HomeMy WebLinkAbout1993-02-09; City Council; 12070; CITY COUNCIL POLICY ON APPOINTMENTS TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION, DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AND HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE,
I
BOARD AND HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT
Adopt, by minute motion, amended City Council Policy No for appointments to the Planning Commission, Design Re Board, and Housing and Redevelopment Advisory Committee. n C 0
*I-! U U rd
U -d w
V
a m
0 w
a, c, 3 G
ITEM EXPLANATION
On June 18, 1991, the City Council adopted Policy No. 47 wl
ad limited membership on the Planning Commission, Design Re? Board, and Housing and Redevelopment Advisory Committee to 01 terms. The proposed amendment would add an exception to
h policy to extend an individual's term if there are extenua. circumstances, such as the need for a suitable number
m experienced members. The extension cannot exceed the le. of a regular term.
2
a, a, m
5 a, a
FISCAL IMPACT
W
G
EXHIBITS 2s $;
1. City of Carlsbad Council Policy Statement No. 47 a, Ch o*
!-I*
wz
ah a,U
.rl 0 UPI d 05 ua, L, ma (do
00
2:
3%i E4 u Y-i -rl V C aJ3 so BV
cr)m am \\
14
c\I\ r\l
2
ma P
a
ij
b 0
d
z
0 s
I
CITY OF CARLSBAD
Policy No.
COUNCIL POLICY STATEMENT Date Issued Feb. 1
Effective Date Feb . Cancellation Date- General Subject: Appointments to Boards, Commissions
and Committees Supersedes No.
dated June 18,
Specific Subject: Term Limitations for Appointments of Members to the Planning
Commission, Design Review Board and the Housing and Redevelopment
Advi so ry Co m mitt e e
Copies to: City Council, City Manager, City Attorney, Department and Div
Employee Bulletin Boards, Press, File
PURPOSE: In order to provide more citizen participation in decisions
affecting Carlsbad, appointments to the Planning Commission,
Committee, shall be limited to two consecutive terms.
Design Review Board and HousinS & Redevelopment Advisory
P 0 LI CY:
1. The City Council of the City of Carlsbad will appoint members of 1
Commission, Design Review Board, and Housing and Redevelopmc
Committee to a maximum of two consecutive terms.
An individual retiring after two terms will be immediately eligible for c
for any other board, commission or committee, or could be reco
appointment to the same board or commission after a two year waitin
Individuals initially appointed to an unexpired term would be el
reappointed for two consecutive terms.
The City Council may make an exception to this policy and extend a1
term if there are extenuating circumstances, such as the need for a suit
of experienced members. The extension shall not exceed one year
granted only one time.
2.
3.
4.
ISP c' LCHL - .' Lf$/ fhlA 0
League of Women Voters
North Coast San Diego COUI
&-5k& -
'.
February 9, 1993
dl[ &[e Mayor Claude "Buddy"Lewis A
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Bear Mayor Lewis:
The League of Women Voters advocates an open governmental
system that assures opportunities for citizen participation in government decision making. With this position in mind, in 1988 the Carlsbad Unit- of the League of Women Voters of North Coast San Diego County undertook a study of citizen participation in Carlsbad city government. One of the recommendations that arose from tne study was to limit membership on citizen advisory bodies to two terms where there are qualified applicants, continuing the policy of staggered terms. On June 18, 1991, the city council adopted
Policy 47 implementing term limits on city boards, committees and commissions.
Tonight the council is considering amending Policy 47 to
allow the extension of the terms of members of the Planning
Advisory Corcmittee if there are "extenuating circumstances" such as the need for a suitable number of experienced members
The extension could be for a period as long as a regular term of four years in addition to the two terms or eight years already permitted by the present ordinance. Such an extension would defeat the purpose of policy 47 which
is to allow as many citizens as possible to participate in citizen advisory bodies.
Are there other "extenuating circumstances" that would make extended terns necessary or is the concern solely the lack of experienced members? If so the way to assure that there will be an adequate number of experienced members is to allow as many citizens as possible the opportunity
to serve. Another solution to lack of experience would
be to provide intensified training for appointees. the present process for making appointments to advisory
the necessary familiarity with the work of the board to
insure that they will quickly be able to make contributions.
Commission, Design Review Board and Housing and Redevelopment
Perhaps
bodies could be reviewed to insure those appointed have
P.O. Box 727, Cardiff-by-the-Sea, California 92007
0 e -. - *
League of Women Voters
North Coast San Diego COUI
To sum up, the League of Women Voters opposes changes to Policy 47. on a particular advisory body can be solved in other ways than changing the excellent policy of term limitations
you have already adopted. staggering terms and while experience may be important, the need to give more citizens an opportunity to serve, bringing fresh outlooks and new ideas to the job should take precedence.
A temporary shortage of experienced members
Continuity will be assured by
Sincerely, h+%/ Jane Feezel,
P.O. Box 727, Cardiff-by-the-Sea, California 92007