HomeMy WebLinkAbout1989-09-26; City Council; Minutes% 0 e MINUTES
Meet1 ng of: CITY COUNCIL (Regular Meeting)
Date of Meetlng: September 26, 1989
Time of Meet'lng: 6:OO p.m. k\b
Piace of Meeting: City Council Chambers COUNCIL 3 %$ '
MEMBERS % $%
CALL TO ORDER:
Mayor Lewfs called the Meeting to order at 6:OO p.m.
ROLL CALL was taken by the C,ity Clerk, as follows:
Present: Councll Members LewSs, PettSne, Mamaux and
Larson.
Absent: Councl! Member Ku!chin.
PRESENTATIONS:
Larry Bag ley, Mayor of Oceansfde, presented a trophy to
Mayor Lewfs for winnfng Second Piace in the Mayors Cup
Race held last year. He stated there would be a rematch
this year on October 7, 1989, when the Oceansfde Chamber
of Commerce presents Harbor Days.
Mayor Lewfs read a Proclamation proclaimlng the month of
October CRIME PREVENTION MONTH. The Procfamatlon was
accepted by Police Chief Vales.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
Minutes of the Regular Meeting held August 22, 1989, Lew I s X
were approved as presented. Pett I ne xx
Mamaux X
Minutes of the Regular Meeting held September 5, 1989, Larson X
were approved as presented.
CONSENT CALENDAR:
Mayor Lewis requested Items #1 and #11 be removed from
the Consent Ca I end ar .
Counci 1 af f irmed the act ion of the Consent Ca l endar, Lew 1 s X
wlth the exceptfon of Items #1 and #11, as follows: Pett I ne xx
Mamaux X
Larson X
WAIVER OF ORDINANCE TEXT READING:
Council waived the reading of the text of al 1
Ordinances and Resolutlons at this Meeting.
(107) 1 . AB #10,259 - VACATION OF A PORTION'OF OAK AVENUE
AND LINCOLN STREET.
Thfs item was removed from the Consent Calendar.
(84) 2. AB #10,260 - PURCHASE OF A 3-4 CUBIC YARD
COMPRESSOR/PATCH DUMP TRUCK.
Councfl adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-333, accepting
the bld and author lzing the execution of a purchase
order to Westrux lnternationa! in the amount of
$60,963.00, plus tax, for a 3-4 cubic yard
compressor/patch dump truck.
(84) 3. AB #10,261 - PURCHASE OF COMPUTER HARDWARE FOR
HYPERCARD AND DESKTOP PUBLISHING PROJECTS.
Councfl adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-334, authorlzlng
the purchase of Apple Macintosh computer hardware
to support Library hypercard and desktop publishing
projects .
as8
h @
\
(97) (45)
(96) (45)
(74)
(99)
(99)
(78)
0 0
MINUTES
September 26, 1989 Page 2
CONSENT CALENDAR: (ContPnued)
4. AB #10,262 - 1988-1989 STREETS OVERLAY PROGRAM
AWARD OF CONTRACT - CONTRACT NO. U/M-26.
Councll adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-335, accepttng
b Ids and award ing a contract to the Da ley
Corporatlon of San Diego In the amount of
$338,275.00, for the 1988-89 Streets Overlay
Program.
5. AB #10,263 - AWARD OF CONTRACT FOR TRAFFIC SIGNAL
SYSTEM AT EL CAMINO REAL AND RANCHO CARLSBAD DRIVE - PROJECT NO. 331 7.
Councll adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-336, accepting
b ?ds and award i ng the contract to Steiny & Company,
lnc., Bn the amount of $59,890.00, for the
lnstallation of a traffic signal system at Rancho
Car lsbad Drive and E l Camino Real.
6. AB #10,264 - EXTENSION OF EMPLOYMENT LIST FOR FIRE
CAPTA I N .
Councfl adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-337, extending
the list for Fire Captaln to October 28, 1990.
7. AB #10,265 - ACCEPTANCE OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS ON
OCEAN STREET - MINOR SUBDVlSlON 735.
CouncP I accepted improvements, authorized the City
Clerk to record the Notice of Completlon, release
bonds, and directed the Utll Itiies and Malntenance
Department to commence maintaining the pub! ic
fmprovements assocOated with the subd iv.islon.
8. AB #10,266 - DENIAL OF APPEAL OF A TENTATIVE TRACT
MAP AND PLANNED UN IT DEVELOPMENT - CT 89-1 /PUD 89-1 - CAMPBELL.
Council adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-338, denylng an
appeal and upholding the Planning Commlsslon's
approval of a nlne-lot tentative map and planned un'ft
development on property genera l l y located north of
Levante Street and west of La Costa Avenue.
9. AB #10,267 - APPROVAL OF INDEMNITY AND HOLD
HARMLESS AGREEMENT AND RELEASE IN FAVOR OF CITY OF
SAN MATEO.
Council adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-339, authorizing
executton of Fndemnity and hold harmless agreement
and release and authorizing the Pollce Chief to
execute the agreement to al low two officers to
attend motorcycle train fng in the CPty of San
Mateo.
2513
-
COUNCIL /\I\ % ?$%%+
MEMBERS Z. 8 Z. 6
-
0 0
MINUTES
September 26, 1989 Page 3
'CONSENT CALENDAR: (Contfnued)
(78) 10. AB #10,268 - APPROVAL OF TRAINING AGREEMENT WITH
CALIFORNIA HIGHWAY PATROL.
Council adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-340, authorizing
agreements between the Pol Ice Department of the
City of Carlsbad and the State of Callfornla
Department of California Hlghway Patrol, and
authorizing the Police Chlef to sign the agreement
to a I low traf f IC off lcers to attend Commerc la I
Enforcement Trafnfng Courses.
( 26) 1 1 . A8 #10,269 - EXTENS I ON OF CONSULTANT AGREEMENT FOR
ASSESSMENT DISTRICT - PROJECT NO. 3151. (45) INSPECTION SERVICES FOR PALOMAR AIRPORT ROAD WEST
-
COUNCIL I\\ % %* $
MEMBERS % $%
Th 1 s Item was removed from the Consent Ca I endar . I Ill
(99) 12. AB #10,270 - ACCEPTANCE OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS ON
PARK DRIVE AND ADAMS STREET - MINOR SUBDIVISION 390. ~. ~~ -
CouncO l accepted Improvements, authorized the City
Cl erk to record the Not Ice of Cmp I et lon and
release bonds, and dlrected the Uti 1 Ities and
Maintenance Department to commence maintalnlng the I pub I fc improvements associated with the I I
subd Pv'lsion.
( 70) 13. AB #10,271 - EXTENS ION OF THE ANNUAL CARLSBAD SAND
(45) SURVEY AND BEACH PROFILE PROGRAM FOR FISCAL YEAR 1 989-90.
Councll adopted RESOLUTION NO. 89-342, approvTng an
extension to an existing agreement between the Cjty
of Car lsbad and Tekmarine, I nc., for the Car lsbad
Sand Survey and Prof I le Program for fiscal year
1989-90, at a cost of $21,256.00.
ITEMS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR:
(107) 1 . AB #10,259 - VACATION OF A PORTION OF OAK AVENUE
AND LINCOLN STREET.
Clty Englneer Lloyd Hubbs explained that tonight's
action wou Id set this matter to a pub! IC hearing on
October 10, 1989. He responded to questlons, statlng
that the med Ian wl I 1 proh'ibit left turns Into
Llncol n Street, and ft wi I I become a one-way street
northbound. A transparency was shown to illustrate the
seven parking spaces el im Inated on Car I sbad Bou levard,
and Mr. Hubbs stated that this vacation will allow
parklng along Lincoln Street.
Council adopted the following Resolution: tew l s xx
Pett 1 ne X
RESOLUTION NO. 89-332, DECLARING COUNCIL'S INTENTION TO Mamaux X
VACATE A PORTION OF OAK AVENUE BETWEEN LINCOLN STREET Larson X
AND CARLSBAD BOULEVARD, AND A PORT i ON OF L.1 NCOLN STREET
BETWEEN OAK AVENUE AND CARLSBAD BOULEVARD, AND SETTING
THE MATTER TO PUBLIC HEARJNG AT 6:OO P.M., ON TUESDAY,
OCTOBER 1 0, 1 989.
256
A @
0 0
MINUTES
(26) (45)
(57)
(114) (77)
(99)
September 26, 1989 Page 4 /\f
COUNCIL % %$ 5
MEMBERS % %%
'.ITEMS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR: (ContOnued)
11. AB #10,269 - EXTENSION OF CONSULTANT AGREEMENT FOR
INSPECT'ION SERVICES FOR PALOMAR AIRPORT ROAD WEST
ASSESSMENT DISTRICT - PROJECT NO. 3151.
Councl t Member Larson requested this Item be removed
from the Consent Calendar so he could make a statement
for the record. He sa id that he had not previous I y
parttclpated in the dicusslon on the Palmar Airport
Road West Assessment Dtstrlct, as his employer was
negotlating with a property owner to relocate thelr
business. In the Interim, that slte Js no longer under
consideration, so Mr. Larson stated he no longer has a
confflct of interest in this matter and wlll take part
In a1 1 dfscusslons and votes in the future.
Councfl adopted the following Reso!ution:
RESOLUTION NO. 89-341, APPROVING AN EXTENSION OF AN
EXISTING CONSULTANT AGREEMENT WITH WILLDAN, ASSOCIATES,
AT A COST OF $57,000, FOR INSPECTION SERVICES FOR THE
PALOMAR AIRPORT ROAD WEST ASSESSMENT DISTRICT, PROJECT
NO. 3151.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
Don Connors, 921 Begonia Court, spoke as a
representative to the Southwst Carlsbad Homeowners'
Assoclatlons' Coatitlon. He told of a Bicycle
Reglstratlon Day held Saturday, September 16, 1989, at
Carlsbad Fire Statlon #4, sponsored by the Coalition
and focal merchants. Mr. Connors told of the
cooperatlon of the City and the success of the event,
and encouraged the other Quadrants to part,lclpate In
this type of activlty.
ORDINANCES FOR ADOPTION:
14. AB #10,256 - AMENDMENT TO THE GENERAL PLAN, LOCAL
COASTAL PLAN AND ZONI'NG CODE TO PROHIBIT ON-SHORE
OIL AND GAS SUPPORT FACILITIES - GPA/LU 89-2/LCPA
89-1 /ZCA 89-1 .
Council adopted the fol lowing Ord inance:
ORDINANCE NO. NS-87, AMENDING TITLE 21 OF THE CARLSBAD
MUNICIPAL CODE TO PROHIBIT ON-SHORE OIL FACILITIES
EXCEPT IN THE C-M, M AND P-M ZONES UPON CERTAIN
FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS.
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
15. AB #10,272 - AMENDMENT TO TENTATIVE MAP TO MODIFY
ROADWAY ALIGNMENTS - CT 84-32 (A)/PUD 73(A)
COBBLESTONE SEA VILLAGE.
Lew Is
Pett I ne
Mamaux
Larson
Lew ls
Pett f ne
Mamaux
Larson
X
~
I i I
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
I Mike HolzmFffer, PlannZng Director, gave the staff
report as contained in the Agenda Blll, using
transparencles to show the exfsting, approved altgnrnent
and the proposed new a1 ignment, and a summary of the
advantages of the proposed alignment.
255
h $j
0 0
MINUTES
(99)
(108)
(99)
September 26, 1989 Page 5 /\I\
COUNCIL so /o $*%$ A MEMBERS Z. rz, Z. 8
'PUBLIC HEARINGS: (Continued)
Mayor Lewfs opened the Pub! ic HearSng at 6:28 p.m., and
lssued the invltatfon to speak.
Bi 11 Hofman, Hofman Planning AssocPates, 2386 Faraday,
representing the fand owner, stated he was present to
answer questions.
Since no one else wished to speak on this matter, the
Public Hearlng was closed at 6:29 p.m.
Council dlrected the City Attorney to prepare Lew 1 s X
documents approvlng the Mitigated Negative Declaration Pett i ne X
and Tentat ive Tract Map/P I anned Development CT 89- Mamaux xx
32(A)/PUD-73(A). Larson X
16. AB #10,238 - APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION DENIAL -
CT 89-10/PUD 89-2/HDP 89-23/V 88-3 - ST. TROPEZ
WEST - CALIFORNIA BU.ILDERS.
Nick Banche, Attorney, 810 Mission Avenue, Sulte 200,
Oceanside, spoke on behalf of the app l icant, statlng
their desire to withdraw the appeal and have the matter
sent back to the Plannlng Commission to al low the
appl lcant to redesign. He a!so walved any time
constraints that may exist.
Councl I approved the request of the appl lcant to iew I s X
withdraw the appea I and return the matter to the Pett i ne X
PIannlng Commfssfon to allow the appllcant to redesign, Mamaux xx
including the appl icant's waive of any time
constra f nts.
X Larson
DEPARTMENTAL AND CITY MANAGER REPORTS:
17. AB #10,278 - APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSiON
DETERMlNATiON OF SUBSTANTiAL CONFORMANCE - Dl 89-4 - MARLBOROUGH DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION.
M,lke Holzmiller gave the staff report as contained in
the Agenda Bil I, using mounted exhibits to iI lustrate
the changes. He summarized the eight changes
required by the Coastal Comm.issPon, and pointed these
out on mounted drawings.
Mr. Ho Izm i I ler stated that the project was reduced by
ten units to 130 total, due to the changes made by the
Coastal Commission. He further stated that the only
issue Counci f is addressfng is whether or not those
changes are mlnor In nature and the project is In
substantlal conformance with the origfnal sEte plan.
Staff and the PlannJng Commission believe these changes
are minor, improve the project, and recommend approval.
Mayor LewTs announced that this project is legal and
meets al I requ lrements by the Councl I at the time it
was approved. The only thing to be d fscussed thts
evenlng is the conformance with the orfgina! approval
because of mlnor changes made by the Coastal
Comm f ss $on.
as Y
0 0
MINUTES
September 26, 1989 Page 6 /\k
COUNCIL % %' ?
MEMBERS % %%
DEPARTMENTAL AND CITY MANAGER REPORTS: (Continued)
Paula Madson, 702 - 4th Street, OceansPde, representlng
Marlborough Development Corporatlon, stated the
applfcant concurred wlth the staff report.
Richard Niec, 28751 Rancho Calffornia Road, Temecula,
representing Marlborough Development Corporatlon,
stated he supported staff 's recommendat lion and wou Id
I Ike to bufld a qual ity project in Carlsbad. He
commented that In moving the bu i ld i ngs to the north,
w ith a minimum of f Ive feet off of the property I ine In
some cases, there was st; f I 35 feet mi n {mum bu I Id Ong
separation.
Mr. N,Iec asked for rebuttal time at the end of the
pub 1 ic comment.
William K. Shearer, Attorney, 101 West Broadway, San
D iego, representing the Agua Hed ionda and Windsong Cove
Homeowners Assoclations, ralsed the Issue of hbs not
belng notifted of this hearing. He said the City
Clerk's Off ice and the Planning Department d id not
notify hlm and he requested a cont.inuance of this matter
P n order to be properly prepared to make a
presentation.
City Attorney Vincent Biondo stated that the people knew
the matter was before Council tonight and were fully
Informed as to the bssues to be heard. He said there
was no reason why Council should not hear this matter
tonight.
The consensus of the Counclt Members was to hear the
matter tonlght.
In answer to Mr. Shearer's query as to the City havlng
any formal notice requlrement to the appellant, Mr.
Biondo stated there Is none.
Mr. Shearer stated that when the bu .I Id i ngs were moved
to wlth9n f Fve feet of the property IFne, this was a
substantlal change and a dlstinct disadvantage to the
owners residtng in the exfstlng projects adjacent to
thPs partlcular slte. He stated that thJs change also
e 1 iml nated the greenbelt.
Mr. Shearer said the developer has a pending proposal to
take the grad Fng into the rainy season, and this Is not
in conformance. Also, this was to be part of one
community, but now 'is to be gated, which would have an
adverse impact on hls cllents, as they would have to
1 eave the gate to their area open wh'l le this area wou Id
be c 1 osed . He concluded , statf ng these th ings were
substantlal changes from the original approval.
2s 3
i e
e e
MINUTES
September 26, 1989 Page 7
DEPARTMENTAL AND CITY MANAGER REPORTS: (Continued)
Dean Van Leuven, 821 A Kalpatl, President of the Agua
Hed fonda Homeowners Assoclatlon, stated he supported
the statements of Mr. Shearer. He Indicated on the
wall map where the ifving rooms were located in the
exQstPng butld ings and added that the moving of the
bulldfngs to five feet from the property line puts them
wlthin five feet of the adjacent driveway. Mr. Van
Leuven sald that when he backs out of his garage, the
driveway Is less than 20 feet In width, making those
proposed buF ldlngs within 25 feet of hfs llvingrom.
He felt that was a tremendous change.
Mr. Van Leuven referred to the traff?c through the
project he I Pves In, whlch Is adjacent to the proposed
project, and stated he had subm ltted a 1 etter to the
Trafflc Safety Commlssfon stating this would be a
dangerous sltuatlon with homeowners trylng to get to
ChPnquapin. This is not a City street, and the
residents Pn his project do not want a third project
s har I ng the I r street.
CBty Attorney VBncent BIondo stated that thls problem
with the streets was a prlvate matter and not one being
consfdered tonfght. The last publ ic hearing on this
project was six years ago and ail discretlonary
approvals were g'iven at that time. The only lssue
ton ight Is the conformance to the orlg lnal approval due
to the changes made by the Coastal CommPsslon.
James Hawes, 4065 Harbor Drive, stated he applauded
Councfl and staff for worklng wtth Marlborough
Development Corporation to obtain an access route and
said he was looking forward to the completlon of thPs
project.
David V lnegrad, 401 6 Agu f la Street, stated that Counc I I
could not make an Informed decislon based on the facts,
as Marlborough is unable to provide the square footage
change from the original plans to the plans that exist
now. Mr. Vlnegrad said that pushing the buildings ten
feet to the north represented a substantlal change In
the plans.
Michael Papenthien, 4016A Layang Layang Circle, stated
h Is remarks were the same as Mr. V inegrad 's.
Barbara Falgoust, 4016A Layang Layang Circle, sald she
dId not bel leve thls project was in substantial
conformance wlth the orlglnal project. She relterated
that the driveway was less than 20 feet from the 1 ivingrooms of the exlstlng project, and backing out of
the garages makes the street more dangerous. She felt
the additional cars using the driveway would add to
the problem wlth the narrow and wind.lng streets. Ms.
Fa lgoust also commented about the ch i Id ren rid ing their
bikes Pn the streets.
Ms. Falgoust stated the EIR was inadequate as far as
evaluation of this project; partlcularly wPth regard to
the narrow streets, the noise pollution and alr
pollution.
2 Sa
-
MEMBERS COUNCIL \Y x?&, .;Z. x? 8 3/ 2. A @
a e
MINUTES
(68)
September 26, 1989 Page 8
DEPARTMENTAL AND CITY MANAGER REPORTS: (Continued)
Mayor Lewis lnqu ired about the el im lnatlon of the
greenbelt, and Mike Holzmil ler said that in moving the
buidings closer to the northerly property line,
some landscaping in that area was being el Imlnated, but
a comparable mount was added elsewhere in the project.
City Engineer Lloyd Hubbs, 'In answer to Councll query,
stated that the C'ity's gradlng resit-ictlons vary from
what the Coastal Commission requires. The City cutoff
is November 15 to April 15; while October 1 is the
Coastal Commfsslon cutoff. The Coastal Cornmisston time
is shorter than the Clty's, and this developer has
requested relief from the Coastal Commlsslon.
Councll Member Mamaux commented that the Coastal
Commlss ion wanted more open space toward the lagoon
than lnsfde the project, which was the reason for the
bu P Id lngs be Ing moved northward.
Mayor Lewis asked staff whether thfs project met the
setback requlrements, and staff said it met al 1 -of
the PUD requlrements. All bulldlngs are below the 35
foot height limitation, and the developer was required
to reduce three port Tons of the one bu I Id ing to two
stor ies.
Mayor Lewls stated that the EIR was glven to Council
six years ago and that is stil 1 in effect. Mr. Biondo
concurred, and added that there were fu! 1 publlc
hearings two separate times and the E IR was found to be
adequate. The last opportunity the neighbors had to
have thelr concerns heard was when the project was
before the Coastal CommlssFon.
In answer to query by Council Member Larson regarding
access to the lagoon trail, Mike Holzmlller stated that
there has been no change from the orig inal approval.
COUNCIL \! 39 "0 $, A 3,
MEMBERS 2. 8 9
Council adopted the fol lowing Resolution:
X Larson CONFORMANCE OF PLANS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEVELOPMENT.
X Mamaux RESOLUTION NO. 89-344, DETERMINING SUBSTANTIAL
X Pett I ne
xx Lew 1 s
Dl 89-4 (FOR CT 83-41 - MARLBOROUGH DEV. CORP.
18. AB #10,277 - SUBCOMMITTEE REPORT ON THE CARLSBAD
CONVENTION AND VISITORS BUREAU.
Council Member Mamaux reported on the Subcommfttee
meetings and referred to the Memorandum dated September
26, 1989, givTng a breakdown of d'lrect costs that the
City would fund, totaI ling $140,000, and I lstlng
Addltlonal Fundlng, as Matching Funds - Admlnistrative
Costs of $30,000 and aud Its and taxes of $4,923, which
made a total budget of $174, 923.
:AS I
4 4
a a
MINUTES
September 26, 1989 Page 9
I
DEPARTMENTAL AND CITY MANAGER REPORTS: (Continued)
The Memorandum a I so suggested fund i ng shou Id run from
October 1 to September 30 each year, to enab I e CCVB to
be aware of any changes that might occur In the City's
operatlng budget.
Sieve Llnk, 2380 Hosp Way, Manager of ConVls sPnce
Ju 1 y , stated he had not heard anyone say that ConV is
was not dolng a good job and read a letter from a
vis.itor to Carlsbad glvlng thanks to ConVls. Mr. Llnk
saId the Bureau has done a god job and fe It that was
the most productive use of City dollars to promote
tour Ism.
Mr. LJnk felt the bureau had been flexlble, and hls
only fear was the $30,000 they would have to ralse in
the communlty. He felt that would d.ivert their energy
from the purpose of the Bureau and was unworkable.
Mr. il nk Ind lcated that he wou id not be ab t e to stay on
at ConVls under these clrcumstances.
Councll Member PettIne asked Mr. Llnk whether he would
stay on $f the match Ing funds were attached to another
part of the budget, and Mr. Llnk fnd lcated he would.
He further stated that the match.lng funds were not
available until matched, and some months it T.s not
possible to ralse money from the community.
Hope Wrlsley, 2080 Basswood Avenue, sald that !t was
unreallstlc to think that the hotel/motel industry Is
the only one to benefft from tourtsm. She satd that
when the TOT tax was low, perhaps the hote I /mote! peop le
were the only ones to benefit. Now that Carlsbad has
a 10 percent TOT, this is drawing a lot of money to pay
for facPf itfes and servtces for a! I of the citizens, and
she d Id not feel that it could be sa,Id that the TOT was
only benef ittfng the hotel / motel people.
Ms. Wrisley expressed the need for a well-paid staff of
people traPned In thls fleld. Also, to have that type
of staff, they wou Id need to know that they wou Id be
paid regularly.
Llsa Seamans, 770 Camel fa Place, spoke as a person
Involved In the hospitality fleld from San DIego to
Orange County. She commented on the Tmportance of
trade shows and said that the smaf ler propert ies wou Id
be hurt if there was no ConVSs. Ms. Seamans said that
advertlslng alone will not promote this area; that a
dedicated program is needed to do it.
25c3 I
COUNCIL /\y % %% ?
MEMBERS ?& %% L 8
0 0
MINUTES
September 26, 1989 Page 10
'DEPARTMENTAL AND ClTY MANAGER REPORTS: (Continued)
Elaine Lyttleton, 4210 Sunnyhl\l Drive, stated she
could not understand what was wrong with the origlnal
plan to fund $200,000, except that it was not enough,
and shou Id be lncreased .
Mrs. Lyttleton stated that ConVis has a very
profess tonal staf f , and that staf f has an army of
volunteers worktng very hard for the City. She said
that no wrong-doing was found in the analysts of the
Bureau, and the City should be working together wlth
them to promote the City. 1
Mrs. Lyttleton asked Council to please reconsider what
they were about to do and ihlnk about the revenues that
can be generated for the City in the future In a much
more effictent manner.
Peder Norby, 2630 Valewood Avenue, addressed Councll
stating that ConVFs was charged with increasing
tour Ism, and Car lsbad tour ism has Increased, even
though It does not have a race track or a harbor. He
felt the cltlzens and leaders of the City have made it
work, and that tourism Hs a partnership that improves
the qual Ity of llfe for everyone, and Is paying for the
amen ltles for Car I sbad .
Mr. Norby recommended releasing the rematnlng $170,000
as proposed at budget the, and not take the $30,000
away from the Administratlve costs.
Scott Little, PresFdent, Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce,
spoke on behalf of the Board of Directors, statfng they
were In favor of the fund I ng , but had prob lems wlth the
method. He sa id It was lack lng in severa l areas and
would not be practlcaf.
COUNCIL \\b Zio A9 "0 +@%? A
MEMBERS - Z. @ Z.
Mr. Lfttle catled attentlon io the $20,000 for
promotion of economic development, and said that Is not
what the Bureau is about; also that special events are
already funded, and those funds cou id be better spent
Iln other areas.
Mr. Lfttle safd that the CCVB, as operated in the past,
is one of the best on the north coast and one of the
best in the State. He pol nted out some of the th ings
provlded by the Bureau that benefit the Clty, and sald
this should be a partnership. He felt the teamwork that
has prevailed wfth the Chamber and the CFty Council is
sad ly f ack lng In th Is whol e process, and that a better
compromlse could have been reached. As the proposa! was
wrltten, he sald the Chamber could not partlcipate.
Mr. Little distributed copies of a proposed allocation
of Clty funds, and stated that they dld not want to d Ip
Into the operatlng funds of the Chamber to sustaln
ConV is.
Jr9
h @
e 0
MINUTES
%%
September 26, 1989 Page 11 COUNCIL \\ % ?&$
MEMBERS Z. 6 Z. d
DEPARTMENTAL AND CiTY MANAGER REPORTS: (Continued)
Mr. LQttle read through the new proposal and refterated
that funds could not be matched every month for salarles
and that was not effective. He concluded, saying he
would hate to lose ConVls, but the Chamber does not have
the money to support It.
Mayor Lewis stated he wou Id 1 ike to make a proposa 1 to
the Council, as follows: CEEC would receive only
$5,000; Special Events $24,000; add those funds of
$20,000 to the $30,000, maklng a total of $50,000 to use
for sa larles. If any money was needed beyond that, It
would be Mr. Link's responslblllty. Also, ?f the amount
for trade shows was to be Increased, that would be the
Bureau's responslblllty.
Mayor Lewls sald that he thought the TOT wll I bring a
great deal of money to Carlsbad and he felt ?t should be
match I ng funds.
Councfl Member Mamaux asked when wiII the City make the
Bureau match funds.
Council Member Pettine supported the matching funds,
but safd If it were on administrative costs, It would
k?lI the program, as Mr. Llnk wlll leave. He sald he
could not support matching funds on salaries.
Council Member Larson commented that he thought It was
fmportant to have matching funds, but Tf Council wanted
guaranteed salaries, that puts the proposal in a
different context.
Mayor Lewls suggested that perhaps It coutd be for
advertislng costs, but not salaries. The comment was
made that If It were in advertis?ng, that wou Id reduce
the 15 percent revenue to the Bureau.
Counc?l Member Pettlne suggested that salaries need to be secured to have ConV Is, and it wou Id be better to
sei- the budget I Im It and take a percentage off of the
top and start matching wSth all the d'lfferent items.
He said he was reluctant to tell Mr. Llnk how much he
can spend on each Stem.
Counctl Member Mamaux stated If thls is a good program,
why Isn't the business communlty supporting it. Thls
money was orSginally to be seed money for ConVis. He
sa Id that anyth I ng above the $145,000 shou Id be
matched.
Asslstant Clty Manager Frank Mannen said that staff
wou Id work with CCVB to cane up wl th a program and
outlfne how the $145,000 would be util tzed, wlth
$30,000 wlthheld for matching funds. Th.?s would be for
the per iod between now and October 1 , 1990.
,&Vd 8
0 e
MINUTES
(77)
(72)
(28)
(39)
(50)
September 26, 1989 Page 12
DEPARTMENTAL AND CITY MANAGER REPORTS: (Continued)
Council made $175,000 available to the Chamber, re-
tafnlng $30,000 as matchPng funds, which are not to be released unless matched; expenditures to be from October
1, 1989, through September 30, 1990; and staff WF I I
work with the Chamber to come up with a program as to
how the funds wl I I be spent on the ltems as 1 lsted .
19. AB #10,273 - REPORT OF THE PROPOSITION C BLUE
RIBBON COMMITTEE - REGIONAL PLANNING.
Councl I brlef 1 y d iscussed the report and f i led It.
20. AB #10,257 - "TWO HOUR PARKING ZONE UPON A PORTION
OF PASEO DEL NORTE AND CAR COUNTRY DRIVE.
Bob Johnson, Traffic Engineer, gave the staff report as
contained in the Agenda Bf 1 I.
Counci I Introduced the fol lowing Ord inances:
(one motion)
ORDINANCE NO. NS-88, AMENDING TITLE 10, CHAPTER 10.40
OF THE CARLSBAD MUNICIPAL CODE BY THE ADDITION OF
SECTION 10.40.72 TO DECLARE "TWO-HOUR PARKING" BETWEEN
8:OO A.M. AND 6:OO P.M., MONDAY THROUGH FRIDAY, WITH
HOLIDAYS EXCEPTED, ON BOTH SIDES OF PASEO DEL NORTE
DRIVE.
ORDINANCE NO. NS-89, AMENDING TITLE 10, CHAPTER 10.40
OF THE CARLSBAD MUNICIPAL CODE BY THE ADD IT1 ON OF
SECTION 10.40.073 TO DECLARE "TWO-HOUR PARKING" BETWEEN
8:OO A.M. AND 6:OO P.M., MONDAY THROUGH FRIDAY, WITH
HOLIDAYS EXCEPTED, ON BOTH SI DES OF CAR COUNTRY DRIVE
FROM CANNON ROAD TO ITS INTERSECTION WITH PASEO DEL
NORTE .
FROM CANNON ROAD TO ITS ,INTERSECTION WITH CAR COUNTRY
21. AB #10,274 - APPOINTMENT TO BEACH EROSION
COMMITTEE.
Counci 1 adopted the fol lowing Resoiution:
RESOLUTION NO. 89-343, APPOINTING BAILEY NOBLE TO THE
CITY OF CARLSBAD BEACH EROSION COMMITTEE.
22. AB #10,275 - REPORT ON CITY INVESTMENTS.
Informatlon item - Report from the City Treasurer on
the City's investment portfolio as of September 1,
1989.
23. AB #10,276 - REVENUE AND EXPENDITURE STATUS REPORT.
Information Item - Staff report from the Finance
Department on the status of Revenue and Expenditures as
of July 31, 1989.
24 7
7
+%
MEMBERS COUNCIL \\ %9$.z;0,, Z. 8 Z. d
Lew I s
X Larson
xx Mamaux
X Pett D ne
X
Lewis
X Larson
xx Mamaux
X Pett f ne
X
Lew i s
X Larson
X Marnaux
X Pett i ne
xx
e e
MINUTES
September 26, 1989 Page 13
COUNCIL REPORTS:
Council Members reported on recent meetings and
act Iv It I es of the Cmm I ttees and Sub-Cmm lttees of
whfch they are Members.
CITY ATTORNEY COMMENTS:
C?ty Attorney Vincent Biondo commented on the Carlsbad
cardroom matter, statlng al I CPty objectives were
ach I eved .
ADJOURNMENT:
By proper motion, the Meeting of September 26, 1989,
was adjourned at 9:49 p.m.
Respectful ly submttted, (&?%4LR&-;3 ..
ALETHA L. RAUTENKRANZ
Clty Cierk
Harrlett Babbltt
Mlnutes Clerk
246
S%
MEMBERS COUNCIL \\ %?&%,I s 6 Z. rl
I
~