Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1982-12-08; Planning Commission; MinutesMBBTn«; OF: DM'B a;, MEETDC: TIME OF MEE"l'DC: PLN:E OF MEETn«;: MINUTES P~n«; a»t!SSI~ Deoeni>er 8, 1982 7:00 P.M. City Council Olant>ers '1he meeting was called to order by Olairman Pan:ow at 7:05 P.M. Present -Olairman Farrow, Cannissicners, Schlehuber, Marcus, lbltx>tis, Joee and Rawlins. Absent -Camlissioner Friestedt. Staff Melli>ers present were: Bill Hofman, Principal PlannE:r Olarlie Grinn, Principal Planner David Hauser, Associate Civil Engineer Kent illiteon, Traffic Consultant Ex--Officio Meld:>ers present were: Michael Holzmiller, Land Use Planning Manager Daniel Hentschke, Assistant City Attorney PLEDGE OF Al.,l.a;I.AlCE was led by Olairman Farrow. O\aiman Farrow explained Planning Cannissioo procedures in its capacity as an advieory Cannissioo to the City Ck>uncil, and identified those matters delegated to the Planning Qalll\i.ssioo for a final decisioo. Olairman Farrow further explained the procedure observed by the Cannission during public hearing items. !D J?tBLIC HBARIK,S 1 ) Occidental Properties A) CT 81-5/SP-186, Jl!NB'1'l' -A request for a 17 lot t:Antatlw tract 11111) and a <Dlllllnity ~rcial/tourist CXlllllercial specific plan for a 17.6 acre area generally located on the northwest cu:ner of Interatate 5 and Poinsettia Lane. B) CT 81~ 82-3, Jl!NB'1'l' -A tentative subdivisioo map ti, ~tin o rrclal lots, and a site developnent plan fer CXlaLW\ity ocaarcial developnent oo prq,erty CJMWrally locaud on the southwest corner of rnt.ntate 5 and Poineettia Lane, east of Avenida llncinM. '11W atatf repcxt on the Mtter was presented by Bill , Prinajpal Plamer. tk. Homan ooted that there ~ to the •taff nport. Nao pa8Md out giving rwi.Nd oon&titlcn no. 26 to Aeeolutioo No. 2033 and ion ot 5 uhiblta far Specific Plan 186. Sea:lndly, c;p-a,;~1J1 no. 29, page 5 of ANolution No. 2033 mien) abcu1d be ~ to imioate lots 11 1 , ia la due to change in deeign. tk. Hofnllln flll:tlll.-that ataff -reo !ding in specific plan ion,, lMt Nnunc» (except Buolllyptus apeci•) (D MINUTES Deoenb:17 8 1983 Paae 2 COMM188IONEIIS \f "\" Mt . Hofman further presented staff presentation with over- head graphics and elaborated o" past designs. 'lhe Ccmnission reoognized Mr. Jack Henthorn, 2956 ltloeevelt Street, c.arlsbad, CA., of the Agatep Q)rporation, representing the applicant. Mt. Henthorn ooted that they basically ooncurred with staff reo:nnendations, with the following exceptions: Resolution No. 2033 -conditions 25 and 26. No. 25 -Felt it was too restrictive. No. 26 -felt 5,000 trip threshold should be IIR)lied. W'>uld like to have flexibility in oondition. Olairman Farrow opened public hearing and i~ired if anyone would like to speak en thE: matter. Since no one wished to speak, public hearing was closed. Following discussion, the Coomission aoopted the following resolutions subject to Condition No. 26 and O:nUtion No. 25, that it read 5,000 ADT at Aver,ina &lcinas and other oonditions and mne:dnents. REOOU1l'I0,1 t«>. 2032 -APPIOV!Mi SP-186, FOR A 23.6 ACRE 'J.OORIST CXMIEICIAl/CXMIJNITY <XMIER:IAL ARFA <amw..LY IJXATm O,I 'lliE tamH'Sl' ~ OF INI'ER- STATE 5 AND POINSBTl'IA LANE. ~10,I t«>. 2033 -APPIOV!Mi A S:IX'I'Em I.Dr Tl!N'rATIVE TRACI' MAP 0,1 PIOPERI'Y GaIBRALLY IJXATID O,I 'DIE ~ CXRmR OF INl'ERSTATE 5 AND POINSETTIA ~- B) er 81-6/SDP 82-3, JEiiE'l"l' Bill Hofllln pntNnted staff report indicating there was a ~ on page 3 of the staff report, site developnent pan, ... deletioo pertaining to Euoalyptus trees, also tha it,_. a 12 lot aubdivision. Mr. Bofaarl oanti....s with staff report and noted that •taff .-re-I lding ewr<JYal. Q\aiman Farrow oper-2 public hearing and i~ired if ~ wiahad to speak on the •tter. \be cxaaiuion re<Djp'\iaed Jack Henthom, 2956 ib:leew,lt, CUllbad, CA. , ~ing the Cl:adsaion, Mr. Henthol.i, a;,n•ld ... oanoama u the lut it on that ciroulation ocndition be reviewed and that ita 33 be -n.,-Sl'Mll'I to reflect ... IIUt as the north eection. inca no one el• wished to on the llllltter, Olairman Parrow cloNd the public hMril'¥J. Farrow X Marcus X lbtt>otis X Schlehuber X X Jose X Friestedt X Rawlins X Farrow X Marcus X R:fflxltis X Schlehwer X X Jose X Friestedt X Rawlins X MINUTES Decent>er 8, 1982 Paqe 3 Following discussion, Camdssion 8'q>ted the following resolutia\S with changes and amerdnents as noted by staff. 2) RESOU1l'IOI to. 2035 -APPIVJI?,li A TfNl'ATIVE SUBDIVISIOI Kl\P 'ID CREATE Tm COM:R:I.AL Wl'S 00 PRPERI'Y GmERALLY l.OCATED OI 'l1iE ~ O'.)R,IBR CF ~ATE 5 AND POINSETI'IA LANE, FA5T OF AVENIIY\ ~INAS. RESOU1l'IOI to. 2036 -APPIVJI?,li A SITE DE.VEWPMENI' PLAN OI PR::>PERl'Y Gm:RAI.LY I.DCATED OI 'l1iE samlWEST O'.>RNER OF ~ATE 5 AND POINSETI'IA LANE, FA5T OF AVENIIY\ ~INAS. ZCA-1~ CITY OF CARLSBAD -An amerdneni: to provide fort share c:iiiianlniiin projects by the requirement of a Conditional Use Permit. Mr. Bill Hofman, Principal Planner, presented staff report, essentially as oontained in the staff report on the matter. Discussion held on reductions in storage and parking and suanittal of plans for oonversion. Cllairman Farrow asked in anyone would like to speak on this item. Since oo one else wished to speak on this matter, public hearing ooncluded. Following discussion, Camdssion 8'q>ted the following resolution: 3) RBSOWl'IOI to. 2050 -APPIOV!Ki A ZOOE ODE Nl!IOl:!NT, MIH>IM'.. TITLE 21 OF 'l1iE CARLSBAD IUUCIPAL CXl>B BY '11IE MDITIOI OF SECTIOIS 21.04.357 Mil 21.42.010(10) 'ID DEFINE AND RlllJLATE '11iE DEVEUP- IBfl' OF TDE-SIIARE Pinnx:TS. IC-l6~l4(D)/SP-187 IUBS INVES'DIENl'S -Request to dewlap property Li.:ieciiately west of Plaza camioo RNl SNn perking lot into a cxmnercial retail and prot_.ional office center. QMarlie Gria, Principal Plamer, presented report, .-.ntially as contained in the staff TI!p()rt and meno pa9Nd out prior to Ocnaiaaioo meeting. Cllanges in repxt u follo.1 RNQlutioo No. l05~ -Condition No. 9 (Null and ~id) that it be changed to two (2) years. Farro,, X Marcus X lbltx>tis X Schlehti:>er X Jose X Friestedt X X Rawlins X Farro,, X Marcus X lbrbotis X Schlehuber X Jose X Friestedt X X Rawlins X Farrow X Marcus X lbrbotis X Schlehlt>er X Jose X X Friestedt X Rawlins X MINUTES Deoent,er 8, 1982 Page 4 Cbnditioo No. 25 -Be changed as per menoraml.111 (lot line adjustment). Daniel Bentschke, Assistant City Attorney, noted that there were changes to Conditioo No. 25 am were adjusted with oonferenoe held with applicant prior to meeting. After oonclusioo of staff presentatioo, floor turned over to Mr. Kent ltlitsoo, Traffic ConRultant, City of CMlsbad. Mr. "1itsoo addressed camri.ssioo giving background il".fomatioo. Chaiman Farrow q>end the public hearing am extended the invitatioo to speak. '!be Camrl.ssioo recognized lGl It>berts, representing Hughes Inves~nts. Mr. It>berts addressed the camri.ssion and staff's ..nicerns for traffic safety along Marron ~- After furthe, discussioo oo this matter with applicant, staff and Camrl.ssioo, staff ooncluded that their rec- cmnendatioo would be to approve project with the deletion of middle driveway with right-in/right-out access on Marron Ibid. After nuch elaboratioo oo all three resolutions am issues pertaining thereto, Cllairman Farrow asked if there were any further oannents or questions regarding item. Since there was oo further public testi.Joony, public hearing was closed. 'Dle Camrl.ssioo adopted the following resolutions with l!lllerllhents to Resolutioo No. 2059 as follows: ,t,aifications to Condition No. 6 am Conditioo No. 25. Also, to allow le.go on mnllllent (oo bottan). Identificatioo of 4 major tenants am drive-thru facilities be returned for Conditlooal use Permit. RBSOWl'IOO W. 2057 -APPIVVIN'.:, A ZCM: ~ ro itii.I(jj iiiE FUxiPLAIN OYERIAY ~ BX.IND,\RIE.S 00 PIO>BRrY GiiNBRALLY LOCATED Dlm>IATELY WEST OF 'ffiE PlAZA CAMm:) REAL SEARS PARKIN:; lDl'. RBSOW'l'la. W. 2058 -APPllJ'IIK. A l?RFX:ISE tiYlf2iiliir Pla\N MEIOl!NI' ro DELETE lDl' 00. 29 F10t '111B PLAIA C'Mll«) REAL PmX:ISE PLAN. 'DUS lDl' IS UXA'1'l!D a. '111B BX'm£IIE ~ l"W OF 'ffiE PLAZA CM1K> REAL pAll{DI. lDl' • Farrow X Marcus X lt:lttlotis X X Sc:hlehliler X Jose X Friestedt X Rawlins X Farrow X Marcus X R:.lltx>tis X X Sc:hlehli>er X Jose X Friestedt X Rawlins X ® MINUTES . Decent>er 8, 1982 Paae 5 RESOI.Ul'IOO 00. 2059 -APP~ A SPEX:IFIC l?LAN 'IO tE\TEIDP A <XMIEOCIAL RETAIL AND PFOFF.SSio,u..1, OFFICE cmrER. Olai rman Farrow called a recess at 9:15 P.M., and the Carmiss ion recxxwened at 9 : 3 5. 4) GPA-66(A), SCX1lllERS -A request to add a sea:>ndary arterial to the Circulation Element of the General Plan to connect with Rancho Del Oro arterial shown on the Oceanside Circulation Element. Olarlie Grillln, Principal Planner, presented report, essentially as oontained in the staff report on the matter. Mr. Grillln noted the issues involved with the oodition of Rancho del Oro and the possible problems that traffic oould cause on Marron Road. Staff also ir.dicated that this project may be premature since Council just appointed a Traff ic Circulation Advisory Carmittee. Staff noted that this camrittee 1oOuld study arterials in the whole City of Carlsbad. 01airman Farrow opened the public hearir¥3 and extended the invit ation to speak. 'lhe Comlission recognized Mr. Nick Banche, 702 Fourth Street, Oceanside, CA. Mr. Banche said that they were askir¥3 that Rancho del Oro be added to the Carlsbad Circulation Element. Mr. Banche stated that they feel it would be to the good of the City. Asked that they oonsider a certain traffic cx:>nsultant to look Oller the circulation issue. Stated that this could benefit carlsbad. 'lhe camdssion reoognized Mr. Olarles Strong, 5252 Balboa Avenue, San Diego, CA., Federal Art and Associates. Mr. Strong noted that this project was unique and that Oceanside was anxious to get this in, also would aid carlsbad. In response to a question, Mr. Grillln noted that there was two letters received which brought up negative points 1) cal Transi 2) Department of Fish and Game. Further discussion revealed that it would be to the interest of the Camdssion to allow the Traffic Circulation Camdttee to do there study and that this was pranature at this time. Pol.lowing diBUCBsion, the Comlission adopted the following resolution with reflection that they were not againat the item, but felt it was premature at this time, and that Buena Vista Lagoon be mentioned in the ll'Otion. Farrow X Marcus X Iattx>tis X X Schlehuber X Jose X Friestedt X Rawlins X MINUTES Decent>er 8, 1982 Page 6 RESOLl.11'100 00. 2056 -DtNYit-li AN AMmrMFNl' 'IO 'IHE CIRCUIATIOO EIDEfl' OF 'IHE GENERAL PLAN, WHIQi W'.XJU) ADO A SfX:nID,f\RY ARl'ERIAL a:mEC'l'Il'-li MARR™ ROM> WI'IH 'IHE RANCK) DEL QR) ARl'ERIAL IN OCEANSIDE APPIOXIMM'ELY • 75 MILE.5 FAST OF EL CAMIOO RF.AL 00 'IHE 9CUm SIDE OF HIGHWAY 78. 5) ZCA-150, CITY OF CARL.5BAD -Amendment to the Zoning Ordinance to mi3ify Section 21.04.065 (Definitions) to redefine •Building Height." Bill Hofman, Principal Planner, presented the report, with the aid of overhead graphics. After discussion, it was the reo:mnerrlation to continue item so that staff oould consider how the height of a parapet roof would be measured. 'nle item was continued to January 12 , 1983. 6) ZCA-153, CITY OF CARL.5BAD -An amendlrent to the zoning Ordinance to establish the Rl}-H, residential density high zone. Bill Hofman, Principal Planner, presented report essentially as contained in the staff report, with the following nodification: Cllange ordinance Section 21 .23.050, page two (2), arrl substitute with wording that was passed out to the Ccrnnission. Cllairman Farrow opened the public hearing an:l exterrled the invitation to speak. Since no one el se wished to speak oo the matter , Cllairman Farrow closed the public hearing. Following discussion, the following resolution was adopted: ~100 00. 2054 -APPRJV!l,I; A ZOOE CXDE AMaU4£Nl', A(IIIH)Ill:; TITLE 21 OF 'IHE CARL.5BAD KJNICIPAL ODE BY 'IHE ADDITIOO OF Oi.'\PTER 21.23 &S'l'ABLISHill:; 'IHE Rl>-H, RESIDmI'IAL DENSITY -HIGH ZOOE . Minutes of Noveni>er 10, 1982, approved as sul:Jnitted. Farrow Marcus Iarbotis Schlelruber Jose Friestedt Rawlins Farrow Marcus Iarbotis Schlehuber Jose Friestedt Rawlins Farrow Marcus lottx>tis Schlehuber Jose Friestedt Rawlins Farrow Marcus lottx>tis Schlehuber Jose Friestedt Rawlins X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X .· MINUT ·S Deoent>er 8 1982 P e 7 tJ'J proper notion, the meeting was adjourned at , ,:20 P.M. Respectfully Sutmitted, MIOiAEL J. OOLZMI Land Use Planning Manager Bibi Leak, Secretary II/Redevelopnent @)