HomeMy WebLinkAbout2005-06-28; City Council; 18188 Exhibit A; Ponto Beachfront Village Vision PlanJUN-28-2885 11:16F1 FR0M:PLRNNING SYSTEMS 768 931 5744
Sincerely
Seth Schulberg, President
T0:7289461
EGEOVE To.
c;4> c\+
=%. CCL
4&Ljit:. ci
CITY OF CARLSBAD CITY CLERK'S OFFICE
P: 2'2
k Batiquitos Lagoon Foundation
Preserve. Protect and Enhance
June 28,2005
Carlsbad City Council
1200 Cartsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, California 92008
AGENDA ITEM # // U Mayor
City copndl
cl9-
City Manage@
CttpAttomq
Subject: Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
The Batiquitos Lagoon Foundation (BLF) has been striving to presewe, protect and
enhance the Batiquitos environs since 1984. We wish we could preserve the Ponto
area in its current semideveloped state. We also recognize the development rights
.granted by the City zoning ordinance and Master Plan. Given that development will
occur in this area, we believe that the City's effort to develop a vision plan that provides
a unifying theme for future development, while protecting the environment to the extent
possible, is appropriate. We think the City demonstrated excellent forward thinking in
developing the Vision Plan.
We firmly believe there are environmental factors that must be considered in developing
the Ponto Beachfront Village Area. The site's proximrty to endangered species nesting
grounds requires setbacks and buffers, while the area's proximity to Batiquitos Lagoon
and the Pacific Ocean require aggressive use of Best Management Practices for urban
runoff and storm water management. The public's right of access to this area must be
safeguarded by expansion and connection to the existing trail network, provision for
adequate public parking and prohibition of gated communities.
We understand that the Vision Plan provides a preliminary environmental assessment
and defers site specific concerns until development plans are proposed. We encourage
the city to continue its usual aggressive enforcement of county, state and federal
statutes that protect our environment. We look forward to working with the City in
crafting sensitive solutions for Ponto Beachfront Village that will benefit both our City
and the environment.
POB 130491 Carlsbad. California 92013-0491 760 895.3501
AGENDAITEM# 4 11
I Mayor
City Cound
City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk Questions about the Ponto Vision Plan
Joanne VanMeter
5 16 Stern Way I
Carlsbad, CA 92009
1. Will any of the parking that will be developed be paid parking?
2. Will beach goers be allowed to use the parking in all of the parking garages for free?
3. Where is the approximately 104 parking spaces mentioned that will be west of 10 1 ?
Theses are not show in the vision plan. Are these spaces the current spaces provided?
4. This weekend, RVs stayed overnight without being ticketed on 10 1, despite my
neighbors calling the police to have them enforce our laws. The police did not respond.
The neighbors called the police to ask why they didn’t respond and were told that the
police were too busy. How can we enforce laws in future high density growth without
the current laws in the current less dense situation being enforced?
5. How many restaurants with views are proposed? The vision plan looks like it doesn’t
maximize the views for the public by providing the maximum amount of restaurants.
There should be many competing restaurants to keep quality standards higher and provide
the public with more choices. What if you don’t like something about the only offered
restaurant? Ideally, we will have choices, with views.
6. What is the fire code for current dry brush that exists on the proposed development
plan. Some of it looks to be head high. I’m concerned about a person driving by and
flicking out a cigarette on this area. Could we please get this scrub mowed in the
meantime?
7. Stern Way will have increased parking due to the added features of this development,
the open gate to the trail and the bridge that is proposed to cross over the train tracks.
Would it be possible for the city to install a gate for this community so the effect of
residence, who pay for our own streets and are not allowed to park on their own streets
per HOA rules, will be minimized?
8. A street light needs to replace the 4 way stop at Avenida Encinas and Marlin to
improve the traffic. Could this be added to the Mitigated Negative Declaration?
9. The interpretive wetlands are poorly placed in relation to actual wetlands that need
protecting. Could this interpretive wetland park be placed at the south end the
development, next to the lagoon, where an actual wetland exists? It would be better to
fill that low lying land with an alternate use and protect the lagoon’s endangered habitats
with a wetland park than to have stagnant water in the middle of a Mix use center. It will
also attract mosquitos.
1 ’ CITYOFCARLSBAD ’ CITY CLERKS OFFICE I
10. How can a vision plan be created when it is unknown how far a setback will be
required due to the proximity of the least tern, gnat catcher, and snowy plower? These
endangered species were not mentioned in the Mitigated Negative Declaration. If it is
found that development is too close to these protected species, the Vision Plan was
created prematurely and certainly voted on prematurely. A full EIR should be done to
settle the popular opinion by the public that this plan needs to be viewed as a whole to
understand how it affects all aspects of the environment.
Ponto Beachfront Village Draft Vision Plan
Dated May 2005
Chapter 1, page 1
The live/work area only of benefit to a few people. There could be better use of this
space that benefits more people.
Chapter 1, page 2
“Increase and improve the affordable housing supply”
This will lower existing residential neighborhood’s property values and is an
inappropriate use of rare and valuable coastal property. There is adequate inland land
supply for affordable housing and therefore using rare coastal for this purpose is not
necessary or prudent.
Chapter 1, page 7
There is mention of Ponto’s southern edge being a jurisdictional wetland. All structures
on the southern edge are depicted much to close to that southern edge. Parking should be
underground each of the resort buildings and the restarant is in an ok location but needs
to be set much further away from the southern edge.
Chapter 1, page 10 Wildlife
The mitigation plan does not call for the recommendation on this page. “It is
recommended that focused protocol surveys for these species be conducted to determine
whether they are present within the study.” Snowy plower and Least tern should be
added to the study.
Chapter 1, page 11 Coastal Bluff Erosion
It is stated that the erosion of the northerly edge of Batiquitos Lagoon could erode at 1”
per year. Given that, setbacks need to be adjusted for long term erosion.
Chapter 1, page 15 Walkways
“The existing access points shall be improved as part of a State Parks and Recreation
Master Plan for Carlsbad State Beaches.”
This Vision Plan will impact walkways to the beach and therefore should be part of this
Vision Plan, paid for by the developers of the Vision Plan.
Chapter 2, The Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan
There is no public grass park in the area, suitable for children to play in, neighbors to
meet for a picnic or families to play a game of football in walking distance to this Vision
Plan or for the existing neighbors. The southern edge of the Ponto Vision plan would
provide the public with a park and a buffer between development and wildlife.
Chapter 2, page 3 Mixed Use Center
The “heart” of the Ponto Beachfront Village provides a useful mix of shops and
restaurants. However, the townhouses or live/work units seem misplaced in an area that
is potentially high traffic. This space would be better served by more shops that could be
useful to many, rather than a live/work unit that can only be useful to a few.
Chapter 2, page 4 Bus Pavillian Needed
Currently there are people waiting for the bus at the corner of Avenida Encinas and
Carlsbad Blvd. In the diagram of this intersection, there is no provisions to upgrade this
area with a shaded Bus bench. This should be done.
Chapter 2, page 5 Wetland Interpretive Area
Having a wetland area in the middle of a shopping area defeats the purpose of shopping
and ignores the fact that true wetlands on the southern edge of this development are being
encroached upon. Better would be to provide a wetland interpretive area at the southern
end of the Beach Resort, where buffer is needed between wildlife and development.
Chapter 2, page 6 Beachfront Resort
The parking garage, restaurant and pool are too close to the Lagoon’s edge and do not
provide noise and disturbance level needed for wildlife to flourish. Parking could be
accomplished under each resort building and the swimming pool could be moved. The
restaurant building should be reduced in half to provide more park like space for the
public and for wildlife.
Chapter 2, page 13 LiveNork Neighborhoods
It is not desirable to force any current owners to sell their property for eminent domain
purposes for any use except for public good. Taking private property via eminent domain
for the purpose of selling to another private party should not be allowed. Private property
rights should be protected if they do not want to sell their land or “blighted” residence.
Even if all parties are in agreement of this sell, a live/work neighborhood is not in the
general interest of many people and only benefits a few. Using this space for restaurants
or shops would serve the public better.
Chapter 2 page 20, Avenida Encinas
The stop signs at Avenida Encinas and Meridian Way need to be replaced with a light so
that traffic can flow freely through Avenida Encinas and only stop if there is a pedestrian
or vehicle that will trigger the light to change.
Chapter 2, page 27, Bicycles
Bicycle racks are needed at the beach, north of the lagoon, south of Avenida Encinas and
west of Carlsbad Blvd.
Chapter 2, page 28, Sidewalk System
Figure should show that raised sidewalks are needed north and southbound extending to
La Costa Boulevard.
Chapter 2, page 29 On-Street Parking
It is not clear if there is currently “1 04 spaces along Carlsbad Boulevard” or additional
parking will be added to achieve 104 spaces.
Chapter 4, page 8 Developer Actions
Surrounding Neighborhood Impact Review needs to be added to the list of Developer
Actions.
Chapter 4, page 8
Need to specify “raised sidewalks” versus just “sidewalks” on the north and south bound
lanes.
Environmental Impact Assessment Form - Part 11, dated March 1,2005
Case No. GPA 05-04, LCPA 05-01
1) All appropriate agencies need to be listed on page 1, number 8.
page 1: 8. Other Public Agencies Whose Approval is Required:
Should be:
0 California Coastal Commission
Army Corps of Engineers
California Deparmtment of Fish and Game
CoastGuard
And the agency that approves that the Environmental Impact Review is
completed and states that all issues have been mitigated.
0 The agency that approves that the Long Beach Settlement is not being
2) An Environmental Impact Report should be required before completing the
Vision Plan.
page 4: Wrong box selected. Box that should have been selected:
“I find that the proposed project MAY have a significant effect on a the
environment and and Environmental Impact Report is required.
Justification:
1) No mention of endangered species, least tern or snowy plower, is mentioned in
any report. The endangered least tern nesting grounds are adjacent to this
development. A study needs to be done to determine what impact this
development will have on the least tern.
2) Lagoon erosion at the rate of 1” per year will cause setbacks to change. 3) Noise generated near the lagoon could impact 183+ migratory birds that include
endangered species nesting grounds.
4) Impact of additional storm drainage into Batiquitos Lagoon. Ref. Ponto Vision Plan, Ch 4 page 13, “All development will ultimately drain into the existing 84-
inch storm drain system.
5) According to the Vision Plan, “Impacts to any western burrowing owl and coastal
California gnatcatcher bird species would be significant, if present and could pose
a constraint to development of the disturbed lands and disturbed coastal sage
scrub, respectively. It is recommended that focused protocol surveys for these
species be conducted to determine whether they are present within the study
area.” The EIR should include this study.
Concerns and Recommendations:
Due to the nature of protected species along the lagoon and the lagoon’s erosion
rate, it is recommended that the setback be greater than what is currently shown
for species protection and bluff erosion purposes. It is recommended to have the
parking structure for the Beach Resort be built under the Resort versus so near the
edge of the Lagoon.
Also, a full Environmental Impact Review needs to be conducted
3) Gate and Public Restrooms Needed.
Page 13 and page 30 “Recreation Facilities Needed”
XIV a) Increased use of existing neighborhood and regional parks.
Gate Needed
Due to the removal of public street parking currently used for beach use, the
additional attractions offered for this area by the Ponto Visoin Plan, and the
addition of a bridge over the train which will connect the Batiquitos Lagoon trail
to the Beach Resort, there is a high potential for increased parking in the San
Sebastian neighborhood.
San Sebastian residence are not permitted to park on their own street, however the
public is allowed to park on these streets. Public parking on these streets is not
currently an issue due to adequate street parking for beach goers east of Carlsbad
Blvd and use of the private land where the Beach Resort will eventually be built.
The residential parking issue creates a disconnect between what the residential
area is allowed to do (not park in front of their homes) and what the public can do
with the residence’s streets (park in front of residence homes).
To mitigate this issue, a gate for the residence of San Sebastian at the entrance on
Windrose and Magellan is requested so that the streets of San Sebastion can be
used only for the residence.
Public Restrooms Needed:
The beach north of the lagoon has no public restrooms. Permanent public
restrooms are needed to prevent public urination near bushes (as is the case
today). Also, beach users will cross the street to use hotel and restaurant
restrooms unless they are provided for them on the beach.
4) Crossing Light Needed
Page 14, XV “Transportation/Traffic”
Crossing Light at Avenida Encinas and Meridian Way
Increased traffic on Avenida Encinas will require the stop sign on Avenida
Encinas and Meridian Way needs to be replaced with a crossing light. This will
allow traffic to flow when there is no activity crossing Avenida Encinas.
5) “Effect on Species” section incomplete.
Pg 20 IV a) Effect on species
No mention is made about the development’s effect on the 183+ avian species known to
migrate through Batiquitos Lagoon (ref batiquitoslagoon.org). Of particular concern,
there is no mention of the endangered least tern or snowy plow. This is a blatant
oversight.
Ref: http://www.npwrc.usgs.gov/resource/birds/wsplover/results.htm
According to http://www.dfg.ca.gov/hcpb/info/brn researchhm ~dfi-~ts/94 07.~df, on
The California Least Tern Breeding Survey states, “Habitat loss due to human
development and climatic events (e.g., storms and flooding), other types of human related
disturbance, predation, and adverse environmental conditions, particularly El Niiio,
continue to dampen recovery of the species.”
A study on how noise and proximity to human disturbance effects the least tern nesting
needs to be conducted to define if the standard setbacks are adequate given the proximity
to this endangered species.
6) Setbacks inadequate on the lagoon side.
Pg 21 Setbacks
“Consistent with setback and buffer requirements of the City of Carlsbad Habitat
Management Plan, all future development shall be sited at a proper distance from
designated open spaces.. .”
The problem with setbacks in this case is that the lagoon is eroding at a rate of 1” per
year minimum, according to the Vision Plan. Setbacks were probably not established
with moving buffers in mind. Therefore, an environmental impact report is needed to see
if the legal minimum setback is still adequate given that the setback will erode over time.
7) Effects of additional runoff in storm drainage unknown
Pg 25 Water Quality
It is stated in the Vision Plan that storm drain discharge will be dumped into the lagoon
utilizing the existing 84” storm drain. It is unknown what the additional impact to marine
and avian life will be with this added oil, pesticide, and trash dumped into the lagoon.
Since the water to be drained comes from the entire Ponto Vision Plan, it is imperative a
water quality impact report be prepared before the vision plan is approved.
All pollutants of concern should be defined and mandated for removal prior to
development contracts submitted.
8) Add Avenida Encinas and Meridian Way to failing intersection list
Pg 36 Potentially Significant Impact Unless Mitigated:
Need to add Avenida Encinas and Meridian Way to the failing intersection list.
9) No Noise, Lights or Odor Impact Done for Current Neighborhoods Bordering the
Ponto Vision Plan
The Vision Plan calls for multi-level parking structures, hotel and resort swimming pools
and parking lots that will generate noise and light late into the night. There has been no
study done to quantify this impact to existing residences. If the findings are that noise
will increase in the area, the Vision Plan should address what will be done to buffer the
noise.
The Vision plan allows for “Restaurants with dancing or entertainment”. This will
increase noise levels to surrounding neighborhoods if permitted noise levels are not
defined.
Also, winds predominantly blow onshore. It is not shown where trash receptacles will be
placed, where restaurant exhaust will be, vehicle exhaust and other odor producing
sources were be. There is no mention of these or other odor sources. There should be
provisions that there will be no increase of odors in existing neighborhoods.
Pg 38 a) Impact to Environment
Since there was no adequate environmental study done, and for the Justifications listed in
#2 above, there is no way to adequately answer the question of if this plan impacts the
environment. The answer to question XVII a) should be, “Not enough information” or
“Not enough data”.
Thank you for your consideration of existing neighborhoods.
Joanne VanMeter
516 Stem Way
Carlsbad, CA 92009
WORDEN WILLIAMS APC
AGENDAITEM#
c: Mayor
Representing Public Agencies, Private Entities, and Individuals
city Cod
4 CityMUuger
CffJTAtt0-Y *- June 27,2005
City Council
City of Carlsbad
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, California 92008
Re: Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
Case Number: GPA 05-04LCPA 05-01
Appellant:
Dear Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council:
This office represents the Ponto Action Committee (“PAC”), a group of local
citizens who are concerned with the proposed Ponto Beachfront Village Vision
Plan (hereafter “Vision Plan”). PAC includes residents of the Hanover Beach
Colony to the north of the Vision Plan site, residents of the San Pacific0
community to the east, and other concerned residents of the community.
The principal concern with the Vision Plan is the failure to prepare an
environmental impact report (“EIR” ) as required by the California Environmental
Quality Act (“CEQA’). An EIR is a comprehensive document that considers all
potentially adverse impacts of a project and then identifies mitigation measures
and alternatives that could avoid or reduce the severity of impacts. It is a “big
picture” document that allows decision makers to consider the entirety of large
projects, such as the Vision Plan, and consider ways that the project can be
mitigated or modified to lessen adverse impacts. For example, could commercial
uses be moved further away from residential areas to avoid impacts? Could traffic
circulation within the development area be changed to avoid conflicts with
existing communities? Could specific standards be put into place to lessen visual
AREAS OF PRACTICE
PUBLIC AGENCY
LAND USE AND
ENVIRONMENTAL
REAL ESTATE 1 PERSONAL INIURY
~ ESTATE PLANNING
AND ADMINISTRATION
1 CIVIL LITIGATION
ATTORNEYS
TRACY R RICHMOND
D. WAYNE BRECHTEL
TERRY J KILPATRICK
TERRY M CIBBS
MALINDA R. DICKENSON
MICHAEL B FURMAW, LL M
Of Counsel
D. DWIGHT WORDEN
Of Counsel
W. SCOTT WILLIAMS
Of Counsel
OFFICE
462 STEVENS AVENUE
SUITE 102
SOLAVA BEACH
CALIFORNIA
92075
(858) i55-6604 TELEPHONE
(8 5 8 I 75 5 -5 19 8 FhCSl jUl LE
www.wordenwilliams.com
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 2
impacts to communities to the east? Could the property be developed as a park?’ Although
the Vision Plan identifies two alternatives that were considered at a workshop some time ago,
there is no comparison of the environmental merits of the various alternatives.
If the City approves the Vision Plan as proposed without doing an EIR, the ability to consider
the “big picture” will be lost because the basic plan, which identifies the specific uses and
roadways, will have been approved. Environmental review in the future, to the extent there
is any, will be limited to the details of individual projects. The ability to make meaningful
changes to the overall Vision Plan will have been lost. The City can and must do better.
PAC requests that the City Council deny the Vision Plan and associated General Plan and
Local Coastal Program approvals on the grounds that the environmental review for the Vision
Plan is inadequate and direct that staff prepare an EIR that fully and adequately addresses the
potential impacts of the Vision Plan, so that consideration of meaningful mitigation measures
and alternatives can occur before it is too late.’ Set forth below is a more detailed overview of
the reasons for this request.
A. The Citv Maw Not Use A Mitigated Negative Declaration Because There Is A
Fair Argument That The Vision Plan Maw Have A Sianificant Effect On The
Environment.
Whenever there is substantial evidence that a proposed project may have a significant effect
on the environment, the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA’) requires the lead
agency to prepare an Environmental Impact Report (“EIR) prior to considering approval of
The City’s LCP cites the need for “low cost” visitor accommodations or recreation in
the unplanned area of the Poinsettia Shores Master Plan. For example, the LCP suggests
planning a public park for the unplanned area west of the railroad tracks. The LCP encourages
parks to be at least 5 acres, but there is nothing to say that the park could not be larger than
5 acres in this area. The reference to a public park is omitted from the Vision Plan’s description
of the LCP in Chapter 1, page 15. The unplanned area has been designated in the Vision Plan
for mixed use development. Although the mixed use includes a wetland interpretive area, this
is a small part of the entire unplanned area. The City should explore alternatives that include
more public park uses.
‘In addition, I hereby incorporate by reference and renew the objections made in my
April 22, 2005 letter commenting on the inadequacies of the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
K\Clients\Lipbow\Letters\CityCouncil.Wl .EIR Required.M.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 3
the project. (Pub. Resources Code 8 21080(d) and 21151; 14 Cal.Code Regs. 9 15064(a)(l),
(f)(l).) In what has become known as the “fair argument” standard, a lead agency must
prepare an EIR if substantial evidence supports a fair argument of a potential adverse
environmental effect, even if the public agency is presented with contrary evidence. (Friends
of “B” Street u. City ofHayward (1980) 106 Cal.App.3d 988, 1002.) In other words, agency
evidence that an impact will not be significant cannot overcome other evidence supporting a
fair argument of significance. It is one of the few instances in which any agency does not get
the benefit of the doubt. Further, a disagreement among experts regarding the significance of
an impact triggers the need to prepare an EIR. (14 Cal.Code Regs. 9 15064(g)) The fair
argument standard furthers CEQA’s goal of protecting the environment by creating a strong
presumption in favor of preparing an EIR. (See Pub. Resources Code 88 21000-21002.)
In this case, City staff proposes use of a Mitigated Negative Declaration. A Mitigated Negative
Declaration is an abbreviated form of environmental review under CEQA that is only permitted
when there is no fair argument of a significant impact and it can be demonstrated with certainty
that a project will not create any significant adverse effects on the environment. (Pub.
Resources Code 8 21080(c)( l).) Such is not the case here.
A situation similar to this matter arose in City ofRedlands u. County ofSan Bemardino (2002)
96 Cal.App.4th 398. There, the County of San Bernardino adopted an amendment to its
General Plan concerning the County’s sphere of influence. As in the Ponto Road matter, the
County of San Bernardino argued that an EIR was unnecessary since the amendment was
merely clarifying the County’s authority relating to planning (Id. at 406) and that future projects
would undergo further environmental review when a project was actually proposed. (Id. at
409.) The Court disagreed. The Court noted that the general plan amendment contemplated
future development and that the County failed to reasonably anticipate the effects of such
development. (Id. at 409.) The Court found that the County’s reasoning was nonsensical
because while conceding the amendment was designed to facilitate greater development, it
denied there was any possibility of a significant adverse effect on the environment. (Id. at 409.)
The same is true in this case. The City of Carlsbad is proposing to amend its General Plan and
Local Coastal Program to facilitate specific and intensive development immediately adjacent
to a busy highway and a residential neighborhood. The Vision Plan is the first step in a land
use process that will result in future development of the Ponto site. Thus, under CEQA, the
City must “use its best efforts to find out and disclose all that it reasonably can.” (14 Cal. Code
Regs. 8 15144.) Likewise, the City must consider all phases of the project. It may not limit
environmental review by claiming additional studies will occur later. (City of Antioch u. City
K\ClientsLipbow‘\Letters\CityCoundl.O01 .EIR Required.02 .wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 4
Council (1986) 187 Cal.App.3d 1325 [piecemeal review of development resulting in use of
negative declaration was improper even though future developments would be examined in
EIRs] .)
The City’s duty under CEQA to do all it reasonably can was recently discussed in County
Sanitation District No. 2 of Los Angeles County u. County of Kern (2005) 127 Cal.App.4th
1544. As the Court explained, “under CEQA, the lead agency bears a burden to investigate
potential environmental impacts. ‘If the local agency has failed to study an area of possible
environmental impact, a fair argument may be based on the limited facts in the record.
Deficiencies in the record may actually enlarge the scope of fair argument by lending a logical
plausibility to a wider range of inferences.”’ (Id. at 1597, citing Sundstrom u. County of
Mendocino (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 296,311 .) Here, the City is avoiding its duty to investigate
potential impacts and the evidence submitted by my clients and other members of the public
leaves no doubt that such adverse impacts are possible.
The Mitigated Negative Declaration is lacking detailed analysis of potential adverse effects of
the Vision Plan. Rather than analyze these issues now, the Mitigated Negative Declaration
claims that additional studies can be undertaken later when site specific proposals are
presented. Indeed, the proposed findings acknowledge a variety of potential adverse effects
on biology, cultural resources, and noise, but then defers analysis of these effects to a later time.
The Biological Section, for example, acknowledges there are endangered and rare plant and
animal species that occur on site and that development could potentially affect these species.
The mitigation, however, is simply to do a more comprehensive study and develop appropriate
mitigation at a later time. This is absolutely not allowed under CEQA. (Sundstrom u. County
of Mendocino (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 296 [deferral of analysis and mitigation would skirt the
requirement for public review and agency scrutiny of environmental impacts]; Gentry u. City
of Murrieta (1995) 36 Cal.App.4th 1359, 1396 [condition requiring compliance with a
mitigation measure that might be recommended in the future was improper] .) Accordingly, the
City must require an EIR to be prepared before going any further on the Vision Plan.
The bottom line is that the City must prepare an EIR for the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision
Plan. The Vision Plan sets forth a plan of how development is anticipated to proceed,
including the location and types of development, and the City must do all that it can to
anticipate the potential effects of such a development. The City must match the level of detail
in the environmental review to the level of detail in the Vision Plan. Enough is known about
the scope of the Vision Plan that such impacts can be evaluated. Indeed, my clients, at their
own expense, have identified several of these potentially significant effects in the areas of traffic
K:\Clients\Lipbow\Letters\CityCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 5
and noise levels. Thus, there is substantial evidence supporting a fair argument that the Vision
Plan may have a significant effect, and an EIR is therefore required. (Pub. Resources Code
0 21080(d).)
1. SiRnificant Traffic Effects
Attached to this letter as Exhibit “A” is a letter from Susan Rosner of Kimley-Horn
Associates that details numerous adverse traffic effects of the Vision Plan that were not
adequately analyzed or mitigated in the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
As an initial matter, the traffic counts used in the Mitigated Negative Declaration appear
to have underestimated the volume and effects of summer beach traffic in the area. For
example, some of the traffic counts were taken in April when there is little or no beach traffic,
and others taken in July on a weekday when traffic would be less than a weekend. However,
during the summer and fall, residents report that Ponto Road and surrounding streets can
become filled with cars since there are few other areas where beach goers can park in this area.
This situation will likely become worse once the project is developed because it will attract even
more beach goers who will be drawn by the increased parking created by the Vision Plan.
This, in turn, will cause increased congestion and increased conflicts between pedestrians and
cars along Carlsbad Boulevard. The City must therefore return to the drawing board and revise
the traffic counts based on realistic estimates of summer beach traffic.
Another problem with the traffic analysis is that it failed to consider the additional traffic
that would be generated on the Garden Hotel site if that site is developed as a visitor-serving
commercial development, as permitted under the Vision Plan and related amendments. As Ms.
Rosner explains, if this occurs, 84,000 square-feet of commercial space could be developed and
generate 10,080 average daily trips with 403 trips during the morning peak hour and 1,008
trips during the afternoon peak hour. This is far in excess of the 1,500 total trips, 90 morning
peak trips, and 120 afternoon peak trips considered in the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
Indeed, Ms. Rosner points out that coupled with traffic from the nearby Hanover Beach
Colony, the level of service at certain intersections could drop to an LOSF. This is a significant
effect that must be analyzed and mitigated in an EIR.
Another concern is that the Mitigated Negative Declaration failed to analyze several
important issues involving pedestrian-safety along Ponto Road, which is currently used by area
residents to access South Carlsbad State Beach. For example, we know that the City is
proposing to locate a parking garage across the street from the Hotel. This in turn will lead to
K:\Clients\Lipbow\Letters\CityCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 6
pedestrians crossing Ponto Road to get to the hotel and/or beach. There is no specific
provision for crossing lights or speed limit restrictions and it is likely that pedestrian/vehicle
conflicts will occur due to the speed of the cars and the curvature of the road in this area.
Specifically, drivers will not be able to stop in time and pedestrians could be seriously injured
or killed as a result.
Another flaw in the Mitigated Negative Declaration is its conclusion that potential effects
to “unplanned” areas will be insignificant based on the assumption that potential uses under
current planning could be worse. This is an inappropriate method for analyzing the potential
adverse effects of a project. The proper starting point for an analysis is “the physical
environmental condition in the vicinity of the project” as it currently exists. (14 Cal.Code Regs. 8 15125(a); Cadiz Land Co. u. Rail Cycle (2000) 83 Cal.App.4th 74, 99 [the environmental
setting should be quantified in order to assess the magnitude of change] .) Thus, because the
unplanned area does not currently generate any traffic, the City must assume that any
additional traffic that could occur in this area will worsen traffic conditions. It cannot compare
the Vision Plan with the theoretical traffic that might exist if the property were built out under
the policies of the current general plan.
Finally, it is noted that the MND identified an impact to the intersection of La Costa
Avenue and the Coast Highway. However, no mitigation for this impact is proposed on the
assumption that the City of Encinitas will be making street improvements that would mitigate
for this impact pursuant to the City of Encinitas’ Highway 101 Corridor Specific Plan. There
is no assurance that the City of Encinitas’ mitigation will take place, or if it does, if it will be on
line by the time that the impacts from the Vision Plan occur, leaving this traffic impact
unmitigated.
2. Significant Noise Effects
Attached to this letter as Exhibit “B” is a letter from RickTavares of Investigative Science
and Engineering, Inc. that details numerous potentially adverse noise effects that were not
adequately analyzed or mitigated in the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
As explained by Mr. Tavares, the Mitigated Negative Declaration is completely lacking
the detail and analysis necessary to make the conclusion that the Vision Plan will not result in
any significant adverse impacts. Indeed, had the City looked at the amount of noise that would
be generated by expected traffic along adjacent roadways, it would have been evident that
noise increases as high as 6.8 dBA CNEL would exist, and that the City’s significance threshold
K:\ClientsVipbowUatters\CityCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 7
of a 3 dBA increase would be e~ceeded.~ More importantly, Mr. Tavares points out that
compliance with the Noise Element will not adequately mitigate such adverse effects.
Mr. Tavares also points out that the Vision Plan does not address the fact that a noise
contour of 60 dBA CNEL will intrude at least 500 feet into the project, which is a significant
effect and is not mitigated nor required to be mitigated in the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
Finally, Mr. Tavares identifies a number of significant adverse noise impacts that can be
expected to occur in connection with the development and operation of a hotel including
HVAC, pumps, blowers, truck deliveries, amplified music, and traffic. The City cannot put
these issues off to another day. Instead, the City must address these issues now and identify
feasible mitigation measures so that the viability of the project design can be evaluated and
mitigation measures and alternative design issues can be explored while they are still feasible.
3. Significant Biological Effects
The Biological Resources section of the Mitigated Negative Declaration identifies several
significant environmental effects of the Vision Plan which have not been adequately mitigated.
For example, the biology section states that four sensitive plant species have been found on site
and that impacts to sensitive plant species are significant. Further, the biology section concedes
two sensitive bird species, including the endangered American peregrine falcon, were observed
on site. Additional evidence will be submitted to you that the threatened California gnatcatcher
is also found on site. Future development will clearly adversely affect these rare and
endangered species by destroying their habitat and killing individual species. However, the
Mitigated Negative Declaration claims that all adverse impacts will be mitigated by conducting
a “comprehensive site-specific biological resource analysis” and developing a mitigation
strategy to avoid impacts. This is woefully inadequate under CEQA. Although the City may
have the best of intentions, the fact is that this approach neither identifies the seriousness of the
adverse impacts or commits the City or the applicant to any particular mitigation requirement.
There are no performance standards or other objective measures by which one could
The City has always identified an increase of 3 dBA CNEL as the threshold for
analyzing significant noise effects as outlined in the City’s Noise Guidelines Manual’s project
processing procedures (page 24). For example, this significance threshold was recently used
in the environmental review for the Villages of La Costa project and the La Costa Robertson
Ranch.
K:\Clients\LipbowVeters\CityCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 8
determine if the City was able to avoid adverse biological impacts. Instead, there is only an
acknowledgment that a development could create significant adverse impacts, and then an
unenforceable promise to mitigate the impacts with some unknown method sometime in the
future.
B. The Citv Is AttemDtinn To lmproperlv Defer Analvsis Of Potential Adverse
Effects
In many parts of the Vision Plan, it is said that additional environmental review and mitigation
will be undertaken when a specific proposal is put forward. This is an inappropriate deferral
of the City’s obligation to analyze such potential effects now as required by CEQA.
I understand the City’s theory that a future study could be more precise to the extent that more
will be known about the exact type of development being considered. However, this approach
is not permitted under CEQA because the reality is that once a project has gone this far, it tends
to make it difficult or impossible to implement feasible alternatives and mitigation measures.
Instead, public agencies are required to explore these issues early on in the planning process
while changes in design are still feasible.
The City already knows a great deal about the development that will occur if the Vision Plan
is approved. The proposed Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan provides for a very intense
development, including up to: 147 Condos, 260 Hotel Units, 800 Timeshare Units, 176
Apartments, 22,000 square feet of office space, 41,000 square feet of specialty retail space and
3 restaurants. The Vision Plan identifies these uses, and their approximate location in enough
detail to analyze the potential impacts at this time. The City has required an EIR for this scale
of development in the past. For example, the City just issued a notice of preparation for the
La Costa Town Square Project, which entails 81.8 acres and proposed the following: Mixed
use 302,000 square feet shopping center, 53,000 square foot cinema, 30,193 square foot
tenant warehouse, 63 square feet detached residential units, 120 multi family residential units
and 45 affordable housing multi family units.
This very issue is addressed in section 15004 of the CEQA Guidelines, which states: “Choosing
the precise time for CEQA compliance involves a balancing of competing factors. EIRs and
negative declarations should be prepared as early as feasible in the planning process to enable
environmental considerations to influence project program and design and yet late enough to
provide meaningful information for environmental assessment.” ( 14 Cal. Code Regs.
0 15004(b) .) And the “Discussion” section following section 15004 goes further and explains
K:\ClientsVipbow\Leters\CityCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 9
that early preparation of the appropriate environmental document enables agencies to make
revisions in the project before the agency becomes so committed to a particular approach that
changes can only be made with difficulty.
Thus, while there is some logic to waiting to undertake environmental review at a later time,
on balance, it is an undesirable and impermissible approach because it jeopardizes the ability
of public agencies to fulfill CEQAs goal of implementing feasible alternatives and mitigation
measures.
This case is virtually identical to other situations in which courts have not hesitated to declare
the use of a negative declaration inappropriate when approving planning type documents. For
example, in City of Redlands u. County of San Bernardino (2002) 96 Cal.App.4th 398, the
Court set aside a negative declaration and required the use of an EIR for a general plan
amendment. Likewise in City of Liuermore u. Local Area Formation Commission (1986) 184
Cal.App.3d 531 the Court set aside a negative declaration used for changes in a sphere of
influence guidelines for urban development. The common thread between the above cases
and the current Ponto Road Vision Plan is that at a certain point the planning process becomes
concrete enough for the lead agency to study the range of potentially adverse effects, even if
some forecasting and assumptions need to be made. In this case, while there is bound to be
some uncertainty in analyzing the potential effects of the Vision Plan, the process is far enough
along for the City to make some reasonable assumptions about the adverse effects of the
proposed project. On the other hand, if the City approves the Vision Plan and waits to
undertake environmental review until a specific development proposal is put forward, both the
City and private landowners and developers will have invested a considerable amount of time
and money into a relatively specific plan that will be hard to modify, should it be necessary or
desirable to do so.
C. Future Environmental Review Is Illusorv Because The Nenative Declaration
Is Presumed To Cover Evervthinn Currentlv Beinn Considered Bv The Citv.
City Staff has suggested that any adverse effects that may result from the Vision Plan can be
studied at a later time. However, additional environmental review of subsequent projects is
required unless one of the following standards is met: (a) substantial changes are proposed in
the project that will require major revisions to the Mitigated Negative Declaration; (b)
substantial changes occur with respect to the circumstances under which the project is being
undertaken that will require major revisions to the Mitigated Negative Declaration; or (c) new
information of substantial importance to the project, which was not known at the time the prior
K\Clients~pbow\Letters\CiiyCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 10
environmental document was certified as complete, becomes available. (Pub. Resources Code
0 21166; 14 Cal.Code Regs. 0 15162.) The basic premise of these criteria is that no further
environmental review will be required if the Mitigated Negative Declaration already discussed
the potential impact at issue. The adequacy of the discussion will not be relevant because
Mitigated Negative Declaration will be presumed adequate and further environmental review
will only be required if the strict standards of Public Resources Code 21166 are met. Finally,
the strict “fair argument” standard will not apply to future decisions regarding environmental
review, making legal challenges to decisions not to prepare EIRs extremely difficult. In other
words, with the City’s current approach, it is quite possible the potentially adverse effects of the
Vision Plan will never be adequately studied in an EIR. Indeed, private landowners and
developers would be within their rights to insist that no subsequent environmental review can
be required unless at least one of the conditions of Public Resources Code section 21166 is
met.
D. The Vision Plan Is An Inadequate SDecific Plan
Staff has asserted that the Vision Plan does not permit any specific development but is meant
only to provide general guidance for development. However, references to the Vision Plan
have been incorporated into both the General Plan and the Local Coastal Program, which do
establish development entitlements. It is therefore disingenuous to portray the Vision Plan as
a non-binding, advisory planning document. To the contrary, the purpose of the Vision Plan
is to provide specific implementation measures of the General Plan for this area. In other
words, the function of the Vision Plan is really to serve as a Specific Plan. However, the Vision
Plan does not contain all of the content required of a Specific Plan. (Gov. Code 0 65451 .) The
Vision Plan is therefore an inadequate Specific Plan.
In order to be adequate to serve as a Specific Plan, the Vision Plan must contain text and
diagrams that specify all of the following elements:
(1) The distribution, location, and extent of the uses of land, including open space.
(2) The proposed distribution, location, and extent and intensity of major
transportation and infrastructure components needed to support the land uses
proposed in the plan.
(3) Standards and criteria by which development and conservation measures will
be implemented.
K:\Clients\Lipbow\Letters\CityCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 11
(4) A program of implementation measures including regulations, public works
projects, and financing.
The Vision Plan does not contain all of the above required elements and therefore is an
inadequate Specific Plan. For example, the Vision Plan does not contain adequate standards,
criteria and regulations to guide development, nor does it contain a financing plan. Before
going any further with the Vision Plan, the City must identify the above-elements and prepare
a legally adequate Specific Plan. Alternatively, the City should abandon the proposed Vision
Plan and wait until an actual development proposal is put forward, which can then be
evaluated on its merits.
Further evidence that the Vision Plan is designed to serve as a Specific Plan can be found in
the proceedings of the City Housing and Redevelopment Commission. In February 2002, that
Commission approved a Work Plan for development on a Land Use Strategy for the South
Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Project Area by adopting Resolution 351. (Attached as
Exhibit “C.”) The Work Plan explained the status of the South Carlsbad Area and outlined a
phased approach to developing a Land Use Strategy. According to the Work Plan, a Specific
Plan is required “for any development within the Ponto Area”. It appears, therefore, that the
Ponto Vision Plan is supposed to be the Specific Plan envisioned by the Commission.
However, for the reasons discussed above, the Specific Plan is incomplete and legally
inadequate.
E. Conclusion
Based on the foregoing, PAC respectfully requests that the Council not approve the Ponto
Beachfront Village Vision Plan, its associated General Plan and Local Coastal Program
Amendments, or the associated Mitigated Negative Declaration. The City has not undertaken
adequate environmental review, and there is a fair argument that the project, as proposed, has
the potential to substantially and adversely affect the environment. Further, to the extent that
the Vision Plan is supposed to serve as a Specific Plan for this area, it is legally inadequate and
must be revised.
K:\Clients\Lipbow\Letters\CityCouncil.KJl .EIR Required.02.wpd
City Council, City of Carlsbad
June 27,2005
Page 12
I appreciate your consideration of these comments and am available to answer any questions
you may have.
Sincerely,
WORDEN WILLIAMS, APC
D. Wayne Brechtel
dwb@wordenwilliams.com
DWB:re
Attachments
cc: Client
Gary Barberio, Planning Department
Deborah Fountain, Housing and Redevelopment Director
K:\Clients\Lipbow\Letters\CityCouncil.OOl .EIR Required.02.wpd
EXHIBIT A
June 24,2005
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel
Worden Williams APC
462 Stevens Avenue, Suite 102
Solana Beach, California 92075
RE: Comments on the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision
Plan, Transportation/Traffic Section of the Mitigated
Negative Declaration, and Traffic Constraints Study
Dear Mr. Brechtel:
Pursuant to your request, &ley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
has reviewed the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan, the
Transportation/Traffic section of the Mitigated Negative
Declaration, and Traffic Constraints Study. I am a certified
planner with 16 years of experience in transportation planning.
I have been with Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc., a nation-
wide engineering and planning fum, since 1992. My role at
Kimley-Horn involves project management, preparation of a variety of transportation planning studies including traffic and
parking studies, traffic study review, etc. My review of the
subject documents revealed a number of instances in which
potentially significant traffic impacts were not adequately
disclosed, analyzed or mitigated. I explain in more detail
below.
The analysis does not meet the requirements for traffic analysis outlined in the Congestion Management Program
(CMP) Update (January 2003) for the San Diego Region.
1. The CMP states that all large projects, defined as having
a daily trip generation of 2,400 or more trips or 200 or
more peak hour trips is required to prepare a CMP
analysis. The Ponto Vision Plan is projected to generate
12,407 trips on a daily basis with 72 1 morning peak hour trips and 1,102 afternoon peak hour trips.
Following are a number of aspects that demonstrate
that the analysis for the Ponto Vision Plan does not meet
the CMP requirements.
w
Suite 140
2100 W. Orangewood Avenue
Orange, California
92868
m
TEL 714 939 1030
FAX 714 938 9488
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel, Page 2, June 24, 2005 rn Kimley-Horn 0 and Associates, Inc.
a) Freeway mainline locations where the project
adds 50 or more peak hour trips in either
direction were not analyzed.
A Near-term Cumulative analysis was not
conducted.
Arterial and signalized intersection analysis using
the methodologes in the Highway Capacity
Manual (HCM) were not conducted
The effect of the project on ramp metering was
not analyzed.
The traffic constraints analysis for the Ponto Vision Plan was
conducted for typical weekday traffic conditions with traffic
counts made in July 2003 and April 2004. Summer weekend
peak analysis should be analyzed as well.
2. While typical weekday traffic analysis is necessary for all
development projects, because the proposed Vision Plan
is in an area of high seasonal beach usage, an analysis
of summer weekend peak hours should be looked at
also. Increased pedestrian activity that would take
place due to the proximity to South Carlsbad State
Beach along with the increased traffic from the Vision
Plan and increased summer beach traffic could have
significant traffic, safety, parking, and circulation
impacts that have not been identified.
Access to the Garden Hotel and the associated hotel parking structure to and from the south needs to be considered as an
alternative to access on Ponto Road because there may be
potentially significant traffic and safety impacts associated
with the proposed access on Ponto Road.
3. The entrance to the proposed Garden Hotel, which
appears to align with Whitewater Street at Ponto Road,
has the potential to cause significant traffic and safety
impacts. For example, increased traffic at this location could have significant impacts on intersection capacity
and delay and physical conflicts between vehicles and
pedestrians. A clearer representation of the specific
access provisions that will be in place for the hotel is
important issue in terms of identifylng potential significant impacts to the Hanover Beach Community
neighborhood that have not been analyzed and for
which there are no mitigations. Potential impacts are
discussed in more detail in Comment 7.
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel, Page 3, June 24,2005 rn Kimley-Horn 0 and Associates, Inc.
4. The location of the Garden Hotel parking structure
access, which appears to be located on the opposite side
of Ponto Road from the hotel, coupled with the
pedestrian activity that would take place across Ponto
Road between the structure and the hotel has the
potential for significant traffic and safety impacts.
Potential impacts could include the possibility of injury
or fatalities of pedestrians being hit by vehicles due to
pedestrians crossing the road to the hotel in a location
where vehicles are accessing the parkmg structure. The
only way to eliminate this significant impact is to
prepare a sight-distance analysis.
5. Because of the curvature of Ponto Road in the vicinity of
Whitewater Street, the traffic study should address line-
of-sight issues in conjunction with the proposed access
to the Garden Hotel and to the associated parking
structure to determine if there would be significant
safety impacts associated with vehicular turning
movements into and out of the hotel access/Whitewater
Street and Ponto Road/ parking structure access and along Ponto Road. The location of the parlung structure
access in relation to the curve on Ponto Road to the
north of the parking structure access could contribute
to sight distance problems and to the possibility of
injury or fatalities to pedestrians crossing Ponto Road to
the hotel depending on the specific speed of the street in
the future. Sight distance needs to be addressed using
City of Carlsbad standards for sight distance to identify any potential safety issues to motorists and pedestrians.
These potentially signlficant impacts have not been
analyzed and identified. If significant impacts are
found, alternative access provisions should be analyzed.
Changes in land use for several of the character areas, as discussed in the vision plan could have potential significant
traffic impacts that have not been analyzed and identified and
for which mitigation measures have not been developed.
6. A change in land use in the Garden Hotel area could
have potential significant traffic impacts that have not been identified and analyzed and for which mitigation
measures have not been developed. Based on the discussion in the vision plan in Chapter 2, pages 16-17,
if it is determined that the Garden Hotel is not suitable
for the site, then the vision plan suggests that
neighborhood or visitor-serving commercial uses could be located on the site. The commercial land use should
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel, Page 4, June 24,2005 rn Kimley-Horn 0 rn and Associates, Inc.
be analyzed as an alternative to determine if there would
be adverse traffic impacts. The Garden Hotel site is
approximately 8 acres. This would translate to about
84,000 square feet of commercial uses that could be
developed on the site. Based on the SANDAG traffic
generation rates, this amount of commercial would
generate about 10,080 trips on a daily basis, with 403
trips during the morning peak hour and 1,008 trips
during the afternoon peak hour. This level of tripmaking is far in excess of the trips analyzed for the
Garden Hotel which is estimated to generate 1,500 trips
on a daily basis, with 90 trips during the morning peak
hour and 120 trips during the afternoon peak hour,
based on the SANDAG rates. Potential commercial uses
could have a far greater impact on the adjacent roadway system. Results from a preliminary analysis are
discussed in Comment 7.
7. The project has the potential to cause signlficant traffic
impacts at the intersections of Ponto Road/Windvane
Lane and Ponto Road/Whitewater Street that have not
been identified and analyzed and for which mitigation
measures have not been developed. These intersections
provide access to an existing residential neighborhood.
It appears that the intersection of Ponto Road/
Whitewater Street will align with the proposed main
entrance to the Garden Hotel. I have estimated morning
and afternoon peak hour traffic volumes based on an
estimated number of homes in the Hanover Beach
Colony (approximately 70 homes), applied trip rates
from the San Diego Association of Governments Traffic
Generators publication for single-family dwelling units,
and made an estimate of existing through traffic along
Ponto Road based on the data in the traffic study for the Ponto Vision Plan. The two unsignalized intersections
were analyzed using the Highway Capacity Software.
The results of the analysis (worksheets attached)
indicate that the critical movements at the two
intersections currently operate at Level of Service (LOS)
A. Using data in the traffic study for the Ponto Vision
Plan, I analyzed the two intersections assuming the Garden Hotel use and through traffic from the other
proposed uses in the Plan. The LOS with the hotel
would be B or better during both peak hours. I then
applied the trip generation for retail land uses as
discussed in Comment 6 above and re-analyzed the two
intersections. The analysis indicates that there could be
LOS F delays at the intersection of Ponto/Whitewater,
assuming that the retail access would align with existing
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel, Page 5, June 24,2005 rn Kimley-Horn
and Associates, Inc.
Whitewater. The addition of traffic to this area may
result in other unacceptable delays and/or capacity
problems that have not been identified. To address
these potentially significant impacts, these intersections
should be added to the traffic constraints analysis so
that traffic impacts of the proposed project on these
intersections and others can be evaluated for existing
and Year 2030 traffic conditions with alternative land
uses.
Analysis using incorrect lane geometry may result in incorrect
conclusions about the level of service at the intersection of
Carlsbad Boulevard/Avenida Encinas.
8. The existing intersection geometry for the intersection of
Carlsbad Boulevard/Avenida Encinas (#26) appears to
be incorrect. Based on a review of recent aerial photos,
the intersection appears to actually be made up of two
adjacent intersections. The northbound and
southbound approaches of Carlsbad Boulevard are
separated by a vacant unimproved area. Review of the
westbound left-turning traffic volumes at the western intersection suggests that because of the short stackmg
distance between the two intersections, there is a
possibility for queues of vehicles to back up across the
eastern intersection, potentially blocking traffic at the
eastern intersection. This condition could have the
effect of causing intersection delays, congestion and
accidents. Intersection analysis should be conducted
for each intersection separately so that appropriate
conclusions can be made about the operation of the
intersections.
9. The potential for significant impacts to pedestrian
circulation has not been considered in the documents.
Pedestrians are common in beach areas, particularly
during the summer months. Area residents currently
use Ponto Road as pedestrian access to and from South
Carlsbad State Beach. It follows that with increased traffic from the proposed Vision Plan coupled with
existing pedestrian traffic and future pedestrian traffic
that would be generated by the future uses in the Vision
Plan. there would be potential significant impacts in
terms of physical conflicts between pedestrians and
vehicles that have not been identified and analyzed and
for which mitigation measures have not been de\.eloped.
Increased vehicles and pedestrians could lead to
increased conflicts that could result in injuries and/or
fatalities to pedestrians.
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel, Page 6, June 24,2005 m Kimley-Horn 0 m and Associates, Inc.
Please feel free to contact me if you have any further needs on this
matter.
KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES, INC
- F91WJ&&U@!
Susan Rosner, AICP
Transportation Planner
K: \94446000 Ponto\06-24-05 VISION PLAN.doc
Knnley-Horn o,n and Associates, Inc.
Susan E. Rosner, AlCP
Susan Rosner is a transportation analyst with sixteen years of professional
experience in the fields of transportation planning and traffic engineering.
She has contributed to numerous environmental impact reports, traffic impact,
parking, modeling/forecasting, and traffic signal coordination studies. Her
experience in transportation planning and traffic engineering include field
investigations, site plan review, trip generation and distribution, capacity and
level of service analysis, signal synchronization analysis, traffic impact
analysis, transportation modeling and forecasting, report preparation and
project management.
Education
- Bachelor of Arts in Geography
(emphasis in Geo-Techniques),
and Minor in Business,
California State University,
Fullerton, 1985
- Two semesters of Computer-
Aided Design classes,
Fullerton College, 1985-1986
Professional Organizations
Previous Experience
- Transportation Analyst,
Basmaciyan-Darnell, Inc.,
Imine, CA 1989- 1992
- Cartographer, Robert J. Lung
and Associates, Tustin, CA
1987- 1989
- Cartographer, NFOTEC
Development. Inc., Costa
Mesa, CA 1985-1987
- American Planning
Association (APA)
- American [nstitute of Certified
Planners (AICP)
Kknley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
Susan E. Rosner Transportation Planning
Principal Area@) of Practice
Traffic Impact Studies for
Traffic Impact Studies . Parking Studies
9 Traffic Modeling and Forecasting
Traffic Signal Coordination Studies
Environmental Impact Reports
Traffic lmpacf Studies for Environmenfal
Impact Reports
Long Range Development Plan for
UCSD, La Jolla, CA
621 E. Colorado Residential,
Pasadena, CA
Quarry Creek Shopping Center,
Oceanside, CA
Old Grove Marketplace,
Oceanside, CA
UCSD East Campus Developments
La Jolla, CA
Ontario Center Redevelopment,
Ontario, CA
Sheraton Hotelhfixed Use
Development, San Gabriel, CA
TnQuest ResidentialDndustrlal
Development, Oceanside, CA
Quivira Basin Redevelopment,
San Diego, CA
Harbor Boulevard Smart Street,
Orange County, CA
Christopherhill Residential
Development, San Diego County, CA
Winchester Hills Specific Plan.
Temecula, CA
Rancho de Oro Village 12.
Oceanside, CA
Homestead Village, El Segundo, CA
hey Ridge Estates, Oceanside. CA
ranyon Vlctq nceancide f
Pacitic Coast Plaza, Oceanside. CA
Camp PendletonINAS Miramar,
OceansideiSan Ihego. ('A
- Christ College, hne, CA
- Rancho San Vicente, Ramona, CA
- Coyote Hills East, Fullerton, CA
- North County Fair Rail Extension of
the Oceanside to Escondido
Commuter Rail, Escondido, CA
- Eli LillyiIVAC Campus Point
Planned Industrial Development,
San Diego, CA
- Relocation of Los Angeles Air
Force Base, Los Angeles, CA
Traffic Impact Studies
Cancer Center on the East Campus
of UCSD, La Jolla, CA
Science Research Park on the East
Campus of UCSD, La Jolla, CA
Jeffries Ranch Residential,
Oceanside, CA
Hanson Aggregates Plant,
Oceanside, CA
El Camino North Shopping Center,
Oceanside, CA
Costco Wholesale Warehouse and
Gas Station, Fullerton, CA
Rancho del Or0 Retail Center,
Oceanside, CA
Del Oro Marketplace, Oceanside,
CA
1800 Space Parlung Lot on the East
Campus of UCSD, La Jolla, CA
Charter School on the East Carnpub
Closure of Salk Institute Road
Entrance at UCSD, La Jolla. C.4
Holtze Hotel and Office
Development, Newport Beach. ('A
West C ounty Commerce Center.
Huntington Beach. CA
La Jolla, CA
UCSD Ilillcrest Medical Center,
of UCSD, La Jolla, CA
T Ilk L"Jh' di TdII2J PlilLS,
San Lht'go, CA
Kirnley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
Susan E. Rosner Transportation Planning
Traffic lmpact Studies (continued)
Henderson Warehouse,
Henderson, NV
Scottsdale Auto Mall,
Scottsdale, AZ
Village Church, Rancho Santa Fe, CA
La Caiiada Day Care Center,
La Caiiada, CA
Creekside Terrace, Agoura Hills, CA
Ocean Ranch Shopping Center,
Laguna Niguel, CA
Ruby’s Jaguar Diner, Newport
Beach, CA
Tract 4968, Fallbrook, CA
Relocation of the Pastoral Center of
the Catholic Diocese of San Diego,
San Diego, CA
Parking Studies
West Anaheim Medical Center,
Anaheim, CA
Amaryllis Court Adult Care,
Anaheim, CA
Centro Vida Church,
Anaheim, CA
Costco Wholesale Warehouse and
Gas Station, Fullerton, CA
Costco Wholesale Store and Gas
Station. Corona, CA
Arctic Cold Storage Facility,
Anaheim. CA
Lakeshore Towers, Irvine, CA
Anaheim Convention Center,
Anaheim, CA
Cinemapol idlmperial Promenade.
Anaheim. CA
UCSD - Hillcrest Medical Center,
San Diego. CA
Vcrh:j I !!:& t’1,7,r1 Yorh IAinc!a c‘4
-Mission Center, Oceanside, CA
- University High School, Irvine, CA
Traffic Modeling and Forecasting
- Traffic Model Update, City of
Oceanside, CA
- Traffic Model Update, City of
Flagstaff, AZ
- Holder Street Bridge Analysis,
Cypress, CA
- SANDAG Model for Rancho
Santa Fe Community, Rancho
Santa Fe, CA
Traffic Signal Coordination Studies
- Fair Oaks Avenue Corridor,
- Oceanside Boulevard at RDO
- Clairemont Mesa
South Pasadena, CA
Gateway, Oceanside, CA
Boulevard/SR-l63, Clairemont
Mesa, CA
- Avenue S PSR, Palmdale, CA
- North Torrey Pines Road,
San Diego, CA
I TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
~~ Project Description
EastMlest Street Ponto Road NorthlSouth Street: Whifewater Lane
Intersection Orientation. East-West Study Period (hrs) 0.25
Vehicle Volumes and Adjustments
Major Street Eastbound Westbound
Movement 1 2 3 4 5 6
L T R L T R
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95 0.95 0 95 095 1 0.!5
Proportion of heavy
Ponfo Whitewater AM fX.hcu
Volume (vehlh) 3 20 0 0
Hourly Flow Rate (vehlh) 3 21 0 0 IoI vehicles, P,, O ! -- ! --
IGeneral Information /site information
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
Movement
Analyst ser
AgencylCo . kh a
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analysis Time Period AM Peak Hour
Undivided
0
1 0
TR
0
Southbound
0 d
LT I 0 1 0 0
0
Northbound
I
7 8 9 10 11 12
intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
Volume (vehlh)
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
Ponto at Whitewater
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
0 0 0 10 0 10
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
0 0 0 10
Percent grade (YO)
Flared approach
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Storage
0 0
N N
0
0 0
-2OlII 0 2
d LR
0 I 0 0 0 0
Approach I EB WB North bound
Movement 1 4 7(8 9
Southbound
10 I 11 1 12
1- IAwroach LOS
Lane Configuration
Volume, v (vph)
Capacity,~,, (vph)
vlc ratio
Queue length (95%)
Control Delay (siveh)
LOS
i __ i __ i
1 I LT I I I I LR I
1 1 1563 1 I I 1 953 I 3 -..-.-J111201-
Oo0 l2lII
0 01 1 IIL
1 73 lIlIl~89
A l2IIdlA---
0.02
0 06
i A
Amroach delav isiveh) __ _. 89
TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
General Information
Analyst ser
Agency/Co. kha
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analysis Time Period PM Peak Hour
Site Information
Intersection Ponto at Whitewater
Jurisdiction City of Carlsbad
Analysis Year Apnl2004
East/West Street Ponto Road
Intersection Orientation. East- West
North/South Street. Whitewater Lane
Study Period (hrs) 0.25
I I 0
Flared approach I2 I Storaqe I I 0
Major Street
Movement
IRT Channelized? I I I 0 I I I 0 I
Eastbound Westbound
1 2 3 4 5
ILanes I 0 I 0 I 0 I 0 I 0 I 0 I
L T R
I1 40 0 I Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0 95 0.95 0.95
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) I1 42 0
L
0
095
0
Proportion of heavy lo
vehicles. P,,, 1 0: 1 I -- --
Volume, v (vph) i?I!/I-2114-/
Capacity, c,(vph) 1 1560 1 I 929 I I
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Undivided
0
0
0 I 0 I
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
I 0 0 I1
Northbound Southbound
Movement 8 9
T R
Volume (veh/h) 0 0 0
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) 0
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95 0.95 0 95
10 11
L T
7 0
7 0
0.95
Movement 1 4 17 18 19 I IO/ 11 1121
vic ratio
Queue length (95%)
Control Delay (slveh)
LOS
0 01 ILd I 002 j I
oE'&llA-
73 1 /&dl 89 12 AIIlIlLA~
TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
Major Street
Movement
Analyst ser
AgencylCo. kha
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analysis Time Period AM Peak Hour
Eastbound Westbound
1 2 3 4 5 6
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
I L T R
Ponto at Whitewater
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
L T R
Project Description
EastWest Street: Ponto Road INorth/South Street: Whitewater Lane
Ponto Whitewater AM EX plus VP with Hote/.hcu
Volume (vehlh)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
I n t e rs ect i on Orient at i on : Ea st- We st [Study Period (hrs): 0.25
Vehicle Volumes and Adjustments
3 106 27 27 107 3
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) I 3 Ill 28 28 112 3
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
Movement
Undivided
I 0 0 I
0
0 0 I2
L TR I L7-R I
.I
I 0 I2 0
0
Northbound Southbound
12
Percent arade (YO) I
Volume (vehlh)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h)
0
18 0 18 IO 0 10
0 95 0 95 0 95 0 95 0 95 0 95
18 0 18 10 IO
Flared approach I/
Proportion of heavy lo vehicles, P,, 0 0
Lanes 0 0 0 0 0 0
Movement I 1 I 4 I 7 18 19 I10 I11 112
Configuration Id LR LR
Lane Configuration
Volume, v (vph)
Capacity, c, (vph)
II LR
3 28 1dAl 2o
L TR LTR I LR
1462 1433 715 71 I
Cop) right C 2003 University of Florida, All Rights Reserved Version 4.Id
Queue length (95%) 0.01 0 06 1 0.16 I 0.09 [
Control Delay (slveh)
LOS
7.5 7.6 I 10.3 10.2 1
A A I5
TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
EastlWest Street: Ponto Road
Intersection Orientation: East-West
Analyst
Agency/Co. kha
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analysis Time Period PM Peak Hour
North/Sou th Street: White wafer Lane
Study Period (hrs): 0.25
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
Major Street
Movement
Ponfo at Whitewater
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
Eastbound
1 2 4 3
R L
5 6
T R
Volume (vehlh) I 17 I 178
Peak-hour factor, PHF
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h)
0.95 0.95
17 187
Proportion of heavy
0.95
37
0.95 0.95 0.95
37 149 I1
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Upstream Signal
-- Io/-- I --
Undivided Io 0 I 0 :Io
I 0 II 0
0 I 0
L TR I LTR I
Minor Street
Movement
Northbound Southbound
7 8 9 10 11 12
L
24 I Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h)
Flared approach I I N I I I N I
R
7 T R LA 0 24 7 0
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
0
2lOl
RT Channelized? I I I I
Storage
Lanes ~~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0
Configuration I2 LR 112 LR
Approach EB WB Northbound Southbound
Volume, v (vph)
Capacity, c, (vph)
v/c ratio
I1 37 l>llA
1408 1334 I 590 I 59 I
0.01 I 0.03 1 I I 0.08 I 0.02 I
Control Delay (s/veh) I 7.6 7.8 I 11.2
Approach delay (slveh) I -- -_ 11.7 11.2
HCSZOO!~‘” Copyright !C 2003 Uni\ei-sity of Florida, 411 Rights Reserved Version 4. Id
I TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY I
I Project Description
Eastmest Street: Ponfo Road NorthISouth Street: Whfewater Lane
Intersection Orientation: Easf-West Study Period (hrs). 0.25
Vehicle Volumes and Adjustments
Major Street Eastbound Westbound
Movement 1 2 3 4 5 6
L T R L T R
3 I06 121 121 I07 3 Volume (vehlh)
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0 95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0 95 0.95
Hourly Flow Rate (vehfh) 127 127 I12 3
Proportion of heavy
Median type Undwided
Lanes 0 1 0
Ponto Whifewater AM EX plus VP with retail hcu
I
-- -- vehicles, P,, 0
RT Channelized? I10 0
1 0
I
0
Analyst
AgencyfCo.
Date Performed
Analvsis Time Period
Configuration
Minor Street
Upstream Signal
kha
6/19/2005
AM Peak Hour
LTR I I LTR I I 2 0 1- 0 I2
Northbound South bound
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
Movement 8
Volume (veh/h) 81 0
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95 0.95
Ponto af Whitewafer
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
10 11 12
L T R
80 IO 0 IO
0 95 0.95 0.95 0.95
I TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY I
~
Analyst I Intersection Ponto at Whitewater
Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
Hourly Flow Rate (vehih)
Agency/Co. kha
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analysis Time Period PM Peak Hour
L T R L T R
I1 178 252 252 142 I1
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
I1 187 265 265 I49 I1
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
vehicles, P,,
Median type
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
--
Undivided
I Project Description
East/West Street: Ponto Road lNorth/South Street: Whitewater Lane
I n t e rsec t i o n Orient at ion :
Ponto Whitewafer PM EX plus VP with retailhcu
East- We st ktudv Period (hrsl: 0 35
Lanes
C o nf ig u rat I on
, -, - -- - .. - __
Vehicle Volumes and Adjustments
Maior Street I Eastbound I Weqtbni inrl
0 1 0 0 I 0 1
LTR I LTR I I1
IProDortion of heavv I I I I I I I
Minor Street N ort ti bou n d Southbound
L ' T R L T R
Peak-hour factor, PHF
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h)
-_- ~~ I
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
265 0 265 7 0 7
Percent grade (%) 0 0
I Storage I- 0 IIla/i RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
0 Ilal 0 I 0 0 0
I I
L IR I LR
Volume, v (vph)
Capacity, c, (vph)
v/c ratio
I l4 II I1 265 265 I I 265 I
1408 1101 157 I I 695 I I 146 I I 1 0.38 I I 0.10 I I 0.01 1 0.24 1.69 1
I IIIII
Icontrot Deay (slveh) i 7.6 9.3 1 386.1 I I 13.3 1 I 32.3 I I
A A AdAIAL
Version 4.1d Copyrighi 'C! 2003 llnlversity of Florida, All Rights Reserved
TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
General Information IS i te Information
Eastbound
2 3
Analyst
Age n cy/Co.
Date Performed
Analysis Time Period
Westbound
4 5 6
ser
kha
6/19/2005
AM Peak Hour
Volume (vehlh)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
~~ L T R L T R
4 13 0 0 38 3
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
Ponto at Windvane
City of Carkbad
April 2004
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h)
Proportion of heavy
vehicles, P,,J
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
Movement
Project Description
EasWest Street: Ponto Road INorth/South Street: Windvane Lane
Ponto Windvane AM €X.hcu
4 13 0 0 40 3
0 0 I -- I --
>I I I Undivided
0
0
0 2 0 1 0 0 1
LT d TR I 0 0 I2
Northbound Southbound
/:IT 8 R 9
Volume (veh/h) 0 0 0
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95 0.95 0.95
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) 0
Proportion of heavy
vehicles, P,,
Percent arade f%) I 0
10 L T a'
70 0 10
0.95 0.95 0.95
IO
0
0 I
Storage
IFlared approach I I N I I I N I I
0 1- 0
Lanes
Configuration
0 0 0 0 0 0
LR I
IMovement I 1 I 4 l718l91101111121
Laneconfiguration I LT I 1 I 1 I I LR 1 1 I Volume. v hhl I 4 I 1 I I I I 20 I I
Iv/c ratio I 0.00 I
IQueue length (95%) I 0.01 I I I I I I 1-1 8.9 ~I I /A I
Control Delay (sheh) I 73
I A I
(Aporoach delay (siveh) I ._ __ I I I 89
A IApproach LOS __
I TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
Major Street
Movement
Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
LGe nera I Information ISite Information
Eastbound Westbound
1 2 3 4 5 6
L T R L T R
12 45 0 0 21 11
0 95 0 95 0 95 0 95
Analyst ser
AgencyICo. kha
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analvsis Time Period PM Peak Hour
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) 12 47
vehicles, P,,/ lol-- I
Proportion of heavy
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
0
0 , of 1 o7 -- Io I I
Ponto at Windvane
City of Carkbad
April 2004
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Minor Street
Movement
Upstream Signal
I Project Description
EasWVest Street: Ponto Road lNorth/South Street: Windvane Lane
Ponto Windvane PM €X.hcu
Undivided
0 0
I 0 0 I 0 I
I 0 I
0
LT TR
0
Southbound North bound
8 9 10 11 12
Intersection Orientation, East- West /Study Period (hrs): 0.25
Vehicle Volumes and Adjustments
T R 1: Volume (veh/h) 0 0 0
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0 95 0 95 0 95
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) 0 0 0
L T R
6 0 6
0 95 0 95 0.95
6 0 6
IPercent grade (%) I 0 I 0
Flared approach IN
Lanes I 0 I 0 I 0 I 0 I 0 I 0
IO
Approach EB WB
Movement 1 4
Northbound Southbound
7 a 9 10 11 12
Laneconfiguration
Volume, v (vph)
Capacity, c, (vph)
vlc ratio
Queue length (95%)
Control Delay (siveh)
LOS
LT 1 I 1 I 1 J LR
1566 1 12 JILL 5L-l
0.01 1221 Ool
O0* ,I'l-A Oo4
73 IIIII 891 AlIIdIA
12&--930
TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY I
EastlWest Street: Ponto Road
Intersection Orientation: East-West
Analyst
AgencylCo. kha
Date Performed 6/79/2005
Analysis Time Period AM Peak Hour
North/South Street: Windvane Lane
Study Period (hrs). 0.25
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
Major Street
Ponto at Windvane
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
Eastbound
Movement 1 2 3 4 5
T
6
R
Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
132 I 3 I -
4 126 0 0
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
I38
0.95
3
Approach I EB I WB I Northbound
Hourly Flow Rate (vehlh) 1 4 132 0 0
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
Movement
Undiwded :Io ’I 0
LT II TR I 0 I 0 I2
0 I 0 0 I 0
Northbound Southbound
7 8 11
L
0 I Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) 0
Proportion of heavy
vehicles, P,, 0
T ;[:“I T k’j
0 0 IO 0 10
0 95 0 95 0.95 0.95 0 95
0 0 IO
0 0 0 :lb”l
I
Southbound
10 I 11 I 12 I
Percent grade (YO)
Flared approach
RT Channelized?
Storage
-A- I 767 I I
0 I> N
0 201 0 202
L I I I 0.03 I I
0 Lanes 0 0 0 0
Configuration
I 0.08 I I
0
I 9.8 I I Queue length (95%)
Control Delay (s/veh) -A-
0.01 Ill
7.5 I 1 I I
A r Approach delay (sheh) I __
HCS2 OOP Copyright C 2003 L:niversity of Florida. All Rights Reseiwd
--
Version 4.ld
-
TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
East/West Street Ponto Road
I n t e rs e c t i o n Or i en t a t i o n : East- We sf
Analyst
Ag ency/Co. kha
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analysis Time Period PM Peak Hour
NorthlSouth Street: Windvane Lane
Study Period (hrs): 0.25
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
Major Street
Movem en t
Ponfo at Windvane
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
Eastbound Westbound
1 2 3 4 5 6
I Project Description Ponto Windvane PM EX plus VP with Hote/.hcu
L T R
12 219 0 I Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95 0.95 0 95
Proportion of heavy
vehicles, P,,
Hourly Flow Rate (vehih) 230 0
--
L T R
0 I62 I1
0 95 0 95 0.95
ILanes I 0 I 1 I 0 I 0 I I I 0
Median type Undivided
Configuration ~
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
Movement
LT I 22-2 TR I 0 122 0
Northbound Southbound
7 8 9 10 11 12
Volume (veh/h) 0 0 0 6 0 6
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) I 0 0 0 6 0 6
Flared approach I2
Copyrighl C 2003 Unwersiry of Florida. All Rights Resen ed Version 4.1 d
N
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
0 Io
0 0 0 0
22
IIII LR
0 0
Approach I EB 1 WB Northbound Southbound
Lane Configuration
Volume, v (vph)
Capacity, c, (vph)
v/c ratio
Queue length (95%)
Control Delay (dveh)
LT I I I I I I LR I Allld A22222A 0011IlII Oo2
0 03
7 6 I I I I I I 10.5 I
1 TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
Analyst
AgencyICo. kha
Date Performed 6/19/2005
Analysis Time Period AM Peak Hour
Intersection Ponto at Windvane
Jurisdiction City of Carlsbad
Analysis Year April 2004
EastlWest Street: Ponto Road
Intersection Orientation: East-West
North/South Street: Windvane Lane
Study Period (hrs): 0.25
Major Street Eastbound Westbound
Flared approach IN N
0
Storage Io loI -02
Movement 1
Volume (veh/h
Lanes 0 0 0 0 0 0
Configuration
2 3 4 5 6
T R L T R
220 0 0 195 3
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95
Proportion of heavy
vehicles, P,,
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) 4
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
23 1 3
__
L T R L T R
0 0 0 IO 0 10 I Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hourfactor. PHF I 0.95 I 0.95 I 0.95 I 0.95 1 0.95 I 0.95
Median type
RT Channelized?
Lanes
Configuration
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
Undivided
0
0 7 0
21 0 1 0
LT 1’1 TR
0 I1 0
Northbound Southbound
Movement I 7 I 8 I 9 I 10 11 I 12
Hourly Flow Rate (veh/h) 0
Proportion of heavy
vehicles, P,,
10 10
Approach
Movement
Lane Configuration
Volume, v (vph)
Capacity, c, (vph)
vtc ratio
Queuelength(95Yo)
Control Delay (slveh)
LOS
Approach delay (s/veh)
EB WB Northbound Southbound
4 7 I 8 19 I10 I11 I12 I LR
2
41II120 A’22-A
0 00 ldlld
A l2~11lA
LT I I I 1 I
I I 001 I I I I 009 I I I 7 7 I 1 I I IO 7 I
-- I _- 10 7
TWO-WAY STOP CONTROL SUMMARY
Major Street
Movement
Analyst
AgencyfCo. kha
Date Performed 61'1 9/2005
Analvsis Time Period PM Peak Hour
Eastbound Westbound
1 2 3 4 5 6
Intersection
Jurisdiction
Analysis Year
L T R
12 435 0 I Volume (vehlh)
Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.95 0.95 0 95
Hourly Flow Rate (vehlh) 12 457 0
Ponfo at Windvane
City of Carlsbad
April 2004
L T R
0 390 11
0.95 0 95 0.95
0 410 I1
I Project Description
Eastmest Street: Ponfo Road 1 Nort h/S ou t h Street: Windvane Lane
Ponto Windvane PM EX plus VP with refail.hcu
Configuration ~
Upstream Signal
Minor Street
Move m en t
LT I 2222 TR I 0 122 0
Northbound Southbound
7 8 9 10 11 12
Proportion of heavy
vehicles, P,,
Volume (veh/h)
Peak-hour factor, PHF
Hourly Flow Rate (vehlh)
14-- I -- lol-- I --
0 0 0 6 0 6
0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.95
0 0 0 6 0 6
Median tvDe I Undivided
Percent grade ("/O)
RT Channelized? I I I 0 I I I 0
0 0
Lanes I 0 1 I I 0 I 0 I 1 I 0
~ ~~
Storage
RT Channelized? 0
IOlIlol I 0 II
Approach
Movement
Proportion of heavy
!O vehicles, P,, 0
EB
1
WB Northbound Southbound
Configuration 12-22 LR
v/c ratio 0.07
Volume, v (vph) I 12
Capacity, c, (vph) I 1130
~~ ~~~ Control Delav (s/veh) I 8.2
LOS I A
Service
I 12 I I 400 I
14.3
Q Y
__ I' I ! __
Copyright 2003 llniversity of' Florida, All Rights Rcserxd Version 4 1 d
EXHIBIT B
Corporate Office 16486 Bemardo Center Drive, #278 San Diego, CA 92128 fhone/fax (858) 451-3505 /(858) 487-0096 www rse us
Scientific, Environmental, and Forensic Consultants
June 24,2005
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel
Worden Williams APC
462 Stevens Avenue
Solana Beach, CA 92075
RE: SUMMARY OF REVIEW OF ACOUSTICAL FINDINGS
PONTO BEACHFRONT VILLAGE VISION PLAN AND MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION - CARLSBAD, CA
Dear Mr. Brechtel:
At your request, Investigative Science and Engineering (ISE) have reviewed the
Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan and Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) for
consistency with the California Environmental Quality Act. Our findings are opinions are
provided in this summary letter.
Qualifications of Reviewer
ISE, and this author in particular, has been preparing technical documents for
both the City and developers within the City for well over a decade. We have been
instrumental in providing the technical guidance on projects to ensure their compliance
under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) as well as making Carlsbad a
better place to live. I am attaching a copy of my CV to this letter.
Review of Vision Pian
ISE has reviewed the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan prepared by RBF
Consulting and found it to be a very informative and well-prepared document as it
pertains to the concept of the overall development. It does not, however, provide any
necessary technical information regarding the projects compliance with CEQA standards
(a necessary requirement for completion of the MND checklist) nor does it provide a
definitive assessment or conclusion as to the projects compliance with the City's Noise
Guidelines Manual, General Plan Noise Element, or the Carlsbad Noise Ordinance of
the Municipal Code.
ISE understands that the intent of RBF was not to provide this information in the
Vision Plan,. nor is the Vision Plan intended to document these types of findings.
Consequently, the Vision Plan cannot be relied upon solely to provide guidance for the
preparation of the MND and subsequent compliance with City codes and policies.
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel Summary of Review of Acoustical Findings
Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan and MND - Carlsbad, CA
June 24,2005
Page 2 of 3
Review of Mitigated Negative Declaration
A review of the MND section provided to ISE by Worden Williams identifies both
individual as well a cumulatively significant temporary and permanent noise impact
potential to both the project site and surrounding communities. The MND defers
mitigation (and the impact for that matter) to a series of site-specific studies to be
performed at a later date. The MND assumes that the findings of these site-specific
technical studies would reduce impacts to below a level of significance and that no
residuai noise impacts would exist.
Overall Comments and Observations
There is an inherent problem that arises in applying a broad-brush type of
conclusion as is seen in the Ponto MND. It is not sufficient to merely state that there is
an impact and then defer mitigation to a series of site-specific assessments at a later
date. This creates problems later on in that a proposed mitigation plan might not be
possible, might not comply with City standards, or the determination of the impacts as a
whole might be markedly different that than envisioned by the MND author.
It is perfectly fine to defer to a site-specific assessment once the proper
environmental work (technical studies) has been completed for the entire project and the
overall constraints of the project are known. ISE acknowledges that rarely final grades
and quantities are known at the time of a project EIR or MND. Thus, it becomes
imperative to address these impacts in a global project fashion, something that does not
appear to have been done in this case. Simple compliance with the Noise Element alone
will not mitigate all potentially significant noise impacts (such as cumulative roadway
segment impacts or structural noise standards such as CCR Title 24, etc.).
For example, the traffic impact assessment (TIA) performed for this project (also
prepared by RBF Consulting dated 9/3/04) identifies an aggregate trip generation due to
the project of 12,407 ADT (Table 6 of the TIA). This is a significantly large volume of
cars with the potential to generate both cumulative as well as localized impacts to both
on- and off-site uses’.
In fact, a cursory inspection of the TIA for the existing and existing plus project
scenarios (Tables 4 and 8 of the TIA) identifies direct significant acoustical impacts
along Ponto Drive with an {with-project} overall noise increase as high as 6.8 dBA
CNEL’, which is above the accepted level of noise detectability for an average human
being. Levels along Poinsettia Lane and La Costa Avenue would have direct increases
approaching 2-dBA CNEL and indirect {cumulative} levels in excess of the 3-dBA CNEL
I These impacts would also affect other issue areas such as air quality (CO hotspots and aggregate
emission exceedances above SDAPCDlCity levels), land use (congestion, quality of life), public utilities, etc.
This cursory analysis assumes a normalized 45-MPH traffic speed for segment consistency and a 95/3/2
traffic mix of automobiles, medium trucks, and heavy trucks. Actual impacts could be even greater based
upon actual segment mixes.
4
Mr. D. Wayne Brechtel Summary of Review of Acoustical Findings
Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan and MND - Carlsbad, CA
June 24,2005
Page 3 of 3
significance threshold used by the City in the past3. These cumulative impacts have the
potential to produce adverse noise conditions along roadway segments not directly
adjacent to the project site and not mitigable by the MND's statement of strict
compliance with the General Plan Noise Element4. Additionally, the MND does not
identify a plan to address these impacts, nor does the Vision Plan/MND account for the
acoustical expectations of a 60 dBA CNEL traffic noise exposure contour in excess of
500-feet into the project site and surrounding community, a very serious design
consideration when laying-out onsite development.
Further, development of the proposed hotel facility adjacent to existing residential
uses can produce adverse acoustical impacts associated with operation of the facility.
ISE has observed past hotel uses producing operational noise associated with fixed
mechanical equipment (such as HVAC, pumps, and blowers), truck deliveries (both
incoming materials and outgoing trash haulage), special events with amplified music,
and general traffic that has produced impacts to surrounding uses. Although ISE
acknowledges that some of these issues can be resolved through site-specific
assessments to develop proper engineering controls, it is also vitally imperative to
identify these impacts a-priori so that the viability of the proposed design can be
assessed. It is far easier to identify and resolve potential issues at a screening level than
to propose a plan and encounter difficulties later trying to resolve them.
Recommendations
ISE would recommend that the project applicant prepare a complete CEQA
technical analysis and subsequently prepare an environmental impact report to identify
all possible. impacts associated with the Vision Plan and develop a programmatic
mitigation plan consistent with City plans and policies which addresses not only onsite
impacts, but impact potential to the surrounding community and give the community the
opportunity to comment on the proposed mitigation.
Should you have any questions regarding the above conclusions, please do not
hesitate to contact me at (858) 451-3505.
Sincerely,
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
Project Principal
Investigative Science and Engineering, Inc.
Based upon past projects such as the Villages of La Costa, Robertson Ranch, Cannon Road Widening, etc. where
In fact, there are no effective mechanisms in place within the City's General Plan Noise Element to correct these offsite
project-wide assessments were performed.
impacts. It is highly doubtful that offsite impacts would or could be mitigated by the project applicant after the fact.
Corporate Office 16486 Bemardo Center Drive, #278 San Diego, CA 92128 PhoneFax: (858) 451-3505/(858) 487-0096 www.ise. us
RICK TAVARES, Ph.D.
President / Principal
rtavares@ jseinc. ws
@ SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS
Dr. Tavares has over 16 years of experience in the analysis and solution of engineering
problems dealing with acoustic and transientlforced vibratory response of structural,
mechanical, and aerospace systems. In the field of acoustics, Dr. Tavares has been involved in
various projects involving potential environmental impacts due to aircraft, highway, and
construction noise on humans as well as wildlife. Dr. Tavares is an expert in the field of seismic
wave propagation and dynamic structural response due to natural and manmade events. He
has worked extensively in the field of composite structural analysis having applied various
technical aspects of the discipline to Civil and Aerospace applications.
Dr. Tavares's technical capabilities include the use of various types of instrumentation including
integrating sound level meters, octave band analyzers, Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) analyzers,
accelerometers, and modal impact equipment. His experience with prediction models include
the following programs: Caltrans Sound 32 and CALINE, SCREEN, ISCST3, ISC-PRIME,
AERMOD, EMFAC, CALPUFF, Urban Airshed Model (UAM), Stamina Traffic Noise Abatement
Model (FHWA RD-77/108), FAA Integrated Noise Model (INM), DOD NOISEMAP, ROUTEMAP,
and OMEGA models, and SMS Star Modal. In addition, Dr. Tavares has worked extensively
with various finite element analysis packages including MSC NASTRAN, CosmodM, and MSC
PAU2, and has written several problem-specific computer programs in use at the academic and
consulting level dealing with problems in acoustics, structural and ground vibration, composite
structural analysis, and boundary element analysis.
cTc> EDUCATION
Ph.D. Civil Engineering, University of California, lrvine - December 2001
Concentration: Wave propagation due to conventional and non-conventional blasting
Dissertation Title: Determination of Blast-lnduced Dynamic Soil Response Usinq
Axisvmmetric Boundary Elements
M.S. Structural Engineering, University of California, San Diego
Concentration: Aerospace composite structural engineering / Dynamic Structural
Analysis
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise. us
Page 2 of 2
M.S. Mechanical Engineering, San Diego State University
Concentration: Experimental dynamic analysis, control system development, robotics
Thesis Title: A Computational Scheme for the Determination of Rectanqular Plate
Deflections, Stresses, and Natural frequencies Subject to Combined Moisture and
Thermal Effects
B.S. Aerospace Engineering and Engineering Mechanics, San Diego State University
Concentration: Composite structural analysis, aerospace flight systems, aircraft and
missile control
@ PROFESSIONAL REGISTRATION I AFFILIATIONS / CLEARANCES
Department of Defense Secret Clearance
Part-time Professor of Aerospace Engineering, San Diego State University
Registered Environmental Assessor (REA), State of California (06775)
Registered Engineer-in-Training (EIT), State of California (098024)
OSHA Hazardous Waste / Emergency Response Certification, 29 CFR 191 0.120
Confined Space Entry Training Certification, 29 CFR 1910.146
OSHNMSHA Mine Safety / Hazard Recognition Certification, PL 91-173, PL 95-164
Life Member, Tau Beta Pi, National Engineering Honor Society
Member, Institute of Noise Control Engineering
Member, International Society of Explosives Engineers
Member, Association of Environmental Professionals
Life Member, National Forensic League, Degree of Excellence
Associate Member, American Society of Mechanical Engineers
@ ENGINEERING COURSES TAUGHT
E 280 - Advanced Engineering Mathematics (5 Semesters)
EM 202 - Statics and Dynamics (3 Semesters)
EM 530 - Composite Structural Analysis (2 Semesters)
EM 621 - Theory of Elasticity (2 Semesters)
EM 340 - Fluid Mechanics (1 Semester)
AE 530 - Rocket and Space Propulsion (1 Semester)
AE 303 - Experimental Aerodynamics (2 Semesters)
CE 496 - Special Topics in Experimental Structural Analysis (1 Semester)
CE 301 - Introduction to Solid Mechanics (2 Semesters)
CE 302 - Solid Mechanics Lab (4 Semesters)
@ PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE / TECHNICAL REPORTS AUTHORED
Transporfation-Related Acoustics and Structural Dvnamics Projects . . .
La Costa Boulevard Widening Mitigation Monitoring - City of Carlsbad.
SR 56 Northern Alignment Acoustical Survey - Rancho Glens Homeowners Association.
Division Street Realignment Engineering Survey - City of National City.
Scripps Poway Parkway Extension Project - City of Poway.
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise . us
Page 3 of 3
rn
rn
rn
rn
B
SR-54/94 Roadway Improvement Environmental Assessment (EA)/Environmental
Impact Report (EIR) - Home Capital Development Group/California Department of
Transportation (Caltrans) District 11.
SR-78/Sycamore Avenue Interchange Project - City of Vista/Caltrans District 1 1.
Windsor EIR Highway Acoustical Analysis - City of Windsor.
Genesee Avenue Widening Acoustical Technical Analysis - City of San Diego.
Hurstbourne Parkway Extension - Kentucky Department of Transportation.
Napa Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Acoustical Highway Acoustical Analysis -
City of Napa, Napa, CA.
Acoustical Engineering Assessment of Proposed San Diego Off-highway Vehicle (OHV)
Trail - KTU+A, San Diego, CA.
Mid Market Redevelopment Plan - City of San Francisco, Mid City Redevelopment
Agency.
Santa Rosa General Plan Amendment - City of Santa Rosa, Department of Community
Development.
Oceanside to Escondido Rail Line Vibration Technical Report - NCTD.
Oceanside to Escondido Rail Line Acoustical Technical Report - North County Transit
District (NCTD).
SR-78ISycamore Avenue Interchange Project - City of Vista/Caltrans District 11.
SR 56 Corridor Acoustical Analysis - Rancho Glens Estates Homeowners Association,
Rancho Santa Fe, CA
Leucadia Blvd. Acoustical Assessment - City of Encinitas - Engineering Dept.,
Encinitas, CA
Bent Avenue Acoustical Study - South Coast Development, Carlsbad, CA
Quail Gardens Drive Acoustical Assessment - Curtis Scott Englehorn & Associates,
Cardiff, CA
Prospect Avenue Widening Acoustical Solutions - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Olivenhain Road Segment Widening Acoustical Assessment - Curtis Scott Englehorn &
Associates, Cardiff, CA
Vista General Plan Update Acoustical Contour Generation - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Brine Diversion System Pipeline South Acoustical Mitigation - Brown and Caldwell, San
Diego, CA
Pier View Underpass Site Assessment - City of Oceanside, Public Works Department,
Oceanside, CA
Infrastrucfure-Related Acoustics and Structural Dynamics Projects
rn
Calabasas Landfill - County Sanitation District of Los Angeles County.
Chiquita Canyon Landfill Expansion - Laidlaw Waste Systems, Inc.
Gregory Canyon Landfill Construction - Gregory Canyon Ltd., San Diego, CA.
La Mesa Materials Recover Facility (MRF) EIR - City of La Mesa.
Fenton Greenwaste Recycling Facility - H.G. Fenton Company, San Diego, CA.
Infrastructure-Related Projects
MTDB-IAD Gas Transfer Facility Acoustical Analysis - San Diego Gas and Electric Co.,
San Diego, CA.
Encinitas Passing Track Ground Motion Analysis - North County Transit District (NCTD).
Casitas Poquitas Acoustical Assessment - North County Transit District (NCTD).
Acoustical Impact Analysis, Emergency Water Storage Project - San Diego County
Water Authority.
Rev. 7002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
da va res@ise . us
Page 4 of 4
m
m
Oceanside to Escondido Rail Line Acoustical Technical Report - North County Transit
District (NCTD).
Oceanside to Escondido Rail Line Vibration Technical Report - NCTD.
North Metro Interceptor Sewer Project Acoustical Analysis - City of San Diego.
Acoustical Survey of the Point Loma Wastewater Treatment Plant - San Diego
Metropolitan Wastewater District, San Diego, CA.
Sewer Groups 72/80 Acoustical Technical Report - City of San Diego.
High Pressure Gas Pipeline Acoustical Technical Report - San Diego Gas and Electric
Co., San Diego, CA.
Mission Valley Light Rail Transit (LRT) Extension Acoustical Analysis - Metropolitan
Transit Development Board, San Diego, CA.
Acoustical Impact Analysis, Lake Nacimiento Water Project EIR - County of San Luis
0 bis po.
Downtown Vista Redevelopment Project - City of Vista Planning Division, Vista, CA
Optimist Ball Field Acoustical Study -, Vista, CA
Zenon Acoustical Wall Field Survey - Olivenhain Municipal Water District, Encinitas, CA
SD Ballpark EIR Review (Clarion Hotel) - Worden, Williams, Richmond, Brechtel, &
Gibbs, Solana Beach, CA
Clarion Hotel Acoustical Retrofit Testing - Worden, Williams, Richmond, Brechtel, &
Gibbs, Solana Beach, CA
Block 371 Acoustical Assessment - City of Brawley, Brawley, CA
OMWD Acoustical & AQ Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting - Olivenhain Municipal
Water District, Encinitas, CA
Orchard Run WWTP Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
OMWD Treatment Plant Acoustical Study - Boyle Engineering Corp., San Diego, CA
School-Related Acoustical /Air Qualitv Proiects
Ryan Park School Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Lincoln high School Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Mt. Miguel High School Acoustical Technical Report - Caltrans District 11.
Steele Canyon High School Acoustical Technical Report - Caltrans District 11,
San Diego, CA.
North & Maryland Elementary School Acoustical Site Assessment - City of Vista, Vista,
CA
Guajome Park Academy Expansion Acoustical Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Oceanside High School EIR Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego,
CA
Mead Elementary School Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego,
CA
Ryan Park School Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Lincoln High School Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Vista Focus Academy Air Quality Site Assessment - Culbertson, Adams & Associates,
Aliso Viejo, CA
North & Maryland Elementary School Air Quality Site Assessment - City of Vista, Vista,
CA
Scripps Ranch Middle School Air Quality Site Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Montessori Preschool Acoustical Compliance Survey - County of San Diego.
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D. rtavares@ise. us Page 5 of 5 . . . .
Scripps Ranch Middle School Acoustical Site Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Oceanside School EIR Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Mead Elementary School Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego,
CA
Lion's Leadership Academy Acoustical Assessment - KMA Architecture & Engineering,
San Diego, CA
Bioloqical-Related Acoustical Assessments / Technical Studies
ESPN X Games Boating Activity - Acoustical Evaluation Study.
Acoustical Impact Report on Passerine Habitat Due to Aircraft Operation - USMCAS
Camp Pendleton.
Rancho Del Oro Acoustical Analysis for Biological Impacts - Gatlin Construction
Company.
Miramar Pipeline Construction Acoustical Assessment - Santa Fe Pacific Pipeline
Partners.
Cannon Road Initial Acoustical Study - City of Carlsbad, Carlsbad, CA
Cannon Road Mitigation Monitoring - Ogden Environmental & Energy, San Diego, CA
Via Ambiente Road Bridge Project - Olivenhain Municipal Water District, Encinitas, CA
Riveria Del Sol Mitigation Monitoring - Reynolds Communities, El Cajon, CA
Scotsman Mitigation Monitoring Program - Hamann Construction, El Cajon, CA
Air Qualitv / Air Toxics Technical Studies . . . . .
m .
. .
. . . .
Villages of La Costa Air Quality Assessment - T&B Planning Consultants, Inc., Santa
Ana, CA
Home Depot El Cajon FEIR Air Quality Assessment - David Evans & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Breeze Hill Air Quality Assessment - Buiellrish Ventures, Solana Beach, CA
Lake Jennings Business Park Air Quality /Air Toxics Assessment - South Coast
Development, Carlsbad, CA
OMWD Air Quality Monitoring - Olivenhain Municipal Water District, Encinitas, CA
Alvarado / Lake Murray Tank Construction Air Quality Assessment - Mooney &
Associates, San Diego, CA
Vista Hacienda Gateway Air Quality Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Luckey Ranch BP Facility Air Quality / Biological Air Toxics Assessment - Mooney &
Associates, San Diego, CA
Oceanside 140 Property Air Quality Site Assessment - Concordia Homes, Carlsbad, CA
National City Retail Development Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
North Coast Church Air Quality Site Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Buena Vista Park TM Air Quality Study - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
San Manuel Indians Parking Lot Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Vista General Plan Transportation Air Quality Analysis - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Plaza De Oro Shopping Center Air Quality Assessment - Capital Income Properties,
Inc., Newport Beach, CA
El Centro Town Center Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D. rtavares@ise.us Page 6 of 6
Morongo Indian Casino Air Quality Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Robertson Ranch Air Quality Assessment - T&B Planning Consultants, Inc., Santa Ana,
CA
Earthlite Dust Collector Study - Earthlite, Inc., Vista, CA
San Diego Wild Animal Park DPEIR Air Quality Study - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Vista Hacienda Gateway Air Quality Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Alpine Blvd Hot Spot Analysis - P & D Consultants, Inc., San Diego, CA
Bent Avenue Commercial Air Quality Assessment - South Coast Development,
Carisbad, CA
Barham Drive Hotspot Analysis - City of San Marcos, San Marcos, CA
San Marcos Blvd. Hotspot Analysis - City of San Marcos, San Marcos, CA
Rancho Santa Fe Road Hotspot Analysis - City of San Marcos, San Marcos, CA
Diamond Environmental Air Quality Assessment - ADJ Enterprises, San Marcos, CA
Guajome Park Academy Expansion Air Quality Assessment - City of Vista; Vista, CA
Robertson Ranch Air Quality Assessment - T&B Planning Consultants, Inc., Santa Ana,
CA
El Centro Town Center Hotspot Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Federal Government 1 Militarv Projects
Ft. Dix Installation Compatibility Use Zone (ICUZ) Plan - Ft. Dix Weapons Test Center,
Ft. Dix New Jersey.
Imperial Beach Border Patrol Station Environmental Assessment - U.S. Department of
Justice, Immigration, and Naturalization Service.
Homeporting Dredging, P-549/700 - U.S. Navy.
Brown Field Border Patrol Station Environmental Assessment - US. Department of
Justice, Immigration, and Naturalization Service.
Naval Air Station (NAS) Miramar Housing Realignment EIR - U.S. Navy.
Helicopter Outlying Landing Field (HOLF) Acoustical Analysis - U.S. Marine Corps Air
Station (USMCAS) Camp Pendleton.
East Lake Boulevard Realignment Project - Birmingham Air National Guard, Alabama.
Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) Compliance Verification of the Joint Primary
Aircraft Training System (JPATS) - U.S. Air Force/U.S. Navy.
MCAS/Marine Corps Air Base (MCAB) Camp Pendleton Realignment EIS - U.S. Navy.
Beach Replenishment Acoustical Survey - Homeporting EIS, U.S. Navy.
Naval Training Center (NTC) EIS Acoustical Survey - U.S. Navy.
El Tor0 Reuse EIR Acoustical - Ogden Environmental and Energy Services, San
Francisco, CA
NTC Acoustical Consultation - P & D Consultants, Inc., San Diego, CA
El Tor0 Reuse Verification - City of Laguna Niguel, Laguna Niguel, CA
Cabrillo Military Housing Acoustical Assessment - Ogden Environmental and Energy,
Inc., Santa Barbara, CA
Camp Elliott Demolition Acoustical / Blasting Assessment - Ogden Environmental and
Energy Services, San Francisco, CA
San Clemente Island EIS Acoustical Assessment - Ogden Environmental and Energy,
Inc., Santa Barbara, CA
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise .us
Page 7 of 7
Drillins, Blastinu, and Tunnelinu Proiects
8
8
8
8
8
8
Mine Inspection Procedure Manual Update - State of Arizona Mine Inspector, Phoenix,
AZ
Olivenhain Water Storage Project Blasting Technical Report - Boyle Engineering
Corporation.
Olivenhain Water Storage Project Blasting Technical Report - Boyle Engineering
Corporation.
San Elijo Hills Rock Crushing Technical Report - San Elijo Hills Inc.
Geothermal Drilling Rig Acoustical Attenuation Analysis - Magma Power Company.
North Metro Interceptor Sewer Project Tunneling Vibration Analysis - City of San Diego.
Gregory Canyon Construction Blasting Vibration Analysis - Gregory Canyon Ltd., San
Diego, CA.
Gregory Canyon Construction Blasting Vibration Analysis Addendum - David Evans and
Associates, San Diego, CA.
Tunneling and Blasting Vibration Analysis - Emergency Water Storage Project - San
Diego County Water Authority.
Tunneling Vibration Analysis, Lake Nacimiento Water Project EIR - County of San Luis
Obispo.
Airport Permittinu / Compliance Sutvevs and Enuineerinq
8
8
8
Potrero Airfield Expanded Initial Study and Major Use Permit - County of San Diego.
San Clemente Island Naval Auxiliary Landing Field (NALF) Study - United States Navy.
BCS FAR 150 Aircraft Study - Greystone Homes, Inc., Carlsbad, CA
Commercial / lndustrial Compliance Survevs and Encrineerinq
8 OPPl Application for Certification (AFC) Acoustical Study - Ogden Environmental &
Energy, San Diego, CA
Arya Automotive Facility Acoustical Survey - Vista, CA.
Home Depot El Cajon Acoustical Survey - Home Depot Inc.
Wal-Mart Acoustical Acoustical Survey - Hall and Foreman Inc.
OSCO Treatment Plant Acoustical Technical Analysis - Laidlaw Systems Inc.,
Pascagoula, MS.
Wal-Mart Acoustical Wall Verification Study - Wal-Mart Inc.
Breeze Hill Air Quality Technical Report - City of Vista.
Magma Geothermal Power Plant AFC Acoustical Analysis - Magma Operating
Company.
Downtown Vista Redevelopment Project Acoustical Analysis - City of Vista
Acoustical and Lighting Survey - Smith’s Food and Drug Centers, Vista, CA
Acoustical Site Evaluation Study - VID Corporate Headquarters - Vista Irrigation
District.
Land Development Proiects
8
8
Maravu Encinitas Acoustical Site Study - Standard Pacific Homes, San Diego, CA
Jefferson at Mission Valley Interior Acoustical Assessment - Helix Environmental, La
Mesa, CA
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise. us
Page 8 of 8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
Downtown Vista Redevelopment Project Acoustical Analysis - City of Vista.
Acoustical Site Evaluation Study - VID Corporate Headquarters - Vista Irrigation
District.
Advanced Structures Site Assessment - Koll Development Group.
Standard Pacific Poinsettia Property Acoustical Assessment - Standard Pacific Homes.
Gateway View Acoustical Assessment - Three Carnations Development Company.
Costa Verde South Development Interior Acoustical Assessment - Garden
Communities.
Laurel Tree Apartments Interior Acoustical Assessment - MAAC Project of San Diego.
Costa Verde North Development Interior Acoustical Assessment - Garden Communities.
Jefferson at Mission Valley II Interior Acoustical Assessment - Helix Environmental.
San Elijo Ranch Development Acoustical Technical Report - San Elijo Ranch Inc.
DeJong Property Acoustical Assessment - Jack Henthorn & Associates.
Sidonia East Development Exterior / Interior Acoustical Assessment - Cornerstone
Communities.
East Campus Site Lease Acoustical Analysis - University of California, San Diego.
La Mariposa Apartments Acoustical Analysis - Manzanita Partners.
Hung/Fritz Property Development Acoustical Assessment - Standard Pacific Homes.
Summit at Carlsbad Acoustical Analysis - The Marina Group.
Bernard0 Vista Del Lago Acoustical Update - Western Communities Group.
BCS Property Acoustical Assessment - Jack Henthorn & Associates.
Eucalyptus View Housing Development Acoustical Analysis - Community Housing of
North County.
Villages of La Costa Acoustical Technical Report - T&B Planning Consultants.
Carmel Del Mar Development Acoustical Assessment - Cooper Engineering Associates.
Quail Hollow East Development Acoustical Assessment - Cornerstone Communities.
North Mesa Quail Hollow East Development Acoustical Assessment - Cornerstone
Communities.
Ocean Bluffs Acoustical Verification Study - Catellus Residential Group.
Eastlake South Greens Parcel R-27 Acoustical Technical Report - Eastlake
Development Company, Chula Vista, CA.
Mariano Residential Development Acoustical Technical Report - Jack Henthorn and
Associates, Carlsbad, CA.
Exterior Acoustical Acoustical Analysis for Fieldstone Summit - The Fieldstone
Company.
Exterior Acoustical Acoustical Analysis for Pardee Hilltop 2 - Pardee Construction
Company.
Santa Fe Valley EIS Acoustical Analysis - County of San Diego, San Diego, CA.
San Elijo Ranch EIS Acoustical Analysis - City of San Marcos, San Marcos, CA.
Eastlake South Greens Parcel R-23 Acoustical Technical Report - Eastlake
Development Company, Chula Vista, CA.
Fieldstone Summit Interior Acoustical Analysis - The Fieldstone Company, San Diego,
CA.
Torrey View Homes Acoustical Technical Report - Shea Communities, Inc., San Diego,
CA.
Villages of La Costa Acoustical Assessment - T&B Planning Consultants, Inc., Santa
Ana, CA
North Mesa Quail Hollow East Acoustical Site Assessment - Cornerstone Communities,
San Diego, CA
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise. us
Page 9 of 9
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
rn
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
Breeze Hill Plaza Acoustical Study - Buie/lrish Ventures, Solana Beach, CA
Roesch Property TM Acoustical Site Assessment - Standard Pacific Homes, San Diego,
CA
Homeland Property TM Acoustical Site Assessment - Standard Pacific Homes, San
Diego, CA
Mayberry Affordable Housing Acoustical Assessment- Southwest Affordable Housing,
Solana Beach, CA
McClenny Property Development Acoustical Study- The McClenny Corporation, Rancho
Santa Fe, CA
SR 56 Rancho San Diego Lakes Acoustical Assessment - Greg Industrial, San Diego,
CA
Allan Business Bldg. INA - Snow Construction, El Cajon, CA
Lake Jennings Market Place Acoustical Assessment- South Coast Development,
Carlsbad, CA *
Capri INA Acoustical Plan Check - Cornerstone Communities, San Diego, CA
VIP Acoustical Siting Study - Vista industrial Products, Inc., Vista, CA
Paydar La Jolla TM Development Acoustical Assessment - Paydar Properties, La Jolla,
CA
North Mesa Upper Parcel Acoustical Study - Cornerstone Communities, San Diego, CA
Sidonia East Customs Acoustical Study + INA - Cornerstone Communities, San Diego,
CA
Encinitas Ranch Apartments Acoustical Study - Del Mar Heritage LLC, San Diego, CA
Sycamore Vista Business Park II Acoustical Study - Dartmouth Development, San
Diego, CA
McDuffee TM Acoustical Study - Vista, CA
Lambesis TM Acoustical Study - Del Mar, CA
Oceanside Parcels 2, 3, and 'A' Development Acoustical Study - Spectrum
Communities, Irvine, CA
SD City Residential INA - GREAT PLANS in 3D, San Diego, CA
Brett Regency Acoustical Study - La Costa Engineering, Carlsbad, CA
Hunter's Run Apartment Acoustical Study - Hunter's Run Apartments, El Cajon, CA
La Piazza Restaurant Interior Acoustical Assessment - Douglas Martin Associates, San
Diego, CA
ChaselAvocado Car Wash Acoustical Assessment - GTB Company, El Cajon, CA
Greystone Communities Acoustical Analysis - Ogden Environmental & Energy, San
Diego, CA
Rancho Pacifica Assisted Living Facility Acoustical Study - Curtis Scott Englehorn &
Associates, Cardiff, CA
Ventura Sports EIR Park Acoustical Study - Ogden Environmental and Energy, Inc.,
Santa Barbara, CA
TM 4725 RPL Acoustical Study - Standard Pacific Homes, San Diego, CA
Kalicki Property TM 4906 Acoustical Assessment -, San Marcos, CA
Otay Mesa Truck Stop Acoustical Siting Assessment - Bennett Realty Group, San
Ramon, CA
Mission Beach INA - Frosch General Contracting, La Jolla, CA
Sun River INA - Reynolds Communities, El Cajon, CA
Lodge at Bonita INA - Irwin Architectural Group, Huntington Beach, CA
Barczewski/Kasai Property Acoustical Study - D. R. Horton, Encinitas, CA
Wightman Place INA - Cuatro Development Inc., San Diego, CA
Rev. 7002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise. us
Page 10 of 10
Soto Residence Acoustical Study - Curtis Scott Englehorn & Associates, Cardiff, CA
Darwin Village Acoustical Study - The Lightfoot Planning Group, Oceanside, CA
Melrose Ice II Facility Acoustical Assessment - Hamann Construction, El Cajon, CA
Sidonia East INA Retrofit Acoustical Assessment- Shea Homes, San Diego, CA
Penasquitos Gardens Affordable Housing Acoustical Study - Fairfield Realty LLC, San
Diego, CA
Mission Trails Business Park Acoustical Study - Hamann Construction, El Cajon, CA
Mario Interior Acoustical Assessment - Standard Pacific Homes, San Diego, CA
Yuri Hofmann INA - Bonsall, CA
Mottino Center Acoustical Site Analysis- Lightfoot Planning Group, Oceanside, CA
Mesa Grande Acoustical Survey - Solana Mesa Partners, Solana Beach, CA
Galena OPC INA - Reno NV -James Leary Architecture & Planning, San Diego, CA
Main & Mace Drive-thru Acoustical Impact Assessment - Gary Engineering, Inc., San
Diego, CA
City Heights Service Plaza Acoustical Study - Murphy’s Market, San Diego, CA
Hoag Cadiz Street INA -, San Diego, CA
Quail Gardens Drive Acoustical Assessment - Cornerstone Communities, San Diego,
CA
Del Monte Condos INA - Stone-Ray Development, San Diego, CA
Carter Collision Center Acoustical Survey - Carter Collision Service Inc., Santee, CA
North Coast INA - VSS LLC, San Diego, CA
Vista Las Flores Acoustical Study - Wakeland Housing and Development, San Diego,
CA
Breeze Hill Rock Crushing Acoustical Assessment - Breeze Hill, LLC, San Diego, CA
Mission Valley Branch Library INA -Wheeler, Wimer, Blackman & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Old Grove Apartments Acoustical Study - Community Housing of North County,
Escondido, CA
KasaUMondeck Acoustical Assessment - D.R. Horton, Encinitas, CA
Hollandia Dairy Acoustical Study - David R. Shibley and Associates, Escondido, CA
Lake Murray Tank Construction Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
TPM 14178 Acoustical Assessment - Poway, CA
Pinjuv Development INA - Du Charme Architecture, La Jolla, CA
Fountains at Carlsbad Acoustical Assessment - Pacific Gulf Properties, Newport Beach,
CA
Park Crest INA - Park Crest LLC, San Diego, CA
Aero Drive Commercial Center INA - Aero Drive Two, LLC., Rancho Santa Fe, CA
Scripps Pomerado Acoustical Assessment - Cat Sun Development Company, Del Mar,
CA
Douglas Drive Apartments Acoustical Study - BREG, Vista, CA
Tanner Residence INA - Shoreline General Contractors Inc., San Diego, CA
TPM 20502 Acoustical Assessment -, El Cajon, CA
Sunrise Assisted Living Acoustical Assessment - Hale Engineering, San Diego, CA
Koll Lot 7 Acoustical Assessment - Architects Hanna Gabriel Wells, San Diego, CA
Boekel TPM 18282 Acoustical Assessment - GPG Construction, El Cajon, CA
Herold TPM 20522 Acoustical Study - Leming and Associates, Inc., Ramona, CA
San Miguel Ranch TM Acoustical Assessment - Trimark Pacific Homes, L.P.,
Escondido, CA
Rev. 7 002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rta vares@ise. us
Page 11 of 11
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
rn
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
Willow Glen Ranch Exterior Acoustical Assessment - G.D.G Incorporated, El Cajon, CA
Home Dept Vista Acoustical - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Estrada Duplex INA - Robert Thompson Architect, Chula Vista, CA
TM 5172 Acoustical Assessment - Leming and Associates, Inc., Ramona, CA
Escondido Tract 817 Acoustical Study - The Kennedy Group, La Costa, CA
Champions Center INA - All Star Equities LLC, San Diego, CA
Vanguard Acoustical Assessment - Van Vechten Construction, San Diego, CA
Emerald Point Acoustical Assessment + INA - Reynolds Communities, El Cajon, CA
Carlsbad Promenade Acoustical Assessment - Koll Development Group, La Jolla, CA
Vista Las Flores INA - Wakeland Housing and Development, San Diego, CA
Pima Development Site Compliance Survey - Koll Development Group, La Jolla, CA
Standish Precision Tools Acoustical Assessment - CDS Architects + Engineers, Palm
Springs, CA
Garden View Business Center Acoustical Compliance Study- West Air Mechanical,
Carlsbad, CA
Bermuda View Development Acoustical Study - WS Management, El Cajon, CA
Southern Hills Subdivision Acoustical Assessment - McCullough-Ames Development,
Inc., San Diego, CA
lwannah Park Acoustical Assessment - Curtis Scott Englehorn & Associates, Cardiff,
CA
7-1 1 Store #6049 Acoustical Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Willow Glen Ranch Exterior Acoustical Assessment - G.D.G Incorporated, El Cajon, CA
La Vida Real INA - Senior Resource Group, LLC, San Diego, CA
Jif-Pak Acoustical Site Assessment - Jif-Pak, Carlsbad, CA
National City Retail Development Acoustical Study - Mooney & Associates, San Diego,
CA
Maravu TM + INA - Standard Pacific Homes, Carlsbad, CA
Skyline Terrace Estates Acoustical Assessment - Carter Reese & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Summit at Carlsbad Acoustical Assessment - All Phase Enterprises, LLC, San Marcos,
CA
Escondido Tract 829 Acoustical Assessment - Szytel Engineering & Surveying, Inc.,
Escondido, CA
North Coast Church Acoustical Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Old Grove Apartments INA - Community Housing of North County, Escondido, CA
Vista Hacienda Gateway INA - Standard Pacific Homes, Carlsbad, CA
Sapper TPM Acoustical Study - Curtis Scott Englehorn & Associates, Cardiff, CA
Oceanside Equestrian Acoustical Study - Fuscoe Engineering, San Diego, CA
California Oaks Acoustical Assessment - The Colony at California Oaks, Temecula, CA
Handler Otay Mesa INA - Helix Environmental, La Mesa, CA
River Ranch North INA - Fieldstone Communities Inc., San Diego, CA
River Ranch South INA - Fieldstone Communities Inc., San Diego, CA
Shoreline Resort Acoustical Survey - Curtis Scott Englehorn & Associates, Cardiff, CA
Gamboni Ranch Acoustical Assessment - Lucas & Mercier Development, Vista, CA
Coronado Terrace STC Assessment - The Related Companies of California, Irvine, CA
Lowe's Vista Acoustical Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Sunrise Assisted Living Pacific Beach Acoustical Study - Sunrise Development Inc., San
Diego, CA
Escondido Tract 81 7 Acoustical Study - The Kennedy Group, La Costa, CA
Rev. 1002
,.
Rick Tavares, Ph.D. rtavares@ise. us
Page 12 of 12
8
8
B
8
8
a
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
B
Bruno's Chevron #9-0156 Acoustical Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Kaiser Permanente Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Sawyer's Mill Tract 25892 Acoustical Assessment, Temecula, CA - Rilington
Communities, San Marcos, CA
Harmony Grove Industrial Site Assessment - CMS Development, San Diego, CA
NTC Liberty Station Exterior + INA - McMillan Land Development, National City, CA
Legacy Sabre Springs INA - Architects Hanna Gabriel Wells, San Diego, CA
The Bluffs Acoustical Assmt + INA - Forum Capital Management, LLC, Pomona, CA
Car Wash Acoustical Site Assessment - Del Cerro Chevron, San Diego, CA
Hibiscus Avenue Development Acoustical Assessment - American Horizons Ltd., San
Diego, CA
Stephens Property Acoustical Site Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
TPM 20620 Acoustical Assessment - Bonsall, CA
Fountains at Seacliff Acoustical Assessment - Pacific Gulf Properties, Newport Beach,
CA
Riveria Del Sol Acoustical + INA - Reynolds Communities, El Cajon, CA
California Oaks Shopping Center Acoustical Study- Silver Creek Properties, Laguna
Hills, CA
Benson Self-storage Facility Acoustical Assessment - Alpine Meat Company, Alpine,
CA
Oak Country Estates Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Harmony Grove Residential Development Site Assessment - CMS Development, San
Diego, CA
Maryland Drive TPM Acoustical Study - Lighthouse Ventures, LLC, Oceanside, CA
SER Addendum Studies C-I - San Elijo Hills, Inc., Carlsbad, CA
SER Addendum Studies G-I - San Elijo Hills, Inc., Carlsbad, CA
Sunrise Bonita INA - Sunrise Development Inc., San Diego, CA
La Costa Multi-Family Housing Acoustical Assessment - Community Housing of North
County, Escondido, CA
Otay Mesa Southern Subdivision Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Plaza De Oro Shopping Center Acoustical Assessment - Capital Income Properties,
Inc., Newport Beach, CA
Villas at Mission Point Acoustical + INA - The Lightfoot Planning Group, Oceanside, CA
North Melrose Auto Complex Acoustical Study - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Sevilla INA - Cornerstone Communities, San Diego, CA
Leung TM Acoustical Assessment - San Diego, CA
El Centro Town Center Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Manning Tamarack Property Acoustical Study - Manning Homes, Newport Beach, CA
Larissa TM Acoustical Assessment - San Diego, CA
Sav-on Drug Acoustical Assessment - City of Vista, Vista, CA
New Covenant Tabernacle Acoustical Assessment - New Covenant Tabernacle,
National City, CA
National University INA - Jack Henthorn & Associates, Carlsbad, CA
Tran Sweetwater Road Duplexes INA - J.P. Construction Company, El Cajon, CA
Douglas Drive Condo Acoustical Assessment - Western Pacific Housing, Carlsbad, CA
Magellan Gateway Hotel Acoustical Assessment - Curtis Scott Englehorn & Associates,
Cardiff, CA
Turning Point Acoustical Assessment - Hamann Construction, El Cajon, CA
Rev. 7 002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D. rtavares@ise. us Page 13 of 13
a
m
B
a
Del Mar Office Centre Acoustical Review - City of Del Mar Planning Department, Del
Mar, CA
Murrieta Corporate Center Acoustical Assessment - Rancon Real Estate, Ternecula, CA
MUP PO1 -024 Acoustical Site Assessment - Chalice Unitarian Universalist
Congregation, San Diego, CA
2822 5th Avenue STC Assessment - San Diego Housing Commission, San Diego, CA
Vista Focus Academy Acoustical Assessment - Culbertson, Adams & Associates, Aliso
Viejo, CA
TM 5238 Acoustical Study -, San Marcos, CA
VOLC TM 3.10 & 3.1 1 Acoustical Assessment - Morrow Development Inc., San Diego,
CA
VOLC TM 3.1 2 & 3.1 3 Acoustical Assessment - Morrow Development Inc., San Diego,
CA
VOLC TM 3.14'Acoustical Assessment - Morrow Development lnc., San Diego, CA
VOLC TM 3.1 5 Acoustical Assessment - Morrow Development Inc., San Diego, CA
Sonoma INA Assessment - Cornerstone Communities, San Diego, CA
Meridian at Eastlake INA - Cornerstone Communities, San Diego, CA
Morgan's Corner INA - Standard Pacific Homes, Carlsbad, CA
TM 5274 Acoustical Site Assessment - REC Consultants, Inc., La Mesa, CA
Villas at Mission Point INA - Ord & Rodgers Construction Inc., Carlsbad, CA
Northrop-Gruman TRA Relocation - Smith Consulting Architects, San Diego, CA
Diamond Environmental Acoustical Assessment - ADJ Enterprises, San Marcos, CA
Home Depot El Cajon FElR Acoustical Technical Report - David Evans & Associates,
San Diego, CA
Home Depot Oceanside - Greenberg Farrow Architecture, Tustin, CA
Escondido Home Depot Acoustical Study - Greenberg Farrow Architecture, Tustin, CA
TPM 20514 Acoustical Assessment - Leming and Associates, Inc., Ramona, CA
Silvergate Retirement Residence San Marcos - Silvergate Fallbrook Retirement
Residences, Fallbrook, CA
O'Brien Condominiums Acoustical Assessment - O'Brien Communities, Anaheim, CA
Mills at Cortez Hill INA - Skandia Real Estate Group, Solana Beach, CA
Oceanside 140 Property Acoustical Assessment - Concordia Homes, Carlsbad, CA
Church Extension INA - South Bay Baptist Church, Chula Vista, CA
Grizzle TPM Acoustical Assessment -, Holtville, CA
Encinitas Mobil Station Acoustical Assessment - Imperial Stations Inc., Garden Grove,
CA
RUSD Ballfield Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Robertson Ranch Acoustical Assmt - T&B Planning Consultants, Inc., Santa Ana, CA
OSHA / Cal-OSHA Comdiance Surveys
= Acoustical Survey: Area Monitoring and Personal Dosimetry - Dennis Co. Precision Tool
Facility, San Diego, CA.
Acoustical Survey: Area Monitoring and Personal Dosimetry - Second Imperial
Geothermal Company, Heber, CA.
Acoustical Survey: Area Monitoring and Personal Dosimetry - Heber Geothermal
Company, Heber, CA.
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D. rta vares@ise. us
Page 14 of 14
NlOSH Liahtins Comlsonent Survevs
8
8
8
Commercial Lighting Survey - Smith’s Food and Drug Centers, Vista, CA.
Smith Field Lighting and Acoustical Technical Report - San Diego State University
(SDSU), San Diego, CA.
Clarion Hotel LighVGlare Study - Worden, Williams, Richmond, Brechtel, & Gibbs,
Solana Beach, CA
Specialized Enaineerina Survevs
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
m
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
a
8
8
8
a
a
8
Acoustical Evaluation of Siemens DMU - North County Transit District.
Gault Field Acoustical Survey - Schmidt Design Group/Canyon Lake Properties,
Riverside, CA.
Interior Acoustical Analysis and Building Retrofit - MWWD, San Diego, CA.
Boulders Condominiums at Rancho Bernardo Acoustical Assessment - Burnham-
Prowswood Inc., San Diego, CA.
Interior Acoustical Verification Assessment - Sharkey’s Bar and Grill, Encinitas, CA.
Nuisance Acoustical Assessment - Beachcomber Bar and Grill, San Diego, CA.
Luckey Ranch FIA Review - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
BCS Aircraft Study - Greystone Homes, Inc., Carlsbad, CA
Interior Design Specialists Code Compliance - Rose, Munns & Chin, Coronado, CA
Vista 7/11 Offsite Assessment - Vista More Plaza LLC, Solana Beach, CA
Oceanside 140 Airflow Analysis - Concordia Homes, Carlsbad, CA
AUI Due Dilligence Report - Acoustical - Western Pacific Housing, Carlsbad, CA
Lowes Oceanside HVAC Compliance Letter - The Lightfoot Planning Group, Oceanside,
CA
Hoag Heliport Site Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Buss Residential Pipeline Assessment - Olivenhain Municipal Water District, Encinitas,
CA
Pema Onesource Site Compliance Survey - Koll Development Company, La Jolla, CA
Home Depot Las Vegas Generator Acoustical Assessment - The Home Depot, Orange,
CA
Residential Electrical Survey - Pardee Construction Company, San Diego, CA
ORCO Block Acoustical Monitoring - City of Oceanside, Building Dept., Oceanside, CA
Relocation Site Assessment - San Diego Drums and Percussion, Vista, CA
Starbucks Acoustical Impact Assessment - Spherion Legal Group, San Diego, CA
C&H Machine Compressor Acoustical Assessment - Ken D. Smith Architects, El Cajon,
CA
Rancho Bernardo Pump Station Acoustical Assessment - Mooney & Associates, San
Diego, CA
Nautical Bean Code Compliance Survey - City of Oceanside - Community Services
Dept., Oceanside, CA
Air Compressor Study - Jackson Drive Group, El Cajon, CA
Exterior Acoustical Assessment - Code Compliance - San Diego Yacht & Breakfast
Company, San Diego, CA
RCC Mitigation Monitoring Plan - San Diego County Water Authority, San Diego, CA
La Jolla Financial Bldg INA - La Jolla Financial, Inc., La Jolla, CA
Trane Quiet Comfort Award - The Trane Company, San Diego, CA
De La Plaza Compliance Study - M&H Property Management, LLC., San Diego, CA
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise. us
Page 15 of 15
Vista Business Park Acoustical Review - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Price Residence Electrical Study - Pardee Construction Company, San Diego, CA
Encinitas Ford Storage Facility Acoustical - Encinitas Ford, Encinitas, CA
Berkov Residence Electrical Study - Pardee Construction Company, San Diego, CA
GP 2020 Phase I - Ogden Environmental 81 Energy, San Diego, CA
Vista Business Park Acoustical Study - City of Vista, Vista, CA
Luckey Ranch BP Facility Acoustical- Mooney & Associates, San Diego, CA
Stewart Residence Pipeline Study - Olivenhain Municipal Water District, Encinitas, CA
La Posada Forensic Assessment - Trimark Pacific Homes, L.P., Escondido, CA
SDecialized Seismic / Vibration Sutvevs
rn
HVAC Vibration Mitigation - Pardee Construction Company, San Diego CA.
Determination of Impact Zone from SD 100D Vibratory Roller - Bonadiman Civil-Design
Corp., Riverside, CA.
Toyota Dynamometer Dynamic Testing - AVL North America, Inc., Plymouth, MI
Parc West Metropolitan Vibration - RGC Courthomes, Inc., Newport Beach, CA
HVAC Acoustical & Vibration Mitigation - Pardee Construction Company, San Diego,
CA
Gregory Canyon Rock Crushing Assessment - The Chase Group, Solana Beach, CA
La Jolla Village Towers Vibration Assessment - Classic Residences By Hyatt, Chicago,
IL
Walker Residence Vibration Assessment - GEOPACIFICA Geotechnical Consultants,
Oceanside, CA
ExDerimental/ Laboratow Analvsis
rn
rn
m
Determination of Seismic Transmissibility of 500KV Transformer-Bushing Pairs- Pacific
Gas and Electric / University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA
IC1 Paints Seismic Walkdown Survey - Ogden Environmental & Energy, San Diego, CA
Experimental Determination of Print Head Spectral Response - Axiohm Components.
Experimental Determination of Sound Characteristics of Reciprocating Gasoline Engine
Determination of Modal Characteristics of Damped and Undamped Composite Missile
Interceptor Structures - Sparta Inc., San Diego, CA.
Determination of Dynamic Failure Characteristics of US. Coast Guard “Star-Rotor”
Assembly - US. Coast Guard, San Diego, CA.
Experimental Determination of Damage in a Lightly Damped Elastic Space Truss -
UCSD.
Development of a Computational Scheme for Rectangular Plate Stresses and Natural
Frequencies - SDSU.
Verification of Shear-Mode Vibratory Properties of Three-story Structure - UCSD.
Optimal Design of Mechanical Damping System - SDSU.
- SDSU.
Environmental Assessment Studies
Alvarado Water Filtration Plant Expansion and Rehabilitation Project Acoustical Study -
City of San Diego Water Utilities Department.
Rev. 1002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rta vares@ise. us Page 16 of 16
B
Emergency Water Storage Project Acoustical and Vibration Technical Report - San
Diego County Water Authority.
Naval Air Station North Island Aircraft Carrier Homeporting EIS Acoustical Technical
Report - U.S. Navy, SWDIV.
Santa Fe Valley Specific Plan EIR Acoustical Technical Report - County of San Diego.
Oceanside to Escondido Light Rail EIS Acoustical and Vibration Technical Report -
North County Transit District.
Gregory Canyon Landfill and Recycling Center EIR Acoustical Technical Report -
County of San Diego.
Gregory Canyon Landfill and Recycling Center EIR Vibration Technical Report - County
of San Diego.
Magma Geothermal Project, Acoustical Analysis of Drilling Operations - Imperial
County.
Jefferson Street Realignment EIR Acoustical Assessment - City of Vista.
Scripps Poway Parkway EIR Acoustical Technical Report - City of Poway
Potrero Air Pori Expanded Initial Study and Major Use Permit - County of San Diego
Sycamore Avenue Initial Study/Negative Declaration Acoustical Technical Report- City
of Vista
La Mesa Materials Recover Facility EIR Acoustical Technical Report - City of La
Mesa/Laidlaw Environmental Services Facility Modification SEIR - Kern County.
Chiquita Canyon Solid Waste Landfill EIR Acoustical Technical Report - County of Los
Angeles
Brown Field Border Patrol Station Environmental Assessment (EA) Acoustical Technical
Report - U.S. Dept. of Justice, Immigration and Naturalization Service.
@ PUBLICATIONS
Tavares, R., Determination of Blast-lnduced Dynamic Soil Response Using Axisymmetric
Boundary Elements - Ph.D. Thesis, 133 pp., 0 2001 University of California, Irvine.
Tavares, R., Pardoen, G.C., Villaverde, R., lmproved Method for Determining Surface Wave
Blast Response, Journal of Explosives Engineering - International Society of Explosives
Engineers (ISEE), Submitted, 11/01,
Tavares, R., Pardoen, G.C., Villaverde, R., Modeling of Rayleigh Wave Vibration in Nastic
Solids due to Construction Blasting, - Journal of the Institute of Noise Control
Engineering (INCE), Submitted, 11/01,
Tavares, R., Pardoen, G.C., Villaverde, R., lmproved Modeling of Electrical Substation
Equipment for Seismic Loads, International Conference on Structural Engineering
Mechanics and Computation - SEMC 2001, Capetown, SA April 2001,
Tavares, R. and Mock, P. Noise Effecfs on Least Bell's Vireo: Studies of Military Helicopter
Activity, Auto Traffic, and Light Rails, Conference on Noise Effects on Passerine Birds,
U.S. Navy, US. Marine Corps, Hubbs-Sea World Research Institute, Jan. 1997.
.
Tavares, R. Calculation of Sound Pressure Levels Due to Isentropic Free Expansion in a
Pipeline, ASME Energy Week '97 Conference Submission 0 1997 ASMElEnergy Week.
Rev. I002
Rick Tavares, Ph.D.
rtavares@ise. us
Page 17 of 17
Tavares, R. Vibratory Influence Zone Calculation Using Modified Modal Impact Methods,
Proceedings of the Institute of Noise Control Engineering INCE 95-43.2.3, 0 1996 INCE.
Tavares, R., et at. Using Experimental Modal Data to Detect Damage in a Space Truss, 25th
AlAA SDM Conference AIAA-93-1486-CP, co-author, 0 1993 AIM.
Tavares, R. A Computational Scheme for the Determination of Rectangular Plate Stresses,
Deflections, and Natural Frequencies Subjecf to Combined Moisture and Thermal
Effects, MSME Thesis, 186 pp., 0 1992 San Diego State Press.
Tavares, R., Dharmarajan, S. Composite Structural Analvsis 3rd Ed., Graduate level
engineering text, 280 pp., co-author, 0 I991 Dharmarajan Engineering Services/lSE.
Rev. 1002
EXHIBIT C
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
ia
19
2c
21
2;
22
24
2:
2t
2:
21
HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 351
A RESOLUTION OF THE HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA APPROVING THE WORK PLAN FOR
DEVELOPMENT OF A LAND USE STRATEGY FOR THE SOUTH CARLSBAD
COASTAL REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA AND AUTHORIZATION TO STAFF
TO PROCEED WITH APPROPRIATE ACTIONS TO OBTAIN CONSULTANT
SERVICES FOR THE PROPOSED PROJECT.
WHEREAS, on July 18,2000, the City Council and Housing and Redevelopment Commission
ook the necessary actions to adopt a redevelopment plan for the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment
kea, and
WHEREAS, as one of the City Council goals for fiscal year 2000-2001, a work plan was
ieveloped and approved by the Housing and Redevelopment Commission on May 15,2001 to prepare a
Land Use Strategy and Master Plan for the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Project Area; and
WHEREAS, the State Board of Equalization took action in November, 2001 which created some
financial uncertainty for the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area as a result of rule changes
related to the assessment of mrchnt power plants; and
WHEREAS, the Carlsbad Redevelopment Agency has reconsidered the original work plan
approved by the Housing and Redevelopment Commission and prepared a revised work pIan in response
to the financial uncertainty created by the State Board of Equalization as related to redevelopment
impIementation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Housing and Redevelopment Commission of
the City of Carlsbad as follows:
1. The revised Work Plan prepared for development of a Land Use Strategy for the South
Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area attached hereto, is hereby accepted and approved, and the
Executive Director of the Carlsbad Redevelopment Agency or designee is authorized to proceed with
implementation of the subject Work Plan.
P
F\WORD\REDPROJ.DIR\SCCRA Workplanll AB Reso.* 1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
e 14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1
2. Staff is authorized to proceed with appropriate actions to obtain consultant services for
mplementation of the approved Work Plan for development of a Land Use Strategy for the South
hlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a renular meeting of the Housing and
tedevelopment Commission of the City of Carlsbad, California, on the 1 9 t h day of -02,
by the following vote, to wit:
AYES: Commission Members Lewis, Kulchin, Finnila, Nygaard
NOES: None A
ABSENT: Commissioner Hall
ABSTAIN: None
YJTEST:
F:\WORDWEDPROJ.DIR\SCCRA Wwkplanll AB Reso.doc 2 5
SGCTH CArnSEttD COASTAL rnEE'r'ELO??Vrn?IT ?ROJECT ARXA
WORK PLAN FOR DEVELOPMENT OF A LAND USE STRATEGY
I. Introduction
On July 18, 2000, the City Council and the Housing and Redevelopment Commission took the
action necessary to adopt a redevelopment plan for the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment
Project Area. Adoption of this plan established the boundaries for this redevelopment project
area, and effectively created a second redevelopment project area for the City of Carlsbad.
The following work plan has been developed in an effort to outline the steps to be taken by the
Carlsbad Redevelopment Agency to develop a Land Use Strategy for the South Carlsbad Coastal
Redevelopment Project Area.
11. Status of Current Adivities/Efforts/StdiedNegotiations
Because there are currently a variety of activities already occurring as related to redevelopment
of the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area, this section will provide a status report on
existing, on-going effortslstudieslnegotiations for information purposes as related to 1)
redevelopment of the Encina Power Plant, 2) realignment of Carlsbad Boulevard, 3)
revitalization of the Ponto Area, and 4) various other projects including negotiations with San
Diego Gas and Electric for development of their commercially-zoned property.
Enciw Power Plant
A staff team has been discussing redevelopment of the Encina Power Plant site for a year or
more with the current owners, Cabrillo Power (DynegyMRG). To date, an agreement has not
been reached with Cabrillo Power. However, the City has indicated its position and has a goal to
enter into a Memorandum of Understanding for any improvements or redevelopment of the site.
The City and Redevelopment Agency's objective is to work towards the complete demolition of
the existing Power Plant at its current location on the existing site and provide for construction of
a new, physically smaller Plant towards the rear of the existing site. The City and Agency's top
preference is to have the new Power Plant constructed within the area between the railroad tracks
and Interstate 5, which is east of the existing Plant site.
With demolition of the existing Power Plant and construction of a new Plant to the rear of the existing site, excess development property will be created which is located in a prime coastal
location. It is staff's opinion that this excess property could be used for both private and public
land uses. Following is a list of ideas generated by staff for potential use of the excess property:
Public Parking.
0 Public Recreational (Passive or Active) Facilities
0 Private Development with a Public Benefit, such as Marine Research with Aquarium
Private Development with a Commercial Benefit, such as a restaurant or hotel.
A combination of some or all of the above uses may be most appropriate for the excess property
created by redevelopment of the Power Plant.
A staff team has been meeting with San Diego Gas and Electric to discuss fume plans for the
48-acre parcel east of Interstate 5 which is zoned for commercial development, and includes
property identified by the City as desirable for public use purposes. This staff team has been
more specifically discussing a lot line adjustment and other activities which would potentially
result in the slight reconfiguration of the 43-acre lot, and allow San Diego Gas and Electric to
separate property ownership from Cabrillo Power for the parcels (east of Interstate 5) which are
to remain under SDGE ownership on a long term basis,
These discussions are separate from the negotiations noted above as related to Cabrillo Power
and redevelopment of the Encina Power Plant site.
Carlsbud Boulevard Realignment Project
The Planning Department was the leader on a project to study the potential land uses for excess
property created as a result of the potential realignment of Carlsbad Boulevard. Although a
decision has not yet been made by the City Council to completely realign Carlsbad Boulevard, a
decision was made approximately two (2) years ago to study the excess or surplus land uses that
are possible options for consideration if the entire Boulevard is realigned at a later date, The
Planning Department was tasked with completing this Land Use Study.
The consultant hired to complete the subject Carlsbad Boulevard Land Use Study was instructed
to study various options for land uses which include public facilities and recreational
opportunities as well as commercial development opportunities. This study has been completed.
Staff is currently reviewing the findings and will make a recommendation at a later date as to
how best to process the results of the study and how best to incorporate the recommendations
into the Land Use Strategy for the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area.
It is important to note that a condition of approval for the Poinsettia Properties project recently
resulted in the installation of public improvements which resulted in a partid realignment of
Carlsbad Boulevard at and around the intersection at Poinsettia Avenue. The enhancement of the
intersection resulted in the creation of some excess property adjacent to the Carlsbad State
Campground. The excess property has been a subject of staff negotiations with the State of
California Parks Department regarding a trade of property at the campground site for other
property that could be created if the City realigned the entire Carlsbad Boulevard.
Redevelotment/Revitalization/Clean- Up of Ponto Area
Currently, there are no ongoing discussions or projects which have been initiated by the City or
Redevelopment Agency within the Ponto Area. However, there has been interest indicated by
various property owners in the Ponto Area who would like to pursue development on their
properties. An example is a recently processed Preliminary Review Application for a hotelhesort
on the property owned by Mr. Dale Schreiber. Staff has indicated to Mr. Schreiber that he has
the right to proceed with processing of a land use development application if he so desired.
However, he would be required to comply with all existing land use regulations, including
zoning and development standards. In addition, the proposed project could not effect other
properties in an adverse manner as a result of road alignments, etc. Staff has suggested that Mr.
Schreiber delay his project application until a Land Use Strategy is completed for all or a portion
of the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Project Area in order to better coordinate with the
long term gods and objectives for the Ponto Arm; and to enswe that carefu! consideration is
given to the best circuiation system for the area for development and revitalization purposes. 'I
t
Other property owners within the Ponto Area have also discussed potential new development at
varying levels with City/Agency Staff. However, no formal land use development applications
are currently pending City/Agency approval or other action. It is important to note that for any
development within the Ponto Area, a Specific Plan is required. This Specific Plan could be
developed for individual properties, or for the whole area (which is proposed within this Work
PlLUl).
Pending Private Developments
Currently, within the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Project Area, there are several
projects which have been approved for private development or are pending completion of the
application review process. These projects include the Cannon Court project which proposes
restaurant, hotel and retail on the property located north of Cannon Road and adjacent to
Interstate 5. A Residence Inn Hotel was approved for the site located south of Cannon Road and
adjacent to Interstate 5 and has been fully constructed as of this date.
Currently, there are two properties located outside, but adjacent to, the boundaries of the South
Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area upon which have private developments proposed which
will have a significant impact on the area from a land use standpoint. The subject properties are
located south of the Ponto Area and west of the railroad tracks (off of Avenida Encinas), and are
cunently part of the Poinsettia Shores Specific Plan area. Staff has indicated to the potential
developers for these properties that they will need to be included within the Land Use Strategy
for the redevelopment area, and requested that development applications not be pursued on these
properties until such time as the land use planning effort is complete. Although these properties
are not located within the redevelopment area boundaries, they can be included within the land
use planning effort due to the significant impact they will have on surrounding land uses, future
redevelopment of the area and development of this key coastal area, which is also a southern
entryway into the City of Carlsbad. The developers have agreed to work with Staff to prepare
the subject Specific Plan for the most southern portion of the South Carlsbad Coastal
Redevelopment Area, and to include their properties within that Specific Plan.
Coastal Rail Trail
For many years, Public Works Staff has been working as the lead agency to develop the Coastal
Rail Trail. Within Carlsbad, this Coastal Rail Trail wili be an important consideration for
incorporation into any new Land Use Strategy for the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment
area.
III. Development of a Land Use Stratem for the South Cartsbad Coastal Redevelo~rnent - Area
The following plan outlines the steps to be taken to develop a Land Use Strategy for the newly
adopted South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area. Essentially, the Land Use Strategy
development process will occur in three phases in the form of three (3) Specific Plans for the
three (3) Planning Areas noted on the attached map and described further within this work plan.
Phase 1: Develop and Process a Specific Plan for Planning Area 3 which includes
the redevelopment area south of Poinsettia Avenue to the city limits to the
south and incorporates two properties outside the redevelopment areas
boundaries, but within dose proximity to ttre South Garlsbad Camtaf
RebevLsloprnePrt mix
Due to an immediate need for a comprehensive Land Use Strategy for properties located within
Planning Area 3 of the South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Area and adjacent to it, the
Redevelopment Agency will initially pursue development of a Specific Plan for the area south of
Poinsettia Avenue, west of the railroad tracks, east of the ocean, and north of the southern City
limits (Planning Area 3).
Product(s): A Specific Plan to include, but not limited to, a Vision for the area, a land use plan,
circulation and roadway alignment, open space and resource preservation, public facilities, and
design theme elements.
Phase 2: Develop and Process a Specific Plan for Planning Area 1, which includes
the Power Want and related properties as well as other properties to the
north and south, and east of 1-5.
Following completion of the Specific Plan for Planning Area 3, the Redevelopment Agency will
pursue development of a Specific Plan for the northern most portion of the South Carlsbad
Coastal Redevelopment Area which includes the Power Plant and related properties as well as
property east of 1-5 (Planning Area 1).
Product(s): A Specific Plan to include, but not limited to, a Vision for the area, a land use plan,
circulation and roadway alignment, open space and resource presewation, public facilities,
design theme elements.
Phase 3: Develop and Prwess a Specific Plan ?or Planning AP- 2, which includes
properties within the boundaries of the South Carlsbad Coastal
Redevelopment Area between Cannon Road and Poinsettia Avenue, west of
railroad tracks.
Following completion of the Specific Plans for Planning Areas 3 & 1, the Redevelopment
Agency will pursue development of a Specific Plan for the middle portion of the South Carlsbad
Coastal Redevelopment Area which includes all properties within the redevelopment area
boundaries from Cannon Road to Painsettia Avenue, along the Carlsbad Boulevard (Planning
Area 2).
Product(s): A Specific Plan to include, but not limited to, a Vision for the area, a land use plan,
circulation and roadway alignment, open space and resource preservation, public facilities,
design theme elements.
Public EnpaPement Process
During development of the above noted Specific Plans, public meetings and workshops will be
held with stakeholders, including property owners and residents in the area, and with Agencies
with jurisdiction within the noted planning areas. At this time, no formal Advisory Committee is
being proposed. Staff believes that open meetings with all appropriate stakeholders will ensure
maximum participation by all persons interested in the land use strategy for each of the planning
areas. Because each of the three planning areas are so unique, the individual Specific PIans will
allow for more focused attention on each area as an effort is made to develop a vision and land
use strategy for each area.
,
It is anticipated that it will take approximately 6 to 9 months to develop and process each of the
three Specific Plans. The process is to be initiated in fiscal year 2001-2002 and to continue in
phases as noted above.
In future years, the three Specific Plans may be combined into one comprehensive Master Plan
and Redevelopment Implementation Program. However, at this time, the three Specific Plans are
needed for land use planning purposes and will be utilized by the Redevelopment Agency to
allow development in the area to continue in a manner consistent with a desired theme and land
use strategy.
V. Summary
The Redevelopment Agency proposes within this work plan to develop and process three (3)
separate Specific Plans for the three (3) planning areas identified on the attached map.
Upon approval of this Work Plan by the Housing and Redevelopment Commission, staff will
initiate the appropriate activities to begin the process as set forth above. Copies of this Work
Plan will be distributed to the various stakehoIders for information purposes,
! t
I South Carlsbad Coastal Redevelopment Project
NORTH 1-1 Project Area A
i
I Projectkea _I---
.---. . A N
FROM : 757-5820C iiim Works PHONE NO. : 7607575820 Jun. 28 2005 83:32PM PI
June 28,2005
To: Ciulsbad City Council
Carlsbad City Manager
Re: Ponto Beachfiont Wage Vision Plan
GPA 05-04LCPA 05-0 1/D 1 05-0 1
My name is Carolyn Krammer and 1 am the Chairperson of the Cibm fbr the P&em&on of Parks and Beaches. Our citizens group is based in Oceanside but believe
the proposed Vision Plan will have serious ramifications on your Caastal neighbors
including Oceanside.
We respectfully request that you deny a Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation
Monitoring and Reporting Program; that you deny an amendment to the text of the Land
Use Element of the General Plan and deny an amendment to the text of the Mello I1 and
West Batiquitos LagoonlSammis Properties Segments of the Local Coastal Frogam;
deny the Ponto Beachfkont Village Vision Plan as proposed.
We request that the City of Carlsbad be required to do an Environmental Impact Report
before going fotward or proceeding any further with plans for redevelopment at Po&.
You can save the time and energy of your City, your staff and any future developers that
may have an interest in proposed changes to the Pow area h order for any
development or developer to propose a project, there should be guidelines for development that would be consist- with findings in an EIR We feel it is the responsibility of the City of Carlsbad to show leadership and do the right thing for its
citizens and future development of this site. I am sure you can find a way for the City to
be reimbursed far its EIR expenses.
Don't go the way of your Oceanside neighbor and end up in an appeal all the way to the coastal Commission. Do the right thing, do an EJR and work with your citizens and community to come up with an enviromental friendly plan.
Thank you Carolyn Krammer, Chairperson, CPPB
904 LRonard Avenue, Oceanside, CA. 92054
COAST LAW GROUP LLr
Delivered via personal delivery
June 27,2005
City of Carlsbad
C/O Gary Barberio
1635 Faraday Avenue
Carlsbad, CA 92008
169 Saxony Road
Suite 201
Encinitas, CA 92024
Tel 760-942-8505
Fax 760-942-8515
www.coastlawmouo.com
AGENDAITEM# / /
C: Mayor
City Council
City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
RE: Agenda Item #11
Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan, DI 05-01
LCPA 05-01
GPA 05-04
Honorable Mayor and City Council,
his family to Ponto Beach to surf and enjoy the beach. Mr. Adams feels very strongly that an EIR
must be conducted to analyze the impacts of the Vision Plan and lessen or avoid the significant
impacts of the project. He would further like the City of Carlsbad (CITY) to explore potential
options for setting aside the entire tract as public open space. These comments are submitted on his
behalf.
Coast Law Group LLP represents John H. Adams, a citizen of Carlsbad, who regularly brings
1. The Vision Plan “Bootstraps” an Entire SDecific Plan into the General Plan and Local
Coastal Plan Without Proper Environmental Review.
The CITY is attempting to “bootstrap” an entire specific plan into the General Plan and Local
Coastal Program. The proposed General Plan Amendment (GPA) and Local Coastal Program
Amendment (LCPA), both specifically state:
Future Proposals for new development within this area of special planning consideration shall
be guided by the Vision Plan and all future development permits (site development plan,
coastal development permit, etc.) shall be reviewed by the city for conformance with the
Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan.
In other words, according to both the GPA and LCPA, all new development must comply
with the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan (“Vision Plan”). The vision plan locks in
development in a certain manner. For example, the Vision Plan locks in an “upscale” luxury
Beachfront Resort south of Avenida Encinas. (See Vision Plan, Ch. 2, P. 6). Without an EIR, it is
currently unknown whether such a large scale resort is the best use of the land, especially considering
the location adjacent to the Batiquitos Lagoon.
Code. However, if one was attempting to put the “vision plan” into a planning box, it fits most
closely with a “specific plan” See Govt. Code 6 65450 et. seq..
Further, a “vision plan” does not have any legal definition under the California Government
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #11, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 2 of 9
The Vision Plan establishes: 1. The distribution, location and extent of the uses of land, including
open space; 2. distribution and location of major components of transportation, water drainage and
other public infrastructure, and; 3. standards and criteria by which development will proceed. See,
Govt. Code 8 65451.
In fact, the only reason that the Vision Plan is not legally a “specific plan” is that it does not
include a “program of implementation measures including regulations, programs, public works
projects, and financing measures necessary to cany out paragraphs (l), (2), and (3).” Govt. Code 6
6545 1. In other words, the most important part of the “specific plan,” how to pay for the necessary
improvements, is absent from the Vision Plan.
Regardless, if it looks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it is a duck. In this case, this is a
specific plan that does not fully comply with the requirements for a specific plan under the
Government Code. Approving the Vision Plan would constitute an abuse of discretion and would be
subject to a writ of mandamus. Code of Civ. Proc. 0 1094.5.
2. An EIR is Rewired Whenever it can be Fairly Armed that a Pro-iect has a Potentially
Simificant Impact on the Environment.
Our client strongly objects to approving the Vision Plan without a full Environmental Impact
Report (EIR). The EIR is the “heart of CEQA.” Laurel Heights Zmprovement Ass‘n v. Regents of
University of California, 47 Cal. 3d 376,392 (1988). An EIR must be prepared whenever it can be
fairly argued that a project may have a significant impact on the environment. No Oil, Znc. v. Los
Angeles, 13 Cal. 3d 68,75 (1974). “If there was substantial evidence that the proposed project might
have a significant environmental impact, evidence to the contrary is not sufficient to support a
decision to dispense with preparation of an EIR and adopt a negative declaration.” Friends of ”B“
Street v. City of Hayward, 106 Cal. App. 3d 988, 1002 (1980).
potential for a significant impact, the lead agency must prepare an EIR. CEQA Guidelines 8
15064(g); Quail Botanical Gardens Found. v. City of Encinitas, 29 Cal. App. 4th 1597, 1606-07
(1994). However, expert opinion is not required to provide substantial evidence of a potentially
significant impact. See e.g., Citizens Assn. for Sensible Development of Bishop Area v. County of
Znyo, 172 Cal. App. 3d 151, 173 (1985) (explaining that substantial evidence may consist of an
adjacent property testifying about traffic conditions). Furthermore, the lack of environmental
analysis in a mitigated negative declaration (MND) strengthens and expands the scope of the “fair
argumenf’standard. Sundstrom v. County ofMendocino, 202 Cal. App. 3d 296,311 (1988). It is up
to the lead agency to do the proper studies, not the public. Id.
If there is a disagreement by experts over the significance of an environmental impact or the
3. The Citv must PreDare an Environmental ImDact Report as Early as Possible to Analvze
the ImDac4s of the Vision Plan.
A lead agency cannot defer analysis of potential impacts until later. As discussed by the
California Supreme Court, “Obviously it is desirable that the precise information concerning
environmental consequences which an EIR affords be furnished and considered at the earliest
possible stage .... Thus, EIR’s should be prepared as early in the planning process as possible to enable
environmental considerations to influence project, program or design.” Bozung v. Local Agency
Formation Corn., 13 Cal.. 3d 263,282 (1975). While there are no requirements to analyze purely
speculative projects, “[An EIR] should be prepared as early as feasible in the planning process to
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #11, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 3 of 9
enable environmental considerations to influence project program and design and yet late enough to
provide meaningful information for environmental assessment.” Laurel Heights Zmprovernent Ass‘n
v. Regents of University of California, 47 Cal. 3d 376,395 (1988).
In this case, the Vision Plan is very detailed. It contemplates the location of hotels, the
location of mixed use centers and the location of parking structures, streets and drainage. Now is the
time that the CITY should be preparing an EIR on the Vision Plan, because the Vision Plan is at an
early enough stage in planning to permit changes to avoid or mitigate significant impact.
Once the Vision Plan is in place, regardless of subsequently identified environmental
impacts, the CITY will be under tremendous pressure to either downplay the impacts or accept a
proposed project regardless of the impacts. This phenomenon was specifically noted by the
California Supreme Court, which stated “the later the environmental review process begins, the more
bureaucratic and financial momentum there is behind a proposed project, thus providing a strong
incentive to ignore environmental concerns that could be dealt with more easily at an early stage of
the project.” Laurel Heights, supra, at 395.
As stated repeatedly throughout the Mitigated Negative Declaration, the analysis of potential
impacts and mitigation will be required for subsequent projects. (See, MND, at 21 & 22 (biological
resources), 23 (cultural resources), 25 & 26 (hydrology and water quality) and 28 (Noise)). In each
of these cases, it is clear that there are potentially significant impacts. For example, in the cultural
resources section, the MND identifies that a cultural resource site exists and there may be a
subsurface component to such site. However, the mitigation simply requires that a future survey is
conducted. (MND at 23; See also Planning Commission Resolution No. 5884, at 2-3).
Finally, the actual mitigation measures for potential impacts will be imposed later in the
process. This sort of future mitigation was expressly rejected by the Court of Appeals. It was
expressly noted that mitigation measures must be incorporated into a project before a project is
approved. Sundstrom v. County of Mendocino, 202 Cal. App. 3d 296,306 (1988). Relying on future
studies to impose mitigation measures is directly counter to CEQA. Id. at 307.
Thus, now is the time that the CITY must prepare an EIR analyzing the impacts of the Vision
Plan and ensure that all impacts, direct, indirect, and cumulative impacts are mitigated or avoided to
the maximum extent possible. Pub. Res. Code $8 21002, 21081.
4. The City must Analyze the Entire Proiect. Which Includes all the DeveloDment Proiects
Anticipated to Comply with the Vision Plan.
A “project” is defined in the CEQA guidelines as “the whole of an action, which has a
potential for resulting in either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably
foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment.” CEQA Guidelines $ 15378. The CITY
must consider all phases of project planning, implementation and operation. See CEQA Guidelines 8
15063(b). Analysis must include the significant impacts of reasonably foreseeable projects. CEQA
Guidelines $ 15130. The CITY must analyze the impacts for six subsequent projects it envisions
under the Vision Plan: The Garden Hotel; the Village Hotel; the Beachfront Resort, the Mixed-Use
Center, the Live-Work Neighborhood and the Townhouse Neighborhood. (See Vision Plan, Chapter
2, p. 1). In this case, the analysis of the impacts of the various projects are deferred until later.
minimize cumulative impacts from a project:
In the Bozung Case, the Supreme Court warned that deferring analysis has a tendency to
One final overwhelming consideration which militates against deferring the preparation and
consideration of an EIR until the proposed development reaches the city level is the mandate
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #11, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 4 of 9
of CEQA that environmental considerations do not become submerged by chopping a large
project into many little ones -- each with a minimal potential impact on the environment --
which cumulatively may have disastrous consequences.
Bozung v. Local Agency Formation Corn., 13 Cal. 3d 263,283-284 (1975); See also, Citizens Assn.
for Sensible Development of Bishop Area v. County of Inyo, 172 Cal. App. 3d 151,166 (1985)
(abuse of discretion to segment approvals for shopping center).
of the project. For example, the urban run-off, which includes significant contaminants from the
street such as oil, pesticides, fertilizers and animal waste will be transported to the Batiquitos Lagoon
in an 84 inch pipe. Such pipe also transports storm water from other developments. Considering
that the project is just north of Batiquitos Lagoon, a protected water body, the CITY must do a
cumulative impacts analysis to determine what impacts the project will have on the lagoon. Clearly,
there are potential cumulative impacts to plant life, wildlife, and water quality. The CITY cannot
minimize the impacts by dividing the analysis up into small projects that may have a minimal
impact, but cumulatively have a disastrous effect on Batiquitos Lagoon. The CITY must prepare an
EIR to ensure that all impacts are either avoided or mitigated to a level of insignificance.
By deferring analysis, the CITY is avoiding even analyzing the potential cumulative impacts
5. The City Failed to Analyze or Mitigate the Significant Impact on the Public Facilities at the
Beach.
The limited beach facilities at Ponto Beach and South Carlsbad Beach provide a perfect
example as to why the cumulative impacts of the entire project need to be analyzed before approving
the Vision Plan. Currently, the South Carlsbad State Beach has limited restroom facilities for its
campers. At Ponto Beach, there is one shower, and no permanent restrooms.
According to the traffic study prepared by the CITY, the Vision Plan will create 710 hotel
rooms, 147 condos, 21 1 apartments, plus numerous restaurants and shops, creating 12,407 additional
daily trips on the roads. (RBF Traffic Study, at 20). If even 25% of those trips include visits to the
beach, then that is an additional 3,100 trips to the beach. Obviously, the addition of 3,100 visits to
the beach will generate a significant increase in the amount of trash and litter, lifeguard services,
ranger services, and impacts to the public facilities, such as restrooms.
Even if only 1,000 extra people a day visit the beach, it is still a significant increase in the
burden on necessary services. The cumulative impacts of the Vision Plan need to be analyzed to
ensure that the current facilities at Carlsbad State Beach are not overwhelmed. Facilities must be
built at Ponto Beach to accommodate the increased use. An EIR is necessary to determine what kind
of facilities need to be constructed to handle the increase in volume of beach users, to determine the
number of rangers and lifeguards which need to be hired, and determine how to fund the increase in
operating expenses. California’s budgetary crisis prevents the State from simply building such
facilities itself. Mitigation for the increased use of the beach must be imposed on all projects within
the Vision Plan.
The MND in this case, does not discuss the impacts on the recreational facilities at all. It
claims that there would be no impact on existing facilities. Failure to actually analyze this impact
raises more than a fair argument that there may be a potential impact. As noted by the Court of
Appeals:
CEQA places the burden of environmental investigation on government rather than the
public. If the local agency has failed to study an area of possible environmental impact, a fair
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #11, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 5 of 9
argument may be based on the limited facts in the record. Deficiencies in the record may
actually enlarge the scope of fair argument by lending a logical plausibility to a wider range
of inferences.
Sundstrom v. County of Mendocino, 202 Cal. App. 3d 296,311 (1988); See also, County Sanitation
Dist. No. 2 v. County of Kern, 127 Cal. App. 4th 1544, 1597 (2005)(finding a fair argument that
there may be an environmental impact, because the Respondent did not analyze a potential impact).
prepare an EIR before approving the project so that these impacts are fully analyzed and mitigated.
The CITY failed to consider the impacts to the beach due to the Vision Plan. The CITY must
6. There is a Fair Armment that Traffic ImDacts of the Vision Plan are Significant.
The CITY comes to the conclusion that, because the Vision Plan doesn’t significantly
increase traffic over what could be built under the existing General Plan, it is not a significant
impact. However, the proper threshold for significance is whether the Vision Plan will cause a
significant impact over the current environmental conditions. Guidelines 8 15064(d); See also,
Guidelines 0 15 125(a)(the baseline for significant impacts is the environmental conditions at the
time the notice of preparation of an EIR is filed). Thus, the question is not whether the impact will
be worse under the General Plan or the Vision Plan, but whether it is a significant impact as
compared to the existing conditions.
Currently, there is a significant amount of traffic along Carlsbad Boulevard during the
Summer, especially on weekends. At times the area becomes grid-locked with the amount of cars
that are already on the road. The traffic study, however, was based on data from April, 2004, which
would not have much traffic, and a number of weekdays during the Summer of 2003. Such study
does not accurately reflect the amount of traffic produced by a major tourist area as contemplated in
the Vision Plan. To properly analyze the amount of traffic impact, the CITY must prepare a traffic
study to determine the weekend use of the project. After all, hotels, resorts and restaurants will have
the greatest occupancy during the Summer and on weekends.
Furthermore, it is completely ludicrous to determine that the level of service (LOS) at La
Costa and Pacific Coast Highway would be reduced to an unacceptable level, but the LOS at the
intersection of Avenida Encinas and Carlsbad Boulevard would maintain a good level of service. In
addition, while the Vision Plan discusses improvements at the Avenida Encinas intersection, the
mitigated negative declaration does not require such mitigation measures.
U-Turn from north to south on Carlsbad Avenue, are absolutely necessary. North-bound surfers and
beachgoers currently make a right turn on Avenida Encinas, and then make a three point U-turn on
Ponto Drive to access Ponto Beach. This system is currently unacceptable. However, if the luxury
hotel is built south of Avenida Encinas, even this option will not be possible. Surfers and other
beachgoers will have to travel all the way to Poinsettia to make a U-turn and park at the beach. That
will require an extra 1.5 miles just to park at the beach. Traffic will be significantly impacted due to
the lack of viable access to the beach from the south, unless mitigation is required at Avenida
Encinas. The MND must be rejected until conditions are attached ensuring that traffic will not be
adversely affected.
The improvements to the intersection at Avenida Encinas, which include a left turn lane for
7. The Vision Plan May Disturb Wildlife Repardless of Setbacks and Other MitiPation
Measures Outlined in the Carlsbad Habitat Manavement Plan.
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #I 1, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 6 of 9
According to Figure 28 of the Carlsbad Habitat Management Plan (HMP), the Vision Plan is
in an area that is set aside for development. It is unclear what conservation standards, if any, apply
to the area to be occupied by the Vision Plan. According to HMP, the primary “mitigation” for
development outside of “standards areas” or other special areas identified by the HMP, is
participation in a “Habitat In Lieu Mitigation” program where the developer pays a fee for the
destruction of habitat. (See HMP, E-7). However, it is not entirely clear that any mitigation
whatsoever is required because the Ponto Vision Plan area is identified for use as development. It
might not ever have any mitigation standards imposed for loss of habitat.
It is also clear that the CITY has not been enforcing its buffer requirements specified in the
HMP. According to the HMP, the Buffer width from wetlands must be 1OOft. (See, Second
Addendum to the HMP, at p. 6). The buffer is to be measured from the edge of the wetland OR
where the wetland bank has a steep slope, 100 ft. from the top of the steep slope. Currently, there is
still mowing and brush clearing occurring within the 1OOft. of the top of the slope in the parcel south
of Avenida Encinas. Furthermore, according to HMP, the developer can propose a reduction in the
amount of buffer. (Id.) There is no guarantee that the buffer will be effective in protecting
endangered and threatened species.
the HMP), the standards will not prevent the loss of habitat (or the continuing loss of habitat) that is
necessary to avoid or mitigate the impacts to wildlife. See, Communitiesfor a Better Environment v.
California Resources Agency, 103 Cal. App. 4th 98, 115 (2002). Furthermore, it will be relying on
a developers’ surveyor to determine the extent of the impact on biological resources. This is exactly
the situation that was disapproved of in Sundstrom, where future mitigation would be reliant on the
developer’s future studies. Sundstrom, 202 Cal. App. 3d at 306.
Batiquitos Lagoon has least tern nesting area just a short distance from the southern end of the
proposed project, where a luxury hotel is planned. According to the Carlsbad “2005 Visitors Guide”
Batiquitos Lagoon contains over 185 species of birds. (Carlsbad, 2005 Visitors Guide, at 9). As
noted in the MND, both the American peregrine falcon and the California homed lark have been
spotted at the project site. (MND at 21). Even the Vision Plan admits that “Impacts to any western
burrowing owl and coastal California gnatcatcher bird species would be significant, if present, and
could pose a constraint to development of the disturbed lands and disturbed coastal sage scrub.”
(Vision Plan at 10). The Vice-Chair of the San Diego Chapter of the Surfrider Foundation, a trained
biologist, observed and photographed a pair of California coastal gnatcatchers on the southern parcel
where the luxury hotel is planned. Thus, by the standards outlined in the Vision Plan itself, an EIR
must be prepared.
The nesting and foraging habitat must be identified at this point to determine whether the 400
room luxury resort development envisioned by the Vision Plan is compatible with Batiquitos Lagoon
located to the south of the project, and the species located within the project. The development may
reduce the number and restrict the range of endangered or threatened species. CEQA Guidelines 8
15065(a). Failure to produce an EIR constitutes an abuse of discretion.
Even though the CITY can point to the standards in the HMP (in this case the addendum to
A number of endangered or threatened species live and breed near the proposed project.
8. Water Ouality in Batiquitos Lagoon and Ponto Beach May Be Significantly ImDacted from
Urban Runoff from the Proiect.
According to the MND, the Vision Plan “will increase the amount of impervious surface.”
(MND at 26). It must be noted that the Vision Plan will not only increase the amount of impervious
surface, it will entirely change the current drainage at the site. Currently, the area is over 90% open
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #11, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 7 of 9
space. There is likely relatively little urban storm water run-off because the open space soil filters
the water. In other words, there is almost no concrete and other hard surfaces that increases run-off
into Batiquitos Lagoon. This will entirely change when the Vision Plan is implemented. The area
will go from 90% pervious surface, to 90% impervious surface.
runoff be channeled into a natural bio-swale, that will eventually become the Wetlands Interpretation
Area. (MND at 26). In other words, the CITY proposes to create a wetlands that it will channel all
the polluted runoff into. After the polluted runoff goes into the Wetlands Interpretation Area, it will
then drain into an 84 inch pipe that ejects water directly into the Batiquitos Lagoon.
This 84 inch pipe includes runoff from other developments as well. According to the Vision
Plan, the existing configuration of the 84 inch pipe includes storm water from development east of
the railroad tracks, and development from north of the project. (Vision Plan, Ch. 4, page 12). The
storm water from the Vision Plan will be combined with the storm water from other developments
and transported via the 84 inch pipe directly to Batiquitos Lagoon. Thus, the CITY must determine
whether there is a cumulative impact from the run-off from these projects as well, that will impact
Batiquitos Lagoon and Ponto Beach. CEQA Guidelines 9 15065.
future development to address any potential flooding or hydrology impacts from development.
(MND at 25) The MND contends that “potential future water quality impacts will also need to be
analyzed when individual development plans are submitted.” Id. Thus, the public has not even been
informed what the existing baseline conditions are, much less what the potential impacts to the water
quality are.
However, the evidence demonstrates that urban storm water run-off has direct impacts to
water quality at Batiquitos Lagoon and Ponto Beach. According to a report by Heal the Bay, an
environmental group that tracks water quality at California Beaches, the water quality at the mouth
of Batiquitos Lagoon was rated “F’ during wet weather in the winter of 2004-2005. (Report attached
as Exhibit 1, available online at htt~://~~~.healthebav.or~rc/~radehisto~.as~?beach=288~.
According to the report, during the 12 weeks of wet weather testing, water quality was unacceptable
for body water contact every time. However, during dry weather, the water quality consistently
measured at an A+ or B level.
What this means is that the current water quality is directly impacted by urban runoff.
Without actually studying the impacts of paving over fifty acres of land, the CITY cannot come to
the conclusion that the project will have no environmental impact. Furthermore, the CITY does not
even know, without a study, if the proposed Wetland Interpretation Area is large enough to treat the
run-off to an acceptable level. It is not up to the public to do the proper studies to ensure that there
will or will not be a significant impact. Sundstrurn v. County of Menducino, 202 Cal. App. 3d 296,
31 1 (1988). The CITY must do the proper studies before it proceeds.
the MND for water quality, and no mitigation for water quality in the Planning Commission’s
Resolution. Not even the Wetland Interpretation Area is required to be constructed by the MND.
All the resolution demands is that “impacts to the onsite drainage within the future development area
should be mitigated for onsite through preparation and implementation of a wetland enhancement
program.” (Planning Commission Resolution No. 5884, Findings l(d)(ii)(D)). However, that is
mitigation for biological impacts, not water-quality impacts from the development. There is no
mitigation for water quality impacts due to the proposed development.
Clearly, there is a fair argument that the project may have a significant environmental impact
if “potential future water quality impacts” need to be analyzed in the future. An EIR definitely needs
The mitigation that the CITY suggests (but not demands) in the MND is that the polluted
The CITY comes to the conclusion that “A hydrology report will need to be prepared prior to
Furthermore, there is no mitigation that is actually required. There is no mitigation section in
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #I 1, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 8 of 9
to be produced at this time to determine and mitigate the impacts on water quality due to storm water
and other runoff from the development.
9. The FindinPs Are Insufficient under the Law.
Findings are absolutely necessary prior to approval of the project. The findings proposed by
the Planning Commission’ do not comply with the law. Public Resources Code section 21081 states,
that prior to approval of a project, the lead agency must make the following findings:
(1) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which
mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment.
(2) Those changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another
public agency and have been, or can and should be, adopted by that other agency.
(3) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including
considerations for the provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers,
make infeasible the mitigation measures or alternatives identified in the environmental
impact report.
Cal Pub Resources Code 0 2108 1
These findings are required even though the CITY is attempting to proceed on solely a
mitigated negative declaration. The findings must address each significant impact. Citizens for
Quality Growth v. City ofMt. Shasta, 198 Cal. App. 3d 433,441 (1988). Furthermore, such findings
must show the analytical route that the agency traveled to make such findings and find that the
mitigation will in fact reduce the impacts to a level of insignificance. Village Laguna of Laguna
Beach, Znc. v. Board of Supervisors, 134 Cal. App. 3d 1022, 1035 (1982).
For example, one of the significant impacts that was identified by the traffic study was the
impact to the intersection of La Costa and Pacific Coast Highway. However, there is no finding that
addresses such impact. Furthermore, as stated above, applying mitigation determined by future
studies by the developers of specific projects is not sufficient for the purposes of CEQA. Almost the
exact same scenario was rejected by the court in Citizens for Quality Growth. The Court commented
that “Council members apparently believed adoption of the proposed mitigation measures was
required only when a specific development plan was submitted.” Citizens for QuaEity Growth, 198
Cal. App. 3d at 442. Although the City in the Citizensfur Quality Growth case eventually dropped
its argument that deferred mitigation was appropriate, it was clear that the City disapproved of such
approach .
court the analytical route for determining that such mitigation measures will reduce the level of
impacts to insignificance. Further, the Findings completely ignore a number of impacts that are
specifically identified in the Traffic Study, the Biological Survey, and the Vision’Plan itself. The
CITY cannot move forward on the findings approved by the Planning Commission.
Regardless, in this case, the findings are entirely insufficient to provide the public and the
’ Planning Commission Resolution No. 5884 was incorporated into the proposed City
Council Resolutions 2005-21 1 and 2005-212. There were no additional findings made.
Coast Law Group LLP
Agenda Item #11, Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
June 27,2005
Page 9 of 9
Finally, the Vision Plan contemplates a taking of private property for the benefit of a private
developer. Such use of eminent domain is not compatible with the redevelopment law of California.
Hlth & Saf. Code 0 33000 et. seq.. Special findings need to be prepared when a project will result in
the taking of private property for public use. Code of Civ. Proc. 0 1245.220. The CITY must make
findings to take private property that include:
(1) The public interest and necessity require the proposed project.
(2) The proposed project is planned or located in the manner that will be most compatible
with the greatest public good and the least private injury.
(3) The property described in the resolution is necessary for the proposed project.
(4) That either the offer required by Section 7267.2 of the Government Code has been made
to the owner or owners of record, or the offer has not been made because the owner cannot be
located with reasonable diligence.
Code of Civ. Proc. 0 1245.230.
pennits the CITY to exercise the power of eminent domain. In fact, one could argue that because the
CITY made it clear that it intends to take private property within the Vision Plan, the Vision Plan has
created an inverse condemnation situation. The private property owners are essentially prevented
from selling their property at its fair market value because of the Vision Plan.
In conclusion, the Findings are entirely inadequate to approve the Vision Plan, approve the
Mitigated Negative Declaration, and approving the projects under such resolutions would constitute
an abuse of discretion.
There is nothing in the proposed findings that address this impact upon private property, nor
10. Conclusion.
The CITY is attempting to avoid the requirements of CEQA by deferring studies of the
environmental impacts of the projects until such projects are proposed. The Vision Plan, however, is
sufficiently detailed to study the impacts of the projects now. The CITY has not properly identified
all the significant impacts of the Vision Plan, and certainly fails to properly mitigate the significant
impacts. An EIR is necessary at this point to ensure that all the significant impacts are identified,
and mitigation measures or alternatives are considered that would lessen or avoid the impacts.
Furthermore, the CITY has failed to produce the proper findings as required by law.
Approving the project under the current conditions would be an abuse of discretion that would be
open to legal challenge. The CITY should prepare an EIR.
Rory R. wicks, Esq.
Attorney for John H. Adams.
Exhibit 1
Heal the Bay I Beach Report Card I Beach Details for Carlsbad, Batiquitos Lagoon outlet Page 1 of 6
In This Section
BRC Home
The Report Cards
Weekly
Summer
Annual
Beach Info
Closures From Spills
Warning Signs * Beach Details
BRC Background Info
Grading System
About the BRC
The Beach Report Card is made possible by a grant from
Beach Details - View
4w
Where's the 0 You may have no beaches have mu
information on thc
Grade History
Carlsbad, Batiquitos Lagoon outlet
Date
611 812005
6/10/2005
6/3/2005
5/29/2005
5/21/2005
511 312005
5/6/2005
511 12005
4/24/2005
411 712005
41 012005
4/3/2005
3/23/2005
311 2/2005
3/4/2005
2/27/2005
2/20/2005
2/13/2005
2/3/2005
1 /30/2005
1 /22/2OO5
111 6/2005
1 /9/2005
111 12005
12/1 812004
12/10/2004
Dry
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
B
6
6
A
ns
ns
ns
ns
Wet
ns
ns
ns
A
A
A
6
A
ns
ns
ns
ns
F
F
F
F
ns
ns
F
F
F
F
ns
ns
ns
ns
Notes
Grade based on 30 day period ending 611 412005.
Grade based on 30 day period ending 6R'/2005.
Grade based on 30 day period ending 5/24/2005.
Grade based on 30 day period ending
5/20/2005.
Grade based on 30 day period ending 5/12/2005.
Grade based on 30 day period ending 5/4/2005.
Grade is for 4 week period ending 411 3/05.
pages (e.g. photo and related links).
have not yet entei data for this partic
Please see the 66 Select Location pi
locations that has information compl
By providing beac Bay hopes to maC Report Card an el
public health tool.
http://www.healthebay.org/brc/gradehistory.asp?beach=288 6/27/2005
Heal the Bay I Beach Report Card 1 Beach Details for Carlsbad, Batiquitos Lagoon outlet Page 2 of 6
12/4/2004
11/28/2004
1 1 I1 a2004
11/5/2004
10/31/2004
1 0/24/2004
10/9/2004
1011 12004
9/24/2004
911 912004
911 012004
9/5/2004
8/29/2004
8/22/2004
811 412004
8/7/2004
7/30/2004
7/25/2004
711 712004
711 1 I2004
7/4/2004
6/26/2004
6/18/2004
6/6/2004
513012004
5/22/2004
511 512004
5/9/2004
5/2/2004
411 1 I2004
411 I2004
3/26/2004
3/19/2004
3/6/2004
2/28/2004
2/23/2004
2/15/2004
2/8/2004
1130l2004
1 /23/2004
1 11 6/2004
1 I1 012004
1/2/2004
12/26/2003
12/18/2003
12/1 212003
12/7/2003
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
F
F
F
F
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
http://www . healthebay .org/brc/gradehi story.asp?beach=28 8 6/27/2005
Heal the Bay Beach Report Card
1 112612003
11/2012003
1 111 512003
1 1 ia12003
10131 I2003
10125l2003
1011 712003
1011 112003
1 01312003
9/26/2003
9121 I2003
911 312003
91612003
812912003
a12 112003
ai1 412003
8/8/2003
8/1 I2003
712712003
711 912003
711 112003
71312003
612712003
612 1 12003
61512003
611 12003
5/27/2003
511 612003
51212003
412412003
411 a12003
411 012003
4/6/2003
313012003
312012003
311 612003
3/7/2003
311 12003
2/24/2003
111 812003
1 I1 I2003
i2/a12002
1 11712002
11/1/2002
1011 3/2002
1016l2002
9/29/2002
Beach Details for Carlsbad, Batiquitos Lagoon outlet Page 3 of 6
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
http://w ww .heal thebay .org/brc/gradehistory . asp?beach=288 6/27/2005
Heal the Bay I Beach Report Card I Beach Details for Carlsbad, Batiquitos Lagoon outlet Page 4 of 6
9/22/2002
911 512002
911 12002
8/24/2002
811 a2002
ai1 112002
a1412002
7/21 12002
711 412002
7/4/2002
6/30/2002
6/23/2002
6/2/2002
5/25/2002
511 a2002
511 112002
4/27/2002
411 a2002
4/5/2002
3/31/2002
311 512002
3/9/2002
3/1/2002
2/14/2002
2/7/2002
2/1 12002
1 /24/2002
111 912002
12/30/2001
12/1 312001
1 1/29/2001
1 1 /25/2001
11/4/2001
10/28/2001
1 012 112001
1011 412001
10/7/2001
9/30/2001
9/23/200 1
911 612001
9/9/2001
9/1/2001
8/26/2001
8/19/2001
8/1 a2001
ai51200 1
7/27/200 1
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
h ttp://w ww. healthebay.org/brc/gradehistory.asp?beach=288 6/27/2005
7/22/2001
711 412001
7/8/2001
6/30/2001
6/1 0/2001
6/3/2001
5/27/2001
5/20/2001
511 1/2001
5/4/2001
4/27/2001
4/21 12001
313 1 12001
3/23/200 1
311 1/2001
3/4/2001
2/22/2001
2/17/2001
2/8/2001
2/2/2001
1/25/2001
111 9/2001
111 412001
1 /4/2001
12/28/2000
12/24/2000
12/3/2000
1 1 /22/2000
1 1/8/2000
1 1/4/2000
10/28/2000
1 0121 I2000
1011 312000
10/6/2000
9/30/2000
9/9/2000
9/1/2000
8/26/2000
811 712000
8/3/2000
7/26/2000
711 412000
7/7/2000
6/28/2000
6/22/2000
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns .
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
A+
A+
A+
A+
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
F
F
F
F
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
ns
. Heal the Bay I Beach Report Card I Beach Details for Carlsbad, Batiquitos Lagoon outlet Page 5 of 6
I
h ttp://w w w . heal t hebay .org/brc/gradehi s tory. asp?beach=28 8
Was Closed (l/lO-l/12)due to 29,000 gallon sewage spill.
Was Closed (111 0-111 2)due to 29,000
gallon sewage spill.
Was Closed (l/lO-l/12)due to 29,000
gallon sewage spill.
6/27/2005
. Heal the Bay I Beach Report Card I Beach Details for Carlsbad, Batiquitos Lagoon outlet Page 6 of 6
611 512000 A+ ns
6/9/2000 A+ IIS
End of list
This page last updated on Monday, June 13,2005
Issues I Get Involved I Conditions I Learn More I Aquarium
Home 1 About Us I Contact-Find Us I Join or Donate I Calendar 1 Store I Media Center I Site Info I Site Map
This website sponsored by the S. Mark Taper Foundation Copyright 0 2005 Heal the Bay. All rights reserved.
CoDvriaht Notice I Privacv Policy
Heal the Bay is a 501(c)3 nonprofit organization. All aifts are tax deductible to the fullest extent of the law.
http://www .healthebay.org/brc/gradehistory.asp?beach=288 6/27/2005
San Diego Chapter
P.O. Box I5 I I
Solana Beach, California 92075 AGENDAITEM #
Mayor Suedm Phonc (858) 792-9940 Fax (858) 755-5627 Foundation. c:
Delivered via First Class Mail
June 24.2005
City of Carlsbad
C/O Gary Barberio
I635 Faraday Avenue
Carlsbad. CA 92008-73 14
city coundl
City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
Re: Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan (GPA 05-04/ LCPA 05-01 - Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan)
Honorable Mayor and City Council,
The Surfrider Foundation is a grass-roots, environmental non-profit organization dedicated the preservation of the
world’s oceans, waves and beaches through conservation, activism, research and education. I am the Vice-Chair of San
Diego Chapter of the Surfrider Foundation. I have a B.S. in Environmental Science from the Northern Arizona
University and have worked for the last five years as biologist in San Diego County performing habitat assessment,
vegetation mapping, biological surveys, construction monitoring, and habitat restoration (see resume, Attachment 1 ).
On June 17th, 2005 at approximately 430 p.m., I walked the site of Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan (Vision
Plan). I observed a pair California gnatcatcher (Polioptila califortiica califorriica) on-site at the southern end of the
proposed development, south of Avenida Encinas. The California gnatcatcher is a federally listed threatened species
under the Endangered Species Act. Photos of the observed gnatcatcher observed on-site are included as Attachment 2.
A map of approximate observed habitat utilized by the gnatcatcher pair is included as Attachment 3. It is possible the
pair was nesting in the area, though protocol surveys are necessary to determine for certain.
It is my professional opinion that impacts to the pair of California gnatcatcher though development of the Vision Plan
are not adequately addressed with the current proposed Mitigated Negative Declaration for the project. In its current
form. the Vision Plan will adversely impact California gnatcatcher habitat. An environmental impact report with the
appropriate U.S. Fish 8r Wildlife Service protocol California gnatcatcher surveys is necessary to determine the full
habitat utilization hy the pair and to determine if additional gnatcatcher may occupy the site. Protocol surveys will also
ensure that development is properly sited to reduce the destruction of gnatcatcher habitat and such habitat is mitigated to
maximum extent feasible. In addition, I suggest that the City of Carlsbad ensure all mowing. grubbing, grading or any
other activities that disturb gnatcatcher habitat be prevented at the site until an appropriate protocol study is conducted
identifying the habitat to be protected.
Sincerely,
Brian Woodward
Biologist
Vice Chair
San Diego Chapter
Surfrider Foundation
70 I
c\chx-.
cc .
CITY OF CAFLSBAD CITY CLERKS OFFICE
The Surfrider Foiitidatioti is a tion-profit grassroots orgaiiizatioti dedicated to the protectioti arid preset-vatioti of our
worldS ocearis. uwes atid beaches. Founded iti 1984 by a hatidful of visionary surfers, the Surfr-idor Fouridcitian tiow
maititairis over 35,000 ttiembers arid 60 chapters across the Utiited States arid Puerto Rim, with iritet-ti~ti~ii~l ~lffiates
in Airstralin. Eitrope, Japati arid Brazil. For ari ovet-vie\c- of the Sari Diego Chapter‘s curretit progr(itris nrid e\wifs, log
oti to our- \c.eh.site ut ,e.~c.,c,..sir,-fi-itlc.t..\d.ot.S or setid etii~iil to ilifi) O.v/ctjt.it/er,stl.or61.
Attachment 1
BRIAN WOODWARD
Biologist
5 127 Voltaire Street
San Diego, California 92 107
c 619.991.0555
Education Bachelor of Science, Environmental Science, Environmental Management
Pursuing Master’s in City Planning, San Diego State University
Emphasis, Northern Arizona University, 1999
Permits1
Certificates1
Trainings
USFWS Permit for Quino Checkerspot Butterfly, Riverside Fairy Shrimp,
Conservancy Fairy Shrimp, Longhorn Fairy Shrimp, Vernal Pool Fairy
Shrimp, San Diego Fairy Shrimp, Vernal Pool Tadpole Shrimp, San Diego
Mesa Mint, Otay Mesa Mint, California Orcutt Grass, San Diego Button-
celery, Otay Tarplant, San Diego Thornmint, Munz’s Onion, Del Mar
Manzanita, Thread-Leaved Brodiaea, No-named Navarretia, San Diego
Ambrosia, and Willowy Monardella; under supervision for Coastal California
Gnatcatcher surveys and nest monitoring, Least Bell’s Vireo nest monitoring,
Stephens’ Kangaroo Rat, San Bemardino Kangaroo Rat, and Pacific Pocket
Mouse
CALTRANS Horizontal Directional Drilling Inspector, 2001
USFWS-approved monitor for Arroyo Toad, 2002
Certification for Flat-Tailed Horned Lizard Surveys, Bureau of Land
Desert Tortoise Trained Monitor/Handler, 2000
USFWS-Approved Monitor for Desert Tortoise, 2004
Certified 40-hour Hazardous Waste Operator (HAZWOPR), 1998
HM 126F DOT Certification, 1998
CDFG Scientific Collecting Permit MI06265 for Insects, Rodents/Small Mammals,
California Stream Bioassessment Procedure/Index of Biotic Integrity (IBI)
Management 2001
Reptiles /Amphibians
Training by the Regional Water Quality Control Board, 2003
Experience 5 years biological; 7 years cumulative environmental consulting
RECON
Conducts habitat assessments; vegetation mapping; focused surveys for
endangered, threatened, and sensitive species; and monitoring in a variety of
habitats in southern California. Prepares biological technical reports to document
findings. Uses global positioning system (GPS) to map vegetation and sensitive
species habitats. Monitors construction activities. Is on-site daily supervising
construction crew compliance with environmental protection measures. Includes
checking all machinery for leaks or spills; providing worker environmental
awareness training; sweying for local listed species; coordinating all machine
set-ups and movements with foreman; handling animals on-site; supervising
frac-out clean-ups for horizontal directional drilling operations; and supervising
leak and spill cleanup. Also supervises the installation of SWPPP protection on
construction sites.
2002 - 2005
Woodward, 2
HDR
2000-2002, Biological Monitor
San Diego & Santa Barbara County. Supervised construction crew’s compliance
with agreements between construction company and permitting agencies in the
field on a daily basis. Monitored construction crew’s installation of fiber optic
cable in the mountains of San Diego County. Familiarity with resident flora and
fauna species, both native and non-native. Responsible for all Storm Water
Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) implementation on site. Identified hazardous
material spills, supervised cleanup, and inspected and reported any equipment
leaks or spills. Submitted daily reports for review by CPUC, clients, and other
government organizations.
Project Resources, Inc.
2000, Project Analyst
Wrote Phase I environmental site assessments for Fannie Mae.
3E Company
1998-2000, Regulatory Specialist - Wrote Hazardous Material Business Plans for
Home Depot, Walgreen’s, Lowe’s, and other large corporate clients.
1998, Program Administrator
1998, Customer Service Technician
Burrowing Owl Survey, Burrow Construction, and Flat-tailed Homed Lizard
Monitoring for Cisa Energy, Inc. 230-kV Transmission Tower and Line
Construction from Imperial Valley to the U.S./Mexico Border, CA
Flat-tailed Homed Lizard Monitoring for Sempra Energy 230-kV Transmission
Line Bundling from Imperial Valley to the U.S./Mexico Border, CA
Relationships Between Reptile Communities and Military Ground Disturbance,
National Training Center Fort Irwin (NTC Fort Irwin), CA
Vernal Pool Monitoring for California Terraces, San Diego, CA
Vernal Pool Surveys and Monitoring for Miramar Mounds Natural Landmark,
Arroyo Toad Monitoring for Construction on the Helicopter Outlying Landing
Arroyo Toad Monitoring for Wildcat Canyon Road Widening, San Diego, CA
Vernal Pool Monitoring for Wire Mountain Restoration, MCB Camp Pendleton,
Biological Surveys and Compliance Monitoring for Otay Mesa Generating Plant,
Least Bell’s Vireo and Coastal California Gnatcatcher Focused Surveys and
Revegetation Maintenance and Monitoring at Rancho Pacifica (formerly Del Mar
Pre-Impact Surveys, Cactus Patch Restoration, and Habitat Management for El
Wetland Restoration Maintenance and Monitoring for Pacific Highlands Ranch,
Reptile Pitfall Trap Surveys for California Terraces, San Diego, CA
Phase I1 Sensitive Species Monitoring for Calavera Hills Residential
Selected Projects
Marine Corps Air Station Miramar (MCAS Miramar), San Diego, CA
Field, Marine Corps Base (MCB) Camp Pendleton, CA
San Diego, CA
San Diego, CA
Monitoring for Mission Gorge Facility, San Diego, CA
Highlands Estates), San Diego, CA
Sobrante Landfill Expansion, Corona, CA
San Diego, CA
Woodward, 3
Development, San Diego, CA
Santa Barbara County, CA
San Diego County, CA
Carmel Development, Del Mar, CA
Sensitive Species Monitoring for Level (3) Fiber-optic Installation, Multiple Areas,
Sensitive Species Monitoring for Level (3) Fiber-optic Installation, Multiple Areas,
Vegetation Impact Minimization and Monitoring and Geologic Soil Testing, Point
Vernal Pool Mapping & Surveys, Camp Pendleton, California
Weed Mapping & Vegetation Surveys, Camp Pendleton, California
Revegetation Implementation & Monitoring, Encinitas Country Day School,
Coastal Sage and Southern Willow Scrub Revegetation Implementation &
San Dieguito Lagoon Restoration Implementation & Monitoring, Del Mar,
Santo Road Slope Restoration, San Diego, California
Costa Azul Liquid Natural Gas Distribution station, Baja Norte, Mexico
Encinitas, California
Monitoring, Suncrest Development, Oceanside, California
California
Attachment 2
Attachment 3
WSA INC PAGE 62
June 28,2005
Cify of Cadsbad
City Councll of Carlsbad 1200 Catisbad villsge Qnve
Fax: 760.720.2037 Cad8bad,
0
e*
eo*
.e..
Wamn W. Scott + Architeciure
**.I..
AGENDAITEM# \
Mayor
City Council
City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
Ann: Cityclerk
Re:
-5
Ponto Beachfroni village Mator Plan
As 8n archikt practicing in the Notth County Am and living in the Community of Leucadi8 for
owr ?8 years, I am in support of fhe pmposeCr Ponto Beachfbnt Village Mater Plen.
1 feel tbjs masterplan will pmvide the community with added improw?ments Mal can be shered with local residents and those in the surrounding arws. The dewlopmnt of hotels and
condominiums will allow the public use of the beach amas the) shoW be made aWlsble to all. The generated hes and futuret finances woukl plovide the moneys fo improve end maintain needed infmstmdums and prvb&*ons to envrionmenta/ smwtivl~ ams.
PIease consider the appmval of the pmposed master plan
Wamn W. SCWA
Wanen W. Sccn't + AIchitectum WSA, Inc. CITY OF CARLSBAD
4406 Manchesler Avenue rn Sub 161 0 EnclnttW CalHOmta - 92024 760.943.6JdO FAX fb6.843.0119
PontoAction.Com
7444 Capstan Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92009
June 28,2005
City Council
City of Carlsbad
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
RE: Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
Dear Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council:
PontoAction.Com represents a group of concerned citizens from Carlsbad and other communities who
feel that the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan will adversely impact South Calsbad State Beach
(Ponto Beach), Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve and the Least Tern Nesting area within. We
believe that the current Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) is not sufficient to address the
environmental concerns of these State assets and are demanding that the City of Carlsbad perform a full
Environmental Impact Report (EIR) prior to approving any plans for development in the Ponto Beach
area. In short, we do not recognize the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan to be environmentally
feasible unless it is validated by an EIR. Between May 3 1 , 2005 and June 2Sth 2005 PontoAction.Com
collected electronic signatures from 3300 California State Residents who are formally asking the City of
Carlsbad to perform an EIR in order to validate the environmental feasibility of the Ponto Beachfront
Village Vision Plan. Registered voters that reside in Carlsbad make up 1200 of the 3300 total signatures.
Registered state voters account for
There are many concerns that we have regarding the impact that the'Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan
will have on Ponto Beach and Batiquitos Lagoon. They include:
0
Toxic storm water runoff into Batiquitos Lagoon and onto Ponto Beach
More beach closures due to bad water quality
Light and noise disturbing the least tern nesting grounds
Additional trash on Ponto Beach
Need for more maintenance of Ponto Beach
Additional lifeguard staffing needs at Ponto Beach
Unreasonable traffic on Highway 10 1 and Avenida Encinas
Our goal is to ensure that any development done in the Ponto Beach area serves the community and
visitors to the beach in the best possible way. This includes keeping environmental concerns in check so
that the wildlife that resides in the lagoon is protected and the water quality at the beach remains healthful
for all.
We are asking the City of Carlsbad to Perform an EIR to validate the environmental feasibility of the
Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan prior to approving any development plans.
Sincerely,
Blake Wood
PontoAction.Com
blake@,pontoaction.com
www.pontoaction.com
I I CITY OF CARLSBAD CITY CLERKS OFFICE
0 STATE CAPITOL
P,O. BOX 942849
SACRAMENTO, CA 94249-0074
(916) 319-2074
FAX (916) 319-2174
DISTRICT OFFICE
1800 THIBODO ROAD SUITE 300
VISTA, CA 92081
(760) 599-1 641
FAX (760) 599-1650 MARK WYLAND
ASSEMBLYMEMBER, SEVENTY-FOURTH DISTRICT
COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS
EDUCATION ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING
UTILITIES AND COMMERCE
VICE CHAIR:
MEMBER:
June 17,2005
Blake Wood
7444 Capstan Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92009
Dear Mr. Wood,
I have read your letter concerning the proposed redevelopment along the South
Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon. I understand your concerns and the importance of careful planning. This issue is important to me.
I have talked to Sherry Hodges in my office and she has contacted the Natural Resources Committee Consultant in Sacramento. We then contacted various state
agencies that the consultant recommended - The Department of Fish and Game, the
Coastal Commission, the Environmental Protection Agency, and the Habitat
Conservation Planning Branch.
Sherry spoke with the Director of the State Department of Parks and Recreation
who informed us that they have already expressed their concerns with the City of
Carlsbad, when they met with them nearly two years ago. The Parks and Recreation
Department is concerned with the close proximity of the proposed building plans to the
beach and lagoon, the increased amount of trash and maintenance, and the increase in
traffic. They did not sign off on the project.
We also spoke to the District Director of the Coastal Commission. He reviewed the plan a year ago and expressed concerns regarding biology, land use, and traffic
circulation. We were informed that the city must comply with the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and with Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. The Coastal
Commission is now in contact with Debbie Fountain of the City of Carlsbad Housing and
Redevelopment Department.
Sherry is also in contact with the California Department of Fish and Game,
Regional Director, regarding the California Least Tern Nesting area and the Batiquitos
Lagoon. In addition, we have notified the Environmental Protection Agency and the Habitat Conservation Planner. These agencies will follow this proposed development to
protect our community and follow public resource codes and legislation.
Represerrting the ooininiinities of: Carlsbad, Del Mar, Encinitas, Escondido, San Marcos, Solana Beach, Vista and portions of Oceanside
Printed on Recycled Paper
STATE CAPITOL
I P!O. BOX 942849
SACRAMENTO, CA 94249-0074
(916) 319-2074
FAX (916) 319-2174
0 DISTRICT OFFICE
18OOTHlBODO ROAD SUITE 300
VISTA, CA 92081
(760) 599-1641
FAX (760) 599-1650 MARK WYLAND
ASSEMBLYMEMBER, SEVENTY-FOURTH DISTRICT
COMMIITEE ASSIGNMENTS
EDUCATION
ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING
UTILITIES AND COMMERCE
VICE CHAIR:
MEMBER:
For the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan development to go forward the preceding
concerns of CEQA must be addressed and disclosure of environmental impacts will be
required. The Coastal Commission will need to approve the plan in conformance with Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. Traffic flow, lighting, and the impact on state resources
need to be addressed for public and state agency review.
Furthermore, we spoke with Debbie Fountain of the Housing and Redevelopment
Department for the City of Carlsbad. She has informed us that she is working with
public and state agencies addressing their concerns. Most of the property is zoned for commercial purposes and is privately owned. The plan is also part of a land use strategy.
There are plans to add public parking, restrooms and trails. In addition, they will
continue to work with the State Beach and Parks Department for an appropriate way to
get to and from the state beach and park. Carlsbad must notify the public for a six week
review and return to the Coastal Commission for approval. A public meeting for review of the project is set for June 28. Debbie Fountain stated “there will need to be improvement,” in order to complete the project.
I am committed to preserving and protecting the environment for all
Californians. States and communities should be allowed, even encouraged, to take a
greater role in environment regulations and oversight. It is likely the Ponto Beachfront
Vision Plan development will change before it comes to its final plan.
I hope this information is helpful in assisting you with your efforts for future
planning of the Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Reserve. Thank you for
giving me this opportunity to serve you. Please do not hesitate to call me at 760-599-
1641 should you have any questions or concerns. Thank you.
Mark Wylav
Assemblyman
MBW:sm
..
Representing the corniminities of: Carlsbad, Del Mar, Encinitas, Escondido, Sun Marcos, Solana Beach, Vista and portions of Oceanside
Printed on Recycled Paper
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Acciacca Acosta Acrey Acuna
Adarns
Adarns Adarns Adarns Adarns Adcock adickes
adler Afolayan Afncano
Agnos
Aguilar Agullera Ahrweiler Airnone Ailchison Albert Albert Alwrta Alderman Alexander algert algorn Allan allan allen Allen Allen Allen Allen Allen allert Alliger Allison
Allred
Alrneras
Alnashef
alper
Alspaugh altenbaugh Altenhoff
ALTlERl
Alton Alvarez
Amador Amato Ambrogio Arnbrosini arnmon Andersen Andersen Anderson Anderson
anderson
Anderson
Anderson
Anderson
Anderson
Anderson
Anderson
Anderson
Anderson
anderson
Andlauer Andrews
Andrews
Andrews
Angel
Ansaldo
apatoff apatoff arballo Arechiga Arney arnold Arthur Artman
Arzaga Asarnen ASBURY
Ash Doherty
Asher Ashworth Astl
Auble
Ault
Avilez
Avilez
Avilez Avina BABBITT Babwck
LNC N8m Fint Name
abbott, Sandra
abbon brandon
Abrarns Christopher
Abrarnson-Beck Beth
' abbott - tirn
Wayne
Allora
Nicole
Clark
Grayson
John Thomas Chns
Greg
Chns
albert
nanci Bukkie
Brad
Charm Annabelle
Marw
Kenneth
Theresa Vidona Susan Madeline Bnan Wendy Susan chad Gianna Steve damon Ron Ruth Maaren David Shelly annette Janet George
Casey Tamara
robert
John
mark Michelle
JOSEPH
William
August
Alex Chnstine paul
Stephen
skip
Colin
John Monica Dylan jenna swtt Nena
Luke Mike M
Todd
Ceulia
Ross
mark
Laura
Sasha
Jeff
Dana
Chns
Clinton
nmle niwle
Andrew
Dana
Cheyenne
Beatnce Mlke
LUIS Elizabeth MICHELLE
scon
ROY
Jeff
Roberta
Chet Jason Werner John bnan Leah Grace Aamn Carlos
BEN
Dominique
MI Addms
I
I
1
S
D
S
H B
E
C
S
w
G L
S C R M i b L b
r
A
J
I
A
P
rn
H
C
A
L
M A D
R A
C
I
P
K
W
I
I
I
M
I E
L
J
F R D
E M
M
6583 windflower dr 6563 windflower dr 8583 windflower dr
3721 GArfield Street
405 Liverpool Dnve 3185 Carr Dnve 11818 DarlingtonAve#207 14540 DICKENS ST 1107 2736 Teresita Street 661 S Cedms Ave 914 Carninito Madngal #E 4643 Los Feliz Blvd #406 34372 Via San Juan #A 1658 Rubenstein Dr 10168 Grandview Dnve 6530 corte rnontecito 502 knots lane 3811 Crownpoint Court 215 North Rios 2251-203 Altisrna Way 2409 Torrejon Place 261 1 Jefferson Si Apt E 7443 Solano St 2315 Terraza Ribera 1494 Hymenus Ave 4336 Highland Dnve 1377 Cassins Street 6812 Shearwaters Dr PO Box 2237
11675 Frames port Place 779 Neptune Ave 294 so grand ave 11082 Madngal St 11 082 rnadngal st
24714 avignon dr 1754 Kennington Road 976 Shore Crest Rd 1372 Neptune Ave 2670 Lindsay Ln
1901 Avenida Joaquin
PO box80 7385 Alicante Rd 1678 Avery Rd
5066 Niagara Ave
135 Oceanview Ct
301 E Verdugo Ave #309
244 calle de rnadera
3313 Camino Coronado 2395 Juan street 7443 Capstan Dr 4178 DECOR0 ST#24 €610 Vireo Ct 1375 N Vulcan Ave 202 Inez Way 2379 Terraza Guitara 727 calle regal 2052 Lee Court 510 N Acacia 455 N Hope Ave 7827 Reposado 41 1 Via Malaga 1865 Hart St 1756 edgefield lane
1166 Hemes Ave 391 Ocean View Ave
170 North Greenfield Circle
3320 Camino Comnado
2936 Escala Circle
2905 Via Carno
CW cadsbad carlsbad carlsbad
Carlsbad
Cardrff by the Sea Oceanside Brentwood SHERMAN OAKS San Diego Solana Beach Carlsbad Los Angeles Capistrano Beach Cardiff La Mesa carlsbad carlsbad carlsbad Solana Beach Carlsbad Carlsbad Cambad Carlsbad Cartsbad Leucadia Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlksbad Auburndale San Diego Enanitas Pasadena San Diego san diego valenua Enunitas Carlsbad Encinitas Soquel Encinitas
cardiff Carlsbad San Marws
San Diego
vista
Burbank
encinitas
Carlsbad san diego Carlsbad
SAN DlEGO Carlsbad Leucadia Oceanside Carlsbad Enunitas Carlsbad Solana beach Santa Barbara Carlsbad Encinitas Medford encinitas
Enunitas Encinitas
coYingtm
Carlsbad San Diego
Carlsbad
51 16 Narragansett Ave Apt 398
4225 Vista Panorama Wav 11289
San Diego
11625 gatito ct
3560 Ponbac Dnve
1206 Manposa Road 7074 leeward st 7074 leeward st
14740 Costa Mesa dr
4500 The Woods Dr #2622
194 jasper st #b
194 jasper st #b
4020 isle dnve
2229 Via Blanca
14221 N 51 Ave MI18
509 la mesa ave
1055 N Vulcan Avenue 8938 Babquitos Dr
185 Saxony Road #2303 265 Fraxinella St 1656 LONE OAK RD 171 1 Bwe Road 208 North Point Rd 400 North Pactfic #lo7 7085 Aviafa Dr
444 Canyon Dr 561 N Windsor Ave 336 Avendia Chapala
325 South Nevada Street #A
325 South Nevada Street #A Carlos 3701 SKY HAVE LANE 6382 Topmast Dr
Oceanside
san diego
Carlsbad
carlsbad
carlsbad
cartsbad
La Mirada
San Jose
laucadia leucadia carlsbad Oceanside Glendale leucadia Encinitas Carlsbad Encinitas Encinitas VISTA Cads b a d Ocean City Oceanside Carlsbad
Oceanside
Bnghtwaters
San Marws
Oceanside
Oceanside La Jolla OCEANSIDE Carlsbad
staie
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA FL CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA OR
CA CA GA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
A2
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
NJ CA CA CA NY CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
ca
zip Phorn
92009 7804192129
92009 7605975009 92009 7609180182
92008
92007 7609446649 92056 90049 3104994755 91403 92104 619-269-3547 92075 92008 760 214-7588 90027 3236616991 92624 92007 (760)943-1102 91941 92009 7809310409
9201 1 92008 92075 949 2463914
92009
92009 760-436-6126 92008 92009 760-632-6838 92009 92024 92008 92009 780-603-9201 92009 760-931-1412 33823 8636774340 92 126 92024 760-942-5481 91105 92129 92129 91355 415-336-7282 92024 92009 760-804-6208 92024 95073 92024 92007 760-436-0695
92078
92107 619-255-8801
92084 760-223-6976
91502 (818) 521-1658
92024
92009
92103 619.277.9367 92009 760-804-1511
92122 619-944-0765
92009 92024 760-230-1995
92057 92009 760-431-2868 92024 9438490 92008 760-729-2374
93110 92009 92024 97501 541 951 3606 92024 92024 760 8362664 92024 30016 92009 92108
92008
92107
92057
92127 858 3850510
92010 760-434-5723
92009
92009
95136
92024
92024
92008
92054 (760) 754-2229
85306 6028960148
92024
92024 92009
92024 760.908.3420
92024
92084 92008 (760)434-7971
8226 6093894594 92054 92009 760-431-9516 92054 7604332617 11718 6316475977 92069 760480-4690 92054 92054 92037 856 922 4256
92056
92009
92009 760-43a7870
92075 858220-2745
9201 1 7e0-26aow6
90638 714-~8-0858
Emprl sanbadaadelphia net abboskigadelphia net sabbogadelphia net crabrarns@grnail com
watergirls2gwx net wamacca@yahoo com alloramstaghotmail corn nicoleda@bu edu clark-awna@hotrnail wrn grayskull79@yahoo corn
johnharnsonadarnsghotmail wm
thornasadarnsgsbcglobal net
cadams-globalgyahoo corn
rscadarns@yahoo corn chnsaduxk2lghotrnail wrn aladickes@yahoo wm
nanuadler@ashbrook net bukkie afolayangnsol wrn bafncanogyahoo corn prnandcharmgadelphia net JcaSibUgaguilar@att net marwaguileraghotmail wm
knssnkengadelphia net
airnonehorne@sbcglobal net taitchisgucsd edu victonaa4gjuno wrn BHFSMOM@aol corn rnadeline@purdyhomes corn
bnanraldeman@hotrnaiI corn Wendy alexandergjackinthebox corn salgert@csupomona edu chad@vicali corn
gallanl@san rr corn
sallanlgsan rrwrn
darnonallengrnsn wrn
ran-allenghotmail wrn
rpiercefwdZ?@hotmail wrn maarengaaol corn
dav-allen@hotmail corn
mfallengucdavis edu
napa7D@hotmail wrn
Alljandm@aol wrn
gtallison75ghotmail wrn
casey-allred@yahoo corn
talmerasgyahoo com
surfcali3@hotrnail wrn
ralper65-ghotrnail wrn
alspaughgscmv wrn altenbra@cox net rnichelleagadelphia net surfegoe64gyahoo corn balton@adelphia net augie@rnoondoggiedesins wrn barbalexlgwx net chnstinearnatogsbcglobal net
paulezloan@cox net sarnbro55gyahoo wm skiparnrnonghotmail corn colinghotmail wrn
paW@adelphia net
lovinlivinl@juno corn
againstallodds07@yahoo wrn
jennagnorthcoastcalvary org
design247@wx net
nena47gsbcglobal net
supersonic30016gYahw wrn
rnrmtandersongyahoo wrn
Amgrlchun@rnsn wm
toddgswitchfootcreative wm
Cecilia andersonggrnail wrn
mssta2@cox net
cowpieanderson@hotmail win
pooh1 958gadelphia net sasha-andrews@sbcglobal net Jeffel@Adelphia net JeffelgAdelphia net kingofchrorne03@yahoo corn
c-ansaldoghotrnail wm justfog@hotmail wm Justfo~ghotmail wrn )arballo24@rnsn wrn FreedumbBum@hotrnail wm arneydana@hotmail wm ahhhhl234@hotrnail corn wheresmejurnpa@grnail wm rnikeagnarntra wm
louie arzagaawx net
bethasal@aol corn
rnichellea@nofear wrn
jurnpngymgaol wrn
caain@corncast net
lason@vivix659 wrn
Werner astl@pseg wm
rjauble@yahw wrn
MsticApathyQyahoo wm
leahtraingyahoo wm
rnrsavilez@yahoo wrn
rnrsavilezgyahoo wrn ernail2carbs@yahw corn BENBgTRYJADVERTlSlNG COM dbabcock@adelphia net
St.kVohr CarkbPdVohr
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 0 1 0
1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0
1 0 I 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1
0 0
0 0
1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0
1 1
1 0
0 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0 0
1 0
1 1 1 1
1 1
0 0
0 0
0 0 1 0 1 1 1 0
0 0 1 0 1 1
0 0 1 0
1 1
1 0 0 0 1 0
0 0
0 0 1 0 1 1 1 1
Page 1
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Babiarz Baer , Baetge-Jolly Baghen
Baghoyan Bagully Bahr Bailey Bailey bailey Bailey Baird Baker
Baker
Baker
Balaoro
Baldwin
Baldwin
baht
Ball
Bandy banks Banuelos Banwell Baran Baran Bardin
Barger Barharn Barker Barlow
Barnas
Barnett
AleC James Ceulia Tom sarkis Stephanie Chris
Samuel linda zane
Robert
Thomas Kathy
Mana
Lisa
Marvin
Roger
Sarah justin
Joshua
Lesli
michael Natahniel Frojon Robert
Mary Enn Chloe Traue Jennifer Rosanne
James
Ronald
barnett-kirnberly lornn
Bamne
Barone
Barre
Barreca
barret
Barrett
Barry
Bane Bartleson Bartolornei
Bamck Basham bashore Bass bass Bassett
Batchelor
Batliner
BATTlSTl
Battisluz
Bauer bauer
Baurngarten Bautista
Baxley
Baynard
BEAGAN Bearmar Bearmar
Beatty
Beany
Beatty
Beaumarchais Beavers Beck Beck beck Beck Becker Beckwth Bedroslan Beener
Beeson Beeson Beetharn Bekkar Belding
Beliveau
bell
Bell
Bell
Beller Bender
Benedetto
Benjamin
Bennett
Bennett
Bennett
Benson Benson
berardi Berbench Berbench Berberich
Berg Bemat
Bema1
berry
Salvatore
Steve
Bjorn
Robert
jamb
Timothy
Barbara
David
GUY Chris Chris Scott heather
Scott katrina Hannah Brannon
Elizabeth
Brian
Diana
april Julie
Isaias
Bllrce
Tommy
CATHERlNE Michelle Douglas Winston
Darrel
Irene
Don Mike Jaime Lucinda Devon
Jay
ALESSANDRA
Robert
Jason Diane Thomas Samantha Joshua Vanessa BNce Wendy Linda rnichael Lars
Gregory Lye1 Erica Nathan Steven
Matt Jenny Christopher Linda
Randall
marc
Samantha
Gloria-Jean
Laura David
Michelle
chuck
ROY
P
R
L
H
T
a
R
E
J
E
J
b
E
E
R
D
L
J
D
A
R
r D W
s
M
C
m
M
R
C
D
W E F
B
m
W L
K
K L s
W M N
M
E
T
k
1544 Burgindy Rd 6800 Watercourse Dr 382 Sunset Drive 8744 Villa La Jolla Dr. #41
6965 El Carnino Real H05-469 916 Bridgeport Court 302 Countrywood 1821 Tusbn St. 3943 Anzona St Apt. #5 529hermesave
934 Alyssum Road 2740 Argonauta S1
11 86 Mariposa
P.O. Box 7284
927 Rosemary Ave
5628 Lamas St.
400 Andrew Ave.
400 Andrew Ave.
4180 park dr.
646 Stevens Ave. #A
4974 112 Cape May Ave. 1829 gatepost rd. 4793 longbranch 4812 Del MonteAve#4
1716 Kennington 1716 Kennington 4686 Long Branch Avenue 66-140 Walikanahele Rd. 2081 Meadowlark Ranch Circle 3055 Enterprise Ct
7303 Starboard Si.
8038 E Kings Ave.
375 Acacia,ave iB2
7080 rnontanes In.
7348 Portage Way
1227 highbluff ave
8680-A Via Mallorca
12885 Caminito de las Olas
3025 columbia st.
867 Beryl Street
1802 Hummock Lane
1361 GrandAve.. X12
5274 wohiford st 5038 Park Rim Dnve
1507 Galveston Street
960 Sapphire St 7238 ponto drv 914 Birchview Dr 914 birchview drive 5205 Quayle lane 3953 Centre St #8 10848AdermanAvenue#146 443 2ND sT 13310 Via Magdalena #4
11 167 Adnatic Place
1162 sunset dr
1329 Kowalski Ave B
555 Second St.
921 Lilac Court
1029 3rd st
6455 LA JOLLA BVLD
250 Julian St
250 Julian Street
121 Stanley Way
7142 SANTA ROSA
7142 SANTA ROSA
701 7 Nutmeg Way 993 Vulcan 744 Dewitt Ave 1642 Buttercup Road 744 Dewin ave
2663 Marquita Place 2719 Avenida de Anita #84 1500 Shadomidge Drive #4 4374 Stanford Street 8072 Paseo Arrayan 1572-A Caudor St. 1572-A Caudor St. 7128TanagerDrive 135 7th St. 4879 1R Long Branch Ave. 4125 Skyline Road 1864 east point ave 1405 Topaz Way 9983 Courtyard Dr 4444 Cape May Ave 3321 Vista RDcosa 2143 Oxford Ave. 4881 Glenhaven Dr. 453 S. Sierra Ave. XI61
218 El Dorado Ave
370 #6 Chinquapin 427 Hilmen PI.
3554 Arnes
3481 Garfield ST #B
346 Foch Blvd
346 Foch Blvd.
346 Foch Blvd. 1335SavannahLane 8768 Lonicera St 6768 Lonicera St 4728 narraganselt ave
End nit as CA Carlsbad CA Encinitas (Leucadia) CA La Jolla Carlsbad San Marcos Encinitas San Diego San Diego encinitas
Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad
Rancho Santa Fe
Carlsbad
San Diego
Enunitas
Enunitas carlsbad
Solama Beach
San Diego enunitas San Diego
San Diego
Leucadia Enunitas San Diego Halerua San Mams vlsla
Carlsbad
Scottsdale
Carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad
san rnarcos
La Jolla
Del Mar
san diego
San Diego
Encinilas
San Diego oceanside San Diego
San Diego san diego carlsbad Encinitas enunitas Sebastopol San Dieog San bego ENClNlTAS
San Diego
San Diego vista
Santa Barbara
Lakeport
San Marcos
Encinitas
LA JOLLA
Ramona Ramona Centerville
CARLSBAD
CARLSBAD
Carlsbad Enunitas Encinitas Encinitas Encinitas Carlsbad Carlsbad vista Carlsbad Carlsbad Encinltas Encinitas Carlsbad Del Mar
San Diego
Carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad
San Diego San Diego Escondido
Cardiff
Oceanside
Solana Beach
Danville
Carlsbad Solana Beach
Carlsbad
carlsbad
Mineola
Mineola
Mineola Carisbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad
san diego
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA HI CA CA CA A2 CA CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
MA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA Ca CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA NY
NY
NY
CA CA CA CA
ca
92024 760-518-7847 92009 92024 7607532316
92037 760-931-9550
92009 92078 92024 92106 92104 92024 760-944-5185
92009 780-929-8500 92009 92009
92067
92009 760-431-5993
92122 92024 760-753-6973 92024 760-753-6973 92008
92075 858-793-3531
92107 92024 7608409414 92107 92107 92024 760-943-7584 92024 92107 96712 808-351-7551 92078 92081 7605996500 92009 760 6003-9366
92008 760-434-6256
92009 92009 760 476.9400 92078
92037
92103 6199859157
92109 619-807-5948
92024
92109 92056 7609400246
921 17
92110
92109
92024 92024 760-753-0181 95472 CA 92103 92126 513-571-1014 92024
85254 480-36ai728
92014 85aw-9133
92009 760-43a8271
92129 85aw-5801
92126 858547-9073
92081
93101
9.5453
92078
92024 619-203-4630
92307 8587404178
92065
92065 2632 508-771-0592
92009 760-602-0734
92009 780-602-0734
92009
92024
92024 92024 760-942-8042
92024
92009 CA
92081 760-727-5280 92008 760-720-7374 92009 92024 92024 92009 92014 CA 92107 92008 7804347004 92008 92009 3103863159
92107 92029 92007 760-213-9973 92056 92075 8583491410 94526 92008 92075 92008 760-720-9052 92008 9493943937 11501 11501
11501 92009 7804310331 92009 92009 92107 619-758-1570
92010 760-20a5583
92131 858373-8969
ababia@ucla edu bigwavejimgadelphia net cecijollgpacbell net tonisgnofear corn
big-sbgyahoo corn
bagullyghotmail corn
bahrlygyahoo corn
robtbaileyjrghotmail corn sarnrny2000@mindspnng corn Iindaatkudosghotmail corn
Zanemanabaileyghotrnail corn
tornbairdgadelphia net
bbbboyzgaol corn
casabaker@yahoo corn
polarbakerggmail corn
marvin balaorc@grnail corn
rogerandsarahgcox net
rogerandsarahacox net
lbalintganaheirn net
ioshuaball@sbcglobal net
star17537grnsn corn milobanksghotrnail corn
misoel@yahoo corn
chaiyngcox net rbarangucsd edu
rnbaranaucsd edu eebardinghotmail corn moonlightchloeghotmail corn
cheekyrnamagcox net
jenbarker9geaglecreek com rlbarlowgadelphia net
jb7302gaol com
rddbgyahoo corn
lornngadelphia naet
sal barone@sbcglobal net
bizrone@hotmail corn
bjorn-barreghotmail corn
rbarrecagucsd edu
jake barret@reef corn
barren-tdghotmail corn
barbarabarry3lgyahoo corn
vbarrse@hotmal corn yoguyndebgcoxnet surfcjbayahoo corn
chnsbGQ7ghotrnail corn basharn78ghotrnail corn hodi64gyahoo corn
Scott bassgpnmedia corn katnna bassgablongman c~n hbassell@earthlink net bbatchelorgcabnllocu corn ebat-OO@yahw m RATgRATSURFBOARDS COM
bnanbgsdscedu
dbauerasan rr corn
apnll152gcox net
baumclodgyahoo corn
green7oldiesgyahoo corn
bcbphdgyahoo corn
tornmyclirnb@aol corn
CATgCATBEAGAN COM bearmaak-online corn douggdg-energy corn
Winlieanygaol corn
debpigsbcglobal net
debpigsbcglobal net
paddleremail-ebaygyahw corn mikebeaversghotmail corn letl212ghotmail corn Igbeckgucsd edu devongsector9 corn shoot802gaol corn HOTABEE@msn corn topjimmy1 gadelphia net drdianebgaol corn tbeenerhome@aol corn Hitch8Oghotrnail corn hitch80ghotmail corn vbeethamgadelphia net
bbekkargedelphia net
wkbeldingghotmail corn
llbeliveaugyahw corn mycholbelgyahoo corn bell-larsgyahoo corn
HebegMlgyahoo corn
Ibellergsciti corn
dancnrnoose@aol corn
nbened36gyahw corn
steveb@arnistar corn
flobee5757@yahoo corn
]ennybennell@rnac corn
cbennenaisisph corn
IindabensonOlgaol corn
bensonr@aol corn
rnarc@bigdrearnsnow corn
waterbaby527@iwon corn
waterbaby527giwon corn
waterbaby527giwon corn laurabergaadelphia net bernatfarnily@hotrnail corn
bernatfarnilyghotrnail corn
berryckaaubum edu
1 1 1
1
1 1
1
I
1
1
1
I
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1 1
1 1 0 1 1 1 1
1 1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1 1 1
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0 1 1
1
1
0 1
0 0
1
0
0
0 0
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0 1
0
0 0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0 1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0 0
0
0 0 1
0 0 0
0
0
1
0
0 1
0
0
0
1
0 0 1 0
1 1 1
0 0 0 0 1 1 0
1 1 0 0
0
0
0
1 1 1 0
0 1
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
0
0 1 1
1
0
Page 2
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Berson
Bertsch-Kelly
Beserner
beserner Best Best-Barbic bestlw
bewley Beyer Bickley Biegalski bierd Bierman Billauer
Bingharn birch Bird Birney Bischof
Bishop
bishop
Black
Black
Blakeslee
Bloch
block
Bloom
Bloornquist
Boden
Boelke
Boethel
Boff
Bonner
Bonner
Bonnen
Borakove Borakove
Boren
BOrg BORSACK
Borsack Bostrorn Bottom Boulware Bourassa Bowen Bower Bowers Bowers Bowman Bowman Bowman Bowman boyce Boyer boykin
BraCCl
brackblll
Bradley
Bradley
Bradley
Bradley
Brady
Brady
brady
Brandt
Brannon
Braun Braunstein Bravender Bravender
Bravo
Bravo Breaux Brecher Breedlove BrelSch Breitrnaier Brenker Brennan Brennan
Brennan bresser Brewer Bndges
Bnght
Bnngas Bnswe Broccoli
Broccoli
Brody
Brolaski
Brookes
Brookes
brooks
bmshears
Bmsk Brown Brown Brown
Brown
Michelle
Jennlfer Wesley lustin
LUCY Caroline
Suzanne
don Donna
Stacy Anna rnelanie Julie
Bradly
austin
Justin
Joseph Sharon
Doug
Sean
Melissa
Elisabeth
Robert
Kenneth
rochelle
Jordan
Tom Laurel Timothy Wwdmw
Bill
Ashleigh
Brent
Richard
Andrew
Mary Cathy Denise Annette William Lana Enca shannan
Mark
Ben Delaney Rhianna Kevin Wendy Molly Susan Kenneth Shelley Jon Sean
Mana
nchard
Derek
Joe Chnstopher
Laune 8 Steve
Phyllis
Dennis
kevin
Grey Marlene
Lynn Molla
Karen
Joanna
Aaron
AliCia Kellie
Sheny Jennifer Richard
Gw Margaret enn David Colleen patncia James Tnva Jeremy Chnstopher
corey Charles Linden Bambi Josh George David kelsey bobby
melissa
Stephanie
Jeff Kapualani Denise
Jason
Josh
K
S
J
a
M
G
rn
I
L
A
e
G
K
M
D
T
S R
D
B
L
P
I
L
B
A B
C
B
R L B
K L
R
CI J A
q
L T
H
H
k K
S
R i f
B R
R
3211 SirenaVista Wy#114
6709 Anblope Street 1324 Del Mar Mesa Road
2534 7th s1 #2
363 Andrew Avenue 3562 Front Street 1774 club heghts lane
2865 loker ave east 1082 Seahorse Court 4042 First Ave 159 23rd St 7922 vista palma 23371 Via Ronda 8469 Paseo Del Ocas0
274 Hygeia Court 744 so cedros
15641 Crownndge PI
15683 Highland Cwrt
2724 Naples Court
510 Stratford Ct #307A
19 bene lane
25 Ellis st
402 Oceanview Ave
927 6th Ave #21
14897 Summerbreeze Way
141 grandviewst
1771 Red Barn Road
6435 merlin dr 735 Cornish Dr 1064 10 Emerald St
51 13 1R Long Branch Ave
413s Ditmar
7586 Dehesa Ct
7586 Dehesa Ct
8621 Onalaska Ave
209 S El Portal St
209 S El Portal St
7933 Calle Madnd
4851 Muir Ave
7066 Pnrnentel lane
7066 Pnrnentel Lane
6961 Ballena Way#13 1150 Hermes Ave 2179 Via RoMes 2866 Mission Blvd 662 Westlake St 1012 Hermes Ave
8795 #D Gilrnan Dnve 323 Beirut Ave 1730s El Carnino Real #HZ01 405 Nautilus Street 7046 Pnrnentel Lane 7046 Pnrnentel Lane 1713 tanenharn road 259 A Hillcrest Dnve 401 pescado place
7653 Pnrnavera Wy
8726 villa la jolla dr
620 Poinsettia Park North
3199 Valley St
1429 River Crest Rd
312 Orpheus Avenue
3615 Haverhill St
3615 Haverhill St
556 3rd street
894 Gallery Dnve
71 10 Santa Cruz
434 La Veta Ave 281 1R Hillcrest Dr 1265 Neptune Ave
3952 Jefferson St
700 Regal Rd Unit 3A
700 Regal Road Unit A3 3115Evening WayApt F 1005 N Vulcan Ave. #2
2635 Madison St #3
4735 Mt AShrnun Dnve 6785 E Woodbndge Rd
3369 Rocking Horse Circle 1314 Chuparosa Way 7926 Vista Palma 7926 Vista Palma 838 1R eolus ave 695 Crete Ct 825 Stratford Knoll 1689 Bacon St #5
2203 sanehjo ave # 262 8005 Hagans Circle 1654 Avery Rd 3568 Beach AVE PO Box 1606 371 Drake Bay 699 N vulcan Ave #7
2220 Montgomery ave
129 Mangano Circle 3825 nviera dr #6
4576 Saratoga Ave
424 1 Colony Terrace 1450 Moreno St 1525 Bonnie Bluff Court 404 Andrew Avenue 602 Barbara Ave
Carlsbad
Carlsbad San Diego Santa Monica Leucadla SAII Diego vista carlsbad Cads b a d San Diego Avalon carlsbad Mission Viejo LA Jolla Encinitas solana beach Sherman Oaks
Solana Beach
Carlsbad
Del Mar
cornrnack
R wood
Enunitas
San Diego SD
encinttas
Encinitas
carlsbad Enunitas San Diego San Diego
oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego Enunitas
Encinitas
Carlsbad
San Diego
CARLSBAD
CARLSBAD
Carlsbad Leucadia Oceans& San Diego Encinitas Leucadia La Jolla Pacific Palisades Enunitas La Jolla Carlsbad Carlsbad encinitas Leucadia en u n i ta s
Carlsbad
la jolla
Encinitas
Carlsbad
San Marcos
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
encinitas
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Leucadia
Leucadia
Leucadia
Carlsbad
Enunitas
Enunitas
La Jolla
Enunitas
Carlsbad
San Diego
Acarnpo
Enunitas Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad leucadia Luecadia Encinttas San Diego cardiff San Diego
San Marws
cARLSBAD
Carlsbad
Oceanside Enunitas
cardiff
Enunitas
san diego
san diego
Encinitas Oceanside Ca Encinitas Leucadia
Solana Beach
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA NJ CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
CA
NY
rno
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
92009
92009 92130 90405 3103141430
92024 92103 92061 7605969636
92009 7607174665 92009 92108 8202 92009 92691 92037
92024 619-708-9414
92075
93401
92075 92008 760-729-31 63
92014
11725
65473
92024
92101 760-477-7551
92126
92024 271-4811
92024
9201 1 92024 760-942-0623
92109 619-920-3622
92107 61 9-523-4003
92054
92009
92009
92123 619.545.2181
92024
92009
92107 92009 760 906-3445 92009 760 519-0045
92009 92024 92054 7605635454 92109 92024 92024 760-635-9065
90272 92024 92037 92009 760-604-5801 92009 760-804-5601
92024 760/929-1180
92024 7604790695
92024
92009
92037
92024
92008
92078 760-672-3698 92024 760-943-1417 92008 760-434-3365 92008 760-434-3385
92024 92057 7066136212
9201 1
92024 92024 760-4362502 92024 760.944.4144 92008 434-3261
92024
92024 92037 92024 315-254-5468 92008 760-444-4860 921 11 95220 209-712-9198 92024 92006 92009 92009 92024 92024 760-230-2485 92024 92107 619-223-3330 92007 760-579-2443
92126 92076 760-331-5255
92018 7609170340
92018 92057 92024 760-944-4561
92007
92024 92109 6195201466
92024 (760)634-3206 92054 760-310-9178 92024 92024 760-942-8862
92075
92024 76m32-86ia
92037 85am-9x10
92107 619-83az719
mishdogger@yahoo corn
sdllfer@sbcglobal net
dennis-guhrnan@aol corn
jbeserner@hotrnail corn
bigIucy2000@yahoo corn
cbest542@earthlink net
suzt7anne@yahoo corn
donbaeufora net donnabeyer@adelphia net Stacy bickley@cox net jadedpopsicle@yahoo corn
savy44@adelphia net
iulieM)t7@yahoo corn
1 bi llauer@ hotmail corn
bradly-bingharn@hotrnail corn
cannong@aol corn
RMnder397agrnail corn
gravityjoe@cox net
jscbischof@adelphia net
freshdawgaadelphia net
cyrax414@msn corn
loser123451 1
eli@vestalindustnes corn
robertlblakeslee@yahoo corn
kblochasan rr corn
mchelleblck@yahoo corn
jgbloornlO@hotrnail corn
bloornquist@iwon corn
laurel bodenaan net
tirnboelkeQyahoo corn
wwdrowboethel@sbcglobal net
bllboff@hotrnail corn
ashleighbonnerayahoo corn
brentbonnerayahoo corn
Richard Bonnewnavy mil
nckyasnnov@yahoo wm rnaryborakove@rnail com cbgeraniurn@sbcglobal net deernalt@sbcglobal net adkorlan@yahoo corn bill@ipushfttness com lanabostrom@sbcglobaI net ebottorff@wx net shannan33@hotmail corn snoboard269@yahoo corn benjbowen@hotrnail corn bnezyboweQwx net
rhiannabowers@yahoo corn kb-bowers@yahoo corn
wlbman77@hotmail corn surfingseraph@yahoo corn bowman7046@adelphia net bowman7046@adelphia net slboyce@cts corn
jonboyer@rnac mrn
sboykin25@yahoocorn
lojuta@adelphia net
shovelclay@yahw corn
aarderek@netscape net
1bradleyO07@hotmail corn
cb@westsider corn Ibradley@inventivernail corn phyllisbrady@rnsn corn phyllisbrady@rnsn com kevin@nixonnow corn
gcbrandt90@yahoo corn
mbrannon@pacbell net boxofpoernsQcare2 corn rnollab@yahoo corn bravdesign@sbcglobal net pbravlaadelphia corn
ibravo88ayahoo corn
aliciarnkerr@hotrnail corn kellieg@san rr corn sherrybrecher@yahoo corn unwinding-u@yahoo corn breisch@aabol corn gregbreitrnaier@rnsn corn rnbrenker@sernprautilities corn pebrennanaadelphia net
dee10713@sbcglobal net wlleenbrennanl @earthlink net luk8iaawx net ]arnesbrew@earthlink net houseofondges@sbcglobal net jbnggsanu edu bluebnsance@yahw corn
surfin009@sbcglobal net
CHDEEZ@HOTMAIL COM lBROCCOL@UCSC EDU
dragonfliebbawx net
brodyt @cox net brolaskiamx net
dsbrookes@hotmail corn
kelseybagen-probe com
bbrooks@tryrnaninc corn
missy92109ayahoo corn
stephbmskt@msn wm leffaprana corn kapualani bmwn@sdwunly ca gov edeniseb03acox net
laybrogadelphia net
1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1
0 1 1 1 1 1
1
1 1
1
0
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
1 1 1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1
1 1 1
1 1 1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1
1
0
1 1 1 1
1
1
1 1 0 0 1 0 1 1
1
1 1 1 1 1 0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
t
1 1
0 1
0
0
0 1 1 0
0 1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
1
0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
0 0 1 t 0
0 1 0 0
0 1
0
0 0 0 0
0 0
0
1
1
1
0 0
0
0
0
0
0 1 1
0 0 0
0 0 1
0 0
0
0
0
Page 3
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Brown Brown Brown Brown Brown Brown Brown
Brown
Brown Brownell Browning brown l ow
brozovich
BNUf BRUCK Bruer Bruinsma Brumley Bruns
Bryan Bryant bucci Bucugrossi Buchanan
Buckley
BUl Bujewski
BUlllS
Burg Burgan
Burgess
Burke
Burke
Burke Burke Burken
Burl Burnett
Burns
Burns Bums bush Bussen
Buswell
BUSwell buswen Butcher butcher bfleld bynum Byrnes Byrnes Cabrera Caesar Cain
calcara
calLno
Camarda
Campbell
Campbell
Campbell
campbell Campos Cansler Cantrell Capistran
Brunski
cappa
Linda Cindy Matthew Ollene
natalie Mark Joseph
christina Kevin
Gregory curbs william Enn Robert KELLY Dave Julie Matthew Stephen Nicholas BNce Cynthia giawmo Debbie
Alison
Olivia
Renee
Jeannette
Sara Enk
Matt
Enka Bnan
Peter Victor curbs
Walker
Jamie
Jawb
Andrew
Robed
Michelle Justin Peter kate
rosemary Caroline lames Konie Devin Sergio Kerryanne Chns charmaine chns Leon
Quan
Diane
Ross
Vicki
Steve
Royce
Angela
Enc mark
David
amy
Mary
Cappellino Jeffrey CARATACHEA MARIE Caraviotis Carbone Cardiff CARIC Cariston Carlton Carman Carmine
Carney caron caron
carr carr Carranza
Carrasw
Carrillo
carrillo
carrol
Carroll
Carroll
Carroll
carmll carroll carroll
Carter CaNSillO caruso Casagrande casagrande casey cashman
cas0
Jerry Nick Todd Melisa Jonathan
Kevan
Steve
Ryan Shelley Shelley Joan Charles Altredo James Alex peter
Jeff Stephanie Stephanie Gail Robert
hY swn
Chnstine
daniel
Nancy
Julia alan
SCOtI Carolyn David
Bany
A
A
N
A
P
M I
R
L C
P
J
M
J
L
B
B
W
M
J e
P S m E a
m R
I
0
C
I
M
G
i
Y
I
C H H M
M
J L
N I
L
P
j
n
M
1966 Spnngdale Lane Encinitas
7012 Nutmeg Way Carlsbad
1839 Lotus Ct Carlsbad
5196 Pendleton Street San Diego
649 hillhaven dr San Marws
3312 Donna Dr Carlsbad
41695 Big sage ct Temecula
654 Brae mar Court Enunitas
654 Brae Mar wult Eminitas
1357 Greenlake Dnve
325 Canyon Side Way Oceanside
2742 caminito verdugo del mar
577 wrnish encinitas
2068 BUlNSh Ln Cardiff
7104 DAFFODIL PLACE CARLSBAD
PO Box 232076 Enunitas
1809 Barry Ave Los Angeles
13671 Via Lactea San Diego
573-6 Hygeia Ave Leucadia
6507 Camino del Parque Carlsbad
7196 Pintial Dnve Carlsbad
562 Knsten Court Enunitas
3450 paseo ancho carlsbad
4561 Carnpobello Street San Diego
462 La Mesa Avenue Enunltas
5130 Bayard St San Diego
9921 Carmel Mountain Road #216 San Diem
Cardfl by the Sea
602 Windcrest Dnve
2563 Navarra Dr , Unit E
4316 Fanuel Street
159 Redwood Ave Apt C
4774 Santa Monica Ave
961 N Vulcan Ave
1632 Tennis match way
177 Monarch bay 3543 Rock Ridge Road
9332 Babauta Rd
3615 Shasta St
3217 Calle Vallarta
945 Agate Street
585 N Garfleld Ave #3
3461 Calle Cancuna 628 tenth st
3641 Strata Dnve
1720 Loretta St 1403 Corwal Way 1403 cod way 11305 Bnarmont Road Apt 203 9114 Caminito Estrada 1830 Parliament Road 732waladr 2506 Navarra Dr 5536 coyote wurl
2009 Shadow Grove Way 912 Rosemary Ave
664 sandcastle dnve
48 broad street
673 Buttercup Rd
9725 Mesa Spnngs Way #I76
2781 Berkeley AV
1732 Haydn Dnve #B
1543 eolus ave 13306 Carninito Ciera
34822 Calle Fortuna 3038 Levante St 6970 Sandcastle Dr 1027Cleveiand St
1009 Tait St Apt 2 1662 MADRONE GLEN 2910 Shady Creek Dnve 5126 Chelterham Terrace 4660 1R Idaho Street 3055 CORTE TRABUCO 3474 Seabreeze Walk
Barry 660 viva ct
3200 Carlsbad Blvd
251 Gloxina St
451 9 North Ave #5
Po box 1502 P>O>BOX 1502 Marron Adobe H 1742 Onole Ct 6872 peach tree rd 7005 Boulevard Dr 4254 Corte De Sausalito 563 Sea Lane 106 Via Morella
461 1 Flying Cloud Way 6926 Peach Tree Rd 620 Cox Rd 1254 Manposa Rd 1254 Manposa Rd 3223 Calle Vallarta
3234 fortuna ranch road
1773 Tara Way 4444bermudaave
2565 Jefferson St
7354 Escallonia Ct
7354 escallorua ct
6976 sandcastle dr 26562 wnejo view dnve 2383 Altisma Way Unit D
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
carlsbad
San Diego
Encinitas
Encinitas
Dana Point Carlsbad
$an Diego
San Diego
carlsbad
San Diego
Pasadena
Carlsbad huntington beach Carlsbad Oceanside Carlsbad carisbad Richmond Carlsbad En ani t a s
oceanside
Carlsbad carlsbad
San Diego Encinitas Carlsbad
cardiff
red bank
Carlsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad Cardiff leucadia San Diego Capistrano Beach Carlsbad Carlsbad oceanside Oceanside ESCONDIDO Pearland San Diego San Diego CARLSBAD Oceanside El Cajon solana bch Carlsbad Enunitas cadsbad I Carlsbad
Carlsbad
carlsbad
La Mesa
San Diego
La Jolla
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Marcos
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad encinitas
San Marws
san diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad carlsbad carlsbad agoura hills Carlsbad
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA va CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA Tx CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA CA
CA CA CA
ca
i
ca
92024
92009 760 931-9831
92009
92109
92076 (760) 390-2673
92008
92591 6055090628
92024
92024 CA
92007 7607536250
92054 92014 92024
92007
9201 1 92023 (760) 634-3237
90025 92129 92024
9201 1
92009 92024 760-942-5729
92009
92130
92024
92109 619-204-6233
92129
9201 1 760-889-6057
92009 760-942-2261
92109 92008 760-445-4621
92107
92024 858-663-9677
92024 7606328691
92629 92006 92 109
92129 7606031557
92009 760-889-0373
92109
91101
92009 92646 92006 92054 760-271-5351 9201 1 760-804-9733 92009 7608049733 23235 (604) 594-0617 92009 760-436-3001 92024 CA 92054 760-721-0362 92009 619-405-0816 92006 92116 92024 92009 760-480-9464
92007
7735 906 601 2483
92009 772-201-9474
92126
92008 760.720-7850
92007
92024 760-632-0750 92129 658 945.8383
92624 92009 92009 1.858 775.9819 92054 92054 760-21 3-7869 92027 77581 92130 921 16 (760) 942-6505 92009 760-753-1 120 92056 92020 CA 92075
92006
92024 92018 760-729-1618 92016 7607291816 92009 760-930-0552 92009 91941 92130 92037 92024 7604197756
92008 92009 92069 (760) 471-9456 92009 7604369232 92009 7604369232 92009
92024 6567564649
92078
921 07
92006
92009 760-445-5543
92009
92009 91301 92009 7602716202
Iindapoet@hotrnail wm
RcaaMgaol wm
manbgewestadvantage wm
obrowngsan rr com
beachiebabe627gyahoo corn
mbrowngkingsleynet wm
mongojoeOl@aol wm
kccn@adelphia net
kevindbrown@adelphia net
greg brownell@wasat corn
curtis-browning@hotmail wm
wbrownlogucsd edu
brozovich Zgosu edu
nurple7gaol com
JKABRUCK@YAHOO COM
tfrc@earthlink net
juliebn90025@yahoo corn
mattgthebrumleys wm
stephengyahoo wm
nickoli@nethere wm
b~ce bryanaelan corn
clbteachgadelphia net
giawmobucci@hotmail wm
gso@san rr com
oceansage@wxnet am buckley00@ hotmail mm
olivia-bui@yahoo wm
bujewski@adelphia net
jettygadelphia net
saraburgZ@gmail corn
enk-burganayahoo corn
mkburgessggmail wm
eburke@rnolecularmed wm
aandiegoburkegsbcglobal net
petert@plsalvage wm
victor burke@gmail wm
curhburken@yahoo corn
wburl@san rr wm
burnett221
jabu707@yahoo wm
aburns@ptlorna edu
robbrevonb@hoimail wm amyebush@hotmail wm michellegmyrealestatew wm justingbuswell com peter@buswell corn kate@buswell wm
mebvagirlghotmail wm
rabian03@yahoo wm
c-byfield@hotmail wm
chip@surfnde
kcress75@hotrnail wm dbymes@deckers wm
sergiocabrera@cox net
kenyannec@hotmail wm
ucainayahw wm
carnivorousmoss@yahoo wm
chnscalfano@aol wm
leoncamardagyahw wm
qyoder@hotrnail wm
diane-campbell@bd wm roSscampbe1100@hotmail win vickigvavoomdesign corn reefrash73gyahoo wm royce cansler@wx net Iccookiequeen@adelphia net ecapistran@qualigeninc wm mark@staywvered wm oceansidel WB@yahoo mrn ACDCOZYgJUNO COM jcaraviobs@houStonzoo org nick-carboneglyahw wm
tcardiff@mastlawgroup wm
micanc@pbsl wm jcarlstongfranchise wm b)cariton@earthlnk net kevan carman@inotherapy wm scarmine@tenaxts wm sdsurferguy@hotmail wm adobega@sbcglobal net
adobegal@sbcglobal net
arrcagsbcglobal net
lonecc.@aol wm
alfredo-carranzaa hotrna il cam
James carrasw@navy mil
wompi210@hotmad wm
saibrookelingsbcglobal net
pMll@adeIphia net
slcarmlll@sbcglobal net
thirdplanetdesigngwx net
gncarroll@sixglobal net
gncarmll@sbcglobal net davenamyc@adelphia net brooke carroll@sbcglobal net
ccarter76@yahoo mm
danielcarusillo@hotmail wm
nancar123456@yahoo wm
Julia casagrande@vananinc wm
bongobaystudiosgadelphia net spaceycasey@sbcglobaI net carolyn@centrelink wrn sdsurl72@aol com
1
1
1
1
0
1 1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1 1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1
1
Page 4
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0 1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0 1 0 0
1
0 1 0 1 1
0
1
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
0 1
0 1
0
0 0
0 1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0 0 0 0 1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
1 1
1 0 1
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Cason
Cassava
Cassel '
Castano castellaw Castillo Castro 111 Caudle Caverly Caylor cerra Cervera Chacon Chamblee Chamness Chandler Chang Chapa Chapa Chapman
Chapman
Chapwesk Chase Chebegia Cheek CHEN Chew Chesley Chesley chesnut
Chi
Chiarella Chiarella Chilwal Chipp chipps
Chiu
Chlarson Chodur Chodur
Christensen
Chnstensen
Christian
chnstian
Christian
Christian
Church Ciallella CIMOCK Cirulnick Clark Clark clave Claypool Cleary Cleary Cleveland
Clexton clifton Clifton Coates
Coffman
Cohen
Chns
Tamara
Dan
Neremiah austtn Ltbrado Carlos
Sherne LOUIS Btll
Sabnna Aka Sunceray Nick
Emily Aurora Cliff Mark James
Ben
Rochell Bilandra swn Diane chns John Chnstina Elizabeth candice David Chns Jazmin Gwyneth David laureen
Dave
Frank
Mary Nancy
Brandon
Paige
Julia
Scott
Sara
steve
David Gian-Marw
COLL Paul Jeff lmran
wrtis
Chris
Ed
Susan
clay Ltza Crawford
Tobias
Chns
greg
Mary
David
Cohen-Waeber Julien
Colagtovanni
wle
Collette
Collette
Collette
Collette Sr.
Colley
Collier Collier collins Collins
Collins
Collins
Collins Collins
Colonna
Colonna
Condon
Cone
Connell Connell Connell Connell Connell CONNOLLY CONNOLLY Connor Connors Con0
conroy
wnstant
Contreras
wok
Cook Cook Cook Cooksley cool
Alyua
michael
Rick
Jane
Nick
Rick
Autumn
Linda Rachelle terah
Terah 8Bnan
Bnan
Melanie
Dan
Ryan
Stefanie
Stefanie
Me9 Hugh
David
Leo Patnck Ken
Allison
STEPHANIE
PAULL Noah Kevin Deborah gretchen ben Mnauel bryan Emma
Mala
Antoinette L Andrea Atwood
A B R S E J
G
V
I
W
J
D K
D L C
m
M L
W
j C
J
M
L
a
S
B
J
b
B
W
F
A
B A
M
k
B
1419 Mountain Meadow Dr 5439 Foxtail Loop 620 cypress hills dnve 1275 Theodore Dr 21891 bacalar 91 7 Palm ave 1254 Cambna Way 7365 Seafarer Place 1463 Neptune Ave 225 N Rios Avenue 2547 meade ave 228 N Mernmac 6745 Lonicera Street 3881 El Camino Real 1055 Laguna Dr 2201 Montgomery circle 2125 Pintoresco court 2750 Wheatstone St #I4 3587 Roosevelt Street #I03 3906 Shendan Place 2113 Nutmeg Ave
2613 Bevelly Dr 1922 Vineyard Ave 1536 Lower Lake Ct 3610 fairlomas road 1209 gold flower road 2310 La Paz Street 775 Cornish Dnve 2016 Via Esmarca #1 1639 valencia ave
2148 Fenton Pkwy #312
1226 Manposa Road 1226 Manposa Rd
4891 Del Monte Ave
17185 Matinal Road 1624#5N coast hwy 101
972 Concord Ct
191 -6
927 Hymenus Avenue
1215 Hygeia Ave
523 Alameda Padre Sena
5451TnnetteAvenue
3436 Gafield SI
1772 Blackbird Circle
1038 Lands End Ct
1647 wlina vista
521 Verbena Ct 733 Del Riego Ave 13 BEACON ST
964 Archer St 1732 Cereus Ct 6049 Paseo Caneta 1362 ranch road 2994 Carnllo Way 502 San Andres Dr PO Box 5692
2604-b El Camino Real 11142
7029 Fern Place
2026 catalina blvd 2026 Catalina Blvd 4577 Park Blvd
3727 Volk Ave
648 Valley Ave
16742 Libra Circle #2
4021 Lamont Street #2
3214 azahar place
7315 Seafarer PI
7315 Seafarer PI
7315 Seafarer PI
7315 Seafarer PI
6807 Embarcadero LN #228
920 Piovana Court 267 Hillcrest Dnve 1730 Wtlstone Ave 1730 Wilstone
1730 Wilstone Ave
210 A St #I1
51 19 Los Robles Dnve 3977 Santa Nella Place
944 Melaleuca Ave
944 Melaleuca Ave
21 1 Grand Ave #3C6
M 274 Hygeta Ct C 16036 Big Spnngs Way J 6618 Zinnia Ct do 135 W Glaucus St Apt M 1617 Vicklan Street 7122 LEEWARD ST 7122 LEEWARD ST POBOX 3392 M 1642 S Dttmar St 1521 Tzena Way r 1100 gardenview rd
2556 Azure Coast Dr 2710 Wilson St
1630 Parliament Road
4955 Niagara Ave #7
6972 Quiet Cove Dnve 2031 Counlrywwd Way 1529 Harbor Dnve
Oceanside Carlsbad encinitas San Dtego mission viejo Wasw Enunitas Carlsbad Enunitas Solana Beach san diego Anaheim
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Placentia La Costa San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Flower Mound vista Cardiff Nabonal City carlsbad Oceanside Enunitas Oceanside carlsbad
San Dtego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Dtego
San Diego
enunitas
Vista
Costa Mesa
Enunitas
Enunitas
Santa Barbara
Garden Grove
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad fallbrook Enunltas Enunltas WEBSTER San Diego Carlsbad
Carlsbad encinitas
Carlsbad
Solana Beach
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
san diego
San Diego
San Dtego
Long Beach
Solana Beach
Hunbngton Beach
SAn Dtego
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Leucadia Leucadia Leucadia Leucadia
Encinnas
Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad
Cads b a d
Lono Beach
163 LeuLdia
Enunitas San Diego Carlsbad B Vicksburg Vicksburg CARLSBAD CARLSBAD Sunnver Oceanside Enunitas enunitas
La Jolla
Carlsbad
Encinitas
San Diego
Carlsbad Enunitas vista
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA Ca CA TX CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA MA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
MS
CA CA OR CA CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
ca
1721 Wilstone Ave Leucadia CA
92056 760-622-8620 92006 92024 760-633-1157 92114 92691 93280 6052344260
92024 92009 92024 92075 921 16 92807
92009 436-4144
92008 92008 760-8450574
92870 92009 (760)944-0793 92111 92008 760-729-1422
92008 760-434-5841
921 03 75022 92081 92007 91950 619 267-5039 92009 92054 760-966-1721
92024 92054 92008
92108
9201 1 760-931-8676
9201 1 760-931-7759
92107
92127 92024 7-32-9760
92081
92627 949.2752385
92024
92024 760-635-4254 93103 8052451784
92845 92008 760-729-5860
92009
92009 92028 92024 760-942-3866 92024 760-436-5703 1571 5069430711
921w 858-486-4336
92009 858-336-5575 92009
92108 92009 92075
92052
92008 760-672-5969
92009
92107
92107 92116 6199615864
90808 310-996-0239
92646
92109
92009 7606349710
92009
92009
92009 92009 92009 4769551
9201 1 92024 7606328918 92024-1 124 92024-1 12 760-633-1600 92024 760-633-1600
92024
92008 92130
92009
92009
90803
92024 760 632-9263 92024 7602301617 92127 658 722-1957
92075 85a344-9519
92009 858-3~5560 92024-141 2 39180 92009 92009 97707 92054 760-722-2935
92024 760-479-9869 92024
92037 92008 760-720-0141
92024 92107
92009 92024 760 753-741 1 92081 92024
ccason@blakesales.net tamara-bogetti@yahoo com dcassel@casseI6nandaI.com
ncastano96@juno corn
auniecas@yahoo.com Ijcastil@calpoly.edu
carloscas75@yahoo.wm sherrte.caudle@shell com louiscaverly@cox net billcaylw@hotmail.wm
gcerra22@excite.wm scervera@sbcglobal net
pchawn@ieee.org
schamblee@gmail.com
nchamnes@calpoly.edu iHRTbdybrding@yahoo.com Changrora@sbcgIobal.net sdsurle@mmode.com markdchapa@yahoo.com JChapman@ptaxresoUrces.com Bejammin99@gmail. wm
xoxostolensta@hotmaiI.com bilandra@wstbook.com scottlooks@hotmail.wm crazyladydi57@aoI.com cchen@semprautiIities.com jcwoodcraft@wx.net mchesleyO1 @yahoo.com tybofighler@cox.net ckchesnut@yahm.com
davidi.713Qgmail wm
cchiarella@adelphia.net
jauysf97@adelphia.net
gwynethchilwat@yahoo.wm
tr1 dave@yahoo.wm
lauriemortgage@yahoo.com
dave-chiu@hotrnail.com
frank.chlarson@wnexant.com
mchodur@cox.net
chcdurdowe@wx net
chnstensensurfs@yahoo.wm
paigechristensen@hotmail.com juIiachnstian@yahoo.com newpbs@sbcglobal.net sarajchristian@yahoo.com RATsc@hotmail.com david@ffgdev.com gmbaseball7@yahoo.com HAPPY42287@HOTMAIL..COM Paul-Cirulnick@hotrnail.com
jeff.clark@adelphta.net tmranclark@hotmail wm
cacl OlOlO@yahoo.wm
chrisandsusie@sbcglobal net
edc@tagsandiego.com
nospam103@yahoo.wm
stcleveland@adelphia.net
clextond@battelle org
clifton16gwx.net
liza2026@cox.net
crawfordwates@hotmail.com
twffman@snlc.net
cwhen@ucsd.edu
jwaebe@hotrnail.com
alyciacola@hotrnail.com
mike.wle@onebox.com wllette-dudeI@msn.com imhereubZ@yahw com nick-dude@mSn.com imfreeubZ@adelphia. net pussyratgrl@excite.com Imwllier49@holmail wm mandrwllier@hotmail.wm terah brian@earprotnpter.com briancollins@cox.net melmileyl B@yahoo.com danmllins-wrk@sbcglobal.net darkside-I 04@hotmail.wm sawlonnl @yahoo.com sawlonnl @yahoo com
ShaShaStarOl @hotmail.com Paradachsl@cox net dmcirish@yahoo com leocannell57@san rr.wm pnnell@ripcurl.wm kwnnell26@hotmail wm thealIi@hotmail.com stephnwnn@adelphia.net paull wnnolly@nextel.wm blueseahorse7@yahoo.com kmconnors@coasthighyphoto.wm deblc@earthlink.net
wyote5122WO@yahoo.wm
greenroomturtle@hotmail corn
Iemanco@yahoo.com
bryantownsendcook@hotmail.com
sdemma@gmail corn maiawok@hotmail.com blltdancer@sbcglobal ne1 ammksley@adelphia.net dan@cool-solutions wm
1 1 1 1 1 0
1 0
1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 t
1 1
0 0
1 1
0 0
1 1 1 1
1 0
0 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0
0 0 0 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
1 1 0 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0
Page 5
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Coomes
Coon,
Cooney
Cooper
Cooper Corwran
Corwran
Corella
Corgiat
cornell
cornell Correll
cony Cortelyou
Cory Costan Cothran Cothran' Coulter Coveney Coveney Covington
Covington Covington
Cowan
Cowell Cowie
Cowie
Cowie Cowley
Cozens Craig Crake Cramer crawford crawford Crawley Crawley Creal
cwg creighton Cremaschi
Creswell
Crewse Crickmore Criqui Cristaldi Cristofaro
mmer
Cromwell
Crosbie
Crosland
Cross Croteau aouch CROUCH Crowder Crowley cruickshank Cruse CNtcMield Cser Cutwell Cupat cupin Curdy
curry
curry Curtis Curtis
Curt0 Cutler
CUtllff
D'Andrea D'oparto
Daigle
Daly
Daly
Daly
Dan
Danieli
danielsen
Dant
Darling DashwOod dastoli
wx
Joanne M
Timothy R
Alice
Kevin
Jaime L John C
Michelle
Olga A
Pamela R
diane k
diane k Gina Mike
Pamela L
James m John Nathaniel Bnan
mark E Sean Sean
Denise A
Darryl Denise
valene and Dennis
Jon Sarah
Laura
Wayne Rick william Tom Melanie AnneMane Katie lames bob Myles Alana Sharon James krysta Carlos
Mark
Laura Janna Shane
Cheryl
lames
Diane
Jackie
George
Jon Scott swtt
Joseph
DAN Ktmberly William kevin
Malvern Phillip patncia Grace
wg William Linda swn Lonny Paul Elizabeth Charles Chns
Mark
Tanessa
Anne
Knsta
Jessica
Deanna
Chns
Bnan
Bill
Florence Ron
mark
Gregory
wry
Davenport Barbel Hank
Davidge Thomas
davies david
Davis Leah Davis Wesley Davis Sonja
Davis Susanne Davis swtt
Davis swtt
Davis Amy dawso john Day Sam Day Michael De La Cruz Belinda De La Fuente Jennifer
D L
C
B J
A
f
S L
F
d
A
M
P
P
M
m
A
H
W E
G
S
S B
P
E
J
A
M
M
A
L
L f
a r B B E M R
a S
J
395 Sunset Dnve Enunitas CA
3022 Rancho Del Canon Carlsbad CA
7042 Snapdragon Dnve Carlsbad CA
3850 Elijah Ct #921 San Diego CA
1750 S El Camino Real unit K202 Encinitas CA
1235 Hygeia Ave
1235 Hygeia Avenue
7602 Calle Madero
3637 Strata Dnve
1741 eucalyptus ave
1741 eucalyptus ave 725 Stratford Dnve 3280 Reynard Way #6 4950 Northaven Ave 3518 Sitio Baya 6620 Curlew Terrace 910 Nardo road 2525 Via Esparto 9074 pimpemel dr 1749 Hygeia Avenue 1749 Hygeia Avenue 827 Palaro Dnve 827 Palaro Dr 827 Palaro Dr 7366 escallonia ct 10915 Corte Melillones 4620 Pannonia Road
4620 Pannonia Road
4620 Pannonia Road P 0 Box 2334 3931 aenes way 2101 Twain Ave 1013 Hygeia Ave 440 Jennileah Lane 834 Agate Street 1233 calle fantasia 33101 buccaneer ct
6741 Cantil Street 6741 Cantil Street 8402 Torreyanna Circle 9172 Regents Rd Apt G
1033 N Vulcan Ave
Av del parque 4403
3080 Linwln st #IO
2730 lnvemess Dr
344 Liverpool Dr
13773 Condesa Dnve
3369 Rocking Horse Circle PO BOX684
6561 camino del parque
7683 Mar Ave
1631 Avery Road
PO Box 2531 609 Prospect Ave #31 262 Santa Louisa 7009 aster place 5237 SHELLY PLACE 33572 Valle Road 4978 Niagara Ave 2340 carol view dr #305
307 W Avenida Gaviota 1659 Neptune Ave 2073 Bawn St 1805 starling ct
4620 Park Dnve
1064 eucalyptus ave 7251 San LUIS St
2890 Luciernaga St 11855A Spruce Run Dnve
232 N Rios Ave
2255 Seaquest Trail
2470 Newport Ave
1727 CorteVentana
2415 Byron Place
7772 Rouo Street
3789 Cameo Dnve
2825 Crystal Ridge Road
6439 Merlin Dr
PO BOX 119 6528 Corte Monteuto
1 150 Lorna Vista Way
3529 Hummock Dnve
1269 blue sky dr
4616 Flonda St #15
I 159 Arden Dr 1397n vulcan ave #8
PO Box 420357
6170 Decanture Ct
4743 iroquois ave
1 bnggs st 5070 NIAGARA AVE 2213-A Clark St 4313 Via Tercero 7004 vista Olas 7004 Vista Olas
3022 Avenida Chnstina 2720 chestnut ave 2104 Bawn St #I2
PO BOX 928144
3892 Ansta Way 1808 Wilstone Ave
171 1 Bruce Road
Leucadia
Leucadia
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
encinitas
encinitas Encinitas San Diego San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad Enunitas Carlsbad san diego Leucadia Leucadia Encinitas
Leucadia Leucadia
carlsbad
San Diego Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Rancho Santa Fe Virginia Beach Carlsbad Enunitas San Marws
San Diego san marws san Juan capistrano Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad La Jolla Enunitas Santiago chile
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Cardiff Del Mar Encinitas Huntington Beach
cadsbad
La Jolla
San Marws
Carisbad
South Pasadena lrv1ne carlsbad CARLSBAD San Juan Capistrano san diego cardiff San Clemente Leucadia San Diego carlsbad Carlsbad vista Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Solana Beach Escondido Cardiff by the Sea Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Oceanside
Enicinitas
Carlsbad
del mar
Carlsbad
vista
Carlsbad
cardiff
San Diego
carlsbad
Encinitas
encinitas
San Diego
San Diego
san diego
taunton
Ocean Beach Columbia Oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad San Diego
San Diego
Oceanside
Enunitas
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA va CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA RM
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
ma
CA sc
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
92024 760-942-2796
92009
92011 760-431-0356
92130
92024
92024 760-943-1280
92024 760-943-1280
92009 760 889-1365
92008 (750)730-1906
92024 943-1845
92024 943-1845 92024 760-944-0661 92103 92110 92009 92009 992024 92W6 92129 858484-7799 92024 92024 92024 760-632-5467
92024 92024
92009 780 476-3658
91230 619-990-5771 92008
92008
92008
23451 92008 92024 7605339710 92069 760-510-2728 92109 92069
92009 619.885.1968 92009 760.212.8214 9201 1
92037 (858) 699-5149
92024 4403 58-2-2436386
92008 760-720-1601
92008 760-729-7757 92007 (760) 753-2651 92014
92648
92009 7807205337
92037
92018 7605054443
91030 92606 92009 92008 7604761814 92675 92107 92007 7604871335 92672 949361 1870 92024 92107 619-225-0335 9201 1 760-502-9683 92008 92084 92009 760-4769618 92009 760-476-9498 92131 92075 92029 760-434-9501 92007 92056 760-717-4468 92008
92009
92058
92024 780.942.5092
92009
92014
92009
92084
92008
92007 760-613-1576
92116
92008 760-494-7971
92024
92024 7144149940
92142
921 17 619-307-1 147
92067 858-334-9334
92675 949-38a2208
92024 85a756-7991
92078 760-79a4147
921 20-2 142
2780 5088224431
92107 6197580650
29201 92056
92009 92009 92009 92008 92107 92192
92054 619 540-6960
92024 7607530236
]womes690@aol wm
twon@neurocnne wm
ALCooney28@msn com
kevin@kcdesign us
]airnerson76@grnail wm lohnwrwran@cox net ladycorwran@wx net
oacorelfgpacbell net newyrbabyO@aol com dianewrnell@hotmail wm dianewrnell@hotmail wm ginacorrell@wx net wrrym@hotrnail com caseyzunitom@san rr wm sorneguy91688@yahoo wm ]costan@sbcglobal net gnatman@gmail wm bcothran2@earthlink net mwulter@san rr wm scoveney@niainc corn scoveney@niainc wm Denise Covington@cox net darrylwvington@cox net denise wvington@wx net vjcdcc@adelphia net jdwwell@san rr corn scdancer-Z8@hotrnail wm scgirl-ZlZ@hotmaiI wm type47fan@pelicanbbs wm rickQnewwavetnp wm wlliamrwx@yahoo corn ptwzens@hotmail wm cmelaniel@hotmail com am@integnty corn kcramer@ucsd edu jettyrewrdsQaol bobpc@stormcycle wm
mylescrawley@hotmail com
skyegoddess247@sbcglobal net
xreal@mhr stloe org
IcreggQucsd edu
kaeighton@ymca org
cremaschi@yahoo wm
dogzgod@hotmail com
lauracrewse@sbcgobal net
cnckmores@cox net
scnqui@hotrnail wm
Icnstal@sdccd net
ccnstofaro@socal rr cam
reeftattoo@netzero wm
docaornwell@san rr corn
la-cmsbie@yahoo wm dirtrag@sprynet corn jgcross@yahoo wm swn-croteau@hotrnail wm surfskatesnowl@yahoo wm DCROUCH@LUSARDI COM kmba28@yahoo wm gregcrowley80@hotmaiI corn ksc23ksc@hotmail wm gregaadreps net mautchfield@wx net headhisurf@cox ne1
patti@brasilia-rsm wm
gcupatZ@yahoo com
gregcupin@cox net wcurdy@aol com currylinda@hotmail wm
scottmcurryQyahaowm
Lonny-Curtis@hotmail corn
pcurtis@hswn org
elizabeth-92067@yahoo wm
ccutler@hrnssoflware wm
CCutllff@adelphia net
mdandrea@sbcglobal net
presleyaron@wx net
wordwiz88@yahoO wm
dandkdaly@adelphia net
]essicada@yahoo wm deannadaly@adelphia net cdan203l@hotmail wm
Bnan Danieli@genzyme wm
garydan@pacbell net
surfZscuba@yahoo corn
flowdl@wx net ron-dashwood@hotrnail wm maarkoawx net
hankscpu@luno wm
tcdavidge@cox net
getnshacked@aol com
Isunshine62@yahoo wm Iifescience@fastmail fm sonla davis@nelsonmullins wm sdavis84@cox net suemart7l@hotmail com sdavis7004@hotmail wm a Jdavis@yahoo wm johndawso@yahw corn braavnuwurld@hotmail wm
michael@heatwavemedia corn
sockerfan@cox net jen@delafuente lv
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
I 1
t 1
1 1
1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0
0 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1
0 0
1 1
1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 0
0 0
0 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 0 0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0 1 0
0 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0
Page 8
de Wit
dean
Dean
Dean
Dean Dean Debbas
Debes decaen
DeCastm
Decker
decker
Decker
Dee
Deenng
Deeter
DeJonge
Dekleermaek
DeLand DeLaRosa
DeLanre
Delphenich
Demain
DeMatteis
De M e u I I e
Demiter
Demma
Denboer
Deneroff
denlinger
Denny
Denton
DePascale
DePmspero
des Jardins
des Pres Destremps
detnch Detnch Dette deutman Devlin DEVRIES
dewart
deweese Diaz Dickey Dierdoiif dietor Dillon
Dimagiba
Dimas
Dimas
Dimas
Dipietro DiPietro
DiSepio
dixon
Djasran Dobson Dockweiler Dodd Dodds Dodds Dodson Doherty Doherly Dolnik Donahoe Donahue Doney donnelley Donovan Donovan Doogan dooyema Dore' doman Downes Downey Downhour
Downing
Downing
Dawning
Doyle
Draves
Dray Drover
Drover
Drumm
Dw' Dua
Dube
Dube
DuChene
D u I g n a n
D u i g n a n Dulmage Dumais Duncanson
Dunlea
DNmm
Leanora
lames
Cheryl
Nicholas
Deborah
Sally
Jack paul Dawn
colleen Jordan
Alex
William
John
Derek
ter Paul
John
Sandra DeSIree
Sharon
Toby
Ryan
Bnan
David
Kellie
Huibert Enc
Janet
Enc
Michael
Nlck
Karen
Tnstan
Robert
Mike
Albert
piper
Pam Gregg Kevin mark Thomas JAYNE edith michael Jencho Kathleen Mike andrea Lauren
Rose
Naomi Jim Genevieve
victona
Michael
Daniel
dave Alexandra
Bob
Lauren Richard Cheryl Glenn Jodi Leslie Sharon Chns Ryan Louise Troy Jeffrey Danielle Lyle Jonathan danell John bryan
Mary Drew David Laura Dave Daniel Barb James Nathaniel
Jan Jan Deborah Jon John Am
Samir
Wendy
Russell
Sara
Michael
Gregory Lance Steven Louise
r
H
L
F
U
M
E
D
L
J
m
L
C
A
S
L a
C A
n
M
M A
J M
8
R
E
L
W
L
W
R
P
J
D
D D M D J
810 Butterfield Lane
244 delphinium st
2110 Whisper Wind Lane
2110WhisperWind LAne
4617 Bermuda Avenue
765 Normandy Rd 7033 Ivy Streel
4055 Park Dnve
2024 reed ave #7
6970 SandcasUe Dr
1041 Beacon Bay Rd
1041 beacon bay
9650 Graceland Way
6009 Paseo Hermosa
3155 Falcon Dnve
410 S Callfornia Street
1806 Palisades Dr
355 Gravilla St
3350 Del Rio Ct
2796 Carlsbad Blvd
21 49 pleasant grove road
2051 Shadow Grove Way
805 Leonard Ave
11 Manwell Rd
12642 Ragweed Street
1630 Landquist Dnve
413s Ditmar
1761 Bruce Road
2871 Rancho Cortes
8235 harton place 2255 Seaquest Trail
7120 Clairemont Mesa Blvd
460 3rd Street
5715 Grove Forest Couli
729 Passiflora
2907 Levante Street
1738 Yourell Ave
Pam 1230 Hoover St 1354 Hermes Ave 61 14 Paseo Monona 4337 Hortensia Street 11 8 JUPITER STREET #2 1060 passiflora ave 1950 coast blvd 7314 Black Swan PI
7948 Calle Posada 893 ginger ave 1880Avenida La Posta
914 C Caminito Madngal
2123 Pintoresco Courl
2123 Pintoresw Ct
2123 Pintoresco Ct
1418 Turquoise Dnve
534 Sweet Pea PI
7374 Escallonia Court
16831 orchard bend road
2271 Edinburg Ave
3306 Piragua St 747 Jamaica Ct 5074 Bnghton Ave 6437 La Gana Ct 6437 La Gama Ct 6519 Hanover Avenue 1054 Hygeia Ave 7435 Neptune Dr 3296 Avenida Anacapa 12685 Lone Cypress Place 961 Melaleuca Ave Apt G 461 1 nanagansett ave 7032 columbine dnve 2376 Altisma Way 8097 Artesian Rd 6968 Waters End Dnve
959 Passiflora ave 336 andrew ave 2307 ~ickory Creek Place
1813 Via Cuarto 2395 Juan St
PO box7301 1561 Loraine 6580 Red Knot Street
8843 Donaker Street 2560 San elijo Ave 22 Brezner Lane
365 Pomelo Dr #G21
365 Pomelo Dr # G-21
2802 Sombrosa Street
2802 Sombrosa Street
PO BOX 699 155 W Jason Street #2
565 Dew Point Ave
565 Dew Point Ave
3727 Billrnan St
34 Corlear Street
34 Corlear Street 1680 N Coast Hwy 101 No 20 4104 La Portalada Dr 3105 Del Rey Ave 723 San Rafael Place
2046 BNceala Ct
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
San Marcos
enunitas
Encinitas
Encinltas
San Diego
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
san diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
carlsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Burbank
Carlsbad
La Jolla
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
enunitas
Encinitas
Oceanside
Chelmsford
San Diego
Encinitas
oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad san diego
Escondido
San Diego
Encinitas
Midlothian
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
N Hollywood Carlsbad Leucadia Carlsbad San Diego ENClNlTAS enunitas
del mar Carlsbad Cardiff Carlsbad carlsbad Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Caarlsbad
Carlsbad
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Cardiff by the Sea Carlsbad San Diego SD Carlsbad Carlsbad Richmond Enunitas Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad san diego Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad 432 encinitas Leucadia encinitas Richmond Oceanside San Diego
San Diego Encinitas
Carlsbad
San Diego Cardff by the Sea
Centerville
Vista
Vista
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Vista
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego Albany Albany Encinitas Carlsbad Carlsbad
San Diego
way
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
MA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
VA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA VA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
VA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA MA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA NY
CA CA
CA
CA
ca
NY
92069 92024 7606341069 92024 760 4369358
92024 760 436 9358
92107 619-225-6112
92024
92011 760-4761940
92008
92109
92009
92009
9201 1
9219
92009
92006 760-801-9910
91505 3231549-4302
92008 760-729-3318
92037 858-456-7830
92009
92008 (760) 434-1122
92024 7606320211
92024
92054
92129
92024
92054
92008
92009
92029
92111
92024 760 944-7767
23112
92024
92009 760644-3492 92OM) 7604380525 91601 CA 92008 (760) 729-2600 92024 92009 92103 92024 760 613 1248 92024
92014
92009 7604380072
92007 760-944-0665
92009 92009 92024
92009
92009
92009
92009
92024 92009
92061
92009 760-685-5306 92109
92009 92009 760-929-2760 23226 804-938-4426 92024 7609949905 92009 92009 (760) 436-3253 92130 92009
1824 97a244-2407
92123 85a353-1302
92009 760-43a2002
92007 85a504-0862
92107 858-342-7711
gzia7
freedomfromdeskjob@hotmail corn jamesmjae@hotmail.com
cdean@scnpps.edu
nick-dean@isisph.com
ddean@qualcomm.com
sallyhdean@cox.net
debbas@capstoneadvisors corn
dontreadonrne@?hotmail.com
paul.decaen@pflzer.com
konasurf2004-aloha@yahoo.com
albertdecker@adelphia.net
casfin@adelphia.net jdeck002@ucr.edu
adee29@hotrnatl.com
wad88@yahoo.com
johnd@mandalay.com
derek@bikernag.com
pauldeke@aol.com
johnd@tfb corn rawskin@sbcglobal.net
desiree-deIattre@yahoo.com
sdelpheQaol com
seemsfake@yahoo.com
RynoRlB@aoI.com
brian@demeulle.com
djderniter@yahoo.com
kelliedemma@yahoo.com
huibert@flamingoholland.com
edeneroff@adelphia.net
piperelfuego@hotmail.com
shopplng@ricochet.com
eric@guitartrader.com
mdepascale@pascalsteel.com
nickd90@comcast.net
kdesjardins@juno com
tTistandeSpTe~sbcglobal.net bobd@calsense.com spazmk@earthlink. net gregg@barkjaw.com psIOnic@yahoo.com mark-dum@mac.com tdevlin@att.net JAYNE@SPADADESIGNS.COM eandkdewart@cox.net
michaeldeweese04@hotmaiLwrn
arrniesofjericho@yahoo.com
kathydickey@adelphia.net
snake48@sbcglobal.net
ceeyasuAn@hotmail corn
ledillon@hotmail.com
joyroselOl4@yahoo cam
ndimas@pacbell net
ndimas@pacbell.net
ndimas@pacbell.net
toriphotos@sbcglobal.net mdpjunk@cox.net dandisepioQadelphia. net davedixon@hotmail.com adjasran@aOl.com bdobson@Rberlink.com Idcckwei@ucsd.edu nch dodd@gmail.com Cheryl-dodds@hotmall.com
glenndodds@grnail.com
jodidod@hotmail.com
leslie@sundiego corn
sdoherty@hologic corn
chrisdolnik54@AOL COM
rdonahoe@ucsd.edu
louise.donahue@sbcglobal.net
.- . tcdoneygyahoo-corn
92009 7606038133~3W ieff@!760media corn
92009 760-602-9696
92127 9201 1 858-5859454
92024 7809446122
92024 436 9617
23294 804-439-3797 92056 760 941 3274 92 103
92167
92024 7606342791
92009 760-916-0773
92129
92007 619 788-6927
2632
92081
92081
92009
92009
92085
92024
92009
92009
92115
12209
12209 92024 92008 760 504 4512 92009 7606340432 92109
92024 760-518-3479
dan>ono@adelphia net lyledon@sbcglobal net jon@carlsbadass corn
ddwyema@yahoo co
cmssouth@aol com
bryan@smartlending corn
mary@nchasen corn
sk8rbupd corn
DavidD08540@yahoo corn
lauradowning@yahoo corn
davedowning@cox net
dwdowning@adelphia net
bad79@san rr corn
mesaconcrete@san n corn
kechele728746@hdmail corn
jandrover@aol corn
jandrover@aol com
debdrumm@adelphia net
ddrumm@earthlink net
enk@StandardFilms corn
artidua@yahoo com
sdube@yahoo com
sdubeayahoo corn
rduchene@hotmail corn dymer6@hotmail corn
mtchaelduignan@hotmail corn gdulmage@cox net Idumais@npcurl com sduncanson@sbcglobal net
louise dunleaareef com
1
1
1
0
1
I
1
1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
t 1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
1
1 1
1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 0 1
1 1 1 1 1 1
1
1 1 1
1
1 0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1 1
0
0 0 1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0 1 0 1
0 0
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1 0 1
0 1 1 0
0 1
1
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
0
0 0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0 1 1
0 0 1 1 0 0
0 0
1
1
0
Page 7
Ponto Beachfront Vision Pian Petition
Dunn
Dunn
Dunn ,
Dunnagan
Dunworth
Dupont
durant
Durrance
Durso
Dwelley
Dynan Dzurec
Eady
Easley Eastham
eastwood Eckenroad eckert
eckert
Eckert Eckmann eclert Edland Edwards Edwards Edwards eggleston elder Eldredge Elenbaas Ellinwood Ellis Ellis Ellison Ellison-Lloyd elovitz Elvins Emerick Emerick Empie
Emre
Engelman
engelsman
engelsman
englehom Enigenburg Enigenburg Enselberg Erhardt enc Eriksson Erlich Erselius ENin Eskew esquer Estep evans Everett
Everett Everett Everett
Evora
Ewalt
Ewen
Failla
Falcone
Fallet
falletta
fallin
Falling
Falorio
Falono
Farah
farinacci
Farinacci
Farinacci
Fans
Fans
Farrar
Farrelly
Fanis Faust Fazio Feemster Feinstein Feldman Feldmeth Fellows Fels Fernrite
Fenton
Ferguson
Ferguson
Ferlazzo
Femandez Ferrante Ferrante FERRARI Ferris
Dupey
Dye
Rebecca
Kirsten
Jane
Tanya
Jeremy
Karen
Chns
autumn
Kaley
Adnenne Mitchell Connie Robert Matt
Ryan
Todd Brad
kimberly Colleen diana
pamela
Gina Kimberly john Steven D Amanda Rachel Alexis katnna michael
GUY
Gregory Charles Jeff Heidi DusOn Susan Jonathan T Todd
Laura Patnck Robert
Nil
Courtney
chns
kate
lauren
Jennifer
Bruce Hillary Nancy kapan
Enn Jason Keith Luke Michael Lorenza Shawn chns David Chns David Craig Darryl Stephanie
Molly
Kann
Frank
celine
chnsty
William
Cyndy LOU
Victor
wry
Gary
Bryn
Mary
Diane
Tracy
Lachelle
Laura
Jesse Alan Natalie Heather Harley Shoshana Damon Sue Kelli Jason Michael Liam Bruce Joan
LUIS
Mike
Heather
PAUL Laurel
A 16641 Madrone Circle
1432 Ranch Road
1764 Orchard Wwd Road
D 2945 Highland Dnve
D 10690 Glendover Lane
L 6909 Waters End Dnve
904 Missoun Street
m 16439 temple ave
A 22 Slumber Meadow Trl
3322 Fosca St 2771 Wilson st T 6579 Daylily Dr K 2626 Nassau Street E 2326 Newcastle Avenue
3334 Eureka PI
A 150 Avenitda Rosa
2206 Margaret Dr
s 702 toulon
T 1600 Guevara Road
j 684lbnarwooddnve
D 11041 TondinoRd h 6841 bnawwd dnve
1864 outngger lane
345 Walnut Ave apt G
2125 Coolngreen Way 6754 Joeve Court
Sonora
Encinitas
Encinitas
Carlsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
San Diego
port charlotte
Palm Coast
Carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Sarasota
Cardrff
Carlsbad
San Clemente
Newport Beach
sandiego
Carlsbad
carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad San Diego carlsbad En u n i t a s San Dieao E 902 Apt. E S. Rancho Santa Fe Rd San Marcos
d k
M
C T
D
P
L
S
E C A
a
1
A
L
N
m
M
D
J
N
E
T H
M
A
A A h
T
E
E
S
A
307 Bmaks Ave 3604sbeachdnve 2646 levante st 225 Fraxibella St 829 Emory St 1417 HaNard StreetXZ 1681 Hill Top On 1005 N Vulcan Ave #2 2929 Fire Mountain Dr #43 1809 High Ridge Ave 7108 daffodil place 14030 Crest Way 2820 Grape St
1623 James Dnve
819 LIDO CT tl 271 1 Llama Court
2169 Dickinson Dnve
6979 waters end dr
6979 waters end dnve
3337 vivienda circle
336 Pine Ave
5163 Don Mala Dr ,
11 816 Darlington Ave #207 7939 Paseo Aliso
735 Cornish dnve
7555 Herschel Avenue #4 3871 Camino Lindo 25307 Ave Ronada 346 9th Street 170 Diana St 13453 Caminito Cannel 120 Phoebe St # 3 171 west avenida san antonio 13121 Silver Saddle Lane 147 Fresnillo Ct 13121 Silver Saddle Lane 4951 Long Branch Ave 11676 Sardis place 1354 Hermes Ave 3056 Via Allicante
1032 19thSt #6
3582 Syndey Place
1005 Foxglove View
3920 lngraham street
228 B Avenue
3429 49th ave SW
7103 Leeward Street
7103 Leeward Street
6749 Tea Tree St
12584 cavallo st
2900 Wintergreen Dnve
2900 Wintergreen Dnve
3105 Madera Court
404 Enunitas Blvd #416
1705 Hornblend St #A
900 Caminito Madngal
6758 Bushy Hill Dr
2040 Chestnut Avenue 168 Walnut Ave 1009s Nevada 619 S Vulcan#210 11 19 Oliver Ave 1645 Oakdale St 819 Santa Regina 4990 Crestview Dr 518 Dew Point Ave 172 East MAin Street 7065 Leeward St 104 Mangano Cir
7939 Calle Madnd 369 In Third Street
7367 Seafarer Place
7367 Seafarer Place
611 SKYSAILAVE
3217 Crest Dnve
Raleigh tampa carlsbad enunitas lmpenal Beach Santa Monica Encinttas Enunitas Oceanside Carlsbad carlsbad Del Mar San Diego Carlsbad SAN DlEGO La Costa Carlsbad
carlsbad
carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Brentwwd
Carlsbad
enunitas
La Jolla San Diego Valencia Del Mar Encinitas
Del Mar
Enunitas san demente Poway Solana Beach Poway San Diego San Diego Enunitas La Jolla
Santa Monica
San Diego
Carlsbad
Jan diego
coronado Seattle
Carlsbad
Carlsbad CARLSBAD san diego
Carlsbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Encinitas
San Diego
Carlsbad
Santee
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Oceanside
Encinttas
San Diego
Pasadena Solana Beach Carlsbad Carlsbad El Cajon Carlsbad Encinitas Carlsbad Enanitas Carlsbad
Carlsbad
CARLSBAD
Manhattan Beach
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA n
FL
CA
CA
CA
FL
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
NC
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA WA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
n
95370 209.586 7356
92024
92024
92008
92126
92009
92109
33948
32 164
92009 760.6353547
92006 760-434-6074
92009 760-603-1203
34231
92007
92006
92672
92663 9495153665
92646 714-366-5133
92006
92008 7607291 146
92009 760-603-0997
92008 760-730-1443 92131 92009 760-603-0997 92024 92119 92078 760598-5226
27607 33629822 813-839-0304 92009 7606320664 92024 91932 90404 3102649955 92024 92024 92054 92006 760-729-8367 92009 7602015635 92014 92102 92W8 92109 658-349-9450 92009 92008
92009 801-24501 21
92009
92009
92008 7607200637
92008 760431 8712
90049 646-47567529
92009 760-942-6566
92024
92037 650814-3227 92122 619 398 6535
91355 92014 92024
92014 858-350 9692
92024 92672 9496366727 92064 92075 CA 92064 92107 92131 92024 92037
90403 310/82&3252 92116 760-519-6536 92009 760-603-1903 92109 92118 6194371645 96116
92009
92009 92009 92130 92006 760-730-3804 92008 760-730-3804
92009 92024 921 09
92009
92071
92006 (760) 720-1385
92006
92054
92024 7606346788
92109
91106 92075
92006 92009 92020
92009
92024 92009 760-944-7581 92024 853-699-9804 9201 1 760 931 5679
92009 7609315869
92009
90266
rundunn@goldrush com
kirstendunn@yahoo corn
janesdunn@adelphia.net
tanya@hazardhutchison.com
Jeremy-dunworth@hotmail.com
kklicky@hotmail.com
cdupont@ucsd.edu
beachgirlinthesun@hotmail.com
Surfmonkey7@aol com
adurso@csusm.edu
Mdwelley@Hotmail com
cdye@adelphia.net
rdynan@verizon.net
mdzurec@hotmail.com
subroza@gmail.com
easley.t@gmail.com
beastham@ripcurl corn
kymwvodZ@aol corn
colleen eckenroad@usmc.mil
becachfmntdi@yahoo corn
meemal912@aol.com
skuIls683@aol.com kimio427@yahoo.com bhsurfr@aol.com sedland@ucsd.edu
aledwards@westemu.edu
reedwarl Z@yahw.com
aedwardslZ@nc.rr corn kandy-07@hotrnail.com surfsailca@aol.com geldredgel J@hotmaiI.com gelll O@sbcglobal.net charlesellinwwd@aol com ellil717@hotmail.com heidib335@hotmail.com dustinellison@yahoo.com susanlloyd@adelphia.net lovitz@aol corn telvins@ucsd.edu laura.spam@cox.net pe395@yahoo.com robertempie@hotmail.com nilemre@ucla.edu COURTNEYNMNCONNELL@MSN.COM Chris
kengelsman@dcshoes com
femme1 14@yahoo.com
)eni@pacbell net
menigenburg@sbcglobaI.net
enselberghillary@hotmail.com
nancy-erhardt@yahOo.com
eric@kapankent.com
enn-enksson@hotmail com jcealoha@yahoo corn
kerseliu@ptloma.edu luke-eNin@hotmail.com emaneml @juno.com
lorenzaae@yahoo.com
shawnestep3@hotmail.com evans@fea.net temp01 @interon.com cjeverl 9@yahoo.com tempOi@interon.com craigalaneverett@yahw.com srsurfdub@hotmail.com flygirlg@yahoo.com
molls98@hotmail.com
murphy22290403@yahoo.com elripster@aol.com mfallet@adelphia.net ceIinehawaii@msn.com christ~llin@sb~lobal.net
wfalling@hotmail.com
Icfalorio@juno.com
Icfalorio@juno.com vfarahIOO@msn.com gary@networkapplications. net
gary-bmw@pacbell.net gary-bmw@pacbell.netq
brynjess@hotrnail.com tfaris@yahoo.com littlemspink@hotmail.com mrsfarreIly@yahoo.com jtfars@cox net
ahf-zen@nehero. net
nataliefazio@cobshomes corn
lafeemagmail com
harleyleinstein@yahoo corn
shoshanafeldman@hotmail corn
damon.feldmeth@cbre com sfellows@csusm edu
kellifels@adelphia net
jfemrite@luce.com mikemuzi k@ya hoo. com
liam@twsnet.com
btf-misc@cox.net ]oanweiner@sb€global net turtleman76@hotmail com mike.ferrante@adelphia net heather.ferrante@viasat.com
PFERRARH 234@YAHOO.COM
ljfems@gmail com
1 1 1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1 1
0
1
1
0 1 1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1 1
1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 0 1 I
1
1
Page 8
0 0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0 0 0 0 0
0 1
1 0 0 1 1 1 0
1
1 1
0 1 1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
0 1
0 1 1
1
0
FETZER Fidel
Field
Fife
Filteau
Findell
Findell
Finkbiner
Fischer
fish
Fisher
Fisher
Fisher Fisk
FitzGibbon
FIX
Flaherly
Flanagan
flanigan
Fleischer
flerning
Flery
Fletcher
Fletcher
flood
Flood
Floyd
flynn
Fogel
Fogliani
Foley folkerth Folk Fong
fontenot Fwte Foote Foote Ford Ford Ford Ford Ford fordharn FOREST Forrest
Forrestar
Fostakowsky
Foster
Foster
fox
Fox
Fox
Fox
Fox
Fox Fox Frame Franus Frank Franklin Fraser Fraser Fraser
frazier
Fredenksen
Fredin
Frednckson
Freeman
French
Fnedrnan
Fnednchs
Fnesen
Fnth
Fnth
Fntsvold
Fntzinger
Froh
Frost
Frost
Fruitwala
Fu
Fuller
Fultz
funakoshi
Furler
furst
Gaitonde
Gale Gale
Gallegos
Galleisky gallenberger Galligani
Gallion
Galloui
Gallup
ganeles
Ganguli Ganpule Garcia
gamey
LARA
Alex
Fielding
Pam
Frankye
Tffany
Chns
Judi
Andrew
matt
Janet
Valene
Kerry-Shannon
Scott
Linda
GARY
Jack
Michael
Jennifer
Enn
lukr
Sooze
Matthew
Robert
george
Timothy
Grady
pierce
Jeremiah Fogel
Holly
Owen lean William Courtney jorden
Enn Susan Stevie Cathleen
Kitty aka Kathryn Pais David Matt stephen CM William
Marsalee
Mike
Alexis
Mark
Robert
Ashley
Timothy
Ellen
Eric Linda Jeffrey Jack Thomas Caryn John Dons Todd
Paul
Fredin
Bnan
Amy Justin
Man
Ted
Arden
Ceul
Donald
Erik
Allie
Jessica
Jennifer
Bnan
Sarah
Samuel
andy
Debra
keith
Alison
Christian
drew
Supnya
LEONARD Andrew
David
Christian robert Daniel Jennifer
Francesca
Ted
lean
Alex
Sachin Adolfo
marl
mary
T
L
L
i
R
C
k
J
j D F
R
rn
M
R
a
W
M
A D H
R
H D
S
R
J
N
L
I
R
A
D S
9 G A
E e
A
V
33 HILLGATE PLACE
1314SavannahLane
3735 Cavern Place
2020 Fife Ridge Court
6432 Merlin Dr
325 Windy Lane
325 Windy Lane
140 Range Street
3535Lebon Dnve#4120
1060 arcadia rd
7523 Brava Street
1062 Beacon Bay Dr
2158 Corte Cidro 393 Date Avenue 1259 Calle Ultimo 1597 CAUDOR ST
1655 little gopher cyn
2406 Albsrna Way
810 dewtt ave
732 Venice Court
11 105 urnarron dr
5202 Soledad Mt Rd
601 1 Paseo Aimso
10M Bangor St
760 solana urcle east 2340 Hosp Way #220 536 Crest Dr
1338 Hermes Ave
7619 Aldea Place
828 Skysail Ave
149 Pheobe St 538 nrnini rd 3364 Seawest Dr 2630 Pinneos Way #20 830 bluewater rd 4023 Calle Juno 2417 La Plancha Lane 213 Surfnder Way 2374-8 Cannga Way 2382 Pnrnrose Ave 3025 Del Rey Avenue 1618 Kerry Lane 45185 Callesito Ordenes 1901 playa nviera dr 3672 SEAFLOWER LN 309 Dunan ST
351 7 Landsford Way
1994 Diamond St
2022 B Oceanview Road
2022 B Oceanview Road
3425 woodland way
1615 Eolus Ave
1907 Chono Street
918 Alyssum Rd
1602 Tucker Lane
2740 Waterbury Way 4592 Scenano Dnve 949 If2 Agate Street 1315 Knoll Dnve
829 Hermes Avenue 2637 Luuemaga Street 4047 Thomas St 4047 Thomas St 1902 Mackinnon Avenue
1736 cereus court
2630 Pinneos Way #2
1749 Forest Ave
1283 Stanislaus Dr
2323 Nicklaus Dr
133 Countryhaven road
5775 Morehouse Dr
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
ALE0 VIEJO
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Roswell
Carlsbad
Vista
Vista
Leucadia
San Diego encinttas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad Oceanside LEUCADIA vista
Carlsbad
en u n i t a s
Sen Diego
Reno
San Diego
Carlsbad
San Diego
solana beach Carlsbad Enunitas
Enunitas
Caflsbad
Carlsbad
Enunitas del mar Carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad San Clernente Carlsbad Oceanside Carlsbad Vista Carlsbad Santa Rosa Ternecula cardiff by the sea OCEANSIDE
vista
Carlsbad
San Diego
Oceanside
Oceanside
carlsbad
Leucadia
San Luis Obispo
Carlsbad
Encinitas
Carlsbad Huntington Beach San Diego Oceanside
Enunitas
Carlsbad Oceanside Oceanside Cardff by the Sea
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Chula Vista
1731 Enanitas
Oceanside
Enucnitas
San Diego
1555 Delight Way
4990 Del Monte Ave Apt 19
55 Fair Dnve 1395
335 Walnut Ave
1318 S Paclflc St Apt D
99 Adarns St
3577 Granite Court
3577 Granite Court
82 Modesto
1553 Martingale Ct
2031 escenico terrace
PO Box 1608
2223 running spnng place
7428 altiva place
15944 valeno st
1 Grand Ave , bldg 113 Cal Poly
6721 Whitesail St
6494 Torreyanna Cirde
240 May Court
2241 E Arnonta Ave
2500 La Golondnna St 1680 north coast highway 101 #37 268 Calle La Montana 120 Phoebe#lO 2140 Vuelta Ct
4799 Gateshead Road 904 rosemary ave
2751 Tiburon Ave
8645 Via Mallorca Unit B
6201 Jurnilla Avenue
Escondido
San Diego
Costa Mesa
Carlsbad
Oceanside
Fairhaven
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Imine
Carlsbad
carlsbad
carlsbad
encinitas
carisbad
van nuys
San Kuis Obispo
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Cardiff
La Habra
Carlsbad Encinitas Moraga Leucadia Carlsbad
Carlsbad carlsbad
Carlsbad
La Jolla
Woodland Hills
CA
CA
CA
GA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
NV
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
MA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
92656
92009
92008 858-722-5473
30075
92009
92083 760-643-9318
92083 760-643-9318
92024 CA
92122 92024
92009 753-1532
92009
92009 760-672-5122 92008 619.733 6789 92056 92024 760-753-1625 92084 7606305872
92009
92024 92109
89506
92109
92009
92107
92075 858-259-1332
92024
92024 760-415-1443
92009 7604364255
92009 760-476-9049
92024 92014 92008 92009 92009 92673 949-240-9283 92009 92054 92009
92083 760-727-4555 92009 944-0529
92592 92007 92056
92083
92010 760-730-9514
92109
92056
92056
92008
92024 93401 (760) 419-5030 92009 760-672-8301
92024
9201 0 92649
92054
92024 858.583.1297
92009
92056 92056 92007
92009 760-445-7725
92009 760-4365220
92008
91913 619-482-4755
92024 780-942-7068
92056 760-929-2319
92024
92121 (619) 206-5052
92026
92107
92626
92008
92054
92008
92008
92602 949-2667523
92009
92009 760 634 0534
92008
92024
92009
91406
93410
92009
92009 (760) 431-8752
92007
90631 (562) 279-6871
92009 (760)929-8106 92023 94556 310-422-7186 92024 92009
92008 92009
92008
92037
91367
92008 8sazos-0492
95403 (707) 3189774
9~109 8sa-48ao89o
2719 (508) 994-0004
lsb12222@yahoo corn
roCKYnrolll3@aol corn
ftfeld@adelphia net parnfife@rnsn corn
gfilteauaadelphia net
tiffanylrayer@hotrnail corn
chnsfindellghotrnail corn
judijae@rnsn corn aRshe86@hotrnail corn rnatthewfishQcox net JanetfIsheQcoldwellbanker corn wisherl50@adelphia net kshanoarnsn corn fisks@rnsn corn Iindafitz@cox net diingg@aol corn fastoys@webtv net
MFLnNZgMSN COM
honeybell8@aol corn ennfleischernyahoo corn stoked4waves@grnail corn
sfleryasan rr corn
sharkbait32arnsn corn
entropy6S@hotrnail corn
kfloodl999@yahoo corn floodsurf@hotrnail corn gofloyd4@hotrnail corn pierce@surfdog corn jerernyggg666@grnail corn hfog@grnail corn owen-l08@yahoo corn jeanfolkerth@adelphia net bfoltz@sbcglobal net
fongcbaexute corn
jnotO3@yahoo corn fourfootes@rnsn corn Foooters@aol corn
stevief@certiRedlolder corn cfordgnsasearch corn
kitford@cax net
IurnaranQaol corn
drford04@yahoo corn
rnadracben@yahoo corn
sfordharn33@hotrnail corn
C4rest@cox net
bill4rest@hotmail corn
Forrestarl@hotrnail corn
rnfostakowsky@yahoo corn
alexisfoste@cox net
rnarkfosteracox net sharpfox Qaol corn bobandjanetfox@cox net anfox@calpoly edu brnfoxx@hotrnail corn efox@ternplesolel net callrneishrnael-I l@yahw corn LFOX@patlawyers corn jeffasurfndersd org
surfroders@cox net
trfrankacox net
cfranklin@wellacorp corn
lfraser@cox net
jfraser@cox net
tnfraser@pacbell net
rnfrazieQdslexlrerne corn
Paul-Fredenksen@hotrnail corn
bobby-stocks@yahoo corn
bfbassnsurfl@cox net
Amyfreernanl@cox net
osidemder@hotrnail corn
rnfrto@adelphia net
tedf@qualcornrn corn
arden66Qcox net
cecil fnthQsbcglobal net
Dnfnthavanguard edu
greenroornsd@hotrnail corn
alice fntzinger@cox net
J-Fmh@hotmail corn
lenandbn@sbcglobal net
lenandbn@sbcglobal net
sarah9874@yahoo corn
ernailsamfuQyahoo corn
captianpjZOOO@yahoo wrn
lraven@cox net
funsufinhb@yahoo corn
alicatys@hotrnail corn
cfdesigns@yahoo corn
dgaff79ayahoo corn
p53iscool@yahoo corn Lennie-Gale@na dole corn drewgale8@hotmail corn
onejollyc=at@yahoo corn
chnsbangalleisky@yahoo corn bobbygkfi@hotrnail corn dannygalliganiQyahoo corn lenga47@hotrnail corn fgallouiQadelphia net
tegallupQyahoo corn
icganeles@adelphia net
ganguli9082aaol corn
sganpule@yahoo corn avgarcia@grnail corn
0
0
1
0
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1 1
1 0 0
0
1
1
1
1 1 1
1
0 1 1 1 I
1
1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
1
1 0
1
0
0 1 0 0 1
0 1
1
1
1
1
0 1 1
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1 1 1 1 0 0 0
1 0
0
0
0
1 0
0
1 0 1 0 1
0
0 1
1
1 0
1
0 1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0 0 1 0 1 0 0
0
0 1
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
1 0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0 1 0
0 1
0 0
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
Page 9
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Gama
garcia
Gama
Gama
Gama
garua
Gardenhire
Gardiner
Gardner
Gardner
Gardner
Gardner
garett
garmo
Garner
Garnson
Gaskin
Gates
gatil
gatti
Gaudioso gavin
gay Gayner
Geary
Geary
Gelbert
Gelvezon
Genet
Gengo
George
George
Geraghty gerber Gerschler gestnng Gestnng Giacobaui Giancola Giancola Gibbs Gibson
Gielow
Gifford
Giger Gilbert
Gilbert
Gilbert
gill
gillet
Gillett
glllottl Gilrnore Giracello Giuliano
Gjata Glernbotski glover Godbout Goddard
Godfrey Godinez Gold goldstein Goldstein Gollong
Golrnan Gornez Gornez gonsoulin
Gonzalez Gonzalez
Gonzalez
Gonzalez Gonzalez
Good
Goodballet Goodfellow
Gwdfellow
Gwdkin
Goodnch
Gordon
Gordon
Gordon
Gordon
Gordon
Gould
Graack Graack grace gracey
Grady
Graf Graham graham Graham Graves
Gray Greaney Green
Gary
GOOdNrn
Joy Mane
arnanda
James
Adnana
Andrew
knsta
Gabnel
Mike
Stacy Enc
Jayrne
Stuart
mike
wanna
Garrett
Janice Cynthia
Genn
Joshua
anthony
Nathan rnartha
sarah
Patnck
Jeff
Shae
Brett Paul
Knstine
Julie
Amber
David Mike
Anton nchard Josh Lindsay Michael Mike Lara
Jusbn
Karl
Brooks
Greg Patnck
Gary Lisa
chns
alex
Tyler
kevin Alyson Tam Kelowna John Airnee danny Kevin Patnck
Cathy Albert Bnan jonah Linda Patnua
David Carolyn Patnua al
Martha Jamie
Philip
Rodoifo Carol
Richard
Ian
Val
Gwen
Mary Ann
Jennlfer ron
Lorraine
Geoffrey
Jimmy
Robert
Kathryn
Heather David
nck
a Tia
Oliver
Megan cathenne Todd Clarke
Jeff
Dale Stephanie
amy
108
Bany
E
e
rn
L
L
W
S
V
D
E H
I
S
M
g e
C
B
A
C
T
A
A
R
A
C
d
t
M L
C
S
P
E
F M
S A A
V
E V
C
A
B
A
G
A
rn W
t
M
e
A
6464 Daucus Ct
1019 baybeny lane
403 Westbourne St
3486 Sitio Borde
2526 La Golondnna St
2526 la golondnna
1201 Steel Ln. Box 128
362 Orange Ave IC
6957 Mimosa Dnve
PO Box 910656
702 NW 62nd St
4136 Datcho Dr
163 pearl
151 elderave
2041 Shendan Rd
6570 Windflower Dr 1247 Hermes Ave 1461 Rancho Encinitas Dr
1762 Sunny Crest Lane
29315 abelia rd
6902 carntaion dr
173 Avocado Street 7184 pintail dnve
573 hygefa apt a
7965 mseland dnve
2350 Montgomery Ave
2350 Montgomery Ave
510 Harland Ave 405 Bay Meadws Way
29960 Pechanga Dr
POBox217
1691 Peppertree Place 4545 Larnbeth Ct 1191 Manposa Road 1165 aloha dnve 914-A North Coast Highway 101 6729 hyaunth urcle
6866 Watercourse Dnve 6655 Carninito Pnrnavera 3959 Hamilton St #24 3959 Hamilton St 2704 Jacaranda Ave
3443 Calle Canwna
2716 Elva Dnve
1420 Neptune Ave
961 N VulcanAve
2325 Pi0 Pico Dr
2325 Pi0 Pic0 Dr
2325 Pi0 Pico Dr
1513 sapphire
4212 conrad ave
1658 Foss Road
6608 urubu street 2606 EL Aguila Lane 1615 Aston Ave Ste 101 467 La Mesa Ave 943 Hermes Avenue 5917 Bounty Street pa box 1200 12602 Cannel Country Road 119 4629 Altadena Ave
7407 Carlina Stl 17040 Daphne Ave 629 Diamond St 263 La Veta 293 Hillcrest Dr
1595 Eolus Ave
404 Andrew Avenue 7021 Leeward St P 0 Box 235300
pobox91306
7309 Lantana Terrace
264 Barbara Avenue
1356 HermesAve
5325 Los Robles Dr 5325 Los Robles Dr
613 Bluewater Rd
219 Chapalita Dr 1849 Avenida Mimosa
1849 Avenida Mimosa
2126 Montgomery Avenue
13625 Mira Montana Dr
6631 Carnation Or
7419 Neptune Dnve
7419 Neptune Dnve
2519 Oxford Ave
720 Orange Grove Ave #15
PO BOX 1055
1600 Shendan Rd
960-D Melaleuca Ave 960-D Melaleuca Ave
640 w solana urcle
21 24 coolngreen way
5235 Madison rd
999 N Paufic st
1594 Bee Canyon Rd 9666 carninito del feliz 312 Laurent St 3052 Rue D Orleans bl15 201 S Lewis Street Apt210
3619 Kmgston
4213 Sierra Morena Avenue
San Diego
collegeville
La Jolla
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
carlsbad
Laytonville
Comnado
Carlsbad
San Diego
Lawton
San Diego
laguna niguel
irnpenal beach
Leucadia
Carlsbad Encinltas Encinitas
Bonita
canyon country
carlsbad
Encinitas carlsbad encinitas
la jolla
Cardiff
Cardiff
Melbourne Beach Solana Beach Temecula
Cardiff
Fallbrook Carl s b a d Carlsbad encinitas Encinitas carlsbad Carlsbad La Jolla San Diego San Diego Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Kokorno
Leucadia
Leucadia
Cartsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
carlsbad
san diego
Alpine
carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Enunitas Enunitas San Diego haliewa San Diego San Diego
Carlsbad Torrance San Diego Encinitas Leucadia Enunitas
Leucadia Carlsbad Encinltas san diego
Carlsbad Solana Beach
Encinitas
Carlsbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Encinitas Encinitas
Encinitas
Encinitas
Del Mar
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Cardff
GI end a I e
Cardff
Leucadia
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
soalan
encinitas
Delray Beach
Oceanside
Arroyo Grande san diego Santa Cruz San Diego Orange
Carlsbed
Carlsbad
CA PA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
OK
CA
Ca
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
FL
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA IN
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA
CA hi CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
FI
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
92129 19426 464 686 1555
92037
92009
92009 92009 95454 707-984-6862
92116
92009 7604365065
73505 580-536-7015
92117 8582706933 92677 91932
92024
92009 92024 760-753-1699 92024 658.504.8443 91902 91351
92009
92024 760-669-3840 92009 438-1918 92024
92037 658-459-6842
92007
92007
32951 92075 92592 92007 92026 760-522-5254 92006 92009 92024 760-230-2030 92024 760-633-4060 92009 760-9087792 92009 760 497-791 5 92037
92104
92104
92009
92009
46902 7654555901
92024
92024 760-943-0945
92006
92W6
92006 92009 6041320
92117
91901
92009 92009 760 431-0760 92008 760-431-1211 92024 92024 92120 96712 606 375-3276
92130 92115 619.224.7610
92009 90504 310-515-8625 92109 92024 92024 760-809-0766 92024
92024 760-942-6862
92009 760-603-7915
92169 6197230094
92009 92075 619-861-3674
92024
92006 (760) 213-2624
92009 760-438-1 544
92024 7606328205
92024
92024 760-942-0563
92007 76063412
92014 856=259-1966
9201 1
92009 760-4387952
92009 760-4387952
92007 760-632-1 337
91205 6167958635
92007
92024
92011 7609299520 9201 1 7609299520
92075
92024 33484 561-797-1037
92054
93420 92121 95060 921 10 92866
92010
92006 760-730-1914
92191 85a229-1375
92023-5300
92008 (760) 43a5035
joygarcia60gyahoo corn
bluwave96gaol corn
jarnesggsandyflojos corn
garcial57@yahoo corn
andw-garciagyahoo corn akrngasbcglobal net blue-guardian7@?yahoo corn
rngsurfl 1 gaol corn
S-Gardnergrnsn corn
egardneraqualcornrn corn
jsggsunnet net
sqgphotogearthlink net nalubufgearthlink net wgarmo@sbcglobal net
calisurfer92002@yahoo corn
garnsonjangadelphia net ungarygyahoo corn ggaskin@ucsd edu jhgate@sbcglobal net sweetangel6@@socal rr corn
tgam@yahoo corn
nategaudiosogcox net vtnegart@aol corn segsrnudgeghotrnail corn pataunx corn
geary608gcox net geary606@cox net brettgcroornconstruction corn poppychulo@grnail corn kgenetgadelphia net yogablugcox net artisticbNin@yahoo corn dgeorgehrghotrnail corn rngeraghtygadelphia net gerbegoeQcox net srfnlawgaol corn rlgestnnggadelhia net gride26@yahoo corn Iindssggyahoo corn
Michael Giancola@sdcounty ca gov
rngiancol@ucsd edu
lollyashfield@adelphia net
tgrnsocalggrnail corn
karlgielw@aol corn
brooks3sdgyahoo corn
ggigergcox net
patnck0615@sbcglobal net
finewoodworkgsbcglobal net
finewoodworkgsbcglobal net cgillgscea corn gilletgsbcglobal net
tylergillettghotrnail com
icecuberulesghotrnail corn alysongaadelphia net tarag314ghotrnail corn kelownagiuliano@yahw corn gataaaol corn buffybabe088O@yahoocorn
kegodbout@@hotrnail corn
pgoddardgnethere corn
arnanjengadelphia net
shaka brahasbcglobal net
brngoldl2@hotrnail corn
jonah-goldsteinghotmail corn
Igoldsteingcox net
paai@gollong corn
dgolrnanlgcox net
cagornez@shellopus corn
Itwahine@sbcglobal net
algonsoulingcox net
Martharnadrnartha@aol corn
Iarniegsurfndersd org
pgonzgcox net
Rdelssolanabeach@sbcglobal net
Rdelssolanabeach@sbcglobal net
iraagrocketrnail corn
goodballe@yahoo corn
ia3ngstanford edu
vgocdfellowsk@hotrnaiI corn
gwencgQexcite corn
rnaresgoodgsbcglobal net
jennggnofear corn
rlgordie@adelphia Net
rlgordie@adelphia net
geoffrey4peace@yahoocorn
radiosityengineghotrnail corn
rpg-cbadghotrnail corn
kathsewsasbcglobal net
hrngraackayahoo corn dgraackayahoo corn nchard graceaubs corn agracey Tprnane73gaol corn
olivermgrafgyahoo corn
wahinehangl Oghotrnafl corn clgraharn@ucsd edu work2surfarnyway corn cgravesgclarkedesign net
hangl0jeffasocal rr corn
dgreaneygadelphia net
stephagreen@hotrnail corn
1
0
1
1
I
1
0
1
1
0
0
1 1 1
1
1 1 1 1 0
1
1 1 1 1
t 1
0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1 1
0
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1 1 1 1 0
1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1 0
0 0
0
1
0 1 0
0
0
0
0 0 0 0
0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1 1 1
0
0
1 1 1
0
0 0 0
0
0
1
0 0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
1 1
0
0
0
1 1
0
0
0
0 1
0
0 0
0
1
1
Page 10
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Greenfield
Greenville
Greer
Gregory
gregory Gregory
Gregory
Greig GRENSTED Gnffiths
Gnffiths
Gngoras
Gnrnaud gnswold
grotey
Grover Guadinez
gualotunia
Gude Guerre guest Guevara Guild Guild gunn Gunner Guralnick
Gunn Guzrnarn Gmlltarn Gmlltarn Gysel Haas Haase Hackworth Hadfield Haeger Hagernan hagen
hagen
Hagen-Holt
Hagen-Holt
Haggar
HAHNLEIN
Halboth
HALEEIAN
Haifacre
Hall
Hall
hall Hall Hall
hall
Hall
Hallinan
Rebecca
Anton Geraldine Bryce
rnargaret rnargaret
Roberl Michael EVlN Aaron
Jennifer
Kevin
Jon Charles zack Tony Natalie
donan Natalie Jake rnatthew Tiffany Carolyn J Whitney Sean Bryan Aka
Hugh David Jarnas Stephanie Dan Susan
Amy Howard Thomas Mark Chnsiopher fredenck
robin
Paul
Jamie
Mary SABRINA
Siacey
shaunt
Jaime
David
Jeff
Nicholas Jacqueline James
chrisbne
Pam
Gregory Hally-Rosendahl Kai Halopoff HALTER Halter Halverson Harnann
Harnann
Harnblin
Hamilton
Hamilton
Hamilton
Harnlin
Harnrnack
harnrnond
Hamrnond
Harnpton
Harnsiter
Hancock
Hancock
Hancock 3
Handler
Handley
Handy
haney
Hanke
Hankins
Hanlon hanna Hannon Hansch Hansen Hansen Hansley Hanson
Hanson
Hanson
Hanson Hapgood
Hararnis
Harcank
Harding
Hardwick
hare
Hargraves
Harker Harmeling Harmeltng
Linda Brock Stephanie Debbie
Margaret
Peter
Nathan
Natalie
hY Nancy
Jack
Robin
jardine
Heather
Cory Kevin
Jim
Rick
James
Judd
Mark
Daphne
mike
Erendan
AIec
Greg paul Knstin Thornas James Julie Laune Pilialoha
Marlene
Brad
Gordon Janie Alison
Todd
Brooke
Tyler
chris
Wallace
Heidi Henry courtney
L 945 3rd St Apt B
j 2380 Fire Mountain Dr R 7722 Lucia Court
I I
L 1926 Altura Dnve J 1570 Martingale Ci
W 5220 Wendela St
A 5220 Wendela St
2010 Shadow Grove Way
9250 Towne Center Dr #8
9250 Towne Center Dr #8
91 9 MELALEUCA AVE #D
L 2802 Carlsbad Blvd
2312 Broadway 3952 Jefferson St 3143 lincoln st #E 7591 Calorna Circle 843 Dawson Ave #3 0 1013 hygeia ave 2361 Vancouver Ave 2347 Mermn Dr 5130 La Jolla Elvd A 1263 Tylee Street M 819ArdenDr
r 899 woodley place C 3315 James Dnve 632 Sunnch Lane 2222 Ulloa Slreet
2046 Red Coach Lane 1012 Regal Ridge Rd 4726 Enghton 12283 CarmelVisia Rd #218 K 1448 Calle Goya 2705 Tonto Way W 4573 Sanla Monica Ave 4320 Point View Ci 28461 Shnke 704 summersong lane
704 summersong lane
1744A Broadway
1744A Broadway
K 6912 Quiet cove Dnve
R 3636 MERRIMAC AVE
1239 Carniniio Septtrno
h 14256 WYETH AVENUE
R 8M)O Via Mallorca
2 Fuchsia PI
M 7226 Columbine Dnve
g 642 n trmontst 2018 MacKinnon Ave M 7955 Carnino Alvaro
a 6404rubyway
A 7101 Whitewaterst
M 4601 Neblina Dnve
1871 5 Paseo Cortez 1871 5 Paseo Cortez 10288 Eayhead Beach Ave C 35816N WthLane 3458 Carnino Alegre M 14169 Half Moon Bay Dr
1354 Hermes Ave
2017 Sandusky Rd
2837 Ivy St
L 3035 Quince St
L 7108 Columbine Dnve
E 2651 Harcwrt Dnve
4446 Montalvo St
2535 man cove dr
A 1542 Fireside Lane
1347 Hygeta Ave
R 274 Hygeia CT
123 Jasper St 28
5202 Alarnosa Park Dr
330 W I St #7
120 N Paufic Street
A 1520 Lower Lake Ci
n 809 kmgsirm ci
W 32938 Galleano Ave
819 Arden Dnve
A 127 Range St B
R 6607 Daylily Dr
3873 Ingraharn. D-106
2008 Countmod Ct
13332 carninito carmel dr api202 14648 Via Eergarno
PO Box 965 1138 Newcasile court 515 Bnarwood Dr 1769 Village Run North 817 S Vulcan 612 Navigator Court 1477 Neptune Ave IC67 Cem Verde Dnve 1465 Eolus 1333 Hermes Ave 32369 Cercle Beauregard
4835 Saratoga Ave t7
6267 Via Trato
5520 highway It
7948 Calle Madnd
1277 Orchard Glen Circle
7976 Arnargosa Dr
7976 arnargosa dr
Enunitas Oceanside Carlsbad Enunitas San Dtego San Dtego
Corona del Mar Carlsbad CARLSBAD Oceanside
Oceanside
Carlsbad
San Diego carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego
encinttas San Diego Carlsbad San Dtego Vista Enunitas Enunitas encinitas Carlsbad Enunitas
San Franusco Leucadia Enunitas Enunitas San Diego San Diego Oceanside San Diego San Diego La Mesa Laguna Ntguel enunitas
enunitas
Oceanside
Oceanside
Carlsbad
SAN DIEGO
Cardiff
IRVINE
La Jolla
Aliso Viejo
Carlsbad
oceanside Cardiff Carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
lrvine lrvine Surnrnerlin Phoenix Carlsbad Del Mar
Leucadia
Oak Harbor
San Diego
San Diego
La Costa
San Diego
San Diego
Cardiff
Vlsta
Encinitas
Encinitas
Leucadia
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Enunitas
San Marcos
Cardff
san diego
San Dtego
Winchester
Enunitas
del mar
San Diego
Rancho Santa Fe
oceanside
Ukiah Enunitas Encinitas Carlsbad Enunitas Solana Beach Encinitas Encinitas Ternewla
San Diego
Carlsbad
pelharn
Carlsbad
Enunitas
Carlsbad
carlsbad
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA Ca CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA Az CA CA CA WA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA AL
CA
CA
CA
CA
92024 92054 760-433-3689 92009 92024 92 121 858-735-72 19 92121 858-526-4958 92625 92009 92009
92056 760-414-9008
92056 760-414-9008 92008 92 102 92008 92008 92009 921 15 92024 92104 619-283-2911 92008
92083 760-525-1743 92024 760-753-4941 92024 92024 92008 92024
941 16 California
92024 760.436.3059
92024 760-809-2761
92024
92107 760.390.9764 921 30 858-337-2251
92056
92117 85E270-4475
92107
91941 "194706234
92677 92024
92024
92054
92054
92009
92117 85E483-9419
92007
92606
92037
92656
92009 760-929-9556
92054 92007 92009 92009 760-613-9821 92009
92006 7607206151
92603 92603 89135 85086 823i374-4184 92009 7609431965
92014 8587559765
92024
98277
92104
92104 760-931-8081
92009
92123
92107 619-224-0787
920007
92084
92024
92024 760522-0476
92024
92057 760 630-0310
92009
92024
92069
92007
92109
92109 (760) €03-9105
925% -3868
92024 760-753-7833
92014 92127 92067 856-735-8440 92056 760-802-5114 95482 707-367-5308 92024 92024 819-985-6831 92009 92024 92075 92024 (760) 944-5242 92024 760-436-9742 92591
92107
92009
35124
92009
92024
92009
92009
CA
rebecca-greenReld@hoirnail corn rngreenvilledesigns@wx net ziadeannie@earlhlink net bryce gregoryagrnail corn rnargaret gregory@pfizer corn rnargaret gregory@pfizer corn rgregory@ileads corn athun@sbcglobal net EVINGRENSTEDQMAC COM Aarong63@cox net
aarong63@cox net danungboo222@yahw corn jgreerno@hotrnail corn charlesgrtswold@rnac corn zackfarms2@hotrnatl corn tgrover@sbcglobal net natlyg@holmatl corn dgualotunia@yahoo corn natcarngude@aol corn jakesk8erlOl@yahoo corn rnatthewguest@holmail corn
1guevaraQnctirnes corn igoisnow@yahoo corn whitguild@hotrnail corn
Sean gunn@cox net wnner@sdcoe k12 ca us aguralnick@yahw corn
hughgunn@hotrnail corn
superguz2001@yahoo corn
jarnasg@grnail corn
sgwllliam@adelphia net
dangyselgyahoo corn haaSNnl@aOl corn
arnyhaase@hotrnail corn
hhh@san rr corn
torn@hadfield corn
rnarkhaeger@holmail corn
chnsrhagernan@yahw corn
fredtsrn@yahoo corn
fredisrn@yahoo corn
hagenholt@hotrnail corn
jhagenholl@hotrnail corn
kabecarlsbad@adelphia net
S23R59EgAOL COM
shalboth@hotmail corn
SHAUNT-HALEBIANgyAHOO COM orcawhale24@yahoo corn
dapegaearthlink net
jhallggenopbx corn
nikosurfl@cox net jahall@ucsd edu rnhall@adagency corn chnstine29l@yahoo corn patli hall@adelphia net grnhallie@hotrnail corn krpitled@cox net lehalopo@cox net broxwotx@cox net
tearnhalter@cox net
debhalverson@adelphia net
peggyharnann@yahw corn
harnannfish2@nelzero corn
twoharnbltns@corncast nwt
taliharnilton@hotmail corn
amy harninon@wesionsolubons corn
dnnharnrny@rnsn corn
]bharnlinesq@sbcglobaI net
robin-harnrnack@yahoo corn
ernailjardine@yahoo corn
haha92084@yahoo corn
coryharnpio@yahoo corn
kevinhameister@rnsn corn
j hancock rnamrnac corn
nckhancock@cox net
jirnihancock@yahw corn
juddhandler@yahoo corn
nccrnarkegaol corn
daphne-ann-handyayahoo corn
rnichael haney@sumardware corn
brendangliberlyleadsource corn
Ahankins@carnpus hpu edu gregory-hanlon@hotrnail corn panyboy917@yahoo corn knsttnhannon@yahoo corn thansch@pacbell net Jhansen@lusardi corn rkhansen@sbcglobal net Launejill@aol corn hansonpi@saic corn
rnarlenehl@adelphta net
gohanson@ucsd edu janiehap@aOl corn alisonsurf@cox net
harcank@adelphia net
brookeh@resrned m
tyler-hardwick@yahoo corn
showupblowup00
drearnrnachtne@cox net
hlharker@yahoo corn
hharmeling@shWetlaw corn
charmelingQyahoo corn
]bhlOO@cox net
1
1
1
1 1 1
1 1 1 1
1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1
1
0 1
0 1 1 1
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
t
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 0 1 1 1 1 t t
1
1
1 1 1
1
1 1
0
1
1
1 1
0
0
1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0
0 0 0 1
1 1
0
0 0 0 1
0 0 0 0 1 0
0 1
0
0
0 1
0
1 0
0
0 0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
1 0 0 1 1 0 1
0 0 0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0 0 0
1
0
0
0 0 0
0
0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1
0 0 0 0
0
0 1
0
1
0 1
1
Page 11
Harmon Harmpn . Harmon
Harmon Harrill hams
harnson
Harnson
Hart
hart
Hart
Hart
Hart-Pack
harth
Hartley
Harvey
Harvey
harvey
Hassebrock
Hasselbach
Hassett
Hastings
Hasty
Hatch
Hatch
hatcher
Hauptrnan
Havens 111
Hawk
Hawke
Hawkins
Hawley
Haworth
Hawtrey
Hayden
Hayden
HAYES
Hayn
Haynes
Hays
Healey Hearn Heaston Heatherly heatherly Heatherly heaton Heaton Heberer
Heck
Hedden
Hedgewck
Hedgewck
Heffner Heflin heit Heller
hellrnan Hellrnan hellrnan Hendershot Henderson Henderson Hendnck Hendncks Hen d n ck s Henken Henry Herbert Henc
Herrnes
Hermes Hermes
Hermosillo
Hernandez
Hernandez
hem an de z
Hernandez
Herr Hanks henera
Hernck
Hernck Hetnck Heuchan
Heydorff
Heyen
Heyen
Heynacher
Hibbard
Hickrnan
hicks Hidalgo HIGDON Higgins Hight Hilbern Hilbern Hill Hill Hill
Hillrnan
Hindges
Chns Douglas Robert Linda Jonathan Stephanie
Scott
bY Heather
kelly
Jennifer
Robert
Kristina
rnichael
Dallas
Margaret
Lynnette
sasha
Lindsay
Grant
Matthew
Nancy
Sarah Joshua
Deborah
katy
Jeff
Fred
Joe Kevin
Daren
Nathan
John
Jill
Enn
Daniel
Pegi
Tawnya
Stuart
Brad
Chns Brandon Ellice Mike Julie Rebecca casey Selina Manna
Deborah
Mark
JArnes
Anne
Knstine
Douglas justin Missy
kirnberly
Joel chns Beth Chanel Cachet Chadevan Diane Leif Man Shane Chnstopher Vanessa Ashley
William Elaine Aaron
Daniel
Jessica
rnargaret
Jessica Joanna rachel
Jeanne
Kate Jordan heidi Tim
Jonathan
Andrea
Chns
Tlflnnie
Brendan
nathan
Eugene
ALLEN Matthew
Peter
Mary Mary Laura Bobbi Justin Knstina
Robert
B D D
J P
e
E
B
Y
G
P
M
E D
A
rn
Z
B
D
A
C
E
S
D
A
L
C
K
W
W
M
A
2663 State Street #D 701 8 Lavender Way 701 8 Lavender Way
7018 Lavender Way 481 Bay Meadows Way 115092 fury In
3229 Juniper st
1341 Greenlake Drive
1340 42nd Avenue
3505 Driftwood place
3228 Madison Avenue
921 Marguerite Lane
2021 Village Wood Rd
1033 st albans drive
1726 Aldersgate
7213 San Lucas Street
1655 Eolus Avenue
12244 arucauna way
2215 California Street
295 Chestnut Ave. #1
4972 tyler st
3783 Redwwd Avenue
914 Marguerite Lane
946 B Laguna Dr.
946 B Laguna Dr.
3910 sierra rnorena av
1325 Urania Ave
6828 Sheamaters Dnve
3870 Woodvale Dr.
2323 Summerhill Dr
924 Ashton Court
1316 craigrnont st
1833 Linbmok Dr.
307 16th St., #3
275 Hillcrest Drive #lo5
275 Hillcrest Dr.
202 HOOVER ST
23160 Napa Drive
23819 Highlander Rd
3211 70 Panamount Dr. NW
2124 Pintoresw Ct. 1502 San Jose Street 14906 SW Rosario 1240 Carninito Septirno via de la valle #c 1240 Carninito Septirno
58-348a Karn. ~wy. P.0 Box 173 2119 Wedgewood Dr.
915 Poppy Lane
1775 Valley Place
2464 Jefferson St
2464 Jefferson St
2030 Mar Azul Way 753 Plurnosa Ave 432 Sylvia st 6744 Tea Tree Street
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Solana Beach el calon
san diego
Cardiff
San Franusw
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Encinitas
encinrtas
Leudadia
Carlsbad
Encinitas
san diego
Oceanside
Carlsbad
oceanside
Los Angeles Carlsbad Carlsbad
C a rl s b a d carlsbad
Enunitas
Carlsbad Carlsbad
Enunitas
Vista
el cajon
san diego
Hunbngton Beach
Enunitas
Enunitas
OCEANSIDE
Valencia
West Hills
Calgary
Carlsbad Oceanside Tigard Cardiff solana beach Cardiff Haleiwa Laie Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Vista
encinitas
Carlsbad
3863 Garfield St. Carlsbad
M 1320 N Sierra Bonita Ave Apt 210 West Hollywood 1695 crest drive 12535 El Carnino Real J 2355 Cornstock Street 228 Fowles St 1347 Summit Ave 7204 Mimosa Dr 7204 Mimosa Dr 4923 Lorna 1278 Lac Flores Dr G 3304 Calle San Blas 1636 Avery Rd E 1051 W El Norte Parkway G 32201 Corte Sabnnas 32201 Corte Sabnnas P 25255 Jesrnond Dane Rd
1237 N Vulcan Ave
A POBOX5242
128 crouch st
L 2375 Louise Ct M 229 Rosebay Dnve 3415 boundary st
S 2590 Davis Ave
2590 Davis Ave 201 B North Vulcan Ave
e 1457 North Vulcan Ave #6
E 1265 Neptune Ave
3507 Calle Hidalgo
S 3507 Calle Hidalgo
4712 Dalea Place
R 6888 Fnars Road #225
P 7126 Leeward St
6499 alexandn circle
8W Leucadia Blvd
W 5755LODlST
2922 Zircon PI
1471 N VulcanAve ApW3
L 4135 Utah St #8 L 4135 Utah St #8 M
C 8775 Fisk Avenue V 3241 Celinda Dr
4020 Gresham St
2325 Paseo de Laura #210 3286 Avenida de Sueno
enunrtas San Diego San Diego Oceanside Card#f Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad San Marws Escondido Ternecula Ternecula Escondido
Enunitas
Oceanside
owanside El Cajon Enunitas san diego
Carlsbad Carlsbad Encinitas Encinitas Leucadia Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Oceanside San Diego Carlsbad
carlsbad
Encintas
SAN DIEGO
Carlsbad
Leucadia
San Diego
San Diego Oceanside Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad San Diego
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA OR CA CA CA HI HI CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
ca
92008 (760) 720-1514
92009
92009
92009
92075 858-254-5244
92019
92104 619-255-6262
92007 760-634-3622
94122
92056 760-5057021
92006
92011 760 931 9621
92024
92024
92024 760 942 8060
92009
92024 760-942-7233
92 129
92054
92008 801-921-3096
92057 7608017372
90066 310-572-4656
92009 760-602-0130
92008
92008
92008 760-505-2353
92024
92009 760-931-7929
92008 760-519-6228
92024
92081 760-597-1124
92019
921 11
92024 7604351336
92024 760 635 1336 92054 760 518 3086
91354
91307
92009 92054 97224 92007 760-632-3676 92075 92007
96762 (760)494-1106 92056 7608055982
92009 760 431 2661
92008 (760) 720-7805
92008 760-4734360
92008
92009 92081 599-9942 92024 6134348 92009 76C-804-1913
92008 90046 92024 92130 92111 858-715-0260 92054 92007 7604736008 92009 92009 92008 92008 92009 92078 92026 92592 92592 92026
92024
92056
92054
92020 92024 7606329396 921 04
92008 760-729-6782
92008 92024 92024 92024 7609446299 92009
92009 760-471-9356
92057 760-439-4341
92108
92009 760-603-0788
92009 760-214-7557
92024
92117 6192247671
92009 CA
92024
92104 619-584-0517
92104 92056 92009 92122 92008 (760) 72C-0934
92109
92648 714 658-5455
T3AOR7 1(403)277-4999
96712 80a285-1547
c harmon@!sbcgbbal net beachyharmonsasbcglobal net
beachyharmons@sbcglobal net
beachyharmonsasbcglobal net
jphamllayahw com irnyurnrny420@hotrnail corn
xpoulhyanetscape net
arnyharnsonaadelphia net
pawsoutsfacorncast net
ryansangell.l@hotmail corn
~enniqua77@sbcglobal net
Harls2244aAOL
pack202l@aol corn
elisabet-harthayahoo corn
dallashartleylO@hotrnail corn
rnparnhayahoo corn
lynnetteharvey@cox net
sasharvey2001@hotrnail corn
Iindsayhassebrock@hotrnail wrn
aquagranmgrnail corn
rnhassettacox net
nancy@hastingspmductions corn
shastyabioeng ucsd edu
]hatched@nehem net
bigrnarnadebl 993ayahoo wrn
Iilrnarysunshyne@aol corn
chefieWcatenng@yahoo corn
fredhacallawaygolf corn
joehahambikes corn
kevin@kevinhawke corn
hawkinsdar~en77@yahoo corn
nhawleyaarner-tech corn
jbhaworthahotrnail corn
jhawlreyasurfside net
dehaydenacoxnet dehaydenawx net pegyver3ahotrnail corn
tawnl43@hotrnail corn
Stuart haynesarecycler corn
bradawrnhproductions corn chns@forceonenetworks wrn osdancsurfer@hotrnail wrn erheastonastoel corn fa b-mike-d@ya hoo corn jujux3@yahoo corn sun-rai@hotmail corn
hangtenahotrnail corn
selinaaegofree corn
MCHebereQcox net
heck-debbie@hotrnail wrn
heddencaaaol wrn
jhedgecockadlspas win
a_ej5000@yahoo corn
jkheffneraaol corn dougheflin@adelphia net justinheitacox net IoudlaffQsbcglobal net
sunrayssaturdays@yahoo corn ]oelhellrnan@yahoo corn chns hellrnanQrcn corn ehendshtasan rr corn rneachanellfe corn cachethendersonahotrnail corn chadevan@sbcglobal net Hendnckswadelphia net Masurfaceoptics corn
drurnsurl@yahoo wrn jiveassrnofo@spinfinder corn CGherbaaol corn vanessah@callawaygolf wrn
ashleyelizabethhermes@yahw corn
ashleyelizabethhermes@yahoo com
ehermesaadelphia net dancingboo222@yahoo corn
dntdarleneanetscape net
surfngrll8ayahoo corn
rneg 1281@wx net
Dynarnojessayahoo wrn herrfotoacox net girlinanooseayahoo corn
pologrlhernck@yahoo corn lordanhetnckahotrnail corn
heidi@art!llerysales corn
tirnheydorf@sbcglobaI net heyen99xayahoo corn
andrea_h_60614@yahoo corn
cheynacheranethere corn
tlflnnie05@hotrnail corn
brendan hickrnanancr corn
pughicksayahoo corn
Hida7777@Hotmail corn
aldosufiasan rr corn
rn_r_higgins2l~hotrnaiI corn
peteraprana corn
rnhil4848@postoff1ca un edu rnhi14848@?postofke un edu ankh92024arnsn corn bobbi hill@sbcglobal net Holywack@san rr corn khillrnan@fpcoceanside org
roberthindgesayahooo corn
lbks2590@sbcglobal net
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
0 0
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0
1 0
t 0
0 0
t 1 1 1
0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
0 0 0 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0
1 1 1 1
1 t
0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1 1 0
t 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
0 0
t 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1
0 0
Page 12
Hines
hines hinrichs '
Hinrichs
hinshaw hinton HixsonHertica
Hmielewski
Hoagland
Hodson Hoeksema Hoffman Hofmann Hogan Hogan hogan Holladay Hollenbeck Holleran Holmes
Holmes Holmes HOLMGREN Holt
Holt Holt homuth Hong honsberger Hood
Hood
Hopkins
Hopwood
Horan Jr.
Horen
Homung
Horosky
Hoskin
Hough
Houghton Houlihan Houlihan House Houser Howard Howell Howell HUCKINS hudak Hudgins Huff Hughen Hughes Hughes
Hughes
H u i s m a n
Hulin
Hull
Hultman
Humpal Humphrey Humphrey Hunt Hunt
Hunter
Hurley Hurt Hurt Huston Huth Hyle lles llic lmai lnskeep 111 lnstone lntfen Irwin Irwin Irwin
Irwin Isen lshidera
lSkW
lssel
luculano
JABLOW
Jachimowiu
Jackson
Jackson
Jacobsen
Jacquet
Jahns
James
James
jamison Janc Janc Janc
Janc
Janiak
Janik
Anne darlynn
Jasmine chns Me1
Sherry1 Nicole Virginia Jeffrey Marc Edward Brody Summer
Knsten Shawn
Tom
Steven
Janine DonandJeane
frednck
David
Sharon
timothy Joon lune Margaret
Nancy
David
Randal
William
Debra Gena James
Rose
Grayson Bnan Michael Wendy Kelly Brenda Clint Janet Rebecca MARK Josephine Brenda Dennis Dain
Knstine
Jason
Lindsay
Enc
Chnstopher
Jamie
Megan Roberta Evan Timothy Daniel
Keith Tim
Gavin Renee Kent Lauren Brett Alexander Yuki Daniel Rebecca Tim Roger Mark Jeff Helen Alicia Kazutaka Laura Zenon Jason
HARRIS
Richard
Gretchen
Jeffrey
nathan
Danielle
Gary Donald
Richard a Mary
charles AI Joel Lisa
Jessica
Michael
Judith
Terry
Larry
KAREN
Ray
Barry
R m F
R
R
L
h
H
P
e
H S
D
J s
H W
J
H R
M
M e K
R
E
H
P
L
A B
C
G A
C
M C B C
J P
K
L A
E
T
j P T R
D
161 1 Rubenstein Dr 6609 conntia street 7127 babilonia st 321 1 Sello Lane #lo2 3207 carvallo court 1545 Buckingham Dr 7903 Code Penca 547 Cornish Dr 486Rd 2AB 1224 Highbluff Ave Marc 6506 Onda Place
1602 Corsica Place
3120 Madison St
745 Nardo Road 11 36 Stratford dr
308 Hillcrest Dr
201 1 Cima Ct
331 1 James Dr
7820 Gaviota Cr
3543 Rock Ridge Rd
6943 Mimosa Dnve
3548 MlRA PACIFIC DR
4642 30th SI
7106 Santa Cruz
7106 Santa Cruz
9721 lamar st
911 112 Emerald St
471 E Glaucus st
7418 Pelican ST
1786 E POINTE AVE
946 Woodgrove Cf
2812 El Rash Lane
390 Oak Ave Apt B
7512 Brava Street 2310 Byron Place 4673 Felton St 7307 San Luis 11018W OceanAirDr Apt266 7350 Spinnaker Street 621 Brookside Ct 621 Bmokside Court 1659 Trenton Way 201 W Mac Arthur Blvd #D8 14401 Starsia SI 24514A Windsor Dnve
19950 Ehin Forest Ln 921 LAW ST 4659 112 cape may avenue 2266 Cameo Rd 11614 SpnngsideRd
362 Holmwwd Lane 2345-2 Cannga Way
605 Palaro Dnve
21 15 Meadowlark Rnch Circle
3962 James Dnve 165 Walnut Ave Apt C
36055 maddaleana
3798 Highland Dr
4134 Lymer Dnve 7351 spinnaker Street 7351 Spinnaker Street 10728242 Sabre Hill Dr 7746 Madnlena Way
269 Arch St 814 Saxony Road 340 Isthmus Way #50 7926 Calle San Felipe POB 4426 4169 Monroe Avenue 305 Campus Mew Dr 140 hemlock #C 6825 Pear Tree Dnve PO Box 2049 909 Caminito Estrada Unit C 1223 Crest rd 522 Turfwood Lane
1550 del mar road 930Via Mil Cumbres #18 1565 Starlight Dr
1621 Avocado Road
1786 N Coast Hwy 101 #7 9632 Hamilton Ave 5532 Dalhart Hill NW 208 E Glaucus St
2407 Sacada Circle
7026 Columbine Dr
6430 EL Penco Lane
1499SandbarDnve
1512W UpasSt
1727 Glasgow Ave
1926 Skyknoll Way
1756 La Playa Dr
5249 Los Robles Dr
1019 oldham way 6587 Red Knot rd 7362 Portage Way 7362 Portage Way 6567 Red Knot St
11233 TIERRASANTA BLVD 64
4113 lngraham Street
Patrick W 7363 Portage Way Carlsbad
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Cardrff carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad La Jolla C a rl s b a d Encinitas Cody San Marcos Spnng Lake Carlsbad
Costa Mesa
Carlsbad
Enunitas
Enunitas
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
OCEANSIDE
san diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
spnng valley
San Diego
leucadia
Carlsbad
CARLSBAD
Cardiff
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad San Marws Santa Ana Westminster Valenua Elfin Forest San Diego san diego
Carlsbad
San Diego
Solana Beach
Carlsbad
Encinitas
San Marcos Carlsbad Carlsbad wnchester Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Laguna Beach Encinitas Oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego San Marws Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Del Mar Solana Beach
oceanside Solana Beach Cardiff
Oceanside
Enunitas Huntlngton Beacg
Calgary Enunitas Carlsbad
SAN DIEGO
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Marws
San Diego
Cardrff by the Sea
Encinitas
Lafayette
Carlsbad
leucadia carisbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad
San Diego
CA CA
CA
CA CA CA WY
CA MI CA CA CA
CA CA Ca CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA ca
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA AB CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
ca
ca
92007 92009 760-476-0004 92009 7604384849 92009 92009 92037 92009 7609423677 92024 62414 92076 49456 6168421840 92009 760-734-5603
92626
92008 CA
92024 92024 760-436-1 160
92024 760 479-0134
92009 (760) 6352962
92006 760-521-1186
92009 760.732.3379
92006
92011 760-431-3737
92056
92116 6192694669
92009 7606030706
92009 7606030706
91977 619-684-8477
92109 92024 92009 760-604-1626
92006
92007
92008 760/720-1883
92008 760-436-4425
92009 92006 760-431-0023 92116 619 723-7626
92009 92130 658-755-3497 92009 760470-0100 92009 92009 92076 92707 92663 714-373-5687 91355 92029 92109 92107 92008 92128 92075 7604646448 92009
92024
92076 760-510-1644
92006
92006
92596
92008
921 16 92009 760-476-1449 92009 760-476-1449 92128 92009
92651
92024 92054 92009 92016 92116 92076 92009 92009 91912 92009 92014 92075 7606225460 92057 92075 760-929-3412 92007
92054 760-966-1198 92024 92646
92024 92009
92124
92009
92009 760 931-7693
92076
92103 CA
92007
92024 760-634-6065
94549
92008
92024 7604363343
92009 800-969-5543 92009 92009 92009 760-604-9161
92109
92009 1-760-476-0247
T3AlS9
Gratitudel@cox.net darlynns@aol.com boodness@aol.com jasminerh@hotmail.com chnshinshaw@holmail.com melhinton@sbcglobal net
shhertica@hotmail.com
nickihm@hotmail.com blankerina@yahoo.com pffahodson@hotmail.wm hoeksemaphoto@yahoo.com Edward.HOffman@djortho corn
bhofmann@acquirex.com
summer@wavelines corn
kristenonaquest@hotmail.com
lastnde25@hotmail.com
tenyholladay@cox net
thollenb@gnf.org
shollera@bowdoin.edu
holmes@holmeslandscape.com
j9holmes@yahoo.com
Hlexadaaol wm
24kholmgren@prodigy.net enviesurf@yahoo.com
sdholtl363@sbcglobal.net
sdholtl363@sbcglobal.net
timhomuth@hotmail wm
wrky-981 OS@yahoo.com
juneymike@sbcglobal.net
maggiehood@adelphia. net
GNHOOD@ADELPHIA.NET
dhopkins@morfacts.com
rhopwocd@yahoo.com
billhoran@adelphia.net
dhoren@sbcglobal.net gshomung@yahoo.com jhorosky@msn.com mse5446@nethere.com ghough@earthlink.net brian.houghton@sbcglobal.net
yaahouli@yahoo.com
rejuvenage@yahoo.com sdhouse@cox.net bren-houser2003@yahoo corn namhsah42o@earthlink.net jhowell@thevine net sandynsurf-beach@yahoo.com
markhuckins
lahudakaamsn com
bhu007@adelphia.net
dhuffasan rrwm
dhughen@altheatech.com
RAYJAY3@sbcglobal.net
kshughes@cox net
jasonh@blackball.us outdoorluvr@hotmail corn erichulin@yahoo.com
tumtum 105@ hotmail. wm gidge60@hotmail.wm meganhumpa@hotmail corn ixrtiehumphrey@yahoo.com bertiehumphrey@yahoo com mtns4th@yahoo.com danielcarterhunt@yahoo.com jahpablo77@yahoo.com thurIey814@yahoo.com barry.hurt@ieee.org gavin-hurt@yahoo wm reneenew@email.com kent.huth@sdcounty.c.gov lalaOZ@san.rr wm
Brett-iIes@hotmail.com ailic@adelphia.net yukimay@yahoo com dannysocali@yahoo.wm beckstar22@hotrnail.com intfenZl@hotmail wm
h2osurfer52@aol.wm
Mark-lrwin@upperdeck.com
plasticfantastic31 @hotmail.com
kayirwin@wx.net
aliciaisen@hotrnail.com ishidera@yahoo.co jp
Iliskiw@ucalgary ca
zenissel@yahoo com
jasonil@pacbell net
sjablow@hotrnail.com
Seniorecho@sbcglobal net
the~acksons4@sbcglobal.net
jtjackson9@gmail.com
njjacobsen@ yahoo.com
daniellej-07asandeigo.edu
garyjahns@lycos.com
don.james1 @comcast.net
Guayule@adelphia net
chuckjamison@hotmail.wm alj@oakley.com joeljanc@hotmail wm leejanc@adelphia.net jessicaaultrafitnutrition.com
seventwo60@yahoo.wm
p.janik@sbcglobal net
1 0 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1 1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0 1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 1 0 0
0 0
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
t 1 1 t
1 1 1 1
1 0
0 0
Page 13
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Janis Jansen Janss Jeffs Jelden Jenkins Jenkins jensen Jensen Jersey Jessee Jessee Jessee Jiles Jirsa Jobbins Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson JOHNSON Johnson Johnson Johnson
Johnson Johnston Johnston
Johnstone
Jolly
jones
jones
Jones
jones
Jones Jones JONES
JONES JONES
JONES jones Jones Jones jones Jones Jonsson Jonsson Jordan
Jordan
Joseph
Josias
Jouras
IOYce Judge JUDGE Julien Juneau Kabobel kaenel
Kagan Kahahawai Kahapaa Kakehashi Kalinkewiw
Kanes Kapan Kapan Kaplan
Karp Karp UARTZ
Karydes Katsoff
Kat2 KaUSZ Kavounas
MY kaye
Keating
kebow
Keck
Keefe
Keenan
keener
Keeping keeping kees KEHLER Kelaher
KalP
Jason Joe Julie Andrew Alan Frank Karen Steven Shanon Rosalinde Jennifer Phyllis William Everett Dave Luke Polly Kim Katharane Hugh Jeff Randall Kelly Megan Ann Walter Dada Wendy V R
L D Gordon LOUISA Jenesa Lisa Michael
Kelly Ian James Quentin
Kathleen
Douglas
david
Crystal Jones
Gracie Candia Ryan JULIA MARTIN MICHAEL STEPHENIE gracie Marcia ANdy apnl Gen Enn Lars
Bonnie
Denise
David
Kyle
emily
Evelyne HUGH Mike William Grant sarah
Mark Chnstian Peter Brenda
Jayce Randy
Jason Tamara Chns Vicki David Elle SHEILA Andrew Dacia
Bnan
Maoi Deborah Veronica jodi
Brandon
Sheila
Robert
Bob
Zachary
Sammy
Joanna
bill
Brett Michael
ryan
Terry
Jeff
P 3524 Mt Anane Dr San Diego 19995 Elfin Forest Rd Eswndido A 321 Shadow Oaks lrvine
390 N Sepulveda Blvd. # 2050
2052 White Birch Dnve Vista M POBox2485 Carlsbad
R 6965 El Camino Real Suite 105-177 Carlsbad
El Segundo
W
L
C 0 D
G
M
M
R
t
C w
A S L
s
G R
J
M
a m
F
J T P V H H
W
L s
W
C
C G
T
S P M
J
M H A G
V L J
M
a
D r
E d
D R
363 andrew ave 2252 soledad rancho rd 7101 San Bartolo Jennifer 7230 Mimosa Dnve 7230 Mimosa Dnve 1754 laslo dr 241 Melrose Ave 5408 Old Ranch Road 1847 Lotus Court 1647 Lotus court
600 Sunset St 1410 Kings Cross Dnve 12639 El Carnino Real M106 2617 Larkin Place 4614 Neblina Dnve 973 Hermes Ave
1570 Mantirne Dnve 1434 wop street
2021 Wwdmoss Court
2741 glasgow dnve 2834 Cazadem 2834 Cazadem
2934 Cazadem 2634 Cazadem PO Box112 830 PALARO DRIVE 4334 oming View Court 842 Skysail Avenue
841 Mistletoe Lane
1057 Lighthouse Road
do 1-4-3-Hart-Avenue
131 Diana St Apt 10
1671 Brady Circle
382 Sunset Drtive
6736 Lonicera Street 4 field
3678 Olive Hill Rd 3610 voyager urcla 4933 Saratoga Ave #203 655 Cole Ranch Rd 1028 SEAHORSE CT 1028 SEAHORSE CT 1028 SEAHORSE CT 1026 SEAHORSE CT 3610 voyager circle 370 Andrew Ave 51 I 6 Narragansett Ave #86 31841 Via Coyote 3566 Wishbone Way
16321 Pacfic Coast Hwy #143
16321 Pack Coast Hwy #143
2157 Pleasant Grove Road
2157 Pleasant Grove Road
7053 Surfbird Circle
349 S Cochran Ave 3 Kann Court
907 21st st
6594 Petunia Place 6594 PETUNtA PLACE 517 1R Stratford Court 33046 Calle Aviador 1541 Thermal Ave 1228 chambord ct 3013 Corte Baldre 771 Camellia Place P 0 Box 3055 1520 Hawk View Dr 2359 Herrnance rd 36523 Cheval Dr 3810 Adair Way 7345 Seafarer PI 7345 Seafarer Place 4535 Picadilly Ct 21 19 Cottage Way 2119 Cottage Way 8367 LAKELAND DR 2491 Caminito Ocean Cove 1531 Glenwood Dnve
2152 Bawn St
321 1 Fosca St 1016 Foxglove View 156 Phoebe Street
2109 wolngreeny way
2549 Hillndge Lane
5061 shore dr
5151 Bnghton Avenue
7571 Calorna Circle
1159 Wales Place
1662 Hilton head Ct
#lo5315 Acacia Avenue
315 acacia ave
PO box 90651 4923 1R SARATOGA AVE 720 Teaberry St
encinitas sd Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Eswndido Enunitas Oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad Ridgecrest Cardiff San Diego San Diego carlsbad Enunitas
Carlsbad
enunitas
Enunitas
carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Pala LEUCADIA La Mesa Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Santa-Monica
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Encinitas Carlsbad irvine Fallbrook san diego San Diego Enunltas CARLSEAD CARLSEAD CARLSEAD CARLSBAD wsan diego Leucadia Ocean Beach Cot0 de Caza Olivenhain
Pacfic Palisades
Pacific Palisades
Encinitas
Enunitas
Carlsbad
LOS Angelas Soquel
san diego Cadsbad CARLSEAD Del Mar
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA San Juan Capistrano CA San Diego oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad Pnnceville Encinitas Galway Winchester Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Vista Vista GRANITE BAY Cardiff San Diego
San Diego
Carlsbad Carlsbad Enunitas
enunitas
Spnng Valley
carlsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
Cardiff
El cajon
Carlsbad
carlsbad sd SAN DIEGO Encinitas
CA
CA
CA CA Hi
CA NY
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
921 11 858-344-7476 92029 92616 949-679-9110 90245 92081 9201 8 760602-8220 92009 949.275.3941 92024 7609428731 92109 92009 7609299576 92009 CA 92009 CA 92009 CA 92025 760-533-5133 92024 7604581108
92009-512 7M) 436-9372 92009-512 760 436-9372 93555 92007 760 942-5021 92130 92123 92W8 92024 760-942-9470
92011
92024 92024 92006 760-720-1 136 92009 760-436-3999
92057 (760) 75a8822
92009 760-436-3999
92009 92009 92059 760.703.8171 92024 91941 619-301-4129 92009 760.431.9135
9201 1
92009 7601604-0043
9 760 230 1690
[go4051 (619) 418-8363
92008
92024
92009 760602.9823
92620
92028
92130 92107 619-602-2776 92024 760 944 9227 92009 92009 92009 92009 92130 92024 760 632.8621 92107 92679 92024 90272 3104594761
90272 3104594761
92024
92024
9201 1
90036 3233504568
95062
92102
9201 1 92014 619.301.0755 92675 92154 92054 92009 760-943-9195 92008 96722 92024 12074 92596 92008 7608452611 92009 92009 760-918-1610 92010 92081 949 533 3438 92081 760.908.4701 95746 92007 92103 92107 619.523.8807
92009 760.436.4916 92009 (760)916-9925 90064 92024 7604360712 91977
92006 760438-1645
92107
92009 92007
92019 92008
92008
92169 92107 92024
92011-2516
jasonjanis@mail utexas adu joejansen04@yahoo wm juliejanss@aol wm megasurfstar@hotmail wm alan jeldenasyntnclty com tniah@yahoo corn
kjenkins@thunderzone wm jense2005@yahw corn shanon@sellsandiego corn leejersey@exute wrn jesselOO@chapman edu jeSSeefam@SbcglObal net oldmansurf@sbcglobal net ejiles@cox net djirsa@hswn org jobbins@sbcglobal net polly@asice wrn kljohnsonacompuserve wm ksjohnsZ@pepperdine edu hjkjincbsQcox net jeffjohnsonlOl@hotrnail wm randallj49@hotmail wrn klindzy@hotmail wm rneganqohnson@wx net
kidjohnson@adelphia net
sellwithswtt@sbcglobal net
darla johnson@djortho wrn
johnsonfarn05@hotmail wm lajohnson@netscape wm lajohnson@netscape wm
lajohnson@netscape wm
lajohnson@netscape wrn
gordonjohnsonamail@yahoo wrn
louisaj2OOO@wx net
jenesaZI@juno wrn hwverphoto@adelphia net
mjcarlsbad@netzero net
kellyatthebeach@msn wm
awvipkpfk@yahoo com
quirkyq@yahoo corn
kathyjohnstone@adelphia net dougoll@pacbell net
rynrnjones@hotmail wm crystaljones@fuhsd net graciesnojonz@sbcglobal net havesurfwilltravel@yahoo wm rtjoneser949@hotmail wm jjOZ@adelphia net jjOZ@adelphia net jjOZ@adelphia net jjOZ@adelphia net graciesnojonz@yahoo wrn catmaj@cox net AWJSlnatra@aoI wrn
apnljgpjsalvage wrn
gljst@aol wm
ennjonsarnac corn
ennjons@mac com
tchn3rs@aol wrn bluagrassl0Qaol corn
djoseph@Qobs corn djjauy_99@yahoowm wmv danejouras@sbcglobal net bunkyawx net Handej64aaol wm HANDEJ64aAOL COM mike@rnichaeljulien wm todd juneauapnrnedia wrn gkabobel@wx net sarah rarnsey@cox net kaganaadelphia net DontBuildThatShit@Bastards wrn surfnder3@hotrnail wm shapeofaheart@aol wrn jaycehaswotles@hotmaii wrn KalpmO@hotmail wm jkanes@sbcglobal net tkapanaadelphia net chnskakapankent wrn vickikaplanghotmail com dkarplO26@yahoo wrn ekarp@fujikuragolf corn LOWGLIDEaSUREWEST NET akarydesawx net daciaf@yahoo com
bdabdkatz net
krausz@adelphia net dk92009@yahoowrn vemnicak08@hotrnail corn
jkayeabarracudanet corn
eifunko99x@hotmail com
dukesheaaol wm
fkob@earthlink net
bkeefewx@yahoo wrn
zacharykeenan@hotmail wm
sammylovesdarcy@hotmail wm
joannaesirn@hotrnail wm
jkeeping@bellyup corn killbees@hotmail corn brett@sdsmfitnass wrn rnrkelaher@yahoo corn
djpwj@sbcglobal net
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0
I 1
1 1 1 0
1 1 0 0 1 0
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
0 0
1 0 1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0
0 0
1 1
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 1 1 1
0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0
1 1 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
0 0
0 0
1 0 1 0 1 0
Page 14
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Kelly
Kelly
Kelly '
Kelly
Kelso kelton Kernper
KENNEDY Kennedy
Kenney Kenney Kenney Kenney Kenney
Kent
Kent Kent Kenton Kenton
Keoughan
Kerins
ken Kessler Kessler Khouri Kibbe Kies Kilbourne Killebrew Killops KillOPS KillOPS KillOPS Kim
Kim
Kim
Kim
King King
King
King
King
kinsel
Kirby
Kirchner
KIRTLAND Kisling Kittinger Klaus klein Klein Klein klier Kltrnowicz
Klirnowicz
Klockenteger
Kloer Kloer Klos
Knatz
Knight
knight
KNIGHT
Knight Knight
Knooihuizen
Knox Knox Kochevar Koenig Koepsel Kolb Kolptn Kolpin Korninsky
Kipp
Knapp
kornraus- Konigsfeld-Mawe Jack
Konkoly Jason
Kono Del
Koops Brent
Koploy Kathryn
Kornahrens Maggie kovary kate kovary glenn Kozlowski Kari Krarn Samuel krarner Cindy Krarnrner Carolyn kratochvil Christopher Krause Alan Krausz Howard
kreih tyler
kreitz leah kriegel matthew
Krohn Pattie
Krone Jordan
KNdwig Donna KNdwig Pete Kmeger Daniel Kmeger Ryne
Gareth
Bnan
Fiona
Brendan Anna Jennifer Debbie FRIEDA Bnan Patnck
John Karen Edward
Sean
Gwen Enka Adam Adam
Joe
Deborah
david Aimee Michelle Andrew Evelyn Enc Evan Nicholas Nate scott Knsttn Enk
Aaron Kathenne Sandy Canterbury
Mary Michael
Charles
Jeff Joe
tony
Nancy
Jeffrey
LOUIS
JULIE Steffany John Elissa knsten
Genevieve bruce Gabnele Jennifer
Enc Shenn Dernian Brad Torn
Came
Shane
evan
Dernck
Enc
Enk
Randall James Peter
Brent Kathenne Laura
Amber
Olivier Michael
hazen
Peggy
Craig
ANN
L
Y
B M
K
T J E L R
G M W W
a E
M
P
P
A
C
R
M
N
n A
rn
G L V
L
D
J
M
C A
W
G
A
E
R
D
L
r
A
h
2523 San Marcos Ave
390 Chestnut Ave Apt 16
2790 Las Palrnas Cove
1100 Liberty Ave 3350 Ridgecrest Dnve 3165 esplanade
1301 McClelland Street 13356 PANTERA RD 2376 Alttsrna Way
3232 Calle Vallarta 3232 Calle vallarta 241% A LaCosta Avenue 893 Lees Ave 2406 La Tinada Ct
15559 Villa Cardiff Dnve
1872 Avenida Josefa 2376 Altisrna Way.Unit B 1720 Loretta St 1720 Loretta St
6550 Ponto Dr #43
7108 Whitewater ST
3663 harbor view way 7781 Falda Place 7668 el carnino real suite 104-458 19512 sierra raton PO Box1165 7665 Via rnontebello #4 11 Roquedo 245 Neptune Avenue 439 SE 68th Street 439 SE 68th Street 439 SE 66th Street 439 SE 66th Street Aaron 4447 Muir Ave 941 Sacramento Ave 1035 Turnstone Rd
6415 Calrnena PI 4214 Sierra Morena Ave 1366 Herrnes Ave
7512 Viejo Casblla Way #13
766 South Nardo Ave Apt C2
993 n vulcan ave
3245 Welrner PI
2894 Woodndge Cinle
1013 6th Ave 3rd Flwr
1965 MISTY CIRCLE PO BOX 7674 1245 Thomas Avenue 1660 N Coast Hwy 101 #38 144 redwood ave 4496 Orchard Ave 2669 Sutter Street 4740 Bryce Circle
910 Glen Arbor Dnve 910 Glen Arbor Dnve 1165 Arden Dr 658 Cypress Hills Dnve 658 Cypress Hills Dr 423 South Sierra Ave #I80 7703 Garboso Place
227 South Freeman St
541 3 Sycamore Dr
676 d st
PO BOX232119
5071 Manor Ridge Lane
7195 Willet Cir
2422 Byron PI
464 Old Via Rancho Dnve
235 Calla 7601 Eads Ave #5
1480 Broadway Unit 2322 508 North Cedros Ave 1027 Agate Street #1
1255 Greenlake Dr
1255 Greenlake Dnve
546 3rd
5016 plainview rd
207 Sanford St
1504 Cordelia St
2048 Wandenng Road
10513 Trernont Lane
7331 Grebe Dnve
66143 Monches Dnve 855 rnansa lane 855 rnansa lane 6550 Ponto Dnve #61 51 38 Chestnut fork Rd 11 14 Dowitcher Ct 904 Leonard Avenue 212 w cota 1492 Serene Rd 321 1 Fosca Street 360 palisades dnve 6821 El Fuerte St
3509 india st 3455 Lebon Dr # 1533
1306 Hyrnettus Ave
1650 Diamond St
1680 N Coast Hwy 101 #39 769 Vine Ave
346 East Jackson Ave
San Diego
Carlsbad
Del Mar
Pittsburgh Carlsbad rndr San Marcos
SAN DIEGO Carl s b a d Carl s b a d Carl s b a d Carl s b a d Long Beach Carlsbad
Cardiff
Enunitas Carlsbad Oceanside Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad imine Cardiff by the Sea San Diego
RSM Enunitas Portland Portland Portland Portland San Diego
San Diego
Spnng Valley Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad Enunitas
Carlsbad Solana Beach
encinitas
San Diego
Carlsbad
New York
ENClNlTAS Tahoe City San Diego Encinitas carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad Enunitas Enonitas Enunitas Encinitas Encinitas San Diego Carlsbad
Oceanside
Roeland Park
enc
LEUCADIA San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Escondido
lrnpenal Beach
La Jolla
San Diego Solana Beach San Diego
Cardfl
Cardiff
Enunitas
san diego
Leucadia
Chula Vista
Encinitas
BelMower
Carlsbad
Fernandina Beach
enunitas encinitas Carlsbad
Gloucester Carlsbad Oceans id e Santa barbara Oceanside Carlsbad santa barbara Carlsbad san diego San Diego Leucadia
San Diego
Encinitas Oshkosh
CA
CA
CA
PA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA OR OR OR OR CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
NY
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA KS CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
FL
CA
CA
CA
VA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA WI
ca
Orange CA
92104
92008
92014 8587945265
15222 92008 760-729-1 697 90292 310-306-2366 92069 760-233-0236 92130 92009 6588661331 92009 760-942-8034 92009 92009 90815 92009 7609449286 92007
92024 760-470-9993 92009 92054 92054 92009
92009 7604381556
92056 760-630-6203 92009 92009 92603 92007 92129 858243-2155 92688 92024 858472-2720 97215 503 252-0603 97215 503 252-0603 97215 503 252-0603 97215 503 252-0603 92037 CA 92107 91977
92009
9201 1
92008 856-449-1025
92024
92009
92075
92024 7609438942
92122
92088
10018 2122680609
92024 96145 7608075990 92109 858-458-1900 92024 92006 92107 (619) 223-8673 92008 92006 760 720-2096 92024 760-943-7315 92024 92024 760 230 1782
92024 7604871482 92024 7604871482 92075 92009 760-869-2036
92054
66205
92024
92023
92130 858-794-8977
92009
92008 760-505-7423
92029
91932 92037
92101 92074 8583364140 92109
92007
92007 760.632.8026
92024
92110
92024
91913
92024 (760) 632-5288
90706
92009
32034
92024 760-942-6215 92024 92009 23061 (804)-695-9110 92009 92054 (760) 439-0663 93101 92057 92009 93109 92009 760.994.6094 92103 619-787-6045' 92122 92024
92109
92024 760-845-1302 54901 920-2033952 92667 714-478-3508
kellyengacox net
bkelly88ayahoo corn
fkellygsan rr corn
bkelly@drnclaw corn alohakelsol@yahoo corn nornad1800@aol corn dkernperanpcurl corn fnedakennedyayahoo corn bkennedyaanonyrnizer corn pkenneyaswinerton corn topkpkgaol corn ]kenney@pnntdeparlrnent corn tinker21 xoxoahotrnail corn psaeclaaol corn seandools@yahoo corn
straykat3450ayahoo corn ernk617@hotrnail corn c$uiserl979@hotrnail corn c$uiserl979@hotrnatl corn Joe-keoughanarnsn corn
debberae03ayahoo corn
dak58@sbcglobal net rnellicirna@yahoo corn ggbaffoonaaol corn andrewkhounayahw corn ekibbealycos corn epkl97layahoo corn gyroevatcewarp us nickacapstoneinvestments corn littlebluebike@nseup net scott b killopsgtntel corn kkillops@hotrnail corn enkillopgunion org za
aaronanewswell corn
katkirn@yahoo corn
spaulkl@wx net
kimcanterbury@hotmaiI corn
rnarehugaaol corn
kingrnix2Wl@yahoo corn
chkingaucsd edu
]effkingappr@yahoo corn
kinplpagrnail corn
tktnsel5@hotrnail corn
nktppasan rr corn
~effktrby004@hotrnail corn
Ikirc@venzon net
jmkirtland@earthltnk net perdida-en-crayahw corn jkittasandiego edu elissa@squarelhorne corn nlantzahotrnail corn oblawsurf@aol corn
g_kletn@berkeley edu patbNce@earthlink net tgklirnomu@sbcglobal net austnalandahotmail corn
lebanonred@yahoo corn
thekloersacox net
thekloersacox net brad-klosahotrnail corn teaknappayahoo corn
camelynngreenayahoo corn
shaneknightgsbqlobal net
777t3 corn
ECONOMOM@COX NET dernckasan rr corn
enc knightaatt net
rockinboorn@sbcglobal net
randallknoxacox net
Jksurfawayayahoo corn kochevarasan rr corn
cgirl@yahw corn kabekcepsel@yahoo corn Ikolb8@yahoo corn
aokolptn@adelphia net
okolpinasunstonehotels corn
rn-korntnskyayahoo corn
hazenkornrausahotrnail corn encchiroayahoo corn
Jason konkolyareef corn
dhkono@aol corn
brentkoops@hotrnail corn
kkmadigparadise corn
rnagzilla25@yahoo corn kov@sbcglobal net kovgsbcglobal net kankozaadelphia net cobra797975@yahoo corn ctndygkrarner@hotrnail corn carolnoceansideacs corn
alan krauseagrnail corn kraus@adelphia net kreitztylerahotmail corn desertedkitten@yahoo corn
rnatt@sundiego corn
pkrohnaucsd edu
Jordkrone@hotrnail corn
donnacalvao@yahoo corn
petekrudwtg@hotrnatl corn uwodankrueger@yahoo corn thecallfornian56@yahoo corn
fOjOSb@hOtrnail corn
1
1
1
0
t 1 1
1
0
1
1 1
1
1
0
0 1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
1
1 1
1 1
1
1 1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1
0 0 1 1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0 1
1 1
0 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
0 1
0
0
1
0
t
0
0
1 1
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
0 1 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 1
1 1
0
1
0
0
0
t
0
0
0 0
0 1 0 1
1 0 0 0 0
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0 1
0 0
0 1 0 0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
Page 15
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Kruidenier
Kube
Kuch
Kuiken
kummelehne Kunoth
Kunz
Kutzman
Kuzniar
Kyle
La Corte Lacy Lacy Ladd Laird Lake Lake Lalor Lamb Lamb Lancelot
Landers
Landis Landman Laney Lang
Lang
lange
lange lange Lanigan Lanningham lantz Lantz Lantz Lantz Lanzetta
Lap LaPointe
LaPP LaPP Lamer Larson
larson
lattlmer Laubert Laughlin
Laughlin Launais
Laune
Laux
Lazarus
Lank
lauaro Le Le Roux Leach Leavitt LeClair Ledford Ledford Ledford Ledford Ledford Lee Lee Lee Lee lee Lee Lee LeFevre LeFors Lehrer
Lehrmann
Leibee
Leibee
Leigh
LEISTMAN
Len ah an
Leon
Leonard
leone
Leone
Leone Leone lemer
lesar
Lesar
Leslie
LeVan Levenson Levine LevitzDavid Levy Lewis LWS LemS liang
Lichtenberger lieberman lievsay
LIZ Maureen
Roger
Mama
mark Laura
Bnttany
Blair
Renee
Sean
Nora Piper Piper Daniel Tami Sean Sean Michael Bryan Lisa
Nathan
Heather Sophie
Marcus David
Kendell
bnon
david Scott Bnan Jerms nowell William Diane Richard Tia Edwin Robert Georgiana James Ross
leslie
nancy Eons Chnstina Gregory Jonathan
Enc
Angle
Elizabeth
Shoshana
frank Thao Jean Kyndra Cadi Susan diane Merl Merl Peter Geoffrey Edward Henry Jason Don Janice Gail Dwayne Nora Lila Brooke
Patnck
Jon-Paul
Monique
Laune
DAWN
Josh
Ann
Bnan
rosemary
Angela
Michael
Susan
michael
lydia
Deanna
Enc
Carl Tracey Steven Elissa Leon Darby Edward Patnua john
Elizabeth
Susan
brent
Mary
swtt
F
C a
E
R
R
J
J M
R
J
R
a
L
D
L a a
S B
C
B
N
E
J S
S
C
f
W
C
L
W
s
C
J
L
M
S
A
S
m
3005 Cadenua Street 6426 Merlin Dnve 747 Jamaica Court 3265 McKinley st 1930 s nevada street
33862 Diana Dnve #C
5008 Long Branch Ave
208 North Cedros
1731 Geranium St
7777 Caminito Monarca#106
2507 La Golondnna St
263 Delphinium St
263 Delphinium St
1927 Coast Blvd
1620 Saint James Ct.
6909 Waters End
6909 Waters End
122 Windvane Ln 5317 Denny Ave #204 13964 Poway Valley Rd
997 Manor Way
3621 Arlington Street
4365 Alabama St #I
75 forest ave
11062ndStreet#351
10658AdermanAvenue#153
1155CaminodelMar#521
6550 ponto dnve #67
1234 oltver ave 1736 s dernentine street 1263 Summit Place 158 Flonta 144 redwood ave 144 Redwood Ave
144 Redwood Ave 2844 Wilson St 902-E Caminito Madngal 1756 Medinah Road 4360 El Capitan Court P 0 Box 130032 974 Merganser Lane 2784 Galiua Way 2875 Blackbush Lane 4171 tiberon dr 132 n el camino real #222 129 Andrew Ave 3210 Harding Street 3210 Harding Street 3691 Mt Ashmun Ct
491 Island Street
apt 62 Pasea De Laura
3516 Woodland way
6637 Via Mallorca
739 arden dr
7073 Leeward Street
2591 1 Toluca 3940 Highland Dnve
722 Ocean Crest Rd
6709 Whitesail Street Diane 605 West Oak Avenue 605 West Oak Avenue 1100EvertonPI#252 556 Third Street 236 25th Street 1720 Butler Ave Apt 5 PO Box 9405 1397 Hymettus Ave 1397 hymenus ave 7777 Caminito Monarca #lo9 1605 Wllowhaven Road 679 S Nardo Ave C-1
700 Regal Rd #lA 12446 Ruette Alliante
1306 Statice Ct
271 CountryHaven Rd
2625 Pinneos Way11128
151 1 Summit Ave
422 S VINE ST
2694 Woodndge Circle
2236 El Camino del Node
829 carninito del mar
2493 Carninito Ocean Cove
Michael
1002 Turnstone Rd
3636 highland dr
3979 Syme Dnve
3979 Syme Dnve
4360 Yosemite St
4621 Lamont St 6B
1000 Chinquapin Ave
3444 Camino Alegre 1650 Sagewood Way 940 Melaleuca Ave Apt N 2182 Caminito Del Barw 163 Coop Ct 2326 Carninito Andada 2515 chicago st #28 6740 Tea Tree Street
2035 red coach lane
303 west D street
P 0 BOX 814
Carlsbad CA Carlsbad CA San Diego CA Carlsbad CA oceanside CA Dana Point CA San Diego CA Solana Beach CA 92009 CA
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Encinitas
Encinitas
Del Mar
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
North Hollywood
Poway
San Diego
San Diego
San Diego
swanzey
Encinitas
San Diego
Del Mar
carlsbad
san diego
oceansdie
Cardtff by the Sea
Enunitas
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad San Marws Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad El Cajon oceanside enunitas Leucadia Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego Morro Bay Oceanside
Carlsbad
La Jolla
encindas
Carlsbad
Laguna HIIIS
Carlsbad
Cardtff
Carlsbad
Visalia Visalia Visalia Riverside Enanitas
Del Mar
Los Angeles Rancho Santa Fe Leucadia enunitas Carlsbad Encinitas Solana Beach Encinitas San Diego
Carlsbad Enunitas Carlsbad
Cardtff ESCONDIDO Carlsbad
Ciivenhain
Solana Beach carlsbad Cardiff
Cardiff Carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Marws
Carlsbad
Del Mar
Leucadia San Diego san diego Carlsbad enunitas
encinitas
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA NH
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
ca
92009 760-944-7417 92009 760.929.8524 92109 92006 92054 92629 92107 92075 92009 6154219
92009 7604366863
92009 92024 7606359714
92024 7606359714
92014
92008
92009
92009
92009
91601
92064
92106
921 17 858.922.7677
92104
3446
92024 760-613-4979
92126
92014 760-633-3315
92009 92109 92054 760-445-5944
92007
92024 7602138680
92008
92008 7607295649
92008 7607295849 92008 730-8966 92009 7601310-5732
92069 92008 760-43402798 92013 92011 92009 92019 92056 92024 92024 92008 760.434.4387 92008 760.434.4387
93442 92009
92008
92037
92024
92009
92653 949-448-0391
92008
92007
92009 760-931-1679
93291 5597373777 93291 CA
93291 CA 92507 92024 760-207-9675
90025 92067 92024 92024 92009 760-943-9247 92024 760.390.6848 90275 92024 92130
92009 92024
921 i I 858-3002640
92014 858-603-4108
92009 92007 760-632-1 157 92025 92008
92024 760942-0194 92075 7606720567 92009 92007 92007 92009 760-431-6330
92008
92008 760-822-2457
92008 760-434-1 386
92008
92109
92008
92009
92078
92009 (760)804-0348
92014 858-755-2419
92024 92107 92110 92009 92024 (760)943-7537
92024 619-261-7715
Liznandygadelphia net maureenkube@adelphia ne1 rogerkuch@yahw corn misaness@hotmail corn makummelehne@cox net laurakunoth@gmail corn sdsurfgirl@juno corn blairkutz@yahoo corn blinkchick141 82Qhotmail corn
srk9@yahoo wm dmoraawebtv net piperlacy@mindspnng corn
piperlacy@mindspnng wm
danielladd@hotmail wm
Tami82165Qaol com
slakeo@yahoo com
slakeo@yahw corn
rnlalor@sbcglobal net
soccer-kicker@hotmail wm
cutestlisa@aol corn
ginaruZu@yahoo corn
blazingheartlight@yahw wm f@f wm
fearrust@cox net
spam-sairnin@yahw wm
virtualcio@hotrnail wm
bnon@sundiego com langedg@cdm wm biglange@cox net
bnan laniganaperegnne wm
]erms@nktml corn
nlantz@hotmail wrn
billglcagroup wm
diane@lcagroup wm
lantzfam@adelphia net
TiaQSpaCucina wm
edwinas41 corn
lapointebreak@sbcglobal net
lapplinx@adelphia net lappub@adelphia net rslarnerQgmail wm slarsoninsd@cox net Ilarson66@yahoo wm wrlydirnples@cox net blaubert@wx net chnssylaughlin@yahoo wm pinkgirlie8@yahoo wm Jonathan launais@surfhardware wm encpia@hotmail wm Iilchunkymonkey4u@yahoo corn lizlazarusl@yahoo corn
slazik@hotmail wm
flauaroQrnsn wm
tdlucsdgadelphia net
yebosurfQcox net
kyndraleachQyahoo wrn
misscane@hotmail wm
sleclair@dinimetncs com
diane07@mac wm m-ledford@pacbell net
m-ledford@pacbell net peterledford@mac wm gledford08@hotmail wm
eddieindo@hotrnail wm
hennnahotmail wrn ilcines@hotmail wrn drsurfl Qwx net leecadia@yahw corn gaillee@sdcoe k12 ca us dwayn&6@hotmail com nlefevre@favnlle wm Iilalefors@cox net bmokelehrerQhotmail wm
plehrmann@hotmail wm EncisensiZB@aoI wm NeekagirllIS@yahoo corn Ileigh@sdwe k12 ca us
DAWNL@NOFEAR COM
joshthepoolguy@hotmail win
awllovestennisQaol cam bnanlanofear corn rose3rrc@aol wm angie@leonedesigns wm michael@leonedesigns wm sleone@treetop com
mikestylern@netscape net
lydial32002@yahoo wm Ilesar@ucsd edu encjleslie@adelphia net clevan@ucsd edu tllevenson@hotmail wm
sml@accelrys com
the-davids@wx net
Ilevy@miracosta edu
delmaqon@msn wm
edlewis@elmspub com lawpal@cox net wandenngtaois@hotmail wm drlizmike@aol corn jelinda@adnc wm blievsay@gmail com
bodhil40@aol corn
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0 1 0 1 0
0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0
0 0 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 1
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 0
0 0 1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0
1 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1
1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1
0 0
0 0
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0
Page 16
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Lillfors
Lin hn
lindal
Lindberg Lindekens lindernann Lindsey Lindsey Lindsley Lininger lipscornb Lisenby Lisle-Crawley
List
Lin Lwesay
Livesay LIVINGSTON Livingston
Livingston
Lloyd
Locke
Loedel
loflen Logan
LOGAN
Lohr
lornbardi Lombard0 Long Looney
lopez
LOUcaS
Love
Lovell
lOwe
Lwe
Lowe
Lowenstein Lucero
Lucero Luuer Luaus LUUUS ludera Lumg Lund Lunt Lusher LUtZ
Luza Lyall Lydick
Lyle Lynch
Lynch
LYON
MacBelh
MACFARLANE
MACFARLANE
Mach an is rnachanis Machen rnachulsky MACK Mackay rnackillop MacKlnnon rnaunanus MacWhorter Madison Madison Magaro rnahi Mahlurn rnahlurn Major Makarow Makielski Malarkey Malek Malley Malone
rnancuso Mancrarek Manfrs
Manfre
Mann
Manor
Manos
Manos
Mansfield Mansfield
Mansuene
rnarceron
Marcinko
rnarcks
March Marcone marcone Marion
John
Stan
James
Sacha
kathleen Tina
Eric
John robert jeff
John
Danica
Galen
Denise
Chad
Bret
JUDITH
Daniel
Devon
Ellie
Karen
Delores
bret
Brooke
TY
Olaf
Louise
Anhony
Scott
Stacy
an
Nancy
Lucinda
Randall
karen
Brad Chase Ginger Matthew Julie Proctor Evalyn Sean Susan Knstoffer Ginger Tod
Amy Phil
Zach
Chris
Lon
Sybil
Betsy
ASLAN
Jason MARK
JOHN
Kathryn rnichael John darren KIMBERLY Carol alan Ashley JW Jim Marc Ann Heather alia Daniel Christine Cara Sunshine Heather Michael Chris Sean
Allen
Jerry Nathan
Jeannette
Albert
Joshua
Jocelyn
Nancy Jennifer
Amy George
Lyndsey
Sean
Mane jiovan Joseph Steven shelly
Beniarnin
Tey
John
Teny
E
C
0 D
I
P
L
M
B
A
C
A
I
A
A
a
H
A
A
a
D
S R
W C
B
B
M J
C A
R
D
F
J
b E r
A K R f
r J
A
j L
L A
A
K
C
H
E
d
2764 Carlsbad BI 2101
6969 Catamaran Dr
6969 Catamaran Dr
336 E Clernrnens Ln
6616 colina Puesta
1447 Hygeia Ave
518 southbndge
414 Ulelah Ave
414 Ulelah Avenue
1036 Dawn Dnve
1614 S Nevada
6226 branting street
2620 Colibn Ln
6741 Cantil Street
7263 Birchcreek Rd
740 Genter Street
152 Ftfth Street
10317 Leafwwd Place
1442 SUN VALLEY ROAD
6952 Sandcastle
7516 Cluinta St
432 S Barnngton Ave #4
6563 Windflower Dr
245 Hillcrest Dr
1128 cloverleaf dr
7958 Arnargosa dr
7958 AMARGOSA DR
25921 ave cabnllo
61 Lexington Ave
2457 Carninito Ocean Cove
8843 CONUS Place
6146 Crtracado Circle
3946 sherbourne dr
2832 Cedamwd Way
861 Chalcedony St
4946 W Point Lorna Blvd
7984 Paseo Aliso
7082 Leeward Street 3927 Atascadero Dr 10366 Rancho Cannel Dr 1224 Highbluff Ave 836 Gage Dnve 511 Third Street 920 Anatra Ct 920AnalraCt 2049 n sheffield av 21 11 Coolngreen Way 840 Sidonia Street 5998 Alcala Park Unit 1 I 10
708 Lotus Blossom St
34015 Sirnpson Rd
146 Avocado St 1137 6th St
3769 Oceanfront Walk
1980 Seabreeze Ct
2946 Avenida Valera
2074 Unda Lane
3560 voyager Court
3710 garfield st apt A 6953 Batiquitos Dr 6953 batquitos dr 5402 Rocking horse In 3508 woodland way 2535 DUNDEE WAY 170 Diana S1 #I7
11205-5 carmel creek road 1302 Skyros Way 5198 LOS Robles Dnve 4930 Colusa Dnve 1326SavannahLane 1326SavannahLane 7555 Herschel Ave 2174 redwood crest 12646 Cannel Country Rd #I50 1083 Crest Dr 936 Analra Court 3052 N Main St
7101 TANAGER DRIVE
1878 HAYMARKET RD
1276 Acapulco Ave
1734 Kennington RD
1445 Carninito Seplnno
1528 Hicks Street
237 24h street
4232 Fiesta Way #2
25491 Bootstrap Place
25491 Bwtstrap Place
4280 Rockport Bay Way
791 I Sitlo Catana
721 I wistena Way
721 1 Wistena way
5471 Via Alcazar
lrabuco canyon
776 la rnirada
914 Carninito Madngal #G
1834 carolyn dnve
2225 Manchester Ave Apt 4 4338 stanford st 4338 stanford st 71 7 Calle de Silva
Amy
Carisbad CA
Carlsbad CA
Carlsbad CA
Fallbrook CA
San Clernenle CA Leucadia CA encinitas CA Palm Harbor FL
Palm Harbor FL
Ocean side CA Oceanside CA
Carlsbad CA Cattsbad CA
San Diego CA
La Jolla CA
Enunitas CA
San Diego CA SOLANA BEACH CA Carlsbad CA
Carlsbad CA
Los Angeles CA
Carlsbad CA
Leucadia CA
el wpn CA
Carlsbad CA
CARLSBAD CA
San Juan Capistrano CA
san diego ca
New York
Cardtff
San Diego Carlsbad
oceanside
Carlsbad
San Diego San Diego
carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
San Diego
San Manos
San Diego EnunItas CarlSbad Carlsbad chicago Encinilas Enunitas San Diego Enunitas Hernet
Enunitas Santa Monica San Diego
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
CARLSBAD
Oceanside
LEUCADIA carlsbad
Carlsbad carlsbad Oceanside carlsbad VISTA Enunitas san diego Ermnitas Carlsbad Oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad La Jolla vista San Diego Enunitas Carlrbad Morn0 Bay
Sirni Valley Encinitas Cardiff Oceanside del mar Oceanside Laguna Hills Laguna HIIIS
Oceanside
Carlsbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego
trabuw canyon
leucadia
Carisbad
chula vista
Cardiff carlsbad calrsbad Redlands
0 Cardtff
NY
CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA il CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
ca
92008
9201 1 760-602-9726
92009
92028
92673
92024 92024 34683
34683 727-636-3215 92056 (760) 945-7873 92054 760-439-2120 92122 61 9-261-5173 92009 438-4829 92009 7602073519
92119
92037 6583362083 92024 76C-634-0506
92131
92075
92009 760-809-7607
92009 (760) 505-2025
90049 CA
92009
92024
92019
92009 760-634-6816
92009 760-535-1936
92675 949 370.8088
10010
92007 4072526372 92126 92009
92056 760 583-5142
92008
921 09
92107
92009 7606326672
92009
92107
92128 6583955996 92076 92106 6197953644 92024 92009 760-431-1789 92009 760-431-1789 60614 92024 92024 92110 92024 92545
92024
90403 310.498 4856
92109
92024
92009 929-1350
92008
92009 760-431-5400
92054 92024 92008 92009 92009 760 807-9368 92057 92008 M)9-462-4234 92008 92024 760-944-0900 92130 92024 7609447260 92008 (760)431-8923
92009 76a6059168 92009 92037 858-337-0656 92081
92056-5400
92 130 92024 7606348199 92009 93442 92007 93065 92024
92007 760-419-8895
92054
92014 858 692.2303
92057 (760)721-3017
92653 949-631-1571
92653 949-631-1571
92054
92009
92009
92009
92009 CA
921 11 658-560-7904
92679
92024
92009 760 268-0799
91913
92007 92009 (760) 729-8831 92009 (760)729-8831 92374
John-Liltfors@Excite corn
irontey@yahoo corn
surfgoy@yahoo corn
robeqon@adelphia net
jlindbergl@cox net Sacha Iindekens@ln corn
Iindpat@cox net
tinke~3@aol corn
ElindseyZB@msn corn
phnfindSky@JUflO Con globill90@sbcglobal net
jeffleq@aol corn
johnlisenbyl 3@hotrnail corn
ashes2io@sbcglobal net
whitewashmike@wx net
deniselitt@hotrnail corn
chad-livesay@hotmail corn
blivesay@hotrnail corn
JUDlTHDBAYgAOL COM
dan-livingston@yahoo corn
boyslieOlO@yahoo corn
elliejlloyd@yahoo corn
graciesunset@yahoo corn
kaindeeawx net
Mlongboard85@yahoo corn
brwke logan@rnac corn
TY LOGANaREEF COM
olohr@cox net
weezienyc@hotrnail corn
AnthonyUP@hotrnail corn
scootnalong@yahoo
slooney@breb corn
drakebll@cox net
cornrnunic8gearthlink net
lucinda-love@hotrnail corn
rlovel@yahoo corn
kalwe@pacbell net
tenydlowe@yahoo corn netloopr@nethere corn bluebillabong@grnail corn rnorningstargrl@hotrnaiI corn polysonic@holmail corn jndworld99@yahoo corn
pwluuus@adelphia net
luuuse@adelphia net jurnpinjehosophat@grnail corn slumgadslextrerne wrn held1 lundacox net ginger-O6@sandiego edu lushrnan90@hotrnail corn
arnybrl@aol corn
phil-luza@yahoo corn
socalzach@npcurl corn
chnslydick@hotrnail corn
rnaillonQcox net
CSMGLYNCH@ADELPHIA NET blynch57@adelphia net
BLUMERLE@HOTMAIL COM jrnacbeth@grnail corn UH60LCHIEF2000@YAH00 COM jrnacfarlane@holmail corn olives56@aol corn rnjrnachanis@aol wm jrnlsurfsbcglobal net
drnachulsky@yahoo corn kimack07@hotrnail corn
carol@nixonnow corn
alarnasan rr corn
ashrnac@tfb corn ]odybryan@aol corn
~imrnacwhorter@cox net
rnarunadison@adelphia net Ayrnadison@adelphia net
rnagaroh@yahoo corn a2lrnhi@hotmail corn
danlrnalrn@yahoo corn
cmahlurn@hotrnail corn
Kam-rnajOr@yahW corn sunshine@surRifeforwornen corn
larnalarkey@yahoo corn
CHRIS-R_MALEK@YAHCO COM seanrnalley@hobnail corn
allenrnalonel3@wx net
jrngwestendvideo lv
nrnanczarekZyahoo corn
netlyrnanfre@hotrnail corn
neRyrnanfre@hotrnail corn
]rnann79@yahw corn
duckerj@sbcglobal net
LadyBe59@aol corn
Jenny5916@aol corn
arnansfield@adelphia net
georgernansfield@rnsn corn
lyndseyO7-93@rnsn com
seanrnarcerorn@hotrnail corn
hanahauQyahoowrn
jio-7@hurnorshack corn
ioe@liveinpeace net tosteve@att net toshelly@an net angnbenavenzon net
0 1
1
0
0
1
1
0 0 1 1
1 0
1
1
1 1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0 0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1
1 1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
t
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 0 1
1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
1 1 1 1
0 1 1
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 1
0 0 0
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
1
1
0 0
0
0 1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0 0 1
1 0 0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1 1
0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 0
0 1
1
0 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0 1 1
0
Page 17
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Markey Marlelt
Marlin
Marr
Marre
Marnner
Marsalek
Marsh
Marshall
Marshall
Marshall
Marshall
Marske
Marsteller
Martel
Martin
Martin
martin
Martin
Martin
martin
Martin Martin Martinet martinet Martinez Martinez
martinez Martocua Marlocua Martos Marts Martyns Marver Mason mason Mastemon Mastrogany MATHEY Matin Matson Matson Matson
mattera
Matthews
MATTlOLl
Mattison
Mattson
Maughan
Maun Mauro
Maxwell-Miller
may May maya mayes mayhan maze
Mazur MCALLISTER mcbnde McBnde McBnde McCabe McCabe McCann McCarter
Molly Justin
Blair
Russell
Kathleen
Ashley
Katie
William
Robert
Richard
Beverly
Jesse
Daniel
Paul
Susan
Jenntfer
Heidi
wlliam
Judith
Rebecca
Cameron
Colin Aaron Rosa n n e michele Mansela Amelia
magnum Chip Chip Kim Michael Alana dana Janey beth Kymberli Janet KEVIN Marla John John Elyse peter
J DAVID
Anita
Micah
Lsa
Patnck
Andrew
Aylea
kevin Nancy Jackie stephen john
andrew
Josh PATRICK peter Mike Gavin Knsten Jeanne Michelle Tort
McCarthy Robert
McCarthy-Payne Cathenne
McCaw Garrett
Mcclelland Chnsbna
McClintock Cody McClintock Cody
McColgan Colleen
McColl Ian
McCormack Travis
McCormack Aaron
McCormack Carey McCoy Dan
McCreary Dann
McCue Chnstlne
McCuerg Gary McDaniel Susan
McDermon Charles
McDermoH Jessica
McDonald Holly McDonald Ursula
MCDONALD BRANDON McElroy David
McFadd Edward mcfadden bnan McFarland Kellie McFarland Marie McFarland Duncan McGarry Ailbe mcgee David McGinnis Mark McGlathely Monte
MCGOLDRICK DEIRDRE
McGovern Michael
McGowan Margaret
McGrane Teresa
C
T
A
W
K
E
M
S
k
A
A
J
C
A
B L a
L
E E
a
M
A
W
I
i m s
P
M
J A
A
D
K
E
D
E
S
C A
A
A
A
M
6844 Haltfax St
Justin
Blair
434 La Vela Ave 6981 Catamaran Dr
513 Richmond Street 2453 Oxford Ave
1624 N Coast Hwy 101 35 Bnggs Ave
922 Rosemary Ave 922 Rosemary Avenue 130 Andrew Ave 1456 Clearview Way 6891 Tradewnds Dnve
6589 Corle La Paz
3833 Jewel1 St Apt 13 2534 Burgener Blvd
1702 glasgow
924 Begonia Court 3145 Via de Caballo
628 Sandside wurt 118 Via Solaro 1216 Highbluff Ave 41 11 Park Dnve 3931 may ct 232 Delphinium St 851 Valley Crest
4512 SALISBURY DR 5059 Ciardi Court 5059 Ciardi Court 1807 Blue Bonnet PI 13212 Magnolia S1 Apt 89 150 Coop Ct 2312 Kimberly Ct 2825 Avenida Valera 431 1 sea bnght dnve 229 Hillcrest Or 1612 Orchard Wood Rd 3710 GARFIELD APT A 345 Juniper Avenue Apt #10
1347 Hygeia Ave 1347 Hygeia Ave
6708 Abanto St
7889 sitio mirto
3203 Calle Vallarla
2146 ENClNlTAS BLVD
20 Harwurt Street 430 Sylvia 3009 Ocean Street #A 335 Regency Cir #205 808 Capn Road 120 Phoebe 1970 swallow In 2041 Shendan mad 6150 Munena ave 603 seagaze dr #331 24372 woodwalk rd 24824 spnngbrook way 350 Chestnut Ave #5 PATRICK 1680 Leora Ln
25901 Pasofino 6W1 Pasm Hermosa 251 W Canada Unit D
6489 Franciscan Rd
36 San Simmn
I 64 Andrew Ave
12896 Futura Street
368 Andrew Ave
11637 Thistle HIII PI
2325 Snead Dr
4071 Tynebourne Circle
4071 Tynebourne Cirde
510 S Burnside Ave
637 Neptune Ave
PO Box 1064
3556 Ames Place
3556 Ames Pi
3535 Caminito Carmel Landing
3011 Quail Road
4672 Adair St
7593 Navigator Cinle
2056 Shendan Road
1255 Hermes Ave
1255 Hermes Ave 1841 Sunset Clffs Blvd #6 143 S Cedros Ave#V105 4883 MOTIF ST 1640 S1 James Ct 879 Hymettus Ave 2238 manchester ave #2 7597 Charmant dr #910 615 Marvista Dnve 445 Deer Path 824 summerhill ct 6499 Faitwater Place 5133 Cass SI
1380 Garnet Avenue E507
609 STATE STREET
1710 Burgundy Rd
3730 Sierra Morena Avenue
4560 Cape Cod Circle
San Diego
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Leucadia
Carlsbad
El Segundo
Cardiff by the Sea
Leucadia
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Encinitas
San Marcos
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
San Diego
Cardiff
Carlsbad
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Encinitas San Marws Carlsbad carlsbad Encinitas Vista
CARLSBAD Carlsbad Carlsbad Endnitas
Garden Grove Leucadia Carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad Encinitas Encinitas CARLSBAD Carlsbad Leucadia Leucadia Carlsbad carlsbad
Carlsbad
ENClNlTAS
San Rafael
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Salinas
Encinitas
Leucadia
carlsbad Leucadia
van nuys oceanside lake forest
menifee
Carlsbad carlsbad Encinitas Laguna Niguel Carlsbad San Clemente Carlsbad Laguna Niguel Leucadia
San Diego
Leucadia
San Diego
oceanside
San Diego
San Diego
Los Angeles
Encinitas Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
Eswndido
San Diego
Carlsbad.
Encinitas Encinitas
encinitas
San Diego Solana Beach OCEANSIDE carlsbad Encinitas cardiff by lhe sea san diego Solana Beach Enunitas
Encinitas carlsbad San Diego San Diego
BLACKWOOD Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA NJ
CA
CA
ca
92120
92024 7604733543
92009 760-599-2999
92024 92009 760436.2295 90245 92007
92024 760-230-1404 92024
92ow 92009 760 930-0908 92024 92078 92009 760-889-4372
92009 760-431-0594
92109 858-775-6514 92110
92007 7607530683
92009 7609316602
92024
92009 CA
92024 92078 780-471-4814 92008 760-729-8466 92008 92024 760-505-7973 92084 92008 7606136264 92008 92008 92024 92844 92024 92008 7607209856 92009 760 929.9585 92W8 92024 92024 92008 760 815-3452 92008 92024 (
92024 (760) 603-2651
92009
92009 760-436-9559
92009
92024
94901 415-453-9971 92024 CA 92008 760-434-8161 93906 831-449-0255 92024 760 753-1266 92024 760-518-0028 92009 92024 91401 92054 760-433-1 748 92630 949-350-6501 92584 92008 92008 760-729-4031 92024 na
92677
92672 92009 92877
92024 760-944-1234
92130
92024 (780) 4360180
92130
92056
92130
92130
90036
92024 760-420-0195
92018
92W8
92W8 619-987-6808
92130
92026
92107
92009 7609318307
92024
92024 8584498033
92024 (760) 943-8795 92107 92024 760-840-0590 92056 7604819274 92008 92024 6192182046 92007 92122 92075 858-755-1806 92024 760-753-9338 92024 858-602-6385 92009 92109 92109
8012 609-221 -1 358
92024
92008 (760)729-6450
92008
92009 780-43a1399
Mollymarkey@gmail wm justin@akasurf wm bmarlin@dcshoes corn boxofpoems@careZ corn KathyM2195@aol wm blackspike@sockrnonkeys net kaateemar@yahoo com wwmamh@msn wm rmarshall88@msn com rmarshall@gem wm rbiemarshall@msn corn marshall Jesse@hotmail wm danmarske@hotmail wm zebraspot@earthlink net californiaq@yahoo wm missmartinj@yahoo wm hkmar@hotmail wm rokymar@cox net healthymiss@yahw com rebecca martmQhds wm cameronmichelleQgmaiI wm ca martin@alt net ajmartinl asbcglobal wm
RMarti3456@aol wm
michmartl@sbcglobal net
sela0lQyahoo wm amartinez@npcurl wm magnumvenQaol wm chipkatieQadelphia net chipkatieQadelphia net
kimQkimmartos wm
dance-and-destroy@yahoo wm Martynsl@wx net
otrvinylQaol wm
janey@lilUebaby wm
bethmason@adelphia net
kymlZ@yahoo wm
janlm@aol wm K-MATHEY@HOTMAIL COM
mjmatingadelphia net
JmatsonQisisph wm
JmatsonQisisph wm
matsons@adelphia net mattera@mail sdsu edu jenntfer@sdsc edu DJMATTIOLI@HOTMAIL COM anita-mQwmcast net miCah@nixonnow wm Imaughan@pacbell net dj20pjOOQyahoo corn akamauroQwx net babiegmlZl@yahw wm kevin@prana wm nmaylQwx net sugardandy88@aol wm
notoempire@wx net
mikemayhanQholmai1 cam
andrew ruzarnZ@holtnail com paddydigital@yahoo wm petartedayahoo wm
mrncbnde@cisw wm
ohana95@adelphia net
knstenkalani@gmail wm
jmm6489Qyahoo com
shelly887@holmail wm tortmccarter@wx net r~muarthy3@hotmail wm cinwdolores@sbcglobal net garrettmccaw@prusb wm sodtrodder@hotmail wm
wdyQmaybelogic wm wdyQmaybelogic wm Camella5849Qaol wm
ian-imiQwx net
tmc07Qwx net
amccormack@docsuence wm
cmcwrmack-work@yahoo wm dan mcwy@westonsolutions wm creatorpaQflyinghouse wm
iloveindy22@aol win
gmccuerg@sbcglobal net
Imcdaniell@wx net jemcdm@att net jemcdm@alt net h2opolcgoalie@hotmaiI wm ursula@adamsdesignass~ates net BRANDONM@AUMl COM dmac32l@adelphia net emcfaddaflash net bnanrncfadden@holmail wm keanmmmsn com
mloQmill net duncan4mcs@wx net
ailbemcgarfyQyahoo daveloan@adelphia net
mmcginnis@dudek com
montemcg@yahoo wm
DEIG123@AOL COM mtmnetQwx net BryanMcGowanC@netscape net tenmcg@hotmail wm
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1 0 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0
0 0
1 1 1 1
1 0
1 0 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0 1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 0 1 0
1 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0
1 0
1 1 1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 0 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Page 18
Ponto Beachfront Vision Pian Petition
McGraw William mcgregor theresa Mcguffie ' Gerald
McGulre Elena
McKee Kevin mckeen
McKnight Kenneth
McLaren Duncan
McLarty Chene
McLaughltn Bnan
McLean Martlee
McLee Donna
McLee Russ
McLeod Paul
McLoughlin Cathy
McMahon C
McMahon Scott
McMahon Sean
McNamara-Meek, Jennlfer
step h a n t e
McNatty
McNetll
McNew
McQueen
McQuerter
McRoberts mcsweeney
mcsweeny
mcturk
MEADOR
Meador Jr Mealy Meaney Medeck medina
Medina Meeker Meektn Megan
MEISTER
Mejia
melbye
melbye Melendez Melendez Mello Melroy mendelson Mendiguchia Mendiola
meredythe
Merlo
Memll
Merrbacher
Merzbacher
Mestemacher
Mettee
meyer
meyer
Meyer
Meyer
Meyers Meyers Meyers Michaelis middleton Mtgdol Mikita Mikolaj@ Milch Mildbrandt
Millard Miller Mtller Miller MILLER
Miller
Miller
Mtller Miller Miller
Miller
Miller Miller milliken
Mills Mills Minan
Mindlin
Mlraglia
miralle
rntramon
Mimlla misiorowski miskho
missio Mitamura Mitchell Mitchell Mitchell Miztanhy
Mock
Moeller
Jonathan
Vtdya
Garland
D%nise
Shane
Shelley
Jill
enn
alec
KAREN
James
mark
Michael
Tffany
Reno
Jack
Molly
Moore
ERIN Giovanni
cathy
Richard Robert David
Dana
JOey evan Daniel Martin Jordan Beth
Angle
Jeffrey James
Joelle Sarah
bnana
summer
Cathenne
Cat h e n n e
Ryan
Linda Gladys Keith
Tal
michael
Alan Jenette Robert Wrsten Meghan gina Km
Tara
SARA Chnstopher
James Sand Jason Cns Danielle
Marsha Marsha mike David LIZ John
Suzanne Loren lauren
Craig
Ron robed
betsy
Jenn
Travis
Brady
Michael
Glona
john
bNn0
Robin
John
F a
M
r
L
J
A
H
M
L
E
A
1 m
A w
R
R
M
m
B R V k R m
M
L
M
I
A
A
C
R
R
M A
A
B
C K
M M
G M
H
e
a
P
W A L D
7390 Escallonia Ct 2407 la macarena avenue
5130 Bayard St 2509 Via Sorbete
122 4th Street 11 06 2nd st #805
1733 Kent Place
1740 S El Camtno Real
7337 Seafarer PI
885 Production Place
639 Santa Rosita
7720 Palacto Dnve
7720 Palacio Dnve
17081 Newquist Lane
120 Via Cantebna D45
1015 Tulip Way
658 Poinsettia Park Court
531 1 SW corbett Ave
220 El Camino Real #21
2607 Jefferson Street Unit I
1408 Hygeia Ave
4001 Ashford St
1513 Turquoise Dr
2121 Bngantine Ct
1141 Reed Avenue
1 1986 tivoli park row
1245 hymettus ave
7104 WHITEWATER STREET
71 04 Whitewater St 1376 Calle Chnstopher
Michael
7 Noble Street
39370 calie san clemente
5966 cirrus st
220 El Camirm Real #21 1412 Sassafras Street
2875 Lincoln Avenue
1521 NEPTUNE AVE
6 Country Walk Dnve
3572 corte rosado
3572 Corte Rosado 3560 Hastings Dr 1597 Martingale Court 2453 Oxford Ave 1016 Third St 1101 #a caUin st
2136 Dunhaven Street 8980 villa la jolla dnve 11 09 arcadia rd
22 Corte Javier
1031 1 Leafwood Place
16127 Podeno Court
9155 Ivy Lane
7762 Rocio St
2068 Montgomery Ave Apt D
1 I10 arcadia rd
11 10 arcadia rd
2180 Fire Mountain Dnve
2180 Fire Mountain Dnve
1148 9th st apt 14 1466 Oepheus Ave 7003 San Bartolo 860 Summersong Court 4509 If2 32nd street 257 Delptnium St 1188 Monterey Place 10922 Belgian Street 2316 Masters Road 3503 Camintto Sierra #IO1 18010 Praine Ave 2355 Marber Ave 951 Daisy Avenue 505 Tewa St
5429 LAKE MURRAY BLVD 112
163 Jupiter Street
31 14 Via Puerta
1841 Wilstone Avenue
1939-8 Alga Road 1459 Beech Tree Road 6404 Calmena Place
1851 St Luua 1851 St Lucta 131 europa st
6724 Lonicera Street
1256 Orchard Glen Circle 125 Diana St
4405 ManchesterAve Ste 206
Loren
1206 highbluff ave
149 cadmus st #I
2186 S Coast Hwy
440 naiad st
385 West I Street
1775 Diamond st #I-318
2761 Kempton Dr 324 Cadillac Circle
1634 Ruthlw Rd 7533 Navigator Circle
908 Gnvetta Court 2308 Starflsh Rd #IO1
7358 Gabbiano Lane
1317 bulrush Court
Carlsbad cadsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
Del Mar
encinitas
vtsta
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Newport Beach
Solana Beach
Carlsbad
Cadsbad Huntington Beach
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Encinitas
Portland
Oceanside
Cadsbad
Leucadia
San Diego
Carlsbad
Encinitas
San Diego
carlsbad
san diego
leucadia
CARLSBAD
Carlsbad Encinitas
Plano
Blue Point
murrieta
San Diego
Oceanside San Diego
San Diego
ENClNlTAS
Aliso Viejo cadsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Cardiff Encinitas sirni valley San Diego la jolla encinitas
San Clemente
San Diego
Ramona
Spring VAlley
Carlsbad
Cardiff
encinitas
encinitas
Oceanside
Oceanside
Santa Monica Encinitas Cadsbad Encinitas san diego Encinitas Encinitas San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad Torrance Long Beach Carlsbad Del Mar LA MESA
Leucadia
Carlsbad
Encinitas Carl s b a d
San Marcos Carl s b a d
Vista Vista encinitas Carlsbad Encinitas Encinitas
Eninitas
Encinitas
san elijo hills
encinitas
Oceanside encinitas encinitas san diego Los Alamitos Oceanside Cardiff Carlsbad Carlsbad
Virginia Beach
Carl s b a d
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
OR
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA TX NY
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA Va
CA
92009 92009 7606334848
92109 858-336-3897
92007 7607218258
92014
92024 (760)8157208
92084
92024
92009
92663 949-5150707
92009 760-943-6381 92009 760-943-6381 92649
92024
92009
92024
97239 503-516-4406
92081 760-458-9362
92008
92024 760.436.8178
92117
92009
92024
92109 858-273-7750
92011 760-603-1813
92128
92024 760 632-8966
92009 760-807-4346
9201 1 760/438-3757 92024 7604363806 75025 11715 92562 951 440-0464
92110
92081 7605869100 92103 92104 92024 7609449804 92656 92009 76G9423628
92009 760 929-2203 92008 92009 760-438-5160 92007 760 310 3425 92024 760-420-5634 93065 92110 619-276-9343 92037 92024
92673
92131
92065
91977 6194632133
92009 760-943-8135 92007 92024
92024
92054 92054 90403 CA 92024 760-942-91 37 92009 760-438-1168 92024 760-633-3024 92116 6197089560 92024 7604366941 92024 92126 619-838-3803 92008 (760) 522-8795
92009 760 4364788
90504
90815
92009 760-431-1633
92014
91942 619-713-0008
92024
92009
92024 760-522-7892
92009
92078mi 760 798-2329
9201 1
92081
92081 92024
92009
92024 7608224320
92075 858259-9126
92024
92024 (760) 4360158
92024
92078
92024
92054
92024 92024 760-672-2577 92109 8582726563 90720 92054 760-525-9909 92007 760-604-3122 92011 760431-0932 92009 760-916-0282
23451
92009
frillZ@copper.net tamcgregor@cs.com jmcg05@hotmail corn
emcguire7@hotmail corn
kevinmrnckee@hoimail corn
jab-gurl@yahoo.com
ken@allabouisurf.com
deepole467@yahoo.com
Cmclarty@adelphia.net
brianjohnmacQyahoo.com
marileemclean@adelphia. net
donnamclee@yahoo corn rmclee@yahoo com mcpaul53@venzon.net
cathym@adnc.com
khmcmahon@aol corn
ksmcmahon@cox.net
mcmahon@hotmaR corn
jennmcna@hotmail.com
jnutty22@yahw.com
vidyali@cox.net
garlandmcnew@navsport. net
mcqueentdks@netzero.net
spmcquerter@gmail.com
Sam-mcmberts@hotmatI wm
Kettelklan@aol.com
hbe@San.rr.com
amct@sbcglobal.net
KAREN76O@PACBELL.NET
jmeador7@pacbell.net mealy52@yahoo.com Dumbsquided@gmail com Snowangel595@aol corn nitroboards2l@yahoo.com
renornedina@yahoo.com
jennmcna@hotmail corn mkmeekin@hotmail.w daughter5@hotmail.com
LITTLEMEISTER@HOTMAIL.COM giovannimejia@cox.net melbye007@hotmail.com Brent.melbye@camcommerce.com mnelend@yahoo corn drmelendez@goldwastchim.com mello4@peoplepc.com deepcave200O@yahoo.com deancut-73@msn.com bajaSurf@ix.netcom.com dirtymartinil31 3@yahoo.com sixthscents6@hotmail corn
bithie3@yahoo.com
asilval8@juno corn
merzbacher@cox. net
jperzer@yahw.com
joelleme@gmail.com sarahrnettee@hotmaiI.com bnemeyer@yahoo.com summerlynnl 8@yahoo.com wakeupfrankie@yahoo wm wakeupfrankie@yahoO.com meyersryan@hotmail.com lindamey@pacbell net lindamey@pacbell.net keith@michaelis.cts.com tmiddy@sbcglobal net elmigdol@mtndspring corn
a-mikita@yahoo.com
jen.kira@gmail.com bmilch@lusardi.com
kasm43@adelphia.net
meghanmillard@aol.com
sugarkanej@yahoo.com
milkbl@eamlink.net
tara@ridesnowboards.com
DAVEANDSARA@COX.NET
rniller259@yahw.com
bradmiller835@msn.com
sand@pbsj.com JeysunZB@yahoo.com
drjmiller@cox.net
dkmillerl @adelphia.net
marsha0378@hotmail.com
marshaO378@hotmail.com
mike@sundiego.com
~urfaddiction65@hotmail.~m
wskk@aol.com
jminan7@hotmail.com
suzie@suzannemindlin.net
elmiraglia@adelphia net
mirallegirl@hotmail.com
cmmsurf@hotmail.com
rmirolla2@cox.net misiorowski@gmail.com neverneeve@yahoo.com bruno-2-k@yahoo.com jmitamur@ucla.edu travis@nixonnw.com ytbrady@cox.net roblm45@aol corn mizshl @adelphia.net
poobaaofstuff@Yahoa.com
justgordi@adelphia net
1
0 0 1
1 0 1
0 1 0
1
1 1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
1 0
1
0
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1 0 1 1 0 0
1 1 1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1 1 1
1
0
1
1
1 1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
0
1
1
0 0 1
0
0
0
0 1
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0
0
0
1
1
0 1 0
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0 0
0 0
0 0
0 1 0
0 0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 1
0
1
1 0
1
Page 19
motse
Mokalis
Molnar '
Monagan
Monahan
MONTALVAN
Montez
Montgomery
Montgomery
montgomery
Montgomery
Montoun
Montrucchio
Moore
Moore
Moore
Moore Moore Moore Moore
Mom
Moore
Moran moreau
rnweland
rnorey
Morgan
Morgan
Morgan
Morgan Morganson
Morganson Mon rnonarly Moms Moms Moms mornson Mornson Mort MORTLAND Moser rnoser
Moser
Moses
Masher
Mouvet
Moye
Moyer
Moysa
Mozdzen
Mozurnder
mueller
Mueller Mueller
shane
Knsttna
Chuck
Roberl
Tiana MARIO Rebecca
Garen
Greg
mark
Heidi Brett Tyson Brooke
Michael
Brady Gaea Karen David ffirsten
Margaret
D
Matthew doug
jesstca anthony Charlie
Pamela
Jack Beau Jacquelynn Mike Rose
adnanne Knsty Richard
swtt
Matthew
Laune
EVELYN
Auna rnegan
Theresa
Samuel
Chnstina
Phil
Matthew Patnck
Gmff
Joe
Lauren
Jason Knsttn Connv
Jim
MULHOLLAND DAMiAN Mullen rnulltgan Murnmau Munro Muoto Muoto Mufin Murphtne
Murphy Murphy
Murphy Murphy murphy
MURPHY
Murray
Murray Murray Murrell
Mumn
muscat
Muschell
Muth
myers
Myers
Myers
Myers
Myman
Myiels
Myiels
Nagy Nakamura
nalt
Nash
Nash
Naswrlhy Nation Naus Neal Neelernan Netheisel Neiley Neilson Neilson
Nelsen Nelson Nelson
Robert bnan
Barb Elizabeth Dolores
David
Darcy
Bnan Anne
Michael
Laura
Jennifer
Nancy
George
Jennrier
Micah
Jared
Jtllian
Jeff
paul
Kirsten Nathan
Robert
Marshall
Nicole
Marc Daniel James
gordon
David
David Frank Tnna Colleen Alex Deborah LOUIS Steve Corbin Lorna
Chad Jennifer Chnshan
Mary
MARC
Joshua
e
L
J
R
C
D
A
C S T W
C
C
m
e
I
A
E
A
L
K
g J A D
e
A
D M
F
J L
M
P
M J
P L R J W L
N
m
M
L
W
L
K
E
C
P L
P
M
C
E
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
1727 kinglet rd sab marcos CA
6937 Mimosa Drive Carlsbad CA 6366 Branchwood Place Rancho Cucarnornea CA
1160 LAKE RIDGE DRIVE
1337 N. Broadway #26 Eswndido
2903 BOUNDARY STREET SAN DIEGO 3367 Calle Cancuna Carlsbad
6653 Spectrum Center Blvd
6653 Spectrum Center Blvd
SAN MARCOS
San Diego
San Dieao
10801 molony rd
348 Shore View Lane 10023 Three Oaks Way
106 Via Morella
24530 Pappas Rd 6455 La Jolla Blvd #342 215AndrewAve 1466 Turquoise Dr 1466 Turquoise Dr 1466 Turquoise Drive
3287 Camino Coronado
2319 Pi0 Piw Dr
91 1 Orchid Way 4085 Harrison Street 112
6923 sandpiper place
1760 greentree rd
6299 Jockey St
2440 Gary Circle
2440 Gary Circle 1170 Etfin Forest Rd W 7570 Gibraltar Street #3 7576 Gibraltar St. #3 3127 Hataca Road 677 san rnario 1031 B Neptune 1461 N. Vulcan Ave. 835 Mosaic Circle
61 1 Venice wurt
1754 Kennington
3325 Avenida De Loyola
3441 SEACREST DR
744 N. Mar Vista Ave. 5268 Gary Street
4345 La Portalada Drive
219 4th Street
223 S. Clernentine St. Apt. C
6815 Ernbarcadero In #222
2835 Via Conquistador
3944 Syme Dr
1405 W Balboa Blvd #2 31675 Circle Dnve
679 S. Nardo Ave. 7345-8 alicante Rd 4861 Santa CNZ Avenue 1064 1R Emerald Street 2105 RUTHERFORD RD 823 Caminito Del Sol 2779 Wilson st 2467 Torrejon Place 1328 Shorebird Lane 6750 Solandra Dr. 6750 Solandra Drive
710 Carnino Del Mar
6466 Shirehall Dr
4976 Randlett
310 Cole Ranch Rd 735 SANTA PAULA 1057 Hemes Ave
1287 Cynthia Ln
1287 cynthia lane
2459 Torrejon Place
2459 Torrejon Place
12529 Oak Knoll Rd. #I8
5036 Voltaire St.
11 lillian lane
1061 Passtflora Avenue
6503 pansawla rd
pobox130992
1635 Playa Riviera Drive
650 Third St.
3813 Skyline Rd
6363 Paseo Cero
867 Marigold Ct
867 Marigold Ct
2007 Oxford Ave.
2235 Jants Way
1804 garnet ave #204
7237 Alrnaden Lane
1904 Glasgow
928 Capri Road 743 4th Street 395 Walnut Ave Apt E PO BOX 99144 1255 Manposa Road 6532 Corte Montecito
31645 Wildwood Rd
culver uty
Enunitas Santee
Enctnitas Ramona San Diego Enunitas Carlsbad Carlsbad Catlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad encinitas Middle Grove Carlsbad
Carlsbad San Marcos Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad solana beach Encinitas Enuntas Oceanside
san diego
cardiff
Oceanside
CARLSBAD
Pasadena san diego
Carlsbad
Encinitas
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad Newport Beach Laguna Beach Solana Beach Carlsbad San Diego SAn Diego CARLSBAD Carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Del Mar
San Diego
La Mesa
En u n i t a s
SOLANA BEACH
Leucadia
Carlsbad
carlsbad
Laguna Beach
Carlsbad
Carslbad
Poway
San Diego
san rafael
Leucadia
ft pierce
carlsbad Cardm by the Sea Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Cardiff Carlsbad
san diego
Carlsbad
Cardm Encinitas Encinitas Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad
2139 Cardm-By-The-Sea
Steve San Diego 3209 Parkchester Square Blvd 206 Orlando 1243 Manposa Road Carlsbad
670 Fen Way Laguna Beach 4519 Castelar Street San Diego 4476 Gila Ave San Diego
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA NY
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
R
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA CA FL CA CA
CA CA
92078 92009 760-431-5006 91730 92076
92026 92104 6195164044 92009
92123
92123 858-694-0750
901 20
92071 92007 760-944-1961 92024 760419-0977 92065 760-789-9542 92037 92024 9201 1 9201 1 9201 1 (760)602-0977 92009 92006 92009 7602716193 92006 760-473-7713 92009 7606033026 92024 6583612106 12850 92006 92006 92078 92009 760-942-8569 92009 92009 760-942-8151 92075 8569674744 92024 92024 92057
92109
92007
92056 760-622-1348
92006
91104
92115 6195823455
92008 760-729-5496
92024
92054 7602017063
92009 760-5351064
92009 415-613-2948 92006 (605) 550-6941 92661 92651 92075 92009 6565253955 92107 92109 92008 7605606718
92011 7606030756
92008 (760)525 - 4099
92009 760-634-0643
92009
92009 7605195809
92009
92014
921 11
91941 6197416674
92024 760-635-0536
92075
92024 760-635-0665
92006 7607291642
92006
92651
92009 760 717-9848
92009 760 717-9848
92064
92107
94901
92024
34951
9201 3 92007 760-230-1972 92024 310591-9776
92008
92009 760-845-4561
92009 760-804-9343
92009 760-804-9343 92007 76061 50968 92006 92109 92009 (760)930-0761 92007 760-7152706 92024 92024 92006 7802075986 92169 92009 760 931-0995 92009 760-931-9914 92107 CA 32635 92009
92651 92107 92117
92024 760-26a4393
smoiseQucsc edu
krnokalis@adelphia net
cmoln350@aol corn
bobsurf@hotmail corn
pheasantrunner@juno com CREATlVECONCEPTSSERVICES@YAHC beckyfern@aol corn
jeffreyhenson@rnydotcornaddress wrn
gregrnottor@hotrnail corn
g33v3r@]uno m
Heidi-rnontgornery@wunbde corn brnontouri@wx net iysonxyz@hotmatl corn saibrookelin@sbcglobal net mrncustompainttng@wx net bradyrnoore@san rr corn gaeamoore@grnail corn rnwrefarn5@sbcglobal net moorefarn5@sbcglobal net rkclimbergrl@yahoo wrn
allstones@hotmail corn
djSOOne~@mindSpnng win
stratovanus-mattghotmail corn dougm42gaol wm
lemoreland@att net tony@axisstudiosfm com SkiPhreaklW@grnail wrn parnorgan2@adelphia net
parnorgan2@adelphia net beau-rnorgan@hotrnail wrn jmorgans@nu edu mikejac@adelphia net sfrosel@adelphia net jim@ideapond wrn
asrntthfloral knstymorns7@yahoo wm
krnori?OOC@wx net
sgrnomson@aol corn
mattinsdjunk
rnortlaune@aol wrn
EMORTLAND@DCSHOES COM
auna rnoser@gmail wm
megrnoser@wx net
theresasvillage@yahoo wrn
brunclejoe@yahoo wrn
chnssy-mosh@rnsn corn
mouvet661 5@adelphta net
rnattmoye%@yahoo corn xphatpat@aol wrn geoff@billabong-usa wrn jrnozdzen@mozdzen wrn Irnanellef@hotrnail wrn
findjasonmueller@hotrnail corn knstinmueller-@hotrnail wm
crazywnny@gmx de drnulholland@npcurl wm rnullen3@!earthlink net tmulli@sbcglobal net AUNTPEACHQADELPHIA NET
barb munro@thecarreraagency wm
eeeeehzabeth@yahoo corn
dollyrnuoio@hotmail corn
rnurfindave@yahw wrn
roboltl@aol wrn
murfdaddyayahoo wm
anrnurphyl2ghotmail wrn
MARCCSUSMOAOL COM
murphyarl@sbcglobal net
murphino@sbcglobal net
murphino @sixglobal net
]ennlferm@pjsalvage com
solononan@yahw wm
rnurraygwjr@yahoo wm oceangirll3@sbcglobaI net
micahdread@hotmail wrn
pacwavender@wrncast net
jmuschellgkpbs org
surferdudel@@wrncast net
pontoadon@flveforty com kkoechley@hotmail wm nethan rnyers@pnrnedia corn
noaernail wm
mrnyrman@cs wm
missnikki2000@excite wm
mytelsQaol corn queen-of-xim@hotrnail wrn nakj760@sbcglobal mi GORWN-TRAVELS@YAHOO COM
dave@sundiego wm
dnrntnbk@yahoo wrn frabeawx net tsnation@yahoo wm divanaus@yahoo corn adndornainsQyaho0 corn nlmngreetu@adelphta net neiheisel@ptnoble wm dagosurf@yahoo wrn
wrbincdub@hotrnail corn
IineilsonQpacbell net
chad9000@yahw corn pmdeennelson@cox net scinerdnelson@hotmaiI corn
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1
1 1 1 1 1 0
1 1
0 1
1 1 0 1
1 0 1 1 1 1
1 0
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1
1 1 1
0 1
0 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 I 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0
1 1 1 1
Page 20
0
1
0
0
0
0 1
0
0
0
1 0 0
1
0 0 0 1 1
0 1 1 0 1 1 0
0 1 1 0 1 1 1 0
0 0 0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0 1 1 1 0 0
0 1
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0 0 1 1 0 1 1
0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 1
0
0 0
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
0 1
0 0 0
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Nelson Nelson nelson
nelson
nelson
nemish NESTRO
Nett Nett Nett Newell
Ng
Ng Nguyen
Nichols
Nichols
Nichols
Nickel
Nicodemus
nierenberg
Nigm
Niles II
Nino
nixon
nixon
Nixon
Noe
Noel
noel Noonan
Nordean
Norling
norman
Normand
Norrbom
Noms
Noms
Noms
Noms Noms
NOrlhNp Norton Novak Novkov Novosedliak Nowlin Nunez Nussbaumer Nussbaumer
Nyberg Nybo
Noel
NY- Nygaard Nylander Nystmm
OErien
OErien
OErien
OCallahan OGara OHagan
Oberg Oberlin Jr OErien OCallahan Owhialini OConnor OConnor Odd0 Odd0 Odd0 Odquist ofsledah1
Ogburn Ogrodnik ohara Ohmer ohnstad Ohrbom Olivas Oliveri
Olsen Olsen olsson
Ordas
oren
omelas
OroSS
Orliz
Orliz
Osbarn Oschin
OShea Osicki osorio
osuch Oswald Oswald
Oswald ota
0
Joshua Heather patrick marcus
barbara mike NICHOLAS Paul
Enan
Paul
Karla
Gary
Gary Jacqueline
David
Richard
Alvin ffimberley
matthew
Stacy LOUIS
Jackie
Suzanne
Zachary
Willard
Kalyn
Tibbals
Rebecca
mike
Jim
Natalie
Enc
Jeffrey Stephanie
Davd
Chnsbne
Nicole
OlY Tennyson Paul Bryce
John Mike Dave Garrett
Patnck Paga
Mynah Chris Diane
Jayna aubrey
John
Melani
Ennn
Luke Knstm
Enk
David Mike Katham
Craig Knstina Enan
Susan
Frank
Frank Karl enk Beau William
ashley Allison anders Knsty
Sandy Jana Shirley Jeff Elizabelh
maw Ryan glen
Aaron
Autumn
Rachel
Enc
Harold
ChflS
Kim Rodenck Suzanne alex
Adam
John
Aida
Keith
John
John
Ruth
Mike
Mary
J
I
k
J
V
M
A
L
E
M m
b M
T
L
k
M
C M
P
J E
J
R
M
E
T
K P
L
A
L
d
a
r
M
S V S
E
D
a
C
P
a L
L
1265 rubenstein cardm 1585 Bonnie Bluff Ct Encinitas 200 turner ave enunitas 7327 calle de fuentes carlsbad
6550 ponto dnve #131 lanikia lane carlsbad
8490 torreyanna urcle carfsbad
6550 PONTO DRIVE #I34 CARLSEAD
921 Fuchsia Lane
9559 vista Tercera 921 Fuchsia Lane
120 Canyon Creek Way 7931 Paseo Aliso 7931 Paseo Aliso
1166 Manposa Road
625 Gravenstein Hwy N #6
351 1 sixth Avenue
7439 Capstan Dnve 6792 Charford Dnve
1716 south durango avenue
131 Diana St #IO
714 Eucalyptus St
2274 Carol View Dr # D202
4131 paseo siembra
4131 paseo siembra
7320 San Earlolo
1121 Saxony Rd
1566 Lower Lake Ct
2901 Hams Dnve
715 snapdragon st
1549 vulcan #75
2637 Cacatua st
1017 Guildford Ct
1514 caudorstreet
645 Sweet Pea Place
1225 Paunc Beach Dnve
3395 Lookout Place
2129 Glasgw Avenue
2640 Madison #5
232 Delphinium St 2901 ocean Street #3N
12268 Sunnse Ct 263 La Costa Ave 1233 Caminito Septimo 3302 E Malapai Dr 608 Saltgrass Avenue 250 W Central Ave 2020 Karen Lane 2222 Eurgener Elvd 2222 Eurgener Elvd
9393 Trade Place 6442 Neddy Ave 2561 1 Bellemore Dr 5020 nightha* Way 101 o Foxglove View
1513 Grand Ave
152 wtham rd
4336 Honzon Dr 4336 Honzon Dr
7661 Sitio Fresno
1659 Haymarket Road 3200 Jams Dnve 1444 Caminito Septimo
691 Moana Dr
6536 Calle Valpenzo 1764 Whitehall Rd
2625 colibn Lane 4466 Tivoli Street 5218 Shelley PI 5216 Shelley PI 7201 Linden Terrace 7201 Linden Terrace 6455 Kingbird Lane 12469 dormouse rd 7635 nueva castilla way 6536 Ocean View St 11545 windcrest lane apt 200 653 camiiw de orchidia
602 N Cleveland St #3 1743 creekside In 1054 Wotan Dnve 7715 Corle Promenade 1242 Manposa Road 405 S Myers Street (14
405 S Myers Street (14
2720 Gregory Street
7325 Seafarer Place
7642 sitio coco
680-6 Nard0 Rd
2366 nw maser dnve
5634 Laurena Street
1627 Wilton Rd 160 N Edgemon Ave
3364 Corle Tiburon
1326 Condor Ct
603 Seagaze Dr (1424
PO 60x6113
4838 Mi Saint Helens Dr 1668 Splitrail Dnve 1666 Splitrail Dnve 5900 Nagel Street 11 0 Ave San Fernando
1621 Avocado Rd
Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad
Oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Oceanside Sebastopol San Diego Carlsbad Huntington Beach
10s angeles
Enunitas
Oceanside
Cardm
bonsall
bonsall
Carlsbad
Leucadia
Cardigg Vista
enunitas
enanitas
Carlsbad
Enunitas
enunitas
Encinitas
San Dew
San Marcos
Cardiff
Carlsbad
Enunitas Carlsbad
Poway Encinitas Cardiff Phoenix Carlsbad Erea Carlsbad San Diego San Oiego San Diego West Hills Ramona
Oceanside Carlsbad San Diego
enanitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Enunitas
Carlsbad Cardiff San Diego
Carlsbad
Enunltas Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego carlsbad Carlsbad san diego enunitas Oceansde vista Enunitas Carlsbad Carlsbad Oceanside Oceanside San Diego Carlsbad
carlsbad
Encinitas
WNaIIis
San Diego
Carlsbad Winter Spnngs Carlsbad Enunitas Oceanside Alhambra San Diego Enunitas Enunitas La Mesa
San Clemente
ca CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA Az CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
or
CA
CA FL CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
ca
92007 92024 92024 92009 760-942-2342
92029 7602504444
9201 1
92009 760-930-0422
92129 6564840153
92009 760-930-0422
92057 92009 7602502916
92009 7602502916
92009
92054 CA
95472 707-629-6689
92103
92009 92646
90035
92024
92054 760-579-3626
92007 760-487-1 103
92003
92003
92009 7609292616
92024
92007 565.410.4790
92084
92024 92024 7609430127
92OW (760)609-0847
92024 760=944-2816
92024 760-635-9019
92024
92109 6503807605
92076
92007 92006 760-720-1 146 92024 92006 92064 92024 92007 760-632-8949 85026 92009 92621 7147842032
92006 92110 658417-6015 92110
92 126
91 307
92056
92009 92109
92024
92008
92006
92009
92024 CA 92006 92007 760-402-6604 92106 92009 CA 92024 760-632-6442 92009 760-715-2376 92107 92006 92006 92006 92006 CA 92009 760-277-7707 92129 92009 760 632-1535
90250 9492260400
92128 252-5759216
92024 92054 7602241592
92061 760-402-2042 92024 92009 760-436-3133
920W 6562593923
92053
92054 92104 (619) 261-1626
92009
92009 7609431046
97330 541-753-0797
92110
92024 (760)942-3375
32706
92009
92024
91 602 921 17 858 279-3800 92024 92024 91942 92672
92009 760-438-3012
92065 760-7t18-6535
92024 619-888-5133
92054 760-458-1071
contento-perdido@hotmail.com nelhea@hotmail.com
waterman59@hotmail.com
nelson-marcus@sbcglobal.net
blnelson@adelphia.net
mnemish@adelphia.net njnest@yahoo com
paulnett@mac com
orthonet@yahoo coin
paulnen@mac. corn
kmnewell@cox net
sandiegong@adelphia. net
sandiegong@adelphia.net
jacqi-nguyen@hotmail com
dnickamac corn
rnichols@coastwalk.org
adamnichols007@hotmail.com
alnickel@adelphia.net
niwsurfln@yahoo corn
maltydn@yahoo corn
h2oak@yahoo.com
lounbr@pacbell.net
surfelnino@yahoo.com
zbnixon9@hotmail.com
zbnixon9@hotmail.com
willardnixon@yahoo corn
k-noe@uop.edu
noelit@sbcglobal.net
beckynoel@wx. net
mikesnappynoel@holmail.com highnwny@sbcglobal
nlnsaveMjc@yahoo.com
ericnorling@cox.net
jeffnonan2000@cox net
surfltl 6@yahoo.com
Norrbomt@bellsouth.net pmhb@cox net
)ohn@jnoms.uc nnonis@escsowtransfers.com espl996@yahoo.com tennyno@yahoo.com paul.nO~tNp@dlapiPer. corn bgn2@georgetown.edu johnpnovak@yahoo.com Boarder-foNrn@yahoo.com dnovosedliak @ adelphia.net
gpnawlin@hotmail.com
acnuneZl@aol.com patricknussbaurner@mac.com
pnussbaumer@yahoo.com
keitt-nyberg@yahoo.com
Myriahnybo@gmail.com
cnyce@holmail.com
dandd2@peoplepc.com
john-nylander@holmail.com
jaynany@hotmail.com
lemonhats@aol.com
jrspobrien@sbcglobal net
jrspobrien@sbcglobal net
melaniomsbcglobal.net ecocl l4@yahoo.com luke-ogara@hotmaiI.com cardiWstar1 O@hotmail.com eoberg@ucsc.edu kobedinl@holmail.com mikeadelic74@hotmail.com kati@abac. corn
ocheel3@yahoo.com obkristina@yahoo.com womesternative@yahoo.com soddo@earlhlink. net soddoQearthlink net oddoarlscaping@yahoo.com
kodquist@prometheuslabs.com
OfsteWl @csusm.edu
beauW@go.com
wogmdnik@gmail.com
ashleyohara@cox.net allisono@nofear.com anders.ohnstad@wellsfargo.com
kristy@northcoastcalvary .org
sandy@blueprintjobs corn
jo@rneisenbaChcapital.com
olsenOl6@owl csusm.edu
olsen0l6@owl.uusm.edu
lolsson@mail.sdsu edu
maryoren@aol.com
ryan@ornelas.org
glen.oross@hp.com
aarono@usa.com
mkoz2004@yahoo.com hurricanehunterl2001@yahoo.com mschin@aol.com mollyo@wirestone corn eosicki@hotmaiI.com Harold@surfree.com Chris.Osuch@westonsolutions. com oswaldk@aol.com rdoswald@aol.com sueoswald@cox.net
alex@sgmag.com
Nth@OrdaS.Wm
1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 1
1
1 1
1
1
1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
0 1
1 1 1 1 1 I 1
0 1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0 0 1
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0 1
0
0
0
0 0
1
0
0
0
0 0
1 1
0 1
0
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0 1
1 1 0
1
0
0
1
0
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0 1
? 0 0 0 1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0 0 0
0
Page 21
Ott
Ottenson Overland
overman Owen Owens Owens oziel
Paane
Pabst
Pachew
Pack
Padilla
Paffrath
pagano
Paglian
Pagnotta
Palenscar
Palenscar
Palguta
Palguta
PALMER
PALMER
Palmer
Palmer
Palmer
Papciak
Papera
Papera Papini Papini parent panzeau
Park
Parker Parker Parker Parker Parks Parton Pasinli Pasquini pastor
Pastor Pastor Pasulka Patncio Patterson
Patterson
Paulsen
Payne
Payne
Paynter
peacher Pearlman Pearson Pearson
Pease Peay
peck peck Pederson pediuni Pedicini Pedraza Peelle Peet Pelber
Pelber
Peluso
Pence Penn Penn Penton
Pentz
Pepe Peragine
Perdikomatis Perez-Monje Perkins
Perkins
Perreira
perret
Pev Perszyk Petcavich
Peters
Peterson
Peterson
Peterson
Peterson Pettx Petrakes Petrone Pezman Ffaff Ffaff Ffaff Ffaff
Ffa hl
pham
on Tim Greta M
Lacy A swn a
William T Chns Helen
Douglas
Jason
Hilary
Come
Susan M
Stephen D
Jeff M
Peter T
tommy m
Lisa
Chns A
Tom, Bonnie 8 Kai
Kai
Patnua
Matthew
mark
mark
Nicholas
GiI
Clay
Brendan
Kathryn
Came Bnan
Gina chns
karen
Jennifer
Dawda Donald
Jenntfer Reta
Craig Aleus
Deniz Sarah kyle Suzanne Carey Kathleen Lorenzo Mark Joel
Markus
Richard
June
Charlie
Jonathan Ruthann John
David Gordon Thomas david jana Mercedes lisa Michael Omar E Chns Zazie Nadine
Phil
Paul
Robert
John
Mary David
Robert
Daniel Ian Adnana Manna
Kasie
Ben Chris
Charles
Danielle
Sasha
Mark
Roger
Bnan
Dorothy
JON Andrew Susan Leslie Steve Ryan Rebecca Tyler Shane
Bngitte
moise
S
E
W
A
S
d
m
S
C
N S C
A A
E
t H F
W
M
A
P
C
G
A
J
J
E
L
z
V
C
R
P
C
M
L D A
F
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
1422 caminito Septimo Cardrff 1422 Caminito Septimo Cardiff 2251 Faraday Ave Carlsbad 767 Hymettus Ave Enunitas
370 Ocean Vew Ct Enunitas 2081 Shendan Rd Encinilas
6502 camino Del Prque Cartsbad
1055 Woodlake Dr Cardiff
1589 Tamarack Ave Carlsbad
1231 Manposa Rd Carlsbad
369 Paseo de Playa Apt 202
2643 Galiua Way Carlsbad
2021 Village Wood Rd Enunitas
645 Del Mar Downs A Solana Beach
9549 La Jolla Shores Dr La Jolla
43 chimneyndge dr wnvent station
457 Coast Blvd La Jolla
2122 Sand Crest Way 3794 Highland Carisbad
3794 Highland Carlsbad
6706 Whilesail Street Carlsbad 6706 Whilesail Street Carlsbad
10938 CLOVERHURST WAY SAN DIEGO
10936 CLOVERHURST WAY SAN DIEGO
529 Manhattan Beach Blvd A$4 B Manhattan Beach
Ventura
San Marws
4670 Pescadetu Ave # 2
6919 Sandcastle Dr
6986 shoreline
2240 Enunitas Blvd # D 41 1
3614 Ruette de Ville
664 seaward ave
664 seaward ave
1915 moreno St
2603 highland dnve
7032 Columbine Dnve
39841 Ivan Dr
39841 Ivan Dr
7538A Gibraltar Street
7767 Corte Promenade 4545 Benhurst Avenue
2424 Franusw Ave 220 1R S The Strand 1588 berkshire 1310 N Evergreen 1588 Berkshire Ct 2186 Crownhill Road 15146 Magnolia Blvd #3
345 Fulvia Street
61 5 S Cedros Ave
Markus
366 Andrew Ave
922 Galloway
8469 Paseo del Ocaso
3640 pi0 pic0 dr #c 1305 Bulrush Ct
24 hillandle
723 Matagual Dr
238 Lolita Street
5764 beaumont ave 749 crest dr 749 crest dr 813SunnchLane 2661 Segovia Way 2681 Sagovia Way 675 Oak Ave 7301 B AItcante Rd 343 Palmbark st 614 11th street 614 1 tth street 7480 Ahcante Rd 2046 Sea Village Circle 1939 Rossini Dr 7271 Spoonbill Lane 1740 Hygeia Avenue
635 Baker SI03
1774 Club Heights Lane
2822 Luuemaga si
1343 Grand ave
922 S Parton Unit B
Pachew de Melo 2586 4050 adams st 7785 Anillo Way 2858 avenida cereza 4025 Louisiana St
149 W Glaucus Apt A
6832 Town View Ln
7374 Sherwood Dnve
150 Acacia Avenue
1510 Casa Real Ln
1430 Vanessa Circle
1031 Seahorse Ct
3050 Rue D Orleans #465
6742 Solandra Dnve
2703 mackinnon Ranch Rd 191 Ave LaPata 6883 Shearwaters Dnve
6883 Sheanvaten Dnve M183 Sheamaters Dnve 5017 N Pnnceton Street
519 arden dnve
1500 Shadowndge Dr #223
605 N Rlos Ave
San Diego
Cartsbad
carlsbad
Encinitas
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
oceanside
carisbad
Carlsbad
Anza
Anza
vista
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
~ewport Beach Oceanside san marws Bumank San Marcos San Diego Sherman Oaks Enunitas Solana Beach
Oceanside
Leucadia
Pacific Palisades
La Jolla
carlsbad
Carlsbad
red bank
vista
Encinitas
la Jolla
enunitas enunitas Leucadia carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carfsbad Vista Hermosa Beach hermosa beach
Carlsbad Cardrff Cardff Carlsbad Enunitas Costa Mesa
vista Carlsbad Paufica Santa ana Buenos Aires
carisbad Carlsbad carlsbad San Diego Enunitas Sna Diego
Huntington Beach
Carlsbad
San Marws
Enunitas
Carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Cardiff by the Sea San Clemente Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Portland Solana Beach
enunitas
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
NJ
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA CA NJ CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CF
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA Or
CA
CA
92007 760-632-2216
92007 7606322216
92006
92024
92024
92024
92009
92007 760-436-5693
92008 760-729-2698
92009
93001
92009 92024
92037 858629-7851
7960
92037
92078
92008 CA
92008 760-525-6126
92009 7604087986
92130 656 720-1076
92130 658 720-1076
90266 310-545-5025
92107 619-5186058
92009 (760)438-6669
92009 9304034
92024 760-942-3363
92130 9201 1 760-436-7417
92054 92W8
92009
92539 951-551-1237 92539 92081 92009 92009 92122 6587052721 92660 92054 760-757-9669 92069
91505 6168464695 92069 6584361167 92109 (619) 525-3827 91403 92024
92075
92054 760-613-6060
92024
90272 92037
92006 92009 70-804-7374 701 92081 92024 760 944-7767 92037 619-917-1343 92024 92024 92024 760436-7012 92009 (760) 634-5077 92009 92008 (760) 720-0496 92009 92063 90254
90254
92009
92007
92007
92009
92024
92626 714-467-6048
92081 760 598 9636
92009 760-431-5759
94044 415-713-4046
92701
92075 85aw5-1oto
CA 92009
92011 760-436-7417
townyca wm
gretaott@yahoo wm
IacyoQyahoo wm
SwttOrepl@wx net
overlmanQwx net
chns@chnsowen wm
ihmowens@aol wm
dougincardrff@sbcglobal net
joziel@adelphia net
hilary paaneaadelphia net
cpabst676gyahoo win
srnpmail@adelphia net pack202l@aol wm jef-m-padilla@yahoo wm
ptpaffrathQyahoo wm
rwurfer44Qoptonline net
Ipaglian@san rr wm
cpagnotta@yahoo corn
tomQtroutpals com
kpalenscar@hotmail cam
pkpalgutagyahoo corn
matthewpalguta@hotmail wm
MPALMER222QAOL COM
MPALMER222@AOL COM
dropinlate@hotmail corn
gpalmer@polkaudio corn
claypalmer@adelphia net
papuak@hotmail wm
readwell@sbcglobal net
camepapera@hotmail wm Gpappys@adelphia net Gpappysgadelphia net
chnsn)@yahoo wm kpanzeau@sbcglobal net
jendonnelley@yahw wm
parkerphoto@aol corn anzapumps@aol wm jenparkerZ8@hotmail wm suninsd2000@yahoo wom solelyouth@yahoo wm apartonlasan rr wm dnzl82@yahoo wm gollywobble@yahoo wm mcgusto66ghotmail corn
spastorZ@earthlink net carpod30@yahoo wm
kapQprowpio wm Lpatncio79@yahoo corn mdpinsd@email wm
joelgtwsnet wm
markuspaulsen@mac wm
unccdolores@sbcglobaI net
junepaygaol wm charlie7673@hotmail wm
jonathanpeacher@adelphia net rhpearlman@aol corn
Japtainmycackofl@hotmail wm archdp03@sbcglobal net gordon@pascalsteel wm joshpeay@hotmatl wm dapgmmker wm the-pecks@sbcglobal net mercedespedersonQwx net askmeificarel668@gmaiI wm mp49@earthlink net omarp7l@hotmaiI wm evaswim@holmail wm chnspanofear wm sweetcndyz4t4Qyahoo wm
mnxagncy@yahoo wm
ppeluso3@yahoo com
ppenceQhotmail wm
rpenn222@hotmail wm
dqgpenn@adelphia net
thepentonsgwx net
davidpentz@gmail com
therobpepeyahw wm
danperagine@aol wm perdiko@wmcast net aDerezmonie~sbmlobaI net 2425 005411-4605-9870 perkinstatiyahoo wk ar
92054 alwayslove777@hotmaiI wm
92009 carverb@hotmail wm
92009 chns perret@windnver wm
92104 usc2000@gmail wm
92024 dperszykOl@yahw wm
92120 squashapolo@hotmail wm
92646 714 375-9755 mpetershb@socal rr wm
92008 760-434-5635 k38roger@yahoo com
92069 redbuffalosurferQyahoo com
92024 760-753-4093 DPeterson@qualigeninc corn
92009 jonplO3lQhotmail wm 92110 ATPnoB@netscape net 92009 760-461-8165 susanpetrakes@adelphia net 92007 760-753-9300 lespetronegaol wm 92673 949 361 0331 steve@surfersjoumal corn 92009 760-931-6256 ryanpfaff@adelphia net 92009 760931-6258 rebeccap7lghotmail corn 92009 760-931 6258 mooseattacktyler@yahoo wm 97203 971-455-4585 spfaffgup edu 92075 '58 7553982 GinalO@adelphia net
92024 7606331984 mosiegwx net
1 1
1 1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
I
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1 1 1 1
1
1
1 1 1
0
1
1
0 1 1
1 I 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 0
1 1 1 1 1 I 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 I
1
1
0 1
0
1
0
0 1 1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 0 0
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
0 1
1
0
0 1 1 1 1
1
0
0 0 0 1 0
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0 0 1 1 0 0
0 0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0 0 0
0 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 1
1 0
0
0
0
Page 22
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
phelps Phillips
Picken Pickrell ptckren PlWU
Pierce Pierce Pierce
Pierro Pike Pike PILKINGTON
Pillsbuiy
Pinwck
Pine Pinkard pirawi
PlVO Plassrneyer Pieso
polonitza
Polster
Poole poosty Porter Poser Posey
Possell
Potash
POtts
Poukkula
Pounds Pounds
Powell
Power
Powers Pravato
Pregerson Prentice Preston
Price Pnce Pnebe
Pnrnes Pnnce Pnnce Pntchard
Pntchett Prosser Pmuse Pmvenzano Pmvenzano
PNssack
prvanov
Pszo tka
Purdy
Pyle Pynes
Quart
Quick
quinlivan
Quinn
auinn
quinn Quisenberiy Raceles
Raddrffe
Rafael Rafter Ragland Ralph Rarney Rarney rarnier Rarnirez Rarnsey rarnuno Randall Randall Raney Ratcliff Ralhbun
Rau Rausa rawluk
Ray rayburn Rayray
Rayray Read
Reardon
rector Redela Redfern Redhair
Redhair
Reding
phllllps
pltt
POBLANO
PUNIS
daniel Patncia stephen Bnan Melissa rnichael
Robert Diana Robert
L Micheal Darren Bill
CHAD
Jillian Amanda Heather Deanna antonio
Bnan
Lon Heather Dana RENEE
lard Lew Peter taryn Ted Kurt David
Wiley Andrew
Kevin
Joel
Chns
Mananne
laune
Ellen Chns
Heather Sarah
Jeff
mark came Jonathan
Kathleen Robert Mlchelle Chnstopher Tyler Sheena Andrew Prouse Sarah Gina
Joe Cathy Dalrna
Margaret
JOe Dan
Susan
Knstine
India
Paul
Kevin
Jim
elise
Ken
TMl
David
William Patnck Rebecca Robert Mike
DNe
Sheree
Rechelda Manlyn
ben Elizabeih Joseph
peg
Jeff
Gary Gary Jeff Bettina mike Ttrn david Gabnel
Patnck
Karen Michael
robert
MEchael Chns Cynthia Richard
KV
g
J
P
E V
L W
S
R
I
E J
K
M
A
J
R
C
D
A A hO
L M
C J
J
S
C S
L
K A
L e M
C A A
L
D
E
R
d
t
S
L
P r
W
A
13714 pine needles dr
PO box 60 8469 Paseo del Ocas0
934 St Albans Dnve 4626 sevilla way 6640 Tanglewood Rd 4055-4 Harrison St 6576 Red Knot St
1650 Pentas Ct 145 Chinquapin Ave 421 Delage Dr 19 Old Milford Road 3481 PECAN ST 1652 Eolus Ave 165 Norfolk Dr
4705 Manna Ave 1624 NCoast Hwy 101 #I8
5218 rnilton rd 1225 Pacific Beach Dnve #l-L
3450 Paseo Ancho 7305D Alicante Rd 6061 Paseo Salinero
3650 HIBISCUS CIRCLE 221 n siem 302 Sanford Street 30843 Bardrnore Dnve
Taryn 906 Orchid Way
6736 blue point dnve 1381 N Vulcan B
7059 Vallean Ave 7384 FayAve 25 SE 143
Joel
7066 Montanes lane
7066 Montanes lane
7401 Magellan Street
1757 Gaswny Rd
7063 Rockrose TeK
521 Wind Sock Way
3734 saddle dnve 6749 Lonicera Street 2361 Newport Ave 416 suoth granados ave 1537 Independence Way 1437 Tzena Way
612 Mansa Lane 1006 Cottage Way 1006 Cottage Way 1663 Linbrook Dnve 1616 Hope ST
656 Vine St #21 PO Box 231846 2636 Ocean Front Walk 6306 Carntnito Juanico
303 West D Street
6575 mndflower dnve
2309 Levante st
3795 Monroe St
1141 Reed ave
136 Coop Ct
2746 lnverness Dnve
3273 Violet Ridge
455 Cole Ranch Rd
643 solana glen ct
1706 Eolus Avenue
2717 York Road 2166 Avd Toronja
6754 Wahl Street 32603 aden circle
11595 Carninito La Bar#12
1955 Seabreeze Court 7623 Exchange PI
6415 Merlin Dnve 3665 Light Horse Loop 11 30 Rangeview Rd 11 30 Rangeview Road 7040 whitewater street 4459 Fanuel St, Apt 11 1262 Plum Tree Rd 1609 debann mad 2361 Oxford Ave 1442 Dolphin Ct
160 Walnut Ave Apt A 2340 Terraza Ribera 4615 N Park Ave Apt 511
1600 burgundy rd 6234 Rorno Street 716 rnunevar rd
2419 34th St
5262 wohlford street 7260 Tail Street
407 Sandahvwd Dr
1674 Calliandra Road
1969 Emerald Street
pobox230761
1834 East 4391 Moraga Avenue 7237 San Bentto 7237 San Benito 1046 Gardena Rd
6423TobnaTerrace#104 del mar Carlsbad cardiff La Jolla
Leucadia carlsbad San Diego
Carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad
Carlsbad Enunitas Mont Vernon IRVINE Leucadia Cardiff by the Sea Cads b a d Enunitas carlsbad San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad CARLSBAD solana beach
Leucadia Ternecula Cadsbad Carlsbad Cadsbad Enunitas
Van Nuys La Jolla
Portland
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Cadsbad
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carl s b a d
carlsbad Carlsbad cardiff solana beach Vista Enunitas
Enunitas Enunitas Enunilas San Diego San Marws Oceanside Encinitas San Diego San Diego
Encinitas
carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
Leucadia
Dnve
Encinitas
Enunitas
solana beach
Emfas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Santee
ternecula
San Diego
Enunitas La Jolla
Cadsbad Virginia Beach vista Vista carlsbad San Diegoq Carlsbad cardiff Cardiff by the Sea San Marws Carlsbad Carlsbad Chevy Chase Encinitas
San Diego
cardlff
San Diego
oceanside San Diego
Aptos
Carlsbad
San Diego
encinitas
Enunitas San Diego Cadsbad
Carlsbad
Encinitas
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
OR
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA VA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA MD
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
ca
92014 (658) 945 5450 92009 760-918-1675 92007 92121 8589223081 92024 760-632-0549 92008 92111 92006 92009 760 6891264 9201 1 92006 (760) 560-2942 92024 760-632-1561
3057 6036725176
92606
92024 92007 92006 92024 92006 7606049727
92109 656-273-0137
92009 92009 438-2291 92009 92008 (760) 518-4453
92075 619-417-9006
92024
92592
92007 CA 92009 92009 7604316465
92024 760-615-5369
91406 6187851151
92037
97233 503-262-52
92117 CA
92009 760-930-4091 92009 760-930-4091 92011 760 431 2814 92024 760-5356214 9201 1 760-431-2021 92009
92010 92009 760-931-9950 92007 92075 92084 92024 92024 92024 92024 921 11 858-874-1982
92078 92054 760-717-2464
92109
92111 92024 7608758070
92009 92009 7604355941 92006 760-729-0437 92109 6194592369 92024 92006 760-729-81 14 92024
92024
92075 92024 760-436-4404 92008 7604701216 92009 760 753-1881 92071 6195725257 92592
92 126 92023 (760)612-2000 92037 92009 23453
92084 7604584876 92009 7606039046 92109 9201 1 92007 92007 92076 92008 760-720-1667 92009 20615
92024 17607536775
92115
92007 760-753-2217
92 104 92056 92111 510-366-9248
95003
92009 760 431 6993
92109
92023 760-942-9201
92024 921 17 92009 (760) 602-0566 92009 (760) 602-0566
92024 61 9-339-3996
92023 658-755-6306
92084 760-941-3681
loperphelpsgyahoo corn artsavesltvesgadelphia net sphilltps66ghobnail corn bpickettgkintera corn Melissa Pickrell@djortho corn unboundvoi@yahw corn cahsurfel923gyahoo corn dianapterce@adelphta ne1 wltnpiercegaol corn none
danungbw222gyahoo corn darren-pikearnsn corn infogmlliarnpikedestgn corn
CHADPILKINGTONgMAIL COM
thedoughboygsbcglobal net pcvarnandagyahoo wrn
heatherpinegaol wrn
Deanna Pinkardanoaa gov
tpiramgadelphia net
bnan-pittghotrnail wrn
Ipivogguidant corn hjplassgsbcglobal net
dplesogsbcglobal net
quotes@anythingirnpnnted wrn
jpolonttzagadelphia net
drurnsinsidegyahoo corn
peter@rnountpalornar win
chekachekeleagyahoo wrn
cbadsurfr@aol wrn
kurtgtheposerfarnily wrn
dposeygdiefaster wm
wileygpossenwnst wrn
a-potashgyahoo wrn
pottskevgyahoo wrn
JoelPouk@pacbell net
gondrue@aol wm golferdruegaol wrn rnopowell@adelphia net Ilpower@sbcglobal net ernp233gaol wrn cpravatogadelphia net hpregersonghotrnail wm ssprenticegyahoo wrn jpresto5lgyahoo wm mark pnc-reef wrn Pncefarnily4@wx net jon2274gaol wrn
pnrnes5gsbcglobal net Rober@Pnnce-usa wrn
echobelli@hotrnail wm
pntchardswtt@hotmaiI win
tylerpntchett@hotrnail corn
xsheenax@grnail wm
houseofprouseghotrnail wrn
salprol3ghotrnail com ginapml gyahw corn
cathyprvanovgyahoo wrn
dalrnapgnofear wrn
rnargiegPurdyhornes wrn joe@beachandutyrealty wrn koalanighotmail wrn pynesgadelphia net kquartgaol wrn iquickgcalpoly edu paul e quinlivan@biola edu krnichaelquinngyahoo wrn
elisequinn@adelphia net kkquizgyahoo wrn tawnirnaR6grnsn wrn Mudhed69gyahoo wrn brafaelgrnsn wm patnckrafterlghotmail wrn beckyragland@pacbell net jspdaddy@aol wrn ramey33gaol wrn SRAMEYg BlakeSales net
rarniergadelphia net RecheldaLRarnirez@yahoo wrn
rrnramsey@adelphia net
benrarnunoghotrnail wm home-tundrahgyahoo wrn joey randallgwx net
jeffraneygearthlink net ratcliffgrgadelphia net grath03gyahoo wm
Surf4jc200Z@holrnail wrn
brausagwx net
rawlukrngyahoo corn
Brn raygngc wrn
brnone72gyahoo wrn
BattalionOlOgaol wrn
patnckrayrayghotrnail wrn
kare readaeds wrn
reardonrntke@hobnail corn
mectorgterrasonics corn
rnikegredela wrn redfern@sandiegoaudubon org credhatr@pacbell net
credhair@pacbell net
kyredingghotrnail wrn
jpNS@hOf~ail Corn
jhqiv@yahoo wrn
1
1
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1 1 1
0 1 1 1 1
1 1 1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
0
1
t
1
1
1
1 i 1 1 1 1 1
1
1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1 0 t
1
1 1
1
1 0 1
0
1
0
0
1
1
1
1 0
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
t
1 1 1 0 0 0
0 0
1
0
1
0
1 1
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1 1
1 0 1 1
1 1 0 0 0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0 0
1 1 1 0 0
1 0 0 0
0
1
1 0 0 0
0
0
t 0 0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0
1 0 0
1
0 1 1 0
Page 23
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Redman
Redmon
Reed
Regan
Reid
Reid
reineman
Reingruber
retman
Reher
Revchuk
Revier
Rex
Reyes
Reynaga Jr
Reynolds
Rhead
Rhead
nch
Richard
Richardson
nchardson
Richardson
Richdale
nchter Rickens
Ricklefs
Reusch
Katie
Jimmy
Rob
Will
Ronald
Jim
dan
Holly
Wendy
Dennis
Olga
Richard
Albert
Ronald
Daniel
Barbara
Edward
joseph
Colin
Elaine
andrew
Jesseca
Emily
Jesse David
Craig
gem
Cary
Ricks Julie-
Ridder-St. Marie Jeannette
Rider
ndpath Riggle Riis
Riker
Riley
Riley
Rillera nsser Rissi Riston
nvers Rlx
REO
Roath
Roberson
Roberts
roberts
roberts
roberts
Roberlson
Robinson
Robinson
Robinson
robinson
Robinson
Robison Robles Robles Robona Robson
Roche Roche
Rock
Rodelander
Rodewald
Rodgers
Rodgers
Rodriguez
Roff
Roff
Rogers
Rogers
Rogers
Rojas
Roland
Rolfes
Roman
Rornaneli
Romero
roney
roo
Root
Root
Rosa Rosales Rosales
Rose Rose Rosenberg Rosenkranz Rosenthal Ross Ross Ross Ross
Ross
ross
Rossman
Roth
Roubitchek Rouleau
James
Nichola
Beth
Julia
Gina
Chnstine
Daniel Suzanne Missi Jenn
deb Barbara
Jonathan
Michelle
Evans
Samantha
kelly
Ursula
James
scon
Gabnel
Mark
jack
Sarah
Dana John Alex Lee Anne Chns
Jim Lisa Angela
Leslie
Chns
Bnan
Marland
Jessica
Crystal
Brad
Thomas
Jarmd
Carey
Richard
Alison
Mary Chnstina
LUIS
Lon
shea
Jennifer
Penelope
Richard
Janice
Man
Ruben
Barbara Frednc Phillip Diane
Sara
Richard
A I I y s o n David David Wendy
Seth Chns
Bradford
LOUIS
bertrand
wry
J
S
r
R
a
S
H
A
D
b
H
G
d S
r
S
W
A
J
C
I M
L
M
L
D
I
M
T
E
R
T
B
K
C
M
C
C
J
A
A
F
A m
M
A
L
C
L
E S M
L
L
J W
T
a
2644 San Marws Ave
2536 Unicornio Street
3203 Calle Vallarta
134 Daphne Street
22 Los Tranws Dr
1311 Sunset Cliffs Blvd
414 sea ndge dr
680-8 Nardo Rd
225 south granados ave
3645 Nautical Dnve
2112 Bulrush Lane
643 Dawson Ave #3
512 Stem Way
6450 Tomyanna Circle
7657 Whitewater Dr
6431 Alexandn Circle
864 Salem Street
3512 Woodland Way
3946 Long PI
8040 La Jolla Shores Dr #D
4605 Castelar St
716 San Dieguito Dr
572ahermesave
1231 Caminito Septimo
924 Begonia Court
3332 harding st apt D
762 S Sierra
6655 Daylily Dnve
760 Clark Ave
907 Alyssum Rd
3534 Ridgewood Way
1201 gold flower rd
1242 Plum Tree
2219 Corle Cicuta
1742 Ceeus Court
3391 Tournament Dr
566 Halalai Street
I337 Maple Leaf Dr 2310Altisma way #230 2335 Cannga Way #20 2000 S Melrose Dnve 6411 Merlin 921 San Dieguito Dr 2605 McGaw Avenue 30903 del rey rd 1640 Scott Place
961 N VulcanAve #8
6617 caminito sueno
6617 caminito sueno
6617 camcnito sueno
116 west glaucus street
3831 Mount Aladin Avenue
2637 Valewood Ave
7074 Pnmentel Lane
513 sunset dnve
4705 Manna Dr #6
145WElNortePkwyX215
7021 Leeward St 234W IOthAve 7069 SurfDird Circle 1515 Summit Ave 7456 Capstan Dr 7456 Capstan Dr 4134 Lyrner Dr 5500 Campanile Dnve
760 Teabeny Street
1428SapphireDnve
1390 Buena Vista Way
777 Manhattan Beach Blvd
1525 Avd La Posta
4 lakeview dnve west
4010 Layang Layang unit E
756 York Ct
344 La Veta Ave
521 Luneta
1551 Tres Hermanas Way
2042 Mar Azul Way
2424 La Plancha Lane
6726 Amherst ST
6705 Barberry Place
922 edwna way
247 centennial parkway north
450 Summerview Circle
450 Summerview Circle
7611 Calle Lornas
6695 NardoAve
2466 Chaucer Place
1833 Palisades Dr
366 River Ranch Way
501 Halsing Court
4751 Wailapa Road
11 772 Camel Creek Road #I08
2252 Via Apnlia #6
1706 Pacific Beach Dnve
P 0 Box 690 P 0 Box 890 3696 Alamo Dnve 231 Avenida Pelayo #A 1734 Schooner Way 1507 Rubenstein Avenue
3347 Avenida Nieve
6937 Beagle SI San Diego
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Leucadia
lrvine
San Diego
la jolla
Encinitas
solana beach
Carlsbad
Cardiff
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Huntington Beach
Carlsbad
Vista
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
La Jolla
San Diego
Encinitas
encinitas
Cardiff
Carlsbad
carisbad
Solana Beach
Carlsbad
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
carlsbad
Carl s b a d
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Oceanside
Kihei
Carlsbad
carlsbad
La Costa Carlsbad
Carlsbad Enunitas lrvine Temecula Enunitas
Enunitas
carlsbad
carlsbad
carlsbad
enunitas
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
oceanside
Carlsbad
Escondido
Carlsbad
Escondido
Carlsbad
Cardiff
Carlsbad
Carlsbad San Diego San Diego
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Manhattan Beach
Encinitas
montague
Carlsbad
San Diego
Enunitas
San Luis Obispo Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
cardiff
ha milt on
Encinltas
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Solana Beach
Thousand Oaks
Carlsbad
Oceanside
Carl s b a d
Wlauea
San Diego
Del Mar
San Diego
Rancho Santa Fe
Rancho Santa Fe Vacaville
San Clemente
Carlsbad Cardiff Carlsbad
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
HI
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA
ca ca ca
ca
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA NJ
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
on CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
HI
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
92104 CA
92009 760-436-2302
92009
92024
92617
92107 619-2254031
92037
92024
92075
92008
92007
921 15
9201 1
92009
92646 714-669-4363
92009
92084
92006 6053350
92006 8053350
92037
92107 6198713708
92024
92024 7606352567
92007
92009 7609298338
92006 760-667-5762
92075 619-733-9735
92009
92009
92008 760-717-3447
92009
9201 1 760602-0343
92009
92009
92056 760-603-2393
96753
92009
92009
92061
92009 9311460 92024 92612 92591 92024 760-943-7764
92009
92009
92009
92024 760-757-3147
92111
92006 7606724532
92009 760 604-0729
92054 7602317964
92008 7607201146
92026
92009 925325-9744
92025
92011 CA
92007
92009
92009 92116 92120 92024 92009
92006 (760) 277-2383 90266 92024 7627
92006 760-729-4716
92109
92024
93405 92024 92009 760-476-3596
92009 CA
92009
92007 (510) 912-1654
92024
92024
92009
92075 6167958507
91362 616-620-7484
92006 760-730-3296
92057 760-231-9029
92011 760-822-7231
96754 608-651-5197
92130
92014
92109
92067 658-756-1161
92067 658-756-1161
95667
92672 760-717-6762
93008 92007 760-436-2632 92009-933 760-436-4956 92111
92024 858336-8995
92009 760-43a9318
92024 85a254-1330
92115 858-531-5555
196~7
ktredrnanacox net wakegunraaol corn robreed55@hotrnail corn
wregan5l@hotmail corn
ronreid54ayahoo corn
jimnnob@cox net
dreinernanayahoo corn
holly reingruberagrnail corn gemaoppersports net
rnwretzer@pacbell net
marden2aadelphia net
orevchukakpmg mm
ronck512@sbcglobal net
alrex43@adelphia net
pnphrlayahw com
dreb007aadelphia net
caryarnddonline corn
brheadapacbell net
brheadapacbell net
brandonchgyahoo wm
lobstertree@hotmail com
SunstarShilohs@aol com
drew1 7@wx net
jesseca-rahotmail wm
enchdale@gmail corn
~nchten35@yahoo corn
davensiv@sbcglobal net
crncklefs@hotmail corn
julie-ncks@hotrnail wm
strnanesj@adelphia net
jiminder@sbcglobal net
gsndpath@sbcglobal net
nicholanggle@adelphia net
tirnnisQaol corn
CRikerlaaol corn
gnleyQisisph corn
RileyMauiNaluaaol
dnlleraasandiego edu
rnzlclttygadelphia net
rnissiranofear corn
justjenn22ayahoo corn
debnversaaol corn nxgraphix@cox net angiapjsalvage corn jrsloth247@aol wrn pmichellr@adelphia net
elr3l@hotmail wm
goIfingirl24@?yahoo corn
insh-dancer-kelly@yahoo corn
ursula900@yahoo wm
lokbox@sbcglobal net
scottQsirreall com
gabnelrobinsonahotmail corn
freediveaearthlink net
jacko95@cox net
srobin33@yahoo com
danalynn-robison@?yahoo corn
roblesjraadelphia net
ratboarderl 3@hotmail corn
larnsll2@sbcglobal net
y-robson@yahw wm
]irnroche@adelphia net
lisarochegadelphia net msrock2Qyahoo wm IrOdelandW@prOJectS sdsu edu barlikova@gmail corn
hvssouthapacbell net danungbw222@yahoo wrn pineapplefusion@hotrnail corn cmd@adelphia net Anarchykd4ahotmail wm tqwr@earthlink net
jrogers@polexis com
careypgers@hotmail wm
art4frog@hotrnaiI corn alison@jdssc corn maryrolfesaprodigy net
ckrornanQadelphia net
surftotal@hotmail corn
lon@matnxdsl wm
encpunk@yahoo wm
jenroo56@hotmail wm pensplaceajuno wm
pensplace@juno corn
janice rosaancrnc corn
man rosalesanoaa gov
rubenwreyayahoo corn
brose363aadelphia net
bnngit04@mx net
psrosenberg@adelphia net
crazykranzayahoo corn
kickbox-chica @hotmail wrn
nchardlrossahotmail wm
allyrnross@hotrnail wm
david j rossasrnilhbarney corn
david j ross@srnithbamey wrn
lucky713ca@aol corn
utopiatool@cox net
crossman@robodesign wm broth@cox net LTRinENCQAOL Com brouIeau-O3@sandiego edu
1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0 1 0
1 0 1 1
0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 1 0 0 1 1
0 0 0 0 1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0 1 1 1 0
Page 24
Roulette Routly rowells ' rowky
Rubenstein
Rubie
Rubin RUff Nle
Rupert Russell
Nsseil
Nssell
Nssell
Russell
Russell Russo Russo
Rutherford
ROY
NSSO
Ryan Ryan Ryan, M.D.
Ryba Ryba Rynski
sablan
Sablan
Sablan Sacchetti
Sadoski
sage
saggese
Sagunsky
Saisho
Saiz sakelliou
salas Sales Salornon
Salva Salzrnann Samaniego Sarnann SAMPSON sampson Sanchez sandberg sandera
sandera
Sanderson
sanntom
santos
Sam0 saunders
savage
Savage-Cairns Savoie Savran
saw
SWdY Scales Scarda Schaefer SCHALL Schectel Scher Scherler scheyer schissler
Schliff
schluntz
Schluntz Schrnauss
Schrnerler
Schmid Schmidt Schmidt Schmidt
Schmitt
Schnack
Schnack
Schneir
Schoaff
SchOll Schorle
Schorle
Schorle
Schrader Schreder
Schuh Schulte Schulh schultz SCHULZ
SchUlZ schulz
SChUPP Shah
schwaner
Julie Enn Jason philip Roberta
Laune Kathy Melanie
chns
Bnan Tonya clayton
heather
knsbe Jennifer Russell Leanne Pasquale
nathan
Sean Timothy Barbara Sean Mike
Dominique
Steven
ernelyne Brenton
Ricky
Craig
Jennifer
Carleton
Gian
Gary Theresa
Denise
dino stevie Evangelina Leah
Spencer Philip Elaina June JAMES Kevin Ralph alexa linda
linda
Julie
Anna
Walter
Laura
lUlS David
Allison
Rhell
Enn smn
Gwg
Baml
Mary
Nick Jack Juliana
JILL Anna rnelinda Kurt neal mate Rob [esse Jeremy Jody Jurgen Scott Chnstina
LLizane Lawrence
JOe Judith Dalton lleese Michael
CalhV
And;ea
ffiana Ekkehard
Ann Man
Tracy
Joan Brandee drew
JURGEN kim
bob Salomi Roman
monica
SCHWEINBERGI DALE
I
P
A S J
a
I
h rn
a
L
C
R
a
C
B
C
T D
E
C
K S
E C
A M
m
A
G i
J
M
a
M L
A
J
J
R
G
D
M
M L e
i a
a
3746 Garden Lane
PO box 4274 2415 Stevens urcle 91 1 arden dr 4767 IL? 32nd Street 620 w Mountain Avenue 2394 Maravilla Way
7034 Columbine Dr 7258 San Luis 959 diamond street 51 39 Delaney Court 1562 Division St
3264 bayside lane 357 chestnut ave 113 2231 edinburg ave 209 Sanford St
1620 Traveld Way
6922 mimosa dnve 1331 Evergreen Dr 616 devon cl 962 Dumitz Dnve 704 Seabnght lane 47 10 Garrield St 4886 Coronado Avenue
1593 Jonathon St 1593 Jonathon S1 6677 Camabon Dnve 4862 sevilla way
4862 Sevilla Way
4662 Sevilla Way
13422 Utopia Road
4464 New Jersey St
1368 Peachwood Dr
2316 via Platillo
2153 Corte Moral
6743 Blue Point Dnve
544 Big Sky Dnve
9660 chesapeake dnve
4705 manna dr
11 44 aloha Dnve 5949 W Country Ave
3932 6th Avenue
356 Dublin Dr 850 3rd St 6707 Camino Del Prado 3497 PASEO FLAMENCO 6155 cargill Ave 1133 1034 Orpheus Ave 1234 happy Street 4051 vista calaveras
4051 vista calaveras
P 0 Box232626
4009 fanuel st
PO box 131434
1751 Eucalyptus Ave
503 rudder avenue
2007 Santa Fe Ave
6006 Paseo Esmerado
1104 Knoll Park Lane
6061 Paseo Arrayan
440 puebta st 125 Hillcrest Dr 260 Coneflower St 583 Via Armado 1445 Hyrnettus Ave
140 EAST GLAUCUS STREET
639 Hillhaven 7244 carpa court 1141 Cem Largo dr 404 endnitas blvd 367 Nautilus 456 E Glaucus St
993 north vulcan #4
925 Woodlake Dnve
742 Munevar Road 12237 Camel Vista Rd 2009 Mackinnon Ave 595 Park Lane 2116 Meadowlark Ranch Circle 7316 San Luis St 2230 J Street #7 354 East Glaucus St 354 E Glaucus St 7693 Sitio Mirto
14375 Gerona Court 2716 Socorro Lane
362 Acaua apt k 382 Acaua apt k 434 Village Run East 924 Anatra Court 926 Rosemary Ave
2433 Impala Dr
6621 Alderwocd Dnve
603 Bluewater Road
1973 freda lane
7037 LEEWARD ST
7432 salano st
7432 solano st 7777-111 Carninilo Monarca 641 Isthmus Ct 3773 via cabnllo 1310 La Mirada Ave
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
San Diego Banff carlsbad enunitas San Diego Fort Collins Ocsanside
Carlsbad Carlsbad san diego Carlsbad Galways san diego
carlsbad
cardiff Leucadia
Enunitas carlsbad Cardiff
san diego San Diego Solana Beach Carlsbad San Diego vista vista Carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad
PWY San Diego
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Oceanside
san diego
carlsbad enunitas Visalia
San Diego Cardiff Enunitas Carlsbad SAN CLEMENTE San Diego Enunitas carddf oceanside
oceanside
Leucadia
San diego
carlsbad
Enunitas
carlsbad
Del Mar
Carlsbad
Fallbrook
Carlsbad
encinitas Encinitas Encinitas Chula Vista
Leucadia
LEUCADlA San Marws Carlsbad Solana Beach enunitas La Jolla Encinitas enunitas Cardiff Cardiff San Diego Carddf Enunltas San Marws Carlsbad Sacramento
Leucadia Enunitas
Carlsbad
San Dtego
Carlsbad Cads b a d
Carlsbad
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad carddf by the sea CARLSBAD carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego
oceanside
Eswndido
CA AB CA CA CA co CA CA CA CA CA NY
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
92106 403 609 0976 92006 760-434-5534 92024 92116 619-584-0703 60521 92056
92011 (760) 931-0516
92109 656-270-1711
92006 7609291297 12074 92109
92006
92007 7606355617
92024 760-635-9335
92024 760-753-9449 92009 92007
921 09
921 96 92075 CA 92008 92107 92063 7607165673 92063
92009 760-310-4016
92006 92006
92006
92064
921 16
92024
92009 7604769604
92009 760/942-9737
92009 7609169332
92054 7606057562
92123 6565143600
92006 310261 7769 92024 93277 92103 92007 7609429261 92024 92009 760.603.7920 92672 949-4961455 92122 656-964-0751 92024 92007 1234567 92056 760-941-3604
92056 760-941-3604
92023 760-632-0335
92109 6195406242
9201 3 760-602-9204
92024 760-634-3033
92009 760-804-1968 92014 6567554624
92009 (760) 944-6654
92-26 760-966-6359
92009 92024 760.402.6272 92024 619-370-5194 92024 760-420-0449 91910 619-656-1655 92024 92024 92068 92009 760-943-6167 92075
92037 92024 92024 7606344673 92007 92007
92130 92007 92024 92076 92009 760-579-8645 95616 (760)445-5210 92024 760-753-6168 92024 92009 760-632-6997 92129 (856) 942-5817
92009 92009 (760)505-1755
92009 (760)522-9047 92024 (760)753-6860 92009 760-918-9863
92009
92006 92009
92009
92007
9201 1 760.436 7696
92009 944-7923
92009 944-7923 92009 92109 92056 760-753-9220 92025501 760-471-6742
TIL 1 E6
92011 760 gie-gioi
92024-6709
Roulette@sandiego edu er-shiatsu@yahoo corn jrowells@adelphia net therowleyrnan@yahoo corn
mbertapauline@yahoo com
barryNbenQyahoo corn
Irnn99@yahoo corn
krobbins@ternplesolel net
MJRuMQcs corn
carul-san rr wm
Nperts@adelphia net
hypster66@yahoo com
IifeguardsdQyahoo wm
knsbeinsd@hotrnail corn
Jendasiar@hotrnail corn
ncbleann@pacbell net
Nssofarnly@aol corn russo546@holrnail corn nathanarusso@hotmail corn
xsurfxburnx@yahoo corn timmytar@hotrnail corn
barbararyansrnailQyahoo corn
doc-ryan@hotrnail corn
REEBSLURES@COX NET rndrybaayahoo corn
ryn-steve@yahoo corn
sablan5Qhoirnail corn
rebelbsQhotrnail corn
SurferRicky@hotrnail corn
craigsac@hotrnail wm
surfnsoccerl Qyahw com
crs@activb corn
csaggese@pacbell net
gerysagun@adelphia net
tksorders@yahoo com denisessaiz@rnsn corn
dino sakelliou@reef wrn stevie@steviesalas corn esales25@aol corn beachchic31 3@aOl corn seasunsurf@grnarl com Phil-salzrnannasd vrlx corn zenshiatsu77@hotrnail corn parnann@adelphia net SAMPSONUSAQCOX NET Ksarnpson@gmail wm lumpalumpal 23@yahoo corn blondepnncess24@sbcglobal net
Iindasandera@yahoo corn
Iindasandera@yahoo corn
RockylZ@wx net
annasantoro@hotrnail corn
brosant@aol com
Idsarno@cox net
luis saunders@adelphia net surfsavages@rnsn corn
ASavageGD@aol corn rhell@surfdsi corn esavran@sbcglobal net rf@sawbladedesign corn gsawdyl@yahoo corn nickscales@cox net jacksd@hotmail corn julie2rowQhotrnail corn JLSCHALLaAOL COM annadl963@hotrnail wm rnscherl@adelphia net vecsafe@yahoo corn swops4fun@hotrnail wm rnatay-nicole@yahoo corn
mb@smartlending wm
captaincarro155@hotmail win
jererny SchluntzQpnrnedia wrn
jody@twsnet corn
jschrnerler@deepskysofare corn
Iivit4u@hotmail mn
kandchornback@cox net
IlizaneQcs corn lschrn3317@aol corn
~schrnitl71 l@hotrnail wrn
judyschnack@wx net
schnackacox net
ischneir@adelphia net
schoaff@sbcglobal net
a~nachala22Qyahw corn
none
no email
ekke schorle@sbcglobal net
arnschrader@rnac corn
schredderZl@yahw wrn
tracy-schuhQwestonsolutlons com Joan SchullegEnglekirk wm brandees@wirestone corn pnrnordialsoup@rnsn corn JURGENQK5 COM kschulz@eusd k12 ca us bomarnigopnnt wrn satorn@inorbrt corn mrnan@schwabbmthers wm
rns4surf@cox net
Dale@TheCornputer corn
hmNSSell@~dCh corn
1 0 1
1
1 0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1 t
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0 1 I 1 1 0
1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 I
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
1 1 1
1
1 1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
1
1
0
0 1 0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
1 0
0
0
0
1
1 0
0 1
0 0
0 0 0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 1
0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0 0 0 1
0
1
1
0 0
1
1
1
1 1 0
1
1
1 1 0
0
0
Page 25
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
scorn scon Scully scurlock
Seal seale Sears-Wiley
SEBASTRN
Seckendorf
Seckendofi
seddig
See Seed
SeRel
Segovia
Segovta Seibert
seid
Seip IV Sekch
SELIK Sennis Servals Seva
Severson Seymour Seymour Shaeffer Shaffer Shaffer Shaken Shakter Shapiro Shanf Shaker Shaw Shaw Shay Shems
Shepard
sheptak
Shenf
Shigenaga
shipman
Shobe
shoffler
Shores
SHORTER
Shnner
SHULL shur Shur Shur Shvodian Stddons Silber Silbert Silverman
Silverman
Silverman
Simeone
Simmons Simmons
Simmons
Simms
SIMON
Simondes
Simons
Simons
Simpkins
SIMPSON
Simpson
Sincfair
Sinclair
Sirota Strota
sisco Siva Skaff Skaff Skee sknvseth Slade Slater Slattery Sledd Slevinske Smiddy Smiley Smith Smith SMITH Smith Smith
Smith
Smith
Smith
Smith Smith Smith Smith
SlPP
Teml Kevin
Audra
carol
Donna
tiffany
Elizabeth
RACHEL
Paul
T
robell
Jack
Elizabeth JeSSica Nenssa Ethan James rob
St e f a n 1 e
Nicholas Cynthia Gina
Jana Linda Stuart Michael Kirk Paul Kaveh Matthew David A21 Luuetla Bonnie Wendy Allison Enn
John
michelle
Joanne
Tyler
benjamin
Enn
Sarah
Bevin
JOSHUA
Rebecca
MATTHEW emily Jennifer Allen
Bnan Lee Rolf M Bradley Elizabeth
Alfred
Dennis Joe Joe
Terry ALVERNON
Devin
Robbi Andy Ken
JULIE
Julie
Leigh
Gregory
Maureen Susan
Karen
Amara
ROY Rosalie Nicole kasey Llnda Evan Bnan Daniel Karen Margaret Patti Jessie Jeanie KENNETH Robert Brendan Mtk8
Step h a n i e
Shane
Randel
Thomas Amee Dominic
Harry
JOEL
Mary
Timothy
Gary
D
M
a
M
a
J L M
L
G
G
C H R
B
A I
F
k m
J
T
L
E W
J
A
A
W
A
K M
D
K
C b
D
T
R L
D A M E J G J
M J J
2699 Medford Ct Carlsbad
1475 GREEN OAK ROAD Vista
1469 Sapphire Dr Cartsbad
5370 Carlsbad Blvd Carlsbad
3870 Woodvale Dnve Carlsbad
810 dewin ave encinitas
PO BOX366 Cardm
1843 EUCLID ST SANTA MONICA
3947 Lago dt Grata Cmle
3903 Stonendge Rd Carlsbad
7757-107 caminlto monarca carlsbad
400 N Myers St Oceanside
3449 Calle Del Sur Carlsbad 76 Breakers Lane Aliso Vielo 2271 Manchester Ave 2271 Manchester Ave Cardiff 3883 Jewel1 St A4
3875 rogers rd spnng valley
160 Hemlock Ave #3 Carlsbad PO Box 151 1
San Dego
Cardiff by the Sea
San Dtego
Solana Beach 9148 NORTH COAST HIGHWAY 1 ENClNlTAS 2304 Altisma Way unit 106 1681 Countryside Drive 14 Via Cordoba 1631 Buttercup Rd. 4620 Pannonia Road 236 Gloxina st 6550 Ambrosia Lane 411 South Main Street #406 655 Tourmaline St Apt. ZD 4368 Temecula Street 0102 7121 Rockrose terrace 4932 ~1. Mdan 814 south sierra
7348 Escallonta court 1165 Sidonia St 3795 Georgia Street 203
3941 Centre Street
2727 De Anza Rd
128 A Europa Street
1093 Normandy Hill Lane
Tyler
2126 Warmlands Ave
333 North Orange Ave.
4003 kansas st.
2200 N French Rd
7510 SENECA PL
353 Tamarack Avenue
1620 ARROW WOOD LN 765 del rio 765 Del Rio 765 Del Rto Ave 956 Law Street 1571 Sunsetcliffs Blvd #4 822 Redondo Ct
13395 Portofino Dr 2216 Caminito Del Barn 2216 Caminito Del Barn
1165 Tamarack
737 1R Neptune Ave Apt C
1734 Gascony Road 1545 Lorraine Drive 1545 Lorraine Drive
33575 Valle Rd
1500 SHAOOWRIDGE DR Y187
2473 TOKejOn PL.
1311 Rubenstein Ave
1200 Manhattan Beach El. Apt. 0
3631 Village Circle, YD
746 CERAMIC LANE
7393 Seafarer Place
1321 3rd St. #1
2550 Chalcedony Street
1624 North Coast Highway, #56 4363 New Jersey Street 169 Saxony Rd, Ste 201
6917 Watefs End Drive 4232 Fiesta Way #2 527 Meridian Way 527 Meridian Way 139 Avocado St. 1337 n broadway apt 26 1632 Splitrail Dr 923 Parkwood Ave 4202 Park Dr 691 Beacon Ct 724 Gloxina Street 1816 Avocado Rd. 7972 Los Pinos Circle 3785 Highland Drive 3785 Highland Drive 651 SOUTH ORCHARD DRIVE 729 Vale View Dr.
1164 Turquoise Street
21 112 Shaw Lane
4319 1R Rialto Street
4314 Mayflower Way
3591 Roosevelt St. npt. 200
2301 Paso De Laura 1223 Highbluff Ave 1909 South Ditmar Street
3250 Ashford St #K
Carlsbad vlsta Santa Marganta
Enunitas Carlsbad Enunitas
Carlsbad
Los Angeles
San Diego
San Diego Carlsbad San Diego solana beach San Diego Carlsbad Enunitas San Diego San Diego
San Dtego Encinitas
Encinitas
Columbus
vista
Fallbmok
san diego
Getzville
LA MESA
Carlsbad
VISTA
encinttas
Encinitas Leucadia San Diego San Deigo San Diego Del Mar Del Mar Del Mar Carlsbad Enunitas Enunitas Leu ca d i a
Leucadia
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA OH CA CA
CA
NY
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA San Juan Capistrano CA
VfSTA CA Carlsbad CA Cardiff Manhattan Beach Carlsbad
FALLBROOK
Carlsbad
Sacramento
San Diego
Leucadia
San Diego
Enunitas
Carlsbad
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Enunitas escondido
Encinltas
Vista Carlsbad vista Encinias Oceanside Carlsbad Cartsbad Carlsbad BURBANK Vista San Diego Huntington Beach San Diego
San Dtego Carlsbad
Oceanside San Marcos Oceanside
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
92008 9208 1
92009
92008 7607273466
92008 92024 7602301321 92007 90404
92130
92008
92009 760-436-8460
92504
92009
92656 (949)831-6984
92007
92007
91977
92W6 3104888906 92075
92024 7604791515
92009 760-8150906
92081
92688
92024 760-944-7452
92008 92024
92008 7606037976
90013
92109
92107 92009 931-0612 92111 92075 92111 92009 92024 92103 92103 92109 916-730-1 907 92024 760-409-4082 92024 760633-1760
92084 92026 760-731-7837
92104
14066
91941
92008
92084 760-7584182
92024 760-436-2767
92024 (760)224-8991
92024 760-436-3072
92109
92109 CA 92014 92014 92014 92008 92024 ..*..... f...
92024 92024 92024 92675 92081 7605005337 92009 92007 90266 92W8
92028
95816 92 109
92024 (619) 820-6745 921 16
92024 760 942-8505
92009 760-929-9287
92057
92009 (760) 4760960
92024
92026 760-740-0183
92024
92081 760-809-1730
92008
92083 92024 760-942-9716
92054 760 231 6191
92009 760-942-91 99
92W6
92008
91506 92081 760 497-0192 92 109 92646 92107
92008 92056
92078 7606450711 92054 7607574636
92109 85a2206948
43201 760-89~4155
92107 85a678-4731
92009 760-43~~~5
92009 (760)91a0426
921 17 658483-7243
scortino@adelphia net
kevtr+sconl@cox net
1984-business@usa.net
scurlocks@cox.net
seald@pacbell net
bff@arsnl corn
onedewuman@hotmail.com
RACHEL-SEBASTIAN@YAHoo.COM
seck66@yahoo.com tseckend@yahoo com
bSeddig@nethere.com
jnp@ruralneiwork.net wudultd@yahoo corn Ulysses44@aol com nerissapower@hotmail.com snakestersegovia@hotmail.com JSeibertl@san rr corn rseid3@galaway.com Skipatthebeach@yahoo.com stefanie@surfridersd.org JuryFowsGroups@aoI.com lieberinis@sbcglobal net pdlnut-stufF@yahoo.com ginas@pjsalvage.com
jseverson@ucsd.edu Icseymour@hotmail corn Stuartseymour@cox.net sdbike62@adelphia.net spanisheight@hotmail.com paulshaff@aol.com chachyshakeri@msn.com smokes1 @sbcglobal.net rsrrhmnky@yahoo.com azi shl@gmail.com
szarvar@hotrnail.com Bonnie@clearpointagency.com
dwshaws@pacbell.net
allishay@gmail.com shernsl 3@wx.net
shepjohnl12@hotmail.com
surfrn@cox.net
jsherif@cox.net shigenaga i@osu.edu
raketraket9@yahoo.com
erinshobe@sbcglobal.net
srnshomer@yahoo. corn
bevin-shores@hotmail.com
JOSH@ONEINDUSTRIES COM
r-shriner@yahoo corn
MSHULL@RIPCURL.COM meemsl 3@hotmail. corn burlap-sack@hotmail corn ashurl @cox net maryrnarysl 2@yahoo.com siddons@h.com leesilber@earthlink.net row-silbert@hotrnail.com
msi1vermQsan.n com
rnsilverm@san.rr com
tsilverman@adelphia.net
alsimeonedeisgn@cox. net
sandmanSb@cox.net jsimmons@sandiegotNst.com
jsimrnons@sandiegotrust.com
tenysQppalvage.com
NOMISLA@YAHOOCOM
bantermenhant@msn.com
sophiamiramar@aol com
andrew-simons@ yahoo am
kenkins@adelphia.net
julie@conceptiontechnologies.com
Juliesweetwokles@hotmail corn
sindaifieigh@hotmail.wm
gdsinclair@hotmail.com
msipp@matl.sdsu.edu
edu@sdmariime.org
gsirota@wastlawgroup.com
karens@voices4children.com amara@UCLAlumni net rsMnc@hotmail. corn
cbsskaff@yahoo.com nicskee@yahoo.com kcbs75@earthlink.net Ihs$s717@yahoo.com evan.slater@primedia.com bslattery@sbcglobal. net dansledd@yahoo com
icedtealady@earthlink net msmiddy@jps.ne psmiley5@sbcglobal net jessiemariel 6@sbcglobal.net jeania378S@sbcglobal.net klmsmith@mac.com surflurtles@sbcglobal net
bsmith@gnf.org msmith5836@aol.com
stephanies@dsdinc.com
s hane@blondstone. corn
waod78@hotmall corn
dancingbo0222@yahoo.com aimjsmith@netscape.net domsmith@cox.net
1 1
1
1
1 0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
1 1 1 1 1
0
1 1 0 1
1
1 1 1 1
0 1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1 0 1 1 1 0
0
0 0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0 1 0
1
0
0
0
1 0 0 0
0 0 1
0
0 0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0 1
0 1 0
0 0
0
0 0
1
0
0 1
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0 1
0 0 0 1 1 1
0 1
0 0 0
0
1
0 1 0
Page 26
Smith Smith Smith ’ Smith 111
Srnits
Snavely
Snider
Snider
Snider Snyder
Snyder
Snyder
Sogorka Solanet Solanet
SOLE
SOLE Solornine Solornine Solono
Sonck Sood Sorensen Sorensen Sorensen Sorensen Sovay Spacher
Spada spalenka Spangler Spencer spencer Spengler
Spengler
Spivey Spradling Springer spnnger St Clair-Patton st pierre Si Mane
Si Martin
staalberg Stacey
Stwg stahrner
StallWP
Stanley
Stanley Stapleton
Stark Starkman Stastwk
stattin Staulters Staulters Steele Steele Steelrnan Stefan steffen
Lance
Jennlfer Kathanne
Raymond
Andrew
Molly
Margaret
Donald
John
bryan
Wendy
Terrin
Dan
Jan
Jan
KELLY
AMANDA
Grace
Chnstian
Ruth
Tracy
Sabinas
Donna Scott
Sara Ashby Tim
Bany Frank
james Cathenne
Steve
kipchoge
Chns
ChnS
Brett
Stephanie Judith
greg Joan lean paul Steven Diane tyler Torn
Ryan
mark
jerre
Karen
W Dean
Joey
Rick
mike
Enc
Jered william Heather Mark Michael Jessica brette
Trudie
sieffen peter Stehly-Dulrnage Kathleen
Steiaenvald
stein
Steinlauf
Sielzl
stelzl
Stelzl
Stenger
Stepanyan
stephan
Stephens
Stephens
stephenson
Stephenson
Stepien
Stem
stem
Stetson Stetson Steuer STEVE stevens Stevenson Stier Stierli stlgllc Stiltwell
Stirneling stinnen Stinson Stipe Stipe Stockharn
Stocking
Stocking
stockwell Stoecklein Stojewa Stone
Jill john
Susan
Chns
hank
Danielle
Kathy
Edik
jennifer
rnonty
caroline
Shelby
Parker
Todd
William
Mary Chnstopher
Robert
Diana
KATZ
charley
Jill
Flonne Danny bnan Lisa Lynne
deborah
John Mike Holly Bnnany Haley Dorothy Eden Hannah Dennis
Mark
C
C
H
K
L
B
B
W
M
L
B
E
C
J
M
S s
J M
J
J
I
S
C
D J
J
a
b
A
H
P
g L
e
m
f
D
L
A
e
e C M a
L M
D
V
4812 Courageous Ln
190 El Valle Opulent0 6831 Carninito Sueno 6831 Carninito Sueno
46 Hinterland Way
137s MyersSt
7133 Lantana Terrace
7133 Lantana Terrace
7133 Lantana Terrace 1411 denise circle
1149 carnbria way
1149 Carnbna Way
1213 Village View Rd 5544 balboa arms dnve
5544 balboa arms dnve
325 CANYON SIDE WAY
2796 CARLSBAD BLVD
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Carlsbad vista Carlsbad Carlsbad
Ladera Ranch
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Catisbad oceanside
emnitas
Enunitas
Encinitas san diego san diego
CARLSBAD
APT 264 OCEANSIDE
576 Raymond Street
2469 E Geddes PI 21 32 Vuelta Ci 6969 Sandcastle Dnve
3554 Carninito El Rincon #53
P 0 Box 232549 2178 Twain Avenue
6979 Waters End Dr 1053-E Golden Road 7551 Delfina 4914 Park Ct
359 Cannon Green Apt G
2358 chalcedony st
9270 Towne Centre Dr unit 35
712 E Shading Lane
29085 hwy 49 2423 Eurgener Blvd
2423 Burgener Blvd
7435 Neptune Dr 961 Boxwood Court 10633 port0 ct 4669 woodstock street 510 La Mesa Ave 123 jasper st 907 Alyssum Rd 1575 Clifftop Avenue 2030 prospect ave 31 17 Via de Caballo
6415 tobna terrace#204
1530 granville ave
651 wrnish dnve
6878 Watercourse Dnve
6878 Watercourse Dr
920 Rosemary Avenue
2289 SE Longhorn Ave
430 Naiad Street 135 panorama hills bay NW
1732 Aldersgale
5749 Crooked St
1905D Alga 131 1 Savannah lane 3974 Carninilo Arnpam 3945 Las Flores Canyon 19612 gault st 136 whiteflower
1680 N Coast tiwy 101 No 20
2237 Corle Ananas
267 Barbara Ave
36% strata Dnve
3861 San Ramon Dr#216
4487 bnsbane way 6
3861 San Ramon Dr#216
776 Saxony Road
7819 ranchito ave
9576 Pipilo Street
1021bnghtwwddnve
1021 bnghtwwddnve
5 altirnira
6244 Citracado Cir
18372 Sycamore Creek Road
P 0 Box 1167
712 Lymd Dnve
25343 Silver Aspen Way #424
510 Barharn Dnve Apt 126
6774 Camino del Prado
2210 Monigomery#8
135 acacia ave #C
826 Windcrest Dr
3471 Seacrest Dr 4619 Torrey Circle R202 1022 cirna 3510 Stockton Place 681 Sonorna Street
375 1R rosecrans st
3151 Dickens St 6638 Elegant Tern Place 6638 Elegant Tern Place 1419 Piraeus Street 1428 Hyrnettus Ave 1428 Hyrnettus Ave 6888 Fnars Rd #225 6743 Oleander Way 7223 San Miguel Dr
3775 Beethoven St #212
5749 Crooked St
El Cajon
Centennial Carsbad Cartsbad
San Diego Leucadia Carsbad Carlsbad Encinitas San Diego Carlsbad
Goleta
san diego
San Diego Draper north san Juan San Diego
San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego carlsbad Enunitas leucadia Carlsbad San Marcos hermosa beach Encinitas
carlsbad
la
encindas
Carl s b a d
Carlsbad Carlsbad
PortSt Lucie Enunitas
Calgaq
Enunitas Broadalbin Broadalbin Carlsbad Catisbad San Diego Malibu reseda irvine Encinitas
Carlsbad
Solana Beach
Carlsbad
Oceanside
oceanside
Oceanside
Enunitas
Van Nuys
San Diego
san rnarws
san marcos
irabuw canyon
Carlsbad
Escondido
Cardfl
Enurutas
Valencia San Marws Carlsbad Cardiff carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad San Diego san rnarws Carlsbad San Marws san diego San Diego Carlsbad Carlsbad Encinitas Encinitas Enanitas
Carlsbad Carlsbad Los Angeles
san Diego
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA co
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
UT
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
FL
Ca AB
CA
NY NY CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
ca
ca
ca
ca
92008
92083 7607270929
92009 760-744-0333
92009 7607440333
92694
92054 760-433-5898
9201 1 760-4359401
9201 1 760-4359401
92011 (760) 438-9401
92054
92024
92024
92024
92117
92117
92054
92008 (760) 434-1 122
92020
80122 303-522-4430
92009 789 436-5058
92009
92130
92023
92008 76090014M)
92009 92024 92127
92008 720-7570
93117
92109
92121
84020 801-864-2577
95960 5302921401
92110
92110 6192751418
92009
92009 7609300048 92124 92008 92024 760-487-1747 92024 92009 92078 90254 310-4051259
92024
92009 7609318699
90025 3107806275
92024
92009 760-931-8012
92009 760/845-9453
92009
34952
92024 13k4x4 (403)461-8128
92024
12025 (518) 882-1597 12025 882-1597 92009 9201 1 92122 858-232-3854 90265 91335 92603 760-8150781 92024
92009
92075
92008
92057
92054
92057
92024
91405
92129 8554@4-8063
92078
92078 92679
92009
92025 (858) 674-2275
92007
92024
91381
92078
92009 760 931-1450
92007 7604436714
92008 7607294828
9201 1
92008 92130 92078 92008 760-720-1224
92078
92106 619-223-2437
92106 92009 92009 92024 7605330850 92024 92024 92108 (619)2957251 92009 92009
90066
freelancevisualsgadelphia net
yesithurt@netzero corn
rcskcsgaol corn
rcskcsgaol corn
andrewgarsnl wrn
davesgirll38@hotmail corn
JES92009gADelphia net
JES92009gAdelphia net
JBS92009@Adelphia net
bqansnydeR003@yahoo wrn
Wendy snydergreef wrn
tsnydergdcshoes wrn
dsogorkagadelphia net
phranken9ghoimail wm
phrankengghotrnail corn
kmsolieghoirnail wm
danungboo333@yahw wrn
pickapepper22gyahoo wrn
csolorningyahoo corn cookie-solonoghotrnail corn
tsonckgadelphia net
sabinasood909gyahoo wm
donnaaguaghotrnail wrn ssorenseng24hourlit corn
sarapotpie@yahoo corn shbeee@yahoo corn tsovay@hotrnail corn
bspaced@earthlink net
frank spada@opl ucsb edu
jspalenka@aol corn
tearnkt@pacbell net steves@staatsbikes wrn
kipchoge@xtracyde wrn cspengle@san rr corn
cspenglernsan rr corn baspivey@adelphia net sspra07@aol wm judyandblue2gyahoo wrn spnngerl4gadelphia net jsipaUon@hotrnail corn tytymwr@cox net sirnanesj@adelphia net strnamin@cox net tylerstaalberg@yahoo wrn
tjstaceygadelphia net
ryanstagggyahoo wrn
spamrneonceghotrnail wrn
jastallwp@wnsbio org
stanfam@adelphia net
stanfarngadelphia net stapleton@rnindspnng corn
joeystarkgbellsoulh net nckgstarkphoto wrn mstastwk@hotrnail corn
rlstatbnggcas net jereddon@aol wrn TransWorldS03@hotrnaiI wm aquaryaaaol wm rnwssasQaol wrn srnsteelrnan96gyahoo wrn jessicastefangvenzon net irate-paetayahoo wrn sieffensm74gyahoo corn
kdulmage@cox net
jillhsQadelphia net
nocoversteingan net
suzela@adelphia net
chnsQstshapes wrn
hankgsishapes wrn
danistelzlgwx net
kstengergsbyllobal net
itaintegralsghotmail wrn
kjmtr5@sbcglobal net
bugabcofairlaxgaol wrn
bugaboofairfax@aol wrn
puppydawgffi8@wx net
gazingus@juno wm
todd@sdrp org
atinfobilly@yahw wm rpsmbs@aol wm
chnss@pdwrp wm stetsonbgwx net isfsurftearnsgaol corn badkat224ugyahoo wrn cabocharleygyahoo com oneljilgrnsn corn brhead2pacbell net dannysberlighobnail wrn bnanQsbgtec wrn sunsisagyahw corn lrnslirnegaol wrn debdin33g~uno corn lohsti@sbcglobal net mike-sbpe-22Qyahoo wm
hollystipegyahoo wrn 1rorne4sukigaol wrn wmetgirlW2@yahoo wrn des54gsbcglobal net
edenstoWellgyahoo wrn
n7tmut@aol corn dtenisball@aol wrn
fortunaieblessings@yahoo corn
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
I 1
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
0 0 1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1 1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 0 1 0
1 0 1 1 1 t 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0
0 0 1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 0
0 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1
0 0 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 1
I 1
1 0
Page 27
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
stoops stom
stotler
Stotsenberg
Stover
Strahl
straley
Strandquist
Strange
Straw
Strernel Strernel Stribling Stuart Stubbs
Stuernpfig stuernpfig StUltS Sturnpo
Sukenik
Sullivan
Sullivan Sullivan Sullivan Sullivan Sullivan SUMMERIL Sveine Svihus Swairn
Swim Swam Swain Swan Swan Swan
swan jr
Swanson
Swanson
Swanson
Swart
Swartz
Swartz
sug9
Enc chet
luke
Jed
Jennifer
Dana
chns
David
Amy Kevin
Patnck Suzanne Daniel Steven
Jennifer
Dave
Jason rnarcia Ten
Jason
Mark
Timothy
Steve Chns
tirn roseane Susan SANDRA Sandra Jeffery Sarah Daniel David Wren Karen John Susan
john
Ron
Karen
Enc
Timothy Steve
Steve
Swatek Davidson Karla
Sweanngen Barbara
Swed Amanda
Swed Kevin swick robyn swln carol SWlt Vera swartwood chns Swge Vickey Sybrandy Risa Syrnanski Sally Syrnons Kent
Szafran Ben
Szot Stacey Szyrnanski Bnan t'Kint Arnould
Tainter Carolyn
Takacs Tncia
Takernon Valene
Talbot David
Talbotl Will
Talbotl Jackie
Talley Shiloh
Talley-Sagunsky Leslie
Tankell Tan0 Tapia Tarnowski Tassara tate Taubrnan tavares Taxer
Taylor
Taylor Taylor Tee1 Telfer Tella Tellechea Ternot Thayer Theios Theiss Thernl Thernl Thomas Thomas Thornas
Thomas
Thomas
Thomas
Thomas
Thomas Thomas Thomas Thomas Thomas
Dana
Lorenzo Nancy
Susan
Mauricio Brigitte Richard rob David
Dan
Karen Jonathan Julie
Dennis
Brock
Elena
Candice Jane Julia Alicia
Larry Maria Christina Alan
Devon
Mike
Mike
Jennifer
Derek Ryland Laurel Mike
NY
Law
H
L
R
C
A
J M
k
M
M
M
J
C
A
W
T
M
t
M
M
L
k
S
R
S
T
N
W
P
D
A
A
L rn
rn
B
L A
J
M
b L
R L K
D
W
C
M
2935 Gaviota Place
5075 Millay Ct
404 la veta ave
126 JasperSt #404A
4590 Salem Place
6725 Whitesail St
4566honzondnve
845 Flonda St
552 Lynn Shores Dnve
7140 Carninito Pepino
6169 Pasea Tienda 928 Rosemary Ave 1400 Washington Street #I1 9943 Via Debbie
9162 Regents Rd Apt C
758 Dewitl Ave
1321 verbena ct 5199 10s robles dnve
1232 River Glen Rw#50
1802 S Nevada St
1828 Ltnwood 16
1363 Hornblend St
6550 ponto dr 23
2426 Skylark Dnve
674 via de la valle
269 coneflower st 1315 Basswood Ave 263 MANGANO CIRCLE 406AndrewAvenue 8121 carnino del sol 1661 Shendan Road 1861 Shendan Road 781 7 Gaviota Circle 6476 Pyrus Place
2907 Corte Celeste 2907 Corte Celeste 2907 Corte Celeste 2907 corte celeste 2112 grand ave 7996 Paseo ABSO 7705 Garboso Place 138 windvane lane 27152 Soledad
27152 Soledad
2835 Avenida Valera
3030 Glenbrook St
1311 Laurel treeln #159
1311 Laureltreeln 159 6608bnanvooddnve 884 del nego ave 539 Samuel Court 356 bach st 1345 Cassins St 7460 Capstan Dnve 4062 Narragansett Ave 1612 Mantime Dr 533 Evergreen Dr #4 7013 Cattail Place 952 Sandcastle Dr 661 1 Daylily Dnve 965 Pine Ave Apt F
301 Sunset Dnve
6655 Towhee Lane
2506 Via Rojo
1680 North Coast Hwy 101
8246 Calle Morelos
2100 Montgomery Ave Apt J
2153 Corte Moral
10032 Branford Rd
1509 Goodwin Dr
3145 Blenkarne Dnve
7813 Gabacho St
23804 Anza Ave #B 1152 glen ellen pl
2716 Socorro In
7402 altiva place
630 compass ct
2181 Teasdale DR
34a~ S Cedros Ave
4095 Harnson ST #3
2063 Fmude Street
3514 Corte Mora
2246 Wales Dr
4730 Biona Dr
559 3rd street 263 Oleander Dr 6818 Zinnia Court 2039 S Ditrnar St 1009 Sparrow Court 1009 Sparrow Court 1624 Ridgeway Street 6583 Daylily Dr 1300 W 7th Ave #I 12 724 Teabeny St
6575 Paseo Frontera Apt E 6575 Paseo Frontera Apt E 3354 Elrnwood Way
3354 Elrnwood Way
3354 Elrnwaod Way 7311-E Alicante Rd 905 Robley PI 510 S Burnstde Ave
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
enunitas
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
lrnpenal Beach
Virginia Beach
La Jolla
Carlsbad Carlsbad San Francisco Santee
La Jolla
Enunitas
carlsbad
carlsbad
San Diego
Oceanside
San Diego
San Diego
carlsbad
Oceanside
Solana Beach
enunitas
Carlsbad
ENClNlTAS Leucadia la jolla Enunitas Enunitas Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad san diego Carlsbad Carlsbad carlsbad Mission Viejo
Mission Viejo
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carisbad
I e u ca d i a Encinitas
cardiff Cartsbad Cartsbad San Diego Cartsbad Cardff by the Sea Carlsbad Cardff Carlsbad Carlsbad Enanitas Carlsbad Carlsbad Leaucadia San Bego
Cardiff
Carlsbad
San Diego
Vista
Cartsbad
Carlsbad
Torrance
san rnarcos
Carlsbad
carlsbad
carlsbad
Virginia Beach
Solana Beach
Cart s b a d
San Diego
Cartsbad
Cardff
San Diego
encinitas
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Oceanside
San Marcos
San Maws Oceanside Carlsbad Anchorage Encinitas Carlsbad. CA Carlsbad. CA San Marcos San Marcos San Marcos
Carlsbad
Cardiff
Los Angeles
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
Va
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
Ca
CA
CA
VA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA AK CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
ca
ca
92009
92008 760-7259774
92024
92024
92006
92009
92008 760-390-3904
91932 619-423-2473
23452
92037
92009 760476.1888 92009 (760)438-1302 941 09 92071
92037
92024
92009
92111
92054 760-645-5874
92110 619-994-6254
92109
92009 419-9209
92054 760-721-2646
92075 858-792-9432
92024
92008 760-720-0265
92024 760-944-9650 92024 92037 92024 92024 (760) 942-9925 92009 (760) 635-2932 92009 760-8061365 92009 760.942.3465 92009 92009 4158673986 92009 92109 92009 92009 92009 7604761967 92691
92691
92009 760-533-9414
92008 760-729-0973
92009 7606030540
92009 7606030540
92009 92024 92024 760-942-5650 92007 8584143042 92009
92107 92009 92007 954-695-8756 92009 92007 92009 92008 760-434-3602 92024 92009 7604383207 92008 92024 760944-3721 92 126 92007 8531699-7570 92009 760/942-9737
92129 6193169355
92084
92008 760-729-7363
92009
90505 310-739-1897
92078
92009 7609317644
92009 619/88965&4
92009
23454
92075
92008
92107 619-255-3443
92009 (760) 744-6338
92007 7609448804
92116 760-807-5457
92024
92057 (760) 728-1246
92009 760-390-9869
92054
92078
92076
92054 7607535594 92009 760-431-9891 99501 9072580625 92024 92009 92009 92078 760-295-4767 92078 760-295-4767 92078 760-295-4787
92009 760 613-6842
92007 8562127673
90036
92008 760-43e-0~3
92009 760 918-9894
charnpionpackaging@sbCglobal net chet storrsgusrnc mil
lukestotler@grnail corn
jedstots@hotrnail corn
calipinacoladagyahoo corn
dana-tracy@sbcglobal net
chnsstraley@yahoo corn
generalsurfgnetscape net
ArnylsLost89@aol corn
kevin strawgsdsu edu
pastrernelgadelphia net
sstrernelgcsusrn edu
dstnblingggrnail corn
thkrthnwtr@yahoo corn
fernijenl@hotrnail corn
dsturnp@rnac corn
surfdrnrghotrnatl corn
scstultsgaol corn
ten-txghotrnail corn
sud blg 176@ hotrnail corn
rn sukenik@cox net
tirnothysul@yahoo win
gopongo@aoI.com
mlguy7@cox net
brnsullivan@wex corn
rhrnartins@hotrnail corn
theladysullivan@aol corn
alohasandyQcox net
enievs@cox net jacsvihusgsbcglobal net sblouie@hotrnail corn dannyswairn@yahoo corn davidswairnjr@hotrnail corn wswain@stanpac corn karen-swan@yahoo corn j~etsS@yahoo corn sueswan@yahw corn jts92009Qyahoo corn rnusicalocean@grnail corn swannie@adelphia net
edogswan@adelphia net tirnswart@rnac corn swartzs@bu edu
swartzs@bu edu
kswakaaol corn
babsin@adelphia net
Akkswed@hotrnail corn
kswed@yahoo corn
robynswickghotrnail corn carolvcswfl@earthlink nei vera6aaol corn csworhvood@cox net vickey-syage@yahoo corn rsybrandygpamcgyre corn sallysyrn@cox net ksyrnons-50gyahoo corn BENSZAFRAN34@HOTMAlL COM stacey-szot@adelphia net szysurf@hotrnail corn arnouldaprana corn
CarolynTainter@wrnconnect corn
tnciagoceansctence corn irornekatgadelphia net sfrdavayahw corn will talbott@grnail corn
basspotato@yahoo corn
shiloh-talleyghotrnail corn
LTalley@adelphia net
DrDanaDC@yahoo corn
ltanogcox net
ntapiaaearthlink net
susanZk83@yahw corn
rntassaraQsocal rr corn
bmtateghotrnail corn
tattalatayahoo corn
mbbyt69O@hotrnail corn
dtaxerayahoo corn
dantrnan9@hotrnail corn
activist@karentaylor org
lance@carlsbadsurfschool corn
julieteel@hotmail corn
denntst@sector9 corn
BwkCTellagjuno corn
elenaltkessurfgyahoo corn
candicetp@hotrnail corn
janegreenjeans@wmcannect corn
jtheiosgwestfield corn
aliciatheiss@yahoo corn
Ithernl@hotrnail corn
Ithernl@hotmail corn
etibellgcox net cthornas217@aol corn akingthornasghotrnail corn dthornas@taic net phylbknygadelphia net phylbknygadelphia net jenandderek@cox net pnandderekacox net jenandderekacox net
laurel@nethere corn
rnike-thornas-5@hotmail corn
Alikona717@yahoo corn
I 1 1 1 0 0
1 0
0 0 1 1
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 I 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0 1 1 0 0
1 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 1 1 0 I 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1 1 0
1 0
0 0 1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
0 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
1 0
0 0
Page 28
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Thomerson
Thompson
Thompson'
Thompson
Thompson
THOMPSON Thomsen
Thomsen
Thomsen
Thomsen
Thornton
Thornton
Thunder
bpler
Tipton
Tirona
Tisdale
todd tcdd Toller TomaSzewSki
Toolson
Toolson
Tornillo
torp Torr
torretto
Torykian
Tosdal
Tota
tow1
tracy Tran
TrwP Travis
trayer trayer Treadwell Treibel Treto Tnrnble Tnnchera Tnnh Tnst Tmsian
Troyer T~jillo
Tsoulos Tucker
Tumasone
Tuminello
Turnbull
turner
Turner Turner-Allen
Turpin
IUS0 Tworoger Udmn Underwood upham urange Uroda Urquhart Vaccaro vahalla Valdivia Valdivieso
vale Valentine
vallentyne van der Schaaf Van Loan Van Meter
Vanderpool
Vandersloot
VanDevender Vangilder
Tibbals
TNpe
Janet Dana
Elena
Kimberly
Bnan
ERIC Gregory Shelley
Brett
Karin
Audrey
Romey Julie
Noel
karen
willow
Barret
Lisa
tess
Mlck Michael
Janette
Jessica
Paul
Sara Neil
Sarah
Dana
TY Attila
stwe
diane
KoW Michelle
lorree
Whitney Paul Nathan Meredith James Anthony Rita Kevi n Chnstopher Antonio Laurence Jennifer Teidi Anthony Kimberly
Holly
Sean
James Deborah
Roger
steve Patnck Lisa
Laune chelsea aron Susan Fiona Nicholas
mary Leia Bntten mark Enn heather Robin Melissa Jill
Chnsbne
Jan Dena tirn
mary
Mike
terry
vanleeuwen jermy VanMeter Joanne
Vanoni James
Varga steve Vasquez Sebastian VAUGHN CATHERINE Vaughn Andrea
Vaughn brad
Velasw Thanya
Veltman James Venuti Monica
Verdu Paula
Vestal Chns Viau Jessica viernes kirn vigo Mary-Jane vigo Anthony Villalobos Nancy Villarroel Sergio VillaViCenCiO Dennis
Virabalin Justin
VOlZ Jeff
P
N
S
S
L
S
T
e
L
M
P
J
M
A
M
a
B R a
M W
L
A
B
J
C
E
C
J a
B L
r
J
D
C
L
M
E G
R
G
R
D
25612 Mendoza Dnve 3566 Wnton Avenue #203 PO Box 232073 1537 Thomas Ave 1660 N Coast Highway #34
6653 ALDERWOOD DR 7155 Linden Terrace 7155 Linden Terrace 350 Concord #I 26 SE 86 Ave 2192 Palomar /wort Road
306 Tamarack
1605 Westminster Dr 1566 Lower Lake Ct
4165 Pilon PI
217 Rodney Ave
404 Enunitas Blvd
2438 Catalina Circle #662
11 4 wrte tierra bella
1213 belleflower road
1351 PaMc Beach Dnve #4
16WShendanRd
2690 Crystal Ridge Road
2690 Crystal Ridge Road
501 Beach Street
355 third street
6930 Wildrose Terrace
14661 Dasn Way
2501 Rosemary Court
2764 Granville Avenue
1660 N Coast HW 101 #6
11 15 alta vista ave
7991 paseo ahso
12665 Salmon River Rd
7464 Capstan Dr
2612 Cazadero Dr
p 0 box 1251 p 0 box 1251 1270 Skyros Way 23412 Pacific Park Dnve#ZEK 1615s Myers 1550 Hornblend St #4 935 Hygeia Avenue
1500 Shadowndge Dr #223 Rita 2120 The Strand 2715 Roosevelt St Apt C 145 Edgeburt Dr 1259 Blue Sky Dnve 553 B Hygeia Ave 451 Mountain Mew Rd
24013 Bnardale Way
2842 Cazadero Dr
7360 Seafarer Place
324 winsome pl
1549 Somerset Ave
1754 Kennington Road
11527 Mesa Madera Ct 3340avedeportugal 335 Via Linda del Sur 447 Ocean View Avenue 300 Countrywood Lane 2166 avenida toronja 4901 avila ave 1750 Cottonwood Dr 165 E D St 5020 River Ave 1353 burgundy rd 3670 Collier Ave 409 Santa Helena 651 Chalcedony st 926 N Allyn Ave 4085 hamson street #2
4224 La Tiera Dnve
2606 El Rastm Lane 155 W Jason Sttl6
3269 Corte Vera CNZ
2221 East 16th Street 25516 Oak St
Tim
4901 avila ave
516 Stern Way
7991 Paseo Aliso
134 Windvane Lane
2625 Colibn Lane
946 WOODGROVE DR
7017 Wa Padilla
7017 Via Padilla
21600 Oxnard Street Suite 1180
1506 Uno Verde Ct
5143 Via Malaguena
7465 Mermaid Lane
402 Ocenaview Ave 4677 Collwood Blvd Unit A
1259 cambna way 609 Navigator Court 609 Navigator Court 2427 Uniwrnio St 4036 Craven Road #36
2333 State Street Suite 200
871 Buttercup
Valenua
LOS hgetes Leucadia San Diego Encinitas CARLSBAD Carlsbad Carlsbad El Segundo Portland
Carlsbad Carlsbad Cardiff Cardiff
san diego
Encinitas
Carlsbad
Oceanside
san demente
carlsbad
San Diego
Leucadia
Olivenhain
Encinitas
Encinitas
encinitas
Carlsbad
Poway
Enunitas
Los Angeles
Enunitas
eswndido
carlsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad vista vista Encinitas Aliso Viejo oceanside Sand Diego Enunitas Wsta
Carlsbad Manhattan Beach Carlsbad Encinitas Cardiff Encinitas Crest
Newhall
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
encinitas
Cardf'f
Enunitas
San Diego sd Enunitas Enunitas Encinitas carlsbad carlsbad Vista Encinitas Newport Beach enunitas San Diego Solana Beach san diego
Ontano Carlsbad Oceanside Carlsbad Encinitas
Carlsbad
Newport Beach
Lomlta
Laguna niguel
carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad CARDIFF
Carlsbad Carlsbad Wwdland Hills Solana Beach Oceanside
Carlsbad Encinitas San Diego encinitas Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Oceanside Carlsbad Carlsbad 5299 Clernens Ct. Carlsbad
CA CA CA CA Ca CA CA CA CA OR CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
91355 90034 92024 760-633-4282 921 09 658-274-3922 92024 619-517-5674 92009 92009 760-603-0143 92009 760-603-0143 90245 97216 503-251-7647 92006 92008 92007 760-436-6951 92007 656.410 4793
92130 92024
92W6
92056 92677 949-369-8633
92009
92109 856-272-9749
92024
92024 (760) 943-9594
92024
92024 92024 760-943-6951
9201 1 (760) 431-5775
92064 658-748-1446
92024 90064 92024 760-436-6846
92027
92009
92129 658-774-2790
92009
92009 (760) 930-9758 92065 760-724-6780 92085 760-724-6780 92024 619.206 0985 92656 949-322-0043 92054 (760) 967-2046 92109 92024 92081 92009 CA 90266 92006 760-729-3697 92024 92007 92024 92021 619-441-9994 91321 92009 92011 760-602-7921
92024
92007 760-467-1 994
92024
92131
92106
92024 656 232-5454 92024
92024 92007 760- 6357655 92006 92081 92024 92663 949-413-6095
92024 92116 92075 (658) 350-7466
92109 856-270-4022 91764 92006 760-672-2416 92056 760-630-8929
92009 92024 760-624-6990
92009
92663 949-548-6326
907 17 92677
92006
92009 760-436-1260
92009
92009 160-438-6274
92009
92007
92009
92009
91367
92075
92057
92009 (760) 268-0010
92024 760-419-8607
92115
92024
9201 1 9201 1
92009 92057 760231-5378 92008 760-730-7770 92009
92008
jtcpa@sbcglobal net Surfdana-2000@yahoocOm elenathompson@wx net berlythornpson@earthlink net bthompson43@cox net
surflolive2003@yahoo com thomsen99@earthlink net thomsen99@earthlink net breRlhomsen@hotmail wm karinthomsen@yahoo cam apthorntongadelphia net mmey@earthproducts wm thunderfamily@wx net noellt@sbcglobal net
btiplerasan rr corn
willowdihom@hotrnail wrn
btirona@gmail corn
faeneluvl?@yahoo wm
tesstodd@hotmail wm
micktoller@yahoo wrn
mywllQsbcglobal net
twlson@adelhpia net
pssicatoolson@yahoo wm
ptornillo@cox net sara@westpachawaii wm
neiltorr@lyws corn
torretto@hotmail wm
torykian@sbcglobal net
ttosdal@lyws wm
ahlatota@wx net
StnosurfQaol wm
dkt57@sbcglobal net
fusionZ-@hotmail wm
IrappkoryQyahoo wm
IravisfamQintegnty wm
ttrayer@aol wm ttrayer@aol corn Whitney Treadwell@ps net treibep@svusd k12 ca us natebikeQvenzon net megaomega74@holmail corn jtnn@yahoo com
anthony tnnh@westonsolubons wm
rmt43@pacbell net trosian@hotmail com mr-chns73@hotmail wm antonio ~NJ~~~O@WX net Lars TNpe@sduhsd net
itmlocator@aol wm
itumasone@yahoo wm
kimberlyIuminell@erac wrn
hollyturnbull@adelphia net
oldhirarn@adelphia net
~imrnyblue3@lhotrnail wm dtalitho@wx net mgerturpin@yahoo wm shakaawx net patl904@hotmail wm 4udwinsl@wx net lundemood@eusd k12 ca us chelsbabe67@yahoo wm amnQhotmail corn surfegirl@msn m teem ail@wx net nicholai60@hotmail wm mvahalla@yahoo wm Ilvaldivia@yahoo wm bntten904Qaol wrn
mpvJr@holmail wm
ennvalentine@holmail wm heathervl@hotmail wrn
robinvanderschaaf@sbcglobal net
melissavl@adelphia net jillvanmeter@ yahoo com
cvpool@adelphia net
JonVJ@aol wm
bambeana25@earlhlink net
ttrn@nghhwsedesign wm
dutchdiggler@hotmail wm jcv9212l@yahoo wm jvan46@msn wm steve varga@sbbtral corn cachitovasquez@hotmail wm cathyaprana wrn techadmirer@yahoo wm brad-vaughn@hotmail wm thanya420@blackplanet win
Iveltmanl@adelphia net moniesmile@yanoo wm pverdu@adelphia net Chns@ZJgroup com fulltwistingforward@yahoo com ksv@cox net beachhag@sbcglobal net surfguitarl 983@sbcglobal net ngvillalobas savUO@hotmail corn
villavicenciolawrgQao1 wm jman_92009@yahw corn jvolzl4@yahoo wm
dmtJQsbcglobal net
Jtsoulos@hohail Corn
1 0 1 0
0 0 1 0 1 0
1 1
1 1
0 0 1 0 0 0
I 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 t
0 0
0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 1
1 1
1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
0 0 1 0
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
0 0
1 1 1 0 1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
0 0 1 1
Page 29
van Bluecher von Merkatz vos vosseller
Waddington Wagner WAGNER Wagner Walker Walker Walker Walker Walker Wallace Wallace Wallace Walsh walsh Walsh Walter Walton Wankier Wansor WARD
Ward
Wardell
ware ware Warner wartell
Washbum
Wastal Waikins
Watson Watson
Watt
watters
watts
watts
watts
Weaver Weaver Webb Webb Weber Weber Weber weber Webster
Webster
Webster
Weekes
Weekes
Weeks Weglarz
Weglarz
Wehba
Wehba
Weiland
weinbaum
Weir Weiss
Enc ChnStian Theresa John Krystal Walter Mattie ROBERT Pamela John Kevin Roberta Susan
Jeff Cathenne
curtis Mania Beth ashley Sheila
michelle Randall Lance Jeremy Lauren
Michael
Terrence
kim
Carl
James
julie
Elizabeth
Jacqueline
Calista
nathaniel
summer
Andrew
lindsay
william
Dan
Susan
Melissa Kelley LOU Stuart Michael Mark
David Jennifer Rosemary
Jeremiah
Dwight
Dana
Brad
Michael
Lezya
Daniel
Audrey
Steve
Benjamin
david Kathenne Tracy Weissenberger Joyce Weissenberger Andy Welburn Phoebe welch angela Wellander Rebecca Wellman Chnstopher
Wells Steve Wells Sandi
wells kim
Welnick Leo Welnick
Welnick Joe Welnick annie Wendell Alex Werbelow Jason Werbelow Anita Werner Enan Wessman-Lavellc Trevor
West Johnny west lama
West 111 Ray Westburg Reid
Westfall Katie
Westwood damon
wev wev
wharton heather
WHEELER ROBERT
Whelan Beth
Whitaker Karla
White Ryder white Jessica
white cathy white shaun white roger white kan white Jesse White MatyAnn
whitehead sandy
Whitehead Nadine
Wells Jay
M M M b R W M H
R
C R
P
C
R
n
C
f
K
L
M
S
N
T
e
D
A
S R
A
N
J
a
C L D
S J
a E W M
S
B
E
M
K
A
i
E
129 basil st 7752 Anillo Way 1139 Neptune Ave 2555 evergreen si
4433 Point Degada 1811 Peach pl
925 Rosemary Avenue
925 ROSEMARY AVE 7504 Solano St 807 Sandbar Way 3620 Milford Place 7777 Caminito Monarca. #I06 6996 Sweetwater St
2305 Ivy Rd
7879 Sitio Abeto
11915MightyRedwoodDr 4429 Mission Ave C112 1831 Milbank Rd 1870 via primem 7005 La Jolla Blvd. #1
219 countryhaven 1680 Lighthouse Rd. 3107 Serrano Drive 1173 Felspar Street
4006 CALLE ISABELLA
16161 Pitman Lane
630 Barbara
1038 santa queta
1038 Santa Queta
788 Via Bahia
1076 opal st #3
3123 Collier Avenue
4918 Park Court
12290 Corte Sabio #3302
739 bmckton street
237 Mangano Circle
5226 Via Del Or0
4793 long branch ave
816 Stanford ave
460 Anchor Way 3337 Vivienda Circle
320 Delage Drive
864 Seabright Lane 2929 KEATS STREET
1060 Solana Drive 3982 Jewel1 Street R303 2270 Avenida Magniflca Apt. S
448 36th Place
2828 webster st #I 0
2929 Via lpanema
630 Highland Si.
6494 Willow Place
145 Neptune Ave.
145 Neptune Ave.
3459 Caminito Sierra #S303
2251 AItisma Way #202 2251 Atisma Way #202
1020 Cottage Way
7064 Surfbird Circle
1678 Ridge Rd
12991 Long Boat Way 4021 Lamont Street Apt. 2 630 Barbara 7208 Azalea Place 7208 Azalea Place 1520 Van Buren Ave 4170 park blvd #5
P.O. Box 684
17478 Caminito Canasto
2731 Galicia Way
2731 Galicia Way
455 Vallejo Street, #210 637 beachcomber drive 3650 Monroe st. 3650 Monroe St
3650 monme St.
11 11 Lincoln Blvd #8
7917 Calle Madrid
7917 Calle Madrid
6352 Citracado Cir.
301 1 Suncrest Dr.
1738 Sorrel CT
4316 sea bright place
2131 Vuelta Court
1439 Oribia Rd
1847 Chalcedony St
1602 Malden Street
123~~
261-c hillcrest dr
9485 FERMI AVE
3243 Via Alicante
PO Box 624
PO BOX 2658 4979 torrey cinle
cathy
carny cathy
2372 Terraza Ribera 7313 seafarer pl
1101 S. Clementine St.
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
enunitas
Carlsbad
Leucadia
san diego
Oceanside
Concord
Carlsbad
CARLSBAD
Cartsbad
Carlsbad
C a rl s b a d
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Oceanside
Carlsbad
Houston
Oceanside
Encinitas
oceanside
La Jolla
enunitas
San Marws
Carlsbad
San Diego
SAN CLEMENTE Huntington Beach Solana Beach
solana beach
Solana Beach
San Marcos san diego
San Diego
Cartsbad
San Diego
el cajon
Enunitas Oceanside san diego chula vista Carlsbad Carlsbad Enunitas Solana Beach San Diego
Del Mar
San Diego
Carlsbad
Manhattan Beach
san francisw Carlsbad Pasadena
Carlsbad Encinitas Enunitas
Carlsbad Cartsbad Cartsbad Enunitas Carlsbad Vista Del Mar San Diego Solana Beach
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Diego
San Diego
Huntington Beach
San Diego
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
San Franusw
seal beach
Cartsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Santa Monica
Carlsbad
Cartsbad
Cartsbad
San Diego
Carlsbad
carlsbad
Carlsbad
Del Mar
San Diego San Diego we encinitas SAN DIEGO La Jolla Cardiff Oceanside san diego carlsbad carlsbad carlsbad carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad
carlsbad
Oceanside
CA CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA
Tx
CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
ca
92024
92009
92024 7605979100
92106 619-743-2039
92052 760-458-6965
94518 9258279515
92009 760-431-1065
92009 800-871-7345
92009
9201 1
92008 760-720-1871
92009 760-634-6663 92009 760-455-8243
92054 CA
92009
77059
92056
92024 65E724-2500
92056
92037 858-344-7182
92024 760-943-8431
92076 760-752-1455
92009
92 109
92647 92075
92075
92075
92069 760-747-3990 92109 921 16 619-297-6474 92008 92128 92020 858663 3686 92024 92056 921 07 91913 92008 760-729-9059 92009 92024 92075 92106
92014
92109 92008
90266
94123 92009 7606334822 91104 626.345.0997 92009 8584053185 92024 760-487-1 173 92024 92002 760-390-1000 92009 92009 92024 92009 7609180788 92081 92014 92109 92075
92009
92009
92103 760-272-9899
92103 6192999167
92648 92127 858-248-7400 92009 92009
94133 41 5-412-5021
90740 562 280-3500
92008 7607296064
92008 7605798906
92008 760 579 8915 90403
92009
92009 760-942-9316
92009 921 16 858-514-3600
92009 760-822-6340
92008 760-803-9042 92009 619-993-0450 92014 92109 92109 93008 911 92024 61 9 549-2244 92123 92037
92007 92051 (619) 708-3104 92130 92009 CA 92009 CA 92009 CA 92009 CA 92009 CA 92009 760.602-0886 92009
92054
92672 (949pga3441
eric@digisweat.com
cvonmeriatz@sbcglobal. net
tmane@jminternational.com
chargvoss@netscape
ccvuncannon@yahoo.com
sitsurf@hotmail.com
Tobeafamousstar@aol.com
robertwagner@uamc corn
wagsx4@sbcglobal.net
johwlk@aol.com
kwalker@optimal.net
Bobbiraew@aol coin
Iikesuzissite@yahoo.com pu@pgsdesign com
cportillow@adelphia.net
caawl23@yahoo corn
imavalkyrie@yahoo.com
beth@clearpointagenq.com
ashwalsh@sbcglobal.net
walsh.sheilamane@gmail.com
mwalter@iconsystems.net
walton@kgalpad cam
hvankie@adelphia.net
sacalsurfer7@yahw.com
Lauren.n.ward@colorado.edu surfding@hotmail.com WARDELLI@aol.com
soxl50@adelphia net
mareQliai org
jwarner@coleman.edu jdw@san.rr corn
ewash777@aol.com
jqwastal@wx.net beachbunny228@yahoO.com
natewat@hotmail.com puresun$hine43@yahoo.com awatt333@gmail.com lwattersl Z3@sbcglobal.net bweze@ hobnail. corn danowatts@yahw.com susiewatts2004@yahoo.com
Ilenadadelgozo@gmail corn
kweava@yahoo corn
cuzl @cox.net
studim@hotmail corn
mswebe69-otheronlinestuff@yahoo.com
weberOl9@csusm.edu
davidjweber@gmail.com
webejenaz@hotmail corn Roseybusy@aol corn jeremiahtwebster@yahw corn
dwight.webSter@kontron.com dana-weekes@hotmail.com brad-weekes@hotmail.com mikedweeks@hotrnail.com Idweglan@sbcglobal net Idweglan@sbcglobal. net audreywe@hotmail.com swehba@mac.com bweiland@ptloma.edu dweinbaum@gierlich-mitchell com
kwei@grahamwebb.com WARDELLl@aol.m
ajhveiss@adelphia. net
ajhveiss@adelphia net
phoebe@guidedmarketing.com
angela welch@mac.com
bwell@socal.rr.com thewellmans@San.rr.com swells77@adelphia.net
swalls77@adelphia.net
jwells@artwel-electric.com
kimwells@adelphia. net
avosteve@aol.com
Avosteve@aOl.com
welnick4@aol.com
alexQhomebizworker.com
werbjraaol. corn
ajwerbelow@aol.com
bri6672@msn corn trevor.wssman@reef.com
johnnysnow@wmcast.net
surfmomie@aol.com
benwest@adelphia.net
rwstation-l@yahoo.com katiewestfall@hotmaiI.com novacaine@san.rr.com 1212@fagget5 heathewharton@hotrnail.com RMWHEELS@YAHOO.COM nd-farmgirll23@yahoo.com
karlawhitaker@yahoo.com bulletryder@hotmail.com jessicawhite27@yahw.com swhitexl O@aol.com swhitexl O@aol.com swhitexlO@aol.wm swhitexl O@aol.com swhitexl O@aal.com marewhite@sbcglobal net
Sandyandrickl @yahoo.com
notoriousnadia@gmail corn
1 1
1 i
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1
1 0
1 0 1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0 1 1
1 1 1 0
1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0
Page 30
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
Whnesides Bnan
Whittaker Cns
.wtchmann' ~eff
Wichmann Zacha Kathenne
Wicks
Wicks
Wukstrand
Wiehl
wiggins Wilber
Wilder
Wiley Wilken wlkerson Williams williams Williams williams Williams williams Williamson Willin Willoughby Wilmot Wilson Wilson Wilson Wilson Wilson Wilson WILSON Wilson
Wilson
Wilson
Wimmers
Winchell
Winchell
Windau
Winfrey
Wingate
Wingler
mnkler
Winterbourne Winterbourne Winters Wissinger Wisstnger Witherall Withendge Witkowskt Witmer wttt Woelfel Wolfe
Wolffe woifson
Wollter
vmod
Wood
Wood
Woodard
woodward Woolhether
works
Wosachlo
wrege
Wnght
Wnght
Wnght
wnght
Wnght
wnght
Wnght
Wnght Wnght Wnght Wnghtson wu Yang Yap0 Yardley Yates Yates Yoder Yoshitomi Yoshitomi Young Young Young
young Young Young Young
young Young-Schult
yurkovic
Zabel
ZaMan Zabmcki Zabrocki Za k
Row Anne
Theresa
Mark
elisa
Jeff
Jean
Mason Scott
max
Mark gerald
Greg
lynne
ShM adelheid Lance Stephanie Jane Alexis
Rick Ross Mark Stacie steve JAMES Jeremy Bnan
maureen
Steve Katie
Theresa
Scott JEn
Susan
Jenny
shelly
Gail Thomas
Steven
Bnan Leynette
Alison Jushn Darbi Andrew Bonnie Julie
Jacqueline Gwen Dana
ben
Ginger
Alex
Bob Ron
ludi
Chns
swot
Mike
Janet
Sarah
greg Leslie
ron
Ryan
Bndget
andy Susan
Teny Steven
Angle
Jake Andrea Ryan Inez Cynthia Ron Lee Dan Anthony Jason Jean
Mary Milene
van Candace
Jim Rob
Charles Patnck Sylvia Sharon
BNW
Mary
Blake
David
Za k Richard
R
R
m
B t
C
M h
L
B
I
A
I
D
G
P T
C
B C A
G
D
e A
R e
L
P
W
L H A
Z d
F
L N
a
B J G L
866 S Sierra Ave
5780 Fleet Street
4239 Cleveland Ave #5
177 Mangano Circle
956 Tarento Dnve
2705 Via Cardel
7421 Pelican Street
3022 Avenida Chrtsbna
3535 Cameo Dr #116
5881 Vale Way
P 0 BOX 83
P 0 Box 366 1632 Avery Road 1736 Swallowtail Road
946 Jasmine Ct 2717 daffodil pl 7028 Whitewater St 906 Hillfleld Ct 23331 Orchard Ave 7217 daffodil pl 4923 Loma Way 1852 Pentas Ct
3452 Corte Sonnsa
225 El Poltal 1130 Niki Lynn PL 37 Pheasant Lane 871 45th Ave 356 Trailview Rd 1562 Manbme Dnve 902-E caminito madngal 2613 EL RASTRO LANE 849 Luna Vista Dr 1085 Chinquapin Ave 3007 pueblo street 4466 Granger St 16942 Lynn St Unit E
6550 Ponto Dr#43 535 Lands End Way
4009 geomia st
3107 Serrano Drt
5036 Litchfield Road
3325 avenida obertura
480 Naiad Street
480 Naiad
7751 Pendon Court
Solana Beach
Carlsbad
San Diego
Enunitas
San Dtego
Carlsbad
Carisbad
Carlsbad
oceanside
San Diego
Oceanside
Cardiff San Marws Enunitas
Carlsbad carlsbad Carlsbad
Oceanside Carson carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Enunitas Carlsbad Aliso Viejo San Franusw Enunitas
Carlsbad carlsbad CARLSBAD Escondido Carlsbad carlsbad San Diego Huntington Beach Carlsbad Oceanside
san dtego
Carlsbad
San Diego
carlsbad
Enunitas
Leucadla
Carlsbad
6755 Mira Mesa Blvd Suite 123-41 San Diego
7663 NorthNp Place San Diego
2912 La Costa Ave Carlsbad
6807 Embarcadero Lane, Apt 127 Carlsbad 6105 Paseo Granito Carlsbad 141 Rodney Ave Encinitas
601 1 Paseo Airoso Carlsbad 2190 Twain Ave Carlsbad 315 So mast Hwy 101 #LIZ35 Encinitas
2642 Galtcia Way Carlsbad 13035 Via Gnmaldi Del Mar
500 N Grape St # 121 Escondido
1280 Santa Fe Dr encinltas
7444 Capstan Dnve Carlsbad
7915 Via Callendo Carlsbad
Po box 234145 encinitas
1109 Agate St San Diego
4810 Lawn Ave Cypress
2078 edinburg ave cardiff
1031 3 San Diego Mission Rd #A1 1 San Dtego
16% boulder creek rd
6544 Conntta St
6544 Conntia Street
1402 Eolus Ave
183 countryhaven rd 183 countryhaven rd
1136 stratford
3669 Harvard Dnve
1261 Veronica Ct 1261 Veronica Ct 921 Morning Sun Dnve 23061 Poplar 10838AdermanAve#141 1486 Bottle Tree Lane 4783 Jutland Dr 4918 Park Court 6756 Tea Tree Street
2447 29th 7304 Borla PI 3020 Cielo Place 3020 Cielo Place 1807 Amalfl Dnve 7268 Rt 20 8959 st Rte 53 1359 knoll dr 1227 Whlte Sands Dnve 1331 Savannah Lane 41320 salt nver ct 218 Marsala dr
540 Orpheus Ave 5620paseodelnorteX119c
522 Turfwood Lane
23001 Covello Street
3605 Eamscliff Place #35 3605 Earnscliff PI #35 1730 Rogue Isle Ct
1730 Rogue Isle Ct
oceanside
Carlsbad
Carlsbad
Leucadia
Encinitas
Encinitas
encinitas
Oceanside
Carlsbad Carlsbad Encinitas Mission Viejo
San Diego
Enunitas San Dtego Carisbad Carlsbad Santa Monica Carlsbad Carlsbad Carlsbad Enunitas Madison Naples oceanside
San Marws
Carlsbad temecula Newport Beach
Leucadia
carlsbad
Solana Beach
West Hills
San Diego San Diego Carlsbad
Carlsbad
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA
CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA CA NY
NY
CA
CA
CA CA CA
CA
CA CA
CA CA CA CA
CA
ca
92075
92008
92103
92024
92106 619223.1332
92008 7298705
92009
92009 760-744-2390
92056
92115
92049
92007 92078 920024 92009 760-931-8082 9201 1 92009 92054 760-722-4254 90745 92009 92008 92009 92009 92024 760-457-5157 92008 760-434-3942 92656 949-581-0292 94121 92024 760.6342538 92009 92009 760)473-0011 92009 92025 92008 92009 92107 92649 92009 760.310.0059
92054
92103
92009 7604361152
92116
92009
92024 760436-0678 92024 (760) 436-0678
92009
92126 8583378020
92009
9201 1 92009 92024 92009 760-815-5383 92008 760-804-9216
92024 619-987-6631
92009 (760)9446911 92014 92025
92024
92009 (760) 431-5718
92009 760-753-1592
92023
92109
90630 92007 760-753-34554
92 108
92056
92009
92009 (760)603-1231 92024 760-436-8703 92024 760419 8618 92024 760-634-3405 92024 7604361180 92056 760-722-4207
92009 92009
92692 92126 92024 92117 92008 9201 1 760-929=9504 90405 310.403.7923 92009 92009 92009 92024 13402 14512 607-566-3617 92054 760-439-6857
92078 7802951502
92009 760-431-1443 92591 92660
92024
92008
92075
91307 California
92111 921 11 92008 92006 760729-6990
92121 85a549-9705
92024-1958
M!tesidesEl@hotmaiI wm
criswhtttaker@hotmail corn
jemeeywl7@hotmail cam
thewt@sbcglobal net
rorylaw@cox net
seabreezeZ705@adelphia.net
terrwick@hotmail.com
wiehl@syndromdist corn
elisawigginsl @yahoo.com
pNilber@regentsbank.com
jeanellenwtIder@hotmail.com
captainamerica69@hotmail.com scotttwilks@hotmail.com snowshreddeR8@yahw.com williamsmk@adelphia.net gwtlliamsQoceprinting.com gregwill@attglobal net hillfleldhouse@webtv.net swil1iams32990@yahoo.com heidw49@ hotmail. wm lancewilltamson@juno.com boxholders@adelphia.net janewilloughby4@9cs.com awilmot@cox.net bwlson@foundation sdsu.edu RWSURF@aol.com r3w2000@earthlink.net wiIson4gadelphia.net stacie71 G@adelphia.net stve@spawcina.com JAMES.WILSON@ADELPHIA.NET
hammaa@yahoo.com bgwilson8@hotmail.com
timothywilson9881 @sbcglobal.net
obcpa@juno.com ktngregQearthlink.net
ellewinchell@msn.com
swindau@hoImail.com
jenni-winfrey@hotmall.com
wingate28@adelphia.net
jrwingler@cox net
jswinkleE@sbcgIboal.net
rosieluvl Ol@sbcglobal.net tom.winterboume@usmc.mil swinters@illumina.com brian@wissfinancial.com leynette@gmail.com mwitherall@aol.com awttheridge@yahoo.com justinwitkowski@hotmail.com darbiatakedasd corn andrewitt@hotmaiI.com bwoelfelI3@hotmatl.com jaewoife@hotmail.com
grejal@adelphia.net tghvolf@aol.com
btgoutdoorguy@aol.com
nineteenO4Qyahoo.com
blake@bwood.net
gingspeech@aol.com
konawoodard@hotmail.com
fincut@san.n.com
lightsparkQSbcglobal.net jmw92007@yahoo.com
chriswinsd@natzero.com
swrege@pacbell.net
m.wright@ngc.com
janetjammaearthlink. net sdw@cox.net gregwrightconstNction@hotmail.com lesliem@sdcoe.kl2.ca.us rdswright@hotmaiI.com ruright@dyn-sd.com briwright@adelphia.net awright@qualcomm.com scwright@sdcoe.kl2.ca.us terry.wrightson@quest.com stwl8@ hotmail. corn Angie.yang@sbcglobal. net dave@erngmupinc.com jyardley@adelphia.net dfhdkfdfh corn ryatesla@yahoo.com Otte&@poSt.haNard edu cyoshitomi@yahoo.com bmw2002tii@go corn lee@allpetsanimal.com macmatic@gmail.com emily8855822@aol.com jyoung7575@hotmaiI.com JJJBYOUNG@AOL.COM myoungfamily@adelphia.net
redriderbero@yahoo.com
ryoung@ripcurl.com
rschult@ucsd.edu
pete@sundiego.com
rdzabel@hOtmail.com
xflipstylw@socal.n corn
patrickrabrocki@yahoo.com surfchiva@yahw com zakhome@sbcglobal.net
rzcheckit@sbcglobal net
1 0
1 1 1 0 1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1 0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0
0 0
1 1 1 1
1 1
1 0
0 0
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 0
1 1
1 0 1 0
1 1
1 0 1 0
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
1 1
1 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0 1 0
1 1
1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0
1 1
1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
1 0
0 0
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 1
0 0 0 0
1 0
0 0
1 0
1 0
1 0 1 0
1 1
1 1
Page 31
Zarnora
Zanardi
Zapfe
zargar
Zelhof
Zillrner Zimrner
Zirnrner Zinn Zinn Zinter Znerold ZOEHRER ZonFrilli
Ian
Torn
Chad
karnNn
Andrew
Doug Roberl Andrea Jason Adam
Sarah ERIC Andrea
Larry
8564 topanga canyon blvd
6424 Ruby Way
5873 One Barnard Dr
340 walnut ave apt "A
1315 Phlox Ct
1017 Diamond Street R 1527 Linda Sue Lane
E 6006 Rancho Mission Rd #292 R 541 Wind Sock Way 541 Wind SoCk Way 1535 Granite Hills Dr ApW5 6267 Via Trato
1358 W GlaucusSt A 954 HAWTHORNE CT
Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan Petition
canoga park CA 91304 818 730 8615
Carlsbad CA 92009
Oceanside CA 90476
carlsbad CA 92008
Carlsbad CA 92009
San Diego CA 92109
Enclnilas CA 92024
San Diego CA 92108
Carlsbad CA 92009 760-579-0214 Carlsbad CA 92009 El Cajon CA 92019 619-566-0997 Carlsbad CA 92009 SANMARCOS CA 92069 619-7256542 Encinitas CA 92024
RRZarnora@socal rrcom
tzanardi@isisph corn
chadzapfe@hotrnail corn
zarkarn78@yahoo corn
azelhofaflyeye ucsd edu
dzillrner@san IT corn roberl-r-zimrner@yahm corn
azearlhasbcglobal net
adarn-zinn@hotrnail corn larfytheshredder@gmail corn sarahaszpr corn ZOEHRER-ERIC@BAH COM zonfnlli@hotrnatl corn
jzinsd@yahoo corn
0 1 1 1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1 1 1
0 1 0 1
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
Page 32
AGENDA ITEM #
C: Mayor
City Council
City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
City Council
City of Carlsbad
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, California 92008
Dear Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council:
June 28,2005
CIJ’Y OF CARLSBAD
cq<e5 TO.‘ I live in Carlsbad at 7155 Linden Terrace. We moved here for coastal open space and clean
beaches for surfing and waking.
Thank you for the public hearing tonight on the Ponto Beachfiont Vision Plan (Vision Plan).
This hearing is an opportunity for you to hear fiom the public. I realize the City of Carlsbad has
put time and money into preparing the Vision Plan and probably thought it was ready to certify it
and move on. But, as the two editorials in today’s North County Times say, we need to step
back and prepare a better Vision Plan and conduct an Environmental Impact Report. In short, we
need to do this right.
cL+> ~~ty-
R55S- c c cc 3% -
The Ponto area is not just land to be redeveloped. Page 16 of the Mitigated Negative Declaration
(MND) calls these coastal bluffs vacant land. The report to the planning Commission states the
parcel contains several vacant or underutilized properties. As I testified at the Planning
Commission hearing on Ponto, I don’t consider open coastal bluffs as vacant land. Calling them
vacant or underutilized makes it sound like they currently serve no purpose. This open space
serves the important function of helping to protect the Batiquitos Lagoon wetland preserve and in
turn the ocean at Ponto Beach and down the coast. The importance of wetlands cannot be over
emphasized. They serve as nesting sites and nurseries to many kinds of birds, fish and
crustaceans. The south coast wetlands are an integral part of the Pacific Flyway, one of the
largest bird migrations on earth. Wetlands also serve as a filter for storm water, releasing clean
water to the ocean. Even though the wetlands themselves are protected, uplands development
generates erosion and pollution that heavily impacts the ecosystem. The degradation puts
pressure on and endangers wildlife. The MND for the Vision Plan glosses over potentially
significant impacts to Batiquitos Lagoon and Ponto Beach. Development of the magnitude
spelled out in the Plan would worsen an already unacceptable situation by creating a high volume
of run off that would hurt the lagoon and the beach. Ponto Beach already suffers from water
pollution. In May this year it was closed twice for several days each time due apparently to a
sewer malfunction.
The Plan would also create a potentially Significant impact to the aesthetics of recreationists at the
campground and beach, to adjacent homeowners, and to the diverse traveling public on the
Pacific Coast Highway. Many of the bicyclists, joggers, and drivers who traverse the PCH
consider it a scenic highway experience. There is virtually no mitigation in the Vision Plan and
MND that addresses the impacts of multi-story parking garages, large hotels, and dense
commercial development in this area.
The amount of development proposed in the Vision Plan would dramatically increase the
visitation to the Ponto Beach, South Carlsbad State Beach. The beach already suffers fiom a lack
of funding and services for maintenance, life guards, trash removal, and resource management.
The large increase in visitation could overwhelm and impact the beach, the visitor experience,
and public safety. This is not adequately analyzed or mitigated in the Vision Plan or MND.
The Vision Plan sets the vision and the tone, and currently locks in a dense array of hotels,
parking garages, restaurants, businesses, and condos. But, it defers most of the environmental
review until later. The courts state that it is inadequate to use future studies as mitigation, or to
say projects will be consistent with approved plans. These kinds of mitigations do not reduce or
remedy identified impacts. There is no methodology stated to evaluate these mitigation
measures. How are the results of the mitigations going to be measured and monitored? What
criteria are going to be used for evaluation? How are the criteria going to be compared in
importance with one another? It does not appear that the City of Carlsbad in the Vision Plan and
MND have met the requirement of the California Environmental Quality Act to provide the
fullest or even adequate protection to the environment.
Other communities are valuing their coasts and are protecting and restoring them. Coastal
restoration is occurring in Bolsa Chica north of Huntington Beach and around Long Beach’s
Terminal Island. Solana Beach is putting in a coastal park near Fletcher Cove.
The Vision Plan in its current form tries to fit in too much development. I hear fiom the City that
the California Coastal Commission desires tourist serving facilities in the Ponto area. From my
research I believe the Coastal Commission wants balanced tourist services, ranging fiom a resort
hotel to public parks. A park, interpretive area in the area south of Avenida Encinas would
enhance the area and create a buffer for the lagoon. A park near the entry to the Hanover Colony
would provide tourist services and avoid the public safety problems that the Vision Plan’s
proposal to locate a hotel there would cause.
In summary, I am asking the City to do three things. First, listen to the public, in the hearing, in
the letters, in the petitions, and in all the ways they are trying to talk to you. Second, treat the
Ponto Beach area as the unique California coastal treasure that it is. You could say these open
coastal bluffs and beaches are Carlsbad’s trademark. And third, redo the Ponto Beachfi-ont
Vision Plan. Put in more of a balance of open public areas along with private commercial
businesses in the area that is already developed. Prepare an Environmental Impact Report to
properly analyze impacts to this sensitive area and to provide strong conditions to guide any
fbture development. The Vision Plan and MND in their current form leave too many unresolved
issues. They do not serve the best interests of the community.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely, 9-
Greg Thomsen
From: <abjanssen@nethere.com>
To: <mstro@ci.carlsbad.ca. us>
Date: 06/26/2005 5:02:16 PM
Subject: Proposed Ponto development
Dear Mayor and Carlsbad council members,
As our precious open space continues to disappear,
we are very concerned about the proposed
development of the Ponto area.
I do not think that greatly increasing density
with a hotel, shops, etc. can possibly give half the enjoyment that the beautiful vistas from the
area now give.
Please do NOT develop Ponto as proposed. Work a little harder and entertain other ideas about
how best to enhance an already beautiful place.
Development can-not always be about the money!
Thank you,
Annabell Janssen Leucadia, CA
AGENDAITEM#
ct Mayor
City Council
City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
n
PACIFIC MEDICAL BUILDINGS
June 16,2005
City Clerk
City of Carlsbad
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Re: Ponto Beachfront Village
Dear Sir,
I am a co-owner of 7100 Whitewater Street, a single family home located in the Hanover
Beach Colony adjacent to the proposed site. I attended the public hearing conducted
by the Planning Commission and have studied the Vision Plan.
I have been an architect for over 40 years during which time, I have been involved in
many projects such as this. I believe that In general, this plan will enhance the South
entrance to Carlsbad along the Coast Highway. The mix of uses should add a vitality to
this end of the City that is currently lacking and the proposed uses will replace
dilapidated, existing buildings. However, there is some poor planning used in this
concept and the environmental impacts have not been addressed and are not mitigated.
The current plan proposes a large hotel with convention facilities to be located on the
North end of the project adjacent to single family homes. The service end of the hotel is
facing these homes and the entry street is shared by these homes. This has the
potential of creating a number of significant impacts including traffic, noise, odors and
views.
The Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) does not quantify these impacts but merely
concludes that the traffic would be less than what is allowed under the General Plan.
The MND does not identify any studies regarding the loss of views from existing
properties. There are no noise studies that identify ways to mitigate noise impacts to
existing properties.
Given the mix of uses in the Vision Plan, there are better uses that can be located in
this part of the project.
A much better plan would be to locate the town homes or multi-family homes adjacent
to the existing single family homes. The hotel would be better located in the interior of
the site where it has less impact on existing uses. There should be a hierarchy of land
use intensity from lower on the project perimeters to higher in the center.
12348 High Bluff Drive, San Diego, California 92130
Telephone 858-794- 1900 Fax 858-794- 19 10 website: pacificmedicalbuildings.com
I believe that this project has multiple owners and perhaps the owner of the parcel(s) on
the North, Wave Crest Development, is pushing for a hotel whereas the owners of the
middle of the site are advocating other uses. This ownership should not be a reason for
bad planning.
It is clear that the impacts on the existing homes in the Hanover Beach Colony have not
been recognized. I request that the Council reject this project in its current form and
send it back to the planners for more study. Thank you for your consideration of this
request. Vl4&&
Robert A. Rosenthal, AIA
President
- CITY OF CARLSBAD CITY CLERK'S OFFICE
June 22,2005
City of Carlsbad
City Council of Carlsbad
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Attn: City Clerk:
Re: Ponto Beachfiont Village Master Plan
I am a professional engineer and land development consultant with 40 years experience
in the San Diego North County area. I am in support of the proposed Master Plan.
The Plan as proposed is a good one and recommend that the Council consider the
Approval of the Plan.
Beachfiont Village for several property owners who want to develop their projects.
The proposed Master Plan will provide guidance for the development of Ponto
The Plan as proposed will serve as guidance for the City Staff members when reviewing
The applications for permits to develop their properties.
The hotels, timeshare condos ,and shops will serve visitors and the community who
Enjoy the ocean front along the coastal highway.
The Village Plan as proposed will improve the existing properties and enhance it's
Image and upgrade the Ponto area for the neighboring properties.
Sincerely,
Richard Dome, PE
Engineer Consultant
pu-4 Y--
' ClTYOFCARLS8AD ' 1
.~ CITY CLERK'S OFFlCE
From: <stephnconn@adelphia. net>
To: ~Planning@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: 05/31/2005 7:16:21 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
Planning.
............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on our community of
Hanover Beach Colony. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to
approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Paull and Stephanie Connolly
Paull and Stephanie Connolly
7122 Leeward St. Carlsbad, Ca 92009 USA stephnconn@adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; Q312461; SVI; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.70.222.82
AUDREY POWERS THORNTON
ATTORNEY AT LAW
2192 Palomar Airport Rd, 2d Floor C&bd CA 92008
TEL (760) 944-7271
E-MAIL: apthomton@adelphia.net
FAX (‘760) 944-7271
ALL RECEIVED
June 8,2005
Carlsbad City Council
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Re: P-
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfkont Vision Plan will have on South
Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad
to perform a fbll Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you.
Sincerely, A n
EMILY M. RICHDALE, ESQ.
924 BEGONIA COURT
CARLSBAD, CA 92009
Telephone: (760) 929-8338
June 21,2005
City of Carlsbad
Attn: City Clerk
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
RE: OPPOSITION TO PONTO BEACHFRONT VILLAGE VISION PLAN
Dear City of Carlsbad and Council Members:
I am writing to voice my concern and opposition to the Ponto Beachfront Village Vision
Plan ("Ponto Vision Plan"). I have lived in Carlsbad since 1991, and am extremely
concerned about the proposed development of the Pont.6. area. As a Carlsbad resident
for almost 15 years, I have seen first-h'md how development prejects can negatively
affect the city's residents.
I fail to see how the Ponto Vision Plan will have a positive and beneficial impact on the
residents of South Carlsbad, such as myself. The project will result in increased traffic,
congestion, noise, and crowds in the Ponto beach area. There is absolutely no benefit to
the residents of South Carlsbad, and in fact, the residents will be made to bear the .. .. bLir&n 0: the negative eficcts af the pxjjsct ,;j hxit t;c;a't-;l?g 2;-iptbJng ;r; i-ckim.
I enjoy surfing and relaxing on the beach just north of the open water inlet that
connects the Pacific Ocean to Batiquitos Lagoon. The Ponto Vision Plan will bring
hundreds, if not thousands, of additional people to the Ponto beaches everyday. This
crowding will be particularly horrible during the summer months. Taxpayer dollars
will need to be spent to provide restrooms, garbage and parking facilities to
accommodate the increased crowds at Ponto beach. These facilities are currently
lacking and will not be able ti> handle the additional crowds without significant
improvements.
Page I
Carlsbad residents should not be forced to provide funding for a development plan
that will have a significantly negative impact on their enjoyment of the Ponto beach
area. The focus of the City of Carlshad and any potentiai development of the Ponto
area should be its effects on the current residents of South Carlsbad, and not on the
interests of developers and tourists.
In addition, the Ponto Vision Plan currently lacks the necessary environmental
assessments required to protect the sensitive wetland habitat and wildlife of the
Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I am opposed to the Mitigated Negative
Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program as inadequate
measures to prevent a significant environmental impact on the Batiquitos Lagoon
Ecological Reserve. The City of Carlsbad must perform a full Environmental Impact
rep or^ prier to ~pp-ci-~hg Cevolopiisi~t hi the l'orit~ Visiai T:an.
I urge the City of Carlsbad to place the interests of its own residents ahead of those of
developers and tourists. Carlsbad residents have already experienced significant
increases in traffic, congestion, noise and overcrowding over the past fifteen years due
to development. Enough is enough. I am in favor of the City of Carlsbad allowing the
Ponto beach area to remain undeveloyed open space.
I look forward to attending the public hearing on June 28; 2005 to speak about the
negative impact I believe the Ponto Vision Plan will have on both myself and the other
residents of South Carlsbad.
Yours Very Truly,
I.
Emily M. Richdale, Esq.
Page 2
From: ctimsullivan @ wwex.com>
To: <ManagerQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Manager.
Tue, Jun 14,2005 10:25 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I'm writing to express my deep regret with the city of Carlsbad for even considering developing in the Ponto Region. The only thing we have left in this world that is still sacred is our environment. And you
people are unfortunately considering altering the course of history for our kids and our grandchildren by developing one of the last remaining beautiful beaches.
Do you think we really need more hotels and more shopping malls? What do you intend to put in the
malls? Linen and things, Starbucks, Payless, Bed Bath and Beyond ... come on, drive over to Palomar
Airport Rd. Do we need that more than we need a beautiful beach with a beautiful reserve? And a hotel, how more traffic can we take in North County?
Keep in mind once you develop, you can never go back to the way it was. I share your aspirations for
wealth and material things, but certainly not at the expense of the environment. Nature is what keeps us
peaceful and inspired. Home Depot does not.
It is disturbing that so many elected officials come into power and quickly side with the developers. I just
wonder if you are going to be proud of the decision you made when you are old and retired. Fighting
money and greed of developers takes much more strength than give in and sign off of on the
development. Developers wanted to put two 500 room hotels in downtown Laguna Beach in the late ~O'S,
but luckily a group led by an artist that owned a coffee shop fought the city. And now 30 years later, look
how unique Laguna Beach looks compared to the development of Newport Beach.
I just ask that you do a little sole searching before you cast your vote. If you are from San Diego County,
do you really want to turn this place into LA or OC? Whose interest are you taking into consideration, the
general publics or the super wealthy few that do not need more money?
Please do not give into the greed!
Tim
tim sullivan
Carlsbad, ca
timsullivan Qwwex.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.236.250.97
From: cahf-zen Q netzero.net>
To: cManager@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Sun, Jun 26,2005 8:20 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department, City Manager.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. .............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
My family has just moved to this area and chose it because it hasn't succumbed to overdevelopment and
we enjoy the quality of life here.
Regards,
Alan Faust
Alan Faust
2040 Chestnut Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 San Diego
ahf-zen Q netzero.net Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
208.20.220.69
From: <bujewski Q adelphia.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 27,2005 2:13 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Save Ponto Beach from development! Will you leave us nothing that is still quaint? This is supposed to
be the Village by the Sea, yet the running joke in Carlsbad is -- "if you stand still long enough, they'll build
something on top of you." The city calls this area of South Carlsbad "blighted." I disagree. It is the last
"unmolested" stretch of coast in the city. I don't live 30 miles from downtown San Diego because I want
more city life. When my husband and I bought our house we could see rolling hills on one side and the
ocean on the other. Now the hills are gone and development has taken away my ocean view. The city
planners seem to have "stars in their eyes" about turning Carlsbad into another Pacific Beach. We didn't
ask for that and we don't want it. We don't want more hotels and apartments. We don't want more traffic
and commercial properties. Leave us this one little piece of quiet coastline. Please.
Renee Bujewski
Renee Bujewski
802 Windcrest Drive Carslbad, CA 9201 1
bujewski Qadelphia.net
Mozilld5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; ~1.4) Gecko/20030624 NetscapeD.1 (ax)
24.52.1 50.1 14
From: <beckyfern @aol.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 27,2005 1:20 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed anc posted the "Contact Us" form to department, City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you, Rebecca Montez
Rebecca Montez
3367 Calle Cancuna Carlsbad, ca 92009
beckyfern Qaol.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
63.1 96.93.62
From: cmarewhite Qsbcglobal.net>
To: <Council 01205.1 42.1 09.1 3]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 1:09 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
MaryAnn White
2372 Terraza Ribera Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
marewhiteQsbcglobal.net Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; .NET CLR 1.0.3705; yplus 4.1 .OOb)
69.1 08.47.1 95
From: clantzfam Q adelphia.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 12:39 PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please perform an Environmental Impact study at Ponto and So CBAd before you develop our last stretch
of relatively natural coastline.Thank you.
Rick Lantz
2844 Wilson st Carlsbad, CA 92008
lantzfam Q adelphia.net Mozilld5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:l.7.6) Gecko/20050225 Firefodl.O.1
69.1 67.1 59.1 62
From: <dannysocali Q yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 12:04 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed anG posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I would like the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Daniel lnskeep Ill
Daniel lnskeep
909 Caminito Estrada, unit C Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
dannysocali @ yahoo.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
160.33.42.1 30
From: <Hlexad@aol.com>
To: ~Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 11 54 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please require and EIR for the proposed Ponto Development plan.
This is too important to short cut the process by a mitigated n.d.
Donald Holmes
6943 Mimosa Dr Carlsbad, Ca Hlexad@aol.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; AOL 9.0; Windows NT 5.1; (2312461) 207.200.1 16.1 96
From: <djoseph 8 rtjobs.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 11 :52 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear City Council -
I am writing to plead with you to please reconsider your plans for Ponto Beach area. The beauty of
Carlsbad is the maintained open areas, lagoons, and the nostalgic beachfront that we residence love and
would like to remain intact. What about "Environmental Studies"???Where are they. Clearly this is NOT
IN OUR BEST INTEREST!! We have plenty of tourist and toursit dollars coming to our city monthly with things as they are. Why do
you continue to want to make this another LA County Beach area??? STOP This madness please.
D. Joseph
Carlsbad, CA 92009
djoseph Q rtjobs.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; sbcydsl 3.12; YComp 5.0.0.0)
69.1 66.1 21 . 1 62
From: <debpi@sbcglobal.net>
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 10:14 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed anc posted the "Contac
City Council. ;" form to department,
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
As a concerned citizen of Carlsbad I wish that
you would have an enviromental impact study performed before proceeding with the Ponto Beach
project.
The traffic on coast hwy in the mornings has become impossible and there is so little open area left the
project is unaccptable.
If you want to clean up blight why not clean up the roadside adjacent to South State Beach where the
weeds have taken over,
Darrel Beatty
7142 Santa Rosa Carlsbaad,, ca 92009
deb pi Q sbcg lobal. ne t
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; (DB29963A-4A43-5C03-FBE9-8B5088D59CFE);
.NET CLR 1.1.4322; yplus 4.1 .OOb)
67.1 24.1 96.95
From: <wudultd @ yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 1O:OO AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE.
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Elizabeth Seed 3449 Calle Del Sur Carlsbad, CA 92009
wudultd @ yahoo.com
Mozilla/4.O (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; yie6-SBCDSL; sbcydsl 3.1 2; YComp 5.0.0.0)
67.1 13.105.226
From: ck38roger Q yahoo.com>
To : cCouncil@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 27,2005 9:12 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "C
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
ntact Us" form to d partm
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Roger Peterson
Roger Peterson
150 Acacia Avenue Carlsbad , CA 92008
k38roger Q yahoo.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
63.197.216.146
From: <adursoQ csusm .edu>
To: cCouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 27,2005 856 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Adrienne Durso
Concerned Carlsbad Citizen
Adrienne Durso
3322 Fosca St. Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
adurso Q csusm.edu Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X; en) AppleWebKitl312.1 (KHTML, like Gecko) Safari/312
144.37.49.69
From: <S-Gardner Q msn.com>
To: <Council @[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sun, Jun 26,2005 10:20 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Stacy Gardner
Stacy Gardner
6957 Mimosa Drive Carlsbad, CA 92009 S-GardnerQmsn.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
63.1 96.84.1 61
From: <rmt43 @ pacbell.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Sun, Jun 26,2005 9:16 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
STOP PONTO DEVELOPMENT! THIS HAS BEEN THE BEACH FOR MY CHILDREN AND
GRANDCHILDREN FOR 20 YEARS.
Rita Trist
2206 Plaza de las Flores Carlsbad, CA 92009 United States
rmt43 @ pacbell.net
Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X; en) AppleWebKit/l25.5.6 (KHTML, like Gecko) SafarVl25.12
64.1 65.1 7.1 15
From: <alohakelsol Q yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sun, Jun 26,2005 7:11 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Members, Why is it that what's great about Carlsbad has to be tampered with? When I
moved to Carlsbad, we had more beach parking and it was easier to pull out of the beach parking stalls.
Now we just have the lots and parallel parking.
We also have a sea wall that completely blocks the ocean view from people driving by unless they are in
high profile vehicles. Shouldn't we be able to SEE what we so enjoy about Carlbad.
The stretch between La Costa Ave. and Poinsettia is one of the last stretches on natural California coastal terrain between here and Ventura. I always choose to drive there when possible because this is how
California is meant to be enjoyed- in its natural state. Can't you imagine what it must have been like just
even fifty years ago? I wish I'd lived here then. As it is, I've been lucky to live here since 1978.
Let's maintain some distance and a buffer zone between new developments and the coast. If you build it
they will undoubtedly come. If you build it a little smaller and a little further back, they will still come and
spend their tourist dollar here. (Have you been to Panama City Beach, Florida? It's high rise condo,
stores that sell fast food and beach towels, etc. People are littering. There are just too many, too close to
the water.)
We can have both worlds. But let's not get greedy with the proximity to the ocean. Everyone can benefit
from a little walk to the beach. It's good for the heart, the legs, and the soul to slow down to appreciate
what we have right here. Let's not pave paradise and put up the proverbial parking lot.
Thank you. Anna Kelso
Anna Kelso
33550 Ridgecrest Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008
alohakelsol Q yahoo.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.166.120.86
From: <allstories Q hotmail.com>
To: <Council Q[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Sun, Jun 26,2005 3:17 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and PO
City Council.
ted the "Cont ct u " form to departm nt,
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Margaret Moore
Margaret Moore
3287 Camino Coronado Carlsbad, CA 92009
allstories Q hotmail.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
72.14.140.139
From: <patti@ brasilia-rsm.com>
To: <Council @[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sun, Jun 26,2005 12:45 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ...............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please preserve Ponto Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve!!!!!!!
Patricia culwell
1605 starling ct
carlsbad, CA 92009 United States
patti@ brasilia-rsrn.com Mozilld5.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X; en) AppleWebKiff312.1 (KHTML, like Gecko) Safari/312
68.1 24.21 4.233
From: <shherticaQ hotmail.com>
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sun, Jun 26,2005 1054 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Bud Lewis, Matt Hall, Ann Kulchin, Mark Packard, and Norine Sigafoose
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Sherryl HixsonHertica
Sherryl HixsonHertica
7903 Corte Penca Carlsbad, CA 92009
shherticaa hotmail.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; Mathplayer 2.0; .NET CLR 1.0.3705; .NET CLR
1.1.4322)
68.70.208.49
From:
To:
Date:
Subject:
A visitor to th
City Council.
<FoootersQaol.com>
<Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Sun, Jun 26,2005 9:29 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted th "Contact Us" form to department,
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Susan Foote
Susan Foote
2417 La Plancha Lane Carlsbad, CA 92009 US
FoootersQ aol.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; AOL 9.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1)
207.200.1 16.196
From: <sal. baroneQsbcglobal.net>
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sun, Jun 26,2005 9:20 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am opposed to the Ponto area development plan. I believe it is to dense and will forever tranform the
area into a commercial hodgepodge that will change the identity and quality of life in this area. I would like
to request a complete Environmental Impact Report.
Thank you!
Salvatore Barone
7346 Portage Way Carlsbad, CA 92009
sal. barone Q sbcglobal.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98; YPC 3.0.1)
69.230.1 9.1 64
From: ecurrylindaQ hotmail.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sat, Jun 25, 2005 9:06 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Linda Curry
2890 Luciernaga St Carlsbad, CA 92009
currylinda Q hotmail.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
4.241.208.21 0
From: <swells77 Q adelphia.net>
To: cCouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Sat, Jun 25, 2005 8:08 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted: Dear Council,
As Carlsbad residents living in the La Costa Heights area we are outraged about the plan destruction &
disruption of Ponto area beach that I understand is currently being contemplated. You are continually
destroying what Carlsbad residents love about the area in your apparent quest to pave everything. Please
leave Ponto as is or revise your grandeous intentions.
Sincerely,
Mr. & Mrs. Wells
Carlsbad, CA.
Steve & Sandi Wells
2731 Galicia Way Carlsbad, CA 92009-8142 USA
swells77 Qadelphia.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.
69.1 67.1 59.231 : Q31246 ; iebar; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
From: ellevy@ miracosta.edu>
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Sat, Jun 25, 2005 556 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please stop the development at Ponto Beach until all the environmental, traffic, and sound mitigation
studies have been studied carefully. We do not need more development of our already scarce natural
resources.
Leon Levy
940 Melaleuca Ave. Apt. N Carlsbad, CA. 92009 IlevyQ miracosta.edu
Mozillal4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0)
24.54.244.1 93
From: chooverphotoQadelphia.net>
To: cCouncil@[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
Sat, Jun 25,2005 1:27 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please do not develop Ponto. We need more open land. In the past 10 years, Carlsbad has developed
all open land increasing traffic and congestion. I'm waiting for the crime rate to increase. I remember
horse back riding and mountain bike riding in the Eucalyptus fields (NOW AVIARA). I remember no
grocery stores (NOW RALPHS AND VONS) and no stop signs (NOW STOP LIGHTS). I remember NO
LEGOLAND. I remember going places without sitting in traffic for hours ... Have you noticed the constant
Saturday morning backup on Southbound 1-5? I can't get to the neighboring cities (Leucadia, Encinitas,
Solana Beach, and Del Mar) in less than 45 minutes. We do not need 750 hotel rooms. What about the
preservation of the least tern breeding ground? Why must we develop every inch of open land? There is
beauty in the natural open space. Wildlife should be considered. Is there a Environmental Impact Study
being conducted? How can I get the results? When will the city slow down develop!
ment?
Lisa Johnson
842 Skysail Avenue Carlsbad, CA 9201 1 USA hooverphoto Q adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.O (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.64.61.45
From:
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
<jcasibugag uilar Q att. net>
Sat, Jun 25,2005 12:38 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Carlsbad Vision Plan has not done an EIR, which at the very least should be required in lieu of getting out of it with Mitigation Negative Dec.
It is clear that the motivation to develop the land is financial based, but the natural beauty of undeveloped
land is priceless. The plants and animals that are able to thrive because that area is not overdeveloped,
allows us to enjoy the ocean and beach, which attracts many tourists and land owners to Carlsbad.
The Council should take a step back and do the right thing when it comes to the Ponto Vision Plan.
Development can occur in a positive manner. Performing an Environmental Impact Review, per the
California Environmental Quality Act is a moral obligation, that in turn profits the City of Carlsbad. Once
we destroy the natural beauty that makes our city so special, we can NEVER rebuild that.
Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
jcasibugaguilarQatt.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98; Win 9x 4.90; AT&T ELC5.5; AT&T CSM6.0; H010818;
YComp 5.0.2.4; AT&T ELC5.5 IE5.0.01)
12.72.58.7
From: <lapointebreakQsbcglobal.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Sat, Jun 25,2005 12:34 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
If you make a decision on developing the Ponto area without the proper impact studies on behalf of the
citizens of Carlsbad I will personally do everything I can to get new City Council members elected. Also,
do you take our precious beauty and resources so lightly? Shame on you if you do.
Robert LaPointe
4360 El Capitan Ct. Carlsbad, CA 92008
lapointebreakQsbcglobal.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
63,199.242.1 15
From: <RAYJAY3 Qsbcglobal.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sat, Jun 25,2005 12:03 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Carlsbad is my home, and I love this city. Please don't further urbanize it by allowing development on the
Ponto area. This is the last tract of land near the ocean that can give meaning to a village by the sea.
Once it has been developed, we will have lost a wildlife refuge, a place of natural beauty, and the very
charisma that makes Carlsbad so special. Please keep the Ponto area intact. Thanks, Ray Hughes.
Ray Hughes
2345-2 Caringa Way Carlsbad, CA 92009
RAYJAY3 Q sbcg lobal. net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; YPC 3.0.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.0.3705; .NET CLR
1.1.4322; yplus 4.1 .OOb)
68.1 24.88.142
From:
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
<ashes2io @ sbcg lobal .net>
Sat,' Jun 25, 2005 1 1 :33 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
It is ludicrous that the development of property located in the immediate vicinity of Ponto Beach should
proceed with no controls over the project outcome, nor with any sort of environmental impact studies to
guide your decisions! The City Council and each and every one of its members individually holds the
power, and with such power the inherent responsibility, to make intelligent decisions that create positive
results for not only developers, but also for the native species who cannot speak for themselves but call
these lands their home. To ignore this responsibility is to mismanage the power you have been entrusted
with, and I hope that you will reconsider your approval of the development measures of the Ponto Beach area and demand thorough independent enviromental impact studies so that you can make informed
decisions about what will impact future generations of Californian humans and wildlife.
Sincerely,
Danica Lisle-Crawley
Danica Lisle-Crawley
6741 Cantil St Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
ashes2io @ sbcglobal.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 5.5; Windows 98; Win 9x 4.90; YPC 3.0.3; yplus 4.1 .OOb)
68.1 24.221.81
From:
To:
Date:
Subject:
cbgwilson8 Q hotmail.com>
<Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Sat, Jun 25, 2005 9:13 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to 1, ,e City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posteL the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Brian Wilson
Brian Wilson
1085 Chinquapin Ave Carlsbad, CA 92008
bgwilson8Q hotmail.com
MozilW4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98)
69.1 66.125.40
From: ccyoshitomi @ yahoo.com>
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date: Fri, Jun 24,2005 4:45 PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posteG .,#e "Contact L,
City Council.
form to department,
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear City Council,
As a Carlsbad resident I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have
on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of
Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you, Cynthia Yosh itomi
Cynthia Yoshitomi
, 92009 cyoshitomi Q yahoo.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl)
69.1 60.137.150
From: calrex43@adelphia.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Fri, Jun 24, 2005 501 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council. ,
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear City Council Member,
As a concerned citizen of Carlsbad, I request that a performing an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) be
performed on the new Ponto Beach Project, before proceeding forward, This study is necessary to
determine the affect to the beach, Lagoon and the surrounding area.
If this study has already been compkted, please send me an e-mail with the results.
Thank you, AI Rex
AI Rex
6450 Torreyanna Circle Carlsbad,
alrex43@adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; FunWebProducts; SV1)
68.71.29.145
From: <mbrown @ kingsleynet.com> To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Fri, Jun 24,2005 6:03 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed anG gosted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Mark Brown
Mark Brown
3312 Donna Drive Carlsbad, CA 92008
mbrown @ kingsleynet.com
Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X Mach-0; en-US; 1~1.7.8) Gecko/20050511 Firefodl.O.4
69.160.137.160
From: <cmccormack-work @ yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject: . Fri, Jun 24,2005 355 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear City Council,
My brother just brought to my attention the new plans to build in the Ponto Beach area. It has been very
sad to see the new devistation done to Carlsbad's wildlife in the last few years. The beautiful thing about
Carlsbad was the untouched nature that was preserved. Now, our town is becoming just another San
Diego tourist trap. Please preserve at least one little peice of my home.
Sincerely,
Carey McCormack
Carey McCormack
3556 Ames PI Carlsbad, Ca 92008 USA
cmccormack-work@ yahoo.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1)
134.1 39.21.1 35
From: <luis.saunders @ adelphia.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Fri, Jun 24, 2005 2:47 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ...............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council,
We are writing because we have serious concerns related to the Ponto Development Plan. As residents
of the area we feel more care should be taken to preserve the beaches, lagoon and overall quality of life
for the residents in this Carlsbad neighborhood. We are not naive enough to believe that "progress" will be
prevented nor necessarily feel the idea of checked and consciously guided development is a bad one.
That being said we do believe the Plan needs to be preceded by an EIR in order to ascertain the true
impact to the surrounding area.
We live in the beautiful San Pacific0 Community and understood when we purchased our property that there are no guarantees when it comes to views and adjoining development within the City of Carlsbad.
We also would have never imagined the "non-guaranteed" views many in the area have as well as the
impression for others as they arrive in this magnificent part of Carlsbad would some day be obstructed by
a behemoth of a development with accompanying overwhelming traffic, noise, three story parking
structures and overall density. This is especially alarming when one considers the beauty of this spot, its proximity to a preserved habitat with its accompanying flora and fauna as well as the fact it serves as the
coastal southern entry to Carlsbad. As such, the look, density, building guidelines and percentage of "green space" left intact as part of the entire project should be strongly considered.
In closing, we found it ironic when we opened last week's copy of The Coast News to find an
advertisement from the City of Carlsbad Environmental Programs group claiming Carlsbad is a great place to live thanks to people that "take care of the neighborhood." We agree. Strangely enough it is a beautiful shot looking west across the northern bluffs of Batiquitos Lagoon toward the ocean, the very
same area that would be affected if this overly dense development goes through as is. We ask that you
consider your own ad copy while making decisions related to the Ponto Development Plan, it would be a
true shame with possible monumental environmental repercussions and some might even say a little
hypocritical to place this type of publicity while proceeding in anything but a conscious fashion.
Sincerely,
Luis and Sherri Saunders
luis & sherri saunders
503 rudder avenue carlsbad, ca 92009 luis.saundersQadelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; SV1; FunWebProducts)
24.54.244.1 12
From: <cameronmichelleQgmail.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Fri, Jun 24,2005 12:48 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Hello Carlsbad City,
Please take into consideration, Ponto Beach itself, one of the only beaches from Cardiff to Carlsbad that has sand! The development around our beaches and state beaches is crucial to the environment. Please
don't destroy this place for the sake of money and prosperity, a housing development would be more
suiting than hotels and retail in this particular area of Carlsbad. Go down there and take a look for
yourself, talk to people who frequent that beach before you make any decision. I have been coming to
Ponto for over 15 years, finally moved nearby, and now it may be in jeopardy.
Thank you,
Cameron Martin
Cameron martin 628 sandside court carlsbad, CA 92009 United States
cameronmichelle Qgmail.com
Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X; en) AppleWebKiV412 (KHTML, like Gecko) Safari/412
68.8.238.1 53
From: <awitheridgeQ yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Fri, Jun 24,2005 10:15 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE.
...............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Alison Witheridge
Alison Witheridge
Carlsbad, CA 9201 1
awitheridge Q yahoo.com
Mozillaf4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; FunWebProducts)
12.1 05.235.202
From: cpchacon @ ieee.org>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Fri, Jun 24,2005 9:45 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Members,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Alisa Chacon
Alisa Chacon
6745 Lonicera St Carlsbad,
pchacon @ ieee.org
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
67.1 19.245.1 30
From:
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
<chrissylaug h I i n @yahoo .com >
Fri, Jun 24,2005 9:lO AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Chrissy Laughlin
Chrissy Laughlin
3210 Harding Street Carlsbad,
chrissylaughlin Q yahoo.com
Mozilld5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; ~1.7.7) Gecko/20050414 Firefodl.O.3
65.1 07.49.24
From:
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
<cheryl-dodds Q hotmai I .com >
Fri, Jun 24,2005 9:00 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
PLEASE do not allow the Ponto area to be developed!! It is one of the last un-touched coastline areas in
our community and it is a treasure to be enjoyed in its natural state.
Cheryl Dodds
6437 La Garza Ct. Carlsbad, CA 92009-431 8
Cheryl-dodds Q hotmail.com Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl ; .NET CLR 1.1.4322; Hotbar 4.6.1)
21 6.70.233.1 32
From: <floodsurf@ hotmail.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Thu, Jun 23,2005 11 :42 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Timothy J. Flood
2340 Hosp Way #220
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Timothy Flood
2340 Hosp Way #220 Carlsbad, CA 92008
floodsurf@ hotmail.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0)
206.251.235.21
From: cvickey-syageQ yahoo.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Thu, Jun 23,2005 11 :08 AM Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I live in South Carlsbad. I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have
on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of
Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Vickey Syage
vickey-syage @ yahoo.com Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; (2312461)
69.166.125.213
I
From: <sstremelQcsusm.edu>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Thu, Jun 23,2005 1052 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Members,
Please keep Ponto Beach the beautiful, pristine place that it is! The idea of this open space being
destroyed by developers is sickening. Carlsbad is over developed as it is, with few natural spaces to
enjoy. Our family visits this beach several times per week all year long. I beg you to do the responsible
thing by banning the idea of this project. Please represent the citizens of Carlsbad as you are the elected
officials we have entrusted to help keep Carlsbad a desirable place to live.
Thank you,
Suzanne Stremel
Suzanne Stremel
928 Rosemary Ave Carlsbad, CA 92009
sstremel @csusm.edu
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1)
69.227.88.1 81
From: cjimiriderQsbcglobal.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Thu, Jun 23,2005 1051 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
As a Carlsbad City resident, I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will
have on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I would like to urge
the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this
plan.
Sincerely,
James Wesley Rider, Jr.
James Rider
3534 Ridgewood Way Carlsbad, CA 92008 jimirider Q sbcglobal.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; yplus 4.1 .OOb)
69.227.3.1 68
From: <stephagreen Q hotmail.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Thu, Jun 23,2005 10:25 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member:
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you, Stephanie Green
Stephanie Green
421 3 Sierra Morena Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 USA
stephagreen Q hotmail.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.1 60.1 32.1 2 1
From: <HendricksSQadelphia.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Thu, Jun 23,2005 10:12 AM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Diane Hendricks
Diane Hendricks
7204 Mimosa DR Carlsbad, CA 92009
Hendricks9 Q adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; DigExt; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.70.225.1 35
From: <jrowells Qadelphia.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Thu, Jun 23,2005 7:37 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Jason Rowells Michelle Rowells
Addalie Rowells
jason rowells
241 5 stevens circle carlsbad, ca 92008 usa
jrowells@ adelphia.net
Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.0; en-US; ~1.7.8) Gecko/20050511 Firefodl.O.4
24.52.1 54.31
From: <psmiley5Qsbcglobal.net>
To: ~CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Wed, Jun 22,2005 6:lO PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Mernber/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Patti Smiley
Patti Smiley
7972 Los Pinos Circle Carlsbad, CA 92009 San Diego
psmiley5Qsbcglobal.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl)
68.1 05.247.1 39
From: <m hall Q adagency.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Wed, Jun 22,2005 2:22 PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ...............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I'm writing to protest the proposed development of the area around Ponto Beach. As a 45-year-old father
of two, I fear there will soon be no open space left for my children to enjoy. After seeing the rampant
development all over Carlsbad I see the city losing it's specialness. The short stretch of relatively
unspoiled coast extending north from La Costa Avenue to Palomar Airport Road is one of the last
remaining scenic beachfront areas south of Camp Pendleton. I think it's tragic that a couple dilapidated
buildings in the area seems to be reason enough for the city council to raze the whole area and turn it into
a strip-mall-by-the sea. Please consider carefully what to do--if anything--with this last priceless length of
coastline.
James Hall
7955 Camino Alvaro Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
mhall Qadagency.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 5.23; Mac-PowerPC)
70.1 83.29.1 62
From: cmichmartl @sbcglobal.net>
To: <Council @ [205.142.109.13]>
Date: Wed, Jun 22,2005 152 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I just learned that the city is in the process of approving a HUGE developemnt near Ponto Beach without
an EIR. Please have an EIR prior to approving any development. Those of us that live in Carlsbad moved herebecause of the quaint feel of our town and the beautiful
coast line.
Please don't let developers come in and ruin this even further for all of us. Don't forget that you live here
too!!
michele martinet , 92008
michmartl @sbcglobal.net
MozillaE.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; ~1.7.7) Gecko/20050414 Firefodl.O.3
67.1 16.208.78
From: csurfskatesnowl Q yahoo.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Wed, Jun 22,2005 1058 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the “Contact Us” form to department,
City Council.
******e***************************************
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
hello im a local surfer from carlsbad and ponto is my local break .... i surf there from up to three times a day
if possible but with croweds its makes it a lil harder ... summer crowds are enough..no more. thanx
scott crouch
carlsbad, CA 92009
surfskatesnowl Q yahoo.com
Mozillal4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.237.230.30
From: <stephagreen Q hotmail.com>
To: <ManagerQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Thu, Jun 23,2005 10:18 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Manager.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE.
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear City Manager,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Stephanie Green
Stephanie Green 421 3 Sierra Morena Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 USA
stephagreen Q hotmail.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.1 60.1 32.1 21
From: <retaparker Q yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Wed, Jun 22,2005 8:12 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I was just informed about the plans for developing the 135 arces of open space near Ponto Beach and
Bartiquitos Lagoon. This is very upseting news. One of the reasons I live in Carlsbad and commute over
an hour to work in Orange County is the fact that Carlsbad has done a wonderful job preserving our natural resources which makes it a beautiful place to live. Turn this area into hotels, garages, and shops
and Carlsbad becomes like any other congested California city-with nothing unique other than Legoland.
Reta Parker
7538A Gibraltar Street Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
retaparker Q yahoo.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; .NET CLR 1.0.3705; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
167.1 07.1 91.21 7
From: <briwright Q adelphia.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Wed, Jun 22,2005 757 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed 8
City Council.
d posted the "Contact Us" form t department,
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am writing to urge you to reconsider the proposed redevelopment plan for Ponto Beach. As a lifelong
resident of Carlsbad, I have slowly seen the erosion of open space, the huge increase in traffic
congestion, and the building of cooke-cutter developments. As proposed, the current plan for Ponto Beach
will only add to these problems. While I agree that some improvement to that area is necessary, such a
massive plan is out of context with the peaceful beach area. My family and I frequent Ponto beach on a regular basis, and it is already crowded and parking is a huge problem. This project will only add to these
problems. Furthermore, to term the area "blighted" and to proceed with such a huge project without first
doing an environmental impact report seems completely ludicrous. I strongly urge you to scale down the
Ponto beach plan, to preserve some of the area adjacent to the lagoon as open space, and to do an
environmental impact report. The citizens of Carlsbad and our chil!
dren deserve that much.
Thank you for your consideration,
Bridget Wright
Bridget Wright
1261 Veronica Ct. Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
briwright Qadelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.64.63.1 40
From: <krangus Qddrsinc.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 9:16 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am a Carlsbad resident and opposed to the development of a hotel and restaurants in the Ponto Beach
area.
I suggest a Beach Park or Dog Park instead. Our beaches do not need more high rise buildings or more
traffic to impact the area.
Kathryn Rangus
101 3 Tulip Way Carlsbad,
krangusQddrsinc.com
Mozilld5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1 ; en-US; ~1.7.2) Gecko/20040804 NetscapeD.2 (ax)
68.64.63.1 27
From: cpmicheller Badelphia.net>
To: <Council @ [205.142.109.13]>
Date: Tue, Jun 21,2005 8:08 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Carlsbad City Council,
My family and I are extremely concerned about the effect the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on
the State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon. We want the City of Carlsbad to perform an Impact Report
prior to approving development. Not to do this would be environmentally irresponsible!
Thank you for your attention to this e-mail and those of other concerned citizens.
Sincerely,
Michelle Roberson and Floyd E. Roberson
P. Michelle Roberson
pmicheller @ adelphia.net
Mozilld5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1 ; en-US; ~1.7.6) Gecko/20050317 Firefodl.O.2
24.52.1 53.224
,
From: <cfgalindoQadelphia.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 7:15 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
The developement of the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan MUST have an Environmental Impact Report.
This is outrageous that the city council would even consider this project without this study. As a taxpayer,
longtime resident, and recent President and current boardmemer of the Las Playas Homeowners, I
strongly urge the council to approve this EIR.
Chris Galindo
Chris Galindo
6896 Batiquitos Carlsbad, CA 92009
cfgalindo @ adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
66.1 25.1 9.130
From: <diane-campbell Q bd.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Tue, Jun 21,2005 518 PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
The Ponto Beach area is such a treasure to our City, coastline, to the future of our environment, a legacy
to future generations!
PLease perform an analysis of the environment !
IT is crucial.
Think about your legacy to the future generations, leave the land to the children ,develop it as open land
and parks, not hotels and shops!
Diane Campbell
Carlsbad, 92008
diane-campbell Q bd.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; T312461; .NET CLR 1.0.3705)
63.1 03.66.62
From: <julia.casagrande Q varianinc.com>
To: ~CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 4:07 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed am posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Repor? prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Julia Casagrande
I julia.casagrande Qvarianinc.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1)
4.241.1 2.1 32
From: <matthewpalgutaQ hotmail.corn>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 3:40 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD 1 CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
**e*******************************************
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Matthew
Matthew Palguta
6706 Whitesail St Carlsbad, CA
matthewpalgutaQ hotmail.com
Mozillal4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; (R1 1.5); .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
64.236.243.16
From: <ham Qtwsnet.com>
To : <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 259 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am a Carlsbad Resident and I would like to meet with a City Council Member to discuss the new Ponto Vision Plan and their upcoming vote on the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
Thank you,
Liam Ferguson
Liam Ferguson
7065 Leeward St. Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
liam @twsnet.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
64.236.245.243
From: <cvpool Q adelphia.net> To: <Council@ [205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 2:26 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted: Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Christine Vanderpool
Christine Vanderpool
3289 Corte Vera Cruz Carlsbad, CA 92009
cvpool Q adelphia. net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.0.3705; .NET CLR 1.1.4322;
Media Center PC 2.8)
68.70.224.238
From: <mwssas@aol.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Tue, Jun 21,2005 1 :44 PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please do not approve the planned Ponto redevelopment without a full EIR. We spent too much time and
money cleaning up Bataquitos Lagoon over the past ten years! We need to understand the impact this
development will have on the lagoon and other senstive areas around Ponto. thanks
Mark Steele
131 1 Savannah Lane Carlsbad, CA 9201 1
mwssas @aol.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
167.206.235.5
From: <mfallet @adelphia.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 1:39 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the “Contact Us” form to department,
City Council.
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Mary Fallet
Mary Fallet
Carlsbad, CA 92009
mfallet @adelphia.net Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1)
68.70.88.1 83
From: cpynes @adelphia.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Tue, Jun 21,2005 12:33 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Re: Ponto Beach
Please do an environmental study before approving the development of hotels, parking garages, and
restaurants near Ponto Beach.
I know the revenue from tourism is grand, but do we really want to become as crowded as La Jolla and
San Diego?
Please consider this vote very carefully-and all the ramifications, not just the financial gains.
Thank you,
Susan Pynes
Susan Pynes
2746 lnverness Drive Carlsbad, CA 92010 USA
pynes Q adelphia.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98; (2312461 ; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.1 67.1 58.14
From: <theladysullivan @aol.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]~
Date: Tue, Jun 21,2005 12:30 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted: Haven't you sold us out enough? There won't be one parcel of land that hasn't been graded left in this city.
Can't you leave one thing the way God intended? We live here to GET AWAY from LA and Orange
County - now you are turning us into them. Have any of you ever gone to the beach in the summer? Do
you drive out of your 5 mile radius into the traffic you have created? Not to mention you haven't increased
the resources; Le.; water, sewer, etc. to accornodate the exponential growth.
LEAVE PONTO ALONE. It's the one last piece of California history we have left.
Oh, and great job with the water desalination - 20 years later. Thanks for giving credit where credit is due.
Susan Sullivan
Carlsbad, CA 92008
theladysullivan Qaol.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; AOL 9.0; Windows 98)
207.200.1 16.196
From: <lappub@adelphia.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]~
Date: Tue, Jun 21,2005 1 1 :25 AM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the “Contact Us” form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Jim Lapp
I lappubQadelphia.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.1 66.1 25.35
From: <acnunezl Qaol.com>
To : <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 20,2005 4:Ol PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "C
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
nta t Us" f rm to department,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Aida Nunez
2020 Karren Lane Carlsbad, CA 92008 USA
acnunezl @aol.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
209.203.70.25
From: cdanidonoQ adelphia.net>
To : cCouncil@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Mon, Jun 20,2005 4:07 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Developing Ponto Beach without an EIR is not responsible government. I frequent that area on a nearly
daily basis and find this anticipated action to be almost incomprehensible.
Danielle Donovan
2376 altisma Way #K Carlsbad, CA 92009 San Diego
danidono@adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl)
69.167.154.34
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page 1 1
From: <bensonrtQaol.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 20,2005 4:34 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us'' form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
PONTO, When is enough ENOUGH?
Can't we have a sleepy little part of town?
South 101 was great as it was a snapshot of the 50's .... beach views and NO TRAFFIC LIGHTS.
How many traffic light has the Planning Commission installed so far ? and killed the simple old
OFF-RAMPS at PONTO.
Sorry, I know you'all will allow the bulldozers free-range, BUT HOW CAN ANYTHING DEVELOPERS DO
IMPROVE THAT PREFECTION along our beach?
Thanks for listing .... now start your bulldozers.
Randall Benson
Randall Benson
Carlsbad, Ca 9201 0
bensonrtQaol.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; SONGS Internet Explorer; .NET CLR 1.1.4322) 192.21 2.253.1 7
From: <Marah1 00 @ msn.corn>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 20,2005 455 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Victor Farah
I vfarahl OO@msn.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; YPC 3.0.3; .NET CLR 1.0.3705; MSN 9.O;MSN 9.1;
MSNbDELL; MSNmen-us; MSNclA; MPLUS)
68.1 24.21 5.1 65
From: csanbad @adelphia.net>
To: cCouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Mon, Jun 20,2005 7:OO PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page 1 1
partment, A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "C
City Council.
ntact Us" form to d
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
sandra abbott
6583 windflower dr carlsbad, ca 92009 usa
sanbad@adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.70.231.38
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD 1 CONTACT US Page 1
From: <abboski @adelphia.net>
To: ~Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Mon, Jun 20,2005 7:Ol PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
tim abbott
6583 windflower dr carlsbad, ca 92009 usa
abboski @ adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.70.231.38
From: csabbo C# adelphia.net>
To: cCouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 20,2005 7:02 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
brandon abbott 6583 windflower dr carlsbad, ca 92009 usa
sabbo Q adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.70.231.38
From: <margie Q purdyhomes.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Mon, Jun 20,2005 8:58 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Margaret L.Purdy
Margie Purdy 3795 Monroe St Carlsbad, Ca 92008
margie Q purdyhomes.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; Maxthon) 67.121.194.90
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page 1
From: cLCSeymour Q hotmail.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 20,2005 10:40 PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the “Contact Us” form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ...............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please save Ponto Beach from being over developed. What has set Carlsbad apart from Oceanside has
been the careful planning and even purchase of land (Hosp Grove) so that we are not over developed. Do
the EIR! Do what is best for the residents. We live here all the time,unlike the tourists who would be the
only ones benefitting from this project. This resort will do nothing for me or my family. Our jobs,schools,
roads and infrastructure will not benefit from hotel rooms. As it is, you can barely see the beach because
of the the sea wall, adding a high rise hotel to one of the last places you can see the ocean is a shame
and unfair to all the residents of Carlsbad.
Please rethink this development. The Constitution does not guarantee, nor does any law, that people have the right to make a profit from their land. Nor does it guarantee a right to develop that land. This is a
speculative land deal, there are no guarantees. The rights of the property owners do not trump the rights
of the citizens!
Linda Seymour
, 92008
LCSeymour Q hotmail.com Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; YPC 3.2.0; .NET CLR 1.1.4322; yplus 4.1 .OOb)
67.1 16.208.154
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page1 1
From: <unboundvoice@ yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]~
Date: Mon, Jun 20,2005 11 :23 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Please stop the construction of the Ponto beach front hotel. Are we trying to ruin all of CA. North county is
beautiful because of its lack of such things. Why turn Carlsbad into a Newport Beach? If we don't start now the entire coast line of southern CA with be hotels and parking structures. There will be no room left
for a father and son to enjoy a day at their local beach, free from mobs of tourists, trafffic, and the
headaches of overpopulation. Please don't take away our last gem. Ponto jetty and the city of Carlsbad
are loved for there carefree family atmosphere. Another hotel will only hinder the city. And all those who
grew up in Carlsbad will look at their city in sadness, remembering what once was.
mike pickren , 92008
unboundvoice Q yahoo.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.228.84.1 00
1 Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Paae 1 I
From: <phyllisbrady Q rnsn.com
To: <Council Q[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 5:34 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I understand that a hotel project is being discussed for Ponto Beach.
PLEASE do NOT approve a development at PONTO BEACH without conducting an Environmental Impact
Report of the area FIRST.
Any discussion of putting a hotel on the beach without an EIR is putting the cart before the horse, and you
need to be mindful of the repurcussions of such a project to the area and people of Carlsbad you
represent.
Thank you!
Phyllis Brady 361 5 Haverhill St. Carlsbad, CA 92008 USA phyllisbrady@ rnsn.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl)
68.71.4.1 20
From: <maggiehoodQadelphia.net>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 21,2005 7:13 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am concerned about the Ponto Beach Hotel Development and it's impact on the Beach, Wildlife and Batiquitos Lagoon where I live. I am requesting an Environmental Impact Study prior to proceeding with
this project
I maggiehood Q adelphia.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.167.156.47
1 Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page 1 I
From: dobreed55 @ hotmail.com>
To: ~Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Tue, Jun 21,2005 7:41 AM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Rob Reed
Rob Reed
3203 Calle Vallarta Carlsbad, CA 92009 USA
robreed55 @ hotmail.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; Genzyme / 1 .Oa; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
199.245.32.1 1
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page 1 1
From: ejennifer @ sdsc.edu>
To: ~Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Tue, Jun 21,2005 7:43 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Save Ponto!
and NO to "La Costa Town Square"
there's a large population ready to replace the city coucil if it doesn't stop over building Carlsbad.
Jenn if er Matt hews
, 92009
jennifer@sdsc.edu
Mozillah.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKiV412 (KHTML, like Gecko) SafarV412
132.239.1 53.83
From:
To:
Date:
Subject :
<maggiehood Q adelphia.net>
<ManagerQ[205.142.109.13]>
Tue, Jun 21,2005 7:ll AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to th- City of Carlsbad Web site has completed
City Manager.
nd posted the "Cor
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
act Us" form to departm
I am concerned about the Ponto Beach Hotel Development and it's impact on the Beach, Wildlife and
Batiquitos Lagoon where I live. I am requesting an Environmental Impact Study prior to proceeding with
this project.
J maggiehood Q adelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.1 67.1 56.47
From: cjessicawhite27 Q yahoo.com>
To: cCouncil@[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 20,2005 11 :25 AM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Jessica White
jessica white
jessicawhite27 Q yahoo.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0)
1 2.1 49.1 66.45
,
1 Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page 1
From: ebenjbowen Q hotmail.com>
To: eCouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 20,2005 1:30 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
ar Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Ben Bowen
Ben Bowen
benjbowen 63 hotmail.com
Mozilld4.O (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; Hotbar 4.1.2.0)
138.64.8.54
1
June 14,2005
Attn: Carlsbad City Council
CC: State Senator Bill Morrow
Assembly Member Mark Wyland
Council Chambers
Carlsbad Clty Hall
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Dear Constituents,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have
on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I
want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full Environmental Impact Report prior to
approving development for this plan. I believe it is essential that we allocate
some oceanfront land to remain in its natural state providing not only land for the
ecosystem but also land to serve legacy for future generations to enjoy.
The State of California has very little natural coastal land left; an unfortunate
result of corporate greed and political oversight. I urge you to take to path less
traveled and provide a legacy for our children and future generations.
Thankyou,
Gavin P. McBride
Carlsbad Resident and Registered Voter
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Paae 1 I
From: eellewinchellQ msn.com>
To : <Council@[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
Sat, Jun 18,2005 12:56 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assem bly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Theresa Winchell
Theresa Winchell
6550 Ponto Dr #43 Carlsbad, CA 92009
ellewinchell Qmsn.com
Mozillal4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322; MSN 9.O;MSN 9.1; MSNbMSNI; MSNmen-us; MSNclA; MPLUS)
63.16.60.175
I Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Page 1 I
From: <melissavl@adelphia.net>
To : <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sat, Jun 18, 2005 8:39 PM
Subject : CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
, melissavlQadelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98; Win 9x 4.90)
68.70.222.1 9
1 Council Internet Mailbox - CITY OF CARLSBAD 1 CONTACT US Page1 I
From: <nakj760-n11 Qsbcglobal.net>
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Sat, Jun 18,2005 7:33 AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am a resident of Carlsbad for 20 years and have many friends here. We all believe the city Council has
trended in the wrong direction after many years of great service. Controlled growth has always been the
motto of Carlsbad.
Perform the Environmental Report on the Ponto project.!!!!! Don't try to hide this necessary step from the
citizens of Carlsbad!
, 92008 nakj760-nll Qsbcglobal.net
Mozillal4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; YPC 3.0.3; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
63.202.234.1 76
From: <cbsskaff @ yahoo.com>
To: ~CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Mon, Jun 20,2005 10:59 AM Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department, City Council.
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
To whom it may concern,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development of this plan.
Thank you,
Rosalie Skaff
Rosalie Skaff
527 Meridian Way Carlsbad, CA 92009 San Diego
cbss kaff Q yahoo.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.70.94.1 51
I Manaqer Internet Email - CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US Paqe 1 I
From: <smokes1 Qsbcglobaheb
To: <ManagerQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Tue, Jun 14,2005 548 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Manager.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
The Ponto Beach development sounds like a bloated and unecessary project for Carlsbad. As a new
resident last year, I attended the Citizens Academy and heard officials talk about being responsive to the
citizenry and how proud they were of the 1986 plan to put limts on growth. What happened to those plans?
Why no environemntal impact study?
Matthew Shakter
7121 Rockrose Terr ,
smokes1 Qsbcglobal.net
Mozillal4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; yplus 4.1 .OOb)
68.1 24.89.1 53
From: <collette-dude1 Q msn.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]~
Date:
Subject:
Fri, Jun 17,2005 11:ll AM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted: I am a 15 year old surfer that lives in the neighborhoods surrounding ponto. As a residenVsurfer I think the
development of the open space by ponto would be a bad idea because with the new development ponto
would be overcrowded and traffic would be horrible. Also when it rains all runoff goes out through the
jetties and causes the surrounding water to be to polluted to surf. With this vision plan runoff would
become even worse and the surrounding water may become to polluted.Thank you for your time.
Concerned ResidenVSurfer
Rick Collette
731 5 Seafarer PI. Carlsbad, California 92009 USA
collette-dude1 Q rnsn.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
68.70.94.1 68
From: 4egallup Q yahoo.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Thu, Jun 16,2005 3:09 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A Visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council.
One the things that makes Carlsbad special is it's beaches. The proposed evelopment of the Ponto Area
is overbloan and unnecessary. Carlsbda shoudl concentrate on the redevlopment of The Village area instead of spoiling the last remaining beachfront open space in the city. The Forum and all the other
housing slated for Carlsbad is enough!!!
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Ted Gallup
Carlsbad, CA 92008
tegallup@ yahoo.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
162.1 19.232.105
From: <gary-bmw@ pacbell.net>
To: <Council Q [205.142.109.13]>
Date: Wed, Jun 15,2005 10:36 AM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Gary M. Farinacci
Gary Farinacci 2900 Wintergreen Dr. Carlsbad, CA 92008 San Diego
gary-bmwQ pacbell.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1)
63.95.170.150
From: <Neekagirll 1 SQaol.com>
To: <Council@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject :
Tue, Jun 14,2005 4:25 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan. This "Vision" is not right for the
city and it's residents!
Thank you, Monique C Leibee
Monique L.
Carlsbad, CA 92009
Neekagirll 19Qaol.com
Mozilla/4.O (compatible; MSIE 6.0; AOL 8.0; Windows NT 5.1)
207.200.1 16.1 96
From: <amanjen Q adelphia.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Tue, Jun 14,2005 1 :47 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department, City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
The Godfreys
The Godfrey's
7407 Carlina St. Carlsbad, ca 92009 amanjen Qadelphia.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
69.1 60.1 32.22
From: <marlenehl Qadelphia.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]~
Date: Tue, Jun 14,2005 12:48 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Marlene Hanson
Marlene Hanson 61 2 Navigator Ct. Carlsbad, CA 92009
marlenehl Qadelphia.net
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.0.3705)
67.20.68.248
From: <dpleso Q sbcglobal.net>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 13,2005 8:38 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
...............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Dana Pleso
A concerned Carlsbad Home Owner
Dana Pleso
Paseo Salinero Carlsbad, Ca 92009
dpleso Q sbcglobal.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1 ; SVl)
67.1 16.21 8.236
From: cCGherbQaol.com>
To: cCouncil@[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
Mon, Jun 13,2005 559 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am concerned about the "Ponto Beachfront Development Plan" and its impact on the environment and
our beautiful beach. Fine sandy beaches are rare and Ponto is one of the finest beaches in Carlsbad and
attracts many tourists. This development plan is being implemented with no environmental impact report,
no concern for the impact on the traffic, and no concern for the impact on our beach community. Please
stop this ill fated plan and save our precious resources that are responsible for more revenue than that of
a few hotels and restaraunts.
Christopher Herbert
3304'Calle San Blas Carlsbad, CA 92009
CGherb@aol.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SVl)
68.70.231.1 6
From: <plehrmann Q hotmail.com>
To: <CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sun, Jun 12,2005 3:58 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
Dear Council Member/Senator/Assembly Member,
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you,
Patrick Lehrmann
Patrick Lehrmann
1306 Statice Ct Carlsbad, CA 92009
plehrmann 62 hotmail.com
Mozilld4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322)
66.1 46.1 90.1 0
From: <slcarrolll @sbcglobal.net>
To: ~CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date: Sun, Jun 12,2005 1:41 PM
Subject: CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
You are our City Council and are voted to protect our city's best interest. You have obviously not done
what we voted for you to do. Regarding the Ponto Beach planned development, I, as a 20 year resident of
Carlsbad totally object. I recall when we voted for a no-growth measure. Well, I understand progress, and
I know it is necessary to develope and improve a city for it to remain healthy. But lands directly adjacent to
the pristine Pacific Ocean
NEED:
An ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT
CONTROL OVER THE ACTUAL OUTCOME
REASONABLE TRAFFIC STUDIES
PROTECTION OF THE BATlQUlTOS LAGOON ECOLOGICAL RESERVE.
I AM A VERY CONCERNED CARLSBAD RESIDENT!
Stephanie Carroll
6926 Peach Tree Rd.
Carlsbad, CA 92009
Stephanie Carroll
6926 Peach Tree Rd. Carlsbad, CA 92009-3934
slcarrolll Qsbcglobal.net
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; sbcydsl 3.12; YPC 3.0.1; FunWebProducts)
67.127.1 58.221
From: <johndQtfb.com>
To: ~CouncilQ[205.142.109.13]>
Date:
Subject:
A visitor to the City of Carlsbad Web site has completed and posted the "Contact Us" form to department,
City Council.
Fri, Jun 10, 2005 7:26 PM
CITY OF CARLSBAD I CONTACT US
..............................................
FOR SECURITY REASONS, DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT LINE. ..............................................
Below, please find the information that was submitted:
I am a homeowner just off of La Costa Ave, with a very small view of Ponto beach. Ponto is where I go
with my family. Ruining my view, and my accessibility with a hotels and parking garages will definitely ,
negatively impact my experience as a Carlsbad resident. Thousands of my neighbors will remember this
at the next election. This project is not good for Carlsbad.
I am concerned about the impact that the Ponto Beachfront Vision Plan will have on South Carlsbad State
Beach and the Batiquitos Lagoon Ecological Reserve. I want the City of Carlsbad to perform a full
Environmental Impact Report prior to approving development for this plan.
Thank you, John DeLand
La Costa
John DeLand
3350 Del Rio Ct. Carlsbad, CA 92009
johndQtfb.com
Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSlE 6.0; Windows 98)
72.1 4.1 41.1 83