� '.­ ,',��-,I A-,�,2A, ��,`1�,. -Il,-_ ' �,,-N-,l�,� � C ;,I,":�.,,�,"I 5,,x-N_ �1I.�I,1x I, � �1I ,t, , _ � -, 5 "�£ _ ,", ,_, `�,� �, ,x-.I��,�, ,� 1k� U,"���,I�",I,A­ 1*I.'.i, 1 , ,. "pit , ,, - q, , �,�_� ­I� K' {5 �, Ii ,_��K��'I,' �_ ,,, ,, %­,,.,' ,_ .: II R�`1,'.,��'� �'�I.,,�! �1,L,"I I , 4M 3 ',,_',, -, ,-r�-, �"! -� ,'1""_'��j,.,,� ,-",-'_, �',�,_ ,"-�'k ?�,," ,. �-,.,,,1� I",$.i .t �� d 'V° M."I �I, i,n �, ,--11,�r -, -�,," ­1. �­Il ,-I I_.�1 -1".�� i­� �,-I,I, �_,� , � "",,,`" %� , � ], ,,,� ,,yy , "�"�,�, ­�- :", " � ,� ., - J f F e ,4"71 -; �, 1,�, ,�- �-,r, ',,I4 I�,­�­ �� :�.,_I,-, I��,1`;�",1 f:��,- ';I",_ ,!II �,"4 ,,i-,�.', iI,�,Z � ,�, "i, 2p"-.'�,, ` I,1I-.,I­ ,� ,1�,,�I_ '%I� �,—� ,�,��,,- -�:� ,'�i,��, -,;,,,�_",� :,Z.:'.I ,�L� .,-�A-, V r v -, 1�� yx,,,')0.. d -,,I 1,�1 ,,, 1,�"Z I I:. I, ��-I,�I kI,, - , , ,, -���. ?,I ,&�; y S ,-�_M �I,� ", , ,� _ c.+1 A_ fR,ai L Y _T ,,­�,­ '-, I1. _,,1'. �, --ffi11",, �l�-� -�I ---�I,.� �r:I. ,,,, ��I z�4 I �_,--`, -`�" "�"�., .,, �1,, ,�..4�,",� ,",I', , �:- Ii �,",I:I ,��,,,� -__',,, "1�):_ ,: . ;-,, �, , p �1 i-`,, ' .,��i _✓� 1 a;: ,', , ­:, ,��-� -,LI.-f'1 1,--I,.' ,-'�-,� ,, ,�.,,��' p� ,.'- �-- �.L-� ,",�-` -I-1 -,_",, �; �,,,, �'�.L .-,A..- ��`�'�, .,. x.,II, �1' --1, �',- ,Y-�� ,I.I,�,::�,' ` , � ,I",� ,,' ,, t uygc� �,,:�"I��,r�,�,I­INM� ,­,�tI - ,%�., I _ ,,� "�,;�, 2� $f ,c.� II �t,, , ­, 1W,I',I I",�,.�,��, �',,,,�!, , -.'1 , 1-- - ti zy„ .fire"i M"Fi� i ax'ei�k." ;. K A Y k ,J$ A 3 I�­, 4 1W;-�_ ,,'*_--',""� , - '�s 11," `01,," o .�— s 6`4 'x fry"i �. ram, A 1 ­� , ,I�� ��° ;,.1a l' '-."l�N, ,,�,,' `,­ ,�LI �,�­�� ',1, ." ,�,"I ,I -, ",`, -',_ �, -j1," '�,�O ,1I -,],'�,-I ,"_71 P" ��� I�,z �,-­ '".-" :i�" �;' '-�I,�'� L,_,'. .,,4,�I,- !,-�, �­­- ,"�"1 �,_�' ,.., ,I ,�,I, ,,_�,,, �,,�,N'�",�AI,,­ '-,,,'"­ "'-.-�,":,�, "�_ ,,­�:- I`,­ _' �41" M-_ -,,-I,I,I�., , � �. -1, I �, � ," I :Z ��", -­.*� '1 �. �� �G ', �Z1 ,yrz, �­,"_,,�;, -,AL",-:,; � -I," ,-, I"I­ ,_,,�� �� 4 , b. �I F I,""� ,t-'-1fflI ,1, 1, ,I �-__",�"��",,,7 M�, 1;-1'�- ,� ,-,,��;`'',, 5: '�:��, , ,-",��, ,,1� ,� , _,_Ar_-�,�, , I­,� I. ,,I ,, ,, ,, ',"-,,"M,, ,, � -, ,.-�1�_ ��, � ff� _ , ",, �,, _- �� ',, :, ,­"l:�. '��-,lI ,,"1,�� ,",' j,,_ `, , ' },zue �-;- ,�,-�!-1­ , ',",I��," "- P),, - a J ,�,I., , �q _-#",�!' , �-_ �,,.- 1.�' i! �"1�,,,' -�,- �,��' ,zI� -f,,, I ',''�, M ���, y .:f i , '!�- , Y�,�d �,,', ­:­;1,, ,,1-,:� �!."�;� �1 ,l -"11�­ ­,­ ,­,�1 �1�1 9�,-�, ,sfL1, �., -?��" ,, I"�,­ § ���,"Z ��; �,�-, , ) .1 ,",,��,. -­ -i.1. ,i,,"�"�',�" _L,- ,-­ , -*- ,�.- fi q fti 2 1 t * A ,,1,,,."., ,�.� � ,,"'� �­��!-`, �7I� , ,I1� '-,��'',"� .",, ,,_ _'_,,r.,, R4. �I�" -,,,,­,," ,I` ,, ' 1 ,,, I ,' ' ,,�,;;- ,'__� ­- 1"I,1�, ,,' ."I� �;­_ ,"-,,,,11 ',-�'--," .,-"I-�'- g��� ,�,�" ­ , t',i,l . -� OfxV" 4 Y_ '�, ��,�" I 11��'x�� ��-�;- ',_t�,,�, �, ,� ,�," "�'_",�,_ --,�j.%�'-'-� ��, ,�,,�,,': ��� N".� �1-,, !�_ �',; ­.�""� s -� ._ , � ,�i_ ,� ­��� ,""y ,," �.�I.1�_N 1-�,�',1-1�- , . , � , , � '�- I"�I. "� w-�. 4�_�,1,;� �. �,�L, 1,I,, ,,�, ',,� ��I� "-,,_,"�" "_, � ,.I�,"., , 1',.� I ,, " - �"- �),,1'_,-�-"-, ," �,-j1- 'o�,_-�""', ,.­ -.­_�,i­ �.-e�.`� ��, _­ 1 , 1,, 1 ",��.�'�,_­ I , P, W, I "I ,� 4I',Pn,I I. ,7"�-��n� ",F ":� _­%:_I-� ,I ­�I� I',, .; ­",� -�I I� ,,�.,� ,,,,-,1,�1, ,t.:++t,. r = .+ I 1�,,l-,4,A," ", ��,� ',N���',4,_. �, �_'," 1- ,"_R,_!�­, >''h >k,:. x � 1 �, a < ,,,,,,,,:�1 '���"I,_'�,,�A,,� :,­,_,7'"!,--� . ;: ,1�.fix=' ^` r a- ",.�i­ 1-,,l,l- !�- ' �. ,,-. �� �.I� 1,,��x.I '.iII ,�,,�9'� , ' :. _�W"-',�""-�.��"_.,,L._..�ft%.��'­`l._I.1"­ ;I, ,--��� ,-�(-'�', , -". �;- -"-,�--�� ,�- ,,,�,,,:."I,"_,,J��"I �1� ] ,Ni, I" :- �,,' :,�I , �I-� _�, ' I_��_ ,1'' Ii����3 ,,,,,,,,,1 ­,,,,! , ��� I�. I`I ", I, �,,'' ": 1�,1I1�v--��Z�,-_ ,1IP-�W",T� ��,r�'-, I�,1, ��"�,;`� -��;�,,�g,_� ", ,�, ­­".-" .""I I �� ,I,,, ­ ,,,,� ­,,_,, �_ - l- �', ­1 ­�", ` ` .� ..:, ,, I 'L, ' ,w� ,,� "w;� ,��,� ��I,',R,-" ,"�� _ # tt 4 _,,,, l�9�,,, -,,,I ,,',1` 'I�, .1,.,��� ' �,,--'' -,�� ­,_ �1 ,,- _ J, ,-. la , �r_,- �k�� ';� ���1-�.I-'t ,,�F,y, ,.," I,V"�. 1"�'; -.�' ,,,i,­ I, .,:.���- I,-1-�', L--,i1, �� 11 1, ,,��,.I",,-,,,y___,I ,�N�, --(, ";--, ,� ,: �,<�� v"� ' �.-,,,. ., � I� o�;2 _,��.,�";��� �I ���,I,��1, _,, ,... , ,�r,��: �_,_��,A-'I,,,,,,'5'�"�. ,,I',�, ,),��`'- ",- ." �,.,--,� �,1J �,��' ,�-��', I,.,., --I1. L­,1,:I� ,�I '.� 1,,-� �,. .�,_ ."�.j '1: -1,,` I11�,t� .I ,- C.,:,,', i�,� -` .,''. ,l,"_",I. , I,,'� �,I�'`�_ , ,, ,I1�,� I _ ��- �I ] - �I���, ,,, �,i - I �,,.�" � I SI,," ,,�_L­ ,I'"I, I�,,i, -M,-,,'U ,A_tfI�, ­ ""� .. .lp,7," ­,1, �L ,-, T.�,,,�� ,,t�� ,,� I %#-+ -;, , ,_� � I II ,I�, ;, �� I', ­�,���� -,�1" I�, � 1 —�" , ��., ,A, �.,,I�,-,,,j�. .,_I -_,I, _,-. -"­'',,-,"_r, ,, �,:_1 ,-I -� 1, I I ` I��,� �:' �-.�,,-,",:�,f" .,, r:��,, 1�I," ,-,-'-�",-'�II,7�,-."," .� -`-,.a,,,"�i,1�, `: ',�-­ I,�,�� ,'_' �I�,.:"­.j`,��,, 1�_.- -� ,:��-: -I,���"�� ,��_ �,, �1,," I , �"1 . I , ,,,', ,_, J - I:"1' -I1_"-_,­ ",,�,,- II. I I � , I , 1� , Ii1�,;�,,�, I I 11 � I �, , - . I 11 I - . I I � ,. _. ,',,­, ��� ,i,, �"eI1­ ,r,�- I�� ,�,,,1-:, .1, � . I III— I � �,! - � � �� 11 I I - , I - ,, -11 . "I i'A I e,. �, I �, I ­ I � I I , I I 1, . I I I I I I I., � I 1, I I ,, , , � Z I I I I ,� I , q, � I I , I ;,.,,,"�' ,''-� ,1�.,..�'1�� ,45_,4� ,iI w, ; � � , ,�_ ��, .111, � " I : I - " , � I - - I - ,� , � I ­,;,�.*L� - �� , I , ,��, ` L � � , ., I , ­ ", ,��: , , � �_ :: , � � � �, e I �,� 1��- ���,I�, ,,_," 1'.,,�,I� -%, ,"�, ­� , - , � � , ,� -��,,�'!_' I � :1 -'I , ,,, �� _� - � o I I � I �1; �,�. : I I : , , . I I -o I .- I : I , � ,�, I�"��,,'1 I�, ,��b­�5 I,� �.,�� -�I; I-�,�� �,� I" 1' ,,�,'�,�iI,­- -" -�"� I : .I",,� " - ; � � � I ,. . , 11 I � ', � _ , , , I I I - . , I , . L I I ­ . .1 ,_ L I I - � �- , I , , I � I- 11 I � '� ��_� , ,� , 'I, I , - �, I I , I 11 11 I el .1 "I , � I I ;. "I � ., I I -, , I - , I I I", I I ,, : : ,� , , � - - � , �� � I '�,' �, �' � , I t ,. : � � �', I ,� 4' ,, I I I I I I I ., . 11 � I ,� � ,,,'- , -�, � I I ­ . I . 1. . , � ��' �, - ," , I I �. � , ;I L12 .�; .1 11 , I �`­­_� � 11 � I � I I �.. . I I � .., '­,,�_ '�k� . � � �� I " - I � I I . I I I � � " �r - �� . I I I I � � I I , _1 ,� � I . I- � I ,� I � ,� 11� I 1. , -1 11 - � �� I - I I - 1, �� t � ,� I _ I I � � I'll I ; I k ; � ,- � � :-- ,-, - , " . , I I � 1 7. 1 I . I ', � I I I I , 4 I I � - - I I , � � I , . ,� I , , �­!', , I I , I _��:! , I . I . �, I I I " , _ � %, I . 11 ­ I k - ._ -_�-,,� , I "I ­� 11.,:�:�:"� �4� ,,, , . I � I I �­_ �!., , I I , I I I 1. I I 1, I. � � I I ,� , � , r- , 11 11 I I - I . �, I �, I � I I I I I I ,� � � I -.1 . 11-11-11 1. I , " , I � I , � I � I . , � I � '11, I � . . ,,, I , � I I I 11 ,�� � I - I , ��, I . ,. I . I '. �, ,- _ , . , " 1� ,. I . , I I 11 I I i ��, ',��,_�� � , ,. , I : � � I I 11 I � I i - -, , ,;; : " � , - I � I 11 �� � I I I "I", ;,",", _ ,, _z , , ,. , I - I - � , � I - � 1" _', � _ � , __ , " , - � � .- , , , , " - , �: ���l ;�, .`�� , - - . I ­ 11 - 11 ­ � I - � � rl_ � � , -�,; � � " �,_ ,:'' ___, - , -, � , � C� � :1 , I I ,� �t';�, ', �. I:,-,;,, i, I ,� � - , I -� � ': "-, i , - , , , , I . , , �,_ , I ,- , , � , � ­ �, , ­, ", , U_ , ,- � I I "', - I I " ,� I �1_ `70L��' � �11 I I I I I "I I : � , � � � � ,, ', , , ,,�� � I I I I . � I � I ,, .:I � � � �,� _- 1? - I I � II � I . I � 1. .1 j ,�� ,_V� 5" �� .... I I , - F., , , .. ,: ': _, : �,,�, 1� � - . � L �� 21 I � . I I . I � , ­e -. 1. :, I '' ; I I -v . - - : " I �,�, " , , ­ , " , . � � i � , - " I I I, .1,; "I -'- � � � , - , ,_ I �,�, e " ': , ., , ,,-, al. - ", .,. , " , I - ,. . � I I I , , - ., � I , ,;� � ., I I , " ., , '' . � , I . �:_ I 4 , � , , __� , __ I I , p :1 I ­1 �_ I � I , , - ., " I I 11 I , 1, ­ I I "" ." I. I � I.- , - I I I - I �� I , " I I - I I . - . . I � 1-1 I , I I I , , �, � I I I .1� I I , ,-_.!,,,,',,,� 'A I I : I I. , c I , ,� � :� , ,� 1, r. , "; , � . '. , � ��, , %,, 1�., - : - I 1. . I , , I", � - : � � I � ��': �',, F1 I I I � ,� �, - , , � ,,,,, � . I I I ,� , - I I � " � . � I : , I � �, �� I I , I I'I , 1. , - '... I - � ­ ' � �, � � _ , ,: ,, ��', " �� t, .�' � , , � . � -1, - , , , , - . � .1 '��2:" :L,;;­,� " � , I , " L - " � � . . �� . - ; ,� � , , , " - , - - , . I , �'! ,,,, I , , ,� -� �� , , 1� � �, , :­ , � , � � , ,� _� , ,� ", , � ,- __ � - � I I I . ,�,�', : ,:� � ��_ , , �-�,�,� , �: , - , .- �', , � -, I I I , , , , , , ,� � � , 1: ", �' I i'l . , , , , , ,�� I I , -_ I - . � �, , ,i; " , 1. ". � , , , , ", - , , , " ., ". � I : I I 11� �, _�, . , , I � I I j."� � ;I � . " , I I � - :� � � . . ��� , , " -_ I I -1 I _ -I 1.„ � I � � � � I ,-. � � - I I '. I I , : , � , , � ,, "', ,I�L�,e,,,'p, .�,,�', � , , , I 11 I � � I . - o . , 1 I._ ,- " , ,_ � , , . , - � I I �o _. : , , - , , " , _��, , , , - �,. , � � f �.,.,,�,,:� � , I 1:� I , � , , � I . - , -, I , , I �� ,, - ,, .... I I I I - 1 I � 11.x; , I I I I _� �11 I '��, :� I 11 , 11 , 1, �",­,,, , ,-- -1 � 'L' � I I ��, , , � ,!_�,� zi �,�, ;��.,.� ,, I." I I � . 2 _ � , .� " , �, I I .I ,, �v I , , , ', - �� . I I I I-_'q ��, , � , � � I . 11 � , � - , , � � , , � � � , � '��'�, ,��,�,'I, L,'.�' "' , , ,' , , :, , I I - , ., , . � � , � � �. � �,`- , I .,- :­� . I , , I I I I I - ­ I I , " ��,� i , � I , , , " - � I , I , * , '­ � � �, _; � � � ,�-,��',",�,, , , � 1, � 1, , ft.�' " ,,, : . _-, , , "L , � , ", � ­?,A`��,��, 11 � ­j" , , 2 ,,�,`��I' ,� � " , , �* - ". :­� ��','�'�,',� , , � ; " � I .,Z�, , , ,� , - , � " _� , , , : ., �,� �,', ",,��,� ", : , , '�­� . , " - �., , , �_ :1 � - � -_ , � e . , I "' 11 , - - , , , ,,� "," �x i rf ¢ 4x&� i d 4 it .a �} ,I .y .c_ ,. I tz• .. .�_:: ,,, v.. .,, ,.:. , l RESOLUTION NO. 5266 2 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, DENYING A CLAIM AGAINST THE CITY. 4 WHEREAS, on November 2, 1977 Zeny Ward filed a claim against' i 5 the City of Carlsbad in the amount of $608.02; and 6 WHEREAS, State law requires that the City Council consider' 7 all claims and take action to approve, approve in part, or -deny 8 said claim; i 9 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the 10 City of Carlsbad as follows 11 1. That the above recitations are true and correct. 12 2. That the City Council has considered the facts and. a d 13 circumstances of the above -described claim. �Q m oW a 14 3. That the City Council hereby denies said claim, a0Dz z� °►'-<0 15 4. That the City Attorney is directed to forward a copy °'cagy ti w 0 16 of this resolution to the claimant and to the City "s insurance N Q zo ` 17 carrier and to comply with all other notice requirements provided a 18 by law. 4 19 PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the 20 City of Carlsbad, California, at a regular meeting held on the 21 day of , 1977; by the following vote, to wit: 22 AYES 23 NOES: 24 ABSENT: 25 ROBERT C. FRAZEE, Mayor 26 ATTEST: 27 3 28 14ARGARET E. ADAMS, City Clerk (SEAL) f