The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2743 STIRLING CT; ; CBR2020-1988; PermitBuilding Permit Finaled Print Date: 07/19/2021 Job Address: Permit Type: Parcel#: Valuation: Occupancy Group: #of Dwelling Units: Bedrooms: Bathrooms: Occupant Load: Code Edition: Sprinkled: Project Title: 2743 STIRLING CT, BLDG-Residential 2081112500 $48,543.30 Residential Permit CARLSBAD, CA 92010-6509 Work Class: Addition Track#: Lot#: Project#: Plan#: Construction Type: Orig. Plan Check#: Plan Check#: {city of Carlsbad Permit No: CBR2020-1988 Status: Applied: Issued: Finaled Close Out: Inspector: Final Inspection: Closed -Fina led 08/24/2020 10/06/2020 PBurn 07/19/2021 Description: BATTAILE: 237 SF ADDITION (CALIFORNIA ROOM)// 180 SF KITCHEN REMODEL//REPLACE SLIDING DOOR AND WINDOWS// REPLACE AC, LIKE FOR LIKE// 200A PANEL UPGRADE (EVSE READY REQUIRED) FEE BUILDING PERMIT FEE ($2000+) BUILDING PLAN CHECK FEE (BLDG) Property Owner: OWNER BATTAILE KRISTEN L 2743 STIRLING CT CARLSBAD, CA 92010 ELECTRICAL BLDG RESIDENTIAL NEW/ADDITION/REMODEL GREEN BUILDING STANDARDS PLAN CHECK & INSPECTION MECHANICAL BLDG RESIDENTIAL NEW/ADDITION/REMODEL PLUMBING BLDG RESIDENTIAL NEW/ADDITION/REMODEL SB1473 GREEN BUILDING STATE STANDARDS FEE STRONG MOTION-RESIDENTIAL SWPPP INSPECTION FEE TIER 1-Medium BLDG SWPPP PLAN REVIEW FEE TIER 1-MEDIUM Total Fees: $1,308.63 Total Payments To Date: $1,308.63 Balance Due: AMOUNT $399.60 $279.72 $41.00 $175.00 $42.00 $62.00 $2.00 $6.31 $246.00 $55.00 $0.00 Please take NOTICE that approval of your project includes the "Imposition" of fees, dedications, reservations, or other exactions hereafter collectively referred to as "fees/exaction." You have 90 days from the date this permit was issued to protest imposition of these fees/exactions. If you protest them, you must follow the protest procedures set forth in Government Code Section 66020(a), and file the protest and any other required information with the City Manager for processing in accordance with Carlsbad Municipal Code Section 3.32.030. Failure to timely follow that procedure will bar any subsequent legal action to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul their imposition. You are hereby FURTHER NOTIFIED that your right to protest the specified fees/exactions DOES NOT APPLY to water and sewer connection fees and capacity changes, nor planning, zoning, grading or other similar application processing or service fees in connection with this project. NOR DOES IT APPLY to any fees/exactions of which you have previously been given a NOTICE similar to this, or as to which the statute of limitation has previously otherwise expired. Building Division Page 1 of 1 1635 Faraday Avenue, Carlsbad CA 92008-7314 I 760-602-2700 I 760-602-8560 f I www.carlsbadca.gov C City of Carlsbad S.--k r I, "j c...t. Job Address 2743 Striling et-- RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION B-1 Plan Check (]lZ1..02..D-t<f5-S Est. Value J:l>4 I) S"V.3.. 30 --1- PC Deposit Date .S 6--L Lf-LD2-0 Suite: ____ .APN: 208-111-25 CT/Project #: _________________ Lot#: 106 Year Built: _1_9_8_2 ______ _ Fire Sprinklers: O YES ¢No Air Conditioning: ¢YES O NO Electrical Panel Upgrade: 0 YES¢ NO BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF WORK: Addition of 237 SF California Room (Open Air), replace sliding door, associated perimeter site work, replace windows and sliding glass door (East), Kitchen remodel, Interior finishes Ii] Addition/New: 237 SF Living SF,. ____ Deck SF, ____ Patio SF,,--___ Garage SF __ _ Is this to create an Accessory Dwelling Unit? O Y pJN New Fireplace? Q v ¢N, if yes how many? __ Ii] Remodel: 180 SF SF of affected area Is the area a conversion or change of use ? O v ~N 0 Pool/Spa: ____ SF Additional Gas or Electrical Features? New Gas Range ------------- o solar:. ___ KW,, ___ Modules, Mounted:O Roof O Ground, Tilt: 0 vO N, RMA: O v O N, Battery: Ov O N, Panel Upgrade: Ov O N Ii] Reroof: Only in affected area by demolition for connection of new CA Room Roof D Plumbing/Mechanical/Electrical Only: _______________________ _ D Other: This permit is to be Issued in the name of the Property Owner as Owner-Builder, licensed contractor or Authorized Agent of the owner or contractor. Th e person listed as the Applicant below will be the main point of contact throughout the permit process, PROPERTY OWNER APPLICANT 0 Name: Kristen Battaile Address: 2743 Stirling Ct. City: Carlsbad State:._c_A __ Zip: 92010 Phone: 760-525-8489 Email: macalear2@gmail.com ' DESIGN PROFESSIONAL Name: Steven Noel Address: 2715 Greenock Ct APPLICANT [ii City: Carlsbad State:_c_A __ Zip: 92010 Phone: 760-535-7847 Email: STEVEN.NOEL.ARCHITECT@GMAIL.COM PROPERTY OWNERS AUTHORIZED AGENT APPLICANT 0 Name:, ____________________ _ Address: ___________________ _ City: __________ State:. ___ Zip:. ____ _ Phone: ___________________ _ Email: macalear2@gmail.com CONTRACTOR OF RECORD Name: Nathan Joseph -Truellne Contracting, Inc. Address: 1605 Chestnut Ave APPLICANT 0 City: Carlsbad State: CA Zip:._9_20_0_8 ____ _ Phone: 760-707-9235 Email: NAJOSEPH4@gmail.com Architect State License: _c_2_95_53 _________ _ State License/class:._0_·9_4.,.17..,,27,...... __ Bus. License: 27•1111640 __.;,;?4-'" b losctdfso 163S Faraday Ave Carlsbad, CA 92008 Ph: 760-602-2719 Fax: 760-602-8558 Email: 8ullding@carlsbadca.gov REV. 08/20 10~0 WILL PERFORM THE WORK BY COMPLETING (OPTION A) OR (OPTION B) BELOW: <::foPTION.Al-. LICENSED CONTRACTOR DECLARATION: I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am licensed under provisions of Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 7000} of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code, and my license is in full force and effect. I also affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following declarations: 0 I have and will maintain a certificate of consent to self-Insure for workers' compensation provided by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the performance of the work which this permit is Issued. Policy No. _______________________________________ _ 0 I have and will maintain worker's compensation, as required by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the performance of the work for which this permit is issued. My workers' compensation Insurance carrier and policy number are: Insurance Company Name: _____________________ _ Policy No. ___________________________ ,Expiration Date: ______________ _ Iii Certificate of Exemption: I certify that In the performance of the work for which this permit is issued, I shall not employ any person In any manner so as to become subject to the workers' compensation Laws of California. WARNING: Failure to secure workers compensation coverage Is unlawful and shall subject an employer to criminal penalties and civil fines up to $100,000.00, In addition the to the cost of compensation, damages as provided for In Section 3706 of the Labor Code, Interest and attorney's fees. CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY, IF ANY: I hereby affirm that there is a construction lending agency for the erformance of the work this permit is issued (Sec. 3097 (I) Civil Code). (OPTION B): OWNER-BUILDER DECLARATION: I hereby affirm that I am exempt from Contractor's License Law for the following reason: 0 I, as owner of the property or my employees with wages as their sole compensation, will do the work and the structure is not intended or offered for sale (Sec. 7044, Business and Professions Code: The Contractor's License Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, and who does such work himself or through his own employees, provided that such Improvements are not intended or offered for sale. If, however, the building or Improvement is sold within onr .r of completion, the owner-builder will have the burden of proving that he did not build or improve for the purpose of sale). r , as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project (Sec. 7044, Business and Professions Code: The .mtractor's License Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or Improves thereon, and contracts for such projects with contractor(s) licensed pursuant to the Contractor's License Law). 0 I am exempt under Business and Professions Code Division 3, Chapter 9, Article 3 for this reason: 0 "Owner Builder acknowledgement and verification form" has been filled out, signed and attached to this application. Proof of identification attached. 0 Owners "Authorized Agent Form" has been filled out, signed and attached to this application giving the agent authority to obtain the permit on the owner's behalf. Proof of identification attached. By my signature below I acknowledge that, except for my personal residence in which I must have resided for at least one year prior to completion of the improvements covered by this permit, I cannot legally sell a structure that I have built as an owner-builder if it has not been constructed in its entirety by licensed contractors. I understand that a copy of the applicable law, Section 7044 of the Business and Professions Code, Is available upon request when this application is submitted or at the following Web site: http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/ca/aw.html. ./ ..-:::;:::::7__ / . • I <'. OWNER PRINT/SIGN:_ (' . ...,_____ APPLICANT CERTIFICATION: SIGNATURE REQUIRED AT THE TIME OF SUBMITTAL By my signature below, I certify that: I am the property owner or State of California Licensed Contractor or authorized to act on the property owner or contractor's behalf. I certify that I have read the application and state that the above information is correct and that the information on the plans is accurate. I agree to comply with all City ordinances and State laws relating to building construction. I hereby authorize representative of the City of carlsbad to enter upon the above mentioned property for inspection purposes. I ALSO AGREE TO SA VE, INDEMNIFY AND KEEP HARMLESS THE CITY OF CARLSBAD AGAINST ALL LIABILmEs, JUDGMENTS, COSTS AND EXPENSES WHICH MAY IN ANY WA y ACCRUE AGAINST SAID CITY IN CONSEQUENCE OF THE GRANTING OF THIS PERMIT. OSHA: An OSHA permit is required for excavations over 5'0' deep and demo/;t;on o, ,on,t,uet;on of"'?~" he;ght. APPLICANT PRINT/SIGN:~ <t <'=< ( DATE: 0 .1,/J,'J,i:> 1635 Faraday Ave carlsbad, CA 92008 Ph: 760-602-2719 Fax: 760-602-8558 Email: Building@carlsbadca.gov 2 REV. 08/20 PERMIT INSPECTION HISTORY for (CBR2020-1988} Permit Type: BLDG-Residential Work Class: Addition Status: Closed -Finaled Application Date: 08/24/2020 Owner: OWNER BATTAILE KRISTEN L Issue Date: 10/06/2020 Subdivision: CARLSBAD TCT#76-12 Expiration Date: 07/27/2021 IVR Number: 28211 Address: 2743 STIRLING CT CARLSBAD, CA 92010-6509 Scheduled Date Actual Inspection Type Start Date Inspection No. Inspection Status Primary Inspector Reinspection Inspection Checklist Item BLDG-Building Deficiency BLDG-Plumbing Final BLDG-Mechanical Final BLDG-Structural Final BLDG-Electrical Final Monday, July 19, 2021 COMMENTS July 19, 2021: 1. No final building inspection Deficiencies. 2. Final structural, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical scope of work, per structural/architectural plans and detail specifications -approved. 3. Forms 8-59 (waste management), and B-51 (Green building/mandatory measures)-obtained and filed in city records. July 19, 2021: 1. No final building inspection Deficiencies. 2. Final structural, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical scope of work, per structural/architectural plans and detail specifications -approved. 3. Forms 8·59 (waste management), and 8·51 (Green building/mandatory measures)-obtained and filed in city records. July 19, 2021: 1. No final building inspection Deficiencies. 2. Final structural, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical scope of work, per structural/architectural plans and detail specifications -approved. 3. Forms 8·59 (waste management), and B-51 (Green building/mandatory measures)-obtained and filed in city records. July 19, 2021: 1. No final building inspection Deficiencies. 2. Final structural, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical scope of work, per structural/architectural plans and detail specifications -approved. 3. Forms s.59 (waste management), and 8·51 (Green building/mandatory measures)-obtained and filed in city records. July 19, 2021: 1. No final building inspection Deficiencies. 2. Final structural, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical scope of work, per structural/architectural plans and detail specifications -approved. 3. Forms B-59 (waste management), and B-51 (Green building/mandatory measures)-obtained and filed in city records. Passed Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Page 3 of 3 PERMIT INSPECTION HISTORY for (CBR2020-1988) Permit Type: BLDG-Residential Application Date: 08/24/2020 Owner: OWNER BATTAILE KRISTEN L Work Class: Addition Issue Date: 10/06/2020 Subdivision: CARLSBAD TCT#76-12 Status: Closed -Finaled Expiration Date: 07/27/2021 Address: 2743 STIRLING CT IVR Number: 28211 CARLSBAD, CA 92010-6509 Scheduled Actual Inspection Type Inspection No. Inspection Primary Inspector Reinspection Inspection Date Start Date Status BLDG-84 Rough 147445-2021 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Combo(14,24,34,44) Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes BLDG-14 Yes Frame-Steel-Bolting-Welding (Decks) BLDG-24 Rough-Topout Yes BLDG-34 Rough Electrical Yes BLDG-44 Yes Rough-Ducts-Dampers 01/07/2021 01/07/2021 BLDG-15 Insulation 147746-2021 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes NOTES Created By TEXT Created Date Paul Burnette Video inspection 01/07/2021 01/1312021 01/13/2021 BLDG-17 Interior 148226-2021 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Lath/Drywall Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes NOTES Created By TEXT Created Date Paul Burnette Video inspection 01/13/2021 01/28/2021 01/28/2021 BLDG-33 Service 149261-2021 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Change/Upgrade Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency No 07/02/2021 07/02/2021 BLDG-Final Inspection 161015-2021 Failed Paul Burnette Reinspection Incomplete Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency No BLDG-Plumbing Final No BLDG-Mechanical Final No BLDG-Structural Final No BLDG-Electrical Final No 07/19/2021 07/19/2021 BLDG-Final Inspection 162138-2021 Passed Tony Alvarado Complete Monday, July 19, 2021 Page 2 of 3 Building Permit Inspection History Finaled {Cityof Carlsbad PERMIT INSPECTION HISTORY for (CBR2020-1988) Permit Type: BLDG-Residential Application Date: 08/24/2020 Owner: OWNER BATTAILE KRISTEN L Work Class: Addition Issue Date: 10/0612020 Subdivision: CARLSBAD TCT#76-12 Status: Closed -Finaled Expiration Date: 07/27/2021 Address: 2743 STIRLING CT IVR Number: 28211 CARLSBAD, CA 92010-6509 Scheduled Actual Inspection Type Inspection No. Inspection Primary Inspector Reinspection Inspection Date Start Date Status 10/08/2020 1010812020 BLDG-SW-Pre-Con 140488-2020 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes 10128/2020 1012812020 BLDG-11 142333-2020 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Foundation/Fig/Piers (Rebar) Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes 1111012020 1111012020 BLDG-21 143524-2020 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Undorground/Underflo orPlumblng Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes 12101/2020 12101/2020 BLDG-84 Rough 145000-2020 Failed Paul Burnette Relnspection Incomplete Combo(14,24,34,44) Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency No BLDG-14 No Frame-Steel-Bolting-Welding (Decks) BLDG-24 Rough-Topout No BLDG-34 Rough Electrical No BLDG-44 No Rough-Ducts-Dampers 12109/2020 12/09/2020 BLDG-13 Shear 145917-2020 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Panels/HD (ok to wrap) Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes 12130/2020 12130/2020 BLDG-15 Roof/ReRoof 147167-2020 Passed Chris Renfro Complete (Patio) Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes 01/05/2021 01/05/2021 BLDG-18 Exterior 147564-2021 Passed Paul Burnette Complete Lath/Drywall Checklist Item COMMENTS Passed BLDG-Building Deficiency Yes Monday, July 19, 2021 Page 1 of 3 ✓• EsG1I A SAFEbuilfCompv:1y DATE: 10-1-2020 JURISDICTION: CARLSBAD PLAN CHECK#.: CBR2020-1988.RC1 PROJECT ADDRESS: 2743 STIRLING COURT SET II PROJECT NAME: SFD PATIO ADDITION + REMODEL FOR BATTAILE D The plans transmitted herewith have been corrected where necessary and substantially comply with the jurisdiction's codes. ~ The plans transmitted herewith will substantially comply with the jurisdiction's building codes when minor deficiencies identified below are resolved and checked by building department staff. D The plans transmitted herewith have significant deficiencies identified on the enclosed check list and should be corrected and resubmitted for a complete recheck. D The check list transmitted herewith is for your information. The plans are being held at EsGil until corrected plans are submitted for recheck. D The applicant's copy of the check list is enclosed for the jurisdiction to forward to the applicant contact person. D The applicant's copy of the check list has been sent to: ~ EsGil staff did not advise the applicant that the plan check has been completed. D EsGil staff did advise the applicant that the plan check has been completed. Person contacted:. Telephone#: Date contacted1'7/ / />-0 (by~) Email: Mail Telephone Fax In Person '\J+.~EMARKS: Smoke Detector in kitchen on sheet A6 to be moved so that it is 20 feet from vv cooking appliances. By: Erich A. Kuchar, P.E. Enclosures: EsGil 9-22-2020 9320 Chesapeake Drive, Suite 208 ♦ San Diego, California 92123 ♦ (858) 560-1468 ♦ Fax (858) 560-1576 CARLSBAD CBR2020-1988 9/08/2020 [DO NOT PAY -THIS IS NOT AN INVOICE] VALUATION AND PLAN CHECK FEE JURISDICTION: CARLSBAD PREPARED BY: Bert Domingo PLAN CHECK#.: CBR2020-1988 DATE: 9/08/2020 BUILDING ADDRESS: 2743 STIRLING COURT BUILDING OCCUPANCY: R 3 BUILDING AREA Valuation PORTION (Sq.Fl) Multiplier CITY ESTIMATE Air Conditioning Fire Sprinklers TOTAL VALUE Jurisdiction Code CB Sy Ordinance 1997 USC Building Permit Fee • ' 1997 use Plan Check Fee I 'i'..I t.~t Type of Review: ,..1 j 0 Complete Review Reg. VALUE Mod. D Structural Only D Repetitive Fee •, Repeats □ Other □ Houty EaGHFee 1--------IIHr.@• ($) 48,543 48,543 v Comments: In addition to the above fee, an additional fee of$ is due ( hour@ $ /hr.) for the CalGreen review. Sheet 1 of 1 DATE: 9/08/2020 JURISDICTION: CARLSBAD ✓• EsG1I A SAFEbuilf Company PLAN CHECK#.: CBR2020-1988 SET: I PROJECT ADDRESS: 2743 STIRLING COURT □ APPLICANT □ JURIS. SEP 2 1 ""'c t.utu PROJECT NAME: SFD PATIO ADDITION + REMODEL FOR BATTAILE D The plans transmitted herewith have been corrected where necessary and substantially comply with the jurisdiction's codes. D The plans transmitted herewith will substantially comply with the jurisdiction's codes when minor deficiencies identified below are resolved and checked by building department staff. D The plans transmitted herewith have significant deficiencies identified on the enclosed check list and should be corrected and resubmitted for a complete recheck. ~ The check list transmitted herewith is for your information. The plans are being held at EsGil until corrected plans are submitted for recheck. D The applicant's copy of the check list is enclosed for the jurisdiction to forward to the applicant contact person. ~ The applicant's copy of the check list has been sent to: D EsGil staff did not advise the applicant that the plan check has been completed. ~ EsGil staff did advise the applicant that the plan check has been completed. Person contacted: Date contacted: Mail Telephone 0 REMARKS: By: Bert Domingo EsGil (by: Telephone#: ) Email: Fax In Person Enclosures: 8/25/2020 9320 Chesapeake Drive, Suite 208 ♦ San Diego, California 92123 ♦ (858) 560-1468 ♦ Fax (858) 560-1576 CARLSBAD CBR2020-1988 9/08/2020 PLAN REVIEW CORRECTION LIST SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS AND DUPLEXES PLAN CHECK#.: CBR2020-1988 JURISDICTION: CARLSBAD PROJECT ADDRESS: 2743 STIRLING COURT FLOOR AREA: REMARKS: DA TE PLANS RECEIVED BY JURISDICTION: DATE INITIAL PLAN REVIEW COMPLETED: 9/08/2020 FOREWORD (PLEASE READ): STORIES: HEIGHT: DATE PLANS RECEIVED BY ESGIL CORPORATION: 8/25/2020 PLAN REVIEWER: Bert Domingo This plan review is limited to the technical requirements contained in the California Residential Code, California Building Code, California Plumbing Code, California Mechanical Code, California I Electrical Code and state laws regulating energy conservation, noise attenuation and access for the disabled. This plan review is based on regulations enforced by the Building Department. You may have other corrections based on laws and ordinance by the Planning Department, Engineering Department, Fire Department or other departments. Clearance from those departments may be required prior to the issuance of a building permit. Present California law mandates that construction comply with the 2019 edition of the California Code of Regulations (Title 24), which adopts the following model codes: 2019 CRC, 2019 CBC, 2019 CPC, 2019 CMC and 2019 CEC. The above regulations apply, regardless of the code editions adopted by ordinance. The following items listed need clarification, modification or change. All items must be satisfied · before the plans will be in conformance with the cited codes and regulations. Per Sec. 105.4 of the 2019 California Building Code, the approval of the plans does not permit the violation of any state, county or city law. To speed up the recheck process, please note on this list {or a copy) where each correction item has been addressed, i.e., plan sheet number, specification section, etc. Be sure to enclose the marked up list when you submit the revised plans. ----------------.......... ----- CARLSBAD CBR2020-1988 9/08/2020 PLANS 1. Please make all corrections, as requested in the correction list. Submit FOUR new complete sets of plans for commercial/industrial projects (THREE sets of plans for residential projects). For expeditious processing, corrected sets can be submitted in one of two ways: 1. Deliver all corrected sets of plans and calculations/reports directly to the City of Carlsbad Building Department, 1635 Faraday Ave., Carlsbad, CA 92008, (760) 602-2700. The City will route the plans to EsGil and the Carlsbad Planning, Engineering and Fire Departments. 2. Bring TWO corrected set of plans and calculations/reports to EsGil, 9320 Chesapeake Drive, Suite 208, San Diego, CA 92123, (858) 560-1468. Deliver all remaining sets of plans and calculations/reports directly to the City of Carlsbad Building Department for routing to their Planning, Engineering and Fire Departments. NOTE: Plans that are submitted directly to EsGil only will not be reviewed by the City Planning, Engineering and Fire Departments until review by EsGil is complete. 2. All sheets of plans must be signed by the person responsible for their preparation. (California Business and Professions Code). 3. Plans deviating from conventional wood frame construction shall have the structural portions signed and sealed by the California state licensed engineer or architect responsible for their preparation, along with structural calculations. (California Business and Professions Code). SEET1, 4. Provide a statement on the Title Sheet of the plans stating that this project shall comply with the 2019 California Residential Code, which adopts the 2019 CBC, 2019 CMG, 2019 CPC and the 2019 CEC. Section R106.1. FIRST PROJECT DATANIOTE SEEA3, KEYNOTE 5. 10. NO EXISTING SPRINKLER SYSTEM. SEEA6. 6. FOR LOCATl'O NS AND NOTES FORSD AND CO SYSTEMS. FIRE PROTECTION Please indicate on the plans whether the existing residence has a fire sprinkler system installed. If so, then provide a note stating that any additions/alterations will be provided with an automatic residential fire sprinkler system. Section R313.2. Show locations of permanently wired smoke alarms with battery backup, per Section R314: a) Inside each bedroom. b) Such smoke alarm locations shall comply with the following: i) They shall be not less than 3' from the door opening of a bathroom. ii) They shall be at least 20' from a cooking appliance. iii) They shall be at least 3' from supply registers of heating/cooling systems. CARLSBAD CBR2020-1988 9/08/2020 SEEA6 FOR LOCATION SAND NOTES FORSD AND CO SYSTEMS. 7. SEEA4 8. KEYNOTE 2 SEE 9. ENERGY MODEL DATA UNDER SEPARATE COVER. SEE 10. SHEETT1 ENERGY CONSERV ATION CONCUR, CARBON MONOXIDE 11 · REMOVED 12. SEE SHEET S1 .2 for top plate connection reference detail to 6 on S5.2 iv) They shall be at least 3' from the lip of the blade of a ceiling- mounted fan. In dwelling units within which fuel-burning appliances are installed (and in dwelling units having attached garages), show the locations of permanently wired carbon monoxide alarms with battery backup, per Section R315: a) Outside each separate sleeping area in the immediate vicinity of the bedrooms. ROOFS/DECKS/BALCONIES Specify on the plans the following information for the roof materials, per Section R106.1.1: a) Manufacturer's name and product name/number. b) ICC approval number, or equal. ENERGY CONSERVATION For plans submitted for plan check on or after 1/03/17, provide an energy design detailing compliance with the Mandatory Measures and either the Performance or Prescriptive Methods of compliance. The Prescriptive design and the latest Performance software programs are available at: http://www.energy.ca.gov/title24/2019standards/index.html Include on the Title Sheet of the plans the following statement: "Compliance with the documentation requirements of the 2019 Energy Efficiency Standards is necessary for this project. Registered, signed, and dated copies of the appropriate CF1 R, CF2R, and CF3R forms shall be made available at necessary intervals for Building Inspector review. Final completed forms will be available for the building owner." MISCELLANEOUS Smoke detector and carbon monoxide is not advisable to be located in the kitchen. Please show how the new top plates would be connected to the old top plates. CARLSBAD CBR2020-1988 9/08/2020 To speed up the review process, note on this list (or a copy) where each correction item has been addressed, i.e., plan sheet, note or detail number, calculation page, etc. Please indicate here if any changes have been made to the plans that are not a result of corrections from this list. If there are other changes, please briefly describe them and where they are located in the plans. • Have changes been made to the plans not resulting from this correction list? Please indicate: Yes □ No I The jurisdiction has contracted with EsGil, located at 9320 Chesapeake Drive, Suite 208, San Diego, California 92123; telephone number of 858/560-1468, to perform the plan review for your project. If you have any questions regarding these plan review items, please contact Bert Domingo at EsGil. Thank you. ~ <::, ~ .... i.., i.., :t.: "' i.., i.., "' 86 ..s, <"<" ..s, -s-<" . <"_,. lllC,t l "Glfll (UING CO .. l'ANT I::;: ;~~~~:~~~w~.:~~~~-,~~~'[,~~~~~:!~ 97 .--/ 118 ~<? ,.s> MAP NO. 993·5 CARLSBAD TRACT NO. 76-12,8 HEET CALAVERA HILLS 7 OF 10 SHEETS SEE SHEET 80 /4 / SEE 79 NO. 6 76 SHEET NO. 10 ' ,.. -- ~ .. ~~ -~ "' .:. ~~ ~ ' SCALE t"z 50' <:) ..... c;:s ~ .... i.., 140 i.., :t.: "' i.., i.., "' ,,_CTNO. 5694 ~ l.C.: STORM WATER POLLUTION PREVENTION NOTES 1. ALL NECESSARY EQUIPMENT AND MATERIALS SHALL BE AVAILABLE ON SITE TO FACILITATE RAPID INSTALLATION OF EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL BMPs WHEN RAIN IS EMINENT. 2. THE OWNER/CONTRACTOR SHALL RESTORE ALL EROSION CONTROL DEVICES TO WORKING ORDER TO THE SATISFACTION OF THE CITY INSPECTOR AFTER EACH RUN-OFF PRODUCING RAINFALL. 3. THE OWNER/CONTRACTOR SHALL INSTALL ADDITIONAL EROSION CONTROL MEASURES AS MAY BE REQUIRED BY THE CITY INSPECTOR DUE TO INCOMPLETE GRADING OPERATIONS OR UNFORESEEN CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH MAY ARISE. 4. ALL REMOVABLE PROTECTIVE DEVICES SHALL BE IN PLACE AT THE END OF EACH WORKING DAY WHEN THE FIVE (5) DAY RAIN PROBABILITY FORECAST EXCEEDS FORTY PECENT ( 40%). SILT AND OTHER DEBRIS SHALL BE REMOVED AFTER EACH RAINFALL. 5. ALL GRAVEL BAGS SHALL CONTAIN 3/4 INCH MINIMUM AGGREGATE. 6. ADEQUATE EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL AND PERIMETER PROTECTION BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICE MEASURES MUST BE INSTALLED AND MAINTAINED. 7. THE CITY INSPECTOR SHALL HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO ALTER THIS PLAN DURING OR BEFORE CONSTRUCTION AS NEEDED TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH CITY STORM WATER QUALITY REGULATIONS. OWNER'S CERTIFICATE: I UNDERSTAND AND ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I MUST: (1) IMPLEMENT BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES {BMPS} DURING CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PRACTICABLE TO AVOID THE MOBILIZATION OF POLLUTANTS SUCH AS SEDIMENT AND TO AVOID THE EXPOSURE OF STORM WATER TO CONSTRUCTION RELATED POLLUTANTS; AND (2) ADHERE TO, AND AT ALL TIMES, COMPLY V.,TH THIS CITY APPROVED TIER 1 CONSTRUCTION SWPPP THROUGHOUT THE DURATION OF THE CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES UNTIL THE CONSTRUCTION WORK IS COMPLETE AND APPROVED BY THE CITY OF CARLSBAD. )--,"~--- ... GNATURE\ lo/s/20 DA E-29 STORM WATER COMPLIANCE FORM TIER 1 CONSTRUCTION SWPPP E-29 CB {Z ~-\'itt:> SW_ BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES (BMP) SELECTION TABLE Erosion Control Sediment Control BMPs Tracking Non-Storm Water Waste Management and Materials BMPs Control BMPs Management BMPs Polrution Control BMPs C C -C 0 --0 .2 .2 :;::; ii -0 ii ., C --"' 0 E C -0 0 " " C .E "' 0 E C 0 -:, :, .2 'E .9-0 E ~ ~ -0 ., ::E -0 ., "' ~ " ---g "-:, >, c,, c,, C o, ~ .E -~ c ., ., ., 0 O" ~ 0 C .:,i Oo Q. -C u, § > ~ w .1t C 0 Best Management Practice* C 0 <D Q. ~ 0 " ~ " :;::; :c ., . ., ,= ., 0 C (.) ~ u -.; ill 0 $~ ., .E E ., "' ~2 ., -0 ., ~ 'O :::E ~ (BMP) Description ➔ " "V) ., ., c,, <D c,, § ., C: 0 ::, " ~ 0 0 •c a1~ §§ = "5 ~ cu " -15 -0 > 0 c,, ., ~E C 0 <D v,·-c,, ., -::E 0 "' ii ., a:: _E 0 ~~ i!l 0 (.) ., criZ " E& 0 ~ ~-3: " X 0 E !;l :=!I:: " ~.Si ~_g " " u.. .s .,, j ., :, ,€1 t:;:; C: 0 :g ~o ]1 .,, "' --0 .s:: C: " ~ ·-" ·--0 .!:: 6 'O 0 0 -·-Q. " " :, :So .Q ~ .Q 0 -" ·s: i " ~ " 0 ~o 0 --0 " 0 ~ " C: 0 c,, 0 0 -.s:: " -o 0 = C ·-C ~ 0 0~ Vj " .s:: ~ ~ -0 0 -~ .B 0 ~8 0 ~o o_ 0 -Q.0 oo 3: W Cl vi V) u (!> Vl> V) V) a. vi C: (/) a:: 3: ct a. :::E (/) ::E (/) (/) (.) V) ::E CASQA Designation ➔ ,.._ 00 0, ,,, .... "' <O ,.._ 00 0 N ,,, ,.._ c:o i N ,,, .... "' I I I I I I I I I I I i t I 'T I I I I I I I (.) (.) u u ~ w w w w w w w I:!: I:!: (/) (/) (/) (/) i i i i i Construction Activity w w w w (/) (/) (/) (/) (/) (/) (/) z z z z Grad inn /Soil Disturbance . Trenchinn /Excavation y Stockpilinq , Drill inn /Borina ~ Concrete/ Asphalt Sowcuttino Concrete Flotwork Povino Conduittl-'ioe Installation .,,, Stucco/Mortar Work .. Waste Disposal Stoqinq/Lov Down Area Eouioment Maintenance and Fuelino Hazardous Substance Use /Storooe Dewoterino Site Access Across Dirt Other (list): Instructions: 1. Check the box to the left of all applicable construction activity {first column} expected to occur during construction. 2. Located along the top of the BMP Tobie is a list of BMP's with it's corresponding California Stormwoter Quality Association {CASQA) designation number. Choose one or more BMPs you intend to use during construction from the list. Check the box where the chosen activity row intersects with the BMP column. 3. Refer to the CASQA construction handbook for information and details of the chosen BMPs and how to apply them to the project. SHOW THE LOCATIONS OF ALL CHOSEN BMPs ABOVE ON THE PROJECTS SITE PLAN/EROSION CONTROL PLAN. SEE THE REVERSE SIDE OF THIS SHEET FOR A SAMPLE EROSION CONTROL PLAN. -BMP's are subject to field inspection- Page 1 of 1 PROJECT INFORMATION Site Address: 'Z."f~ ~fl-\.\i,lC::, t:.:{". Assessor's Parcel Number: 2@-\\ \ --Z'S Emergency Contact: Nome: ~T~ .i~ 24 Hour Phone: 7f,o.1tf7 -~s;- Construction Threat to Storm Water Quality (Check Box) □ MEDIUM ~ow ., -., ., 0 -3:-., o-C 3: ii ., ., " E " E .g ., -., " c,, ~ "' oO ho NC C: C: co oo :Z::::E U:::E "' 00 I I i i ,-~ REV 02/16 I ' ( City of Carlsb ad PURPOSE CLIMATE ACTION PLAN CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST B-50 Development Services Building Division 1635 Faraday Avenue (760) 602-2719 www.carlsbadca.gov This checklist is intended to assist building permit applicants identify which Climate Action Plan (CAP) ordinance requirements apply to their projects. The completed checklist must be included in the building permit application. It may be necessary to supplement the completed checklist with supporting materials, calculations or certifications, to demonstrate full compliance with CAP ordinance requirements. For example, projects that propose or require a performance approach to comply with energy-related measures will need to attach to this checklist separate calculations and documentation as specified by the ordinances. NOTE: The following type of permits are not required to fill out this form ❖ Patio I ❖ Decks I ❖ PME (w/o panel upgrade) I ❖ Pool ..111 If an item in the checklist is deemed to be not applicable to a project, or is less than the minimum required by ordinance, an explanation must be provided to the satisfaction of the Building Official. ..111 Details on CAP ordinance requirements are available on the city's website . ..111 A CAP Building Plan template (form B-55) shall be added to the title page all building plans. This template shall be completed to demonstrate project compliance with the CAP ordinances. Refer to the building application webpage and download the latest form. Project Name/Building Permit No.: Battaile Residence BP No.: [B ~1.02o-( ff Jg' PropertyAddress/APN: 2743 Stirling Ct -------------------------------- Applicant Name/Co.: Kristen Battaile Applicant Address: Same Contact Phone: 760-525-8489 Contact Email: macalear2@gmail.com Contact information of person completing this checklist (if different than above): Name: Company name/address: Steven Noel Steven Noel Architect 2715 Greenock Ct, Carlsbad CA 92010 Applicant Signature: ~ , __, ( Contact Phone: Contact Email: Date: 8/20/20 8-50 Page 1 of 6 760-535-784 7 steven.noel.architect@gmail.com Revised 06/18 ' City 6f Carlsbad Climate Action Plan Consistency Checklist Use the table below to determine which sections of the Ordinance Compliance checklist are applicable to your project. For alterations and additions to existing buildings, attach Building Permit Valuation worksheet. Building Permit Valuation (BPV) from worksheet: $ L-( l> , 541--- Construction Type I Complata Section(•> I Noa: [2] Residential A high-rise residential building is 4 or more stories, including a Low-rise High-rise mixed-use building in which at least 20% of its conditioned floor area is residential use □ New construction 2A,3A, 1B, 2B, 4A 3B,4A 0 Additions and alterations· ~ BPV < $60,000 <....wA __, N/A \ All residential additions and alterations 0 BPV <!: $60,000 1A,4A 4A 1-2 family dwellings and townhouses with attached garages □ Electrical service panel upgrade only only *Multi-family dwellings only where interior finishes are removed □ BPV <!: $200,000 1A, 4A* 1B, 4A* and significant site work and upgrades to structural and mechanical, electrical, and/or plumbing systems are proposed D Nonresidential □ New construction 1B, 2B, 3B, 4B and 5 I □ Alterations: □ BPV <!: $200,000 or additions <!: 1,000 18,5 square feet □ BPV <!: $1,000,000 1B,2B,5 Building alterations of<!: 75% existing gross floor area □ <!: 2,000 sq. ft. new roof addition 2B,5 1 B also applies if BPV <!: $200,000 *. ,---;r·~r•~ .. :.,r • --/~~ -;,.'I I)..(;""( • -, ' • <.J • ,:--~ ' • • . . .--~~J ., ••. _ Checklist Item Check the appropriate boxes, explain all not appllcable and exception items, and proYide ~ calailllonB and documentation as necessary. 1. Energy Efficiency Please refer to Carlsbad Municipal Code (CMC) sections 18.21.155 and 18.30.190, and the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen) for more information when completing this section. A 0 Residential addition or alteration ii!: $60,000 building permit valuation. D NIA ________ _ See CMC section 18.30.190. D Exception: Home energy score~ 7 ( attach certification) Year Built Single.family Requirements Multi.family Requirements Select one: D Before 1978 D Duct sealin D Attic insulation D Cool roof D Attic insulation 0 1978 and later Select one: 0 Lighting packag ater heating Package 0 Between 1978 and 1991 Select one: D 1992 and later D Lighting package B. D Nonresidential* new construction or alterations ii!: $200,000 building pennlt valuation, or additions ii!: 1,000 square feel Updated 8/15/2019 0 NIA D Water heating package 2 City of Carlsbad Climate Action Plan Consistency Checklist See CMC 18.21.155 and CALGreen Appendix AS, Division AS.2-Energy Efficiency. AS.203.1 .1 Choose one: □ .1 Outdoor lighting □ .2 Warehouse dock seal doors □ .3 Restaurant service water heating (comply with California Energy Code section 140.5, as amended) 0 NIA _________ _ □ .4 Daylight design PAFs □ .5 Exhaust air heat rer.overy AS.203.1.2.1 Choose one as applicable: □ .95 Energy budget □ .90 Energy budget 0 NIA AS.211.1•• □ On-stte renewable energy 0 NIA AS.211.3 .. □ Green power (if offered by local utility provider, 50% minimum renewable sources) 0 NIA AS.212.1 □ Elevators and escalators 0 NIA AS.213.1 □ Steel framing 0 NIA • Includes hotels/motels and high-rise residential buildings .. For alterations 2: $1,000,000 BPV and affecting> 75% existing gross floor area, or alterations that add 2,000 square feet of new roof addition: comply with CMC 18.30.130 instead. 2. Photovoltaic Systems A. D Residential new construction (for low-rise residential building permit applications submitted after 1/1/20). Refer to 2019 California Energy Code section 150.1(c)14 for requirements. Notes: 1) High-rise residential buildings are subject to nonresidential photovoltaic requirement (28 below) instead. 2) If project Includes Installation of an electric heat pump water heater pursuant to CMC 18.30.150(8) (high-rise residential) or 18.30.170(8) (low-rise residential), Increase system size by .3kWdc if PV offset option Is selected. Floor Plan ID (use additional CFA #d.u. calculated kWdc* sheets if necessary) Total System Size: kWdc = (CFAx.572) / 1,000 + (1.15 x #d.u.) *Fonnula calculation where CFA = conditional floor area, #du = number of dwellings per plan type If proposed system size is less than calculated size, please explain. Exception □ □ □ □ kWdc 8. D Nonresidential new construction or alterations ~1,000,000 8PV and affecting i?:75% existing floor area, or addition that Increases roof area by i?:2,000 square feel Please refer to CMC section 18.30.130 when completing this section. Note: This section also applies to high-rise residential and hotel/motel buildings. Choose one of the following methods: □ Gross Floor Area (GFA) Method GFA: □If< 10,000s.f. Enter: 5 kWdc Min. System Size: □If .?: 10,000s.f. calculate: 15 kWdc x (GFA/10,000) ** __ kWdc **Round building size factor to nearest tenth, and round system size to nearest whole number. □ Time-Dependent Valuation Method Updated 8/15/2019 3 · City of Carlsbad Climate Action Plan Consistency Checklist Annual TDV Energy use:*** ______ x .80= Min. system size: _____ kWdc ***Attach calculation documentation using modeling software approved by the California Energy Commission. 3. Water Heating A. D Residential and hotel/motel new construction Please refer to CMC sections 18.30.150 and 18.30.170 when completing this section. D For systems serving Individual dwelling units choose one: D Heat pump water heater AND Compact hot water distribution AND Drain water heat recovery (low-rise residential only) D Heat pump water heater AND PV system .3 kWdc larger than required in CMC section 18.30.130 (high rise residential hotel/motel) or CA Energy Code section 150.1(c) 14 (low-rise residential) D Heat pump water heater meeting NEEA Advanced Water Heating Specification Tier 3 or higher D Solar water heating system that is either .60 solar savings fraction or 40 s.f. solar collectors D Exception: D For systems serving multiple dwelling units, install a central water-heating system with all of the following: D Gas or propane water heating system D Recirculation system per CMC 18.30.150(8) (high-rise residential, hotel/motel) or CMC 18.30.170(8) (low- rise residential) D Solar water heating system that is either: D .20 solar savings fraction D .15 solar savings fraction, plus drain water heat recovery D Exception: B. D Nonresidential new construction Please refer to Carlsbad Ordinance CMC section 18.30.150 when completing this section. D Water heating system derives at least 40% of its energy from one of the following (attach documentation): D Solar-thermal D Photovoltaics D Recovered energy □Water heating system is (choose one): D Heat pump water heater D Electric resistance water heater(s) □Solar water heating system with .40 solar savings fraction D Exception: Updated 8/15/2019 4 · City of Carlsbad Climate Action Plan Consistency Checklist 4. Electric Vehlcle Charging A. 0 Resldentlal New construction and major alterations* Please refer to Carlsbad Ordinance CMC section 18.21.140 when com ✓ One and two-family residential dwelling or townhouse with attached garage: (2]one EVSE Ready parking space required D Exception: □Multi-family residential· D Exception· Total Parking Spaces EVSE Spaces Proposed Canable Ready Installed Calculations: Total EVSE spaces= .10 x Total parking (rounded up to nearest whole number) EVSE Installed= Total EVSE Spaces x .50 (rounded up to nearest whole number) EVSE other= Total EVSE spaces -EVSE Installed (EVSE other may be "Capable,• "Ready" or "Installed.") Total *Major alterations are: (1) for one and two-family dwellings and townhouses with attached garages, alterations have a building permtt valuation~ $60,000 or include an electrical service panel upgrade; (2) for multifamily dwellings (three units or more without attached garages), alterations have a building permit valuation ~ $200,000, interior finishes are removed and significant site wori( and upgrades to structural and mechanical, electrical, and/or plumbing systems are proposed. B D Nonresidential new construction (Includes hotels/motels) D Exception · Total Parking Spaces EVSE Spaces Proposed Capable I Readv I Installed I Total 10 2 I 5 I 1 I 8 Calculation· Refer to the table below· Total Number of Parkino Soaces provided Number of roouired EV Soaces Number of roouired EVSE Installed Soaces 0-9 1 1 10-25 2 1 26-50 4 2 n 51-75 6 3 □ 76-100 9 5 n 101-150 12 6 n 151-200 17 9 7 201 and over 10 percent of total 50 oorcent of RMuired EV Soaces Updated 8/15/20 I 9 5 · City of Carlsbad Climate Action Plan Consistency Checklist 5. 0 Transportation Demand Management (TOM): Nonresldentlal ONLY An approved Transportation Demand Management (TOM) Plan is required for all nonresidential projects that meet a threshold of employee-generated ADT. City staff will use the table below based on your submitted plans to determine whether or nor your permit requires a TDM plan. If TDM is applicable to your permit, staff will contact the applicant to develop a site-specific TDM plan based on the permit details. Acknowledgment: Employee ADT Estimation for Various Commercial Uses EmpADTfor first 1,000 s.f. EmpADT/ 1000 s.f.1 Office (all)2 20 Restaurant 11 Retai13 8 Industrial 4 Manufacturing 4 Warehousin 4 1 Unless otherwise noted, rates estimated from /TE Trip Generation Manual, 1CJhEdition 13 11 4.5 3.5 3 1 2 For all office uses, use SANDAG rate of 20 ADT/1 ,000 sf to calculate employee ADT 3 Retail uses include shopping center, variety store, supermarket, gyms, pharmacy, etc. Other commercial uses may be subject to special consideration Sample calculations: Office: 20,450 sf 1. 20,450 sf/ 1000 x 20 = 409 Employee ADT Retail: 9,334 sf 1. First 1,000 sf= 8 ADT 2. 9,334 sf -1,000 sf = 8,334 sf 3. 8,334 sf/ 1,000 x 4.5 + 8 = 46 Em lo ee ADT I acknowledge that the plans submitted may be subject to the City of Carlsbad's Transportation Demand Management Ordinance. I agree to be contacted should my permit require a TDM Pl an understa tan approved TDM plan is a condition of permit issuance. ' Date: 8.18.20 Person other than Applicant to be contacted for TOM compliance (if applicable): Name (Printed): Steven Noel Ph N be 760-535-7847 one um r: ____ _ ErnailAddress: steven.noel.architect@gmail.com Updated 8/15/2019 6 . . ( City of Carlsbad CLIMATE ACTION PLAN {CAP) COMPLIANCE CAP Building Plan Template B-55 Development Services Building Division 1635 Faraday Avenue 760-602-2719 www.carlsbadca.gov The following demonstrates project compliance with the applicable Climate Action Plan ordinances of the carlsbad Municipal Code and California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen), current version. The following certificate shall be included on the title sheet of all building permits: 1. ENERGY EFFICIENCY APPLICABLE: YES/NO Complies with CMC 18.30.190 & 18.21.155 Existing Structure, year built: 1982 Prepared Energy Audit? Energy Score: _____ _ Efficiency Measures included in scope: Yes/N/A T-24 exterior and interior lighting, insulation (walls and roof), cool roof (addition only), T 24 windows a11d do01s. 2. PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEM APPLICABLE: YES~ Complies with CMC section 18.30.130 and 2019 California Energy Code section 150.l(c)l4 Yes /N/A Required Provided Size of PV system (kWdc): Sizing PV by load calculations Yes/No If by Load Calculations: Total calculated electrical load: 80% of load: Hardship Requested Hardship Approved Yes/No Yes/No 3. ALTERNATIVE WATER HEATING SYSTEM APPLICABLE: 4. Compiles with CMC sections 18.30.150 and 18.30.170? Alternative Source: □ Electric □ Passive Solar Hardship Requested Hardship Approved Yes/ N/A Yes/No Yes/No ELECTRIC VEHICLE (EV) CHARGING APPLICABLE: ®NO Complies with CMC section 18.21.140? @NIA .JC::\ Panel Upgrade? Ye~ Total EV Parking Spaces: No. of EV Capable Spaces: No. of EV Ready Spaces: No. of EV Installed Spaces: Hardship Requested Hardship Approved Required Provided 1 1 Yes/No Yes/No S. TRAFFIC DEMAND MANAGEMENT APPLICABLE: YES,€) Compliant? TOM Report on file with city? Yes/ no Yes/ no