The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2013-09-17; City Council; 21370; Presentation Animal Services Animal AdvocacyCITY OF CARLSBAD - AGENDA BILL AB# 21,370 PRESENTATION BY STAFF AND COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO DEPT OF ANIMAL SERVICES REGARDING PET ADOPTION AND ANIMAL ADVOCACY DEPT. DIRECTOR MTG. 9-17-13 PRESENTATION BY STAFF AND COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO DEPT OF ANIMAL SERVICES REGARDING PET ADOPTION AND ANIMAL ADVOCACY CITYATTY. KK. DEPT. Police PRESENTATION BY STAFF AND COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO DEPT OF ANIMAL SERVICES REGARDING PET ADOPTION AND ANIMAL ADVOCACY CITY MGR. RECOMMENDED ACTION: To receive a follow up presentation from Police Department regarding animal advocacy. ITEM EXPLANATION; At the July 16 council workshop, Police Department staff and a representative from the County of San Diego Department of Animal Services presented information on pet adoption and animal advocacy. The presentation included an overview of the adoption, spay/neuter, vaccination, and licensing services made available to community members via the City's contract with the County of San Diego Department of Animal Services. In addition, staff discussed how the City of Carlsbad can support responsible pet ownership. Finally, staff presented an overview of ordinances passed in other California cities banning the retail sale of puppies. This follow up presentation will include an overview of actions taken to-date as a result of council direction to enhance the City's participation in adoption, spay/neuter, vaccination, and licensing events. Additionally, staff will provide requested information to assist council in decision-making regarding changing the number of dogs allowable by residents, and whether the City should introduce an ordinance banning the retail sale of puppies. FISCAL IMPAa: None. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPAa: Pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21065, this action does not constitute a "project" within the meaning of CEQA in that it has no potential to cause either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment, and therefore does not require environmental review. EXHIBITS: None DEPARTMENT CONTACT: Fiona Everett 760-931-2297 fiona.everett@carlsbadca.gov FOR CITY CLERKS USE ONLY. COUNCIL ACTION: A minute motion by Council Member Blackburn was approved directing staff to develop a plan to allow the single existing business in Carlsbad to continue commercial pet sales and prohibit the commercial pet sales by any new business. 3/2/0 A minute motion by Council Member Blackburn to amend the Carlsbad Municipal Code to permit residents to have a fourth adult animal temporarily if the fourth animal is a foster animal failed. Morgen Fry From: Council Internet Email Sent: Monday, September 16, 2013 9:38 AM ^'^^•ii^ -Jkiasi^#erai# | ?L . ^.Z^^?^"^ For the Information of the-~" Subject: FW: Please, no increase in the animal limits within Carlsbad! . Q^jy COUNCIL ACM AXCAJXCC Pate 1(({7city Manager^ From: Bruce Burkland rmallto:burklandb(a)Yahoo.cQm] Sent: Sunday, September 15, 2013 11:07 AM To: matthallforcltvhall(5)amall.com; Council Internet Email; keithb911(q)aol.com; lorralne(q)lorralnewood.com Cc: Bruce Burkland; Melissa Genewlch Subject: Please, no increase in the animal limits within Carlsbad! Carlsbad Mayor and City Council, I totally agree with the attached message from Melissa Genewich. I live in close quarters with my neighbors and to allow additional animals in this neighborhood would be a tremendous nuisance. We currently have cats that climb over our fence and defecate in our planters, and dogs that wake us in the morning with their barking. Allowing more animals would further decrease the enjoyment of our home. Please do not increase the number of animals per household beyond what is already allowed. Six animals is entirely too many within the city of Carlsbad! Thank you, Bruce Burkland 2253 Masters Rd Carlsbad, CA 92008 From: Melissa Genewich <melissaqenewich@vahoo.com> To: "matthallforcitvhall(g)qmail.com" <matthallforcitvhaH@qmail.com>: "Council@carlsbadca.qov" <CouncH@carlsbadca.qov>: "keithb911@aol.com" <keithb911 @aol.com>: "lorraine@lorrainewood.com" <lorraine@lorrainewood.com> Hello Mr. Mayor Matt Hall and City Council Members, I understand that Council member Keith Blackburn Is yet again pushing for a change in the city code that would allow for an increase in the number of adult animals per household. I am astounded that this keeps sneaking it's way onto your agenda. It would be irresponsible and a detriment to our community to change this city code. I wish I could attend the meeting on Tuesday morning, however with a preschooler at home, I am unable to do so. I have copied just a few of our city residents that feel the same way I do regarding this issue. My next door neighbor used to run dog rescue out of her home (against the current code) so I can say with confidence that passing this would be a HUGE mistake for our city! As parents of two young children, we spend numerous hours enjoying our backyard and would like to do so without smelling animal waste, without having to listen to constant barking, without dealing with an excessive amount of flies, and without feeling potential concerns for our children's safety. With the current code, we already experience nights filled with howling and barking dogs and a neighbor with 3 adult dogs that provide our wake up call regularly at 6:00am In the morning. Please don't help to compound the problem. As avid walkers, we also spend quite a bit of our time on our city sidewalks and streets. I can honestly say that almost EVERY DAY we see animal waste on the sidewalks of old Carlsbad...all around our neighborhoods. This waste ends up polluting our creeks, waterways and the ocean that we all share and enjoy! Increasing the number of animals allowable will only add to these disappointing problems. We are dog owners and lovers, however we feel strongly the current domestic animal limits are fair and In such close proximity with our neighbors, any number in excess of that presents health, safety, and noise issues. Please fight for the sensible choice. We do not live in an area that has multi-acre properties that would be suitable for an excessive number of animals. 6 adult animals In one household = more noise, more waste, more smell, more flies. Thanks for your prompt attention to this matter! Respectfully, Melissa Genewich (760)271-5203 Morgen Fry Subject: FW: NO increase in animal limits - save Carlsbad! From: Melissa Genewich rmailto:melissaqenewlch@yahoo.cQm] Sent: Sunday, September 15, 2013 8:57 AM l^' matthallforcltyhallpqmail.com; Council Internet Email; keithb911@aol.cQm; lorraine@lorrainewood.cQm Cc: Rebecca Carper; Julie Peterson; ashlevshannonharris@Qmail.mm; Nicole DesAutels; Libby McGuffin; Terra Barton- Tracey Hageman; Erin Padilla; Heather Bensen; Beth Walsh; Heather Mohr; Bruce Burkland; Rebecca Curry; Rebecca ' Hoy; pbavlon43@cox.net Subject: NO increase in animal limits - save Carlsbad! Hello Mr. Mayor Matt Hall and City Council Members, I understand that Council member Keith Blackburn is yet again pushing for a change in the city code that would allow for an increase in the number of adult animals per household. I am astounded that this keeps sneaking it's way onto your agenda. It would be irresponsible and a detriment to our community to change this city code. I wish I could attend the meeting on Tuesday morning, however with a preschooler at home, I am unable to do so. I have copied just a few of our city residents that feel the same way I do regarding this issue. My next door neighbor used to run dog rescue out of her home (against the current code) so I can say with confidence that passing this would be a HUGE mistake for our city! As parents of two young children, we spend numerous hours enjoying our backyard and would like to do so without smelling animal waste, without having to listen to constant barking, without dealing with an excessive amount of flies, and without feeling potential concerns for our children's safety. With the current code, we already experience nights filled with howling and barking dogs and a neighbor with 3 adult dogs that provide our wake up call regularly at 6:00am in the morning. Please don't help to compound the problem. As avid walkers, we also spend quite a bit of our time on our city sidewalks and streets. I can honestly say that almost EVERY DAY we see animal waste on the sidewalks of old Carlsbad...all around our neighborhoods. This waste ends up polluting our creeks, waterways and the ocean that we all share and enjoy! Increasing the number of animals allowable will only add to these disappointing problems. We are dog owners and lovers, however we feel strongly the current domestic animal limits are fair and in such close proximity with our neighbors, any number in excess of that presents health, safety, and noise issues. Please fight for the sensible choice. We do not live in an area that has multi-acre properties that would be suitable for an excessive number of animals. 6 adult animals in one household = more noise, more waste, more smell, more flies. Thanks for your prompt attention to this matter! Respectfully, Melissa Genewich (760)271-5203 Morgen Fry Subject: FW: MORE THAN THREE DOGS????? From: Meg Beauchamp rmailto:meabowenl@mac.rnm] Sent: Monday, September 16, 2013 9:58 AM To: Council Internet Email Subject: MORE THAN THREE DOGS????? Recently information has been circulated that at the City Council Workshop, discussion was made concerning mcreasmg the amount of adult dogs allowed in one home. The current code allows for three dogs-more than enough for a house to enjoy the benefits of pet ownership without putting undue burden on their neighbors As It currently stands, some of our neighbors have two dogs-two more than they can control. If two dogs left outside create noise all day-what would 6 be like? Are residents going to be restricted to keeping their 6 dogs mside 24/7? I have filed two complaints with the animal department about the aggressive nature of our neighbors dogs (two large dogs getting loose and chasing down a mom and 6 year old was no picnic) Can you imagine the outcome had it been 6 dogs? Very few people have the training and common sense necessary to raise and control 6 dogs. Six dogs without proper guidance and responsible ownership can become a huge danger to our kids and neighborhoods. For the record, I have one dog and am trying to adopt another. We are a dog friendly family that recognizes the reward of having pets, but not to the detriment of the community. Sometimes when I hear proposals such as this, that sound so outlandish for the community, I can only wonder who city council is pandering to? Keep the code at 3-good for the community and good for neighbors. Meg Beauchamp megbovv^enl (olmac.com 760-585-6195 Morgen Fry Subject: FW: NO increase in Animal Code in Carlsbad Attachments: 9-17-13AgendaPacket.pdf From: Rebecca Carper rmailto:rebecca.carper@hotmail.com] Sent: Monday, September 16, 2013 10:18 AM To: keithb911@aol.com; Council Internet Email Subject: NO increase in Animal Code In Carlsbad Dear Mr. Blackburn, I see that you have, yet again, pushed your agenda for the upcoming council meeting. For the past four years, I have tried to elicit some response from you, other than your sneakily addressing this issue. The issue, to be clear, is that of increasing the number of adult animals per Carlsbad residency from 3 to 6! You have never contacted me directly. You have never answered my emails, or those of the other fine citizens of this city. Other than robo- responses, just sent by the city! I have appealed to the human side of you, siting child safety issues, concerns over potential loose packs of dogs. No response. I have highlighted pollution issues caused by animal waste and noise pollution. No response. I have been an advocate for responsible pet ownership and civic pride. No response. Your love of PIT BULLS has become more important than the HUMANS you are supposed to serve. I am shocked and disappointed. I will continue to let people know what you have been trying to do to our lovely Carlsbad. I hope that they, too will contact you with their concerns. I trust they will send this email to other caring Carlsbad citizens. Perhaps some will even join me tomorrow morning at the Council meeting. Mrs. Rebecca Carper Morgen Fry From: Council Internet Email Sent: Monday, September 16, 2013 11:04 AM To: Morgen Fry Subject: FW: 3 dogs From: Meg Beauchamp rmailto:meqbowenl@mac.cQm] Sent: Monday, September 16, 2013 10:40 AM To: keithb911@aol.com: Council Internet Email Subject: 3 dogs I wrote a letter to the council and reps a while ago concerning the 3 dog discussion and would like to reiterate my stance. The current code allows for three dogs-more than enough for a house to enjoy the benefits of pet ownership without putting undue burden on their neighbors. Allowing six dogs to reside in a neighborhood home defies common sense, as this is not a rural community where we all sit on acres and acres of land. Are residents going to be restricted to keeping their 6 dogs inside 24/7 to keep neighborhood free from the barking of six dogs? How is the city going to enforce nuisance issues with a home with 6 dogs? Very few people have the proper trainmg to raise and control 6 dogs and 6 dogs without proper guidance and responsible ownership can become a huge danger to our kids and neighborhoods. Sometimes when I hear proposals such as this, that sound so outlandish for the community, I can only wonder who city council is pandering to? Keep the code at 3-good for the community and good for neighbors. Meg Beauchamp 3070 Monroe St, 92008 megbowenl@mac.com 760-585-6195 Morgen Fry From: Sent: To: Subject: Council Internet Email Monday, September 16, 2013 11:04 AM Morgen Fry FW: amendment to 3 dog rule From: Meg Beauchamp rmailto:meQbowenl(a)me.cQm] Sent: Monday, September 16, 2013 10:56 AM To: Council Internet Email; keithb911(q)aol.com Subject: amendment to 3 dog rule It was brought to my attention that the city only wants to increase the 3 dog rule to 4, with the 4th dog being a "temporary" foster. That essentially makes the dog a Ml time resident and once it leaves I am certain the home owner will waste not time in replacing dog with another foster. SO exactly how is the city going to define temporary? One week, 1 month or until foster gets adopted??? Who will be enforcing this code? The reality of this proposal is allow homeowners to have FOUR dogs and you still get a big fat NO fi-om me. Meg Beauchamp megbowenl (a).mac.com 760-585-6195 Morgen Fry Rebecca Carper <rebecca.carper@hotmail.com> Sent: Thursday, July 18. 2013 6:40 AM I°i. , Matt-Mayor Hall; Council Internet Email; keithb911@aol.com; lorraine@lorrainewood com Subject: Concerned Carlsbad Citizen Dear Mr. Mayor Matt Hall and Carlsbad Council Members, It has come to my attention that your recent City Council Workshop (7/16/13) included discussion about increasing the amount of adult dogs Carlsbad allows per household. The current code allows for 3 adult pets. I am greatly concerned that you would consider raising this amount under any circumstance. Carlsbad is not a rural community that has space and services for homes with large numbers of dogs. We live close to our neighbors. Multiple dogs are a noise and safety issue! My daughter, and many of her friends, walk to school. Play in the neighborhoods. Can you make any guarantees for their comfort and safety? We already dodge many dog obstacles. Our lovely beachside community is over run with dog waste on it's sidewalks. Storm drain pollution is a real concern. Let alone the smell, flies, and germs the multiple dog waste brings. As responsible dog lovers, we try to meet the needs of our pets and balance the common respect for our neighbors. I have been dealing with a neighbor that continually ignores the codes and evades the code enforcement on this very subject. How will you enforce future codes with such extreme numbers? Honestly, who can truly care for 6 dogs in our neighborhoods. How fair is that to the dogs? The Neighbors? The greater reputation of Carlsbad? I trust you'll do whatever it takes to insure that Carlsbad does not become a place that considers 6 dogs per household a good idea. Thank you for your time and attention to this community, Mrs. Rebecca A. Carper Morgen Fry ^^om: Susan Briggs <briggs_suesue@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, July 18, 2013 7:28 AM To: Council Internet Email Please do not increase the number of dogs an owner can have. Our yards are used as dog poop parks as it is. Attending Carlsbad functions such as the Farmer's market make it difficult to navigate with the dogs attending. Jazz in the park is supposedly dog free, not so. I have gone to each concert with dogs. Hike dogs and I am a responsib le, thoughtful community member for 31 years. Three dogs is more than most people can and do take care of That is more than enough. Susan B. Morgen Fry ^^om: Meg Beauchamp <megbowen1@mac.com> Sent: Thursday, July 18, 2013 7:52 AM matthallforcityhall@gmail.com; Council Internet Email; keithb911 @aol.com; lorraine@lorrainewood.Gom Subject: 3 Dogs per home Recently information has been circulated that at the City Council Workshop, discussion was made concerning mcreasing the amount of adult dogs allowed in one home. The current code allows for three dogs-more than enough for a house to enjoy the benefits of pet ownership without putting undue burden on their neighbors. As It currently stands, some of our neighbors have two dogs-two more than they can control. If two dogs left outside create noise all day-what would 6 be like? Are residents going to be restricted to keeping their 6 dogs mside 24/7? I have filed two complaints with the animal department about the aggressive nature of our neighbors dogs (two large dogs getting loose and chasing down a mom and 6 year old was no picnic). Can you imagine the outcome had it been 6 dogs? Very few people have the training and common sense necessary to raise and control 6 dogs. Six dogs without proper guidance and responsible ownership can become a huge danger to our kids and neighborhoods. Sometimes when I hear proposals such as this, that sound so outlandish for the community, I can only wonder who city council is pandering to? Keep the code at 3-good for the community and good for neighbors. Meg Beauchamp megbowenl fa)mac.com 760-585-6195 Morgen Fty ^rom: Carper, Randy <Randy.Carper@smawins.com> Sent: Thursday, July 18, 2013 11:55 AM """0= "Rebecca Carper'; Matt-Mayor Hall; Council Internet Email; keithb911@aol.com; lorraine@lorrainewood.com Subject: RE: Concerned Carlsbad Citizen Hi Mayor Hall and Council Members, I would like to add that I oppose a change to the codes and ordinances that would increase the quantity of adult animals(mainly dogs) in a household based on the safety of our children In Carlsbad. I would like you to think how dogs love to go where they are not allowed to go. That would be out of the yard and down the street trying to be curious about everything new. Now get an aggressive dog out roaming around, maybe a pack of 6 dogs out roaming around because if one can get, they all can get out. I know that not all dogs are aggressive, but it only takes a pack of dogs to become more aggressive than usual. If you Increase the allowed adults dogs in a household, there Is a huge potential for this to happen increasing the likeliness that it will happen. Can you imagine a 6-8 year old walking to school and run into this? Maybe your kids or grandkids? There is no way that a regular home owner will take every measure to ensure their dogs do not get out. Take a look at the measures a shelter takes, this Is probably cost prohibited and not to mention the home owners knowledge to prepare the home for that quantity of animals. I have experienced firsthand with a code violator in Carlsbad who had 6-8 dogs most of them rescue dogs in her home. The noise all the time was horrible, the smell from the back yard was horrible, and I can remember at least four times the dogs got out and were roaming around the streets. 1 know that is just one person, think about it if you allowed more dogs. We called code enforcement and she played the games to not get inspected at a time when she had all eight dogs. Does Carlsbad want to take on the financial burden of more calls to code enforcement on a bunch of howling dogs? Or inspections because the smell is so bad people can't enjoy their back yard because their neighbor has 6 dogs and the smell is horrible? You know this will happen. Seems like a simple thing to me. Do the right thing "Keep our kids safe" and make it so people can enjoy living in Carlsbad. Thanks, Randy MIS Manager (949) 975-1550 Ext 273 From: Rebecca Carper rmailto:rebecca.carper(g)hotmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 18, 2013 6:40 AM To: Matt-Mayor Hall; Council(g)carlsbadca.qov; keithb911@aol.com; lorraine(g)lorrainewood.com Subject: Concerned Carlsbad Citizen I Dear Mr. Mayor Matt Hall and Carlsbad Council Members, 1 It has come to my attention that your recent City Council Workshop (7/16/13) included discussion about increasing the amount of adult dogs Carlsbad allows per household. The current code allows for 3 adult pets. I am greatly concerned that you would consider raising this amount under any circumstance. Carlsbad is not a rural community that has space and services for homes with large numbers of dogs. We live close to our neighbors. Multiple dogs are a noise and safety issue! My daughter, and many of her friends, walk to school. Play in the neighborhoods. Can you make any guarantees for their comfort and safety? We already dodge many dog obstacles. Our lovely beachside community is over run with dog waste on it's sidewalks. Storm drain pollution is a real concern. Let alone the smell, flies, and germs the multiple dog waste brings. As responsible dog lovers, we try to meet the needs of our pets and balance the common respect for our neighbors. I have been dealing with a neighbor that continually ignores the codes and evades the code enforcement on this very subject. How will you enforce future codes with such extreme numbers? Honestly, who can truly care for 6 dogs in our neighborhoods. How fair is that to the dogs? The Neighbors? The greater reputation of Carlsbad? 1 trust you'll do whatever it takes to insure that Carlsbad does not become a place that considers 6 dogs per household a good idea. Thank you for your time and attention to this community, Mrs. Rebecca A. Carper Morgen Fry Randy Carper <randy.carper@hotmail.com> Sent: Thursday, July 18, 2013 11:57 AM Rebecca Carper; Matt-Mayor Hall; Council Internet Email; keithb911@aol com- lorraine@lorrainewood.com Subject: Concerned Carlsbad Citizen Hi Mayor Hall and Council Members, 1 would like to add that I oppose a change to the codes and ordinances that would Increase the quantity of adult animals{mainly dogs) in a household based on the safety of our children in Carlsbad. I would like you to think how dogs love to go where they are not allowed to go. That would be out of the yard and down the street trying to be curious about everything new. Now get an aggressive dog out roaming around, maybe a pack of 6 dogs out roaming around because if one can get, they all can get out. 1 know that not all dogs are aggressive, but it only takes a pack of dogs to become more aggressive than usual. If you increase the allowed adults dogs in a household, there is a huge potential for this to happen increasing the likeliness that it will happen. Can you imagine a 6-8 year old walking to school and run into this? Maybe your kids or grandkids? There is no way that a regular home owner will take every measure to ensure their dogs do not get out. Take a look at the measures a shelter takes, this is probably cost prohibited and not to mention the home owners knowledge to prepare the home for that quantity of animals. 1 have experienced firsthand with a code violator in Carlsbad who had 6-8 dogs most of them rescue dogs in her home The noise all the time was horrible, the smell from the back yard was horrible, and I can remember at least four times the dogs got out and were roaming around the streets. I know that is just one person, think about it if you allowed more dogs. We called code enforcement and she played the games to not get inspected at a time when she had all eight dogs. Does Carlsbad want to take on the financial burden of more calls to code enforcement on a bunch of howling dogs? Or inspections because the smell is so bad people can't enjoy their back yard because their neighbor has 6 dogs and the smell is horrible? You know this will happen. Seems like a simple thing to me. Do the right thing "Keep our kids safe" and make it so people can enjoy living in Carlsbad. Randy Carper Morgen Fry ^fom: Melissa Genewich <melissagenewich@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, July 18, 2013 4:08 PM matthallforcityhall@gmail.com; Council Internet Email; keithbQ11 @aol.com- lorraine@lorrainewood.com Subject: Very concerned Carlsbad resident! Hello Mr. Mayor Matt Hall and City Council Members, A neighbor and friend brought to my attention that someone is trying to pass a City ordinance to allow residents to own up to 6 dogs. My next door neighbor used to run dog rescue out of her home (against the current ordinance) so I can say with confidence that passing this would be a huge mistake for our City! As parents of two young children, we spend numerous hours enjoying our backyard and would like to do so without smelling animal waste, without having to listen to constant barking, without dealing with an excessive amount of flies, and without feeling potential concerns for our children's safety. With the current ordinance, we already experience nights filled with howling and barking dogs. Please don't help to compound the problem. As avid walkers, we also spend quite a bit of our time on our city sidewalks and streets. I can honestly say that almost EVERY DAY we see animal waste on the sidewalks of old Carlsbad...all around our neighborhoods. Increasing the number of dogs allowable will only add to this disappointing problem. We are dog owners and lovers, however we feel strongly the current domestic animal limits are fair and in such close proximity with our neighbors, any number in excess of that presents health, safety, and noise issues. Please fight for the sensible choice. We do not live in an area that has multi-acre properties that would be suitable for an excessive number of animals. 6 dogs in one household = more noise, more waste, more smell, more flies. Thanks for your prompt attention to this matter! Respectfully, Melissa Genewich (760)271-5203 Morgen Fry ^^om: Ashley Harris <ashleyshannonharris@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, July 18, 2013 4:41 PM matthallforcityhall@gmail.com; Council Internet Email; keithb911@aol com- lorraine@lorrainewood.com Subject: Dog Issue Please don't allow more than 3 dogs per household. Thank you, Ashley Harris Morgen Fry From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Nicole DesAutels <nicoledesautels@yahoo.com> Friday, July 19, 2013 7:17 AM matthallforcityhall@gmail.com Council Internet Email Concerned Carlsbad resident Dear Mr. Mayor Hall, I'm writing you today as a dog owner myself in concern with the recent discussion about raising the legal limit of dogs per household. I feel the 3 dog per household now is more than enough. Raising the legal limit to 6 seems a bit excessive. My children walk to school, I'm concerned with their safety and not to mention the waste that seems to be always left behind. The added noise in the neighborhood is also a big issue. I love the city/community we live in and just want it to stay safe for my family. I want my beaches and streets to stay clean and beautiful. Thank You for your time, Nicole DesAutels Morgen Fi From: Sent: To: Subject: Rebecca Hoy <beccahoy@gmail.com> Saturday, July 20, 2013 10:24 AM matthallforcityhall@gmail.com; Council Internet Email; keithbQIiaaol com No more than 3 Dogs To Whom it May Concern, Please don't raise the current code to allow for more than 3 dogs. Our home is near the beach. Everyone comes to walk their dog along the coast. Visiting friends already comment on the amount of dogs and dog poop found along our beach front walkway. We live close to our neighbors and every sound is heard. Our neighbor, three houses away, has two basset hounds and they are noisy! The owners do a good job of monitoring the noise level, but I can't imagine them havmg more than two! I am concerned about people walking more than three dogs safely. Our girls are cautious of dogs. Owners tend to think their dogs are friendly, but many people don't feel comfortable. Our city doesn't need to spend more money monitoring more dogs. Thank you for reading and listening to our concerns, Rebecca Hoy Follow Up to Pet Adoption and Animal Advocacy City Council Workshop September 17, 2013 Today’s Agenda •Recap of last meeting •Actions taken to-date with regard to animal advocacy activities •Present additional information on: –Permissible number of dogs –Ordinances restricting pet sales Recap from Last Workshop •Reviewed Carlsbad’s contract with the County of San Diego Department of Animal Services (DAS) •Carlsbad/DAS partnership to advocate for responsible pet ownership •History and evolution of animal welfare laws, including recent bans on commercial sale of puppies Recap from Last Workshop •Carlsbad’s contract with DAS includes: –Law enforcement, sheltering, veterinary care, and pet adoption services –Low cost spay/neuter services –Hosting clinics in the community for rabies vaccination and licensing –Hosting adoption events Direction from Council •Work with DAS to host vaccination, licensing and adoption events •Host mobile spay/neuter clinics •Provide information about the number of dogs per household in Carlsbad and other cities •Provide information on what other cities are doing regarding ordinances restricting commercial sales of puppies Animal Advocacy Events •Family Arts Day at Dove Library (Sept 7) –Partnered with DAS to hold an adoption fair at the event •Vaccination and licensing clinics every Thursday at the shelter in Carlsbad •“One Stop” clinic on weekdays at Mohnacky Animal Hospital Animal Advocacy Events •DAS will have a vaccination and licensing event on Sunday, November 17 at the shelter in Carlsbad. •Spay/neuter services –Shelter does not provide for owned pets –Agreements in place with local vets for affordable service –Spay Neuter Action Project (SNAP) Animal Advocacy Events Staff will continue to partner with both the County of San Diego Department of Animal Services and SNAP to provide ongoing events to provide education about responsible pet ownership in addition to licensing, vaccination, adoption, and affordable spay/neuter services. Permissible Number of Dogs City Number of Dogs Carlsbad 3 Del Mar 6 Encinitas 6 Escondido 1 - 6 dependent on zoning Oceanside 3 San Marcos 1 - 6 dependent on zoning Solana Beach 6 Vista 4 Unincorporated County 6 Ordinance Restricting Pet Sales •History and evolution of animal welfare laws –Federal •1966 Animal Welfare Act – minimum care standards for animals bred for commercial resale •2008 Farm Bill – prohibits importation of puppies under 6 months –State of California •Higher standards of care beyond the federal level •Nutrition, space, socialization requirements •In the last three to five years, animal rights advocates have had an impact on city legislation, resulting in ordinances against commercial pet sales Ordinance Restricting Pet Sales •Thirty-three U.S. cities, including 13 in California have passed ordinances against commercial pet sales •They are addressing public concern over the practice of irresponsible breeding by “puppy mills” •“Puppy mill” implies high volume commercial breeding facility Ordinance Restricting Pet Sales •Summary of ordinances in place in other California cities: –Ban the retail sale of dogs, cats, puppies, kittens and rabbits in retail businesses –Provide exceptions for local rescues and humane societies –Protect local private, small scale breeders –Some include a grace period to allow existing businesses time to adjust their business model Ordinance Restricting Pet Sales •Of the 13 California cities with ordinances: –Five have banned with no grace period –Three have a six-month grace period –Three have a one-year grace period –Two have a two-year grace period Ordinance Restricting Pet Sales •Carlsbad has: –One retail store that sells animals –Multiple pet supply stores that sell pet supplies, but no dog/cat sales Questions? 15