Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-05-09; City Council; ; Amendment No. 4 to the Agreement with GHD Inc. for Additional Engineering Design and Environmental Permitting Services for the Beach Access Repairs and Upgrades from PineCA Review GH Meeting Date: May 9, 2023 To: Mayor and City Council From: Scott Chadwick, City Manager Staff Contact: Lauren Ferrell, Associate Engineer lauren.ferrell@carlsbadca.gov, 442-339-2558 Hossein Ajideh, Engineering Manager hossein.ajideh@carlsbadca.gov, 442-339-2756 Subject: Amendment No. 4 to the Agreement with GHD Inc. for Additional Engineering Design and Environmental Permitting Services for the Beach Access Repairs and Upgrades from Pine Avenue to Tamarack Avenue Project District: 1 Recommended Action Adopt a resolution approving Amendment No. 4 to the professional services agreement with GHD Inc., for additional engineering design and environmental permitting services for the Beach Access Repairs and Upgrades from Pine Avenue to Tamarack Avenue Project, increasing the not to exceed amount by $189,935 and extending the term by three years. Executive Summary This project will make necessary repairs and upgrades to the five beach access stairways, the elevated upper sidewalk, hand railings, guardrails and lighting on the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard between Pine Avenue and Tamarack Avenue. The city, along with the California Department of Parks and Recreation, or State Parks, wants to provide the necessary repairs and maintenance to improve the safety and accessibility of these heavily used access routes to the beach, which attract thousands of residents and visitors year- round. The City Council authorized a professional services agreement with GHD Inc. in January 2018, in an amount not to exceed $500,000. The project has since faced multiple design and permitting challenges because the project is within State Parks property and the coastal zone. The agreement has been amended three times under the delegated authority of the City Manager and is set to expire on May 10, 2023. Approval of the proposed fourth amendment exceeds the City Manager’s authority under Carlsbad Municipal Code Section 3.28.040(D)(3), so requires the City Council’s approval. May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 1 of 24 Staff are requesting an amendment to the agreement with GHD Inc. to supplement the scope of work, increase the not to exceed amount by $189,935 and extend the term for an additional three years until May 9, 2026. Sufficient funding is available in the project’s account to cover the additional cost needed for this amendment. Explanation & Analysis The upper and lower sidewalks, along with the seawall and stairways along the west side of Carlsbad Boulevard between Pine Avenue and Tamarack Avenue, were built between 1986 and 1988. The upper sidewalk between Pine Avenue and Maple Avenue is elevated and cantilevered over the bluff. There are four elevated stairways within the project area, and one on-grade stairway near Tamarack Avenue. City staff observed these facilities had deteriorated and needed further investigation and repairs. Comprehensive evaluation identified deficiencies that include deterioration of the elevated upper sidewalk structure, exposed and rusted steel reinforcements, cracked and broken away concrete and rusting of stairway components. The repair project was originally considered a maintenance project but has expanded into an improvement project to address code requirements and increased demand for beach access. Additional work that was not in the original scope of the agreement was subsequently identified for improved access, mobility and aesthetics. This work involves: • Widening the upper sidewalk • Removing the metal beam guardrails • Replacing streetlights • Replacing the walking surfaces and stairs adjacent to the Tamarack Avenue restrooms • Installing walkway lighting • Extending the lower sidewalk’s retaining walls to help maintain the slope at the base of the stairways Construction phasing of the project has been modified and extended to minimize impacts along Carlsbad Boulevard and Tamarack State Beach during the summer season from Memorial Day through Labor Day. Construction will occur in two phases, over a total of 15 months. The project’s geographical limits are entirely within the State Parks’ right-of-way as shown on the location map provided as Exhibit 2. As a result, the city must comply with the state’s design standards and coordinate design reviews and approvals with State Parks. Additionally, city staff have coordinated with State Parks staff to determine how to reimburse State Parks for its costs associated with the plan reviews and construction inspection services. May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 2 of 24 Project timeline Jan. 10, 2018 The City Council adopted Resolution No. 2018-002, authorizing execution of a professional services agreement with GHD Inc. in an amount not to exceed $500,000 to provide engineering and environmental analysis for the project. April 24, 2020 The term of the agreement was extended for an additional three-year period, and the scope of services were amended to include additional design improvements requiring additional studies and analysis, and environmental analysis. These additional services constituted Amendment No. 1, and the additional fees were not to exceed $220,000. The amendment extended the agreement term to May 10, 2023. June 14, 2021 The agreement was amended a second time to include services for a topographical survey along Carlsbad Boulevard in an amount not to exceed $6,000. Jan. 31, 2022 A third amendment in an amount not to exceed $99,855 added services to prepare visual simulations to develop the plans, revise the project description to include additional design features and revised technical studies and add the requirement for an additional 65%-completed design to be submitted to the city. Amendment No. 3 increased the total agreement not to exceed amount to $825,855. The proposed Amendment No. 4 will provide additional funding in an amount not to exceed $189,935 for GHD to complete the engineering design and environmental permitting services for the project for a new total agreement amount not to exceed $1,015,790 and extend the term by three years until May 9, 2026. Fiscal Analysis Sufficient funds are available in the Capital Improvement Program Project No. 3896 budget to cover this amendment and complete the engineering design and environmental permitting for the project. Fiscal impacts for Amendment No. 4 to the agreement with GHD Inc. is shown in the following table: Estimated costs and available funds Beach Access Repairs and Upgrades from Pine Avenue to Tamarack Avenue Capital Improvement Program Project No. 3896 Total appropriation to date $12,111,750 Total expenditures and encumbrances to date -$1,622,859 Total available funding $10,488,891 Additional project costs Amendment No. 4 with GHD Inc. -$189,935 Remaining balance $10,298,956 Additional appropriation needed $0 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 3 of 24 Options Staff provide the following options for the City Council’s consideration: 1. Approve Amendment No. 4 to the professional services agreement with GHD Inc. for additional engineering design and environmental permitting services for the project in an amount not to exceed $189,935, and to extend the term by three years. Pros • Provides funding for services needed to successfully complete the project • Amendment to the agreement complies with applicable municipal code sections • The additional scope of services and fees have been negotiated with GHD Inc. • Sufficient funding is available for the amendment Cons • None identified 2. Do not approve Amendment No. 4 to the agreement with GHD Pros • None identified Cons • Potential further deterioration of the existing sidewalks, stairways and handrails • Delays implementing needed repairs and upgrades • Potential increase in construction costs with delay to design completion • Maintenance and repair issues would continue to exist Staff recommend Option 1 for the City Council’s approval. Next Steps Upon the City Council’s approval, staff will process Amendment No. 4 to the agreement, and GHD Inc. will provide the additional services provided for in the amendment. Staff anticipate that the design will be completed in late 2023. Staff and GHD will continue to work on the final engineering design and environmental clearance to prepare the construction plans, specifications, cost estimates and environmental permits as needed to advertise the project for construction bids. Staff and GHD Inc. will continue coordination with the State Parks staff to receive the necessary project approvals. Staff plan to return to the City Council in late 2023 with a recommendation to approve the plans and specifications and for authorization to advertise for construction bids. Staff plan to return to the City Council with a request to award a construction contract in spring 2024. Construction is expected to start in fall 2024 with completion in spring 2026. Environmental Evaluation This action does not constitute a project within the meaning of the California Environmental Quality Act under Public Resources Code section 21065. It has no potential to cause either a direct physical change in the environment or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment and therefore does not require environmental review. Public input received and technical information prepared during the process will be used in preparing an environmental document to analyze the possible effects of the project. This action that amends the professional services agreement does not have a legally binding effect on any possible future discretionary action related to the project. May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 4 of 24 Exhibits 1. City Council resolution 2. Location map May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 5 of 24 RESOLUTION NO. 2023-119 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING AMENDMENT NO. 4 TO THE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH GHD INC., FOR ADDITIONAL ENGINEERING DESIGN AND ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITTING SERVICES FOR THE BEACH ACCESS REPAIRS AND UPGRADES FROM PINE AVENUE TO TAMARACK AVENUE PROJECT, INCREASING THE NOT TO EXCEED AMOUNT BY $189,935 AND EXTENDING THE TERM BY THREE YEARS WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California has determined it necessary, desirable and in the public interest to maintain public safety and accessibility to make repairs and upgrades to stairways, sidewalks, handrails and improve existing pathways to the beach area; and WHEREAS, on Jan. 9, 2018, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 2018-002, authorizing GHD Inc. to provide engineering and design services for the Beach Access Repairs and Upgrades from Pine Avenue to Tamarack Avenue, Capital Improvement Program, or CIP, Project No. 3896, or Project, in an amount not to exceed $500,000; and WHEREAS, on April 24, 2020, Amendment No. 1 to the Agreement was executed to revise the scope of services for an additional fee of $220,000 and to extend the term of the Agreement by three years; and WHEREAS, on June 14, 2021, Amendment No. 2 to the Agreement was executed to revise the scope of services for an additional fee of $6,000; and WHEREAS, on Jan. 31, 2022, Amendment No. 3 to the Agreement was executed to revise the scope of services for an additional fee of $99,855; and WHEREAS, the term of Agreement currently ends on May 10, 2023; and WHEREAS, to complete the Project, the parties desire to amend the scope of work for additional engineering design and environmental permitting services, for an additional amount of $189,935 for a total agreement not to exceed amount of $1,015,790, and to extend the term by three years until May 9,2026;and WHEREAS, sufficient funding from the General Capital Construction and Infrastructure Replacement funds is available in the project account to cover the additional fee associated with Amendment No. 4 to the Agreement; and WHEREAS, the City Planner has determined that the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act under State Guidelines Section 21065, in that it has no potential to cause Exhibit 1 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 6 of 24 either a direct physical change in the environment or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Carlsbad, California, as follows: 1.That the above recitations are true and correct. 2.That the Amendment No. 4 to the Agreement for additional engineering design and environmental permitting services for the Project, as described in Attachment A, is hereby approved, and the Mayor is hereby authorized and directed to execute said Amendment. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of Carlsbad on the 9th day of May, 2023, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NAYS: ABSTAIN: ABSENT: Blackburn, Bhat-Patel, Acosta, Burkholder, Luna. None. None. None. KEITH BLACKBURN, Mayor Lj SHERRY FREISINGER, City Clerkr -(SEAL) May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 7 of 24 \\ \ \ \ \ ll'l l i / 1 / / f / / / ,,, , , , CJ - , . t:' 11 1 , ❖" r ½ ~ ······· · · · - . o ~ ~ ') / ') / ·• ... ,< \ ~ [~ /~f? /1.lt . ·---, ~ ~:;; u ~ ~ !I.~ , ► ~ ~ 0 · .. -,. ~ - <:r:1 ::: :;:c .. . . . •• • ~-- ; r- . £:: ~ ~ --._ \ : _ . .-c, $ ~. "/ . ·· ... - .. ··A ; ~ ~ '-< I ···· · · · · ····- r v "' ' /,,/ Q" - l ,, , l/ f t t / / ( l f / / l ! ! l \ .1 \ \ \ \ \ \\ \ \ DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 Attachment A TRAN1651 AMENDMENT NO. 4 TO EXTEND AND AMEND THE AGREEMENT FOR ENGINEERING SERVICES FOR BEACH ACCESS REPAIRS ALONG CARLSBAD BOULEVARD FROM PINE AVENUE TO TAMARACK AVENUE GHD INC. This Amendment No. 4 is entered into and effective as of the \ D -rt,--day of ____ _,_.........,._----".-----' 2023, extending and amending the agreement dated January 10, 2018 {the "Agreem nt") by and between the City of Carlsbad, a municipal corporation, ("City"), and GHD Inc., a Cali ornia corporation, ("Contractor") (collectively, the "Parties") for engineering services and for beach access repairs along Carlsbad Boulevard from Pine Avenue to Tamarack Avenue ("Services). RECITALS A. Under the Agreement, the City retained the Services of the Contractor for a period of 850 days, for an amount not to exceed five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000). B. On April 20, 2020, the Parties executed Amendment No. 1 to the Agreement to extend the term of the Agreement for an additional three (3) years, to amend and supplement the Scope of Work for to include widening the elevated upper sidewalk, and to increase the total amount paid for Services by two hundred twenty thousand dollars ($220,000), for an amended not to exceed amount of seven hundred twenty thousand dollars ($720,000) and C. On June 14, 2021, the Parties executed Amendment No. 2 to the Agreement to amend and supplement the Scope of Work for additional survey services along Carlsbad Blvd., and to increase the total amount paid for Services by six thousand dollars ($6,000), for an amended not to exceed amount of seven hundred twenty six thousand dollars ($726,000); and D. On January 31 , 2022, the Parties executed Agreement No. 3 to the Agreement to amend and supplement the Scope of Work to include additional visual simulations of the proposed improvements, additional design services for converting the existing guard rail to illuminated non- traffic rated bollards, and additional biological mapping and CEQA services; and to increase the total amount paid for Services by ninety nine thousand eight hundred fifty five dollars ($99,855), for an amended not to exceed amount of eight hundred twenty five thousand eight hundred fifty five dollars ($825,855); and E. The Parties now desire to extend the Agreement for an additional three (3) years, amend and supplement the Scope of Work to include final engineering, environmental, permitting, and construction support for the completion of the project, and to increase the total not to exceed amount. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of these recitals and the mutual covenants contained herein, City and Contractor agree as follows: 1. In addition to those Services contained in the Agreement, as may have been amended from time to time, Contractor will provide those services described in Exhibit "A", Scope of Services and Fee (SUPPLEMENTAL). 2. City will pay Contractor for all work associated with the Services described in Exhibit "A", Scope of Services and Fee (SUPPLEMENTAL) on a time and materials basis an amount not-to-exceed one hundred eighty nine thousand nine hundred thirty-five dollars City Attorney Approved Version 12/28/2022 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 8 of 24 DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B102123C199 TRAN1651 ($189,935). With this Amendment, the total Agreement amount shall not exceed one million fifteen thousand seven hundred ninety dollars ($1,015,790). Contractor will provide City, on a monthly basis, copies of invoices sufficiently detailed to include hours performed, hourly rates, and related activities and costs for approval by City. 3. The Agreement, as may have been amended from time to time, is hereby extended for a period of three (3) years until May 9, 2026. 4. All other provisions of the Agreement, as may have been amended from time to time, will remain in full force and effect. 5. All requisite insurance policies to be maintained by the Contractor pursuant to the Agreement, as may have been amended from time to time, will include coverage for this Amendment. 6. The individuals executing this Amendment and the instruments referenced in it on behalf of Contractor each represent and warrant that they have the legal power, right and actual authority to bind Contractor to the terms and conditions of this Amendment. [signatures on following page] City Attorney Approved Version 12/28/2022 2 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 9 of 24 DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-681D2123C199 CONTRACTOR GHD Inc., a California corporation By: By: (sign here) Greg Watanabe, Principal & Vice-President (print name/title) (sign here) (print name/title) TRAN1651 CITY OF CARLSBAD, a municipal corporation of the State of California By: eith Blackburn, Mayor Attest: ~ for Sherry Freisinger, City Clerk If required by City, proper notarial acknowledgment of execution by Contractor must be attached. If a corporation, Agreement must be signed by one corporate officer from each of the following two groups: Group A Chairman, President, or Vice-President Group B Secretary, Assistant Secretary, CFO or Assistant Treasurer Otherwise, the corporation must attach a resolution certified by the secretary or assistant secretary under corporate seal empowering the officer(s) signing to bind the corporation. APPROVED AS TO FORM: CINDIE K. McMAHON, City Attorney BY: ___ bt_1A.A,_fu,n,w __ ~ ____ _ Deputy City Attorney City Attorney Approved Version 12/28/2022 3 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 10 of 24 TRAN1651 City Attorney Approved Version 12/28/2022 4 EXHIBIT “A” SCOPE OF SERVICES AND FEE (SUPPLEMENTAL) DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 11 of 24 Beach Access Repair - Amendment No. 4 Scope March 27, 2023 Proposed Effort (May 2023 Through Construction May 2025) The following tasks define our team’s scope to assist the City in advancing the project through final permitting and design efforts, as well as bidding and construction services on a time and materials basis. TASK 1 PROJECT COORDINATION AND MEETINGS GHD will attend up to thirteen (13) bi-weekly meetings during the remaining design, bid and permitting process for six (6) months from May 2023 to the end of October 2023. In addition, we assume participation in six (6) meetings with State Parks, Coastal Commission, regulatory agencies, City's Planning and/or Parks and Recreation departments, as needed. We will produce meeting minutes for documentation purposes. GHD will also produce progress reports to be submitted with the monthly invoice for the project through the anticipated through the end of construction in May 2025. This task will also include project management efforts related to overseeing the project and coordination with the team and City staff when needed. TASK 2 100% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS AND FINAL SUBMITTAL The GHD team will advance the design and associated plan set to the 100% level for all disciplines and will provide a formal comment resolution table identifying all design review comments received. We will update the construction documents based on the agreement and resolution of comments for final submittal of sealed plans and specifications to the City. This submittal will represent the final contract documents that will be issued for bid and construction. The Engineer’s Estimate of Probable Construction Cost / Bid Schedule will be updated to match the 100% / Final submittal and unit costs will be verified by O’Connor Construction Management, Inc. (OCMI) given recent material escalations, bidding climate, and other project requirements. Deliverables: - 100% and Final Drawings for Construction - 100% and Final Technical Specifications - 100% and Final Engineer’s Estimate of Probable Construction Cost / Bid Schedule Assumptions: - The City will reproduce the complete final bid set of project drawings and specifications for the project for distribution to potential bidders. TASK 3 SDG&E COORDINATION GHD will coordinate with the City and SDG&E as needed for the replacement of the existing street lights and design review of new service for the proposed under rail lighting at the four (4) elevated stairways and one (1) on grade stairway adjacent to the Tamarack Avenue restroom. We anticipate attending up to four (4) meetings with City and/or SDG&E staff during the design period. DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 12 of 24 TASK 4 REMAINING PERMITTING EFFORTS Our team has developed an Initial Study / Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) and supporting documents for the project in accordance with California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) guidelines, of which three (3) versions have been reviewed by the City to date. The IS/MND and associated figures, drawings have been further revised and are currently in a fourth round of review with the City. GHD will continue to coordinate with the City to address further comments, if any. We assume up to two (2) more rounds of review with the City before adoption and that additional technical studies or quantitative analysis are not needed. Once the City Planning Commission approves for release, GHD will prepare the MND for public review. CEQA Public Review Period Per CEQA Guidelines Section 15072, GHD will prepare a Notice of Intent (NOI) to Adopt an MND for review by the City. The NOI together with the Public Draft IS/MND will be publicly distributed for 30 days as required by the CEQA Guidelines. GHD will develop a mailing list in coordination with the City. The City has advised that they will distribute the IS/MND to the State Clearinghouse, responsible agencies, affected property owners, and persons requesting notice. The City will also prepare and post an advertisement for a local newspaper, and will submit a copy of the NOI to the San Diego County Clerk. Deliverable: One (1) electronic copy in both MS Word and PDF of the Public Draft IS/MND and NOI Finalize MND After the required 30-day review period, GHD will compile all comments received on the Public Draft IS/MND, including comment letters, emails, and oral comments. GHD will conduct an initial review of all comments received on the Public Draft IS/MND, number them, and categorize them by subject. GHD will then prepare responses to each comment. GHD will prepare one draft and one final response to comments document for City staff to review. The Final IS/MND presented to the City for consideration will consist of the Public Draft IS/MND, comments received, the responses to comments, and the Mitigation Monitoring and Report Program (see Task 6 below). For purposes of this proposal, GHD assumes a total of up to 10 comment letters consisting of up to 2-pages each will be received and require brief qualitative responses. We will revise the Final IS/MND in response to up to two (2) rounds of City review, including preparation of a comment tracking table. GHD will prepare a draft Notice of Determination (NOD) and submit it to the City for review. GHD’s project manager and environmental document task leader will attend one (1) Planning Commission meeting at which the project will be considered for approval. We understand that the City will file the final NOD with the State Clearinghouse and San Diego County Clerk within five (5) working days of project approval. This scope of work does not include CEQA filing fees (e.g., County Clerk, California Department of Fish and Wildlife), which we assume will be paid directly by the City. Deliverables: - One (1) electronic copy in both MS Word and PDF of each of the Final IS/MND - One (1) electronic copy in both MS Word and PDF of NOD DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 13 of 24 Coastal Development Permit GHD will prepare a Coastal Development Permit (CDP) application and support the City with acquisition of the CDP under the City’s Local Coastal Plan (LCP). The CDP application will be submitted to the City for up to two (2) rounds of review and revision and will be developed consistent with the project CEQA documents. GHD’s project manager and environmental permitting task leader will attend one (1) Coastal Commission hearing. Deliverable: CDP application package submitted to the City for review and approval Assumptions: - The project is located in the California Coastal Commission (CCC) appeal jurisdiction and additional support if appealed is outside this scope of work and can be provided on a time and materials basis if needed. TASK 5 BID SUPPORT SERVICES After the completion of the construction documents, the design team will support the City during the bidding stage. The GHD Team will be available to provide the following Bid Support Services: - Preparation of Bid Addenda - Prepare responses to bidder questions GHD will provide these services on a time and materials basis up the allowable budget for this task. TASK 6 CONSTRUCTION SUPPORT SERVICES Our Team will provide assistance to the City during the three construction phases (1A, 1B and 2) of the project to support the technical aspects of the design and any design changes. Construction is anticipated to occur outside of prime vacation summer months (Memorial Day to Labor Day) and take 15 months to complete. The GHD Team will be available to provide the following Construction Support Services: - Attend site visits and meetings during 15 months of construction (assumes 2 hours per week) - Review Contractor Shop Drawings and Submittals (assumes up to 20 submittals) - Respond to Contractor RFIs (assumes up to 30 RFIs) - One (1) structural site observation related to the construction for each of the project phases - One (1) landscape pre-maintenance meeting - One (1) walk-thru with the City for each of the project phases - Prepare As-Built (Record) Drawings based on Contractor markups GHD will provide these services on a time and materials basis up to the allowable budget for this task. If more hours are required to perform the work an amendment to contract will be requested by GHD and additional work will be performed after approved by City. DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 14 of 24 TASK 7 CONSTRUCTION MONITORING Mitigation Monitoring Reporting Plan (MMRP) Revisions / Compliance Verification GHD and KTUA will revise the current draft Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan (MMRP) with City concurrence to identify and delineate responsible parties for implementing any mitigation measures presented in the IS/MND. The MMRP will include all mitigation measures, responsibility for their implementation, and method and schedule for reporting on their implementation. Our team will coordinate with the City to select and appoint qualified responsible parties / individuals (i.e. biologists, scientists, and other qualified contractors) to implement and carry out monitoring and/or reporting activities. We will track and manage the timing and completion of mitigation monitoring measures and reporting actions during construction, as well as compliance verification dates. The scope outlined for this task is comprehensive and supersedes the original scope and addenda for the project. Deliverable: One (1) electronic copy in both MS Word and PDF of the MMRP DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 15 of 24 ASSUMPTIONS The proposed project scope of work includes the following assumptions: o The scope outlined for the Amendment 4 tasks is comprehensive and supersedes the original scope and amendments for the project. o Scope and fee based are based on schedule attached created February 2023 o No construction services to be provided between Memorial Day and Labor Day o Scope and fee based on 15 months (60 weeks) of construction activities o Assumes attendance at on site recurring construction meetings not required o Assumes SWPPP will be prepared and submitted by contractor o Assume City to coordinate tribal and cultural resource consultation efforts and requirements o San Diego Gas and Electric (SDG&E) will not require that a new metered service or transformers be provided o There will be no further public outreach or stakeholder meetings needed o City will pay for all permit and application fees for the project o No historic built environment analysis and evaluation is needed o This scope assumes no focused surveys for special status plant or wildlife species would be required subsequent to the Biological Resources Assessment o The City will provide documentation required to acquire the CDP and take over filing and administration of the CDP once the application has been submitted to the City by GHD o Assumes no 401, 404 or 1602 permits are needed for the project o Comments from the City will be limited to one (1) round of consolidated comments to be addressed per submittal o Analytical test for agricultural suitability of soil samples and planting amendment recommendations prepared by a licensed soils testing laboratory are available o Frontend ‘boiler plate’ specifications will be provided by the City, with limited input required from the GHD Team o The City will reproduce the complete final bid set of project drawings and specifications for the project for distribution to potential bidders o GHD does not control the review and approval of regulatory agency permits o City / Contractor to produce As-built record drawings DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 16 of 24 City of Carlsbad | Beach Access Repairs Along Carlsbad Blvd from Pine Ave to Tamarack Ave Subconsultants Organizational Chart Project Manager Robert Sherwood, PE QA/QC Review Satish Chilka, PE, SECharles Smith, AICP, LEED AP (Permitting QA/QC) Principal-in-Charge Craig Lewis, PE, SE GHD Project Resources Civil Brittany Zambrano, PE Erika Hall, EIT Structural Samantha Faddis, PE, SE Ishan Goel, EIT Electrical Mehdi Mardi, EETomoki Masui, EE Landscape Architect KTU+A Tim Henderson, ASLA Bernard Everling Permitting Brian Leslie (CDP) Nicole Greenberg (CEQA) Ryder Burliss (MMRP) Geotechnical ENGEO Walter Crampton, PE, GE Taylor Strack, PE, GE Stormwater Nathan Towlerton, PE Robin Raines, PE Surveying Alta Land Surveying Miguel Martinez, PLS Cost Estimating QC OCMI John Mauk, LCPE, CCP DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 17 of 24 ('cicyof Carlsbad California ID Task Name Duration Start Finish 0 Planning / Engineering  Design / Construction 593  days Fri 1/27/23 Tue 5/6/25 1 Permitting 128  days Fri 1/27/23 Tue 7/25/23 2 Third City Review of  IS/MND & Applications  (Screencheck #3) 0 days Fri 1/27/23 Fri 1/27/23 3 Address City  Screencheck #3  C 11 days Fri 1/27/23 Fri 2/10/23 4 Fourth City Review of  IS/MND & Applications  (Screencheck #4) 20 days Mon 2/13/23 Fri 3/10/23 5 Agency Pre‐application  Meetings 5 days Mon 3/13/23 Fri 3/17/23 6 City Review to Finalize  MND for Public Review 10 days Mon 3/20/23 Fri 3/31/23 7 CEQA Public Review  Period and Applicant  R 20 days Mon 4/3/23 Fri 4/28/23 8 GHD draft responses to  comments & Final  IS/MND 10 days Mon 5/1/23 Fri 5/12/23 9 City Staff Review 10 days Mon 5/15/23 Fri 5/26/23 10 GHD Prepare Final  IS/MND 5 days Mon 5/29/23 Fri 6/2/23 11 City Staff Review /  Planning Commission  Cl d 10 days Mon 6/5/23 Fri 6/16/23 12 City Planning  Commission Approval 10 days Mon 6/19/23 Fri 6/30/23 13 Submit CDP and Permit  Applications to  Ai 1 day Mon 4/3/23 Mon 4/3/23 14 CDP / Permit Review by Various Agencies 80 days Tue 4/4/23 Mon 7/24/23 15 Obtain Agency Permits 1 day Tue 7/25/23 Tue 7/25/23 16 90% Construction  Documents 56 days Mon 2/13/23 Mon 5/1/23 17 City & California State  Parks 85% Review 20 days Mon 2/13/23 Fri 3/10/23 18 85% City / Parks Review Comments to GHD  T 1 day Mon 3/13/23 Mon 3/13/23 19 Address City Comments / Develop 90% PS&E 35 days Mon 2/13/23 Fri 3/31/23 20 90% Cost Estimate 10 days Mon 3/20/23 Fri 3/31/23 21 90% Submittal to City /  California State Parks 0 days Fri 3/31/23 Fri 3/31/23 22 City & State Parks 90%  Review 20 days Mon 4/3/23 Fri 4/28/23 23 90% City / Parks Review Comments to GHD  T 1 day Mon 5/1/23 Mon 5/1/23 24 100% Construction  Documents 62 days Tue 5/2/23 Wed 7/26/23 25 Produce 100%  Drawings and  Sifii 20 days Tue 5/2/23 Mon 5/29/23 Permitting 1/27 1/27 Address City Screencheck #3 Comments 2/13 Fourth City Review of IS/MND & Applications (Screencheck #4) 3/13 3/17 Agency Pre-application Meetings 3/20 City Review to Finalize MND for Public Review 4/3 4/28 CEQA Public Review Period and Applicant Response 5/1 5/12 GHD draft responses to comments & Final IS/MND 5/15 5/26 City Staff Review 5/29 6/2 GHD Prepare Final IS/MND 6/5 6/16 City Staff Review / Planning Commission Calendar 6/19 6/30 City Planning Commission Approval 4/3 Submit CDP and Permit Applications to Agencies 4/4 7/24CDP / Permit Review by Various Agencies 7/25 Obtain Agency Permits 90% Construction Documents 2/13 3/10 City & California State Parks 85% Review 3/13 85% City / Parks Review Comments to GHD Team 2/13 3/31Address City Comments / Develop 90% PS&E 90% Cost Estimate 3/31 90% Submittal to City / California State Parks City & State Parks 90% Review 5/1 90% City / Parks Review Comments to GHD Team 100% Construction Documents Produce 100% Drawings and Specifications Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun2022Qtr 1, 2023 Qtr 2, 2023 Qtr 3, 2023 Qtr 4, 2023 Qtr 1, 2024 Qtr 2, 2024 Qtr 3, 2024 Qtr 4, 2024 Qtr 1, 2025 Qtr 2, 2025 Page 1 DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 Ma y 9 , 2 0 2 3 It e m # 2 P a g e 1 8 o f 2 4 - ~ - - -- - -- - -- - -- - -- - -- - -- ►• - .. ►- .. .f - .. 1 .. [ J ~ ►.- J ~ , - .. - - - , i - .. - J ►- - I - .~- .. i - - --- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ID Task Name Duration Start Finish 26 100% Cost Estimate 10 days Tue 5/16/23 Mon 5/29/23 27 100% Submittal to City 1 day Tue 5/30/23 Tue 5/30/23 28 City Public Works &  Planning 100% Review 20 days Wed 5/31/23 Tue 6/27/23 29 Final Doc Edits and  Coordination w/ City 10 days Wed 6/28/23 Tue 7/11/23 30 Final Bid Package 1 day Wed 7/26/23 Wed 7/26/23 31 Bid Period 60 days Thu 7/27/23 Wed  10/18/23 32 City Admin &  Signatures 10 days Thu 7/27/23 Wed 8/9/23 33 Bid Advertisement  Period 40 days Thu 8/10/23 Wed 10/4/23 34 Bid Review and Award 10 days Thu 10/5/23 Wed  10/18/23 35 Bid Award 0 days Wed 10/18/23 Wed  10/18/23 36 Construction 383  days Thu 10/19/23 Mon 4/7/25 37 General Requirements 51 days Thu 10/19/23 Thu 12/28/23 38 Contract Negotiation 10 days Thu 10/19/23 Wed 11/1/23 39 Construction Kickoff  Meeting 1 day Thu 11/2/23 Thu 11/2/23 40 Material  Procurement /  Sb i l 40 days Fri 11/3/23 Thu 12/28/23 41 Mobilize Onsite 10 days Fri 11/3/23 Thu 11/16/23 42 Phase 1 Construction 136  days Fri 11/17/23 Fri 5/24/24 43 Pine Ave to Maple  Ave ‐ Upper Sidewalk 136  days Fri 11/17/23 Fri 5/24/24 44 Phase 1 Completion 0 days Fri 5/24/24 Fri 5/24/24 45 Summer 2024 Tourist  Season 71 days Mon 5/27/24 Mon 9/2/24 46 Phase 2 Construction 155  days Tue 9/3/24 Mon 4/7/25 47 Remobilize Onsite 15 days Tue 9/3/24 Mon 9/23/24 48 Maple Ave to  Tamrack Ave ‐ Upper  Sid lk 140  days Tue 9/24/24 Mon 4/7/25 49 Phase 2 Completion 0 days Mon 4/7/25 Mon 4/7/25 50 Final Acceptance 21 days Tue 4/8/25 Tue 5/6/25 51 Final Walk‐through  Inspection 1 day Tue 4/8/25 Tue 4/8/25 52 Complete Punch List  Items 20 days Wed 4/9/25 Tue 5/6/25 100% Cost Estimate 5/30 100% Submittal to City City Public Works & Planning 100% Review Final Doc Edits and Coordination w/ City 7/26 Final Bid Package Bid Period 7/27 City Admin & Signatures 8/10 10/4Bid Advertisement Period Bid Review and Award 10/18 Bid Award 10/19 4/7Construction General Requirements Contract Negotiation 11/2 Construction Kickoff Meeting 11/3 12/28Material Procurement / Submittals 11/3 11/16 Mobilize Onsite Phase 1 Construction 11/17 5/24Pine Ave to Maple Ave - Upper Sidewalk Phase 1 Completion 5/24 5/27 9/2Summer 2024 Tourist Season Phase 2 Construction 9/3 9/23 Remobilize Onsite 9/24 4/7Maple Ave to Tamrack Ave - Upper Sidewalk Phase 2 Completion 4/7 Final Acceptance Final Walk-through Inspection 4/8 Complete Punch List Items 5/6 Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun2022Qtr 1, 2023 Qtr 2, 2023 Qtr 3, 2023 Qtr 4, 2023 Qtr 1, 2024 Qtr 2, 2024 Qtr 3, 2024 Qtr 4, 2024 Qtr 1, 2025 Qtr 2, 2025 Page 2 DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 Ma y 9 , 2 0 2 3 It e m # 2 P a g e 1 9 o f 2 4 t- - - - - - - • [ • J ~ ~ .- r' Ta s k Ta s k D e s c r i p t i o n Se n i o r T e c h n i c a l D i r e c t o r - A 0 1 (P r i n c i p a l E n g i n e e r ) Se n i o r T e c h n i c a l D i r e c t o r - A 0 3 (S e n i o r E n g i n e e r i n g L e a d ) Te c h n i c a l D i r e c t o r 1 - A 0 4 (S e n i o r E n g i n e e r / M a n a g e r ) Te c h n i c a l D i r e c t o r 2 - A 0 5 (S e n i o r E n g i n e e r ) Se n i o r P r o f e s s i o n a l 1 - A 0 6 (P r o j e c t E n g i n e e r ) Se n i o r P r o f e s s i o n a l 2 - A 0 7 (P r o j e c t E n g i n e e r ) Pr o f e s s i o n a l 1 - A 08 (S ta f f E n g i n e e r ) Pr o f e s s i o n a l 3 - A 10 (S ta f f E n g i n e e r ) De s i g n T e c h n i c i a n 1 - B 0 6 (C A D D e s i g n e r ) Pr o j e c t S u p p o r t 5 - D 0 9 (A d m i n S u p p o r t ) To t a l G H D H o u r s GH D L a b o r C O S T S KT U A (L a n d s c a p e A r c h i t e c t u r e ) OC M I (C o s t E s t i m a t i n g ) EN G E O (G e o t e c h n i c a l E n g i n e e r i n g ) To t a l F e e Pr i n c i p a l ( K T U A ) Se n i o r A s s o c i a t e ( K T U A ) As s o c i a t e ( K T U A ) Se n i o r D e s i g n e r ( K T U A ) Co s t E s t i m a t o r ( O C M I ) Se n i o r C o s t E s t i m a t o r ( O C M I ) Co s t e s t i m a t o r M E P ( O C M I ) Pr i n c i p a l ( E N G E O ) As s o c i a t e E n g i n e e r / G e o l o g i s t (E N G E O ) Pr o j e c t E n g i n e e r / G e o l o g i s t (E N G E O ) Te c h n i c a l S u p p o r t ( E N G E O ) 310 260 240 225 210 190 180 135 185 130 190 155 135 115 145 190 230 365 305 235 160 /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR Including 0.0% Markup /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR /HR Task 1 Project Management 12 8 20 $ 3,920 $ - $ - $ - $ 3,920 Coordination & Meetings (6 Month Duration)60 60 $ 14,400 $ - $ - $ - $ 14,400 Subtotal 72 8 80 $ 18,320 $ - $ - $ - $ 18,320 Task 2 Construction Drawings 2 8 40 20 20 8 12 40 150 $ 32,080 $ 15,570 $ - $ 975 $ 48,625 10 20 34 52 1 2 Technical Specifications 24 16 40 $ 9,120 $ 3,270 $ - $ 975 $ 13,365 3686 12 Cost Estimate 2 2 $ 480 $ 1,230 $ 4,070 $ - $ 5,780 12246124 Subtotal 2 8 66 20 36 8 12 40 192 $ 41,680 $ 20,070 $ 4,070 $ 1,950 $ 67,770 14 28 44 62 6 12 4 2 4 Task 3 SDG&E Coordination 12 16 28 $ 5,760 $ - $ - $ - $ 5,760 Subtotal 12 16 28 $ 5,760 $ - $ - $ - $ 5,760 Task 4 Permitting Coord / Mtgs 6 32 10 48 $ 9,930 $ 2,160 $ - $ - $ 12,090 8 8 CEQA Public Review 10 30 40 $ 9,400 $ - $ - $ - $ 9,400 Finalize MND 10 40 10 60 $ 12,850 $ - $ - $ - $ 12,850 CDP Application 24 8 32 $ 6,840 $ - $ - $ - $ 6,840 Subtotal 26 24 102 28 180 $ 39,020 $ 2,160 $ - $ - $ 41,180 8 8 Task 5 Prepare Bid Addenda $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - Responses to Questions (6)(6)(3)(15) $ (3,315) $ 155 $ - $ - $ (3,160) 1 Subtotal (6)(6)(3)(15) $ (3,315) $ 155 $ - $ - $ (3,160) 1 Task 6 Site Visits / Meetings (15 Months Duration)95 1 1 97 $ 23,120 $ 1,620 $ - $ - $ 24,740 6 6 Review Contractor Shop Drawings / Submittals 4 9 4 17 $ 3,720 $ (4,850) $ - $ - $ (1,130) (10) (21) (1) Respond to RFIs 9 20 8 37 $ 8,940 $ (1,985) $ - $ 5,180 $ 12,135 (6) (1) (8)2578 Walk-thru and Checklist for Each Phase 4 16 2 22 $ 5,330 $ - $ - $ - $ 5,330 Record Drawings 3 3 10 16 $ 3,350 $ 6,055 $ - $ - $ 9,405 3 13 1 29 Subtotal 20 143 10 1 10 5 189 $ 44,460 $ 840 $ - $ 5,180 $ 50,480 (7) 13 (21) 26 2 5 7 8 Task 7 CONSTRUCTION MONITORING Revise Draft MMRP / Compliance Verification 3 7 5 15 $ 3,075 $ 3,240 $ - $ - $ 6,315 12 12 Subtotal 3 7 5 15 $ 3,075 $ 3,240 $ - $ - $ 6,315 12 12 Task 8 Reimbursable Expenses (Design and Permitting) $ 145 $ - $ - $ - $ 145 Reimbursable Expenses (Bid and Construction) $ 2,000 $ 1,125 $ - $ - $ 3,125 Subtotal $ 2,145 $ 1,125 $ - $ - $ 3,270 31 22 317 24 145 9 28 30 50 13 669 $151,145 $27,590 $4,070 $7,130 $ 189,935 7 62 23 108 6 12 44978Total Cost - Tasks 1 thru 8 REIMBURSABLE EXPENSES CONSTRUCTION SUPPORT SERVICES BID SUPPORT SERVICES REMAINING PERMITTING EFFORTS SDG&E COORDINATION 100% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS COORDINATION & MEETINGS (MAY THRU OCTOBER 2023) Subconsultants GHD - Compensation and Fee Schedule (Delta Version) Date: 3/24/2023 CITY OF CARLSBAD - BEACH ACCESS REPAIRS ALONG CARLSBAD BLVD DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 Ma y 9, 20 2 3 It e m #2 Pa g e 20 of 24 GHD Discounted Rates for Carlsbad Beach Access Repair Project GHD Class GHD Job Category / Description Discounted Rates Staff Positions A01 Senior Technical Director  (Principal Engineer)$310 / hr Charles Smith, Bill Silva A03 Senior Technical Director (Senior  Engineering Lead)$260 / hr Craig Lewis, Casey Raines A04 Technical Director 1 (Senior Engineer / Manager)$240 / hr Robert Sherwood, Satish Chilka, Brian Leslie,  Francisco Andrade, Mehdi Mardi A05 Technical Director 2 (Senior Engineer)$225 / hr Nathan Towlerton, Samantha Faddis, Monica  Martinez‐Maruri A06 Senior Professional 1                 (Project Engineer)$210 / hr Brittany Zambrano, Robin Raines, Nicole Greenberg A07 Senior Professional 2              (Project Engineer)$190 / hr Patrick Brutzman A08 Professional 1 (Staff Engineer)$180 / hr Erika Hall, Tomoki Masui, Ishan Goel A10 Professional 3 (Staff Engineer)$135 / hr Braden Froble, Ryder Burliss B06 Design Technician 1 (CAD Designer)$185 / hr Carlos Martinez, Vincent Cruz D09 Project Support 5 (Admin Support)$130 / hr Nicole Tuon, Elissa Overton, Jenni Simpson March 27, 2023 DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 Ma y 9 , 2 0 2 3 It e m # 2 P a g e 2 1 o f 2 4 IJ DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 Ma y 9 , 2 0 2 3 It e m # 2 P a g e 2 2 o f 2 4 2023 Standard I Job Category Rates* as of 1/1/23 Staff Positions -Jan 20, 2023 Principal II $205.00 Principal I $190.00 Joe, Brooke, Chris, Mark Sr Associate II $175.00 Cheri, Bernard, Tom, Tim Sr Associate I $155.00 Jerod, Jacob Associate II $145.00 Darren, Matt C Associate I $135.00 Alex, Stephen, Josef Sr Designer/Planner II** $125.00 Difan, David, Morgen, Kolbe Sr Designer/Planner I $115.00 Cisy, Gwen, Nicole Designer /Planner $105.00 Brendan, Mariella, Ashim Cl erical $85.00 Nancy, Wendy, Amy E., Kristie I ~ II * Some project may require more competitive rates. Standard rates may be reduced by $5 in each category if necessary, but must be approved by a principal or senior associate 1Jrior. 1; I **Includes Sr. Designer II and 1111 I ktua GEOTECHNICAL ENVIRONMENTAL WATER RESOURCES CONSTRUCTION SERVICES COASTAL/MARINE GEOTECHNICS February 1, 2023 www.engeo.com PREFERRED CLIENT FEE SCHEDULE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Effective February 2023 President ...................................................................................................................................... $465.00 per hour Principal ....................................................................................................................................... $365.00 per hour Associate ..................................................................................................................................... $305.00 per hour Subject Matter Expert .................................................................................................................. $400.00 per hour Senior ........................................................................................................................................... $265.00 per hour Project .......................................................................................................................................... $235.00 per hour Staff .............................................................................................................................................. $205.00 per hour Assistant ...................................................................................................................................... $165.00 per hour Construction Services Manager II ............................................................................................... $210.00 per hour* Construction Services Manager I ................................................................................................ $200.00 per hour* Senior Field Representative II ..................................................................................................... $176.00 per hour*/** Senior Field Representative I ...................................................................................................... $157.00 per hour*/** Field Representative .................................................................................................................... $145.00 per hour*/** Senior Laboratory Technician ..................................................................................................... $180.00 per hour Laboratory Technician ................................................................................................................. $160.00 per hour GIS Developer ............................................................................................................................. $190.00 per hour Senior GIS Analyst ...................................................................................................................... $185.00 per hour GIS Analyst .................................................................................................................................. $175.00 per hour Senior CAD Specialist ................................................................................................................. $175.00 per hour CAD Specialist ............................................................................................................................. $160.00 per hour Network Administrator ................................................................................................................. $250.00 per hour Project Assistant .......................................................................................................................... $145.00 per hour *Two-hour minimum portal to portal and cancellations within 24 hours. *OVERTIME RATES: Rates increased by factor of 1.5 for all hours worked in excess of eight (8) Monday through Friday, and the first eight (8) hours worked on Saturday. Rates increased by factor of 2.0 for all hours worked in excess of twelve (12) Monday through Friday, all hours worked in excess of eight (8) on Saturday and all hours worked on Sunday and holidays. ** For Prevailing Wage projects, increase the hourly rate by $19. ** Rates increased by factor of 1.25 for night shift hours (hours commencing after 4:00 p.m. or before 4:00 a.m.); rates increased by factor of 1.875 (an additional factor of 1.5) for all night shift hours in excess of eight (8); rates increased by factor 2.5 for all night shift hours worked in excess of twelve (12). ADDITIONAL SERVICES OFFERED In addition to our core services of geotechnical, hydrologic and environmental engineering, including construction-phase testing and observation, ENGEO provides clients with services for establishment and management of Geologic Hazard Abatement Districts (GHAD) and for Entitlement and Permitting Support (EPS). For more information about these services and associated pricing, please contact ENGEO at (925) 866-9000. OTHER FEES •Equipment and materials will be charged in addition to the above hourly rates. •Outside Consultants, Subcontracted Services and Equipment Rental .................................................................................................. Cost plus 25% •Expert Witness, Deposition, Mediation, Arbitration, or Court Appearance (Minimum Charge) ..................... $2,400.00 half day, $4,800.00 full day DocuSign Envelope ID: CB407234-6CAA-4F47-9813-6B1D2123C199 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 23 of 24 ENGEO -Expect Excellence------------------- CHINQ U A P I N A V G A R F I E L D S T GRAN D A V MAGNOLIA AV O C E A N S T CHES T N U T A V H A R D I N G S T TAMA R A C K A V OAK A V S T A T E S T PINE A V PALM A V H I B I S C U S CR M A D I S O N S T S H E R I D A N P L CHES T N U T A V CITRUS P L WALN U T A V J E F F E R S O N S T CAROL PL B A L D W I N L N A D A M S S T LO N G P L OAK A V CAMEL L I A P L W O O D L A N D W Y AVOCA D O L N J E F F E R S O N S T T Y L E R S T R O O S E V E L T S T W A S H I N G T O N S T LI N C O L N S T MAPL E A V ACAC I A A V CHER R Y A V JUNIP E R A V HEML O C K A V OLIVE A V REDW O O D A V SEQU O I A A V DATE A V P I O P I C O D R H A R B O R D R EU R E K A P L L I N M A R L N S Y D N E Y W Y A N C H O R W Y PINE A V SYCA M O R E A V CARLS B A D V I L L A G E D R C A R L S B A D B L Copyright nearmap LOCATION MAP PROJECT NAME EXHIBIT2BEACH ACCESS REPAIRS AND UPGRADES FROM PINE AVENUE TO TAMARACK AVENUE $!Å **#5$·|}þ78 VISTA ENCINITAS SAN MARCOS S.D.COUNTYOCEANSIDE PACIFIC OCEAN PAL OMARAIRP O R T R D TAMARA C K AV LA COSTA AV P O I N S E TT IA LN MELRO S E D R C A R L S B A D B L ELCAMIN O REAL C AR L S B A D VILLAGEDR R A N CHOSANT A FERD FARAD A YAV C O L L E G E BL AL G A R D CAN N O N R D Created By: Sara Jadhav 4/5/2023 J:\SaraJadhav_Customers\LaurenFerrell\Project\Beach Access Repairs\MXD\LocationMap3896.mxd PROJECTSITE $!Å CIP No. 3896 Exhibit 2 May 9, 2023 Item #2 Page 24 of 24