Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout3557; Carlsbad Blvd Las Encinas Creek & Bridge; Carlsbad Blvd Las Encinas Creek & Bridge; 2010-10-01ARCHAEOLOGICAL MONITORING REPORT FOR THE ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT PROJECT CITY OF CARLSBAD, SAN DIEGO COUNTY, CALIFORNIA Prepared for: Mr. John Cahill Municipal Project Manager City of Carisbad 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 Prepared by: AECOM 1420 Kettner Boulevard, Suite 500 San Diego, CA 92101 ' (619)233-1454 Authors: Cheryl Bowden-Renna and Rebecca McCorkle Apple., MA, RPA Confidential Information - Restricted Distribution USGS Quadrangle: San Luis Rey 7.5" October 2010 Keywords: Archaeological Monitoring, CA-SDI-17,408, Encinas Creek Bridge National Archaeological Data Base Information Authors: Firm: Cheryl Bowden-Renna and Rebecca McCorkle Apple AECOM Client/Project Proponent: City of Carlsbad Report Date: Report Title: Type of Study: New Sites: Updated Sites: USGS Quads: Acreage: Permit Numbers: Key Words: October 2010 Archaeological Monitoring Report for the Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, San Diego County, Califomia Archaeological Monitoring None CA-SDI-17,408 San Luis Rey 7.5" N/A N/A Archaeological Monitoring, CA-SDI-17,408, Encinas Creek Bridge TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page MANAGEMENT SUMMARY ; iii INTRODUCTION 1 Project Personnel 1 Report Organization ; , 1 SETTING ; : ...5 Natural Setting ' 5 Cultural Setting.. 5 Regional Prehistory 5 Ethnohistoric ; 6 Historic , 6 Premonitoring Literature Review 7 , CA-SDI-17,408 (SDM-W-111) 8 MONITORING METHODS AND RESULTS 9 CONCLUSIONS........: :. 13 REFERENCES CITED : ; :.. 15 APPENDICES A Resumes of Key Personnel B Monitoring Logs C Site Form Update D Master Catalog Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Page i 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpl 10/20/10 LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 1 Regional Map ; 2 2 Proj ect Vicinity 3 3 Area Monitored ; 4 LIST OF PLATES Plate Page 1 Metal sheeting placed for support during bridge demolition and construction. View to the northwest ..10 2 Bridge demolition. View to the northwest 10 3 New bridge construction. View to the northwest 11 Page ii Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Moniloring Rpt 10/20/10 MANAGEMENT SUMMARY The City of Carlsbad (City) has identified the need to remove and replace the Encinas Creek Bridge due to severe deterioration and based on recommendations by the Califomia Department of Transportation (Caltrans). The bridge is located over Encinas Creek along Carlsbad Boulevard. Carlsbad Boulevard (southbound) is bounded on the west by Carlsbad State Beach and on the east by Encinas Creek and the northbound lanes of Carlsbad Boulevard. The bridge is located just north of the Carlsbad State Beach campgrounds. Structural concrete members of the bridge exhibit severe deterioration, exposing reinforcing bars that have become heavily corroded. For several years, the bridge has been classified as structurally deficient. AECOM conducted a site check and a literature review update in 2009 (Bowden-Renna 2009). This report indicated that one prehistoric resource, CA-SDI-17,408 and one historic-era bridge listed on the Caltrans Local Bridge Inventory, Bridge Number 57C0214L, Encinas Creek Bridge, are located within the project area. Based on the poor condition of the bridge, it had been listed as not eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. While no surface artifacts associated with CA-SDI-17,408 were observed during the site check, there is a potential for buried deposits within the study area. Therefore, monitoring of all ground-disturbing activity during constmction by a qualified archaeologist and a Native American monitor was recommended. Archaeological monitoring was conducted between Febmary 16, 2010, and May 10, 2010, for a total of 39 days. Monitoring was conducted by an AECOM archaeologist and a Native American representative. All ground-disturbing activities were monitored during the demolition and excavation of the bridge. While no intact historic or prehistoric deposits were observed during the monitoring effort, several unprovenienced isolated historic and prehistoric artifacts were observed and collected during the monitoring effort. It is expected that the City of Carlsbad will curate collected artifacts at the San Diego Archaeological Center, a federally approved curation facility for Southem Califomia. Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 Page iii Page iv Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 I I I INTRODUCTION The City of Carlsbad (City) has identified the need to remove and replace the bridge due to severe deterioration and based on recommendations by the Califomia Department of Transportation. The City will replace the existing Encinas Creek Bridge located along southbound Carlsbad Boulevard approximately 0.6 mile south of Palomar Airport Road and 1 mile north of Poinsettia Lane (Figures 1 and 2). .The project is located at the mouth of Encinas Creek. Carlsbad Boulevard (southbound) is bounded on the west by Carlsbad State Beach and on the east by Encinas Creek and the northbound lanes of Carlsbad Boulevard. The bridge is located just north of the Carlsbad State Beach campgrounds. The study area consists of the existing Encinas Creek Bridge and the immediately adjacent vicinity (Figure 3). Stmctural concrete members ofthe bridge have exhibited severe deterioration, exposing reinforcing bars that have become heavily corroded. For several years, the bridge has been classified as structurally deficient and is now in need of replacement. This report describes the methods and results of the archaeological monitoring for the demolition and cleanup effort associated with the Encinas Creek Bridge removal and replacement. PROJECT PERSONNEL Rebecca McCorkle Apple, MA, Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA), served as principal investigator. Stacey Jordan-Coimor, Ph.D., provided the technical review. Coordination of the fieldwork and report preparation was conducted by Cheryl Bowden-Renna. Heather Thomson served as archaeological monitor on-site. Cami Mojado, P.J. Stonebumer, and Stacey Mojado, from the San Luis Rey Band of Mission Indians, served as Native American monitors. Resumes of key project personnel are presented in Appendix A. REPORT ORGANIZATION This report is based on the format guidelines for Archaeological Resource Management Reports by the Califomia Office of Historic Preservation (OHP 1990). These guidelines provide a standard for preferred report content and organization for cultural resources studies in California-. The first section of this report introduces the project and persormel. The second section summarizes the. natural and cultural setting. The third section discusses monitoring methods and results. The fourth section provides a summary of the monitoring effort. Appendix A contains resumes of key personnel; Appendix B contains monitoring logs. Appendix C includes an updated site form for CA-SDI-17,408 and Appendix D includes a master catalog. Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Page 1 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 ORANGEtpK COUNTY f RIVERSIDE COUNTY SAN DIEGO COUNTY / .._\^an Ysidro U.S.A^ \ ^i._J.-^^—^ MEXICO 3-75 7.5 V = 7.5 Miles 15 Miles Figure 1 Regional Map Page 2 Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge P:\2007\070S0213.01 Encinas Creek Bridge ReplaccmcnIo.O Graphics (Non.CAD)'5.4 Proj Graphics'figuresWig I rmcp.ai (dhrad}') 3/23/09 I 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I V\ ,1,' \ Ufiltwl fMily'wi .1? m MF^m-W7'' .^t^^Uk r PolDHduPlrt t m Or g 'I H « 0 * f Btgonia =^1 ^^"^^^^^ Feet 1 inch - 2,000 feet Figure 2 Project Vicinity Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Page 3 Path: P:\2007\070S0213.01 Encinas Creek Bridge Replacemenl\6.0 G1S\6.3 Layout\irchaeologicalJvloniloring\fig2jiteJoolprint 8xlLmxd. 10/13/10. SorensenJ 2 Project Monitoring Area ——' Additional Monitoring Area Source: DigitalGlobe 2008 / Project Data ~ City of Carisbad 2009 ; SanGIS 2009/EDAW 2009 ©200 100 0 200 Feet Scale: 1 = 2,400; 1 inch = 200 feet Figure 3 Area Monitored Page 4 Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Path: P:\2007\070802I3.0I Encinas Creek Bridge Replacemenl\6.0 CIS-6.3 La}.oul\Archaeological_Momloring\flg3_site JoolprimJxU.mxd, 10/25/10. SorensenJ SETTING NATURAL SETTING The project area is located within the City of Carlsbad, along Encinas Creek, bounded by beach to the west and undeveloped lands to the east. Open space is also located on the south and north, bisected by Carlsbad Boule'vard. Vegetation in the project area is disturbed, primarily normative ice plant. A small riparian area is located to the east of the project area. The creek has a natural charmel bottom and banks, and is approximately 10 feet above mean sea level. The creek is primarily freshwater but is subject to tidal influence during extreme high tides. CULTURAL SETTING The following discussion briefly describes the current understanding of major prehistoric, ethnohistoric, and historic developments in the vicinity of the project area. Regional Prehistory The earliest well-documented sites in the San Diego area belong to the San Dieguito complex, thought to be over 9,000 years old (Warren 1967). Related materials have been found in the Mojave Desert and in the Great Basin, sometimes called the Lake Mojave complex (e.g., Campbell et al. 1937; Warren and Ore 1978). Diagnostic artifact types and categories associated with the San Dieguito complex include scraper planes; choppers; scraping tools; crescentics; elongated bifacial knives; and Silver Lake, Lake Mojave, and leaf-shaped projectile points (Rogers 1939; Warren 1967). In areas adjacent to the coast, many Paleoamerican period sites have probably been covered by rising sea levels since the end of the Pleistocene. In more inland regions, alluvial sedimentation in valley areas may have covered these materials. The stable mesa landforms in the region, the abundance of appropriate lithic material, and soil column exposures along areas such as the San Diego River have made the foothills an important area for Paleoamerican research. The Archaic period (7,000 to 1,500 years before present [B.P.]) brings an apparent shifl: toward a more generalized economy and an increased emphasis on seed resources, small game, and shellfish. The local cultural manifestations of the Archaic period are called the La Jollan complex along the coast and the Pauma complex inland. Pauma complex sites lack the shell that dominates many La Jollan complex site assemblages. The La Jollan tool assemblage is dominated by rough, cobble-based choppers and scrapers as well as slab and basin metates. Recently, there has been considerable debate about whether San Dieguito and La Jollan pattems might represent the same people using different environments and subsistence techniques or whether they are separate cultural pattems (e.g., Bull 1983; Ezell 1987; Gallegos 1987; Warren etal. 1993). Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Page 5 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 The Late Prehistoric period (1500 B.P. to 200 B.P.) is characterized by higher population densities and elaborations in social, political, and technological systems. Economic systems diversified and intensified during this period, with the continued elaboration of trade networks, the use of shell-bead currency, and the appearance of more labor-intensive but effective technological iimovations. During the Late Prehistoric, subsistence is thought to have focused on acorns and grass seeds, with small game serving as a primary protein resource and big game as a secondary resource. Fish and shellfish were also secondary resources except for areas immediately adjacent to the coast where they assumed primary importance (Bean and Shipek 1978:552; Sparkman 1908:200). The settlement system is characterized by seasonal villages where people utilized a central-based collecting subsistence strategy. Artifactual material is characterized by the presence of arrow shaft straighteners, pendants, comales (heating stones), Tizon Brownware pottery, ceramic figurines reminiscent of Hohokam styles, ceramic "Yuman bow pipes," ceramic rattles, miniature pottery, various cobble-based tools (e.g., scrapers, choppers, hammerstones), bone awls, manos and metates, and mortars and pestles. The arrow point assemblage is dominated by the. Desert side-notched series, but the Cottonwood series and the Dos Cabazas Serrated type also occur. Ethnohistoric The project area is in the traditional territory of the Kumeyaay. Also known as Kamia, Ipai, Tipai, and Diegueno, the Kumeyaay occupied the southern two-thirds of San Diego County. The Kumeyaay spoke a language belonging to the Hokan language family, which includes the lower Colorado River tribes and Arizona groups to whom they are closely related. The Kumeyaay lived in semisedentary, politically autonomous villages or rancherias. Most rancherias were the seat of a clan, although it is thought that some clans had more than one rancheria and some rancherias contained more than one clan (Bean and Shipek 1978:555). Several sources indicate that large Kumeyaay villages or rancherias were located in the river valley areas, as well as along the shoreline of coastal estuaries (Bean and Shipek 1978; Brackett 1951; Hoover et al. 1966; Kroeber 1925). A large village, Ystagua, is located approximately 15 miles south of the project. Historic Cultural activities within San Diego County between the late 1700s and the present provide a record of Native American, Spanish, Mexican, and American occupation and land use. An overview ofthe history of San Diego County is presented as a general background to the region. The Spanish period (1769-1821) represents a time of European exploration and settlement. Dual military and religious contingents established the San Diego Presidio and the San Diego Mission. The mission system used Native American labor to build the infrastructure needed for European settlement. By about 1821, the traditional lifeways were dismpted and Native American populations were tied economically to the missions. In addition to providing new constmction Page 6 Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monuoring Rpt 10/20/10 methods and architectural styles, the mission system introduced horses, cattle, and other agricultural goods and implements to the area. The cultural systems and institutions established by the Spanish continued to influence the region beyond 1821, when California came imder Mexican rule. The Mexican period (1821-1848) retained many of the Spanish institutions and laws; however, in 1834 the mission system was secularized. This led to for increased Mexican settlement, but also to the dispossession of the Native American population. After secularization, large fracts of land were granted to individuals and families, with the land used primarily for grazing cattle (Pourade 1963:73). Cattle ranching dominated the agricultural activities and the development of the hide and tallow trade with the United States increased during the early part of this period. The Pueblo of San Diego was established at this time and Native American influence greatly declined. The Mexican period ended when Mexico ceded Califomia to the United States after the Mexican-American War (1846-1848). Just prior to the signing of the Treaty of Guadalupe-Hidalgo, which formally ended the Mexican- American War, gold was discovered in Califomia. Following the start of the American period of governance in Califomia, few Mexican ranches remained intact because of land claim disputes. Development of the railroads opened up much of the country to settlement. The homestead system encouraged American settlement beyond the coastal plain. The gro'wth and decline of communities occurred in response to an increasing and shifting population, fostering a "boom and busf cycle. As early as 1868, San Diego was promoted as a natural sanitarium, and many people suffering from tuberculosis came to the area seeking a cure in the moderate climate. After the Califomia Southem Raikoad connected San Diego with the east in 1885, land speculators and health-seekers flocked to San Diego. Hundreds of people arrived daily and property values soared. San Diego's Great Boom lasted from 1886 to 1888. At the peak of the Great. Boom, San Diego had an estimated 30,000 to 40,000 residents, most of these having arrived within a span of just two years (Smythe 1908). A continual increase in population has brought growth and wealth to Southem Califomia. The entry of the United States into World War I, and later World War II, helped to firmly establish San Diego as a major military port. Tourism, agriculture, education, and the military are some of the major social and economic factors in the region today. PREMONITORING LITERATURE REVIEW One prehistoric site, CA-SDI-17,408, was previously identified within the vicinity of Encinas Creek Bridge. Prior to conducting archaeological monitoring in the project area, an updated records search was conducted at the South Coastal Information Center, located at San Diego State University and at the San Diego Museum of Man to obtain all current information regarding this site to aid in the monitoring effort. Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Page 7 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 CA-SDI-17,408 (SDM-W-111) Site CA-SDI-17,408 was first recorded by Malcolm Rogers during the 1920s and 1930s. Rogers described the site as located at the mouth of Encinas Creek, mnning north for approximately 0.25 mile, and ranging from 100 ft to 300 ft wide. Rogers identified this site as San Dieguito Complex II with traces of San Dieguito III and Lit. II (Archaic) and Y-II (Late Prehistoric). He observed evidence of defused hearths, lithic and groundstone scatter, ceramics, shell midden deposits, and evidence of buried deposits. He also collected several surface artifacts, including two knives, two projectile points, a "Bowling Stone" and a piece of debitage (Rogers n.d.). Rogers noted that a large portion of the site had been plowed. The site was relocated in 1998 (Kyle and Gallegos 1998), north of the current study area, along a bluff above the northbound land of Carlsbad Boulevard and extending westward in the median between the southbound and northbound lanes. Lithic debitage, shell, and groundstone were observed. Kyle and Gallegos noted that the site had been previously disturbed by constmction of Old Highway 101, Carlsbad Boulevard, and a mobile home park located northeast of the project area. Heavy vegetation and previous constmction activity were noted within the site area. Pages Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge I 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 ™ I MONITORING METHODS AND RESULTS Archaeological monitoring for the Encinas Creek Bridge replacement was conducted between Febmary 16, 2010, and May 10, 2010, for a total of 39 days. The daily monitoring activities were determined by the constmction crew work schedule. Monitoring was usually conducted between 7:00 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. and included weekend work when necessary. Both a qualified archaeological monitor and a Native American monitor were present during ground-disturbing activities. The monitors detailed the demolition, cleanup, and monitoring activities on a Daily Monitoring Log Form. Copies of these forms are included in Appendix B. Potholing was conducted to locate existing utilities in the vicinity of the bridge; identified utilities included electrical, gas and sewer lines. Potholes averaged 2 ft in diameter and were excavated up to a depth of 7 ft. Pile driving of large metal sheets for bridge supports during constmction activities was conducted, as was placement of riprap along the sides of the bridge for erosion control (Plate 1). Trenching along the sides and base of the existing bridge was conducted to expose the footings prior to demolition of the bridge (Plate 2) and to aid in the constmction of the new bridge (Plate 3). Large local rocks and boulders were used to help support the metal sheeting. A concrete culvert and culvert pipes were also installed. Additionally, sewer trenching and potholing were conducted south of the bridge for a new sewer line and vault box installation connecting the sewer to the South Carlsbad State Beach. During the current monitoring effort very little culmral material was identified within the project area. Artifacts were recovered from previously disturbed backfill deposit and back dirt piles. All soils observed appeared to be disturbed fill and aeolian sand over hard packed sand. Artifacts were point provenienced with a submeter global positioning system unit when possible and sent to AECOM's San Diego office for temporary curation. No intact prehistoric or historic deposits were observed. Organization of the collection and cataloging of materials was completed by a knowledgeable laboratory technician under the direction of the principal investigator and laboratory director. All items were washed and separated by material class prior to cataloging. Each artifact was weighed and given a sequential catalog numbers, which was marked on an archival bag. A computerized master catalog was created in a Paradox database program. The collection was prepared for permanent curation using archival quality materials. Once the project is completed, it is anticipated that the City will arrange permanent curation of the collection at the San Diego Archaeological Center, which offers curatorial services that meet state and federal standards. Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Page 9 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 Plate 1. Metal sheeting placed for support during bridge demolition and construction. View to the northwest. Plate 2. Bridge demolition. View to the northwest. Page 10 Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 Plate 3. New bridge construction. View to the northwest. Prehistoric artifacts recovered included two mano fragments, one complete mano, two flaked stone tools, one chopper, one scraper, two shell beads, one portion of a shell ornament or pendant, and one piece of possible fire-affected rock. Historic artifacts included six whole bottles, two glass insulator fragments, a large wrench, ceramic whiteware fragments, and glass fragments. Modem bottles and plastic were also observed. It is likely that the prehistoric artifacts were washed down from the more intact portion of CA-SDI-17,408, located upslope of the project area within Encinas Creek, or were redeposited with soil from the surrounding area during previous constmction activities. Historic era artifacts were likely placed in the disturbed soils during constmction of the original bridge. A site form update was prepared on appropriate Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR) forms and can be found in Appendix C, A master catalog of collected artifacts can be found in Appendix D. Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpl 10/20/10 Page 11 Page 12 Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Moniloring Rpl 10/20/10 CONCLUSIONS Work conducted for this project included an updated archival research and 39 days of cultural resources monitoring of ground-disturbing activities associated with the demolition and replacement of the Encinas Creek Bridge. A qualified archaeologist and a Native American representative monitored ground-disturbing activities during the demolition ofthe existing bridge and the construction of the new bridge. One previously documented prehistoric site, CA-SDI-17,408, is located within the project area. This site had been previously disturbed by constmction of Old Highway 101, Carlsbad Boulevard, and a mobile home park located northeast of the project area. A small number of prehistoric artifacts likely associated with this site were observed and collected during the current monitoring effort. Artifacts recovered included manos and mano fragments, flaked stone tools, shell beads, and a portion of a shell omament or pendant. While soils within the project area appear to be disturbed, the range of artifacts types recovered indicated that there may be buried deposits in the vicinity of the new Encinas Creek Bridge. Therefore, continued monitoring by a qualified archaeologist and Native American monitor is recommended for all ground disturbing activities within the site boundary for CA-SDI-17,408. In the event cultural resources are encountered during ground-disturbing activities, work in the immediate vicinity will be suspended until the discovery is assessed by a qualified archaeologist and treatment is determined. In the event human remains are encountered during ground-disturbing activities, all work shall cease and the county coroner shall be contacted per the Califomia Public Resources Code. Should the remains be identified as Native American, the Native American Heritage Commission shall be contacted within 48 hours to provide a Most Likely Descendent to determine reburial practices for the remains. ArchaeologicalMonitoringReport, Encinas Creek Bridge Page 13 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 • I I I Page 14 Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 I REFERENCES CITED Bean, Lowell J., and Florence C. Shipek 1978 Luiseno. In California, edited by Robert F. Heizer, pp. 550-563. Handbook of North American Indians, Vol. 8, Smithsonian Institution, Washington D.C. Bowden-Renna, Cheryl 2009 Letter Report: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement Project - Archaeological Site Check and Literature Review Update. Prepared by EDAW, Inc. Brackett, R. W. 1951 The History of San Diego County Ranches. Union Title Insurance and Trust Co., San Diego, Califomia. Bull, Charies 1983 Shaking the Foundations: The Evidence for San Diego Prehistory. Casual Papers 1 (3): 15-64. Unpublished report on file at the South Coastal Information Center. Campbell, E. W. C, W. H. Campbell, E. Antevs, C. E. Amsden, J. A. Barbieri, and F. D. Bode 1937 The Archaeology of Pleistocene Lake Mohave. Southwest Museum Papers No. 11, Los Angeles, Califomia. Ezell, Paul H. 1987 The Harris Site - An Atypical San Dieguito Site, or Am I Beating a Dead Horse? In San Dieguito-La Jolla: Chronology and Controversy, edited by D. Gallegos, pp. 23-34. San Diego County Archaeological Society Research Paper Number 1. San Diego, Califomia. Gallegos, Dennis 1987 A Review and Synthesis of Environmental and Cultural Material for the Batiquitos Lagoon Region. In San Dieguito—La Jolla: Chronology and Controversy, , edited by Dennis Gallegos, pp. 23-34. Research Paper No. 1, San Diego County Archaeological Society, San Diego, Califomia. Hoover, M- B., E. G. Rensch, and H. E. Rensch 1966 Historic Spots in California. Third edition. Stanford University Press, Palo Alto, Califomia. Kroeber, A. L. 1925 Handbook of the Indians of Califomia. Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin 78. Smithsonian Institute, Washington. Reprinted in 1976 by Drover Publications, New York. Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge Page 15 07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 Kyle, Carolyn, and Dennis Gallegos 1998 Cultural Resource Survey for the Carlsbad Boulevard Realignment Project. Unpublished report on file at the South Coastal Information Center. Office of Historic Preservation (OHP) 1990 Archaeological Resource Management Reports (ARMR): Recommended Contents and Format. Department of Parks and Recreation, Sacramento. Pourade, Richard F. 1963 The History of San Diego: The Silver Dons. San Diego Union-Tribune Publishing Company, San Diego, Califomia. Rogers, Malcolm J. n.d. Site for form CA-SDI-17,408 (SDM-W-111). Form on file at the South Coastal Information Center and the San Diego Museum of Man. 1939 Early Lithic Industries of the Lower Basin of the Colorado River and Adjacent Desert y4rea5'. San Diego Museum of Man Papers 3. Smythe, William E. 1908 History of San Diego 1542-1908: An. Account of the Rise and Progress of the Pioneer Settlement on the Pacific Coast of the United States. The History Company, San Diego, Califomia. Sparkman, Philip S. 1908, The Culture of the Luiseno Indians. University of California Publications in American Archaeology and Ethnology 8(4): 187-234. Warren, Claude N. 1967 The San Dieguito Complex: A Review and Hypothesis. American Antiquity 32:168-187. Warren, Claude N., and H. T. Ore 1978 Approach and Process of Dating Lake Mojave Artifacts. Journal of California Anthropology 5{2):\19-m. Warren, Claude N., Gretchen Sieglar, and Frank Dittmer 1993 Paleoindian and Early Archaic Periods. In Historic Properties Background Study for the City of San Diego Clean Water Program. Document on file at the City of San Diego, Califomia. Page 16 Archaeological Monitoring Report, Encinas Creek Bridge •07080213 Encinas Crk Bridge Replacemt Monitoring Rpt 10/20/10 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I APPENDIX A RESUMES OF KEY PERSONNEL Design -F Planning Resume Cheryl Bowden-Renna Archaeologist/Associate Assistant Laboratory Director Education BA, Anthropology, San Diego State University, 1987 Square supervisor and Field School Instructor, at Tel Dor, Israel, U,C- Berkeley Affiliations Member, Society for California Archaeology ' Certifications 40-Hour Hazardous Waste Operations and Emergency Response (HAZWOPER Course maintained since 1996) Lectures ••• Instruction Sandstone Features Adjacent to Lake Cahuilla (with S, Rose), Volume 12, Society of California Archaeology, 1999 The Cultural Resources ofthe Chocolate Mountains (w/ith R. Apple); Society of California Archaeology, 2004 Cheryl Bowden-Renna has served as archaeologist and assistant laboratory director for several cultural resource firms in San Diego. With 15 years of archaeological experience, Ms. Bowden-Renna has worked'at sites throughout the southwestern United States. She also has a background in accounting, database management, and has developed solid management and supervisory skills. Ms. Bowden-Renna has extensive archaeological monitoring experience of ordnance removal at the Salton Sea Test Base in Imperial County. She has also served as archaeological monitor of the test excavation for the Inmate Reception Center in,downtown San Diego. In that role, she was responsible for monitoring excavations, including the use of backhoes, during the data recovery of features from an urban historic site. Project Experience Department of General Services Federal Services Caltrans District 11 New [Headquarters, San Diego, CA Performed cultural monitoring for historic and prehistoric resources during preconstruction and construction for Caltrans 11 new headquarters building. County of San Diego Camp Lockett Monitoring, Campo, CA Performed monitoring during construction of a sewage treatment facility in Campo, San Diego County. NAVFAC Southwest and IVICAS Miramar East Miramar Housing Alternative, San Diego, CA As Project Archaeologist, conducted cultural resources survey, excavation, and evaluation of several sites located on MCB Miramar. Cheryl Bowden-Renna Resume NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Miramar Jet Fuel Line, San Diego, CA As Crew Chief, conducted cultural resources survey for proposed fuel line for the Marine Corps, San Diego County. Riverside County Economic Development Authority OHV Project, Riverside County, CA As Crew Chief, conducted cultural resources survey of over 1,000 acres in Riverside County, California. Sempra Utilities Coronado Monitoring Project, Coronado, CA Monitoring of powerline trenching on Coronado Island, California. City of Santa Clarita and Caltrans District 7 Cross Valley Survey, Los Angeles County, CA As Crew Chief, conducted cultural resources survey in Los Angeles County, California. City of San Diego McAuliffe (Winterwood) Community Park, San Diego, CA Crew Chief for cultural resources survey of a proposed park. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Two Crash Sites on The Barry M. Goldwater Range, Yuma, AZ Crew Chief for cultural resources survey of two helicopter crash sites. NAVFAC Southwest Cultural Resources Inventory For the Infantry Squad Battle Course (P-633), Marine Corps Base Camp Pendleton, CA Crew Chief for cultural resources survey and site recordation. San Diego County Water Authority Emergency Storage Project, San Diego County, CA As Project Archaeologist, Crew Chief, Field Technician and Laboratory Analysis, conducted cultural resources survey, testing and evaluation of several large project sites within San Diego County. San Diego Gas & Electric Valley Rainbow Transmission Line Project, Riverside and San Diego Counties, CA Crew Chief for cultural resources survey and site recordation for major portions of a large transmission line project. LMXU Village Center Crew chief for cultural resources excavation and water screening. Los Angeles Department of Parks and Recreation Plum Canyon Park Project, Los Angeles County, CA As Crew Chief, conducted cultural resources survey for a community park in Saugus, Los Angeles County, California. City of Escondido Tract 207A As Project Archaeologist, conducted cultural resources survey of 1.13 acres in the City of Escondido. Tactical Aircrew Combat Training System Range Upgrade, MCAS Yuma, Yuma County, AZ Phase I cultural resource survey of proposed transmission line and 17 threat emitter stations. North Baja Gas Pipeline Project, Riverside and Imperial Counties, CA Conducted cultural resources survey and monitoring for large pipeline project in Riverside and Imperial counties, California. Archaeological Testing and National Register Evaluation of Site CA SDI-16,002 Near Range 210 Marine Corps Base Camp Pendleton, CA Field Director for test excavation of CA-SDI-16,002. Ballpark Infrastructure, San Diego, CA As Field Monitor, performed historic monitoring and testing of downtown east village area for the proposed Ballpark. Ballpark Remediation, San Diego, CA As Field Monitor, performed historic monitoring and testing of downtown east village area for the proposed Ballpark. Required hazardous materials certification. Nobel Drive, San Diego County, CA As Field Monitor, performed prehistoric monitoring of road extension to 1-805 interchange. Sempra Utilities On-call Cultural Services, San Diego, CA As Field Monitor, historic monitoring and testing of downtown east village area for the proposed Ballpark. Required hazardous materials certification. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Cheryl Bowden-Renna Resume County of San Diego Inmate Reception Center Project, San Diego County, CA As Laboratory Supervisor, conducted field monitoring of large machinery, including backhoes, during the data recovery of features from an urban historic site in downtown San Diego. Catalog and database management for. project. NAVFAC Southwest Levee Bridge, San Diego County, CA As Crew Chief/Laboratory Supervisor, was responsible for catalog, database management, table creation for CA-SDI- 10,156, and discovery sites. U.S. Navy Salton Sea Test Base Project, Imperial County, CA As Crew Chief, was responsible for site recordation, test excavation, and monitoring of 130 prehistoric sites in the County. . City of San Diego and Caltrans SR-56 EIR, Cultural Investigations, San Diego County, CA As Laboratory Technician, cataloged .12 prehistoric sites during preparation of EIR. Kern River Project, San Bernardino County, CA, Beaver, Miller, and Utah Counties, UT, and Clark County, NV Excavated, surveyed, and monitored along pipeline right-of- way. Analyzed artifacts from all phases of project in Las Vegas, Nevada. Pacific Rim Laboratory Analysis, San Diego County, CA As Field Technician, analyzed CA-SDI-691, a prehistoric site on Batiquitos Lagoon. County of San Diego Cal Terraces Laboratory Analysis, San Diego County, CA As Laboratory Technician, analyzed one prehistoric site, and reanalyzed two prehistoric sites, in Otay Mesa. Elsmere Corporation Cultural Resource Survey, Los Angeles County, CA As Field Technician, conducted cultural resource survey of 2,200 acres in the San Gabriel Mountains. Caltrans Coursegold Excavation, Madera County, CA As Field Technician, excavated site for Caltrans road widening. I I City of San Diego and Caltrans SR-56 Cultural Resources Testing, San Diego County, CA As Crew Chief, performed testing at 12 prehistoric sites. P-527 Santa Margarita/San Onofre Cultural Resources Testing and Monitoring, MCB Camp Pendjeton, San Diego County, CA Performed monitoring of water treatment pond and pipeline construction in the County. NAVFAC Southwest San Clemente Island Existing Conditions Study for Pumped Hydrostorage/Wind Farm Project, Los Angeles County, CA As Field Technician, responsible for recording 80 sites on San Clemente Island. NAVFAC Southwest Tactical Aircrew Combat Training System Range Upgrade, MCAS Yuma, Yuma County, AZ As Field Technician, responsible for Phase I cultural resource survey of proposed transmission line and 17 threat emitter stations. Boulder Valley Project, San Diego County, CA Cultural resource survey of proposed reservoir and pipeline tunnels in the County. U.S. Navy Vandenberg Laboratory Analysis, Santa Barbara County, CA As Laboratory Technician, sorted artifacts and wet-screened column samples. Camelot Cultural Resource Survey, Kern County, CA As Crew Chief, conducted a cultural resource survey of a 200- acre lot split in the Mojave Desert. Caltrans SR-86 Cultural Resource Survey, Imperial County, CA As Crew Chief, conducted a cultural resource survey of SR-86 road widening in the County. Black Mountain Ranch Excavation, San Diego County, CA As Laboratory Supervisor, excavated and analyzed 15 prehistoric sites in the La Jolla Valley. City of Carlsbad Cannon Ranch Reaches 3 and 4, San Diego County, CA As Crew Chief, excavated and analyzed two prehistoric sites in Carlsbad. Cheryl Bowden-Renna Resume San Diego Gas & Electric Rancho San Miguel Project, San Diego County, CA As Field Technician/laboratory Supervisor, excavated and analyzed nine sites and conducted extensive surface collections in the County. Cottonwood Canyon Laboratory Analysis, Riverside County, CA As Laboratory Supervisor, analyzed two prehistoric sites in the County. Rancho del Rey (Spa III) Excavation, San Diego County, CA As Field Technician/laboratory Supervisor, excavated and analyzed a prehistoric site in Chula Vista. Stallions Crossing Laboratory Analysis, San Diego County, CA As Laboratory Supervisor, analyzed five prehistoric sites in Del Mar. Valley Ranch Cultural Resource Survey, Palmdale, CA Conducted cultural resource survey of 350 acres in Palmdale. Fairbanks Highland Cultural Resource Survey, San Diego County, CA Conducted cultural resource survey, excavation, and analysis. Eagle Mountain Cultural Resource Survey, Riverside County, CA Conducted cultural resource survey ofthe Eagle Mountain mine and railroad to Salton Sea. Santa Margarita River Cultural Resource Survey, San Diego and Riverside Counties, CA Conducted cultural resource survey of Santa Margarita River from Temecula to the Pacific Ocean. Scripps Ranch North Excavation, San Diego County, CA Excavated and analyzed two prehistoric sites and one historic site in Poway. Sycamore Canyon Excavation, San Diego County, CA Excavated and analyzed two prehistoric sites east of Poway. Los Campanos Excavation, San Diego County, CA Excavated and analyzed four prehistoric sites and one historic site in Valley Center. American Girl Mine Cultural Resource Survey, Imperial County, CA Conducted cultural resource survey, excavation, and analysis of historic artifacts from a historic gold mining town in the Cargo Muchacho Mountains. Railroad Canyon Cultural Resource Survey, Riverside County, CA Conducted cultural resource survey, excavation, and analysis of a road realignment in Temecula. U.S. Air Force Edwards Air Force Base Cultural Resource Survey, Excavation, and Analysis, Kern County, CA As Field Technician/Laboratory Technician, conducted cultural resource survey, excavation, and analysis of 1,000-acre area on Edwards Air Force Base. County of San Diego Parks and Recreation Department Johnson-Taylor Adobe Excavation, San Diego County, CA As Field Technician/Laboratory Technician, excavated and analyzed the area around the Johnson-Taylor Adobe and C wing. Pacific Rim Laboratory Analysis, San Diego County, CA As Field Technician/Laboratory Technician, conducted extensive shell and lithic analysis of prehistoric sites on Batiquitos Lagoon. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Design + Planning Resume Rebecca Apple, RPA Principal/Manager, Cultural Resources Group/ Senior Archaeologist I I Education MA, Anthropology, San Diego State University, 1990 BA, Anthropology, San Diego State University, 1978 • Professional Registrations Register of Professional Archaeologists Accreditation Certified Archaeology Consultant, County of San Diego Professional Affiliations Member, Society for American Archaeology Member, Society for California Archaeology Awards + Honors Phi Kappa Phi . Phi Beta Kappa University Scholar, 1987 and 1988 Publications + Teclnnical Papers Introduction to Recent Archeological Investigations at the.Salton Sea Test Base, Imperial County California. Proceedings ofthe Society for California.Archaeology, Volume 12, Fresno, California (1999), Recent Archaeological Investigations in the North Las Vegas Valley (with J,H, Cleland and M S, Kelly). In Crossing the Borders: Quaternary Studies in Eastern Califomia and Southwestern Nevada. San Bernardino County Museum Association Special Publication (1991). Presentations Mafjping and Managing Pathways to the Past. Paper presented at the 22nd Annual ESRI International User Conference, San Diego, California (2002). Introduction to Recent Archaeological Investigations at Salton Sea Test Base, Imperial County, Califomia. Paper presented at the 32nd Annual Meeting for Society for California Archaeology, San Diego (1998). A Lake Mojave Period Site Near Silver Lake, California (with A. York), Presented at the.26th Annual Meeting of the Society for California Archaeology, Pasadena (1992), Preliminary Project Results of the San Diego County Studies for the Southwest Powerlink Transmission Project. Presented at the 17th Annual Meeting of the Society for California Archaeology, San Diego (1983), Rebecca Apple has over 20 years of experience in cultural resource management and serves as senior archaeologist for AECOM. Her experience includes managing cultural resources compliance efforts for large complex projects. She is knowledgeable in the procedures and guidelines associated with implementation of NHPA and CEQA. She has managed numerous cultural resource projects, induding prehistoric, historic, and ethnographic studies. She has directed inventories, evaluations, data recovery efforts, and monitoring programs. She has also prepared management plans and conducted feasibility studies. Her work frequently includes consultation with municipal, state, and federal agencies, as well as Native American representatives and the public. As part of interdisciplinary teams, she has managed cultural resources investigations and authored cultural resource sections for ISs, EAs, EIRs, and EISs. Her experience includes cultural resource investigations for pipelines, transmission lines, power plants, highways, landfills, water resource facilities, military installations, and commerciai and residential development. Project Experience Energy and Transmission Projects Solar Millennium Power Projects, Mojave Desert, CA Responsible for oversight of archaeological and architectural surveys, technical reports, coordination with CEC staff, and preparation of.AFC sections for a 2,000-acre solar project. North Baja LLC (TransCanada) Yuma Lateral Pipeline Project, Yuma, AZ Responsible for cultural services, conducting records searches, archival research. Native American consultation, and survey of the preferred alignment. Identified resources included the Yuma Valley Railroad, a National Register-eligible property. Rebecca Apple, RPA Resume I I I Harper Lake Cultural Resources Constraints Study, San Bernardino County, CA Responsible for field reconnaissance and constraints analysis for a proposed 3,300-acre specific plan area. Potential development included a diary and energy park. North Baja Pipeline Project, Ehrenberg, Arizona to Mexican Border Responsible for cultural services, conducting records searches, archival research. Native American consultation, survey of the preferred alignment and alternatives, site evaluation, and data recovery. DeAnza Pipeline Constraints and Permitting Analysis, Ehrenberg, AZ to Calexico, CA Responsible for cultural services, providing information on distribution of natural and cultural resources along the proposed pipeline corridor in report format, with accompanying maps showing these resources and other constraints. Sempra Utilities On-call Cultural Services, CA Resource manager for cultural resource task orders. Most recent task order dealt with artifact curation for a City project. Imperial Irrigation District Cultural Survey, Imperial County, CA Responsible for cultural resources component of two transmission line studies. Survey and testing were conducted in conjunction with pole replacement along the R and L transmission lines. Los Angeles Department of Water & Power Mead-Adelanto Transmission Line, Clark County, NV, and San Bernardino County, CA Cultural resource survey. San Diego Gas & Electric Sycamore Canyon Substation to Rancho Carmel Substation 69-kV Transmission Line Project, San Diego County, CA Responsible for cultural resources component ofa PEA document for submittal to the CPUC that evaluated the potential environmental impacts of a proposed 69-kV transmission line. Los Angeles Department of Water & Power Coso Known Geothermal Resource Area, Inyo County, CA Responsible for data recovery investigations at two geothermal well-pads located in the Sugarloaf Mountain Obsidian Source National Register District. Exxon Corporation Santa Ynez Unit Development, Santa Barbara County, CA Supervised data recovery excavations of a prehistoric coastal site. Southern Californian Edison Big Creek Expansion Project Transmission Line, South Central, CA Responsible for cultural resource impact assessment of alternative routes for a proposed transmission line from the Big Creek Hydroelectric Project in the Sierras to the Los Angeles Basin. Kern River Gas Transmission Project, WY, UT, NV, and CA Inventory, evaluation, data recovery, and construction monitoring for California portion of this Class I overview. Argus Cogeneration Expansion, San Bernardino and Inyo Counties, CA Supervised cultural resource survey and documentation for a water pipeline for Kerr McGee. Sacramento Municipal Utility District Geothermal Public Power Line Project, North Central CA Responsible for cultural resource surveys for a proposed transmission line from the Geysers Geothermal Area to Sacramento. San Diego Gas & Electric Southwest Powerlink 500-kV Transmission Line EIR/EIS, Imperial and San Diego Counties, CA Participated in Section 106 compliance activities, including data recovery, analysis, and report preparation. Military Projects NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Integrated Cultural Resources Management Plan and Cultural Affiliation Study, Chocolate Mountains Aerial Gunnery Range, Marine Corps Air Station Yuma, Riverside, and Imperial Counties, CA Preparing an ICRMP for CMAGR to guide cultural resources compliance efforts to facilitate CMAGR mission. ICRMP will summarize existing inventory and provide a process to streamline the inventory and evaluation process. Components ofthe ICRMP are a Regional Archaeological Research Design and a Cultural Affiliation Study. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Rebecca Apple, RPA Resume NAVFAC Southwest and Navy Region Southwest Archaeological Evaluation of Sites on San Clemente Island, Los Angeles County, CA Responsible for National Register of Historic Places Evaluation of four archaeological sites on San Clemente Island. NAVFAC Southwest and Navy Region Southwest Cultural Resources Survey and Evaluation for Spring Hill and Associated Access Roads, Riverside County, CA Directed archaeological resource survey of proposed facility to improve communications for aircraft and vehicles with the Chocolate Mountain Aerial Gunnery Range (CMAGR). Two sites were evaluated for eligibility to the National Register of Historic Places..One site appeared to contain very limited information potential and did not qualify for the NRHP. Site CA-RIV-8236 appeared to possess information relevant to addressing regional research issues and was recommended eligible for the NRHP. U.S. Navy, Naval Facilities Engineering Command and Naval Base Point Loma Integrated Cultural Resources Management Plan Naval Base Point Loma, San Diego, CA Preparing an ICRMP for CMAGR to guide cultural resources compliance efforts to facilitate CMAGR mission. ICRMP will summarize existing inventory and provide a process to streamline the inventory and evaluation process. Components ofthe ICRMP are a Regional Archaeological Research Design and a Cultural Affiliation Study. • NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Archaeological Survey for the Chocolate Mountains Aerial Gunnery Range Central Training Area, Marine Corps Air Station Yuma, imperial, CA Responsible for cultural resource survey of proposed central training area on CMAGR. The 1,580-acre survey identified fours sites on R-2507S and four on R-2507 N. One of the sites on the South Range (the remains of a ranch complex) and three of the sites on the North Range (rock art, ceramics scatter, and a rock ring) were identified as potentially eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yumav Chocolate Mountains Aerial Gunnery Range: Cultural Resources Survey of 12 Targets and Monitoring of 14 Archaeological Sites, Riverside and Imperial Counties, CA Directed cultural resource survey of 1,523 acres and site monitoring program on CMAGR. Inventoried site types were lithic scatters, trail segments, pot-drops, rock features, and a mining area. Monitoring program included lithic scatters, rock art, cleared circles, mining complexes, and a segment of historic road. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Cultural Resources Survey of Six Areas on the Chocolate Mountains Aerial Gunnery Range, Imperial County, CA Directed cultural resource survey of proposed Forward Air Reporting Position, range access, and target areas. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Evaluation of 24 Sites at the Chocolate Mountains Aerial Gunnery Range, Imperial County, CA Responsible for National Register of Historic Places evaluation of 24 sites in the Chocolate Mountains. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Historic and Archaeological Resources Protection Plan, Chocolate Mountain Aerial Gunnery Range, Imperial and Riverside Counties, CA Directed archival archaeological research and field visit for the Chocolate Mountain Aerial Gunnery Range. Prepared HARP Plan for the installation. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Evaluation of Two Sites, MCAS Yuma, AZ Evaluation of two archaeological sites near the MCAS Yuma airfield. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma San Clemente island Operations Management Plan EIS, Naval Auxiliary Air Field, San Clemente Island, Los Angeles County, CA Assessed current cultural resource inventory and supplemented in specific areas. Project involved preparation of technical report documenting inventory efforts, including shipwreck study. Impact analysis conducted for existing and proposed military operations on San Clemente Island. NAVFAC Southwest Indefinite Quantity Contract for Cultural Resource Services, CA and AZ Contract manager for multiple task orders on a variety of projects involving archaeological surveys and archaeological evaluations, throughout California and Arizona. Tasks include managing budget, overseeing staff, acting as point of contact, and preparation of final reports. Rebecca Apple, RPA , Resume NAVFAC Southwest Archaeological Support for Environmental Assessment of Wind Farm Project, Naval Auxiliary Landing Field, San Clemente Island, Los Angeles County, CA As Resource Manager, prepared cultural resource portion of the EA and placed protective signs at nine archaeological sites near or adjacent to the Wind Farm construction area. NAVFAC Southwest Special Warfare Training and Range Survey, Naval Auxiliary Landing Field, San Clemente Island, Los Angeles County, CA As Senior Archaeologist, performed cultural resource survey of proposed training ranges on San Clemente Island. Prepared technical report in support of an EA. U.S. Navy, North Island Evaluation of Six Sites near the Missile Impact Range, Naval Auxiliary Landing Field, San Clemente Island, Los Angeles County, CA As Project Manager, provided technical assistance for the NRHP evaluation of six archaeological sites on the Central Plateau of San Clemente Island. NAVFAC Southwest and MCAS Yuma Historic and Archaeological Resources Protection Plan, MCAS Yuma, AZ As Project Manager, directed archival archaeological research and building inventory for MCAS Yuma. Lead author on Historic and Archeological Resources Protection Plan for the installation. NAVFAC Southwest Pumped-Hydro Storage Wind/Energy System, Naval Auxiliary Air Field, San Clemente Island, Los Angeles County, CA As Resource Manager, relocated and recorded 76 archaeological sites in proposed water storage and wind/energy development area. Prepared existing conditions report. NAVFAC Southwest Tactical Aircrew Combat Training System Range Upgrade, MCAS Yuma, AZ As Project Manager, performed cultural resource survey of proposed transmission line and 17 threat emitter stations. Prepared testing plan. NAVFAC Southwest Cultural Resource Inventory Survey at Salton Sea Test Base, Imperial County, CA As Project Archaeologist, conducted intensive cultural resource survey for approximately 6,000 acres and evaluation program for 170 sites. Survey and test excavations were conducted in compliance with the NHPA, NAGPRA, and other federal regulations. NAVFAC Southwest Historic and Archeological Resources Protection Plans, Los Angeles, Imperial, and San Diego Counties, CA As Resource Manager, prepared HARP Plans for the following six Naval installations: Morris Dam Test Facility, Azusa; Naval Air Facility, El Centre; Naval Shipyard, Long Beach; Point Loma Complex, Sah Diego; Naval Station, San Diego; and the Naval Radio Receiving Facility, Imperial Beach. NAVFAC Southwest Cultural Resources Technical Studies, MCAS Yuma, Yuma Training Range Complex, AZ and CA As Project Archaeologist, directed cultural resource sample survey in the Chocolate Mountains Gunnery Range. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Mission Trails Regional Park Explosive Ordnance Demolition Environmental Assessment, San Diego County, CA As Project Manager, directed cultural resource survey in support of an environmental assessment addressing the removal of ordnance from the former location of Camp Elliott. U.S. Marine Corps Archeological Survey of Sierra I Impact Area, MCB Camp Pendleton, San Diego County, CA As Resource Manager, performed cultural resource survey of approximately 2,500 acres on the northern portion of MCB Camp Pendleton. Water Projects San Diego County Water Authority Emergency Water Storage Project, San Diego County, CA Resource Manager responsible for the cultural Resources Evaluation Program and Treatment Program. Assisted SDCWA with Native American consultation, implementation ofa programmatic agreement, and coordination with ACOE. Project involved evaluation of over 20 cultural resources including San Vicente Dam. Under a Historic Properties Treatment Plan prepared by AECOM, research designs were prepared and carried out for prehistoric and historic period resources. Treatment measures included data recovery, site stabilization, and preparation of Historic American Engineering Record documentation for San Vicente Dam. Prepared Public Interpretive Plan. I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Rebecca Apple, RPA Resume City of San Diego Water Departrhent North City Water Treatment Plant, San Diego, CA As Resource Manager, managed cultural resource component ofthe North City Water Treatment Plant EIR. Project included survey and limited testing. City of San Diego Balboa Park Wastewater Treatment, San Diego County, CA As Archaeologist, participated in cultural resource documentation for a facility siting study. City of San Diego Mission Valley Water Reclamation Plant, San Diego County, CA Resource Manager .responsible for archaeological testing and monitoring program in an area of potential archaeological sensitivity. City of San Diego North Metro Interceptor Sewer, San Diego-County, CA Resource Manager resjDonsible for cultural resource investigations for constraints analysis of proposed sewer alignments. Los Angeles Department of Water and Power Freeman Junction, Kern County, CA Resource Manager responsible for the survey of portions of 1^' Los Angeles Aqueduct for cap strengthening project. Southern California Edison Eastern Sierra Hydroelectric Relicensing, Mono and Inyo Counties, CA As Field Director, participated in assessment of 22 sites within three hydroelectric project areas. Pacific Gas and Electric Company Pit 3, 4, and 5 Hydroelectric Relicensing Project, Shasta County, CA As Project Archaeologist, directed limited data recovery efforts at six archaeological sites threatened by shoreline erosion prior to stabilization. City of San Diego Rose Canyon Trunk Sewer EIR, San Diego County, CA As Archaeologist, conducted windshield reconnaissance and records search and prepared overview for proposed sewer. San Diego County Water Authority Pamo Dam and Reservoir, San Diego County, CA As Archaeologist, assisted in preparation of research design and conducted archaeological monitoring of geotechnical investigations. Otay Water District Reservoir 657-2, San Diego County, CA As Archaeologist, supervised survey and report preparation of proposed covered reservoir site in Spring Valley. Pacific Gas and Electric Company Mokelumne River Hydroelectric Relicensing, Alpine, Amador, and Calaveras Counties, CA As Crew Chief, participated in archaeological test excavations and NRHP evaluations- Transportation Projects VHB and Clark County Department of Aviation Southern Nevada Supplemental Airport EIS, Clark County, NV Co-Principal Investigator responsible for cultural resource inventory of over 17,000 acres for a BLM and transfer. Class III survey also included Radar and Navaid facilities and retention basins. Class I studies for multiple alternatives. Project involved consultation with BLM, USFS, FAA, SHPO, Native American groups, and 106 other interested parties. Caltrans and SANDAG SR-76 East, San Diego County, CA Principal Investigator responsible for the cultural resource inventory and evaluation program for the SR-76 East widening project. Oversaw the survey of three alternative routes for archaeological and architectural resources, along with Extend Phase I excavations, ASR, HRER, and HPSR. City of San Diego SR-56, San Diego County, CA Resource Manager responsible for the cultural resource evaluation program forthe SR-56 EIR. Evaluated 16 sites along two alternative freeway alignments. Caltrans La Costa Avenue/1-5 Interchange, San Diego County, CA As Project Archaeologist, directed an archaeological survey of proposed interchange improvements in the City of Carlsbad. The project requires close coordination with City and Caltrans staff. Rebecca Apple, RPA Resume County of San Diego SA 680/SF 728 Roadway Project Environmental Studies/EIR, San Diego County, CA As Project Archaeologist, directed the test excavation and NRHP evaluation of four sites on the proposed project alignment. These investigations addressed the potential association of the sites with the Harris Site Complex. Riverside County Transportation Commission SR-79, Riverside County, CA Resource Manager responsible for cultural resource investigations for widening and realigning two highway segments. Prepared cultiiral resource sections for ISs and coordinated archaeological survey reports, historic architectural survey reports, and historic study report. City of Victorville La IVIesa/Nisqually Road Overpass, San Bernardino County, CA As Project Archaeologist, supervised survey and prepared positive archaeological survey report and historic property survey report. Landfill and Waste-Related Projects Elsmere Corporation Canyon Landfill, Los Angeles County, CA As Project Archaeologist, directed cultural resource assessment for the EIR/EIS. County of San Diego Southwest San Diego Landfill Siting Study, San Diego County, CA Resource Manager responsible for cultural resource assessments of potential landfill sites throughout the southwestern quadrant of San Diego County. Ranked the relative sensitivity of each potential site. Land Development Projects State of California Department of Parks and Recreation Heber Dunes Off-Highway Vehicle Park, Imperial County, CA State Parks recently acquired Heber Dunes and is in the process of preparing a General Plan and EIR for the Park. As part of these efforts approximately 350 acres were inventoried for cultural resources. Ms. Apple served as the Cultural Resources Project Manager for the project. State of California Department of Parks and Recreation and Riverside County Economic Development Authority Laborde Canyon Off-Highway Vehicle Park, Riverside County, CA The areas ofthe SVRA that would be open to some leyel of OHV use would cover approximately 1,480 acres within the 2,640-acre Laborde Canyon site. We were contracted to conduct environmental studies for the Laborde Canyon site, including a cultural resource records search and an intensive cultural resources pedestrian survey of the proposed OHV park. Two prehistoric sites and the Lockheed Facility (Beaumont Site No. 2) were recorded within the study area during the survey. A preliminary assessment of the complex at Beaumont Site No. 2 was made to determine eligibility for the California Register of Historical Resources. Ms. Apple served as the Cultural Resources Project Manager. State of California Department of Parks and Recreation Data Recovery for Goat Canyon Retention Basin Border Field State Park, San Diego County, CA As Cultural Resources Project Manager, conducted data recovery under stringent time constraints based on wildlife issues and construction schedule. Excavation of 50 units at CA-SDI-16,047 Locus B indicated that the site was a buried temporary camp whose occupants exploited littoral, near-shore, and terrestrial subsistence resources. Data recovery investigations successfully collected data important in local and regional prehistory. The identification of a single component locus dating to the Archaic-Late transition is an important contribution. Del Mar Land Management Company Fairbanks Country Villas, San Diego, CA As Project Manager, prepared testing plan and implemented testing program for proposed residential development. County of San Diego Inmate Reception Center, San Diego County, CA Project Manager responsible for testing and data recovery of half a city block in downtown San Diego. Gerald D. Hines Interests 343 Sansome Street, San Francisco County, CA As Project Archaeologist, participated in archaeological data recovery excavations at a Gold Rush-period site in downtown San Francisco. I I I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I Rebecca Apple, RPA Resume City of North Las Vegas Land Transfer, Clark County, NV As Project Archaeologist, directed cultural resource survey of 4,000-acre land transfer from the BLM to the City of North Las Vegas. Kerr-McGee Apex Industrial Park, Clark County, NV As Project Archaeologist, conducted archaeological survey and NRHP evaluations for BLM land transfer. Fargo Industries Walnut Hills Subdivision, San Diego County, CA As Archaeological Monitor, conducted archaeological monitoring of site preparation and grading in San Marcos. Fellowship Center, Inc. Alcoholism Service Center, San Diego County, CA As Project Archaeologist, conducted archaeological survey of proposed rehabilitation center adjacent to Mission San Luis Rey in Oceanside. Other Projects County of San Diego Pefiasquitos Park, San Diego County, CA As Archaeologist, participated in survey, including documentation of three adobes. California Department of Parks and Recreation/FIR Old Town State Historic Park, San Diego County, CA As Archaeologist, participated in excavation before placement of underground utilities in San Diego. County of San Diego Rancho Guajome Adobe, San Diego County, CA As Archaeologist, participated in excavation, cataloging, and analysis for work conducted before building stabilization efforts. California Department of Parks and Recreation Anza Borrego Desert State Park, Riverside County, CA As Archaeologist, participated in resource inventory sun/ey. Glamis Imperial Corporation Project, Imperial County, CA As Archaeologist, conducted cultural resource survey for proposed gold mine. Fort Cady Minerals Corporation Boric Acid Mining and Processing Facility, San Bernardino County, CA As Project Archaeologist, directed survey, testing, and evaluation of 24 sites in Newberry Springs- U.S. Sprint Rialto-to-EI Paso Fiber Optics Cable, San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, CA As Archaeologist, conducted cultural resource survey along western extent of project. Selected Reports A View Across the Cultural Landscape of the Lower Colorado Desert: Cultural Resource. Investigations for the North Baja Pipeline Project (with Jamie Cleland). Prepared for TetraTech and North Baja, LLC: EDAW, Inc., San Diego (2003). Cultural Resources Evaluation for the North Baja Gas Pipeline (with C. Dolan, J. Underwood, and J.H. Cleland). Prepared for Foster Wheeler Environmental, Inc. EDAW, Inc., San Diego (2001). Histoncal and Archeological Resources Protection Plan (HARP) for the Chocolate Mountain Aerial Gunnery Range, Imperial County, Califomia (with J.H. Cleland). Prepared for U.S. Navy Southwest Division, Naval Facilities Engineering Command. EDAW, Inc., San Diego (2001). Archaeological Resources Evaluation Report State Route 56 Between Coast and Foothill, City of Sah Diego, California (with J.H. Cleland, A. York, T. Wahoff, and D. James). Prepared for the City of San Diego. KEA Environmental, Inc., San Diego (1997). Archeological Survey and Evaluation Program for the Salton Sea Test Base, Imperial County, Califomia (with A. York, A. Pignolo, J.H. Cleland, and S. Van Wormer). Prepared for U.S. Navy, Southwest Division, Naval Facilities Engineering Command. KEA Environmental, Inc., San Diego (1997). Two Sides ofthe River: Cultural Resources Technical Studies Undertaken as Part of Environmental Documentation for Military Use ofthe MCAS Yuma Training Range Complex in Arizona and Califomia (with G. Woodall, L. Peterson, and J.S- Bruder). Prepared forthe Southwest Division Naval Facilities Engineering Command and MCAS Yuma. Dames & Moore Intermountain Cultural Resource Services Research Paper No. 5, San Diego (1993). Rebecca Apple, RPA Resume Bank Stabilization at Lake Britton: Limited Data Recovery (with A. MacDougall). Prepared for Pacific Gas and Electric. Dames & Moore, San Diego (1990). Kern River Pipeline Cultural Resource Survey Report (with J.H. Cleland, A.L. York, and P. Friedman). Submitted to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. Dames & Moore, San Diego (1990). Sugarloaf Mountain in Prehistory: Archaeological Testing and Data Recovery for the Exploratory Drilling Program II and the Unit No. 1 Project (wWh J.H. Cleland and E. Nilsson). Prepared for the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. Dames & Moore, San Diego (1990). An Archaeological Research Design for the Evaluation of Cultural Resources in Pamo Valley, San Diego, Califomia (with J.H. Cleland, J.R. Cook, and J. Schaefer). Wirth Environmental Services, a Division of Dames & Moore, San Diego (1985). I I APPENDIX B „ MONITORING LOGS I I I I I I I I I I I • ENCINAS CREER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 I DATE: Page 1 of 2 I LOCATION: fiorXf-\^:^ Y^C^f^ r\C3n4-% ^t^-fe^ I MONTTOR^SNAME: ^^^^^jAgC"" ~TVX>^S^/% ARRIVAL: HINCH:iL5^j5_ DEPARTURE: I fROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATIONr r>ek \ Ox^e¥A RESOURCE DESIGNATIONCS): I I OTBERMONITORSPRESENT: 5>fe<g€y rn^^cSta {n LXryA^ \J SinmARYOFACTIONS/ACTITOIESr ""^^^'^ CB^^ 3 I EQWMENT: HSQC^ '-b!>'^^S B OBSERVATIONS: V^l^.S 'BppCr^ , /j^(gQ . g ' ^ r " IMPACr(S) TO CmTOHAI, RESOURCES: (^^^^^ . p^sTcA^ fApA. I I I I COMMENTS: gA^'t^- niK\e7- i^^^Pc- (Continue an Page 2 if necessary} HABLYMomasimiiSx ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 PATE: J\~y [ ivy Page lof 2 LOCATION: Fr\CJ^r<^S> CVPP^ (I^rr\M\^^^^:^r^^ MOMTOR»S NAME: ARRIVAL: ^',CO UmCH^\^J>0 DEPARTURE: PROIECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: f^rCXc^^^ Cf^e^ rSrSdoP RESOURCE DESIGNATIONfS): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: SUMMARY OF ACTION^ACTIVrnES: Qjgynrfr, ^^epxTrVv -^L^ EQUIPMENT: P^Wx --'Vxng>':^A'XDlg ^ OBSERVATTONS: POnA^rr-s 4rgL^K rVy-4V> IMPACT<S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: ^^J^f&^SP- *>\^6r^ ^ ^^V^ 9\e>rv\-ir ^^gor -:^^ O^es^ A\?^s\ bA^^e ^^<3^r>%vr^^o4- sW-p^ O COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 ffitecessary) I I I I I I I I I v I I I I I I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: Febmary 24,2010 Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: South Carlsbad State Beacb/Ponto .__ MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson • ARRIVAL: 8:00 LUNCH: Vahr. DEPA TURE: 3:15 PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTIIER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Excavation of beach cobble on west side of bridge area. All large boulders were removed so when piles are driven, they would not impede progress. The boulders were set aside and will be used for rip rap later. ^ EQUIPMENT: Track-hoe . ' ^ OBSERVATIONS: Exposed concrete foundation on west side of bridge. I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: none I — COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILY MOmromNCdoc I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: February 25,2010 Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: South Carlsbad State Beach/Ponto MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 7^00 LUNCH: Vi hr. DEPA TURE: 3:30 PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Motado, Lindsey Teunis in A.M. . SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTrvITIES: Main activity for the day was pile driving. Some additional excavation of beach cobble south of the bridge. EQUIPMENT: Track-hoe, crane, pile driver, Manlift OBSERVATIONS: .Some of the boulders excavated from this area are sandstone rather than what we have been seeing used for rip rap. IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: none COMMENTS: 40' steel pile toppled while being held in place against the bridge by the track hoe bucket The second incident occurred when the pile driver (attached to the crane) malfunctioned lesuliing ia il losing ifs grip on the pile. The pile fell over smasMng the Man-M bucket. (The— operator had just stepped out of the bucket) • . (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILYMONm)KiNG.doc I I I I I 0 I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: February 26,2010 . Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: South Carlsbad State Beach/Ponto . • MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 10:30 LUNCH: Vi hr. PEPA TURE: 4:00 PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTrVITIES: Activity for the day was pile driving. ,| RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): ^ OTHER MONITORS PRESENT; Stacey Mojado I I I I EQUIPMENT: crane, pile driver, Manlift OBSERVATIONS: I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: none I — — — I I I COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILY Mornvmadoc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: March 09,2010 . Page lof 2 LOCATION; South Carlsbad State Beacb/Ponto MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 7:00 LUNCH:'/2hr. DEPA TURE: 4:00 I I PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Moiado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Activity for the day was pile drivmg and trying to locate boulders on west side of bridge holding up piles. EQUIPMENT: crane, pile driver, ManM OBSERVATIONS: - IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: none COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) miLYMOmTommid^ I I I I I I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: March 10,2010 _^ Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: South Carlsbad State Beach/Ponto , MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 7:00 LUNCH; Vihr. DEPA TURE: 4:00 PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Activity for the day was pile driving. I RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S); ^ OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado I I I I EQUIPMENT: crane, pile driver, Manlift OBSERVATIONS: - I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: none I =— I — I I I COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILY MONimRiNGdoc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: March n, 2010 Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: South Carlsbad State Beach/Ponto MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 7:00 LUNCH: DEPA TURE: 11:00 PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Pile driving EQUIPMENT: crane, pile driver, Manlift OBSERVATIONS: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: none COMMENTS: (Continue onPage 2 if necessary) DAILY Monrromadoc I I I I I I I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: [O Page lof 2 LOCATION; Carlsbad ' • MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson I , ARRTVAL: ^ -OQ LUNCH: , DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION; Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement H RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): ^- OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado I i SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: 'B^\p fii^ ^=A^^^Sh\ j^^^-ja^ EQUIPMENT: --eA.e.^:i^^3-^ofe-^ OBSERVATIONS: k^^\^^ >Na^-v\^ c<:^^t^y^2^ ^ I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: V C^<oA>s, . _ COMMENTS; ^ OA^ / ^ li^ £ . Cn OQ fP"-^ r - I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 I I I DATE: ^sCUCSl^ \ ,c5l>lO ^ Page 1 of2 I LOCATION: C jC^^-Q^&rgi^ j | MONIIOR^SNAME: ^^iQ^-gl£pU.A,, . . ARRIVAL: "^/CO LUNCH: DEPARTURE: \ ^L) I PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: fyV^xJx-Ay^cA Q^V^€^-- - - • ' RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): • | OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: EQUIPMENT: OBSERVATIONS: I I I mPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: LJ CSAZpp • CA^^Q jA^y ^C^u^ferrg^- ^" • .^AA^^ ^PiP-A^..A.yOX COMMENTS:^^^!"^ ^ ..AA^<-. ^^^O't-^L^.^T^ -xP"^^ (Continue on Pa^e 2 if necessarv)' DAILY MONITORINGJIOC * I I f I I I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: Oo^p^JkiL ^ y . \riLd<>^ Page 1 of 2 I LOCATION: - MONITOR'S NAME: ^0/<l>C^=^ _ ^^^A^>r».^^ry\ ARRIVAL: ^ ' LUNCH: DEPARTURE;-^ • PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: i ^^"^^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: I I I I I . —pppp^;;ppp^^^ I ^—p—^::^pppp:pp I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: rVjV'-Q--^ EQUIPMENT OBSERVATIONS: COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAiLYMONiTORiNG.doc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: C^p^^^ 3> LOCATION Page 1 of 2 MONITOR'S NAME ARRIVAL: %2 LUNCH^ DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Pvt X^-e^O RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTTVITIES: EQUIPMENT OBSERVATIONS IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILYMONrrORim.doc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: ^J^M}^ ^ Ijl NC:>rt3^1^ Page 1 of2 LOCATION: MONITOR'S NAME ARRTVAL: '<OQ LUNCH:^ DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: ^.^^'VX /^<^ CAfljg^L^ ^^b^)^ rHj^&^-Cg/C^-^Aj^ :^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT :>yteLCU4 ppJyMr. (ip SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTTVITIES: EQUIPMENT: OBSERVATIONS: - ^ IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: (Continue on Pase 2 if necessary) DAILY MONimsmcdoc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE LOCATION (lj^^Q_, (p> 2XMAljU>^ . Page lof 2 MONITOR'S NAME: ^p.jO^_Q. ..jW-yr^l^gN/^ ARRIVAL: I LUNCH: DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S) OTHER MONITORS PRESENT SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES EQUIPMENT: ^-^^Aj^_Xx_.U^^Cr»=g::^\ U.J V-Orj^g^-C-^C, OBSERVATIONS: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAiLYMONiTOimfG.doc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: G pJ}'xSi. ^ U^^g^^rv^^cW^ Page 1 of2 h LOCATION: MONITOR'S NAME: ARRTVAL: ^ ^Of^ . LUNCH:_ DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): . OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTTVITIES: EQUIPMENT OBSERVATIONS IMPACT(S) TO CULTURALRESOURCES: COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAiLYMONnoRim.doc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: Ocp^:g .Srb .^^lO Page 1 of2 LOCATION: Carlsbad ; . MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: LUNCH: DEPARTURE: ^-^^^Q PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas (^^^fe^^Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION (S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado .SUMMARY OF ACTTONS/ACTIVITIES: ^C?t£)-VCxQjg .^JCTX^ .2^ QA^\JIJ\^<^ "i^X^^^-cnYVN^gudi EQUIPMENT: (Q T^^O^r^^-^^^ky^ OBSERVATIONS: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: O-^ CP:^<JUGQSL. of^ .^P^^i^X COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAlLYMOmOimG.doc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: April 08, 2010 . Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: Carlsbad ' . • MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ^ • ARRIVAL: 7:30 LUNCH: Vi hr^ DEPA TURE: 4^30 • PROJECT AREA NAME/LO CATION: Encinas Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTXONS/ACtlVITIES: Pothole for sewer and gas lines in preparation for Phase 2 EQUIPMENT: (1) back hoe - OBSERVATIONS: Spoke to Don, Casey and Mark (City of Carlsbad) and expressed my concems regarding no one on beach keeping public out of harms way when pilings are being lifted and driven by crane. '. IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: A couple of glass frags collected form back dirt of SDG&E pothole #3 COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILY MomoRiNadoc ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: April 09,2010 Page i of 2 LOCATION: Carlsbad ____„ MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRTVAL: 7^30 LUNCH: lihr;____ DEPA TURE: 5:30 PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION; Encinas Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Bridge demo EQUIPMENT: OBSERVATIONS: I^ACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: 7-up bottle 1939-1953 (Lockhart; 2005) YOS^. Pl^^^ ^oni ip»'^p& / - ^r.ux^L'^ I COMMENTS: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILrMONrrOItING.dx I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: April 09, 2010 Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: Carisbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ' ', • . ARRIVAL: 7:30 • LUNCH: V2 hr. ; DEPA TURE: 5:30 PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: . Encinas Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Bridge demo EQUIPMENT: (2) excavators, (1) loader - bucket and hammer attachments OBSERVATIONS: demolition and removal of NE wing wall and remaining portion of SE wing wall IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: 7-up bottle 1939-1953 (Lockhart; 2005) SE wing wall back dirt. Possible flake tool and bettered implement/core? 4696461/3664220 (out of context)—] ' '• • •• COMMENTS: pile driving crew (McMahon) did not have caution tape up or anyone watching out for public on beach. (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) [>AU.rMONrioiuNG.aL ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: 4-/10 (IO LOCATION: Carlsbad Page 1 of2 MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: "7 fPO PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: LUNCH: RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES- "3 I I I I I I I I DEPA TURE: 1^ Bncinas Bridge Replacement EQUIPMENT: (:-j>e>r>v»..4<jrs CS") It^a^ OBSERVAnONS: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: I t I I I i ll (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) DAILYMOhrrmKTNr. i ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE; LOCATION: Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson [ /JC^ LUNCH: ______ DEPA TURE: i>>^-^ ARRIVAL: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION; _______,&icin^^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado . SUMMARY OF ACTlONS/ACTIVmES: '^( A.Ai^^ ^4^--r--g . EQUIPMENT: ^ Tg^tg. IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: OBSERVATIONS: ^ 0-/\.^fe::ajt^S:^->'- \ i'^^- - - ^ \ — COMMENTS: OA^^^^^^Q:^^:^^^ J, K:g::~~ 4 ^ /u.>^^. (^'/pA^<^ (b^^f^P,:f:P=^^^ p-.K^. ^Q^JtpZ^ry. f^-^A- ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 ^ l{^\nn\n ITl-^a^^^ Page lof 2 LOCATION: Carlsbad _j [ ___ ^ MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson AT^I^TVAT.:"~7f'^X> LUNCH: DEPA TURE: S>'-QO PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCx\TION: RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: X^-^t^C) COMMENTS: I I I I I I Encinas Bridge Replacement | - I - I QUIPMENT: BSERVATIONS: W->oC^J^ yjr^S, . — — I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: —ZZZZZZZI' I ============ I = I " = I — —— — I I I I I I i I f I I I I I I I I I I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: Page 1 of2 LOCATION: Carisbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 1\00 LUNCH;. PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: DEPA TURE: u Encinas Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: EQUIPMENT: OBSERVATIONS: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: (pY^-^^ COMMENTS: Qt _ ^ / — ! ~- ga^y.Q5/ti.y^^ ^^^^^ ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: 04/14/2010 . Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: Carlsbad \ . MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ; ARRIVAL: 7:00 LUNCH: DEPARTURE: ILOO PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Enemas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION (S): OTHER MONTTORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: EQUIPMENT: OBSERVATIONS: .Loading concrete today, no excavation. IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) • DAiLrMONrroiiiNG.doc i I I I I t I I I I I I 1 I I COMMENTS; I Spoke to Mark (City of Carlsbad) about people using the bak and bluff to get || around the construction site. ( The top of the bluff is W-11 whose site boundaries have not ben • defined) He told me there was nothing thai he could do about it. I I I I I i 8 II ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: Page 1 of2 LOCATION: Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: LUNCH: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: DEPA TURE: Encinas Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: - \4/jvJU> C^^a^ "Sal^a..,: *^i^tA I i J'^-^-v^^v, EQUIPMENT: __ ^ OBSERVAHONS: gr^L-' V^x f^gP ^^^.^^W. ^^^^U^^g-^^^^^^ •pgpCpJ f%M^PPl -.g: ••V'«^'%^--\ A IMPACT(S) TO, CULTURAL RESOURCES: (2'>4jO ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DAIE: (W11/2010 - —— P^g^ ' °" LOCATION: Carisbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 7:00 LUNCH: ^ DEPARTURE: 1L00_ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S); OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTTVITIES: EQUIPMENT: COMMENTS: , DAILY MONirOSING-doc (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) I I I I I i I I I I I OBSERVATIONS: .Upon arrival at jobsite, learned al 7-year old giri in an F150 had_jriven t through 2 sets of barricades and a cham link fence and come to rest under the back ot an excavator. No digging today. However, when I was walkilfg back the hdl from the lop of r-^^l.y.^ pi..^ T notireH th«t thp stock pile ^T^^ wRs imparting the blufFon the ^f^^-^^^ Carlsbad Blvd The arch site W-111 is situated on top of this bluff and the possibility ot there bemg artifacts erodmg down is a possibility. 1 did not observe any, however, I did fmd one grape diiiik bulllB dial had beui cAuosed bv Oic heav v cuuiDuiciil: " • IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: TheUjMl.f"'-^""^^ r " have spoken to the super about this and he assm-es me that his crew will avoid disturbmg the bank a the lulure. lu addition, di^coveied ai a depdt of abuUl IT Ift the afea of die SE wmg ^^^^ ^-^f eariier bri'lg- ^'-^ - Ffir^. Ront Beer bottle a larae ^^rrevch with a ttig ^vith th^ date 1The approximate UTMs are 469682/ 3664173. [ I I 1 i I I f ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 "^hj^hO^^^ Pagel of2 DATE: _ LOCATION: Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME; Heather Thomson : ^lOD . LUNCH: _____^ DEPA TORE:, ARRIVAL: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stecej^Mojado ^ _— — SUMMARY OF ACTTONS/ACnVITIES: ^T^^^^LLiil^MiiiS^ o,_A\ier=v pp^. „ —^ — EQUIPMENT: oBSERVAnoNS: ^DfZa.LO^ibere>^^«±^^ IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: (S>CaKJc>zte^ ' C^O^ < ^ ^ I coMME^«.:L.M^^^.;^V>^]^£^:^^£J£^^ ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: 04/16/2010 . • ^^^^ ' °" LOCATION: Carlsbad : — — MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson . — ARRIVAL: 7^00 LUNCH: DEPARTURE: ii00_ AKKIVAL: 1-^^ _ PROJECT ARFA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado ^ SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Excavate for and install (1) additional culvert pipe. EQUIPMENT: (1) excavator and (1) loader _ — OBSERVATIONS- More inclepient weather is expected. Due to current culverts not being able to handle the flow during die last rain, contractor is putting one additional pipe adjacent to and south ofthe current two. ' IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: (S), approx. 469695/3664164 - lm ekvation, found m die back dirt which the excavator had dug up were several bottles. These include: 1 Pepsi bCTtte-fwle juice, I FleiscMiaim-s and 1 cyliiidiLal brown boide widi a Mu Uadeuialk. Also,' near th- t-r -^^'--^ ^-^"'^ '^^'^ r^^^ fr""^ nrnnons rulvert in^t^llf^tinn WRS dofound 1 possible FGV scraper The contractor had excavated this area without noting us. Although out ol context, die UTM's where it was found are- 469692/3664168 - elevation 5m COMMENTS: DAILY MONnORBiadoc (Continue on Page 2 if necessary) I I I I I i i 1 I I i I i I I I i I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DAm _HVrzi2QLQ_ LOCATION: Carlsbad ^ — MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson Page 1 of2 ARRIVAL; /7ioo LUNCH: _ DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: EncinasQ^^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): _ _ OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: _ ._. •ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^-^ SUMMARY OF 0Q2<3LX\ IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: V^jcO^ <^ --^ ^i=i=777=^ ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DAm _i±Z^^iaOUD C:^QCW Page lof 2 LOCATION: Carlsbad _ — ^ MONITOR'S NAME; Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: ^'OO LUNCH: DEPARTURE: ARRIVAL: / _ ^ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement _ | I RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): \ . •. ^ • " OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojadg _ | SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACnVITIES: ^ C'B^ . EQUIPMENT; 0^ OBSERVATIONS: —— —. ^ ^ IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS; i I 1 I I 6 I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG i 2010 I ^I.rn.. MmlSSm _ib^ta&^J*J.- Fagelof2 LOCATION: Carlsbad i " MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson _ ^-^.'/^ I ARRIVAL: :P3n - LUNCH:^ _ DEPATmE: • ^ X Pnrinfls Rridee Re PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION; Enemas Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): I OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacey Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIQNS/ACriVmES: ^-^^^C.^^^ /V^-^ O/. I SUMMARY OF ACTIO rpp~^ r^^t^^^^'^VS^^'^^ ' ' ------~-T:.l^£^OS..a^ EQUIPMENT: I • - OBSERVATIONS; ^HjO^fc (£^1 - IMpIcTtS) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: -=fl^!:^5^^^-G^^ * ^ ^ o , COMMENTS: lL:Ui^HJ^#%=^^ ^ gcq523Z5k5=i ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 Page 1 of2 DATE: April 20, 2010 ^ ^ — ^ LOCATION: Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARKIVAL; 7:30 LUNCH: Vjfa: DEPARTURE: 4^ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOcI^^ON: Enemas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES; Bridge footing excavation. EQUIPMENT: 1 excavator, 1 loader OBSERVATIONS: clav at 6' below grade IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: . ^^^^^^^^^t^^S 469679/3664185 to 469681/3664192 old spice bottle, several glass fragments, (1) half pint w/ feder^aw iorbid^, 1 H & A Gilbey gin boille, (1) rouud food jai, sc.cidli^emffiieTtete fra^ieats Unifacial flake tool & 1 poss. Bead'.^F^NA thinks possible hole dnlled thru, found in sLockuileddnl.No uiu^uiiuicc. ' COMMENTS- Asked loader operator (Mike^ to avoid putting stockpiled material against bank on SSl Blvdl^i^lSkidTS^^ that if Mike couldnot^^^^b^^ wopfahiEsdtCFimt^ome sill fence. He sald ok. Went lo check ^Ici ^Idte^ he wo. .UU .a.i.otb.nk TtoldRobprtthnt wrnnwHADtohavesom^ye^^fham^^ ^gggg^^ They completed maybe 20' offenceandtogo^ pulled off to do something else. . „ 1 I . Pi^\ 0,QAX-^>:>CKJ Page 1 of2 DATE LOCATION; Carlsbad I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT • AECOM MONITORING LOG ^ 2010 m. t I I 1 MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: , ^ LUNCH:. DEPARTURE: \\CX ^ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION; Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): I OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado I SUISiMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: jDy-^^^f^ToS^X •-/y- .4 A- OBSERVATIONS: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: i EQUIPMENT cn .J^Jvt.C^J^'fi^. V Q&CL^. I I 1 I I COMMENTS: ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: LOCATION; Carlsbad Page 1 of2 MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRTVT^L: LUNCPI: DEPARTURE: 1^ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encuias Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVniES: EQUIPMENT: \ -..LJ^yj^.-J^X A y€x OBSERVATIONS \:>^<xypi^ "^^O fef i ^-^SLQ. > T IjvgACTtS)TOCULT-URAL.^ESQUReBS;-X^/->^^g^ .KJA^CV 3^ COMMENTS; I I i s I I I I i I I I I I I I I 1 ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 Page 1 of2 DATE; April 22, 2010 — LOCATION: Carlsbad I I I I I I I ARRWAL- 7;30____ LUNCH: !ihr^__ DEPARTURE: 1:30. • PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: EadiKsCreekB^^ I I i MONITOR'S NAME: Headier Thomson RESOURCE DESlGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: Bridgybotin^exc^^ EQUIPMENT: 1 excavator, 1 loader I m..ERVATlONS- Babyseal^undunde^^ Sl^^^^y^eidk^^^h^^ —• -I". xl A:,,.^^^r,^Ainn thp remiest to halt work. I I I up close TO IKt.yJV Miu wiuim uu^.....^ ... , T— took fiill responsMity for them disregarding the request to halt wort:. IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: I COMMENTS- A ;.j^^rt;>j^hle,u with the stoekpiled dirt 3.e^:i^C^^mdi^^S^ SrSo^' I ^;iSdte?i?ii5S:T3ied Cheryl^OUp^^^f^^^^P I ^ • • l';-. =============—-—- ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: LOCATION: Carlsbad Page 1 of2 MONITOR'S NAME; Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: LUNCH:. DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIOj^S/ACTIVITlES: cyyr-p-py^r^^. A A. EQUIPWIENT: d2pC^f^^<^^^ CVH^t?^^J-^^-: OBSERVATIONS; I I I I I I f i I i I I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: 6 /W.£J^ t •^_^P /) r^^frr ^."^ ^ Q ^qj^-a ' — I I I I I I I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT ^ AECOM MONITORING LOG I 2010 :| r. ATP. April 23. 2010 ^ ^ Page 1 of 2 LOCATION: Carlsbad ; . •. — I I I MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ARRIVAL: 7:00 LUNCH:^jhr^ DEPARTORE: L30_ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): I' OTHER MONITORS PRESENT; Stacy Mojado : , , _ I SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES; Bridge footing excavation I EQUIPMENT: 2 excavator, 1 loader I OBSERVATIONS; There is another concrete footmg below the one already taken oujondie^ * ocean side ofthe bridge. It is about 3'thick and uses cobbles for fill. ^ I f IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: i COMMENTS: There is now silt fence up between the stockpiles and the bluffon Carlsbad Blvd. I ^ ==zz= I •. ZII===== ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT - AECOM MONITORING LOG 1 2010 DATE; U Page 1 of2 LOCATION: Carlsbad RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: I I MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson _^ • | ARRIVAL ^ 'VLJ LUNCH:'A-W=_ DEPARTURE: J^35__ PROJECT AMiA NAM^A^^^ON; EncimsCreekB^ | OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: StsigyMoiado ; ^ — — • I EQUIPMENT: ^U'Jh'—' | ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^-^K- I 4 .^b— COM>^NIS:-l.^g^^^VigE£^^X^'^^,'^>^^-^ 3^^g^^l^ DATE: "7/t ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 LOCATION; Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME; Heather Thomson ^ • ^ - ARRIVAL: ^ie^_ LUNCH: _ DEPARTURE: JS^SQ- ARKlVAi.: f < '— — —— PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: .^gn^^ek Bridge Replgg^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION{S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT; ^^reyMojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: ^^3=.c2:d NUMMARY OF ACTIONS/AC! iViiiJib; v .^^-^^ — 5^^:= — - * , EQUIPMENT: OBSERVATIONS: ^^^^JO^^P^^^^P^^^^^-^^^^-'^PX JLTURAL RESOURCES: PX^^^^^i^^^^^-^^^^'^^^^''' > .^£-_= ^(^^t^7^UHlQ& —— ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 H: io-bl a9vo u:)vaf9>v^g.&J^ p^ge i of 2 DATE; LOCATION: Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME; Heather Thomson [ . . — ARRIVAL: '^[nr^ LUNCH: DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encmas Creek Bridge Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: ^^l^^^^X^^^. >Avjd^ QgvL^ '^^'^C^ EQUIPMENT; 1^LT" feiVv£) OBSERVATIONS: 'gn_8>^ArAg^ IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES; CO yCA^V^s^^A 0<S^:^2X. ^ C\ ^ COMMENTS; i I I I I ^.r.^/^CA I AO Page lof 2 I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 LOCATION: Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson I ARRIVAL: 7 iDO LUNCH: DEPARTURE: I ^ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: Encinas Crcck Dridflc Rcplacomciat "l^^^/pA^yQ- I — — RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S); I OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Sia^jjjj^So . '^S"\QrV? y-QrV^^S^ I SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: "I^^-V^U Tw^^ bp >t <g- ^CP>^ " rg^y-\rv2^e:^OA - — I EQUIPMENT: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: I OBSERVATIONS: 'DrV /O-g C^XjJ^ I ' I - I I I I i COMMENTS; I I AECOM MONITORING LOG 1 2010 I DATB: Agi^=^£^^a^lEL— '•^8'=^°" - LOCATION: Carlsbad — ^— MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson ——•. — ^ — • ARRIVAL: LUNCH: DEPARTURE: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCA-nON; giicinas 6 sejleplacement ^ . | ZZZZ I RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S); ^ : : ^ ' OTHER MONITORS PRESENT; ^ _ • SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTIVITIES: I EQUIPMENT; "^^^gAzT C>Vg^-- ^ ;^ — , • I IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: O'^ S^ff^ ^^^'^^'^^^ , , i .iQ I —— ; - I I EH€TOST^EKmi©eESpLACEMENTMONITORI^^ AECOM MONITORING LOG 1 2010 I . LOCATION: Carlsbad Page 1 of2 MONITOR'S NAME; HeadierThomson PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: -T?fn^m^*^4;e@k=BgteeReplacement ..^'^^ I \t)^n^ TTINCH- DEPARTORE: _ ^ • . ARRIVAL: V^^PU LUNCH. . ^ ^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado I I I SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTmTIES;^ i..J^^^.4^^1-^-^ ^ EQUIPMENT: I OBSERVATIONS: Q^C^^^ ^V^- ^ • ' • zEEEEEEEEEEEEEz I I I I I IMPACT(S) TO CULTORAL RESOURCES COMMENTS: ^©di^lAS-eK^^PCTODe&REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: LOCATION: 'CSrlsbad > DOiP P^e 1 of2 MONITOR'S NAME: Heatiier Thomson ARRIVAL: '^tp^ LUNCH: ¥2V^' DEPARTURE: lV»^"g^!) PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION; Sae^e»^@Qfe^4gg: Replacement RESOURCE DESIGNATION (S): OBSERVATIONS: IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: ( ^^y^fc^ COMMENTS: I 1 I I I I I I OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado .... J'^fe' i^^^'f ^'-'-""Ij SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACTTVITIES:. ^^J3^V^>^- Cf^%%<^^A ' ^ ^ ^ ^ I EQUIPMENTf\yfefiy^$^... fp iM^^ml^tK^X. I _ ^ _ ,| I I I I I I I ^^^^:SC^EKBRIDQE REPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: ^ ^ LOCATION: Carlsbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson _ ARRIVAL: •T':^_—LUNCH^^^ PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: ^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: Stacy Mojado / CuXr\ Y^^'^^Cj. SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/ACnVITIES; iag^^^^J^^-^-X^M^ A ^Swy^ EQUIPMENT: fPj^j^^^^^ OBSERVATIONS: ^ : IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: I I I ^^.^^^I^^^^S^Bee^PLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT AECOM MONITORING LOG 2010 DATE: LOCATION: Carisbad MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson _ ARRIVAL: ^7;^5_____ LUNCH; _____ DEPARTURE: J^l^^ PROJECT AR^I^^^Ii^i^AX^ON: B^^:€^^^:BndgeRepl^^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OBSERVATIONS; IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES; COMMENTS; I I I OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: tov^^d^^ . , — — | ....^.....^x..r-rTr>XK/ArTTVTTTES:. n^^T-TTX^. Ce4M^^4g£—^ I "1= I I I I I I I I ENCINAS CREEK BRIDGFREPLACEMENT MONITORING PROJECT ENCINAS GKii ^^^^ MONITORING LOG 2010 Page 1 of2 DATE; LOCATION: Carlsbad , MONITOR'S NAME: Heather Thomson __ ^ — ^\00 LUNCH:. DEPARTURE: SJ^- ARRTVAL: PROJECT AREA NAME/LOCATION: EncinasCree^^ RESOURCE DESIGNATION(S): OTHER MONITORS PRESENT: ggtcrMojado SU]MMARYOFACriONS/ACnVITIES: ne^^^^S^^^—^^^^^'^^^^ ,M^=iU4pA^M^2^^ jE,£^vv^iAilv2^jC4^ ~ EQUIPMENT OBSERVATIONS; : . — IMPACT(S) TO CULTURAL RESOURCES: COMMENTS: APPENDIX C SITE FORM UPDATE state of California - The Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial CA-SDI-17.408 Page L of 2 'Resource Name or #: (Assigned by recorder) 'Recorded by; C. Bowden-Renna *Date: 10/2010 •Continuation • Update Site CA-SDI-17,408 was first recorded by Malcolm Rogers during the 1920s and 1930s. Rogers described the site as located at the mouth of Encinas Creek, running north for approximately 0.25 mile, ranging from 100 ft to 300 ft wide. Rogers identifies this site as San Dieguito Complex II with traces of San Dieguito III and Lit. II (Archaic) and Y-N (Late Prehistoric). He observed evidence of defused hearths, lithic and groundstone scatter, ceramics, shell midden deposits, and evidence of buried deposits. He also collected several surface artifacts, including two knifes, two projectile points, a "Bowling Stone" and a piece of debitage (Rogers n.d.). Rogers noted that a large portion of the site had been plowed. The site was relocated in 1998 (Kyle and Gallegos 1998), north of the current study area, along a bluff above the northbound land of Carlsbad Boulevard and extending westward in the median between the southbound and northbound lanes. Lithic debitage, shell and groundstone were observed. Kyle and Gallegos noted that the site had been previously disturbed by construction of Old Highway 101, Carlsbad Boulevard, and a mobile home park. Heavy vegetation and previous construction activity was noted within the site area. Site monitoring was conducted by AECOM and a Native American monitor for the removal and replacement of the Encinas Creek Bridge due to severe deterioration. During the current monitoring effort very few cultural resources were identified within the project area. Artifacts were recovered from previously disturbed backfill deposit or back dirt piles. All soils observed appeared to be disturbed fill and aeolian sand over hard packed sand. Artifacts were point provenienced with a sub-meter global positioning system (GPS) unit when possible and sent to AECOM for temporary curation. No intact prehistoric or historic deposits were observed. Prehistoric artifacts recovered included two mano fragments, one complete mano, two flaked stone tools, one chopper, one scraper, two shell beads, one portion of a shell ornament or pendant, and one piece of possible fire-affected rock. Historic artifacts included six whole bottles, two glass insulator fragments, a large wrench, ceramic whiteware fragments, and glass fragments. Modern bottles and plastic were also observed. It is likely that the prehistoric artifacts have been washed down from the more intact portion of CA-SDI-17,408, located upslope of the project area within Encinas Creek, or were re-deposited with soil from the surrounding area during previous construction activities. Once the project is completed, it is anticipated that the City will arrange permanent curation of the collection at the San Diego Archaeological Center, which offers curatorial services that meet state and federal standards. While soils within the project area appear to be disturbed, the range of artifacts types recovered indicated that there may be buried deposits in the vicinity of the new Encinas Creek Bridge. Therefore, continued monitoring in the future for all ground-disturbing activities within the site boundary for CA-SDI-17,408 by a qualified archaeologist and Native American monitor is recommended. References Bowden-Renna, Cheryl 2010 Archaeological .Monitoring Report for the Encinas Creek Bridge Replacement Project, City of Carlsbad, San Diego County, California. Prepared by AECOM. Prepared for City of Carlsbad. Kyle, Carolyn, and Dennis Gallegos . 1998 Cultural Resource Sun/ey for the Carlsbad Boulevard Realignment Project. Unpublished report on file at the South Coastal Information Center. Rogers, Malcolm n.d. Site form for CA-SDI-17,408 (SDM-W-111). On file at the South Coastal Information Center. DPR 523L (1/95) 07080213 Master Catalog Encinas Creek Bridge Monitoring 07/29/2010 Artifact number State Code County Code Site Number UTM E UTM N Depth (cm) Artifact type Material Count Weight (g) Comments 1 CA-SDl-17408 469653 3664220 15 Mano Granitic 1 1500 mano with hammerstone properties 2 CA-SDI-17408 469703 3664035 Mano Quartzite 1 750-FAR, bifacially ground and exhibits pecking 3 CA-SDI-17408 469712 3664108 FAR Quartzite 4 855 found in sewer pot hole 4 CA-SDI-17408 469712 3664108 Mano Quartzite 1 1000 found in sewer pot hole 5 CA-SDI-17408 N/A N/A Tool Meta-volcanic 1 38.9 found in pile of dirt, no prov. unifacially worked 6 CA-SDl-17408 469646 3664220 Chopper Meta-volcanic 1 1000 7 CA-SDI-17408 469646 3664220 Tool Meta-volcanic 1 39.2 bifacially flaked 8 CA-SDI-17408 469692 3664168 Scraper Meta-volcanic 1 30.4 turtle back scraper 9 CA-SDI-17408 469693 3664168 30 Ornament Shell 2 6.7 abalone pendant 10 CA-SDI-17408 " N/A N/A Bead Shell 1 1.1 found in sewer pothole / olivella 11 CA-SDl-17408 N/A N/A Bead Shell 1 1 12 CA-SDl-17408 469687 3664180 6' Bottle Glass 1 Clear, complete without cap, "Federal Law Forbids Sale or Reuse of this Bottle" "ONE PINT', on bottom "Anchor Hawkins mark with D-126//67/44' 13 CA-SDI-17408 469722 3664066 Bottle Glass 1 Clear, no cap, "Pepsi Cola" on bottom "Des. Pat.120,277//15A54//124//3" 14 CA-SDl-17408 469712 3664108 Bottle Glass 1 Clear, "Santa Fe Select QualityVintage Co.//Re-filling Prohibited", on bottom "Des. Reg. U.S. Pat. Off.//610//LM mark//E 15 CA-SDl-17408 469695 3664164 Bottle Glass 1 Brown, "FLE1SCHMANNS//EST. (bird symbol) 1870//HALF PINT',"Federal Law Forbids Sale or Reuse of this Bottle", on bottom D-247//96 / (vase with a M) /48//2/36308 16 CA-SDl-17408 469679 3664185 Jar Glass 1 Clear, Mason Jar with rubber seal and decomposing twist lid, on bottom ""Anchor Hawkins mark // l-K-383" 17 CA-SDl-17408 469679 3664185 Bottle Glass 1 Clear, "Federal Law Forbids Sale or Reuse of this Bottle",H &JA Gilbey LTD.//Gin, on bottom "R592//56- 42//8.//with Owens Illinois mark" Page 1 APPENDIX D MASTER CATALOG 07080213 Master Catalog Encinas Creek Bridge Monitoring 07/29/2010 Artifact number State Code County Code Site Number UTM E UTM N Depth (cm) Artifact type Material Count Weight (g) Comments 1 CA-SDl-17408 469653 3664220 15 Mano Granitic 1 1500 mano with hammerstone properties 2 CA-SDI-17408 469703 3664035 Mano Quartzite 1 750 FAR, bifacially ground and exhibits pecking 3 CA-SDl-17408 469712 3664108 FAR Quartzite 4 855 found in sewer pot hole 4 CA-SDl-17408 469712 3664108 Mano Quartzite 1 1000 found in sewer pot hole 5 CA-SDl-17408 N/A N/A Tool Meta-volcanic 1 38.9 found in pile of dirt, no prov. unifacially worked 6 CA-SDI-17408 469646 3664220 Chopper Meta-volcanic 1 1000 - 7 CA-SDl-17408 469646 3664220 Tool Meta-volcanic 1 39.2 bifacially flaked 8 CA-SDI-17408 469692 3664168 Scraper Meta-volcanic 1 30.4 turtle back scraper 9 CA-SDl-17408 469693 3664168 30 Ornament Shell 2 6.7 abalone pendant 10 CA-SDl-17408 N/A N/A Bead Shell 1 1.1 found in sewer pothole / olivella 11 CA-SDI-17408 N/A N/A Bead Shell 1 1 12 CA-SDI-17408 469687 3664180 6' Bottle Glass 1 Clear, complete without cap, "Federal Law Forbids Sale or Reuse of this Bottle" "ONE PINT", on bottom "Anchor Hawkins mark with D-126//67/44" 13 CA-SDI-17408 469722 3664066 Bottle Glass 1 Clear, no cap, "Pepsi Cola" on bottom "Des. Pat.120,277//15A54//124//3" 14 CA-SDI-17408 469712 3664108 Bottle Glass 1 Clear, "Santa Fe Select QualityVintage Co.//Re-filling Prohibited", on bottom "Des. Reg. U.S. Pat. Off.//610//LM _^ mark//E 15 CA-SDl-17408 469695 3664164 Bottle Glass 1 Brown, "FLEISCHMANNS//EST. (bird symbol) 1870//HALF PINr',"Federal Law Forbids Sale or Reuse of this Bottle", on bottom D-247//96 / (vase with a M) /48//2/36308 16 CA-SDI-17408 469679 3664185 Jar Glass 1 Clear, Mason Jar with rubber seal and decomposing twist lid, on bottom ""Anchor Hawkins mark // l-K-383" 17 CA-SDI-17408 469679 3664185 Bottle Glass 1 Clear, "Federal Law Forbids Sale or Reuse of this Bottle",H &JA Gilbey LTD.//Gin, on bottom "R592//56- 42I/8.II with Owens Illinois mark" . Page 1