HomeMy WebLinkAbout1976-12-08; Planning Commission; MinutesMEETING OF: P.LANNINC; COMMISSION
DATE : December 8, 1976
TIFIE: 7:OO P.M.
' PLACE: COUNCIL CHAMBERS
CALL TO ORDER
The meetinq was cal'led to order at 7:96 P.M.
ROLL CALL
All .Present. . . '
APPROVAL OF M.1NUTE.S
Minutes of November 22, 1976 - Approved with
followina chanaes: Under Item 6 (PUD-1. Bil
note thai RombGtis abstained. Under Item 9,
101A, Bank of America), note thqt Watson and
abstained.
the lings), (CUP- * Romboti
APPROVAL OF RESOLUTIONS
Resolution No. 1296, Pe R. Hadley (GPA-40) - Not
approved as the app1ica;:'requested that this matter
be reconsidered by the Planning Commission.
A minu-te motion was made not approvinq this resolu-
tion as the anplicant will submit an amended appli"
cation requestins a commercial desiqnation in the .nature of travel services and traffic dependent commercial uses rather than extensive regional com- mercial. ..
Resolution No. 1298, Robert Gillinqham (WS-285) -
Approved.
Reiolution No. 1'299, M. Diana Pace Commendation -
Aoproved.
!?IRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS
Chairman L'Heureux stated that two individuals would
speak to the. Commission about holding a second meet-
inq in December, specifically December 22, as a hardship would be created if a hearinq was not held this year.
1.) Bob Knauf, Attorney at Law, 810 Yission Avenue
Suite 300, Oceanside, CA 92054 spoke on behalf
of Car Country and asked that a meetinq be held
on 12/22/76 to con-sider' the foFlowinq matters:
a) CUP to allow freestandinq signs; h) Review buildinq plans*for Rorick- Buick; .and c). Review buildina plans for Lincoln/Mercury
-
" - \
dealership.
.-2) Frank Wells, 2311 Warinq Way, Carlsbad, repre- sentative for Edward Langer, asked-thak PIS-295 he considered on December 22nd rather than on
Jan. 12, 1977 as the Lanqers would be unable
to sell their property after that date,.
A.minute motion was made to hold a regularly scheduled meetinq on December 22, 1976 at 7:OO P.M.
Commissioner Larson stated that he 'no objection to holding a meeting on 12/22/76 to hear any items that might be continued from tonight's hearing or to hear MS-295, but he did not wish' to hear Car Country's request ,as he felt the CUP should follow
the normal administrative channe1.s.
'resent
lotion
iyes
rbstain
lotion
lye s
,bstain
lotion
,yes
,bs ta i n
lotion
,yes
otion
Yes oes :
,,
X
X X
X X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X X
ORAL COMMUNICATLONS . ..
PUBLIC HEARINGS
Continued
1) Case Nos. CT 76-12 and PUD-4, Calavera Hills,
Robert Ladwiq (Agent) - Request for approval of
a tentative tract map and planned unit develoD-
i ment to provide 138 dwelling unit, 142 lot A
! subdivision on approximately 63 acres.
-
Acting Planning Director Bud Plender ga've the staff
prescntation and referred to a memorandum given to each Commissioner re amendments.
. . . . . . "" . . - . -~ ..- 1 -
CITY OF CARLSBAD- .
MEETING OF: PLAN[i.-.rG COMMISSION
DATE : December 8, 1976
TIFIE: 7:OO P.M.
PLACE: COUNCIL CHAMBERS . Page 2
Roy J. Ward, Lake Calavera Hills, 4321 Birch Street,
Newport Beach, Ca1iforni.a 92.660, owner/developer,
presiented a history of -the Calavera property,
the 'surrounding developments (both present and future), and what the entire Calavera Hills project would look like when completed. He also inquired
if all Commissioners.and Staff had received a copy
of his 1etter.of November 30, 1976 commenting on
cqnditions. All Commissioners-and Staff acknowledge
receipt of his--11 page letter. Mr. Ward closed by
saying they were concerned about three areas: 1)
Park Requirements, 2) Vidth of Tamarack Avenue, and 3) Access for emergency vehicles.
The Commissioners then discussed many aspects of this project, and felt that there were just too .many inconsistencies (that on the one hand, the applicant states he will accept the Staff's recommendations; but on the o.ther strongly.opposes many of the change as indicated in his letter).
A minute motion was made to continue CT 76-12 and PUD-4 to an adjourned Planning Commission meetinq on January 5, 1977 at 7:Or) p.m. They also directed the staff and the applicant to work closely together
Recess from 9:50 to 11):OO p.m. with all Commissioner present when meeting reconvened..
. to work out the various problems.. ..
.-.--'?) Case No.. CT 76-13, Samuel W. Pearlman - Request for approval of a 3 lot, 16 dwellinq unit condo- - minium project.
Mr. Plender stated that a school letter had not beer L received. -
Sam.ue1' W. Pearlman, 1801 Century Park 'East, Los
. Angeles, CA 90067 apologized to the Commission and to the Staff for the manv continuances of his case. ~~~.
He said that he was not ible to meet with the School Board until November 16th and has had diff;iculty in obtaining a surety bond that would take care of the fee requirements. He asked that this matter be
continued till February 9, 1976.
A minute motion was made to continue CT 76-1'3 to February 9, 1977.
"
3) Case No. CT 76-5, Rancheros de la Costa, La Cost;
Land Company - Request for approval ot a bY lot
!j
e;
C
I
1
.. -
lotion \yes
Motion .
Ayes
X
X X
n . . "
I. "". . - - .. .
MEETING OF: PLANNING COMMISSION
DATE : December 8, 1976
TIME: 7:OO P.M. PLACE: COUNCIL CHAMBERS Page 3
Fred Morey, Vice President, La Costa Land .Company, /
asked that this item be continued to a workshop
or to an adjourned meeting as many of the standard conditi"ons do not apply to this subdivision. 'He stated that Rancheros De La Costa is a different type of housing .that has not been created in Cads- bad prior to this time - it would involve minimum grading, low demand on public facilities, and rela- tively high as-sessed valuation, and it would be a subdivision with "rural. standards".
A minute motion was made continuing CT 76-5.to an adjourned meeting on January. 19, 1976 at 7:OO P.M.
New
.h"."..tr.r ."_ e-,... 4 b J' - .."
11 4) Case Nos. CT 76-17 and PUD-7., La Costa Land - Company -. Request for deletion of portions of SP-38 and resubdivision of approximately 50 .-'-*.. acres to provide 212 lots and 209 res,idential . . . units in a Planned Unit Development.
Mr. Plender gave the staff presentation stating that this would be a zero lot line development with lots averaging 5,800
Mr. Fred Morey, Vice President, La Costa Land Co. stated he concurred with staff's recommendation and conditions and the-changes submitted this eveninq by memorandum dated December 8, 1976.
Don Woodward, .The Woodward Companies, 4500 Campus Drive, Newport Beach, Ca., buil-der for Vale 11, answered questions regarding zero lot lin&develop- ments.
A motion was made approving CT 76-17 for the reasons a.nd conditions outlined by staff with changes indi- cated on December 8th memorandum.
A motion was- made approving PUD-7 for the reasons 'and conditions outlined by staff with chanqes indi- .cate on December 8th memorandum.
5) Case Nos. CT 76-15 and PUD-.6,.. Douqlass South- west Cor - Request for deletion oT Specific 18 Citv Council Reso. No. 3177. Auaust m" - 7, 1973) and approval 0-f CT .76-15 and-PUD-6- to allow for 136 single-family-detached dwell- "-: * .. ings on-43.99 acres.
Dan Salerno, Snipes and Salerno, 4007 Camino Del Rio South, Suite 207, San Diego, CA-92103, engineer for Douglass Southwest Corp. asked that the above - cases be continued to December 22, 1976.
A motion was made to continue CT 76-15 and PUD-6 to the meeting of December 22, 1976.
6) Case No. SP-l71(A), La Costa Land Company - Reauest for SDecific Plan Amendment to.provide
. foi, 18 lots on approximately 7 acres.
- -Bud Plender gave' the staff presentation stating that this.was basically an action of administrative clean-up.
A motion was made recommending approval of SP-171A per the reasons and conditions outlined in the staff report.
\ \\
.*
Motion Ayes
i.. __
q. ft.
Motion Ayes
MO t i on
A.WS
Moti'on . Ayes
!lotion
AY es
!
X
X
X
X
X
X
..-
X X
X X
X
X
x
...
X
X
X
X
X
MEETING OF: P-LANJING COMMISSION DATE : December 8, 1976 TIME: 7:OO P.M. PLACE: COUNCIL CHAMBERS Paqe 4
7) Case No. ZC-184, K. David Minnich - Request for
approval of i Z.one Change from R-1-7500 to R-P-f (Residential Professional with ?uali.fied Overla; Zone). The City of Carls,bad is mitigati'nq a change of zone over additional properties wi,th- .in the ar.ea -from R-1 to R-P-0..
Bud Plender gave the staff presentation advisi.ng the Commission.-that the Cit,y owned pr0pert.v on both sides of Elm had never been rezoned from R-1-7500 td R-P-I), thus the reason for the request at this time alonq with Mr. Minnich's request. He also stated that the property north. of Laguna to Knowles along Pi0 Pic0 Drive could not be considered as the Notice of Declaration of Nonsiqnificant Environ- mental Impact had not been done o.n this pro.perty.
Rodger A. Rusch, 1210 Stratford Lane, Carlsbad presented a petition to the Comm.ission with 21 signatures ,asking the Commission to deny ZC-184 for property along Pi0 Pic0 north of Laguna as they wished their area to remain a residential one. .. - L
Galen Nornhold, 4025 Baldwin-Lane, Carlsbad and James Scanlon,. 2955 Elmwood, Carlsbad stated.that they desired that this propertv be rezoned to R-P-fl and that the City' should-initiate this change of zone also for their properties that are on Laguna nor-th of City Hall site.
Chairman L'Heureux advised Mr. Nornhold and F.Zr. Scanlon that they could initiate a zone chdnge by app1,yinq for same.as did hlr. Flinnich, Flr. Plender added that a General Plan amendment may also be needed.
Mr.. Davi-d Min.nich, 2055 Linda Lane, Carlsbad stated he did not appreciate the Citv tanaina on their zone chanqe recommendations to his .zone change application as he felt it .had created many problems and he had not beeri notified by the City of their intent to do so.
.I i .I
Mr. Minnich was then advised by Mr. Plender that the City Council had directed the Planning Commissiot
to rezone properties within the area of a current - request so- that the area cou-ld be' brought into
"" General Plan consistency.. .. \
A motion was made recommending approval of ZC-184 per staff conditions to include only that- property indicated south of Laguna.
8) Case No. ZC-183, David Koyl - Request for approval of a change of'zone from R-1-7500'to RD-M..
Flr. Ko.y1 asked that this matter be continued till Janua.ry 12, 1976 as he was not aware that he needed a school letter for this particulaln pro,ject.
A motion was made.to continue this item to the -January 12, 1977 meetinq. . 9) Case No. CUP-128, City of Carlsbad - Request for approval of a conditional use Dermit to . " allow'the utilization of the.old Si. Patrick' Church site for recreational activities and meetings.
~~d plender gave the Staff presentation.
S
lotion \yes rbstain
lotion ,yes
X
X
K K
CITY OF CARL "3A.D .
DATE : December 8, 1976
TIME: 7:30 P.M.
PLACE: COUNCIL CHAMBERS
MEETING OF: 'PLANNING COMMISSIO!
Page 5
David Minnich, 2055 Linda Lane, Carlsbad, recommend€
approval of this CUP as many of these uses were
occurinq at the church site at thi.s time-.
The Commission then discussed many items they felt
were not covered by the Staff Report:
A motion was made .to continue this item to the m.eet-
i-ng of January 12, 1977 in order that more informa-
tion could be provided regarding water flow for .
fire protection, parking facilities, traffic flow,
etc.
NEW BUSINESS-
10) Planninq Commission Ca.lendar. - 1977
A motion was made apnrovinq the 1977 Planninq
Commission Calendar.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 12:15 a.m.
.. ...-
-r,
/mdp (1 2/17/76)
Motion Ayes
Motion
Ayes
X
X
X
X