HomeMy WebLinkAbout1990-12-11; City Council; 10942; INVESTIGATION OF ALTERNATIVE CARLSBAD LOCATIONS FOR THE EMERGENCY SHELTER PROGRAMCll-F CARLSBAD - AGENDWILL J;.’ - h
AB#4 ‘& TITLEm INVESTIGATION OF ALTERNATIVE DEPT.
MTG. ‘A// Q CARLSBAD LOCATIONS FOR THE
DEPT.
CITY 1
CITY 1 EMERGENCY SHELTER PROGRAM ” C’D
4 rl $!
[I) a
h rl
.rl L)
4 P
a 3
u aJ
(d
*rl M
u m E .rl
0 u
Lcl +I
u a
[o
0 u
g .rl u
Q)
L)
k .rl a
5 -?I 3
n
h
cc) -3
0-d I.
mEl (d
m *rl
&aJ Q)a
d 3 U ah orl
&+ (d
.d -4 L)k Cn 3
urd om
22
0 m \ rl
\ rl
hl
2 0
4
..
5
4
0 i
z
0 3
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
98-#3? Adopt Resolution No. directing staff to investigate alternative locations for th
emergency shelter project, and assist Caring Residents of Carlsbad in soliciting offer.
from local landowners.
ITEM EXPLANATION
On April 4, 1990, a local citizen group called Caring Residents of Carlsbad, appearec
before the Carlsbad City Council to discuss their concern for the migrant populatiol
in Carlsbad. The group investigated a number of ways to assist local migrants anc
ultimately developed a proposal for an emergency shelter in Carlsbad. The groul
successfully enlisted the support of Catholic Charities, local volunteers, professional5
businesses and a local landowner who offered to donate the use of a small para
of land for a two year period. The parcel is located in a non-residential area G
Carlsbad on the north west corner of Palomar Airport Road and Hidden Valley Road
On April 26, 1990, the City Council called a special meeting and gave it’s unanimou:
support to the Caring Residents of Carlsbad/Catholic Charities proposal and t
state/federal grant application for funding of a shelter project. Additionally, Counci
directed staff to assist Caring Residents with development processing for the project
if funded.
In August 1990, the California Department of Housing and Community Developmen
(HCD) awarded a grant in excess of $345,000 to Caring Residents of Carlsbad an(
Catholic Charities for the shelter project. Funds received by the group would bc
used to finance construction and furnishing costs.
Upon verification of funding, staff met with members of Caring Residents of Carlsbac
engineering issues related to the project. Subsequent to the meeting, staff wa:
notified that the property owner who donated the temporary use of land for the
project would no longer be able to offer the site, instead an alternate site was offered
The site is located south of the Carlsbad city limits (Green Valley area), within the
sphere of influence of the City of Encinitas, and under the jurisdiction of the Count)
of San Diego. In response to local community support of the project, staff contactec
the landowner and asked that the original site or an alternate site in Carlsbad bc
considered. According to the owner’s representative, the only other parcel available
for use is located on the south side of Palomar Airport Road, just southwest of the
original site on Hidden Valley Road. Staff evaluated this site and found significanl
environmental issues associated with any use of this parcel. Issues included; nc
direct access to the property without destruction of sensitive wetlands habitat,
to coordinate development processing and discuss potential planning anc
0
I
e e
PAGE TWO OF AGENDA BILL NO. 14 94L
and the parcel lies within the 100 year flood plain. For this reason staff could no.
recommend this site for the project. To date the land located in the Green Vallel area is the only offer which has been made.
Caring Residents of Carlsbad contacted the Mayor and City staff regarding the ne\n
proposed location and indicated that, while they would consider changing the
location of the shelter to Green Valley site, their primary desire was find a suitable sit€
within Carlsbad. In April of 1990, staff was directed by Council to assist Caring
Residents of Carlsbad with development processing for the shelter project, if fundinc
were received. Since Council’s support of the shelter project was partially based or
a Carlsbad location, staffs direction from Council may no longer be appropriate.
Once a contract with HCD, for funding, has been signed by Catholic Charities, only
14 months will be available to complete the project. In view of this time limitation,
staff has recommended the City Council direct them to begin investigating alternative
locations for the emergency shelter, and assist Caring Residents in soliciting offers
from local landowners.
FISCAL IMPACT
None
EXHIBIT
1. Resolution No. %- #jT
2. Staff Report
W e
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18'
RESOLUTION NO. 90-437
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAC
CALIFORNIA DIRECTING STAFF TO INVESTIGATE ALTERNATIVL
LOCATIONS FOR THE EMERGENCY SHELTER PROJECT, AND ASSIST
CARING RESIDENTS OF CARLSBAD IN SOLICITING OFFERS FROh
LOCAL LANDOWNERS.
WHEREAS, on April 26, 1990, the Carlsbad City Council gave it's un;
support to a grant proposal submitted to the California Department of Housi
Community Development by Caring Residents of Carlsbad and Catholic Charitie:
emergency shelter in Carlsbad; and
WHEREAS, the project administrators received a notification of grant fur
August 1990; and
WHEREAS, subsequent to funding notification, the City was notified of a (
in the location Of the shelter to a site outside of the Carlsbad city limits; and
WHEREAS, the project is generally supported by citizens of Carlsbad.
~ NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the City Council of the
~ Carlsbad as follows:
1
19
20
i A) That the foregoing recitations are true and correct.
emergency shelter project, and assist Caring Residents of Carlsbad in sc
B) That the City Council hereby directs staff to investigate alternative locations
21 offers from local landowners.
22
23
24
25
26 .---
27 ....
....
....
....
28
JJ
w 0
1
2
3
4
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Carlsl
Council held on the 11th day of December , by the following vote, to wit:
AVES: Council Members Lewis, Kulchin, Larson, Stanton and Nyga;
5
7
ABSENT: None 6
NOES: - None
9
8
lo
ALETHA L. fWU<6M=q 12
ATTEST:
l1 a
13
14
15
16
17
18
19 I
20
21
I
22
23
(SEAL)
24
25
26
27
28
e e
November 20, 1990
TO: Cs-Ty MANAGER
FROM: Community Development Director
)dl&
UPDATE; CARING RESIDENTS OF CARLSBAD EMERGENCY SHE;LTEI
PROJECT
On April 4, 1990, a local citizen group called Caring Residents of Carlsbad appeared beforc
the City Council to discuss their concern for the migrant population in Carlsbad. The groq
investigated a number of ways to assist the local migrants and ultimately developed :
proposal for an emergency shelter in Carlsbad. The group successfully enlisted the suppor
of local volunteers, professionals, businesses and Mr. Paul Ecke Sr., who offered to donatc
the use of a small parcel of land for a two year period. The Ecke parcel is located in a non
residential area on the northwest comer of Palomar Airport Road and Hidden Valley Road
On April 26, 1990, the Carlsbad City Council called a special meeting and gave it’s suppor
to a state/federal grant application submitted by Caring Residents of Carlsbad and Catholil
Charities for funding of a shelter project. Additionally, Council directed city staff to assis.
Caring Residents with in with development processing for the project, if funded.
In August of this year, Caring Residents of Carlsbad and Catholic Charities receivec
notification of funding for the emergency shelter project from the California Department 0:
Housing and Community Development (HCD). According to HCD, the group would bt
eligible to receive funding in excess of $345,000 which would have to be used towarc
construction and furnishing costs.
Once funding was verified, Community Development staff met with members of Carinl
Residents of Carlsbad to coordinate development processing and discuss potential planninl
and engineering issues related to the project. The group also asked the City to considel
providing financial assistance via a waiver of development fees. Subsequent to meeting wit1
Caring Residents, staff was notified that the property owner would no longer be able to offe:
the original parcel of land near Palomar Airport Road for the shelter site. Instead The
Carltas Company, offered an alternate site, south of the Carlsbad city limits. This parcel is
under the jurisdiction of the County of San Diego and within the sphere of influence of the
City of Encinitas (Green Valley area). In response to community support of the project,
staff contacted Carltas and asked them to reconsider the original site offered, or evaluate
other properties they own in Carlsbad. Carltas’ responded with an alternative site locatec
on the south side of Palomar Airport Road, just southwest of the original site offered
Planning staff evaluated this site and found significant environmental issues associated wit1
any use of this parcel. Issues included; no direct access to the property without destructior
e 0
of sensitive wetlands habitat, and the parcel lies within the 100 year flood plain. For these
reasons staff cannot recommend this site for the project. According to Carltas, the family'!
current offer to Caring Residents for the alternate site in the Green Valley area, still stand!
(see attached letter).
Kathleen Wellman of Caring Residents contacted both the Mayor and staff regarding thc
new offer. The City Council's initial direction to staff in April was to assist Caring Resident:
with development processing for the project, if they received grant funding. Since the
original site proposed in Carlsbad is no longer available, staffs direction from Council maJ
no longer be appropriate.
It would be my recommendation that the City Council consider these options with regarc
to recent events:
1. Withdrawing support for the project, given the potential change ir
location.
2. Providing continued staff support to Caring Residents in developing tht
shelter on the Ecke property located between the Cities of Encinitas
and Carlsbad, and under the jurisdiction of the County.
3. Directing staff to investigate alternative locations for the emergenq
shelter, either within the Carlsbad city limits or sphere of influence,
and assist Caring Residents in soliciting offers from other local
landowners.
Based the community support and recent meetings with the Mayor, staffs recommendatior
to Council would be to pursue option #3. According to Kathleen Wellman, they are anxiou
to find a fixed location in Carlsbad, since almost all of their volunteers are residents. She
has estimated they will receive a contract for the grant monies sometime in late November
or early December and are concerned that delays in obtaining a firm location could
jeopardize their funding. Staff has communicated our intention to take the "location issue"
forward to Council as soon as possible. Once the contract for the project and funding has
been signed, Catholic Charities will have only 14 months to complete the project. Given this
somewhat aggressive schedule, if Council selects option 3, staff will need to start investigating
alternate locations as soon as possible.
MARTY ORENYAK
M0:CH
a. *
November 16, 1990
Mr. Martin Orenyak
Community Development Director City of Carlsbad
2075 Las Palmas Drive Carlsbad, CA 92009
Re: Emerqencv Shelter
Dear Marty:
I received your letter of November 15, 1990. As you are aware, tk
willingness of the Ecke Family and its land holding company to mak
property available for the provision of the emergency shelter wa in recognition of the community needs and a desire on the part c
a number of citizens in the community to try and deal with
problem with which local governments and other public agencies ha%
had a difficult time.
For reasons related to both constraints involving the property ar the personal circumstance of members of the family, we ha\ determined that the site originally proposed would be inappropriat
for the Location of a such a facility knowing that at least a ful two-year period would be necessary to make the proposed shelte ;effective. Given environmental, land use, economic, and othe constraints, we have also determined that no other property unde our control in Carlsbad can be made available.
We have made a proposal to the Caring Residents of Carlsbad t
provide a location within the county in the area between Carlsba and Encinitas which we believe would both be suitable and could b made available.
However, we understand your concern and desire that the project b located within the City limits. We recognize the Carlsbad base o
the community group and the committed body of local residents
businesses, organizations and professionals, as well as thl
direction to the City staff to assist.
We also acknowledge that our willingness to assist in a temporar: solution is clearly less desirable than the City's participation il
a long-term solution.
5600 AVENIDA ENCINAS SUITE 100 CARLSBAD, mL1FORNIA 92008 US
(619) 431-5600 FAX (619) 431-9020
.< - w Q)
Mr. Martin Orenyak
Community Development Director City of Carlsbad November 16, 1990
2
-4.
\
We are aware that the City has substantial property much of wh has not been developed for other purposes, whose characterist are either good or better than any properties which Carltas ow
Because of the City's ownerships, this property would insurt longer term solution than a solution which involves the Carl properties.
Obviously, it would be less disruptive if property within the C
of Carlsbad could be provided. Given the temporary nature of project and the commitments that have been made by the City st to date which affect this project I we urge you to give seri consideration to the City's vast land holdings, or the county la within the boundaries of the City of Carlsbad, which could be m available for this limited, temporary shelter.
Finally, should this not be feasible and should the Car
Residents group choose to continue with the alternative we h
with the county administration in providing support of
application and processing within the county, since we underst
that the county will look to the adjoining cities for direction guidance in considering any such proposal.
proposed, we believe that the City could exercise its influe
very9m
Christdph . alk for a ltas Company
CCC/dsf
cc: City Manager
Assistant City Manager
Kathleen Wellman