The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2016-09-07; Planning Commission; ; SS 16-01 - VILLAGE BARRIO AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDYThe City of Carlsbad Planning Division A REPORT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION P.C. AGENDA OF: September 7, 2016 Item No. Application complete date: N/ A Project Planner: Pam Drew Project Engineer: N/ A G) SUBJECT: SS 16-01 -VILLAGE, BARRIO AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDY -Presentation and public comment opportunity on the Village, Barrio and Beach Area Parking Study. The Village, Barrio and Beach Area are generally located west of Interstate 5 between Tamarack Avenue and Buena Vista Lagoon, west to the ocean. Parts of the study area are in the Coastal Zone. I. RECOMMENDATION To receive a presentation on the parking study and data collection efforts, receive any comments from the community and Planning Commissioners on parking in the study area, and outline next steps. Therefore, no recommendation is proposed as staff is not requesting the Planning Commission take action at this time. II. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND BACKGROUND The purpose of this meeting is to present to the Planning Commission and the public the results from the data collection, and provide an opportunity for additional public input on any parking issues and/or on the results of the data collected to date. The data collected and analyzed includes an inventory of on-and off-street parking facilities {i.e., marked and unmarked parking spaces), associated parking regulations, parking occupancy and turnover rates, as well as data collected from intercept and on-line surveys. This information will help formalize a Parking Management Plan which will be developed in support of the Village and Barrio Master Plan objectives. The Parking Management Plan will provide implementable strategies that will improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the parking system in the study area. No action will be taken at this meeting. Input on parking issues/concerns and on the data collected to date will be considered as part of the preparation of the final Parking Management Plan, which will be presented to the public, Planning Commission and then the City Council in early 2017. Ill. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW This action to receive information about the comprehensive parking study and the data collected and analyzed and to solicit feedback regarding parking issues is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act {CEQA) per State CEQA Guidelines Section 15306 -Information Collection. ATIACHMENTS: 1. Village, Barrio and Beach Area Parking Boundary Diagram 2. Draft Executive Summary, dated August 30, 2016 3. Draft Technical Memorandum #1, dated August 30, 2016 Carlsbad Village, Barrio and Beach Area Parking Study Boundaries {City of Carlsbad Magnolia Ave Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDY Technical Memorandum #1: Data Collection DRAFT Executive Summary August 30, 2016 Kimley >>>Horn (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA S. UD FOn . n£ SoJ D Parking Study Background The City of Carlsbad is developing a parking study for the Carlsbad Village, Barrio, and Beach Area. The intent of this parking study is to develop a parking management plan that will provide recommended near-term and long-term strategies to maximize efficiency of parking and improve mobility in the project area. During the planning process for the draft Village and Barrio Master Plan, it was realized that in order to identify parking management strategies and provide recommendations, it was necessary to conduct a thorough analysis of existing public and private parking supply, current use and turnover rates, and determine anticipated future parking needs in the project area. As a result, the Village, Barrio, and Beach Area Parking Study, as well as a future Parking Management Plan for the area, are being developed to support and help implement the Village and Barrio Master Plan, particularly its mobility guiding principles with the following goals in mind: A Make parking more convenient for community members and visitors A Promote more efficient use of existing parking A Support future parking needs A Explore options for making the project area more inviting for walkers, bicyclists and people who use public transportation to support the vision outlined in the Village and Barrio Master Plan The driving force behind the Village, Barrio, and Beach Area Parking Study is the need for more data to better understand current parking conditions-particularly parking occupancy, demand, and behavioral data. This is being accomplished through a thorough analysis of observed parking conditions, existing plans, and parking restrictions and regulations in the Carlsbad Municipal Code. During the development of this study, two rounds of weekday and weekend data collection efforts were conducted to capture the existing parking landscape in the study area. Parking occupancy and parking duration data were captured, and an updated inventory of on and off-street parking spaces was created. Occupancy is the percentage of spaces in a facility that are being utilized at given times. The industry standard threshold for determining effective capacity for a facility is 85-90% occupied. When facilities operate at this level of occupancy, the remaining 10-15% of available spaces are difficult to find for the user. Duration refers to how long vehicles will park in a given facility throughout the data collection period. For the purposes of this study, the on-street parking facilities were included in the duration analysis. Additionally, community participation and feedback is a crucial component of this study. Stakeholder feedback has been, and will continue to be captured, through online surveys and community meetings. The data collected, combined with public feedback, will be used to identify appropriate parking strategies for the community. The strategies and management techniques will be compiled into a draft Parking Management Plan which will be available for public review and comment in early 2017. The Parking Management Plan is expected to be finalized in spring 2017, where it will be presented to the Planning Commission and City Council for review and comment. The study area is shown in Figure ES-1 on the following page. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 2 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDY FOR THE CIT OF CARLSBAD Figure ES-1: Carlsbad Village, Barrio, and Beach Area Parking Study Area Map Legend Study Area Boundaries Barrio Neighborhood Beach Area Village Neighborhood Parking Facilities On-Street -Off-Street (Public) -Off-Street (Private) Kim ley>>> Horn N A o--==0.:112iii5-==:Jo.2iil5 _____ _.o.~iles Esri, HERE. Del orme, Mapmylnd1a, C> OpenStreetMap contnbutors. and the GIS user commun1ty Page I 3 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PAR INC STUDY FOR T-IE CIT f OF CARLSBAD Data Collection Process The Carlsbad Village, Barrio, and Beach Area Parking Study is rooted in the evaluation of existing parking conditions and behaviors in the study area as well as public input. Below is a timeline of data collection efforts thus far: ...,. Parking Occupancy Data Collection and Analysis: May-July 2016 ...,. On-Site Survey: May-June 2016 ...,. Online Survey: May-August 2016 (It should be noted that at the time of this technical memorandum the data for the online survey was analyzed between the dates of May gth and July 18th. The online survey is to remain open through the end of August to capture input during and after the public meeting). Additionally, representatives of the City of Carlsbad have actively been meeting with various neighborhood groups and organizations within the community to inform citizens about the parking study and to encourage their participation by completing the online survey. Community feedback has been gathered at various neighborhood and homeowners' association meetings, as well as a City of Carlsbad Traffic Safety Commission meeting and a Beach Preservation Committee meeting. Additionally, website and e-newsletter announcements, social media, 4,420 postcard mailings in the study area and distribution of postcards to businesses in the study area, and stories in local media have been utilized to help spread the word about the study and encourage community feedback. Summary of Analysis and Results Collecting parking data and hearing what users of the parking system have to say are integral components of understanding where, when, and how long people park, and any frustrations they experience with parking. This section presents a summary of the findings from the parking data collection and input received from the public through July 18th, 2016. On-Site Surveys Pedestrian intercept surveys were conducted on May 14th, 18th, 2Pt, and 26th, and June 16th, 18th, 22nd, and 26th, with the intent of identifying parking behaviors on typical weekday and weekends for those traveling within the study area. Surveys were conducted in both months to capture responses during the off-peak season (May) and peak season (June). The survey asked participants questions about where they were from, how they traveled to the area, where they parked, and the ease with which they found parking in relation to the time it took them to park and the proximity to their destination. The intent behind this survey was to gain knowledge on user experiences with parking in the study area. Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 4 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDY FOR THE CIT\' OF CARLSBAD Professional surveyors were stationed at eight locations throughout the study area, including three in the Beach Area, three in the Carlsbad Village, and two in the Barrio. A total of 2,139 people participated in the surveys. In May, 1,282 people participated in the survey, while 857 were surveyed in June. An additional 971 people in May and 660 people in June were approached but declined participation. The following summarizes the survey results: ~ 49% of all survey takers answered that they came to the study area to visit the beach. • Beach Area: Visiting the beach received the highest response from survey respondents during the weekend and weekday in both May and June (48% May average of weekday and weekend; 50% June average of weekday and weekend). • Carlsbad Village : Reasons for visiting the Village varied. During the weekend, dining received the most responses for visiting the Village (27% May; 20% June). On a weekday, shopping received the most responses (19% May; 16% June). • Barrio Neighborhood: In May, the highest response received of those in the Barrio Neighborhood was that participants were area residents (38% May average of weekday and weekend). In June, this was true for the weekday (43% of respondents stating they were area residents), however, for the weekend dining received more responses (33%). ~ Approximately half of respondents drove alone in a car during the weekday surveys. On weekends respondents drove more frequently with others . ..,. 54% of respondents answered that they parked on-street during both weekday and weekend surveys . ..,. 58% of respondents answered that it took them less than two minutes to park for both weekday and weekend surveys. ~ On weekdays, 57% of participants answered that they were able to park directly at their destination. On weekends, 66% of all weekend respondents were able to find parking within two blocks of their destination (37% of the 66% stated that they were able to park directly at their destination). Further discussion on the results of the online surveys can be found within the body of the technical memorandum. Additionally, responses to all questions can be found in Appendix B. Online Surveys In addition to the on-site surveys, an online survey was developed to gain perspectives from study area residents, business owners, employees, and visitors. The purpose of the study was to identify typical parking behaviors and thoughts on improving the parking system. The survey was distributed on the City's website, and business cards with the survey's web address were distributed during the on-site surveys and were provided to businesses and other popular destinations in the study area. A total of 4,420 postcards were also mailed within the study area. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 5 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P/..R INC STUDY FOR THE C/ rY OF CARLSBAD Input from this survey should be considered in a similar way to input received during public comment at a City Council meeting, remarks at a public workshop or comments provided via email to city staff. Due to the way survey participants were identified, the survey sample may not be representative of all project stakeholders. As a result, unlike a scientific study, the responses cannot be generalized to the larger population with a known margin of error. The survey went live in May and will remain open until August 3Pt. As of July 18th, a total of 647 people had participated in the survey. The following summarizes online survey responses by user type. The results shown are the highest response for that question. Further discussion on the results of the online surveys can be found within the body of the technical memorandum. Additionally, responses to all questions can be found in Appendix D. ... Resident Results-residents are those who live within the boundaries of the study area. Parking needs for this group typically focus on availability of spaces near their residence for themselves and their guests. • 223 participants identified themselves as "Residents" • 72% noted that they have designated parking and are able to park in less than two minutes ... Business Owner Results-business owners are those who own or manage a business in the study area. Parking needs for this group focus on available parking for their customers within what respondents deemed to be an appropriate distance of their business. • 48 participants identified themselves as "Business Owners" • 58% responded that they don't provide parking for their employees • 84% responded that their customers park two blocks away or less from their business. 40% responded that their customers park less than one block from their business. ... Employee Results-parking needs for employees working in businesses in the study area focus on the ability to park near their place of employment (typically within 1-2 blocks) but also being able to park long-term. • 78 participants identified themselves as "Employees" • Over 50% noted they are able to park in less than two minutes • 53% noted they park in off-street spaces close to their workplace ... Visitors-visitors are those who live outside of the study area, whether they are from a nearby city, another part of Carlsbad, or outside of the state or country. These users are coming from outside of the study area and may not be as familiar with the parking system as those who reside or work in the study area. They provide a different perspective on the parking system. • 289 participants identified themselves as "Visitors" in the survey • 75% of visitors noted they are able to park in five minutes or less Kim ley>>) Horn Page 1 6 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA .. G S U:JY 0 • 60% of visitors noted they could park within one block of their destination "" When asked about the greatest challenge with parking in the study area, the majority of respondents considered consistently finding an available space close to their destination to be the greatest challenge. "" Common themes among the general comments provided by respondents from all user groups include the following: • The parking situation in the study area is adequate and they do not desire any changes • Paid parking is not desirable • Off-street parking that is centralized between the Village and Beach areas was recommended • Enforcing time limits was recommended Parking Data Collection Parking inventory and behavioral data (occupancy and duration) was collected to determine weekday, weekend, and seasonal parking demands throughout the study area. As part of the inventory, designation of off-street and on-street facilities was identified, the number of spaces in each facility, and any restrictions regulating the facility. Occupancy and duration data was collected in the field on Thursday, May 19th and Saturday, May 2Pt between the hours of 6 a.m. and 9 p.m. Additionally, data was collected on Thursday, July 14th and Saturday, July 16th from 6 a.m. until11:30 p.m. Data was collected in both May and July to capture responses during the off-peak season (May) and peak season (July). The primary industry accepted threshold for identifying parking constraints is when 85-90% of parking spaces within a given area are consistently occupied. When occupancies for a parking system reach this level, parking efficiency starts to deteriorate and changes need to be implemented to maintain a balanced parking system. The 10-15% remaining capacity accounts for those few spaces that are scattered throughout the system that a user might have to circle to find. This level of occupancy does not necessarily have to happen across the entire system for users to experience frustrations. When facilities with the highest demand are consistently full, the perception of parking can deteriorate throughout the entire study area. This is particularly notable for communities that attract a lot of visitors to their area. Unlike residents or people who work in the area, visitors tend to be unfamiliar with the area streets and lack knowledge about where to park. Findings from parking data collection efforts are summarized below. Further discussion on the results of parking data collection can be found within the body of the technical memorandum. Additionally, a complete index of data collected can be found Appendix E. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 7 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA T ... 1-0 May Occupancy (off-season) Data collected in May represents off-season parking demands. The following are the average occupancies for the entire study area during the peak hours on the days that data was collected. "" Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 46% (1 p.m.} "" Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 49% (9 a.m.} In May, the peak for the entire study area was during the weekend at 9 a.m. During this period, the following occupancies were observed by parking type: "" On-street: SO% occupied "" Public Lots: 21% occupied "" Private Lots: 32% occupied If the private parking facilities are removed from the analysis and the on-street and public facilities are considered only, the peak occupancy for the study area 49% during both the 9 a.m. and 1 p.m. hours. July Occupancy (peak season) Data collected in July represents the peak seasonal parking demands. The following are the average occupancies for the entire study area during the peak hours on the days that data was collected. "" Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 53% (7 p.m.} "" Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 54% (7 p.m.} In July, the peak was during the weekend at 7 p.m. During this period, the following occupancies were observed by parking type: "' On-street: 53% occupied "" Public Lots: 52% occupied "" Private Lots: 36% occupied If the private parking facilities are removed from the analysis and the on-street and public facilities are considered only, the peak for the study area is 1 p.m. with an occupancy of 57%. These conditions are shown in Figure ES-2 and Figure ES-3 on the following pages. Kim ley>>> Horn Page I 8 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDY FOR THE CITY OF CARLSBAD Figure ES-2: May Weekend Peak Parking Occupancies {9 a.m.) Legend c:JPublicLot c::J Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kim ley >>> Horn N A Carlsbad .. ~ ~· 0 0.5 --===--==-------Miles 0.125 025 Sources Esri. HERE, Delom1e. USGS, lntermap. Increment P Corp., NRCAN, Esr1 MET!. Esri China (Hong Kong), Esri (Thailand). . Mapmylndia. () con~ibutors. and the GIS u..,r Page I 9 {City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDY FOR THE CITY OF CARLSBAD Figure ES-3: July Weekend Peak Parking Occupancies {7 p.m.) Legend CJ Public Lot CJ Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% -76-90% -91+% Kim ley>>> Horn 1\ A SlJ.alt«d Ln "' .. .. ., .... Carlsbad 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --==--==------Miles Sources Esri. HERE, Delorme, USGS, lntarmap, increment P Corp , NRCAN Eon Japan, METI. Esn China (Hong Kong), Esrt (Thailand), Mapmylndia. C OpenStreetMap contributors and the GIS User Page 110 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ' , ro ~.. T OF RL D D Overall the parking occupancies observed during the data collection efforts are well below the industry threshold. However, as the maps indicate, there are a number of on-street and off-street facilities that experience demands greater than 90%. Facilities that tend to have higher parking occupancies are within one or two blocks of the beach and the retail areas in the Village. This can be expected since these areas are a major destination point in the study area. However, users can become frustrated with the parking system because the parking facilities near this popular destination are operating near or at capacity during the peak. Furthermore, it is notable that public parking (on-street and off-street lots) experiences significantly greater demands (nearly double) than private parking lots, indicating that the private facilities are underutilized and have capacity to absorb more demand but users are not allowed to park in these facilities. This can further cause user frustrations and perceptions that there is a lack of available parking. Parking Duration In addition to occupancy, length of stay (duration) was evaluated for the on-street facilities. Parking duration data adds another layer of information with regards to parking behaviors in the community. It allows for a greater level of understanding of how long users tend to stay in the area. This information can inform identification of appropriate time limit regulations--particularly in business districts where parking turnover is important to providing customer access to businesses. May and July presented similar duration trends, with the majority of users (average of 63%) parking on the street for two hours or less. In the Barrio, nearly half (49%) of the users are parking on the street for periods longer than two hours. This is indicative of the residential nature of the neighborhood. This parking behavior varies greatly from those experienced in the Village, where 73% of the users are parking for two hours or less. Where these neighborhoods intersect, strategies may be sought to balance the competing parking behaviors. The durations in the beach area are similar to the Village, where 64% of users park for two hours or less. Figure ES-4 illustrates the average length of stay for all days that data was collected. 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% SO% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Figure ES-4: Average Lengths of Stay May and July 1111 •••• • •• •• • .••• -··· 0-2 hours 2-4 hours 4-6 hours 6-8 hours 8-10 10-12 12+ hours hours hours • Village • Barrio • Beach • Study Area Average Kimley>>>Horn Page 1 11 {City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 011 T -1£ Cl 1 OF C 1L AD Summary of Findings The following summarizes some key findings of the on-site survey, online survey (as of July 18th), and parking data collection results. A On-site and online survey results indicate that most people parking within the study area are able to find available parking quickly (within two minutes) and near their destination (directly in front of or within a block of their destination). However, a common perception remains that available parking in the study area is difficult to find close to destinations. As the occupancy analysis shows, there is available parking throughout the study area. However, in areas of high demand, toward the beach and commercial areas, the parking facilities are nearly at capacity during the peak period. Therefore, even though the system as a whole has availability, the experience for the user can become frustrating because spaces are limited in the desired parts of the study area. A In the open comments, reoccurring comments included that they would not support the implementation of paid parking, they would like to see the existing parking time limits enforced, and that the main issue with the parking system is finding available parking near destinations. A The majority of business owners or managers indicated that they do not provide parking for their employees. 64% of employees noted they park directly in front of or adjacent to where they work. However, business owners/managers indicated that they believe only 15% of the parking spaces closest to their business are being utilized by their employees. This indicates that there may be some lack of knowledge regarding who is parking in the spaces in front of businesses. A 40% of employees noted that they park in on-street spaces close to their destination. Typically, on- street spaces should be made available for customers so they have easier access to the businesses in the area. Employees parking in these spaces results in fewer on-street spaces near these businesses for customers. " The average occupancy for the entire study area during the peak is 54%, which is below the industry threshold of 85-90%. Occupancies were greater during the weekend than they were during the weekday for both May and July. • May Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 46% (1 p.m.) • May Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 49% (9 a.m.) • July Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 53% (7 p.m.) • July Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 54% (7 p.m.) " July experienced an increase in occupancies of 5% across the entire study area. However, certain areas experienced a far greater increase in occupancy. This increase is likely due to the influx of visitors which impacts parking availability and can cause frustration for regular users. Kim ley>>> Horn Page 112 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA IT D ..,. The public parking experiences greater demands than the private parking. In the Village on the weekday the public parking operates at 72% occupancy whereas the private parking during the same day and time period operates around 30%. The higher use of public parking places a stress on the parking system and could be the cause of f rustrations from daily users . ..,. Occupancies throughout the study area are relatively low throughout the day and the parking system as whole has enough capacity to handle the demand. However, there are specific locations that experience high demands (greater than 90%), particularly areas within one or two blocks of the beach . ..,. The majority of the off-street parking in the study area is privately owned and operated. The private facilities tend to operate at lower occupancies than the public facilities. There may be opportunity to balance the demands in the area by sharing parking resources and allowing users to park in the private facilities . ..,. The majority of users in the study area are typically parking for less than 2 hours. However, 50% of the users in the Barrio stay longer than two hours, whereas users in the neighboring Village area tend to stay no more than two hours. Given the differing land development of these two areas and the differences in parking behaviors, appropriate parking management strategies will have to be identified that meet the differing needs of the two areas. As the study moves forward, the data presented in this Technical Memorandum will be presented to the public for their review and feedback. Their comments will help provide further context to these observations and findings, and will help to guide the process for identifying appropriate strategies and management techniques for the community. The study will also review how additional growth (both development and population) in the study area may impact the overall availability of parking, both in the already congested beach area and in the study area as a whole. Kimley>>>Horn Page 113 Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKING STUDY DRAFT Technical Memorandum #1: Data Collection August 30, 2016 Kimley >>>Horn (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D FO T c IT :J 'HSoAD Table of Contents Introduction ...................................................................................................................................................... 5 Existing Regulations and Management Practices ........................•••.....••••.•.•..••.....••..•...•....•........•••......•••.•.........•........................••••• 7 On-Site Survey Process and Analysis ................................................................................................................. 9 On-Site Survey Summary for the Carlsbad Village Locations .•.....•..........•.......•..................•.........•.••.•.••••........••.•.•.•....•.••...•...•..•.•... 12 On-Site Survey Summary for the Barrio Neighborhood Locations .•......•.•......•..•.•...•.•........•.•.......•.•.......................•....•......•.....•.•.... lS On-Site Survey Summary for the Beach Area Locations ................•........•.......•.........•.•.............................•..........•.•.•••••••..........•.•... 18 Online Survey Analysis .................................................................................................................................... 21 Business Owner Responses ...•..........•......•......•.•.•.......•..•.•...•......••.•.......•.........•........••......•...•....•.•..................•.......•.•.•.........•.....•. 22 Employee Responses •.•.••••.•.•••.•••.•.•••••.••.•.•••..••.•.•••••.•.•••.••••.•.••••••.•.•••.••••••••••.•••..•.••.•.........•..................•..........•.......••................•.. 23 Resident Responses ..•............•.......•.........•......•.•..............••.•.•................•....•••..........•.................•.......•.••..•............•................•.•... 24 Visitor Responses ..........................•.•.•...............•.......•.•.......•.•......•.......•.........•.....•..........•.•...........................•......•...•..•...........•.•.. 25 All User Responses .....•••••••••..•.••...•.••.••........................•.•••••..•.•....•.••.•...•••.................••......•.•..........•.......•.•.......••........•..............••.. 26 Parking Analysis .............................................................................................................................................. 27 Data Collection Methodology ...........•.•......•......•.•........•......................................................•..................•.•.......•.................•.........• 27 Parking Occupancy Analysis ...•........•.•.........................••....•.•.•.......•.•.......................•.•...................•..•....••....•.•.•.•.....•.•.......•.........• 30 Average Parking Duration .•.....•.•....•••••.........................•......•.•.•......•••.......•.••.•••••••..•.....•........................•.•.......••.........•................• 42 Findings ........................................................................................................................................................... 43 Kim ley>>> Horn Page Iii (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA T ro IT 0 D List of Figures Figure 1: Study Area ...................................................................................................................................................................... 6 Figure 2: Existing Study Area Parking Restrictions ......................................................................................................................... 8 Figure 3: Village-What Brings You Here Today? (May) .............................................................................................................. 13 Figure 4: Village-What Brings You Here Today? (June) .............................................................................................................. 14 Figure 5: Barrio-What Brings You Here Today? (May) ............................................................................................................... 16 Figure 6: Barrio-What Brings You Here Today? (June) ............................................................................................................... 17 Figure 7: Beach Area -What Brings You Here Today? (May) ....................................................................................................... 19 Figure 8: Beach Area-What Brings You Here Today? (June) ....................................................................................................... 20 Figure 9: Who do you think is parking in the on-street parking spaces closest to your business? (Check all that apply) .............. 22 Figure 10: How close to work do you usually park? ..................................................................................................................... 23 Figure 11: How close to your home do you usually park? ............................................................................................................ 24 Figure 12: How close to your destination do you usually park? ................................................................................................... 25 Figure 13: Please select what you consider to be the biggest challenge(s) you have when parking in the Study Area (Check all that apply) ................................................................................................................................................................................... 26 Figure 14: Parking lnventory ........................................................................................................................................................ 29 Figure 15: May Weekday Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood .................................................................................................. 31 Figure 16: May Weekend Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood .................................................................................................. 31 Figure 17: May Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) ......................................................................................................... 34 Figure 18: May Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) ......................................................................................................... 35 Figure 19: July Weekday Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood ................................................................................................... 36 Figure 20: July Weekend Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood ................................................................................................... 37 Figure 21: July Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) .......................................................................................................... 40 Figure 22: July Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) ......................................................................................................... 41 Figure 23: May and July Average Length of Stay by Neighborhood .............................................................................................. 42 Kim ley>>> Horn Page I iii (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p List of Tables Table 1: May On-Site Survey locations, Dates, Times, and Number of Surveys Collected ...•.....•....•......•.....•.•......•....................... 10 Table 2: June On-Site Survey locations, Dates, Times, and Number of Surveys Collected •..•••..•••••......•.........•.•.....•..............•..•... 11 Table 3: Online Survey Responses by User Type ••.••..•••••••••.•..............•..••••••..•.•..•••.•••••.•....••.•••.•.•.••...•.•••.....•...•.•...........•.•.......•.•.• 21 Table 4: May Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type ••••••.•.....•......•••...••••••......•.•...••.•.••....•.•.•.....•••.••..•..... 32 Table 5: May Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type-Carlsbad Village .•.•.......••.......•........•.•......•.......•... 32 Table 6: May Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type-Barrio Neighborhood ..•..•.....•.•......•.•.....•.•......•.•.. 33 Table 7: May Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type-Beach Area .......•.•.................•.................•......•.... 33 Table 8: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type ...••.•...•..•.........•.•.....••.......•.••.•.......•....•.•......••.•......... 37 Table 9: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type-Carlsbad Village ..............................•........••.......... 38 Table 10: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type-Barrio Neighborhood ...••..•..•...........••.••...••....•.•.. 38 Table 11: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type-Beach Area .•.....•.•..•....•..•.•.......•.....•......•...•........ 39 Kim ley>>> Horn Page I iv (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA IN TUDf FOR _ Ll Introduction The City of Carlsbad is currently in the process of developing a Village and Barrio Master Plan in an effort to not only revitalize the Village, but also to rejuvenate the Barrio. During this planning process, it was realized that in order to identify parking management strategies and provide recommendations, it was necessary to conduct a thorough analysis of existing parking conditions, as well· as collect additional parking data. The intent of this parking study is to develop a Parking Management Plan that will provide recommended near- term and long-term strategies to maximize efficiency of parking and improve mobility in the project area. The Carlsbad Village, Barrio, and Beach Area Parking Study is being developed with the following goals in mind: ..,. Make parking more convenient for community members and visitors ..,. Promote more efficient use of existing parking ..,. Support future parking needs ..,. Explore options for making the project area more inviting for walkers, bicyclists, and people who use public transportation to support the vision outlined in the Village and Barrio Master Plan The driving force behind the Village, Barrio, and Beach Area Parking Study was the need for more data to better understand current parking conditions-particularly parking occupancy, demand, and behavioral data. During the development of this study, two rounds of weekday and weekend License Plate Recognition (LPR) data collection were conducted to capture the existing parking behaviors in the study area. As a result of this effort, parking occupancy and turnover data were captured, and an updated inventory of all available parking spaces was created. Additionally, community participation and feedback is a crucial component of the development of this plan. Stakeholder feedback has been captured through public outreach, on-site surveys, and an online survey, and will continue to be captured through community meetings. Included in this technical memorandum is a summary of the following: ..,. Summary of on-site survey efforts, analysis, and results ..,. Summary of online survey analysis and results ..,. Parking behavior data collection process, analysis, and results This document concludes by summarizing the data and presenting key findings that will help to guide the identification of appropriate parking strategies for the study area. Figure 1 depicts the study area. Kim ley>>> Horn Page I 5 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PAR INC SfUD "'E CIT OF CARL581;0 c't1"RUS"'V Legend Study Area Boundaries Barrio Neighborhood Beach Area Village Neighborhood Kimley >>>Horn LAOUNADR N A Figure 1: Study Area Carl,bad 0 0.5 --=:::.--===--------Miles 0.125 0.25 Esn, HERE, DeLonne Mapmylndoa. 0 OpenStreetMap contnbutors and the GIS user commumty Page I 6 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ro T .J I 0 ci'O Existing Regulations and Management Practices In addition to collecting data on parking behaviors and input from the users, an analysis of existing plans, parking restrictions, and regulations listed in the Carlsbad Municipal Code was conducted. A review of these materials provides an understanding of the City's current management practices and lays the ground work for developing recommendations and strategies that will improve parking in the Village, Barrio and Beach Area. Throughout the study area, there are streets where parking is limited to two or three hours, and is enforced from 7 a.m.-6 p.m., Monday-Saturday (except holidays). Overnight parking, certain streets restrict parking between 2 a.m. and 5 a.m. or 3 a.m. and 5 a.m. to allow for street sweeping. Additionally, vehicles are restricted from parking in any space for longer than 72 consecutive hours. Any vehicle not driven more than one-tenth of a mile from its original position every 72 hours is subject to citation or towing at the owner's expense. Recreational vehicles (RVs) may park on public streets if they have the proper permitting; trailers must remain attached to a vehicle. Figure 2 on the following page shows streets where parking is prohibited, or where there are time limits in place for parking. The overnight parking regulations were implemented to address concerns regarding the parking of RVs on the street. The City of Carlsbad ordinance (CS-204} states that a person cannot park their RV in their front yard. Therefore, people park their RV on the street. This is also not allowed per the ordinance and overnight parking is restricted on many streets to discourage RV parking overnight. The fine for parking an RV on-street is $50. Citizens can apply for a free oversize vehicle permit that will allow them to park overnight for a period of 72 hours. However, the public has voiced that the presence of RVs on the street is still an issue. It is apparent that although these regulations are in place, the lack of enforcement of them has allowed the continued use of on- street spaces by RVs. Although there are parking restrictions in place to manage the on-street spaces, frequent comments from the public and City indicated that enforcement practices were not conducted regularly. As a result, the parking system within the study area is not functioning as intended to help balance the demands and create available spaces. Establishing practices, strategies, and regulations is only one component of creating a successful parking system. The other component is ensuring that those regulations are enforced. Proper enforcement upholds the regulations and ensures that the system operates effectively and efficiently. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 7 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D Figure 2: Existing Study Area Parking Restrictions Legend Parking Restriction -No Parking Anytime -2-Hour Parking 3-Hour Parking lAGUNA DR: -No Parking 2 a.m. • 5 a.m. -No Parking 3 a.m. • 5 a.m. Study Area Boundaries Barrio Neighborhood Beach Area Village Neighborhood Kim ley>>> Horn Carl:.bad *GN0\.1AAV 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --==-•-==:::iii.------· Miles Esri. HERE Delorme Mapmylnd:a, C OpenStreetMap conlnbutors, and tne GIS user commumly Page I 8 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 . _ nD On-Site Survey Process and Analysis As part of this Parking Study, on-site surveys were collected to solicit input from community citizens and visitors with regard to their parking behaviors within the study area. The goal of the survey was to collect information on parking behaviors, such as where and why people parked and how they traveled to the area. The survey was offered in both English and Spanish. Copies of the survey questions, both English and Spanish, are provided in Appendix A. Additionally, a complete set of responses for all of the surveys collected are provided in Appendix B. On-site surveys were conducted over eight days-four days in May and four days in June-during weekday and weekend evening and morning time periods. Wednesdays were chosen to perform the surveys to coincide with the Farmer's Market that occurs weekly on that day. However, other dates were chosen to avoid events in the study area so that the responses would represent behaviors on typical weekdays and weekends. The on-site surveys were conducted by a team of 12 professional surveyors positioned at eight locations throughout the Barrio, Village, and Beach areas. Each surveyor was equipped with an iPad, which were used to collect responses. The use of iPads allowed for streamlined analysis of the data received. In May, a total of 1,282 people participated in the on-site survey. An additional971 people were approached but declined to take the survey. In June, a total of 857 people participated in the on-site survey. An additional 660 people were approached but declined to take the survey. Table 1 and Table 2 present the specific dates, times, and locations the on-site surveys were conducted, as well as the number of surveys collected at each site on each day. Kimley>>>Horn Page I 9 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ro h 8 D Table 1: May On-Site Survey Locations, Dates, Times, and Number of Surveys Collected 1!a]BJ!iB. Indicates that location was not collected on that date and time The demographic of respondents was similar between May and June, with half of the respondents being male and the other half female in both months. Kim ley>>> Horn Page 110 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ~ C/1 8 D Table 2: June On-Site Survey Locations, Dates, Times, and Number of Surveys Collected Indicates that location was not collected on that date and time Kimley >>>Horn Page 111 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA __ uorro 4-f_ The following sections present the survey findings for the Village, Barrio, and Beach areas. It should be noted that input from this survey should be considered in a similar way to input received during public comment at a City Council meeting, remarks at a public workshop, or comments provided via email to City staff. Due to the way survey participants were identified, the survey sample may not be representative of all project stakeholders. As a result, unlike a scientific study, the responses cannot be generalized to the larger population with a known margin of error. Qn-')lte ::,urvey Summar, •O• rnp umsbad \/jllage Locations The survey responses for both May and June were fairly consistent for all survey questions. The following is a summary of responses given by those surveyed in the Carlsbad Village. A full analysis of the survey responses is provided in Appendix B. ~ Carlsbad Village: Reasons for visiting the Village varied. During the weekend, dining received the most responses for visiting the Village (27% May; 20% June). On a weekday, shopping received the most responses (19% May; 16% June). A full breakdown of why people were visiting the Carlsbad Village is presented in Figure 3 and Figure 4 below. ~ The majority of respondents stated that they drove alone in a car during the weekday surveys (61% in May and 52% in June). On weekends, respondents drove more frequently with others (57% in May and 54% in June). ~ In May, 47% of respondents answered that they parked in a parking lot during weekday surveys, while 34% parked on-street. During the weekend, 49% answered that they parked on-street, while 45% responded that they parked in lots. ~ In June, 44% of respondents answered that they parked on-street during weekdays, while 38% utilized parking lots. During weekend surveys, 34% of respondents indicated they parked in parking lots and on-street respectively. ~ Respondents answered that it took them less than two minutes to park during both weekday and weekend surveys (May-63% weekday and 70% weekend; June-57% weekday and 44% weekend). ~ On average, nearly 60% of respondents answered that they parked directly in front of their destination or one block away. Kimley>>>Horn Page 112 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I SB/\D Figure 3: Village-What Brings You Here Today? {May) 0% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kimley >>>Horn • Weekday • Weekend 0% 0% 10% 9% 8% 9% 20% 30% 27% 16% 19% 16% 40% SO% 60% 70% 80% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 473 WEEKEND TOTAL= 105 90% 100% Page 113 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA UD 0 D D 0 Figure 4: Village-What Brings You Here Today? (June) • Weekday Weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kimley >>>Horn 6% 2% 2% 0% 5% 13% 20% 15% 9% 4% 11% 11% 14% 14% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 308 WEEKEND TOTAL= 152 Page I 14 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA .OR On-Site Survey Summary for thP Barrio Neighborhood Locations The survey responses were less consistent between May and June in the Barrio Neighborhood than they were for the Village. This could be attributed to the residential nature of the area, and during the peak season of June it attracts users from outside the area that utilize the parking facilities within the Barrio. The following is a summary of responses given by those surveyed in the Barrio Neighborhood. A full analysis of the survey responses is provided in Appendix B . .., In May, the highest response received of those in the Barrio Neighborhood was that participants were area residents (38% May average of weekday and weekend). In June, this was true for the weekday (43% of respondents stating they were area residents), however, dining received more responses for the weekend {33%). A full breakdown of why people were visiting the Barrio Neighborhood can be seen in Figure 5 and Figure 6 below . .., On average, 43% of respondents stated that they traveled to the area by walking. However, in June, 41% stated they drove either alone or with others. The higher levels of pedestrian activity could be attributed to the fact that the majority of survey participants stated that they lived in the Barrio and were not visiting from outside the area, allowing them to walk to their destinations. "' In June, the majority of respondents during both weekday (100%) and weekend (87%) surveys answered that they parked on-street. "' With regard to how long it took respondents to find parking, 49% answered "non-applicable" because their mode of travel for that particular trip was walking. Of those that did drive, 23% in May stated that it took people less than two minutes to find parking . ..; For June, 70% stated that they were able to find parking in less than two minutes. The responses indicate that those who do drive to the area are able to find parking promptly upon arrival. " With regard to how far participants parked from their destination, the most popular response for May weekday was that people parked one block away from their destination (34%). During weekend surveys, the most popular response was "non-applicable" (41%), with 34% of respondents finding parking directly in front of their destination. For June, the majority of respondents answered that they parked directly in front of their destination during both weekday (65%) and weekend (70%) surveys. Kim ley>>> Horn Page 115 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Figure 5: Barrio-What Brings You Here Today? (May) •weekday •weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% 80% 90% Work 3% 0% Dining 0% 0% Entertainment 20% 17% Shopping 0% 2% Special Event 0% 0% Visit the beach 0% WEEKDAY TOTAL: 75 0% WEEKEND TOTAL: 54 Visit a service business 0% 0% Visit a professional business 0% 0% Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) 16% 15% Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) 1% 2% I live in this neighborhood 40% 35% Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood 9% Other, please explain: 11% 26% Of those who responded as "Other", the responses were mainly walking the dog and exercising. Kim ley>>> Horn 100% Page 116 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA o ro1 I Figure 6: Barrio-What Brings You Here Today? (June) • Weekday Weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kimley >>>Horn 0% 6% 3% 3% 3% 3% 1% 0% 0% 3% 6% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 1% 9% 33% 27% 31% 43% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 30 WEEKEND TOTAL= 67 Page 117 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I . FO L c D On-Site Survey Summary for the Beach Area Locations The survey responses for both May and June were fairly consistent in the Beach area . The following is a summary of responses given by those surveyed in the area. A full analysis of the survey responses is provided in Appendix B. ~ Visiting the beach received the highest response from survey respondents during the weekend and weekday in both May and June (48% May average of weekday and weekend; 50% June average of weekday and weekend}. A full breakdown of why people were visiting the Beach area is shown in Figure 7 and Figure 8 below. ~ On the weekday, most participants in this area stated that they drove alone (49% average}. On weekends, however, 53% stated that they drove with others. ~ On average, 54% of respondents stated that they parked on the street. ~ On average, 58% of respondents answered that it took them less than two minutes to park, and 48% stated that they parked directly at their destination. Kimley>>>Horn Page 118 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA T c _8. D Figure 7: Beach Area-What Brings You Here Today? (May) Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kim ley>>> Horn Weekday • Weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% I 0% 0% 0% 0% I 0% 0% 0% 2% 3% 5% 11% 11% 10% 11% 11% 53% 42% 19% WEEKDAY TOTAL = 257 WEEKEND TOTAL= 611 Page 119 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA on .I Figure 8: Beach Area-What Brings You Here Today? (June) 0% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident -but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: •weekday 10% 20% 4% 0% 1% 5% 2% 7% 1% 1% 1% 2% 0% 0% 1% 0% 10% 3% 3% 13% Weekend 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 54% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 136 WEEKEND TOTAL= 473 Overall, the results of the on-site surveys indicate that users coming to the study area are able to find parking relatively quickly (within two minutes) and near their destination (within two blocks). Analyzing this data alone would indicate that there are no parking capacity issues with the study area. However, as stated previously, the intent of the on-site survey was to analyze user behaviors during a snapshot in time. The limitation of this data is that the survey did not reach a wide range of people and it was limited to those who happened to be walking by on those days at that time. Although this information provides insight to how people are using the system, the data must be looked at in conjunction with the responses of the online survey and the parking data collected in the field. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 20 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Online Survey Analysis An online survey was created, in both English and Spanish, to capture opinions and feedback from a broader range of users than those who were able to participate in the on-site survey. While the on-site surveys captured parking and travel behaviors for specific days (weekday and weekend, shoulder and peak season), the online survey is able to reach more people with the purpose of determining general parking behaviors and to identify issues within the parking system from various user perspectives. The survey was designed so that perspectives were gained from residents, visitors, employees, and business owners. The survey questions, in both English and Spanish, are provided in Appendix C. The online survey was posted on May 9, 2016, and as of July 18, 2016, there were 647 responses. The survey will remain open until the end of August 2016. The link to the survey was distributed through the City's website, e-newsletters, social media announcements, and community group meetings. Additionally, during the on-site surveys, surveyors distributed business cards with links to the survey. These cards were also left at businesses and community centers within the study area willing to place them on display for patrons to take. This section presents the preliminary results from the survey that represents responses between May gth and July 18th. All of the responses to the survey for all user types is included in Appendix D. Final analysis of the online survey responses will be conducted once the survey closes at the end of August. The survey was developed so that participants could identify themselves as either a business owner, employee, resident, or visitor. Even though each user type was asked similar questions, the intent of identifying the user type was to be able to differentiate the responses. Table 3 lists the number of respondents that took the survey for each user type. Table 3: Online Survey Responses by User Type* *One Spanish language survey was received The following sections summarize the analysis results of the online survey for each of the user types. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 21 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Rusiness Owner Responses Business owners are those who own or manage a business in the study area. Parking needs for this group focus on available parking for their customers within what respondents deemed to be an appropriate walking distance of their business. The following is a summary of responses given by online survey participants indicating that they own or manage a business within the study area. A Of the online survey respondents indicating they own or manage a business in the study area, 88% own or manage a business in the Carlsbad Village. A 59% of participants stated that they do not provide parking for their employees. A With regard to defining a reasonable parking distance, the answer that received the most responses was a distance of less than one block (40%). A 54% of business owners or managers believe that the on-street parking near their business is typically being utilized by customers from area businesses, or individuals who are parking near their business and walking to another location. A 46% of business owners or managers believe the on-street parking closest to their business is being utilized by employees from area businesses. A full breakdown of who business owners or managers believe is utilizing the parking closest to their business can be found in Figure 9. Figure 9: Who do you think is parking in the on-street parking spaces closest to your business? (Check all that apply) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% My customers Customers from area businesses Residents who live in the area My employees TOTAL=46 Employees from area businesses Visitors to the beach Beach Users Individuals parking near business and walking to another location Other, please explain: - Kim ley >>) Horn Page 1 22 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Employee Responses Parking needs for employees working in businesses in the study area focus on the ability to park near their place of employment (typically within 1-2 blocks) but also being able to park long-term. The following is a summary of responses given by online survey participants indicating that they are employed in the study area . .., The majority of respondents (62%) employed in the study area work in the Carlsbad Village area . .., The vast majority of respondents (82%) employed in the study area drive alone in a car to get to work . .., 54% indicated that they are able to find parking within two minutes . .., 53% of respondents say they usually park in a parking lot . .., Most employees participating in the survey (64%) indicated that they usually park directly in front of or adjacent to where they work. A full breakdown of how close respondents usually park to their place of business is presented in Figure 10. However, business owners or managers indicated that they believe only 15% of vehicles utilizing the spaces closest to their business are their employees. This indicates that there may be some lack of knowledge regarding which user groups use the spaces. Figure 10: How close to work do you usually park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Directly in front of or adjacent to where I work One block away from where I work Two blocks away from the where I work - Three blocks away from where I work II Four blocks away from where I work Five blocks away from where I work Six blocks away from where I work TOTAL= 64 Employee users and patrons often compete over available parking near businesses. Taking into consideration the responses from the business owners, designated employee parking is typically not provided throughout the study area and therefore employees are able to park as close as they are able to their destination. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 23 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Whether these spaces are in a lot or on-street, it is encouraged that the spaces directly in front of or adjacent to a business should remain available for cu stomers in order to improve access to the businesses. ResirlPnt RPsponses Residents are those who live within the boundaries of the study area. Parking needs for this group typically focus on availability of spaces near their residence for themselves and their guests. The following is a summary of responses given by online survey participants indicating that they live in the study area . ..., The most frequent response (45%} of online survey respondents live near the beach, while 39% live in the Carlsbad Village . ..., The vast majority of respondents {72 %} indicated that they park either in a driveway or a garage on their property. A full breakdown of how close residents are able to park to their home can be seen in Figure 11 . ..., Since most participants have designated parking, most (80%) are able to find parking in less than five minutes . ..., Most respondents (53%} are usually able to find a pa rking spot in less than two minutes. Figure 11: How close to your home do you usually park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% I have a designated parking spot at my home I park in the street directly in front of or adjacent to my home I can usually find parking on my block but not directly in front of my home • I can usually find parking within two blocks from my home I I can usually park within three blocks from my home I I cannot usually find parking within three blocks of my home I Kim ley >>> Horn TOTAL= 204 Page I 24 (_City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 7 Vicitor Responses The following is a summary of responses given by online survey participants indicating that they visit the study area. For the purposes of this study, a visitor is someone who lives outside of the study area. Visitors experience the parking system different from other users, and their responses can provide insight into gaps in the parking system that a frequent user-such as a resident, employee, or business owner-may not experience due to their familiarity with the system. ~ 72% of respondents indicated that they visit the Carlsbad Village area. ~ The vast majority of respondents travel by car when visiting the study area. Of those indicating that they visit the study area, 53% drive alone, while 38% drive with others. ~ When visiting the study area, 45% of the respondents indicated that they park on the street in the Carlsbad Village and 27% of respondents indicated that they use parking lots when visiting the study area. ~ 44% of respondents indicated that it takes 2-5 minutes to find an available parking space, while 31% are able to park in less than two minutes. ~ Respondents are typically parking within close proximity to their destination when visiting the study area. 41% of respondents indicated that they park one block away from their destination when traveling to the community, 22% said they usually park two blocks away from their destination, and 19% park directly in front of or adjacent to their destination. A full breakdown of how close respondents park to their destination is presented in Figure 12. Figure 12: How close to your destination do you usually park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Directly in front of adjacent to my destination - One block away from my destination Two blocks away from my destination - Three blocks away from my destination • Four blocks away from my destination I Five blocks away from my destination Six blocks or more from my destination All User Responses Kim ley >>> Horn TOTAl= 282 Page I 25 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA The following is a summary of re sponses given by online survey participants indicating that they visit the study area . ~ The majority {60%) of respondents consider finding an available space close to their destination to be the greatest challenge when parking in the study area . .,. 47% consider the biggest challenge to be finding an available space quickly. A full breakdown of what respondents consider to be the biggest challenges when parking in the study area can be seen in Figure 13. Even though participants indicated that they were able to find parking close to their destination in a short amount of time, as indicated in the user type ana lyses, users feel that there are issues finding available spaces . .,. The age group with the highest response rate {29%) are between the ages of 50 and 59 years old . .,. 63% of respondents indicated that they are female, while 38% are male. Figure 13: Please select what you consider to be the biggest challenge(s) you have when parking in the Study Area. {Check all that apply.) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Finding an available space quickly Finding an available space that is close to my destination TOTAL= 451 Parking and exiting my vehicle safely Knowing where I can park Free response comments on the survey revealed that many respondents believe the parking situation in the study area is adequate and they do not desire any changes. Common themes among the general comments provided by respondents from all user groups include the following: .,. The parking situation in the study area is adequate and they do not desire any changes . .,. Paid parking is not desirable . .,. Off-street parking that is centralized between the Village and Beach areas was recommended. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 26 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA A Enforcing time limits was recommended. Many of the comments reiterated the point that the main issue with the parking system is finding available parking near destinations. The parking analysis, discussed in the next section, is able to provide insight into the parking behaviors in the study area to explain where these problem areas may be occurring. All free response comments are provided in Appendix D. Parking Analysis Parking occupancy data was collected during the off-peak season and peak season using License Plate Recognition (LPR) technology, which allows for an automated processing of the parking data. The intent of this data collection effort was to determine occupancies within the study area during the morning, mid-day, and evening peaks. Off-street and on-street parking facilities were collected in the study area. These facilities are shown in Figure 14. The existing inventory by facility type in the Study Area is as follows: A On-Street: 4,971 spaces A Public Off-Street: 1,147 spaces A Private Off-Street: 5,539 spaces A Single Family Homes: 567 spaces (this value is based on the number of driveways observed in the study area) Da~a Col~ect1on Methodology The mobile LPR equipment uses a dual camera configuration, placed on the roof of the data collection vehicle. The vehicle drives continuous loops through each collection area, counting the number of vehicles parked on- street. The intent of this effort was to count the number of parked vehicles in the area in order to determine parking occupancy and duration behaviors. Off-peak seasonal data was collected on Thursday, May 19th and Saturday, May 21st between 6 a.m. and 9 p.m. Peak season data was collected at the same locations in the same manner in July as it was conducted in May. However, upon receiving feedback from citizens raising concerns about adequately capturing the residential demand, it was decided to extend the data collection period in July and do another run later in the evening. For July, parking data was collected on Thursday, July 14th and Saturday, July 16th to obtain representative peak season parking conditions. For the purposes of this analysis, LPR technology was used to take reads on license plates along curb faces to determine occupancy and parking behavior. The data received from the LPR unit was limited to a license plate number, the time stamp the read was taken, and a GPS location. The license plate number was used to create a unique identifier for each vehicle observed, which was assigned to each read, replacing the license plate number. Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 27 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ,.o r 8 D Using the LPR data, parking occupancy and duration data for the morning, mid-day, evening, and late night (July only) peak periods were able to be obtained and analyzed for the on-street and off-street facilities in the study area. The following sections summarize the results of the data collection efforts conducted in May and July. Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 28 {City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Legend Study Area Boundaries Barrio Neighborhood Beach Area Village Neighborhood Parking Facilities On-Street -Off-Street (Public) -Off-Street (Private) Kimley >>>Horn N A Figure 14: Parking Inventory 0 0.125 0 25 05 .. ~==~ .. c=~ ............. M~ Esn. HERE. Delorme Mapmylnd a. C> OpenStreetMap conlnbutors. and the GIS user commuruly Page I 29 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D Parking Occuparcy Analvsis When analyzing parking occupancy, it is important to understand that the primary industry accepted threshold for identifying demand constraints for a system is when occupancies reach 85-90% consistently. When occupancies for a parking system reach this level of occupancy, parking efficiency starts to deteriorate and changes need to be implemented in order to maintain efficiency of the system. The 10-15% remaining capacity accounts for those vehicles leaving a space and the few spaces that are scattered throughout the system or a facility that one might have to circle to find. However, it is important to note that this level of occupancy does not necessarily have to happen across the entire system for users to experience frustrations. When facilities with the highest demand are consistently full, the perception of parking can deteriorate throughout the entire study area. This deterioration is often the cause of poor public perception of the parking system or patron frustration. Using this industry standard, the parking occupancy within the study area was evaluated for on-street and off- street facilities on the days that data was collected in May and July. Note that parking occupancies for single family homes were included in this analysis. These occupancies were included in the parking occupancies for the overall study area, but have no impact on the availability of public parking. The following sections summarize the occupancy analysis for the on-street and off-street parking, including single family homes, within the study area. May 2016 Analysis Data collected in May represents the off-season peak demands. The following are the average occupancies for the entire system on the days that data was collected in May: ... Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 46% (1 p.m.) ... Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 49% (9 a.m.) In May, the peak was during the weekend at 9 a.m. During this period, the following occupancies were observed by parking type: ... On-street: 50% occupied ... Public Lots: 21% occupied ... Private Lots: 32% occupied If the private parking facilities are removed from the analysis and the on-street and public facilities are considered only, the peak occupancy for the study area 49% during both the 9 a.m. and 1 p.m. hours. The data indicates that during the week, the Carlsbad Village experiences a greater change in occupancies than the Beach and Barrio neighborhoods. This type of parking behavior can be expected due to the employment-based land uses that are prevalent in the Village. The Barrio and Beach areas are mostly comprised of residential land uses, creating less varied occupancy trends throughout the day. Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 30 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA HE I Unlike the weekday, the weekend occupancies in May are relatively stable throughout the day, especially in the Beach area. This is likely due to users coming into the area and staying for longer periods of time than they typically would during a weekday, thus creating less of a variance in the parking occupancy throughout the day. It should also be noted that occupancies for the Beach area are nearly 10% higher on the weekends than they are during the weekday. A breakdown of observed occupancy by neighborhood throughout the day can be seen in Figure 15 and Figure 16. Figure 15: May Weekday Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Barrio 50% -Village 40% -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% 9 a.m. 1 p.m. 7p.m. Figure 16: May Weekend Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Ba rrio 50% -Village 40% -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% 9a.m. 1p.m. 7p.m. Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 31 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA J During the May data collection period, greater occupancies were observed across all facility types during the weekend as compared to the weekday peak hour. Table 4 compares the parking occupancies by fac ility type throughout the study area. Figure 17 and Figure 18 on the following pages illustrate the parking occupancies throughout the study area during the weekday peak hour (1 p.m.) and weekend peak hour {9 a.m.). Table 4: May Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type 42% 50% 48% 46% 42% 45% 26% 21% 58% 41% Wee 31% 31% 16% Weekend 32% 30% 31% Wee 82% 73% 93% Weekend 83% 73% 94% Throughout the study area, the private parking experiences lower occupancies than the public parking facilities, nearly half the occupancy on the weekend. This distinction is further realized when observing the demands of each of the parking types by neighborhood. Table 5 through Table 7 compares the parking occupancies by facility type in each of the study area neighborhoods, Carlsbad Village, Barrio, and Beach Area . Kimley >>>Horn Page I 32 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA H I The Village contains the most public off-street parking in the study area and it experiences the highest occupancy for public off-street facilities (72% during the weekday afternoon), whereas the private facilities operate at only 34% for the same day and time period. The high demand for public parking in the Village can be attributed to the business and commercial land uses present in the Village that attract employees and visitors to the area that utilize public off-street parking. The high demand for public off-street parking in the Village can make finding available spaces close to destinations difficult for users, thus contributing to user frustrations with the parking system in the study area. In contrast to the Village, the disparity between public and private off-street facility occupancy is less distinct in the Barrio Neighborhood. This is likely due to the fact that there are far fewer spaces of public parking available in the Barrio than private, but also because of the land uses that exist in the Barrio. The Barrio is mostly residential and not as commercial or business oriented as the Village, thus the demand for public parking is less. Similar to the Village, the Beach area also experiences a drastic difference in demand between the public and private facilities. The private operates at nearly 30% whereas the public off-street facilities operate at 46% and 56% during the weekday and weekend respectively. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 34 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Figure 17: May Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy {1 p.m.) Legend c:J Publiclot CJ Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kimley>>>Horn N A Jcratbd La La.,..!\a Dt ~·· 0~ <-' .. .... " Ia& *' 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --====--===-------Miles Sources Esri, HERE, Del orme, USGS. lnlonnap, increment P Corp., NRCAN, Esn Japan, METt Esn Ch1na (Hong Kong), Esn 1 Mapmytnd1a, Q contributors. and the GIS Page I 35 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA /rJG _ UD't 0 TH CIT OF ARLSB. D Figure 18: May Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy {9 a.m.) Legend c=J Publiclot CJ Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kimley >>>Horn N A lbartofdb. ~·· o~" ~·· .#· 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 .. ~==~ .. ===-............ Mi~ Sources e ..... HERE Del orme USGS, lntermap. oncrement P Corp NRCAN, Esro METI. Esn Chona (Hong Kong). Esn (Thaoland). Tom Tom. Mapmylndia, contributors and the GIS User Page I 36 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA July 2016 Analysis Data collected in July represents the peak seasonal demands. The following are the average occupancies for the entire system during the peak hours on the days that data was collected. .... Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 53% (7 p.m.} .... Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 54% (7 p.m.} As shown above, the July weekend peak hour (7 p.m.} parking occupancy was the greatest amongst the days that data was collected. During this period, the following occupancies were observed by parking type: .... On-street: 53% occupied ...11 Public Lots: 52% occupied .... Private Lots: 36% occupied If the private parking facilities are removed from the analysis and the on-street and public facilities are considered only, the peak for the study area is 1 p.m. with an occupancy of 57%. The parking occupancy trends in July are similar to those experienced in May. Just as in May, the data indicates that during the week, the Carlsbad Village area experiences a greater change in occupancies than the Beach and Barrio neighborhoods. Also similar to May, the weekend occupancy trends are more constant than those observed during the week. A breakdown of observed occupancy by neighborhood throughout the day can be seen in Figure 19 and Figure 20. Figure 19: July Weekday Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Barrio 50% -Village 40% -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% 9a.m. 1 p.m. 7p.m. 11 p.m. Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 37 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA /I Figure 20: July Weekend Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Barrio SO% -Village 40% -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% Morning Afternoon Evening Late Night Although the trends might be similar, the average occupancy for the study area increased by 5% between May and July. Table 8 compares the parking occupancies by facility type throughout the study area . Figure 21 and Figure 22 on the following pages illustrate the parking occupancies throughout the study area during the weekday peak hour {7 p.m.) and weekend peak hour {7 p.m.). Table 8: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type ... 48% Weekend SO% 57% 53% 52% 57% 38% Weekend 20% 49% 52% Wee 33% 38% 35% Weekend 35% 36% 36% Wee 83% 73% 95% Weekend 82% 72% 94% 96% *The Late Night run was conducted on the on-street facilities only. Throughout the study area, the private parking experiences lower occupancies than the public parking facilities, nearly half the occupancy on the weekend. This distinction is further realized when observing the Kimley >>>Horn Page I 38 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA demands of each of the parking types by neighborhood. Table 9 through Table 11 compares the parking occupancies by facility type in each of the study area neighborhoods, Carlsbad Village, Barrio, and Beach Area. Table 9: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type Carlsbad Vi Table 10: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type borhood Kim ley>>> Horn Page I 39 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ST D ro u D Table 11: July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type Beach Area 61% 76% 68% Wee 22% 42% 42% Weekend 36% 46% 53% Wee 34% 38% 45% Weekend 44% 42% 52% *The Late Night run was conducted on the on-street facilities only. The trends for July are simtlar to those found in May, where the public facilities in each of the three neighborhoods within the study area experience greater occupancies than the private facilities. Even though there is parking available in the system, is it not accessible to the public for parking, making it difficult to find available spaces and contributing to user frustrations. However, there may be opportunities within the system to share the available parking resources to make spaces more available for public use. Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 40 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D INC:J STuDY rO THE CIT'f O, ARLScr1D Figure 21: July Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) Legend C]Publiclot c::J Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% -76-90% -91+% Kim ley>>> Horn N Slullotdlft Corlsbad L•~JN~Dt ;; l . 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --===---==::::::~------•Miles Sources Esti. HERE. Delorme. USGS. lntermap. tncrement P Corp • NRCAN, Esri Japan. METI. Esri China (Hong Kong). Esti (Thatland). TomTom. Mapmylndta. C contnbutON> and lne GIS User Page I 41 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA RK ilJu S UDY t-OR TH IT f OF r<LSBAD Figure 22: July Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) Legend c:JPubliclot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kim ley>>> Horn N A ... ". "'' C..-lsbod 0 0.5 --===--==-------Miles 0.125 0.25 Sources Esro. HERE DeLorme. USGS. lntermap. mcrement P Corp., NRCAN. Esn Japan. METI. Esri China (Hong Kong). Esri (Thaoland). Tom Tom, Mapmylndra. 0 and the GIS User Page I 42 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 1 a 'lr Average Parkine: Dur.r:Jtion In addition to occupancy data, the LPR technology allows for analysis of how long vehicles tend to park in the area. The length of stay information was analyzed for on-street parking facilities. Higher rates of turnover are typically encouraged for on-street parking to improve access to bus inesses, whereas long-term parkers are encouraged to use off-street facilities. May and July presented similar duration trends, indicating that the majority of users (average of 63%) park on the street for two hours or less. In the Barrio, nearly half (49%) of the users are parking on the street for periods longer than two hours. This is indicative of the residential development in that neighborhood. This parking behavior varies greatly from that experienced in the Village, where 73% of the users are parking for two hours or less. Where these neighborhoods intersect, strategies may be sought to balance the competing parking behaviors. Length of stay data throughout the study area for on-street facilities is shown in Figure 23. Figure 23: May and July Average Length of Stay by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 0% II I •••• •••• • ••• .I •• -··· 10% 0-2 hours 2-4 hours 4-6 hours 6-8 hours 8-10 hours 10-12 hours 12+ hours Kimley >>>Horn • Village • Barrio • Beach • Study Area Average Page I 43 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA .T Findings Collecting parking data within the community, as well as gathering public input, are integral components of understanding the parking behaviors, user frustrations, and identifying appropriate strategies for managing the system in a manner that makes sense for the community. The following summarizes the findings of the intercept survey, online survey, and parking data collection results: ..,. On-site and online survey results indicate that most people parking within the study area are able to find available parking quickly (within two minutes) and near their destination {directly in front of or within a block of their destination). However, a common perception remains that available parking in the study area is difficult to find close to destinations. As the occupancy analysis shows, there is available parking throughout the study area. However, in areas of high demand, toward the beach and commercial areas, the parking facilities are nearly at capacity during the peak period. Therefore, even though the system as a whole has availability, the experience for the user can become frustrating because spaces are limited in the desired parts of the study area . ..,. In the open comments, recurring comments included that they would not support the implementation of paid parking; they would like to see the existing parking time limits enforced, and that the main issue with the parking system is finding available parking near destinations . ..,. The majority of business owners or managers indicated that they do not provide parking for their employees. 64% of employees noted that they park directly in front of or adjacent to where they work. However, business owners or managers indicated that they believe only 15% of vehicles utilizing the spaces closest to their business are by their employees. This indicates that there may be some lack of knowledge regarding which user groups use the spaces . ..,. 40% noted that they park in on-street spaces close to their destination. Typically, on-street spaces should be made available for customers so they have easier access to the businesses in the area. Employees parking in these spaces results in fewer on-street spaces near these businesses for customers . ..,. Enforcement of the existing parking regulations has been noted as inconsistent, allowing people to park freely throughout the study area. As a result, the system is not operating as effectively as it could be . ..,. The average occupancy for the entire study area during the peak is 54%, which is below the industry threshold of 85-90%. Occupancies were greater during the weekend than they were during the weekday for both May and July. • May Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 46% {1 p.m.) • On-Street: 42% • Public Off-Street: 45% • Private Off-Street: 31% Kimley >>>Horn Page 144 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA fl_ u • May Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 49% (9 a.m .) • On-Street: 50% • Public Off-Street: 21% • Private Off-Street: 32% • July Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy: 53% (7 p.m.) • On-Street: 50% • Public Off-Street: 38% • Private Off-Street: 35% • July Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy: 54% (7 p.m.) • On-Street: 53% • Public Off-Street: 52% • Private Off-Street: 36% ..., July experienced an increase in occupancies of 5% across the entire study area. However, certain areas experienced a far greater increase in occupancy. This increase is likely due to the influx of visitors which impacts parking availability and can cause frustration for regular users . ..., The public parking experiences greater demands than the private parking. In the Village on the weekday the public parking operates at 72% occupancy whereas the private parking during the same day and time period operates around 30%. The higher use of public parking places a stress on the parking system and could be the cause of frustrations from daily users . ..., Occupancies throughout the study area are relatively low throughout the day and the parking system as whole has enough capacity to handle the demand. However, there are specific locations that experience high demands (greater than 90%}, particularly areas within one or two blocks of the beach . ..; The majority of the off-street parking in the study area is privately owned and operated. The private facilities tend to operate at lower occupancies than the public facilities. There may be opportunity to balance the demands in the area by sharing parking resources and allowing users to park in the private facilities . ..; The majority of users in the study area are typically parking for less than two hours. However, 50% of the users in the Barrio stay longer than two hours, whereas users in the neighboring Village area tend to stay no more than two hours. Given the differing land development of these two areas and the differences in parking behaviors, appropriate parking management strategies will have to be identified that meet the differing needs of the two areas. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 45 (_City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA The information gathered through the on-site and online surveys indicate that users are able to find parking near their destinations relatively quickly (five minutes or less). Combine that information with the data collected stating that the occupancy for the entire system during the peak is 54%, well below the industry threshold of 85-90%, and it would appear that there isn't a critical parking issue in the study area today. However, the participants of the online survey also stated that their top issue with the parking system was a lack of available parking. The data analysis concluded that while the parking system as a whole has capacity, there are a number of on-street and off-street facilities close to the beach that experience occupancies greater than 90%. This could be the cause of users experiencing frustrations with available parking. The data presented in this Technical Memorandum was presented to the public for their review and feedback on August 24, 2016. Their comments will help provide further context to these observations and findings, and will help to guide the process for identifying appropriate strategies and management techniques for the community. The study will also review how additional growth (both development and population) in the study area may impact the overall availability of parking, both in the already congested beach area and in the study area as a whole. Kimley >>>Horn Page I 46 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p 11 OF Appendix A-On-Site Survey Carlsbad Parking Management Plan Intercept Survey Questions -English D D The City of Carlsbad is working on a study to improve parking in the Village, Barrio and nearby beach area. The study will determine future parking needs so the city can make sure these popular areas remain easy to access. This could include new approaches to parking and encouraging alternate ways to get around, including walking andbiking. Instructions to surveyor: Before asking the first question, specify the following : Location: Carlsbad Village a. #1-Christiansen Way, west of State Street, adjacent to the Train/Coaster Station b. #2-Carlsbad Village Drive and State Street c. #3-Carlsbad Village Drive and Carlsbad Boulevard Barrio d. #4 -Southwest Corner of Pine Avenue & Harding Street, adjacent to Pine Avenue Park/Senior Center e. #5 -Northwest court of Chestnut Avenue & Harding Street, adjacent to Chase Field Beach f. #6-Ocean Street & Carlsbad Village Drive at beach entrance g. #7-Grassy area south of Ocean Street parking lot to the west of Carlsbad Boulevard h. #8 -Grassy area north of Tamarack Street restrooms (Tamarack Avenue and Carlsbad Boulevard Gender: a. Male b. Female Ql: What is your home ZIP Code? Q2: What brings you here today? (Check all that apply) a. Work b. Dining c. Entertainment d. Shopping e. Special Event f. Visit the beach g. Visit a service business (i.e., salon) h. Visit a professional business (i.e., doctor, law office, bank) i. Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Kimley >>>Horn Page 11 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D\ FO oc C k 8 D j. Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) k. I live in this neighborhood I. I'm visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood m. Other, please explain: _______ _ Q2a: How did you get here? (Check all that apply) a. Drove alone in a car b. Drove with others (carpooled/vanpooled} c. Motorcycle I scooter d. Bicycle e. Public Transit (Bus/Train) f. Walked g. Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service h. Longboard, skateboard, hover board or other personal mobility device i. Dropped off j. Other, please explain: _______ _ Q3: Where did you park? a. On-street b. Parking lot c. N/A d. Other, please specify: ________ _ Q4: How long did it take you to find your parking spot? a. Less than 2 minutes b. 2-5 minutes c. 6-10 minutes d. 11-15 minutes e. More than 15 minutes f. N/A QS: How close was this parking spot to your destination? a. Directly in front of or adjacent to my destination b. 1 block away from my destination c. 2 blocks away from my destination d. 3 blocks away from my destination e. 4 blocks away from my destination f. 5 blocks away from my destination g. 6 blocks or more from my destination h. N/A Q6: Were you able to find a bike rack or bike locker nearby your destination? a. Yes b. No Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 2 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I c. N/A Q7: Do you have any suggestions about how to improve the parking and /or transportation access here? Date and Time: Thank you for taking the survey Carlsbad Parking Management Plan Intercept Survey Questions -Spanish La ciudad de Carlsbad esta trabajando en un estudio para mejorar los lugares de estacionamiento el aparcamiento en las areas de Village, Barrio y cerca de Ia zona de playa. El estudio determinara las necesidades estacionamiento a futuro pora que Ia ciudad puede asegurarse de que estas zonas populares continuen siendo de facil acceso. Esto podrfa incluir nuevos enfoques para estacionamientos y fomentar formas alternativas para moverse porIa ciudad incluyendo caminar y andar en bicicleta. lnstrucciones a/ encuestador: Antes de hacer Ia primera pregunta, especifique lo siguiente: Ubicaci6n: Carlsbad Village a. Christiansen Way, al oeste de State Street, junto a Ia estaci6n de Tren/Coaster b. Carlsbad Village Drive y State Street c. Carlsbad Village Drive y Carlsbad Boulevard Barrio d. Esquina suroeste de Pine Avenue y Harding Street, junto a Pine Avenue Park/Senior Center e. Corte noroeste de Chestnut Avenue y Harding Street, junto a Chase Field Playa f. Ocean Streety Carlsbad Village Drive en Ia entrada de Ia playa g. Zona de cesped al sur del estacionamiento de Ocean Street al este de Carlsbad Boulevard h. Zona de cesped al norte de los banos en Tamarack Street (Tamarack Avenue y Carlsbad Boulevard) Genero: a. Hombre b. Mujer Ql: (.Cu;U es el c6digo postal de d6nde vive? Q2: (.Que te trae aqui hoy? (Marque todos que aplican) a. Trabajo b. Comedor Kimley >>>Horn Page I 3 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I FO. T -0 c SBA:J c. Entretenimiento d. lr de compras e. Evento Especial f . Visitar Ia playa g. Visitar una empresa de servicios (por ejemplo, salon) h. Visitar una empresa de servicios profesionales (por ejemplo-doctor, oficina de abogados, Banco) i. Otra recreacion (residente) j. Otra recreacion/vacaciones (no residente) k. Yo vivo en este barrio I. Estoy visitando a una persona que vive en este barrio m. Otra razon, por favor explique: _______ _ Q2a: (.Como llegaste aqul? (Marque todos que aplican) a. Condujo solo/a en un automovil b. Condujo con otras personas en su automovil (carpooled/vanpooled) c. Motocicleta/vespa d. Bicicleta e. Transporte publico (tren/autobus) f. Camino g. Taxi, Uber, Lyft o servicio similar de viaje com partido h. Patineta-Longboard, skateboard, hover board, u otro dispositivo de movilidad personal i. Lo/la dejaron aquf j. Otros, por favor especifique: --------- Q3: (.06nde se estaciono? a. En Ia calle b. Estacionamiento c. No a plica d. Otros, por favor especifique: ________ _ Q4: (.Cuanto tiempo tardaste para encontrar su Iugar de estacionamiento? a. Menos de 2 minutos b. 2 -5 minutos c. 6-10 minutos d. 11 -15 minutos e. Mas de 15 minutos f. No aplica QS: (.Que tan cerca estaba este Iugar de estacionamiento a su destino? a. Directamente en frente de, o junto a mi destino b. 1 cuadra de mi destino c. 2 cuadras de mi destino d. 3 cuadras de mi destino e. 4 cuadras de mi destino Kimley >>>Horn Page I 4 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PAR f/NG STUDY FOR THE CITY OF CARLSBAD f. 5 cuadras de mi destino g. 6 0 mas cuadras de mi destino h. No a plica Q6: <.Pudo encontrar un portabicicletas o un armario de bicicleta cerca de su destine? a. Si b. No c. No aplica Q7: (.Tienes alguna sugerencia sobre como mejorar el estacionamiento y/o acceso de transporte aqul? Fecha y hora de examen: Gracias porto marIa encuesta! Kimley >>>Horn Page I 5 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA K ,. I Of r IE T OF L " D Appendix B-On-Site Survey Responses and Graphs M~v What is your gender? Gender • Male • Female What is your home zip code? Home Zip Code • 92008 {Inside Study Area) • Other Kimley >>>Horn TOTAL= 1310 TOTAL= 1293 Page I 6 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Fi rn OFC4.RLt.t'"'D What brings you here today? (Check all that apply) Beach Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study ... Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kim ley>>> Horn 3% 1% 4% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0% 53% WEEKDAY TOTAL = 257 WEEKEND TOTAL= 611 •weekday •weekend Page I 7 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA /. ft _ TUDY FO Village Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study ... Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this ... Other, please explain: Kimley >>>Horn 0% 0% 27% WEEKDAY TOTAL=473 WEEKEND TOTAL=lOS •weekday •weekend Page I 8 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I Lo. D Barrio Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study ... Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this ... Other, please explain: 3% 0% 0% 0% 0% 2% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 20% 17% 16% 15% 11% 26% 40% 35% WEE KDAY TOTAL= 75 WEE KEND TOTAL= 54 Free responses to "Other, please explain:" Date Collected Base Ball Coach At The Park 5/25/2016 21:13 Walking 5/25/2016 21:09 Walking Home From Li brary 5/25/2016 20:46 Excersize@ Park 5/25/2016 20:14 Ater 5/25/2016 18:50 Baseball Practice I Sports Event 5/25/2016 18:46 Coming Home From Work 5/25/2016 18:44 Water 5/25/2016 18:43 Son's Baseball Practice 5/25/2016 18:43 Farmers Market 5/25/2016 18:27 Masage 5/25/201618:19 Kimley >>>Horn • Weekday • Weekend Page I 9 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 17 0 R !BAD Walk Dog 5/21/2016 16:33 Excersize 5/21/2016 15:12 Orchestra Rehearsal At Church 5/21/2016 14:51 Exercise 5/21/2016 14:46 Baseball Game 5/21/2016 14:43 Exercise 5/21/2016 14:14 Exercise 5/21/201614:10 Walking The Dog 5/21/2016 14:07 Walking 5/21/2016 13:54 Surfing 5/21/2016 13:52 Exercise 5/21/2016 13:47 Beach Walk 5/21/2016 13:43 Walking Dog 5/21/2016 13:34 Walking My Dog 5/21/2016 13:28 Little League Game 5/21/2016 13:26 Went To Get Breakfast 5/21/2016 13:21 Going To Pick Up Dry Clean 5/21/201613:17 Walking The Dog 5/21/2016 13:13 Went To Grab Breakfast 5/21/2016 13:02 Beach 5/18/2016 16:09 Jogging And Walking My Dog 5/18/2016 15:26 Jogging 5/18/2016 15:03 Walking 5/18/2016 14:58 Walking My Dog 5/18/2016 14:39 Walking My Dog 5/18/2016 13:56 Walking Dogs 5/18/2016 13:20 Walking Dog 5/14/2016 21:34 Excercise 5/14/2016 21:18 Walking the Dogs 5/14/2016 19:50 Kimley >>>Horn Page 110 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA f I Walking The Dog 15/14/2016 19:29 How did you get here? Beach Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Drove alone in a car Drove with others (carpooled/vanpooled) Motorcycle I scooter 1 ~~ Bicycle Public Transit (Bus/Train) Walked Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service Skateboard or other personal mobility device Dropped off Other, please explain: 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0% 14% 19% Village Locations 47% WEEKDAY TOTAL = 201 WEEKEND TOTAL = 475 • Weekday • Weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Drove alone in a car Drove with others (carpooled/vanpooled) Motorcycle I scooter Bicycle Public Transit (Bus/Train) Walked Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service Skateboard or other personal mobility device Dropped off Other, please explain: Kim ley>>> Horn 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0% I o% 0% 1% 0% 17% 12% 57% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 201 WEEKEND TOTAL= 475 •weekday •weekend Page Ill (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA c ro Barrio l ocations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Drove alone in a car 25% 7% Drove with others (ca rpooled/vanpooled) 19% 36% Motorcycle I scooter 0% 0% WEEKDAY TOTAL = 201 WEEKEND TOTAL= 475 Bicycle Public Transit (Bus/Train) 8% 0% Walked Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service 0% 0% Skateboard or other personal mobility device 0% 0% Dropped off 2% 2% Other, please explain: 2% 2% Free responses to "Other, please explain:" Walking Dog (daily) Coaster Live Here Exercise Walked From Home Kimley >>>Horn 40% 50% Date Collected 5/25/2016 20:25 5/25/2016 18:44 5/25/2016 18:23 5/21/2016 14:58 5/18/2016 13:20 •Weekday •w eekend Page 112 (City of Carlsbad • CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Where did you park? On-street Parking Lot N/A Other, please specify: Kim ley >>> Horn I fj D Beach Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 15% 14% 5% 7% 54% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 196 WEEKEND TOTAL= 424 • Weekday • Weekend Page 113 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA On-street Parking Lot N/A Other, please specify: On-street Parking Lot N/A Other, please specify: Kimley >>>Horn r: nLSB D Village Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 17% 2% 3% 49% 47% 45% Ba rrio Locations WEEKDAY TOTAL= 390 WEEKEND TOTAL= 77 •weekday •weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 49% 2% 0% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 47 WEEKEND TOTAL= 34 •weekday •weekend Page 114 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OF RL J D How long did it take you to find your parking spot? Less than 2 minutes 2-5 minutes 6-10 minutes 11 -15 minutes More than 15 minutes N/A Less than 2 minutes 2-5 minutes 6-10 minutes 11-15 minutes More than 15 minutes N/A Kimley>>>Horn 0% 0% 0% 2% 0% 3% 4% 1% 3% 1% 0% Beach Locations 20% 40% 60% -~--51% Village Locations 20% 40% 60% 21% 17% 80% 100% 71% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 193 WEEKEND TOTAL= 424 •Weekday •weekend 80% 100% 70% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 384 WEEKEND TOTAL= 77 • Weekday •weekend Page 115 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p OR.h 0% Less than 2 minutes 2 -5 minutes 6-10 minutes 11-15 minutes More than 15 minutes N/A OF C4/iL5BAD 6% 3% 0% 0% 0% 20% Barrio Locations 40% 60% 41% 49% How close was this parking spot to your destination? Beach Locations 80% 100% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 47 WEEKEND TOTAL = 34 •weekday •Weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Directly in front of or adjacent to my destination 1 block away from my destination 2 blocks away from my destination 3 blocks away from my destination 4 blocks away from my destination 5 blocks away from my destination 6 blocks or more from my destination N/A Kim ley>>> Horn 1% 3% 58% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 192 WEEKEND TOTAL= 415 •weekday •weekend Page 116 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p ror (I OF CARLSBAD Directly in front of or adjacent to my destination 1 block away from my destination 2 blocks away from my destination 3 blocks away from my destination 4 blocks away from my destination 5 blocks away from my destination 6 blocks or more from my destination N/A Directly in front of or adjacent to my destination 1 block away from my destination 2 blocks away from my destination 3 blocks away from my destination 4 blocks away from my destination 5 blocks away from my destination 6 blocks or more from my destination N/A Kimley >>>Horn Village Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 31% 29% 26% 13% 15% 1% 0% 2% 1% 7% 18% 0% Barrio Locations 48% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 388 WEEKEND TOTAL= 81 •weekday • Weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 0% 3% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 25% 41% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 32 WEEKEND TOTAL= 29 • Weekday •weekend Page 117 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ARI Hrcn or:c nL D Were you able to find a back rack or locker nearby your destination? • Yes • No • N/A TOTAL= 250 Do you have any suggestions about how to improve the parking and/or transportation access here? # Free Responses to "Do you have any suggestions about how to improve parking and/or Date Collected transportation?" 1 There is a fence along the train tracks i get that it is there for safety but i livr less than a quarter 5/25/2016 21:46 mile from the beach and used to walk but now with the fence i have to drive. And a multi level parking structure too 5 Its not real bad when i come down here 5/25/2016 21:41 6 Interested in more parking but not a parking structure. 5/25/2016 21:40 7 Less development, less people. More bike friendly on grand. Keeping parking in lieu of fee east 5/25/2016 21:39 of tracks, preventing expansion 9 Something else to park besides the street. 5/25/2016 21:37 10 I know its bad but i have no idea how to fix it 5/25/2016 21:36 11 More parking at the Coaster 5/25/2016 21:36 12 N/A 5/25/2016 21:34 13 No issue 5/25/2016 21:34 14 Make more parking lots. 5/25/2016 21:33 15 We dont think its bad because we can park at the hotel 5/25/2016 21:32 17 Offsite parking with shuttle to destinations 5/25/2016 21:30 18 5/25/2016 21:30 19 We have only lived here for a mere 30 years and we think the parking is completely okay the 5/25/2016 21:27 way it is 22 N/A 5/25/2016 21:26 Kim ley >>> Horn Page 118 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA NG S UDY 0 '"# t/7 F CJ1RLSBAD 23 No suggestions 24 We just got here. So far so good 25 Have more public transportation. Promote more biking. 26 It is tough but cant think of a space for more parking 27 Should be more parking ... make lot by chase 2 stories. Timed parking around businesses to two hours or so 30 Bigger parking lot not at the transit station 31 Put more parking on State Street 32 I hear you want to build a structure. Our town doesnt need it. Please dont 33 Horrible parking and no I ott available-must be because of the games and practices at the parkn 34 Less cars 35 Do not want a parking structure. 37 Well in the summer people park in permit parking without a permit so regulate that and tell them to go to the paid patking 39 Streets are really packed after about 4pm-a parking lot for park use would be very helpful for parents whose children play sports and attend events here 40 No suggestions 42 I dont know enough ... lm just here on vacation 44 Can park on a open space near by. 45 Happy about them being no charge, but maybe they can make a public lot somewhere. Or maybe a parking structure. 46 Maybe use dirt lots 47 Only objection is size of parking space size ... theyre all to narrow 48 Parking lot for park 49 We think it is just fine so We think its really good 52 Enjoy walking, good com unity, would't change anything. 53 Dont charge to park! 54 Make a parking lot there is a public parking lot that should be accessible to everyone . We live on ocean ave and cant even park to enjoy the beach it is rediculous 55 Make red zones longer to eliminate blind spots 57 No suggestions 58 If there were more public lots and less dedicated to only one restayrant 59 Likes that street parking is free 60 No issue. 61 We need additional parking. Poor sign age. Would like overnight parking available so they can leave cars overnight after drinking. Kimley >>>Horn 5/25/2016 21:26 5/25/2016 21:26 5/25/2016 21:24 5/25/2016 21:23 5/25/2016 21:22 5/25/2016 21:20 5/25/2016 21:20 5/25/2016 21:20 5/25/2016 21:18 5/25/2016 21:17 5/25/2016 21:16 5/25/2016 21:14 5/25/2016 21:13 5/25/2016 21:13 5/25/2016 21:12 5/25/2016 21:11 5/25/2016 21:11 5/25/2016 21:11 5/25/2016 21:10 5/25/2016 21:09 5/25/2016 21:07 5/25/2016 21:06 5/25/2016 21:04 5/25/2016 21:04 5/25/2016 21:04 5/25/2016 21:03 5/25/2016 21:03 5/25/2016 21:02 5/25/2016 21:01 5/25/2016 21:01 5/25/2016 21:00 Page 119 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 CttRLSBAD 62 Don't like to change anything I'd rather walk. 63 I dont think its that bad 64 No 65 No issue 66 Underground parking structure 67 Build underground parking structure 68 Have to know where to go, tourists are confused, diagonal parking is a good idea. The people with the parking problem ar the tourists. 69 Make it more biker friendly 70 Dont maje one or two hour parking. 72 lm not here enough to have a good suggestion but i never have a problem 73 People linger in their cars/spots a lot 74 So busy on the weekends hardly any parking amd weekly during the evening because of sport events 75 Fewer free parking lots and optimizing spaces, make high rise parking structures. 76 Its not bad ... Summer is probably a lot worse 77 No issue. 78 No, can park in employee paring lot, nut have to watch for time limits 79 Its really fine unless there are people driving around for hours but thats never me so im not sure what to change 80 More/better public transportation. Encourage a more active lifestyle (walking and biking) to get more cars off the roads. 81 Parking ordinance where residents cannot park multiple vehicles on street 83 #1 suggestion where the railroad track is off chestnut, should create a pathway for pedestrians Sunday nights are the only nights i really have trouble parking because the trash trucks pick up, they should request setting out their trash cans on monday morning instead so we can actually park i nfront of 84 No development without parking 85 Quit building condos without parking spots. Parking garage downtown. 86 Add parking structures without impact the beauty, move upward 87 We got right in no problem this street fair is making more traffic than yesterday but still not bad 88 Uput a small parking garage with validation. Need one place 89 More parking lots are always helpful but i dont know where they would put them 90 Lots of hourly parking is annoying but it's better than meters 91 No issue 92 Maybe a centrally located parking garadge not like on state street but tucked away a little 5/25/2016 21:00 5/25/2016 21:00 5/25/2016 20:57 5/25/2016 20:56 5/25/2016 20:55 5/25/2016 20:54 5/25/2016 20:53 5/25/2016 20:52 5/25/2016 20:51 5/25/2016 20:50 5/25/2016 20:49 5/25/2016 20:49 5/25/2016 20:49 5/25/2016 20:48 5/25/2016 20:48 S/25/2016 20:47 5/25/2016 20:47 5/25/2016 20:47 5/25/2016 20:46 5/25/2016 20:46 5/25/2016 20:46 5/25/2016 20:44 5/25/2016 20:44 5/25/2016 20:44 5/25/2016 20:40 5/25/2016 20:40 5/25/2016 20:40 5/25/2016 20:39 5/25/2016 20:39 Kimley>>>Horn Page 1 20 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA J. FO I ur-c 11 L a,...o 93 Theres no parking. We usually get one, reduce quality of life to reduce acceess to cars 94 No issue 95 Its better here than where we live 96 N/A 97 Where the city was going to put a dog park make it a lot. Syre people dont want something like a structure but thats really what we need 98 Had to walk because parking sucks, dont build more condos 99 N/A 100 We live here so we walk everywhere. But in the summer you can charge to park at the beach 101 Build a parkingstructure with in a few blocks 102 No issues. 103 Its good, 104 I arrived during a mellow time so parking was easy 105 More parking just not sure how to do it 107 Dont charge for parking and remove 20 minute parking, doesnt work. 108 Easy to park this time of day 109 I live on this street and on the weekends there is absolutely NO parking. It is unfair that i am a resident and besides my drive way it is tough to park my vehicle or a guests vehicle because of events that take place at the park daily 110 Minimize tourists 111 Adding more lots, expanding lots 112 I do not live in the area, came for a game and was able to park quickly. Seems like a busy street so maybe for "slow down" traffic signs because it is near a park and school with lots of children walking around 113 Not really, make hotels have their own parking 114 Parking lot off the freeway then bike or walk into the village 117 A pretty parkng structure. Parking depends on the day 118 Flasing lights for walking pedestrians. Alot of kids walk un attended near this crosswalk and cars do not pay attention 119 Not mess with carlsbad vibe. Keep it as it is 121 Longer limits on spots. 122 None 123 No 125 None 126 New mayor would do great, dont charge for parkinh 128 More public transportation 129 Not really Kim ley>>> Horn 5/25/2016 20:37 5/25/2016 20:36 5/25/2016 20:36 5/25/2016 20:34 5/25/2016 20:34 5/25/2016 20:33 5/25/2016 20:33 5/25/2016 20:32 5/25/2016 20:32 5/25/2016 20:31 5/25/2016 20:29 5/25/2016 20:29 5/25/2016 20:27 5/25/2016 20:26 5/25/2016 20:26 5/25/2016 20:25 5/25/2016 20:25 5/25/2016 20:23 5/25/2016 20:22 5/25/2016 20:22 5/25/2016 20:21 5/25/2016 20:19 5/25/2016 20:19 5/25/2016 20:19 5/25/2016 20:16 5/25/2016 20:14 5/25/2016 20:12 5/25/2016 20:11 5/25/2016 20:11 5/25/2016 20:09 5/25/2016 20:09 Page I 21 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p I OF 4RLSb D 130 None 132 Dont have a problem 133 Wish there was coaster options, id love to take that 134 Making sure that anything new here should provide their own parking. People don't use as much as they should the public transportation. To be able to park at the train station and/or put a time limit. 135 No suggestions 136 Dont build more businesses. If they build a structure do it near the train tracks .. not so close to beach. Maybe by boys and girls club 138 I bike sonparking isnt a problem for me 139 Dont over build the village in the first place. Traffic noise makes me want to move. Dont build more ... tourists just have to walk. Daughter wont even walk on cvd 141 Build more private city parking 142 Its not usually that bad for us 143 No, its fair 144 No garage 145 Keep free parking 146 More near carlsbad village dr 148 N/A 149 No 150 Talk to local bussiness to share their parking area, especially during summer. Coordinate shuttes ane business. 151 No 155 Dont change a thing and never charge it will ruin everything 156 More of it 157 Dont own a car 158 Except for summer its really not bad 160 N/A 161 N/A 162 No suggestions 163 Open most of the day, except when it comes to happy hour times 164 N/A 165 No problem on finding a parking spot today. 166 Snychronize traffic lights. Need a parking structure. 167 I dont think its that bad .... Maybe carpool 168 No suggestions 169 N/A 170 Please no meters! Kim ley>>> Horn 5/25/2016 20:09 5/25/2016 20:07 5/25/2016 20:06 5/25/2016 20:06 5/25/2016 20:05 5/25/2016 20:04 5/25/2016 20:02 5/25/2016 20:02 5/25/2016 20:00 5/25/2016 19:58 5/25/2016 19:58 5/25/2016 19:58 5/25/2016 19:58 5/25/2016 19:57 5/25/2016 19:57 5/25/2016 19:56 5/25/2016 19:56 5/25/2016 19:54 5/25/2016 19:51 5/25/2016 19:51 5/25/201619:51 5/25/2016 19:49 5/25/2016 19:48 5/25/2016 19:48 5/25/2016 19:47 5/25/2016 19:47 5/25/2016 19:45 5/25/2016 19:44 5/25/2016 19:44 5/25/2016 19:44 5/25/2016 19:44 5/25/2016 19:44 5/25/2016 19:43 Page I 22 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p or: Af L BAD 171 Nope 172 Its great 173 Haven't live long enough here to make a suggestion 175 N/A 176 extend 1 hour parking spots 177 Locals only parking, charge tourists. 178 We have a timeshare here with permit parking but there is always stuff around here 180 Dont charge for parking. Dont block off parking structures during community events 181 Dont know. Downtown parking garage? 183 More parking especially in the summer the diagonal spots on state stare problematic when people try to back out 185 No suggestions 186 Love the turnaround. Long wait at the lights but its safe for pedestrians so thats good. Maybe more rapid transit or new bus routes. 187 Usually no problem, but when fairs are around and during summer even in this area gets full. 189 Maybe a pass for locals? Surfers shouldnt have to pay 190 Bigger parking lots, make parking spaces bigger 192 Dont build high rise parking, this is a village so keep it as a billage. Utilize parking at the train station. Have businesses have employees park in certain areas, and light those areas for the night employees. Better signage for parking. 193 Have more public transportation 194 Make a parking garage 195 No, no idea 196 More metered parking 197 No 198 Underground parking 199 I dont know how to beginto do that. Its a challenge. Maybe a parking building 200 A structure if you can find a good spot for it. 201 I have seen worse so i dont think its that bad 202 No suggestions 204 Better labeling in lots so we know if it is okay for public parking 205 3or 4 level parking at the coaster station 207 Need more parking but no genius solutions 208 Add a parking garage 209 None 210 I park at the hotel and walk everywhere i go Kim ley >>> Horn 5/25/2016 19:43 5/25/2016 19:42 5/25/2016 19:42 5/25/2016 19:41 5/25/2016 19:40 5/25/2016 19:38 5/25/2016 19:38 5/25/2016 19:38 5/25/2016 19:38 5/25/2016 19:36 5/25/2016 19:35 5/25/2016 19:35 5/25/2016 19:34 5/25/2016 19:33 5/25/2016 19:32 5/25/2016 19:30 5/25/2016 19:30 5/25/2016 19:29 5/25/2016 19:28 5/25/201619:27 5/25/2016 19:27 5/25/2016 19:26 5/25/2016 19:25 5/25/2016 19:24 5/25/2016 19:23 5/25/2016 19:23 5/25/2016 19:20 5/25/2016 19:20 5/25/201619:19 5/25/2016 19:18 5/25/201619:18 5/25/2016 19:18 Page I 23 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I OR f I 0 A L:>btD 211 Everyone parks in employee spaces it, we have permits and no one polices it. Cant find parking even tho pwying for permits 213 I havenever had a problem here 214 Underground garages 216 No issue 217 N/A 218 More public lots and street parking 219 No suggestions 220 Bring back free parking by the jetty. 221 Have Pine avenue park lot available for residents. 222 Parking wasnt that bad 224 Big parking lot by beach, like balboa. 225 Make park and senior center lots available for residents to park, overnight. 228 More street parking. 229 It has been quite good we are only visitors really 230 No garage 232 More bus stops and visible. More spaces in the village and beach 233 I always get lucky and spots open up 235 Parking garage ... build up not out 237 Make a parking garadge please! And enforce the 3 hour parking! 238 There should be parking passes for people who work down here 239 Dont have a problem, harder in downtown. Harder in summer and at nigt. Had to come early to get a parking spot 240 Dont think it is that bad 241 No 242 Not really 243 Most parking spots are taken because of tourism 244 No 245 No 246 None 247 lm not familiar enough with it 248 More parking 249 No 251 We think an underground lot would be good so its hidden. Maybe make it free 252 In shopping area make a multi level garage. 253 Not really 254 Avoid carlsbad in evenings and the weekends 255 Nice if area was pavec because it messes up your car Kim ley >>> Horn 5/25/201619:18 5/25/2016 19:16 5/25/201619:15 5/25/201619:15 5/25/201619:14 5/25/201619:14 5/25/201619:13 5/25/201619:11 5/25/201619:10 5/25/201619:10 5/25/2016 19:08 5/25/2016 19:08 5/25/2016 19:06 5/25/2016 19:05 5/25/2016 19:05 5/25/2016 19:04 5/25/2016 19:03 5/25/2016 19:02 5/25/2016 19:02 5/25/2016 19:01 5/25/2016 19:01 5/25/2016 18:57 5/25/2016 18:57 5/25/2016 18:56 5/25/2016 18:56 5/25/2016 18:56 5/25/2016 18:55 5/25/2016 18:55 5/25/2016 18:55 5/25/2016 18:54 5/25/2016 18:54 5/25/2016 18:52 5/25/2016 18:52 5/25/2016 18:51 5/25/2016 18:50 5/25/201618:50 Page I 24 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 OF -RL 6 LJ 256 Its not bad here you should go fix pacific beach and mission beach its terrible there 257 Parking depend on day amd time, after 2 pm you II have to look. Everyone comlains about the dirt here. ld like to see it paved. Were only getting busier 258 Faster changing lights 259 Beach areas will always be conjested 260 Dont let shops put patios on parking spots 261 No issues 262 NA 263 Valeted parking lots or 20 bucks a day lots would be cool 264 Never had a problem even on weekends 265 No issues. 266 No suggestions 267 Parking structure 268 Get more parking spots and pave it 269 Doing the weekends the street is packed so we have to park a couple of blocks down 270 No issues. 271 No i love it 272 New construction is taking away parking ... dont know what can be done 273 No multi story parking lot, she doesnt notice an issue. If its not broke dont fix it 274 Pretty congested 275 Pave here at this address 276 We got in right away so i dont think change needs to be made 277 Garage structure, residential permits 279 Maybe get a shuttle. And The one way streets are difficult. 280 No 281 Dont come when its busy and you wonthave a problem 282 No 284 More parking near beach 285 I would like them to come up with more parking 286 No 289 I think ocean st. Should be a pedestrian st or parking allowed only on one side 290 Block off lots in busy times like for the street fair and summer so the disabled can be close to where they need to go 295 The parking here is baddddd but there really isnt anywhere the city can throw in another lot 296 More beach going parking ... maybe underground leading to beach 298 Open lot on beach st should be turned into parking ... Its really bad by the beach as well 300 Build bike rack in the village. Kimley>>>Horn 5/25/2016 18:49 5/25/2016 18:49 5/25/2016 18:46 5/25/2016 18:46 5/25/2016 18:46 5/25/2016 18:46 5/25/2016 18:46 5/25/2016 18:45 5/25/2016 18:45 5/25/2016 18:44 5/25/2016 18:44 5/25/2016 18:44 5/25/2016 18:43 5/25/2016 18:43 5/25/2016 18:42 5/25/2016 18:42 5/25/2016 18:41 5/25/2016 18:41 5/25/2016 18:40 5/25/2016 18:39 5/25/2016 18:39 5/25/2016 18:38 5/25/201618:37 5/25/2016 18:37 5/25/2016 18:37 5/25/2016 18:37 5/25/2016 18:35 5/25/201618:35 5/25/2016 18:34 5/25/2016 18:33 5/25/2016 18:32 5/25/2016 18:30 5/25/2016 18:30 5/25/2016 18:28 5/25/2016 18:27 Page I 25 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p DY FOh 1 E JC:(. __ ,.,o 301 Free Parking structure similar to downtown ventura 302 Make roundabout larger 304 No office at the Coaster station. No maps and no luggage storage either. 305 We have handicap so we never have trouble 306 Have lots dedicate parking spots to farmers market shoppers on certain days 307 I cant answer that because i always find parking here 308 There is not many diagonal street parking 309 Its excellent 312 Bicycles should stay in line to make it easier to drive in the little lanes. They should contribute to gas or vehivle taxes 313 N/A 314 Enjoys the 1 way parking lots 315 Just come earlier than you think 316 There is always spots you just might have to walk a bit 317 No suggestions 318 Wish they would grant parking to ocean palms whi live there. It should be there 321 More parking places, during summer really crowded. 322 I dont ever have much trouble parking here 323 A the end of carlsbad parkway put in a sidewalk 325 Has become more congested over the years 327 Stop over developing and encourage more bikers 328 Buses can be a little late sometimes. 329 I Dont 331 Have another parkng area or garage 332 Usually challenging to find a spot 333 There is a lot of permit parking around here so maybe make those open for the public to buy 334 Challenging to find parking 335 I like that it is free and we didnt have trouble finding a spot today 336 People abusing time limit 337 Mas seguridad en las calles y mejores lugares para estacionarnos. 338 Keep the parking free 339 I think its working out pretty well right now 342 None 343 None. 344 Utilize empty lots berrer to provide parking. 345 None. 346 In the summer it gets really busy. Maybe more parking here by the boardwalk. Kim ley>>> Horn 5/25/2016 18:26 5/25/2016 18:26 5/25/2016 18:25 5/25/2016 18:25 5/25/2016 18:24 5/25/2016 18:24 5/25/2016 18:23 5/25/2016 18:23 5/25/2016 18:21 5/25/2016 18:21 5/25/2016 18:21 5/25/2016 18:20 5/25/2016 18:20 5/25/2016 18:19 5/25/2016 18:19 5/25/201618:17 5/25/201618:17 5/25/201618:16 5/25/201618:15 5/25/201618:14 5/25/201618:13 5/25/201618:13 5/25/2016 18:11 5/25/201618:11 5/25/201618:11 5/25/2016 18:09 5/25/2016 18:08 5/25/2016 18:06 5/25/2016 18:04 5/25/2016 18:04 5/25/2016 18:03 5/21/2016 16:56 5/21/2016 16:51 5/21/2016 16:51 5/21/2016 16:48 5/21/2016 16:48 Page I 26 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKING TtJDY t 0 TH CIT OF CARLSBAD 347 No 348 Add more lots. 349 City shuttle service 350 More public areas or structures 351 None 352 Nothing 353 No suggestions 354 None 355 Satisfied with parking the way it is. No parking structures; dont obstruct the view. 356 Widen parking spots 357 I don't 358 On the whole it is good. I have never had an issue. I can usually find a spot in the residential neighborhoods. 359 Slow down traffic and more parking options 360 Build vertically for additional parking garages. 361 No i think its okay. 362 I've never had an issue with parking. 363 Build more lots, not enough now. 364 Striped parking places to fit in more cars. 365 Add more lots or make it free 366 I have no ideas. Not a lot of land to work with. 367 More accessible for locals 368 Add more lots 369 Provide more bike facilities 370 None 371 Maybe add shuttles 373 2 or 3 level parking garage 375 Add free lots 376 None. 377 Need more parking, parking structure near freeway 378 Provide more sidewalks so people will walk 379 One large parking lot with shuttle service into the Village 380 None. 381 There is sufficient parking. 382 None. 383 No. 374 Shuttle service 386 No suggestions Kim ley>>> Horn 5/21/2016 16:47 5/21/201616:47 5/21/201616:47 5/21/2016 16:44 5/21/2016 16:44 5/21/2016 16:44 5/21/2016 16:42 5/21/2016 16:42 5/21/2016 16:41 5/21/2016 16:41 5/21/2016 16:41 5/21/2016 16:39 5/21/2016 16:38 5/21/2016 16:37 5/21/2016 16:36 5/21/2016 16:35 5/21/2016 16:35 5/21/2016 16:33 5/21/2016 16:33 5/21/2016 16:30 5/21/2016 16:29 5/21/2016 16:28 5/21/2016 16:28 5/21/2016 16:27 5/21/2016 16:26 5/21/2016 16:26 5/21/2016 16:23 5/21/2016 16:22 5/21/2016 16:22 5/21/2016 16:22 5/21/2016 16:21 5/21/2016 16:19 5/21/2016 16:18 5/21/201616:18 5/21/2016 16:18 5/21/2016 16:17 5/21/2016 16:16 Page I 27 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA t rc 388 Provide more bike facilities 389 More free parking 390 Please add more public transit. 391 free parking where the surfers are. 392 Provide sidewalks for people to walk on to help them get out of the car. 393 Get rid of people. 395 No trouble parking 396 None. 397 I own a motorcycle and there is no parking for the rsidents on the street because there are always baseball games on the evenings and all parking spaces are taken 398 NA 399 Difficult for parking 401 Free buses doing a loop around the village to get tourists around 402 Have more parking spots 403 Less paying for parking At the beach 404 Larger public structure by the beach. 405 More Parking meters. 407 None 408 He liked the fact that they added more security to the bikes, such as bike racks and bike lockers. 409 Not a problem as they normally walk 410 No 411 No problem 413 People can take uber. 414 Provide more bike facilities. Get people out of their car 415 I'd say that it's needed but I don't have any suggestions 416 Overall im extremely happy 417 No parking structure. They like the limited parking so it deters out of city folk 419 Build a parking structure. Usually takes longer to find parking. Lucky today. 420 It's been fine for us because we have parking provided. 421 Don't love parking, but don't want parking structures paid with tax money. Shuttles on strategic places would work as well. 422 No 423 Seems fine 424 Not a problem 425 None 426 Give the locals priority 427 No Kimley>>>Horn 5/21/201616:14 5/21/201616:13 5/21/201616:13 5/21/2016 16:12 5/21/201616:11 5/21/2016 16:10 5/21/2016 16:09 5/21/2016 16:08 5/21/2016 16:08 5/21/2016 16:07 5/21/2016 16:06 5/21/2016 16:06 5/21/2016 16:05 5/21/2016 16:04 5/21/2016 16:04 5/21/2016 16:03 5/21/2016 15:59 5/21/2016 15:59 5/21/2016 15:58 5/21/2016 15:55 5/21/2016 15:54 5/21/2016 15:51 5/21/2016 15:51 5/21/2016 15:51 5/21/2016 15:50 5/21/2016 15:48 5/21/2016 15:47 5/21/2016 15:46 5/21/2016 15:45 5/21/2016 15:45 5/21/2016 15:44 5/21/2016 15:44 5/21/2016 15:43 5/21/2016 15:42 5/21/2016 15:42 Page I 28 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OR E 17 0 L 428 Give money to hotels for parking spots 429 Dont pay 430 No. I know you need it here but no I don't 431 Shuttle or parking sructure 433 More of it. It is Always a problem at the beach. You used to be able to park down there but it's now reserved for surfers and you have to pay $10 a day. The one thing we love about Carlsbad is that parking is free. 434 NA 435 Dont want it to turn into a LA. Like small feel. Huge beach and no where to park. The city could angle patking a ling beavh area to fit more cars. Or take some of the grassy area for parking. 436 There's no solutiom 437 We love it here 438 More spaces 439 Add underground parking. 440 Don't let this many people come. 441 Trolley/shuttle 442 None. 443 Need to keep the parking free so people and visitors can come and visit and shop. 444 More bike facilities 445 More parking ... commuter rail shuts down too early 446 Parking structure 449 No. I don't do a lot of driving. I park at my house and walk every where. 450 No suggestions 451 None 452 Lower the railroad like Solana Beach to improve access to the area 453 Big ferry ... Floating parking structure 454 I have problems with the delivery trucks for smart and final. Live on the same street and always blocking my driveway or car parked on street. 455 On the weekends, it's crowded. Otherwise, no problem. 456 No suggestions 457 No idea 458 Add crosswalk so people dontjaywalk. 459 More free beach parkig 460 NA 461 None 462 More public transportation ... keep it free Kim ley>>> Horn 5/21/2016 15:41 5/21/2016 15:40 5/21/2016 15:38 5/21/2016 15:37 5/21/2016 15:35 5/21/2016 15:34 5/21/2016 15:32 5/21/2016 15:32 5/21/2016 15:30 5/21/2016 15:28 5/21/201615:27 5/21/2016 15:27 5/21/2016 15:26 5/21/2016 15:24 5/21/2016 15:23 5/21/2016 15:22 5/21/2016 15:22 5/21/2016 15:22 5/21/201615:19 5/21/201615:19 5/21/201615:19 5/21/201615:19 5/21/201615:18 5/21/201615:17 5/21/201615:17 5/21/201615:16 5/21/201615:16 5/21/201615:15 5/21/201615:15 5/21/2016 15:13 5/21/2016 15:13 5/21/2016 15:12 Page I 29 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OF C RLSBA.J 463 Feels parking is convient as it is. Dont want to add more expense by paying for parking. Hard on senior citizens. Residents already pay a lot in taxes. No meters please. 464 None 465 No suggestions 466 No parking structures. 467 more public transportation 468 Add more parking spots along the coast. 470 Get some subways or light rails but that is probably impractical. 472 Identified public parking with large lots. 473 NA 475 Not really. If you are coming from the south, you have to drive a long way to find a u-turn, but I would want you to add parking and wreck the lagoon. It is really a first world problem. It 's fine. 476 Cut down on number of new condos the vity is building. 477 None 478 More parking near shops. 479 Underground parking, better train situation, village exclusive parking program where the money stays in the village, tax the events in the village to pay for parking improvements 480 None 481 Shuttle service ... moving tram. 482 We need parking. Valet parking takes the spots. More parking is needed. The holidays. It's a problem. 483 None. 484 Shuttle service from end of beach to tamarak at bathrooms 485 None 486 Build a parking structure near the power plant. Far enough away but still serves visitors to beach. 487 I take the buss most of the time, I parks on the parking lot when I drive. 488 How about another public parking lot? There is one at Tamarack but this one here is too small. 489 Add more bicycles. 490 no suggestions 491 Bike access improvements 492 Shuttle service like coronado. No parking garage ... 493 Dont build a large lot 494 None 495 No. Kim ley >>> Horn 5/21/201615:11 5/21/2016 15:11 5/21/201615:10 5/21/2016 15:09 5/21/2016 15:08 5/21/2016 15:08 5/21/2016 15:07 5/21/2016 15:04 5/21/2016 15:04 5/21/2016 15:02 5/21/2016 15:02 5/21/2016 15:02 5/21/2016 15:02 5/21/2016 15:01 5/21/2016 14:58 5/21/2016 14:58 5/21/201614:58 5/21/2016 14:57 5/21/2016 14:56 5/21/2016 14:54 5/21/2016 14:53 5/21/2016 14:53 5/21/2016 14:51 5/21/2016 14:51 5/21/2016 14:50 5/21/2016 14:50 5/21/2016 14:49 5/21/2016 14:48 5/21/2016 14:46 5/21/2016 14:46 Page I 30 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p 496 None 497 Diagnal parking between the jetties. I like the idea of a parking structure. 498 Add lights to pedestrian crosswalks. Very dangerous otherwise with the crossing that only have blinking lights 499 Seems like parking is pretty good 500 I think its great. 501 I haven't really thought about. I surf a lot so I don't want too many people. Shuttle maybe. 502 Feels parking is ok. 504 Make parking for customersonly ... and more park n ride 505 Add parking meters to the area so it would fund city cleanup of streets. 506 Parking is pretty good. 508 No parking structures, maintain village scene 510 No parking meters 511 No suggestions ... more biking 512 Alii can say is that I hope we don't have to pay. No parking meters. I just noticed that the added the deal where you have to buy a ticket behind Las Olas like at Tamarack. Not that. No parking meters 513 No parking garage in the barrio. Could consider making the surfing spot near North pathos a pay lot like did at tame rack. 514 Add moreparking lots during the weekends 515 3 hr parking benefits multiple users 516 None 517 Make lot on tamarak free again 518 More spots, no parking structures 519 No suggestions 520 No. I feel like everything is under control. 521 None. 522 No but someone has to work on it 523 Shuttle system 524 They walk everywhere. 525 Nice to have a parking structure at train station .. .its not that bad 526 Don't charge at Tamarack because it moves everyone up here to ours. You can't have anyone over. 527 Make it more pedestrian friendly. 528 More beach lots 529 Centrally located parking structures, no more than 3 stories high 530 More Kim ley>>> Horn 5/21/2016 14:45 5/21/201614:44 5/21/2016 14:44 5/21/201614:44 5/21/2016 14:43 5/21/2016 14:43 5/21/2016 14:43 5/21/2016 14:42 5/21/2016 14:42 5/21/2016 14:41 5/21/2016 14:40 5/21/2016 14:39 5/21/2016 14:39 5/21/2016 14:38 5/21/2016 14:38 5/21/2016 14:37 5/21/2016 14:36 5/21/2016 14:35 5/21/2016 14:35 5/21/2016 14:34 5/21/2016 14:32 5/21/2016 14:32 5/21/2016 14:32 5/21/2016 14:31 5/21/2016 14:31 5/21/2016 14:30 5/21/2016 14:30 5/21/2016 14:29 5/21/2016 14:28 5/21/2016 14:28 5/21/2016 14:28 5/21/2016 14:27 Page I 31 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 17 v _AfiL o D 531 Quit building. That should have been a parking lot instead of a Marriott. What they are doing now is opening restaurants with parking lots that charge for parking. I refuse to pay. I've been here my whole life. There is no parking from here to Tamarack. 532 Angle the parking on street to fit more cars in sll the way down to power plant. Could add some parking on other side. Elevated parking at tame rack could build up existing lot a level. Normally takes longer to find a space. 533 Glad forfree parking no time limits 534 Keep it free 535 Widen sidewalks. 536 None 537 Empty lot near historical park by army navy dorms should convert to public parking ... Pretty parking structures 538 None. 539 Beach stop on the bus 540 It a little confusing on the street. Businesses say it is reserved for them but I'm not sure if it is bull shit or not. Clearly delineating it would be good. I don't want to wake up and my car is towed. 541 None. 542 Never have problems 543 Build a parking lot and shuttle people to their destinations. 545 None 546 No. In the summer it gets crazy but there is nothing you can do about that. 547 Encourage more biking 548 Look at Parking ratio to type of homes (condos) they are building. Condos dense housing and each have several cars. 549 Add public transportation. 550 No its pretty good & convenient. 551 Parking is rough on tamarack. Dont put meters 552 Not specifically. I think it is pretty good at this point. 553 Parking structure 554 Expand the beach lots. 555 More parking or structure 556 Our response is not our typical experience ... more city lots with free parkng. Creative lots worked n nicely with community 557 Parking lot needs to be at the train station and blend in with the community. No lots in the middle of town. 558 Great for bikers! Kimley >>>Horn 5/21/2016 14:26 5/21/2016 14:25 5/21/2016 14:24 5/21/2016 14:24 5/21/2016 14:22 5/21/2016 14:22 5/21/2016 14:22 5/21/2016 14:21 5/21/2016 14:21 5/21/2016 14:20 5/21/2016 14:19 5/21/2016 14:18 5/21/201614:16 5/21/2016 14:15 5/21/2016 14:15 5/21/201614:14 5/21/2016 14:14 5/21/201614:13 5/21/201614:13 5/21/2016 14:12 5/21/2016 14:12 5/21/2016 14:10 5/21/2016 14:10 5/21/2016 14:09 5/21/2016 14:09 5/21/2016 14:09 5/21/2016 14:08 Page I 32 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Of 559 To put in wheel blocks for parking spaces that are orthogonal so it won't block wheel chairs. I wrote a letter and they did it here. It makes it easier for people with walkers and wheel chairs and a lot of people come down here. I don't think there are any parking meters in Carlsbad. It's a parking friendly city. The only place you pay for parking is at the state beach. 560 Have a rotating trolley pick up and drop off at popular spots 561 Like palm springs the buzz...takes people for free .. also helps with drunk driving ... also great if carl bad cound team up with encinitas to oceanside 562 He walk because there is no parking, improve met transit, more trains. 564 None. 565 Add public transportation. 567 More driveways for residents 569 Parking structures 570 Turn existing public lots into atructures. Not too high though. At Train station where there is already a lot, tourn that into a multi level garage. 571 More parking 572 We like the way it is ... let tourists fight for their spots. Not interested in seeing change 573 None. 576 not that i can think of 577 More parking. 578 Compact parking spaces are not big enough. Also, more diasbled parking. 579 Not charging in tamarak parking lot 580 Parking structure. 581 Carpooling, bike, walk 582 Add more handicapped parking. 583 No 584 Worked well for us 585 No i find it really good .. no complaints 586 This parking lot, they made it smaller. The need to widen it again. 587 No its pretty good 588 Remove fees from lots 589 Keep up the good work. For visitors it was easy to find free parking close 590 Valet run by the city 591 No. 592 No land is limit maybe a public parking garage because I noticed downtown there isn't one. 593 No parking structures!! Kim ley>>> Horn 5/21/2016 14:08 5/21/2016 14:07 5/21/2016 14:07 5/21/2016 14:06 5/21/2016 14:06 5/21/2016 14:05 5/21/2016 14:03 5/21/2016 14:01 5/21/2016 14:01 5/21/2016 14:01 5/21/2016 14:00 5/21/2016 13:59 5/21/2016 13:57 5/21/2016 13:57 5/21/2016 13:56 5/21/2016 13:56 5/21/2016 13:55 5/21/2016 13:55 5/21/2016 13:55 5/21/2016 13:55 5/21/201613:54 5/21/2016 13:54 5/21/2016 13:52 5/21/2016 13:52 5/21/2016 13:51 5/21/2016 13:51 5/21/201613:51 5/21/2016 13:50 5/21/201613:49 5/21/2016 13:48 Page I 33 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 o~c u D 594 More parking 595 None 596 Go to the end at the train station and build a parking garage. The biggest concern living here is to keep it free because so many beach cities are charging, putting in parkig meters. 597 Parking is not bad sometimes with sporting events 598 Na 599 More parking would be nice .. always struggle on the weekends. i got lucky 600 Keep it free 601 No suggestions 602 Parking structure 603 Parking lots do not go with community Research what other cities are doing and get ideas from this. Seattle and Portland. 604 More parking is definitely needed. I got lucky today. I would suggest underground. Or up? 605 Parking is not too bad 606 None. 607 None 608 No suggestions 609 Corner where he lives there is fast traffic, put something to slow it down. He always walks. 610 No. Your signs are helpful. Keep it free. In Santa Monica, they charge an arm and a leg 611 Keep out of towners away from Carlsbad. 612 Na 613 More free pArking 614 No garage 615 None. 616 Parking garage 618 Dont build restaruant in parking lot next to off shore 619 There is a lot of congestion on the weekends hard to find parking 620 Not really. 621 None. 622 Keep it free 623 So far you are the only ones who have free parking at the beach. In the summer it's bad but now it's beautiful. 624 Develop undeveloped land for parking lots. 625 parking spots are too narrow 626 You need a parking structure. We've come here before and couldn't find parking and had to leave. This time we rented a place with parking and had to pay extra. 627 Remove fees from lots. Especially the ones that were free before. 628 Build parking stalls to get revenues. Kim ley>>> Horn 5/21/201613:47 5/21/201613:47 5/21/2016 13:46 5/21/2016 13:46 5/21/2016 13:46 5/21/2016 13:46 5/21/2016 13:45 5/21/2016 13:43 5/21/2016 13:43 5/21/2016 13:43 5/21/2016 13:42 5/21/2016 13:41 5/21/2016 13:41 5/21/2016 13:40 5/21/2016 13:40 5/21/2016 13:40 5/21/2016 13:39 5/21/2016 13:38 5/21/2016 13:38 5/21/2016 13:37 5/21/2016 13:36 5/21/2016 13:36 5/21/2016 13:34 5/21/2016 13:34 5/21/2016 13:34 5/21/2016 13:34 5/21/201613:33 5/21/2016 13:33 5/21/2016 13:33 5/21/2016 13:32 5/21/2016 13:31 5/21/2016 13:29 5/21/2016 13:29 5/21/2016 13:28 Page I 34 (_City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA r OF C D 629 Tension with tourists. Reserved parking areas for residents. Frustration with having to pay for parking at tame rick now. 630 There is no where to park .. you would have to build up ... 631 During summer everything is full, she likes there are no meters in downtown. 632 No. I don't. I've had a pretty easy time. 633 No i dont. 634 None 635 We could use a parking ramp downtown Carlsbad. We walk but every now and then we drive and tgere is never any parking 636 When he drives it varies how long does it take him to park, depending on the season. Coul take him less than a minute or as long as 15-30 minutes. 637 None. 638 I really don't. 639 Reality there is no other space but more lots would be better 640 None. 641 In our household we own two cars but only one parking space and its really hard to find parking on the street. 642 Vehicals are continuosly parked in spots and neverhas to move and some are living out pof their cars 643 Limit the number of RVs that park along the street during the summer, 644 Ask me in summer when its full and busy 645 Open the senior center to park after 1130 pm 646 Expand lanes, area by Cannon only one lane and gets backed up. 647 No suggestions 648 Lot would be ok but not on beach. Needs to blend it not stick out. 649 Such a walkable city. No suggestions 650 There is not enough parking and if there is an event residents are not able to park. She is not sure if the senior center parking is available for residents at nights and weekends. 651 I dont know. It would be hard but it would be convenient because there are a lot of games. 652 When driving it takes her about 10 minutes to park in the area. 653 Preserve the way it is. Dot change much. 654 Get rid of RVs. Add lines in parking spaces so folks dont park too far apart. 655 None 656 I dont own a car but there is never parking on the streets around here 657 Utilize dirt parking lot 658 The restaurants in the Village shouldn't be able to extend into the street. Takes up a lot of parking. Kim ley>>> Horn 5/21/2016 13:28 5/21/2016 13:28 5/21/2016 13:27 5/21/2016 13:27 5/21/2016 13:26 5/21/2016 13:26 5/21/2016 13:25 5/21/2016 13:24 5/21/2016 13:22 5/21/2016 13:22 5/21/2016 13:22 5/21/2016 13:21 5/21/2016 13:21 5/21/2016 13:20 5/21/201613:19 5/21/201613:18 5/21/201613:17 5/21/201613:16 5/21/201613:16 5/21/201613:15 5/21/201613:14 5/21/201613:13 5/21/201613:11 5/21/2016 13:11 5/21/201613:11 5/21/2016 13:09 5/21/2016 13:06 5/21/2016 13:02 5/21/2016 13:02 5/18/2016 16:59 Page I 35 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA :JF C. . _o. D 659 Limited parking is caused my tourists-we pay taxes ans are barely able to park in our own town 660 None 661 Parking here isn't too bad. In Huntington Beach you'd have to murder someone to get a parking spot. Here you'd just have to be a little belligerent. 662 Add more lots. Too busy during the summer at the beach. 663 None 664 Add a parking structure. 665 Increase public transit. 666 None 667 The parking lot at south end of beach should be free. I parked in the lot at the other end of the beach but would never park in the paid lot. 669 Increase awareness of public transit. 670 Make Tamarack parking lot free 671 Make tamarack lot free parking 672 Keep it free. 673 Underground parking. 674 No suggestions 675 Maybe leave earlier? There is always a space 678 No. 680 No suggestions on parkng just more bike lanes 681 None 682 Not too bad for the beach 683 Make Tamarack lot free 684 Make the beach parking lot free. Also lengthen the parking zone along Carl bad Blvd. the red zone takes up too much of the street. 685 More parking lots 686 A double garadge but we dont want more people 687 Easy to find parking during the day but really hard at night 688 Make tamarack lot free 689 A parking structure i guess but where is the room for that? 690 Make cars stop at pedestrian crossings. 693 Dont really know 694 I think the parking here is fine 695 Every time i come here i easily find a spot 696 Keep parking free. They charge enough in taxes that they don't need to charge us for parking. 697 I dont think its that bad right now 5/18/2016 16:57 5/18/2016 16:56 5/18/2016 16:53 5/18/2016 16:53 5/18/2016 16:51 5/18/2016 16:49 5/18/2016 16:48 5/18/2016 16:48 5/18/201616:47 5/18/2016 16:41 5/18/2016 16:41 5/18/2016 16:38 5/18/2016 16:37 5/18/2016 16:36 5/18/2016 16:36 5/18/2016 16:35 5/18/201616:34 5/18/201616:34 5/18/2016 16:34 5/18/2016 16:33 5/18/2016 16:31 5/18/2016 16:31 5/18/2016 16:30 5/18/2016 16:30 5/18/2016 16:28 5/18/201616:27 5/18/2016 16:27 5/18/2016 16:26 5/18/2016 16:24 5/18/2016 16:24 5/18/2016 16:22 5/18/2016 16:18 5/18/201616:18 Kimley >>>Horn Page 136 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ror 1.1 c1 r C/ RLBAD 698 Fix i-5 traffic so it doent use coast high way. 700 I always walk if i come down here 701 No its getting busier. 702 More beach parking and get rid of pay lot. 704 Build a parking garage somewhere. 705 Underground parking for development 706 Add more parking 707 Provide more parking. Streets are pretty full. 710 No i think parking around here is really easy. 712 Theresa lot of parking. 714 Underground parking 715 N/A 716 I stay at a hotel down the street and we park in the lot there. So no parking issues for me. 717 No. 718 No. 719 Stop building. Lower density would really help the parking situation. 720 A parking structure 721 Quit coming down here on the weekends because it's too crowded. They should stop building condos and apartments down here. Just adds too much traffic. 722 None 723 Add synchronized lights. Add a train from Palomar airport to the beach. 724 Parking structure would be convinient i usually do a lot of walking since I live close Benches have been removed-hoping city can change that and replace them 725 Dont put a structure anf get rid of tourists 726 There's nothing you can really do without knocking down a building. 727 None 728 No suggestions .... its perfect here 729 Longer time limits for lots and street parking. More spaces in general. ... Structure 730 Give free pubic transportation to property owners or residents/tax payers. Would alleviate a lot of parking problems. 731 Need parking structure sometimes no parking on the street 732 Add shuttles frm lots during holidays and busy times. 733 Need public transportation. Need more public parking. 734 More free parking lots. 736 Parking structure i live down the street from here so i walk everywhere because of the parking it is really hard to park in my own neighborhood 737 None Kim ley >>> Horn 5/18/201616:17 5/18/2016 16:16 5/18/2016 16:15 5/18/201616:14 5/18/201616:13 5/18/201616:13 5/18/2016 16:12 5/18/2016 16:09 5/18/2016 16:08 5/18/2016 16:06 5/18/2016 16:06 5/18/2016 16:0S 5/18/2016 16:04 5/18/2016 16:03 5/18/2016 16:01 5/18/2016 16:00 5/18/2016 15:58 5/18/2016 15:57 5/18/2016 15:56 5/18/2016 15:56 5/18/2016 15:55 5/18/2016 15:53 5/18/2016 15:53 5/18/2016 15:52 5/18/2016 15:52 5/18/2016 15:51 5/18/2016 15:49 5/18/2016 15:49 5/18/2016 15:48 5/18/2016 15:48 5/18/2016 15:48 5/18/2016 15:46 5/18/2016 15:45 Page I 37 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA [' 0 f OF R b D 738 I always bike so i dont have trouble with parking 739 None. 740 Bigger lot the one by the water is too small 741 I have never had a problem parking here i always use the same lot 742 Add time limits to the spaces to increase turnsround. 743 It is small hoping for bigger space or another structure 744 N/A 745 Build a parking lot or parking structure. But I don't know where you would do it. 746 I guess a parking structure would help even if it was ugly 747 Remove RVs that take up spots 748 Dont build a parkng garage 749 Sometimes the signs on the street a rent that clear about when you need to move your car so i have gotten a ticket so i would want them to be more clear 750 None. 751 I usually take public transportation 752 Parking in the village is so bad that we only walk in and out. We don't even try to deal with parking. 753 Parking garage 754 They do a good job i lved here for 12 years with no issues. Just recently moved 755 Add more pedestrian crosswalks by the beach. 756 I think with parking you have to tear things down. They should have more buses. 757 They could build a big parking structure downtown and provide a free shuttle down to the beach. 758 More municipal parking lots if there's room. Timed parking. 759 Possible parking garage like oceanside does, i come from vista fairly often during the week ans always find quick parking but i dont come down on the weekends because it is almost impossible to park 760 Improve parking during busy events. 761 Larger parking spaces near the beach. A compact car could not even fit 762 Police never make sure that cars stop for pedestrians at the crosswalks along Carlsbad Blvd. Makes walking down to the beach less appealing during the summer. 763 no suggestions 764 None. 765 No 766 Underground parking near beach-even if there is a slight charge it is better than having to walk so far to enjoy the beach/scenery & dining/shopping 767 Add more lots at the beach, especially in summer. Kim ley>>> Horn 5/18/2016 15:45 5/18/2016 15:44 5/18/2016 15:43 5/18/2016 15:42 5/18/2016 15:42 5/18/2016 15:42 5/18/2016 15:42 5/18/2016 15:41 5/18/2016 15:41 5/18/2016 15:40 5/18/2016 15:38 5/18/2016 15:38 5/18/2016 15:38 5/18/2016 15:37 5/18/2016 15:37 5/18/2016 15:37 5/18/2016 15:35 5/18/2016 15:35 5/18/2016 15:35 5/18/2016 15:34 5/18/2016 15:33 5/18/2016 15:33 5/18/2016 15:32 5/18/2016 15:32 5/18/2016 15:31 5/18/2016 15:31 5/18/2016 15:29 5/18/2016 15:29 5/18/2016 15:27 5/18/2016 15:27 Page I 38 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA BAD 768 Shouldnt allow motor homes to park along Carlsbad Blvd during the summer. They take up too much parking. 769 A shuttle 770 Hardest thing is farther by power plant street spaces are not adequate-lots of events almost impossible to park, especially on the weekends 771 None 772 No suggestions 773 Add a lot. 774 None 775 They should never have made the parking lot paid. Maybe on weekends but not during the week. 776 None 777 None. 778 Keep no time limits on spots. Limit high density building projects. Limit the lofts. Keep it a small beach town. Too much development. Reqire undeground parking. 779 I dont live in the area-stopped by for lunch break from work meeting, there are few signs indicating if we can park in designated areas, so more clear reading signs would be helpful in resulting to mis-parking and future tickets 780 No suggestioms i think We are good. 781 None. More trees for shade. 782 Looks pretty good here 783 None 784 Shuttle from the village to the beach to improve beach parking. 785 Have more lots near beach and a biking system like they have in new york 786 Local residence should have free parking and others should pay for parking because they are taking over our spots-makes it hard to enjoy our own neighborhhod if we can not park efficiently 788 None, 789 More parking spaces. 790 None. 791 Encourage more bike riding ... Maybe designate certain areas for just parking 792 Add another parking structure. 793 No suggestions 794 Parking structure would be worthwhile, and helpful for people working in the area and tourists daily. The transportation is great-lots of people take the coaster it is very convinient 796 None. 797 No complaints Kimley >>>Horn 5/18/2016 15:27 5/18/2016 15:26 5/18/2016 15:26 5/18/2016 15:25 5/18/201615:24 5/18/2016 15:24 5/18/2016 15:22 5/18/2016 15:21 5/18/2016 15:21 5/18/2016 15:20 5/18/2016 15:20 5/18/2016 15:19 5/18/2016 15:19 5/18/201615:18 5/18/201615:17 5/18/201615:16 5/18/2016 15:15 5/18/2016 15:15 5/18/2016 15:14 5/18/2016 15:13 5/18/2016 15:11 5/18/2016 15:09 5/18/2016 15:08 5/18/2016 15:08 5/18/2016 15:07 5/18/2016 15:07 5/18/2016 15:05 5/18/2016 15:04 Page I 39 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P. f c C hLSB,..D 799 "None. 800 No parking structures please 801 no its pretty good now but summertime its hard to park .. 802 None. 803 None 804 We are just visitors and park at the hotel 805 Definitely more parking space , today we were lucky to find parking in the lot but normally 3-4 blocks down 806 Lots of cities have free cable trolleys ... should have free trolley up and down to the beach like West Palm Beach Flordia is a good example 807 None 808 None 809 Have more of it. Trolley would be cool to have. 810 Parking garage 811 No problems because of resorts parking lot for free 812 Add number of u-turns to be able to change direction. 813 Parking structure 814 I think an attractive parking structure would be good for tourists at the beach who dont know where to look for parking 815 None 816 No 817 Add a shuttle. Remove fees. 818 If you get here early enough you will always find a spot 820 Not from the area. 821 Make it cheaper so folks dont have to park far away. 822 Never been a problembecause we have handicaped permit 823 More parking ... valet parking would be great 824 No more paylots by the beach 825 Walks because it is a nightmare to park 826 "I never have issues parking when i visit SD and this area inparticular, but i think its because i come before lunch time during the week so parking is a breeze" 828 Add more spots. 829 Get rid of parking meters by the beach because then people park in the neighborhoods and i cant park in front of my house 830 No parking structure. Diagonal spots to help parking space along sidewalk. 831 No just moved here recently and dont know much about the parking areas. 832 Having parking meters 833 Add more parking spaces. Kimley>>>Horn 5/18/2016 15:04 5/18/2016 15:03 5/18/2016 15:02 5/18/2016 15:02 5/18/2016 15:01 5/18/2016 15:00 5/18/2016 14:59 5/18/2016 14:58 5/18/2016 14:58 5/18/2016 14:58 5/18/2016 14:57 5/18/2016 14:55 5/18/2016 14:55 5/18/2016 14:53 5/18/2016 14:53 5/18/2016 14:50 5/18/2016 14:49 5/18/2016 14:49 5/18/201614:47 5/18/201614:47 5/18/2016 14:46 5/18/2016 14:45 5/18/2016 14:44 5/18/2016 14:44 5/18/2016 14:43 5/18/2016 14:42 5/18/2016 14:41 5/18/2016 14:41 5/18/2016 14:41 5/18/2016 14:40 5/18/2016 14:39 5/18/2016 14:39 5/18/2016 14:39 Page I 40 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA u ro L 8 J 834 Need more parking by the beach 835 Improve crosswalk safety for the pedestrians. 836 Well i dont know where most parking spaces are. 837 Dont need a parking structure 838 More established public parking. 839 Make more lots unpaid. 842 More signs determining if you can park in certain locations or not, when i parked on the street i had to ask a resident if i was even allowed to park there 843 No not really. 844 Remove the fees on the paid lots. 845 No its actually okay. 846 Tamarack parking free for residents. 847 There is always extra parking some where but it is a little busy right now 849 Build pubic parking up ... get rid of meters .. should be free parking 850 I would say create like a designated parking spot within this area without disrupting atmosphere of area. 851 Likes that parking is free and that there are a lot of great restaurants and things to do. Could be more stuff for kids though. Keep parking free! 853 None 854 N/A 855 Build more parking 857 More parking like a structure 858 Garage off railroad 859 No i dont. 860 More parking on weekends 861 I live here so i really dont think its that bad 862 More parking ... weekends are really difficult 863 We had easy parking since we are renting a condo a block away, it seems pretty mellow and easy parking access during the week, weekends it is so packed and seems that to find parking is overwhelming 864 Don t put more parking meters like in oceanside 865 Dont charge for parking. 866 Closer access to the beach. 867 Decrease RV parking. Expand lots. 868 I dont think its that bad 869 None 870 When friends come by its difficult to find parking on the street Kim ley >>> Horn 5/18/2016 14:38 5/18/2016 14:38 5/18/2016 14:37 5/18/2016 14:35 5/18/2016 14:35 5/18/2016 14:35 5/18/2016 14:34 5/18/2016 14:34 5/18/2016 14:33 5/18/2016 14:32 5/18/2016 14:32 5/18/2016 14:32 5/18/2016 14:30 5/18/2016 14:29 5/18/2016 14:29 5/18/2016 14:28 5/18/2016 14:28 5/18/2016 14:28 5/18/2016 14:27 5/18/2016 14:27 5/18/2016 14:25 5/18/2016 14:24 5/18/2016 14:24 5/18/2016 14:23 5/18/2016 14:22 5/18/2016 14:22 5/18/2016 14:22 5/18/2016 14:22 5/18/2016 14:20 5/18/2016 14:20 5/18/201614:17 5/18/201614:16 Page I 41 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Cr 0 871 Used to live the neighborhood. Doesn't like that the parking lot in front of the beach is paid parking. Just makes the surfers park in the residential areas in front of people's houses. 872 We have a state beach pass and that makes a big difference 873 None 874 Hyland city should take lot and make it for parking. 875 Tamarack parking free for Carlsbad residents. 876 None 877 A parking structure. 878 No im from australia and just visiting. 879 None 880 Big parking lot on carl bad blvd. city should buy it. Restaurants shouldnt reserve spots for customers. 881 None 882 N/A 884 Shuttles to the area from lots. 885 Input parking garage along railroad. Police are great about removing cars from property. 886 None 887 We dont think its that bad 888 No more parking meters the city has enough mney 889 I never go to the Village because the parking is so bad. 890 "Dont come down here often but when i do for lunch or walk on the beach it is usually during the week and for the most part i always find quick parking" 891 N/A 893 "We use public transportation to come down to enjoy the beach because prior visits we have had no luck being able to park near the water. I would suggest maybe an extra structure especially for summer time-people come from different parts of the county and its hard to enjoy the beach being stressed about finding a place to park" 894 I love Carlsbad because parking is free! 895 We used to live here the parking isnt that bad 896 Make more lots free. 897 Wish there was more near Carlsbad inn shops 898 I dont think its that bad. I dont mind a stroll. 900 None. 901 None 902 Make sure the pedestrian walkways are safer, so either remove the number of walkways or put clearer lights that protect people. 903 No Kimley >>>Horn 5/18/201614:16 5/18/2016 14:16 5/18/2016 14:16 5/18/2016 14:15 5/18/2016 14:15 5/18/2016 14:14 5/18/2016 14:14 5/18/201614:14 5/18/201614:13 5/18/201614:13 5/18/2016 14:12 5/18/2016 14:12 5/18/2016 14:11 5/18/201614:10 5/18/2016 14:08 5/18/2016 14:07 5/18/2016 14:07 5/18/2016 14:07 5/18/2016 14:07 5/18/2016 14:05 5/18/2016 14:05 5/18/2016 14:04 5/18/2016 14:04 5/18/2016 14:03 5/18/2016 14:03 5/18/2016 14:02 5/18/2016 14:00 5/18/2016 14:00 5/18/2016 13:59 5/18/2016 13:58 Page I 42 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OF r 8 D 904 Dont know the area that well since im just visiting. 905 Less lane merging. More turn lanes for slowing before a turn. 907 I feel like no one really uses the buses. Should create some sort of cute attractive form of bus or trolley 908 Make sure the big RV campers dont take up all the spots by the beach by parking for several days in a row. 909 Bike facilities are pretty good in Carlsbad. 910 No parking by the beach areas 911 I just moved here and so far i have found no problems 912 Summer is worse 913 No meters. No parking garage. 914 No 915 Looks very well. Weve been walking around since we arrived and everything looks good. 916 "Summer-adding a new structure in the summer gets really crowded, i dont come doen here often however i was able to park quickly on the street a block away-im assuming because its a week day though" 917 N/A 918 Make more lots free. 919 No 920 Not much you can do. Good setup. 921 Designate a parking lot... I dont really want a structure here 924 N/A 925 Don't start charging for parking. Keep it free. 926 Parking has been awesome way better than previous years 927 I live in carlsbad and i have never had a problem with parking 928 Putting "backs" on the benches for resting, the parking isnt too bad however there are so many cops i feel like they are finding people to give tickets to every chance they get 929 None 931 More parking. Hard to park when its busy. 932 Remove fees on the lots. People will visit more. 933 There is more parking than people think. But i think they should just charge 10 bucks a day to park at the beach. Please no meters! 935 None. 936 No. Siempre es facil. It's always easy to fine parking because I have a designated parking spot in the Barrio. 938 Monorail down the center of the freeway. 939 I really dont think its that bad ... Havenever had a priblem and i live here 941 Does seem like friday and weekend it gets busy. Kim ley >>> Horn 5/18/2016 13:58 5/18/2016 13:57 5/18/2016 13:56 5/18/2016 13:55 5/18/2016 13:55 5/18/2016 13:53 5/18/2016 13:52 5/18/2016 13:51 5/18/2016 13:51 5/18/2016 13:50 5/18/2016 13:50 5/18/2016 13:50 5/18/2016 13:49 5/18/2016 13:49 5/18/2016 13:48 5/18/201613:47 5/18/201613:47 5/18/2016 13:46 5/18/2016 13:46 5/18/2016 13:46 5/18/2016 13:46 5/18/2016 13:45 5/18/2016 13:45 5/18/2016 13:44 5/18/2016 13:44 5/18/2016 13:43 5/18/2016 13:42 5/18/2016 13:42 5/18/2016 13:41 5/18/2016 13:40 5/18/2016 13:39 Page I 43 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA or: 942 No 943 Dont build a parkng structure 944 Permanent parking in residential areas. Right now there is no such thing. 945 Need police patrolling along the boardwalk to deal with skateboarders, the homeless and other people who sometimes cause disturbances. 946 Its great 947 I would say the day of the farmers market and more parking along the streets or a structure. When they have races it gets tricky driving around. 948 None 950 Weekends and summer bad. No parking garage. Empty lots free parking. 951 N/A, said it's always fine. 952 Add more free lots. They are all becoming paid now. 953 No 954 "Parking is limited, i purposly come down to the beach before 12 because after kit is nearly impossible to park near the beach" 955 Add more parking lots around the beach 957 Put in a parkmg garage close to the village 958 None 959 "Parking fees-"del mar" is charging for people to park along the roads of the beach. Hopefully that is not the outcome here " 961 It's not too bad except summer and on weekends. 962 I just deal with the parking situation. Only bad for like the street fairs 963 Not really. Its worse during summer and they should have more parking signs. 965 The red streetlights are way too long. Shorten them to ease the flow of traffic. 966 More parking. 967 During summer late night there is no parking 968 None 969 None 971 Park in hotel parking 972 Add more lots. preferably free. 973 Biggest concern is lack of parking that will result and build structure. Get rid of street parking. 974 Possibly more structures behind housing 975 We desperately need a parking structure 977 Wish they had more 978 Not at this time 980 I didnt have trouble parking Kim ley >>> Horn 5/18/2016 13:38 5/18/2016 13:38 5/18/2016 13:37 5/18/2016 13:37 5/18/2016 13:36 5/18/2016 13:36 5/18/2016 13:35 5/18/2016 13:34 5/18/2016 13:34 5/18/2016 13:34 5/18/2016 13:34 5/18/2016 13:34 5/18/2016 13:31 5/18/2016 13:28 5/18/2016 13:28 5/18/2016 13:27 5/18/2016 13:27 5/18/2016 13:27 5/18/2016 13:27 5/18/2016 13:25 5/18/2016 13:24 5/18/2016 13:22 5/18/2016 13:22 5/18/2016 13:21 5/18/2016 13:21 5/18/2016 13:20 5/18/2016 13:20 5/18/2016 13:19 5/18/2016 13:19 5/18/2016 13:19 5/18/2016 13:19 5/18/201613:18 Page I 44 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA on OF CA ,. AD 981 Keep parking free. They live in Oceanside but would rather drive to Carlsbad to not have to pay for parking at the beach. 982 None 983 N/A 984 None 985 No 986 None 988 Stop building condo apartments its ruining the city. 989 Have a shuttle going to the beach from other lots. 990 None. School provides parking pass for surf team. 991 It seems pretty good right now to me 992 None 993 None 994 No 995 None 996 No. 997 Add parking 998 No. 999 More parking structures. 1000 One fee year long permit for the entire city of Carlsbad. This is what they do in San Clemente. 1001 N/A because she walks here. She doesnt want anymore development along the beach and leave it the way it is. 1002 Worked for me 1003 Need to circle around to get parking but dont feel like there needs to be more parking 1005 None. 1006 Maybe Build parking structure 1007 More spaces at the coaster would be good. 1008 No 1010 She walks everywhere, lives two blocks away. Parking is not an issue. 1011 There is not enough parking at the village. 1012 None 1013 Wants a better Coaster schedule. Too limited on the weekends. 1014 None 1015 None. 1016 No I dont never thought about it 1018 No. Everything in Carlsbad is fantastic. 1019 None Kim ley>>> Horn 5/18/2016 13:18 5/18/201613:17 5/18/201613:17 5/18/201613:16 5/18/2016 13:16 5/18/2016 13:16 5/18/2016 13:14 5/18/2016 13:14 5/18/2016 13:12 5/18/2016 13:11 5/18/2016 13:09 5/18/2016 13:08 5/14/2016 21:53 5/14/2016 21:51 5/14/2016 21:51 5/14/2016 21:48 5/14/2016 21:47 5/14/2016 21:45 5/14/2016 21:44 5/14/2016 21:44 5/14/2016 21:43 5/14/2016 21:42 5/14/2016 21:42 5/14/2016 21:41 5/14/2016 21:40 5/14/2016 21:39 5/14/2016 21:38 5/14/2016 21:38 5/14/2016 21:38 5/14/2016 21:38 5/14/2016 21:38 5/14/2016 21:37 5/14/2016 21:37 5/14/2016 21:35 5/14/2016 21:35 Page I 45 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P/.. fOR f.JEr/1 or:rARL 1020 Carlsbad parking is always going to be a little difficult. But no suggestions. 1022 I lived here summertime is busy but i dont know if parking is really a big deal here. Is it? 1024 None 1025 Summer time there are less parking spaces but im not fond of adding more parking spaces or strucutures because people can walk further away to get parking and walk down. 1026 I don't know it's pretty built up here. Public lots? 1028 To built at least two floor parking lot, during summer there is no space to park 1029 None but dont want a parking structure at the beach 1030 I've never experienced it so I have no opinion. 1031 Trolley? Dont drive much. Dont have a problem keep major roads without parking so good for biking and doesnt block ocean view 1032 No complaints. 1033 More parking 1034 More parking. A big building. 1035 During summer is awful. 1036 No 1037 Not yet 1039 Just moved here. N/A 1040 A train stop 1041 No 1042 Wants more Uber drivers in area. 1043 Have more trains. Not enough parking during peak seasons. 1044 Parking garage would be nice. 1045 Quit building so much 1046 Not really 1047 None 1048 None. 1049 Add more parking lots. 1050 Get rid of sandag, solution is parking structure but noone wants to admit it 1051 Too much emphasis on bike lanes. Streets too narrow for cars where bike lanes are. Suggestung diagonal parking on one side of street. 1054 More spaces. 1055 I haven't been here long enough to offer any useful information. 1056 Trentching when they put in the double tracks. As for parking i have no idea since i dont have to park 1057 Keep the tourist out, locals only. 1058 No. 1059 No not from here Kimley >>>Horn 5/14/2016 21:35 5/14/2016 21:34 5/14/2016 21:33 5/14/2016 21:33 5/14/2016 21:33 5/14/2016 21:32 5/14/2016 21:31 5/14/2016 21:31 5/14/2016 21:31 5/14/2016 21:30 5/14/2016 21:29 5/14/2016 21:29 5/14/2016 21:28 5/14/2016 21:27 5/14/2016 21:26 5/14/2016 21:25 5/14/2016 21:25 5/14/2016 21:24 5/14/2016 21:24 5/14/2016 21:23 5/14/2016 21:23 5/14/2016 21:22 5/14/2016 21:21 5/14/2016 21:20 5/14/2016 21:19 5/14/2016 21:19 5/14/2016 21:19 5/14/2016 21:18 5/14/2016 21:15 5/14/2016 21:15 5/14/2016 21:14 5/14/2016 21:13 5/14/2016 21:13 5/14/2016 21:13 Page I 46 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA fJ 'IT OF CAhL 8 D 1060 Probably wont take public transportation if implemented and no parking structure because it ruins the community atmosphere 1061 Building more parking in the area. 1062 None 1063 N/A 1064 One driving lane on each way on street to have more parking. 1065 Not meters put in grass over parking spaces here that wasnt good 1067 None. 1069 Add a multilevel parkin lot at the beach for overflow during busy seasons 1070 We find parking pretty quickly so we think it is good 1071 No 1072 It was good today 1073 Expand sidewalks so people can walk too. 1075 Carlsbad is too small, carpool, less people will solve the problem .. 1077 Use funds charged for the lots for improving parking around Carlsbad. 1079 More public marking, wayfinding signs 1080 Promote biking and rollerblading 1081 We've always had a problem with parking. The City should desigante a parkimg area and provide a shuttle. (Surveyor note: They drove but could have walked to the beach. He made this suggestion. She asked him if they would use it.) 1084 Most would say build a parking lot no land around stop building high rises and put in parking maybe i dont know 1085 No 1086 Dont make too many paid lots. It decreases the enjoyment of the beach. 1089 Open transit station lot up to public parking, especially on weekends 1090 Public garage. Private owners could Lease their lots to expand options. 1091 Get rid of the cars. They are determined to come to the beach to walk and park as close as they can. On a nice day there will never be enough. Build a parking structure, bur where? Across Pacific Coast Highway but there is always parking over there. There will never be enough. 1092 Parking by beach should be free for 1 or two hours.( she was talking about lot south of pine 1093 Hard to find parking in busy weekends. More public transpotation. 1095 Keep parking zones ordered. 1096 Parking structure needed to accommodate restaurants. 1097 Nothing you can do 1098 Any taxis would help. Had to walk from the hotel. 1099 Information on public parking, rates and availability Kimley >>>Horn 5/14/2016 21:12 5/14/2016 21:11 5/14/2016 21:11 5/14/2016 21:10 5/14/2016 21:09 5/14/2016 21:09 5/14/2016 21:08 5/14/2016 21:06 5/14/2016 21:06 5/14/2016 21:05 5/14/2016 21:05 5/14/2016 21:04 5/14/2016 21:03 5/14/2016 21:03 5/14/2016 21:02 5/14/2016 21:01 5/14/2016 21:00 5/14/2016 20:59 5/14/2016 20:59 5/14/2016 20:59 5/14/2016 20:57 5/14/2016 20:56 5/14/2016 20:55 5/14/2016 20:55 5/14/2016 20:54 5/14/2016 20:53 5/14/2016 20:53 5/14/2016 20:52 5/14/2016 20:51 5/14/2016 20:51 Page I 47 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 01 FO LS 1101 None 1102 Definate parking lines to minimize the wasted space between cars. 1103 Build a structure. I understand it's the beach.We are used to it. You just need a structure. 1104 Always stays at the same hotel, no problem with parking. 1105 Worse saturday nights 1106 Decrease tourism, too many parking spots taken. 1107 More street parking. 1108 Resident lives close by, no suggestions. Resident suggest that there should be limited 2 hours spaces in the village. 1109 No 1110 He doesn't struggle with parking. 1111 Magnet transpoetation system, electric skateboards available when you park or hoverboards 1112 Likes parking in carlsbad 1113 Add another street for parking. Very hard to find spots during tourist season. 1114 Not from around here so dont know 1115 Make it cheaper. 1116 Walk everywhere, does not affect 1117 Put wayfinding parking signs 1118 I like parking situation 1120 Parking is fine. Transpotation for elderly is needed. 1121 None. 1122 Parking building, during summer everything is full. 1123 More signs for parking, hard to find the lots when you are a tourist. 1125 No. 1126 Cant create spaces here. Too many people. 1127 A hidden parking structure and trolley or golf cart from the parking structure to the beach and the village 1128 None 1129 Parking area for beach goers. Parking marks/ white lines that designates parking. Person is a resident. 1130 Add more parking. 1131 Increase the number of lots. Very difficult to get to the beach now and impossible during summer season. 1133 Open up more areas for lots. Doesn't like street park in ftont of resedential homes. 1134 Underground parking lot 1136 Pretty easy to bike here 1137 No suggestions. Kim ley>>> Horn 5/14/2016 20:49 5/14/2016 20:48 5/14/2016 20:48 5/14/2016 20:48 5/14/2016 20:48 5/14/2016 20:48 5/14/2016 20:47 5/14/2016 20:44 5/14/2016 20:44 5/14/2016 20:44 5/14/2016 20:43 5/14/2016 20:42 5/14/2016 20:42 5/14/2016 20:40 5/14/2016 20:40 5/14/2016 20:38 5/14/2016 20:38 5/14/2016 20:36 5/14/2016 20:34 5/14/2016 20:34 5/14/2016 20:34 5/14/2016 20:32 5/14/2016 20:30 5/14/2016 20:30 5/14/2016 20:29 5/14/2016 20:28 5/14/2016 20:27 5/14/2016 20:26 5/14/2016 20:25 5/14/2016 20:23 5/14/2016 20:23 5/14/2016 20:21 5/14/2016 20:19 Page I 48 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p 1139 Like parking situation 1141 I don't know. That's a tough one. We know how it is when you are coming to the beach. 1142 More parking at beach area. 1143 None. 1144 More parking needed. Sometimes it takes 15 minutes to find a spot. 1145 People park on my street but im fine with it 1146 Credit card machine doesnt work. Lighting in lot at night. Good parking. 1147 Public parking lot. 1148 Makes freeways wider 1150 Nope 1151 Improve security for cars left in lot. Put in a patrol. 1152 I wish I did. What do you with all the cars? A tram? A structure at the train station or south of Grand by the bank. Where do you park for the Farmer's Market? 1153 Add space to lot for events. 1154 Parking garages will be of great help. 1155 Wants a parking srtucture near train station to accommodate more cars. But keep it far enough from the beach. 1156 Its pretty easy to find a spot. 1158 Make zoned parking with some closer areas as 2 hour parking and others unlimited farther away. No paid parking lots. 1159 Like that there are no meters. Stay out of special events. Parking probably worse then. 1161 More spaces. Co sharing parking in lots that a rent being used at full capacity. Offer this temporary parking at low cost. Parking structure is another idea. 1162 More coaster service. You can get downtown but cant get back. 1163 Parking structure a mile to 2 away and then a shuttle to the bus to alleviate parking 1164 Muti parking structure. 1166 More space in lots. Maybe 2nd story 1167 Parking lot used to be free would appreciate free lots. Now we have to find street parking which is not nice 1168 Why doesnt train run every half hour? Problem for big events. Train should go later hours. 1169 They come here because the parking is free. Please dont put in meters. 1170 Paint lines so people take one spot on street spaces 1172 Remote parking with shuttle. 1173 None 1175 Shuttle service from parking lot further away 1176 Summer is very hard to find parking spaces about 30 mins 1177 Keep free parking. That is one thing Carlsbad does right. Usually doesnt have a hard time finding a spot. Kimley >>>Horn 5/14/2016 20:18 5/14/2016 20:18 5/14/2016 20:18 5/14/2016 20:17 5/14/2016 20:17 5/14/2016 20:16 5/14/2016 20:16 5/14/2016 20:16 5/14/2016 20:15 5/14/2016 20:14 5/14/2016 20:14 5/14/2016 20:13 5/14/2016 20:13 5/14/2016 20:12 5/14/2016 20:11 5/14/2016 20:11 5/14/2016 20:11 5/14/2016 20:10 5/14/2016 20:09 5/14/2016 20:09 5/14/2016 20:07 5/14/2016 20:07 5/14/2016 20:07 5/14/2016 20:06 5/14/2016 20:05 5/14/2016 20:04 5/14/2016 20:03 5/14/2016 20:02 5/14/2016 20:02 5/14/2016 20:00 5/14/2016 20:00 5/14/2016 19:58 Page I 49 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 1178 No 1179 None what can you do 1180 Increase number of lots and means of transportation to the beach. 1181 I think it's pretty good compared to other beaches 1182 Have more parking maybe under ground. If you dont park illegally at train station parking is awful 1183 No trouble parking. Weekends are tougher. But overall fine 1185 No parking meters. Doesnt mind druving around to look for parking. 1186 None 1188 Not really 1189 Parking lot at beach 1190 None. It was very easy. 1191 More access points between the barrio and the beach. Especially across the tracks. 1192 Parking ramps increase frequency of train double track train to san diego 1193 More time allowed in timed parking areas. 1194 From the UK, he enjoys how its easy to travel by car no suggestions. 1195 I like the situation 1196 Less people. Parks in lot at his condo rental. 1197 Like that there is no limit. Can eat and shop. 1199 Add more parking lots 1200 Thinks the parking is good!! 1201 Number of parking spaces. Hotels in area should provide parking for guests so dont have to use the street parking. 1202 They usually dont come down in summer because it is too crowded. They stay at a hotel with easy parking access. 1203 Parking in village around coaster was taken up by new condos, most parking needs to happen in the village because you cant go in residential areas. Theyve talked about a parking structure but you hate to take away from the aesthtics of the area or peoples views of the ocean 1204 I guess I don't 1206 Muti level parking 1207 More 2 hour parking to have more turn over so people would not park and stay all day. 1208 Maybe some signs that designate public parking 1209 Shuttle to beach from other lots. Double decker bus to make the shuttle ride enjoyable. 1211 None. Very pedestrian friendly. 1212 Underground parking 1213 Nope Kimley >>>Horn 5/14/2016 19:58 5/14/2016 19:58 5/14/2016 19:57 5/14/2016 19:56 5/14/2016 19:56 5/14/2016 19:55 5/14/2016 19:54 5/14/2016 19:52 5/14/2016 19:52 5/14/2016 19:52 5/14/2016 19:51 5/14/2016 19:50 5/14/2016 19:49 5/14/2016 19:49 5/14/2016 19:49 5/14/2016 19:48 5/14/201619:47 5/14/2016 19:46 5/14/2016 19:45 5/14/2016 19:45 5/14/2016 19:45 5/14/2016 19:44 5/14/2016 19:43 5/14/2016 19:42 5/14/2016 19:41 5/14/2016 19:41 5/14/2016 19:40 5/14/2016 19:40 5/14/2016 19:38 5/14/2016 19:38 5/14/2016 19:36 Page I 50 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA RLSBA& 1214 I live east of garfield. Corners get parked so close that you cant see to pull out. It causes many accidents 1215 Today was easy, during summers gets crazy. 1216 Larger parking lots. 1217 Limited ... its an issue drive around in cicle. Feel ba d for older and disabled who get around. Unless the city buys property and puts in property what can they do. 1218 More free lots 1219 More parking area or more access to private parking areas. 1220 More parking. Walked 1.5 miles - 1221 Allow parking in Coaster station and shuttle to the beach 1222 Parking garage. 1223 No idea 1224 Diving diving lines on parallel parking areas. 1225 During summer months there isnt enough. Good public transportation is the answer but I dont think ill see that in my lifetime. Parking further from beach with shuttle maybe 1226 More spots for parking,especially during busy beach days. Meters are not the answer. 1227 There's nothing you can do now. It's not like you want some ugly parking garage. 1228 Parking lot or shuttle when really busy. 1229 Weve gotten lucky and found parking quickly. Only been here 2 times 1230 The lot for the train can be bigger 1231 Keep it the way it is with less people 1233 No 1234 None 1236 No 1237 Can't stand driving around here, 1238 Build a larger lot with a shuttle around the area 1239 None 1240 Need more parking low structures no big structures if we do we lose the heart of our city. 1241 Maybe have lot somewhere with free shuttles 1242 Permits for residential area 1243 Get rid of the one hour parking in area. 1244 Need more parking on the street 1245 I'm not driving yet so I don't really know 1246 Keep village small 1248 Just visiting, parking was easy 1250 Add trains from temecula to carlsbad 1251 No 1252 Parking tower at the beach. Kim ley >>> Horn 5/14/2016 19:36 5/14/2016 19:35 5/14/2016 19:34 5/14/2016 19:33 5/14/2016 19:33 5/14/2016 19:33 5/14/2016 19:32 5/14/2016 19:30 5/14/2016 19:29 5/14/2016 19:29 5/14/2016 19:29 5/14/2016 19:27 5/14/2016 19:27 5/14/2016 19:26 5/14/2016 19:26 5/14/2016 19:23 5/14/2016 19:23 5/14/2016 19:23 5/14/2016 19:23 5/14/201619:22 5/14/2016 19:20 5/14/2016 19:20 5/14/2016 19:19 5/14/2016 19:18 5/14/2016 19:18 5/14/2016 19:18 5/14/201619:17 5/14/201619:16 5/14/2016 19:15 5/14/2016 19:15 5/14/2016 19:15 5/14/2016 19:14 5/14/2016 19:13 5/14/2016 19:13 5/14/2016 19:13 Page I 51 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p 1254 If it was like when !lived here in 1974 and you could have fires in the fire pits on the beach 1255 Free parking and beach free 1257 It is a good experience. 1258 More street parking near the train station. East of Garfield. Not parking lots near the beach. Accessibility parking near beach ok. 1259 Just got to San Diego two hours ago. 1260 A free hop on and off trolley to explore the city 1262 If the Coaster ran more frequently 1263 Parking structure 1264 Make the beach less car centric 1265 I noticed parking is hard to find coming in to town. Streets are narrow and you cant tell if people are turning or parked or what 1266 Easier to park here than other areas north of here. San Cemente. 1268 None 1269 N/A 1270 Not really 1271 Make tamarak parking free again. Keep it the way it is. Less development. 1273 Special lot for beach parking. 1274 Not enough parking for residents. Too many hotels taking up parking spots. 1275 No 1277 None 1278 Not from here so don't know 1279 More. Not enough sidewalks to encourge walking. 1280 Stop charging for the lots. Makes it more accessible. 1281 Nothing 1282 During tourist season, it is difficult to find parking. Resident wants parking access designated for locals and tourists. 1283 More parking. 1284 Property is outrageous they need multi level parking that provides parking within quarter mile or less 1285 Doesnt use bike racks. Thinks they are attractive to theives. 1286 Nothing 1288 Dedicated motorcycle parking 1289 None 1290 More bike rakes. 1291 None 1292 None firsttrip here 1293 More frequent bus services and more buses to go to the beach Kim ley>>> Horn 5/14/201619:11 5/14/2016 19:10 5/14/201619:10 5/14/2016 19:09 5/14/2016 19:09 5/14/2016 19:07 5/14/2016 19:06 5/14/2016 19:05 5/14/2016 19:04 5/14/2016 19:04 5/14/2016 19:04 5/14/2016 19:01 5/14/2016 19:00 5/14/2016 18:58 5/14/2016 18:58 5/14/2016 18:58 5/14/2016 18:57 5/14/2016 18:56 5/14/2016 18:55 5/14/2016 18:54 5/14/2016 18:54 5/14/2016 18:54 5/14/2016 18:54 5/14/2016 18:54 5/14/2016 18:53 5/14/2016 18:52 5/14/2016 18:52 5/14/2016 18:52 5/14/2016 18:50 5/14/2016 18:50 5/14/2016 18:48 5/14/2016 18:48 5/14/201618:47 5/14/201618:47 Page I 52 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA :J r ~or . ' L b D 1294 More parking, without a structure. 1295 Add parking garages. Free parking at coaster station could be turned into a parking garage. Or the parkimg at the Old fishouse parking area. Make this a 2 strory garage. 1296 N/A 1297 Mark parking spots along the beach on carlsbad blvd so the cars dont park in the wrong spaces. 1298 Dont come here often but i know it gets busy on the weekends. there is only so much space for parking 1299 No 1300 Shuttle bus to lots. 1302 Keep lots free! 1303 No big buildings in village 1304 More parking spaces 1305 It would be helpful to have signs for public parking 1306 Assign parking in front of homes of residents. 1308 Possibly more parking lots by the beach limited building height. Possibly more parking in the freeway. Native and familar with carlsbad 1309 Build parking lot for proposition A that was supposed to build a lot where there are strawberry fields. 1310 Parking is terrible in general. 1311 Nope 1312 More bus access and shuttles 1313 Not really 1314 None. First time visitor. 1315 Dont make it paid Kimley>>>Horn 5/14/201618:47 5/14/2016 18:46 5/14/2016 18:46 5/14/2016 18:45 5/14/2016 18:43 5/14/2016 18:43 5/14/2016 18:41 5/14/2016 18:41 5/14/2016 18:39 5/14/2016 18:38 5/14/2016 18:38 5/14/2016 18:38 5/14/2016 18:37 5/14/2016 18:37 5/14/2016 18:37 5/14/2016 18:34 5/14/2016 18:33 5/14/2016 18:33 5/14/2016 18:31 5/14/2016 18:31 Page I 53 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 OF c L D D IIII"'P What is your gender? Gender • Male • Female What is your home zip code? Home Zip Code • 92008 (Inside Study Area) • Other Kimley >>>Horn TOTAL= 857 TOTAL= 853 Page I 54 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA H What brings you here today? {Check all that apply) Beach Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event 4% 0% 1% 1% 1% 2% Visit the beach --~----.... 46% Visit a service business g~ Visit a professional business ) J~ Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kim ley>>> Horn 10% 13% 54% WEEKDAY TOTAL = 136 WEEKEND TOTAL= 473 • Weekday Weekend Page I 55 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0% Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kimley >>>Horn -IJ. ::J Village Locations 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 6% 2% 5% 0% 2% 0% 5% 15% 9% 11% 11% 14% 14% WEEKDAY TOTAl= 308 WEEKEND TOTAl= 152 • Weekday Weekend Page I 56 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA vF Work Dining Entertainment Shopping Special Event Visit the beach Visit a service business Visit a professional business Other recreation (resident-but not in Study Area) Other recreation/vacation (non-resident) I live in this neighborhood Visiting someone that lives in this neighborhood Other, please explain: Kim ley >>> Horn L 8 D Barri o Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 0% 6% 3% 1% 0% 0% 3% 6% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 1% 9% 33% 27% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 30 WEEKEND TOTAL= 67 • Weekday Weekend Page I 57 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA FO OF C D D Free responses to "Other, please explain:" Date Collected Health 6/25/2016 21:36 Hotel 6/25/2016 21:24 Bar 6/25/2016 20:43 Visit This Area Once A Month 6/25/2016 20:35 Hooka 6/25/2016 20:33 Bars 6/25/2016 20:32 Bars 6/25/2016 20:28 Bars 6/25/2016 20:28 Just To Hang Out In The Area 6/25/2016 20:27 Walking With Friends 6/25/2016 20:27 Walking Dog 6/25/2016 20:24 Going To A Bar 6/25/2016 20:15 Moving to San Diego 6/25/2016 20:14 Walking-shopping 6/25/2016 20:14 Live Music 6/25/2016 20:11 To hang out And Enjoy The Area 6/25/2016 20:10 Live Music 6/25/2016 20:02 Walking Dog 6/25/2016 19:56 Shopping, Walking Starbucks 6/25/2016 19:51 Exercising, Window Shopping 6/25/2016 19:33 Bar-live Music 6/25/2016 19:28 Starbucks 6/25/2016 19:23 Son Moved, Visiting Food 6/25/201619:15 Walking Dog 6/25/201619:14 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 21:27 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 21:25 Walk My Dogs 6/22/2016 21:23 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 21:22 Kimley>>>Horn Page I 58 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA c OF b D Farmers market 6/22/2016 21:13 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 21:07 Nightly Walk 6/22/2016 21:06 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 20:54 Work 6/22/2016 20:45 Farmers Market. 6/22/2016 20:45 Swimming Lessons 6/22/2016 20:36 Walking Dog 6/22/2016 20:35 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 20:33 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 20:28 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 20:22 Eating Dinner 6/22/2016 20:21 Sons Baseball 6/22/2016 20:18 Farmers Market 6/22/2016 20:17 Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 59 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OF f..LSb D How did you get here? Beach Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Drove alone in a car Drove with others (carpooled/vanpooled) Motorcycle I scooter Bicycle Public Transit (Bus/Train) Walked Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service Skateboard or other personal mobility device 1------~~----51% 23% 1% 0% 3% 4% 0% 0% 11% --· 13% 1% 1% 0% 0% 32% Dropped off O% I 1% Other, please explain: I ~~ Village Locations 57% WEEKDAY TOTAl= 115 WEEKEND TOTAl= 350 • Weekday •weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Drove alone in a car Drove with others (carpooled/vanpooled) Motorcycle I scooter Bicycle Public Transit (Bus/Train) Walked Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service Skateboard or other personal mobility device. Dropped off Other, please explain: Kim ley >>> Horn •--lls%--' 32% 15% 0% 0% 6% 2% 1 0% I 2% 0% 0% l 0% I 2% 1% 2% 11% 20% 48% 54% WEEKDAY TOTAl= 219 WEEKEND TOTAl= 104 •weekday • Weekend Page I 60 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Barrio Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Drove alone in a car Drove w ith others (carpooled/vanpooled) Motorcycle I scooter Bicycle Public Transit (Bus/Train) Walked Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service 0% 0% 3% 0% 0% 0% 0% Skateboard or other personal mobility device 1°% 2% Dropped off Other, please explain: 0% 0% 0% 0% 17% 21% 8% 29% 40% 41% 38% Free responses to "Other, please explain:" Date Collected Parked At Hotel, But Dont Use Car Because 6/25/2016 21:24 Its Easier To Walk Around. Were Big Transit People 6/25/2016 20:35 Parents Dropped Them Off. 6/25/2016 19:44 Farmers Market 6/22/201611:28 Drove My Golf Cart 6/18/2016 15:29 Renting A Condo Across The Street. 6/18/2016 14:04 At The Apartment Parking 6/15/2016 15:34 Site Seeing-We Are From Out Of Town 6/15/2016 14:05 Kimley >>>Horn WEEKDAY TOTAL = 29 WEEKEND TOTAL= 48 •weekday •weekend Page I 61 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Where did you park? Beach Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% On-street Parking Lot N/A Other, please specify: Village Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% 44% On-street Parking Lot N/A Other, please specify: Kim ley >>> Horn 80% 80% 90% 100% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 110 WEEKEND TOTAL= 326 90% 100% •weekday • Weekend WEEKDAY TOTAL= 207 WEEKEND TOTAL = 95 • Weekday • Weekend Page I 62 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 oc C LSBALI Barrio Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% On-street 0% Parking Lot 0% 0% N/A 8% 0% Other, please specify: 5% How long did it take you to find your parking spot? Beach Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% Less than 2 minutes 111111111111111111114~--~65% 46% 2-5 minutes 11% 23% 6-10 minutes 9% 11% 11-15 minutes More than 15 minutes 0% • 3% N/A 13% 14% Kim ley>>> Horn 80% 80% 90% 100% • Weekday • Weekend WEEKDAY TOTAl= 16 WEEKEND TOTAl= 39 90% 100% WEEKDAY TOTAl= 132 WEEKEND TOTAl= 326 •weekday •weekend Page I 63 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA oc: Village Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% Less than 2 minutes t=========::iiiiiiiiiiiii 57% 44% 2-5 minutes 24% 6 -10 minutes 11-15 minutes More than 15 minutes N/A 10% 21% Barrio Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 80% Less than 2 minutes ~~ .................................... 6.5o/c·o· 1• 74% 2-5 minutes 4% 5% 6-10 minutes 0% I 2% 11-15 minutes 0% 0% More than 15 minutes 0% I 2% N/A 16% 31% Kim ley>>> Horn 90% 100% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 204 WEEKEND TOTAL= 95 • Weekday • Weekend 90% 100% WEEKDAY TOTAL= 26 WEEKEND TOTAL= 43 •weekday • Weekend Page I 64 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ro or:c r. J o How close was this parking spot to your destination? Village Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Directly in front of or adjacent to my destination 1 block away from my destination 2 blocks away from my destination 3 blocks away from my destination 4 blocks away from my destination 5 blocks away from my destination 6 blocks or more from my destination N/A Directly in front of or adjacent to my destination 1 block away from my destination 2 blocks away from my destination 3 blocks away from my destination 4 blocks away from my destination •..... 28% 26% 29% 16% Beach Locations WEEKDAY TOTAl= 202 WEEKEND TOTAl= 95 •Weekday •weekend 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% •-----lr-3i6% _ __, 57% 36% 0% -8% WEEKDAY TOTAl= 105 WEEKEND TOTAl= 320 •weekday •weekend 5 blocks away from my destination I 3":; 6 blocks or more from my destination N/A Kim ley >>> Horn 0% • 3% 13% --14% Page I 65 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA CF Cl\hL D Barrio Locations 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Directly in front of or adjacent to my destination 1 block away from my destination 2 blocks away from my destination -O% 3 blocks away from my destination 1o~% 4 blocks away from my destination 5 blocks away from my destination 6 blocks or more from my destination 0% 0% 0% I 2% 0% 0% 7% N/A 0% ..... 16% Were you able to find a back rack or locker nearby your destination? • Yes • No N/A TOTAL= 530 WEEKDAY TOTAL= 26 WEEKEND TOTAL= 43 •weekday •weekend Kimley >>>Horn Page 1 66 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA " ,Q H! 0 L_. C Do you have any suggestions about how to improve the parking and/or t ra nsportation access here? # Free Responses to "Do you have any suggestions about how to improve parking and I or Date Collected transportation access here?" 1 Add some kind of public transportation during busy seasons like summer. 6/25/2016 21:54 2 Add more crosswalks to increase safety. 6/25/2016 21:48 3 Take away paid parking lot. 6/25/2016 21:45 Add Parking signs so people know where to park. 4 Increase the frequency of the Coaster and Surfliner trains. Not enough trains running. 6/25/2016 21:44 5 Add a shuttle going from downtown to the beaches, back and forth. 6/25/2016 21:39 6 Took coaster because i know parking is a problem. Dont know how to fix it though. 6/25/2016 21:37 7 Make the drop off area for passangers larger. Got dropped off recently and almost got hit when 6/25/2016 21:36 opening a door because the lanes were so narrow. 8 No. 6/25/2016 21:34 9 Really easy we had no problem 6/25/2016 21:33 10 Restrict RVs, they take up too much space. Also mark the street spots so that people dont park 6/25/2016 21:30 in a way that takes up too much space. 11 Its a problem, bullet train with side train, something like uban in germany, street satellite 6/25/2016 21:30 parking with transportation to village 12 Add a crosswalk to Tamrack and Carlsbad blvd. Its difficult to cross from the paid lot area. A real 6/25/2016 21:26 mess. 13 Not a problem for me, but i know it can be a problem finding a spot. 6/25/2016 21:26 14 Limit development 6/25/2016 21:26 15 Signs letting you know where to go for parking 6/25/2016 21:25 16 Nope 6/25/2016 21:24 17 None. 6/25/2016 21:23 18 Build a structure, but I don't know where 6/25/2016 21:23 19 Dk 6/25/2016 21:23 20 None 6/25/2016 21:22 21 Not sure. 6/25/2016 21:21 22 Its pretty good. There are just so many people what are you going to do 6/25/2016 21:21 23 Its great as is. Much better than normal beach cities. Free parking that we have is especially 6/25/2016 21:20 great. 24 Parking structure like they have in oceanside 6/25/2016 21:19 25 No, maybe more spots. lve never had a problem, but maybe its because i know where to park. 6/25/2016 21:19 26 No 6/25/2016 21:17 27 The parking is good, no problems. 6/25/2016 21:17 28 Not really you just have to be patient 6/25/2016 21:15 Kimley >>>Horn Page I 67 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p~ H tl CF CARL 6 D 29 Maybe less timed parking, because a lot of the spaces are reserved so its hard to find free parking. 30 No the transit station helps a lot 31 No 32 Turn power plant into a parking structure. 33 Carlsbad is better than most other beaches 34 Parking lot and shuttle underground parking structure 35 Making the public transit more efficient, im from the east coast and the wait time between trains is huge and i think thats what keeps people from using transit, a huge amount of people probably would use transit if it didnt take so long 36 Not enough 37 Underground parking. 38 Dk 39 More public parking. 40 Keep spces without time limits 41 Light rail to go down to pier or micxed transit 42 None 43 72 hour parking is great but a lot of people dont know that it is there 44 Maybe the city could charge for parking so people who live close by could use other means 45 Make parking lot free. Enforce parking. 46 Dk 47 None 48 More public parking lots available. lve had some other days were we have struggled finding parking, but today we were lucky. 49 No suggestions so Add more parking and make parking free. 51 Seem 52 No, not really. 53 Add shaded area close to the beach. Add more parking. 54 Put it down by the end of the beach , i feel like if there is one right on the beach it will "blemish" the city 55 Weekends are busy 56 Sync the lights 57 Underground parking, and section for dogs 58 Weekdays its fine. Weekend is a bit more hard but youll find a spot eventually. 59 Too many hotels Kimley>>>Horn 6/25/2016 21:14 6/25/2016 21:14 6/25/2016 21:13 6/25/2016 21:12 6/25/2016 21:12 6/25/2016 21:12 6/25/2016 21:11 6/25/2016 21:10 6/25/2016 21:10 6/25/2016 21:09 6/25/2016 21:07 6/25/2016 21:06 6/25/2016 21:06 6/25/2016 21:06 6/25/2016 21:05 6/25/2016 21:04 6/25/2016 21:04 6/25/2016 21:04 6/25/2016 21:03 6/25/2016 21:01 6/25/2016 21:00 6/25/2016 21:00 6/25/2016 20:58 6/25/2016 20:58 6/25/2016 20:57 6/25/2016 20:56 6/25/2016 20:56 6/25/2016 20:52 6/25/2016 20:50 6/25/2016 20:49 6/25/2016 20:48 Page I 68 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p,...p -5 ) ro OFC1-Rl~ 0 60 1 hour is to short. Dont put the meters because it would be scam. 61 Some kind of shuttles from a parking far from here 62 No handicap near the visit 63 No its pretty easy to get to. 64 As a resident i think theresa problem, fortunately i can walk. Maybe a structure in the trolley station could help the parking availability 65 More lots 66 Need more parking available to us especially on the weekd 67 Add more parking. 68 Add a structure. Too many people and not enough spaces. 69 No but people should be encouraged to take transit more 70 More parking 71 Have a physical barrier on the steet to seperate bike lane from street lanes, making it more safe for bikers. Add Peak rack for bikes. 72 Nothing 73 Its generally okay pretty bad if you have an apartment without guest spots on the weekend but not really a suggestion 74 None. 75 More signs to show that there is public parking 76 There could be more 77 The streets are wide enough to have parking on the streets, but there wasnt much by the beach. So increase side parking. 78 Its hit or miss if its the weekend it can take some time but theres always uber or lyft, i drove because im picking someone up soon 79 Its good here 80 None. 81 Nope-i think it is good 82 We parked at the station i dont think the res a big issue though 83 Charge more for parking. Dont charge parking on streets. No RV parking allowed. 84 Hard to say. Underground parking 85 Its too good here. No suggestions. 86 Wished the locals had a pass or got extended time to park 87 None. Kimley >>>Horn 6/25/2016 20:43 6/25/2016 20:43 6/25/2016 20:40 6/25/2016 20:40 6/25/2016 20:39 6/25/2016 20:39 6/25/2016 20:38 6/25/2016 20:37 6/25/2016 20:35 6/25/2016 20:35 6/25/2016 20:34 6/25/2016 20:34 6/25/2016 20:33 6/25/2016 20:32 6/25/2016 20:31 6/25/2016 20:31 6/25/2016 20:30 6/25/2016 20:29 6/25/2016 20:28 6/25/2016 20:28 6/25/2016 20:28 6/25/2016 20:27 6/25/2016 20:27 6/25/2016 20:26 6/25/2016 20:26 6/25/2016 20:25 6/25/2016 20:25 6/25/2016 20:24 Page I 69 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA c 0 L 6AD 88 Theres been talk of a dog park in this area and the argument is that there would be a need for parking but anyone living here would benefit from having a dog park and would likely walk their dog to the park so i think the local community would support a park without parking 89 Have traffic cop go around and determine how many spots there are, what spots are open and get the info out 90 None 91 Dont like the parking bacause of the towing in this parking lot (village fa ire) across street from transit station. People come to listen to music and have a good time and get towed. 92 Not big of a problem. 93 No 94 Nothing comes to mind. In order to mke more parking, youd have to tear something down 95 Local map of where parking is. New to area and i see the "p" signs but it isnt always obvious where the lot is 96 Make parking lot bigger, dont care if i have to pay for it. 97 Parking is a big problem. Transportation is terrible here and in california 98 None 99 No it seems normal 100 Add more parking if you can, the beach is always busy so i understand if theres no pat king. 101 Small parking garage or underground parking 102 No suggestions. Carlsbad is ,uch better than other beaches. 103 Nothing i can think of 104 Horrible, because it is summer 105 Add more parking next to coaster station. 106 Underground structure 107 No suggestions. 108 Underground parking 109 Have more available 110 Its fine here. No comment. 111 Put an ugly parking garage 112 Connect the rail trail to the lagoon. Add crosswalk to the lagoon by Tamrack, dangerous for pedestrians to be around. 113 A parking structure in the transit station would be really beneficial to the area and then the could put in more bike lanes 114 No unless you build underground or structures where are you going to park 115 Add more parking on empty street space, add paid parking on street. 116 More parking. Underground structure 117 118 None Kim ley >>> Horn 6/25/2016 20:24 6/25/2016 20:23 6/25/2016 20:23 6/25/2016 20:22 6/25/2016 20:18 6/25/2016 20:18 6/25/2016 20:18 6/25/2016 20:17 6/25/2016 20:17 6/25/2016 20:15 6/25/2016 20:14 6/25/2016 20:14 6/25/2016 20:13 6/25/2016 20:12 6/25/2016 20:12 6/25/2016 20:11 6/25/2016 20:10 6/25/2016 20:09 6/25/2016 20:09 6/25/2016 20:08 6/25/2016 20:06 6/25/2016 20:06 6/25/2016 20:05 6/25/2016 20:04 6/25/2016 20:02 6/25/2016 20:02 6/25/2016 20:02 6/25/2016 20:01 6/25/2016 20:00 6/25/2016 19:59 6/25/2016 19:59 Page I 70 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I '-1 I 0 Cl\f,LSbAD 119 Add a lot 120 Get rid of tourists 121 Its pretty bad around the corner, over here its okay 122 Parking structure off the beach. 123 Parking garage -but noone wants that, make parking t free -that wont happen, shuttles-but i hate shuttles 124 Unrestricted parking 125 NA 126 127 Diagonal spots 128 Dont know its summer right now. 129 Add parking structure next to the coaster station. 130 It seems fine now( 4:30pm) an hour ago it was pretty bad so i guess its just the time of day 131 Widen the walkways around the powerplant for pedestrians. 132 Did not answer 133 More parking. 134 Not too many vehicles 135 More dedicated lots to parking, more inland parking, less coastal 136 Its the crosswalks that take too long at this intersection 137 Make parking lot bigger. 138 No garage 139 Improve public transportation 140 I thought itd be pretty bad because its a beach town but it wasnt bad at all i cant say i have any suggestions 141 More lots 142 No parking meters. Increase enforcement of red curb parking. Too many cars parking in illegal spots, but not enough enforcers. 143 Parking structure double decker especially needed for summer 144 Keep up with the master plan. Love the roundabout at tamarack 145 More parking, puts garage. Lots are too cramped. 146 Never really had problems parking in the area 147 No idea 148 Parking is okay, I lucked out with front row but it usually takes me a couple minutes on the street 149 None. 150 So much better then anywhere else 151 Yes build a parking lot & have the city build it & charge for it. 152 Build up so first floor is a garage Kim ley >>> Horn 6/25/2016 19:59 6/25/2016 19:56 6/25/2016 19:56 6/25/2016 19:56 6/25/2016 19:56 6/25/2016 19:55 6/25/2016 19:55 6/25/2016 19:54 6/25/2016 19:54 6/25/2016 19:53 6/25/2016 19:51 6/25/2016 19:51 6/25/2016 19:51 6/25/2016 19:50 6/25/2016 19:50 6/25/2016 19:50 6/25/2016 19:49 6/25/2016 19:48 6/25/201619:47 6/25/201619:47 6/25/2016 19:46 6/25/2016 19:46 6/25/2016 19:46 6/25/2016 19:45 6/25/2016 19:45 6/25/2016 19:45 6/25/2016 19:44 6/25/2016 19:44 6/25/2016 19:44 6/25/2016 19:43 6/25/2016 19:43 6/25/2016 19:43 6/25/2016 19:42 6/25/2016 19:42 Page I 71 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA HE 0 R D 153 Add more parking next to the train station. 154 I come to visit every summer today i got lucky with parking but it is usually packed during weekends and a structure would be helpful 155 Transportation is good-rail. Unless they build a structure which noone wants because its an eyesore. They need more public parking 156 Add a little trolley or shuttle with an offsite parking structure. 157 Add more parking. 158 Need more parking lots 159 More lots 160 No problem. 161 Parking garage 162 Make parking free. 163 N/A 164 No idea. Maybe a parking structure, but thats unsghtly. 165 NA 166 No meters, no permits 167 I chose to park far for exercise and think people should do that instead, theyre walking around and shopping anyway so you might as well get exercise 168 No idea. 169 None 170 Increase Parking enforcement people are parking in red. 171 Saw spots that are in between driveway that are too small 172 No suggestions 173 None 174 Cant really think of anything 175 When i visit i find a spot so its not too bad 176 Less permits 177 None 178 Visiting. Parking took a little while but must be because of the beach 179 Parking is pretty easy except I have a large truck so finding a big enough one is somewhat difficult on busy days but i bought my truck knowing thats a consequence. As a resident the parking isnt bad in my opinion 180 No 181 Inform visitors where to park. 182 I live here i always skateboard around town 183 No problem. 184 Free hot air balloon rides. 185 Compact and i dony think people would like parking structures Kimley >>>Horn 6/25/2016 19:42 6/25/2016 19:41 6/25/2016 19:40 6/25/2016 19:39 6/25/2016 19:39 6/25/2016 19:37 6/25/2016 19:37 6/25/2016 19:37 6/25/2016 19:36 6/25/2016 19:36 6/25/2016 19:36 6/25/2016 19:36 6/25/2016 19:35 6/25/2016 19:35 6/25/2016 19:33 6/25/2016 19:33 6/25/2016 19:32 6/25/2016 19:32 6/25/2016 19:31 6/25/2016 19:31 6/25/2016 19:30 6/25/2016 19:30 6/25/2016 19:30 6/25/201619:29 6/25/2016 19:29 6/25/2016 19:28 6/25/2016 19:28 6/25/2016 19:27 6/25/2016 19:26 6/25/2016 19:25 6/25/2016 19:25 6/25/2016 19:24 6/25/201619:24 Page I 72 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA f.l C/1 OF CAR SDAD 186 Usually get dropped off at the beach because of the poor parking 187 NA 188 Parking isnt too bad on the street and because of the transit station the overflow typically goes there. Maybe a parking structure at the station could take away some street parking and close off some parking spots to create a green area where people could have picnics and sit on the grass for outdoor movies 189 No suggestions-visiting from out of town and chose this place because she can take train to downtown san diego 190 No 191 NA 192 193 Slight parking on weekends and during the week too they should add a stucture by the beach 194 They have as many bike racks that a person could want 195 Trolley or vehicle to take people from far off parking lot 196 197 Not really. 198 Love carlsbad 199 This specific area is always packed but parking is usually tough during weekends regardless 200 No not my area of expertise. Its a beach city and it is crowded and that is how it is 201 Typically during the summer it takes 7-10 minutes to find a spot, its not too terrible but the weekends and summer make it difficult 202 Theres only so much space around. I dont think the res much you can do. 203 No 204 More parking structures 205 No 206 None 207 No suggestions. 208 NA 209 Stop building houses, condos, and townhomes in carlsbad to increase parking and not try to attract more people. Dont need more people. 210 Parking garage by the train station. Add more outside seating, even if it takes away parking. 211 Bigger parking structures 212 I work in thw city and park blocks away from my building and walk because the parking is horrible they need a structure or lot for all of the tourist and non residents 213 Stop letting the restaurants spill out and leave room for more parking. 214 NA 215 Have a private lot so not a problem. More bike parking is needed. 216 Have not had any trouble finding parking here. Kimley >>>Horn 6/25/2016 19:24 6/25/2016 19:23 6/25/2016 19:23 6/25/2016 19:22 6/25/2016 19:22 6/25/2016 19:22 6/25/2016 19:21 6/25/2016 19:20 6/25/2016 19:20 6/25/2016 19:20 6/25/2016 19:19 6/25/2016 19:19 6/25/201619:16 6/25/201619:16 6/25/201619:15 6/25/2016 19:14 6/25/201619:14 6/25/2016 19:13 6/22/2016 21:30 6/22/2016 21:30 6/22/2016 21:29 6/22/2016 21:28 6/22/2016 21:27 6/22/2016 21:27 6/22/2016 21:25 6/22/2016 21:24 6/22/2016 21:23 6/22/2016 21:22 6/22/2016 21:21 6/22/2016 21:20 6/22/2016 21:19 Page I 73 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA rtr OF c kL Me, 217 I dont have a problem parking because i have my parking spot. 218 N/A 219 Add more parking, but dont know how. 220 There's going to be a problem once they build the apartment complex down the street. 221 Its pretty easy and going good. No suggestions. 222 No promblem with parking. 223 Strucures maybe. No paid parking though. 224 Have more parking 225 Less restrictions in certain areas 226 NA i am carless and walk just about everywhere 227 Use business parking lots that are closed on the weekends as open lots for extra parking. 228 NA 229 Parking is so easy here. Compared to her home area, we are very generous. 230 NA 231 People shouldn't use the car, should use more bikes. 232 NA 233 N/A 234 Seems fine 235 NA 236 Make new lots somewhere. 237 Na 238 Parking is fine. 239 Normally there is plenty of bike parking spaces. 240 NA 241 I think there no parking problem. 242 NA 243 Always uber to the beach cause parking is limited. A structure would be helpful with so many visitors here 244 NA 245 More parking spaces needed. Didnt see many handicap parking spots. 246 Parking structure, not by the beach ( more bars by the beach)ut it by train station) . In ugly part of town north or trainstation. 247 SHavent moved my car since ive been here. I have walked everywhere. 248 Free parking spots 249 The parking isnt helpful cause its only 1-3 hour parking wish they were longer 250 Biking facilities are really good here. Would like more information to be more aware of underground parking. 251 Not at the moment. Kim ley >>> Horn 6/22/2016 21:17 6/22/2016 21:16 6/22/2016 21:15 6/22/2016 21:15 6/22/2016 21:15 6/22/2016 21:13 6/22/2016 21:13 6/22/2016 21:09 6/22/2016 21:07 6/22/2016 21:06 6/22/2016 21:05 6/22/2016 21:02 6/22/2016 21:01 6/22/2016 20:59 6/22/2016 20:58 6/22/2016 20:57 6/22/2016 20:57 6/22/2016 20:55 6/22/2016 20:55 6/22/2016 20:54 6/22/2016 20:53 6/22/2016 20:50 6/22/2016 20:50 6/22/2016 20:50 6/22/2016 20:50 6/22/2016 20:48 6/22/2016 20:46 6/22/2016 20:45 6/22/2016 20:45 6/22/2016 20:44 6/22/2016 20:42 6/22/2016 20:41 6/22/2016 20:40 6/22/2016 20:38 6/22/2016 20:36 Page I 74 {City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PA IG StUD ro OF C RL_O. D 252 Seems good this time of year so no suggestions. 253 None 254 Bus route with its own lane would be nice for the kids 255 More signs indicating which lots are open. Maps or a flier of all parking spots either in the area or online web page. New to the area, would be helpful to have more direction. Have left the area because i wasnt able to find parking. 256 No suggestions 257 High rise parking 258 Not from here 259 Increase bike racks. Add a bike lot somewhere. The lot on tamarack used to be free but now we have to pay. Dont like the restrictions on parking near the beach. More free parking and less restrictions on parking near the beach. 260 Dont let carlsbad get too big 261 More stalls 262 No problems 263 Build bridges or underpasses for the train. 264 More parking structures 265 No problems. No meters 266 More parking structures 267 The parking is easy here, sometimes crowded because of games but not too bad, I can always find a spot 268 Nothing you can do, the res no room unless you tear a few buildings down. 269 None. 270 Nothing I can think of 271 No suggestions. 272 None. Parking is good 273 Not from the area. Don't know 274 No suggestions. 275 More parking structures. 276 Close off grand to carlsbad. Pedestrial only, garage off roosevelt. Redevelpe around train station. ,Quieter train crossing, its too loud. Employ Advanced signalling systems. Enforce parking codes. 277 Better sign age 278 Not that I can think of 279 More street parking. Underground parking? Maybe a garage? 280 None. Parking seems fine. 281 Local trolley service. More lots, unrestricted, and free. 282 Its been easy to find parking for us. Kimley >>>Horn 6/22/2016 20:35 6/22/2016 20:35 6/22/2016 20:35 6/22/2016 20:33 6/22/2016 20:33 6/22/2016 20:30 6/22/2016 20:29 6/22/2016 20:28 6/22/2016 20:27 6/22/2016 20:26 6/22/2016 20:24 6/22/2016 20:22 6/22/2016 20:21 6/22/2016 20:20 6/22/2016 20:18 6/22/2016 20:18 6/22/2016 20:17 6/22/2016 20:15 6/22/2016 20:15 6/22/2016 20:12 6/22/2016 20:12 6/22/2016 20:10 6/22/2016 20:10 6/22/2016 20:08 6/22/2016 20:07 6/22/2016 20:06 6/22/2016 20:06 6/22/2016 20:03 6/22/2016 20:03 6/22/2016 20:01 6/22/2016 20:01 Page I 75 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA R ... I OF AnL D 283 Parking spaces are really small 284 Parking structure or something, trouble for friends that visit 285 Nothing you can do 286 Likes the bike trails, make more 287 Shuttles and parking garages 288 Its nice that you dont have to pay for parking. Gives us more options. 289 Passes to buy I for lots especially near the beach. 290 Shuttle, underground parking 291 Never really have a problem parking here. Would rather have a hard time parking than have a large parking structure that pulls visitors in. 292 NA 293 Bike lanes have made a difference on parking. Theyve made it worse. 294 Seems fine. No problems. 295 No parking on wednesdays so we walk Barley parking suggested parking structure . 296 Dont usually have trouble dindinf a parking spot. Having a two or three story parking lot would improve parking further out east. 297 Happy parking is free. Please keep it free. 298 Parking structure, maybe put it in the construction it's been going on forever 299 Na 300 Not really. 301 No problem. 302 More parking at the beach. Keep lots free. 303 More signage for public parking. 304 More parking lots 305 The City is doing a great job with parking. We should take these spots on state street and turn this street into a walking only area. 306 Really easy or maybe got lucky 307 Lucked out today, but parking is normally worse. No suggestions. 308 Build a garage 309 Create available Parking behind businesses, never in the street 310 None. 311 Reevaluate red curbs (do they all make sense?) 312 Parking garage 313 Youve done a lot to increase visibility of parking, keep doing that. 314 Open up lots for small business to public on rush hours or busy times. 315 Strucure near the beach to accommodate more cars. 316 Require underground parking for condos, nothing over 2 stories. 317 None. We usually ride our bikes everywhere and its been great. Kimley >>>Horn 6/22/2016 19:59 6/22/2016 19:59 6/22/2016 19:59 6/22/2016 19:58 6/22/2016 19:58 6/22/2016 19:57 6/22/2016 19:57 6/22/2016 19:55 6/22/2016 19:54 6/22/2016 19:53 6/22/2016 19:53 6/22/2016 19:52 6/22/2016 19:51 6/22/2016 19:50 6/22/2016 19:49 6/22/2016 19:49 6/22/2016 19:47 6/22/2016 19:47 6/22/2016 19:46 6/22/2016 19:45 6/22/2016 19:44 6/22/2016 19:42 6/22/2016 19:41 6/22/2016 19:40 6/22/2016 19:38 6/22/2016 19:37 6/22/201619:36 6/22/2016 19:36 6/22/2016 19:36 6/22/2016 19:35 6/22/2016 19:35 6/22/2016 19:34 6/22/2016 19:33 6/22/2016 19:32 6/22/2016 19:32 Page I 76 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 5 Y ro AD 318 Add more beach access parking. The lots were kimds of hard to get in and out of. 319 Add a parking structure near the train. 320 More public transportation 321 NA 322 Underground parking garage 323 We have been coming here from Oceanside for 10 years now and never really had a problem with parking. 324 NA 325 I live here so i walk everywhere but seems like the streets are always flooded and no parking 326 No problems 327 More city lots. Either 4-hours free or free with validation. 328 No, this was perfect! 329 Have more parking that lastsover 3 hours. 330 Dont have an issue. Coaster would be cheaper. 331 More open parking lots 332 Parking will just be a problem this time of year. Not sure if you can really do anything about it. 333 Very much needed during dum mer with all thr tourists. Extend parking to the east or have rickshaws or buses drive people into the Village or the beach. no high-rise parking. Dont restrict time limits or increase time limits. Have the City ticket people who stay in timed spots for longer than the limited time (1 hour or 3 hour etc.) because people are not currently being ticketed. 334 No issues. No permits or structures 335 Usually take my bike when i go to the beach because of limited parking 336 Impressed. It has been a lot easier than i thought it would be. 337 Make room for more parking. 338 No issues parking at all. 339 Really tough finding parking we parked in a neighborhood far from the beach . It is always really packed here so we are use to parking far 340 No 341 Parking is fine today, but during games or practice i have to park a block away from home. 342 Make more public lots. 343 Parking Garage 344 NA 345 N/A 346 Wants more parking lots. No structures. 347 More bike routes in this area, they seem discontinuous-better paved bike lanes-sometimes the library has parking congestion Kim ley >>> Horn 6/22/2016 19:31 6/22/201619:29 6/22/2016 19:29 6/22/2016 19:29 6/22/2016 19:29 6/22/201619:28 6/22/2016 19:27 6/22/2016 19:26 6/22/2016 19:25 6/22/2016 19:24 6/22/2016 19:24 6/22/2016 19:22 6/22/2016 19:22 6/22/2016 19:22 6/22/2016 19:22 6/22/2016 19:21 6/22/2016 19:21 6/22/2016 19:20 6/22/2016 19:19 6/22/2016 19:19 6/22/2016 19:19 6/22/201619:18 6/22/201619:18 6/22/2016 19:18 6/22/201619:17 6/22/201619:16 6/22/201619:15 6/22/2016 19:14 6/22/2016 19:14 6/22/2016 19:14 Page I 77 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OFCARL_B D 348 None 349 None 350 Parking deck would be helpful especially during the 351 None parking is fine. 352 No problems. 353 Parking Deck 354 Increase time limits so that there are more spaces to park and you dont have to move your car every hour. 355 NA 356 Specific psrking for farmers market 357 Not too sure, im not familiar with the carlsbad area. 358 Parking strucures. No meters 359 More public lots 360 Never had a problem parking here. 361 I am not from here but we found parking quickly 362 Parking is awful im the afternoon. (Gave her a card if she thinks of anything.) 363 Make more visible signs to direct to parking lots. 364 Free shuttle service, from off location parking lot 365 No suggestions. There is a problem but domt know where to put structure. Get rid of time limit on parking spaces. 366 No I love the way the City of Carlsbad is doing everything 367 During the week parking is okay, its during the weekend that the streets are flooded with people parking and us as residents a rent even able to enjoy the beach because we want to avoid the bad parking 368 Parking is fine 369 Large Parking structure with Solar Panels 370 Do not build any structures parking should be for residents and we are unable to park because so many tourist come and take up parking spaces. I am a resident and cant even park 371 N/A 372 She has just learnd to get there early. 373 No suggestions, bike parking was easy. Keep doing what we're doing. 374 No i think parking is great. Better public transportation. 375 No suggestions 376 More parking spots 377 Parking is good today. 378 More lots in the downtown area. 379 NA usually walk everywhere Kim ley >>> Horn 6/22/201619:14 6/22/2016 19:13 6/22/201619:13 6/22/201619:12 6/22/2016 19:11 6/22/201619:10 6/22/2016 19:09 6/22/2016 19:09 6/22/2016 19:07 6/22/2016 19:07 6/22/2016 19:07 6/22/2016 19:06 6/22/2016 19:04 6/22/2016 19:04 6/22/2016 19:04 6/22/2016 19:04 6/22/2016 19:03 6/22/2016 19:02 6/22/2016 19:01 6/22/2016 19:01 6/22/2016 18:59 6/22/2016 18:59 6/22/2016 18:58 6/22/2016 18:58 6/22/201618:58 6/22/2016 18:56 6/22/2016 18:56 6/22/2016 18:56 6/22/2016 18:55 6/22/2016 18:55 6/22/2016 18:55 6/22/2016 18:54 Page I 78 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ,. f' l I Oil H 17 OF C f..L ___ D 380 N/A 381 Nothing really 382 No suggestions, parking was great! 383 More lots 384 Parking is very limited would help for a structure or lot in the summer 385 Parking here is fine 386 More parking for trucks 387 I dont know since i dont live here and im just visitng. 388 Block off another street to create more parking. 389 Busy during weekends parking is horrible 390 NA 391 Tell the trains not to honk so loud. 392 No problem at all. 393 Dont charge for parking close to the beach 394 Let residents buy parking passes, not tourists. That lot is $10 a day and that's steep. It should be for all the beaches. 395 Promote the parking areas available. 396 None 397 Add parking garages. 398 Build a tall parking lot to help cars find spots. The paid parking lot at Tamrack doesnt work. 399 No 400 No 401 This is our first time here and it has been very easy so far. 402 I dont feel the res a parking problem 403 More lots but how do you do it? 404 No problems 405 Add shuttles or build a parking structure. 406 Add more parking. Impossible to find parking. Even paid is hard to find. 407 Make underground parking. 408 None. 409 I heard that you are working on this intersection, adding cross walks and widening it on the beach side. I think those are all good ideas. Otherwise, it's all pretty good. 410 Get more parking spots. 411 Keep lots free. Turn tamarack back to a free lot. 412 No meters 413 Mark the parking spaces so that people don't take more than one spot. 414 Not really 415 No parking srtructures. Kimley >>>Horn 6/22/2016 18:53 6/22/2016 18:53 6/22/2016 18:53 6/22/2016 18:53 6/22/2016 18:52 6/22/2016 18:52 6/22/2016 18:51 6/22/2016 18:51 6/22/2016 18:50 6/22/2016 18:50 6/22/2016 18:48 6/22/2016 18:45 6/22/2016 18:43 6/22/2016 18:41 6/18/2016 16:52 6/18/2016 16:51 6/18/2016 16:50 6/18/2016 16:48 6/18/2016 16:44 6/18/2016 16:43 6/18/2016 16:40 6/18/2016 16:39 6/18/2016 16:38 6/18/2016 16:38 6/18/2016 16:38 6/18/2016 16:38 6/18/2016 16:36 6/18/2016 16:36 6/18/2016 16:35 6/18/2016 16:33 6/18/2016 16:32 6/18/2016 16:32 6/18/2016 16:31 6/18/2016 16:29 6/18/201616:29 6/18/2016 16:28 Page I 79 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I NG STUD. OR 416 No meters 417 Stop tourism 418 Paint street to mark parking 419 None 420 NA 421 Carpool or ride a bike. 422 Enforce the oversight vehicle parking. 423 I hate that that is a pay lot now. 424 Less tourists, bigger lots inland 425 Undergroumd parking 426 N/A it's been smooth 427 Knock down buildings. There's no land. No place to go. You need a parking structure somewhere. 428 Stop charging people millions of dollars for parking. 429 Create more spaces somehow. 430 Parking garage 431 Keep people off beach and allow dog on entire beach. 432 No problems 433 N/A 434 I think parking should be free for residents if the city 435 The parking and traffic is awful. Hopefully they come up with somethinh 436 Create more parking somewhere. He comes early to get good spots. 437 No problems 438 Build another lot. 439 No. Everything is fine 440 Keep small towm vi be 441 Parking lots for free parking 442 None. 443 Turn tamarck park back to a free lot. 444 Obviously we need more but I don't have any suggestions 445 Less red curbs. More availability 446 N/A 447 Better signage. Mark the signs on the main streets to direct people to lots. 448 Public parking structure 449 Not letting the big RVs park and take up multiple spaces. It would be really great if there was parking inland with shuttles dropping people off around the beach 450 None 451 N/A Kimley >>>Horn 6/18/2016 16:27 6/18/2016 16:26 6/18/2016 16:25 6/18/2016 16:24 6/18/2016 16:24 6/18/2016 16:24 6/18/2016 16:23 6/18/2016 16:23 6/18/2016 16:21 6/18/2016 16:20 6/18/2016 16:20 6/18/2016 16:20 6/18/201616:18 6/18/201616:18 6/18/2016 16:18 6/18/201616:17 6/18/201616:16 6/18/2016 16:16 6/18/201616:16 6/18/2016 16:14 6/18/2016 16:14 6/18/2016 16:13 6/18/201616:13 6/18/201616:13 6/18/2016 16:12 6/18/201616:10 6/18/201616:10 6/18/2016 16:08 6/18/2016 16:06 6/18/2016 16:04 6/18/2016 16:04 6/18/2016 16:02 6/18/2016 16:02 6/18/2016 15:59 6/18/2016 15:59 6/18/2016 15:57 Page I 80 (_City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA n NC S uu 0 452 RVs need a time limit. They take up too many saces. 453 Parking garage 454 No parking issues today because there are no games in chase field. 455 I think it's a shame that they started charging to park down here. 456 N/A 457 Build Parking structures. 458 Need more parking but there is no more space downtown. We need more public lots. 459 More parking spots on the other side of the road 460 It's always going to be crowded in the summer. It's nice that there is parking on the side streets and you don't have to pay. No metered parking. We don't to be like Del Mar. 461 Keep free parking. 462 463 They need more street parking or maybe a big lot 464 465 It all seems to be pretty easy when they visit. 466 Shuttle from a parking lot located more inland. 467 No 468 I like how Carlsbad operates, like putting up signs not to feed the animals with three reasons why. They treat people with respect I think. 469 Angled parking. 470 Build a garage, not on the beach 471 No. 472 No problems 473 I don't want more paid parking lots. The street we parked on wasn't paved. It was rocks. But they don't own it. 474 Add crosswalk by the lagoon. Widen the sidewalks at the beach by powerplant. 475 More parking lots 476 Don't meter it. 477 No 478 No 479 There is no parking 480 No more development 481 Get rid of all these people 482 Add shuttles to the beaches. 483 Opening a free lot thats huge. More street parking parking 484 No Kimley >>>Horn 6/18/2016 15:57 6/18/2016 15:56 6/18/2016 15:55 6/18/2016 15:55 6/18/2016 15:54 6/18/201615:53 6/18/2016 15:52 6/18/2016 15:50 6/18/2016 15:48 6/18/201615:47 6/18/2016 15:46 6/18/2016 15:45 6/18/2016 15:45 6/18/2016 15:44 6/18/2016 15:44 6/18/2016 15:42 6/18/2016 15:41 6/18/2016 15:37 6/18/2016 15:37 6/18/2016 15:36 6/18/2016 15:32 6/18/2016 15:31 6/18/2016 15:31 6/18/2016 15:29 6/18/2016 15:29 6/18/2016 15:27 6/18/2016 15:26 6/18/2016 15:25 6/18/2016 15:25 6/18/2016 15:23 6/18/2016 15:23 6/18/2016 15:23 6/18/2016 15:22 Page I 81 {City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I . D OR THt. 48S We came to this beach because the beach across from our hotel was hard to access. There are no stairs. But the shuttle dropped us off right here. So it's fine 486 Always been fine for them 487 Add a city parking lot. 488 None 489 There needs to be crosswalk here to the bus stop 490 ldk. We we rent clear on where we were allowed to park, less ppl. 491 This intersection is a issue. I know the city is working on it. I'd love to see this be a crisscross like Carlsbad blvd & Grand or Carlsbad blvd and Carlsbad Village. There is no crosswalk to the bus stop. You can't safely get to the parking lot. We need a crosswalk there. Sometimes drivers don't see this light (the accessing the parking lot) and I am constantly grabbing kids so they don't get hit. Maybe make it slower. I'm all about safety. People do park on our street. We live a block away. And we don't get bummed about that. It' part of living at the beach. We love our city and enjoy the improvements and look forward to more. 492 Maybe parking garage 493 ldk. 494 None. 49S Make more parking if you can find the room. 496 Lower the cost of parking passes at the beach or make them free. 497 A parking lot that will be helpful! when basball games take place. 498 Didn't notice anything wrong 499 Improve public transport availability. soo Tear down old houses on carlsbad village drive. Buy and nake multi level garage. S01 Noticed lots of red curbs by the beach. S02 Bigger parking lots S03 Other a parking gararge, no, the parking here is usually good, ppl are just lazy to walk ,ore than two or three blocks S04 There's no space sos Add more parking spaces. S06 More parking lots S07 Create more parking spots. S08 None. S09 Not from here SlO Possibly another small lot S11 No mall. No parking strucures it js underground. S12 Parking isok i do not have any problems Kimley >>>Horn 6/18/2016 1S:21 6/18/2016 1S:20 6/18/2016 1S:18 6/18/20161S:17 6/18/20161S:16 6/18/20161S:1S 6/18/2016 1S:1S 6/18/20161S:14 6/18/20161S:11 6/18/20161S:10 6/18/2016 1S:09 6/18/2016 1S:08 6/18/2016 1S:07 6/18/2016 1S:07 6/18/2016 1S:06 6/18/2016 1S:OS 6/18/2016 1S:OS 6/18/2016 1S:03 6/18/2016 1S:02 6/18/2016 1S:01 6/18/2016 1S:01 6/18/2016 1S:OO 6/18/2016 1S:OO 6/18/2016 14:S8 6/18/2016 14:S8 6/18/2016 14:S8 6/18/2016 14:S7 6/18/2016 14:S7 Page I 82 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA UL.f 0 513 I bike everywhere and we ALWAYS find bike racks available 514 I grew up in Orange County. I like it better here. I have a State park pass so I park here all the time. 515 Add a trolley. North County is the forgotten child, the trolley goes eveywhere but here. 516 Maximize the spots on chesnut ave by making parallel just like they have in solana beach. Other than that parking next to baseball fie I is really nice 517 Increase trains to downtown so more frequency. Parking, there's no space. Lots inland with public transportation to the beach. 518 Keep parking free and don't put in meters. S19 More lots, less timesd parking. 520 None. 521 Need more parking in the village. 522 No problems, garage will brimg too many tourists 523 I always have pretty good luck so I've got nothing. 524 None 525 Put in more pay to park lots and lower the prices so it's affordable and people actually use them. 526 Underground and multitiered lots in the downtown area would conserve space and provide needed parking. It would be great if it could be free but we can't have everything. 527 None. 528 Keep lots free. 529 The apartment complexes take all the parking on the street 530 Its not too bad if you pay for parking, theres lots by the railroad that are available, you just have to know whete to go. lm not sure how they would improve parrking though 531 Dont imstall meters 532 None. 533 None. 534 I just walk all the time so it's not a problem for me. 535 Add more free parking. 536 No 537 Add parking structures. Under gound. 538 NA 539 Make a building structure on unuse arreas. 540 No problems at all. 541 Sync the lights 542 No high density. when apartments are created have them provide two parking spaces for each apartment. 543 No parking meters. Kimley >>>Horn 6/18/2016 14:56 6/18/2016 14:56 6/18/2016 14:55 6/18/2016 14:54 6/18/2016 14:54 6/18/2016 14:53 6/18/2016 14:53 6/18/2016 14:51 6/18/2016 14:50 6/18/2016 14:49 6/18/2016 14:48 6/18/2016 14:48 6/18/2016 14:46 6/18/2016 14:46 6/18/2016 14:45 6/18/2016 14:44 6/18/2016 14:44 6/18/2016 14:44 6/18/2016 14:44 6/18/2016 14:43 6/18/2016 14:42 6/18/2016 14:41 6/18/2016 14:40 6/18/2016 14:40 6/18/2016 14:38 6/18/2016 14:37 6/18/2016 14:37 6/18/2016 14:36 6/18/2016 14:36 6/18/2016 14:36 6/18/2016 14:36 Page I 83 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 544 Always parking here except during lunch time, there is a school and park close so parking can be impossible 545 Nothing 546 Add a lot on state 547 No suggestions. Just live that you looking at this. 548 Train station a bit closer. It seems I'm right in the middle. There's a train station either two miles that way (north) or that way (south) 549 Add more lots at the end of the beach by the powerplant. There is no space to park other than by the curbside. 550 Add parking on oak street. 551 Disallow RVs from street parking. 552 No suggestions 553 Dont put any paid meters or paid lots. 554 Not right now 555 N/A 556 There's not much you can do, there's no space. A shuttle from downtown would be nice, There's more parking there. In a loop to bring people to the beach. 557 Need more parking. We should have rental bikes here. No garages. 558 More free spaces, more curb parking 559 No meters 560 Build a parking garage. 561 Get more parking structures. 562 No parking meters. 563 NA 564 Dont charge for parking. 565 I ride my bike a lot. Not today. Getting from Tamarack to the bike path is terrifying. There is no way to do it without getting into the traffic. It would be great to have a safe way to get to the beach from the Barrio. There are no connectors. This intersectiom is pretty functional. I wouldn't change it. A cross walk on the other side of bridge would be good because there is more parking down there. It looks like there is room for more street parking in this section along here so you could add that. Kimley >>>Horn 6/18/2016 14:36 6/18/2016 14:34 6/18/2016 14:33 6/18/2016 14:32 6/18/2016 14:30 6/18/2016 14:30 6/18/2016 14:29 6/18/2016 14:29 6/18/2016 14:27 6/18/2016 14:26 6/18/2016 14:26 6/18/2016 14:25 6/18/2016 14:23 6/18/2016 14:23 6/18/2016 14:22 6/18/2016 14:22 6/18/2016 14:21 6/18/2016 14:21 6/18/2016 14:20 6/18/2016 14:19 6/18/201614:19 6/18/201614:19 Page I 84 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ,. 1UDf 0 rn 0 c D 566 None. 567 Stop building so many apartments, there is limited parking because of it 568 Add markers between parking spots so people dont waste space. 569 Dont build garage 570 More handicap parking. 571 Maybe a parking tower, three story 572 None. 573 No problem 574 Transportation is really good. Parking is tough because the area is overbuilt. 575 No problems 576 Remove or improve the RV situation. 577 Mark the spots on the road for each car. 578 More lots, i guess. 579 No big condo complexes 580 Add a bikeshare service 581 No idea how to, take out bicycle lanes? 582 Shuttle people from a remote parking area. 583 Enforcing parking laws. Also make shuttle from mall to the beach area. No big parking structures since it will make the area more urban. 584 Get rid of the campers. They take three spots instead of one. New parking by the train tracks. Even if it's metered. It's better than nothing. 585 None 586 No trouble finding spots 587 Add a parking structure. 588 Youd have to tear down real estate, the res nota lot you can do 589 Not a lot of parking. Add more. 590 Do not build multi-density dwellings, it drastically decreases parking availability. Also add public trams that go to and from lots. 591 I walk to work and everywhere else since i dont have a car 592 No problems 593 No paid parking by the beach to keep them off the residental streets. City should buy a building to make th property into a lot. 594 They need more public parking here. That's obvious. I don't know where they'd put it though 595 Add shuttles from different lots on busy weekends. 596 Will think about it and go online. 597 No suggestions 598 Not really. I don't like that they charge for parking at Tamarack. I don't park there anymore. 599 No idea. Dont know about situation, maybe a parking garage Kimley>>>Horn 6/18/201614:18 6/18/201614:17 6/18/201614:17 6/18/2016 14:16 6/18/201614:16 6/18/2016 14:15 6/18/2016 14:15 6/18/2016 14:14 6/18/2016 14:14 6/18/2016 14:12 6/18/2016 14:11 6/18/2016 14:10 6/18/201614:10 6/18/2016 14:10 6/18/2016 14:09 6/18/2016 14:08 6/18/2016 14:08 6/18/2016 14:07 6/18/2016 14:06 6/18/2016 14:06 6/18/2016 14:05 6/18/2016 14:05 6/18/2016 14:04 6/18/2016 14:04 6/18/2016 14:03 6/18/2016 14:02 6/18/2016 14:02 6/18/2016 14:01 6/18/2016 13:59 6/18/2016 13:59 6/18/2016 13:59 6/18/2016 13:57 6/18/2016 13:57 6/18/2016 13:56 Page I 85 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p Cl FC LSB J 600 Tourists take up all the spots. Tourists suck. 601 Parking structure. They are starting to build more apartment complexes in the neighborhood and the streets are flooded amd its hard to park even when youre a resident 602 I think everything is fine if you come early. We park in a lot that I think is the city's anyway. There's no time restrictions like State Street and there's restaurants there so we don't want to park there. 603 Add parking and make it free for residents. 604 Directions to lots could be better. Not a lot of places for bikes. Extend the rail trail. 605 No meters 606 Parking in the barrio and village is not the problem. Beach parking is an issue add more and make it free. 607 None 608 A parking structure will be nice since neigh boors take many parking spots for baseball games. 609 Better mass transit. 610 Garage but farfrom beach 611 None 612 Nothing 613 As long as they don't put any meters on the street. I know the state took over that lot (Tamarack) and are charging people. They have to make money somehow. I know the city is considering meters and all that revenue. No meters. Keep it simple. 614 I live down the street somi walk here to get food but in general the parking in carlsbad is tough especially because tons of tourist visit the city 615 No, were not a good judge be we have an in for parking. Our son works here 616 Impeach Matt Hall and get rid of Packard. 617 N/A,thinks parking is fine. 618 Add more parking, but stop adding resturant patio's on street which takes away parking spots. 619 Make sure businesses have more than one exit. 620 Like that it's free. 621 No suggestions 622 NA 623 No. Its just going to be busy in the summer. 624 No. I don't have a problem finding parking here. 625 Public parking lot, free. Like churches. 626 Parking is terrible but idk what you could do, a parking structure would be ugly and theres no space. It dies mean less ppl on the beach 627 Add a bus that brings people around the area more often. Kimley>>>Horn 6/18/2016 13:56 6/18/201613:56 6/18/2016 13:55 6/18/2016 13:55 6/18/2016 13:54 6/18/2016 13:54 6/18/2016 13:54 6/18/2016 13:53 6/18/2016 13:53 6/18/2016 13:52 6/18/2016 13:51 6/18/2016 13:51 6/18/2016 13:51 6/18/2016 13:50 6/18/2016 13:50 6/18/2016 13:50 6/18/2016 13:50 6/18/2016 13:49 6/18/2016 13:49 6/18/2016 13:48 6/18/2016 13:48 6/18/2016 13:48 6/18/2016 13:47 6/18/2016 13:47 6/18/201613:47 6/18/2016 13:46 6/18/2016 13:45 6/18/2016 13:45 Page I 86 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA R. FC L D 628 Dont kmow, it's onlybad on the weekends. Put up signsfor street sweeping. Make parking free next to the beach so people dont movero the neighborhoods. 629 Garage and a shuttle 630 Not really. It's getting crowder and crowder here. They have to circle to find a place to park. We don't have that problem becayse we live here. 631 Add parking on beach area. 632 Every tme there are basbell games its hard to find a parkng space. Not a problem finding a spot today 633 Add a trolley that brings people back and forth. Make it more pedestrian safe and cyclist safe. Build a large parking lot to accomodate all the demand. 634 Please dont make Carlsbad into rolando beach. Please keep this community charming and stop building condos. 635 I don't know. They don't have any place to build a parking structure. Everyonejust has to hike in. All the beaches are the same way. All the way to Point Loma. 636 Doesnt want to see more parking lots. Maybe shuttle people from lots elsewhere (Vista). 637 No 638 More bus stops be we had to get off past our destination 639 No problems 640 NA 641 No 642 No 643 Just make more spaces available on the street 644 Limit rvs how long they can park. There's a lot of unauthorized rv parking. 645 No meters 646 Its not that bad, maybe a parking structure for dtate street area. Restaurants going into oceanside be better parking so would allow that here 647 Make skating in downtown legal. Add more parking around coaster area. 648 NA 649 None 650 Should make empty lot into parking lot. 651 If possible build parking garages on the outside of town with shuttles to keep the traffic out of town. Or have parking underground like under the time shares and hotels. So they won't block the view of the ocean,! know they have their own. In New York, they have these things where you drive your car on it and it lifts it up so the cars are stacked. I don't know what it's called but it's an idea. 652 653 No meters, 2 story parking garage. 654 None Kimley >>>Horn 6/18/2016 13:45 6/18/201613:44 6/18/2016 13:44 6/18/2016 13:44 6/18/2016 13:43 6/18/2016 13:42 6/18/2016 13:42 6/18/2016 13:41 6/18/2016 13:41 6/18/2016 13:41 6/18/2016 13:39 6/18/2016 13:39 6/18/2016 13:39 6/18/2016 13:38 6/18/2016 13:37 6/18/2016 13:37 6/18/2016 13:36 6/18/2016 13:36 6/18/2016 13:36 6/18/2016 13:36 6/18/2016 13:36 6/18/2016 13:36 6/18/2016 13:35 6/18/2016 13:34 6/18/201613:34 6/18/201613:34 6/18/2016 13:32 Page I 87 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA UDYI-OR 7 oc CARLS_ D 655 Doesnt know yet. 656 A car park but theyre so ugly. Even extra lots will get filled 657 No problems 658 Shuttles or more public transportation to the area. Loves the free parking. 659 Dont have a problem, know where to look. 660 Fire Matt Hall. 661 Keep free lots. 662 Add four lanes at the end of the road behind the powerplant. It is a disaster right now. 663 Have a parking structure like Oceanside. Make it free. 664 No garage 665 Build a parking structure? 666 Add more free spots. 667 None 668 None 669 Make a place for RVs to park all the time to make more room for street parking. 670 None 671 The city is not entirey bike friendly. The traffic is too tight and too fast. Slow down the speeds. Reduce it from 35 to 30. Also, The motorcycle noise is really bad when the rev their engines. Enact sound a ord if above a certain decible. I think some cities have sound ordinances. I'm not sure. I'd have to look into it. It might take an additional staff member on a motorcycle to enforce it. 672 Make this street one way to give you more parking, angled parking be parking is bad especially in the middle of summer 673 Stop the motorhomes from parking on the streets and taking up space 674 Please add more public transportation like buses. And make sure they run often enough that people would take them. 675 More public transportation from downtown areas to the beach. Something like shuttles. 676 State st. From village to grand: improve parking facilities here. 677 Easy turn around in the parking lot. 678 Maintain free parking lots. No metering. 679 Make it a one way street 680 None 681 None 682 None. 683 Need more parking. 684 None 68S None Kim ley>>> Horn 6/18/2016 13:32 6/18/201613:31 6/18/2016 13:31 6/18/2016 13:30 6/18/2016 13:29 6/18/2016 13:29 6/18/2016 13:28 6/18/2016 13:27 6/18/2016 13:26 6/18/2016 13:25 6/18/2016 13:25 6/18/2016 13:25 6/18/2016 13:22 6/18/2016 13:21 6/18/2016 13:21 6/18/2016 13:21 6/18/2016 13:21 6/18/2016 13:20 6/18/2016 13:19 6/15/2016 16:52 6/15/2016 16:45 6/15/2016 16:43 6/15/2016 16:43 6/15/2016 16:40 6/15/2016 16:39 6/15/2016 16:38 6/15/2016 16:35 6/15/2016 16:33 6/15/2016 16:31 6/15/2016 16:29 6/15/2016 16:27 Page I 88 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D t-0 OF CARL L D 686 Monitoring the one hour parking. Shuttle bus to help people go back and forth maybecharging a dollar per ride. 687 Not as bad bcause is a weekday. But try find parking on weekends 688 NA 689 Develop land to build more parking lots. 690 Add seats along coastal trail. 691 During the summer there is no parking anywhere 692 We share our parking with the coaster parking lot, most of the time parking is full so have to park in 2 hour parking and constantly ,move my car, it becomes a hassel if there is no parking in the coaster I ott 693 More free spots. 694 Underground parking 695 More parking. 696 Increase safety of cars pulling out from parking spaces on the street. 697 Make the parking lots by the beach free. 698 Not enough parkng 699 Use offside spot, where we can use shettles back and forth. 700 Need to patrol the sidewallk and prohibit skateboards. 701 NA 702 Great area for walking I shopping i usually find street parking easily but wednesdays are crowded as are the weekends would be helpful! for extra space for parking 703 We don't need parking, because more people, more responsability, lifeguard can't handle to much people. 704 Next to the railroad construct a parking structure 705 I enjoy walking this area with my kids and stopping for lunch, usually always find meter parking in the street 706 Can make it a one way street an place parking in the middle of the road. 707 NA 708 Always ride my bike here and there are plenty of bike racks 709 Easy during the week to find parking but during the weekend its a hassel 710 Add more free spots. 711 Maintain current facilities. 712 None 713 Improve train system. Parking garages. 714 Ocean ave north of harbor fish, add diagonal street parking. It doesnt impede the flow of traffic and creates more spots. 715 Leave two lanes for driving. Dont take away 716 None Kimley >>>Horn 6/15/2016 16:24 6/15/2016 16:22 6/15/2016 16:21 6/15/2016 16:20 6/15/201616:19 6/15/201616:17 6/15/201616:16 6/15/2016 16:15 6/15/201616:12 6/15/201616:12 6/15/2016 16:08 6/15/2016 16:06 6/15/2016 16:02 6/15/2016 16:01 6/15/2016 15:51 6/15/2016 15:47 6/15/2016 15:45 6/15/2016 15:44 6/15/201615:38 6/15/2016 15:36 6/15/2016 15:34 6/15/2016 15:33 6/15/2016 15:32 6/15/2016 15:29 6/15/2016 15:28 6/15/2016 15:28 6/15/2016 15:25 6/15/2016 15:23 6/15/2016 15:21 6/15/201615:18 6/15/201615:14 Page I 89 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA R ft. 717 More parking near power plant. 718 None 719 Maintain current facilities. 720 None. 721 None 722 More mass transportation. More convenient public transportation. 723 Add parking, but not too much more. 724 Parkng is terrible in the evenings and summer 725 None 726 Crosswalks 727 Add more spots. 728 No paid parking for residents. 729 Maintan current facilities. 730 Add more of it. 731 I would hate to see a parking structure to go up. 732 Add shuttle buses to run to and from downtown to the beach. Remove parking fees at lots for residents, at least during the week because fees discourage people from visiting. 733 Better signs of where topark 734 Make ocean blvd a pedestrianonly area. 735 More spaces. Parking lot. 736 Shuttles 737 Synchronize the lights to make the traffic smoother. 738 Maintain current parking facilities. No parking structures. 739 Parking garage needed 740 Not allow RVs in parking lot for transient population. 741 Maybe a buss that can pick people up from the library. 742 Maintain current facilities. 743 None 744 It works that we can park for only an hour. They should put a separate parking spot for motorcycles, they take car parking spaces 745 No parking structure, more parking options. Ungergroumd facilities. 746 Build more structures. 747 I flew into town and took uber. Did not need to find parking space 748 If someone ask I tell them to go park on the streets 749 Needs a lot of work. Better than two parking lots that are here. More parking options. More convenient to local residents. 750 None we parkedat resort 751 Add a parking structure in downtown. Kim ley>>> Horn 6/15/201615:13 6/15/2016 15:10 6/15/2016 15:09 6/15/2016 15:07 6/15/2016 15:04 6/15/2016 15:03 6/15/2016 14:54 6/15/2016 14:52 6/15/2016 14:52 6/15/2016 14:51 6/15/2016 14:46 6/15/2016 14:43 6/15/2016 14:40 6/15/2016 14:38 6/15/2016 14:38 6/15/2016 14:35 6/15/2016 14:33 6/15/2016 14:30 6/15/2016 14:27 6/15/2016 14:27 6/15/2016 14:27 6/15/201614:25 6/15/2016 14:25 6/15/2016 14:23 6/15/2016 14:21 6/15/2016 14:20 6/15/201614:19 6/15/201614:19 6/15/201614:16 6/15/2016 14:15 6/15/2016 14:13 6/15/2016 14:08 6/15/2016 14:07 6/15/2016 14:06 6/15/2016 14:06 Page I 90 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OF RL ___ D 752 Permits or meters or passes on the street, paid parking. 753 Free trolley up and down coast. Reverse angled parking. No meters, paid parking. 754 More parking lots. 755 More trolley stops. 756 Create more areas for parking even if it means fees. Out of town residents should pay for parking. 757 Dine oft em and usually find street parking but is limited 758 None 759 NA 760 None 761 Increase public transportation. 762 Maintain current facilities. 763 Do not install parking meters. Keep it free. 764 More parking 765 Satisfied. No parking structures. Improve bike facilities. 766 We got lucky finding a spot in front of the cafe it oule be helpful if their were more spaces. It gets pretty busy down here 767 It is hard to park in the summer and in general, most spaces are meeters 768 None 769 Maintain free parking. 770 More parking, less people 771 None. lots of good parking already. 772 I am here for work and have a designated parking spot but a structure would be helpful people are always shopping dinning in this area or here ror the beach and parking is limited 773 None 774 In July parking is horrible 775 None i always walk 776 None 777 Maintain free parking. No meters. 778 Weekdays there are no problems findingparking. 779 None, it is good 780 No comment. It is good as is. 781 Add parking meters and resident only parking on some streets. 782 Multi level parking garage. Ban dogs along coastal trail and extend trail. 783 More street parking especially in this area 784 No comment. 785 That's why I'm on a bike. Maybe to find parking on carlsbad mall park and use shuttle bus to the beach. And use the shuttles from sears directly to the fair. Kimley >>>Horn 6/15/2016 14:05 6/15/2016 14:04 6/15/2016 14:02 6/15/2016 14:01 6/15/2016 14:00 6/15/2016 13:56 6/15/2016 13:54 6/15/201613:54 6/15/2016 13:54 6/15/2016 13:52 6/15/2016 13:52 6/15/2016 13:50 6/15/2016 13:46 6/15/2016 13:46 6/15/2016 13:46 6/15/2016 13:42 6/15/2016 13:41 6/15/2016 13:39 6/15/2016 13:39 6/15/2016 13:38 6/15/20t613:38 6/15/2016 13:37 6/15/2016 13:36 6/15/2016 13:36 6/15/2016 13:36 6/15/2016 13:34 6/15/2016 13:33 6/15/2016 13:32 6/15/2016 13:30 6/15/2016 13:27 6/15/2016 13:26 6/15/2016 13:25 6/15/2016 13:25 6/15/2016 13:24 Page I 91 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA E 17 0 786 NA i usually walk or bike everywhere 787 Add more trolleys from Amtrak to the village and beach so people dont have to rely so much on the cars. 788 Parking is limited here in the village because of shopping stores and eateries 789 Add more parking lots. More signage for public parking. 790 To get here early or late 791 Keep on street parking. No meters added. Kim ley >>> Horn 6/15/2016 13:23 6/15/2016 13:20 6/15/201613:19 6/15/2016 13:19 6/15/2016 13:18 6/15/2016 13:14 Page I 92 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OF h Appendix C-Online Survey Questions City of Carlsbad Parking Management Study-English Online Questionnaire -FINAL May4, 2016 INTRODUCTION The City of Carlsbad is working on a study to improve parking in the Village, Barrio and nearby beach area. The study will determine future parking needs so the city can make sure these popular areas remain easy to access. This could include new approaches to parking and encouraging alternate ways to get around, including walking and biking. The specific areas included in this study are shown on this map . Kim ley >>> Horn .. ·-"' .. \ i' Page I 93 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p kLB. D Q: How would you describe yourself? _I live in this area (Carlsbad Village, Barrio, beach area) Smart Logic: go to RESIDENTS ONLY PAGE-7) -?EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _I own or manage a business in this area Smart Logic: go to BUSINESS ONLY PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _I live in and own or manage a business in this area Smart Logic: go to RESIDENTS ONLY PAGE-7)-7BUSINESS ONLY PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _I work in this area Smart Logic: go to EMPLOYEE ONLY PAGE-7 EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _I live and work in this area Smart Logic: go to RESIDENT ONLY PAGE -?EMPLOYEE ONLY PAGE-7 EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _I am a visitor to this area (i.e., to visit a business, go to an event or the beach) Smart Logic: go to VISITOR PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _Other, please explain: ____ _ Smart Logic: go to VISITOR PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE RESIDENTS ONLY PAGE Q: Where do you live? _Carlsbad Village _Barrio _Near the beach Q: Where do you typically park in your neighborhood? _On-street _In a parking lot _In my driveway or elsewhere on my property _In a garage _I do not have a personal vehicle (Smart Logic: go to EVERYONE PAGE) Kim ley>>> Horn Page I 94 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA B. D Q: How close to your home are you usually able to park? _I have a designated parking spot at my home (Smart Logic: go to Q#) _I park in the street directly in front of or adjacent to my home _I can usually find parking on my block but not directly in front of my home _I can usually find parking within two blocks from my home _I can usually park within three blocks from my home _I cannot usually find parking within three blocks of my home Q: How long does it usually take you to find a parking spot? _Less than 2 minutes _2-5 minutes _6 -10 minutes _11-15 minutes _More than 15 minutes Kimley >>>Horn Page I 95 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Q: When is it most challenging to find available parking in your neighborhood? (Please make only one selection per day of the week.) Before 7:00-9:00 -11:00 1:00-3:00-5:00-I do not find it 8:59 2:59 7:00PM challenging to 7:00AM 10:59 AM AM-4:59PM 6:59 or later AM 12:59 PM PM PM find parki ng. Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday BUSINESS ONLY PAGE Q: In which community do you own or manage a business (Check all that apply)? _Carl sbad Village _Barrio Near the beach Q: What type of business do you own or manage? _Retail (i.e. clothing store, gift shop) _Service (i.e. salon) _Professional (i.e. law office, ban k) _Dining, nightlife, or entertainment (i.e. restaurant, pub or bar, t heater or music venue) _Other, please explain: ____ _ Q: How many employees work at this location? ____ _ Q: Do you provide parking for your employees? _All employees Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 96 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA LJD. D _Some employees only (i.e., full time only, not part time) _No employees Q: Please rate the following statements on a scale from 1 to 5 with 1 indicating strongly agree and 5 indicating strongly disagree. Strongly Strongly Agree disagree There is typically enough parking for my employees within a reasonable distance of 1 2 3 4 5 my business There is typically enough parking for my customers within a reasonable distance of 1 2 3 4 5 my business Q: What maximum distance do you think is reasonable for your customers to walk from their parking space to your business? _Less than one block _One block _Two blocks _Three blocks Four blocks _Five blocks _Six blocks or more _I don't think about how far my customers have to walk Q: Who do you think is parking in the on-street parking spaces closest to your business (Check all that apply)? _Customers from area businesses _Residents who live in the area _My employees _Employees from area businesses Kim ley>>> Horn Page I 97 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA F LSuA _Visitors to the area _Customers, residents or visitors who are parking near my business and walking to another location _Other, please explain: ______ _ Q: When do you think there is the highest demand for parking near your business? (Please make only one selection per day of the week.) I do not think Before 11:00 AM-1:00-3:00-5:00-that there are 7:00-9:00-7:00PM any high 7:00 8:59AM 10:59 AM 12:59 PM 2:59PM 4:59PM 6:59PM or later AM demand times on this day. Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday EMPLOYEE ONLY PAGE Q: In which community do you work? _Carlsbad Village _Barrio _Near the beach Q: How do you usually get to work? Drive alone in a car _Drive with others (carpooled/vanpooled) _Motorcycle I scooter _Bicycle _Public transit (Bus/Train) Kim ley>>> Horn Page I 98 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P RKING STUD'f rOR THE rJT) OF CARL.SBAD _Walk _Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service _Longboard, skateboard, hover board or other personal mobility device _Dropped off _Other, please explain: _______ _ Q : How long does it usually take you to find a parking space? Less than 2 minutes _2-5 minutes _6-10 minutes _11-15 minutes _More than 15 minutes _I never drive to work (Smart Logic: go to EVERYONE PAGE) Q: How close to work do you usually park? _Directly in front of or adjacent to where I work _One block away from where I work _Two blocks away from where I work _Three blocks away from where I work _Four blocks away from where I work _Five blocks away from where I work _Six blocks or more from where I work Q: Where do you usually park? _On-street in Carlsbad Village On-street at the beach On-street in the Barrio _Parking lot _Other, please specify: _______ _ Kim ley>>> Horn Page I 99 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA T oc: 1\ D D VISITOR ONLY PAGE Q: Which community do you typically visit? _Carlsbad Village _Barrio _Near the beach Q: How do you typically travel to this community? _Drive alone in a car _Drive with others (carpooled/vanpooled) _Motorcycle I scooter _Bicycle _Public transit (Bus/Train) _Walk _Taxi, Uber, Lyft or similar ridesharing service _Longboard, skateboard, hover board or other personal mobility device _Dropped off _Other, please explain: _______ _ Q: When driving to this community, where do you usually park? _On-street in Carl sbad Village On-street at the beach On-street in the Barrio _Parking lot _Other, please specify: _______ _ Q: How long does it usually take you to find a parking space? _Less than 2 minutes _2-5 minutes _6-10 minutes Kimley >>>Horn Page 1100 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO,· AND BEACH AREA 11-15 minutes _More than 15 minutes Q: How close to your destination do you usually park? _Directly in front or adjacent to my destination _One block away from my destination _Two blocks away from my destination _Three blocks away from my destination _Four blocks away from my destination _Five blocks away from my destination _Six blocks or more from my destination EVERYONE Q: Please select what you consider to be the biggest challenge(s) you face when parking in the Study Area? (Check all that apply) _Finding an available space quickly _Finding an available space that is close to my destination _Parking and exiting my vehicle safely _Knowing where I can park (i.e., lack of signage, information about parking rules and regulations) _Other: __________ _ Q: Do you have any other questions, comments or concerns about parking in the Study Area? (Open-ended) , Q: What is your sex (optional)? Male _Female Q: How old are you (optional)? _under 17 _40-49 17-24 _50-59 _25-30 _60-69 _31-39 _70 and Older Kim ley>>> Horn Page 1101 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA OF L D Optional: If you would like to stay informed about the parking study and management plan, please enter your name and email address below. Name: ________________ _ Email:--------------------- Thank you screen Thank you for taking the survey! For more information about the parking study, visit http://www.carlsbadca.gov/services/depts/planning/parking study.asp. City of Carlsbad Parking Management Study -Spanish Online Questionnaire May 10,2016 INTRODUCCION La ciudad de Carlsbad esta trabajando en un estudio para mejorar los lugares de estacionamiento en las areas de Village, Barrio y cerca de Ia zona de playa. El estudio determinara las necesidades estacionamiento a futuro para que Ia ciudad puede asegurarse de que estas zonas populares continuen siendo de facil acceso. Esto podrfa incluir nuevas enfoques para estacionamientos y fomentar formas alternativas para moverse porIa ciudad incluyendo caminar y andar en bicicleta. Este mapa muestra las areas especfficas incluidas en este estudio. Kim ley >>> Horn Page 1102 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PJ\ H CJ F CAI\LbAD Q: (.C6mo se describirfa usted a sf mismo? _Yo vivo en esta zona (Carlsbad Village, Barrio, zona de playa) Smart Logic: go to RESIDENTS ONLY PAGE-7) -7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _Yo soy el propietario o administro un negocio en esta zona Smart Logic: go to BUSINESS ONLY PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _Yo vivo en y soy el propietario o administro un negocio en esta zona Smart Logic: go to RESIDENTS ONLY PAGE-7)-7BUSINESS ONLY PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _Yo trabajo en esta area Kim ley >>> Horn Page I 103 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA c o_ CF 6 D Smart Logic: go to EMPLOYEE ONLY PAGE-7 EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _Yo vivo y trabajo en esta area Smart Logic: go to RESIDENT ONLY PAGE -7EMPLOYEE ONLY PAGE-7 EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _Soy un visitante de esta zona (es decir, para visitar un negocio, ira un evento o en Ia playa) Smart Logic: go to VISITOR PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE _ Otro, por favor explique: _____ _ Smart Logic: go to VISITOR PAGE-7EVERYONE PAGE-7THANK YOU PAGE RESIDENTS ONLY PAGE Q: (_En d6nde vives? _Carlsbad Village _Barrio _Cerca de Ia playa Q: (_Donde se suele estacionar en tu comunidad? En Ia calle En un estacionamiento _En Ia entrada de mi casa o en otra parte de mi propiedad _ En un garaje _No tengo un vehfculo personal (Smart Logic: go to EVERYONE PAGE) Q: (_Que tan cerca de su hogar se estaciona regularmente? _En un Iugar de estacionamiento designado en mi casa (Smart Logic: go to Q#) En Ia calle directamente en frente de o a allado de mi casa _ Generalmente puedo encontrar estacionamiento en mi cuadrapero no directamente en frente de mi casa _ Generalmente puedo encontrar estacionamiento ados cuadras de mi casa _ Generalmente puedo encontrar estacionamiento a tres cuadras de mi casa Generalmente no encuentro estacionamiento a tres cuadras de mi casa Kimley >>>Horn Page 1104 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA roP 1 H' o OF CAR 58 c; Q: (.Cuanto tiempo setarda generalmente para encontrar un Iugar de estacionamiento? Menos de 2 minutos 2-5 minutos 6-10 minutos 11-15 minutos Mas de 15 minutos Q: (.Cuando es mas diflcil encontrar estacionamiento disponible en su comunidad? (Por favor hacer solo una selecci6n por dla de Ia semana). Antes de 7:00-9:00-ll:OOAM-1:00-3:00-5:00-7:00PM Noes difkil 7:00AM 8:59AM 10:59 AM 12:59 PM 2:59PM 4:59PM 0 mas encontrar 6:59PM tarde estacionamiento. Lunes Martes Miercoles Jueves Viernes Sabado Domingo PAGINA UNICA DE NEGOCIO Q: En que comunidad (.Es propietario o administrar un negocio (marque todos que aplican)? _Carlsbad Village Barrio _ Cerca de Ia playa Q: (.De que tipo de negocio es propietario o administra? _ Tienda al par menor (tienda de ropa, tienda de regalos) _ Servicio (es decir, salon) Kim ley >>> Horn Page 1105 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA J-0 I _ Profesional (es decir, oficina, banco) _ Restaurantes, vida nocturna, o entretenimiento (es decir, restaurante, pub o bar, cine o musica) _ Otros, por favor explique: _____ _ Q: (.Cuantos empleados trabajan en este Iugar? _____ _ Q: (.Ofrecen estacionamiento para sus empleados? _ Todos los empleados _Algunos empleados sola mente (es decir, solo a tiempo completo, no medio tiempo) _ Ningun empleado Q: Por favor califique las siguientes afirmaciones en escalade 1 a 5 con lo que indica 1 totalmente de acuerdo y 5 que indica totalmente en desacuerdo. Nide Total mente Total mente de De acuerdo ni En acuerdo acuerdo desacuerdo en en desacuerdo desacuerdo Normalmente hay suficiente estacionamientopara mis empleados 1 2 3 4 5 dentro de una distancia razonable de mi negocio Normalmente hay suficiente estacionamiento para mis clientes a 1 2 3 4 5 una distancia razonable de mi negocio Q: (.Que distancia maxima crees que es razonable para sus clientes caminen a su negocio desde un Iugar de estacionamiento? Menos de una cuadra 1 cuadra 2 cuadras 3 cuadras 4 cuadras 5 cuadras Kimley >>>Horn Page 1106 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p 11 0 CARL BAD 6 0 mas cuadras _No pienso en Ia distancia que mis clientes tengan que caminar Q: <.Quien crees que se esta estacionando en los espacios de estacionamiento en Ia calle mas cercanas a su negocio (marque todos que aplican)? _ Clientes de negociosde Ia zona _ Residentes que viven en el area _ Mis empleados _ Empleados de negociosde Ia zona Visitantes en Ia zona _ Clientes, residentes o visitantes que se estacionan cerca de mi negocio y caminana otra ubicaci6n _ Otros, por favor explique: -------- Q: <.Cuando cree que hay mayor demanda de estacionamiento cerca de su negocio? (Por favor hacer solo una selecci6n por dfa de Ia semana). No creo que Antes de 7:00-9:00 -ll:OOAM-1:00-3:00 -5:00 -7:00PM haya algun 7:00AM 8:59AM 10:59AM 12:59 PM 2:59PM 4:59PM 6:59PM 0 mas momenta de tarde alta demanda en este dfa. Lunes Martes Miercoles Jueves Viernes Sabado Domingo Kimley >>>Horn Page I 107 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 1 PAGINA UNICA DE EMPlEADO Q: (.En que comunidad trabaja? _Carlsbad Village Barrio _ Cerca de Ia playa Q: (.Generalmente como llega al trabajo? _ Condujo solo/a en un autom6vil _ Condujo con otras personas en su autom6vil (carpooled/vanpooled) _ Motocicleta/vespa Bicicleta _Trans porte publico (tren/autobus) Caminando _Taxi, Uber, Lyft o servicio similar de viaje com partido _ Patineta-Longboard, skateboard, hover board u otro dispositive de movilidad personal _ Lo dejaron aquf _ Otros, par favor especifique: _______ _ Q: (.Cuanto tiempo tarda generalmente para encontrar un espacio de estacionamiento? Menos de 2 minutos 2-5 minutos 6 -10 minutos 11-15 minutos Mas de 15 minutos _ Nunca conduzco al trabajo (Smart Logic: go to EVERYONE PAGE) Q: (.Que tan cerca a su trabajo generalmente se puede estacionar? _ Directamente en frente o junto allugar donde trabajo _ 1 cuadra de donde trabajo Kim ley >>> Horn Page 1108 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P I CST D 0 I OF C RL D _ 2 cuadras de donde trabajo _ 3 cuadras de donde trabajo _ 4 cuadras de donde trabajo _ 5 cuadras de donde trabajo -6 0 mas cuadras de donde trabajo Q: (.06nde usted generalmente se estaciona? _En Ia calle por Carlsbad Village _En Ia calle porIa playa _En Ia calle por el Barrio Estacionamiento _ Otros, por favor especifique: _______ _ PAGINA UNICA DE VISIT ANTE Q: (.Que comunidad visita normalmente? _Carlsbad Village Barrio _ Cerca de Ia playa Q: (.Por lo general como viaja a esta comunidad? Conduce solo en un autom6vil _ Condujo con otras personas en su automovil (carpooled/vanpooled) _ Motocicleta/vespa Bicicleta _Trans porte publico (tren/autobus) Caminando _Taxi, Uber, Lyft o servicio similar de viaje compatido _ Longboard, skateboard, hover board u otro dispositivo de movilidad personal _ Lo dejaron aquf Kim ley>>> Horn Page 1109 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA r'" UDYfO en D _ Otros, por favor explique: --------- Q: (.Cuando se conduce a esta comunidad, donde se suele estacionar? _En Ia calle en Carlsbad Village _En Ia calle en Ia playa En Ia calle en el Barrio Estacionamiento _ Otros, por favor especifique: ________ _ Q: (.Cuanto tiempo generalmente tarda para encontrar un espacio de estacionamiento? Menos de 2 minutes 2-5 minutes 6-10 minutes 11 -15 minutes Mas de 15 minutes Q: (.Que tan cerca de su destine general mente se puede estacionar? Justo en frente o allado de mi destino 1 cuadra de mi destino 2 cuadras de mi destino 3 cuadras de mi destino 4 cuadras de mi destino 5 cuadras de mi destino 6 0 mas cuadras de mi destino TO DOS Q: Por favor seleccione los que considere los mayores retos que enfrenta al estacionarse en Ia zona de de este estudio? (Marque todos que aplican) _ Encontrar un espacio disponible rapidamente _ Encontrar un espacio disponible que esta cerca de mi destino _ Estacionamiento y salir de mi vehfculo con seguridad Kimley >>>Horn Page I 110 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA o. rH_ £. 0 CA b D _Saber donde puedo me puedo estacionar (es decir, falta de senalizacion, informacion sobre el estacionamiento de las normas y reglamentos) Otros: ----------- Q: Hienes otras preguntas, comentarios o dudas sobre estacionamiento en Ia zona de este estudio? (Abierta) Q: (.Cual es tu sexo (opcional)? Hombre _Mujer Q: (.Que edad tienes (opcional)? _Menor de 17_40-49 17-24 _25-30 _31-39 _50-59 _60-69 _70 y mayores Opcional: Si desea mantenerse informado sobre el plan de estudio y gesti6n de estacionamientos, introduzca su nombre y correo electr6nico abajo. Nombre: _______ _ Correo electronico: __________ _ Thank you screen Gracias porto mar Ia encuesta! Para obtener mas informacion acerca del estudio de estacionamiento, visite http://www.carlsbadca.gov/services/depts/planning/parking study.asp. Kim ley>>> Horn Page 1111 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Appendix D-Online Survey Responses R11~inP~~ nwners/ManaPers The following graphs depict preliminary results for online survey respondents indicating they own or manage a business within the study area. In which community do you own or manage a business? (Check all that apply) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Carlsbad Village 88% TOTAL=48 What type of business do you own or manage? Dining, nightlife, or entertainment 26% TOTAL= 39 Professional (i.e. law office, bank) 33% Service (i.e., salon) 15% Retail (i.e., clothing store, gift shop) 26% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% . 100% Kimley >>>Horn Page 1112 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p,.. ,.., l-OR I H~ OF CAhLS_AD Do you provide parking for your employees? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% All employees 33% TOTAL=46 Some employees (i.e., full time only, not part time) 9% Less than one block One block Two blocks No employees 59% What maximum distance do you think is reasonable for your customers to walk from their parking space to your business? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% TOTAL=47 Three blocks .. Four blocks • Five blocks I Six blocks or more Don't think I about it Kim ley>>> Horn Page 1113 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PA .0 0 C4RL SBAD Who do you think is parking in the on-street parking spaces closest to your business? (Check all that apply) 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% My customers 26% Customers from area businesses 54% Residents who live in the area 35% TOTAL=46 My employees -15% Visitors to the beach -22% Beach Users -17% Other, please explain: • 7% 100% Kimley >>>Horn Page 1114 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D Y Oil H CIT 0 hl AD l='mnln\fee~ The following graphs depict preliminary results for respondents indicating they are employed within the study area for the online surveys. In which community do you work? 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Carlsbad Village 62% Barrio 1 3% TOTAL=77 Near the beach 35% How do you usually get to work? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Drive alone in a car 82% Drive with others 0% Motorcycle I scooter 0% Bicycle I 1% Public transit (bus I train) 0% Walk -7% Taxi, Uber, Lyft, etc. 0% Skateboard or other personal mobility device 0% Kim ley >>> Horn Dropped off I 1% Other, please explain: -9% TOTAL=77 Page IllS (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA H C/7 When driving to work, how long does it usually take you to find a parking space? Less than 2 minutes 2-5 minutes 6-10 minutes 11-15 minutes More than 15 minutes 0% 10% 20% .4% 0% -9% lnever -3% . 1 0 dnve to ... 30% 40% 50% 60% 54% 21% How close to work do you usually park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% Directly in front of or adjacent to where I work One block away from where I work 25% Two blocks away from the where I work • 6% Three blocks away from where I work • 5% Four blocks away from where I work 0% Five blocks away from where I work 0% Six blocks away from where I work 0% 70% 80% 90% TOTAL= 78 60% 70% 80% 64% TOTAL= 64 100% 90% 100% Kimley >>>Horn Page 1116 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA D Where do you usually park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% On-street in Carlsbad Village 25% On-street at the beach -9% TOTAL= 64 On-street in the Barrio I 3% On-street south of the Village I 3% Other, please specify: • 6% The following graphs depict preliminary results for respondents indicating they reside within the study area for the online surveys. Where do you live? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Carlsbad Village 39% TOTAL= 221 Barrio 15% Near the beach 45% Kim ley>>> Horn Page 1117 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA On-street In a parking lot In my driveway or elsewhere on my property In a garage I do not have a personal vehicle 0% 10% 6% I have a designated parking spot at my home I park in the street directly in front of or adjacent to my home On my block but not directly in front of my home Within two blocks from my home Within three blocks from my home More than three blocks from my home Kim ley >>> Horn Where do you typically park in your neighborhood? 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 20% TOTAl= 223 42% 30% How close to your home are you usually able to park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 72% -15% ... 7% .4% I 2% 11% TOTAl= 204 100% 100% Page 1118 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA :Jf ro Less than 2 minutes 2 -5 minutes 6-10 minutes 11-15 minutes More than 15 minutes 0% 0% OF So How long does it usually take you to find a parking spot? 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 53% 28% 14% 6% 80% 90% 100% TOTAL= 51 .A The majority of online survey respondents indicating they reside in the study area do not find parking in their neighborhood to be challenging, or they find parking challenging daily between Sp.m.-7p.m. \lic.itnr<) The following graphs depict preliminary results for respondents indicating they are visitors to the study area for the online surveys. Which community do you usually visit? 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Carlsbad Village 72% TOTAL= 288 Barrio 11% Near the beach 27% Kim ley>>> Horn Page 1119 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA rO OF L D D How do you typically travel to this community? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% Drive alone in a car •••••••••••• 53% Drive with others --------38% Motorcycle I scooter I o% Bicycle I 2% Public transit (bus I train} 0% Walk I 1% Taxi, Uber, Lyft, etc. I 1% Skateboard or other personal. .. 0% Dropped off 0% Other, please explain: -5% 70% 80% 90% TOTAL= 289 When driving to the community, where do you usually park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% On-Street in Carlsbad Village On-street at the beach -14% On-street in the Barrio I 2% On-street south of the Village (south of Oak Avenue} I 3% Other, please specify: • 10% Kimley >>>Horn 45% TOTAL= 281 100% Page 1120 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Uv. FOn E I {) How long does it usually take you to find a parking space? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Less than 2 minutes 31% TOTAL= 282 6-10 minutes -18% 11 -15 minutes I 3% More than 15 minutes II 4% How close to your destination do you usually park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Directly in front of adjacent to my destination -19% One block away from my destination 41% TOTAL= 282 Two blocks away from my destination -22% Three blocks away from my destination .. 11% Four blocks away from my destination I 4% Five blocks away from my destination I 1% Six blocks or more from my destination 11% Kimley >>>Horn Page 1121 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA FO The following graphs depict preliminary results for respondents indicating they reside and own a bus iness within the study area for the online surveys. Where do you live? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Carlsbad Village 30% TOTAL=57 Barrio 11% Near the beach 60% Where do you typically park in your neighborhood? 0% 20% On-street -12% In a parking lot • 11% In my driveway or elsewhere on my property In a garage I do not have a personal vehicle I 2% Kimley >>>Horn 40% 60% 80% 100% TOTAL=57 51% 25% Page 1122 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA R r How close to your home are you usually able to park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% I have a designated parking spot at my home I park in the street directly in front of or adjacent to my home I can usually find parking on my block but not directly in front of my home I can usually find parking within two blocks from my home I can usually find parking within three blocks from my home I cannot usually find parking within three blocks of my home .. 12% -15% I 2% I 2% 0% 69% TOTAL= 52 How long does it usually take you to find a parking spot? Less than 2 minutes 2-5 minutes 6 -10 minutes 11-15 minutes More than 15 minutes 0% 10% 20% 30% 25% 0% 0% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% TOTAL= 12 42% 33% 100% A The majority of online survey respondents indicating they reside and own a business within the study area generally do not find parking in their neighborhood to be challenging. Some indicated that finding available parking in their neighborhood nightly after 7p.m. is challenging. Kimley >>>Horn Page 1123 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA c The following graphs depict preliminary results for respondents indicating they reside and are employed within the study area for the online surveys. 0% Carlsbad Village Barrio Near the beach 20% 17% Where do you live? 40% 26% 60% 80% 57% TOTAL= 23 Where do you typically park in your neighborhood? 100% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% On-street In a parking lot II 4% In my driveway or elsewhere on my property In a garage I do not have a personal vehicle Kimley>>>Horn .8% 0% 46% TOTAL= 24 42% Page 1124 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p 0 How close to your home are you usually able to park? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% In the street directly in front of or adjacent to my home • 10% On my block but not directly in front of my home -19% Within two blocks from my home I 5% Within three blocks from my home I 5% More than three blocks from my home I 5% TOTAL= 21 How long does it usually take you to find a parking spot? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Less than 2 minutes 22% TOTAL=9 6-10 minutes 0% More than 15 minutes -11% .... The vast majority of online survey respondents indicating they reside and are employed within the study area find parking in their neighborhood to be most challenging nightly after 7p.m. Additionally, a large percentage answered that they find parking to be challenging on weekends between lla.m. -lp.m. Kim ley >>> Horn Page 1125 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA All llt:t:>rc T()J .. OR (JC ( fiLS_ D Please select what you consider to be the biggest challenge(s) you have when parking in the Study Area. (Check all that apply.) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Finding an available space quickly -------47% TOTAL= 451 Finding an available space that is close to my destination --------· 60% Parking and exiting my vehicle safely --·18% Knowing where I can park --·16% What is your gender? (Optional) 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Male 38% TOTAL= 546 Female 62% Kim ley >>> Horn Page 1126 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA /l G ... UDY FO HE RL r D How old are you? (Optional) 0% 20% 40% 60% Under17 0% 80% 100% 17-24 • 2% 25-30 -6% 31-39 TOTAL= 546 13% 40-49 19% 50-59 •••••• 29% 60-69 21% 70 and Older 10% # Free Responses to "Do you have any other questions, comments, or concerns about parking in the Study Date Collected Area? 1 I think the 3 hr parking limit should be enforced Jul17, 201610:17 PM 2 Let's not let parking get in the way of making this happen. Jul14, 2016 2:08AM 3 As a business owner I am concerned with the proposed redevelopment of the city parking lots on Roosevelt Jul 13, 2016 7:25 PM between Carlsbad Village Dr and Grand. These lots support many businesses for both employee and customer parking. Closure of these lots during redevelopment will substantially impact my business. 4 I will NOT support paid parking on the street or in a lot. I will take my business to other surrounding Jul 12, 2016 6:20PM communities with free parking. 5 Would like more areas for electric golf carts, or small electric vehicles to park. This would encourage others to Julll, 2016 2:50PM utilize more small electric vehicles. Less pol uti on, smaller parking areas needed, quieter, easier to get around, & creates a small town feelto the community. 6 Most beach areas are much more crowded than Carlsbad. It's not that big of a problem. Jul 9, 2016 3:12AM 7 I paid $1,475,000 for an 1800 sq. ft. condo precisely because there was an unobstructed view with no vehicle Jul 9, 2016 2:36AM parking as there is down towards Tamarack. I wouldn't have purchased this home if cars were allowed to block my view. This plan will cause a devaluation in my property value as well as my neighbors and I am prepared to fight this. Why don't you plant trees in front of our homes while you're at it! 8 This is the worst idea ever. Think about what you are doing to the people of Carlsbad. We will fight this all the Jul 9, 2016 2:08AM way even if we do a lawsuit. Out next door neighbor is a lawyer who's highly regarded here. He'll represent us for free 9 Having a shuttle between Village and beach similar to the one in Santa Barbara would be useful on weekends, Jul 7, 2016 2:49 PM holidays, during events like marathons and at other high use times. It would also take you from outlying parking into t he Village itself. The State and Grand area could then be pedestrian only. 10 Camper parking along Carlsbad Blvd. needs to be prohibited. Jul 5, 2016 12:01 AM Kimley >>>Horn Page 1127 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA UD. FO D 11 It's not in the village but the RVs and campers along coast highway are a parking problem more serious than anything in the village. 12 I think the current parking lots are well distributed in the village and should be retained. Multistory parking would be out of character for Carlsbad Village. 13 parking problems are exacerbated by short-term vacation rentals 14 I typically avoid the area altogether during peak seasons. I live in the Aviara area and I prefer downtown Encinitas or Moonlight beach where they have nicer facilities. 1S The Barrio is changing and growing. I do not see enough parking spaces on residential property for any new growth in the Barrio area. Many residences in the Barrio have only one single garage/driveway but own three or more cars/vehicles. Most of these are parked on the street near their residence. And when there is a Oty event (street fair, race). there is no street parking to come back to if you leave to go shopping or do errands in your car. We need any new housing development to have enough parking for residents and guests on their property and not on the street. One of my neighbor has like five cars/trucks and all are parked on the street! Imagine if we had another 100 more neighbors like this family. The Barrio neighborhood will become like Mission and Pacific Beaches that have major parking problems-too many people with vehicles and not enough off street parking. 16 I would like to pari by the beach -but there never is any parking available-either by the top of the beach or in a parking lot. I can never get to the beach for a quick visit. I miss Tamarack parking, 17 I was on State Street around 6pm the other night. As I was trying to get to Carlsbad Dance Centre in a timely manner to pick up my young daughter from class, not just in front of me, but also the car coming from opposite direction decided to stop to let out people from their cars to go to the restaurants there. Both labes were stopped for S minutes as they got out slowly and then talked amongst themselves trying to figure out where to eat. This is not the first time this has happened. Is there some kind of solution to this annoying problem? 18 I have ZERO interest in making additional accommodations for bicyclists or walkers. Bicyclists should either learn to ride in city traffic, or DON'T RIDE THERE. I've never seen a situation in SO years where existing sidewalks aren't good enough for walkers, and I walk through the area almost daily. 19 All the new condos-where are the residences and their guests going to park? 20 Please DO NOT make this a permit parking or pay parking area .... 21 Stop wasting our time and money 22 I am afraid that as a citizen that I will have to pay for parking in the Village Barrio. I think that the fee in leu of parking for developers is a sham, and that any developer should pay for their share of parking on the street no matter what. The Wave is a bad example, where the sump pump allows for below ground parking. Those people will park on the street instead of in an area where a car elevator is available. I do not want parking structures at the village since that destroys our small village feel. I do NOT like the idea of trolleys. I have bad knees and cannot bicycle around and need to park near my destination. 23 Finding parking during events like the street fair and the weekly farmers market is much harder. 24 NO METERS!!!! Kimley >>>Horn Jul 4, 2016 1:42AM Jul 2, 2016 4:49AM Jun 28, 2016 6:12 PM Jun 28, 2016 2:1S PM Jun 27, 2016 4:S6 PM Jun 27, 2016 12:21 AM Jun 26, 2016 11:SO AM Jun 2S, 2016 7:13 PM Jun 2S, 2016 2:29AM Jun 2S, 2016 2:26AM Jun 24, 2016 8:S1 PM Jun 24, 2016 4:46 PM Jun 22, 2016 9:37 PM Jun 21, 2016 12:S2 AM Page 1128 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA TUD FO h.. I 0 D 25 Obviously, the time of year and day make a big difference. It is hard to accommodate all surge scenarios. 26 Congestion at Carlsbad Blvd and Carlsbad Village Drive. Hard to get through and find parking. And if one lot is full, sometimes have to go through intersection again to find another lot. Wish there was no street parking on Carlsbad Blvd North right before CV Drive. Sometimes hard to see well, especially with bikes and pedestrians all around. Too many cars, too many people. Hard to be safe. 27 Yes, I walk 4 miles every day along the beach sidewalk and see how motorhomes are causing a lot of inconvenience for others by 1.) taking up an inordinate amount of parking along PCH and, 2.) encroaching on the beach sidewalk with their pop-outs, steps and patio furniture put on the sidewalk. In fact, I've seen doors swing open directly in the face of a person walking by. 28 I have lived in Carlsbad for 30+ years. I don't even try to park on carlsbad Blvd anymore. Too many RVs PR tourists who don't park close to each other (painted spots/sections would help). Off steer overwhelmed the community but garages etc are not the answer. Crosswalks with lights make parking easier. 29 The tenants in my building and their customers have had to deal with vagrants who like to "hang out" in our parking lot as well as Fish House Vera Cruz' parking lot. They gather to drink at any hour and then make a mess in my parking lot. The city has contributed because the adjacent city parking lot has large hedges of calliandra which create a dark somewhat hidden secluded haven for the regular gathering. There is lighting in the public parking lot, but because of growth will not be trimmed down (I have asked street maintenance, but been denied). light is not shed on the area. Not to be indelicate, but they make the area behind the dumpster on my parking lot their bathroom leaving a mess for me, my tenants, and my landscape maintenance crew to clean up after them. There is public bathroom facilities within easy walking distance, but they typically will not walk that far. I would like the city to do what is legally possible to make the parking lot less convenient/comfortable for gathering vagrants. 30 Please do not put parking structures next to the beach. If any are built, I hope they are underground or near the freeway. Thanks, 31 How about a shuddle system Kimley >>>Horn Jun 21, 2016 12:24 AM Jun 20, 2016 7:45 PM Jun 20, 2016 5:51 PM Jun 20, 2016 6:44AM Jun 18, 2016 3:19AM Jun 17, 2016 8:03PM Jun 17, 2016 3:29PM Page 1129 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA .) 32 Keep the village/beaches/barrio walking friendly. Police the crosswalks and TICKET the pedestrians who do not use the crosswalks and the cars that do not stop. It is even scarier out there now with the flashing lights. There are people (locals, tourists, children) who believe the cars will stop but that is not always the case. Even when 31anes stop there is that driver that will continue through on the 4th lane. The summer will only get worse. If you want to build a parking garage put it out by the freeway not in the village. If it is too far to walk offer a shuttle to escort people to the restaurant, bars, sand. DO NOT PUT A PARKING GARAGE IN THE VILLAGE!!!! Also, get the dogs off the lower seawall and sand. I see dogs every morning between 6-8am (when I am walking on the sidewalk above) on the sand and I see multiple dogs every day up by Buena Vista Lagoon every day over my noon run (all year long). I am tired of stepping in dog poop in the sand (this has to be unhealthy for the beach goers) and I am tired of the confrontational situation at the BV Lagoon border with Oceanside. It is getting nasty between dog owners and beach goers. I saw a group of girls this winter log roll over the sand ledge into dog poop, I saw a couple of young adult men going at it ugly (one with a dog, one with a small child) and refused to get involved in their argument because they were both so out of control. I've even had people yell at me when I am running because they think the dog frolicking in the waves is with me. I love my dog but the best thing we have in Carlsbad is the beach -let's try to keep it family friendly. Either post that BV Lagoon is a dog beach ( as a multitude of dog owners seem to think and tell the beach goers it is so they can go elsewhere) or start TICKETING the dogs on the lower seawall and sand. Unless it is enforced no one is going to change. 33 People parking in the residential area during the Street Fair and blocking driveways and leaving trash. I live on Davis Ave. and parking is always an issue during big events. 34 I've never had to park more than four blocks away when attending things in the Village (with the exception of fair and race days) 35 The city keeps taking away the street parking by giving restaurants outdoor dining on our PUBLIC sidewalks. Customers cannot find parking and drive in circles looking for a spot. Many give up and go to the mall. This hurts the business owners in the Village. The farmers market on one of our most popular shopping streets really harms the parking situation. It should be located off the main drag. Perhaps Roosevelt. We desperately need multi level parking on the public lots that are spaced few and far between. Anyone who lives and works in the Village knows how bad the parking situation is here. It seems that the council must all live on the South east side of town where adequate parking has been designated. The Village is what makes Carlsbad stand apart and gives this city it's unique charm. Please add underground parking! 36 The city council allows new construction that does not have the necessary spaces to pay for on street parking. This brings the city money but I really pay the price since then there is more parking in front of my house. This is not fair to the residents. New construction should be forced to create the necessary spaces on their own property, be it underground on surface. Kim ley >>> Horn Jun 16, 2016 8:51 PM Jun 16, 2016 5:58 PM Jun 16, 2016 12:57 AM Jun 15, 2016 9:25 PM Jun 15, 2016 7:49 PM Page 1130 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 5 JD~IO~TI 11 or:c 37 I don't think you're asking the right questions. You should be asking about specific incidents--the last time I parked--specific places I've visited within the last month, etc. This whole survey is very confusing and I wouldn't be very confident in the data that you get out of it. 38 Are you going to increase handicap parking spaces? 39 Harder to find parking around the beach area than in the village 40 I would like to see a park & ride lot at the vacant lot on the south/west corner of Tamarack & Interstate 5, with a shuttle going into the village or a shuttle from the Mall to the village. 41 parking issues are mostly during events and street fairs, we visit often from La Costa and on non event days/nights parking is not much of a problem. 42 I am concerned about any changes that will negatively impact my communities private residential/commercial parking area. {Village by the Sea) 43 There continues to be issues with homeless persons hanging around and using parking lots to camp out and meet up. This causes security and sanitary problems and makes the Village area unappealing to visitors. Also people using parking lots for skateboarding-not safe. 44 The street fairs and Wednesday farmers market place undue strain on parking. I multi-level structure near the train station is advised. 45 I think currently things are done well. Going forward with more people coming in and visiting it will grow to be a problem, so good to address it now. Paid parking should not be a part of it, though. Unfair for residents and visitors. 46 Nope 47 It's difficult to have overnight guests due to lack of available overnight parking on State Street {2500 block). 48 produce more parking behind businesses off street 49 Out-of-town visitors parking in the beach neighborhoods during the summer makes finding a spot after work for our second car an issue. Additionally, due to the extra parking volume during the summer it become extremely difficult for our visitors to find parking near our home. 50 Available overnight parking on state street (north end) for family and guests that come to visit. 51 Carlsbad needs to subsidize parking at Tamarack Beach. 52 I would model the parking like Del Mar has set up with the meters. It works real well considering the options and generates some income for the City. 53 I am eager fur as many roads to be closed to vehicles in the village to promote waking, bicycles etc to remove congestion. Most of all i hope to see vehicle parking space converted to business space .. why don't we have a Rucker shuttle to and from the village from the predominantly empty mall parking. 54 This is a non scientific survey and should be thrown out. Planning policy from a non scientific survey is contemptuous toward the public you serve. Kim ley>>> Horn Jun 15, 2016 7:08PM Jun 15, 2016 6:04PM Jun 15, 2016 5:35 PM Jun 15, 2016 5:15 PM Jun 15, 2016 5:10PM Jun 15, 2016 4:52 PM Jun 15, 2016 4:37PM Jun 15, 2016 4:32 PM Jun 15, 2016 4:29PM Jun 15, 2016 4:25PM Jun 15, 2016 4:20PM Jun 15, 2016 4:19 PM Jun 15, 2016 4:14 PM Jun 15, 2016 4:12PM Jun 14, 2016 9:26PM Jun 12, 2016 7:21 PM Jun 12, 2016 5:03PM Jun 12, 2016 4:01PM Page 1131 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ro , h OF RL D 55 Yes the study should consider seasons and holidays. Summer, weekends and holidays are much more difficult to find parking. 56 It can be eery difficult to find parking on the the streets from roosevelt to the beach (down by my office harding and grand its not as hard) I have driven atound for almost 15m ins before to find a spot to shop on state street. Then I end up parking down by my office and walking. And if it rains, the east side of state is a puddle of water that lve tried to junp before to get to a store on that side 57 Has a parking structure been considered? Multi-level and/or underground? Consider paid parking, $1/hour 58 Please, please, please ... No more pay lots. Parking must remain free to visitors. It would seriously affect my desire and frequency to visit if charged for parking. 59 I do NOT want to see more paid parking (meters or lots). It's bad enough to have to pay to park at the Tamarack lot. 60 more handicap parking. 61 Why don't you require developers to fully park their projects? 62 Summer and weekends are a challenge 63 Parking is not super easy, but it's also not that bad unless you are coming down at 7 on Saturday. 64 All the first blocks directly adjacent to carlsbad blvd until Garfield should have a 3 or 4 hour limit to encourage turnover and let more spots open up so ppl don't sit at the beach all day taking up neighborhood spots. 65 No parking meters this is a town a community and I want to be able to go support my local community stores w/out having to watch the Meter pay extra for parking and not just be able to enjoy my hometown 66 None at this time. 67 what is a study area 68 No parking structures please!!! 69 Don't want and large parking complexes in these areas. 70 The street parking need to be labeled so that people don't block other people's drive ways. 71 I'm concerned about having a multi story parking structure 72 No 73 Any plan should increase available parking to accommodate increases in visitors. 74 Carlsbad village has an abundance of bars and nightclubs yet no overnight parking for the party goers. In fact, people are not allowed to park in the village between certain hours. I believe not providing parking /overnight parking for intoxicated folks just promotes drinking and driving as people are more prone to drive for fear of having their car towed and impounded. This is increases the dangers of an accident or fatality being that more people are driving under the influence because they do not have a place to leave their cars. Thank you. Kim ley >>> Horn Jun 12, 2016 4:00PM Jun 12, 2016 3:28 PM Jun 12, 2016 2:05 PM Jun 12, 2016 7:29AM Jun 12, 2016 6:09AM Jun 12, 2016 5:19AM Jun 12, 2016 5:00AM Jun 12, 2016 4:33 AM Jun 12, 2016 3:32AM Jun 12, 2016 2:57AM Jun 12, 2016 2:38AM Jun 12, 2016 2:15AM Jun 12, 2016 12:30 AM Jun 11, 2016 11:59 PM Jun 11, 2016 11:45 PM Jun 11, 2016 11:32 PM Jun 11, 2016 9:34PM Jun 11, 2016 9:28PM Jun 11, 2016 9:27PM Jun 11, 2016 7:15 PM Page 1132 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P. R NC T 0 7 kLSaAD 75 There is no problem. Parking is just fine as is. I have family and friends that visit and they have no issues with parking. I think you the city think there's a problem and by creating this survey and letting residents think parking is an issue. It's not. Leave it alone. City staff need to stay out of this as well as the consultants. 76 Don't waste precious tax dollars on this non problem. 77 I do feel we need more parking that is centrally located in the village/barrio areas. Perhaps a parking structure which would provide lots of spaces in a limited square foot space. 78 Current street parking is usually over-crowded resulting in cars parked too close to intersections, difficult to pull out safely when driving through these intersections. 79 Don't want to have to pay for parking, bad enough we now have to pay to park at tamarack beach 80 It seems we have lost MANY parking spaces on State, between Grand and Village drive in the last 5 years- between the new restaurant street venues and use of the parking lot at Grand and State for "gathering"-makes it hard to shop down there. 81 STOP THE GROWTH! INFRASTRUCTURE, INFRASTRUCTURE, INFRASTRUCTURE! 82 Some parking is not well lit at night so I am reluctant to visit the area after dark. 83 I live a block and a half from tamarack beach. During the summer and on weekends it can be very hard to find parking on my street. 84 I really enjoy the fact that carlsbad doesn't charge for parking like in oceanside and that is why I spend my money in your town. 85 An accurate parking study must reflect the increased impact of summer visitors. 86 The parking along the coast should be addressed, to many places in the summer are taken by motorhomes. The height restrictions needed to be extended it is not safe you line of sight for joggers cyclist and pedestrians is severely limited. 87 Handicapped parking, I use a wheelchair 88 Please put a parking garage in the downtown Carlsbad village. There are two many people there and not enough parking. Plus parking on the busy streets isn't that safe. 89 None 90 No meters ever please It's the best part of the village 91 Parking spaces in the village are narrow. Difficult to load family in the car when cars on both sides. We have a mid-size SUV and 4 door sedan. 92 Yeah leave it 93 There should be more Peking lots available. With how congested and active the area is, people get impatient and pull up behind you on the main streets that it takes forever to pull out because the cars won't let you. Kimley >>>Horn · Jun 11, 2016 6:54PM Jun 11, 2016 6:50PM Jun 11, 2016 5:41 PM Jun 11, 2016 5:36 PM Jun 11, 2016 5:14 PM Jun 11, 2016 4:53 PM Jun 11, 2016 4:40 PM Jun 11, 2016 4:30PM Jun 11, 2016 3:55PM Jun 11, 2016 3:32PM Jun 11, 2016 2:02 PM Jun 11, 2016 1:43 PM Jun 11, 2016 11:46 AM Jun 11, 2016 6:56AM Jun 11, 2016 6:28AM Jun 11, 2016 5:39AM Jun 11, 2016 4:46AM Jun 11, 2016 4:32AM Jun 11, 2016 4:07AM Page 1133 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD Vll:LAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 94 Please keep it free to park, I love that it is free to go to the beach and the village in Carlsbad, that makes our city awesome! 95 Carlsbad tends to not have enough parking lot space at the malls. The only time I struggle for space in the village is near the 101 and sea wall. 96 Parking at the public beach should be free I Re: Tamarack beach 97 No 98 Don't close State Street. Get rid of tables in parking places, like Garcias. 99 The only challenges are during peak times for holidays and summer tourist dining times. And we know better, just as we do in any other beautiful city that we visit. 100 Problem with cars being parked longer than the designated and posted time limits. 101 Under ground parking is a necessity in Southern California. Not to disturb the view corridor. The view corridor is the essential part in owning property. You want to keep the view. Dig down to avoid obscene structures. 102 Unless there's an event such as the farmer's market or a race, I generally do not have problems parking anywhere in the zone. 103 Rv's and fifth wheels should not be allowed to park on Carlsbad Blvd, especially between tamarack and cannon. The beach along that stretch is rarely a quarter full because most of the parking in summer is clogged by rv's who park there from 5 am untillOpm. Even early in the mornings or evening I can park to walk my dog or take a run. It's ridiculous and infuriating. 104 When parking downtown, hard to find at lunch time and Wednesdays (Farmer's Market). Unless you want to walk many blocks, which all seniors can not dol 105 One of the main reasons we have chosen to live in Carlsbad because of the existing Village/Barrio/beach area. in 2015 we moved within Carlsbad to specifically be within walking distance. While some of the charm of the Village already seems to be slipping away with the addition of the live/shop/vacation buildings, our sincere hope is that future changes to the area allow the current charm to remain. No more tall buildings; no big, ugly parking structures. Old-time charm can not be maintained with those additions and all too soon Carlsbad will just be another beach city that looks exactly like all the others, crowded and overgrown. 106 Open up Chestnut train crossing. This will eliminate A LOT of cars. 107 There are signs that say 3 hour parking and they are not enforced so people that work in the area park all day long in these spots. 108 Even though I live here, I drive to all destinations in that area and never have a problem with parking. I have problems with our ugly on and off ramps at 5, homeless, lack of healthy places to eat, and a farmer's market that encourages high prices through restrictions competition. Wrong issue to tackle. 109 Yes what are the plans. Kim ley >>> Horn Jun 11, 2016 3:23AM Jun 11, 2016 2:57AM Jun 11, 2016 1:49AM Jun 11, 2016 1:27AM Jun 11, 2016 12:46 AM Jun 10, 2016 10:12 PM Jun 10, 2016 10:01 PM Jun 10, 2016 9:54PM Jun 10, 2016 9:32 PM Jun 10, 2016 8:17PM Jun 10, 2016 6:27PM Jun 10, 2016 5:48PM Jun 10, 2016 4:21PM Jun 10, 2016 3:01 PM Jun 10, 2016 2:55 PM Jun 10, 2016 9:37AM Page 1134 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA N II or R 6 D 110 I don't think a parking garage will enhance the village feel and look. 111 Very difficult to park diagonally on roads like State street. 112 Love that the parking is free and love the designated city lots of free village parking. 113 Where's the handicap parking? Seems to me it's far away from the businesses. Need to rethink this. 114 What did you do with all the in leau parking fees that were collected over the year7 There should be money to build additional parking lots or structures. 115 the new Carlsbad village lofts have 106 units with some that are 2 & 3 bedroom also retail space and a total of 130 parking spots??? not sure if that's going to work especially on the weekend when everyone has visitors at the beach 116 I think our parking lots are underutilized and that bigger signs might help people. 117 Carlsbad is to crowded. Keep the village the way it is just quit bringing in more people there's no room anywhere and traffic is horrendous! I! 118 Why doesn't the city planning dept require builders of apts/ condos/timeshares to provide enough parking for residents & their guests 119 We need more cross walks on State St. Grand to the roundabout, we have none 120 Village parking is too limited 121 Keep parking free 122 Please! I seriously don't think we need any concrete parking garages. I don't have too many issues with parking! Disabled parking, for my son, was a HUGE issue but you finally added some spaces on State St. It took forever, but at least you finally recognized the need or were you more afraid of a law suit? 123 how can we avoid an ugly, unnecessary parking structure in the village. Because we should. 124 No parking meters, please. Let's not ruin what we have special here in Carlsbad. Metering Tamarack Beach ruined the locals beach experience already. 125 Please consider the aesthetic impact and the idea of a walking village when thinking about parking 126 My biggest comment is in regards to paid parking. I, along with many others who frequent the Village, beach and Barrio are very against paying for parking. We were all very upset that Tamarack Beach required paid parking along with the village center of Knockout Pizza and Las Olas. Because of that, we never park in those lots and leave it for the tourists who don't understand our history and standing. 127 The last thing I would want to see is metered parking or a parking garage. We are a VILLAGE and need to keep that atmosphere. We are not LA JOLLA or downtown SD. Please listen to our voices. 128 Appreciate the free parking. More desirable to return to the Village. 129 I love that most parking is free. PLEASE do not change this. I know you can't do anything about the parking at Tamarack beach, but free parking elsewhere makes Carlsbad special and inviting. 130 Yes. Keep motorhomes off beach parking unless they purchase a parking permit fir two spots Kim ley>>> Horn Jun 10, 2016 6:36AM Jun 10, 2016 6:12AM Jun 10, 2016 4:35AM Jun 10, 2016 4:34AM Jun 10, 2016 4:26AM Jun 10, 2016 4:22AM Jun 10, 2016 4:11AM Jun 10, 2016 1:24AM Jun 10, 2016 12:51 AM Jun 10, 201612:49 AM Jun 9, 2016 11:54 PM Jun 9, 2016 11:33 PM Jun 9, 2016 11:25 PM Jun 9, 2016 11:09 PM Jun 9, 2016 10:03 PM Jun 9, 2016 9:56PM Jun 9, 2016 8:39 PM Jun 9, 2016 8:27PM Jun 9, 2016 5:59 PM Jun 9, 2016 5:30PM Jun 9, 2016 5:23 PM Page 1135 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA AR C/7 UF fARL L f, 131 In general there is always parking available within a short walk from my destination. We've lived here over 30 years and know of some less frequented parking areas as well. We also walk from the Barrio to downtown on many occasions. A smaller parking structure at the train station would provide a lot of extra parking during the day. 132 Definitely need more parking downtown and near beach and restaurants. 133 More lots are needed! 134 Stop over developing Carlsbad and parking will not be an issue. We don't have to add homes on ever piece of open land. 135 Personally, I think the city should add parking meters to the beach curb parking from Carlsbad Village Dr. To Palomar Airport Rd. We have a beautiful area and we get a lot of tourists who come to this city. However, it is part of our taxes, which are used to pay for services such as: cleaning up the beach, emptying the waste cans, and upkeep (e.g. removing burnt wood from illegal fires, charcoal graffiti on the walls, etc.). The revenue produced by the parking meters could go to services such as: meter/parking officers, additional traffic officers and/or beach patrol (bike/ATV detail}, etc. 136 NO Only too many hair salons with employees not using the parking lots and taking all the curb parking 137 The concern I have is that pro-development city leadership will use data collected from the parking study to justify higher density development, and parking structures in the village. Carlsbad needs to lay off the "visitor/tourist serving" expansion and development, and focus on the wishes of people who live here. 138 I normally stay away from Carlsbad Village during summer and over crowded tourist times. 139 If parking was to be restricted, or charged for, I would like to see those costs passed on to people from outside the area. If you live or work in the proposed area, where fees and restrictions are to be considered or placed, you should be able to get a sticker to place on your car making you exempt from fees and fines, while legally parked. 140 I am concerned that tall structures will be in this space. Being discreet is very important when adding parking structures and they don't have to be right on the coast either. We are happy to walk blocks to get to the beach. The ocean is worth the walk. I am also concerned about eroding the cliffs because of too much impact. 141 Better signage for bicycles!! And bring back parking on Carlsbad Village Drive!! Kimley >>>Horn Jun 9, 2016 1:57 PM Jun 9, 2016 1:47PM Jun 9, 2016 6:05AM Jun 9, 2016 2:24AM Jun 9, 2016 12:18 AM Jun 8, 2016 11:47 PM Jun 8, 201611:10 PM Jun 8, 2016 10:59 PM Jun 8, 2016 9:29 PM Jun 8, 2016 9:19 PM Jun 8, 2016 8:45 PM Page 1136 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA p CIT :J C hL5 AD 142 Parking structures are unsafe and impractical for families with children or strollers. They limit the ability to get in and out of a shop quickly. They are smelly and require security cameras or people. They allow thieves and criminals places to hide. They prevent vehicle owners from keeping an ear on their alarm, and keeping an eye on their car. Putting a Parking structure in the village would be bad for business, as we would not want to go through that hassle for just one short shopping trip. Putting a parking structure in a center and placing business around the external perimeter increases the need for walking around, and prevents shoppers from seeing other shops that might catch their eye across a courtyard. It would also be dangerous to have to use a perimeter sidewalk with small children who dart away near traffic curb. Street parking is more appealing. Open air parking like that if the coaster station is more desirable. 143 No 144 I think the residential areas on garfield street should be designed for resident parking only. The overflow of beach victors congests the streets. It makes it hard to come out of any of the side streets like Hemlock, jumiper, redwood. 145 I do not want high rise parking structures to ruin the village atmosphere. New construction needs to include parking. The number of units being built need to take parking into consideration .. .for example residents in the new units will have visitors ... For this reason density needs to be controlled. 146 What is the long-term parking relationship with the NCT parking areas? Why no business/economical shared parking agreements with private ownerships and/or Churches in the area? Why no parking management program for owners & employees in the Village? Why no Village courtesy bus to provide access to key parking lots and amenities? Bicycle promotion & ridership is not "THE SOLUTION" to the lack of parking spaces in the Village. 147 Study the parking during summer. There is never any parking close to the beach causing people to drive around looking for a space. And then you have to dodge people and bikers and it's frustrating. 148 The city should reduce Carlsbad Blvd from 4 lanes to 2 lanes between Tamarack and Cannon. It is a raceway and unsafe ... and all that extra pavement could be converted to angled parking to increase access to the beach. There is always plenty of parking within a block or so of my destination in the village. Even on State! And walking is good for me to get a little exercise. 149 the traffic is to congested ... especially on weekends ,summer ,holidays. 150 There is plenty of parking how about a pilot program where you guys fund a circulator bus down Roosevelt and up Carlsbad village past city hall 151 Keep beach parking free Kim ley >>> Horn Jun 8, 2016 8:34 PM Jun 7, 2016 8:37 PM Jun 7, 2016 12:05 AM Jun 6, 2016 6:14PM Jun 6, 2016 5:02PM Jun 5, 2016 3:19AM Jun 5, 2016 2:37AM Jun 5, 2016 1:34AM Jun 4, 2016 11:36 PM Jun 2, 2016 9:30PM Page 1137 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ro fjAD 1S2 Carlsbad Village drive should remain two lanes. If it becomes one lane it will slow traffic down. Especially when one is looking for a parking space. Parking spaces in the village can be tagged with a RFID type tag. That feed information back to an App. That one can use to find open parking spaces. This could help with traffic flow as drivers do not have to slow down to find a parking space. The parking at the Oak street that borders the railroad tracks, should be lit. At night it is very dark. Because of that people do not want to park there. 1S3 There are not enough red curbs at intersections. This means one has to edge out onto intersection and get yelled at, flipped off and almost cause an accident because folks are allowed to park on the edge of each corner and one cannot see if it's safe to cross. I've lived here for 16yrs, went to all the meetings, brought up this problem many, many, many times. Need to paint 30/40 ft of red paint at each intersection on all 4 corners. Some intersections in the Barrio are painted but NOT ENOUGH, need to do them all. Everybody knows this, it's been brought up for 16yrs that I've been attending all the STUPID MEETINGS and for 16yrs the city of Carlsbad has accomplished NOTHING, ZERO, NADAl II I have quit all the meetings because NOTHING gets done. The city is so political, bound in red tape, and incompetent that it can't even paint some curbs red!!!!!!! 1S4 Curbs need to be painted to prevent parking on corners near the beach. Signs need to prevent parking on certain days for street sweeping. 1SS Central Parking lots in the Downtown village are way over due. The parking lot across from 83 degrees and the lot just before Grand on Roosevelt should become at least 3 high multi level structures. The down town area has long outgrown the single level parking lot approach. 1S6 Do not allow gated parking. Make sure there is adequate visited parking and additional spaces for residential with three bedrooms or more. 1S7 The apartments should have designated parking spots for all their tenants & use them. They should not use on street parking. 1S8 There is not enough parking in this area 1S9 Please do not cater to the few small businesses who insist there be more parking directly adjacent to their business. More centralized lots would be ok, to accomodate the growth of the village. Also I find this to be a VERY generic, and VERY short survey 160 No 161 A favor to ask of the planning team: Please remember whatever the solution(s) that are proposed and/or adopted, that Carlsbad is a destination to many who visit us every year, but is home to many who live here every day. Do not turn the Carlsbad Village, Barrio & beach area into what downtown Huntington Beach has become ... an large outdoor mall with a complete lack of an identity. Thank you!:) 162 I don't like the idea of having a large parking garage in the village. 163 There is plenty of parking. We need more people walking! Kimley >>>Horn Jun 1, 2016 4:03 PM Jun 1, 2016 2:33 PM Jun 1, 2016 2:38AM Jun 1, 2016 12:28 AM Jun 1, 2016 12:27 AM May 31, 2016 10:S2 PM May 31, 2016 9:02 PM May 31, 2016 8:16PM May 31, 2016 8:14PM May 31, 2016 7:S4 PM May 31, 2016 7:S2 PM May 31, 2016 7:08PM Page 1138 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA f P NC S I OF Cl\hl D 164 There needs to be a better signed and closer locations for beach goers to park. They won't walk as far as the Coaster Parking. Could the Church and Time Square (behind Las Olas) parking lots be subsidized and then restricted to beach parking?? 165 I request that more parking is made available during special events (i.e. where parking is not permitted or limited during certain hours, open it up to the public-if you're going to close down streets, you can change the no parking parameters for one day unless it affects emergency vehicles). 166 Ocean st is a disaster waiting to happen. People leave there doors open, walk baby carriages in the middle of the street, bicycles, drive to fast, no place to park, very narrow street, everything on Ocean st is not conducive to safety ............ 167 I think the parking lot by surf ride should be closed after 10 pm . No overnight sleeping in cars. I live next to this and people sleep in cars EVERY NIGHT! campers, cars ... They pee first thing in the morning. I can see it from my kitchen. Limit RV's from parking overnight on streets. They take up too much room and there is ALWAYS one parked in front of my house. 168 Please think long-term. Within the next 10 years, with driverless cars, there will be decreased need to own a car Uust summon a car when needed), thereby reducing the need for more parking. Also, putting in more protected bike and walking lanes (check out Redondo Beach, near the beach where they have separated these areas from the cars) encourages people to safely use alternative transportation. Think of maybe using decomposed granite (DG) rather than putting in more paved parking or structures, as DG can easily be transformed into other things later on and is more environmentally friendly. Think of increasing pedestrian only areas and increase public transportation (make it cheap or free) rather than building more parking areas. 169 the village is very crowded during the summer and weekends-I have to time my trips for shopping and dining in the village because of parking issues. There is not enough parking in the village right now and the streets become grid locked during the day with cars as people are circling looking for parking spaces. Parking garages will be necessary (as they have done in La Jolla Village) especially near the center of the village where dining and shopping are centered. also-time limits should be a factor as people will want to use parking to go to the beach but then you have people who want a few (at least 3) hours to shop and dine so there is a problem. You can't have a two hour parking and expect to be able to dine and then perhaps shop .... maybe parking stickers for residents for street parking and metered for tourists? 170 No 171 Although I want sufficient parking, I am NOT in favor of large parking structures in the Village. 172 There is no need for more parking and I want to keep Carlsbad a small Village and as a resident I do NOT want high density buildings. Mayor Hall and Councilman Packard need to recuse themselves from any input for the Village/Barrio plan since they both own property there. 173 It feels like the parking situation is already bad, and further development of the village would make it worse. Projects like The Wave will hurt us more. Kimley >>>Horn May 31, 2016 6:55 PM May 31, 2016 6:46 PM May 31, 2016 6:44 PM May 31, 2016 6:43 PM May 31, 2016 1:47PM May 30, 2016 4:32PM May 27, 2016 8:35 PM May 27, 2016 2:39AM May 26, 2016 10:58 PM May 26, 2016 3:00PM Page 1139 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA FOI\ u 17 OF A L_ 174 The City should already know there is NOT enough parking. And should be considering parking when they approve new businesses such as at the former El Corral Pottery site. What did the last parking study find and what has been done to address issues from the study already conducted and paid for by tax payers? There was some discussion of a shuttle I trolley as part of Prop A. A shuttle that makes frequent circuits thru- out this area would significantly mitigate worrying about parking close, or perhaps parking at all, for those living here and who could leave their car home if a shuttle would conveniently take them close. 175 At busy times, difficult to find any parking and I either do not travel to area or find another way(bike). Parking by beach difficult in mornings at north end of trail 176 I am a Carlsbad resident and try to use local businesses. Over the last 5 years I have found it more of a hassle, parking and traffic wise, to use businesses in the Village. Also some areas are dark at night so I don't feel safe. 177 Parking is a huge challenge during peak season. 178 I'm concerned about over development and density with the new projects going in. I'm also concerned about tourists and timeshare users disproportionally effecting access and parking. 179 My bank, grocery store, post office, etc. are in the Village. My friends live by the beach. Traffic is always much worse from end of May to Sept. Your survey is flawed, the questions create misleading answers by limiting the options. I will be at public meeting, for sure. 180 I don't believe that there is a need for additional parking in the Village nor Barrio. 181 That area needs a park n' ride tram/shuttle with several separate parking/pick-up areas. 182 Parking is never a problem ... however, with all the building of residential, and the Marriott, i can see where there might start being a problem ... lf all the growth wasn't occurring, no problem ... do not want a parking structure!!!! that does not fit in with Carlsbad's "small beach community feel" 183 I currently do not have any problems with parking in the Village. If we do not overdevelop the area we will not need any more parking structures. 184 I love that there is free parking. I brag about that to everyone I know. NO meters!!! 185 We need a parking garage in the Village! 186 As a barrio resident,homeowner, and landlord -we strongly DO NOT want to be folded into the Village's "parking in lieu" plan. It sounds like a mess, and where have all the inlieu $gone to all these yrs? Certainly not the barrio. Too many curbs are painted red without good reason. It's a bad idea to mess around with the streets and make it hard to drive down State St to get to the train station to catch a train. It's an ESPECIALLY BAD IDEA to cram a fully functioning neighborhood, village, and beach town with high density housing and timeshares with elevator schemes and create a big problem where there is not one to start with ! ! ! ! Kim ley>>> Horn May 26, 2016 12:14 AM May 25, 2016 9:23 PM May 25, 2016 9:22PM May 25, 2016 7:18AM May 25, 2016 12:46 AM May 24, 2016 7:42 PM May 24, 2016 6:54 PM May 24, 2016 5:41 PM May 24, 2016 5:37PM May 24, 2016 5:08 PM May 24, 2016 4:38 PM May 24, 2016 3:00PM May 24, 2016 2:38AM Page 1140 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA f'u_.u OR r 0 R 187 We make other plans of it takes too long to find parking near the area we are visiting. Often if we cannot find parking we take our business and money to Oceanside where we find parking more easily. 188 Please stop increasing density, creating mixed use zoning, and granting parking variances. The city officials are creating a parking problem. Please do not build parking structures. They are not attractive in a quaint village like ours. Why does the mayor & city council want to enrich themselves with these projects near the property they own, at the expense of ALL residents of Carlsbad? Isn't this an illegal and immoral conflict of interest? 189 Yes, we do not need trenching since that will obliterate the parking lot for the train. We do not need multi unit time shares or condos, and do not want a multi use commercial/residential there. 190 Stop the WAVE project 191 The recent profusion of high-density housing projects currently being approved by the City Council will have a negative impact on access to parking. Slowing down approval of these plans and making sure they include sufficient parking. Increasing bus and Coaster services before any more high density housing is approved would be prudent. Some of the property slated for development is owned by 2 members of the City Council and the Carlsbad citizens needs should be considered before those of the Council members. At public meetings (Oty Council and Planning Commission) members of the City govt have acknowledged that parking is a problem currently in Carlsbad, but no one seems to addressing the issue. Approving a General Plan without completing a complete study of the need for parking and legitimate solutions seems to be putting the cart before the horse. 192 I believe our parking situation in the Village and Barrio areas is fine, as long as we adhere to slow, reasonable growth. Our tone-deaf mayor is pushing through developments (such as the dreaded "Wave" on Sate St.) that this area is not equipped for. Public transport options--Coaster and bus service--should be increased before any further high-density development continues. I'm aware that Mayor Hall and Councilman Packard own many properties in the subject areas, and I believe reckless development is a way for them to enrich themselves at the expense of the true character of this area. 193 I don't see any problems. I like the way things are currently .. 194 I never have a problem finding parking. The mid block parking is usually only halffull. 195 As a 26 yr resident, I have not found parking to be a problem in the Village nor Barrio. Beach parking can be difficult only in summer due to tourism 196 Lack of parking in front of zero lot line businesses/residences is horrible. When parking is available behind, it holds few cars and the space is so tight. This survey was useless, because it didn't ask any specific questions. Parking for new building on NW corner of CBD and Harding is awful. Same with SE corner of Las Flores and Madison. Structures must provide parking lots. Street parking is insufficient. Kim ley>>> Horn May 24, 2016 1:07 AM May 24, 2016 1:03AM May 24, 2016 12:27 AM May 24, 2016 12:19 AM May 23, 2016 11:00 PM May 23, 2016 10:59 PM May 23, 2016 10:44 PM May 23, 2016 10:42 PM May 23, 201610:37 PM May 23, 2016 10:30 PM Page 1141 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 01\ T D 197 There isn't enough parking now and I can't imagine how bad it is going to be with your intention of adding more people to our town. 198 The city's revised General Plan calls for too much density which will alter parking. I do not currently think there is a parking issue in the study area. Even on holidays, big event like the Street Fair, etc, we can usually find adequate parking in a reasonable amount of time. If we continue to build high density housing and mixing use buildings, parking will become an unbearable problem. No projects should be approved prior to an adequate parking plan in place to support them!!! 199 Parking in the Study Area is more than adequate. It will only become an issue if the area is over-developed going forward. I am certain our city leaders will not pursue a path that would favor development over the realistic expectations of the residents. 200 The availability of parking obviously changes depending on the season so it would be good to have ample parking that allow for easy access even during the summer. 201 a lot of growth is expected and parking is needed to accommodate that growth. 202 Need more bike parking and bike lanes. Rnish the rail trail. Trench the tracks 203 I have always found parking exceptduring the street fair. I will not park in a pa rking structure and do not want one in the village. 204 The questions regarding difficulty in finding parking, day and time are not reflective of the time of year. Summer parking is a game changer, becoming impossible to find parking. 205 It needs to be coupled with a circulating trolley. My gosh, plenty of small cities inCA have invested in shuttle trolleys to keep people from using their cars for short trips within the city. I used a free shuttle to get from a BART station in Oakland/Berkeley to the AMTRAK Station in Emeryville. Most riding the EmoryGoRound were actully employees going to work in their city center. At least consider a trolley/shuttle and maybe include Terra mar in the affected area. Even including the Poinsettia Coaster Station in the loop. My wife and I as retirees would certainly buy a yearly pass for up to $20 if it was free from that point on. The Sheraton has even invested in a shuttle/trolley for daily trips to the beach and Village. 206 We walk or bike ride during summer because of tourist. Stop this high density building. That will destroy our Village. It is not a town. That will make parking horrible! Take a breath city council! Slow Down! 207 I will NOT pay for parking in the Village. I will go somewhere else. I live as close to the Village as to Encinitas. Kimley>>>Horn May 23, 2016 10:23 PM May 23, 2016 10:16 PM May 23, 2016 9:29 PM May 23, 2016 9:17PM May 23, 2016 9:12PM May 23, 2016 9:08PM May 23, 2016 9:08 PM May 23, 2016 8:56 PM May 23, 2016 8:41PM May 23, 2016 8:31 PM May 23, 2016 8:25 PM Page 1142 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA F ~G T D\' OR or: Afi 8 D 208 I don't have too many problems parking in the Village now. Parking is fine. However, if more behemoth overly dense projects like The Wave are built, with 4 stories, 10 condos, 13 timeshares, plus retail all picked in a 1/4 acre lot, soon there will be no parking. I do not want a bunch of parking structures as 1} I am sure you will charge for such--city revenue after all, and 2} they are not very safe. I really dislike parking in the Oceanside one they have by their City Hall due to security worries. Also, allowing these developers to simply fatten your wallet with "in lieu of" fees, and they don't have to provide parking to their residents and businesses, creates a huge problem for all of us. Dr. Packard's building was about to be turned into another monstrosity-and there is a place that serves autistic kids and young adults, adjacent. Parking there is a bit tight now, but it would be unbearable with that huge project, as I believe they were allowed 'in lieu of". Glad the project fell through. I also am shocked that "lift parking" is going to be allowed. You and I both know that the timeshare people will park in the street, not in the buildling. I am also keenly aware that Mayor Hall and Councilman Packard own large amounts of property in the Village and stand to benefit immensely from all this extra development. I will be sure that is made as public as possible. 209 concerned it is getting worse My clients are elderly! Will you buy me a bike? 210 Would you consider the fact that having so many developments in a small town is taking away from the nature of the town and causes the residents problems? 211 I don't think this is a priority issue for the city. I think controlling expansion is and making more of town pedestrian friendly so that people leave their cars at home is 212 STOP with the high density buildings. If the property cannot hold enough cars for its residents/customers, go smaller!! We need our growth slow and low!!! Just because the city council are developers, that isn't in the best interest of our city. What is Matt hall planning to do with all his properties on Tyler?? 213 Often difficult to find parking space in lots and on-street, especially during peak tourism times. 214 If the city didn't allow extremely high-density developments like the proposed Wave in the neighborhood, we wouldn't even need to have this discussion. First, increase and improve public transportation (e.g., trenching and double-tracking rail and increasing Coaster and bus service}. Then we can discuss high-density development and needs for parking from that. Kimley >>>Horn May 23, 2016 8:20 PM May 23, 2016 8:01 PM May 23, 2016 7:22 PM May 23, 2016 7:17PM May 23, 2016 6:47PM May 23, 2016 6:45PM May 23, 2016 6:17PM Page 1143 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA UD. tOR I ._ I 215 Finding a parking space is always biggest challenge! Not in study area much on week ends. Dislike idea of backing into parking space on one way street! 216 enforcement of drivers stopping for pedestrians-the crosswalk on Grand bet State and Roosevelt. More bicycle friendly areas in village-scary to ride on CBV drive, scary to ride on Garfield, scary to ride on Tamarack. Fear factor is what prevents me from riding bicycle more often, time factor is issue for walking to Village. I always walk to the beach. Intersection at Tamarack and Garfield is a challenge for drives and pedestrians alike. At night headlights from eastbound traffic blinds the westbound left turn driver turning onto Garfield - inadequate lighting, no place for pedestrians. Maybe no parking at that corner to allow more visibility. Make walking and biking safe! 217 The survey only allows one choice to pick and also non of above is not an option. You should allow for comments on every category. I think the city needs to complete this year long study before any village I Barrio plan is up for vote. Carlsbad needs to slow down redeveloping and listen to the citizens. The building of high density building is going to be a problem for all citizens. Please listen to the majority ofthe voters and slow down development .... 218 There have been many times when we could not find a convenient parking spot and opted to leave and go to another restaurant outside of the area. 219 Do not install parking meters. We like Carlsbad the way it is. We do not want to become Newport Beach with meters. 220 Thank you for the opportunity to comment. My main concern is the parking lot at the south end of Ocean St. that serves walkers and beach goers, as well as customers for Harbor fish cafe and Offshore surf shop. The parking lot has been shrunken east to west width wise to accommodate for a beachside walkway. The parking lot has also had its individual spaces shrunken width wise. Neither work. There are now many accidents and it is difficult to park there due to these changes. Additionally, I have seen plans for a building being proposed that will take more room and parking spaces away from the parking lot. It is said to possibly offer a cafe and beach rentals business while blocking the parking lot view form the park. None of these are need and the idea is counterintuitive to the city's vision of not blocking any view of the ocean, not taking away more parking, and helping supporting local businesses, two of which (Harbor fish cafe and Offshore surf shop) already serve these needs at this area. Do Not make the same mistakes of those who brought the Bars to the beach and Do follow those who fought to remove those bars and install a park with open view and easy access for all to enjoy. Thank you. 221 We live about 3 miles inland from downtown. We go downtown to dine and shop. If I can't find a nearby parking space quickly (after driving around for 5+ minutes) we give up and go elsewhere or go home. We don't go to places where parking is an issue. I do not like to have to park in a lot that is many blocks from my destination. I am unhappy that Carlsbad allows Park In Lieu fees which reduces street parking. Kimley >>>Horn May 23, 2016 2:54 PM May 22, 2016 4:58 PM May 21, 2016 8:28PM May 21, 2016 8:07 PM May 21, 2016 8:00PM May 21, 2016 6:20 PM May 21, 2016 5:31 PM Page 1144 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA uo ro J c LS D 222 We need a people mover--trolley bus or monorail --to connect concentrated parking near freeways-- Tamarack, CBVDrive, etc. --with merchants in the Village, Westfield mall, and in a re-envisioned barrio area. 223 There are some "parking" spaces that are too small for a car (except a Smart car) but the curb is not painted red. Some people park in these spots and make it impossible for home owners to get into their driveways. While I am sensitive to the limited, available street parking, the city should consider marking locations that are unrealistic for any car parking. 224 Instead of parallel parking along the roads, why not make diagonal parking spaces, as they do in some parts of Encinitas on the 101. 225 There is no street lighting on Redwood and sidewalk is uneven so it is dangerous after dark. Also so many beach users park on my street it is almost always hard to find parking so your survey questions are not getting an accurate response. Also, frequent street closures for marathons etc exacerbate the difficulties. 226 Parking lots in general in all new developments in the last 5 years have to few spots and then the spots are to small for a full size car and the access lanes are to narrow. 227 When approving new development be sure parking and ALL infrastructure is considered. Why not promote The Coaster, have a Oty shuttle bus using Plaza Camino Real as The Parrking Lot. 228 We need more parking lots or parking structures. 229 This is quite literally one of the worst created surveys I have ever come across. Your first question is BIASED-- as you don't have a location for citizens and residents of Carlsbad to enter so you lump them into VISITOR. Nice try. Your results are completely invalid from question 1. Then you go on to ask loaded questions that will not give you any usable information. Look at question 7--you asked for a negative answer that will prove you need parking lots etc, but you didn't give an option for "no challenges" thus you can only come up with issues. You should be ashamed of yourselves for creating such a stupid--yes, stupid--survey. Throw out the results, consult with a statistician who knows how to ask questions and start over! 230 Beach parking should continue to be by annual pass or daily rate. 231 My husband and I, long-time Carlsbad residents, used to go to Frazee almost every single day after work to play ball at the beach. But for the last several years, we go to Oceanside beaches instead because it is easier to park. We go to Buccaneer, the pier area or up to Harbor where parking is always available. I think that the parking spots at Frazee are taken before anyone has a chance to nail one because the hotel people and the rental tourists in that area take up all of the parking. It is impossible to park and go to Frazee. We have no access whatsoever to that beach. We do go to Tamarack. Kim ley >>> Horn May 21, 2016 5:21 PM May 21, 2016 5:11PM May 21, 2016 4:11PM May 21, 2016 3:49PM May 21, 2016 3:44 PM May 21, 2016 3:31 PM May 21, 2016 2:16PM May 21, 2016 2:04 PM May 21, 2016 1:22 PM May 21, 2016 8:56AM Page 1145 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P Rl . FOn [ 0 C D 232 The City has been allowing new developments to build out, have fewer on-site parking. As a result, (especially new) residents use public street as their regular parking spots. I remember going to the public hearing of the low-income housing project on Roosevelt years ago, only to learn the city council approved to reduce (instead of increase) planned parking spots. The townhouse development Seagrove only has TWO visitor parking spots for the entire property. Same story for the new townhouse (?) on Laguna Drive. Each unit has only two parking spots (incl. garage). And many are three bedroom units. I can just imagine mos of them with 3 cars or have visitors would constantly park on street. It's not too late to enforce all residential and business to have plenty of parking spots. Also, just like many well-run cities (San Francisco, Pasadena etc). Carlsbad should start enforcing "No overnight street parking" or mandatory "no parking on this side of street every other morning" etc. to discourage people from parking on the street. 233 I would like to see large vehicles (campers, RVs,etc.) be prohibited from parking on the street within the study area. Thst includes Carlsbad Village Blvd. 234 The coaster needs more parking. 235 The city needs a larger public parking lot. 236 Ocean Rd needs sidewalks on both sides to keep people from walking in the street around cars. 237 During the weekend, especially in the summer, there are huge RV's and similar vans that take up ALL the beach front space. This is very frustrating, they park on Friday afternoon and don't leave until later on Sunday 238 Stop our self-serving idiot and crook city council members from pushing the construction of over-sized private parking lots, and allowing business and new construction to circumvent parking requirements in exchange for a fee. The village plan is a monstrosity. 239 Finding a parking spot near the beach is almost impossible during the summer. All the RVs that are taking up most of the space makes it worse. Why does the city allow this? City should restrict RVs to a specific area NOT the entire stretch of Carlsbad Blvd. 240 Hemlock/Garfield is my cross street. Most of the time (but especially on weekends and during the summer) people park right up to the corner and it is very difficult to see onto Garfield and make a safe turn. This is true of all ofthe Garfield cross streets. 241 The Carlsbd Village and Barrio master plan should be postponed until the parking study is completed. 242 My concern has to do with trying to cross the street as a pedestrian when trucks/cars are parked at the corner. I cannot see unless I get out in the middle of the street and it's very dangerous for an older person to creoss. 243 Please do not implement any paid parking or parking meters. Timed parking may be a good idea to consider, but only in the areas expecting high turnover (near businesses, not near the beach). Kimley >>>Horn May 21, 2016 7:40AM May 21, 2016 7:03AM May 21, 2016 4:00 AM May 21, 2016 3:49 AM May 21, 2016 3:48AM May 21, 2016 3:03 AM May 21, 2016 2:31 AM May 21, 2016 2:11AM May 21, 2016 1:24AM May 21, 2016 1:24AM May 21, 2016 1:23AM May 20, 2016 11:37 PM Page 1146 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA I OP T Ll 0 D 244 If you put in additional lots, would there be a charge to use them? If additional lots are considered, what are some possible locations? How will the new parking considerations affect my daily parking situation? 245 Would be great to have hybrid and electric car parking and to have electric car plug in stations. Carlsbad needs to Keep up with technology. 246 Used to work in this area. Our office did not have enough on site parking and we had to use the street. It is a bad idea to allow more residential or commercial to be built without adaquate on site parking. Also village is already walkable ONCE you get there by car. 247 Could use more police presence. Like a lot of places in California, the homeless are increasingly more aggressive and numerous. Also crime and drug use is increasing. 248 The City should purchase an empty lot on the east side of Ocean Street just south of Beech for public beach parking, restrooms, showers and green space. 249 I live in the village have two cars and only one off street parking space. sometimes park a block away. I lived in oceanside and they built 3/4 story parking lots, seems like a good idea 250 As long as you don't build parking structures in our beautiful town, I may support a parking plan. Otherwise, I'm happy walking. Carlsbad residents enjoy the walk 251 Questions 1. What parking options are currently being considered? 2. What parking options were considered but eliminated? Concerns 1. The density of the parking solution should be commensurate with the throughput capabilities of the ingress and egress routes to avoid major traffic issues. 252 So many banks in the village with empty parking lots. 253 I would like state street to be pedestrianized. I would be more likely to dine there if there was a no-traffic area similar to what we have on farmers market days. 254 Roosevelt street lacks signage with parking rules, making if difficult to find appropriate parking 255 As a 50+ year resident of Carlsbad, I am totally AGAINST any effort to reduce vehicular traffic in the study area. I personally don't care about providing anything for bikers or walkers and I never will. 256 Commuters and employees take up most of the one street parking all day as no enforcement of the 3 hour parking signage 257 One of the things I love about the Carlsbad Village is that you do not have to pay to park. This is a very attractive feature for guests/visitors to the area. Kim ley>>> Horn May 20, 2016 10:49 PM May 20, 2016 4:50PM May 20, 2016 3:34PM May 19, 2016 11:53 PM May 19, 2016 4:13 PM May 19, 2016 1:34 PM May 19, 2016 4:38AM May 19, 2016 3:56AM May 19, 2016 2:00AM May 18, 2016 11:47 PM May 18, 2016 9:37 PM May 18, 2016 7:57 PM May 18, 2016 6:55 PM May 18, 2016 5:57PM Page 1147 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA J 258 I think parking standards need to be relaxed fro businesses in Village so we reduce the glut of beauty shops and add a mix of shops including new restaurants. I don't think adding density will make the village nicer; it will negatively impact parking for residents of this city and hurt businesses I like to use in the Village. I'll avoid if no parking. Please support businesses in the village. 259 We usually park one car in our driveway and one in the street in front of the house. Parking is usually manageable by our house but becomes very difficult with any events in the downtown area. Adding increased density without sufficient on site parking will directly affect my property and likely change the currently ok parking situation to near impossible. 260 I own rental property on anchor way, i am concerned with development bringing in parkers from other development no related tp norma residential neighborhood activity 261 crossing Carlsbad Blvd. and the railroad tracks. 262 Will you study Parking in the residential Barrio area when demand is at it's peak .... between the hours of 6 pm and 5 am? 263 The city should enforce the three hour parking in the Village. 264 Why do I get the feeling that no matter what anyone says you (ie Hall and City Council) are going to do whatever you damn well please 265 hello Kim ley >>> Horn May 18, 2016 1:24PM May 17, 2016 4:32PM May 17, 2016 5:45AM May 16, 2016 11:06 PM May 16, 2016 4:52 PM May 16, 2016 4:24 PM May 15, 2016 1:57AM May 12, 2016 11:01 PM Page j148 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA 0 1R (/f'IG TUDY FOR THE Cl Y Or c. '\RLSU,. D Appendix E-Parking Data Collection Legend Study Area Boundaries Barno Neighborhood Beach Area Village Neighborhood Parking Facilities On-Street N -Off-Street (Public) ! -Off-Street (Private) Jl4. Kimley >>>Horn Parking Inventory 0 0125 025 05 --==:::::lii-===-----Molos Page 1149 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Occupancy Maps May Weekday Parking Occupancy {9 a.m.) Legend 0 Pubhclot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kimley >>>Horn .. .. _ M "'· ! q ! •.. .,. .. . ~ •.. •.. . ~· ·~ .( j .. o•-==o=1•2s.._c:=::oiil25-----•o.t;~es Sources Esri HERE. DeLorme USGS lnlermap. increment P Corp NRCAN. Esro , MeTI. Esn China (Hong Kong), Eori (Thailand), Tom Tom. Mapmylndia, Cl and the GIS U..,. Page 1150 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA STUDI fOR THE TY OF c '\RL_bAD May Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy (1 p.m .) Legend c:J Publiclot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kimley >>>Horn .,_..,..,.,., llll"O.HA·• . ~ ....... , .. C.-lsbad j . 0~--==0=.1-25--~=0~.2·5 ............. 0.5 • Miles Sources Esn HERE Delorme USGS lntormap. rncrement P Corp . NRCAN, Esn Japan. METI, Esn Chooa (Hong Kong). Esn (Tt18oland) TomTom. Mapmylndoa, C OpenStree!Map conlnbutors, and the GIS User Communoty Page 1151 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA TUD I l-OR THE C I OF C 1RL 13 D May Weekday Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) Legend c:J Public lot CJ Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% -76-90% -91+% Kim ley>>> Horn N A ....... "' Corlsbad ~·· 0~ ~·· .... • .... o. o~~==o~.1-2s-.~=oi.2•s .......... _.o.s • Miles Sources· E6ll HERE: Delorme. USGS, lntermap, oncremenl P Corp . NRCAN, Esro Japan, METI, Esro Chtna (Hong Kong), Esn (Thailand) TOmTom Mapmylndia, Q OpenStree!Map oontrobu1ors. and the GIS User Page 1152 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA n <lNG STUD ITY OF CAPL 0 May Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) Legend c:J Publiclot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kim ley>>> Horn N A •.. ., ... •.. ,. .. Carlsbad .... (.~ 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --===--==-------Miles Sources Esn. HERE. Del cnne, USGS. lnlormap. u>crement P Corp NRCAN Esro Japan. METI Esro Chtna (Hong Kong). Esn (Thatland) Tom rom Mapmylndta C> contnbutors. and the GIS User Page 1153 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA ~ CING STUDY l-OR THE .If, OF <.ARL c/\0 May Weekend Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) Legend 0 Publiclot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) -0.50% -51-75% -76-90% -91+% Kim ley>>> Horn N A 0 0.125 Stutlotdlil' 0.25 •.. o•, ¥ ... "' ..• Carhbad ,.,. . .... 0.5 --===--c::::::::::JI ______ MIIes Sources Esri HERE. Delorme USGS, lntermap. tncremenl P Corp . NRCAN Esn METI E.,. Chtna (Hong Kong), Esn (Thatland). TomTom, Mapmylndta, 0 C<>rltnbutors and the GIS User Page 1154 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA r IN6 ... TUDY FOR THE ClfY OF CI\RL-vAD May Weekend Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.} Legend CJ Public lot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) -()..50% -51-75% -76·90% -91+% Kimley>>>Horn N A L.lp•• Ot •" -t•~ .. •• ~·· c. •.. 0~ Carlsbad llau•o. 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --===--==-------Miles Sources Esn, HERE DeLorme, USGS, lntermap, oncrement P Corp., NRCAN, Esn Japan. MET!, Esro China (Hong Kong), Esri (Thaoland). TomTom, Mapmylndra, contributors. and the GIS Uset Page 1155 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA Ak INC. S UDY FOR THE Cl f OF AFiL A.D July Weekday Parking Occupancy {9 a.m.) Legend r=:JPublic l ot CJ Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) -0-50% -51-75% -76-90% -91+% Kimley >>>Horn ~· ,;• .. N A ..... ~· 0 ... ., .. Corhbad •.. o•~ •.. .... . .. ;; j 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --===--=::::::11------Miles Sources. Esri. HERE. DeLorme USCS.Intermap. onerement P Corp .. NRCAN. Esn Japan. METI, Esri Chona (Hong Kong). Esri (Thailand). Mapmylndia, . and the GIS User Page 1156 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA r R. lNG S 1 UD Y FOr< THE IT f OF CARL OAD July Weekday Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) Legend c:J PublicLot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kimley >>>Horn N A 0~ ~·· •.. ,.-· .. 't 0 0.125 0 25 0.5 •-===--=::::i _____ __.MIIes Soorces Eso. HERE DeLorme. USGS. lntermap oncrement P Corp. NRCAN, Esn Japan. METI, Esri China (Hong Kong). E.sri (Thaolond). TomTom. Mapmylndia. C> OpenStreetMap contnbutO<S. and the GIS User Page 1157 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA rOR THE July Weekday Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.} Legend CJ Public l ot c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kimley>>>Horn N A. ltraUgrd lft Carlsbad 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 .. ~==~ .. c=~ ............. Mi~ Sources· Eon HERE, Delonne USGS, lntermap rncrement P Corp , NRCAN, Esn Japan. METI Esn Chrna (Hong Kong), Esn (Thailand) Tom Tom Mapmylndra, Q OpenS~tMap contnbutors. and !he GIS Use< Page 1158 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PI R. l/G STUDY 0 H rt OF C RL r!JAD July Weekday Parking Occupancy (11 p.m.) Legend c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (11 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kimley >>>Horn N A .. · ., .. 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --===--===:J _____ Miles Sources Esn, HERE, Delorme USGS lntermap, 1ncrement P Corp . NRCAN, Esn Japan. METI. Esn Chona (Hong Kong). Esn (Thaoland), Mapmylndoa. C> OpenSireetMap contributors and the GIS User Commvn.ty Page 1159 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA PARKIN& STUD, fOW THE IT f 0 C \RL cAD July Weekend Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) Legend O Public lot c::J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (9 a.m.) -0-50% 0 Stu.tloutlft 0.125 0.25 Carlsbad 0.5 -51-75% --===--=::::~~ ______ Miles -76-90% -91+% Kimley>>>Horn N A Sources. Esri. HERE, Delorme USGS, Esn Japan METI. Esri Chona (Hong Kong). Esn COpenStreetMap oontnbtotors. and the GIS Page I 160 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA P 1.</Nu STUiJY 1-0d f-IE I fOr July Weekend Parking Occupancy (lp.m.) Legend CJ Public l ot c::J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (1 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kim ley >>> Horn N A C.lsbad 0~ •.. 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 .. ~==~ .. c=~ ............. Mi~ Sources Esrl, HERE, Delorme. USGS. lntermap Increment P Corp NRCAN, Esn Japan METI. Esn Chtna (Hong Kong), EM (Thailand) Tom Tom. Mapmylndla, ~ OpenStreetMap contnbutors and the GIS User Commun.ly Page 1161 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA July Weekend Peak Parking Occupancy (7p.m.) Legend c:J Publicl ot CJ Study Area Boundary Parcels Peak Parking Occupancy (7 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kim ley >>> Horn N A o~.c=o=.1•2s._~=0 .• 2s-. ......... o.s • MileS Sources Eso. HERE. Delorme, USGS lntermop. 1naement P Corp. NRCAN, Esn Japan. METt Esn Ch•na (Hong Kong). Esn (Thailand). Mapmylndia C OpenStreetMap comnbutors and tne GIS Page 1162 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA July Weekend Parking Occupancy (llp.m.) Legend c:J Study Area Boundary Parcels Parking Occupancy (11 p.m.) -0-50% -51-75% 76-90% -91+% Kim ley>>> Horn N A. lh"""" Pt lotiO.HA•• ..... .,. Carlsbad 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 --===--==-----Miles Sources Esn HERE Delorme USGS lntermap .ncrement P Corp • NRCAN. Esn Japan. MET! Esn Chona (Hono Kono). Esn (Thaoland). Mapmylndoa. C> OpenStreetMap contributors and the GIS User Communtty Page 1163 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA .AR TH I. Occ.Jpancy Figures and Table~ May Weekday Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Barrio 50% -village 40% > -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% 9a.m. 1 p.m. 7p.m. May Weekend Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Barrio 50% -village 40% -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% 9a.m. 1p.m. 7p.m. Kim ley>>> Horn Page 1164 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA H May Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type July Weekday Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Barrio 50% -Village 40% -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% 9a.m. 1 p.m. 7p.m. llp.m. Kim ley >>> Horn Page 1165 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE , BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA c ro D July Weekend Parking Occupancy by Neighborhood 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% -Barrio 50% -Village 40% -Beach Area 30% 20% 10% 0% Morning Afternoon Evening Late Night July Weekday and Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type 50% 57% 53% Wee 52% 57% 38% Weekend 20% 49% 52% Wee 33% 38% 35% Weekend 35% 36% 36% Weekday 83% 73% 95% Weekend 82% 72% 94% Kim ley >>> Horn 32% 96% 96% Page 1166 (City of Carlsbad CARLSBAD VILLAGE, BARRIO, AND BEACH AREA R G U IT L Comparison Tables Weekday Parking Occupancies by Facility Type 43% 48% 50% 42% 45% 26% 52% 57% 38% 31% 31% 16% 33% 38% 35% 82% 73% 93% 83% 73% 95% Weekend Parking Occupancies by Facility Type 50% 48% 46% May July 50% 57% 53% 21% 58% 41% May July 20% 49% 52% May 32% 30% 31% July 35% 36% 36% 83% 73% 94% May July 82% 72% 94% Kimley >>>Horn N/A N/A 96% 32% N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 96% Page 1167