HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-05-13; Housing Element Advisory Committee; ; HOUSING ELEMENT HANDOUT/FAQAgenda item 4 — DRAFT one page handout
EeI11 I'M 0 RIYAL��1�13�� �J;3
Since 1969, California law has required that all cities and counties
demonstrate how they will meet the housing needs of everyone in the
community through housing plans, known as Housing Elements. The state
regularly forecasts the need for housing in each region based on population
projections, and then each region distributes this projected need to each
city and unincorporated county area. This is referred to as the Regional
Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA), and the current allocation provides the
housing needs for the City of Carlsbad through the year 2029. To show how
this housing need can be met in Carlsbad, Housing Elements must be
updated regularly. At the end of the process, the City's updated Housing
Element must be approved by the state.
Updating Carlsbad's Housing Plan... Together
The city started its Housing Element update in 2020. It's a very public
process. In fact, the City has established the Housing Element Advisory
Committee to help guide plan development. Whether you comment at a
committee meeting or online, we need your input so the new plan reflects
our community values.
General Plan
The Housing Element is officially part of the city's General Plan, a collection
of policies that guide future development in Carlsbad. These policies are
based on what the community told us was most important, which is
summarized in the nine core values that make up the Carlsbad Community
Vision.
Why a Housing Element is Important
■ State law requires the city to adopt a Housing Element by April
2021.
■ Providing housing to meet the needs of all income levels is critical
to the social and economic health of the city.
■ With an approved Housing Element, Carlsbad is eligible for state
grants to help fund infrastructure improvements. Without an
approved plan, the city could face fines, penalties, and lawsuits.
■ The Housing Element will also include policies to address housing
for special needs populations, including homelessness.
For more information
■ Carlsbadca.gov/housing plan
■ Scott Donnell, Senior Planner,
760.602.4618/scott.donnel I @carlsbadca.gov
TIMELINE
JAN 2020
Work begins on
housing plan update
JAN -MAR 2020
Citywide housing sites
inventory starts
Spring 2020
Public input on site selection
criteria and scope of
environmental review
Summer 2020
Analysis of potential sites
available for review
Public input evaluating
potential sites
Fall 2020
Draft plan and environmental
document released for
public review
JAN - MAR 2021
Public hearings for final
plan adoption
APRIL 2021
Current housing plan expires
Deadline for final approval of
new plan
Provide plan to the state
for approval
Agenda item 4 — FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions:
1. What is a Housing Element and what does it contain?
Since 1969, California has required all local governments to plan to meet the housing needs of
everyone in the community through the development of a Housing Element. A component of
the General Plan, the Housing Element provides a strategy for promoting safe, decent and
affordable housing. The General Plan is Carlsbad's blueprint for how it will grow and develop.
Per state law, the specific purposes of the Housing Element are to assess both current and
future housing needs and constraints, and establish housing goals, policies and programs that
provide a strategy for meeting the city's housing needs.
The current City of Carlsbad Housing Element, adopted in 2017, identifies strategies and
programs that focus on these five objectives to satisfy housing needs:
• conserving and improving existing affordable housing
• maximizing housing opportunities
• assisting in the provision of affordable housing
• removing constraints to housing investment, and
• promoting fair and equal housing opportunities.
2. When and why does the Housing Element need to be updated?
State law requires regular updates to the Housing Element to ensure relevancy and accuracy.
These updates are required every eight years. The time from one update to the next is called a
housing cycle. All San Diego jurisdictions are in the fifth housing cycle that began in 2013 and
will end in 2021. (State law required Carlsbad to adopt a mid -cycle element in 2017.) The
upcoming sixth Housing Element Cycle will cover the next eight -year planning period (2021-
2029).
To comply with state law, the Carlsbad City Council needs to adopt an updated element by
April 15, 2021. Following adoption, and as a final step, the updated element will require state
review and certification.
If Carlsbad does not meet this deadline, the city would need to prepare a new Housing Element
in just four years and could face tens of thousands of dollars in fines per month until it approves
a plan. In addition, without an approved housing plan, the risk of housing -related lawsuits and
challenges to the city's entire General Plan increase.
Having an approved housing plan avoids these significant problems, helps maintain local control
over land use decisions, and makes Carlsbad eligible for state grants to help fund infrastructure
improvements.
3. What is the Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) and what is the City of Carlsbad's
RHNA?
Agenda item 4 — FAQ
A huge component of the Housing Element update is RHNA. The RHNA is a representation of
future housing need for all income levels in a region. Carlsbad's RHNA for meeting regional
housing needs is defined by the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) and state
Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). More details about RHNA are
available in a city informational brochure.
Providing housing to meet the needs of all income levels is critical to the social and economic
health of a city. Carlsbad is required to plan for its income -based housing allocation to address
its share of the San Diego region's housing needs. Income groups include: "very low income"
(<50% of the San Diego region's annual median income (AMI)), "low income" (50-80% AMI),
"moderate income" (80-120% AMI), and "above moderate income" (>120% AMI). The current
AMI for San Diego County is $86,300 for a family of four.
The table below shows Carlsbad's allocation of housing units by income group for the upcoming
sixth housing cycle. Over 50% of the allocation satisfies the housing needs of very low and low
income families. In total, nearly 3,900 housing units are needed to accommodate 2021— 2029
growth for all income groups as estimated through the RHNA process.
The RHNA is required by California state law for every jurisdiction in the state and it is the
responsibility of the City of Carlsbad to track progress towards the building of these units during
the planning period (2021-2029). See the city's 2019 Housing Element Annual Progress Report.
4. Must cities build the housing required by RHNA?
While cities do not build housing — that is the function of private developers — they do adopt
plans, regulations and programs that provide opportunities for how and where housing
development occurs. An example of an adopted plan is the General Plan, which through its
Housing Element provides housing programs and through its Land Use and Conservation
Element shows where and at what densities housing can be built.
5. What makes a house affordable to an income group?
In a word, density. The foundation of Housing Element Law is based on the premise that density
is a proxy for affordability. The idea being, the more housing units on a site (density) translates
to lower construction costs per unit, which translates to lower rental/sale prices of those units
(affordability). As such, HCD assigns minimum density figures to each income category. In
Carlsbad, the highest density figure, a minimum 30 dwelling units per acre of land, is assigned
to the very low- and low-income categories.
6. How will housing locations be selected?
Agenda item 4 — FAQ
The updated housing plan must show the exact locations where future housing can be built and
identify the potential number of homes that can be built at those locations. When it comes to
these important decisions, the City of Carlsbad is not starting from scratch. During the
beginning stages of reviewing housing locations, the city limits or eliminates sites:
• With sensitive habitat or species
• Where the topography isn't conducive to building
• That aren't safe because they're in a flood zone or high -fire area
• Within areas deemed off limits by the airport because they are in the flight path or noise
levels would be too high
Areas that could be designated for additional housing include:
• Vacant lots not designated as open space AL,
• Underutilized sites, such as lots with uses that are no longer needed or need
rehabilitation
• Locations where housing could be become denser than it is toda
• Locations near public transit and essential services like libraries and neighborhood
serving retail centers
• Areas where housing could be added near commercial buildings or in business parks,
creating "live -work" neighborhoods
• Sites where infrastructure, such as water and sewer service, can support more housing
City regulations ensure housing is not located where sensitive habitats or other constraints
occur. They work together with city policies, such as those in the General Plan, to identify
suitable housing sites. For example, one General Plan policy encourages medium and higher
density residential uses, or homes affordable to very low, low, and moderate -income families,
to locate near commercial services, job centers, and transportation corridors.
7. What about other important topics, like housing the homeless or the high cost of housing?
Are those addressed too?
Yes, a Housing Element discusses issues, trends, and solutions for many topics, including
homelessness and high housing costs. The city's current Housing Element is a great resource to
see a wealth of information that elements must contain, ranging from age of residents to
supportive and transitional housing, and from building permit fees to new home prices.
8. Where can I find more information?
For more information about the Carlsbad Housing Element and what the city is doing to address
the housing needs of its residents, visit the City of Carlsbad Housing Element Update website:
www.carlsbadca.gov/housingplan.