HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-02-10; Beach Preservation Committee; MinutesMINUTES OF: BEACH PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
DATE OF MEETING: February 10, 2004
TIME OF MEETING: 4:00 P.M.
CALL TO ORDER: The meeting was called to order at 4.05 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
Present Members: Ed Andrews, Bud Carroll, Dick Erhardt, Bruce Macklin, Norine Sigafoose, Nora
George, and Jon Campbell
Absent: None
Guests: Carlsbad Police Officers Chad Oppenborn and Steve Thomas, Ray Duncan, Sally
Vigil, Mike Howes, Shaun Dressel, Jayne Strommer
APPROVAL OF MINUTES; By a 7-0 vote, the minutes of the January 13, 2004 meeting were approved.
1. Beach Enforcement Activities; Carlsbad Police Officers Chad Oppenborn and Steve Thomas provided
a brief summary of enforcement activities as it relates to dogs on the beach. The officers indicated they
have stepped up a presence on the beach and are strictly enforcing beach use prohibitions. The current
enforcement actions include no dogs, glass, alcohol, skateboarders, fires and surfing outside designated
areas. The officers also stated they have issued tickets for dog violations rather than providing verbal
warnings. The two officers mentioned they would be patrolling the beach for the remainder of their
assignment (18 months).
Committee members indicated they have noticed an increase in dogs at the northern reaches of the
coastline and have witnessed recent dog fighting. The officers provided phone number to report illegal
activity and encouraged the members to contact them when they notice a violation. All complaints will
be responded to.
The Committee expressed their appreciation for the officer's diligent work and taking the time to address
the Committee. The Committee instructed staff to write a letter of appreciation to the Police Chief and
ensure that a copy is forwarded to Council member Ann Kulchin and the City Manager.
2. FY 04/05 Budget: Staff provided a recommended budget request for FY 04/05 that funds the programs
the Committee has normally covered for the past few years. These include funding for both the local and
regional shoreline monitoring programs, a budget for as-needed consulting services, membership to
ASBPA and CalCoast, and an estimate to attend the annual CSPBA conference. Staff also indicate the
city is looking to tighten its budget and recommended the Committee consider areas where funds could
be saved.
Member Carroll indicated his concern regarding the President's budget proposal to cut funding for beach
protection. He mentioned Howard Marlowe is actively lobbying in Washington to save federal funding
for beach nourishment projects. Member Andrews wanted to make sure the city does not allocate funds
from the BPC budget without consideration by the Committee. Member Macklin would like to have the
city continue to pay ASBPA dues for the BPC because the Shore and Beach magazine provides an
essential informational tool for the BPC.
After further discussion, a motion was made by Member Macklin (George second) to eliminate the
consultant services estimate of $25,000 and reduce the contribution to the Sandag Shoreline Monitoring
program to $12,500. The motion failed by a 3-4 vote. Member Carroll (Erhardt second) made a motion
to reduce the coastal consulting service by $15,00 and leave the remaining budget un-affected. The
motion passed by a 5-2 vote. Staff will revise the budget and submit to the City Engineer for inclusion in
the Engineering Department budget.
Beach Preservation Committee Minutes
February 10,2004
3. Shoreline Preservation Committee: Member Campbell provided a summary of the Shoreline
Preservation Committee meeting of February 5, 2004. The highlights were the summary of the beach
sand and offshore biological monitoring for the Regional Beach Sand Project. The consultants indicated
the project has not had an adverse affect on coastal resources. Also, the BPC was apprised of a proposal
to fund future regional sand nourishment projects. The Shoreline Preservation Committee (SPC) will be
considering various funding mechanism to be included in the Regional Comprehensive Plan. Finally, the
Department of Boating and Waterways, in conjunction with other state resource agencies, will be
conducting public workshops for the development of the Coastal Sediment Master Plan. This plan
should be completed within 2004.
4. OLD BUSINESS:
• Visioning Workshop - The Committee discussed the date for their visioning workshop. The
workshop is tentatively scheduled for the second week of April. Member Sigafoose will inquire with
local hotels for use of a conference room. Staff will develop a draft workshop program for
consideration by the Committee at their March meeting.
• Opportunistic Sand Program - Staff indicated approval has been given to continue with the
permitting process for the Opportunistic Sand Program. Prior to the next meeting, staff will develop
a strategy and outline for further work efforts to secure the necessary permits.
• Public Education Video - Staff indicated the city will be preparing a community video highlight the
efforts regarding urban runoff to the lagoons and beach. The Committee recommended Member
Macklin be the spokesperson for the issues on the coastline. Staff will coordinate with the city's
Public Information Office.
5. COMMITTEE MEMBER COMMENTS; Member Campbell noted the response from the City
Attorney on the city's current situation with regard to the ban of cigarettes on the beach. Member
Campbell will investigate the program approved by the City of Solana Beach and provide information at
the next meeting.
6. PUBLIC COMMENT; None
ADJOURNMENT/NEXT MEETING
By proper motion, the meeting was adjourned at 5:30 p.m. The next meeting of the Beach Preservation
Committee will be Tuesday, March 9, 2004, 4:00 p.m. at the City of Carlsbad Faraday Administration
Building, (1635 Faraday Avenue, Carlsbad, 92008).
STEVEN C. JANTZ
Associate Engineer