Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1985-11-19; City Council; 8409; PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN AND ZONE CHANGE TO EXPAND AN EXISTING COMMERCIAL SITE GPA|LU 85-3 | ZC-326 COUNTRY STORE | APPEALr I PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN AND ZONE CHANGE TITLEm TO EXPAND AN EXISTING COMMERCIAL SITE. AB# pVQ? MTG. 11-19-85 GPA/LU 85-3/ZC-326 (COUNTRY STORE) rl rd *rl u g DEPT. PLN (APPEAL) DEPT.~ CITY A' CITY M .rl a a cd 5 vi 4 3 I; Lno mM cna 4i? n ow do Mm au PC Ea a& c)3 auc La 4 .: wu OK! 30 cd .d G ck!+ vi a (d OM6 a QM a aa E E ';1 52 2 u oum uam ha -0 TI c) aa 0 3@J dm *rl (d M &I 3 .s g ha 3j-p c)ah crd mMb0 (doa N4 m ad u hO u u .rl (d -4 c, E u -rl a aac AS 0 WH c) mm moo I1 cno 44 I1 rlw 44 .. 2 0 E 4 $ z 3 0 0 I 29 I/; ,/ 3 CI~OF CARLSBAD - AGEN~BILL / RECOMMENDED ACTION: Both the Planning Commission and staff are recommending that tk City Council DENY the applicant's appeal and direct the City Attorney's Office to prepare documents DENYING GPA/LU 85-3 and ZC-326. ITEM EXPLANATION The applicant is requesting a General Plan Amendment and Zone Change to expand the existing Country Store commercial site by additional 2 acres. The Country Store is located on the west I of El Camino Real approximately 500 feet south of Kelly Drive i contains an existing small commercial center. The 2 acres in question are located adjacent to the existing commercial propel on the north side and are currently shown as RLM (0-4) on the General Plan. The major issues regarding this application include compliance General Plan criteria for commercial, intersection spacing, an< question of whether this is the best location to establish the ultimate commercial center for this area. The site does not mc General Plan criteria for neighborhood commercial in that it i: located at the intersection of arterial streets. The applicanl suggested the possibility of adding an arterial street at the southern end of the property. Even if such a street could be implemented the site is too narrow to accommodate a proper commercial development. The site would not meet existing city spacing policy on El Camino Real. Kelly Drive exists 500 feet the north and the entrance to a mobile home park is located seT hundred feet to the south. Finally, neither the Planning Commission or the staff felt thii the proper commercial location to ultimately serve the surrounc area. The General Plan states that commercial sites should no' located within one mile of each other. Staff feels that there sites nearby which have few or no problems associated with the1 could ultimately serve the community much better. An example 1 be the southeast corner of Tamarack and El Camino Real. Both Planning Cornmission and staff felt that the establishment of a commercial site in this area should be done right and the prop site has too many problems associated with it. However, it wa! felt that the existing complex should be permitted to operate the present manner as long as the owner wished. The Planning Commission denied both the General Plan Amendment the Zone Change at their meeting of October 9, 1985. For furtl information please see the attached staff report to the Plannii Commission. e a I Page 2 of Agenda Bill No. gyo 7 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT Because of possible traffic and access problems a negative declaration was not issued by the Land Use Planning Manager. FISCAL IMPACT If approved, increased need for city capital facilities result: from this development will be offset by the payment of the pub: facilities fee. Any capital facilities related directly to th: development will be constructed and paid for by the developer. Increased operating expenses related to this development will 1 offset to some extent from increased tax or fee revenue general by the development. No detailed economic impact analysis of tl: development has been conducted at this time so predictions of i portion of operating expenses covered by additional operating revenue created as a result of this project cannot be made. EXHIBITS 1. Location Map 2. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2497 (GPA/LU 85-3) 3. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2498 (ZC-326) 4. Planning Commission Staff Report dated October 9, 1985 w/attachments L 0 R-A-RESIDENTIAL AGRICULTURE 0 R-1-SINGLE FAMILY 0 C-2-COMMERCIAL 0 C0.-COUNTY 0 RM-RESIDENTIALM MEDIUM 4.1 (7 RLM-RESIDENTIAL LOW-MED 1.5 II 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 e e PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2497 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, DENYING AN AMENDMENT TO THE LAND USE ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL PLAN FROM RESIDENTIAL LOW MEDIUM (RLM) TO NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL (N) ON PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE COUNTRY STORE, AT 4901 EL CAMINO REAL APPLICANT: THE COUNTRY STORE CASE NO.: GPA/LU 85-3 WHEREAS, a verified application for an amendment to 1 General Plan designation for certain property located, as shoj Exhibit "A", dated October 9, 1985, attached and incorporated herein, has been filed with the Planning Commission; and WHEREAS, said verified application constitutes a reqi for amendment as provided in Title 21 of the Carlsbad Municipe Code; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission did, on the 9th day October, 1985, hold a duly noticed public hearing as prescribe law to consider said request; WHEREAS, at said public hearing, upon hearing and considering all testimony and arguments, if any, of all persor desiring to be heard, said Commission considered all factors relating to the General Plan Amendment. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad, as follows: A) That the above recitations are true and correct. R) That based on the evidence presented at the public hearin Commission DENIES GPA/LU 85-3, based on the following findings: //// //// 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 e W F ind ing s : 1) The proposed amendment does not meet the criteria descrii the Land Use Element of the General Plan for locating neighborhood commercial development at the intersections primary and secondary streets and for reasons stated in . staff report. 2) The proposed amendment would increase a strip commercial along a primary arterial roadway (El Camino Real) which contrary to policies in the Land Use Element of the Gene. Plan. 3) The intensification of land use from residential to commc would greatly increase traffic generated onto El Camino at a location where access driveways currently do not me( intersection spacing policies as discussed in the staff report. 4) Development of the property with commercial uses would b( inconsistent with the intent of the El Camino Real Corril standards for Area 2 for reasons stated in the staff rep1 PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad, California, held 9th day of October, 1985, by the following vote, to wit: AYES : Chairman Schlehuber, Commissioners: L'Heur Marcus, McFadden, Smith, Holmes and Hall. NOES: None. ABSENT: None . ABSTAIN : None. CLARENCE SCHLEHUBER, Chairma CARLSBAD PLANNING COMMISSION ATTEST: \ 25 26 27 28 LAND USE PLANNING MANAGER PC RES0 NO. 2497 -2- 1 c LOCATION MAP EXHIBIT 1 1019-85 PROPOSE ZC: R-A- 10 ti GPA: RLM to 1. ZC-32t THE COUNTRY STORE GPA-LU E 0 R-A-RESIDENTIAL AGRICULTURE 0 R-1-SINGLE FAMILY 0 C-2-COMMERCIAL 0 C0.-COUNTY 0 RM-RESIDENTIALM MEDIUM 4.14 0 RLM-RESIDENTIAL LOW-MED 1.5- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 e e PLANNING COMMISFIOF RESOLUTION NO. 2498 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, DENYING A ZONE CHANGE FROM R-A-10 TO C-2 ON PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE COUNTRY STORE, AT 4901 EL CAMINO RIEAL, APPLICANT: THE COUNTRY STORE CASE NO: ZC-326 --- - WHEREAS, a verified application for certain property Portion of Lot "I", Rancho Agua Hedionda, Parcel 1, the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to parcel map thereof No. 3451., wit: has been filed with the City of Carlsbad, and referred to the Planning Commission; and WHEREAS, said application constitutes a request as providGd by Title 21 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission did on the 9th day October, 1985, hold a duly noticed public hearing as prescrib law to consider said request; and WHEREAS, at said public hearing, upon hearing and considering all testimony and arguments, if any, of all perso desiring to be heard, said Commission considered all factors relating to the Zone Change; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Plannin Commission as follows: A) That the above recitations are true and correct. B) That based on the evidence presented at the public hearin Commission DENIES ZC-326, based on the following findings and subject to the following conditions: Findings: 1) The proposed zone change is not consistent with the RLM residential land use established for the site by the Gene Plan. 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 19 @ 2) The street system serving the project is not adequate to handle the increased traffic that would be generated by a change in zone. 3) The C-2 zone would intensify a strip commercial situation which is contrary to policies in the Land Use Element of General Plan. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad, California, held the 9th day of October, 1985, by the following vote, to wit: Marcus, McFadden, Smith, Holmes and Hall . AYES : Chairman Schlehuber, Commissioners: L'Heur NOES : None . ABSENT: None. ABSTAIN: None. CLARENCE SCHLEHUBER, Chairmal CARLSBAD PLANNING COMMISSION ATTEST: MICHAEL J. HOMMILLEW LAND USE PLANNING MANAGER PC RES0 NO. 2498 -2- II @ (3 STAFF REPORT DATE : OCTOBER 9, 1985 TO: PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: LAND USE PLANNING OFFICE SUBJECT: GPA/LU 85-3/ZC-326 - THE COUNTRY STORE - Request for a General Plan Amendment from a Residential Low Medium (RLM) land use designation to Neighborhood Commercial (N) and a Zone Change from R-A-10 to C-2 on property Country Store . I. RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that the Planning Conmission ADOPT Resolution No. 2497 and No. 2498 DENYING GPA/LU 85-3/ZC-326,based on the findings contained therein. 11. PROJECT DESCRIPTION The applicant is requesting a General Plan amendment and zone change for 3.67 acres of land located adjacent to the existing Country Store commercial establishment on El Camino Real, approximately 500 feet southeast of Kelly Drive. The applicant wants to expand the comrriercial use; to do so reauires changing the residential land use designations and zoning to commercial. Preliminary plans indicate that approximately 27,000 square feet of retail/office uses are proposed at a later planning stage. Land uses surrounding the subject property include undeveloped land and single family homes to the north and south, a SDG&E easement and Kelly Drive to the north and northeast, and the existing Country Store to the southeast. The property fronts on El Camino Real. General Plan land use designations to the north south and east are residential RLM (1 .O-4.0 du/ac) which is zonec R-A-10, and to the west, the existing store is N(Neighborhood Commercial) with C-2 zoning. Access to the property is via an existing driveway off El Camino Real, approximately one-third mile from the Tamarack Avenue intersection. About 500 feet to the west is a second driveway for the Country Store and adjoining nursery. located at 4901 El Camino Real, on the west side of the m 0 111. ANALY S I S Planning Issues 1) Does the proposed commercial designation meet the standards for commercial development as delineated in the Land Use Element of the General Plan? 2) Is the proposed General Plan amendment and zone change consistent with the El Camino Real Corridor Study? 3) Is the street system serving the project adequate to handle any increase in traffic generated by the zone change and General Plan amendment? 4) Would a commercial land use designation and zone be compatible with surrounding land uses? DISCUSSION General Plan The proposed commercial designation and zone do not comply with criteria established in the Land Use Element of the General Plan which state that neighborhood commercial development should be located at intersections of primary and secondary streets. The proposed project would not be located at arterial intersections; instead, it would add to an existing strip commercial area on El Camino Real which is comprised of the Country Store. The Countr! Store is a landmark from Carlsbad's rural past. It has been there many years and its charm was acknowledged when just the existing store was designated (and, therefore, preserved) as neighborhood commercial when the General Plan was first written in 1974. The area is no longer rural and development is now encroaching into this area. Because of new residents in Calaver( Hills and surrounding areas, it will soon be necessary to establish the ultimate site for commercial use in this area. Staff feels that the southeast corner of El Camino Real and Tamarack Avenue is the most appropriate location for commercial use in this area as it meets the General Plan criteria and has enough street frontage to meet the City's intersection spacing requirements whereas the applicant's proposal would not. That site would also be topographically isolated from adjacent residential uses. This should not preclude the continual use of the Country Store as a commercial site as long as the owner wishes. Staff feels that the applicant's proposal is encouraging strip commercial development along El Camino Real. The General Plan has policies discouraging strip commercial on arterial streets. The Council has also given staff continual direction with regard to discouraging strip commercial. The Citizens Committee reviewing the Land Use Element also wished to discourage any new strip commercial areas from forming. Staff feels that strip commercial diminishes the viability of arterial streets to complete their purpose of moving traffic safely and efficiently. -2- m 0 The General Plan also indicates that neighborhood type commercia. centers should be at least a mile apart. As mentioned, the appropriate site is at El Camino Real and Tamarack Avenue. Sincc there should only be one ultimate commercial center in this area it is important to select a safe and efficient site which has thc proper attributes. Expanding a substandard site will only creatc additional problems in the future. The ultimate commercial center for the area should be designed with safety in mind and with adequate size to accommodate the future needs of this area. El Camino Real Corridor Study The El Camino Real Corridor Study includes the subject property in Area 2 which is from Chestnut Avenue to the Country Store. Because Area 2 is predominated by residential uses, the corridor study anticipated that the trend would continue. The standards contained in Area 2 are intended to preserve the established residential character along this portion of the corridor, Circulation/Access The primary issue related to the adequacy of the street system i access. Access to the proposed expansion violates the 2,600 fee (half mile) intersection spacing policy along El Camino Real. The existing driveway is situated approximately 1,700 feet (one- third) mile from Tamarack Avenue and about 600 feet from Kelly Drive. In addition, the entrance to the mobile home park is located just to the south on El Camino Real, In other words, there is no way that this property can meet spacing policy, creating a sub-standard situation. In addition, the site is located near a curve in El Camino Real making the site even less desirable from a circulation standpoint. In terms of trips generated by a change in zone and land use designation, commercial use would generate more than 20 times as much traffic as would residential development and would create more conflicts. Based upon the San Diego Association of Governments Vehicular Traffic Generation Rates, a neighborhood commercial center, less than 10 acres in size, would generate approximately 1200 trips/acre, or 120 trips/1,000 square feet, compared to a residential subdivision which would generate up to 10 trips per dwelling unit. Thus, a proposed commercial project, indicated on the application as 27,000 square feet, on this 3.67 acre site could generate up to 3200 average daily trir (ADT). A residential development at RLM (1.0-4.0 du/ac) would generate between 40 and 150 ADT. -3- w 0 Land Use comgatibility Land use compatibility with the surrounding area is of less concern than the issues previously discussed. The parcel actually has several natural buffers, i.e. El Camino Real to the north, a steep slope to the south, and the SDG&E easement to the west. However, it still is possible that the intensification of commercial development and subsequent trip generation could create potential traffic, noise and nuisance impacts on the adjacent existing single family and future residential subdivisions to the west and south. In conclusion, staff believes the proposed General Plan amendment and zone change do not meet the standards or intent of the General Plan or the El Camino Real Corridor Study; in addition, circulation and access would be significantly impacted by the intensification of cornmerial use on the property. Therefore, staff recommends denial of GPA/LU 85-3/ZC-326. IV. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW The Land Use Planning Manager has determined that this project could have significant effects on the environment. A Negative Declaration has not been issued. ATTACHMENTS 1. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2497 and No. 2498 2. Location Map 3. Background Data Sheet 4. Disclosure Form NER: ad 9/17/85 - -4- @ 0 EWJXGF?OUND DATA SHEET CASE NO: BA/LU 85-3/ZC-326 APPLICANT: The Country Store REQUEST AND LOCATION: General Plan amendment & zone change frm residential to commercial use on property located next to the Country Store at 4901 El Camino Real LEGAL DESCRIPTICIN: Portion of Lqt "I", Rancho Agua Hedionda, Parcel 1, in the City of Carlsbad, County of SD, State of CA, according to parcel map thereof No. 3451 APN: 207-101-16 Acres 3.67 proposed No. of Lotshnits N/A GENERAL PLAN AND ZONING Land Use Designation RLM Density Allowed 1.0-4.0 Density Proposed N/A Existing Zone R-A- 1 0 Proposed Zone c-2 Surrounding Zoning and Land Use: Zoning Land Use Site R-A-10 vacant North A-1-8 (County) roadway/vacant South R-A-10 residential East C-2 residential West R-1-10 commercial - PUBLIC FACILITIES School District Carlsbad Water Carlsbad Sewer Carlsbad mu's N/A Public Facilities Fee Agreement, dated November 8, 1985 I3NI-A.L IMPACT ASSESSMENT - Negative Declaration, issued E.I.R. Certified, dated - Other , Negative Declaration not issued - ~- 0 C..IIC ----.- ------------ ,+- ' i. g AepLIcANT: Mr. & Mrs. Jay Hoffman 4901 El Nwe (individual, partnership, joint Venture, corpration, syndic Camino Real - Carlsbad, CA 92008 Business Address 729-2042 Telephone Numbu AGENT : Ramberg & Associates NatB P.O. Box 1876 - Rancho Santa Fe, CA 92067 -. 756-1 148 Business Address .. Telephone Number MEEBES: ~amc ,(individual, partner, joint. venture, corporation, syndication) Home Bddress Biisiness Address Telephone Nmbr Telephone Xumber 539 Home Address 3isiness =dress Tzie2hor.s Nrsrber Telepirone Xuxrrber - (Attach more sheets if necessary) I/We dsclze uzder Senalty of perjury that the infomation contained in this t closure is tns and correct and that it will remain true and correct and may : relied upon as being true and correct until znended, BY VJ 0 7- /+J$S- "- -7 rF - 1200 ELM AVENUE TELEP CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA 92008 (714) 4: -0 %. * Office of the C~ty Clerk Citp of Carls'bab APPEAL FORM b I (We) appeal the following decision of the .dm 18, #C 'I (---n,, T 7, %* a *-, I &&+/LQgJ - - 3 /SI c2 - 3 2. L ( kc- c c&v/.. $2+ -S+d =u* Date of decision: /&?/F,L FA <Z JAia re/ +7- s-+$/cy -- FAC173 M L9 ' e&;) 5, d=vz e_'L -3 r to the City Council: Project name E&$ number (or subject of appeal):, I Reason for appeal: '. fP5 ,;o* 4 J - -, F?AJ-- leph-die Number CITY OF CARLSBAD 1200 ELM AVENUE CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA 92008 438-5621 ACCOUNT NO. DESC RI PT IO N RECEIPT NO. hd &/d /cJ34w--- D.i&.* P3?----+ O+.' "ti Jay F. Hoffman ?? m- """I- Marja Acres 4901 El Camino Real Carlsbad, CA 92008 October 29, 1985 City Clerk Carlsbad City Council City of Carlsbad 92008 It is requested that the date of our appeal of the Planning Commission decision on GPA/LU 85-3/ZC-326--The Country Store, be postponed from the presently assigned date of November 19, 1985 to December 10, 1985, Because of a prior commitment on that date, it will not be possible for us to present our appeal. Thank you for your consideration, Respectfully submitted, r ..._... -- *'--*7 /&-<- fF/,- /' 1 q Jay F. Hof an 8 0 Carlsbad Journal Decreed a Legal Newspaper by the Superior Court of Son Diego County 31 38 ROOSEVELT ST. P.O. BOX 248 0 CARLSBAD, CA 92008 729-2345 Proof of Pub I ica t ion STATE OF CALIFORNIA, ss, COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO, I am a citizen of the United States and a resident of the county aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to or interested in the above entitled math I am principal clerk of the printer of the Carlsbad Journal a newspaper of general circulat published twice weekly in the City of Carlsbad, County of Sun Diego, State of California, and wl newspaper is published for the dissemination of local news and intelligence of a general character, which newspaper at all times herein mentioned had and still has a bona fide subscription list of pal subscribers, and which newspaper has been established and published at regular intervals in the ! City of Carlsbad, County of Sun Diego, State of California, for a period exceeding one \ - -. next preceding the date of publication of notice hereinafter referred to; and that the nc of which the annexed is a printed COPY, has b published in each regular and entire issue of 1 newspaper and not in any supplement thereo NOTICE OF PUBLIC APPEAL on the west side of the Countw Store and more pafiicularly de- PortionofLot"I"ofRanchoAgua Carlsbad, County of Sari Diego, HEARING scribed as: GPAILU 85-3lZC-326 Hedionda, Parcel 1. in the city Of NOTICEISHEREBYGIVENthat State of Cali€ornia, according to the following dates, to-wit: the City Council of the City Of CarlS- bad will hold a public hearing at the City Council Chambers, 1200 Elm Avenue, Carlsbad, California, at 600 T.M ,on Tuesday, November 19,1985, to consider an appeal ofa Planning Commission denial of a General Plan Amendment from a Residential Low Medium (RLM) land use designation to Neighbor- hood Commerciai (N) and a zone change from R-A-10 to C-2. on prop- &rtylocatedat4901 ElCaminoReal, parcel map thereof No. 3451. Ifyou challenge the General Plan Amendment or Zone Change in c~~rt, YOU may be limited to raising ohiy those issues you or someone &e raised at the public hearing described in this notice. or in writ- ten correspondence delivered to the City of Carlsbad at or prior to the public hearing Appellant: Jay Hoffman November 9 19 ................................. ................................. 19 CARLSBAD CITY COUNCIL ? LOCATION MAP ................................. 19 ................................. 19 ................................. 19 I certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing i! - 6202- - THE COUNTRY STORE GPA-LU 85-3 I CT 4668 November 9,1985 DATE 10-28 Mr. Hoffman was told that his item will be scheduled for 11/19/85. He indicates that is not a good date for him and wants to know if the matter can be continued for two weeks. I realize that GPA's can only be set for certain meetings at specified times during the year, and would like your opinion. If one GPA is continued, do the others have to be continued? Would his item have to be continued to the next GPA hearing date (next year)? Before I respond to Mr. Hoffman, I'd appreciate your help. L SF M-4- FoQo[tT UmG-IWf jj[5 VABV a wx?- Wf WILL- IjOw m&(dn/ '4 ,+p ff * yL ~ 1 i. $ C‘ . Q ‘Co>i/,~ F& A-+: v 4’ 1200 ELM AVENUE - TELEPHoI Office of the City Clerk CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA 92008 (714) 438-5 - Citp o€ Carlsbab APPEAL FORM 0 o the City Council: . .. ,. Date of decision: d &/,?d-i- - $YTICEL OF PUBLIC HE7llU"G NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad will hold a public hearing at the City Council Chanhers, 1200 Elm Avenue, Carlsbad, California, at 6:OO p.m. on Wednesday, October 9, 1985, to consider approval for a General Plan anendment frcxn a Residential I;ow Medium (RLM) lad use designation to Neighborhood Commercial (N) and a zone &ange frat R-A-10 to C- 2 on property located at 4901 El Camino Real, on the west side of the Country Store and mre particularly described as: Portion of Lot "I", Rancho Agua Hedionda, Parcel 1, in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, according to parcel map thereof No. 3451. Those persons wishing to speak on this propsal are cordially invited to atterd the public hearing. Office at 438-5591. If you challenge the General Plan Amendment or Zone Change in murt, you may ;be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence deliver& to the City of Carlsbad at or prior to the public hearing. If you have any questions please call the Land Use Planning CASE FILE: GPA/LU 85-3/ZC-326 APPLICANT: THE CKXTNTRymN PUBLISH: September 28, 1985 CITY OF CARTSBAD PLANNING U3MISSICN 7 __ A&, L,UI ..I -a- LY&LI ..--.UI.Y.U. 4846 Kelly Drive 4goi*~;1 Cainino Real @ Carlsbad, CA 92008 0 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Wlsbad, CA 92008 4811 Kelly Drive LIjay .ana LWL~ULI nuLitiiw 207-101 -16 207-230-18 207-230-07 13)William & Dorismae Wiedemann 24) Theresa Benjamin 4809 Kelly Drive 4842 Kelly Drive 2) Jay and Maryon Hoffman 4901 El Camho Real Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-230-19 207-230-08 I 207-101-19 1 I :3) L R Partnership LTD. t C/O Kamar Construction 4846 Kelly Drive 4807 Kelly Drive j Post Office Box 1155 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 14) Dean and Natalie Meyers 25) Michael Clarke 207-230-22 207-230-09 CArlsbad, CA 92008 4) Virgina K. Robertson ' 207-101-09 15) Edward and Kathryn Flores 26) Jerry And Sue Hens( 4656 El Chino Real 4850 Kelly Drive 4858 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-230-23 207-230-25 ! 208-010-32 [5) *bert and wlla Butts 1 i 16) Otto and Frances Robertson 7924 Wb Avenue Apt 46 27) ThmS ober 4810 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Panorama City, CA 91004 Vista, CA 92083 1020 Maryland Drivc 207-230-19 207-230-24 207-230-26 6)Ross J and Mabel L Barber 17) Jack and Doris Varice ' . 28) Joseph Mazurkiewic 5892 El Camin0 Real 4835 Kelly Drive 4866 Kelly Drive brlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-230-12 207-230-01 207-230-27 i I 7 17) Charles and Joyce Stiffler i 4820 GUY Drive 18) Dorothy M Thompson 29) Edward And Kathy L 4831 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 4868 Kelly Drive 207-230-13 207-230-02 207-230-28 8) Joseph and Halyna Holy 19) William and Soyk Witt 4824 Kelly Drive 4827 Kelly Drive 941 Shorepoint Cou Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Alameda, CA 94501 30) Peter Anderson 207-230-14 207-230-03 207-230-23 9) Eric C Wiseman 20) Otto and Marie Haunold 4826 Kelly Drive 4823 Kelly Drive 4839 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 31) Michael and Kathy 207-230-15 207-230-04 207-230-30 10) Charles and Mildred Beyer 21) Edson and Junko Card 4830 Kelly Drive 4819 Kelly Drive 4843 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 32) Edmund & Margaret 207-230-16 207-230-05 207-230-31 22) Peggy IXlPont 33) William & Patricia 4857 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 4815 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 11) John and Margaret Murphy 4836 Kelly Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-230-06 237-230-17 207-230-32 ---- -1- iULILLLCL L.L.Li a llzawm we q-l) CLLlCaL U LU5WLF-LAU LhL 4946 Park Drive 4934 Park Drive 34.) @&‘keY?y Lve 0 Carlsbad, CA 92008 *--’ Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, eA 92008 207-331-05 207-290-1‘4 ‘ ‘207-230-33 35) Edgar and Frances Billups 46) James and Merceda Arnold 57) Richard and Christine 4865 Kelly Drive 4948 Park Drive 4936 Park Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-230-34 207-331-06 207-290-15 36) Robert and Judith Eisele 47) Sharad and Vimal Bankar 4.869 Kelly Drive 14396 Janal Qay 4961 Cindy Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 San Diego, Ca 92129 Carlsbad, CA 92008 58) Arthur and Doris Anc 207-370-12 207-230-35 207-331-07 37) Carl and Lois Galloway 4871 Kelly Drive 4952 Park Drive 4959 Cindy Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 48) James and Donna Robinson 59) william Sr Virginia E Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-230-36 207-331-08 207-370-13 38) Charles and Maurine Prall 49) Karl and Kathreen Smith 60) Walter and Grace Er 913 Orchid Way 4954 Park Drive 4957 Cindy Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-370-14 207-230-27 207-331-09 39) William and Gloria Smith 50) Jung Downing 61) Roland & Eosemary B 4803 Kelly Drive 911 Vista Way 4955 Cindy Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 Oceanside, CA 92054 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-230-43 207-331-10 207-370-15 40) Donald and Elizabeth Main 51) George and Toni Krepps ’ 62) J.B.and Ruth be: 4805 Kelly Drive 4958 Park Drive 1453 Camino De Vel; Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 San Marcos, CA 920f 207-230-44 207-370-16 63) Donald & Doris RO~ 4938 Park Drive 4960 Park Drive 2284 Julie Place Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-331-11 ---rr 41) Leo and Susan Fradelis 52) Robert and Elain Sti1h-B.n 207-331-12 207-370-17 207-331-01 42) Charles and Kathleen Ables 53) john and Shirley %nes 64) Richard and Helen 4940 Park Drive 4962 Park Drive 2283 Julie Place Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 207-332-01 207-370-18 207-331-02 43) Thcmas and Sheryl Chase 54) Augustine & Joanna Pave1 65) Edgar and Agnes SI 4942 Park Drive 4930 Park Drive 2281 Julie Place Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92001 207-290-12 207-370-19 207-333-03 E Camino Estates 4944 Park Drive 4932 Park Drive 3345 Don Diablo P Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 92008 Carlsbad, CA 920C U+) Robert Duff 55) Donald and Barbara Glatz 66) c j 0 A Anderson 207-370-21 .I 2 0 7-33D-04 207-290-13 m e u 43. -We- support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. .= ‘. . La,-& J+LSA <’<>+,\* r\ Gwq Q-;v& v v (7 - I’\ (. \&.,!JL&Xh2!, f- \ I-\\\ -Lxb.Jw\,YLes 1 , J -’ c _- 1 PAL;? L-, G ,a,-- - G<y&-&k , s,<> *A=-&- \\ L %Xu.&.&- -?x%. %?,? u i. .L9%ss- * 1 1 L ’1 ?\ G - 0 m 1 We support the Zone change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. 6% Ba/\n-3+= 6aQc /LL 3463 4db 9- I U We support the Zone Change to allow for the expans Pdu !< /q4+ 2#p / We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion ?f tfie country Store. ! *,it a + 0 ne change to- e expansion We - -- of the Co ntry Store- 22 F '3 ;, I (' \I t', LA - * ( Uq~,>~'- AALL & a 2 q: 7 CC,L iLLcbLL(u' /- / ( i J L.L*b-L .( (. d, 72L(;/ I We support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the. Country Store. We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Country Stors. \ - e I a\% 7 B\f@ La5 Pph&f$ csP . a 0 . We support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. I We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. #LE&- P'm? ~CW?d- #/ /JET &u=d/?@ & Y7/0 &&Ge-L.hd /EJaof We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion of t Omtry Store, we sty.Ongly oppose the construction of a Shopping center at %.@i%ck and EI Camin0 Real. /qc .P - . k$fi--7&&///<, 7 ,/' /4-. z- ALG/<-YLZ> 4.205 Trieste Drive carlsbad, CA 92008 ~ w I b We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Country Store. \ 7. \d- ,/' '..-.&+A4 3 -, J///&< / -1 ,-/'G Tc I L F - /p ' C/L, /!; /'L / We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion of the C % &? $67 fiLeL?ooQ L&@T /sP J& ykr- 3A?J-/? A,/ fyac. / /+&?&/&e- uax - I b3 We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. +4 Jl 7Ld4 + --+Aw% L <;.#/ 8,>1/4// 3 Y/'* ,&< A* 17 u ,&! /, 0 ,/ #! !; flfl - - w We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the CountryStore. > <-- e &rv- y I/ 4&ek?45e)AmOD Cr cg&..; B&&2 G9 9AOOP We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. - .I -- ./ 1 c - .-gi /A,,/ I' . /' 1 -. -_ -7/ --L">:/-&L, ,/? , L;, J ,-/ 1 ,I"-'- - , /- Ne support the Zone change to allow the expansion of the Country Store, L n, /yod y- 7;7&/ &kGJc2 &ab&.LC& 2.i/'3'c 4 ef4 ,/&& kg-&, - ,a -'.&*--< , &, V&%&OX &f&&#-L 6 p5d4i? m m 'we support the Zone change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. -. a, yr p - -?u 5-A &\-- LOLL' ./& * r 2 4J/ (> f-d;cy mk" ,. I #s .J<&E(u75- A l,/5 rfiRLs&f+a p13L'ZILfbE-J We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. L R$LtM5L Tr G&%&J @ HRi-C PTE s: G&?L 14s Lp7J-C j3AWRu.:$ GLL)(17- P ns c\ gQJ ., b Q*d j, I" i \icrr 1 v -.- e&w-s w-bJ M- -9 hL- r 3w-33 3f 6. We support the Zone Change to permit expansion of the Country Store. 'f /& /MAC K,2,5?&7,= / 9LP /-/A lF /- v /7) , 0 :', 4% /AC-L'3? / w W We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Country Store. 'e. .+ --_ -_ - We support the Zone change to allow the expansiol? of the Country Store. -_ We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Count~y Store. T~\ ( . * 4 w/ -\ ,:I ,i ' ~'i 'L c 0 -rl m 5 2 a a, s -c, B a 0 Q a, zn ?-c 5 . .- 0 th rr- r 0 n 0 c 3 rt Y Y m rt 0 Y 0 0 e b We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Country Store. UE/h C&&A.4?d e&# 7Z-c We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of $he Country Store, /f4 w- 7k&4/ 2->7jj- LI,, s;l >& / We support the Zone change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. -.- /,.< - /i f$@&7>,' LC BL w We support the Zone Change to - * & &+-h RYEA 1 / ' the Country Store expansion. +-,vob / --p 7 \x, \%I b'i 8- -8,- --r L.l$'pA .4 -. k &\;Q r-\ 4 --n s s i q k <I I\ + a' \:. '? Q+:\-\LA$J t* q4 \C t-3 ,?A/ A // - /L> c- -= Z&-- '7 +? /r >Jd&>& fl .=77?/&L. //-f-7--pJ- 57 ,>&J-A-/ rn We support the Zone Change to permit expansion of t v w -)We support the Zone Change to allow . A”i expansion of the Country Store. \.+ c We support the Zone change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. - b&&&d(y,-q. u /” pd I90 /&,& ’ We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. t 44&+&/ /@ P4z--f,f 9Jmf . m I z?& c L*L&% We support the Zone Change to allow the proposed Country Store expansion. fiepL.& l/r' 9;b,l+u* &*.;;-. s (--&u-y CG h q kt& ?&& k) \ .. We support the Zone Change to permit the proposed Country Store expansion. *q /e!' (h/d 7 Ade &d 5bzd- 1 &if ?'&eog D I 42 - %"/VT f 'axoqs AxqUno3 ayq 30 uorsu~d= q-pnad oq aEju1ey3 aUOZ ay7 WOddnS aM w w I We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store= MVRfk45 IjcmS&ELcY fi Y ' PE.;SORJJ &%j.h*- /rT- /c E.&- 3";! UR( d ~~ We support the Zone Change to Pernit expansion of the CO - We suPPort the Zone Change to permit expansion of the Country Store, L?c,4ddr // J ,, \\P Ad& 1 i t2x&uub 6 7&&.7>+ Y82y .-mqJy,p* ?A4Ldd*L &- yyc&;,y -LA /&9.- J w 0 We support the Zone Change to allow the Country Store expansion. J We support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. F&>&/& t L W-%-Q+%> < We support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. - 0% Y4.J &/J3e.7Y- 2% 50-5"7 &dLl #d R,td A5 LLdi4-&/ f?@ 92 .&dd w - We s the‘ Country “Store expansion. rt 9e Zone Change to permit .- L- -A,&%??#/&U ~~aJLLr5 abde &iLrk/a$ f4 ?Z??=T L the Zone Change to permit the OU~E~Y Store expansion. -- / /*- ~ -v dM.?+dd7 1 3. z&dLL // 1 J MR and MAS ROLAND F. BOYDEN 4955 Cindy Avenue Carisbad CA 92008 %a. w-* I b We SuPPort the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. I - &I \ 7y-I cl 9-c. k V - We support the Zone Change to Permit expansion of the Country Store- C- -- We support the Zone Change to permit the proposed Country Store expansion .r’ ,, &&y4 &:A&& ’4 4&%L x., a$$&& y7.tt7 Gwsy @7G; We support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. L ”& 3 & f 4-3- 2-zz).q~ ,. &(--& ;rr<‘LA 1 c. - e\ /jC.gtff /dd’4 d. &&.&L7, e y2?ceF A \. e i We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. M We strongly urge you to support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. 7w.,&. ;Ir rn/k /&.IL/iL.Lp& 1-e -SC5,$ g (3i./m9,*Ld x &ti-( 1. &J& L " c72C.c.y I- 1 W W gYGGz)KF We support the Zone Change to permit @Qansior, of the country Store. /i +887 Lzz ";is& &I? -_ -_- 5,' ci We support the zone Change which would permit exparision of EIG co'mtry Store. iT& '8 ., L.- /i- &Ab r. -1 ~ L &.&LC -_ \ rr I w w We strongly urge you to support the Zone Change to Allow expansion of the Country tore. 5f -iAL +$LW hL3 G$L/LL&& 4 0 &$ - (4 L0 Q* ,,( J o''&B-/ 3 c/c <-- - -_I IL Itu @A@- 9%- ( L/t Ly&~--,.Q (?&- /LW-L/ 4$-- q-J\ 0 0 8 &?Ij L" I/ >lLL-lck4;u A-.L'i We strongly urge you to support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store D - < pg/c k si- /a //i 4 w w We strongly urge YOU to support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. 7 ?I!qLLL/& 1 // 17 1 BI fA35L]d 3 $ We strongly urge you to support the Zone Change I to allow expansion of the Country Store, &&Q-&SW$&& /-'I w w We strongly urge you to support the Zone Change to allow expansion of Country Store w w We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. *''i"/7 d /qfl,"A -3 3- /q gg>(J $!&& &q&&& Q4(& d,q- /-4/ rqL7- 7?7>7 - f /&d2 J&. /t 948 ELZ 92qy /ab/%))- We support the Zone Change to C-2 to permit the expansion of the Country Store. /Q?3G T/ /4 / 9 -' ,,I /5 ?JTC8P<?/-$+ flt? a*& /3 Z?GJ$2$2 ?/$. -72 &OK r P W W We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Country Store. We support the Zone Change to permit expansion of the Country Store. TEL!!fJ 4330 Z,ey J4 -a?, P4lZlsbA 04 ~ @4. 52200 g. W W We strongly urge you to support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. @h & yL-- Tf d.5435- GA&d c /#ec&, &?4k’4&d ’ w, / We support the Zone change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. * < 514 -7 -,LJ!& i! a 111 lJJ& \ &L c7iA Ke(1y bL"- Otkd -tJClLk +@* 't-ks Cs-+% Sj3L-C st.laL((& bJa 9j\CLO!& K 2OkS c-I.\c,uq$& +a p""?"t- Tka "%& 9GCL4, Y --i hd /+.a OP-y I kppoue -4~7t+9-kI.i& he;ij(?barhac& $&,pa LU'Y~.,(& b~ twos* fiWth ibL-e I,_s. qh eygXo~.e had. bcTccY-c&, Daws, c4 E\/ bu,",4Qb*o,b,k, 4SYZ IeI(y Dl" w w We support the Zone change to allow the expan the Country Store. $y&r/,Pl15i ' We support the Zone change to allow the expansion od the Country Store. qwy P\>W%Lp~ We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion o +? .-- .' A, 3, L+dJ, ?+!u&&z 'V&W t.'?L5-CW a*, u @& .%"a Ud 8 1 ~- 0 82 50 *t2 6rt '3 e C $2 Cno wo 0 % Yad s/ e I-J- e rt =z 0 9 e m We support the Zone Change to (2-2 to all expansion of the Country Store- ceQaqC4 'iz We support the Zone Change to C-2 to permit the expansion of the Country Store. . 7aL = ti2w Jt J? Pp&;l: X% 7L' L/ e, ';,;A & ?C&&&J :4, I J n We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion of the @=try Store, _- * L- &U& 7 &?-& #€4*/4&@4.L a. @ m a We support the Zone change to allow the exp of the Country Store, q.., q-' \ LWCL, jsc/Ll ,-- -L%-- ---- - ---- -- --- -- - 'Yf 5 lb 5- b'kL\U &&a (1 ------------ ---------- .-"s ,--- U&*,&U' <>&& -- -- -- - - - -- - -'---_ ---L ) B We support the Zone Change to permit expansion of the Country Store. I Ti c. g;b )c&dLbad 3392 eQ&;Jr7 Rk3-q / -k-* us{ ! flX7, c ,? 9a---&-tp We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion of the Country Store. 7 ,,qbd!l-j 7 a# i ;;:@( & f fldL& Y' i/ , - c_ ; I ,.- ' --Tc ' 'J , JUG 2/$4 / &-h t :;l$f(Jvi h ~$fpbfj&l Lfl fm: I ,- I /' b- - U W 1 We support the Zone Change to allow for expansion of the Country Store, - We support the Zone Change to allow the expansion of th e Country Store. Z’f 7 A7 &-/.--* X-- -&:+-Jc c d~W*9& /f - 4&&gZ/i. p& q2c;i. F / <& ’ &4- / W w -- We.support the Zone Change to C-2 to permit . the expansion of the Country Store. .- ,- F- 5: i /tt L><a 1 i ? ;fM& I If 7 *I I A 1 3, \. il L/CL'\ \ ;, _ti i( . - /-' i 1- ;/ We support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. Hne JAA e.3 50 +# &- 6t %dcQ We support the Zone Change to permit expansion of a $B-$$d4& &Aid< 4- ?W/ W 0 We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion We support the Zone Change to permit expansion of the Country Store. <- +%zs //?/e ?& j NtPLs 34 f J& 7A We support the Zone Change which wnuld permit expansion of the Country Store. 3616 CaJhI~ic, Dt- Gr/Sdad, 02 ciud8 . 0 0 . We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Country Store. j$&g /ILL/& I t J7c 7 &&L&&??d G, 0 /cl. c 2, /ha/y5- (4Ald/up- (2 La &h=&, $JLf& f' -- --~-- We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. 7 -- - ----. 47Lf - [-dl u. &!Ld, c3L 74 BG!? We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. -,.r&f&? - *. zp---cpdTaJ A W w .L We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Countr-tore. -. ,“< I? 1 ?IU& - ’ 3 L‘; ,./ CLj .”3 ?h TCf-”, JLL&QLf s+. 37 &ri.% bod’ {(-!(x j 9&9@ d - __~__ -~ We Support the Zone change to allow the expansio: of the Country St 4 7 ~k 5.;. i jpj2 7F ;r L Of \ i i” fL,J&/(&\ , C[< q zi l?? We support the Zone Change to permit expansion of the Country Store, ’ +/A&Jd 1 ’//” &J&@ +- 1 &&, &d&&& I1 f +Y35- j5&?e &&?e Ca</r5;sd CR ~~OOCY w We support the Zone Change to allow for the expansion of the Country i/' y//pg2:d+ /g$$ grf+&:&/ c-&c./i ( J2L&++/&& /' 1- /+-LLLG74 4 /j@&/&Y&+"~ -P k5L-4 '? 1-I & - We suPPort the Zone Change to permit the =Pansion of the-komtry Store - ~ We support the Zone Change to Permit the expansion of a We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store. cii 1' LY' -x. yh-L&LL, ;??I , 4 5 2 L c-.c,q 5 r6-pf; flq C' 0 (4'v/iG4J 7 (2 sL).cc,c- L& ?jyFJ.9&&, ++* 1,' 4 m 0 Y We support the Zone Change to allow thc expansion of the Cot&ry Store. - /7F Ln--!G <, /4 &a PlJ We SuPPort the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. 2 haw fdu We support the Zone Change to permit the expansion of the Country Store- We support the Zone Change to allow expansion of the Country Store. r.l; LT= & - - &A +.- -A& - WW .&W*fuG/ &M&-d &$&?i?Lf& LM yyy@ /4?#eK &+*