Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1984-09-18; City Council; 7158-8; Twenty-Seventh Supplement to the Basic AgreementCARLSBAD — AGEND/QlLL A mi /~7 / £T&— ?*" C*An# / /O0 . o MTG 9/1R/84 nPPT_ U/M TITLE: TWENTY-SEVENTH SUPPLEMENT TO THE BASIC AGREEMENT DEPT. HD./^Tj CITY MGR.,2^1 RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve Resolution No. 11 7^7 authorizine the Mavor to execute the Twentv Spvpnth 1 I oo oorH I CTi oI_l oz§ Supplement to the Basic Agreement for the Encina Water Pollution Control Facility. ITEM EXPLANATION; Section 17.3(b) and (c) provided for the payment of the Encina operating costs based on the flow of the respective agencies and Article 32 required that all flows be utilized in the computation regardless of the fact that the flows may have been reclaimed. These provisions are no longer appropriate and should be amended. 1. Section 17.3 (b) & (c) are modified to be consistent with the Revenue & Financial Plans developed as a part of the conditions for the grant to construct Phase III. This assesses O&Mxosts on the basis of "Ownership" which includes general plant management and overhead and upon "usage" which includes charges for volume of flows and strength of flows (BOD and solids). This method is considered a more equitable spread of the costs and provides for appropriate charges for those members who may be using the plant for sludge disposal for their reclamation facilities. 2. Article 32 is modified to insure a minimum plant flow of 10 MGD to be pro- vided on the basis of ownership to ensure that the plant is operating at an efficient level. Flows less than 10 MGD could be detrimental and cause digester foaming and possible odor problems. Current plant flows are about 14 MGD and there is sufficient reclamation plant capacity if all were up and operating to reduce the flows below the 10 MGD level (this is considered only a remote possibility but not probable), however, this condition will preclude that circumstance. The revised article also requires a tri-annual review of the 10 MGD limit. The JAC approved the Supplement at their meeting of August 22, 1984 based upon a specially convened "Article 32 Subcommittee" recommendation. Council member Chick was the City representative to the subcommittee which also included the following representatives: San Marcos - Stanley Mohr Encinitas Sanitary District - Jack Kubota Buena Sanitation District City of Vista - Mike Flick Leucadia County Water District - Elaine McDaniel It is recommended that the City approve the Twenty-Seventh Supplement to the Basic Agreement. Twenty-Seventh Supplement to the Basic Agreement Page 2 FISCAL IMPACT: There is no direct impact although per unit (per MGD) costs may be slightly higher since the fixed cost (ownership) is spread over fewer units for those reclaiming effluent. EXHIBITS: 1. Resolution No. 17H°\ . 2. Twenty-Seventh Supplement to the Basic Agreement. i. J 1 2 3 4 E E r 4 t s 1( 1: 1: 1: 1< 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 RESOLUTION NO. 7749 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA AUTHORIZING EXECUTION OF THE AND (c) AND SECTION 32 OF THE BASIC AGREEMENT RELATIVE TO RECLAMATION AND TO APPORTIONMENT OF CHARGES OF OWNERSHIP AND USE OF EWPCF TWENTY-SEVENTH SUPPLEMENT TO AMEND SECTIONS 17.3 (b) WHEREAS, the City of Vista, City of Carlsbad, Buena Sanitation District, ,ncinitas Sanitary District, Leucadia County Water District, and San Marcos :ounty Water District are parties to a Joint Powers Agreement (Basic greement), which provides for the operation and maintenance of a joint 'ewer system commonly known as the Encina Water Pollution Control Facility EWPCF); and, WHEREAS, Section 17.3 (b) of said Basic Agreement provides that all !xpenses for operation and maintenance of the EWPCF shall be paid by members if the Joint Powers based on their respective flows to the EWPCF; and, WHEREAS, Section 17.3 (c) of said Basic Agreement requires the Adminis- :rator of the Joint Powers to annually estimate the budget for EWPCF based on 111 sewage originating in each of the jurisdictions, including reclaimed rastewater; and, WHEREAS, Section 32 of the Basic Agreement requires that each member )f the.Joint Powers pay a proportionate share of the operation and maintenance :ost of the EWPCF for all wastewater originating within its jurisdiction without :onsideration for reclamation; and, WHEREAS, the Encina Joint Powers obtained a grant from the Federal ;overnment for enlargement and upgrading of the EWPCF, which project is :omonly known as PHASE I11 ENLARGEMENT & UPGRADING; and, WHEREAS, one of the conditions of said grant was the adoption and imple- mentationof a Financial and Revenue Plan by the Joint Powers in accordance with the guidelines set forth in said grant; and, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 a 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 1E 19 2c 21 22 22 24 25 26 27 2E WHEREAS, Section 17.3 (b) and (c) and Section 32 of the Basic Agreement are inconsistent with the requirements of the aforesaid Financial and Revenue Plan; and, WHEREAS, the Twenty-Seventh Supplement will amend Section 17.3 (b) and (c) and Section 32 of the Basic Agreement so as to meet the requirements of the aforesaid mandated Financial and Revenue Plan, and will provide consideration for reclamation together with procedures for a review of proposed reclamation facilities; and, WHEREAS, on May 22, 1985, the proposed Twenty-Seventh Supplement to the Basic Agreement was considered by the Joint Advisory Committee to the Joint Powers at a regular meeting thereof, and was unanimously approved by said Joint Advisory Committee; and, WHEREAS, it is in the best interests of this City and that its City Council be authorized to execute the Twenty-Seventh Supplement to the Basic Agreement; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Carlsbad as follows: Section 1. That the City Council of this City be, and is hereby authorized to execute the Twenty-Seventh Supplement, which Supplement amends Section 17.3 (b) and (c) and Section 32 of the Basic Agreement of the Encina Joint Powers. //I I// /// I// /// /I/ /I/ /// -2- 1 'a J 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 e 9 1c 11 12 12 14 1: 1C 1'; 1t 1: 2( 21 2: 2: 2L 2! 2t 2' 2t PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council of :he City of Carlsbad held the 2nd day of JdY , 1985, by the Eollowing vote, to wit: AYES: Council Menbers Casler, Lewis, Chick and Pettine NOES: None -1 ATTEST : (SEAL) -3- TWENTY-SEVENTH SUPPLEMENT TO BASIC AGREEMENT TO PROVIDE FOR AMENDMENT OF SECTION 32 AND AMENDMENT OF SECTIONS 17.3(b) AND 17.3(c) RE COST OF OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE This Twenty-Seventh Supplement is made and entered into this day of , 1984, by and among: THE CITY OF VISTA, (VISTA), a General Law City; CITY OF CARLSBAD (CARLSBAD), a General Law City; SAN MARCOS COUNTY WATER DISTRICT (SAN MARCOS), a County Water District; BUENA SANITATION DISTRICT (BUENA), a County Sanitation District; ENCINITAS SANITARY DISTRICT (ENCINI- TAS), a Sanitary District; and LEUCADIA COUNTY WATER DISTRICT (LEUCADIA), a County Water District. Recitals A. On or about July 13, 1961, the CITY OF CARLSBAD, a gen- eral law city, and the VISTA SANITATION DISTRICT entered into a written Joint Powers Agreement for acquisition, construction, ownership, and operation of a joint sewer system, commonly known as the Encina Water Pollution Control Facility (EWPCF); said joint powers agreement is commonly known as the "Basic Agreement." B. The aforesaid Basic Agreement has been modified and supplemented from time to time by written agreements signed by the parties to said Basic Agreement. C. BUENA became a party to the Basic Agreement by virtue of the Second Supplement thereto dated January 6, 1964. D. SAN MARCOS became a party to the Basic Agreement by virtue of the Third Supplement thereto dated March 22, 1965. E. LEUCADIA and ENCINITAS became parti^ to the Basic Agreement by virtue of the Fifth Supplement thereto dated Septem- ber 17, 1971. F. At all times since July 13, 1961, the Basic Agreement, as modified and supplement, has been and still is in full force and effect. G. On or about September 14, 1983, the VISTA SANITATION DISTRICT was dissolved and the functions theretofore performed by said District was assumed by the CITY OF VISTA. H. Section 32 of the Basic Agreement for the ownership and operation of the Encina Joint Sewer System provides as follows: "Any party to this Basic Agreement, at its own expense, may, and shall have the right to, reclaim water from any sewage in the Joint System and to install at any place approved by the parties to said Basic Agreement facilities for the reclamation of water from sewage. Any such reclamation shall not reduce the M & 0 expenses payable by any party and such M & 0 expenses shall be charged and paid as though there had been no such reclamation. In the event the requests to reclaim water exceed the available supply, each party shall be entitled to reclaim water from that portion of the total sewage entering the Joint System that is equal to the proportion of capacity of the treatment (Unit I) owned by such party as shown in Exhibit "C" hereto attached." I. Section 17.3(b) of the Basic Agreement provides as follows: "All administration, maintenance, and operation expense (in- cluding overhead) of the Joint System, (except Units "A", "B", and "C"), hereafter sometimes referred to as M & 0 expense, shall be paid by each party in an amount equal to that portion of the total M & 0 expenses which the actual amount of sewage received that fiscal year from such party (plus its share of inflow from leakage as provided in Section 18) bears to the total actual quantity of sewage handled and treated that fiscal year by the Joint System. This amount shall be determined in accordance with recog- nized accounting principals." J. Section 17.3(c) of the Basic Agreement provides as follows: -2-7 "Not later than May 1st in any year the Administrator shall estimate the amount of money required to maintain and oper- ate the Joint System during the ensuing fiscal year, and the proportionate amount to be paid by each party to this Basic Agreement. Such estimate shall be based on the cost, main- tenance, and operation during the current fiscal year as such proportion of the sewage developed and originating within the jursidiction of each of the parties bears to the total amount of sewage developed and originating in the jurisdictions of all parties; provided, however, at the com- mencement of operation of the Joint System the Administrator shall estimate such costs for the balance of the current fiscal year based upon estimates of the sewage to develop and originate within the jurisdiction of each of the parties and be handled and treated by the Joint System. It shall be the duty of each party to include the sum for maintenance and operating expense in its budget or other program of expenditures but in any event to make payments promptly at the time the same become due." K. That as a precondition to a state and federal grant for Phase III Upgrading and Enlargement of the Encina Water Pollution Control Facility, the Joint Powers agreed to implement a Finan- cial and Revenue Program providing for a "user charge system." L. That the requirements of the Financial and Revenue Pro- gram required by the state and federal governments conflict with the provisions of Sections 17.3(b) and 17.3(c) and Section 32 of the Basic Agreement. M. That it is necessary and in the best interest of all members of the Encina Joint Powers to amend Section 32 and amend Section 17.3(b) and 17.3(c) of the Basic Agreement to provide that all future M & 0 expenses shall be based on ownership and usage in accordance with the Financial and Revenue Program imple- mented by the Encina Joint Powers and submitted to the State of Calfornia, and any revisions thereof or amendments thereto. NOW, THEREFORE, the parties hereto agree as follows: -3- 1. From and after the effective date of this Twenty-Seventh Supplement, the provisions of Section 32 of the Basic Agreement shall be hereby amended as follows: "(a) Any party to this Basic Agreement, at its own expense, may, and shall have the right to, reclaim water from any sewage in the Joint System which emanates within the jurisdiction of the respective reclaiming party. And, subject to the limitations hereafter stated, each party shall have the right to install facilities for the reclamation of water from sewage. Provided, how- ever, no party hereto shall have the right to reclaim water unless the average daily sewage flow from such party's jurisdiction that is entering Unit I of the Joint System is in the same percentage of 10 MGD as is such party's percentage of capacity-ownership right in said Unit I. Further provided, that any reclamation shall require the approval of all the parties hereto in the event that such reclamation facility, or proposed reclamation facility, is so designed and/or constructed that any solids or non-treated effluent from any such facility may be discharged into Unit I of the Joint System. Provided, however, such approval shall not be unreasonably withheld. Approval of such use or pro- posed use of a reclamation facility shall not be with- held unless the use of such facility will adversely affect one or more of the non-proposing parties hereto, and the reclaimer cannot reasonably mitigate the adverse impact. Nothing in this Section 32 shall be construed so as to require approval by the parties hereto as to the geographic location of a reclamation facility constructed solely within the boundaries of any party hereto. (b) Because of the uncertainties associated with the pend- ing 301H Waiver and possible benefits of water recla- mation, a good faith review will be held by the parties hereto within three (3) years in order to consider equitable adjustments to reclamation entitlement as set forth above herein. (c) In the event that any party hereto constructs, or pro- poses to construct, a reclamation facility that may utilize Unit J of the Joint System for discharge of reclaimed water, such party, prior to the construction of such facility, shall first submit the plans therefor to all parties hereto for review. Should any party reasonably believe that such facility may adversely affect the operation of Unit J or the exercise of their ownership rights, such party(s) shall request a tech- nical review by the General Manager of EWPCF, who shall submit his findings to the Joint Advisory Committee (JAC). Should, in the opinion of JAC, there be an adverse, or potential adverse, impact upon Unit J or any party's ownership rights, the reclaimer will not unreasonably refuse to implement mitigating conditions as recommended by JAC." 2. Section 17.3(b) of the Basic Agreement is hereby amended to read as follows: "(1) All administration, maintenance, and operation expenses (including overhead) of and for Unit I of the Joint System here after sometimes referred to as M & 0 expen- ses, shall be paid by each party based on each party's percentage of ownership and usage of Unit I. For the purposes of this Section 17.3(b)(l), the following definitions shall apply: "usage" shall mean the costs for power, chemicals, maintenance, and other sewage treatment, solids handling and disposal process which results from sewage entering Unit I; "ownership" shall mean the costs for insurance, administration expenses, laboratory expenses, plant operations, services, and maintenance, and other sewage collection and treatment, solids handling and effluent disposal costs which are incurred irrespective of the amount of sewage which enters Unit I. (2) Except for Units I, B, and C of the Joint System, which Units are otherwise provided for in this Basic Agree- ment), all administration, maintenance, and operation expense of the Joint System shall be paid by each party in an amount equal to that portion of the total M & 0 expenses of said system, which the actual amount of sewage received that fiscal year from such party (plus its share of inflow from leakage as provided in Section 18) bears to the total actual quantity of sewage handled and treated that fiscal year by the Joint System. This amount for all units of the Joint System (except Units I, B, and C) shall be determined in accordance with recognized accounting principles. (3) Each party hereto shall pay its proportional share of the administration, operation, and maintenance expenses provided for in Sections 17.3(b)(l) and 17.3(b)(2) above pursuant to and in accordance with the Revenue and Financial Plan as incorporated in the annual budget for the Joint System as adopted by all members of the Encina Joint Powers." 3. Section 17.3(c) of the Basic Agreement is hereby amended to read as follows: -5- "Not later than May 1st in any year, the Administrator shall estimate the amount of money required to maintain and oper- ate the Joint System during the ensuing fiscal year, and the proportionate amount to be paid by each party to this Basic Agreement. Such estimate shall be based on the total main- tenance and operation costs (M & 0 expenses) during the current fiscal year as such costs are set forth in the cur- rent Revenue and Financial Plan incorporated in the current approved budget for the Encina Joint Sewer System; and each party shall pay that portion of said total M & 0 expenses as determined pursuant to and in accordance with Sections 17.3(b)(l) and 17.3(b)(2) of this Basic Agreement. It shall be the duty of each party to include the sum for M & 0 ex- penses in its budget or program of expenditures, but in any event to make payments promptly at the time they become due." 4. As expressly modified by this Supplement, the Basic Agreement as heretofore supplemented and modified in writing shall remain in full force and effect until further modified or supplemented in writing signed by all the parties hereto. 5. This Twenty-Seventh Supplement may be executed in counterparts and upon execution thereof by all parties set forth on Page 1 hereof, each such counterpart shall be deemed to con- stitute the original of this Agreement. 6. This Twenty-Seventh Supplement shall become effective on the last date that a party hereto adopts a resolution author- izing execution hereof. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, each party hereto has caused this Agree- ment to be signed by its respective officials heretofore duly authorized by the legislative bodies thereof. Approved by Resolution No. on , 1984. CITY OF VISTA, Mayor -6- Approved by Resolution No. on , 1984. CITY OF CARLSBAD, By Mayor Approved by Resolution No. on , 1984. Approved by Resolution No. on , 1984. Approved by Resolution No. on , 1984. LEUCADIA COUNTY WATER DISTRICT By SAN MARCOS COUNTY WATER DISTRICT, By BUENA SANITATION DISTRICT, By Approved by Resolution No. on , 1984. ENCINITAS SANITARY DISTRICT, By -7-