HomeMy WebLinkAbout1958-02-25; Planning Commission; MinutesMINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF CARLSBAD CITY PLANN~G COMMSSIOF i-
February 25, 1958
1- The meeting was called to order at 7:35 P.M. by Chairman Baumgartner. Present beoides the Chairman were Commiesioners Fennel, Jarvie, Swiraky, Stringer and Engelmann; City Manager Nelson, City Engineer Kubata. Absent Commirsionar Eba4gM.
2.. Members of the Commisri.on requested ht tha minutes of February 11, 1958 be corrected to show the correct rpelling of Mrr. Schuyler's name, and on page 5 tbo motion mads by Co-. Swirslty road as follows: "That Resolut$on No. 54 be adopted recommoudiry an amendment to Section 1400 of Ordinance No. 9060 by adding a new item (1.5) Ambulance Service. and item (7.5) Mortuaries; and deleting Mo&uaried from Section 800 of Ordinance No. 9060". It was moved by Commb Jarvicj 8nd reconded by Comm. Engelmann that the minutes of February 11. 1!.S8 be approwd as correctod. All ayes. motion carried.
3- HEARING - Roeone - Eaat ri:le of Madiron, north of Graad - YoureU, et al. Rotice of hearing was read whrein an appacation for recmasiftcatton from
side of 'Madison, north of Grand Avepue, beginning at a point 100' north of Zona R-P to Zone Cs.2 of propwty described or those parcels on tha east
the intersection of Grand Aven ae and Madison Street. and continuing north
SAX1 and SA1 , baing a portion c.:i Block 48, Seaside lands. The application 120.50 feet more particularly inscribed in Asseeear% Code No. 35-119-
and plat map wsm presented ta +:am Commiasion for their review.. The Secretary stated that there was 10 written correspondence received, Mr. Yourell was present and was asled if he wished to state anything further on the matter
put up a can depoeif for him io arect a building on this property.
MR. ED. YOURELL, informed the Commission that he had a part bo had P
MR- WM. S. HEALEY, 2686 :JIodison, stated ,thst hi. property adjoined
notice in tho papcr and would Ske to ask what type of business was contem- &e property out had not rroeived a notice , however. he had road Oha
was contemplated, plated? Mr, Yourell informd the Commlseion that a Patio Furniture Shop
MR. JOE KINGSTON, 786 Gmnd Avenue, stated that tha proporty on the corner adjoining thir property war already in a C-2 Zone 8nd folt tbis proparty should bn aomd C-2 Aso. He further stated that this is a now City and 'CT~ should not hold ba k progress.
MR STEIN, owner of the Buynnd Seve propwty,. asked the Commission
ww?iZl turned down his abdication for .a C-2 Zone of his property
f.zzsir.g on l70000velt Street. &a:, Stein was informed tbnt at the time of &is npplfcation €01" the rezoning t f the Buy and Save' property this property
wa3 included $a the application, .nd 'tt that tirno.Mr. Skin had requested
that, this prcpmty be withdrawn lrom the application, It was suggested
that tho minutes of that meeting be reviewcbd, as tb members did not feel tba request bad bam turned down.
fAMgS SCAMLON, 2770 Madison Sereet, atated that he bad not been con-
Save Market had ‘Yeen put in the entire block b8kntwm G.rand Avenua and acted prior to receiving a notice by card, Ha felt fhat since the Buy and
Ar bucuc Court should be rezoned, and this applicatiol; should not be con- sidered until such time ao the entire block ie considered,
MR. TUCKER, 751 Arbuckle Court, rtatod thd Madison Street betwren G~and Avenue and Arbuckle Court io a dead street siWe the market had
gono in, and the entire black ohould be zoned C-2 as he did not feel that rasidential property should face commercial.
HUBERT SMITH, 2815 Jefferson &re&, aakod why, if Gknd Avenue between
and Grand Avenue ir to be zoned C-2, Jeffertun 6kou1d not be reaoned hdtson ana Jedreon is C-2 Zone, and Mad:.son between Arbuckle Court
between Grand Avenue and Arbuckle Court?
plan shoula be adopted before roacming this ama~ MR. STEIN, stated that the satire area ahodd be zoned 54 but a precire
MR. SCANLON stated he felt the area should ire reamed fird and at such he a$ a aumng ia to be erected then a precite plan shauld be adopted.
Public hearing clomd at 8:02 P.M.
Mrq Whitna11 informed tho Commisrion that if they coluidertd re&ming the whale arevt would have e0 be considorod at a Faparate haring as this proparty is tha 03dy one, that has bem published; the only amion before the Commission at tbiS time i6;ShOuld thin property be soned \*,“.-2; the ordinance statea “char alleye bo provided for in a cunmercial zc-m.
Mr. Yourell statad that he would dcdicah 10’ ahng the rear port.sn of this property for an allay.
thio block rezoned C-4 then theycould dedicate the rear portion oft teir
MP- ’VJMtmatl stated that if the property owners in the area desire t hive
Ad,
property EQP alley purposes and improve it under the 1911 Improvemnli
Mr, Yours11 infa-mad the Commission he had purchased a lot on Gran’
Avcrac 80 tkat in the eve& thio block would go commepcid there wouh be access from Grand Avenue.
After considerable discuesion Comm. Fennel movod that a committee bg appointad to cheek into tbis matter and report back to th~ Commiooion ct the meeting of rihrch llv 1956. Seconded by Cornm. Stringer. Chairm.u
the Commii%ea. Baumgarber appointed Comm3rraione~e stringer, Fennel and Jarvie to
Mr. Yourell infor:med tb Corhmisoion that i€ this math; could not be decihntd bcfcre the meding oE the 11th that he would have to withdraw kio
-2 ”
request because of tho ifme. eUment involved a5 be was leaving the latfer part of March for an extended vacation.
It wa5 suggested that the Committee atart immediately on their reprt and that an adjotped merting be held on Monday. March 3, 1958 at
as he would be out of town tlw nat of the week. The Chairman appinCed Comm. &ringer stated that he would bpve withdraw from the Codttea
Comm. Swir8ky to bis place and named Comm, Faanel as Cbafrman of the committee.
With th. conseat of tbe second, Comm. Fannri amended his motion to further consider the matter at an Bdjouraed moeting to be held on March 3, 1958. at 5:OO P.M. All ayes, motion carried.
at 9:.i5 P.M. A ohdrt'racese wae declared by tha Chairman. The meeting reconvened
9:OO P.M.
4.. AMBULANCE SERVXCE and MORTUARIES.
had transpired at tho het.meating regarding ambulance service and
ct5mm. Swirsky was astea to bnng tm r;ommiosion up to date as to what
mortuaries. He stabd that the real question regarding tbs0 two items io whether they should be excluded from "R" zones, if they w0rci to be added to Sectiau 1400, Conditional uses. Mr. Nelson stated that in re- viewing the sodug ordinance under conditional UM permit. they ara defined as to rcntriction of mnes. The only items permitted in a resb dentis1 area are ,;rho88 that bave to bo permitted ouch as €ire rtstiona,
moved that Resolution of Mention N.o. 4 be adopted to amend Zoning achooh, chu~cbo, Btc. After conalderable discu~~aion Comm. Swireky
Ordinance No. 9060 by adding to Saction 1400, Conditional Usos, Subscc- tion lorn, Ambulance Servico. and subsection lOdd, Mortuaries, which plaCQS both Ambubnce Service and Mortuariee u&r the items excluded from tho R-1, R-2 and R-3 sonas; deleting Mortuariee from Section 800, Subsection 2, Itern (i): and that the matter be eet for hearing March 11,
1958 at 7:30 P.M. Seconded by Comm. Stringer. Six ayes, Comma Ebright absent.
MRS. NEWMAN asked where an ambulance aervf ce could be placed? She states thstwmatter had been delayed for weeks, and that an ambulance
thc reason for lhc delay was that Ambulance Service had been omitted service VJRS R necessity to a community. Mrs. Newman was informed tbat
from the zoning ordinance.
STREET VACATION -- Portion of Buena Vista Circb - C. H. Wilson.
311 t~e rneutiug of r-ebruory 1 I, 1938
m&zu a reno& 3n the vacation of thio wrtion of Buem Vida Circle. Thai? a commltlee mu men appointee tb
.. repwf wan read and reviewed by the eommiosion. It was pointed out that if ths? City vacated thio portion. oE Bueaa Vista Circle that it would not go to the Wilsons, but to the adjoining property owners. Comm. Sbringer moved that the Conmiaaion submit a mnmorendum to tho Council recoma nrlending that this vacation be denied due to the following reasons:
~ .- .~ ~ ~~ ~
I. Tbt if the property weye to be vacated that it would go to the adjoining property owners.
2. That it would take approximately 176' away from a dedicated stre&
3. That it would deprive street frontage to the adjoining proprti@r.
s Seconded by Comrn. Engelmann. All aps, motion carried.
would. Comm. Swirokg movcd that Resolution of Mention No. 5 be adopkd reclassification of his proporty on Roorevolt Street. Hc stabd thot h9
for the purpose of calling a haring to consider the reclaseification of tbQ eaatrcrly half of the 17,,20 feet of Lot 31 and the aoeterly hlf of Lot 32,
for lMarch 25. 1948 at 7:30 P.M. Seconded by Comm. Fennel. Six ayes, Zjeaeide Land6 , from Zone R- P to Zone C-2, and that a hearing be set
Comm. Ebright absent. Resolution aaO]pted
7- Memo from City Council Street widths. Memorandum from the Council
was read wherein they requested tne.c;ommie~ion to consider street widthe for hillside properties. Mr. Whitnall 6uggGBtcd that they proceed with
grade increases to determine the curve. Ne 6taf.d that rev era^ of the standard widtha and make studies of hillside streets and plot out a6 the
was an angineeriq problem, and that exomplee should be made up in order grew are doing this at present. Comm. Swirrky atatad that he felt this
to set a policy foor tkese mtreete. It was mutually agreed by the Commission that Mr ; Vlhitull and the City Engineering Department wark on this problem to present to the Sommiasion for their review.
Memo from City Coancil - Entrance Gates. Memorandum from the City
Entrance Gates. After considerable di6CUSriOn Camm. Swirsky moved Council was reviewed, enclosing a propoaed statement of poiicy for
that tb Commission concur with &e Council in their propo8rd statement of policy in reforonce to their terms and conditions inpored for entrance
gates. Seconded by Comm. Jarvie. Fiw ayes, Comm. Stringer voting Itno"
Council that the Commission be furnished with a copy of sameo Comm. Swirsky requested that if thia policy was eBtablinhed by the
are more than rtgkt angles and that some &texttion should be given to this Comm. Feme1 ststed that there are seventeen corners in the City that
Washington Skeet and have it become a dedicated street. The City Manager aituation. MEO that consideraiion should be given to the extension of
pensive ~I*O~FZ~ :md we do not have the atsf€ to take care of them problums. stated that the City was well aware of %eo% problems; this was an 8x1
At the prcecnt i?me the staff is worlriug on the cornera around the High
SChOd.
Ms. UTXtnall suggedod that a irinaor meeting be held at 5:OO P.M. on
that iz dinner meeting be held at 5:OO P.M. at the pantry Shelf on March 11, March 11, 1958 * By muttrsl consent of *&e Commission it was agreed
1956.
-4"
Tt waa moved by Comm. Fennel and seconded by Comm. Engohanu tbat tb meeting he adjourned Po Adarch 3, 1958 at 5:OO P.M. A11 ayes, motion carrlcd. The meeting was declared adjourned at 10140 P.M.
Rerpectfully rubmitbd.
a
-5-