HomeMy WebLinkAbout1987-12-08; City Council; 9234; GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT RLM (0-4 DU'S/AC) TO O (OFFICE) AND LOCAL COASTAL PLAN AMENDMENT GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-2E)CI~OF CARLSBAD - AGEN~BILL c,
'v, u d 3 U 0 TI
a,
aJ a
h a
0 u
2
x a, E
2
0 u
h
*rl
u
V
a, 5
TI
c1 a,
U a, k
a 7-l
ha OOG ma
ri -g ":
Q2 E@J
Vl -d
!-IN aJd
urn
"$ a,
q4 4 00 rd Ma
-d z CQJ
a,U a,& EU
CQJ a,a
uu
u
E41 43 4; a> ab a, ri k 3 *rl a d ua .d d rd u3 d ow
V 0 uo
h
hco 031
cod Iq
l-ld
AA
2 0 F 0 4 s Z 3 0 0
AB#=- DE TITLE: GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT RLM (0-4 DUlS/
MTG, 12 / 8 / 8 7 AC) TO 0 (OFFICE) AND LOCAL COASTAL PLAN
AMENDMENT GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 CI'
DEPT. PLN
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
(LCPA 87-23) - LAUREL TREE CI'
The Planning Commission and staff are recommending that tl
City Council ADOPT the Negative Declaration issued by tl Planning Director and direct the City Attorney's Office 1 prepare documents APPROVING GPA/LU 87-4 and LCPA 87-3.
I ITEM EXPLANATION
The applicant is requesting a General Plan Amendment ar
Local Coastal Plan Amendment on property located just soui of Palomar Airport Road along the east side of futul College Boulevard. The proposal would change the Generz Plan and Local Coastal Plan from RLM (0-4 du's/ac) to (Office use) on approximately 9.2 acres.
Traditionally the separation between the industrial uses j
the floodplain south of Palomar Airport Road and futur
residential uses further south has been the bluffs. Th
bluffs provide a good buffer because they are fairly hig
and, for the most part, form a continuous southern terminu
of the floodplain area. There are several canyons tha
project into the bluffs that still maintain a simila elevation to the industrial valley area. The subjec property is located in one of these canyons and makes gradual transition up the bluff. For this reason it wa felt that a transitional use such as office would he1 buffer residential use from industrial use where no bluff exist.
The site is presently zoned L-C, a holding zone. No zonc
change is being proposed at this time because thc
alignment for future College which has not been set a.
this time will set the precise boundaries for the zoning.
The Planning Commission heard this item on November 12 anc
voted unanimously to recommend approval. For furthe;
information please see the attached report to the Planninc
Commission. I ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
The Planning Director has determined that this project wil: not cause any significant environmental impacts and, therefore has issued a Negative Declaration, dated September 30, 1987, which was approved by the Planning
a 9a3q Q Page 2 of Agenda Bill No.
Commission on November 12, 1987. A copy of tt
environmental documents is on file in the Plannir
Department.
FISCAL IMPACT
The increased need for City capital facilities resultir from this development will be offset by the payment of tl
public facilities fee. Any capital facilities relatc
directly to this development will be constructed and pa:
for by the developer.
Increased operating expenses related to this develolpme~ will be offset to some extent from increased tax or fc
revenue generated by the development. An economic impac
report has not been completed for this project and tl
monetary impact to the City of Carlsbad cannot 1
determined at this time.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT
Approval of this General Plan Amendment would n
establish specific development on site. The project
located in the boundaries of the Zone 5 Local Faciliti
Management Plan and it is anticipated that possib increases in traffic could be handled by Zone 5 streets mitigated.
EXHIBITS
1. Location Map
2. Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 2682 €i 2697
3. Planning Commission Staff Report dated November 4,
1987 w/attachments
"
GENERAL PLAN
RESIDENTIAL RL I.0W DE35ITY (0- I q>
RESIDENTIAL
RLM LOW-hIEDILM DENSITY(O.4)
RVH VEDIL" HIGH DENSITI(B-I5)
P.C PL4N3ED COIIMLTfITY ZONE
R.A RF5lDENTlALM;RICCLTLRAL ZONE RM MEDIt'M DENSITY(4.8) R.E RL'RU RESIDENTL+L EXATE ZONE R. I 0FiE-F.hWLY RESIDENTIAL ZON€ RH HIGH DENSITY( 15.23) R-2 lU'O-F.L\IILY RESIDENTIAL ZONE
COMMERCIAL R.3 .Ml'LTlPLE FAVILY REqIDENTLU ZONE
RRI IhTENSIVE REGIONAL RETAIL (Cg. Plaza ClminO Real) R-3~ UMITED Mun.F.wILr RESIDE.~U ZONE
RRE EXTENSIVE REGIONAL RETAIL (cg CU COUflfrY Carlsbad) 2; ~~~E~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~N~oKE R5 REGIONAL SERVICE C ('OhlhllHlN COMMERCIAL &HHP RESIDER flAL MOBILE HOME P.4M ZONE N NEI(iIIBORI1OOD CO.MMERCIAL TS TRAVEL SERIICES COMWERCLAL
0 PROFESSIONAL RELkTED
PI PL4NhED INDl STRIL 0 OFFICEZOhT C GOVERNMENT F.4CILITIES C.1 NEIGHBORHOOD COM.MERC1.U ZONE C PC'BLIC LTILITIES C-2 GWERAL COMMERCLU ZONE
R-P RESIDENTL4L PROFESSIONAL ZONE
RW WIDENTUL UXTERUAY ZONE RT RESIDENTIAL TOCRlST ZONE
CBD CFNTML 81 Slr'iESS DISTRICT COMMERCIAL
RC RECRETION COMMERCIAL C-T COMMERCW-TOURIST ZONE C-M HUW COMSERCLU-UMITED WDCSTRW ZONE
P.M PUWED LNDC'STRLU ZONE : J Jt'NIOR I!IGH ' H III(;H SCHOOL P PRIVATE
M WDcsmu ZONE
OWlR
US OPEN %PACE L.C LLbtITED COhTROL F.P KOODPLUN OVERIAY ZONE
P.U PLEUC LTlUTY ZOM 3RR WON RESIDENTIAL RESERVE OS OPE? SP.4CE
LAUREL TREE
0 0
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2682
1
2
3
4
5
6
A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, RECOMMENDING
APPROVAL OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE LAND USE ELEMENT
OF THE GENERAL PLAN FROM RLM (0-4 DU/AC) TO 0
(PROFESSIONAL AND RELATED) ON PROPERTY GENERALLY
LOCATED SOUTH OF PALOMAR AIRPORT ROAD ALONG THE
APPLICANT: LAUREL TREE
FUTURE COLLEGE AVENUE EXTENSION,
CASE NO.: GPA/LU 87-4
1 7
8
9
10
11
WEREAS, a verified application for an amendment
General Plan designation for certain property located, a
on Exhibit IIA", dated September 30, 1987, attach
incorporated herein, has been filed with the Planning corn
and
I.2 /I WHEREAS, said verified application constitutes a
l3 // for amendment as provided in Title 21 of the Carlsbad Mt
14
15 Code: and
WEREAS, the Planning Commission did, on the 4th
16
17 the 12th day of November, 1987, hold a duly noticed
hearing as prescribed by law to consider said request:
18 11 -
WHEREAS, at said public hearing, upon hear: 19 I1 -
20 I ~ considering all testimony and arguments, if any, of all
desiring to be heard, said Commission considered all
relating to the General Plan Amendment.
21
22
23 /I NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the I
11 Commission of the City of Carlsbad, as follows: 24
25
26 hearing, the Commission recommends APPROVAL of GP.
4, based on the following findings and subject 27 following conditions.
28
11 A) That the above recitations are true and correct.
B) That based on the evidence presented at the
11 ll
II e e
1 Findinas :
2
3
4
5
6
1. The site is appropriate for office uses due topographic relationship with the City's industrial along Palomar Airport Road and its proximity below residential uses to the west, south, and east bluff t
2. The site as an office area serves as a buffer residential land uses and traffic patterns on the bl
traffic patterns to the north.
to the west, south, east, and the industrial land 1
7 3. The Local Facilities Management Plan for Zone 5 has
public facilities impacts for the site based
facilities impacts of the proposed office use hc
8
analyzed and addressed. 9
residential land use; therefore, generalized
10
11
4. The Mello I1 segment of Carlsbad's Local Coastal does not preclude the proposed amendment to the : plan to change the site's land use to office. The land use change does not conflict with the coastal 12 policies of Carlsbad's Local Coastal Program.
13 1 5. The project will not cause any significant envir
15
Planning Director on September 30, 1987, and recomme 14 impacts, and a Negative Declaration was issued
approval by the Planning Commission on November 4, 15
16 '
17
////
///I
//// 18 1
19 1 //// 1 //// 20 I
21 1 ///I 22
23
24
////
////
////
//// 25 /I
26 11 ////
27 11 PC RES0 NO. 2682 -2-
28 Jl I/
*
1 PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meet
2
on the 12th day of November, 1987, by the following vote, ' 3
the Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad, Californi,
4
5 AYES: Chairman Marcus, Commissioners: Hall, Mc McBane, Holmes, Schlehuber, and Schramm
6
ABSENT: None 7
NOES : None
8
9
10
11
12
ABSTAIN: None
MARY MARCUS, Chairperson Carlsbad Planning Commissi
l3 (( ATTEST:
14 11 15
l6 Planning Director
MICHAEL J. HOLZMILLER
I? I1 18 I/
19 1 I
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28 11
PC RES0 NO. 2682 -3-
9-30
RLM to 0 -
1
RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RL I OW DEN(Il7 (0. I 7) P-C PL4hVED CO?d&lLWlR ZONE
RLN I.OU.hlE~lChl DENSITY (0.4) R.A RESIDENTIAL AGRICULTCRAL ZONE R-E RCR4L RESIDENTIAL UT.41T ZONE R-l ONE-FkVILY RESIDENTML ZONE R-2 TU'O.F,WILY RESIDENTIALZONE
RD-H R€SIl)ENTIAL DENSITYIIIGH ZONE
R-P RESIDENTIAL PROFESSIONAL ZONE KT RESIDENTIAL TOCRIST ZONE RW RESIDENTUL UATERWAY ZONE
(: (.Ohlbll'NIN COMMERCIAL N Nk-l(;llnoRI!Oou COM(YERCIAL
(1 PROFESSIONAL REUTED CRD CFN IRAL BISINESS DISTRICT PI PI.ANNF.1) INDI'SlRI.4L G GOkERNLIENT FACILITIES U PLBLIC C'IILITIES C-2 GENERAL COMMERCW ZONE
pJ,fllp RESlDENnAL hlOf3llP IIOME PARK ZONE
TS 1RAVELSERVICES COMMERCIAL
COMMERCIAL 0 OfflCE ZONE c- I NEIGHBORtiOOD CO&IMER<:IAL ZONE
C-T COMMERCIAL-TOCRIST ZONE C-M HEAVYCOM>IERCIAL.UMIlTD LNDUSTRJN ZONE
E ELEMENTARY P.M PLANNED WDUSTRJN ZOM J JI'NIOR IllGFi
P PRIVATE F-P FLOODPMN OVERLAY ZONE
M WDCSW ZONE
II III(;H SCI1OOL OTHER
05 OPEN $PACE NRR NON RESII)ENTLAL RESERVE P.U PL3UC
* a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
l8 !
19 I
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2697
A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE CARLSBAD LOCAL COASTAL PLAN TO CHANGE THE DESIGNATION FROM RLM, RESIDENTIAL LOW- MEDIUM 0-4 DU/AC, TO 0, OFFICE, FOR A 9.2
ACRE SITE LOCATED SOUTH OF PALOMAR AIRPORT
ROAD ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF THE FUTURE SOUTHERLY EXTENSION OF COLLEGE AVENUE.
APPLICANT: CITY OF CARLSBAD CASE NO.: LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-23]
WHEREAS, California State law requires thist
Coastal Plan and General Plan designations for properti
Coastal Zone be in conformance;
WHEREAS, a verified application for an amendme
Local Coastal Plan designation for certain property IC
shown on Exhibit ttAtt, dated September 30, 1987, att
incorporated herein, has been filed with the Planning Cc
and
WHEREAS, said verified application constitutes
for amendment as provided in Title 21 of the Carlsbad
Code; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission did on the 4
the 12th day of November, 1987, hold a duly notic
hearing as prescribed by law to consider the propo
Coastal Plan Amendment shown on Exhibit ttA*t, and;
WHEREAS, at said public hearing, upon he,
considering all testimony and arguments, if any, of a:
desiring to be heard, said Commission considered a1
relating to the Local Coastal Plan Amendment.
e 4
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
l4
~
15
-
WHEREAS, State Coastal Guidelines requires a !
public review period for any amendment to the Local
Program.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the
Commission of the City of Carlsbad, as follows:
A) That the foregoing recitations are true and correlct.
B) At the end of the State mandated six week review
starting on November 4, 1987, and ending on Dece
1987, staff shall present to the City Council EL su the comments received.
C) That based on the evidence presented at the public the Commission recommends APPROVAL of LCPA 87-3 (LC1 as shown on Exhibit ttAtt, dated September 30, 1987, hereto and made a part hereof based on the : findings :
Findinss:
1. The recommended Local Coastal Plan Amendment will k
designations on the General Plan and Local Coastal 1
conformance as required by State law.
16 relates more to the non-residentially zoned prope the north than it does to the residentially dc 17
3. The proposed 0, Office, designation will allow 18
properties to the south, east, and west.
I 2. Due to topographical constraints, the subject
creation of a buffer area between the property d' 19 I for industrial development to the north and the p
~ designated for residential development to the sout 20 and west.
21
22
4. The project will not cause any significant envi impacts, and a Negative Declaration was issued
Planning Director on September 30, 1987, and recomm approval by the Planning Commission on November 4, 1 23
24 11 //'/
25
26
~ /I//
////
27
28
1 PC RES0 NO. 2697 -2-
1
I1 0 *
PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meetins
1
2
3
Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad, held on the
of November, 1987, by the following vote, to wit:
AYES: Chairman Marcus, Commissioners: Hall, 8
4 McBane, Holmes I Schlehuber , and Schramm
5
ABSTAIN: None 7
ABSENT : None 6
NOES : None
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
ATTEST :
MARY MARCUS, Chairpersc
CARLSBAD PLANNING COMM:
MICHAEL J. HOLZMILLER
Planning Director
I? /I
l8 I
19 1
2o il
21 I1
22 11
23
24
I
25
26
'
PC RES0 NO. 2697 -3- 27
28 I
1 e 0 ~ ~ ~~~ "
EXHl I 9-3
~
\
GENERAL PLAN ZONING
RLSIDCNTIAL RL I.OWDENFIT((O.I 7) RESIDENTIAL
R1.N IOU'~hlEKllChl UENSlTY(O.4)
RhIII blF.I)lIJM IIIGH DENSlIY(8.15)
P.C PUh'KED CO%hlL'NIIY ZONE R-A RESIDESTUL AGRICCLlLRAL ZONE R-E RLR4L RESIDENTIAL ESTATE ZONE R.1 ONE-FAVILY RESIDENTUL ZONE R-2 lWO.F,L\IILY RESIDENTIALZONE R.3 MI'LTIP1.E FLMILY RESIDENTLALZONE
Rh1 MEI>I[J.V DENSlrY(4.8)
RII IllGI1 DENSITY ( 17-23)
RRI IN1 ENSIVE REGIONAL RETAIL (cg Plaza Camlno Real) RRE EXTFNSIVE REGIONAL RETAIL (cg Cx Counrry Carlsbad) RD.M RESIDEmL DENSITYMCLTIPLE ZONE
COMMERCIAL
R.3L UhllTED MCLl"F.kMILY RESIDENTIAL ZONE
RS REGIONAI. SERVICE C (:OhlhlI'NITY(CUMMER~:IAL N NElGll~ORIIOOD COWvlERCIAL TS 1 RAVEL SERVIC-ES COMIIERCIAL 0 PROFESSIONAL RElAlED CRD CFNlRAI. EC'SINESS DISTFdCT PI PIANNEII INDI'STRIAL G GIIYERNCIENT F.4CILITIES
U PVRLIC VI'ILITIES RC RECREATION COMMERCIAL
RD-H RESII)ENllAL DENSITY.HIGI~ ZONE
R-P RESIDENTIAL PROFESSIONAL ZONE KT RESIDEKTULTOCRIST ZONE RW RESIDENlLAL UiATERWAY ZONE
RMllP RESlDENnAL MOIlllP HOME PARK ZONE
COMMERCIAL 0 OWICE ZONE C-I NElGtlBORIIOOD COhlVERCIALZONE C-2 CENERU COhlhfERCLV ZONE C.T COM.MERCUL-TO~RISTZONE
E ELEMENTARY
ti 111(;11 FCliOOL J JI'NIOR IIICH P.M PUWED LNDUSW ZOM
P PRItATE F-P FLOOOPLUN OVERUY ZONE
C-M HFAbY COM5lERCLU.UMITED INDUSTTUN. ZONE M Ih'DUSTUU ZONE
OTHfR
LAUREL TREE
..
0 e
STAFF REPORT a
DATE : NOVEMBER 4, 1987
TO : PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM: PLANNING DEPARTMENT
SUBJECT: GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-23] CITY OF CARLSBZ
(LAUREL TREE) - Request for a General P1;
Amendment and Local Coastal Plan Amendment frc
RLM (0-4 du/ac) to 0 (Professional and Related) fc a 9.2 acre site located south of Palomar Airpol
Road along the future southerly College Avenl extension in Public Facilities Management Plan ZOI
5.
I. RECOMMENDATION
That the Planning Commission recommend APPROVAL of tl Negative Declaration issued by the Planning Director a1 ADOPT Resolution No.'s 2682 and 2697 recommending APPROVAL (
GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-2E), based on the findinc contained therein.
11. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
On April 21, 1986, Agatep Corporation requested that the la use designation of the proposed site be changed from RLM (
4 du/ac) to PI (Planned Industrial). An application for th
change could not occur until the Local Facilities Manageme Plan for Zone 5 had been approved. Even though this area h
a General Plan designation of RLM, it was included in Zone
This was done because it was topographically separated fr
existing and future residential uses to the west, south, a
east. Now that Zone 5 has been approved, the owner of t
property has requested that staff act on this issu However, upon evaluation, staff feels that a change from F
(0-4 du/ac) to 0 (Professional and Related) may be a mc appropriate designation. The 0 designation would be bett suited for the proposed site since the site is locat between residential and planned industrial uses. An off i area would create an appropriate buffer area between t
industrial development on the level areas along Palon
Airport Road to the north and residential land uses at t
tap of the bluffs to the west, south, and east.
e 0
November 4, 1987
GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-23)
Pacre 2
111. ANALYSIS
Plannina Issues
1. Is the land use designation of 0 (professional an related) more appropriate for the site than the existin RLM (0-4 du/ac) designation and consistent with th policies of the General Plan?
2. Would the uses allowed by the 0 General Plan designatic be compatible with existing and proposed surroundir uses?
3. Is the General Plan Amendment consistent with the :Loce Facilities Management Plan for Zone 5?
4. Is the General Plan Amendment and Local Coastal Progrz Amendment in conformance with policies of the Mello 1 segment of Carlsbad's Local Coastal Program?
Discussion
The site is located in a small canyon to the south of Canyc
de las Encinas and Palomar Airport Road. (See Exhibit A,
Bluffs to the west, south, and east surround the site a1 provide a topographic buffer for residential land US(
planned for the bluff tops. The office designation wou: provide a land use buffer between the intense industrial us(
along Palomar Airport Road and the residential land uses f
the south. This type of topographic and land use bufferil
is consistent with the land use policies of Carlsbad
General Plan.
Additionally, the planned roadway network could support change from residential land use to office. Collel Boulevard, a four lane major arterial, is planned to align
grade directly west of the site, and Palomar Airport Road,
six lane prime arterial, is less than 1,000 feet to the nor
of the site, Office uses, which are less sensitive to ro noise than are residential uses, would be more appropria for this site. Office use on the site would help assu frequent and heavy industrial type traffic is confined to t Palomar Airport Road corridor and is not directed south alo
College Boulevard into residential areas. An office ty
traffic pattern would be a more appropriate transition fr
heavy and intense industrial to a lighter residential roadw
use. Office use on the site is estimated to generate 8
0 0
November 4, 1987
Pase 3
GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-2E)
average daily trips (ADT) as opposed to the estimated 368 AD for RLM - Residential. However, the site's location o
College Boulevard and proximity to Palomar Airport Roa
should in this case be able to handle the increase. The Zon
5 Local Facilities Management Plan estimated such generalized traffic impact in its circulation facilitie
analysis and planning. Additionally, the Zone 5 Loca
Facility Management Plan incorporated non-residential lan
use impacts from the site in the analysis and planning of a1
public facilities. More detailed analysis may be necessar when a specific land use and design is proposed for thi
site.
Staff does feel, however, that there are some argument.s t
change this area to PI because it is closely associated wit
the existing PI area to the north. The area is small in siz
(9.2 acres) and could easily be incorporated with th
adjacent designation. Also, it may be possible for futur
development to argue for more office to the south because o
its small size. Overall, however, staff feels that offic
use has more advantages.
The present land use plan map of the Mello I1 segment c
Carlsbad's Local Coastal Program identifies RLM - Residentia
Low Medium, 0-4 du/ac - use for the site. A Local Coasta
Program Amendment (LCPA) is necessary to attain conformanc with the proposed General Plan Amendment to office use. E significant coastal resource policies are attributed to tt site's exclusive residential use. There is, however, requirement that the site as a designated coasta agricultural area must mitigate the loss of this agriculturz land once converted to an urban use. This requirement woul
equally apply whether the land was designated residential c off ice. Consequently, an LCPA to 0, Office, would nc conflict with the coastal resource protection policies of ti
Mello I1 segment of Carlsbad's Local Coastal Program.
At the present time, this site is zoned L-C, Limited Control
Limited Control is basically a holding zone. Staff is nc
proposing that this zone be changed until the exact alignmer
of College Avenue through this area has been determined. 2
alignment was originally established as part of CT 84-3:
Cobblestone Sea Village. However, staff has been talking 1 affected property owners about a possible realignment severi hundred feet to the west. This would result in less gradil and a more level roadway. General Plan boundaries ai
general and can be interpreted, while Zoning boundaries ai exact. When the alignment of College Avenue has bet
e 0
November 4, 1987
Pase 4
GPA/LU 87-4jLCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-2E)
determined, then a zone change to 0, Office, will :
appropriate.
For these reasons, staff recommends the Planning Commissil recommend approval of GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-23) the City Council and California Coastal Commission.
IV . ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Environmental analysis was conducted for this site as part l ZC-261 according to City Council Resolution No. 9659. Upl
the Planning Director determined that the project will n
cause any significant environmental impacts and, therefor
has issued a Negative Declaration on September 30, 1987.
review of this analysis and analysis relative to the projec
ATTACHMENTS
1. Planning Commission Resolution No.'s 2682 and 2697.
2. Location Map
3. Background Data Sheet
4. Environmental Document
5. Letters dated April 21, 1986, and September 8, 1987
6. Exhibit "Afig, dated September 30, 1987
LBS/WD: dm
10/1/87
0 0
BACKGROUND DATA SHEET
CASE NO: GPA/LU 87-4
APPLICANT: CITY OF CARLSBAD
REQUEST AND LOCATION: A General Plan Amendment from RLM (0-4 du/
0 (professional and related] south of Palomar Aimort Road and e
the future Colleae Avenue extension.
LEGAL DESCRIPTION: A portion of lot 6 of Rancho Aqua Hedionda. C
(portic
of San Dieqo. State of California, Map No. 823 APN: 212-04
Acres 9.2 Proposed No. of Lots/Units :N/A
GENERAL PLAN AND ZONING
Land Use Designation RLM
Density Allowed 0-4 du/ac Density Proposed N1
Existing Zone L-c Proposed Zone L-c
Surrounding Zoning and Land Use:
-
Zoninq Land Use
Site L-c Vacant
North L-c Vacant
South L-c Vacant
East L-c Vacant
West L-c Residential
PUBLIC FACILITIES
School District Carlsbad Water* Carlsbad Sewer Carlsbad EDU'sN/.
Public Facilities Fee Agreement, dated
(*The City of Carlsbad will provide water servie to all projt
Carlsbad except those located in the Olivenhain and San Marc02 Districts.)
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
X Negative Declaration, issued September 30, 1987
E.I.R. Certified, dated Other,
e 0 2075 LAS PALMA
CARLSBAD, CALIFORb
PLANNING DEPARTMENT (619) 438-1 1
Gtp of clCarI$i.mb
NEGATIVE DECLARATION
PROJECT ADDRESS/LOCATION: South of Palomar Airport Road 1
Laurel Tree Road and Paseo del Norte.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION: General Plan Amendment fro]
Residential Low-Medium, (0 - 4 du/ac) to 0: professior
related for a 9.2 acre area.
The City of Carlsbad has conducted an environmental review
above described project pursuant to the Guidelinc Implementation of the California Environmental Quality I
the Environmental Protection Ordinance of the City of Ca
As a result of said review, a Negative Declaration (decl,
that the project will not have a significant impact
environment) is hereby issued for the subject p
Department.
A copy of the Negative Declaration with supportive documc on file in the Planning Department, 2075 Las Palmas
Carlsbad, California 92009. Comments from the pub1
invited. Please submit comments in writing to the P
Department within ten (10) days of date of issuance.
Justification for this action is on file in the P
DATED: September 30, 1987 - MICHAEL J. %LZMI&R
CASE NO: GPA/LU 87-4 Planning Director
APPLICANT: CITY OF CARLSBAD
PUBLISH DATE: September 30, 1987
.. (L. I. . I. 1: - 0- -. .I - ; - . : F..?T-*.--7 ,.=.> ,r - ".iz -..- v i ':
.: ~ . - . ..'?- ,;; ; , - 'S.4 : . .> I $ "2: .I .. .-. - . ' i ; - : . : SAC" .. ,... . J' ,. ~ ;-,y ;. -i :i +T ,?-I-.. ". ' -.e{ t". . ...* "I! , '.fr (,.?:;*;?i ,.?;i ?& .- .* ;:
.,.-, 2 I-.. .. ,AT;:, ."~=?Ti?TP '.? , . ' . ' " _._,." , -:<z,.;:*: ~~.~-~~~~~-~~~.~,.~~-~.- r i' .. -._; - ._ * , F;JlIi ~,>-~!/J,~ y ;
: ..
I, ;- .'.. . . 2-.. .. .. "-I . -Fr.yrr4m~:??ly:T+~" :;-" ,
" - ..',~!:~5:7-?~r;;j~~ .-. 2 . .._
c"itr9 &_ Regional Yiann!'l;,o Co>?sulinnh-
. I. . . A$+j 21, ises
IWe Ewes
Plxnjnq Depzrtrnwt
City of Carlsbad
1 ZOO Elm Avenue *.
C2risbzd, CA 92023
.- $
. . . . . - .
RE: Growth Manatjernegi, Program - redesignation fron; Fzzil i:i?s K~~~~~~~~<~~~i
(F.K.) Zone 20 to F.M. Zore S pro~erty aGjaxT!t tc l-jz,jcxx A.\irport 2szd ax;
fiftcre College BM.
Mike:
r.. -. Labre] Tree Ini/ostznnts QC:;?~ 2 c.:.zrce] ( anngx. 5.5~~:::) z!~;~.:~~~: 10 .. ..
'. +PiJ d:siS>?ted Planned indi;sf_riai propcrtjes (F.Iy, Zoce 23). The Z,:;;C~?T::J .. sk)illi L.i " ut
jnci:L&d in zone 5 iris.tead c[ F.Y. Za,?.? 20 b2cause t:-8< ;:-~2i js jl-i?p:ctK/ by :h
exte,;sjcr; i;f Col12ge FJvC., tp,e p,-,~~;~j+,y tl; z,?j~~y,:.;~; ~;;j~:~;~;;~~~ j~?~.:;~ a.?G
ii'npz:;tzd by noi? s?p?rzt~d >y F2j.::r~;z~,- ,~,i~~~r~.
-. . .
.. .. .
d
Th?r?f~r?; ):/e r~~~~~t tr,~ ~:~~~~i~~ D~~~rt-~~~~~ z,?,-j triz Cifl,' &? (-,?:>*:jI c
to reG;sic?mte 1 ;he gar.:el to F.M. Z?*y 5 ~~c~~:~~:
X The pygperty 23j2im eyistir-q ?\w,~e:C .,.2.dwL IF;.<: '=;+Tiz: ,-.-;.-j
LI8 +~:;es ts .. ..
ti.:.? Rwth and Wes!
-
7: -. -x i pe ,-,#;p~,cr+t./ is ti"3,~~r;1r.i.i.-.1''\-~ CC~--Z+: 4 f-,-.w r-r,,=- iz-!g ;is2 .. 3.
_. ,J u 1 " 7 u. ,.,-. llbul;, ,.r2< LL"4 . ",I( i\." to :>? SgGti- I.
.X 792 prggerty is 1!7f;i~~.;,c,:d t!.; p~l,?;?? ,A.'~y-i Q;~y~~j3,~:
!Palmar Airport Xzsster Plan findinss)
.\I _. -a. j.;.!'? r,yr,;-,.?\rf\J :-!,?qifr?.-.:-r. 4 .. .. ... i ,ZL _,,-. 1.' ,. >.,. , ._ . ,*I!''>iLC'. ???l9-.>cl: .r I,._____I :.:: ." p\"" r- -.-"I . ; , L!<. i I; 22
.. --""~-,~:?;~ ,.,ir', ?<+:,n: "" - . - . . . . "- ,-, 3 x .: .-I -: . ' ,-,,,: , ..;. .. , c ..., ;.; .:: .-, i -." : .t !F ,! 1"; zr;!; ::J-r? '- - :- .. '
.. .: .
>
,,
2356 .~ou;z,.c.i! Srr,.r: -3 ,DSs[ 03rr a,>= 596 a Cgr.':&yLJ a ~~.t<:~.-7.~; ?:;;.j:.j : '" - z,, " -J9- '. * ' 'T=A j.. -
. . . . . . - . - . . . . ". . . . " . -.
' ?.AGE T'dC
G!+ P
a; 9 e
,L.-77{ 1 2 1 t 7.~2.S
NOTE: Pi? hzve ~~bmitteil a reql:sst to 2mei1d the Gener?'I ?lsn (land Use)
under separz te ccrver.
s
t f you ~,zve further q~~tisns, piease contact me at your conveience.
. . .. /
".
..-.
" . - - . - . - - . " - -. "" .
?espectfully,
KL ."". " . . . . _~_.
r . 1? iun~ld r. . .. A. A~ztsp
t" r ,
P
\
,- . I. .
..
CC: Lawd Tree Investzents
CAVCl
.I
c cyy-J-0'- r tg-4 1 oLuc2J @,
I .!'.','
'I } ,' '
' '> ! ', , .I
li
SPIERS ENTERPRISES
17911 Mitchell St.
bine, CA 92714
(714) 663*\767
September 8, 1987
Mr. Michael Holzmiller
City of Carlsbad
2075 Las Palms
Carlsbad, Ca. 92009-4859
b
Re: Request for Activating Laurel Tree General Plan An"n&it
On April 21, 1986, Agatep Corporation, at that time acting on
behalf of Laurel Tree Investments, filed two requests relating to this property.
The first request was to adjust the boundary between facilities
zones 5 and 20 to permit the northern portion of ttus site to be
planned as a part of Zone 5. This zone, a non-residential management
zone, was seen as mre appropriate than Zone 20 due to conqtraints
. outlined in the request (attachment #I).
The sgond involved a request to designate the northern portion of this property from RT%z (residential) land :ise designation to PI
(planned industrial) '(attachment #2)- This request was made'during
the City's analysis of land use inconsistencies in the Palomar brpor Iniluence Area.
Action was taken by the City in July, 1986 to accomxdate the Fa-
cilities Management Zone boundary adjustment. The facilities plan
for Zone 5 has naw been approved by the City Council and reflects
the adjustment.
In followiq up on the request for General Plan Amendment, we were
advised that the change in use was appropriate and that it would pre
ceed as a part of the City initiated Airprt Influence and Land Use
Inconsistency package. However, when the package went forward, this
site was not included. We were advised that there had.been an over-
sight and that the change could proceed once the Zone 5 plan was
complete. .
Now that the Zone 5 plan has been approved, it is requested that
the change in land use designation be scheduled for the next availab General Plan Amendment hearing.
. .. a ._.
\
If you have any questions or need additional information regard-
ing this matter, please contact Jack Henthorn at (619) 434-3135.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sinberely,
..
Attachments
cc: Mlke Howes
Jack Henthorn
LAUREL TREE Immmnrs cc
A hted Partnership
.-
5 Dwight W. Spiers
Nanaging General Partner
\
F - """---
I rEXHIB I' e 9-301 1
b
GENERAL PLAN ZONING
RL RLPI
Rh1 I I
Rbl
RH
RRE RRI
Rs
(: N
TS 0
PI G U RC
cm
E
I
RESIDENTIAL
I ow DF.rv<ITY (0.1 5 I IOU MEDIL'PI DENSIlY(O.4)
hIEl>llJV IIItiH DENSITY(E.15)
VEI>IUM DENSITY(( 8)
111G11 DFVSITY( 15.23)
COMMERCIAL INTENSIVE REtiIONAL RETAIL (Cg EXrENSIVE REGIONAL RETAIL (CR REGIONALSERVICE
( OhlbtL'NITY COHMERCIAL NFl(;lIDORIIOUD COMMERCIAL 1MVELSERVlCES COMMERCIAL PRClFESSIONAL RELATED CFNTR4L BLSISESS DISTRICT PI.ANNFI> INDI'STRIAL GOVERNhlENT FACILITIES PLBLIC UllLlTlES RE( RE4TION COMNERCLAL scnooLs
FLE3tENTARY II NIOR fllGI1 li ill(;ll ZCIIOOL P FRI\ATE
NRR NON RESIDENTLAL RESERVE CIS []PEN IPKE
Plaza Camlno Rcrl) Cu Country Clrlsbad)
P.C PL4hXED COhl%lLNTY ZONE R.A FESIDENTLALAGRICULTLRAL ZONE R-E RCR4L RESIDESTIAL EsT.4lT ZONE
R.1 ONE-F.4VILY RESIDENTIALZONE R-2 TWfl.FLVILY RESIDENTW ZOhT R.3 MI'ITIPIL FCIllLY RE5IDENTIALZOM
RESIDENTIAL
R.;i U~~T~.LGM~.CI"F~MILY RESIDENTIAL ZONE RD-M RESIDE~L DENSI~ w.nw ZONE
MllP RESlDENn4L bfODll+ IIUhtE PARK ZONE RD-H RESIDESll4L DE.i5lTYIII(;H ZONE
R-P RESIDENll4L PROFESSIONAL ZONE RT FSIDEbTIAL TOCRIST ZONE RW FSIDENTIAL U4lTRWAY ZOhiE
COMMERCIAL
C-I NEIGHBOMIOOD COhl3lERC.IAL ZONE C-2 CENERU COMMERCLU ZOhE
C.T COM.VERCLUTOCMST ZONE C-M HUVYCOM>IERCLU-UMIIED INDUSTRW
P.M PUWED L*QL'STTXALZONE
0 OIFICE ZONE
M IPITlUSU ZONE
OTHER F-P FLUODPLUN OVEF'JAY ZONE 1.C UMITTD COFFlROl
P.U PMUC LTIUTT 205. OS OPEN SP+CE
ZONE
4
City of Cal
LCPA 8;
(LCPA 871
I r
LAUREL TREE I GPA/LU €
I
0 Carlsbad Journal
Decreed A Legal Newspaper by the Superior Court of Sun Diego County
Mail all correspondence regarding public notice advertising to
North Coast Publishers, Inc. corporate offices: P.O. Box 878, Encinitas, CA 92024
(61 9) 753-6543
Proof of Publication
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, ss,
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO,
I am a citizen of the United States and a resident of the county aforesaid;
I am over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to or interested in the above enti.
I am principal clerk of the printer of the Carlsbad Journal a newspaper of general
published twice weekly in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California
newspaper is published for the dissemination of local news and intelligence of a generai ch
which newspaper at all times herein mentioned had and still has a bona fide subscription I
subscribers, and which newspaper has been established, printed and published at regular
the said City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California, for a period exceeding 0'
preceding the date of pubiication c NOTICE OF PUBLIC ly College Avenue extension in Public Facilities Management Plan hereinafter referred to; and that tI HEARING Zone 5. GPAnU 87-4lLCPA Ifyou have any questions. please which the annexed is a printed cor
4381161. published in each regular and entire
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that If you challenge the General newspaper and not in any suppleme
87-3 (LCPA 87-23) call the Planning Department at
theCityCounciloftheCityofCarls- Plan Amendment and/or Local
bad will hold a public hearing at Coastal Plan Amendment in Court. the following dates, to-wit:
the City Council Chambers, 1200 you may be limited to raising only Elm Avenue, Carlsbad, California, those issues you or someone eke
8, 1987, to consider an application scribed in this notice, or in written at6:00 P.M., on Tuesday, December raised at the public hearing de-
for a General Plan Amendment and correspondence delivered to the Local Coastal Plan Amendment City ofcarlsbad City Clerks Office from RLM (0-4 duiac) to 0 (Profes- at or prior to the public hearing. sional and Related) for a 9.2 acre Applicant City of Carlsbad site located south of Palomar Air- (Laurel Tree) port, Rsad along the Suture souther- CARLSBAD CITY COUNCIL ..............................
November 27 ..............................
-
,; $j 4 I
ALA
.............................. bv Y" $7 c"'o'clr;'
.............................. .lL \'.e ?*$I 4\ 5 $!< $L*4&s=&" d --zp ............................. -g( ':' LcpA 87.3
,1.5.5-- '!>
u, *.." *\% I certify under penalty of perjury that the fore; -* correct. Executed at Carlsbad, County of Sal
California on The 27th
(LCPA 67-2E) day of - 7 November, 1-g
LAUREL TREE
CJ 4940: November 27,1987 Clei
!'! b$j fJ GPAlLU 07-4 ___
fr202-2M-7 86 "~
-
@ NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING 0
GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-2E)
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Carlsbad will hold a pi
at the City Council Chambers, 1200 Elm Avenue, Carlsbad, California, at 6:OO P.M.,
December 8, 1987, to consider an application for a General Plan Amendment and Loca
located south of Palomar Airport Road along the future southerly College Avenue ex
in Public Facilities Management Plan Zone 5.
If you have any questions, please call the Planning Department at 438-1161.
If you challenge the General Plan Amendment and/or Local Coastal Plan Amendment in
you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the
hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to th.e Ci
Carlsbad City Clerk's Office at or prior to the public hearing.
Plan Amendment from RLM (0-4 du/ac) to 0 (Professional and Related) for a 9.2 acre
APPLICANT: City of Carlsbad (Laurel Tree)
PUBLISH: November 27, 1987 CARLSBAD CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Planning Commission of the ( of Carlsbad will hold a public hearing at the Council Chambf
1200 Elm Avenue, Carlsbad, California, at 6:OO p.m. on Wednesc
November 4, 1987, to consider approval of a General 1
Amendment and Local Coastal Plan Amendment from RLM (0-4 du, to 0 (Professional and Related) for a 9.2 acre site located s(
of Palomar Airport Road along the future southerly College Avt extension in Public Facilities Management Plan Zone 5.
Those persons wishing to speak on this proposal are cordiz
please call the Planning Department at 438-1161.
invited to attend the public hearing. If you have any questic
If you challenge the General Plan Amendment and/or Local CoaE Plan Amendment in court, you may be limited to raising only tk
issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing descri
in this notice or in written correspondence delivered to the (
of Carlsbad at or prior to the public hearing.
CASE FILE : GPA/LU 87-4/LCPA 87-3 (LCPA 87-2E) APPLICANT: CITY OF CARLSBAD (LAUREL TREE)
PUBLISH: OCTOBER 23, 1987
CITY OF CARLSBAD PLANNING COMMISSION
r * I. ..
QJCCOLA 0
ENGINEERIN6 inc. ' . -
December 2, 1985
PROPERTY OWNER LIST FOR
LAUREL TREE SUBDIVISION * i&cd lolzdo
Numb e r Name and
Mailing Address
Assessors
Parcel Number ~~~~
1. Laurel Tree Investment CO. 212-040-22 17941 Mitchell I.+. % Irvine, CA 92715 ?11,,.-j I
2,4,6G 7 Richard Kelly 6 Robert P. Kelly 212-040-32 c/o Robert P. Kelly 212-040-36
2770 Sunny Creek Road Carlsbad, CA 92008 212-040-38 % 212-040-37
3. Sudan Interior Mission Inc. 212-040-23 1400 Flame Tree Lane Carlsbad, CA 92008 Y-
5. Fraz-ee H. Edwin 6 bIabel..-G: Edwin ti 2 -04-0-34 p.0. Box '1091-----.-:. ." 213 - & 0" '7 Rancho Santa Fe, CA""92067 ' 4 ?!3. yL./i)+ 6
(,q..C I>/>: L 4 1351-
d"
8. Hiroshi Ukegawa 6 Eliwako 212-040-25'
Joe 6 Irene Ukegawa
Carlsbad, CA 92008 '4218 Skyline Road
94 .I. .I ;b* ; , . '
t _.
31 42 Vista Way, Suite 301 0 Oceanside, California 92054
I.
.r
,- BeJCCOLA * 0' .', . . , ,; .,
..
a, I
ENGINEERING, inc. r.
Page 2
PROPERTY OWNER LIST FOR LAUREL TREE SUBDIVISION
9. BCS Program L-2 212-04.0-2
1303 Avocado St. Newport Financial Center Newport, CA 92660 %-
10. Carlsbad Land Investors 212-040-3 c/o Secure Properties Inc.
17332 Irvine Boulevard c*ts13 !L./ 'I , ,+ Tustin, CA 92680
11. Roesch Ronald L. 215-070-1
2800 Neilson TJay #70S
Santa Monica, CA 90405 %
12. Sunbelt Planning Co., Inc. 214i140-0 c/o Shunichi Naito 14151 Newport Ave.
Suite 201 !=v Tustin, CA 92680
13. Joseph Sherman 7423 Garvey Ave. Rosemead, CA 91770 *
! ..
214-140-1
, .7 .. .. ', ,", .;&
" .1 h.;;;<
f ,;;?+
. t., ,_ ,
' . .'. * j
3142 Vista Way, Suite 301 0 Oceanside, California 92054
9.
e
e
-I
a
3 4 3Q + v 67 . 9'1 y$ cs g4 uh
3-
! ',
/."I .: . .-
ii ?> -.
<3 - ,
'. ' i
( .;i
.:; fl
8:) v;\ ; 1
i
'J .- I " 7
. ..
(2 _ou & -
<,7 ;;<I
I
'i
-
: i> , ""
1
-* r& 'i
~ ..
(.' Pi ,
;L
i ' i"
\' -} -.
r- ,",
t') L ,
.>.
21 ' '
7.;
__ -2 '
. .-
a 4 (.-,>
q .:r3
tJ 3 t- 3
CL" .? . > _..- "
d -- .6';
-. "
\' U'
t"k 23
-
,t L"
Ci- s-)
!
<! j
6 .. 7.
I 3 r;7i
-. 'I
..
c?
CL
:i ,
" .-
[ .j c
" <
-. \)
p/- -.
..-
2? ...->
"_ "> "i
9
-1
-J i3
!
.i
"
- "
-._ i' I
c
1$