The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About1991-04-16; City Council; 11111; Adoption of City Historic Resource InventoryCl’“‘OF CARLSBAD - AGENT- BILL ADOPTION OF TEE CITY OF CARLSBAD HISTORIC RESOURCE INVENTORY DEPT. RED I RECOMMENDED ACTION: Adopt Resolution No . g \-j\y approving the adoption of the City of Carlsbad's Historic Resource Inventory. I ITEM EXPLANATION: As part of the 13th year Community Development Block Grant program, the City Council approved funding for development of a Cultural Resource Survey. In addition, the City received a Certified Local Government (CLG) Grant from the State Office of Historic Preservation to augment the CDBG funds and provide for total funding of this project. The Cultural Resource Survey was conducted City-wide in an effort to identify sites/properties that have potential historic significance. February 18, The Survey report was completed 1991, and was received and approved by the Historic Preservation Commission. The completed Survey documents 325 sites of potential historic significance within the entire City's jurisdiction. The Survey report contains sufficient data on each site to establish and recommend appropriate historic site designation. Individual historic site significance was evaluated on the following grading scale: Grade 1: Major Significance; Potential National Register Resource (05 sites) Grade 2: Significant; Potential California State Register (06 sites) Grade 3: Local Carlsbad Significance (93 sites) Grade 4: Site designated for recognition purposes only; individually neither architecturally nor historically unique yet meets criteria for inclusion as a part of the historic fabric. On a per-site basis, additional research may be warranted if demolition is planned; upgrading to Grade 3 possible; many of these resources have been given a 3/4 grading. (221 sites) The recently amended Historic Preservation Ordinance provides for City Council adoption of a City Historic Resource Inventory. This Inventory would be comprised of a list of historic sites within the City. In order to establish the most up to date list of historic sites, it is the recommendation of the Historic Preservation Commission to adopt the Cultural Resource Survey report as the City's Historic Resource Inventory. PAGE 2 OF AGENDA BILL # 11. /I/ J ’ FISCAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact as a result of this action. EXHIBITS: 1. Resolution No. y/-j)y r 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 34 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 RESOLUTION NO. 91-114 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING THE ADOPTION OF TEE CITY OF CARLSBAD HISTORIC RESOURCE INVENTORY. WHEREAS, the City Council approved funding for a Cultural Resource Survey conducted for the entire City's jurisdiction; and WHEREAS, the Cultural Resource Survey was conducted City-wide in an effort to identify sites that have potential historic significance; and WHEREAS, the Cultural Resource Survey identified 325 sites of potential historic significance; and WBEREAS, the Historic Preservation Commission has received and approved the Cultural Resource Survey report; and WHEREAS, the City's Historic Preservation Ordinance provides for City Council adoption of a City of Carlsbad Historic Resource Inventory; and WREREAS,theHistoricPreservationCommissionrecommends the adoption of the Cultural Resource Survey report as the City of Carlsbad's Historic Resource Inventory. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED, by the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California, as follows: 1. That the above recitations are true and correct. 2. That the adoption of the Cultural Resource Survey report, a copy of report table titled "Table 1 - Summary of Evaluations,tU is attached as EXHIBIT '*At1 and incorporated herein by reference, as the City of Carlsbad Historic Resource Inventory is hereby approved. .- -. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California held on the 16th day of April , 1991, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: Council Members Lewis, Kulchin, Larson, Nygaard and Stanton NOES: None ABSENT: None ATTEST: ALETHA y RAU~ENKRANB, City Cl&k . (SE=) - EXHIBIT “A” TABLE 7 SUMMARY OF EVALUA77ONS Grade/ Significance Style Condition Level of Documentation ADAMS 314 3J4 314 3 314 3383 C 3401 C 3447 C 3640 B B/C - Spanish Vemaculal vemacuiar Spanish Eclectic (1923) VeXlMClllat Good Fair/Good Excell/Good Good 3781 C ARBUCKLE 3i4 752 C VematXlh ARLAND 2778 C B/C -Craftsman Good 314 BASSWOOD . vemacu1ar GOOd Vernacular Good BKI- Folk Vem Excell/Goocl 314 314 3 1252 C 1284 C 1432 B BEECH A GOOd/FZliI 3 retaining wall n/a (1920s) Folk Victorian (1887-1888) Livery Barn Vernacular (post 1928) Vernacular Craftsman (pre 1929) ExceWGood 3 258 A Good 3 Good/Fair 3 258 (barn) B 327 B 314 3 C B GOOd Excellbod 333 351 BUENA VISTA 314 314 314 Vernacular Good Vernacular Good/Fair Vernacular Good/Fair 1375 C 1444 C 1858 C 103 TABLE 7 CONTl SUMMARY OF EVALiJATlONS Grade/ Significance Level of Documentation Style Condition CARLSBAD BLVD A A n/a n/a @re 1925) Spanish Eclectic (1927) Spanish Spanish Eclectic (1927-1939) Carpenter Gothic (1894) Medieval European (1%3 Queen-Anne Vict (orig.- 1887) Spanish Eclectic ww Spanish Eclectic (1929) B/C- Craftsman B/C- Spanish Vernacular B/C- Spanish (1929-33) Good GOOd 3 3 Highway 101 RR overpass 2560 B GOOd 3 2564 C 2585 A Good 3f4 ExceU/Khod _ 3 2775 A Excell/Good 3 2802 A ExcelUGood 3 2978 A Excewaod I 2855 A ExceWcod 3 3003 ExceWcod 3 A 3406 B 3418 C 3424 C 3862 B GOOd Good GO0l.l Good 3 314 3J4 3 CHESTNUT B C C B C C C C C C C B Good 3 God/F& 314 Good/Fair 314 GOOCI 3 GO&F& 3f4 GOOCWi3if 314 GOOd/Fti 314 GOOd/Fak 3i4 Good/Fair 3/4 GOOd/Fti 3f4 GOCXl/Fti 314 Good 3i4 142 442 452 1088 1202 1211 1585 1645 1650 1674 1694 1749 B/C- Spanish Vernacular Vernacular B/C-Tudor B/C- Spanish Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular B/C- Spanish B/C Craftsman 104 .- - CHINQUAPIN 319 344 519 519 (rear) 608 CHRISTIANSEN 352 380 381 385 CHUPAROSA 1330 Level of Documentation Style Condition Grade/ Significance C C C B C A A C C A C B B C C A A A B/C -Spanish B/C -Spanish B/C -Spanish ve.macuiaf (pre 1928) Vernacular Good Good Good Fair GOOd/F& Vernacular @Fe 1919) Vemacular (1897; 1905) B/C -Craftsman BK -Craftsman ExCell/Good Excell/Good Good GOOd Craftsman Good ww CREST 2521 2597 2691 2729 DATE 314 EL CAMINO REAL El Camino Real 4867 (Kelly House) vemacu1ar veknacu1ar Vernacular (1938) Vernacular Good GOOd/FZiir Good Good/Fair Vernacular Good/Fair n/a BarIl ww Folk Victorian (1896) Excellent Deteriorated ExcelVGood 314 3f4 314 314 314 3 3 3l4 314 3 314 3 3 311 314 7 ‘I? 3 ELM 363 C Vernacular Good 314 395 C B/C- Spanish GCIOCI 34 TABLE 1 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUATIONS 105 TABLE 1 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUAIIONS Style Condition Grade/ Significance Level of Documentation ELM 400 A A A B C A B Carpenter Gothic w37) Commercial (pn 1925) commercial (1927-1930) Commercial (1930s) Commercial (1929-46) Vernacular ww Vernacular Excellent GOOd Good Good GOOd GOOd Good/Fair - 417-425 505 56@562 571 1166 1265 ELMWOOD C 2793 EUREKA 3218 C VernacUlar GOOCI 314 3236 - C Vernacular Good 3i4 FOREST Good 314 ExcelVGd 3 1323 C 1448 A Vernacular Vernacular (1894) GARFIELD Excell/Gocd 3 2650 A Vernacular (1933 B/C -Craftsman (pre 1928) Vernacular B/C -Spanish B/C -Spanish Vernacular B/C -Spanish Venacular Vernacular B/C- Spanish Vernacular B/C -Craftsman Vernacular ExcelVGood 3 3288 B 314 3J4 3 314 314 314 314 314 3/4 314 3t4 GCKXUFk GOOCUFti GClOd Good Good GCXXI Good GWd/Fb Good G&d 3319 C 3360 C 3363 B 3416 C 3423 C 3449 c 3487 C 3570 c 3588 C 3590 C 3622 C 106 TABLE 1 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUATIONS Level of Documentation Style Condition GradeI Significance GARFIELD 3688 C 3748 C 3839 B B/C -Spanish Vernacular B/C- Craftsman (post 1929) Vernacular Good Good Good Good/Fair 314 3/4 3 314 4016 C HARDING 2942 C Vernacular GOCXI 314 HAYMAR Marron Adobe A Spanish Eclectic (1842) ExcelMkod 2 HEMLOCK 335 vemacular C 314 HIGHLAND Excell/Good 3 Good 3/4 GWd/Fti 3 2658 B 2701 C 2916 A B/C -Spanish Vernacular B/C -Craftsman (pre 1929) Vernacular @re 1928) B/C -Tudor (post 1929) Neo-Classic (post 1929) B/C Craftman Carriage House (1887) Quenn-Anne Vict (1887) Vernacular B/C -Craftsman B/C-Tudor Spanish Eclectic (post 1928) B/C -Craftsman 2987 B 3 B ExcelUGood 3 3081 A ExceWGood 3 3057 3140 C B ExcelUGood 314 BxcelVGood n/a ExcelYGood 3 3140 B 3154 c * 3264 C 3307 B 3384 B Good 314 Good 314 Good 3 Excell/Good. 3 3252 C 314 107 TABLE 1 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUAnONS HIGHLAND 3690 3788 3798 3828 4095 4379 JEFFERSON 2446 C 2480 C 2546 C 2639 c 2753 C 2801 B 2879 B 2892 B 2928 C 2943 C 2959 C 3021 C 3037 C 3048 B 3071 C 3091 C 3111 C 3113 C 3463 C 3983 C 3971 B JUNIPER 146 270 369 C A C Level of Documentation Style Condition VernaCllbU B/C -Craftsman vernacular vemacular Colonial Revival ww VemaCular Good Excell/Good GoocuFair EXCdlfGOOCl ExcelllGood GOOd/F& B/C -Spanish B/C- Spanish VernaCulW vemacular B/C -Spanish Folk Victorian BK: -Craftsman B/C -Colonial (1928) Vernacular vemacular vernacular Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular B/C -Craftsman B/C -Craftsman Vernacular Vemacualf Vernacular Vernacular B/C- Spanish GOOdlFitir GOOCl/F& GOOdIF& GOOdIF& GOOdiF& ExcelUGood ExcelWood GOWF& 314 GOOdiF& 3J4 GCtOd 314 GOOdiF& 314 Good 314 GOOd/F& 3 GO0dfFS.G 314 Good 314 Good&air I 314 Good 3J4 G&Xl 314 Good 314 Good 3 B/C -Spanish Vernacular (pre 1928) Vernacular GOOCi GOOd GOOdlFtlif Grade/ Significance 3l4 3 3 3 3 314 314 314 314 314 3J4 3 314 3 3J4 3 3f4 108 , _. TABLE 7 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUAllONS Level of Documentation Style Condition Grade/ Significance KNOWLES 1101 B 1138 B 1279 C 1306 C B/C -Folk Vict B/C -Spanish Vernacular B/C -Craftsman GOOdIF& GOOdIF& GOOdIF& Good 3 3 314 314 LAGUNA 624 A Vernacular (1890s) Vernacular vernaculaf B/C -Engl Tudor Vernacular Good . 3 902 C 960 C 1216 C 1236 C GtXXVF& 314 GOOdIF& 314 Good 314 Good/I& 314 LINCOLN 3080 A Monterey (1925) Vernacular (1890-1910) B/C -Craftsman ExccWood 2 GOOd/Ftk 3 3112 B 3259 C Good 314 MADISON C B/C -Craftsman C Vernacular C Vernacular C Vernacular B B/C -Craftsman C B/C -Craftsman C Vernacular C B/C -Craftsman C Vernacular C Vernacular C Vernacular C Vernacular C Vernacular C B/C- Spanish C Vernacular GOtXVFti 314 GOCKVFti 314 GOOdIF& 314 GOOCUFaif 314 ExcelVGood 3 Good 314 Good/Fair 314 Good 314 Good 314 Good 314 Good 314 GCXXI 314 Good/Fair 3/4 GOCNI 314 GOCXI 314 2645 2714 2737 2738 2945 2951 2975 3120 3143 3145 3159 3167 3207 3208 109 TABLE 1 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUATlONS MADISON 3221 3230 3231 3240 3279 3291 3306 3315 ’ 3322 3354 3366 3367 3391 33% 3421 3429 3434 3437 3443 3455 3468 3475 3485 3516 3535 3580 MAGNOLIA 1098 B 1165 C 1184 C 11% B 1257 C 1281 C 1369 C MAPLE 158 Level of Documentation C Vernacular C vemacldar C VernaCti C vemaculiu C Vernacular C Vemacular C VemaCllk B vemaclllar C B/C -Craftsman C VeTnacular C Vernacular C vernacular C Vemacular C Vernacular C Vernacular C vemacu1ar C Venacular C Vernacular C Vemacular C B/C -Craftsman C Vemacular C Vernacular B Vernacular C Vernacular C Vemacular C Vernacular C Vernacular C B/C -Spanish GOOd Style Condition GOOCUFi32 Good Good GWd Good Good GOOdIF& Good Good GOOdIF& Good GWd Good GOOd GOOd GOOdlFik GOOd Good Good Good Good ExceWGood GWdfFi-iir GOOCUFti Good GWdlFti B/C -Spanish Vernacular Vernacular Craftsman (pre 1929) Colonial Revival (post 1929) Vernacular B/C -Craftsman Excell/Good Good Good Good ExcelVGood GOOdIF& GOOCUFti GradeJ Significance 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 3 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 3 314 314 314 314 3 314 3/J 3 110 TABLE 7 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUA77ONS Style Condition Grade! Significance Level of Documentation MOUNTAIN VIEW 3 2476 B Vernacular GOOlllFti NORMANDY 314 221 B B/c -Craftsman EXCdUGOOd OAK 314 314 314 314 314 3l4 3 335 354 897 1139 1199 1173 1212 vernacular vernacular vemacular vemacular vernacular VernaCular CraftsIniUl tP= 1=9 Vtmacular vemacu1ar (188~90s) Good Good GOOdlF2lh GoocVFair - GOOdlFZk Exccwood 314 3 1337 1542 C A OCEAN 2480 C B/C -Spanish 2634 C vemacular 2688 C Vernacular 2901 C Vernacular GOOd Good GOOdIF& 314 314 314 314 PACIFIC C B/C -Craftsman Good 314 230 PARK Vernacular Vernacular Good/Fair 3 Fair 3 4050 4055 C B PINE 314 314 GOOd GWd 926 C 938 C Vernacular Vernacular 111 (next) 982 C Vernacular 1022 C B/C -Craftsman 1028 C B/C -Craftsman 1144 C B/C- Spanish 1190 C B/c- Craftsman 1198 C Vernacular 1232 B Vemacular 1250 C vemacular 1260 C vernacular 1308 C vemaculaf 1344 c vemacular 1366 C VemaWk 1475 C B/C -Spanish PI0 PICO 2359 2392 ROOSEVELT 2569 2578 2667 2740150 2747 2906 2921b 3055 3085 3091 30% 3147 3155 3190 3203 3206 3243 3255 3256 Level of Documentation C C C C C C C B B C C C C C C C C C C B. C TABLE 1 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUAllONS Style Condition Fair Good Good Good/Fair Good/Fair GOOdiF& GOOdiF& Good GOOdIF& GOOd Good GOOCUFb VenraCular Good Vemacular Good vemacular Vernacular Vemarcular Vernacular Vernacular B/C -“Pueblo” Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular B/C -Spanish Vernacular Vernacular B/C -Spanish Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular Vernacular B/C -Craftsman GOOdlFZiir GOOd Good Good GOOd ExcelVGood ExcelVGood Good GCXMVFC GOOCUFti Good Good Good/Fair GOOdiF& Good FairDeterio GOCd Grade/ Significance 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 3/4 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 3 3 314 3f4 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 314 3 314 112 ’ ‘. TABLE 1 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUATIONS Level of Documentation Style ’ Condition Grade/ Significance ROOSEVELT 3280 C 3286 C 3304 B 3309 A vernaclllar B/c -Craftsman Commercial Vernacular (1918) Vernacular (pre 1929) vemacular B/C -Spanish (1923) B/C -Craftsman B/C -Craftsman Vtinacular VemaCIll~ vemacular B/C -Craftsman um Vernacular 314 314 3 1 GOOd Good/Fair FairDeterio 3312 B 3 3328 C 3329 A GOOdJFti Fair/De&o 314 1 3 314 314 314 314 3 3379 B 3395 B 3408 C 3420 - c 3435 C 3442 A Exccll-Good Excell-Good Good Good Good/-Fair . Excellent 3594 C Good 314 SEQUOIA C C Good Good 314 314 172 3941 vernacular Vernacular SPRUCE 2245 2246 C Vernacular C B/C -Spanish Good GCXXi 314 314 STATE 2627 C 2633 C 2639 B 2646 C 2647 C 2787 A Vernacular Vernacular B/C -Craftsman Vernacular Vernacular Commercial (1924-29). Commercial (1926-27) Commetiial (1920s) Spanish Eclectic (1925) vemacular Good/Fair 314 GOOdiF& 314 Excell-Good 3 GOdfFklif 314 GOOdlFti 314 Good 3 2822 A GOCUI 3 2900 Block A Good 3 2901 314 A 2929 (rear) B 3 113 * “ . TABLE I CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUATIOEIS Level of Documentation Style Condition Grade/ Significance STATE B Commercial (pn 1929) Commercial @rc 1925) Commercial (1925-29) B/C -Tudor (1938) VellUWk Vernacular Commercial (1925-1929) B/C -Spanish Excell/Good 3 A 2 B Good 3 B 3 C C B Good Good Good/Fair 314 3/4 3 3080 C Good 3l4 Sunny Creek Rd 2770 A Adobe + Outbuild. (1838-1842) EXCCI-DCteliO SYCAMORE 151 c 155 C 165 C 168 B B/c -Spanish B/C -Craftsman B/C -Craftsman B/C -Craftsman Good Good Good ExcelUGood 314 314 314 3 TAMARACK 148 C 234 C 310 B 522 C Vemacular B/C -Spanish B/C -Craftsman B/C -Spanish Good. GWCI ExcelUGood Good 3J4 3i4 3 314 TYLER 3190 3176 3281 3327 3344 3395 Vernacular B/C- Spanish B/C -Craftsman Vernacular Vernacular Verhacular DeteriOfilkd lktWiOt@Xi Excell-Good Good GOCldlFtik DeteriO~ted 3 3 314 314 314 314 114 C ‘ Level of Documentation VALLEY 3215 WASHINGTON 2733 C 2747 C WILSON 2628 C 2736 C 2779 C OTHER CaIavera Lake/Dam Cdavera School CaIavera Rock Quamy EI Camino ReaI Edna Power Plant Ranch0 10s Quiotes Stage Coach Park C A A A A A A A TABLE 7 CONT. SUMMARY OF EVALUA77ONS Style vernacular VemacuIar Vernacular VemaCular Vernacular vemaclllar n/a n/a n/a n/a da MiX- Spanish-American Adobe Condition GOCXVFti Good Good/Fair GOOd Good/Fair Good Gone n/a n/a Excellent GWCJ/F& IkkXiOrated Grade/ Significance 314 3i4 314 314 314 314 2 115