HomeMy WebLinkAbout1999-05-06; Arts Commission; MinutesMINUTES
Arts Commission Meeting
MAY 6, 1999 • 4:30 p.m.
City Council Chambers
The Meeting Was Called To Order at 4:30 p.m.
Present: Commissioners Wood, O'Meara, Chattier Lignante, Shaw,
Commissioner Pynes arrived at 4:34 p.m.
Absent: Commissioner Willis
MINUTES FOR APPROVAL
On Motion by Commissioner Lignante, the Minutes of April I, 1999, were approved as
amended.
AYES: Wood, Shaw, Lignante, O'Meara, Chartier
Chair Wood introduced new Arts Commissioner Jim O'Meara.
COMMITTEE REPORTS
Chair's Report
Chair Wood reported that three Arts Commissioners attended a California Assembly of
Local Arts Agencies workshop in San Diego May I. He further reported that he attended the
Arts Associates gala on April 30 and the opening of the Skateboard Park takes place on May 8.
Festejando a las Madrecitas takes place on May 9, starting at Noon and on May 12, there is a
joint workshop between the Arts Commission and Arts Associates at the Senior Center.
Manager's Report
Mrs. Beardsley announced that Studio 2 designed and executed the artwork for the
Skateboard Park. Two professional musical groups have been hired to perform at Festejando
a las Madrecitas. Students will also be performing. The City has received $250,000 for the
Gallery, which will now be named the William D. Cannon Art Gallery. Exhibits have been
planned through the summer of 2000. The opening date of the Gallery and Library is
scheduled for September 25. Following the opening, an entire week of free events will take
place at the Library and Gallery. The Gallery will officially open its exhibition on September
29. Staff and the City are in the process of developing the budget. The budget slated tobe
presented to before City Council on June 1st.
Carrillo Ranch Art Contest Judging
Commissioner Chartier reported that the Friends of Carrillo Ranch sponsored an art
contest. Twelve 4th graders painted images of what they saw at Carrillo Ranch.
Commissioners Lignante and Chartier reviewed the artwork and decided the winners. The
winners and the Commissioners met at Carrillo Ranch to tour the Ranch. Each student was
given a camera to use during the tour.
Arts Commission Minutes - May 6, 1999
I
Arts Education
Commissioner Pynes reported that CUSD is still working on funding to place the music
program in all K-6 grade classes. The current plan puts the music program in all K-6 classes
for one semester. If the schools want to continue the program, the schools must fund it.
Commissioner Pynes further informed Commissioners about the Arts Education component
of the CALAA conference. She stated that she received new information and students which
she will make available to Commissioners interested in reading it. She will also try to
condense most of this information into a one-two page summary.
Arts Associates Report
Mrs. Beardsley reported the Arts Associates needs volunteers. They are looking for board
members. Chair Wood reported that the fund-raising gala held on April 30 went very well.
OLD BUSINESS
Placement of Benbow Bullock Sculpture
Commissioner Chattier suggested moving the piece to the grassy knoll at the Senior Center.
He felt the artwork needed a "background". He also suggested moving the piece to the
entrance on the right at Stagecoach Park, and after the entrance to the right at Poinsettia Park.
Chair Wood stated the Senior Center location will provide a lot a visibility. Commissioner
Shaw asked about the property at the North County Transit District site at the Poinsettia
Coaster Station. She stated the area is travelled by many people every day. Commissioner
O'Meara stated NCTD is "open" and agreed that something is needed at that site. Mrs.
Beardsley stated to the Commission that it should pick three places for its recommendation
to City Council. She further informed the Commission that these locations need approval by
the Senior Commission or Parks Commission before going forward to City Council.
Commissioner Pynes felt that the front of City Hall might provide an opportunity for the
sculpture. Mrs. Beardsley stated she would talk to staff of the various locations mentioned for
further information.
On Motion by Commissioner O'Meara, it was unanimously voted to place the Benbow
Bullock sculpture item on the next Commission agenda.
Report and Discussion Regarding Possibilities of Benches (Blufftop Area near the Ocean)
Mrs. Beardsley provided the Commission with a staff report on benches. She reiterated the
various types of benches the Commission had considered. Nine benches have been order for
the blufftop area near the ocean. She said some Commissioner were interested in doing
something to these benches.
Discussion ensued on the staff report. Chair Wood stated he visited the site and a number of
the benches will place on gravel and some will be placed around the grassy area.
Commissioner O'Meara said there was a manufacturer of glass tile on Tyler Street that we
might look in to. Commissioner Chartier stated he didn't think the Commission should deal
with this area now. Chair Wood replied that he talked with the Mayor and City Council along
with several business people who spearheaded the drive against Split Pavilion and they like the
Arts Commission Minutes - May 6, 1999
2
idea. He does not agree that benches at Split Pavilion would be a constant reminder and does
not agree that the Arts Office/Commission should do public art quietly. Commissioner Pynes
asked if we delay in putting tile on the benches and decided to do it at a later date would this
present a problem. Mrs. Beardsley replied that Raul Guerrero who tiled a bench further
south on the blufftop walkway did not construct the bench, but added the tile to an existing
bench. Commissioner Pynes stated she would like some kind of public art at that site but
time needs to pass first.
Commissioner Pynes motioned that the Commission not make a decision until the benches
have been installed and wanted the Commission to revisit this topic again in August.
Commissioner Lignante seconded.
Commissioner Chartier commented he would like to let the site rest more and wouldn't
support the idea of artwork in this area in three months.
AYES: Commissioners Wood, Shaw, Lignante, Pynes
OPPOSED: Commissioners Chartier, O'Meara
Benches for the Redevelopment Area and Bus Stops
Mrs. Beardsley reported that North County Transit District is in favor of the City placing
benches at bus stops. The City says that this is NCTD's responsibility, there is no funding
available for benches, and it does not want the liability and maintenance. Mrs. Beardsley
explained that the Commission can go before City Council and request funds be appropriated
to purchase one or two benches. There is a City Ordinance that prohibits advertising on
benches, so corporate sponsorship is probably not possible. Redevelopment has funding
available and the Arts Commission could ask to have benches placed in that area and hire and
artist to design the benches. Chair Wood asked if it was the Arts Commission's
responsibility of placing benches around the City. The Arts Commission can be involved only
if it is requested to have an artist-designed bench. Commissioner Lignante stated if there was
a question of liability, the Commission should not get involved. Commissioner Chartier
stated he did not feel it was in the Arts Commission's purview to design benches for the City.
The first step is to design a standard bench for the City. The second step would be to have
the Arts Commission propose to place artwork on the bench. Commissioner Shaw stated
she did not understand what role the Arts Commission was playing. The Commission should
consider the opportunity because bus bench artwork has tremendous visibility. Chair Wood
asked that the bus bench idea be clarified. Commissioner Shaw asked if more information
could be provided to the Commission on this issue. Commissioner Chartier wanted to staff
to explore if there are others interested in this issue. Commissioner O'Meara stated he
wouldn't want to recommend anything that could result in a potential lawsuit or liability
situation for the City. He would support pursuing an artwork design on a park bench.
On motion by Commissioner Lignante this item is tabled until further information is gathered
and available for presentation to the Commission.
AYES: Commissioners Wood, Lignante, Pynes, O'Meara, Shaw, Chartier
Arts Commission Minutes - May 6, 1999
3
Chair Wood announced that more that three Commissioners would be present at the
Skateboard Park dedication on Saturday, May 8, 1999.
Commissioner Shaw moved to cancel the June Commission meeting , subject to call in case
of an emergency.
AYES: Commissioners Wood, Lignante, Pynes, O'Meara, Shaw, Chartier
The meeting adjourned at 6:05 p.m.
Arts Commission Minutes - May 6, 1999
4
April 9, 1999
TO: CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: Mayor Lewis
APPOINTMENT TO THE ARTS COMMISSION
It is my intention to make the following appointment at the Council Meeting of April 13, 1999:
Arts Commission
Appoint: Jim O'Meara
I have attached his application since it was not included with the agenda bill.
Please contact me if you wish to discuss this appointment.
CLAUDE A. "BUD" LEWIS
Mayor
mhs
Attachment
c: City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
APPLICATION FOR APPOINTMENT
BOARD(S) AND/OR COMMISSION(S)
(Please print or type)
NAME(S) OF BOARD(S) AND/OR COMMISSION(S) IN WHICH INTERESTED:
NAME: / Jt Wf O '
ADDRESS:
CITY: aril faA-£- ZIP CODE:
HOME PHONE: Vj?V- %L/73
PRESENT OCCUPATION:
BUSINESS NAME:
BUSINESS ADDRESS:
WORK PHONE: 4/3 /-
U. S. Citizenship (required for all appointments) _f__Yes No
Resident of Carlsbad (required for all appointments) I/ Yes No
Registered voter in Carlsbad (required for all appointments) r Yes .No
I am familiar with the responsibilities assigned to the Board(s) or Commission(s)
on which I wish to serve.
I am willing to be interviewed regarding my qualifications for appointment by a
committee designated by the City Council or at the request of an individual
Council Member.
I am willing to file financial disclosure statements as required by the state's or
city's Conflict of Interest codes.
SIGNATURE: \kg£^^ C^/fLA^m^ DATE: /T
Upon completion of your application, please mail or deliver the application to the following address:
City Clerk's Office
City Hall .
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
ACTIYITIES
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION OR COMMENTS:
(/ /
s#*6