HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-08-02; Traffic and Mobility Commission; Minutes
Page 1 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
Council Chambers
1200 Carlsbad Village Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Monday, Aug. 2, 2021, 4:00 p.m.
CALL TO ORDER: Chair Gocan called the Meeting to order at 4 p.m.
ROLL CALL: Present: Gocan, Perez, Hunter, Penseyres, Fowler and Linke
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Commissioner Hunter led the Pledge of Allegiance
This meeting was conducted virtually via Zoom due to the stay-at-home order for COVID-19.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
Motion by Commissioner Linke, seconded by Commissioner Hunter to approve the minutes for the July
6, 2021 meeting as amended.
Motion carried: 6/0/1
PUBLIC COMMENTS ON ITEMS NOT LISTED ON THE AGENDA:
1. 1. Diane Nygaard - Honorable Chair and Commissioners
It has now been over a year since the TDM ordinance was adopted and the TDM
program was implemented. We believe it is timely for you to request a progress report
on program implementation and results.
We are particularly concerned because at the same time this program was being
initiated the city modified their Climate Action Plan (CAP) related to TDM. While the
revised CAP still assumes substantial GHG reductions from TDM, there is no
apparent monitoring system in place.
Furthermore, we are aware of several projects where TDM programs were approved as
part of overall project approval before the Planning Commission and City Council, but
were later modified by City staff.
On-road transportation accounts for almost 50% of the community-wide GHG in
Carlsbad. Achieving the benefits of this TDM program is a key element in meeting the
goals of the CAP- and the related reduction in traffic congestion and air pollution.
Please request a progress report on the TDM program so we can all make sure this
program is achieving its intended results.
CONSENT CALENDAR:
1. TRAFFIC CALMING FOR MAGNOLIA AVENUE FROM BRADY CIRCLE TO VALLEY STREET - Support staff’s recommendations for proposed traffic calming improvements on Magnolia Avenue from Brady Circle to Valley Street as part of the Magnolia Avenue Storm Drain Project, CIP No. 6608 (Project).
TRAFFIC AND MOBILITY COMMISSION
Minutes
Page 2 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
ACTION:
Motion by Vice-Chair Perez, seconded by Commissioner Hunter to approve Consent Calendar Item 1 as
presented.
Motion carried: 6/0
DEPARTMENTAL REPORTS:
2. POLICE MONTHLY REPORT – (Staff Contact: Lt. Steve Thomas, Police Department)
Lieutenant Thomas presented the report and reviewed a PowerPoint presentation (on file in the
Office of the City Clerk)
DISCUSSION:
Lieutenant Thomas shared that they have started the OTS Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety Enforcement.
Schools open August 24 therefore the Motors will be back to traffic enforcement at schools to keep kids
safe and Crossing Guards back at the school locations.
3. KELLY DRIVE AND PARK DRIVE COMPLETE STREET IMPROVEMENTS, CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT
PROGRAM PROJECT NO. 6075– (Staff Contact: Brandon Miles and Hossein Ajideh, Public Works)
Staff’s Recommendation: Receive information and provide input
Engineering Manager Ajideh presented the report and reviewed a PowerPoint presentation (on file in
the Office of the City Clerk).
DISCUSSION:
Commissioner Linke inquired about the change in width within the roadway on Kelly Drive and the
impact of removing the center turn lane.
Transportation Director Frank addressed both questions and referenced experience from San Clemente
about the benefits of traffic calming based on this design. He also confirmed that no property
acquisition will be done to accomplish these designs. Some of the segments have different
environmental and storm water requirements that adds to the changes in the width between the curb
to curb improvements.
Engineering Manager Ajideh wanted to clarify that we have coordinated with all the governing
authorities associated with habitat management, but have not formally requested the permit.
Commissioner Linke had other clarifying points; first point was a confirmation that the stop sign at the
roundabout would be removed. Second point was for the children riding bikes to the school, that they
will have two options depending on their comfort level for transitioning from the bike lanes to the
roundabout, and to the school.
Vice-Chair Perez wanted to confirm that the medians in the second section can be mountable by
emergency response as well as how back in, reverse angle parking works. All of these points have been
incorporated into the design and will not be an issue as all modes of travel and safety have been
addressed.
Transportation Director Frank said that staff appreciated all of the good questions and they will continue
to incorporate these comments, the comments of the public, and public outreach.
Page 3 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
Commissioner Penseyres was pleased that many of his questions have already been answered. He did
inquire about the access to the school at the roundabout.
Transportation Director Frank confirmed that we are in coordination with the schools as it is very
common to have congestion during pickup and drop off periods. We plan to maximize efficiency and
safety and yes, the roundabout will facilitate that movement from the left turn lane.
Commissioner Fowler inquired about car traffic at this location and what does the number of cars look
like in comparison to the City of San Clemente reference.
Transportation Director Frank said that the City of Carlsbad volumes would be lower.
Associate Engineer Miles said that there is a substantial difference in traffic between peak and off-peak
traffic.
Traffic Engineer Kim said that we have historical data that shows it is probably below 8,000 cars.
Commissioner Fowler was wondering how many other streets will be part of complete streets projects.
Traffic Engineer Kim said that staff implements speed cushions when the community requests them.
They take these traffic calming issues on a case by case basis and include public outreach to see if the
community supports speed cushions.
Chair Gocan is interested in when we will receive more details about the roundabout, like vertical
designs.
Transportation Director Frank said that they plan on doing another round of public outreach to give the
community a chance to address any concerns and collect input, which staff will bring back in a report to
the commission. This report will also include the commissions comments. The next step is to work with
the design consultants, if the roundabout alternative moves forward. They would first refine the
horizontal design for staff to determine if it is technically acceptable. The vertical design follows which
looks at the slopes approaching the roundabout and through it. This also would include a review of
landscaping and the opportunity for an art component. We will come back to the commission with
staff’s recommendation.
Engineering Manager Ajideh said that in response to Chair Gocan’s question about the timeframe for
the Kelly Drive project, the goal is to start construction next summer although that might be a little bit
optimistic. The challenge is obtaining permits from the resource agency.
Deputy City Manager Gomez commented on the public art component, which is led by the Library and
Cultural Arts team. They will go through a Request for Qualifications to the potential artists to create
ideas of what the public art would look like and then selecting the art is about a year process. After
that, depending on their art selection, it could take another year for fabrication also known as
construction of the artwork. At a minimum the art component is usually a two-year process.
PUBLIC COMMENTS ON ITEM 3:
1. Catherine Clancy - I live on Kelly Dr., and I would like to know when you're going to get started
putting in speed bumps on our street. After seeing someone drive down our street last night
(7/27) between 60-70 mph and treating our street like they're at a drag race, I am tired of seeing
people drive like this again and again.
You just completed work on Hillside Drive. Why haven't you started on our street yet? Enough
is enough. The people who live along Kelly Drive deserve to have this speeding problem fixed
immediately, not years from now. I'm tired of putting my life at risk when I cross the street
Page 4 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
because people drive like maniacs down our street. Thank you for your time and attention to
this matter.
2. Simon Freedman - To the members of the Commission my name is Simon Freedman and I am a
30+ year resident of Carlsbad. I have been cycling on a regular basis for over 20 years. I support
the installation of Class 2 Buffered Bike lanes on Kelly. I strongly disagree with the
recommendation for Class 4 Bike lanes on Park.
Class 4 bike lanes like these give cyclists very little room to maneuver in the event a pedestrian
or skateboarder appears in the lane, or in the event a cyclist (or e biker) coming in the opposite
direction is not operating their cycle in a safe fashion. With so little room to maneuver the
chance for a fall, with corresponding injuries is greatly increased. In my opinion installation of
these Class 4 lanes will increase the risks to cyclists. Please reconsider this decision and install
buffered Class 2 bike lanes instead.
3. Doug Reiter - I live at the end of Kelly Dr by the school. It would be great if there is a way to
control the speed of the traffic on our street. The circle in front of our house doesn't do much to
slow down traffic, drivers either go around it at speed, cut on the other side of it or just go
through it. The speed humps that were installed on Hillside and the one on Donna Dr are a good
idea. With all the new building that's gone on in the last few years our street has become a busy
shortcut, which is fine if the cars would come a little closer to the 25mph residential speed
limit. Thanks for looking into this.
4. Tom Wellman - I am writing to you regarding the roundabout at the intersection of Kelly &
Hillside Drive. This is a poorly designed roundabout as it has a stop sign at the terminus of
Hillside Drive. I thought the whole point of a roundabout was to encourage traffic to yield and
not to have to come to a complete stop (which traffic from Hillside Dr must do). Perhaps a
median should be installed on to encourage motorists to slow down on Hillside Drive as they
approach Kelly Drive or for an even more cost-effective safety measure is removing the
roundabout and turning the intersection into an all way stop. I'm not against roundabouts when
they are designed properly as they do work, however I am against poorly designed roundabouts
and the one at this location is just as bad the previous roundabouts that were eventually
shuttered down on Cassia Rd. Thank you and have a great day,
5. Mike Anderson - Please remove the traffic circle at Hillside and Kelly in favor of more
familiar, traditional and safer methods of traffic control, i.e. stop signs.
My family has been at 4870 Kelly Dr for 5 decades, we pre-date Kelly School. We live exactly in
front of the traffic circle at Kelly and Hillside. The traffic circle has been and continues to be
the single, largest negative on our quality of life since moving to Carlsbad in 1973.
The traffic circle was installed to join 1 ½ roads in a 25mph school zone in a residential
neighborhood for the purpose of traffic “calming.” There is absolutely nothing calming about
this traffic feature. Every single day, at all hours, no exaggeration, there is hostile honking
around the circle because most do not understand who has right of way, despite the signage. I
have heard and seen verbal and physical confrontations because of this confusion. This year
there was a bad bike wreck with a car that required police and fire assistance.
Upon installation the City removed the bike lanes on both sides of the street so there is no
longer a buffer between pedestrians and traffic. If you have ever witnessed the students of
Page 5 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
Kelly Elementary walking across the Hillside crosswalk you will notice that cars pass within
inches of them where they would normally be several feet, the width of a bike lane. I urge you
to ask the Kelly crossing-guards for their opinion.
This also means our driveway has no buffer. All traffic from the street, including bikes are
steered within inches of our driveway. Backing out of our driveway is now always a distressing
task. We cannot use the space in front of our driveway for brief visitors or deliveries as every
other resident in this neighborhood does. Bikes and Ebike will ride on the sidewalk in front of
our house to avoid this area that has no bike lane. We had to move the location of our mailbox
because the postman no longer had a safe place to deliver our mail, even now the mailbox is in a
precarious location for safe delivery. About once or twice a month there are cars that do
multiple donuts around the traffic circle. In 2019 they lost control and destroyed our mailbox.
Just waiting for them to hit one of our cars or worse.
The circle produces road noise beyond acceptable levels, daily! Big trucks and autos with
trailers will drive through the circle hitting the raised yellow dots because they cannot or refuse
to negotiate the turning radius of the circle. This creates a huge crash sound every time they hit
those dots. Then those dots, hubcaps, fenders and lights break off and usually find their way
onto our property. Please remove the traffic circle!!!!!!!
6. Lauren Foulger - I would like to thank you for proposal street improvements and formally
express my full support of installing a raised traffic circle at the junction of Park and Kelly drive,
and speed bumps down the hill on Park drive. We live on the corner at 4900 Park Drive and have
children that cross the street almost daily to go to school and/or Laguna Riviera park. This
intersection is DANGEROUS and there have been multiple times that my children and other
children have nearly been struck my cars speeding down the hill at Park drive turning onto Kelly.
There is no stop sign and no speed bumps to deter cars from picking up speed and turning
blinding, and the Yield sign is simply not enough. Also, during school pickup and drop off hours,
it is a chaotic mess. Given that this intersection is principle to Kelly elementary school crossing
and Laguna Riviera SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE DONE for the safety of our children and
community.
I know that there is group in our neighborhood not in support of these traffic calming measures,
but I want you to know that so not represent the majority of us. They are the older and more
vocal minority that do not have children whose lives are in danger every time they attempt to
cross these streets to get to school or the park. There has been a large turnover in our
neighborhood with many younger children, and as parents we stand in full support of these
measures proposed measures.
During the school year, there are masses of children walking across this hazardous interaction. It
is NOT safe. Not only are cars picking up a lot of speed and going without stopping before they
turn onto Kelly Dr down the hill from the Loma Laguna neighborhood, but almost daily there are
racing cars intentionally pick up speed to do racing donuts and peel out at that junction. We
hear the screeches and see cars zooming down that street on a regular basis. It is extremely
dangerous.
As a Loma Laguna resident and mother, I stand in full support of the installation of the raised
Page 6 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
round about at Park and Kelly Drive, and speed bumps. It the safety of our children on the line,
and this would be I’d great help in protecting them. The safety of our residents and all children
attending Kelly elementary are worth these measures.
7. Kris Wright - I am a 42-year resident in the same home in Loma Laguna which consists of 130
homes at the very east end of Park Drive, east of Kelly Drive. I have been following the plans for
the Kelly Drive and Park Drive traffic improvements over the past 3 or so years. I have been in
contact with Brandon Miles, the traffic engineer on this project.
I have also been in contact with my neighbors in Loma Laguna regarding this project. We all live
in a community that has one ingress/egress-in other words, there is only one way in and out. of
our community. In addition, our community borders to the south, the Agua Hedionda
"wetlands" which are typically not wet but consist of coastal scrub and other plant life that are
dry and brittle during most of the year. That area. is ideal tinder for a fire as we know that
some of the homeless reside in that area as we have seen evidence every year.
My concern is evacuation from our community in case of a fire. My neighbors and I have
consulted the Carlsbad Fire chief who said, "in case of a fire, your community would stay in
place." That is not a satisfactory solution to our community since we would like to be able to
evacuate safely.
One of the ways we know to safely evacuate is to have a double lane exit along Park Drive as
that is the main street in our community. If this new project is approved with a traffic circle at
the bottom of Park Drive, we are concerned that our evacuation will be impeded as the traffic
circle only allows one lane within it.
The current set up is that there are small road bumps creating a traffic circle with a yield sign at
the bottom of Park x Kelly coming out of our community. It is still possible with this traffic circle
in case of a fire, to exit in an emergency with two lanes. An additional potential hazard is that
part of the traffic circle to the south borders the Kelly Trail and the wetlands which also could
somewhat impede an evacuation.
What we are asking is that either the traffic circle be eliminated in this project and adding a
three way stop sign at the T intersection of Kelly and Park Dr. or if a traffic circle is absolutely
necessary, that it be built with our two lane evacuation in mind.
Residents of Loma Laguna do NOT want to stay in place if there is a fire. We want to save our
families and our pets and move safely to another area. We have seen how fires can decimate a
neighborhood in minutes not only in Carlsbad but in northern California where in 2018, the
Camp fire destroyed the community of Paradise and killed 85 people.
Please consider our very important request. We chose not to remain in place in case of a fire.
8. Blake Boyer - I am a 7-year resident of Loma Laguna which consists of 130 homes at the very
east end of Park Drive, east of Kelly Drive. Along with my neighbors, I have been following the
plans for the Kelly Drive and Park Drive traffic improvements.
We live in an area where there is only one way in and out. In addition, our community borders
to the south, an area of Agua Hedionda that is susceptible for a fire as we know that some of the
homeless reside in that area as we have seen evidence every year. The coastal shrub and other
plants are dry and brittle during most of the year.
Page 7 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
My concern along with our neighbors is the ability to evacuate quickly from our community in
case of a fire. My neighbors who have consulted the Carlsbad Fire chief who said, "in case of a
fire, your community would stay in place." That is an unacceptable solution to our community
since we would like to be able to evacuate safely.
One of the ways we know to safely evacuate is to have a double lane exit along Park Drive as
that is the main street in our community. If this new project is approved with a traffic circle at
the bottom of Park Drive, we are concerned that our evacuation will be impeded as the traffic
circle only allows one lane within it.
The current set up is that there are small road bumps creating a traffic circle with a yield sign at
the bottom of Park x Kelly coming out of our community. It is still possible with this traffic circle
in case of a fire, to exit in an emergency with two lanes. An additional potential hazard is that
part of the traffic circle to the south borders the Kelly Trail and the wetlands which also could
somewhat impede an evacuation.
What we are asking is that either the traffic circle be eliminated in this project and adding a
three way stop sign at the T intersection of Kelly and Park Dr. or if a traffic circle is absolutely
necessary, that it be built with our two lane evacuation in mind.
Fires show no mercy, they move quickly, destroy structures in minutes and we should never be
creating a situation to lose lives. We do not want to stay in place if there is a fire - it is beyond
dangerous. Every year we continue to see the destruction of fires in California and across the
nation.
I am currently in Polson MT for a family vacation and two days ago was evacuated at 3am. I
could not imagine if we were not able to drive away safely and quickly as we saw the fire
spread. Please consider our request as if your home was in our neighborhood.
9. Jeff Wilson - I live on Park Dr. in between Valencia and Kelly. I see in the letter I received that
bicycle / pedestrian paths are the main focus of the upcoming project... however there is a
bigger safety concern to address before any of those can reasonably be considered safe to use.
We have had continued problems with people speeding through our neighborhood. Many of
my neighbors have called in and emailed for years regarding this problem, but nothing has been
done about it. To reiterate the concern, it is a 25 MPH zone, and vehicles travel at an average of
around 45 MPH through our neighborhood, with some ripping through at up to 80 MPH. It is, in
a word, infuriating. As you know, this area is heavily populated with pedestrians, cyclists, dogs,
children and elderly neighbors. I have seen several occasions where myself or neighbors are
trying to simply pull out of our driveways and the drivers whipping around the corner have had
to slam on their brakes just to avoid a big accident.
It is only a matter of time until something really awful happens on this block.
That is the last thing I want to see for the City of Carlsbad, or for our neighborhood. So, I am
now begging you for some help, as are the rest of the residents on the block. Please do
something to slow automobiles down in our otherwise beautiful neighborhood.
10. Stephen Dunham - Thank you for taking comments regarding the traffic problems we have in
our community. I think as a top priority, before bike lanes or anything else, you need to act
immediately to control the horrible speeding problem on Park Drive in front of the lagoon.
Page 8 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
It is not uncommon for traffic to come racing by at 50 or 60 miles an hour in a 25 MPH zone.
People walking with their kids, their pets, and bicycling, plus those of us who are just trying to
get out of our driveways safely have a life-threatening risk because of the speeding problem.
We've called the police multiple times, but they tell us that it is out of their jurisdiction and
cannot even write tickets, which is ludicrous.
We need help now please. Please install speed bumps as soon as possible before somebody gets
hurt or killed. I'm available anytime for discussion if any is needed at 619-987-3909. Thank you
for your attention on this urgent public safety matter.
11.Rosanne Bentley - I tried several times to view today's Agenda Packet but it would not load for
me, so I don't know what agenda item this is, but in general, MORE and BETTER traffic
circles/traffic calming measures are needed in Carlsbad.
I have mentioned it before, but it bears repeating...if you want a template for an excellent
neighborhood solution to traffic safety, take a look at Ballard outside of Seattle in Washington
state. They did it right, no one complains, and traffic is successfully slowed.
What was done on Hillside Dr as well as Kelly -- is virtually worthless. It definitely doesn't do
much to slow people down. The traffic circle on Hillside isn't big enough to be any kind of real
deterrent to speedy drivers; in fact, it just angers them, and they speed up to drive faster and
even more recklessly.
I wonder who authorized MY tax dollars to bow to the angry resident who demanded that the
traffic hump/bump in front of this house (on Hillside) be removed and Replaced one house
down. Why was that done and why did the other residents in Carlsbad have to pay for it? This
should be investigated.
12.Mike Foulger - I am writing to express my support of installing a raised traffic circle at the
junction of Park Drive and Kelly Drive as well as speed bumps down the hill on Park drive. My
wife, children, and I live on the NE corner of Park; our children cross the street daily to go to
school and/or Laguna Riviera Park. This intersection is extremely unsafe as many cars heading
west bound on Park down the hill toward Kelly have come close to hitting children and adults
crossing the street at the crosswalk. There is no stop sign and no speed bumps to deter cars
from picking up speed and turning blinding; although there is a Yield sign, this is not sufficient. In
order to ensure the safety of our children and neighbors as they cross the street, a traffic signal
is needed.
In addition to people gaining speed down the hill and crossing or turning on to Kelly without
yielding, there have been countless days with cars doing donuts around the round-a-bout or
peeling northbound on Kelly past the elementary school.
I stand in full support of the installation of the raised round about at Park and Kelly Drive as well
as speed bumps
13.Kathleen Maxwell - The traffic “circle” on Kelly Drive is not a true traffic circle. Since only two
sides of the four-way intersection have to stop and the other two do not; therefore, rendering it
as merely an obstruction. It actually makes the intersection more dangerous. The unusable
center section of this so-called circle is much too large and makes negotiating the turn much too
difficult and squeezes cars into the bike lane and dangerously close to parked cars. (While you
are at it please do something about the newly installed one on Hillside which is actually even
worse.)
Page 9 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
14. Joe Whitaker - Kelly Drive between El Camino Real and Hillside Drive I am in very strong support
of the cycle track option. Reducing the vehicle travel lane to 11 feet will reduce vehicle speeds.
The landscaping is attractive and appropriate. And the cycle track is the safest and best option.
DISCUSSION:
Chair Gocan inquired about the benefits or differences between a roundabout and a four way stop,
especially at Hillside Drive and Kelly Drive.
Transportation Director Frank sited several great reference points, including the city’s website, for
understanding roundabouts, including exhibit three in the staff report. At a high level, the roundabout
offers a safer, more efficient intersection control that is more positive on the environment, GHG
reductions, and noise control.
Traffic Engineer Kim mentioned that one of the more common references for comparisons between the
two designs is the number of conflict points for vehicles. A roundabout has eight conflict points and the
four way stop sign has 32 conflict points. More conflict points represent an increase in the potential for
collisions.
Engineering Manager Ajideh pulled up another example that included additional data.
Transportation Director Frank said that in this design option they were considering curb extension to
provide a tighter radius for turning cars, to slow the speed of the cars. He reiterated the importance of
listening to the community feedback and their comfort level with any design improvement.
Commissioner Penseyres was asked to comment on the differences of the bike classifications II and Class
IV. This location near a school is more geared towards safe routes to school facilities. One should
consider the number of driveway and visibility. Kelly Drive east of Hillside Drive it is not a good location
for a Class IV bike lane. He recommends going with the staff proposal to put in buffered bike lanes at
that location.
Chair Gocan requested that each commissioner state their preference for the type of bike lane and
roundabout option to give staff adequate feedback.
Commissioner Penseyres is in favor of roundabouts and understands the importance of public
acceptance. He understands that there will be resistance, yet in other locations, after the roundabout
was installed, the 80% against it were now for it; the key is education.
Commissioner Hunter is in favor of a roundabout when they are done right. Separated bike lanes look
like a good option in that location.
Commissioner Linke said that he can support the roundabout at Kelly Drive and Hillside Drive, with
specific design improvements. He has skepticism about locating a roundabout near a school due to drop
off and pick up peak time conditions. Staff should consider a field observation for bicyclists. He does
understand the benefits for bicyclists in a roundabout. On the bike lanes, he supports what
Commissioner Penseyres recommends. He would like to see a more honest analysis and evaluation of
the Kelly Drive and El Camino Real, and get more feedback from the residents. He would like a
comment on the fire evacuation plan.
Transportation Director Frank said that he will work with the Fire Department to incorporate their
suggestions.
Page 10 of 10 Public Works
Transportation 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2746 t
Commissioner Fowler feels that a roundabout decision is a matter of acceptance. He does support a
roundabout. He will leave the bicycle judgement to staff and Commissioner Penseyres.
Vice-Chair Perez feels that if the roundabout is designed right, the place is right, and include information
and education, then he supports them. He supports Commissioner Penseyres on the bike lanes, if it is
designed right and placed right, based on the school and driveways, he can support it.
Chair Gocan has a lot of experience driving roundabouts and agrees about the importance of education
and the benefits of safety. She supports the roundabouts and staff’s recommendations on the bike
lanes. She is interested like Commissioner Fowler if we can put in speed cushions in an earlier stage due
to the size and duration of this project, to address speeding concerns and safety issues. The residents
have been waiting for a while and it would be better to address the safety concerns soon.
Commissioner Penseyres wanted to add that he supports reversed parking.
CITY TRAFFIC ENGINEER REPORT:
City Traffic Engineer Comments: Attachment A
Transportation and Mobility Manager Schmidt highlighted an upcoming Biking with Kids class with the
San Diego County Bicycle Coalition on August 10, 2021.
There is one open position on the Traffic and Mobility Commission, the application period will close on
Friday, August 13, 2021.
On August 17, 2021, The City Council will make two new appointments for the Traffic & Mobility
Commission vacancies.
Transportation and Mobility Manager Schmidt read a proclamation in recognition of Commissioner
Hunter service on the Traffic and Mobility Commission for eight years.
TRAFFIC AND MOBILITY COMMISSION COMMENTS:
Commissioner Linke stated the importance of reviewing the various TDM initiatives and evaluations in a
timely manner.
Commissioner Penseyres expressed his appreciation for how staff is handing the project discussed
tonight and enjoys the chance to give comments at the front end of the project.
ADJOURNMENT:
Chair Gocan adjourned the Traffic and Mobility Commission Meeting on Aug. 2, 2021 at 6:38 p.m.
___________________________
Eliane Paiva, Minutes Clerk r t
Attachment A
Meeting Date: Aug. 2, 2021
To: Traffic and Mobility Commission
Staff Contact: John Kim, City Traffic Engineer
John.Kim@carlsbadca.gov, 760-602-2757
Subject: City Traffic Engineer Report
Past City Council Items on Traffic and Mobility
July 20, 2021
• Ordinance to restrict overnight parking on Avenue Encinas
July 27, 2021
• Semiannual Transportation Report
• Traffic and Mobility Commission FY21-22 Work Plan, Chair Gocan represented
the T&MC
Upcoming City Council Items on Traffic and Mobility
Aug. 17, 2021
• Engineering Design Services for College Boulevard Reach A
• Two (2) Traffic and Mobility Commissioner Appointments
Aug. 31, 2021
• Award of Contract: FY 20-21 Pavement Overlay Project
• Advertise for Bids: El Camino Real and Cannon Road Phase II Improvements
• Advertise for Bids: 2021 Slurry Seal Project
• Advertise for Bids: FY 2020-21 ADA Improvement Program
• FY19-20 Growth Management Plan Monitoring Report
Other Items
Traffic & Mobility Commission motion to review the Vehicle Miles Traveled Guidelines: To be
reviewed by the T&MC in Fall 2021
City Traffic Engineer Report
Page 2
Non-Agenda Public Comments
Item Action
Grand Promenade (Village and Barrio
Master Plan Mobility Project)
The prioritization of the mobility projects
identified in the Village and Barrio Master Plan
will be considered by City Council once a
District 1 Council Member appointment has
been made.
Traffic concerns on Cerezo Drive
including request for all-way STOPs at
Las Robles Drive and El Arbol Drive
Staff is working with Ms. Achey on specific
requests and will be bringing back all-way STOP
study to Traffic and Mobility Commission as a
future agenda item.
Implementation of Thoroughfares (Ealy) Signal Systems staff will contact requestor.
Traffic circles on Kelly Drive (Ahlquist) Project Manager of Kelly Drive/Park Drive
project notified requestor of Traffic and
Mobility Commission agenda item on Aug. 2 to
discuss this project.
Commissioner Comments
Item Action
Report on College Boulevard speed
feedback sign data
Project not complete.