HomeMy WebLinkAbout1978-03-28; City Council; Minutes-2? ,,,,z> c I-/ - c ,*
(( .. ,:- < : L . -. .
:,-, ., 7 i" .._ . ,~ ...,, .A",?.> . r- . -, ,. .. , , ., L . \, . :-,i*. .... '?' : ..,,I ,,.*I. ,, .:_. e, i. '~ "."< i i: ! .. .J ; +:&,+~',:2 ; e.: ; . ,*. ,, ,. ." __. L .. r ,,a _. .. : , ;.*:.~. .. ..., 1. ,?': ', .. 5 ,: i .- ., .. : 1 : _.. - - . . ,. i.! .- I
@x' L .? :<:- ,\, !;' /.:, . - -2"
X..# g k $1 ;: . , :,-
,'.;- .;;' Q.;
k:>i.' ; \,,lp<: ii ".;. ;: ..-l_. .>,,>." , -. ;$fi c. ,i; _-I j!
.. . ? '. ':. ,''
,//...< i ... "~, . ,,.,.<,"".."
I,_ ...,-
~-. ~,..~, , . . .. I . . . . .. L.<\,/.<.':,:,::' ,,:, j:< .!"
-3-
March 28, 1978
:A::.. ~~~-~~~~,~~,~.,.~,~,.~~~,~,~.~~-,":,~~~.~~.~~~~~~.~~~.~~,;~~~~~.~~~~;~.~.~,~~~~~,~.~~~: ..;x.: -.~~~~.~-~..~.*~~..-,.~~ .:<...::.. ;~,-'Z;.:.~~,~,;;~~~T,.~.~ .,,,, ::;."~;;,&:, ~~~~~~~~....~,~,,,~, ~=~,~,~~~,-~~,;~,~,~~~~":.~ .,.,--:y=*;">,., 8 9_ I. .
r F He detailed the n'umber of items in each of the F
!: three questions which should be considered in 1 c reaching a determination. 1
k
t: EPA's outlook on the Encina expansion. ; 5 1 I) E! i: to apply to EPA unless the ocean outfall would f b be used. In addition, the plants would initiallyf E be treatment plants and would be reclamation plants
i; later when it was determined to be economically 1
ii feasible.
8 I
Council questioned whether it would require E application to EPA and if it could possibly affect
Staff reponse indicated there would not be a need!
r
e
ti
i;
I
p 1 !? p
r;
!j
i:
11 ' u p 1 . ij E
* $1 F F f i P f E
1 1' r:, 6 ii E Ij i; 1 I 1 f E
b
g p 2
h
f i: k
c q
;:
q
:$
@I 1 I
B
A
j
I 1
i i I d 1 fj i
k Council expressed concern about the proposed 1
that would exceed the CPO Population Forecast. g methods of financing these plants creating growthf
Council also expressed concern about the many f factors that would have a direct bearing on the $ i'
Capital Improvement Program and the City's abilit$ to provide all other services. [
Council questioned where the funding for such plants would be obtained other than City. $ k Staff response indicated realistically at this tide private enterprise would be the only source; t however, a possibility may be State funding or funds from other service agencies.. I
Council then questioned how the resulting sludge ! from these plants would be treated. E E
Staff indicated if Council desired to proceed wit
as other areas would be addressed in a major k project report which would need to be completed. h i
$ Council recognized Mr. Roy Ward, 3088 Pi0 Pic0 2 Avenue, Carlsbad, one of the land owners of Lake i Calavera Hills. He stated they are anxious to pro'ceed but wish to indicate the most important 1 factor is the long term planning for Carlsbad. E Mr. Ward introduced Mr. Dennis O'Leary, Mr. I! William Fannon, Mr. Ed Haworth and Mr. Roger Grab$e to Council, who were present to respond to Council questions. c
Mr. Ed Haworth of Haworth and Anderson, Inc., [ 31882 Camino Capistrano, San Juan Capistrano, E addressed Council. He stated the proposed system! should not be considered a replacement for the 1 I: Encina facility. He indicated if Council deter- mined it was a feasible concept, a great deal of F: consideration should be given to how it will be processed.
Mr. Dennis O'Leary of Lowry & Associates, 3505 c El Camino del Rio South, San Diego, addressed 'Council. He stated the report was intended as a conceptual plan only, to provide an analysis of reclamation opportunities in this area. He dis- played a transparency showing the area of concen-P tration in the report and proposed locations of 1 the plants.
I
t. g
li E
satellite plants, the problem of sludge as well 4 F
1
I t 1
E 1
!, L , s.
h., 5; 5 ;
il-.~. : <>- -..: -. ,.% .. _.: - e:.=* .? ... :.
s:,. . L
,; i < ;_ 1:. ,2" , TT-,. .; c.:;"' .< rc ,. _. ~ .?,, ~- ,j- I.;+.'::. i- ! ; ;" . - x.
c ,. i' ._ > B L*.<_r ,i b* ; , t.,,:'".:.-: . ~, i :. i' li .%..
-4-
c.. 4 ;+ ;;.y .,,. b 1 .e'% , ,.
,~..(,+ : . - _..I :.: 1 , ,
:,.-<,: <:.,-,, : ,-., ', .
%y\. j%;, - ., ': ,, , ', .,
&:A yL.-. L-, s; .
.. ,. ..? ,. C\ ,*'.. .:.. . .' vi. ,, -; , ,
' ..__ ;> 'k ...
t ,-,., ';.:. .
,_ .-I '?-I, 'C&.
L' ._ .. . ' ~
.. * -
March 28, 1978 90 ;~ :: :;
\:>. .< .::. 1
, ,. _.., -,2>r,."-."," _,>L ._ :_ - ..., _..."j ...,.. A ....... -.. -. ..~. < ^.. ."_/. .. _."". "._.. i .I . .-... _.,I ~,~.;,; ._.? ,- ...._ ~" _* .- .",rr ....". -._-,. _.""l> ..,".. __ ",". - w.~,->.,~,,....e" ."-~_"_-."_I .",....I ".,~~.~,,~~~~.-~,-~~~; ..Lr.A7 ,.,:.,. & .-., y-izI" ,,.._ ~:~.~~~,~,.~~~~-"~-~.:,-~.-:,.~~~~,.;~-,.~..," ..,_ ".':.: ; ,, .. .. 7 j., : 1; b
6 He continued stating the basic concept would C require failsafe connections to the Encina ocean E
d outfall. In addition, if it is not possible to 5 1 put the'sludge into the sewer system to be Carrie$
Ir: to Encina for processing, it would be processed b P via a different method on site of the reclamation::
i-; i
i concept and the satellite plants are in the 208
L Program. 1
I? p P.M. and Council reconvened at 9:12 P.M. with all! B Council members present. 1
$ i!
.. .
!:
.1
2 a plant. E
Mr. O'Leary concluded by stating this general e 5
0; p
9 e t RECESS: Mayor Packard called a recess at 9:02 P k;
5
1: t
6
u b [ i b r:
c
<;
1
i: t:
5
h ' ;s 1; [. i'? i: ", ![
;$ ::
;? (t
I ,e ?t ,$ c . .. $F
;: ;
,; 3 kb
i ;:
1: r b !.
$ i
t. I,
;; jl i F p I. 1: r c Le. :, 5 I ;> ., /i i: .x : 1;; : b ;. 1 Council discussed the desirability of obtaining 1 1 1 i ;;
b agencies of JAC, the Regional Water Control Board! [ t. :
1 and may be affected. -6 f!'
,I__
opinions re this matter from the other member
t: and CPO in that they are mentioned in the report [ 1:
E I.:
:: :A 5 ;., b
(L; i! 8' /I : : j:
;. ! j ,. . , 5 The City Attorney reported to Council briefly on 1 li procedural matters indicating if the City desiredt I 0 to prepare an amendment to the Sewer Master Plan 1
i complete EIR. !. E
f
t to include satellite plants, it would require a 6
t
I:
1;
5
5
[
E b
E
l'
!.
2
E
i.i
i
i
i
>
c It was moved that the report be filed without 6 brdotion !! i; . !x il 1
6 further action. The motion died for lack of a 1 !i second.
1; B b c j i i. i.' Council accepted the Overview of Waste Water 1 Motion h I gx
s k Reclamation Opportunities as an acceptable concep ..Ayes F ix [x ;x
1
[: recommendation that satellite treatment plants beiAyes h considered on the basis of drainage basin. r: B'! [;; c 1, t f
I. .
;ar:
5r: E<: r: .. . . .. i 2 i
I:
r I !.
i; Council accepted the Public Works Administrator'siMotion [x I, i: 7 iX ._
ij h L !
1
k; 1;
b 1 1
5 [i
I:
k E.
ri *I
I I
1
1
I 1
I I
1
I
I
Staff then reported on the status of the Lake 1 [[i Calavera Hills project and additional work re- i: \st
quired as a result of Council's previous action. 1 f 2 \ ,~
j
b:;
.. $8 .. ,
>i:
Discussion then related to the desirability of [ returning the matter to staff for preparation of i! a report containing a recommended course of actio$ for processing a satellite plant in a drainage f basin. !
Mr. Haworth, Haworth and Anderson, Inc. , addressel Council .. He concurred with the desirability of ' staff furnishing an additional report and request? ed it be accomplished and retu'rned to Council at g the earliest possible meeting. E
F t /j
F < 5
i;
1
5 1
1
5
k'
E 2
,. 9 :,
1. i I 8 6 *
5 ..
I:$ t i: E! g2 6
f; ip q $ .. kg $(i
1 :: [E
FL: t : I' >
Council instructed staff to return with a report. ;Motion 1 ! Xi
Mayor Packard requested the City Attorney to .prepare the appropriate wording of the motion i(! and to furnish same to the City Clerk.
ADJOURNMENT:
!Ayes p: xi x[ ) g /I/
I
E ti!?
%&[ IGf g !I1 -
$$;
By proper motion, the meeting was adjourned 'at [ I k 1; 10:04 P.M. 1;; I, [!E [ " E 1 [$F bk;
. f" E .X ..... _I e. , ,., L.? f' ,-~. i';;"'
..e> <*.. ., . .. . , r-.. .;. <-. -& ," $..L1. i.-_.
,.: , -
: ,._ <,,e; ,?: 7-7
i. " '
;.%.& ?, r' ii P. i . 1: -, j,,;:.. ' , ' : , . 1. ,) : I
..,L:L.<.<..,!; ..~. :. '1 . : ?.>+ ;
_. , .
,"., 1: ...~~.~..:~.:~~~".~-', ';e<'
-5-
March 28, 1978 ..-. .n". ~.~ I_l;,~, ..~ .. ....". - :..,,..... .I.,.. . , , i , ,,,~, -:.-.,b..--..,fl..:~ ^..-.~-1."i.-iij- ..."~-~.-~-.-~.~.~"-..."~ ..... _,.i ". ."..... 7 ..."._ ;-~ ,,., .,. i: ;:
".<-.."A ._ ...,. .). .._. .~." ..-.,."I_.- A*,.&..,u .. ...a _.,. _c" , . _...._.__.._ ___,. . ,__.,_^ .... ~, -.:>,+y: ,.:~~~.,,~~~~~="-~~.~~~,~~~":~,~,~-~.~"-~~~~~,~:~~~~;,.~..~,"~
2
1: Respectfully submitted, F i; g c
/. t F@& $ F
6 E. ADAMS, City Clerk 1 c,
$ F. Secretary i: k nkranz, Recording i:
p p
t; 5 e* 1; The motion as prepared by the City Attorney is as c j F follows: p 8
; Council directed staff to report back with a /j
1 sewer plant for that drainage basin. L'
fj
1: E
1: recommended course of action for processing the g p 2 Lake Calavera Hills Master Plan and a satellite f
E 6
& 1
$ f: li E
J' r: 1: p g 5
I:
)i
i! 1
t: '! li f I E I I
Y .(
1 1
5'
6 .I; 1
k E
F li I
. t. I
,1
e
1:
1 $
$
i: 1 I g
t .a 1
i! I k
ii t
i 1
f 1
1 1 t
E
E p
1,;
!i
r: F
i; 6
B fl
4
6: f;
1
i:
li I e! 1
8 1: 1
1 1
1
1
..! 1 1 ! I 8 fi E