Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1994-08-17; Planning Commission; ; SDP 94-05|MP 177K - GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENTAPPU~10N COMPLETE DATE: JUNE 7. 1994 STAFF PLANNER -JEFF GIBSON c{ftJ-. Sf AFP REPORT ® DATE: AUGUSf 17, 1994 TO: PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: PLANNING DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: SOP 94-05/MP 17700-GREYSfQNE RESIDENITAL DEVELOPMENf - Request for approval of a Site Development Plan and Minor Master Plan Amendment to construct 118 single family homes on pregraded, subdivided lots within Planning Area 24 in Phase II of the Aviara Master Plan, and to amend the development standards in Planning Area 24 of the master plan to allow a less restrictive 15 foot front yard setback for one-story, side-loaded garages. Planning Area 24 is generally located southeast of the Poinsettia Lane and Alga Road intersection, in Local Facilities Management Zone 19. I. RECOMMENDATION That the Planning Commission ADOPT Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 3702, and 3703, APPROVING SOP 94-05, and MP 177(1{), based on the findings and subject to the conditions contained therein. II. PROJECT DESCRIPTION & BACKGROUND Greystone Homes Inc., is requesting approval of a Minor Master Plan Amendment and Site Development Plan to allow the construction of 118 single-family homes in Aviara Planning Area 24, within Phase II of the master plan, and to amend the development standards in Planning Area 24 to allow a less restrictive 15 foot front yard setback (A 20 -24 foot setback is currently required) for one-story, side-loaded garages. A Site Development Plan is required according to Section III(B)(2) of the Aviara Master Plan (MP 177(J)), which states that no building permit may be issued within any planning area without the prior approval of a Site Development Plan. The intent of the Site Development Plan is to ensure that all applicable development standards and design criteria of the master plan are incorporated into any proposed construction. Aviara Planning Area 24 is located within Phase II of the master plan, southeast of the Poinsettia Lane and Alga Road intersection between Poinsettia Lane and Towhee Lane. The planning area has been partially graded as part of an approved grading permit and has been subdivided into 118 single-family lots and 5 open space lots by recorded Final Subdivision Map Nos. 12969 -12972. As shown on Exhibits "A" -"P", dated August 17, 1994, the planning area takes access off Alga Road at Towhee·Lane and Nightshade Road. SOP 94-05/MP 177(K) 0 GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AUGUST 17, 1994 PAGE 2 The proposed single-family homes will range in size from 2,175 to 2,770 square feet and will include both one and two-story homes. As illustrated on Exhibits "G" -"O", dated August 17, 1994, the proposed architecture is a contemporary Mediterranean style with tile roofs and stucco exteriors. To add visual interest to the neighborhood, each plan proposes three different front elevations with differing materials, window treatments, and roof configurations. The units are arranged with varied front and side yard setbacks and building orientations to provide a more pleasing street scene. Street trees, slope landscaping, and selective enhanced front yard landscaping will be installed by the developer. The applicant is also requesting an amendment to the Planning Area 24 section of the existing Aviara Master Plan text (MP 177(J)) to allow a less restrictive 15 foot front yard setback (A 20 -24 foot setback is currently required) for one-story, side-loaded garages. This proposal was placed on the Planning Commission agenda with the Site Development Plan because Section 21.38.120 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code requires that a Master Plan Amendment be presented to the Planning Commission to determine the magnitude of the request. If the Commission determines the amendment to be minor in nature, then the request can be approved by the Planning Commission in conjunction with the Site Development Plan. III. ANALYSIS 1. The findings required for the approval of a Site Development Plan can be found in Section 21.06.020 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code, as well as the attached Planning Commission Resolution No. 3702. Therefore, the following analysis stresses the essential aspects of these findings. A. Is the proposal consistent with the various elements and objectives of the General Plan? B. Is the proposal consistent with the applicable sections of the Aviara Master Plan (MP 177(J)) and the Carlsbad Municipal Code? C. Is the proposal consistent with the approved subdivision map (CT 90-15) for Planning Area 24? D. Will the proposal be properly related to the site, surroundings and environmental settings, not detrimental to existing or future uses, and not an adverse impact to the site, surroundings, or traffic circulation? SOP 94-05/MP 177(1<) " GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AUGUST 17, 1994 PAGE 3 2. Can the proposed Master Plan Amendment be considered minor in nature, according to the criteria in Section 21.38.120 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code? Is the less restrictive 15 foot front yard setback for side-loaded garages consistent with the intent of the master plan and compatible with the surrounding neighborhood? DISCUSSION 1. A. SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN: General Plan Consistency: The proposed development is consistent with the various goals and objectives of the General Plan. The Land Use Element designates the property for residential land use at a low-medium density (RLM). The project's density of 2.18 dwelling units per acre falls within the low-medium density range of 0.0 to 3.2 dwelling units per acre. Two objectives of the Circulation Element require adequate sidewalks and traffic safety measures for residential development. The proposed project will meet these objectives by including sidewalks on both sides of the street, the local streets are designed to meet all City Standards, and the proposed fencing would not interfere with intersection sight distance requirements. Due to the project's proximity to Alga Road, an arterial roadway, noise attenuation walls would be provided along the roadway to shield adjacent homes from excessive traffic noise. In addition, 18 of the homes would be required to include mechanical ventilation so that windows need not be opened and interior noise levels can be lowered to 45 dBA CNEL. By doing so, the project conforms with the goal of the Noise Element, which seeks to achieve and maintain an environment free from excessive or hannful noise~ All public facilities would be in place prior to or concurrent with development, in conformance with the objective of the Public Facilities Element. By adding housing stock to the City's housing inventory, the proposed single-family development is consistent with one of the goals of the Housing Element, which calls for the development of sufficient new housing to meet the City's share of the total regional housing need. There is also an affordable housing agreement for the Aviara Master Plan which ensures the provision of affordable housing for the master plan. The master plan developer is participating in the provision of affordable housing units as part of the Villas Affordable Housing Project located on the west side of El Camino Real in Local Facilities Management Zone· 21. As part of the approved subdivision (CT 90-15), 5 open space lots have been established that protect coastal sage scrub and chaparral habitat on the intervening hillsides throughout the project site, therefore, the development is consistent with the goals and objectives of the Local Coastal Program and the Open Space and Conservation Elements. SDP 94-05/MP 177(1<) C GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AUGUST 17, 1994 PAGE4 B. Aviara Master Plan and Municipal Code Consistency: The Aviara Master Plan contains most of the development standards and design criteria that guide development within Planning Area 24. In addition to the master plan criteria, the single family neighborhood is subject to the provisions of the R-1 Single Family Residential Zone. As part of this project the development standards for Planning Area 24 would be amended to allow a reduced 15 foot front yard setback for single-story, side- loaded garages on no more than 33% of the 118 lots. The applicant is proposing to develop 11 or 9% of the homes with 15 foot front yard setbacks and side-loaded garages. To offset every home that has a 15 foot front yard setback, an additional home would be required to have a 24 foot front yard setback where 20 feet is currently required. This will balance or average out the front yard setbacks, create larger offsets to enhance the street scene, while at the same time encouraging the use of side-loaded garages. The project's street scene can be improved by turning the garages to the side and away from the street, and by enhancing the landscaping and facade along the building elevation facing the street. The project also conforms to the required development standards as follows: (1) The rear yard setbacks conform to the 20 percent of the lot width standard; (2) At a minimum, 4 7 of the homes would have 24 foot front yard setbacks. 11 of the homes would have reduced 15 foot front yard setbacks with single-story, side-loaded garages, and the remaining homes would have, at a minimum, 20 foot front yard setbacks; (3) The homes would be setback a minimum of SO feet from Alga Road and future Poinsettia Lane; ( 4) The homes would be setback a minimum of 30 feet from the SDG&E powerline easement and 25 feet from the westerly planning area boundary; (5) At least 15% of each lot would be reserved for recreational open space; (6) As shown on Exhibits "G" -"O", dated August 17, 1994, all the homes within the planning area are limited to the maximum height of 30 feet, with the required minimum 15 percent of the homes being limited to one-story and 22 feet in height; (7) The architectural style would be in keeping with the master plan design criteria, which requires rectangular building forms, varied massing, and stucco exteriors with clay tile roofs. The architectural elevations have also been approved by the Aviara Master Association Architectural Review Committee; SOP 94-05/MP 177(K) GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AUGUST 17, 1994 PAGE 5 (8) All homes would have at a minimum a 20 feet by 20 feet, two car garage, with the majority of the homes containing a three car garage. The applicant is requesting, per Section 21.10.040 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code, that 19 or 16% of the homes be permitted to have a reduced side yard setback on one side of the lot. For administrative permits the Planning Director is given the authority to approve side yard reduction requests, however, since this is a Site Development Plan, the Planning Director is recommending that the Planning Commission approve the request based on the following findings: 1) On all the lots requesting a side yard reduction: (1) the reduced side yard is at least 5 feet wide; (2) the opposite side yard is at least 10 feet wide; and (3) the opposite side yard has been increased in width an amount equal to the reduction; 2) None of the reduced side yard setbacks abut another lot that also has a reduced side yard. In all cases where side yard reductions are requested there is at least 15 feet of building separation between the homes on adjoining lots; 3) When the homes are viewed from the street the reduced setback on one side of the lot would not be visually apparent due to the fact that adequate building separation would be maintained. Portions of the project site are graded with stepped building pads containing intervening fill slopes between the pads. A reduction in the side yard setback on the downhill side of the building pad would allow the home to be shifted away from the toe of the intervening uphill slope, thus, creating more level pad area for lot drainage along the side of the home. All of the large graded slopes along the perimeter and throughout the planning area would be planted with the permanent landscaping approved by the subdivision map (CT 90-15). As illustrated on Exhibit "P", dated August 17, 1994, the project's landscaping conforms to the provisions of the master plan and the City's Landscape Manual by providing street trees and slope planting. The developer would be required to provide the front yard landscaping for the homes having reduced 15 foot front yard setbacks and side-loaded garages per Exhibit "P", dated August 17, 1994. On the remaining lots the individual homeowner landscaping will be installed by the homeowner and each landscaping palate could vary. The perimeter planting contains trees and shrubs that will accomplish the necessary landscaped screening along Alga Road and all the fire suppression zones were established through the approved subdivision map. By incorporating these various aspects into the project, the Site Development Plan proposal has demonstrated consistency with the provisions of the Aviara Master Plan and the R-1 Single Family Residential Zone. SDP 94-05/MP 177(1() C GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AUGUST 17, 1994 PAGE6 C. Consistency with The Approved Subdivision Map: The proposed construction of the 118 single family dwellings does not include any changes to the approved lot lines or perimeter and slope landscaping. No alterations to the approved street, storm drain, sewer, or water line improvements are proposed with this development. Therefore, since no significant changes to the existing approvals are proposed, the Aviara Planning Area 24 Site Development Plan is consistent with the approved subdivision map (CT 90-15). D. Proper Relation to Site and Surroundings: Aviara Planning Area 24 is in the process of being graded and improved per the approved subdivision map (CT 90-15) and grading permit. The open space boundaries have already been established and all access points and internal circulation patterns have been set. The proposed construction of the homes on pregraded lots does not include any substantial changes to the existing grading plan, open space system, or circulation patterns. The single-family residential homes comply with adopted development standards. In addition, the homes would consist of a mix of one and two-stories and would incorporate a variety of setbacks, building elevations, materials, and roof lines. Since no substantial changes to the approved grading and circulation plans are proposed, and the buildings would vary in size, shape, and position on the lot, the proposed development in Planning Area 24 is properly related to the site, surroundings, and environmental setting. The proposed single-family residential development will not be detrimental to existing land uses or to the land uses specifically permitted in the area in which the proposed project is to be located. The surrounding land uses are the same as the proposed land use (RLM and Open Space) and are consistent with the Aviara Master Plan and the General Plan Land Use Element. The proposed single-family development will not adversely impact the site, surroundings, or traffic circulation since Aviara Planning Area 24 has been specifically designed for single-family development at a scale appropriate for 7,500 square foot single- family lots. 2. MASTER PLAN AMENDMENT: According to Section 21.38.120 of the Zoning Ordinance, a Minor Master Plan Amendment "shall not change the densities, or the boundaries of the property or involve an addition of a new use or group of uses not shown on the original master plan or the rearrangement of uses within the master plan". The proposed Master Plan Amendment involves an addition to the development standards for Planning Area 24. The minor amendment meets the criteria in Section 21.38.120 and would potentially affect only 38 single-family lots in the entire master plan by creating a development standard intended to enhance the planning area's street scene and encourage the use of single-story, side-loaded, garages, therefore, the Planning Director recommends that the Minor Master Plan Amendment be approved by the Planning Commission concurrently with the Site Development Plan. SOP 94-05/MP 177(K) GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AUGUST 17, 1994 PAGE 7 To meet the intent of the Aviara Master Plan to provide site plans that incorporate an informal, almost random arrangement of buildings and to create a neighborhood that has a varied and visually interesting street scene, the applicant is proposing to amend the development standards of Planning Area 24 in the following manner: (1) No more than 33% of the lots in the planning area would be permitted to contain a one-story, side-loaded garage with a reduced 15 foot front yard setback. These lots must be dispersed throughout the planning area. This would ensure that there is a variety of front yard setbacks along the street, ranging from 15 to 24 feet. If the standard is utilized to its fullest potential, 1 in every 3 homes could be located 5 feet closer to the street. (2) For every lot developed with a reduced 15 foot front yard setback associated with a side-loaded garage there would be an additional increase of 4 feet on a lot required to have a minimum 20 foot setback. This would help balance the front yard setbacks and create an average front yard setback closer to 20 feet. Creating this 15 to 24 feet offset accentuates the variation in the front yard setbacks and provides more visual relief and interest along the street. (3) Due to the fact that the home would be located 5 feet closer to the street, on lots containing the 15 foot front yard setback associated with a side-loaded garage, there would be a requirement for the developer to provide enhanced landscaping and building elevations on the side of the garage facing the street in order to soften the visual appearance of the structure. ( 4) Homes with the reduced front yard setback have been located on lots that have less level pad area. By placing the home 5 feet closer to the street there would be more level and useable pad area in the backyard of the home. · IV. ENVIRONMENf AL REVIEW In review of the proposed project the Planning Department has taken into consideration the Environmental Impact Report (EIR 83-02(A)) for the Aviara Master Plan and the Mitigated Negative Declaration that was completed in March 1991 when the planning area was subdivided into 118 residential lots, (CT 90-15/Final Maps 12969-12972). The proposed Site Development Plan is consistent with the mitigation requirements of these adopted environmental documents and the appropriate mitigation measures have been incorporated into Planning Commission Resolutions No. 3702. The site planning and construction of the 118 individual homes on already subdivided and graded lots would not create additional significant impacts beyond what was already discussed and evaluated in the two existing environmental documents. ,,...~ SOP 94-05/MP 177(K) ~ GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AUGUST 17, 1994 PAGES Homes would be setback a minimum of 50 feet from Alga Road, 28% of the homes are single-story, and the homes would incorporate design features such as varying front yard setbacks, enhanced building elevations, and varying roof lines, therefore, any subsequent visual impacts from the public roadways would be reduced to below a level of significance. In addition, the Minor Master Plan Amendment to allow the reduced front yard setback for side-loaded garages would also not significantly impact the environment. Creating a new development standard that encourages the design of garages that do not face directly onto the public right-of-way, and requires enhanced architecture and landscaping along the front building elevations would help reduce visual impacts along the street. The Planning Director has determined that the project is in prior compliance with EIR 83- 02(A) and the Mitigated Negative Declaration for CT 90-15, on file in the Planning Department, and there are no additional significant adverse environmental impacts associated with the project, therefore, no further environmental review of this project is required. The Planning Director will send a Notice of Determination to the County Clerk upon approval of the project by the Planning Commission. V. SUMMARY Considering that the proposed single-family development meets all applicable development standards, the Master Plan Amendment is minor in nature and meets the intent of the Aviara Master Plan, and will not have any significant adverse environmental impacts, staff is recommending approval of SOP 94-05/MP 177(K). ATIACHMENfS 1. Planning Commission Resolution No. 3702 2. Planning Commission Resolution No. 3703 3. Location Map 4. Background Data Sheet 5. Disclosure Statement 6. Local Facilities Impact Assessment Form 7. Reduced Exhibits 8. Exhibits "A" -''P", dated August 17, 1994. JG:lh JULY 12, 1994 AR'ORT 11111111111: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ,...... : • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .......... : • • • • • • • 111111111•: MTIQUITOS LAGOON GREYSTONE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMEN • City of Carlsbad MP 177(K)/ SDP 94-05 C BACKGROUND DATA SHEET :> CASE NO: SOP 94-05/MP 177(1() CASE NAME: Greystone Residential Development APPLICANT: Greystone Homes Inc. REQUFSf AND LOCATION: A Site Development Plan and Master Plan Amendment for the construction of 118 single family homes on pregraded, subdivided lots within Planning Area 24 of the Aviara Master Plan, located southeast of the Poinsettia Lane and Alga Road intersection. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Units 1 -4, Lots 1 -122 of Carlsbad Tract No. CT 90-15, Aviara Planning Area 24, City of Carlsbad, according to Map Nos. 12969 -12972, filed on September 17, 1992, in the Office of the County Recorder. County of San Diego, State of California. APN: 215-642-01 -35/215-641-01 -32/215-640-01 -OS Acres 54.6 Proposed No. of Lots/Units 122 lots/118 units (Assessor's Parcel Number) GENERAL PLAN AND ZONING Land Use Designation _.RL=M......_ ___________ _ Density Allowed 3.2 dus/acre Density Proposed 2.18 dus/acre Existing Zone _ ___.P __ -C=-----Proposed Zone ---=-P....a-C"---- Surrounding Zoning and Land Use: (See attached for information on Carlsbad's Zoning Requirements) PUBLIC F ACILffiES Site North South East West Zoning Land Use P-C L-C P-C L-C P-C Partially Graded Open Space Alga Road Agriculture/Open Space Alga Road/PA 25 School District Carlsbad Water District Carlsbad Sewer District Carlsbad Equivalent Dwelling Units (Sewer Capacity) .... l,._.1...,8=.0.._ ______________ _ Public Facilities Fee Agreement, dated ..... M ...... a"""y--=27....,, ....... 1 ..... 9._.9....,.4...__ _____________ _ ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT _ Negative Declaration, issued _____________________ _ Certified Environmental Impact Report, dated ________________ _ Other, Prior Compliance with EIR and Mitigated Negative Declaration JG:lh 01Y OF CARLSBAD GROWTI-1 MANAGEMENT PROGRAM LOCAL FAClLITIF.S IMPACTS ASSESSMENT FORM (To be Submitted with Development Application) PROJECT IDENTIIY AND IMPACT ASSESSMENT: FILE NAME AND NO: Greystone Residential Development -SDP 94-05/MP 177(K} LOCAL FACIU1Y MANAGEMENT ZONE: 19 GENERAL PLAN: RLM ZONING: DEVELOPER'S NAME: Greystone Homes Inc ADDRESS: 495 E. Rincon Suite 115 Corona CA 91719 P-C PHONE NO: (909) 273-9494 ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NO: 215-642-01 -35/215-641-01 -32/215-640-01 -OS QUANTI1Y OF LAND USE/DEVELOPMENT (AC., SQ. FT., DU): 54.6 acres, 118 dwelling units ESTIMATED COMPLETION DATE: A B. C. D. E. F. G. H. I. J. K. City Administrative Facilities: Demand in Square Footage = Library: Demand in Square Footage= Wastewater Treatment Capacity (Calculate with J. Sewer) Park: Demand in Acreage = Drainage: Demand in CFS= Identify Drainage Basin = (Identify master plan facilities on site plan) Circulation: Demand in ADTs = (Identify Trip Distribution on site plan) Fire: Served by Fire Station No. = Open Space: Acreage Provided - Schools: (Demands to be determined by staff) Sewer: Demand in EDUs - Identify Sub Basin - (Identify trunk line(s) impacted on site plan) Water: Demand in GPD - 436.37 233.4 0.874 NIA DC 1,180 4 NIA NIA 118.0 19A 25,960 ) 1 [~ r PLAN I FLOOR PLAN AVIARA BEDROOM OPTION (~ 1] r -~ .-----... ul MEDIA OPTION CARLSBAD.CALFORNIA C,RE VSTOI,£ HOMcS . ~ 48 -c¼--==-"lc----~4 t 1"t t II I R+ ' [ I CAR GARAGE o;r.,r lltllHJUM'-'l lit:GIA<Jt'IOO 2175 SOFT Qf!:! IO'•lt 1BEDAOOM/25 BAnt/DENIFAl\,W. V 1NOQK BEDROOM 4 OPTION/MEDIA OPT ION (1T~-:"· ~) I IJ I ,..,., .... ,~) ~-z-(~- llllBM o·,u WJlM. o-,o- 2 CAR GARAGE /l),;x) Oul I ' I r ;;J (WH; SHI ~Pl'fV Ht /MAI HAL.CH l AS.'illl IAl~S INC r A•'"' Ii' I 11•t "' AIIIII II<. I" I I a1g• 1 0 u (1.1 I CONCRETE S TLE WOOOFASOA STUCCO 0/ TAM WROUGl1T RONDETAL __ ~,.- WOOO StUT TEA.. _ STUCCO 01 TAM_ /- Pl.AN 1 / FRONT ELEVATIONS AVIARA CARSBAO CAU'OANA GREYSlOI-E 1-tOM:S C SECT ION GARAGE DOOR , .. , i - liti()WN W/'-':DIA ROOM OPTION '--..._ 8 WOOO OUTLOOKEA CONCRETE S TLE STUCCO RECESS STUCCO WOOOSHJTTER W0005t£LF A t 5HIH'f'H HU Mt\l HAICH AS.SOCl/\1 lS. INC WOOOFASOA WROUGHT RONDElAL ll ~) ~~ l' '.. ~"'TI ----r-..._ I r--· ~IO.<OW r r-J)' h ~ PlAN2 FLO<lfl PlAN AVIARA CARLSBAD, CALFORNA GR::YSTOI-E HOM'.S llOOM llOOM ·~ V,v I I I I l..f'PER LEVEL 1060 SOFT l ... ii" o o · 1 · r 7 · ' cftmts t) 0 -0 o .. 0(, 0 1 rr :l:.::l; I 1 ! ,I •··•' Jll~ ~T:J I I -_ . ri1m;) -0 ·"' II I l!!i 1 7 i~1/4t!f , ~ti ~ . • . ~ BA CI-N .... IIJi 2500 SO Fl 4 BEDROOM/358ATtVFAMLYINOOK DEN OPTION '"·· t -l 3 CARGARAQE "''"' -... ~,-,,.,_ .................. " c.c..-.-~--:e-- LOWER LEVEL 1440 SOFT t SHI EPP£Y HEZMALIIALCH ASSOCIATES. INC ~~s STUCCO DETAL_ STUCCO 0/ TRM ~ PI.AN2 FRONT ELEVATIONS AVIARA CARLSBAD. CALFOANIA GREYSTOI-E HOl'JES STUCCO COLWN ""'-. ', ,,, r C WOC,:, SHJT TEA CONCRETES TLE A t,«[_~f~ / STUCCO ,,. _WOOO OUTLOOKER CONCRETES TLE B WROUGHT RON OE TAL .CONCAE TE S TLE SECTIONAL GARAGE DOOR SHLEl'PEY HEZMALH/\LCH ASSOCIATES INC 1T RONOETAL ~~) l>'I="'° ai..c.- PLAN3 FLOOR PLAN "AVIARA CARLSBAD, CALFOINA GAE YSTOI£ HOf,£5 <,- r~1 , 'C1 l U'PER LEVEL 1240 SOFT 1-46" l :n~~): ( l I • I I i J ~1 l £Hit.HU ·I JI _~ ( -=-- Qftl .... 8t_LH':)J,l(Jlf'10f 3CAflQARAGE I :1,-» I ----------~:::_--~ .. -~ .. " 2770SOFT 4 BEDROOM/4 BATH/DEN/FAMLY /NOOK BEDROOM 5 OP flON .... r~r r LOWER LEVEL 1530 SOFT t ~tLEPl'£Y HEZMALHALCH ASSOCIATES INC lllf!M ~ (j.0 ..... STUCCOO/ T- WOOOSl-£1.F_ ........___ ~ PLAN3 FRONT ELEVATIONS AVIARA CAR..SBAD. CALFOANA GAEYSTOl',E HOMcS CONCRETE S TLE STUCCO DETAL C , .. ,~.□- B STUCCO 0 1 TRIM CONCRETES TLE /~ STUCCO DETAL A ~ _WOOO TRELLIS -SECTIONAL GARAGE DOOR SHLEPPEY HEZM/\LH/\LCH ASS00/\1 ES INC ~2) J -