Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-02-06; City Council; ; Strategic Plan UpdateCA Review __AF__ Meeting Date: Feb. 6, 2024 To: Mayor and City Council From: Scott Chadwick, City Manager Staff Contact: Jason Haber, Intergovernmental Affairs Director Jason.haber@carlsbadca.gov, 442-339-2958 Subject: Strategic Plan Update Districts: All Recommended Action Receive an update on progress made toward the goals of the Carlsbad Strategic Plan 2023- 2027, an update on city finances and an overview of strategic actions planned to occur through Fiscal Year 2024-2025 and provide feedback to staff. Executive Summary This item presents a progress report on the goals and objectives of the city’s 5-year strategic plan, an update on current and forecasted city finances, and a summary of the strategic actions planned to occur over the coming year. This item provides an opportunity for the City Council to provide feedback that will inform the development of the city’s Fiscal Year 2024-2025 budget and the work plan that supports the 5-year Strategic Plan. Explanation & Analysis On October 11, 2022, City Council adopted Resolution No. 2022-245, adopting the Carlsbad Strategic Plan 2023-2027 (Exhibit 1). The plan’s purpose is to: 1. Establish a common vision that will help align city policies, day-to-day operations, and resources with the community’s most important values, needs and aspirations. 2. Build momentum for major goals by maintaining a focused effort over multiple years. 3. Identify agreed upon priorities, timelines and performance measures. In consideration of the core values that make up the Carlsbad Community Vision, the City Council identified five areas of focus for its Strategic Plan: • Community Character: Maintain Carlsbad’s unique community character • Quality of Life & Safety: Prioritize the safety and well-being of the community • Sustainability & Natural Environment: Protect the environment and natural resources • Economic Vitality: Foster a healthy economy • Organizational Excellence & Fiscal Health: Be a model for effective and efficient local government Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 1 of 71 The strategic plan includes high-level goals, strategic objectives, priority projects and service commitments that support the Carlsbad Community Vision. Specific work plans and resource allocations are developed each year and included in the city’s annual budget. The 2023-2024 Strategic Actions Update, provided as Exhibit 2, details how city staff have implemented the City Council’s policy direction and provides a summary of the strategic actions planned to occur over the coming year. Staff continuously monitor the city’s progress toward achieving the adopted goals and have developed a dashboard to track and display the city’s progress, with a focus on key performance indicators. This dashboard can be accessed through the city website at carlsbadca.gov/city-hall/city-council/strategic-plan. The Strategic Plan is intended to enable the city to maintain a consistent focus to build the momentum needed to achieve results. However, the city operates in a dynamic environment and must take into account unanticipated needs, changing economic conditions, community priorities and emergencies, all of which could require a change in focus or the reallocation of resources. The City Council may direct staff to reprioritize elements of the Strategic Plan at any time during the five-year implementation period, with the understanding that city staff will inform the City Council of how any updates could affect the achievement of the five priority goals. This item provides the City Council with an opportunity to review the plan’s progress and provide direction on any adjustments and refinements regarding the strategic actions planned to occur over the coming year. City staff will propose an annual work plan and fiscal year 2024- 2025 budget later this year that will advance the goals and objectives of the 5-year Strategic Plan, consistent with the City Council’s direction. Community Engagement Nearly 1,700 people participated in the public input process leading up to the City Council’s adoption of the Carlsbad Strategic Plan. City staff designed and implemented a public involvement strategy with three main ways to engage with community members, an online survey, an online idea wall and a virtual workshop. This strategy generated 1,544 survey responses and 800 idea wall comments and attracted 95 workshop participants. Community input was compiled, analyzed, and presented to the City Council in the 5-Year Strategic Plan Public Input Report, which is included as an appendix to the strategic plan. Fiscal Analysis An accelerated economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic coupled with unprecedented inflation sustained by consumer demand contributed to the city’s General Fund ending fiscal year 2022-23 with a healthful surplus. The combined impact of budget reduction efforts in fiscal year 2023 and 2024 and the larger-than-anticipated surplus in fiscal year 2023 positively impacted the General Fund’s 10-year forecast. The projected deficit is now not anticipated to occur until fiscal year 2028-29, three years later than the timing projected last year. However, the city is still facing economic uncertainty, most notably from extreme inflationary increases since 2021 that have added pressure to the budget. The city’s progress on the various Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 2 of 71 goals, objectives, projects and services outlined in the strategic plan will continue to be subject to the actual amount of funds available and appropriations authorized by the City Council each year in the annual budget. Next Steps Staff will present the preliminary fiscal year 2024-2025 budget to the City Council for its review on May 21, 2024. Environmental Evaluation In keeping with Public Resources Code Section 21065, this action does not constitute a project within the meaning of the California Environmental Quality Act in that it has no potential to cause either a direct physical change in the environment or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment and therefore does not require environmental review. Exhibits 1. Carlsbad Strategic Plan 2023-2027 2. 2023-2024 Strategic Actions Update Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 3 of 71 Exhibit 1 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 4 of 71 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTIO N 2 ABOUT THIS PLAN 2 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 3 PLAN STRUCTURE 4 SUCCESSFUL IMPLEMENTATION 5 TRANSPARENCY & ACCOUNTABILITY 6 CARLSBAD COMMUNITY VISION 7 CORE SERVICES 8 2023 -2027 STRATEGIC GOALS 9 GO AL 1: CO MMU N IT Y CH AR ACTE R GO AL 2 : Q U AL ITY O F L IFE AN D SAFE TY GO AL 3 : SU ST AIN AB IL IT Y AND T HE N ATU R AL E N V IRO N ME NT GO AL 4 : E CO NO MIC V IT AL ITY GO AL 5 : O R GAN IZ AT IO N AL EX CE L LE N CE AND FISCAL H E AL T H APPENDICES 22 COMMUNITY INPUT REPORT EXISTING POLICIES & PLANS ONGOING CAPITAL PROJECTS DEPARTMENT OVERVIEWS Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 5 of 71 2 INTRODUCTION The City of Carlsbad is ideally situated in north San Diego County, where a great climate, beautiful beaches and lagoons, and abundant natural open space combine with world-class resorts, a thriving and diverse business community, and well planned neighborhoods to create the ideal California experience. Covering nearly 40 square miles and home to about 115,000 residents, the City of Carlsbad is governed by a five- person City Council who, along with a dedicated workforce led by a professional City Manager, work toward one key purpose: To enhance the lives of all who live, work and play in our city by setting the standard for providing top quality, efficient local government services. ABOUT THIS PLAN The purpose of this strategic plan is to focus city resources to fulfil the Carlsbad community’s vision for the future. For many years, the Carlsbad City Council engaged in an annual goal-setting process to identify high priority projects and initiatives toward this end. In 2021, the City Council decided to instead create a 5- Year Strategic Plan to accomplish several important objectives: Focus The City Council understands that if everything is a priority, then nothing is. Choosing five goals for a five-year period allows resources to be focused, increasing results. Momentum Provide clear and consistent policy direction to city staff, enabling the momentum needed to achieve major goals important to the Carlsbad community. Alignment Create better alignment between City Council policy direction and the operational realities of day to day city operations. Connection Connect everything the city does to the fulfilment of the community’s vision, from core services to major construction projects to aspirational policy goals. Accountability Identify key indicators of success that are measurable and transparent. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 6 of 71 3 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS The City of Carlsbad engaged The Centre for Organization Effectiveness to assist with the development of the strategic plan. To create the plan, the city took an inclusive approach by inviting a wide range of stakeholders to provide input at multiple milestones during the process. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 7 of 71 4 PLAN STRUCTURE The 5-Year Strategic Plan includes high level goals, objectives, projects and service commitments that support the Carlsbad Community Vision. Specific work plans and resource allocations are developed each year and included in the city’s annual budget. Aspirational statement that supports one or more of the community values in the Carlsbad Community Vision Capital Improvement Program (major construction) projects that support goals Major initiatives/areas of focus to achieve the goal Day to day city services that will continue to be provided at a high level to achieve the goal Indicators of success. Things that can be measured to show progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 8 of 71 5 SUCCESSFUL IMPLEMENTATION This success of this strategic plan depends on everyone involved understanding their roles in realizing the city’s goals over the next five years. City Council Provides policy direction, allocates sufficient resources, and limits competing direction that could divert attention from the five goals. Adopts annual budget and work plan that supports 5-Year Strategic Plan. Boards, Commissions & Committees Understand the five goals of the strategic plan and create and implement annual work plans to support them. City Manager Aligns and deploys resources to achieve the goals of the strategic plan. Ensures all city employees understand how their work supports the 5-Year Strategic Plan. Notifies City Council if adjustments are needed due to unforeseen events and resource constraints. Informs the City Council if new direction could interfere with achieving the goals of the 5-Year Strategic Plan. Tracks and reports status of key performance indicators and makes operational adjustments as needed to ensure measures will be achieved. City workforce Understands how their day to day work supports the 5-Year Strategic Plan. Alerts supervisors of opportunities to increase alignment with the plan goals and potential roadblocks so they can be overcome. Community members Learn about the 5-Year Strategic Plan and provide ongoing feedback that will help ensure the five goals are achieved. Engage in the annual budget process to monitor progress and help guide short term priorities for alignment with five goals. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 9 of 71 6 TRANSPARENCY & ACCOUNTABILITY Alignment with the City Council 5-Year Strategic Plan will become an integral part of everything the city does, highlighted through the following: Public dashboard City staff will develop a digital dashboard to track and display progress on strategic plan goals, with a focus on key performance indicators. This dashboard will be available on an ongoing basis and highlighted during the annual budget process. Annual budget process During the annual budget process, the City Council will have an opportunity to review the plan’s progress and provide direction on any adjustments and refinements desired, keeping in mind the importance of remaining focused and building momentum around the goals identified in the plan. City staff will propose a work plan and budget each year that focuses on the goals of the 5-Year Strategic Plan. Goal visibility City staff will highlight strategic plan goals in staff reports and presentations to the City Council and its boards, commissions and committees. This will help reinforce alignment between the day to day work and the 5-Year Strategic Plan and demonstrate to the public how city resources are supporting the plan. Adaptation The 5-Year Strategic Plan is intended to provide consistent focus on five key goals to build the momentum needed to achieve results. However, the city operates in a dynamic environment and must take into account unanticipated needs, changing community priorities and emergencies, all of which could require a different allocation of resources. As such, the City Council may direct staff to update its strategic plan during the five-year implementation period, with the understanding that city staff will inform the City Council of how any updates could affect the achievement of the five priority goals. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 10 of 71 7 CARLSBAD COMMUNITY VISION Carlsbad is guided by nine core values that make up the community’s vision for the future. These values were identified over 10 years ago through a collaborative process with the community and have been reaffirmed over the years through regular check-ins and ongoing community engagement. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 11 of 71 8 CORE SERVICES The city fulfills its purpose and supports the Community Vison every day through the collective work and contributions of the city workforce who focus on the core services and functions of municipal government. Even with the best strategic plan, the City of Carlsbad would not be the city it is today without a firm commitment to providing these core services at a very high level of quality. And, from a resource perspective, these ongoing services represent the vast majority of the city’s annual budget. Without this attention to high quality work and dedicated employees, those who live, work, and play in Carlsbad would not be able to enjoy the parks, trails, open space, libraries, arts, clean and safe water, well-maintained streets, and the peace of mind knowing they are safe. This plan is focused on achieving five goals over the next five years, and those goals are described in the pages ahead. Ongoing core services and major projects that support the goals are included in each section, along with new initiatives. By including new and ongoing work, this plan helps connect everything the city does, creating more alignment and enabling momentum to build around those things most important to the community. Even with the best strategic plan, the City of Carlsbad would not be the city it is today without a firm commitment to providing the highest level of service Even with the best strategic plan, the City of Carlsbad would not be the city it is today without a firm commitment to providing the highest level of service Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 12 of 71 9 2023 -2027 STRATEGIC GOALS The Carlsbad City Council has endorsed the Strategic Goals, Objectives, Capital Improvement Projects and Core Services to be prioritized over the next five years. Progress on specific projects and objectives, ongoing service levels, and a variety of Key Performance Indicators, will be tracked and reported on to demonstrate achievement of the Strategic Goals. In 5 years … Even though the city has grown and changed, residents agree that it still has the small- town beach community character and connectedness that made them want to live here in the first place. Diverse community members of all ages enjoy participating in the wide array of programs and events offered by the city, where they run into neighbors, meet new friends and, mostly importantly, feel welcome and included. Key performance indicators _____________________________________________________________  Resident responses to survey questions related to community character  Participation in civic engagement opportunities  Participation in city library, arts and recreation programs and events  Number of volunteer hours Strategic objectives _______________________________________________________________________ 1 Work with the community to develop a new approach to maintain quality of life while managing growth in Carlsbad, consistent with state law. 2 Develop objective design standards for multifamily housing throughout the city. 3 Create opportunities for more affordable housing in Carlsbad by implementing the policies and programs in the 2021-2029 Housing Element. 4 Work with the San Diego Association of Governments and the North County Transit District to prioritize, determine costs, and work with state and federal representatives to seek funding for preliminary design and technical studies for lowering the railroad tracks in the Village. 5 Develop, implement and promote programs that enhance wellness, socialization, inclusion and active living. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 13 of 71 10 6 Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: Age-Friendly Action Plan Arts & Culture Master Plan Carlsbad General Plan Local Coastal Program Homeless Goal Work Plan Parks & Recreation Master Plan Library Strategic Plan Trails Master Plan Village and Barrio Master Plan Homeless Response Plan Priority Projects __________________________________________________________ The city expects to complete the following work on Capital Improvement projects to support this goal through 2027: • Complete design work for the Monroe Street Pool Renovation and Replacement Project • Complete design and permitting for the South Carlsbad Boulevard Realignment between Manzano Drive and Island Way • Complete conceptual design for the South Carlsbad Coastline Project • Complete plans, specifications, bidding and construction of Veterans Memorial Park • Complete conceptual design/master plan and permitting for Robertson Ranch Community Park • Complete conceptual design/master plan for Business Park Recreational Facility (Zone 5 Park) • Complete design and construction of a community garden at Stagecoach Community Park • Complete the installation of additional pedestrian lighting throughout the Village as part of the Carlsbad Village Lighting Study • Complete a feasibility study to make Tyler Street in the Barrio one-way • Complete construction of five new traffic circles and other traffic calming measures in two other intersections in the Barrio • Complete a feasibility study for turning part of Grand Avenue into a pedestrian only “Grand Promenade” • Enhance existing crosswalks on Carlsbad Boulevard between Mountain View Drive and Tamarack Avenue • Begin construction of walking, biking and traffic improvements (includes a roundabout at the intersection of Cannon Road and Carlsbad Boulevard), and a new blufftop gathering area in the Terramar area • Implement a new intelligent parking program in the Village • Initiate the installation of new pedestrian lighting along main sidewalks in the Barrio • Enhance bike lanes by adding green paint to conflict areas at various locations citywide including Carlsbad Boulevard, La Costa Avenue, Cannon Road and Jefferson Street • Audio-visual upgrade/replacement for Schulman Auditorium and Cannon Gallery Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 14 of 71 11 Core services _____________________________________________________________________________ The city will maintain the following high levels of service annually in support of this goal: • Maintain 432 acres of community parks and special use areas, and 51 miles of open space trails • Provide a diverse array of affordable recreation, library and arts programs, classes and events for all ages • Operate four community centers and a senior center, open a total of approximately 17,000 hours annually • Operate two aquatic centers with programming for all ages and abilities • Host special events throughout the year to bring the community together • Maintain three library locations, open a total of 7,600 hours annually • Circulate over 800,000 library materials annually • Manage a rental assistance program serving 600 lower income households • Provide 35,000 meals via the senior nutrition program annually • Address approximately 1,200 code enforcement cases annually, including those related to public safety • Process an average of 4,500 building permits and conduct over 18,000 building inspections each year Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 15 of 71 12 In 5 years … The City of Carlsbad remains one of the safest cities in the region due to new investments in fire and emergency medical services and a well-equipped and highly trained Police Department that enjoys excellent relationships with the community. Critical infrastructure like roads and pipes are well-maintained, while parks, community centers, libraries and other facilities reflect the community’s high standards. Key performance indicators _____________________________________________________________  Resident responses to survey questions related to safety, quality of life, city services and amenities  Carlsbad crime statistics  Emergency response times  Condition of city assets like roads, parks and buildings  Indicators to be identified in an updated Homeless Response Plan that show progress addressing homelessness, such as: o Number of persons placed in temporary or permanent housing o Number of persons who received services Strategic objectives _______________________________________________________________________ 1 Enhance the quality of life for everyone in Carlsbad by adopting and implementing an updated Homeless Response Plan that addresses the complex needs of individuals experiencing, or at risk of experiencing homelessness in a compassionate and effective manner and reduces the impacts of homelessness on the community. 2 Foster strong relationships between community members and members of the Police Department, including the formation of a community-police engagement commission. 3 Bring Fire Department up to Standards of Cover to ensure the city is prepared to meet the community’s changing fire and emergency medical needs. 4 Manage, maintain and enhance the city’s roadway to provide a safe, efficient and cost-effective multi-modal transportation system. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 16 of 71 13 5 Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: Age-Friendly Action Plan Asset Management Master Plan Carlsbad General Plan Community Development Block Drainage Master Plan Grant Consolidated Plan Fire Department Standards of Coverage Homelessness Goal Work Plan Homeless Response Plan Parks & Recreation Department Master Plan Public Housing Authority Plan Recycled Water Master Plan San Diego County Multi-Jurisdictional Hazard Mitigation Plan SCADA Master Plan Urban Water Management Plan Wastewater Master Plan Water Master Plan Priority projects __________________________________________________________________________ The city expects to complete the following work on Capital Improvement projects to support this goal through 2027: • Complete Palomar Airport Road and College Boulevard Improvements • Complete traffic calming project on Tamarack Avenue from Skyline Avenue to Adams Street • Complete traffic calming projects at various locations in the city including Victoria Avenue, Monroe Street, Highland Drive, Nueva Castilla, Celinda Drive, Circulo Sequoia, Park Drive, Hummingbird Road and Black Rail Road per the Carlsbad Residential Traffic Management Program • Complete El Camino Real widening from o Poinsettia Lane to Camino Vida Roble o Arenal Road to La Costa Avenue o Sunny Creek Road to Jackspar Drive • Complete reconfiguration of right turn lane from northbound El Camino Real to eastbound Alga Road. • Initiate construction to repair and upgrade beach access stairs and upper sidewalk between Pine and Tamarack avenues • Initiate projects as part of the Utility Undergrounding Program, in coordination with San Diego Gas & Electric and other utility providers • Complete Avenida Encinas Coastal Rail Trail and pedestrian improvements • Complete design of Carlsbad Boulevard and Tamarack Avenue pedestrian improvements • Initiate project to improve Americans with Disabilities Act beach access from Pine to Tamarack avenues • Complete Avenida Encinas and Palomar Airport Road pedestrian improvements • Initiate design of Carlsbad Boulevard pedestrian lighting improvements between Tamarack Avenue and State Street, in coordination with SDG&E • Complete design of La Costa Avenue traffic improvements • Complete Melrose Drive right turn lane to westbound Palomar Airport Road • Complete traffic signal modifications at Maverick Way and Camino De Los Coches • Evaluate new intersection control at Camino De Los Coches and La Costa Avenue Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 17 of 71 14 • Complete improvements to Christiansen Way • Complete design of Valley Street traffic calming between Magnolia and Chestnut avenues • Complete design of Chestnut Avenue complete street improvements between Valley Street and Pio Pico Drive • Complete design of Chestnut Avenue complete street improvements between I-5 and the railroad tracks • Complete design of street improvements for State Street and Grand Avenue • Complete construction of Fire Station 2 • Complete construction of temporary Fire Station 7 • Identify site and complete preliminary design for permanent Fire Station 7 • Complete the design of new walking, biking and traffic improvements on Valley Street between Magnolia and Chestnut avenues • Begin construction of walking, biking and traffic improvements on Kelly and Park drives by Kelly Elementary School and initiate Safe Routes to School program • Complete Local Roadway Safety Plan and start implementation • Complete construction of retaining wall, drainage and street improvements on Park Drive from Bayshore Drive to just west of Marina Drive • Work to expand homeless shelter capacity at La Posada de Guadalupe Core services _____________________________________________________________________________ The city will maintain the following high levels of service annually in support of this goal: • Respond to approximately 100,000 police calls for service annually with a response time for priority one calls that is lower than the national average of six minutes • Maintain a 24/7 dispatch center that answers approximately 36,000 9-1-1 calls annually • Complete investigations for violent crimes, property crimes, fraud and financial crimes, auto theft, juvenile crime, elder abuse and child abuse • Provide canine units, bicycle patrol, crisis negotiations, bilingual services, and mental health assistance teams • Participate in regional task forces that focus on narcotics and gangs • Provide school resource officers to middle and high schools • Provide rangers to protect safety in parks, on beaches and city trails • Maintain a SWAT capability that assists with high-risk situations • Support public safety at approximately 30 special events annually • Inform the community about crime prevention, fire prevention and traffic safety including educating the public on e-bike safety • Respond to about 14,000 Fire Department incidents and transport about 6,500 patients to local hospitals for care • Perform over 350 beach rescues annually while also providing about 25,000 actions aimed at preventing beach emergencies to the more than 750,000 visitors to Carlsbad beaches Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 18 of 71 15 • Conduct over 3,500 fire inspections to limit the community’s risk through preventive actions • Complete over 750 plan reviews for fire prevention • Supply and maintain 4,441 fire hydrants citywide • Provide homeless response services including social worker and housing placement services, hotel vouchers, and encampment cleanups • Maintain over 450 city-owned fleet vehicles so city services run seamlessly • Repair over 30,000 square feet of sidewalk and asphalt annually • Maintain 350 miles of streets • Maintain 342 acres of community parks and special use areas • Provide 4.8 billion gallons of drinking water to more than 30,000 homes and businesses each year with 455 miles of pipeline, 17 pressure zones, 71 pressure regulating stations, three pumping stations, 14,369 valves and over 30,000 potable meters • Manage the recycled water system’s three storage tanks, four pump stations, three pressure reducing stations, five pressure zones, 95 miles of pipelines, 815 valves, 961 meters and water recycling plant • Manage a sewage collection system that includes 11 wastewater lift stations and wet wells, 265 miles of mainlines and 6,056 access holes Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 19 of 71 16 In 5 years … Thanks to the city’s strategic approach to environmental sustainability, Carlsbad is seen as a model for how to leverage partnerships and innovation to achieve climate and environmental goals. City residents and businesses feel supported in their own environmental sustainability efforts, whether it’s complying with new mandates or taking advantage of opportunities to go above and beyond. As a result, the city has met or exceeded goals for eliminating greenhouse gas emissions, reducing what goes to landfills, keeping creeks, lagoons and the ocean clean, and protecting native habitat and natural open space. Key performance indicators _____________________________________________________________  Greenhouse gas emissions  Lagoon and ocean water quality  Reduction in materials going to the landfill  Community compliance with environmental regulations  Acres of habitat managed, restored and preserved  Percentage of the city fleet powered by hybrid or electric vehicle technology  Percentage of energy for city operations using clean sources Strategic objectives _______________________________________________________________________ 1 Research and evaluate a Climate Adaptation/Sustainability Plan to address the impacts of climate change, including but not limited to extreme heat, drought, erosion, flooding and wildfire. 2 Transform roadways and implement programs that provide options to move around Carlsbad, such as walking and biking, that reduce the city’s greenhouse gas emissions. 3 Increase citywide electric vehicle charging infrastructure and transition all passenger fleet vehicle purchases after FY 2022-23 to be electric vehicles, with the exception of public safety vehicle purchases, which will be electric where feasible. 4 Seek grant funding to develop a Sea Level Rise Adaptation Plan (following Coastal Commission approval of the 2021 comprehensive update to the city’s Local Coastal Program). 5 Develop partnerships with nonprofit, academic and other non-governmental organizations to leverage environmental sustainability efforts and programs. 6 Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: Carlsbad General Plan Climate Action Plan Community Forest Management Plan Habitat Management Plan Integrated Pest Management Plan Jurisdictional Urban Runoff Management Plan Local Coastal Program Sustainable Materials Management and Implementation Plan Sustainable Mobility Plan Water Quality Improvement Plan Preserve Management Plan Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 20 of 71 17 Priority projects __________________________________________________________________________ The city expects to complete the following work on Capital Improvement projects to support this goal through 2027: • Meet implementation goals for the Sustainable Mobility Plan • Complete Maerkle Reservoir Solar Project • Complete Trash Amendment Compliance Program improvements • Complete preliminary design and permitting for the South Carlsbad Boulevard Realignment between Manzano Drive to Island Way Core services _____________________________________________________________________________ The city will maintain the following high levels of service annually in support of this goal: • Oversee the management of a 6,200 acre preserve system that protects native species and habitats • Protect, manage and maintain urban forests and undeveloped open space • Protect creeks, lagoons, and ocean by implementing the storm water permit, preventing sanitary sewer overflows, and preserving and restoring natural open space • Ensure areas of open space and the natural environment support sustainable access to recreation and active, healthy lifestyles • Implement waste reduction and waste diversion programs • Remove approximately 1,000 tons of debris that otherwise would pollute the city’s storm drain system • Ensure permit compliance through inspections of construction projects and the storm drain system • Meet all stormwater regulatory requirements with zero violations • Oversee contracted trash and recycling services for over 30,000 households and over 1,700 businesses in Carlsbad and ensure compliance with organics waste requirements • Secure final approvals from the California Coastal Commission and implement updated Local Coastal Program Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 21 of 71 18 In 5 years … The City of Carlsbad has a strong and diverse economy that combines a thriving small business community with leading industries of the future. Smart, talented professionals want to work here, and entrepreneurial leaders want to invest in their own startup ventures. Those looking to grow their skills will find opportunities for workforce development in Carlsbad. Carlsbad has excellent relationships with key industries, business organizations, other cities in the region, and academic institutions. By achieving this goal, the city as a whole is financially stable and more residents have the jobs they want right in their own backyards. Key performance indicators _____________________________________________________________  Ratings from local businesses through a scientific survey  Carlsbad unemployment rate  Size of Carlsbad’s GDP  Sales and hotel tax revenue  Indicators to be identified in a new Economic Development Strategic Plan Strategic objectives _______________________________________________________________________ 1 Create a strategic approach for a vibrant economy that includes talent & workforce strategies, small business assistance, inclusive growth & diverse business support, key industry cluster development, and fostering an ecosystem for startups & entrepreneurs to thrive. 2 Provide resources to grow and support key industries in Carlsbad’s economy. 3 Support the long-term viability of Small Businesses, Startups & Entrepreneurs in partnership with local and regional collaborators. 4 Implement the policies and programs in the Carlsbad General Plan and Economic Development Strategic Plan based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Core services _____________________________________________________________________________ The city will maintain the following high levels of service annually in support of this goal: • Support more than 25 business expansion, attraction, and retention projects in Carlsbad’s key industries. • Manage lamp post banner program to beautify seven retail, commercial, and community areas in the city to help create a sense of place and support small businesses. • Connect talent to local business through the Life in Action campaign featuring more than 240 local companies, and generating around 45,000 views. • Develop a talent recruitment program that directly connects at least 175 job seekers with local Carlsbad companies. • Maintain partnerships with local and regional business support organizations, bringing collaborative operations to Carlsbad. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 22 of 71 19 In 5 years … Following the creation of a 5-Year-Strategic Plan, the City Council, the community and city employees have remained aligned around common goals. This sustained focus has not only generated measurable results, it has translated into operational efficiencies and cost savings. The very best in their fields want to work for the City of Carlsbad because of the culture that has been created around innovation, inclusivity and engagement. The city’s financial health has been maintained while meeting or even exceeding the community’s high expectations for service delivery. Investments in technology have led to enhanced efficiency, transparency, accountability and value. Key performance indicators _____________________________________________________________  General fund balance and reserves  City credit rating  Pension funding  Customer satisfaction  Internal operation standards and measurements  Information Technology incidents and outages Strategic objectives _______________________________________________________________________ 1 Develop and implement a performance tracking, management and reporting program for the 5- Year Strategic Plan. 2 Foster a culture of continuous improvement that equips the organization to deliver excellent service to the community. 3 Maintain the city’s fiscal health and sustainability. 4 Model trust, ethics and civility. 5 Attract and retain a talented, diverse and engaged workforce. 6 Achieve CalPERS funded status of 80% or greater (Council Policy No. 86) in each of the next five years. 7 Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: Annual City Budget Capital Improvement Program City Council Code of Ethics Connected Carlsbad Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Work Plan Real Estate Strategic Plan Strategic Digital Transformation Investment Plan Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 23 of 71 20 Priority projects __________________________________________________________________________ By 2027, the city will accomplish the following in support of this goal as resources allow: • Complete Fleet Maintenance Facility refurbishment • Complete design and construction of the Orion Center (centralized public works yard) • Complete conceptual design for new City Hall and Civic Center • Complete the Police & Fire Headquarters Renovation including the Emergency Operations Center Reconfiguration • Initiate design for construction of a new public works storage facility • Complete feasibility study to identify the need and location for Fire Administration offices • Research, evaluate and implement a Section 115 Pension Trust • Core System Consolidation • Expansion of the Digital Information Network • Implementation of an Enterprise Asset Management System • Implementation of cutting edge Computer Aided Dispatch system with a real time crime center • Implement new tools for citywide project management • Build a data driven decision making platform and training program Core services _____________________________________________________________________________ The city will maintain the following high levels of service annually in support of this goal: • Prepare a realistic and fiscally sound annual city budget each year that follows all best practices • Monitor the city’s fiscal health and provide regular reports to the City Council and the public • Process over 40,000 outgoing payments to vendors and service providers annually • Issue over 10,000 business licenses annually • Issue over 41,000 payments to employees annually • Respond to approximately 600 public records act requests • Conduct biennial review and re-affirm policy commitment to Code of Ethics • Operate a fraud and abuse reporting system for employees • Handle scheduling, public noticing and other support for over 170 public meetings • Maintain the city’s website, which includes about 1,000 pages of information about city programs and services • Create ongoing opportunities for community engagement • Ensure Carlsbad’s interests are represented with our state and federal lawmakers and oversee regional collaboration efforts, such as participation in the Clean Energy Alliance, SANDAG, and NCTD • Process approximately 6,000 job applications and support leadership in onboarding new staff • Oversee learning and development opportunities for staff as well as ensure completion of mandatory training Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 24 of 71 21 • Deliver technology services to city users including thousands of endpoint devices • Support digital network services to city staff and guests over a 200 Gb backbone • Manage the city’s cybersecurity risk with cutting edge technology, processes and policies • Provide effective project management of technology service implementations • Maintain portfolio of over 200 business applications used to facilitate effective service delivery by city staff • Manage the city’s real estate and properties to maximize taxpayer value Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 25 of 71 22 APPENDICES Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 26 of 71 23 COMMUNITY INPUT REPORT For more information on the Community Input Report, please visit the city website: www.carlsbadca.gov/input Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 27 of 71 24 EXISTING POLICIES & PLANS The City of Carlsbad has a number of policies and plans already in place. Some are required by regulations; others address a previous City Council goal or best practice in the industry. Each plan contains existing actions and timelines, which are not repeated in this strategic plan. Instead, they are referenced below and in each goal section so the reader can gain a fuller appreciation for the breadth of work taking place to support the five key goals of this strategic plan. RELATED GOALS Last update Next update Age-Friendly Action Plan 2021 2026 Annual Operating Budget 2022 Annual Arts & Culture Master Plan 2018 2028 Asset Management Master Plan 2019 N/A Capital Improvement Program 2022 Annual City Council Code of Ethics 2021 Annual City Council Homelessness Goal Work Plan 2022 Annual Continuity of Operations Plan 2021 2026 Climate Action Plan 2020 2024 Community Development Block Grant Plan 2020 2025 Community Forest Management Plan 2019 N/A Connected Carlsbad 2020 N/A Department of Homeland Security Community Resilience Indicator Analysis (2020) 2020 N/A Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Workplan 2022 2024 Drainage Master Plan 2008 2024 Fire Safety Regulations 2019 2025 Carlsbad General Plan 2015 2023 Growth Management Plan 1986 2023 Habitat Management Plan 2004 N/A Homeless Response Plan 2017 2022 Housing Element 2021 2029 HUD Consolidated Five Year Plan 2020 2025 Integrated Pest Management Plan 2017 N/A Jurisdictional Runoff Management Plan 2021 2025 Library Strategic Plan 2016 2023 Parks & Recreation Department Master Plan 2015 2023 Preserve Management Plan 2022 2027 Public Housing Authority Administrative Plan 2016 N/A Real Estate Strategic Plan 2017 2022 Recycled Water Master Plan 2019 2026 San Diego County Multi-Jurisdictional Hazard Mitigation Plan 2017 2022 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 28 of 71 25 RELATED GOALS Last update Next update SCADA Master Plan 2019 N/A Local Coastal Program, Sea Level Rise Analysis 2021 TBD Standards of Cover (Fire Department) 2020 N/A Strategic Digital Transformation Investment Plan 2022 Annual Sustainable Materials Management Plan 2019 Annual Sustainable Mobility Plan 2021 2023 Trails Master Plan 2019 N/A Urban Water Management Plan 2020 2025 Village & Barrio Master Plan 2021 2023 Wastewater Master Plan 2019 2024 Water Master Plan 2019 2024 Carlsbad Watershed Management Area Water Quality Improvement Plan 2021 2025 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 29 of 71 26 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 30 of 71 27 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 31 of 71 DEPARTMENT OVERVIEWS 28 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 32 of 71 Department overviews City departments do work every day that supports the overall city mission and the City Council’s 5-Year Strategic Plan. The following pages provide an overview of some of the key functions of city departments, key activities, staffing and budgets, based on fiscal year 2022-23. 29 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 33 of 71 AT A GLANCE Human Resources Finance Information Technology Internal Auditor Full-time staff 87 $26.2 million ANNUAL BUDGET Administrative services includes departments that handle the day-to- day business functions of the city. As a steward of the city’s assets and liabilities, the Finance Department sets and implements a strategic financial management plan, ensuring the city makes sound financial decisions. The Information Technology Department supports the technology needs of all city departments to help them meet their goals, builds technology infrastructure and ensures the public has access to digital city systems, such as online permitting and public records. The Human Resources Department helps ensure the city can provide the highest level of service to the public by recruiting and training a nimble, talented and professional workforce. Manage annual budget $342.2M 10,000 Computer help desk requests fulfilled 6,000 Job applications processed Budget Excellence Award Excellence in Financial Reporting Award Government Finance Officers Association #1 40,000 Vendor payments processed 151 Workforce trainings Administrative Services 1635 Faraday Ave. | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2440 Administrative Services 30 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 34 of 71 Community Development Building permits valued at more than $132M Professional staff 696 Carlsbad Planning Commission Advised by 52 $10.4 million ANNUAL BUDGET 1,131 Engineering permits 1,200 Code enforcement cases Residential housing units approved, including 116 low-income units 4,500 18,000 Building inspections Planning Permits Code enforcement Building inspections Community Development oversees the delivery of land development programs and services complying with adopted codes and engineering standards, maintains and updates the city’s land use regulations and ensures new growth and development complies with established regulations, provides guidance and reviews projects for conformance with state and local building standards, and helps maintain safe and healthy living and working conditions for the members of the community through code enforcement Community Development 1635 Faraday Ave. | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2710 | building@carlsbadca.gov AT A GLANCE 31 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 35 of 71 Oversee private development project construction Employees 16 $3.3 million ANNUAL BUDGET TYPES OF CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS Transportation The Construction Management & Inspection Department ensures safe construction of Capital Improvement Program and private development projects in compliance with legal, regulatory and contractual requirements. Parks Construction Management & Inspection 1635 Faraday Ave. | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2780 | cmi@carlsbadca.gov Facilities Water Sewer and drainage Manage city construction projects AT A GLANCE Construction Management & Inspection 32 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 36 of 71 Professional staff 17 $5.1 million ANNUAL BUDGET 6,200 Acres of open space preserved 30,000 1,700 households businesses Surpassed the Climate Action Plan’s 2020 target to reduce greenhouse gas emissions 4% below 2012 levels Manage trash and recycling services contract Environmental Sustainability 1635 Faraday Ave. | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2729 | environmental@carlsbadca.gov The Environmental Sustainability Department is responsible for environmental regulation compliance review and monitoring, implementing the Climate Action Plan, assembling and conserving a citywide habitat preserve system, executing the waste reduction and recycling program, protecting creeks, lagoons, and ocean, and ensuring the use of open space and the natural environment support access to recreation and active, healthy lifestyles. Trash & recycling Habitat preservation Climate Action Plan Clean oceans & lagoons AT A GLANCE Environmental Sustainability 33 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 37 of 71 Fire Operations Emergency Medical Fire Prevention Emergency Preparedness Lifeguard Beach rescues Fire inspections Professional staff 3,500 350 123 $37.8 million ANNUAL BUDGET 14,000 Respond to The Fire Department enhances the quality of life for all who live, work, and play in the city through excellence in emergency and support services. Fire Administration provides leadership, strategic planning, and organizational support across all department programs. Emergency Operations is an all-hazard first responder agency safeguarding lives, property, and the environment. Community Risk Reduction & Resiliency mitigates all types of hazardous conditions and ensures incident response readiness. 6,500 Hospital transports Fire Department City Hall | 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive | Carlsbad, CA 92008 6 Fire stations Incidents AT A GLANCE Fire Department 34 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 38 of 71 Facility maintenance Vehicle maintenance Professional staff 35 $15.6 million ANNUAL BUDGET 450 City-owned fleet vehicles The Fleet & Facilities Department maintains city-owned vehicles and facilities. The city’s fleet consists of 456 vehicles and equipment necessary to complete the city’s mission of delivering quality and efficient services. The fleet maintenance and replacement programs enable departments to achieve their operational mission in a safe, efficient manner. Fleet & Facilities Department 405 Oak Ave. | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 760-434-2980 Facility maintenance jobs completed 1,539 Named Top 50 Leading Fleets nationwide by Government Fleet magazine and the American Public Works Association Custodian services at all city facilities Transforming city fleet through electric and hybrid vehicles AT A GLANCE Fleet & Facilities 35 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 39 of 71 Housing assistance Affordable units in progress Households provided rental assistance Professional staff 550 200 CARLSBAD HOUSING COMMISSION Advised by 16 $11 million* ANNUAL BUDGET 2,800 Affordable housing units built Formed July 2021 ▶Preserve and increase availability of affordable housing units in the community ▶Provide rental assistance and homeownership opportunities to lower income households ▶Devote local resources to prevent and reduce homelessness ▶Maintain quality of life of residents and reduce the impact of homelessness on the community ▶Create critical services for people in need ▶Distribute grants that enhance the community $52 M SI N C E 1 9 9 3 Invested in affordable housing 15% of new units set aside as affordable *$7 million from federal funding Homeless services Affordable housing Community assistance AT A GLANCE Housing & Homeless Services Housing & Homeless Services City Hall | 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2810 | housing@carlsbadca.gov 36 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 40 of 71 Economic growth Business attraction Partnerships Data-driven decision Professional staff 25 Golf Lodging Business Improvement District 9 $2.5 million ANNUAL BUDGET 240 Business expansion, attraction and retention projects 175 45,000 Tourism Business Improvement District Companies featured views Job seekers connected with local companies Innovation & Economic Development 1635 Faraday Ave. | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2222 | business@carlsbadca.gov GIS Mapping AT A GLANCE Innovation & Economic Development 37 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 41 of 71 Visual and performing arts Circulation services Digital initiatives Adult & teen services Full-time staff 51 $14.1 million ANNUAL BUDGET The Library & Cultural Arts Department provides community members with access to high quality resources and services to inform and enrich individual and community life. With three locations, the library provides services such as administration, digital initiatives and special projects, circulation services, adult and teen services, genealogy and Carlsbad history services, children’s services, collections and technical services, outreach, literacy and bilingual services and is the community destination for information, enjoyment of reading, lifelong learning and cultural enrichment. The Cultural Arts Office plans, promotes and carries out visual and performing arts programs, arts education activities, temporary and permanent public art and other cultural offerings to promote a thriving, diverse and creative city. 85 Bilingual program offerings Arts Commission Library Board of Trustees Historic Preservation Commission Advised by Library materials circulated 800,000 110,000 Sessions on public computers Cannon art gallery exhibits 4 TGIF Concerts in the Park 9 Library & Cultural Arts 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2049 | librarian@carlsbadca.gov AT A GLANCE Library & Cultural Arts 38 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 42 of 71 Parks & trails Aquatics Sports Classes & camps Senior services Recreation programs Full-time staff 3,270 59 $21.2 million ANNUAL BUDGET 339 Acres of community parks and special-use areas The Parks & Recreation Department provides community members with access to indoor and outdoor recreational opportunities and conserves open space for resident and visitor use. Through the services provided by the department, community members have access to 41 community parks and special use areas and over 51 miles of open space trails, as well as a variety of programs and services that support health and wellness. 67+ Miles of trails Parks & Recreation Commission, Beach Preservation Commission Senior Commission Advised by Aquatic programs Community centers open 17,000 hours a year 35,000 senior nutrition program meals Two pools 715 AT A GLANCE Parks & Recreation Parks & Recreation 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2826 | parksandrec@carlsbadca.gov 39 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 43 of 71 Patrol Investigations Homeless Outreach SWAT Crime Prevention Minutes of response time for highest priority calls Dispatch center Full-time staff 24/7 5.2 187 $51.2 million ANNUAL BUDGET 100,000 Calls for service The Carlsbad Police Department is a full-service police department that prides itself on its strong partnership with the community and high service levels. These field services include patrol, traffic, canines, lagoon patrol, and police rangers to respond to emergencies and non-emergencies as well as professionals that make up the following expert teams: Crime Suppression Team, Homeless Outreach Team, SWAT Team, Crisis Negotiation Team, Investigations Division, Family Services, Communications and Records. Through the hard work and dedication of the men and women of the Police Department, and the support of council members and the community, the city continues to be a safe community to live, work and play. School crossing guards Police Department 2560 Orion Way | Carlsbad, CA 92010 | 442-339-2100 | police@carlsbadca.gov 36Park ranger program AT A GLANCE Police Department 40 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 44 of 71 Office of the City Council Email updates to community Public records requests fulfilled Professional staff 600 550 34 $8.5 million ANNUAL BUDGET 170 Public meetings The City of Carlsbad follows a council-manager form of government, in which elected City Council members provide direction on the policies and regulations that govern the operations of the city. The Policy & Leadership branch includes the following areas: •Office of the City Council •Office of the City Treasurer (elected) •Office of the City Manager •Office of the City Attorney •Office of the City Clerk (elected) •Communication & Engagement The Office of the City Manager handles administration and oversight of the city organization, including hiring the city workforce, supervising city departments and ensuring the City Council’s policy priorities are met. Legislative affairs Office of the City Manager Office of the City Attorney Office of the City Clerk Communication & Engagement Policy & Leadership City Hall | 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2820 | manager@carlsbadca.gov AT A GLANCE Policy & Leadership 41 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 45 of 71 Transportation and Streets and Storm Drains Traffic Transportation Planning Drainage Engineering and Mobility Streetlight and electrical maintenance repairs Employees272 TRAFFIC & MOBILITY COMMISSION Advised by 43 $13.1 million ANNUAL BUDGET 350 Miles of streets maintained The Transportation Department is responsible for maintaining and improving the city’s road infrastructure to keep people moving; enhancing mobility and safety citywide through ongoing transportation planning, streets and traffic engineering, streets maintenance and signal operations; providing maintenance and posting of street signs, street legends, striping, graffiti and trash removal, pothole and sidewalk repairs. The department also maintains storm drain infrastructure such as gutters and pipes under city streets. Traffic signals operated and maintained 1801,000 Tons of debris removed from streets AT A GLANCE Transportation 42 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 46 of 71 Water services Wastewater services Drainage system Average water use down since 2008 Gallons of safe water provided Professional staff 4.8 billion 48% 64 $77.9 million ANNUAL BUDGET 30,405 Homes and businesses served The Utilities Department provides safe and reliable water and wastewater services while protecting the natural environment and meeting regulatory requirements. The department provides community members with access to safe drinking water, wastewater collections, and recycled water for a greener Carlsbad. The Utilities Department also promotes water conservation and access to diversified and local water sources to supplement imported water. MAINTAINED 434 miles of water pipelines 265 miles of sewer pipelines 83 miles of recycled pipeline Meets all state and federal drinking water quality standards Utilities Department 5950 El Camino Real | Carlsbad, CA 92008 | 442-339-2722 | water@carlsbadca.gov AT A GLANCE Utilities 43 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 47 of 71 Faffordable STRATEGIC PLAN ACTIONS UPDATE 2023-2024 Exhibit 2 Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 48 of 71 2 On Oct. 11, 2022, the City Council approved a five-year Carlsbad Strategic Plan to focus city resources toward fulfilling the Carlsbad community’s vision for the future. The plan includes high level goals, objectives, projects, and service commitments. The five goals in the plan are: • Community character • Quality of life and safety • Sustainability and the natural environment • Economic vitality • Organizational excellence and fiscal health The resources to implement the 5-year Strategic Plan are approved each year through the annual city budget process. The Strategic Plan Actions Update 2023-2024 provides the activities, tasks, and steps taken to further the Strategic Plan Objectives, which support the Strategic Plan Goals. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 49 of 71 3 Significant actions have been taken to implement the 5-Year Strategic Plan and progress has been made on all its objectives. 28 Total Strategic Objectives 5 Completed Objectives 116 Total Strategic Actions 43 Completed Strategic Actions This update provides information on the Strategic Plan Objectives and the strategic actions that have been taken to support them. The status of the objectives is listed by: • In Progress – Strategic actions to achieve the objective have started and are underway. • Complete – All required strategic actions to achieve this objective are complete. The status of the strategic actions is listed by: • In Progress – The strategic action has started, and progress is being made on it. • Complete – The strategic action has been completed. A Strategic Plan implementation updated will be provided annually. In addition, the public can see its status on the Strategic Plan Dashboard at https://www.carlsbadca.gov/StrategicDashboard. Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 50 of 71 4 Community Character Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 1.1: Work with the community to develop a new approach to maintain quality of life while managing growth in Carlsbad, consistent with state law. In Progress City Council received recommendations from the Carlsbad Tomorrow Citizen's Committee on the update to the Growth Management Plan on July 18, 2023. Staff will return to the City Council with a scope of work to implement in spring 2024. In Progress Objective 1.2: Develop objective design standards for multifamily housing throughout the city. Complete City Council adopted the objective design standards for multifamily housing citywide and Village & Barrio Master Plan on Aug. 29, 2023. Complete Objective 1.3: Create opportunities for more affordable housing in Carlsbad by implementing the policies and programs in the 2021-2029 Housing Element. In Progress City Council adopted comprehensive amendments to Inclusionary Housing Policy and in-lieu fee on March 22, 2022. Complete City Council adopted the Housing Rezone Program to accommodate the city's regional share of housing on Jan. 30, 2024. Complete City Council adopted the Zoning Code Amendments to increase allowances for supportive housing, low barrier navigation centers, and emergency shelters on May 23, 2023. Complete City Council approved the Pre-Approved Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Plans on May 23, 2023. This provided building permit ready ADU plans. Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 51 of 71 5 Community Character Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 1.4: Work with the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) to prioritize, determine costs, and work with state and federal representatives to seek funding for preliminary design and technical studies for lowering the railroad tracks in the Village. In Progress Develop a draft memorandum of understanding to memorialize the roles and responsibilities of the city, SANDAG and NCTD in a joint effort to secure outside project funding. The draft memorandum will be presented to the City Council for approval in spring 2024. The City Council appropriated $5.22 million in FY 2023- 2024 to fund a local match toward grant opportunities to advance the project’s preliminary engineering and environmental clearance phase. In Progress Work with SANDAG and NCTD to gain a collective understanding of the practical fundamentals of implementing a railroad trenching project in Carlsbad. Staff have participated in workshops to develop expertise in project funding, environmental review, permitting, structural and architectural design, construction phasing, right of way acquisition, utility relocation, facility maintenance, impact mitigation and community outreach. SANDAG, NCTD and city staff will tour trench projects completed in the region in Spring 2024. In Progress Objective 1.5: Develop, implement, and promote programs that enhance wellness, socialization, inclusion, and active living. In Progress The Parks & Recreation Department and the Library & Cultural Arts Department continue to develop and conduct programs to achieve this goal. In collaboration with various partners, the city provides diverse and inclusive offerings to meet the needs of the community. Nearly 4,000 programs were offered by the Parks & Recreation and Library & Cultural Arts departments in FY 2022-2023. In Progress City Council approved the Parks & Recreation Master Plan on Sept. 26, 2023. This plan included an overview of community needs and an analysis of how the Parks & Recreation Department can meet the needs of the community through programming. This will serve as a guide for program development and improvement. Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 52 of 71 6 Community Character Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 1.6: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Age-Friendly Action Plan • Arts & Culture Master Plan • Carlsbad General Plan • Local Coastal Program • Homeless Goal Work Plan • Parks & Recreation Master Plan • Trails Master Plan • Village and Barrio Master Plan • Homeless Response Plan Objective continued on the next page. In Progress The nine plans associated with this objective have different reporting and update requirements. The City Council receives reports and acts on each plan based on its respective requirements. The strategic actions listed under this objective include any plans that may have been updated since the adoption of the 5-year Strategic Plan. It also includes examples of activities within the plans that further the objective. In Progress City Council approved the Age-Friendly Carlsbad Action Plan on Dec. 7, 2021. The five goals of the plan related to outdoor buildings and spaces, social & civic participation, housing, health and wellness and mobility were pursued through a multi-departmental effort. Some of the activities under the plan include offering a transportation program for meals shopping and medical appointments. A congregate home meal deliver program is ongoing. The city provided intergenerational programs such as Teens Teach Tech. Senior services were conducted including Silver Paddles Pickleball, alignment of mind, body and nature and community builder’s meetings. The volunteer program supports social and civic participation. The next update to the plan is anticipated to occur in 2026. In Progress The Arts & Culture Master Plan outlines the city’s role as a provider, partner, connector, and leader in arts and culture. Some of the activities associated with the implementation of the plan include community arts grants, gallery exhibits, arts education, public art projects, TGIF concerts and year-round performances. The plan was approved in 2018 and sets a 10-year vision for arts and culture in Carlsbad. In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 53 of 71 7 Community Character Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 1.6 cont’d: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Age-Friendly Action Plan • Arts & Culture Master Plan • Carlsbad General Plan • Local Coastal Program • Homeless Goal Work Plan • Parks & Recreation Master Plan • Trails Master Plan • Village and Barrio Master Plan • Homeless Response Plan City Council approved the Parks & Recreation Master Plan Update on September 26, 2023. Some of the accomplishments that have been made in implementing the plan include: • Completed construction plans for Stagecoach Community Garden. • Completed construction plans for Veterans Memorial Park. • Initiated community engagement and conceptual design of Veterans Memorial Park. • Made progress on construction plans for Monroe Street Pool. • Made progress on beach access repairs and upgrades. • Invested in upgrading aging infrastructure. • Explored partnerships with individual volunteers. The department continued to integrate Commission for the Accreditation of Parks & Recreation Agencies best practices, ensuring diverse offerings and equity of access. In Progress City Council approved the Trails Master Plan on Aug. 27, 2019. The Trails Master Plan is being implemented including trail development, trail operations and maintenance and the trails volunteer program. Village H South Trail Phase 1 was completed. City staff ensured access to and maintained 51 miles of open space trails. An average of 1,200 volunteer hours per year were utilized for monitoring and maintenance tasks. In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 54 of 71 8 Quality of Life & Safety Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 2.1: Enhance the quality of life for everyone in Carlsbad by adopting and implementing an updated Homeless Response Plan that addresses the complex needs of individuals experiencing, or at risk of experiencing homelessness in a compassionate and effective manner and reduces the impacts of homelessness on the community. Complete City Council adopted the Homeless Action Plan on Feb. 7, 2023. The plan includes the programs and initiatives the city will carry out over the next five years and the measures that will be used to track progress. The plan focuses on three key areas: • Shelter and housing • Outreach and access to services • Public safety The city has secured a $2 million grant from the County of San Diego to help expand La Posada de Guadalupe shelter. An annual Housing and Urban Development Continuum of Care grant has been secured to expand the rapid re-housing program. $2.4 million from the State of California’s Encampment Resolution Fund is going to be used to address homelessness in impacted areas. The next report on plan implementation will be presented to the City Council in June 2024. Complete Objective 2.2: Foster strong relationships between community members and members of the Police Department, including the formation of a community-police engagement commission. Complete City Council established the Community-Police Engagement Commission on Dec. 6, 2022. The Commission held their first meeting on July 10, 2023. A calendar of meetings for 2024 has been set. The Commission is developing an annual workplan. Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 55 of 71 9 Quality of Life & Safety Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 2.3: Bring Fire Department up to Standards of Cover to ensure the city is prepared to meet the community’s changing fire and emergency medical needs. Objective continued on the next page. In Progress Completed staffing for temporary Fire Station 7 in January 2023. Complete Completed construction of Fire Station 2 in October 2022. Complete Completed construction of Temporary Fire Station 7 in January 2023. Complete Establish a permanent Fire Station 7 in the area of Cannon Road, west of the I-5. In Progress Added 12 full-time EMT positions in October 2022. Complete Deployed fourth person on ladder truck in January 2023. Complete Procured a fire engine in February 2022. Complete Launched real-time fire operations intelligence system in Oct. 2023. Complete Created lithium-ion battery educational outreach program at Carlsbad Unified schools in Oct. 2023. Complete Officially designated at Cal Office of Emergency Services as Regional Task Force 13 in Oct. 2023. Complete Launched FireSafe Carlsbad, a commercial kitchen fire safety program in January 2024. Complete Provide training on various health and safety topics to city staff and community organizations. In Progress Launch a new referral program that improves healthcare access for the homeless population. In Progress Deploy new regional Evacuation Management Planning System. In Progress Adopt citywide fire hazard severity zone map. In Progress Finalize the Public Safety Element of the city’s General Plan. Complete Update the Local Agency Formation Commission Municipal Service Review. In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 56 of 71 10 Quality of Life & Safety Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 2.3 cont’d: Bring Fire Department up to Standards of Cover to ensure the city is prepared to meet the community’s changing fire and emergency medical needs. Update Insurance Services Office classification. In Progress Utilize opioid settlement funds to support community health. In Progress Implemented administrative realignment strategies to improve effectiveness and efficiency across the department in Oct. 2023. Complete Objective 2.4: Manage, maintain, and enhance the city’s roadway to provide a safe, efficient, and cost- effective multi-modal transportation system. In Progress City Council adopted the Sustainable Mobility Plan on Jan. 12, 2021. Council approved a contract to initiate the Sustainable Mobility Plan Implementation Plan, Multimodal Transportation Impact Fee Study and Vehicle Miles Traveled Mitigation Program. The focus is currently on completing the goals of the high priority Capital Improvement Projects. Staff will use the annual Active Transportation Monitoring Report and bi-annual Transportation Demand Management survey reports to monitor changes in multimodal transportation use throughout the city. Examples of projects that have been completed to support this objective include: • Traffic calming on Tamarack Avenue from Skyline Avenue. to Adams Street. • Citywide green paint enhancement of bike lanes. The Safer Streets Together plan was adopted in September 2022. It included significant efforts on education, engineering, and enforcement to improve safety for all modes of transportation. Activities associated with that plan continue and support this objective. In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 57 of 71 11 Quality of Life & Safety Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 2.5: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Age-Friendly Action Plan • Asset Management Master Plan • Carlsbad General Plan • Community Development Block Grant Consolidated Plan • Drainage Master Plan • Fire Department Standards of Coverage • Homeless Action Plan • Parks & Recreation Department Master Plan • Public Housing Authority Plan • Recycled Water Master Plan • San Diego County Multi- Jurisdictional Hazard • Mitigation Plan • SCADA Master Plan • Urban Water Management Plan • Wastewater Master Plan • Water Master Plan Objective continued on the next page. In Progress The 16 plans associated with this objective have different reporting and update requirements. The City Council receives reports and acts on each plan based on its respective requirements. The strategic actions listed under this objective include any plans that may have been updated since the adoption of the 5-Year Strategic Plan. It also includes examples of activities within the plans that further the objective. In Progress Continue to implement the 2019 SCADA (Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition) Master Plan. Fully integrated the SCADA system to support utility- wide business intelligence to optimize operations and provide flexibility for future growth and adaptability as a smart utility. In Progress Continue to implement the 2019 Recycled Water Master Plan for the expansion of the recycled water system to serve more customers. In Progress Continue to implement the 2020 Urban Water Management Plan. Submitted the Jurisdictional Runoff Management Plan Annual Report in January 2023. An update is planned for FY 2024-2025 to forecast five- year water demand and supplies for Carlsbad Municipal Water District. In Progress A Wastewater Master Plan update is planned for FY 2024-2025. Staff are working on a request for proposals. The department intends to award a contract in FY 2023-2024 and begin work. Identify capacity needs to support development. Identify opportunities to increase the resiliency of the potable water system. In Progress A Water Master Plan update is planned for FY 2024- 2025. Staff are working on a request for proposals. The department intends to award a contract in FY 2023- 2024. Identify capacity needs to support development. In Progress Continue to implement the 2019 Asset Management Master Plan. In Progress City Council approved the Parks & Recreation Master Plan on September 26, 2023. Parks & Recreation Master Plan updates for Strategic Actions include parks; maintenance and operations; In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 58 of 71 12 Quality of Life & Safety Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective cont’d 2.5: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Age-Friendly Action Plan • Asset Management Master Plan • Carlsbad General Plan • Community Development Block Grant Consolidated Plan • Drainage Master Plan • Fire Department Standards of Coverage • Homeless Action Plan • Parks & Recreation Department Master Plan • Public Housing Authority Plan • Recycled Water Master Plan • San Diego County Multi- Jurisdictional Hazard • Mitigation Plan • SCADA Master Plan • Urban Water Management Plan • Wastewater Master Plan • Water Master Plan programs, events and facilities; funding and marketing. Contributed to compilation of citywide facilities security needs. Coordinated with the Police Department on enforcement of parks and facilities regulations to facilitate positive user experiences. Encouraged community participation in reporting maintenance or safety concerns. Prioritized staff time and resources to address critical maintenance needs and concerns. Identified potential grant opportunities and developed grant proposals to secure funding. Implemented fee study findings to ensure fees are competitive to those of surrounding cities for similar offerings. Reviewed athletic field use fees competitive to the market. City Council approved an update to the General Plan on September 22, 2015. City Council approved stronger enforcement remedies for noncompliance and received a presentation of the Codes Case Processing and Prioritization Guide on September 27, 2022. In Progress City Council adopted comprehensive amendments to the city's General Plan Safety Element on January 30, 2024. Complete City Council adopted the Public Housing Authority Plan on July 1, 2023. As a Public Housing Agency, the city administers the Housing Choice Voucher program, a federally funded rental assistance program that helps pay rent for qualified low-income residents. Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 59 of 71 13 Sustainability & the Natural Environment Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 3.1: Research and evaluate a Climate Adaptation/Sustainability Plan to address the impacts of climate change, including but not limited to extreme heat, drought, erosion, flooding, and wildfire. In Progress Initial research was conducted to define and explain the differences between a comprehensive Climate Adaptation Plan and the city’s Climate Action Plan. A high-level review of other jurisdictional adaptation plans was conducted, and federal and state guidance documents were evaluated to determine plan components and applicability to the city. Research is continuing as next steps are being determined. In Progress Objective 3.2: Transform roadways and implement programs that provide options to move around Carlsbad, such as walking and biking, that reduce the city’s greenhouse gas emissions. In Progress City Council adopted the Sustainable Mobility Plan on January 12, 2021. Staff is actively working with our partners at NCTD and SANDAG to implement mobility related services in Carlsbad. The installation of green paint at 37 locations and the completion of the East/West Corridors resurfacing and restriping of over 16 miles of improved bike lanes, including green paint applications, are examples of projects supporting this objective. Staff will utilize the annual Active Transportation Monitoring Report and bi-annual Transportation Demand Management survey reports to monitor changes in multi-modal transportation use throughout the city. In Progress Objective 3.3: Increase citywide electric vehicle charging infrastructure and transition all passenger fleet vehicle purchases after FY 2022- 2023 to be electric vehicles, with the exception of public safety vehicle purchases, which will be electric where feasible. In Progress Add EV charging capacity at Fire Station 2 by the end of 2024. In Progress Installed Level 2 EV charging capacity at Fleet in August 2023. Complete Add Level 3 EV charging capacity at Fleet by the end of 2024. In Progress Expand EV charging capacity at State Street in 2024. In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 60 of 71 14 Sustainability & the Natural Environment Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 3.4: Seek grant funding to develop a Sea Level Rise Adaptation Plan (following Coastal Commission approval of the 2021 comprehensive update to the city’s Local Coastal Program). In Progress Coastal Commission approval of the 2021 Local Coastal Program (LCP). Approval of the LCP is required before further actions can be taken. The Coastal Commission has not provided a timeline for review and approval. In Progress Objective 3.5: Develop partnerships with nonprofit, academic and other non-governmental organizations to leverage environmental sustainability efforts and programs In Progress Joined the San Diego Regional Climate Collaborative Advisory Board. Complete Member of the Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce Green Business Committee Member. Complete Joined the California Green Business Network Board of Directors in 2023. Complete Joined the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation Advisory Board in 2022. Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 61 of 71 15 Sustainability & the Natural Environment Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 3.6: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Carlsbad General Plan • Climate Action Plan • Community Forest Management Plan • Habitat Management Plan • Integrated Pest Management Plan • Jurisdictional Urban Runoff Management Plan • Local Coastal Program Objective continued on the next page. In Progress The 11 plans associated with this objective have different reporting and update requirements. The City Council receives reports and acts on each plan based on its respective requirements. The strategic actions listed under this objective include any plans that may have been updated since the adoption of the 5-year Strategic Plan. It also includes examples of activities within the plans that further the objective. In Progress City Council adopted the first Climate Action Plan on Sept. 22, 2015, and amended it in May 2020. Staff are working on a comprehensive update to the Climate Action Plan estimated to be completed by summer 2024. Present an annual report for the existing Climate Action Plan in spring 2024. In Progress Jurisdictional Urban Runoff Management Plan was certified on March 23, 2021. Submitted the Jurisdictional Runoff Management Plan Annual Report in January 2024. In Progress City Council adopted the Sustainable Materials Management and Implementation Plan on Sept. 20, 2021. Provided 2,605 technical assistance site visits to businesses for new organics and single use plastics requirements on compliance with SB 1383 and single- use plastics ordinances since July 1, 2022. Provided 714 technical assistance site visits to multifamily properties for new organics requirements since July 1, 2022. In Progress The Water Quality Improvement Plan was certified on Aug. 24, 2021, and accepted by the San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board on Dec. 13, 2021. Staff submitted the Water Quality Improvement Plan Annual Report in January 2024. In Progress City Council approved the Community Forest In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 62 of 71 16 Sustainability & the Natural Environment Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 3.6 cont’d: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Carlsbad General Plan • Climate Action Plan • Community Forest Management Plan • Habitat Management Plan • Integrated Pest Management Plan • Jurisdictional Urban Runoff Management Plan • Local Coastal Program Management Plan on Sept. 24, 2019. Staff are continuing to implement Community Forest Management Plan Measures which include: • Street Trees • Community Forest Operations • Urban Forest Interface • Heritage Tree Program • Emergency Operations • Community Greenwaste • Wood & Tree Recycling Program Add an average of 500 trees per year to the city's inventory through 2026 to sustain a healthy community forest. Retained Carlsbad’s designation as a Tree City USA from National Arbor Day Foundation for 19 consecutive years. City Council approved the Integrated Pest Management Plan on Dec. 5, 2017. Staff are continuing to implement the Integrated Pest Management Plan Measures. Apply limited pesticides in an environmentally conscientious manner. Incorporate environmentally friendly practices into parks designs and operations. In Progress City Council approved the Preserve Management Plan on Dec. 7, 2021. Staff are continuing to implement the Preserve Management Plan Measures which include: • Field activities • Management and implementation strategies Monitor and maintain nearly 630 acres of healthy natural habitat. In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 63 of 71 17 Economic Vitality Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 4.1: Create a strategic approach for a vibrant economy that includes talent & workforce strategies, small business assistance, inclusive growth & diverse business support, key industry cluster development, and fostering an ecosystem for startups & entrepreneurs to thrive. Complete City Council adopted the Economic Development Strategic Plan on Jan. 10, 2023. 31 Economic Development strategic actions were started in FY 2023-2024 and 39 strategic actions are proposed to be undertaken in FY 2024-2025 should funding be approved by the City Council during the annual budget process. Complete Objective 4.2: Provide resources to grow and support key industries in Carlsbad’s economy. In Progress Use business data and recent business surveys to assess and engage with industry clusters to develop support for their expansion, attraction, and retention.  Launched the Biennial Business Survey which is estimated to be completed by the end of spring 2024. In Progress Promote the city’s business locator website to businesses looking to move to Carlsbad, developers, brokers, and investors. Promotion in Life in Action newsletter and social media. In Progress Continually review the planning application and permitting procedures to identify process improvements. Complete Enhance the Welcome to Carlsbad Program for new businesses by providing information and resources on the pre-application program, permitting process, and business resources. Complete Continue to support Carlsbad business organizations that maintain the tourism economy in Carlsbad. Regular meetings with Visit Carlsbad and hoteliers, re- establishment of the Carlsbad Tourism Business Improvement District under different state law. Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 64 of 71 18 Economic Vitality Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 4.3: Support the long-term viability of Small Businesses, Startups & Entrepreneurs in partnership with local and regional collaborators. In Progress Host industry advisory groups with leaders in key business clusters, with a specific emphasis on the innovation economy. Holding monthly industry discussions. In Progress Partner with business organizations to develop a shop local initiative to encourage patronage at Carlsbad businesses. A resource and marketing kit for businesses to demonstrate the importance and impact of shopping local is being created. In Progress Utilize partnership with Innovate78 to connect Carlsbad businesses with regional resources. Continuing collaboration with North County cities. In Progress Create Small Business and Entrepreneur Symposium on basic and critical issues for small business owners. Topics may include marketing, social media, finance, human resources, access to capital, technology, and more. In Progress Expand partnerships with entrepreneur support organizations and regional business partners. Partnered with Connect, Startup San Diego, and San Diego Sport Innovators to connect entrepreneurs and startups with resources, networks, and capital. In Progress Objective 4.4: Implement the policies and programs in the Carlsbad General Plan and Economic Development Strategic Plan based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Objective continued on the next page. In Progress Enhance Life in Action tools to assist in talent attraction for Carlsbad businesses in key industries. Transition the Life in Action Recruiter platform from a pilot to an ongoing resource for Carlsbad businesses. The Life in Action Recruiter pilot connected 40 companies with 400 employees. Funding proposal would go from pilot to long-term with two times the participation. In Progress Enhance and promote educational workshops provided by Library & Cultural Arts, Parks and Recreation and other resources that provide skill development to Carlsbad’s workforce. In Progress Enhance the Welcome to Carlsbad Program for new businesses. Provide information and resources on the pre-application program, permitting process, and business resources. In Progress Added more minor permits to online permit portal. Added Pool & Commercial Solar in 2023. Four to six new permits will be added in 2024, including EV In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 65 of 71 19 Economic Vitality Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 4.4 cont’d: Implement the policies and programs in the Carlsbad General Plan and Economic Development Strategic Plan based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Charger. Staff are looking to add online inspections request in 2024. Explore and implement technology that streamlines the development process (intake to closeout). Looking to add inspections request online in 2024. In Progress Used technology to increase communication with Community Development customers. Developing a new automated email to planning customers in 2024. In Progress SolarAPP+ city's first fully automated online permit went live in September 2024. Complete Updated online permit portal to allow uploads of photos on residential solar projects in June 2023. Complete Updated online permit portal for 24/7 plan check status on building permits in December 2022. Complete Created a digital kiosk at Faraday Center for Paperless check-in in November 2022. Complete Developed permit automation for minor building permits that are issued when permit fees paid in May 2022. Complete Automated emails for updating Community Development customers on permit status and issuance in April 2022. Complete First roll out for select minor permits on the online permit portal in February 2022. Complete Offer online appointments to Community Development customers via city website for the Online system (QLess) in January 2022. Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 66 of 71 20 Organizational Excellence & Fiscal Health Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 5.1: Develop and implement a performance tracking, management, and reporting program for the 5-Year Strategic Plan. Complete Strategic Plan Dashboard was publicly launched on July 26, 2023, achieving this objective. The dashboard data is updated monthly. Staff will regularly review it to ensure it is providing timely and valuable information to the public. Complete Objective 5.2: Foster a culture of continuous improvement that equips the organization to deliver excellent service to the community. Objective continued on the next page. In Progress Developed in-house capacity to design, build and perform analysis for city data visualization dashboards to inform departments operations, increase the city’s operational efficiency and improve outcomes for the community. Developed six live data dashboards in-house. Four additional dashboards will be completed in 2024. In Progress Conduct business process improvement, digitization, and automation for internal processes and forms saving thousands of hours of staff time. Completed examples include: • Credit card reconciliation • Digital intake for CIP projects • Eliminating duplicate keying • Telecommute approval • Discretionary leave • Computer loan program There are two projects in process and five others in the queue that will reduce staff time, avoids costs, and provide insights to reduce risk and liability. A new online application and digital processing project for boards, commissions, and committees will launch in Spring 2024. In Progress Developed internal capacity for conducting research studies and survey analysis, implemented a systematic process for collecting, analyzing, and interpreting data to provide insights for city leadership, department staff, and the business community, to the identification of organizational strengths, and areas for continuous In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 67 of 71 21 Organizational Excellence & Fiscal Health Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 5.2 cont’d: Foster a culture of continuous improvement that equips the organization to deliver excellent service to the community. improvement. Conducted 13 survey analysis and reports with a minimum estimated cost-savings of $110,000. Developed an analytical data training program for city staff to upskill talent and built in data-informed decision-making capacity citywide. Conducted 80 hours of data training for city staff, saving the $60,000 by using in-house trainers rather than outside vendors. Complete The consolidation of core systems for departments are underway. This will enhance system capability, drive efficiency, improve accuracy, and enhance transparency. Responses to request for proposals have been reviewed and staff from multiple departments are involved in the selection of a proposed vendor. In Progress Objective 5.3: Maintain the city’s fiscal health and sustainability In Progress City Council adopted Policy No. 95 - Cost Recovery on March 14, 2023. It will be implemented over a three-fiscal year period and managed on an ongoing basis. In Progress Implementing a new software solution to continue timely and accurate vendor payments with enhanced internal controls. In Progress The external financial statement audit was conducted between April 2023 - January 2024. Final report will be presented to City Council on Feb. 27, 2024. In Progress Refunding of Outstanding Bonds for Reassessment District No. 2012-1 was completed in August 2022. Complete Objective 5.4: Model trust, ethics, and civility. In Progress Annual review and approval of the City Council Code of Ethics. The next review by the City Council is expected to occur in the summer of 2024. In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 68 of 71 22 Organizational Excellence & Fiscal Health Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 5.5: Attract and retain a talented, diverse, and engaged workforce. In Progress Human Resources broadened recruitment advertising to over 600 websites to boost inclusivity which resulted in 5,000 job applications. There were 84 full-time positions out of 204 available positions filled by the promotion of existing full-time employees. Provided 230 in-person and online trainings. These actions led to a low vacancy rate of 5.2%. In Progress Objective 5.6: Achieve CalPERS funded status of 80% or greater (Council Policy No. 86) in each of the next five years. In Progress Section 115 Pension Trust was adopted for establishment on Sept. 12, 2023. Management and reporting of the trust will continue on an ongoing basis. In Progress Objective 5.7: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Annual City Budget • Capital Improvement Program • City Council Code of Ethics • Connected Carlsbad • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Work Plan • Real Estate Strategic Plan • Strategic Digital Transformation Investment Plan (SDTIP) Objective continued on the next page. In Progress The seven plans associated with this objective have different reporting and update requirements. The City Council receives reports and acts on each plan based on its respective requirements. The strategic actions listed under this objective include any plans that may have been updated since the adoption of the 5-year Strategic Plan. It also includes examples of activities within the plans that further the objective. In Progress The FY 2023-2024 budget was adopted by City Council on June 18, 2023 FY 2024-2025 budget development is currently in progress from January-June 2024. Complete Approximately two-thirds of the Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Work Plan goals have been completed or are in progress. The DEI Work Plan will be reviewed in March 2024 to assess new goals or to revise or modify goals not completed. In Progress Complete an ambulance fee study to assess and adjust ambulance transport fees. In Progress Participated in Ground Emergency Medical In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 69 of 71 23 Organizational Excellence & Fiscal Health Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 5.7 cont’d: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Annual City Budget • Capital Improvement Program • City Council Code of Ethics • Connected Carlsbad • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Work Plan • Real Estate Strategic Plan • Strategic Digital Transformation Investment Plan (SDTIP) Objective continued on the next page. Transportation reimbursement program, generating supplemental ambulance revenue of $1 million. Deliver a digital dashboard to communicate the achievement of the Standards of Cover. In Progress Real Estate Strategic Plan was adopted in October 2017. The plan addressed 23 city properties. Staff are currently managing 9 property leases, 11 large cell wireless communication facility licenses, and 5 Master license agreements for 166 Small Cell sites in the public right of way, generating total annual revenue of $1,640,334 in calendar year 2023. A five-year update to the Real Estate Strategic Plan is underway. In Progress Rebuild City Hall and the Cole Library. City Council selected the existing City Hall site as the site for a new City Hall in August 2022. The next step is to complete Surplus Land Act process for the Farmers Property. In Progress Orion Center and Storage Facility. The next step will be to develop a request for proposals. In Progress Renovate Police & Fire Headquarters. In Progress Reconfigure the Emergency Operations Center. Bid and award completed. Construction started. In Progress Refurbish Fleet Maintenance Facility. Design awarded, completed, and submitted for permitting. In Progress Connected Carlsbad The City Council adopted Connected Carlsbad: An Complete Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 70 of 71 24 Organizational Excellence & Fiscal Health Objective Objective Status Strategic Action Action Status Objective 5.7 cont’d: Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council: • Annual City Budget • Capital Improvement Program • City Council Code of Ethics • Connected Carlsbad • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Work Plan • Real Estate Strategic Plan • Strategic Digital Transformation Investment Plan (SDTIP) Inclusive Civic Innovation Roadmap on Jan. 14, 2020. In included 28 projects and initiatives to move the city forward on five goals: • Pursue Communitywide Digital Transformation • Build Capacity for Data-Driven Decision Making • Foster a Vibrant Civic Engagement Culture • Enhance Accessibility and Transparency • Promote Security and Sustainability through Connectivity The roadmap focused time and resources investment in data, technology, and performance management. Of the 28 projects identified in the roadmap 90% have been completed and the remainder are underway. In 2021, the roadmap became the principles for the city’s Strategic Digital Transformation Investment Program Connected Carlsbad was completed upon the adoption of the 2021-2022 SDTIP and any ongoing projects are now furthered through that process. Strategic Digital Transformation Investment Program SDTIP is the annual funding strategy for data and technology that is a part of the annual budget process and a comprehensive approach to planning for funding and digital transformation citywide. The FY 2023-2024 SDTIP that was approved by the City Council represents a $33.7 million investment over the next five years. The City Council reviews, revises, and approves the SDTIP during the annual budget process. A few examples of significant projects underway include: • Consolidation & replacement of core systems • Replacement of the police dispatch system • Traffic fiber network The following projects are complete: • Enterprise digital asset management • Parks artifacts management software upgrade • Regulatory water usage analytics • Strategic plan dashboard In Progress Feb. 6, 2024 Item #11 Page 71 of 71 Strategic Plan Update Jason Haber, Intergovernmental Affairs Director Zach Korach, Finance Director David Graham, Chief Innovation Officer City Manager Office, Finance, Innovation & Economic Development February 6, 2024 RECOMMENDED ACTION Receive an update on progress made toward the goals of the Carlsbad Strategic Plan 2023-2027, an update on city finances and an overview of strategic actions planned to occur through Fiscal Year 2024-2025 and provide feedback to staff. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE KEY BUDGET DATES May 21 Preliminary budget Capital Improvement Program Strategic Digital Investment Program Master fee schedule June 18 Public hearing to adopt budget and master fee schedule July 1 New fiscal year begins Community budget workshop May 23 4 ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE FISCAL CONDITION PANDEMIC UNCERTAINTY INFLATION SUPPLY CHAIN ISSUES GEOPOLITICAL CONFLICT ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 6 $3.5 M -3.8 M -$5 M $800,000 FY 25-26 FY 26-27 FY 24-25FY 23-24 JUNE 2022 FORECAST FY 22-23 $460,000 $9.4 M $5.8 M 7 $8.5 M $13.2 M -$4.2 M FY 25-26 FY 26-27FY 24-25FY 23-24 FY 27-28 $1.9 M FY 28-29 OCT 2023 FORECAST BUDGET NEXT STEPS •Strong fiscal condition to weather economic uncertainty •FY 2024-25 budget development •City Council approval in June 2024 ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 61% 39% Strategic Actions In Progress Completed 9 STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 5 Objectives Complete 23 Objectives In Progress 116 Strategic Actions 14% 68% 19% Priority Projects Complete Ongoing Not Started 10 STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 5 Objectives Complete 23 Objectives In Progress 116 Strategic Actions 88 Priority Projects 11 12 COMMUNITY CHARACTER ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 1 Objective Complete 5 Objectives In Progress 14 Strategic Actions Maintain Carlsbad’s unique community character and connectedness 4% 74% 22% Priority Projects Complete In Progress Not Started 13 OBJECTIVE 1.1 Status: In Progress July 18, 2023 | Carlsbad Tomorrow Citizens Committee recommendations on Growth Management Plan Update. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Work with the community to develop a new approach to maintain quality of life while managing growth in Carlsbad, consistent with state law. Next Steps: Staff will present a scope of work in Spring. 14 OBJECTIVE 1.2 Status: Complete Aug. 29, 2023 | Objective design standards for multifamily housing and Village & Barrio Master Plan. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Develop objective design standards for multifamily housing throughout the city. Next Steps: Continue to implement objective design standards for projects. 15 OBJECTIVE 1.3 Status: In Progress May 23, 2023 | Zoning Code Amendments May 23, 2023 | Pre-Approved ADU Plans Jan. 30, 2023 | Housing Rezone Program ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Create opportunities for more affordable housing in Carlsbad by implementing the policies and programs in the 2021-2029 Housing Element. Next Steps: Continue to implement the 2021-2029 Housing Element. 16 OBJECTIVE 1.4 Status: In Progress Workshops with SANDAG and NCTD Spring 2024 | Touring trench projects ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Work with the San Diego Association SANDAG and NCTD to prioritize, determine costs, and work with state and federal representatives to seek funding for preliminary design and technical studies for lowering the railroad tracks in the Village. Next Steps: Present a three-party MOU to City Council. 17 OBJECTIVE 1.5 Status: In Progress 4,000 programs offered by Parks & Recreation and Library and Cultural Arts. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Develop, implement, and promote programs that enhance wellness, socialization, inclusion, and active living. Next Steps: Continue programs in FY 2023-2024. Request funding for programs in FY 2024-2025. 18 OBJECTIVE 1.6 Status: In Progress Nine plans being implemented. Sept. 26, 2024 | Parks & Recreation Master Plan Update. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Next Steps: Continue to implement in FY 2023-2024. Implement plans based on FY 2024-2025 budget approval. 19 20 QUALITY OF LIFE & SAFETY ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 2 Objective Complete 3 Objectives In Progress 33 Strategic Actions Prioritize the safety and well-being of the community. 16% 59% 25% Priority Projects Complete In Progress Not Started 21 OBJECTIVE 2.1 Status: Complete Feb. 7, 2023 | Adopted the Homeless Action Plan. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Enhance the quality of life for everyone in Carlsbad by adopting and implementing an updated Homeless Response Plan that addresses the complex needs of individuals experiencing, or at risk of experiencing homelessness in a compassionate and effective manner and reduces the impacts of homelessness on the community. Next Steps: June 2024, staff will present a report on plan implementation to City Council. 22 OBJECTIVE 2.2 Status: Complete Dec 6, 2022 |Established the Community-Police Engagement Commission. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Foster strong relationships between community members and members of the Police Department, including the formation of a community-police engagement commission. Next Steps: Develop an annual workplan. 23 OBJECTIVE 2.3 Status: In Progress Completed 12 actions associated with bringing the department up to Standards of Cover. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Bring Fire Department up to Standards of Cover to ensure the city is prepared to meet the community’s changing fire and emergency medical needs. Next Steps: Staff will complete actions in progress. Fire Operations Intelligence System is used to strategically improve operations. 24 OBJECTIVE 2.4 Status: In Progress 2022-2023 Safer Streets Together Plan. Implement the Sustainable Mobility Plan. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Manage, maintain, and enhance the city’s roadway to provide a safe, efficient, and cost- effective multi-modal transportation system. Next Steps: Monitor and adjust multimodal transportation based on Annual Active Transportation Monitoring Report and bi-annual Transportation Demand Management survey. 25 OBJECTIVE 2.5 Status: In Progress Sixteen plans are being implemented. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Next Steps: Continue to implement in FY 2023-2024. Implement plans based on FY 2024-2025 budget approval. 26 27 SUSTAINABILITY & THE NATURAL ENVIRONMENT ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 0 Objectives Complete 6 Objectives In Progress 18 Strategic Actions Protect the environment and natural resources. 29% 57% 14% Priority Projects Complete In Progress Not Started 28 OBJECTIVE 3.1 Status: In Progress Conducted review of other adaptation plans. Federal and state guidance documents evaluated to determine plan components and applicability to the city. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Research and evaluate a Climate Adaptation/Sustainability Plan to address the impacts of climate change, including but not limited to extreme heat, drought, erosion, flooding and wildfire. Next Steps: Continue research and determine future actions. 29 OBJECTIVE 3.2 Status: In Progress Implement the Sustainable Mobility Plan. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Transform roadways and implement programs that provide options to move around Carlsbad, such as walking and biking, that reduce the city’s greenhouse gas emissions. Next Steps: Staff will use the annual Active Transportation Monitoring Report and bi-annual Transportation Demand Management survey to monitor changes in multi-modal transportation use throughout the city. 30 OBJECTIVE 3.3 Status: In Progress November 2023 | Added EV charging Capacity at Fire Station 2. August 2023 | Installed Level 2 EV charging capacity at Fleet. City fleet has 96 hybrid or electric vehicles. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Increase citywide electric vehicle charging infrastructure and transition all passenger fleet vehicle purchases after FY 2022- 23 to be electric vehicles, with the exception of public safety vehicle purchases, which will be electric where feasible. Next Steps: Add Level 3 EV charging at Fleet by the end of 2024 and expand EV charging at the State Street lot in 2024. 31 OBJECTIVE 3.4 Status: In Progress Coastal Commission review and approval of the 2021 Local Coastal Program. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Seek grant funding to develop a Sea Level Rise Adaptation Plan. Next Steps: Approval of the LCP is required before further actions can be taken. 32 OBJECTIVE 3.5 Status: In Progress Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce Green Business Committee Member. San Diego Regional Climate Collaborative Advisory Board. Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation Advisory Board. California Green Business Network Board. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Develop partnerships with nonprofit, academic and other non-governmental organizations to leverage environmental sustainability efforts and programs. Next Steps: Continue to collaborate and build relationships with these organizations and others. 33 OBJECTIVE 3.6 Status: In Progress Eleven plans being implemented. Two plans submitted annual reports in January 2024. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Next Steps: Continue to implement in FY 2023-2024. Implement plans based on FY 2024-2025 budget approval. Present annual reports. City Council consider Climate Action Plan update in Summer 2024. 34 35 ECONOMIC VITALITY ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 1 Objective Complete 3 Objectives In Progress 25 Strategic Actions Foster a healthy local economy. 75% 25% Priority Projects Complete In Progress 36 OBJECTIVE 4.1 Status: Complete Jan. 10, 2023 | Economic Development Strategic Plan. 31 Strategic Actions in FY 2023-2024. 39 Strategic Actions proposed for FY 2024-2025. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Create a strategic approach for a vibrant economy to thrive. Next Steps: Present the Jan. 30, 2024, Economic Development FY 2024-2025 budget recommendation to City Council. Next Steps: Use business data and recent business surveys to assess and engage with industry clusters to develop support for their expansion, attraction, and retention. 37 OBJECTIVE 4.2 Status: In Progress Launched Biennial Business Survey. Review planning and permitting for process improvements. Tourism BID converted to PBID. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Provide resources to grow and support key industries in Carlsbad’s economy. 38 OBJECTIVE 4.3 Status: In Progress Partnership with Innovate78 to connect Carlsbad businesses with regional resources. Partnerships with Connect, Startup San Diego, and San Diego Sport Innovators. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Support the long-term viability of Small Businesses, Startups & Entrepreneurs in partnership with local and regional collaborators. Next Steps: Shop local program, host monthly industry discussions, key cluster tours, and continue Innovate78. 39 OBJECTIVE 4.4 ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Implement the policies and programs in the Carlsbad General Plan and Economic Development Strategic Plan based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Next Steps: Continue to implement in FY 2023-2024. Implement plans based on FY 2024-2025 budget approval. Status: In Progress Enhanced Life in Action with Recruiter connecting 40 companies with 400 job-seekers. Launched Welcome to Carlsbad program for businesses Made more online permitting options available. 41 ORGANIZATIONAL EFFICIENCY & FISCAL HEALTH ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 1 Objective Complete 6 Objectives In Progress 26 Strategic Actions Be a model for effective and efficient local government. 93% 7% Priority Projects In Progress Not Started 42 OBJECTIVE 5.1 Status: Complete July 26, 2023 | Launched the Strategic Plan Dashboard. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Develop and implement a performance tracking, management, and reporting program for the 5-Year Strategic Plan. Next Steps: Dashboard is updated monthly. Strategic Plan Working Group will continue meeting. Strategic Actions will be added to the dashboard in March 2024. 43 OBJECTIVE 5.2 Status: In Progress 6 live dashboards developed in-house. 13 surveys and analysis completed. 80 hours of data training for city staff. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Foster a culture of continuous improvement that equips the organization to deliver excellent service to the community. Next Steps: Developing 4 more dashboards. New online board, commission, committee application. Select vendor for consolidation of core systems. 44 OBJECTIVE 5.3 ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Maintain the city’s fiscal health and sustainability. Next Steps: Staff will present a final report of external financial statement audit in February 2024. Status: In Progress Adopted Cost Recovery Policy No. 95. Conducted external financial statement audit. New software solution for vendor payments. 45 OBJECTIVE 5.4 Status: In Progress Annual review and approval of City Council Code of Ethics. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Model trust, ethics, and civility. Next Steps: City Council review Summer 2024. 46 OBJECTIVE 5.5 Status: In Progress Advertised on over 600 websites to boost inclusivity which resulted in 5,000 job applications. 84 full-time positions out of 204 available filled by promotions. Provided 230 in-person and online trainings. 5.2% vacancy rate. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Attract and retain a talented, diverse, and engaged workforce. Next Steps: Continuous improvement to support the city workforce. 47 OBJECTIVE 5.6 Status: In Progress September 12, 2023 | Adoption of Section 115 Pension Trust. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Achieve CalPERS funded status of 80% or greater (Council Policy No. 86) in each of the next five years. Next Steps: Staff will manage and report on the trust. 48 OBJECTIVE 5.7 Status: In Progress Seven plans are being implemented. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE Implement the policies and programs in the following city plans based on annual budget appropriations by the City Council. Next Steps: Continue to implement in FY 2023-2024. Implement plans based on FY 2024-2025 budget approval. STRATEGIC PLAN DASHBOARD STRATEGIC PLAN DASHBOARD STRATEGIC PLAN DASHBOARD STRATEGIC PLAN DASHBOARD 53 STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE 5 Objectives Complete 23 Objectives In Progress 116 Strategic Actions 88 Priority Projects 61% 39% Strategic Actions In Progress Completed RECOMMENDED ACTION Receive an update on progress made toward the goals of the Carlsbad Strategic Plan 2023-2027, an update on city finances and an overview of strategic actions planned to occur through Fiscal Year 2024-2025 and provide feedback to staff. ITEM 11: STRATEGIC PLAN UPDATE