HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-03-04; Clean Energy Alliance JPA; ; Adopt Resolution Establishing Initial Clean Energy Alliance Rates and Power Supply OptionsWIMP-
CLEAN ENERGY ALLIANCE
Staff Report
DATE: March 4, 2021
TO: Clean Energy Alliance Board of Directors
FROM: Barbara Boswell, Interim Chief Executive Officer
ITEM 1: Adopt Resolution Establishing Initial Clean Energy Alliance Rates and Power Supply
Options
RECOMMENDATION
1)Adopt Resolution 2021-007 Establishing Clean Energy Alliance Rates and Power Supply
Options.
2)Direct staff to develop a Renewable Energy Self-Generation Bill Credit Transfer Program and
Return to Board for Approval March 25, 2021.
3)Approve enrollment phasing of Net Energy Metering customers in Carlsbad and Del Mar.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Clean Energy Alliance (CEA) will begin serving customers in May 2021, with customer
enrollments occurring over the months of May and June. Before the Board for consideration is
adoption of initial customer rates and power supply options.
Clean Energy Alliance Rates
As a community choice aggregation program, CEA will replace San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E)
in the generation side of the electric service for customers in Carlsbad and Del Mar and replaces
Solana Energy Alliance for customers in Solana Beach. SDG&E will continue to be responsible
for delivering the energy, billing, responding to power outages, and maintenance of poles and
wires. Pursuant to the joint powers agreement (Agreement), CEA will procure energy to
achieve a portfolio from a minimum 50% renewable sources. In addition, the Agreement also
sets a target of establishing rates to provide a 2% savings compared to SDG&E on the
generation side of the customers' bill.
In order to ensure financial viability, and compliance with financing covenants, CEA must set
rates to produce revenue sufficient to fund power supply costs, debt payments, operating
expenses and a 5% operating reserve. The rates as proposed are estimated to generate
sufficient revenue to meet these requirements.
SDG&E Schedule CCA-CRS
(Eff. 3/1/21)
Carlsbad & Del Mar
2020 Vintage
Solana Beach
2017 Vintage
March 4, 2021
CEA Rates & Power Supply
Page 2 of 7
For ease in bill comparison, CEA's rates are designed to replicate SDG&E's current rate tariffs,
utilizing the same time of use periods. The comparable proposed CEA per kWh generation rate
compared to SDG&E's per kWh generation rate for residential rate schedule DR is as follows:
Residential Schedule DR
CEA
(per kWh)
SDG&E
(per kWh) % Difference
Summer (July 1 — Oct 31) $.12627 $.16964 (25.5%)
Winter (Nov 1 —June 30) $.04600 $.08659 (46.9%)
CEA's proposed summer generation rates are 25.5% lower than SDG&E's and proposed winter
generation rates are 46.9% lower. Unfortunately, due to additional charges assessed by
SDG&E, CEA's customers do not realize these significant cost savings.
Customers who enroll with CEA are charged a Power Charge Indifference Adjustment (PCIA or
exit fee) by SDG&E. The purpose of the exit fee is to pay any loss incurred by SDG&E in
liquidating energy supply contracts it has entered into on behalf of those customers.
Remaining SDG&E customers are to be "indifferent" when it comes to CCA enrollment. In
developing CEA rates, the exit fees are taken into account when comparing average monthly
electric utility costs of service between CEA and SDG&E. The exit fee is charged to customers on
a per kWh basis each month by SDG&E and is determined based on when the customer leaves
SDG&E's generation service. The exit fee is set annually through SDG&E's Energy Resource
Recovery Account (ERRA) rate setting process.
Solana Beach customers departed SDG&E in June 2018 when they enrolled with Solana Energy
Alliance, resulting in those customers being assigned the 2017 PCIA vintage. CEA customers
that depart SDG&E in May & June 2021 are assigned the 2020 PCIA vintage.
The applicable exit fees effective March 1, 2021 are:
$.03769 $.04340
The impact of the proposed CEA rates and exit fees on an average monthly bill comparison can
be seen in the following charts:
March 4, 2021
CEA Rates & Power Supply
Page 3 of 7
Carlsbad & Del Mar 2020 PC1A Vintage Customers:
Residential: DR CEA SDG&E % Difference
Generation $ 28.33 $ 43.06 -34.2%
SDG&E PCIA+FF5 -2020 Vintage $ 13.77 $ -
Generation Related Costs $ 42.10 $ 43.06 -2.2%
SDG&E Delivery $ 67.00 $ 67.00
Total Average Monthly Bill $ 109.10 $ 110.07 -0.9%
After taking into account SDG&E's exit fees, CEA's proposed rates provide a 2.2% savings on
generation related costs compared to SDG&E, achieving CEA's goal of 2% savings, based on
average customer usage on residential schedule DR rates. The average total monthly bill savings
is 0.9%.
Solana Beach 2017 PC1A Vintage Customers:
Residential: DR CM SDG&E % Difference
Generation $ 28.33 $ 43.06 -34.2%
SDG&E PCIA+FFS -2017 Vintage $ 15.78 $ -
Generation Related Costs $ 44.11 $ 43.06 2.4%
SDG&E Delivery $ 67.00 $ 67.00
Total Average Monthly Bill $ 111.11 $ 110.07 0.9%
For customers in the 2017 PCIA vintage, SDG&E's charges eliminate the generation savings,
resulting in generation related costs 2.4% higher than SDG&E, and total average monthly bill
.9% higher, or $1.04, higher than SDG&E bundled average costs.
The CEA Board requested additional products to be analyzed for rate impacts. These products
and rates are:
PRODUCT
Proposed
Per kWh
Rate
Average Monthly Cost
(Savings) based on
353 kWh
Green Impact - 100% Renewable Energy $.00750 $2.65
50% Renewable/75% Carbon Free Product $.00100 $.35
Local Impact - Minimum State Renewable Energy ($.00210) ($.74)
The proposed rates for the Green Impact and 50% Renewable/75% Carbon Free products are
based on the actual incremental costs of these energy products. Customers that opt-up to
Green Impact with average usage of 353 kWh per month, would incur a cost of $2.65 per
month.
March 4, 2021
CEA Rates & Power Supply
Page 4 of 7
The following bill comparisons reflects an average bill for a residential customer on Schedule
DR, enrolled in Green Impact:
Carlsbad & Del Mar 2020 PCIA Vintage:
Residential: DR CEA SDG&E %Difference
Generation $ 28.33 $ 43.06 -34.2%
Green Impact Premium $ 2.65
SDG&EPCIA+FFS -2020 Vintage $ 13.77 $ -
Generation Related Costs $ 44.75 $ 43.06 3.9%
SDG&E Delivery $ 67.00 $ 67.00
Total Average Monthly Bill $ 111.75 $ 110.07 1.5%
The average monthly bill for a residential customer in PCIA vintage 2020, who opts up to the
Green Impact 100% renewable energy product, would be $1.68 higher, or 1.5%, than taking
generation service with SDG&E's default (39% renewable in 2019).
Solana Beach 2017 PCIA Vintage
Residential: DR CIA SDG&E %Difference
Generation $ 28.33 $ 43.06 -34.2%
Green Impact Premium $ 2.65
SDG&E PCIA+FFS -2017 Vintage $ 15.78 $ -
Generation Related Costs $ 46.76 $ 43.06 8.6%
SDG&E Delivery $ 67.00 $ 67.00
Total Average Monthly Bill $ 113.76 $ 110.07 3.4%
The average monthly bill for residential customers in PCIA Vintage 2017, who opt up to Green
Impact, would be $3.69, or 3.4%, higher than SDG&E's default energy (39% renewable in 2019).
The costs of increasing to 50% Renewable/75% carbon free energy, which is the current Solana
Energy Alliance default power supply, would be an average cost of $.35 per month on customer
bills.
The bill comparisons for this product are as follows:
March 4, 2021
CEA Rates & Power Supply
Page 5 of 7
Carlsbad & Del Mar 2020 PCIA vintage customers:
Residential: DR CEA SDG&E % Difference
Generation $ 28.33 $ 43.06 -34.2%
50%115% Premium $ 0.35
SD G&E PCIA+FFS - 2020 Vintage $ 13.77 $ -
Generation Related Costs $ 42.45 $ 43.06 -1.4%
SDG&E Delivery $ 67.00 $ 67.00
Total Average Monthly Bill $ 109.45 $ 110.07 -0.6%
With the added 50% renewable/75% carbon free premium, the generation cost savings for CEA
customers is 1.4%, and total bill savings 0.6%.
Solana Beach 2017 PCIA Vintage customers:
Residential: DR CEA SDG&E % Difference
Generation $ 28.33 $ 43.06 -34.2%
50%/75% Premium $ 0.35
SDG&E PCIA+FFS -2017 Vi ntage $ 15.78 $ -
Generation Related Costs $ 44.46 $ 43.06 3.2%
SDG&E Delivery $ 67.00 $ 67.00
Total Average Monthly Bill $ 111.46 $ 110.07 1.3%
Increasing to the 50% renewable/75% carbon free energy results in an average bill being $1.39,
or 1.3%, higher than SDG&E's default energy.
CEA has been considering providing an energy product that would be based on the state's
minimum required renewable energy, for low income residential, and certain eligible small
business customers. The cost savings of reducing from 50% renewable to the state's minimum
36% renewable saves on average $.74 per month. Due to the low average monthly savings, the
Local Impact program is not recommended to be offered.
CEA Board has approved the Personal Impact Net Energy Metering program for those
customers who have self-generation systems such as rooftop solar. Throughout a 12-month
relevant period, customers kWh electricity production for their systems is tracked, and the total
kWh production is compared to the total kWh electricity used by the customer during those
same 12 months. If the customer's system produced more electricity than the customer used,
the customer is eligible for net surplus compensation. It is proposed the net surplus
compensation rate be set at $.06 per kWh. This is the same net surplus compensation rate
offered by Solana Energy Alliance. SDG&E's net surplus compensation rate that customers
receive for excess generation changes each month. During 2020, the rate fluctuated from a low
March 4, 2021
CEA Rates & Power Supply
Page 6 of 7
of $.01392/kWh in July 2020 to a high of $.04452/kWh in December 2020. CEA's proposed rate
of $.06 per kWh would exceed SDG&E's 2020 rates.
Power Supply Product Options
Staff recommends the following power supply product options to be offered at launch:
•Clean Impact — minimum 50% Renewable Energy Default
•50% Renewable/75% Carbon Free Energy Option —for cities to select as default
•Green Impact — 100% Renewable Energy Opt-Up for customers to elect
Based on the analysis, the savings generated by the lower renewable energy of the Local Impact
product do not provide any meaningful savings to the customer. As a result, staff does not
recommend approval of the Local Impact product.
Renewable Energy Self-Generation Bill Credit
CEA's eligible customer list identified accounts currently being served on SDG&E's Renewable
Energy Self-Generation Bill Credit tariff (RES-BCT). The RES-BCT program allows credits
generated by off-site generation facilities to be credited against other non-contiguous account
charges. This SDG&E program is not available to CEA customers, because SDG&E is not
providing the electric generation. In order to ensure customers enrolled in this program do not
lose the benefits they currently receive, it is recommended that the Board direct staff to
develop a RES-BCT program and return the proposed program terms and conditions to the
Board for approval at its March 25, 2021 meeting.
Net Energy Metering Customer Enrollment Phasing
Staff has been evaluating the eligible customer list and phasing of enrollment to determine
possible customer impacts that need to be addressed. Through this process, CEA and SDG&E
staff have considered the impact of enrollment on Net Energy Metering (NEM) customers.
Customers with self-generation systems, such as rooftop solar, apply to be enrolled in SDG&E's
net energy metering program. A 12-month relevant period is established, with the first month
being the first month the customer begins the program. Each month throughout the 12-month
period, customers receive credits for the energy generated by their system based on the rate in
effect at the time the energy is being generated. These credits offset charges on the
customer's bill. Credits and charges are accrued throughout the 12-months and trued-up at the
end of the 12-month period. When a NEM customer is enrolled with a CCA, the customer's
account is trued-up, no matter where the account is in their relevant period. This can result in a
customer having a charge due that could have been covered by generation credits if the
account had the benefit of the full 12-months.
March 4, 2021
CEA Rates & Power Supply
Page 7 of 7
In order to avoid mid cycle true-ups, CEA staff and SDG&E agree that it is in the best interest of
the Carlsbad and Del Mar NEM customers to enroll them in CEA in the month their relevant
period ends. Doing so ensures the customer has the benefit of the full 12-months and allows
the customer to maintain their current 12-month relevant period. Solana Beach NEM
customers have a relevant period ending in May, which coincides with their planned transition
to CEA. Staff recommends that the CEA Board approve the NEM phasing, with Carlsbad and Del
Mar NEM customers enrolling in CEA in the month of their true-up.
FISCAL IMPACT
Proposed CEA rates have been developed to ensure sufficient revenue is collected to fund
operating costs including power supply, debt service, administration and a 5% reserve
contribution.
ATTACHMENTS
Resolution 2021-007 Establishing Initial Clean Energy Alliance Rates and Power Supply Options
DocuSign Envelope ID: AC467BC7-2DAD-40CD-B9DE-D365F1326B47
CLEAN ENERGY ALLIANCE
RESOLUTION NO. 2021-007
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE CLEAN ENERGY
ALLIANCE ESTABLISHING INITIAL CLEAN ENERGY ALLIANCE RATES AND
POWER SUPPLY PRODUCT OFFERINGS
WHEREAS, the Clean Energy Alliance (CEA) is a joint powers agency, formed in
November 2019, by the founding members cities of Carlsbad, Del Mar and Solana Beach; and
WHEREAS, Section 4.6 of the Joint Powers Authority (JPA) Agreement establishes the
specific responsibility of the CEA Board of Directors to adopt retail rates for power; and
WHEREAS, Section 6.5 of the JPA Agreement states CEA's power supply base product
will be greater than or equal to 50% qualified renewable resources and the Board shall establish
other product offerings; and
WHEREAS, CEA will begin serving customers in May 2021; and
WHEREAS, the CEA Board desires to set initial rates and power supply products.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Board of Directors of the Clean Energy
Alliance, as follows:
Section 1. The Board of Directors of the Clean Energy Alliance hereby sets initial CEA
Rates as detailed in Exhibit A.
Section 2. The Board of Directors of the Clean Energy Alliance hereby establishes initial
product offerings:
Clean Impact — minimum 50% Renewable Energy Default Product
Green Impact — 100% Renewable Energy Product Voluntary Opt-Up
50% Renewable/75% Carbon Free Product Option for Member Agencies to select
as default.
1
DocuSign Envelope ID: AC467BC7-2DAD-40CD-B9DE-D365F1326647
The foregoing Resolution was passed and adopted this 4th day of March 2021, by the
following vote:
AYES: Druker, Bhat-Patel, Becker
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
APPROVED:
‘risfi tub%
7PnAgncnA &tuba
Kristi Becker, Chair
ATTEST:
L
DocuSigined by:
5401:4 ediark
Sheila Cobian, Interim Board Secretary
DobuSIgned by: L
23A78718710248C...
Exhibit A
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Schedule DR, DM, DS, DT, DT-RV
Summer
Winter
Schedule DR-LI and medical baseline customers
Summer
Winter
Schedule E-LI (Non-Residential CARE)
E-LI for Schedules (TOU-A, TOU-A-2, TOU-A-3, TOU-M
Summer
Winter
E-LI for Schedules AL-TOU, AL-TOU-2, DG-R
Summer
Winter
Schedules DR-TOU, DR-TOU-CARE, DR-TOU-MB
Summer
On-Peak Energy: Up to 130% of Baseline
On-Peak Energy: Above 130% of Baseline
Off-Peak Energy: Up to 130% of Baseline
Off-Peak Energy: Above 130% of Baseline
Winter
On-Peak Energy: Up to 130% of Baseline
On-Peak Energy: Above 130% of Baseline
Off-Peak Energy: Up to 130% of Baseline
Off-Peak Energy: Above 130% of Baseline
Schedules DR-SES, DR-SES-CARE, DR-SES-MB
Summer: On-Peak Energy
Summer: Off-Peak Energy
Summer: Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter: On-Peak Energy
Winter: Off-Peak Energy
Winter: Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedule EV-TOU
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
CEA Rate
0.12627
0.04600
0.12627
0.04600
0.07815
0.05937
0.09216
0.07007
0.15637
0.15637
0.08247
0.08247
0.02485
0.02485
0.01880
0.01880
0.34361
0.08454
0.02475
0.04529
0.03597
0.02563
0.34361
0.08454
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective M ay 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedules EV-TOU-2, EV-TOU-2-CARE, EV-TOU-2-MB
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedule EV-TOU-5, EV-TOU-5-CARE, EV-TOU-5-MB
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedule TOU-DR-1, TOU-DR-1-CARE, TOU-DR-1-MB
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedule TOU-DR-2, TOU-DR-2-CARE, TOU-DR-2-MB
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
CEA Rate
0.02475
0.04529
0.03597
0.02563
0.34361
0.08454
0.02475
0.04529
0.03597
0.02563
0.34361
0.08454
0.02475
0.04529
0.03597
0.02563
0.31427
0.07525
0.02001
0.05756
0.04686
0.03499
0.31427
0.05431
0.05756
0.04162
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Schedule TOU-DR, TOU-DR-CARE, TOU-DR-MB
Summer .
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedule TOU-A
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Schedule TOU-A-2
Secondary
Primary
Secondary
Primary
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
CEA Rate
0.19916
0.13968
0.08079
0.04470
0.03544
0.02518
0.20216
0.20099
0.09542
0.09478
0.05301
0.05261
0.03789
0.03763
0.27076
0.26930
0.08397
0.08341
0.03121
0.05119
0.05081
0.04178
0.04147
0.03124
0.03104
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Schedule TOU-A-3
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Schedule A-TC
Summer
Winter
Schedule TOU-M
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedule OL-TOU
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
CEA Rate
0.20551
0.20437
0.11379
0.11308
0.03087
0.03057
0.05120
0.05082
0.04179
0.04148
0.03125
0.03105
0.04181
0.04181
0.27390
0.08469
0.03223
0.05138
0.04195
0.03139
0.36333
0.11207
0.04171
0.06699
0.05552
0.04280
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Schedule AL-TOU
Maximum On-Peak Demand: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Maximum On-Peak Demand: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
CEA Rate
12.19000
12.13000
12.19000
12.13000
11.61000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.11435
0.11364
0.11435
0.11364
0.10725
0.08973
0.08915
0.08973
0.08915
0.08387
0.06072
0.06039
0.06072
0.06039
0.05653
0.09230
0.09171
0.09230
0.09171
0.08637
0.07796
0.07750
0.07796
0.07750
0.07287
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Schedule AL-TOU-2
Maximum On-Peak Demand: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Maximum On-Peak Demand: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
CEA Rate
0.06206
0.06174
0.06206
0.06174
0.05785
21.31000
21.20000
21.31000
21.20000
20.30000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.10124
0.10058
0.10124
0.10058
0.09475
0.07884
0.07831
0.07884
0.07831
0.07349
0.05181
0.05151
0.05181
0.05151
0.04801
0.08045
0.07991
0.08045
0.07991
0.07507
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Schedule DG-R
On Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
CEA Rate
0.06745
0.06702
0.06745
0.06702
0.06283
0.05303
0.05274
0.05303
0.05274
0.04920
0.36212
0.36153
0.36212
0.36153
0.35634
0.17200
0.17134
0.17200
0.17134
0.16524
0.10076
0.10050
0.10076
0.10050
0.09742
0.06705
0.06658
0.06705
0.06658
0.06230
0.05556
0.05518
0.05556
0.05518
0.05147
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Schedule A6-TOU
Maximum Demand at Time of System Peak: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Maximum Demand at Time of System Peak: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Schedule TOU-PA < 20kW
On Peak Demand
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
CEA Rate
0.04281
0.04256
0.04281
0.04256
0.03943
12.13000
12.13000
11.61000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.11364
0.11364
0.10725
0.08915
0.08915
0.08387
0.06039
0.06039
0.05653
0.09171
0.09171
0.08637
0.07750
0.07750
0.07287
0.06174
0.06174
0.05785
0.00000
0.15980
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
CEA Rate
0.15888
0.07645
0.07594
0.04346
0.04313
0.03022
0.03000
8.76000
8.72000
0.00000
0.00000
0.06453
0.06410
0.04904
0.04869
0.03472
0.03442
0.05487
0.05449
0.04572
0.04542
0.03558
0.03538
0.00000
0.00000
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
On Peak Energy: Winter
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Schedule TOU-PA-2 >=20kW
On Peak Demand
Summer
Winter
Primary
Secondary
Primary
Secondary
Primary
Secondary
Primary
Secondary
Primary
Secondary
Pri mary
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Pri mary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Schedule TOU-PA-3 < 20kW
On Peak Demand
Summer
Secondary
Primary
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Winter
Secondary
Primary
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Schedule TOU-PA-3 >=20kW
On Peak Demand
Summer
Secondary
Primary
Winter
Secondary
Primary
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
CEA Rate
0.00000
0.00000
0.18784
0.18681
0.08413
0.08360
0.02880
0.02853
0.04216
0.04184
0.03444
0.03419
0.02589
0.02571
2.07000
2.06000
0.00000
0.00000
0.11804
0.11736
0.08975
0.08919
0.02041
0.02018
0.05539
0.05502
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Secondary
Primary
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Schedule PAT-1
On Peak Demand
Summer
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Winter
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Super Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Schedules LS-1, LS-2, LS-3, OL-1, DWL and LS-2 DS
Energy: Summer
Energy: Winter
CEA Rate
0.04619
0.04588
0.03598
0.03577
4.87000
4.85000
4.64000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.07458
0.07410
0.06978
0.05750
0.05711
0.05356
0.04180
0.04157
0.03883
0.06430
0.06389
0.06008
0.05409
0.05376
0.05046
0.04277
0.04255
0.03977
0.05338
0.05338
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Schedule OL-2
Energy: Summer
Energy: Winter
Schedule LS-2 AD
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
TOU GRANDFATHERING COMMODITY RATES
Schedule DR-SES
Summer
Winter
Schedule EV-TOU
Summer
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedules EV-TOU-2, EV-TOU-2-CARE, EV-TOU-2-MB
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Super Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
CEA Rate
0.06420
0.06420
0.21239
0.12067
0.03775
0.05808
0.04867
0.03813
0.34056
0.34054
0.08745
0.08016
0.07308
0.29370
0.27470
0.05128
0.06891
0.06116
0.05011
0.28950
0.25239
0.05128
0.06504
0.06413
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Super Off-Peak Energy
Schedule TOU-DR, TOU-DR-CARE, IOU-DR-MB
Summer
On-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Winter
On-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
Schedule TOU-M
Summer
Winter
Schedule OL-TOU
Summer
Winter
Schedule TOU-A
On-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
On-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
On-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
On-Peak Energy
Semi-Peak Energy
Off-Peak Energy
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Semi-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
CEA Rate
0.05011
0.23966
0.14414
0.10104
0.05317
0.03951
0.03121
0.17167
0.16618
0.04096
0.06005
0.04626
0.03756
0.22801
0.21127
0.05744
0.07402
0.05762
0.04763
0.21792
0.21660
0.11407
0.11331
0.03411
0.03377
0.05730
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Primary
Semi-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Schedule AL-TOU
Maximum On-Peak Demand: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Maximum On-Peak Demand: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Semi-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
CEA Rate
0.05686
0.04393
0.04359
0.03547
0.03525
6.94000
6.90000
6.94000
6.90000
6.59000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.10808
0.10732
0.10808
0.10732
0.10101
0.10088
0.10024
0.10088
0.10024
0.09449
0.07302
0.07263
0.07302
0.07263
0.06826
0.10419
0.10353
0.10419
0.10353
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Transmission
Semi-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Schedule DG-R
On Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Semi-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy; Summer
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Semi-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
CEA Rate
0.09758
0.08324
0.08272
0.08324
0.08272
0.07782
0.07048
0.07012
0.07048
0.07012
0.06588
0.23597
0.23534
0.23597
0.23534
0.23011
0.22188
0.22126
0.22188
0.22126
0.21608
0.09649
0.09614
0.09649
0.09614
0.09225
0.07854
0.07799
0.07854
0.07799
0.07314
0.06144
0.06102
0.06144
0.06102
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Secondary Substation
Primary Substation
Transmission
Schedule A6-TOU
Maximum Demand at Time of System Peak: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Maximum Demand at Timeof System Peak: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Semi-Peak Energy: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
On Peak Energy: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Semi-Peak Energy: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Primary
Primary Substation
Transmission
Schedule PA-T-1
On Peak Demand
CEA Rate
0.05702
0.05104
0.05074
0.05104
0.05074
0.04728
6.90000
6.90000
6.59000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.10732
0.10732
0.10101
0.10024
0.10024
0.09449
0.07263
0.07263
0.06826
0.10353
0.10353
0.09758
0.08272
0.08272
0.07782
0.07012
0.07012
0.06588
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Summer
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Winter
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Semi-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
On Peak Energy: Winter
Semi-Peak Energy: Winter
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Secondary
Primary
Transmission
Schedule TOU-PA < 20kW
On Peak Demand
Summer
Secondary
Primary
Winter
Secondary
Primary
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
CEA Rate
2.37000
2.36000
2.25000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.06911
0.06861
0.06439
0.06453
0.06410
0.06025
0.05050
0.05023
0.04712
0.07270
0.07222
0.06799
0.05778
0.05741
0.05392
0.04871
0.04844
0.04543
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.20298
0.20177
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1, 2021 (Proposed)
Semi-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Semi-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Schedule TOU-PA >=20kW
On Peak Demand
Summer
Secondary
Primary
Winter
Secondary
Primary
On-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Semi-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Summer
Secondary
Pri mary
On Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Semi-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
Off-Peak Energy: Winter
Secondary
Primary
CEA Rate
0.08133
0.08076
0.03270
0.03239
0.04583
0.04548
0.03495
0.03468
0.02833
0.02815
0.98000
0.97000
0.00000
0.00000
0.15724
0.15628
0.08204
0.08147
0.02516
0.02489
0.06417
0.06373
0.05054
0.05019
0.04224
0.04201
Clean Energy Alliance
Generation Rates Effective May 1,2021 (Proposed)
Green Impact
Customers electing the 100% renewableGreen Inpact option will paythe applicable
ratefor Clean Impact service plusthefollowing energy charge:
Summer
Winter
TBD
Customers electing the 50% renewable and 75% Carbon Free option will pay theapplicable
rate for Clean Impact service plusthefollowing energy charge:
Summer
Winter
CEA Rate
0.00750
0.00750
0.00100
0.00100