Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1979-02-06; City Council; 5742; Satellite plant master plan- .' CITY OF CARLSBAD - Dept. Initia1:z Hd . C, Atty. v@ . AGENDA BILL NO. ,~7~2 DATE : Februzry 6, 1979 DEPARTMENT : Pub1 ic Works C, Mgr. Jcfiject: SATELLITE PLANT MASTER PLAN. - Statement of the Mat-izr City Council, instructed staff to report back regarding a program to establish a ,Satellite Plant Master Plan for the City sewer service area. It is proposed that the Project Report (Master Plan) and its Environmental Impact Report be prepzred by separate firms. and provide the degree of objectivity necessary for a project of this magnitude. The budget necessary to accomplish both reports is estimated at between $45,000 and $50,000. This will facilitate processing Normal procedure for a project of this nature is to send a Request for Proposal to a number of qualified firms. Ba'sed on analyses of proposals received, a recommendation is forwarded to City Council. This was the procedure followed when the City retained James M. Montgomery Engineers to prepare a similar com- The cost of that report was approxima-rely $28,000. It is proposed that we follow this procedure for the Envirbnmental Impact Report. The Master Plan presents a di fferent se? of ci rcumstances. The firm of Lowry & Associates prepared the "Overview" report, a number of project reports for public agencies and private parl-ies in the Encina Basin and performed considerable professional work as part of -the San Diego Regional 208 Report. . It is the opinion of the Pub1 ic'Works Adminiktrator that considerable stafi time and money could be saved by negotiating a contf-act with Lowry & Associates to prepare the Satel I ite Plant Master Plan. . bined report for 4,000+ acres in the northeast section of the City. .r I .. Exhibit -- , Staff report Resolution No. ,q&&?authorizing transfer oi funds in the amount of $50,000' from Genera I Fund Unappropriated Reserves. to Pub1 ic Works Professional Ser- . vices Account Recommendation That Council authorize transfer of $50,000 from unappropriated reserves to an appropriate account; authorize slaff to negotiate contract with Lowry & Associ- ates for preparation of a Satellite Plant Master Plan; and authorize staff to solicit proposals for the Environmental Impact Report portion. (See page 2 for Council ~ction) . . Page 2 Agenda Bill No. 5742 February 6, 1979 Council Action: 2-6-79 Council directed that the Satellite Plant Master Plan be delayed until such time as the City Council has had the opportunity to act on the forthcoming project report for the Lake Calavera Hills Satellite Treatment Plant. MEMORANDUM TO : City Manager FROM : Pub1 ic Works Administrator DATE : January 30, 1979 SUBJECT: SATELLITE PLANT MASTER PLAN The City Council on December 5, 1978 unanimously voted to instruct staff to prepare a report on the effort and funds necessary to prepare a Satel- lite Plant Master Plan and E.I.R. for all portions of the City's sewer service area other than that covered by the Montgomery report. Analysis of the effort necessary to complete the task has included con- sideration of available useful information. Among the resources consid- ered, we included the Encina Phase Ill E.I.R., the Agua Hedionda Specific Plan E.I.R., the Montgomery report and E.I.R. and the Plaza Camino Real expansion E.I.R. The reports prepared for the Leucadia County Water Dis- trict and the San Marcos County Water District wi I I be used as resource material but have no direct information about lands within the City's sewer service area. Soon after receiving Council's direction, staff met with Mr. Dennis O'Leary of Lowry 8, Associates to discuss the scope of work and effort to complete the project. The attached proposal was a result. The proposal was analyzed by the Planning Director and the Public Works Administrator. assumptions were made which should be modified before a contract is nego- tiated, the proposal gives a good indication of the scope of work and effort requ i red. While some Following review of the Lowry proposal, discussions were held with RECON which resulted in the attached proposal. This level of effort assumes con- sideration of information available in existing certified E.1.R.s. The inclusion of one-third of our City in the coastal zone and the uncer- tainty of the completion schedule for our local coastal program precludes the studies in question from containing the specificity of the Montgomery report. The proposed Master Plan should be able to identify logical ser- vice basins within the coastal zone and analyze the environmental impact in sufficient detail to allow for adoption of the Master Plan. Preparation of specific project reports, within the guidelines established by an adopted Master Plan, and supplementary E.1.R.s would be the responsibility of parties proposing specific projects. The following outlines are suggested as being appropriate for the Master Plan and E.I.R.: Master Plan I . Introduction It. Development of satellite concept to date I I I. Background information - 2- IV. Variations of satellite concept V. Impact of regional solids handling facility VI. Drainage basin boundaries, alternatives and recommendations VII. Satellite plant site - feasibility, alternatives and recommenda- t ions VI I I. Recommended program IX. Specifications Env i ronmenta I Impact Report I. Introduction II. Environmental setting and summary Ill. Environmental analysis of proposed Master Plan IV. Environmental analysis of the implementation of reclamation fa- ci I ities V. Unavoidable adverse impacts if program implemented VI. Significant irreversible impacts if program implemented VII. Short-term use versus long-term productivity Vlll. Alternatives It is my opinion that each document can be prepared in 45 days, not includ- ing printing time. two weeks after the Master Plan. The total budget for the project is esti- mated to be $50,000. The E.I.R. should be started and completed approximately The normal process for projects of this nature would be to solicit pro- posals, review and recommend to Council. Staff would feel comfortable in following this process for both parts of this project. We recommend that it be followed for the E.I.R. portion. It is our opinion that significant time and money can be saved if, instead of requesting proposals for the Master Plan portion, we were authorized to negotiate with Lowry & Associ- ates for that portion of the project. They have done considerable work of this nature for public agencies and private parties in the Encina Basin and they have an existing level of knowledge that would be expensive to dupli- cate in another firm. RECOMMENDATIONS That City Council: 1. Authorize transfer of $50,000 from unappropriated reserves to an appro- priate account for this project. 2. Authorize staff to send out a Request for Proposal for the E.I.R. por- tion of the project. .. -3- 3. Authorize staff to negotiate a contract for Council approval for the Master Plan portion of the project with Lowry & Associates. Ronald A. Beckman, P.E. Pub1 ic Works Administrator RAB:VEB CC: Planning Director December 22, 1978 Mr. Ron Beckman CITY OF CARLSBAD P.O. Box 265 Carlsbad, California 92008 Dear Mr. Beckman: Subject: PROPOSAL - Waste Water -Reclamation Master P1 an Lowry & Associates appreciates this opportunity to submit a proposal to the City of Carlsbad for preparation of a waste water reclamation plan. water reclamation planning to date in north San Diego County, we believe that we can develop in minimum time a plan that is completely responsive to your needs and goals. Because of our participation in and familiarity with waste Lowry & Associates proposes to conduct a study and recommend a waste water reclamation plan to the City of Carlsbad in conformance with the following outline: Study Area The area to be covered by the study will include the entire City of Carlsbad with the exception of: both that area encompassed by the study Environmental Impact and Faci 1 i ti es P1 an for a Sate1 1 i te Sewage Treatment Facility (James M. Montgomery, Consulting Engineers, Inc., December 1978) and lands served b.y special sewerace districts. A plan now exists for the former area and it is understood that special sewerage districts will develop their own waste water reclamation plans. Objective Objective of the study will be to develop a plan for reclamation of domestic sewage within the study area and for beneficial use of the re- sulting reclaimed water supply. Use of reclaimed water would be primarily diverted toward irrigation of crops, landscaping and the like, but other opportunities for use, such as industrial supply and ground water waste recharge will also be investigated. 17748 SKY PARK BLVO , IRVINE. CALIFORNIA 92714 (714) 751-3820 Mr . Ron- Beckman CITY OF CARLSBAD December 22, 1978 Page 2 Previous Studies Reference will be made to and guidance obtained from previous studies having to do with waste water reclamation in the Carlsbad area. These reports include: Overview of Waste Water Reclamation Opportunties in the City of Carlsbad (Lowry & Associates, March 1978) .. Water Qual i ty Probl ems & Management Responsi bi 1 i ties , Part I1 Wastewater Reclamation and Reuse (CPO, Apri’ 1978). Technical Approach The technical approach to the study will be as follows: (a) the overview report referred to above will be made. Written recommendations will be made, to City staff for selection of projects to be included .in this study. Upon approval of staff, the study will proceed. A preliminary review and screening of projects in, (b) Analytical and flow data will be obtained from agency records or by sampling and analysis performed by the agency and estimates of flow based upon unit contributions and population data. Projections of future sewage flow in the study area will be based upon population data from the City of Carlsbad. Sewage flow projections will be for the purpose of determining the sufficiency of sewage supply for production of reclaimed water at each location studied. Therefore, these projections will not be sewage flow projections for the total City of Carlsbad. (c) and demographic data for the study area will be obtained from the City of Carlsbad. (d) Volumes and quality of reclaimed water available now and in the future at the project locations will be estimated and projected from the above data. projections wi 11 take water supply qual i ty into account. Present and projected land use plans, land use data Quality Mr. Ron- Beckman CITY OF CARLSBAD December 22, 1975 Page 3 (e) mensurate with quantity and quality of available re- claimed water will be sought. In general , it is ex- pected that irrigation will provide the greatest market for reclaimed water. While irrigation is expected to create sufficient demand to use the total projected reclaimed water supply, consideration will also be given to such other uses as industrial supply. Water quality requirements intrinsic to each beneficial use of re- claimed water contemplated will be determined and considered. Areas in which beneficial uses of reclaimed water wi 11 take place will be mapped. No commi ttments for taking or purchase of reclaimed water by potential users would be obtained at this stage. Opportunities for use of reclaimed water com- (f) of reclaimed water for each use and location would then be established. The following will be taken into account: Anticipated water quality and requirements for use . requir.ements intrinsic to the use, as discussed in (e) above . surface and ground water quality in the area of use . water quality objectives of the Regional Water Quality Control Board . Title 22 standards and requirements of the State Department of Health Services. In carrying out this task, meetings will be held with the staff of the Regional Board and the State and County Health Departments, so that the anticipated require- ments developed may more realistically reflect the future regulatory actions of those agencies. (9) Criteria will be developed from the above requirements, the standards of engineering practice and the plans of the City of Carlsbad for: waste water reclamation plant design, pumping, installations, transmission lines, storage facilities and fail-safe operation. waste water reclamation plant siting, . .- Mr. Ron Beckman CITY OF CARLSBAD December 22, 1978 Page 4 (h) Waste water reclamation plant sites will be evaluated and selected, on the basis of the foregoing criteria, availability of sewage, proximity to use areas, and proximity to potential storage areas. Alternative treatment processes will be evaluated for installation at each site and a specific treatment methodology recommended on the basis of the aforementioned criteria and requirements, and cost of production of reclaimed water. Also to be analysed for each site are storage, distribution and fai 1 -safe a1 ternatives , and selection made on the basis.of the foregoing criteria, reliability and costs. (i) 'Maps, schematics, plot plans and other drawings will be prepared as appropriate to the explanation of all alternztives considered. (j) will be prepared. A final cost estimate of each recormended alternative (k) Specific waste water reclamation projects will be recommended to suit the potantial markets and depending .upon monetary costs and environmental, and social factors. (It is anticipated than an EIR study of potential waste water reclamation projects will be in progress concurrently with this study and that a continuous exchange of information will be taking place. Report A report of the above study will be prepared, consisting of text, tables, other presentation of data, maps, schematics., plot plans and diagrams, in sufficient detail to set forth the analytical and planning procedure and recommendations clearly, concisely and completely. Ten copies of the report will be submitted. An initial outline of the report contents is. attached. The study and report described above w.ill be performed by Lowry on a time and material basis, at rates commensurate with Lowry's fee k _- Mr. Ron Beckman CITY OF CARLSBAD December 22, 1978 Page 5 schedule current at the time of billing. A copy of Lowry's current fee schedule dated January 1, 1978 is attached. The maximum limit of fee will be $25,000 and Lowry will not bill above that amount without written authorization from the City of Carlsbad. Per sonne 1 will be Study Manager/Engineer. Mr. Dennis O'Leary will be Study Director and Mr. William Fannon I am indeed appreciative of the opportunity to submit this proposal to the City of Carlsbad. If there are any questions, I shall certainly be happy. to meet with you to discuss them. ' Sincerely, Dennis A. O'Leary Vice-president DA0:mh Enclosure JANUARY 1, 1978 STANDARD SCHEDULE OF COMPENSATION Applicable for Services Furnished on Per Hour Basis CLASSIFICATION PER HOUR Senior Principal Engineer ............. $ 55.00 Principal Engineer. ................ $ 47.00 Senior Engineer .................. $ 41.00 Senior Planner .................. $ 41.00 Senior Scientist ................. $ 41.00 Engineer ..................... $ 32.00 Resident Engineer .................. $ 32.00 Planner ...................... $ 30.00 Computer Programer ................ $ 27.00 Assistant Engineer. ................ $ 24.00 Senior Draftsman. ................. $ 24.00 Construction Inspector. .............. $ 20.00 Draftsman ...................... $ 20.00 Computer Operator ................. $ 20.00 Engineering Technician. .............. $ 12.00 Technical Report Preparation. ........... $ 13.00 . other Approved Outside Services -, ........... Cost Plus 10% Computer Time, Reproduction and Billed at Actual . Incidental Expenses ................ AboveJees Include Incidental Costs for Local Trans- portation, Telephone Costs, etc. Lodging, and other Related Travel Costs Billed at Actual CDst Travel Costs. ..................... Air, Bus and Taxi, Minimum daily charge for court testimony as an expert witness is $600.00. hourly rates. Preparation for a court case willsbe charged at regular CITY OF CARLSBAD WASTE WATER RECLAMATION AND REUS E PROGRAM I MPL EMENTAT I ON REPORT OUTLINE I. INTRODUCTION A. Purpose of Report B. Authorization 11. HISTORY OF SATELLITE CONCEPT A. Present Status 111. BACKGROUND INFORMATION A, Statement of Intent B. Population C. Land Use D. Agricultural Practices E. Irrigation Requirements IV. SATELLITE CONCEPTS A. B. C. .. D. E. F. G. Reclamation and Reuse is Primary Objective Fail-safe Outlet Storage Facilities Contracts with Irrigators Charges and Costs Review A1 ternate Approaches Treatment Method V. REVIEW PLANT LOCATIONS A. From Overview Report B. C. Deferred Plants D. E. Batiquitos Plant F. Palomar Aiport Plant G. Any Others Other Agency Plants not Considered Here Lake Calavera Hills Already Studied k , -1- REPORT OUTLINE (Cont'd) VI. BATIQUITOS PLANT A. Service Area B. Site C. Size and Layout D. General Discussion of Ai ternatives 1. Reuse 2. 3. Disposal 4. Consolidation 5. costs Treatment, Distribution, Fail-safe & Storage E. Recommended Reuse & Disposal System F. Permits and Agreements 1. Coastal Commission 2. 3. RWQCB 4. Leucadia 5. JAC 6. EPA (maybe) City (for Zoning, General Plan, Etc.) G. Financing 1. By Developer at Reimbursement 2. Other Methods VII. PALOMAR AIRPORT PLANT A. Service Area 1. Direct from Carlsbad 2. From Other Agencies B. A1 ternate Locations 1. Depends on Service Area 3. 4. Consolidation 5. costs u 2. Reuse Considerations Treatment, Distribution, Fail-safe & Storage C. Recommendation Location and Size D. Recommended Reuse & Disposal System E. Permits & Agreements 1. City (Zoning, Etc.) 2. RWQCB 3. JAC 4. EPA (maybe) 5. Upstream Agencies G. Financing I -2- .. .. REPORT OUTLINE (Cont'd) VIII. RECOMMENDED PROGRAM A. Process Lake Calavera Hills B. . Approve Batiquitos Proposal if Acceptable C. Consider Specific Proposals for Palomar Airport IX. SPECIFIC ACTIONS .. A. Accept this Report B. Authorize EIR C. D. Announce Interest in Specific Proposals Inform Interested and Affected Agencies -3- . Regional Environmental Consultants 1094 Cudahy Place Suite 204 San Diego. CA 921 10 275-3732 January 25, 1979 Mr. Ron Beckman City Engineer 1200 Elm Avenue Carlsbad, California 92008 Reference: Proposal for the Preparation of a Draft Environmental Impact Report for the Carlsbad Wastewater Reclamation Master Plan Dear Mr. Beckman: Pursuant to the request of Lowry and Associates, RECON is pleased to submit this proposal to the City of Carlsbad for the preparation of a draft environmental impact report (EIR) for the Carlsbad Wastewater Reclamdtion Master Plan. The attached proposal briefly summarizes and outlines RECON'S approach to the proposed draft EIR. This sum- marized scope of work and the suggested outline for the draft EIR will introduce you to the more formal proposal that we shall submit next week. RECON the e relat RECON Costa RECON has had much experience working in the City of Carlsbad and in the entire north county area. We have enjoyed an excellent working relationship with Lowry and Associates on .a number of prbjects. RECON recently completed the Environmental Impact Report for the La Costa Northeast/San Plarcos County Water District Wastewater Treatment and Reclamation Project for a project designed by Lowry ani Associ- ates and under the jurisdiction and authority of the San llarcos and H ates has had much experience working ntire north county area. We have ionship with Lowry and Associates recently completed the Environme Northeast/San Plarcos County Wate ecla or a project and iction and au -- .mation project f under the jurisd in the City of Carlsb enjoyed an excellent on-a number of prbje ntal Impact Report fo r District Wastewater designed by Lowry and thority of the San lla ad a wor cts. r th Tre Ass rcos .I_ .nd in king e La atment oci- ' County Water District. A copy of that EIR is enclosed for your re- view. Other projects on which RECON has worked in association with Lowry and Associates.include preliminary studies for the feasibility of wastewater reclamation in La Costa South within the jurisdiction of the Leucadia County Water District and the Environmental - Impact Report for Lake Calavera Hills Master Plan of Development and Alter- native Sewaqe Treatment Facility. RECON has also prepared a study of urban runoff into Batiquitos Lagoon and numerous EIRs for residen- tial, commercial, and industrial development in the City of Carlsbad. RECON therefore feels expertly qualified to' prepare a draft environ- mental impact report for the proposed wastewater reclamation master plan. RECON will address the proposed project as described in the report proposed by Lowry and Associates. RECON will also take advantage of the existing information in the draft environmental impact report for the Encina Phase I11 expansion, the Environmental Mr. Ron Beckman -2- January 25, 1979 Impact and Faci.lities Plan for a Satellite Sewage Treatment Facility by James PI. Montgomery, Consultinq Engineers, Inc., the Overview of Waste Water Reclamation Opportunities in the City of Carlsbad by Lowry and Associates, and Water Quality Problems and Manaqement Responsibilities, Part II Wastewater Reclamation and Reuse prepared for CPO. It is recognized that much of the proposed draft EIR must be prepared concurrently with the master plan, thus necessitating a close working relationship with the consulting civil engineers and the City of Carlsbad. Every effort will be made to produce a com- plete and accurate document in-a minimum amount of time in order to meet the city's objectives. The environmental services described in the attached proposal will be perEormed for an estimated fee of $18,000.00. This estimate does not include printing, blueprinting, xeroxing, and other miscellaneous expenses. Should any unforeseen circumstances arise resulting in additional work and therefore additional fees, RECON will notify the city as soon as possible. The proposed draft EIR will be prepared by John Larson under my supervision as Senior Environmental Consultant and with the direction of'Royce Riggan, President of RECON. If you have any questions, please feel free to call any of us. 1 Sincerely, JRH:njh At t ac limen t Enclosure -. I/ Senior.Environmenta1 Consultant cc: Dennis O'Leary, Lowry and Associates PROPOSAL' FOR THE PREPARATION OF A DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR THE CITY OF CARLSBAD WASTEWATER RECLAMATION MASTER PLAN SCOPE OF WORK The proposed project is a master plan to implement the concept for establishing a system of satellite wastewater treatment plants that would, as an integral part of the plan, reclaim wastewater for beneficial reuse. The environmental impact report for the proposed project must address the re- gional issues implicit in -providing sewage treatment capacity for new development and new population growth. It must also analyze the potential impacts of using reclaimed wastewater for irrigation and the physical impacts from construction of the necessary facilities. The attached outline suggests an approach to these different levels of analysis. Since the proposed master plan is to implement a concept, many specific impacts and specific mitigation cannot be iden- tified until specific projects are proposed. Therefore, in addition to analyzing the proposed master plan relative to . the necessary topical list of enviropmental concerns, the proposed draft EIR will have an extensive summary of issues in an effort to be as specific as possible as to the true impacts of the master plan. The draft EIR will also clarify at which .points in the implementation process mitigation measures should be required. The proposed draft EIR will not attempt to redo the circulation element, the open space element, or the land use element of the Carlsbad General Plan in analyzing the impacts of growth that would be allowed in the city with the avail- ability of sewage treatment capacity and the implementation of a wastewater reclamation program. Although additional planned studies may be necessary to implement the proposed master plan, a city-wide traffic analysis, an economic or fiscal analysis, detailed soils engineering technical re- ports, or technical. reports based on detailed field surveys for biological and cultural resources are not within the scope of this report. APPROACH An environmental impact report is an information docu- ment written for both the public and the implementing agency. Preparation of such a document involves full disclosure of all the potentially significant environmental impacts and the recommendations for mitigation to those impacts. This analy- sis requires a close working relationship with the City of Carlsbad and the other participants in the project. Above all, the EIR must meet, to the fullest extent possible, both the letter and intent of the Caiifornia Environmental Quality Act. FEE - RECON will prepare the proposed draft EIR for an esti- mated fee of $18,000.00. This fee does not include printing, blueprinting, xeroxing, or other miscellaneous expenses. If unforeseen circumstances require additional work and, as a result, additional fees, RECON will notify the city as soon as possible. b DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT CITY OF CARLSBAD WASTEWATER RECLAMATION MASTER PLAN . FOR THE I. INTRODUCTION 11. ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND SUMMARY A. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT 1. Abstract 2. Location 3. Objectives 4. Technical, Economic, and Environmental Characteristics B. SUMMARY OF THE CENTRAL ISSUES 1. 2 .. 3. Growth Inducement and Growth Management a. b. d. e. f. C. g* Satellite Plants vs. Expansion at Encina Timing and Phasing Controls on Development Traffic Circulation Air Quality Community Services and Public Facilities Local and Regional Growth Management Policies and CPO Series IV Population Forecasts Energy Conservation Land Application and Beneficial Use of Reclaimed Wastewater a. Water Quality b. Environmental Health c. Land Use, i.e., Open Space Policies and Park Planning d. Agricultural Uses e: Effects on Native Biological Habitats -f. Water Conservation Construction of the Wastewater Treatment and Reclamation Facilities a. Land Use b. Topography and Visual Aesthetics c. Biological Resources- d. Archaeological Resources e. Odor f. .Noise g. Energy i. Safety of Dams for Reclamation Reservoirs j. . h. Solid Waste Use of Encina Ocean Outfall C. SUMMARY OF RESPONSIBLE AGENCIES AND REQUIRED PERMITS 1. City of Carlsbad (Lead Agency) a. Land Use b. Zoning c. Conditional Use Permits d. Discretionary Action on Individual Projects 2. Regional Water Quality Control Board a. Waste Discharge Requirements b. Wastewater Reclamation Requirements 3. California Department of Water Resources, Division of Safety of Dams a. Design Approval b. Approval to Fill Reservoir After Comple- c. Annual Structural Checks of the Dam tion of the Dam 4. Encina Joint Administrative Council: Ocean Outfall 5. Environmental Protection Agency .. a. Discharge into Federal Waters b. Federal Grants 6. California Coast Regional Commission: Con- struction in the Coastal Zone 7. California Department of Fish and Game: Pos- . sible Alteration of Streambeds D. SUMMARY OF MITIGATION TO POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Land Application of Treated Wastewater Safety of Dams B'io 1 o g i c a 1 Re source s Archaeological Resources Odor Energy Growth Inducement 8. Community Services and Public Facilities 9. Other Potential Impacts Identified in the Analysis E. RECOMMENDATION FOR FURTHER STUDY WITH THE IMPLE- MENTATION OF SPECIFIC RECLAMATION PLANTS AND OTHER LAND DEVELOPMENT 1. Soil Studies 2. Landscaping and Irrigation Plans 3. Biological Resource Surveys 4. Archaeological Resource Surveys 5. Environmental Analysis of the Direct and Indirect Impacts of the Specific Projects 111. ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS OF THE PROPOSED MASTER PLAN A. LAND USE B. GROWTH MANAGEMENT C. HYDROLOGY AND WATER QUALITY D. TRAFFIC CIRCULATION E. AIR QUALITY F. UTILITIES AND ENERGY G. ’ COMMUNITY SERVICES IV. *ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RECLAMATION FACILITIES A. LAND USE B. TOPOGRAPHY AND VISUAL AESTHETICS C. GE-OLOGY AND SOILS D. HYDROLOGY AND WATER QUALITY E. BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES F. ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCES G. ODOR H. SOLID WASTE .. I. NOISE V. VI. VII. VIII. J. ENERGY K. GROWTH INDUCEMENT I 1. Traffic Circulatzon 2. Air Quality 3. Utilities and Energy 4. Community Services ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS WHICH CANNOT BE AVOIDED IF THE PROPOSAL IS IMPLEMENTED SIGNIFICANT IRREVERSIBLE ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGES WHICH WOULD BE INVOLVED IN THE PROPOSED ACTION SHOULD IT BE IMPLEMENTED THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LOCAL SHORT-TERM USES OF MAN’S ENVIRONMENT AND THE MAINTENAMCE AND ENHANCEMENT OF LONG-TERM PRODUCTIVITY ALTERNATIVES TO THE PROPOSED ACTION A. NO PROJECT ‘ 1. With expansion at the Encina Water Pollution Control Facility 2. Without Expansion at Encina B. ALTERNATIVE SEWAGE TREATMENT POSSIBILITIES C. ALTERNATIVE WASTEWATER RECLAMATION POSSIBILITIES Y . rT L L 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 I 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 c- 4"- RESOLUTION NO. 5669 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, AUTHORIZING TRANSFER OF FUNDS TO COVER PREPARA- TION OF A SATELLITE PLANT MASTER PLAN AND ENVIRONMENTAL IM- PACT REPORT FOR THE CITY'S SEWER- ABSENT : ATTEST : MARGARET E. ADAMS, City C.ferk (SEAL)