Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
2020-06-03; Planning Commission; ; CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF
Item No. Application complete date: March 21, 2020 P.C. AGENDA OF: June 3, 2020 Project Planner: Cliff Jones Project Engineer: Kyrenne Chua SUBJECT: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF - Request for approval of a Conditional Use Permit to allow the installation, operation, and maintenance of a temporary Wireless Communications Facility (WCF) consisting of two 55-foot-tall ground mounted faux mono-eucalyptus trees and an equipment enclosure constructed of an 8’- 6” tall tan vinyl fence with lattice located on a graded 5.54-acre site at 3465 Trailblazer Way, in the Open Space (O-S) zone, within Planning Area 12 of the Robertson Ranch Master Plan and in Local Facilities Management Zone 14. The City Planner has determined that the project belongs to a class of projects that the State Secretary of Resources has found not to have a significant impact on the environment, and is therefore categorically exempt from the requirement for the preparation of environmental documents pursuant to Section 15303 – New Construction of Small Structures, of the State CEQA Guidelines. I. RECOMMENDATION That the Planning Commission ADOPT Planning Commission Resolution No. 7370 APPROVING Conditional Use Permit CUP 2019-0032 for a period of 3 years, based upon the findings and subject to the conditions contained therein. II. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND BACKGROUND Project Setting: The 5.54-acre project site is located at 3465 Trailblazer Way, near the northeast corner of El Camino Real and Cannon Road, within Planning Area 12 and the West Village of the Robertson Ranch Master Plan. According to the Robertson Ranch Master Plan, Planning Area 12 is a 16.1-gross-acre site intended to be developed by the city as a park (Trailblazer Park) with sports fields and associated lighting, parking and other recreational uses. Approximately two acres of the 16.1-gross-acre site is currently improved with Carlsbad Fire Station 3. Planning Area 12 consists of three separate parcels with the WCF proposed on the southernmost portion of the site that is 5.54-acres in size and nearest to Cannon Road. However, the total lease area for the proposed WCF is only 1,210 square feet. In addition to the fire station, the project site is surrounded by both open space and residential uses with access through the residential neighborhood. Table A below includes the General Plan designations, zoning and current land uses of the project site and surrounding properties. 4 CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF June 3, 2020 Page 2 TABLE A - Zoning and General Plan Designations Location General Plan Designation Zoning Current Land Use Site Open Space (OS) Planned Community (P-C) Fire Station 3 and undeveloped park site North Open Space (OS) and R-8 Planned Community (P-C) Open space and single- family residential South Open Space (OS) and R-8 Planned Community (P-C) Open space and Rancho Carlsbad Mobile Home Park East R-4 and R-8 Planned Community (P-C) Single-family and multi- family residential West Open Space (OS) Planned Community (P-C) Open Space Background: The proposed project is a temporary multi-carrier WCF to be used as a short-term replacement for four carriers including AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon Wireless and Sprint until a permanent location is available. Currently, there are three existing WCF’s located along a ridge above Bobby’s Hideaway Café on the south side of El Camino Real west of the W. Ranch Street entrance to Robertson Ranch. The existing WCF site is proposed to be developed into a new mixed-use community, Marja Acres, that will displace the existing WCF’s. The leases for the three existing WCFs expired this year, and building permits were recently issued for the decommissioning and removal of all three WCFs. The applicant is currently paying penalties to remain at the current site and do not have rights to remain. Immediate removal of the WCF at the existing site could be required. A temporary location is required for AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon Wireless and Sprint to maintain current network coverage for existing customers and ensure continuity of emergency services. The applicant, Crown Castle, in conjunction with the cellular companies, worked for over three years to find an alternative location on the existing property. However, none of the locations were suitable to meet coverage needs as the existing facility is being reduced in height by grading that will lower the ground elevation. Due to the expired leases and the inability to find a location on the existing property, the four major cellular carriers are seeking approval for a temporary facility while they continue their due diligence to identify a permanent relocation site. The proposed site was selected as it is considered the only suitable location that could meet all of the applicant’s criteria necessary for a WCF. The criteria includes but is not limited to receiving a license agreement from the city in a timely manner, providing coverage to a sizeable portion of the coverage gap that will be produced by the loss of the three existing WCF facilities, and ensuring that the site is not encumbered with conservation easements that would preclude development of the WCF. The WCF is considered temporary as the proposed conditional use permit approval term is limited to three (3) years with the ability of the City Planner to approve three (3) additional one-year (1-year) extensions. The temporary site will allow the four carriers to remain on air and provide continued service to existing customers until a permanent facility can be identified and developed with approval of a permanent CUP. The applicants are confident that they will be able to accomplish development of a permanent site within three to six years. CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF June 3, 2020 Page 3 Proposed Project The project consists of the installation, operation, and maintenance of an unmanned WCF consisting of two 55-foot-tall faux mono-eucalyptus trees. The WCF is proposed to be approximately 520 feet to the west of the existing fire station. The site will be accessed from Trailblazer Way through the undeveloped vacant park land. A total of 36 panel antennas (nine for each carrier) and four microwave dishes (one for each carrier) are screened behind the faux trees leaves and branches. There are two carriers on each tree, three panels per sector at three sectors, for a total of nine antennas per carrier. The WCF installation is temporary as the faux trees are proposed on non-permanent ballasts. Also included is the installation of a new ground mounted 22-foot by 55-foot equipment enclosure with associated equipment. The ground equipment is proposed on a temporary platform which can be easily removed. The equipment enclosure is visually screened by an 8-6” tall vinyl equipment enclosure comprised of a six-foot-tall tan vinyl fence with a two-foot six-inch-tall tan vinyl lattice atop the vinyl fence. The combination of vinyl fence/lattice will ensure the equipment is screened from view. The facility will operate 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Since the facility is unmanned, it will not generate any traffic. Maintenance of the facility is needed no more than monthly visits by the carriers except in cases of emergencies. If an emergency arises, it is expected that maintenance crews will be immediately dispatched to correct the situation. The applicant is not proposing backup generators as it is not feasible to incorporate the generators while balancing factors important to the temporary site such as a small footprint and noise levels. III. ANALYSIS The proposed Wireless Communication Facility is subject to the following regulations and requirements: A. General Plan Land Use designation – Open Space (OS); B. Robertson Ranch Master Plan (MP 02-03H), underlying Open Space (O-S) zone designation (Chapter 21.33 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code); C. Wireless Communication Facilities Policy (City Council Policy Statement No. 64); D. Conditional Use Permit Regulations (Chapter 21.42 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code); and E. Growth Management Ordinance (Chapter 21.90 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code) and Zone 14 Local Facilities Management Plan. The recommendation for approval of the project was developed by analyzing the project’s consistency with the applicable city regulations and policies. The project’s compliance with each of the above regulations is discussed in detail in the sections below. A. General Plan Land Use Designation – Open Space (OS) The project site is designated Open Space (OS) on the city’s General Plan Land Use Map. The proposed WCF is consistent with the OS General Plan Land Use designation in that the OS Land Use designation does not preclude the use of WCF’s. The proposed use will serve and benefit the residential and business community and region as a whole, including emergency service providers. Therefore, the proposed WCF use is consistent with the OS General Plan Land Use designation. B. Robertson Ranch Master Plan (MP 02-03H) and underlying Open Space (O-S) zone (Chapter 21.33 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code) CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF June 3, 2020 Page 4 The proposed WCF consisting of two temporary 55-foot tall faux mono-eucalyptus trees is located within a portion of PA 12 of the Robertson Ranch Master Plan. Planning Area (PA) 12 has an underlying zone designation of Open Space (O-S) which allows for wireless communication facilities (WCFs) subject to approval of a conditional use permit (CUP) and all proposed development in PA 12 is subject to approval of a CUP. The project is required to comply with the standards outlined in the Master Plan and all applicable regulations and development standards of the O-S zone. The O-S zone does not specify any setbacks, lot coverage or lot size requirements. It does, however, specify that structures shall not exceed 25 feet tall unless a higher elevation is approved by the Planning Commission through a CUP. This topic is discussed in Sections C and D, Conditional Use Permit and City Council Policy No. 64. The project’s compliance with the unique Development Standards of the Master Plan for PA 12 is outlined in Table B. TABLE B – COMPLIANCE WITH THE ROBERTSON RANCH MASTER PLAN Setbacks A 40-foot structural setback shall be provided from the right-of-way on Cannon Road. The WCF is set back 55 feet from Cannon Road. A 60-foot setback shall be provided from native vegetation to combustible structures. The WCF is set back at least 500 feet from native vegetation. C. Wireless Communication Facilities Policy (City Council Policy Statement No. 64) Pursuant to Carlsbad Municipal Code (CMC) Section 21.42.140.B.165.b, a WCF Conditional Use Permit (CUP) application that does not comply with both the preferred location and the stealth design review and approval guidelines of City Council Policy Statement No. 64 (Policy 64) shall be conditionally approved or denied by the Planning Commission. The WCF has been designed using “stealth” design techniques consistent with the Policy 64 design review guidelines; however, it does not comply with the height recommendation as listed in Design Guideline B.4 of Policy 64. Specifically, a WCF should adhere to the existing height limitations of the zone in which it is located unless a higher elevation is approved. Pursuant to CMC Section 21.33.060, no building or structure in the Open Space (O-S) zone shall exceed twenty-five in height unless additional height is approved by the Planning Commission through the CUP. The proposed faux eucalyptus trees’ foliage measures 55 feet high from grade with the top tier of the collocated antennas mounted at a height of 50 feet and the lower tier at 40 feet. However, there are relatively no visual impacts in locating the antennas at the proposed heights. The WCF antennas will all be screened within the branches and dense foliage of the faux mono- eucalyptus trees which are near other existing mature trees of similar height to provide additional buffering and softening. Although the WCF will be visible to the residential homes within the Foothill Community to the north, the distance to the nearest residence is over 500 feet. The antennas are mounted at this height to meet the Radio Frequency (RF) calculations of clearance from solid interference (obstructions), FCC standards and the minimum needs of all four wireless carriers. Attachment 5 are photo simulations of the proposed faux eucalyptus trees and equipment enclosure, and Attachment 6 is a photo of a similarly constructed faux eucalyptus tree. The WCF project is also proposed in a discouraged location as listed in Location Guideline A.2.a. of Policy 64 (although it is proposed within a future park site and park sites are identified as preferred locations per Policy 64). Specifically, a WCF should not locate within an O-S zone or lot unless the applicant demonstrates no feasible alternative exists that can accommodate the applicant’s proposed facility. CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF June 3, 2020 Page 5 After analyzing approximately twelve other potential sites, the applicant has demonstrated that no location in a preferred zone or area as listed in Location Guideline A.1. can accommodate the proposed facility. Therefore, staff is recommending approval of the proposed temporary WCF at this location (See attachment No. 4 - Alternative Site Analysis). As mentioned, the WCF has been designed using “stealth” design techniques and is consistent with the Design Guidelines listed in Policy 64. The proposed equipment enclosure located at the base of the fauxtrees is designed so that the equipment cabinets will be screened by 8’-6” fencing. The 36 panel antennas are small in scale and mounted as closely as possible to the faux-tree “trunk” poles. The placement of the antennas will reduce an outward noticeable appearance, and the antennas will be concealed behind the faux-tree branches and leaves, thereby minimizing any visual impacts. A detailed photo simulation was prepared and is included as Attachment No. 5 to the staff report. Additionally, a Radio Frequency (RF) Electromagnetic Fields Exposure Study was prepared by Hammett & Edison, Inc. Consulting Engineers (March 10, 2020) demonstrating that the cumulative exposure levels from this facility will be well below the Federal Communication Commission’s (FCC) Maximum Permissible Exposure (MPE) limits for the public. Furthermore, in accordance with Performance Guideline C.5 of Policy 64, the project has also been conditioned to comply with FCC RF Exposure Guidelines. Lastly, because the proposed CUP is for a temporary term, any future permanent installation of WCF(s) for the carriers will be subject to an amended or new CUP for the permanent location and will need to demonstrate compliance with Policy 64 at that time. D. Conditional Use Permit Regulations (Chapter 21.42 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code) The proposed project is a use which is allowed in the Planned Community (P-C) Zone and Robertson Ranch Master Plan (Planning Area 12) subject to the approval of a conditional use permit (CUP). The Carlsbad Municipal Code has no separate provisions for temporary CUPs, so this request follows the procedures and requirements like any other CUP request. Chapter 21.42 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code requires that four findings be made in order to approve a CUP. All of these findings can be made for this project as discussed below. Conditional uses such as WCFs possess unique and special characteristics that make it impractical to include them as permitted uses “by right” in any of the various zoning classifications (i.e. residential, commercial, office, industrial, and open space). The authority for the location and operation of these uses is subject to City Council Policy Statement No. 64 – Wireless Communication Facilities Policy (see discussion in Section D below), Planning Commission review and the issuance of a CUP. Staff has reviewed the proposed project and found that all of the necessary findings can be made to approve the CUP. In summation, the required CUP findings can be made for the proposed WCF as it is a desirable critical component of the regional communications system for emergency services, and thus a necessary public convenience; and with its stealth design as two faux eucalyptus trees, sufficiently screened equipment enclosure, and mature landscape at the property’s perimeter, is not visually intrusive or incompatible with adjacent residential land uses. The required findings and satisfaction of these findings are provided below. 1. That the requested use is necessary or desirable for the development of the community, and is in harmony with the various elements and objectives of the general plan, including, if applicable, the certified local coastal program, specific plan or master plan, in that the use is consistent with the General Plan in that the Open Space Land Use designation does not preclude the provision of WCF uses. The Robertson Ranch Master Plan PA 12 states that uses are allowed per the Open Space (O- S) zone, CMC Chapter 21.33; WCFs are conditionally permitted uses on the Open Space zone. The requested temporary use is considered necessary for the development of the community as it is a CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF June 3, 2020 Page 6 desirable critical component of the regional communications system for emergency services, and thus a necessary public convenience. The temporary location for four wireless carriers is critical to ensure continued service for existing customers and for emergency communications within this area of the city. Although the WCF is proposed within an Open Space zone, which is not identified as a preferred location per City Council Policy No. 64, it is proposed within a future park site and park sites are identified as preferred locations per City Council Policy No. 64. Therefore, the WCF is at a site that will be a preferred location in the future. Lastly, the stealth, temporary faux-tree design complies with the General Plan objectives that seek to maintain and enhance Carlsbad’s appearance by screening the cellular equipment within the faux trees. 2. That the requested use is not detrimental to existing uses or to uses specifically permitted in the zone in which the proposed use is to be located in that the proposed temporary WCF is stealthily disguised as two faux mono-eucalyptus trees and visually blends with the existing mature landscaping at the property’s perimeter so as not to be visually intrusive or incompatible with adjacent residential land uses. Additionally, a Radio Frequency (RF) Electromagnetic Fields Exposure Study was prepared by Hammett & Edison, Inc. (March 10, 2020) demonstrating that the operation of up to four wireless carriers from this facility will be well below the Federal Communication Commission’s (FCC) Maximum Permissible Exposure (MPE) limits for the public. Furthermore, in accordance with Performance Guideline C.5 of City Council Policy Statement No. 64, the project has also been conditioned to comply with FCC RF Exposure Guidelines. The approval of the WCF will not preclude the future park use that is specifically intended for PA 12 because the CUP will be limited in duration to an initial term of three years. Three additional one-year extensions could be approved at the discretion of the city planner provided such extensions would not interfere with the development of the future park. It is estimated that planning, design and construction for the future Trailblazer Park at the subject property could take between three and six years. The proposed CUP time frame provides adequate time to allow for both the design and development of the park and the identification of a permanent site for the WCF. 3. That the site for the proposed conditional use is adequate in size and shape to accommodate the yards, setbacks, walls, fences, parking, loading facilities, buffer areas, landscaping and other development features prescribed in this code and required by the City Planner, planning commission or City Council, in order to integrate the use with other uses in the neighborhood, in that the proposed WCF consisting of two 55-foot tall ground mounted faux mono-eucalyptus trees and a ground mounted equipment enclosure complies with all requirements of the code, with the exception of the O-S zone 25-foot structure height limit that may be exceeded with the approval of the CUP. The site size and shape are adequate to accommodate the required separation from Cannon Road and natural habitat. The WCF is stealthily disguised as faux eucalyptus trees, which visually blend with the existing mature landscaping at the property’s perimeter so as to not be visually intrusive or incompatible with adjacent residential land uses. Although the WCF will be visible to the residential homes within the Foothill Community to the north, the size of the site is adequate to ensure the distance from the temporary WCF to the nearest residence is over 500 feet. Lastly, ground mounted equipment will be adequately screened by an 8-6” tall vinyl equipment enclosure comprised of a six-foot-tall tan vinyl fence with a two-foot six-inch-tall tan vinyl lattice atop the vinyl fence. The combination of vinyl fence/lattice will ensure the equipment is screened from view of the neighborhood. 4. That the street system serving the proposed use is adequate to properly handle all traffic generated by the proposed use in that the use generates very little traffic, requiring only one routine monthly CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF June 3, 2020 Page 7 maintenance visit and the occasional emergency visit in response to operational problems. The existing street system is adequate to property handle any traffic generated by the use. 5. That the increase in the height limit of 25 feet for the O-S zone is necessary for the proposed WCF in that an increase in the O-S zone height limit from 25 feet to 55 feet is the minimum necessary to accommodate the four wireless carriers, allow the antennas to meet the Radio Frequency (RF) calculations of clearance from solid interference (obstructions) and FCC standards. The antennas cannot be located lower on shorter faux trees as the height is needed to maintain the same level of service to the community without cellular interference, ensure the minimum separation between carriers’ antennas is maintained, and maintain the current E911 system supporting emergency services. To maintain that service and avoid significant gaps in cellular coverage for all four carriers, the proposed 55-foot height is necessary. E. Growth Management Ordinance (Chapter 21.90 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code) and Zone 14 Local Facilities Management Plan. The proposed WCF is located in Local Facilities Management Plan Zone 14. Installation of the facility on the existing site and monthly facility maintenance visits will not result in increased public facilities demands. Therefore, the project would not exceed performance standards for public facilities. IV. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW The City Planner has determined that the project belongs to a class of projects that the State Secretary for Resources has found do not have a significant impact on the environment, and it is therefore categorically exempt from the requirement for the preparation of environmental documents pursuant to Section 15303 (Construction and installation of small new equipment facilities or structures) of the state CEQA Guidelines. Additionally, as Crown Castle must comply with FCC regulations, it has been determined that the cumulative radio frequency emissions from the proposed WCF are below levels established as acceptable by the FCC and are therefore not considered a health hazard. In making this determination, the City Planner has found that the exceptions listed in Section 15300.2 of the state CEQA Guidelines do not apply to this project. V. DEVELOPMENT PROJECT PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT POLICY The proposed project is subject to the Early Public Notice and the Enhanced Stakeholder Outreach processes outlined in City Council Policy No. 84 – Development Project Public Involvement Policy. The policy requires applicants of certain development projects, such as the proposed Conditional Use Permit, to provide an opportunity for, and to consider input from, interested and affected stakeholders prior to project consideration by city decision-makers. Before an application for the WCF site was formally submitted on September 9, 2019, the applicant met with the city at least three times between October 15, 2018, and August 20, 2019. There was input from city staff to reduce the height of the single 75-foot tall pole envisioned at that time and/or to add stealth characteristics to it. There was a general agreement to propose the temporary WCF close to the existing tall fire station and the taller trees along Cannon Road within the future park site in PA 12 of the Robertson Ranch Master Plan. CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF June 3, 2020 Page 8 On October 29, 2019, Crown Castle (the applicant) representatives held an informational open-house meeting at Sage Creek High School to inform residents of the project and to listen to community concerns. Approximately 15-20 individuals attended the meeting. Project renderings as well as other exhibits were posted for the public to review. The applicant discussed the proposed WCF and its operations. Verbal feedback received from the public fell along two main issues: a) concerns about visual impact (including related concerns about potential effects to real estate value); and b) electromagnetic emissions (EM) concerns. A third recurring but less predominant theme was the proposed location and its relation to existing residences. Residents raising this concern were unanimous in their feedback that if a WCF was to be located at the proposed site, they would prefer it closer to the intersection of Cannon Road and El Camino Real, further away from the residents. After meeting with City officials over resident concerns, the applicant revised the application to include the residents’ preferred location with the two faux mono-eucalyptus trees. On January 15, 2020, Crown Castle and the four carrier partners held a second outreach meeting at Sage Creek High School with the revised proposal. Approximately 10-15 individuals attended the meeting. Several questions were asked from the residents and feedback was provided by Crown Castle. Verbal feedback received from the public primarily included: a) concerns about loss of cellular coverage; b) concerns about potential effects to real estate value; c) health concerns related to the proposal; and d) length of CUP approval. Since this most recent meeting, Crown Castle has not received any new feedback from the community. Additionally, since the revised application was presented at the meeting and as of the date of report preparation, staff has not received any correspondence from the public in opposition to the proposed design. A summary of the applicant’s outreach efforts and public comments received are provided within the attached Enhanced Stakeholder Outreach Report. The early public notice and the informational meetings described above satisfy the requirements of City Council Policy No. 84. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Planning Commission Resolution No. 7370 2. Location Map 3. Disclosure Statement 4. Alternative Site Analysis 5. Photo Simulations 6. Constructed Faux Eucalyptus Tree Photo 7. Enhanced Stakeholder Outreach Report 8. Radio Frequency Study 9. Reduced Exhibits 10. Exhibits “A” – “P” dated June 3, 2020 11. Public Comments A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ALLOW FOR THE INSTALLATION, OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF A TEMPORARY WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS FACILITY (WCF) CONSISTING OF TWO 55-FOOT-TALL GROUND MOUNTED FAUX MONO-EUCALYPTUS TREES AND AN EQUIPMENT ENCLOSURE CONSTRUCTED OF AN 8’-6” TALL TAN VINYL FENCE WITH LATTICE LOCATED ON A GRADED 5.54-ACRE SITE AT 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY, IN THE OPEN SPACE (O-S) ZONE, WITHIN PLANNING AREA 12 OF THE ROBERTSON RANCH MASTER PLAN AND IN LOCAL FACILITIES MANAGEMENT ZONE 14. CASE NAME: TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF CASE NO.: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) WHEREAS, Crown Castle USA Inc., “Developer,” has filed a verified application with the City of Carlsbad regarding property owned by City of Carlsbad, “Owner,” described as That portion of Parcel 2 of Lot Line Adjustment ADJ 01-13 per Certificate of Compliance CE 01-55, Recorded November 28, 2001 as File No. 2001-0865065, in the City of Carlsbad, County of San Diego, State of California (“the Property”); and WHEREAS, said verified application constitutes a request for a Conditional Use Permit as shown on Exhibit(s) “A” – “P” dated June 3, 2020, on file in the Planning Division, CUP 2019-0032 – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF, as provided by Chapter 21.42 of the Carlsbad Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission did, on June 3, 2020, hold a duly noticed public hearing as prescribed by law to consider said request; and WHEREAS, at said public hearing, upon hearing and considering all testimony and arguments, if any, of all persons desiring to be heard, said Commission considered all factors relating to the CUP. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad as follows: A)That the foregoing recitations are true and correct. PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 7370 ATTACHMENT 1 PC RESO NO. 7370 -2- B) That based on the evidence presented at the public hearing, the Commission APPROVES CUP 2019-0032 – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF, based on the following findings and subject to the following conditions: Findings: 1. That the requested use is necessary or desirable for the development of the community, and is in harmony with the various elements and objectives of the general plan, including, if applicable, the certified local coastal program, specific plan or master plan, in that the use is consistent with the General Plan in that the Open Space Land Use designation does not preclude the provision of WCF uses. The Robertson Ranch Master Plan PA 12 states that uses are allowed per the Open Space (O-S) zone, CMC Chapter 21.33; WCFs are conditionally permitted uses on the Open Space zone. The requested temporary use is considered necessary for the development of the community as it is a desirable critical component of the regional communications system for emergency services, and thus a necessary public convenience. The temporary location for four wireless carriers is critical to ensure continued service for existing customers and for emergency communications within this area of the city. Although the WCF is proposed within an Open Space zone, which is not identified as a preferred location per City Council Policy No. 64, it is proposed within a future park site and park sites are identified as preferred locations per City Council Policy No. 64. Therefore, the WCF is at a site that will be a preferred location in the future. Lastly, the stealth, temporary faux-tree design complies with the General Plan objectives that seek to maintain and enhance Carlsbad’s appearance by screening the cellular equipment within the faux trees. 2. That the requested use is not detrimental to existing uses or to uses specifically permitted in the zone in which the proposed use is to be located in that the proposed temporary WCF is stealthily disguised as two faux mono-eucalyptus trees and visually blends with the existing mature landscaping at the property’s perimeter so as not to be visually intrusive or incompatible with adjacent residential land uses. Additionally, a Radio Frequency (RF) Electromagnetic Fields Exposure Study was prepared by Hammett & Edison, Inc. (March 10, 2020) demonstrating that the operation of up to four wireless carriers from this facility will be well below the Federal Communication Commission’s (FCC) Maximum Permissible Exposure (MPE) limits for the public. Furthermore, in accordance with Performance Guideline C.5 of City Council Policy Statement No. 64, the project has also been conditioned to comply with FCC RF Exposure Guidelines. The approval of the WCF will not preclude the future park use that is specifically intended for PA 12 because the CUP will be limited in duration to an initial term of three years. Three additional one-year extensions could be approved at the discretion of the city planner provided such extensions would not interfere with the development of the future park. It is estimated that planning, design and construction for the future Trailblazer Park at the subject property could take between three and six years. The proposed CUP time frame provides adequate time to allow for both the design and development of the park and the identification of a permanent site for the WCF. 3. That the site for the proposed conditional use is adequate in size and shape to accommodate the yards, setbacks, walls, fences, parking, loading facilities, buffer areas, landscaping and other development features prescribed in this code and required by the City Planner, planning commission or City Council, in order to integrate the use with other uses in the neighborhood, in that the proposed WCF consisting of two 55-foot tall ground mounted faux mono-eucalyptus PC RESO NO. 7370 -3- trees and a ground mounted equipment enclosure complies with all requirements of the code, with the exception of the O-S zone 25-foot structure height limit that may be exceeded with the approval of the CUP. The site size and shape are adequate to accommodate the required separation from Cannon Road and natural habitat. The WCF is stealthily disguised as faux eucalyptus trees, which visually blend with the existing mature landscaping at the property’s perimeter so as to not be visually intrusive or incompatible with adjacent residential land uses. Although the WCF will be visible to the residential homes within the Foothill Community to the north, the size of the site is adequate to ensure the distance from the temporary WCF to the nearest residence is over 500 feet. Lastly, ground mounted equipment will be adequately screened by an 8-6” tall vinyl equipment enclosure comprised of a six-foot-tall tan vinyl fence with a two-foot six-inch-tall tan vinyl lattice atop the vinyl fence. The combination of vinyl fence/lattice will ensure the equipment is screened from view of the neighborhood. 4. That the street system serving the proposed use is adequate to properly handle all traffic generated by the proposed use, in that the use generates very little traffic, requiring only one routine monthly maintenance visit and the occasional emergency visit in response to operational problems. The existing street system is adequate to property handle any traffic generated by the use. 5. That the increase in the height limit of 25 feet for the O-S zone is necessary for the proposed WCF in that an increase in the O-S zone height limit from 25 feet to 55 feet is the minimum necessary to accommodate the four wireless carriers, allow the antennas to meet the Radio Frequency (RF) calculations of clearance from solid interference (obstructions) and FCC standards. The antennas cannot be located lower on shorter faux trees as the height is needed to maintain the same level of service to the community without cellular interference, ensure the minimum separation between carriers’ antennas is maintained, and maintain the current E911 system supporting emergency services. To maintain that service and avoid significant gaps in cellular coverage for all four carriers, the proposed 55-foot height is necessary. 6. The City Planner has determined that the project belongs to a class of projects that the State Secretary for Resources has found do not have a significant impact on the environment, and it is therefore categorically exempt from the requirement for the preparation of environmental documents pursuant to Section 15303 (Construction and installation of small new equipment facilities or structures) of the state CEQA Guidelines. Additionally, as Crown Castle must comply with FCC regulations, it has been determined that the cumulative radio frequency emissions from the proposed WCF are below levels established as acceptable by the FCC and are therefore not considered a health hazard. In making this determination, the City Planner has found that the exceptions listed in Section 15300.2 of the state CEQA Guidelines do not apply to this project. 7. The Planning Commission has reviewed each of the exactions imposed on the Developer contained in this resolution, and hereby finds, in this case, that the exactions are imposed to mitigate impacts caused by or reasonably related to the project, and the extent and the degree of the exaction is in rough proportionality to the impact caused by the project. Conditions: NOTE: Unless otherwise specified herein, all conditions shall be satisfied prior to issuance of a building permit. PC RESO NO. 7370 -4- 1. If any of the following conditions fail to occur, or if they are, by their terms, to be implemented and maintained over time, if any of such conditions fail to be so implemented and maintained according to their terms, the city shall have the right to revoke or modify all approvals herein granted; deny or further condition issuance of all future building permits; deny, revoke, or further condition all certificates of occupancy issued under the authority of approvals herein granted; record a notice of violation on the property title; institute and prosecute litigation to compel their compliance with said conditions or seek damages for their violation. No vested rights are gained by Developer or a successor in interest by the city’s approval of this temporary Conditional Use Permit. 2. Staff is authorized and directed to make, or require the Developer to make, all corrections and modifications to the temporary Conditional Use Permit documents, as necessary to make them internally consistent and in conformity with the final action on the project. Development shall occur substantially as shown on the approved Exhibits. Any proposed development, different from this approval, shall require an amendment to this approval. 3. Developer shall comply with all applicable provisions of federal, state, and local laws and regulations in effect at the time of building permit issuance. 4. If any condition for construction of any public improvements or facilities, or the payment of any fees in-lieu thereof, imposed by this approval or imposed by law on this Project are challenged, this approval shall be suspended as provided in Government Code Section 66020. If any such condition is determined to be invalid, this approval shall be invalid unless the City Council determines that the project without the condition complies with all requirements of law. 5. Developer/Operator shall and does hereby agree to indemnify, protect, defend, and hold harmless the City of Carlsbad, its Council members, officers, employees, agents, and representatives, from and against any and all liabilities, losses, damages, demands, claims and costs, including court costs and attorney’s fees incurred by the city arising, directly or indirectly, from (a) city’s approval and issuance of this temporary Conditional Use Permit, (b) city’s approval or issuance of any permit or action, whether discretionary or nondiscretionary, in connection with the use contemplated herein, and (c) Developer/Operator’s installation and operation of the facility permitted hereby, including without limitation, any and all liabilities arising from the emission by the facility of electromagnetic fields or other energy waves or emissions. This obligation survives until all legal proceedings have been concluded and continues even if the city’s approval is not validated. 6. Prior to submittal of the building plans, improvement plans, grading plans, or final map, whichever occurs first, developer shall submit to the City Planner, a 24" x 36" copy of the Site Plan, reflecting the conditions approved by the final decision making body. The copy shall be submitted to the City Planner, reviewed and, if found acceptable, signed by the city's project planner and project engineer. If no changes were required, the approved exhibits shall fulfill this condition. 7. This project shall comply with all conditions and mitigation measures which are required as part of the Zone 14 Local Facilities Management Plan and any amendments made to that Plan prior to the issuance of building permits. PC RESO NO. 7370 -5- 8. This approval shall become null and void if building permits are not issued for this project within 24 months from the date of project approval. 9. Developer shall pay the Citywide Public Facilities Fee imposed by City Council Policy #17, the License Tax on new construction imposed by Carlsbad Municipal Code Section 5.09.030, and CFD #1 special tax (if applicable), subject to any credits authorized by Carlsbad Municipal Code Section 5.09.040. Developer shall also pay any applicable Local Facilities Management Plan fee for Zone 14, pursuant to Chapter 21.90. All such taxes/fees shall be paid at issuance of building permit. If the taxes/fees are not paid, this approval will not be consistent with the General Plan and shall become void. 10. Developer shall submit to the city a Notice of Restriction executed by the owner of the real property to be developed. Said notice is to be filed in the office of the County Recorder, subject to the satisfaction of the City Planner, notifying all interested parties and successors in interest that the City of Carlsbad has issued a temporary Conditional Use Permit by Resolution No. 7370 on the property. Said Notice of Restriction shall note the property description, location of the file containing complete project details and all conditions of approval as well as any conditions or restrictions specified for inclusion in the Notice of Restriction. The City Planner has the authority to execute and record an amendment to the notice which modifies or terminates said notice upon a showing of good cause by the Developer or successor in interest. 11. CUP 2019-0032 shall be reviewed by the City Planner annually to determine if all conditions of this permit have been met and that the use does not have a substantial negative effect on surrounding properties or the public health, safety and general welfare. If the City Planner determines that: 1) the temporary Conditional Use Permit was obtained by fraud or misrepresentation; or 2) the use for which such approval was granted is not being exercised; or 3) the temporary Conditional Use Permit is being or recently has been exercised contrary to any of the terms or conditions of approval or the conditions of approval have not been met; or 4) the use for which such approval was granted has ceased to exist or has been suspended for one year or more; or 5) the use is in violation of any statute, ordinance, law or regulation; or 6) the use permitted by the temporary Conditional Use Permit is being or has been so exercised as to be detrimental to the public health, safety or welfare or so as to constitute a nuisance, the City Planner shall recommend that the Planning Commission hold a public hearing and after providing the permittee the opportunity to be heard, the Planning Commission may revoke and terminate the temporary Conditional Use Permit in whole or in part, reaffirm the temporary Conditional Use Permit, modify the conditions or impose new conditions. 12. This temporary Conditional Use Permit is granted for a period of three (3) years from June 3, 2020, through June 3, 2023. This permit may be revoked at any time after a public hearing, if it is found that the use has a substantial detrimental effect on surrounding land uses and the public’s health and welfare, or the conditions imposed herein have not been met. This permit may be extended for a reasonable period of time not to exceed three (3) additional one-year (1-year) terms upon written application of the permittee made no less than 90 days prior to the expiration date. Upon the expiration of term(s), the temporary conditional use permit shall be null and void and the Wireless Communications Facility shall be removed within 90 days. 13. Developer/Operator shall comply with the Federal Communication Commission’s guidelines on limits for human exposure to radio frequency (RF) electromagnetic fields. Within six (6) months PC RESO NO. 7370 -6- after the issuance of occupancy, and with any time extension or amendment request, the Developer/Operator shall submit to the City Planner either (1) verification that the project is categorically excluded from having to determine compliance with the RF exposure guidelines per 47 CFR §1.1307(b)(1); or (2) a project implementation report which provides cumulative field measurements of RF emissions of all antennas installed at the subject site. The report shall quantify the RF emissions and compare the results with the exposure limits established by the FCC guidelines. Said report shall be subject to review and approval by the City Planner for consistency with the Project’s preliminary report on RF exposure submitted with the initial project application and for consistency with the FCC guidelines. If, on review, the City finds that the Project does not meet the FCC guidelines, the City may revoke or modify this temporary conditional use permit. 14. Developer shall report, in writing, to the City Planner within 30 days, any address change from that which is shown on the permit application, any change in the telecommunications provider, or any transfer in ownership of the site. 15. No outdoor storage of materials shall occur onsite unless required by the Fire Chief. When so required, the Developer shall submit and obtain approval of the Fire Chief and the City Planner of an Outdoor Storage Plan, and thereafter comply with the approved plan. 16. Prior to issuance of the building permit, Developer shall submit an acoustical analysis complying with the City requirements of the Carlsbad Noise Guidelines Manual to ensure that the proposed WCF noise sources will comply with the 60 dB(A) exterior noise level as measured from the nearest residential building. Code Reminders: 17. Approval of this request shall not excuse compliance with all applicable sections of the Zoning Ordinance and all other applicable City ordinances in effect at time of building permit issuance, except as otherwise specifically provided herein. 18. Premise identification (addresses) shall be provided consistent with Carlsbad Municipal Code Section 17.04.060. NOTICE TO APPLICANT An appeal of this decision to the City Council must be filed with the City Clerk at 1200 Carlsbad Village Drive, Carlsbad, California, 92008, within ten (10) calendar days of the date of the Planning Commission’s decision. Pursuant to Carlsbad Municipal Code Chapter 21.54, section 21.54.150, the appeal must be in writing and state the reason(s) for the appeal. The City Council must make a determination on the appeal prior to any judicial review. PC RESO NO. 7370 -7- NOTICE Please take NOTICE that approval of your project includes the “imposition” of fees, dedications, reservations, or other exactions hereafter collectively referred to for convenience as “fees/exactions.” You have 90 days from date of final approval to protest imposition of these fees/exactions. If you protest them, you must follow the protest procedure set forth in Government Code Section 66020(a) and file the protest and any other required information with the City Manager for processing in accordance with Carlsbad Municipal Code Section 3.32.030. Failure to timely follow that procedure will bar any subsequent legal action to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul their imposition. You are hereby FURTHER NOTIFIED that your right to protest the specified fees/exactions DOES NOT APPLY to water and sewer connection fees and capacity charges, nor planning, zoning, grading, or other similar application processing or service fees in connection with this project; NOR DOES IT APPLY to any fees/exactions of which you have previously been given a NOTICE similar to this, or as to which the statute of limitations has previously otherwise expired. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission of the City of Carlsbad, California, held on June 3, 2020 by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: VELYN ANDERSON, Chairperson CARLSBAD PLANNING COMMISSION ATTEST: DON NEU City Planner CANNO NRD GLEN AV ELCAMINOREAL WINDTRAI LWYDON M A T A D R DONRICARDODR TRAILBLAZER WY G A G E D RD O N R O D OLFODR P U B L I C TRAIL CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF SITE MAP J SITE E L C AMINO R E ALLA COSTA AVCARLSBAD B L MELROSE DR POINSETT I A L N ATTACHMENT 2 ATTACHMENT 3 Alternative Site Analysis: 824560 and 856641 – Relo to 831227 Trailblazer Park Laura Stearns/Crown CastlePage 1 of 6 Zoning Map ATTACHMENT 4 Alternative Site Analysis: 824560 and 856641 – Relo to 831227 Trailblazer Park Laura Stearns/Crown Castle Page 2 of 6 General Plan Land Use Map Alternative Site Analysis: 824560 and 856641 – Relo to 831227 Trailblazer Park Laura Stearns/Crown Castle Page 3 of 6 Alternative Site Analysis Key Map: Areas reviewed within the carrier provided search ring (pink). Only areas within the ring could cover the coverage gap from the loss of the WCFs. Alternative Site Analysis: 824560 and 856641 – Relo to 831227 Trailblazer Park Laura Stearns/Crown Castle Page 4 of 6 Map Key Physical Address or APN if no address Zone Owner / Point of Contact Tower Type Design and Concealment Elements Height and achievable centerline(s) Notes Outside of Coastal Zone Area 1 Green Proposed Site – Future Park 33.151017°, ‐117.296975° APN 208‐010‐38‐00 APN 208‐010‐42‐00 APN 208‐010‐39‐00 P‐C OS in General Plan City of Carlsbad Curtis Jackson, Real Estate Manager 760‐434‐2836 curtis.jackson@carlsbadca.gov Temporary Faux‐Eucalyptus x2 See application Verizon ATT TMO Sprint Proposed Temporary Tower Site Conforms to City Council Policy 64 Location Guideline A.2 Area 2 Red APN 208‐195‐09‐00 (Approx 40‐acre open space, natural area) P‐C Rancho Costera LLC 725 West Town and Country Rd #200 Orange CA 92868 N/A N/A N/A No response to certified letter sent to Rancho Costera LLC Discouraged location per City Council Policy 64 Location Guideline A.2 Prohibited by provisions of Conservation Easement Deed in favor of Center for Natural Lands Management (Instrument 2007‐0786167 recorded in San Diego County Public Records) Area 3 Red APN 168‐360‐07‐00 (HOA common area on west side of Cannon Road)) P‐C Foothills at Carlsbad Homeowners Association c/o The Prescott Companies 5950 La Place Court #200 Carlsbad CA 92008 760‐634‐4700 www.prescottmgt.com N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact property owner Not enough space to accommodate temporary tower; temporary tower would block sidewalk and would be too close to Cannon Road. This is only a small sliver of land. Area 4 Red The Shops at Robertson Ranch Gage Drive – Exact address to be determined at a later date APN 208‐195‐01‐00 P‐C Shapell Robertson LLC 1990 South Bundy Drive #500 Los Angeles CA 90025 POC: Adrian Taghdiri Portfolio Director and Regional Development Director Shapell Properties, Inc. 11200 Corbin Avenue, Suite 201 Porter Ranch, California 91326 323‐988‐7541 ataghdiri@shapell.com N/A N/A N/A Several emails and a phone call The owner/developer is still working on the design of the Retail Center based on the evolving tenant mix. Unable to review a formal design proposal (as of 8/12/19). As of 12/19/19, the owner has still declined to lease space to Crown Castle. THE SHOPS AT ROBERTSON RANCH CT2018‐0007 05/11/2018 THE SHOPS AT ROBERTSON RANCH: 6 RETAIL BUILDINGS, INCLUDING BANKS, RESTAURANTS, & PRIVATE EDUCATIONAL FACILITY OR DAYCARE (SUBDIVIDED INTO 5 LOTS) CUP2018‐0009 05/11/2018 THE SHOPS AT ROBERTSON RANCH: CUP FOR DRIVE‐THRU BANK CUP2018‐0010 05/11/2018 THE SHOPS AT ROBERTSON RANCH: CUP FOR EDUCATIONAL FACILITY PUD2018‐0005 05/11/2018 THE SHOPS AT ROBERTSON RANCH: 6 RETAIL BUILDINGS, INCLUDING BANKS, RESTAURANTS, & PRIVATE EDUCATIONAL FACILITY OR DAYCARE (SUBDIVIDED INTO 5 LOTS) SDP2018‐0005 05/11/2018 THE SHOPS AT ROBERTSON RANCH: 6 RETAIL BUILDINGS, INCLUDING BANKS, RESTAURANTS, & PRIVATE EDUCATIONAL FACILITY OR DAYCARE (SUBDIVIDED INTO 5 LOTS) SUP2018‐0007 05/11/2018 THE SHOPS AT ROBERTSON RANCH: 6 RETAIL BUILDINGS, INCLUDING BANKS, RESTAURANTS, & PRIVATE EDUCATIONAL FACILITY OR DAYCARE (SUBDIVIDED INTO 5 LOTS) Alternative Site Analysis: 824560 and 856641 – Relo to 831227 Trailblazer Park Laura Stearns/Crown Castle Page 5 of 6 Map Key Physical Address or APN if no address Zone Owner / Point of Contact Tower Type Design and Concealment Elements Height and achievable centerline(s) Notes Area 5 Red Robertson Ranch Single‐Family Multiple APNs P‐C Multiple Owners of Single‐Family Homes N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact Single‐family residential uses; not suitable for temporary tower. This is a least preferred location under policy 64. Area 6 Red Robertson Ranch Multi‐Family APN 208‐195‐11‐00 ‐ Shapell Portola LLC APN 208‐195‐10‐00 ‐ Shapell Montecito LLC APN 208‐195‐03‐00 ‐ Robertson Ranch West Village Owners Association APN 208‐195‐02‐00 ‐ Shapell Montecito LLC P‐C Shapell Montecito LLC 1990 South Bundy Drive #500 Los Angeles CA 90025 N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact apartment complex manager; discussed with Adrian Taghdiri, Portfolio Director and Regional Development Director, Shapell Properties, Inc. Multi‐family uses; not suitable for temporary tower. This is a least preferred location under policy 64. Area 7 Red APN 208‐195‐06‐00 P‐C Robertson Ranch West Village Owners Association 501 West Broadway #19 San Diego CA 92101 N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact Open space area is a habitat restoration area with high voltage transmission towers and lines on one side that cause interference with cellular signals. Topographic issues further make this area unusable as a replacement for cellular coverage. Area 8 Red APN 208‐195‐05‐00 P‐C Rancho Costera LLC 725 West Town and Country Rd #200 Orange CA 92868 N/A N/A N/A No response to certified letter sent to Rancho Costera LLC Topographic issues make this area a less than ideal and possibly unusable replacement for cellular coverage. Within Coastal Zone Area 9 Red Multiple APNs P‐C OS R‐A‐10000 R‐1‐8000 Multiple Owners N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact owners Single‐family residential and mobile home uses Topography issues (vegetation and hilly terrain) make this unsuitable for temporary tower. Area 10 Red APN 207‐101‐35‐00 (proposed residential) APN 207‐101‐37‐00 (proposed commercial) P‐C Michael & Marja Dawn Selna Residential Phase ‐ Hoffman Legacy Trust 12‐17‐12 Commercial Phase ‐ Selna Family Trust 09‐10‐81 N/A N/A N/A Existing site location. The proposed locations‐‐a clock tower and a water tower on site‐‐were limited in height. With the loss of elevation, this would not work for the carriers. The developer, New Urban West, rejected other proposals on site, such as a free‐standing tower in the southwestern portion of the property. Area 11 Red Multiple APNs OS R‐A‐10000 R‐1 Multiple Private Owners, along with State of California Owner N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact owners Predominantly residential uses and state‐owned open space with heavily vegetated slopes. Within the California Coastal Zone. Terrain and vegetation will interfere with RF coverage and with attempts to place any temporary structure. Alternative Site Analysis: 824560 and 856641 – Relo to 831227 Trailblazer Park Laura Stearns/Crown Castle Page 6 of 6 Map Key Physical Address or APN if no address Zone Owner / Point of Contact Tower Type Design and Concealment Elements Height and achievable centerline(s) Notes Other properties of note Arrow points off map to Sage Creek HS 3900 Cannon Rd. APN 168‐050‐61‐00 APN 168‐050‐46‐00 P‐C L‐C City of Carlsbad/School District (Property contains Sage Creek High School) N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact property owner Sage Creek High School and the stadium lights on property are too far from the existing WCFs that are being decommissioned. A site there cannot rectify the impending significant coverage gap. Note on distances: The search area of usable properties provided by the major wireless carriers includes areas up to 3,500ft from the existing WCFs and as little as 1,000ft in areas with restrictive terrain. Only locations within this area are viable alternative locations. The school is an additional 3,800ft from the outer line of the search ring and 3,300ft from the fire station. Although some have noted the increase in elevation up to the school, that height is not sufficient to overcome the huge distances to the edge of the search ring. In short, a site at the school would not significantly impact the coverage gap created by the loss of three WCFs simultaneously. Arrow points off map to water tank APN 168‐050‐08‐00 APN 168‐050‐50‐00 APN 168‐050‐44‐00 L‐C Carlsbad Municipal Water District (Property contains water tank) N/A N/A N/A No attempt to contact property owner The water tank above Sage Creek High School and the surrounding property are too far from the existing WCFs that are being decommissioned. A site there cannot rectify the impending significant coverage gap. Note on distances: The search area of usable properties provided by the major wireless carriers includes areas up to 3,500ft from the existing WCFs and as little as 1,000ft in areas with restrictive terrain. Only locations within this area are viable alternative locations. The tank is an additional 6,000ft from the outer line of the search ring and 5,300ft from the fire station. Although some have noted the increase in elevation up to the tank, that height is not sufficient to overcome the huge distances to the edge of the search ring. In short, a site at the water tank would not significantly impact the coverage gap created by the loss of three WCFs simultaneously. 3465 Trailblazer Way Carlsbad CA 92010 831227 Traiblazer Park Temp Site Accuracy of photo simulation based upon information provided by project applicant. Looking north from El Camino Real and Cannon RoadProposed View 1 Existing proposed monoeucalyptusproposed monoeucalyptus ©2019 Google Maps ATTACHMENT 5 3465 Trailblazer Way Carlsbad CA 92010 831227 Traiblazer Park Temp Site Accuracy of photo simulation based upon information provided by project applicant. Looking northwest from Don Mata DriveProposed View 2 Existing proposed monoeucalyptus beyondproposed monoeucalyptus beyond ©2019 Google Maps 3465 Trailblazer Way Carlsbad CA 92010 831227 Traiblazer Park Temp Site Accuracy of photo simulation based upon information provided by project applicant. Looking south from along fencelineProposed View 3 Existing proposed monoeucalyptus proposed equipment enclosure proposed monoeucalyptus ©2019 Google Maps 3465 Trailblazer Way Carlsbad CA 92010 831227 Traiblazer Park Temp Site Accuracy of photo simulation based upon information provided by project applicant. Looking southwest from Cannon RoadProposed View 4 Existing proposed monoeucalyptus proposed monoeucalyptus proposed equipment enclosure ©2019 Google Maps 3465 Trailblazer Way Carlsbad CA 92010 831227 Traiblazer Park Temp Site Accuracy of photo simulation based upon information provided by project applicant. Looking southwest from 3545 Glen AvenueProposed View 5 Existing proposed monoeucalyptus beyond ©2019 Google Maps 3465 Trailblazer Way Carlsbad CA 92010 831227 Traiblazer Park Temp Site Accuracy of photo simulation based upon information provided by project applicant. Looking southeast from Chase CourtProposed View 6 Existing proposed monoeucalyptus proposed equipment enclosure proposed monoeucalyptus ©2019 Google Maps 3465 Trailblazer Way Carlsbad CA 92010 831227 Traiblazer Park Temp Site Accuracy of photo simulation based upon information provided by project applicant. Looking east from El Camino Real and Crestview DriveProposed View 7 Existing proposed monoeucalyptus proposed equipment enclosure proposed monoeucalyptus ©2019 Google Maps ATTACHMENT 6 2552 Walnut Ave. Tustin, CA. 92780 · tel: 800.678.1169 Public Outreach Report Date: To: Project: From: April 24, 2020 City of Carlsbad Planning Department Attn: Cliff Jones 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 760-602-2710 760-602-8560 fax www.carlsbadca.gov CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF Jonathan Restivo Pramira 2552 Walnut Ave. Phone: Email: (800) 678-1169 jonathan.restivo@pramira.com Tustin, CA 92780 Regarding: PART B – ENHANCED STAKEHOLDER OUTREACH REPORT Enclosures / Attachments: Exhibit A: Public Outreach Letters and Affidavit of Notice Exhibit B: Notice Recipients of October Meeting Exhibit C: Notice Recipients of January Meeting Exhibit D: Emails Received from Residents/Stakeholders Exhibit E: January Meeting Summary and FAQ Dear Mr. Jones: We have completed the Part B – Enhanced Stakeholder Outreach Report for the Trailblazer Park project. The following is a summary report of the activities completed and the results. 1.Program Description Two public outreach meetings were held within the community, with notice of the meetings mailed to all property owners within 600-feet of the subject property, along with any additional “stakeholders” who had reached out to the City or the Applicant regarding the project. These public outreach meetings were pursued pursuant to the Guidance of Development Project Public Involvement handout supplied by the Planning Division. 2.Notice Contents and Timing Letters were sent to the aforementioned property owners and interested parties via postal mail, referencing the applicant, project name and address, date of the meeting, project description, meeting invitation and ATTACHMENT 7 2552 Walnut Ave. Tustin, CA. 92780 · tel: 800.678.1169 Public Outreach Report format, status of the project, and designs at the time of the meeting. The recipient of the letter was invited to the open forum referenced therein. Notice for the first meeting was sent October 9, 2019. The first public outreach meeting was held at 6:00 PM at Sage Creek High School on October 29, 2019. Notice for the second outreach meeting was sent on January 2, 2020. The second meeting was held at 6:00 PM at Sage Creek High School on January 15, 2020. The second letter included revised site plans and a photo simulation of the redesigned project. Both letters and affidavits of postage are included in Exhibit A. 3. Neighboring Properties List and Stakeholders The initial public outreach meeting was sent to a total of 623 property owners, within 600’ of the subject property. The list of stakeholders has grown since the project application on September 9, 2019 and the initial notice letter was sent on October 9, 2019. At the time of the second public outreach meeting in January, there were 632 stakeholders. At the time of this report, the applicant is maintaining a list of 645 property owners and stakeholders. A list of the parties to which the public outreach meeting notices were sent is included as Exhibit B and C, respectively. 4. Comments Received Over the course of the project application review, the City has forwarded a number of comments received by email regarding the project. The twenty (20) emails included here that were sent by the City were all received prior to the plan revision in coordination with staff which led to holding the second public outreach meeting for that revised design. The emails are enclosed here as Exhibit D. The general concerns range from EMF exposure, property value diminishment, aesthetic issues, questioning the lack of alternative options and the need to relocate the existing, the truly temporary nature of the tower(s), a desire to see the park completed, and an undefined 5G technology aversion. We did not receive, and are not aware of, any further comments received after the second public outreach meeting in January in which the redesigned project (addressing stakeholder comments) was presented along with enhanced graphics explaining the need for this site. 5. Second Public Outreach Meeting Summary Many of the comments expressed by the residents/stakeholders prior to and following the initial public outreach meeting in October have been addressed as best as feasible by the Applicant given the circumstances. The concerns and resultant changes include the project’s significant redesign and new compound and tower placement, as well as through the more detailed information on coverage objectives and potential loss, alternative property siting issues, EMF data, and photo simulations of the improved aesthetics provided at the public outreach meeting in January. A summary of the meeting, along with collected questions from the residents/stakeholders in attendance, many concerns of which were expressed to the Applicant and the City prior to this meeting, are included with answers addressed to those concerns in the summary documents included in Exhibit E. 2552 Walnut Ave. Tustin, CA. 92780 · tel: 800.678.1169 Public Outreach Report Given the level of concern for this project expressed by residents and stakeholders from October to December of 2019, the Applicant made significant changes to the proposal in coordination with staff recommendations to address the reasonable nature of the comments of the interested parties. The reception at the second public outreach meeting in January was generally favorable, especially given the design of the new proposal into more aesthetically functional, shorter faux trees, in a location farther from residential properties. We anticipate that it is unavoidable that there will still be opponents to this project. However, our efforts to address stakeholder concerns and our work on multiple occasions with city staff make us confident that this proposal is the least intrusive means available to prevent a significant gap in cellular coverage. This coverage gap must be prevented or mitigated to the greatest degree possible as it will affect all four major wireless carriers and their customers in this community. We are proud of the work Crown Castle, our outside experts, and our partners at all four major wireless carriers have done to ensure that this project will have the minimum impact possible on the community while still providing cellular and mobile internet access in these troubled times and beyond. We have seriously considered and addressed the concerns of the public in ways that also serve the community’s needs and its communication ability in this short term. Given that the immediate community has been engaged on multiple occasions through project development, and listened to as best as practicable, it is our conclusion that Part-B – Enhanced Stakeholder Outreach Program should be satisfied for this project. Sincerely, Jonathan Restivo Pramira, on behalf of Crown Castle EXHIBIT A October 10, 2019 Subject: Notice of Application # CUP 2019-0032--Crown Site 831227 Trailblazer Park, Temporary Wireless Telecommunications Facility Dear Neighbors and Interested Stakeholders: Per City Council Policy No. 84, this is to inform you that Crown Castle has submitted the following development application to the City of Carlsbad: Project Number: CUP 2019-0032 Project Name: Crown Site 831227 Trailblazer Park Project Address: n/a—vacant land (corner of Cannon and El Camino Real Road) Assessor Parcel Number: 208-010-38, -39 and -42 Date of Application: 9 September 2019 Project Description: Installation and operation of a temporary multi-carrier wireless communication facility as a short-term replacement of three neighboring sites (AT&T, T-Mobile and Verizon Wireless) coming off-air in early 2020. Applicant Name: Tom Hanna, Ph.D. (858) 602-6253 tom.hanna@cmhcg.com Crown Castle 2055 S. Stearman Dr, Chandler, AZ 85286 City Project Planner: Shannon Harker, Associate Planner (760) 602-4621 Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov If you would like more information or would like to provide input on the project, please do not hesitate to contact me. Additionally, Crown will be holding an open-house forum on Tuesday, October 29th, from 6:00p to 7:00p at Sage Creek High School (3900 Cannon Rd, Carlsbad, CA 92010) in the cafeteria, where we will have Crown representatives available to answer any questions or address any concerns. The project is currently under review by the City and your input is welcome. A decision to approve or deny this application will be made by the City at a future public hearing and you will be notified of the hearing in advance. Sincerely, Tom Hanna, Ph.D. Crown Castle Representative Attachments: Site Plan and Building Elevations December 20, 2019 Subject: Notice of Application # CUP 2019-0032--Crown Site 831227 Trailblazer Park, Temporary Wireless Telecommunications Facility Dear Neighbors and Interested Stakeholders: Per City Council Policy No. 84, this is to inform you that Crown Castle has submitted a revision to the following development application to the City of Carlsbad: Project Number: CUP 2019-0032 Project Name: 831227 Trailblazer Park Temp Site Project Address: n/a—vacant land (corner of Cannon and El Camino Real Road) Assessor Parcel Number: 208-010-38, -39 and -42 Date of Application: 20 September 2019 (revised application) Project Description: Installation and operation of a temporary multi-carrier wireless communication facility as a short-term replacement of three neighboring sites with AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon, and Sprint coming off-air in early 2020. Applicant Name: Tom Hanna, Ph.D. (858) 602-6253 tom.hanna@cmhcg.com Crown Castle Towers 06-2 LLC 200 Spectrum Center Dr., Suite 1700, Irvine, CA 92618 City Project Planner: Cliff Jones (760) 602-4613 cliff.jones@carlsbadca.gov If you would like more information or would like to provide input on the project, please do not hesitate to contact me. Additionally, Crown will be holding an open-house forum, our second, on Wednesday, January 15th, from 6:00p to 7:00p at Sage Creek High School (3900 Cannon Rd, Carlsbad, CA 92010) in the cafeteria, where we will have Crown and cellular carrier representatives available to answer any questions, address any concerns, and hear feedback on further changes missed in this revision. The project is currently under review by the City and your input is welcome. A decision to approve or deny this application will be made by the City at a future public hearing and you will be notified of the hearing in advance. Sincerely, Matt Levesque Crown Castle Representative Attachments: Site Plan, Building Elevations, and Photo Simulation EXHIBIT B CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST ID APN OWNERS MAIL NO DIR MAIL STREET SFX UNIT MAIL CITY STATE ZIP 1 168-050-37-01 CLARK TRUDEL FAMILY TRUST 3349 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 2 168-050-37-02 BERNADINE FENDRICK 3346 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 3 168-050-37-03 CORNWELL DONALD P & JUNE M LIVING TRUST 3338 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 4 168-050-37-04 DIANNE C PICCINI 3330 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 5 168-050-37-05 JAMES HARN 3322 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 6 168-050-37-06 STACY Y & CAROL A COX 3314 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 7 168-050-37-07 MOU KIZEN LIVING 1996 TRUST 3302 DON QUIXOTE DR UNIT 7 CARLSBAD CA 92010 8 168-050-37-08 CHARLES A & LUCIA G GENSLER 3301 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 9 168-050-37-09 GHISLAINE LAPOINTE 3315 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 10 168-050-37-10 REINHOLZ RIKKI TRUST 3323 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 11 168-050-37-11 MCANDREW FAMILY TRUST 3331 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 12 168-050-37-12 NOVAK EDWARD T REVOCABLE TRUST 3339 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 13 168-050-37-13 POSYLUZNY NANCY E INHERITANCE TRUST 3347 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 14 168-050-37-14 ARTHUR W HENTSCHEL 301 SUNRISE RD BREA CA 92821 15 168-050-37-15 GERARDO N TEMPESTA 69 RICE RD WAYLAND MA 1778 16 168-050-37-16 STANDERFER TRUST 3332 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 17 168-050-37-17 PAEZ JOSE I & CLARA I IRREVOCABLE TRUST 3324 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 18 168-050-37-18 MAXVILLE JUNE D LIVING TRUST 3314 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 19 168-050-37-19 MARSHA L PATCHEN 3302 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 20 168-050-37-20 FREDERICK L & DEBRA K WILSON 3301 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 21 168-050-37-21 CRAWFORD CATHY TRUST 3311 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 22 168-050-37-22 EDWARD F & ANGELA A CROWE 9520 STOAKES AVE DOWNEY CA 90240 23 168-050-37-23 BARNETT FAMILY TRUST 3420 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 24 168-050-37-24 CHARLES H & LINDA L HENRY 3337 DON DIABLO DR UNIT 24 CARLSBAD CA 92010 25 168-050-37-25 ROBERT D & CINDY J WRIGHT 3345 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 26 168-050-37-26 LEVINE BURTON A TRUST 3390 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 27 168-050-37-27 PLESSNER JOAN LIVING TRUST 3384 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 28 168-050-37-28 FLANIGAN NANCY A FAMILY TRUST 3378 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 29 168-050-37-29 DEANNA HARRIS 3372 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 30 168-050-37-30 JOSEPH H & FREDERICKS BETH C LEE 24 MANOR HOUSE RD NEWTON MA 2459 31 168-050-37-31 THORPE MCGRATH-THORPE FAMILY TRUST 3358 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 32 168-050-37-32 HOOVER FAMILY TRUST 3350 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 33 168-050-37-33 OBERST ROBERTA M REVOCABLE TRUST 3342 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 34 168-050-37-34 MORENO FRANK A & SANDRA M TRUST 3336 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 35 168-050-37-35 SMITH MARY LOU TRUST 3328 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 36 168-050-37-36 ROCKLIN J & RONELL BERSCHNEIDER 3318 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 37 168-050-37-37 LAUDERBACK RUSSELL REVOCABLE TRUST 3312 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 38 168-050-37-38 THEODOR J & NANCY LASHLEY 3302 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 39 168-050-37-39 DAVID D SALKIN 3301 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 40 168-050-37-40 KOHL FAMILY TRUST 3317 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 41 168-050-37-41 HANKIN FAMILY TRUST 3319 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 42 168-050-37-42 TURNER FAMILY TRUST 3327 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 43 168-050-37-43 LEIBELT FAMILY TRUST 3333 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 44 168-050-37-44 MARTINEZ FAMILY TRUST 3339 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 45 168-050-37-45 DRIVER CELESTE M FAMILY TRUST 3343 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 46 168-050-37-46 DAVE HEGAN 3349 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 47 168-050-37-47 COLBURN CRAIG B & NANCY J FAMILY TRUST 3355 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 48 168-050-37-48 HENDRIX ROBERT M & MARY E FAMILY TRUST 1280 HIDDEN SPRINGS AVE OAK PARK CA 91377 49 168-050-37-49 STRANGE FRANK & MARILYN REVOCABLE TRUST 3367 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 50 168-050-37-50 MICHAEL A STORTI 4552 ESSEX CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 51 168-050-37-51 SCHEURING LORI LIVING 2010 TRUST 3379 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 52 168-050-37-52 FRANCIS T & BARBARA J FOX 3385 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 53 168-050-37-53 BARBARA S ZANE 3340 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 54 168-050-37-54 PAGE OTIS S III & ROBIN A REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 5382 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 55 168-050-37-55 MILLER THOMAS G & SALLY J TRUST 5376 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 56 168-050-37-56 JONES FAMILY TRUST 5370 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 57 168-050-37-57 SNELSON REAL PROPERTY TRUST P O BOX 1175 EASTSOUND WA 98245 58 168-050-37-58 WALLIG FAMILY TRUST 5356 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 59 168-050-37-59 HILL MARJORIE B REVOCABLE TRUST 5348 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 60 168-050-37-60 WILLIAM J WARREN 5342 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 61 168-050-37-61 MARY C SHARPE 5336 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 62 168-050-37-62 DINSMORE ROBERT W & DEBORAH M REVOCABLE 2003 TRUST 1541 9TH ST SANTA MONICA CA 90401 63 168-050-37-63 SAWICKI FAMILY TRUST 5320 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 64 168-050-37-64 DILGARD SANDRA K FAMILY TRUST 2588 EL CAMINO REAL UNIT F404 CARLSBAD CA 92008 65 168-050-37-65 ALMOND SUSAN J LIVING TRUST 5308 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 66 168-050-37-66 PELUSO ROBERT L & JANICE L REVOCABLE TRUST 5302 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 67 168-050-37-67 EDWARD E & MARLENE E WATHEN 650 WAKEFILED CT LONG BEACH CA 90803 68 168-050-37-68 MIDKIFF FAMILY TRUST 5307 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 69 168-050-37-69 LOUIS C DIONESE 5315 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 70 168-050-37-70 PHILLIPS FAMILY TRUST 5321 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 71 168-050-37-71 DONALD W WOLF 5327 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 72 168-050-37-72 SULLIVAN FAMILY TRUST 3758 HIGHLAND DR CARLSBAD CA 92008 73 168-050-37-73 DEEANN SUMMERS 5343 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 74 168-050-37-74 GARCIA ANGELA M REVOCABLE TRUST 5351 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 75 168-050-37-75 RAGLAND DAVID C & KATHLEEN E REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 5359 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 76 168-050-37-76 MICHAEL M WARNER 5367 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 77 168-050-37-77 COSGROVE PATRICIA LIVING TRUST 5302 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 78 168-050-37-78 MCALLISTER CONCETTA REVOCABLE TRUST 2960 EMERALD PL CARLSBAD CA 92009 79 168-050-37-79 ROGELIO S & KEELY C ALBA 2188 DICKINSON DR CARLSBAD CA 92008 80 168-050-37-80 WEKSLER DELORES J REVOCABLE TRUST 3545 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 81 168-050-37-81 CONSTANCE R HUBBARD 124 MELROSE DR MISSION VIEJO CA 92692 82 168-050-37-82 MARDEN FAMILY TRUST 5338 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 83 168-050-37-83 DONALD M & BARBARA M VEALE 5346 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 84 168-050-37-84 SUMNER WILLIAM R REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST P O BOX 43 CARLSBAD CA 92018 85 168-050-37-85 STARK BARBARA J REVOCABLE TRUST 5362 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 86 168-050-37-86 STANLEY FAMILY JOINT REVOCABLE 2009 TRUST 10343 S FAIRFIELD AVE CHICAGO IL 60655 87 168-050-37-87 AQUAZOOM WASHES LAND MANAGEMENT CO LLC 27452 CALLE ARROYO SAN JUAN CAPO CA 92675 88 168-050-37-88 CARLO & MICHELE TITONE 5365 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 89 168-050-37-89 JESSE L & MAYER BARBARA J STILLIONS 111 MORRIS ST DADEVILLE MO 65635 90 168-050-37-90 FARROW SANDRA K LIVING TRUST 5349 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 91 168-050-37-91 GREEN JOHN F & DOROTHY E TRUST 5341 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 92 168-050-37-92 PAUL J & SHERRI R SISK 5335 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 93 168-050-37-93 FLOYD R RINGSTAD 5327 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 94 168-050-37-94 BEVERLY R HINSEY 5321 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 95 168-050-37-95 JOHNETTA SCHOONOVER 5313 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 96 168-050-37-96 SHERRY L GRIEPP 5301 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 97 168-050-38-01 DYER FAMILY TRUST 5270 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 98 168-050-38-02 DALL SHARON FAMILY TRUST P O BOX 684 BORREGO SPRINGS CA 92004 99 168-050-38-03 SAILER NINSUDA C 2019 FAMILY TRUST 5256 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 100 168-050-38-04 ANCHISA FARRANT 5244 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 101 168-050-38-05 PERRY JOSEPH & MARJORIE E TRUST 5236 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 102 168-050-38-06 SIENKOWSKI MICHAEL A REVOCABLE FAMILY TRUST 5230 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 103 168-050-38-07 CLARK & CANDLER KAY L ERICKSON 29 CORNELL RD BALA CYNWYD PA 19004 104 168-050-38-08 LEE GLORIA A REVOCABLE TRUST 5216 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 105 168-050-38-09 MORTON D & LI LING CAMPBELL 5210 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 106 168-050-38-10 ATKINSON FAMILY TRUST 5202 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 107 168-050-38-11 WILLIAM & HELEN CHESTNUT P O BOX 2604 CARLSBAD CA 92018 108 168-050-38-12 RAY & BARBARA E BARRIENTOS 5265 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 109 168-050-38-13 LEONARD J SMITH 5257 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 110 168-050-38-14 MCLOUGHLIN JAMES M TRUST 5245 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 111 168-050-38-15 JENNIFER L MITCHELL 3080 CAMINITO TERCER VERDE DEL MAR CA 92014 112 168-050-38-16 MELANIE HOFF 5229 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 113 168-050-38-17 ROBERT B & CAROL N DANZIGER 5223 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 114 168-050-38-18 BENNETT PAULINE C LIVING TRUST 5217 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 115 168-050-38-19 OTT LORA A TRUST 5209 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 116 168-050-38-20 BEVERLY J JONES 5201 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 117 168-050-38-21 MICHELLE G BETTIS P O BOX 332 CARLSBAD CA 92018 118 168-050-38-22 TIERNEY TRUST 3452 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 119 168-050-38-23 RHONDA E CRAWFORD 5218 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 120 168-050-38-24 JACQUELINE MCKELVEY 1854 W 66TH AVE DENVER CO 80221 121 168-050-38-25 WALDEN MALVIN A & ELIZABETH A REVOCABLE TRUST 5232 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 122 168-050-38-26 ROBERT J BUSH 5240 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 123 168-050-38-27 EAHEART MARY J TRUST 5246 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 124 168-050-38-28 AMORSEN LINDA L TRUST 5258 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 125 168-050-38-29 REGINATO FAMILY TRUST 554 HARVEY LN CORVALLIS MT 59828 126 168-050-38-30 MARTINI 2013 FAMILY TRUST 5272 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 127 168-050-38-31 BRADFIELD BETTY L 2010 TRUST 5279 DON RICARDO DR UNIT 127 CARLSBAD CA 92010 128 168-050-38-32 NORMA PAYNE 3484 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 129 168-050-38-33 A P F INVESTMENTS L P 826 ORANGE AVE UNIT 295 CORONADO CA 92118 130 168-050-38-34 DONNA GRACE-LORENZ 5253 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 131 168-050-38-35 FOSTER RICHARD L & JULITA A TRUST 5241 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 132 168-050-38-36 BSHARAH FAMILY TRUST 5239 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 133 168-050-38-37 ASPIRAS RICHARD TRUST 5227 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 134 168-050-38-38 ONEIL FAMILY TRUST 48485 BIG HORN DR LA QUINTA CA 92253 135 168-050-38-39 PAUL A & SHARON M LORKOVIC 5211 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 136 168-050-38-40 RICHARD J & JUDITH A SEGAL 5201 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 137 168-050-38-41 ANNE C WOODARD 5165 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 138 168-050-38-42 MILAM JEAN TRUST 5163 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 139 168-050-38-43 ANNE FUSCO 5152 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 140 168-050-38-44 GARY L & PHYLLIS F WEED 5144 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 141 168-050-38-45 UNDERWOOD JAMES L & LOIS T REVOCABLE TRUST 5136 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 142 168-050-38-46 NELSON 1999 FAMILY TRUST 5128 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 143 168-050-38-47 RAFFY TOM & LORI LIVING TRUST 1125 VIA PINTADA RIVERSIDE CA 92507 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 144 168-050-38-48 BLACKLEDGE FAMILY TRUST 5101 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 145 168-050-38-49 2001 ROSS ROADS REVOCABLE TRUST 5119 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 146 168-050-38-50 BOWEN JAMES & CATHERIN TRUST 5125 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 147 168-050-38-51 CAPITOL TRUST 5135 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-38-52 SAME AS 72 149 168-050-38-53 TERRY W & BARBARA E STEPHENS 5147 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 150 168-050-38-54 JUDY A WINDSOR 5155 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 151 168-050-38-55 JERRY & SUZANNE TEMPESTA 68 RICE RD WAYLAND MA 1778 152 168-050-38-56 MICHIELI MARIA T SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST 5114 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 153 168-050-38-57 RICHARD & MELINDA HALEY 5120 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 154 168-050-38-58 MERITT CYNTHIA S LIVING TRUST 5126 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 155 168-050-38-59 MOLINA CARLOS & PATRICIA LIVING TRUST 5134 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 156 168-050-38-60 LARRY C & COOK KATHRYN L WINDEMULLER 5140 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 157 168-050-38-61 STEELE LARRY L & SHARI R REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 5146 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 158 168-050-38-62 PHILIP LIZARRAGA 5157 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 159 168-050-38-63 SPECIAL NEEDS TRUST 1198 VIA SANTA PAULO VISTA CA 92081 160 168-050-38-64 THEIS FAMILY TRUST 5145 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 161 168-050-38-65 DARRYL & CINDY SMITH 5139 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 162 168-050-38-66 LANCE & ANNETTE MALKIND 5133 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 163 168-050-38-67 THOMAS & MARGARET GRASZER 5127 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 164 168-050-38-68 COSGROVE SHANNON LIVING TRUST 5121 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 165 168-050-38-69 DALE & DONNA REICH 5115 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 166 168-050-38-70 NANCY BAILEY 5109 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 167 168-050-38-71 SCIULLI LIVING TRUST 9819 LYNCAROL DR LA MESA CA 91941 168 168-050-38-72 TORNBORG MARY E TRUST 5101 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 169 168-050-39-01 DUNGAN FAMILY TRUST 5102 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 170 168-050-39-02 RITTER TRUST 5106 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 171 168-050-39-03 STEPHENSON LIVING TRUST 5110 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 172 168-050-39-04 DEELEY-BARNARD FAMILY TRUST 5116 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 173 168-050-39-05 HILDA J SHAW 5120 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 174 168-050-39-06 GROGAN CHARLINE FAMILY 1993 TRUST 5124 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 175 168-050-39-07 DUFFIN L FAMILY 2012 TRUST 5128 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 176 168-050-39-08 BOWER RAYMOND & BERTHA REVOCABLE TRUST 5132 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 177 168-050-39-09 PRUITT RAYNEL I REVOCABLE TRUST 5136 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 178 168-050-39-10 HILLIARD SURVIVORS FAMILY 1994 TRUST 5140 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 179 168-050-39-11 GEOFFREY C & SUSAN E CRONK 5144 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 180 168-050-39-12 JENNIFER A WELLS 8911 KITTIWAKE ST LITTLETON CO 80126 181 168-050-39-13 DIANE B COTTINGHAM 5152 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 182 168-050-39-14 HALL SANDRA J SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST 5156 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 183 168-050-39-15 JUDITH REYNOLDS 5160 DON RODOLFO DR UNIT 183 CARLSBAD CA 92010 184 168-050-39-16 JAIME & MILAGROS LIMJOCO 5164 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 185 168-050-39-17 KENNETH & LORINDA DORFF 5168 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 186 168-050-39-18 CLARENCE A & JUDITH H JUHL 5172 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 187 168-050-39-19 LOUIS M & ZISKA CATHERINE A SERRANO 5176 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 188 168-050-39-20 MURPHEY FAMILY TRUST 5180 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 189 168-050-39-21 STOABS FAMILY TRUST 5184 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 190 168-050-39-22 HEATHMAN FAMILY TRUST 5186 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 191 168-050-39-23 GLENN & AMY GREANEY 5188 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 192 168-050-39-24 LAUBE FAMILY TRUST 5190 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 193 168-050-39-25 KENNETH L & LAURA J STANHOPE 2172 E 26TH WAY YUMA AZ 85365 194 168-050-39-26 JOE R & SHIRLEY A BEEMER 5194 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 195 168-050-39-27 ARBOLEDA TRUST P O BOX 3121 S PASADENA CA 91031 196 168-050-39-28 JOHN FERGUSON 5163 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 197 168-050-39-29, 30 ALFREY FAMILY TRUST 5155 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 198 168-050-39-31 RADOGNA FAMILY TRUST 5139 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 199 168-050-39-32 KATHY S GOLDEN 5131 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 200 168-050-39-33 GLADYS K CARBONE 5123 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 201 168-050-39-34 ROCK FAMILY TRUST 5178 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 202 168-050-39-35 GREGORY H KUVER 5172 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 203 168-050-39-36 GUNN FAMILY TRUST 5166 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 204 168-050-39-37 ROBERT A & SHAWN M PERKINS 5158 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 205 168-050-39-38 BARKER RICHARD & MELINDA FAMILY TRUST 5150 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 206 168-050-39-39 LINCOLN BRADNER 5144 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 207 168-050-39-40 JACOBSON FAMILY REOVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 5132 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 208 168-050-39-41 CUNRADI FAMILY TRUST 5128 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 209 168-050-39-42 EDWIN D & LUCY SARGEANT 5117 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 210 168-050-39-43 WAYMAN FAMILY TRUST 5101 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 211 168-050-39-44 TAYLOR FAMILY TRUST 5107 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 212 168-050-39-45 JANIS STANSFIELD 653 STANFORD DR SN LUIS OBISP CA 93405 213 168-050-39-46 RAZZA FAMILY TRUST 5121 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 214 168-050-39-47 MOORE JUDITH A TRUST 5129 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 215 168-050-39-48 BARKER N JEAN TRUST 5135 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 216 168-050-39-49 LARRY R & JUDY L BREM 5143 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 217 168-050-39-50 JACKIE L & MARIE T KESSLER 5151 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 218 168-050-39-51 PACE FAMILY LIVING TRUST 5157 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 219 168-050-39-52 BUSBY CATHY L FAMILY TRUST 5163 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 220 168-050-39-53 GALLERY FAMILY TRUST 5171 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 221 168-050-39-54 BOOZER ELYSIA LIVING TRUST 5177 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 222 168-050-39-55 S & S TRUST P O BOX 2604 CARLSBAD CA 92018 223 168-050-40-01 WYATT FAMILY TRUST 3443 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 224 168-050-40-02 AVALLONE ELAINE M TRUST 3435 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 225 168-050-40-03 PARK TRUST 3427 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 226 168-050-40-04 ROBERT & EUGENIAS-GONZALEZ LINDA GONZALEZ 3419 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 227 168-050-40-05 TURNER LAWRENCE D FAMILY TRUST 3411 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-40-06 SAME AS 218 229 168-050-40-07 WALTRIP JAMES C & NOREEN M FAMILY TRUST 3406 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 230 168-050-40-08 KENNING KATHRYN M TRUST 3414 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 231 168-050-40-09 GLEDHILL JOHN & MARTHA M REVOCABLE TRUST 3422 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 232 168-050-40-10 DAVID W & JEAN E CRAWFORD 3430 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 233 168-050-40-11 ASPIRAS GRACE TRUST 3438 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 234 168-050-40-12 WILLIAM LAWRENCE & NARISSE FRANCES JOHNSON 3446 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 235 168-050-40-13 SCHIMPF EMIL & JEAN FAMILY TRUST 3454 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 236 168-050-40-14 WILLIAM M BENJAMIN 9860 LA TORTOLA PL SAN DIEGO CA 92129 237 168-050-40-15 CRAMM GERALD G & KATHLEEN A JOINT LIVING TRUST 3445 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 238 168-050-40-16 MCKINNEY FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST 3437 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 239 168-050-40-17 JOHN D & KARLA O ANTOL 3429 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 240 168-050-40-18 WILMA MILLER 18831 HIGHLAND VALLEY RD RAMONA CA 92065 241 168-050-40-19 WARD FAMILY TRUST 3413 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 242 168-050-40-20 DION FAMILY TRUST 3407 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 243 168-050-40-21 JOHNSON DOLORES FAMILY TRUST 5302 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 244 168-050-40-22 FITZPATRICK DIANE TRUST 342 HILLCREST DR ENCINITAS CA 92024 245 168-050-40-23 CADE INTER VIVOS TRUST 5318 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 246 168-050-40-24 SUSAN OSMANSKI 5326 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 247 168-050-40-25 VAVEL J & JUDKINS CAROL J WRIGHT 5342 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 248 168-050-40-26 TOSHIAKI & SAILAJA P HARADA 5350 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 249 168-050-40-27 CLEM VALERIE A TRUST 5358 DON ALVAREZ DR UNIT 250 CARLSBAD CA 92010 250 168-050-40-28 TANAEL FAMILY TRUST 5366 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 251 168-050-40-29 MURRAY SUZANNE SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST 3402 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 252 168-050-40-30 EBERT ROBERT R & DONNA C LIVING FAMILY TRUST 6600 N TREE HAVEN WAY MERIDIAN ID 83646 253 168-050-40-31 HEWITT DEBORAH J EXEMPT TRUST P O BOX 675550 RANCHO SANTA FE CA 92067 168-050-40-32 SAME AS 23 254 168-050-40-33 QUEEN TRUST 3426 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-40-34 SAME AS 181 255 168-050-40-35 HUNSICKER JOHN K & SANDRA L REVOCABLE TRUST 3438 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 256 168-050-40-36 NEAL FAMILY TRUST 3444 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 257 168-050-40-37 ROBB JILL REVOCABLE TRUST P O BOX 675550 RCHO SANTA FE CA 92067 258 168-050-40-38 ALFRED & PENNY W DAPELLO 3456 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 259 168-050-40-39 SPECTOR RENEE N REVOCABLE TRUST 3462 DON JOSE DR UNIT 303 CARLSBAD CA 92010 260 168-050-40-40 HOFFMAN FAMILY TRUST 3468 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 261 168-050-40-41 TORNELLO FAMILY 2017 TRUST 3474 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 262 168-050-40-42 PAUL F HARGADON 3475 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-40-43 SAME AS 202 263 168-050-40-44 GIPNER VIRGINIA L REVOCABLE TRUST 3457 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 264 168-050-40-45 GREER ARTHUR & CARMEN REVOCABLE TRUST 3449 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 265 168-050-40-46 ASHLEY MITCHELL LONDON NW3 7SB ENGLAND 266 168-050-40-47 PRICE FAMILY TRUST 3433 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 267 168-050-40-48 CALLAHAN SURVIVORS TRUST 3423 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 268 168-050-40-49 SKINNER FAMILY TRUST 3415 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 269 168-050-40-50 ANDERSON SOCORRO R TRUST 3420 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 270 168-050-40-51 HAARSTAD VERNA M LIVING TRUST 3438 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 271 168-050-40-52 DEVANY THOMAS & KAREN TRUST 3434 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 272 168-050-40-53 CHRISTY LIVING TRUST 3444 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-40-54 SAME AS 118 273 168-050-40-55 RUDY FAMILY TRUST 3460 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 274 168-050-40-56 HALSTEAD NANCY R 2016 TRUST 3468 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 275 168-050-40-57 JOHN BROHARD 3512 PRINCETON AVE SAN DIEGO CA 92117 276 168-050-40-58 JONES FAMILY TRUST 3489 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 277 168-050-40-59 DONALD J & CYNTHIA LADD 15885 FETLOCK LN CHINO HILLS CA 91709 278 168-050-40-60 TERRIE NATAN 3473 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 279 168-050-40-61 JAMES A & PATRICIA R LAYMAN 3465 DON PORFIRIO DR UNIT 284 CARLSBAD CA 92010 280 168-050-40-62 RUSSELL L & SUZANNE H HANTHORN 3457 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 281 168-050-40-63 MARGARET A CRICKS 3450 S OWL SLICK RD CORNVILLE AZ 86325 282 168-050-40-64 COURTNEY LUCIEN & MARION FAMILY TRUST 3441 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 283 168-050-40-65 ROBERT W & ANITA M FLORES 3435 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 284 168-050-40-66 STEVEN HARKINS 3432 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 285 168-050-40-67 NEVILLE FAMILY IRREVOCABLE TRUST 3440 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 286 168-050-40-68 BOTTO JOAN REVOCABLE TRUST 3446 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 287 168-050-40-69 ARMSTRONG CHRISTINA R REVOCABLE TRUST 3452 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 288 168-050-40-70 THULIN GRACE LIVING TRUST 3458 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 289 168-050-40-71 MARY BENNETT 3464 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 290 168-050-40-72 AARON LAMB 3472 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 291 168-050-40-73 CLARENCE & JANICE RIDDLE 3480 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 292 168-050-40-74 MARILYN MEMORY 3488 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 293 168-050-41-01 STEVEN SMITH 3485 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 294 168-050-41-02 REITER LAVONNE TRUST 3479 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 295 168-050-41-03 JOHNSON LLOYD M FAMILY TRUST 3473 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 296 168-050-41-04 JAMES F & MARY A CARR 3467 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 297 168-050-41-05 BARBARA A COREY 3461 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 298 168-050-41-06 CRAIG CARRIE J REVOCABLE TRUST 3455 DON ARTURO DR UNIT 303 CARLSBAD CA 92010 299 168-050-41-07 PATTI A ADAMS 3449 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 300 168-050-41-08 DEREUS GERARDUS J TRUST 3443 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 301 168-050-41-09 SWANSEN FAMILY TRUST 3437 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 302 168-050-41-10 BEAR FAMILY TRUST 3431 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 303 168-050-41-11 FISSORI NELLIE J LIVING TRUST 3430 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 304 168-050-41-12 PIPPEN NANCY M LIVING TRUST 325 COPPER CANYON TRL CARY IL 60013 305 168-050-41-13 CONWAY MONICA L REVOCABLE TRUST 3436 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 306 168-050-41-14 MCCRACKEN JOANN TRUST 3438 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 307 168-050-41-15 JANET M SWYSGOOD 3442 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 308 168-050-41-16 ENIGENBURG FAMILY TRUST 3444 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 309 168-050-41-17 BABA THOMAS V TRUST 3446 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 310 168-050-41-18 JOAN R SCHNEIDER 3448 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 311 168-050-41-19 HAINES JANET L REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3450 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 312 168-050-41-20 KRISTINE & SMERDU PATRICE BROWN 3499 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 313 168-050-41-21 BOHEN ROBERTA REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3454 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 314 168-050-41-22 DIANE F COOPER 3456 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 315 168-050-41-23 VOLGAMORE FAMILY TRUST 3458 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 316 168-050-41-24 PODRUP TRUST 3460 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 317 168-050-41-25 SUSAN K AFENTUL 3462 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 318 168-050-41-26 MARKEY LIVING TRUST 3464 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 319 168-050-41-27 WHEELER CAROL N IRREVOCABLE TRUST 36240 PECAN CT FREMONT CA 94536 320 168-050-41-28 MACE BRYAN A REVOCABLE TRUST 3468 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 321 168-050-41-29 FRANCES JEAN REVOCABLE TRUST 3470 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 322 168-050-41-30 TOBY S SLOVER 3472 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 323 168-050-41-31 CULBERT FAMILY TRUST 3476 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 324 168-050-41-32 WEISS GARY F & REBECCA J REVOCABLE TRUST 3478 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-41-33 SAME AS 72 325 168-050-41-34 MARTHA L OXLEY 3484 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 326 168-050-41-35 BERRY FAMILY TRUST 3488 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-41-36 SAME AS 202 327 168-050-41-37 PAMELA C DESMOND 3481 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 328 168-050-41-38 JAMES A & BARBARA J KORNOFF 3479 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 329 168-050-41-39 STRINGER VIOLET B REVOCABLE TRUST 3475 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 330 168-050-41-40 MELISSA W COOK 647 ALAMEDA BLVD CORONADO CA 92118 331 168-050-41-41 LAYNE BONNIE L LIVING TRUST 3469 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 332 168-050-41-42 CROWE FAMILY TRUST 3467 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 333 168-050-41-43 SALVATORE R & SUSAN M GAGLIANO 3465 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 334 168-050-41-44 CHU IRIS J GOODRIDGE TRUST 3461 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 335 168-050-41-45 AWERMAN BONITA LIVING TRUST 3459 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 336 168-050-41-46 EVANSON FAMILY TRUST 3457 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 337 168-050-41-47 TERSOLO REMO J & MARGARET C TRUST 7101 MANZANITA ST CARLSBAD CA 92011 338 168-050-41-48 MITCHELL GEORGE S & PHYLLIS J JOINT LIVING TRUST 3449 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 339 168-050-41-49 MARGUERITE L HUNT 3447 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 340 168-050-41-50 LOMBARDI FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST 3445 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 341 168-050-41-51 KATHLEEN Y MACKZ 3443 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 342 168-050-41-52 JAMES V STORELLI 3439 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 343 168-050-41-53 MATA MARGO REVOCABLE TRUST 3437 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 344 168-050-41-54 RUNNER FAMILY LIVING TRUST 3433 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 345 168-050-41-55 BAUMEISTER GENEVIEVE M TRUST 203 ACACIA AVE HUNTINGTN BCH CA 92648 346 168-050-41-56 CRISPEN FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST 2378 TERRAZA RIBERA CARLSBAD CA 92009 347 168-050-41-57 ARNOLD FAMILY TRUST 3432 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 348 168-050-41-58 BLANCO FAMILY 2004 TRUST 1341 CORVIDAE ST CARLSBAD CA 92011 349 168-050-41-59 MORRIS E & PATRICIA A TILDEN 3438 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 350 168-050-41-60 KAMPMANN FRANK & RUTH REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3440 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 351 168-050-41-61 ROCHELLE GERLICH 3442 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 352 168-050-41-62 TURIACE FAMILY TRUST 3444 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 353 168-050-41-63 RICHMOND H & VERONICA K WARREN 3446 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 354 168-050-41-64 SONNENBERG RICHARD H FAMILY TRUST 3450 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 355 168-050-41-65 WILLYARD FAMILY 2004 TRUST 3454 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 356 168-050-41-66 EDWARD W & DIETRICH NYDALEE B BUTTS 3456 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 357 168-050-41-67 VANSLYKE ALASKA COMMUNITY PROPERTY TRUST 300 HERMIT ST UNIT 8 JUNEAU AK 99801 358 168-050-41-68 KLINKO FAMILY TRUST 3462 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 359 168-050-41-69 BORISON PATRICIA L LIVING TRUST 3466 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 360 168-050-41-70 JABEZ TRUST 3468 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 361 168-050-41-71 ANNABLE LOUISE K REVOCABLE TRUST 3470 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 362 168-050-41-72 DENOOY HERMAN R TRUST 5105 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 363 168-050-41-73 NAUTA FAMILY TRUST 3478 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 364 168-050-41-74 ANTHONY N & SAYLES NANCY J KURLOVICH 3534 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 365 168-050-42-01 HEADINGS FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST 3479 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 366 168-050-42-02 SWEARINGEN 2007 FAMILY TRUST 3475 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 367 168-050-42-03 DAWSON FAMILY SURVIVORS TRUST 3473 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 368 168-050-42-04 ELIZABETH R LEBARON 3471 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 369 168-050-42-05 KASTENHOLZ LINDA REVOCABLE TRUST 3467 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-42-06 SAME AS 189 168-050-42-07 SAME AS 107 370 168-050-42-08 DAPELLO/KEYES FAMILY TRUST 3451 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 371 168-050-42-09 KATHLEEN A SPRAGUE 3445 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 372 168-050-42-10 2009 HALEY FAMILY TRUST 3019 AZAHAR CT CARLSBAD CA 92009 168-050-42-11 SAME AS 217 373 168-050-42-12 SCHUMACHER FAMILY TRUST 3439 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 374 168-050-42-13 DINGLE BARRY L & KATHERINE J TRUST 3435 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 375 168-050-42-14 MCCULLAH RONALD & MARIANNE TRUST 3433 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 376 168-050-42-15 GRESHAM FAMILY TRUST 3446 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 377 168-050-42-16 ODELL SUSAN M LIVING TRUST 3450 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 378 168-050-42-17 RAYMOND D & SHARON L LARSON 3454 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 379 168-050-42-18 LEONARD B & CAROLYN A FOLEY 3458 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 380 168-050-42-19 CORREIA LEWIS A & JENNIFER L REVOCABLE TRUST 3462 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 381 168-050-42-20 STONE FAMILY TRUST 3464 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 382 168-050-42-21 JEFFREY E LANDES 916 PIOVANA CT CARLSBAD CA 92011 383 168-050-42-22 WILLIAM H & SUSAN P WILSON 3472 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 384 168-050-42-23 CLEMENT LON F SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST 3474 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 385 168-050-42-24 RENTERIA TERESA SEPARTE PROPERTY TRUST 3478 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 386 168-050-42-25 JAMES H & JANICE B NEWLOVE 2749 ABERDEEN LN EL DORADO HILLS CA 95762 387 168-050-42-26 BROOKS LEONA M TRUST 3505 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 388 168-050-42-27 HESTER DAYL SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST 3515 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 389 168-050-42-28 HANDELMAN FAMILY 1998 TRUST 3523 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 390 168-050-42-29 ABBAMONTE CRAIG D LIVING TRUST 14011 VENTURA BLVD UNIT 301 SHERMAN OAKS CA 91423 391 168-050-42-30 AMOS ALBERTA 2007 TRUST 3539 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-42-31 SAME AS 80 392 168-050-42-32 GARRY L & LAKE JOCELYN L FOSTER 3553 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 393 168-050-42-33 JOHNSTON PAUL M & MARJORIE E REVOCABLE TRUST 3561 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 394 168-050-42-34 DELANGE PHYLLIS E TRUST 3569 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 395 168-050-42-35 PRICE FAMILY TRUST 3506 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 396 168-050-42-36 WHITING BROEDER FAMILY TRUST 3514 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 397 168-050-42-37 SHARON J GULIZIA 3522 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 398 168-050-42-38 MITCHELL FAMILY IRREVOCABLE TRUST 3530 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 399 168-050-42-39 HORNA LOUISE M FAMILY TRUST 3538 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 400 168-050-42-40 WILLIAM L & ANNIE M SIMONTON 3546 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 401 168-050-42-41 WOODROW W & BRIGGS-POORE PAULA A POORE 3554 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 402 168-050-42-42 JENKS FAMILY TRUST 3562 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 403 168-050-42-43 PATRICIA A PALUMBO 3570 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 404 168-050-42-44 CINKO FAMILY TRUST 3571 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 405 168-050-42-45 BLANCO FAMILY 2004 TRUST 1341 CORVIDAE ST CARLSBAD CA 92011 406 168-050-42-46 LEWIS FAMILY TRUST 4784 BEACHWOOD CT CARLSBAD CA 92008 407 168-050-42-47 PETRACH REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3547 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 408 168-050-42-48 KOSCIELSKI FAMILY TRUST 3539 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 409 168-050-43-01 FANT DOYLE & BONNIE REVOCABLE TRUST 3497 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 410 168-050-43-02 SIMES RONALD V TRUST 3491 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 411 168-050-43-03 MELLER DIANA L REVOCABLE TRUST 3485 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 412 168-050-43-04 REED FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST 3479 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 413 168-050-43-05 DORIS F HERMES 3471 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 414 168-050-43-06 RAYMUNDO & REBECCA C MURILLO 3463 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 415 168-050-43-07 SCOTT & CHERYL L SUTCLIFFE 3455 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 416 168-050-43-08 BLAZAK FAMILY TRUST 1254 WINCHESTER CT VISTA CA 92083 417 168-050-43-09 THOMAS T & KATHLEEN A MYRON 3443 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 418 168-050-43-10 PERCY N & MARGARET J CRIDDLE NORTH SAANICH BC CANADA V8L5T4 419 168-050-43-11 FINN KATHLEEN M LIVING TRUST 3431 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 420 168-050-43-12 SCOTELLA FAMILY TRUST 3420 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 421 168-050-43-13 RONALD D MARBEN 3424 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 422 168-050-43-14 BETTY KENNEDY 2729 LA GRAN VIA CARLSBAD CA 92009 423 168-050-43-15 ROXANNE K REGINATO 544 HARVEY LN CORVALLIS MT 59828 424 168-050-43-16 KENT & MARILYN M ALLEN 3446 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 425 168-050-43-17 DONNA GOOLEY 3454 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 426 168-050-43-18 ESTUESTA RICHARD L & VICKY L REVOCABLE TRUST 3462 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 427 168-050-43-19 OLEARY LIVING TRUST 3468 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 428 168-050-43-20 GUNNY LIVING TRUST 3476 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 429 168-050-43-21 NORMA R PAYNE 3484 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 430 168-050-43-22 BURMEISTER FAMILY TRUST 3490 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 431 168-050-43-23 GOLDSMITH CHRISTINE REVOCABLE TRUST 3496 DON ALBERTO DR UNIT 442 CARLSBAD CA 92010 432 168-050-43-24 ROLLER FAMILY TRUST 3461 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 433 168-050-43-25 RICCI DOROTHY L LIVING TRUST 3457 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 434 168-050-43-26 JOHN G & FRANCES J ELLENA 3453 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-43-27 SAME AS 62 435 168-050-43-28 WYNNE HELEN P F REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 537 MARIPOSA AVE UNIT 9 MOUNTAIN VIEW CA 94041 436 168-050-43-29 BOSWORTH L C 2018 FAMILY TRUST 3441 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 437 168-050-43-30 LILIANE G ALBERTS 3437 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 438 168-050-43-31 THEODORE F SPRIGGS 3433 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 439 168-050-43-32 CUSTODERO FAMILY TRUST 3429 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 440 168-050-43-33 FITZGERALD CARYL L REVOCABLE TRUST 3425 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 441 168-050-43-34 PAUL R & CHERYL L BLANKENSHIP 3410 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 442 168-050-43-35 KOHL MOTT REVOCABLE TRUST 3414 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 443 168-050-43-36 LAJOYE LIVING TRUST 3418 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 444 168-050-43-37 PHEGLEY REVOCABLE TRUST 3422 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 445 168-050-43-38 FLORENCE V ANSELONA 3426 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 446 168-050-43-39 JAMES M & EVANS JUDY A SCHENK 1670 MAKALOA ST UNIT 204-4HONOLULU HI 96814 447 168-050-43-40 LEMOI DONNA 2014 LIVING TRUST 3434 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 448 168-050-43-41 STRONG ALAN G & DOROTHY E FAMILY TRUST 3438 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 449 168-050-43-42 SCIALDONE FRANK JR LIVING TRUST 5580 AZTEC DR UNIT 610 LA MESA CA 91942 450 168-050-43-43 BROWN RUTH S TRUST 3446 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 451 168-050-43-44 PEDROTTA FAMILY SURVIVORS TRUST 3450 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 452 168-050-43-45 CLUTTER FAMILY TRUST 3454 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 453 168-050-43-46 GLADDEN ELLEN J TRUST 3458 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 454 168-050-43-47 STEPHEN B & BRADY-RUBIN PAULA L RUBIN 3479 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 455 168-050-43-48 SHARI L RANSFORD 31016 SADDLEBACK RD VALLEY CENTER CA 92082 456 168-050-43-49 BONNIE B SAWYER 3467 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 457 168-050-43-50 A R A FAMILY TRUST 3461 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 458 168-050-43-51 ROLLER ADOLF A & JANE R TRUST 3455 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 459 168-050-43-52 HOBSON DENIS & DOROTHY TRUST 3449 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 460 168-050-43-53 RODDENBERRY ROD TRUST 15260 VENTURA BLVD UNIT 1040 SHERMAN OAKS CA 91403 461 168-050-43-54 FLORENCE H RHEBERG 3439 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 462 168-050-43-55 FROKE FAMILY TRUST 5410 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 463 168-050-43-56 JANET L WEIGEL 5418 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 464 168-050-43-57 WOOD DOROTHY B TRUST 5426 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 465 168-050-43-58 MAYER REVOCABLE TRUST 5434 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 466 168-050-43-59 UNDERHILL JAYNE E TRUST 2870 WINTERWARM WAY FALLBROOK CA 92028 467 168-050-43-60 DAVID H BAKER 5205 NE 32ND AVE PORTLAND OR 97211 468 168-050-43-61 BALANCIO BILL & PAMELA TRUST 5460 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 469 168-050-43-62 VIRGIL L & MARY MINKS 5459 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 470 168-050-43-63 VICTORIA J JACOBSON 5451 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 471 168-050-43-64 KNIGHT FAMILY TRUST 5443 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 472 168-050-43-65 PACE FRANK & SHEILA M FAMILY TRUST 5435 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 473 168-050-43-66 THOMAS M & SUSAN M BLACKWELL 5427 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 474 168-050-43-67 ARTHUR H & MURIEL M WAHL 5419 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 475 168-050-43-68 PAULA C MANHEIM 5411 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 476 168-050-43-69 MEACHAM ROMY C FAMILY TRUST 5405 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 477 168-050-43-70 HURTADO RALPH F TRUST 245 MARGUERITA LN PASADENA CA 91106 478 168-050-43-71 ANDERSON FAMILY TRUST 5446 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-43-72 SAME AS 422 479 168-050-43-73 OVERLAND JOANNE FAMILY TRUST 5430 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 480 168-050-43-74 PRATT FAMILY TRUST 5422 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 481 168-050-43-75 SELTSER TRUST 5414 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 482 168-050-43-76 RUSSELL SAMUEL & NORMA FAMILY TRUST 5406 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 483 168-050-43-77 ERNST JOANNE C LIVING TRUST 5455 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 484 168-050-43-78 RONALD A MILLER 5447 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 485 168-050-43-79 VAUGHAN CHALDY CAROLYN LIVING TRUST 5439 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 486 168-050-43-80 MENNING FAMILY TRUST 5431 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 487 168-050-43-81 BRADFORD ROBERTA J 2003 TRUST 5423 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 488 168-050-43-82 SAAR CHARLES E LIVING TRUST 5415 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 489 168-050-43-83 MUCKEY ROY W & BARBARA L LIVING TRUST 7929 LOS PINOS CIR CARLSBAD CA 92009 490 168-050-43-84 MYERS FAMILY TRUST 3428 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 491 168-050-43-85 PEDROTTA FAMILY SURVIVORS TRUST 3442 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 492 168-360-01-00 C I C GLEN RIDGE L P 6339 PASEO DEL LAGO CARLSBAD CA 92011 493 168-360-06, 07-00 FOOTHILLS AT CARLSBAD HOMEOWNERS ASSN 5950 LA PLACE CT UNIT 200 CARLSBAD CA 92008 494 168-360-11-01 SABRINA CARLI 3595 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 495 168-360-11-02 LEE TRUST 3599 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 496 168-360-11-03 LAWRENCE & LEE DIGNEY P O BOX 124 PRINCETON MA 1541 497 168-360-11-04 SHIH LIVING TRUST 3527 ROCK RIDGE RD CARLSBAD CA 92010 498 168-360-11-05 DU KONG TRUST 111 CANDLEGLOW IRVINE CA 92602 499 168-360-11-06 RAJENDRA N & MOHITE VAISHALI SALVI 3591 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 500 168-360-11-07 AHMED E ABURAHMAH 3571 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 501 168-360-11-08 ANDREW & YUAN WONG 8108 AURORA LN WHITTIER CA 90605 502 168-360-11-09 NATACHUK LLC 3905 SKYLINE RD CARLSBAD CA 92008 503 168-360-11-10 SHELLKOPF LIVING TRUST 3503 FOUR PEAKS ST CARLSBAD CA 92010 504 168-360-11-11 BARBARA BRANT 3563 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 505 168-360-11-12 LONG KY & ANNIE CHANG TRAN 3559 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 506 168-360-11-13 DOUGLAS J & KATHERINE A BOBECK 3550 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 507 168-360-11-14 DEQI & FU RAO CHEN 3554 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 508 168-360-11-15 NICOLE T VASIL 3562 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 509 168-360-11-16 DYLAN MALAYTER 3558 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 510 168-360-11-17 A & M FAMILY TRUST 2750 ARGONAUTA ST CARLSBAD CA 92009 511 168-360-11-18 MCNAMARA CASO FAMILY TRUST 3566 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 512 168-360-11-19 DIANA RADESTOCK 3578 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 513 168-360-11-20 MEAD FAMILY TRUST 3574 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 514 168-360-11-21 JENNIFER SELLERS 3586 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 515 168-360-11-22 KASEM & CEYDA S MARIFET 48 GOLDENBUSH IRVINE CA 92604 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 516 168-360-11-23 GEORGE H & SANDRA GROZA 3594 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 517 168-360-11-24 ARENSTORF ROSANNA J REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3590 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 518 168-360-11-25 CHARLES J A & KRISTIN M HARTMANN 3602 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 519 168-360-11-26 JOEL & HEIDI MONSON 3598 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 520 168-360-11-27 BERRY FAMILY LIVING TRUST 4833 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 521 168-360-11-28 LISA M SETTLECOWSKI 4837 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 522 168-360-11-29 KENNETH F FINNIGAN 3643 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 523 168-360-11-30 ROBERT A & PATRICIA A PASCOE 4825 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 524 168-360-11-31 DANIEL A & ODONNELL ANNE M CAMPBELL 4829 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 525 168-360-11-32 BRENT E & CHRISTINE R LABOUNTY 3631 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 526 168-360-11-33 JEFFREY & SUSAN WERNER 3635 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 527 168-360-11-34 ANCONG SHEN 3639 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 528 168-360-11-35 DREUSIKE GUY & ELLEN FAMILY TRUST 3619 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 529 168-360-11-36 JAGADEESWAR R & KAMATHAM KAVITHA BUTTI 3623 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 530 168-360-11-37 HAN CHIEN-PAI & MARIA LEE-FAN REVOCABLE MANAGEMENT 5020 BRIDGEWATER DR ARLINGTON TX 76017 531 168-360-11-38 DOUGLAS A & DEBRA J EATROS 3607 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 532 168-360-11-39 JENIFER F DUBERCHIN 7849 CERRO DEL SUR SAN DIEGO CA 92127 533 168-360-11-40 KENT A & WARE KERRI BRICKNER 3615 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 534 168-360-11-41 STUART & KIMBERLY OVERLIN 3605 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 535 168-360-11-42 RYAN & MARAHI RITA WILSON 3609 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 536 168-360-11-43 ROBINSON COLLEEN M LIVING TRUST 3597 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 537 168-360-11-44 OLIVA SHEN 3601 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 538 168-360-11-45 CHAUHAN FAMILY TRUST 3589 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 539 168-360-11-46 WILLIAM R & LAUREN K MATHIAS 3593 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 540 168-360-11-47 CHRISTOPHER M & PAMELA G F CASAS 3581 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 541 168-360-11-48 JEAN C CLENET 3585 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 542 168-360-11-49 SAN LIVING TRUST 3573 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 543 168-360-11-50 SANJIV & MONICA MEHTA 3577 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 544 168-360-11-51 NICOLE J DEGRAAN 3565 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 545 168-360-11-52 EVAN & MARIKA DIXON 3569 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 546 168-360-11-53 PAUL & NICOLE WYSOCKI 3557 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 547 168-360-11-54 JASON & DIANA E EVANGELISTA 3561 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 548 168-360-11-55 PHILLIPA A ORIMOLOYE 3553 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 549 168-360-11-56 SIDJONN M & KRISTINE TRAN REGALA 3549 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 550 168-360-17 TO 19-00 CASA ALDEA CARLSBAD LP 6102 GULLSTRAND ST SAN DIEGO CA 92122 168-361-03-00 SAME AS 493 551 168-370-84-00 FOOTHILLS AT CARLSBAD HOMEOWNERS ASSN 5966 LA PLACE CT UNIT 170 CARLSBAD CA 92008 552 168-372-01-00 MICHAEL K & LAURA M CHAN 3502 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 553 168-372-02-00 HERBERT D & DEBORAH S BUTLER 3506 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 554 168-372-03-00 JOSEPH C & MICHELLE C MARTELL 3510 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 555 168-372-04-00 SHIJIANG & ZHAO BIN LIANG 3514 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 556 168-372-05-00 DMITRY & PUSTOVALOVA ELENA PUSTOVALOV 3518 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 557 168-372-06-00 OSCAR M & SYLVIA R CUEVAS 3522 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 558 168-372-07-00 YUNGHANS FAMILY REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3526 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 559 168-372-08-00 PATRICK & WAGARI HANNA HOWELL 3530 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 560 168-372-09-00 SEAN P SILLSTROP 3534 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 561 168-372-33-00 FU-DONG & WU LIN WEI SHI 5258 COLERIDGE CT CARLSBAD CA 92008 562 168-372-34-00 SAHU DAS FAMILY TRUST 3521 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 563 168-372-35-00 ADRIAN & MENDES DEBRA ELLIOTT 3517 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 564 168-372-36-00 RUSSELL W & MARCIA R TASSINARI 3513 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 565 168-372-37-00 TRINH HUY CHAN FAMILY TRUST 3509 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 566 168-372-38-00 SWYNEY FAMILY TRUST 3505 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 567 168-372-39-00 HERRINGTON FAMILY TRUST 3501 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 568 168-372-40-00 HOWE LIVING TRUST 3782 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 569 168-372-41-00 HADDEN FAMILY REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3486 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 570 168-372-42-00 STEVE & SHERRIE BARRETT 3490 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 571 168-372-43-00 WILLIAM C & LINNEA S MARTIN 3504 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 572 168-372-44-00 PAUL G & DIANA R HAGERTY 3508 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 573 168-372-45-00 SALVATORE A & KATHLEEN H DANNA 4482 PALM AVE YORBA LINDA CA 92886 574 168-372-76-00 MARQUISS REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 3410 FOUR PEAKS ST CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-372-83, 84, 87-00 SAME AS 551 575 168-380-01-00 ANTHONY P & NICOLE DEROSE 3461 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 576 168-380-02-00 BRANDON S & NERI CATHERINE C SOUTHWORTH 3465 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 577 168-380-03-00 PATEL BIPIN & SHOBHANA 2016 TRUST 3469 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 578 168-380-04-00 ERIK Y & GUO XIAOMENG ZHANG 3473 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 579 168-380-05-00 BRIAN RAUCH 3477 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 580 168-380-06-00 FRENCH LEONARD & SANDRA FAMILY TRUST 3481 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 581 168-380-07-00 RADD EASON FAMILY TRUST 3485 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 582 168-380-08-00 CLARK FAMILY TRUST 3442 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 583 168-380-09-00 SUN ZUOMING & ZHOU HAIYING REVOCABLE FAMILY TRUST 1927 HIGHLAND OAKS DR ARCADIA CA 91006 584 168-380-10-00 MIKIE J & SOMMER N KETRON 3450 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 585 168-380-11-00 NORMAN A & MAMIE I LEE 3454 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 586 168-380-12-00 HALL FAMILY TRUST 3458 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 587 168-380-13-00 THAI C & MORIMOTO JEANETTE F CHEN 3462 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 588 168-380-14-00 JEFFREY S & HEIDI ORR 3466 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 589 168-380-15-00 KHALILI FRED & AZAM LIVING TRUST 3470 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 590 168-380-16-00 MONTHER J & ALAFRANJI LEENA S ABUSHABAN 3474 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-380-17, 20-00 SAME AS 551 591 168-380-22-00 STEPHEN J & KRISTIN M BLAKE 3481 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 592 168-380-23-00 MARK RIPPERGER 3477 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 593 168-380-24-00 DENISE M WILSON 3473 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 594 168-380-25-00 STANLEY & TRACY S FELDSOTT 3469 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 595 168-380-26-00 SATISH R & APARNA JAYANTHI 3465 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 596 168-380-27-00 WILLS ANN M REVOCABLE TRUST 3461 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 597 168-380-28-00 JAMES E & COLWELL MARTI J BRUSH 3457 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 598 168-380-29-00 REBECCA A CORNILLE 3453 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 599 168-380-30-00 PATRICK R & RUTHJOY R BITNER 3449 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 600 168-380-31-00 JUSTIN & MICHELLE LEVY 3445 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 601 168-380-32-00 SAMMY FAMILY TRUST 3441 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 602 168-380-33-00 JORDAN & PHANY S RACEY 3442 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 603 168-380-34-00 TY & CHERI ONDATJE 3438 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 604 168-380-35-00 CHARLES & CAROLYN LUNA 3433 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 605 168-380-36-00 ERIC & TANYA A WATANABE 3437 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 606 168-380-37-00 ANNETTE L PEER 3441 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 607 168-380-38-00 RYAN W & MELISSA L TEDDER 3445 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 608 168-380-39-00 BERT & JULIE A ORTIZ 3449 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 CROWN CASTLE BUN 824560 HOFFMAN PRAMIRA - TOM HANNA CANNON RD & WIND TRAIL WAY CARLSBAD - 600' OWNERS LIST 609 168-380-40-00 SUSAN M STOREY 3453 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 610 168-380-41-00 SCOTT & MARTZ KRISTINA PACE 3457 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 611 168-380-42-00 GAST-MIDDLETON TRUST 3461 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 612 168-380-43-00 BRIERY FAMILY TRUST 3454 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 613 168-380-44-00 JODI & RODNEY SQUIRES 3460 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 614 168-380-45-00 ROBERTSON RANCH WEST VILLAGE OWNERS ASSN 501 W BROADWAY SAN DIEGO CA 92101 615 168-380-46-00 CITY OF CARLSBAD 1200 CARLSBAD VILLAGE DR CARLSBAD CA 92008 208-010-38, 39, 42-00 SAME AS 615 616 208-020-39-00 STATE OF CALIFORNIA 100 S MAIN ST LOS ANGELES CA 90012 617 208-040-17-00 PAUL & STACEY FREDERIKSEN 5010 EUCALYPTUS LN CARLSBAD CA 92008 618 208-162-34-00 CARLSBAD CANTERBURY ASSN 10721 TREENA ST UNIT 200 SAN DIEGO CA 92131 619 208-170-37-00 HIDDEN RIDGE AT CARLSBAD HOMEOWNERS ASSN 15375 BARRANCA PKWY UNIT B212 IRVINE CA 92618 620 208-195-01-00 SHAPELL ROBERTSON LLC 1990 S BUNDY DR UNIT 500 LOS ANGELES CA 90025 621 208-195-09-00 RANCHO COSTERA LLC 725 W TOWN AND COUNTRY RD UNIT 200 ORANGE CA 92868 622 212-152-01-00 EVANS POINT HOMEOWNERS ASSN 10721 TREENA ST UNIT 200 SAN DIEGO CA 92131 CMH CONSULTING GROUP - PRAMIRA TOM HANNA 11835 CARMEL MTN RD SUITE 1304 353SAN DIEGO CA 92128 GC MAPPING SERVICE GILBERT CASTRO 3055 W VALLEY BLVD ALHAMBRA CA 91803 GC MAPPING SERVICE GILBERT CASTRO 5005 LA CALANDRIA WAY LOS ANGELES CA 90032 EXHIBIT C PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 1 168-050-37-01 CLARK TRUDEL FAMILY TRUST 3349 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 2 168-050-37-02 BERNADINE FENDRICK 3346 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 3 168-050-37-03 CORNWELL DONALD P & JUNE M 3338 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 4 168-050-37-04 DIANNE C PICCINI 3330 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 5 168-050-37-05 MEDLIN ANDREW G 3322 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 6 168-050-37-06 STACY Y & CAROL A COX 3314 DON QUIXOTE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 7 168-050-37-07 MOU KIZEN 3302 DON QUIXOTE DR #7 CARLSBAD CA 92010 8 168-050-37-08 CHARLES A & LUCIA G GENSLER 3301 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 9 168-050-37-09 GHISLAINE LAPOINTE 3315 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 10 168-050-37-10 REINHOLZ RIKKI 3323 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 11 168-050-37-11 MCANDREW FAMILY TRUST 3331 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 12 168-050-37-12 NOVAK EDWARD T 3339 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 13 168-050-37-13 POSYLUZNY NANCY E 3347 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 14 168-050-37-14 ARTHUR W HENTSCHEL 301 SUNRISE RD BREA CA 92821 15 168-050-37-15 GERARDO N TEMPESTA 69 RICE RD WAYLAND MA 1778 16 168-050-37-16 STANDERFER FAMILY TRUST 3332 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 17 168-050-37-17 PAEZ JOSE I & CLARA I 3324 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 18 168-050-37-18 MAXVILLE JUNE D 3314 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 19 168-050-37-19 MARSHA L PATCHEN 3302 DON TOMASO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 20 168-050-37-20 FREDERICK L & DEBRA K WILSON 3301 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 21 168-050-37-21 CRAWFORD CATHY 3311 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 22 168-050-37-22 EDWARD F & ANGELA A CROWE 9520 STOAKES AVE DOWNEY CA 90240 23 168-050-37-23 BARNETT FAMILY TRUST 3420 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 24 168-050-37-24 CHARLES H & LINDA L HENRY 3337 DON DIABLO DR #24 CARLSBAD CA 92010 25 168-050-37-25 ROBERT D & CINDY J WRIGHT 3345 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 26 168-050-37-26 LEVINE BURTON A 3390 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 27 168-050-37-27 PLESSNER JOAN 3384 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 28 168-050-37-28 FLANIGAN NANCY A 3378 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 29 168-050-37-29 DEANNA HARRIS 3372 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 30 168-050-37-30 JOSEPH H LEE & FREDERICKS BETH C 24 MANOR HOUSE RD NEWTON MA 2459 31 168-050-37-31 THORPE MCGRATH-THORPE FAMILY TRUST 3358 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 32 168-050-37-32 HOOVER FAMILY TRUST 3350 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 33 168-050-37-33 OBERST ROBERTA M 3342 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 34 168-050-37-34 MORENO FRANK A & SANDRA M 3336 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 35 168-050-37-35 SMITH MARY LOU 3328 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 36 168-050-37-36 ROCKLIN J & RONELL BERSCHNEIDER 3318 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 37 168-050-37-37 LAUDERBACK-ADAMS FAMILY TRUST 3312 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 38 168-050-37-38 THEODOR J & NANCY LASHLEY 3302 DON DIABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 39 168-050-37-39 DAVID D SALKIN 3301 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 40 168-050-37-40 KOHL FAMILY TRUST 3317 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 41 168-050-37-41 HANKIN FAMILY TRUST 3319 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 42 168-050-37-42 TURNER FAMILY TRUST 3327 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 43 168-050-37-43 LEIBELT FAMILY TRUST 3333 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 44 168-050-37-44 MARTINEZ FAMILY TRUST 3339 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 45 168-050-37-45 DRIVER CELESTE M 3343 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 46 168-050-37-46 KELLY ROBERTIS 3349 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 47 168-050-37-47 COLBURN CRAIG B & NANCY J 3355 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 48 168-050-37-48 HENDRIX ROBERT M & MARY E 1280 HIDDEN SPRINGS AVE OAK PARK CA 91377 49 168-050-37-49 STRANGE FRANK & MARILYN 3367 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 50 168-050-37-50 MICHAEL A STORTI 4552 ESSEX CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 51 168-050-37-51 SCHEURING LORI 3379 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 52 168-050-37-52 FRANCIS T & BARBARA J FOX 3385 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 53 168-050-37-53 BARBARA S ZANE 3340 DON PABLO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 54 168-050-37-54 PAGE OTIS S III & ROBIN A 5382 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 55 168-050-37-55 MILLER THOMAS G & SALLY J 5376 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 56 168-050-37-56 JONES FAMILY TRUST 5370 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 57 168-050-37-57 SNELSON REAL PROPERTY TRUST P O BOX 1175 EASTSOUND WA 98245 58 168-050-37-58 WALLIG FAMILY TRUST 5356 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 59 168-050-37-59 HILL MARJORIE B 5348 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 60 168-050-37-60 WILLIAM J WARREN 5342 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 61 168-050-37-61 MARY C SHARPE 5336 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 62 168-050-37-62 DINSMORE ROBERT W & DEBORAH M 1541 9TH ST SANTA MONICA CA 90401 63 168-050-37-63 SAWICKI FAMILY TRUST 15550 S 5TH AVE #164 PHOENIX AZ 85045 64 168-050-37-64 DILGARD SANDRA K 2588 EL CAMINO REAL #F404 CARLSBAD CA 92008 65 168-050-37-65 ALMOND SUSAN J 5308 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 66 168-050-37-66 PELUSO ROBERT L & JANICE L 5302 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 67 168-050-37-67 EDWARD E & MARLENE E WATHEN 650 WAKEFILED CT LONG BEACH CA 90803 68 168-050-37-68 MIDKIFF FAMILY TRUST 5307 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 69 168-050-37-69 LOUIS C DIONESE 5315 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 70 168-050-37-70 PHILLIPS FAMILY TRUST 5321 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 71 168-050-37-71 DONALD W WOLF 5327 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 72 168-050-37-72 SULLIVAN FAMILY TRUST 3758 HIGHLAND DR CARLSBAD CA 92008 73 168-050-37-73 DEEANN SUMMERS 5343 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 74 168-050-37-74 GARCIA ANGELA M 5351 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 75 168-050-37-75 RAGLAND DAVID C & KATHLEEN E 5359 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 76 168-050-37-76 MICHAEL M WARNER 5367 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 77 168-050-37-77 COSGROVE PATRICIA 5302 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 78 168-050-37-78 MCALLISTER CONCETTA 2960 EMERALD PL CARLSBAD CA 92009 79 168-050-37-79 ROGELIO S & KEELY C ALBA 2188 DICKINSON DR CARLSBAD CA 92008 80 168-050-37-80 WEKSLER DELORES J 3545 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 81 168-050-37-81 CONSTANCE R HUBBARD 124 MELROSE DR MISSION VIEJO CA 92692 82 168-050-37-82 MARDEN FAMILY TRUST 5338 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 83 168-050-37-83 DONALD M & BARBARA M VEALE 5346 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 84 168-050-37-84 SUMNER WILLIAM R P O BOX 43 CARLSBAD CA 92018 85 168-050-37-85 STARK BARBARA J 5362 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 86 168-050-37-86 STANLEY FAMILY TRUST 10343 S FAIRFIELD AVE CHICAGO IL 60655 87 168-050-37-87 AQUAZOOM WASHES LAND MANAGEMENT CO LLC 27452 CALLE ARROYO SAN JUAN CAPO CA 92675 88 168-050-37-88 CARLO & MICHELE TITONE 5365 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 89 168-050-37-89 JESSE L STILLIONS & MAYER BARBARA J 5357 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 90 168-050-37-90 FARROW SANDRA K 5349 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 91 168-050-37-91 GREEN JOHN F & DOROTHY E 5341 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 92 168-050-37-92 PAUL J & SHERRI R SISK 5335 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 93 168-050-37-93 FLOYD R RINGSTAD 5327 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 94 168-050-37-94 BEVERLY R HINSEY 5321 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 95 168-050-37-95 SCHOONOVER JOHNETTA K 5313 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 96 168-050-37-96 SHERRY L GRIEPP 5301 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 97 168-050-38-01 DYER FAMILY TRUST 5270 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 98 168-050-38-02 DALL SHARON P O BOX 684 BORREGO SPRINGS CA 92004 99 168-050-38-03 SAILER NINSUDA C 5256 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 100 168-050-38-04 ANCHISA FARRANT 5244 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 101 168-050-38-05 PERRY JOSEPH & MARJORIE E 5236 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 102 168-050-38-06 SIENKOWSKI MICHAEL A 5230 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 103 168-050-38-07 CLARK & CANDLER KAY L ERICKSON 29 CORNELL RD BALA CYNWYD PA 19004 104 168-050-38-08 LEE GLORIA A 5216 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 105 168-050-38-09 MORTON D & LI LING CAMPBELL 5210 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 106 168-050-38-10 ATKINSON FAMILY TRUST 5202 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 107 168-050-38-11 WILLIAM & HELEN CHESTNUT P O BOX 2604 CARLSBAD CA 92018 108 168-050-38-12 RAY & BARBARA E BARRIENTOS 5265 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 109 168-050-38-13 LEONARD J SMITH 5257 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 110 168-050-38-14 MCLOUGHLIN JAMES M 5245 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 111 168-050-38-15 JENNIFER L MITCHELL 3080 CAMINITO TERCER VERDE DEL MAR CA 92014 112 168-050-38-16 MELANIE HOFF 5229 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 113 168-050-38-17 ROBERT B & CAROL N DANZIGER 5223 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 114 168-050-38-18 BENNETT PAULINE C 5217 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 115 168-050-38-19 OTT LORA A 5209 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 116 168-050-38-20 BEVERLY J JONES 5201 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 117 168-050-38-21 MICHELLE G BETTIS P O BOX 332 CARLSBAD CA 92018 118 168-050-38-22 TIERNEY FAMILY TRUST 3452 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 119 168-050-38-23 RHONDA E CRAWFORD 5218 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 120 168-050-38-24 JACQUELINE MCKELVEY 1854 W 66TH AVE DENVER CO 80221 121 168-050-38-25 WALDEN MALVIN A & ELIZABETH A 5232 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 122 168-050-38-26 ROBERT J BUSH 5240 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 123 168-050-38-27 EAHEART MARY J 5246 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 124 168-050-38-28 AMORSEN LINDA L 5258 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 125 168-050-38-29 REGINATO FAMILY TRUST 554 HARVEY LN CORVALLIS MT 59828 126 168-050-38-30 MARTINI FAMILY TRUST 5272 DON VALDEZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 127 168-050-38-31 BRADFIELD BETTY L 5279 DON RICARDO DR #127 CARLSBAD CA 92010 128 168-050-38-32 NORMA PAYNE 3484 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 129 168-050-38-33 A P F INVESTMENTS L P 826 ORANGE AVE #295 CORONADO CA 92118 130 168-050-38-34 ARNOLD LORI 2904 RANCHO BRASADO CARLSBAD CA 92009 131 168-050-38-35 FOSTER RICHARD L & JULITA A 5241 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 132 168-050-38-36 BSHARAH FAMILY TRUST 5239 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 133 168-050-38-37 MAUER DONALD R & PATRICIA S 5227 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 134 168-050-38-38 DONALD E & JUDY L BAKER 5215 DON RICARDO DR #134 CARLSBAD CA 92010 135 168-050-38-39 PAUL A & SHARON M LORKOVIC 5211 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 136 168-050-38-40 RICHARD J & JUDITH A SEGAL 5201 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 137 168-050-38-41 ANNE C WOODARD 5165 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 138 168-050-38-42 MILAM JEAN 5163 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 139 168-050-38-43 ANNE FUSCO 5152 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 140 168-050-38-44 GARY L & PHYLLIS F WEED 5144 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 141 168-050-38-45 UNDERWOOD JAMES L & LOIS T 5136 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 142 168-050-38-46 NELSON FAMILY TRUST 5128 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 143 168-050-38-47 RAFFY TOM & LORI 1125 VIA PINTADA RIVERSIDE CA 92507 144 168-050-38-48 BLACKLEDGE FAMILY TRUST 5101 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 145 168-050-38-49 2001 ROSS ROADS TRUST 5119 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 146 168-050-38-50 BOWEN JAMES & CATHERIN 5125 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 147 168-050-38-51 CAPITOL TRUST 5135 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 148 168-050-38-52 SULLIVAN FAMILY TRUST 3758 HIGHLAND DR CARLSBAD CA 92008 149 168-050-38-53 TERRY W & BARBARA E STEPHENS 5147 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 150 168-050-38-54 JUDY A WINDSOR 5155 DON RICARDO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 151 168-050-38-55 JERRY & SUZANNE TEMPESTA 68 RICE RD WAYLAND MA 1778 152 168-050-38-56 MICHIELI MARIA T 5114 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 153 168-050-38-57 RICHARD & MELINDA HALEY 5120 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 154 168-050-38-58 MERITT CYNTHIA S 5126 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 155 168-050-38-59 MOLINA CARLOS & PATRICIA 5134 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 156 168-050-38-60 LARRY C WINDEMULLER & COOK KATHRYN L 5140 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 157 168-050-38-61 STEELE LARRY L & SHARI R 5146 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 158 168-050-38-62 PHILIP LIZARRAGA 5157 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 159 168-050-38-63 SPECIAL NEEDS TRUST 1198 VIA SANTA PAULO VISTA CA 92081 160 168-050-38-64 THEIS FAMILY TRUST 5145 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 161 168-050-38-65 DARRYL & CINDY SMITH 5139 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 162 168-050-38-66 LANCE & ANNETTE MALKIND 5133 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 163 168-050-38-67 THOMAS & MARGARET GRASZER 5127 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 164 168-050-38-68 COSGROVE SHANNON 5121 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 165 168-050-38-69 DALE & DONNA REICH 5115 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 166 168-050-38-70 NANCY BAILEY 5109 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 167 168-050-38-71 SCIULLI FAMILY TRUST 9819 LYNCAROL DR LA MESA CA 91941 168 168-050-38-72 TORNBORG MARY E 5101 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 169 168-050-39-01 DUNGAN FAMILY TRUST 5102 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 170 168-050-39-02 RITTER FAMILY TRUST 5106 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 171 168-050-39-03 STEPHENSON FAMILY TRUST 5110 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 172 168-050-39-04 DEELEY-BARNARD FAMILY TRUST 5116 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 173 168-050-39-05 HILDA J SHAW 5120 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 174 168-050-39-06 GROGAN CHARLINE 5124 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 175 168-050-39-07 DUFFIN FAMILY TRUST 5128 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 176 168-050-39-08 BOWER RAYMOND & BERTHA 5132 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 177 168-050-39-09 PRUITT RAYNEL I 5136 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 178 168-050-39-10 HILLIARD FAMILY TRUST 5140 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 179 168-050-39-11 GEOFFREY C & SUSAN E CRONK 5144 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 180 168-050-39-12 JENNIFER A WELLS 8911 KITTIWAKE ST LITTLETON CO 80126 181 168-050-39-13 DIANE B COTTINGHAM 5152 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 182 168-050-39-14 POWELL FAMILY TRUST 5156 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 183 168-050-39-15 JUDITH REYNOLDS 5160 DON RODOLFO DR #183 CARLSBAD CA 92010 184 168-050-39-16 JAIME & MILAGROS LIMJOCO 5164 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 185 168-050-39-17 KENNETH & LORINDA DORFF 5168 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 186 168-050-39-18 CLARENCE A & JUDITH H JUHL 5172 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 187 168-050-39-19 LOUIS M SERRANO & ZISKA CATHERINE A 5176 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 188 168-050-39-20 MURPHEY FAMILY TRUST 5180 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 189 168-050-39-21 STOABS FAMILY TRUST 5184 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 190 168-050-39-22 HEATHMAN FAMILY TRUST 5186 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 191 168-050-39-23 GLENN & AMY GREANEY 5188 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 192 168-050-39-24 LAUBE FAMILY TRUST 5190 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 193 168-050-39-25 KENNETH L & LAURA J STANHOPE 2172 E 26TH WAY YUMA AZ 85365 194 168-050-39-26 JOE R & SHIRLEY A BEEMER 5194 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 195 168-050-39-27 ARBOLEDA FAMILY TRUST P O BOX 3121 S PASADENA CA 91031 196 168-050-39-28 JOHN FERGUSON 5163 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 197 168-050-39-29, 030 ALFREY FAMILY TRUST 5155 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 198 168-050-39-31 RADOGNA FAMILY TRUST 5139 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 199 168-050-39-32 KATHY S GOLDEN 5131 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 200 168-050-39-33 GLADYS K CARBONE 5123 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 201 168-050-39-34 ROCK FAMILY TRUST 5178 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 202 168-050-39-35 GREGORY H & ISABEL KUVER 5172 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 203 168-050-39-36 GUNN FAMILY TRUST 5166 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 204 168-050-39-37 ROBERT A & SHAWN M PERKINS 5158 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 205 168-050-39-38 BARKER RICHARD & MELINDA 5150 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 206 168-050-39-39 LINCOLN BRADNER 5144 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 207 168-050-39-40 JACOBSON FAMILY TRUST 5132 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 208 168-050-39-41 CUNRADI FAMILY TRUST 5128 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 209 168-050-39-42 EDWIN D & LUCY SARGEANT 5117 DON RODOLFO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 210 168-050-39-43 WAYMAN FAMILY TRUST 5101 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 211 168-050-39-44 TAYLOR FAMILY TRUST 5107 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 212 168-050-39-45 JANIS STANSFIELD 653 STANFORD DR SN LUIS OBISP CA 93405 213 168-050-39-46 RAZZA FAMILY TRUST 5121 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 214 168-050-39-47 MOORE JUDITH A 5129 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 215 168-050-39-48 BARKER N JEAN 5135 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 216 168-050-39-49 LARRY R & JUDY L BREM 5143 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 217 168-050-39-50 JACKIE L & MARIE T KESSLER 5151 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 218 168-050-39-51 PACE KENNETH E 5157 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 219 168-050-39-52 BUSBY CATHY L 5163 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 220 168-050-39-53 GALLERY FAMILY TRUST 5171 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 221 168-050-39-54 BOOZER ELYSIA 5177 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 222 168-050-39-55 S & S TRUST P O BOX 2604 CARLSBAD CA 92018 223 168-050-40-01 WYATT FAMILY TRUST 3443 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 224 168-050-40-02 AVALLONE ELAINE M 3435 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 225 168-050-40-03 PARK FAMILY TRUST 3427 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 226 168-050-40-04 ROBERT GONZALEZ & EUGENIAS-GONZALEZ LINDA 3419 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 227 168-050-40-05 TURNER LAWRENCE D 3411 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 228 168-050-40-06 DEVANE-PACE SUSAN 5157 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 229 168-050-40-07 WALTRIP JAMES C & NOREEN M 3406 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 230 168-050-40-08 KENNING KATHRYN M 3414 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 231 168-050-40-09 GLEDHILL JOHN & MARTHA M 3422 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 232 168-050-40-10 DAVID W & JEAN E CRAWFORD 3430 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 233 168-050-40-11 ASPIRAS GRACE 3438 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 234 168-050-40-12 WILLIAM L JOHNSON & NARISSE FRANCES 3446 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 235 168-050-40-13 SCHIMPF EMIL & JEAN 3454 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 236 168-050-40-14 WILLIAM M BENJAMIN 9860 LA TORTOLA PL SAN DIEGO CA 92129 237 168-050-40-15 CRAMM GERALD G & KATHLEEN A 3445 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 238 168-050-40-16 MCKINNEY FAMILY TRUST 3437 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 239 168-050-40-17 JOHN D & KARLA O ANTOL 3429 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 240 168-050-40-18 ROBERT A PERKINS 5158 DON MATA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 241 168-050-40-19 WARD FAMILY TRUST 3413 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 242 168-050-40-20 DION FAMILY TRUST 3407 DON COTA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 243 168-050-40-21 JOHNSON DOLORES 5302 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 244 168-050-40-22 FITZPATRICK DIANE 342 HILLCREST DR ENCINITAS CA 92024 245 168-050-40-23 CADE FAMILY TRUST 5318 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 246 168-050-40-24 SUSAN OSMANSKI 5326 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 247 168-050-40-25 REBECCA L DELEISSEGUES 5342 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 248 168-050-40-26 TOSHIAKI & SAILAJA P HARADA 5350 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 249 168-050-40-27 CLEM VALERIE A 5358 DON ALVAREZ DR #250 CARLSBAD CA 92010 250 168-050-40-28 TANAEL FAMILY TRUST 5366 DON ALVAREZ DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 251 168-050-40-29 MURRAY SUZANNE 3402 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 252 168-050-40-30 EBERT ROBERT R & DONNA C 3408 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 253 168-050-40-31 ROBB JILL P O BOX 675550 RANCHO SANTA FE CA 92067 168-050-40-32 SAME AS #23 254 168-050-40-33 QUEEN TRUST 3426 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-40-34 SAME AS #181 255 168-050-40-35 HUNSICKER JOHN K & SANDRA L 3438 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 256 168-050-40-36 NEAL FAMILY TRUST 3444 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 257 168-050-40-37 ROBB JILL P O BOX 675550 RCHO SANTA FE CA 92067 258 168-050-40-38 ALFRED & PENNY W DAPELLO 3456 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 259 168-050-40-39 SPECTOR RENEE 3462 DON JOSE DR #303 CARLSBAD CA 92010 260 168-050-40-40 HOFFMAN FAMILY TRUST 3468 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 261 168-050-40-41 TORNELLO FAMILY TRUST 3474 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 262 168-050-40-42 PAUL F HARGADON 3475 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-40-43 SAME AS #202 263 168-050-40-44 GIPNER VIRGINIA L 3457 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 264 168-050-40-45 GREER ARTHUR & CARMEN 3449 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 265 168-050-40-46 ASHLEY MITCHELL LONDON NW3 7SB ENGLAND 266 168-050-40-47 PRICE FAMILY TRUST 3433 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 267 168-050-40-48 CALLAHAN FAMILY TRUST 3423 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 268 168-050-40-49 SKINNER FAMILY TRUST 3415 DON JOSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 269 168-050-40-50 ANDERSON SOCORRO R 3420 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 270 168-050-40-51 HAARSTAD VERNA M 3438 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 271 168-050-40-52 DEVANY THOMAS & KAREN 3434 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 272 168-050-40-53 CHRISTY FAMILY TRUST 3444 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 272A 168-050-40-54 LEXINGTON TRUST 3452 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 273 168-050-40-55 RUDY FAMILY TRUST 3460 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 274 168-050-40-56 HALSTEAD NANCY R 3468 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 275 168-050-40-57 JOHN BROHARD 3512 PRINCETON AVE SAN DIEGO CA 92117 276 168-050-40-58 JONES FAMILY TRUST 3489 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 277 168-050-40-59 DONALD J & CYNTHIA LADD 3481 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 278 168-050-40-60 TERRIE NATAN 3473 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 279 168-050-40-61 JAMES A & PATRICIA R LAYMAN 3465 DON PORFIRIO DR #284 CARLSBAD CA 92010 280 168-050-40-62 RUSSELL L & SUZANNE H HANTHORN 3457 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 281 168-050-40-63 MARGARET A CRICKS 3450 S OWL SLICK RD CORNVILLE AZ 86325 282 168-050-40-64 COURTNEY LUCIEN & MARION 3441 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 283 168-050-40-65 ROBERT W & ANITA M FLORES 3435 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 284 168-050-40-66 STEVEN HARKINS 3432 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 285 168-050-40-67 NEVILLE FAMILY TRUST 3440 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 286 168-050-40-68 BOTTO JOAN 3446 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 287 168-050-40-69 ARMSTRONG CHRISTINA R 3452 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 288 168-050-40-70 THULIN GRACE 3458 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 289 168-050-40-71 MARY BENNETT 3464 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 290 168-050-40-72 AARON LAMB 11633 SORRENTO VALLEY RD #200 SAN DIEGO CA 92121 291 168-050-40-73 CLARENCE & JANICE RIDDLE 3480 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 292 168-050-40-74 MARILYN MEMORY 3488 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 293 168-050-41-01 STEVEN SMITH 3485 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 294 168-050-41-02 REITER LAVONNE 3479 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 295 168-050-41-03 JOHNSON LLOYD M 3473 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 296 168-050-41-04 JAMES F & MARY A CARR 3467 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 297 168-050-41-05 BARBARA A COREY 3461 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 298 168-050-41-06 CRAIG CARRIE J 3455 DON ARTURO DR #303 CARLSBAD CA 92010 299 168-050-41-07 ADAMS PATRICIA A 3449 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 300 168-050-41-08 DEREUS GERARDUS J 3443 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 301 168-050-41-09 SWANSEN FAMILY TRUST 3437 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 302 168-050-41-10 BEAR FAMILY TRUST 3431 DON ARTURO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 303 168-050-41-11 FISSORI NELLIE J 3430 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 304 168-050-41-12 PIPPEN NANCY M 325 COPPER CANYON TRL CARY IL 60013 305 168-050-41-13 CONWAY MONICA L 3436 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 306 168-050-41-14 MCCRACKEN JOANN 3438 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 307 168-050-41-15 JANET M SWYSGOOD 3442 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 308 168-050-41-16 ENIGENBURG FAMILY TRUST 3444 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 309 168-050-41-17 BABA THOMAS V 3446 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 310 168-050-41-18 JOAN R SCHNEIDER 3448 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 311 168-050-41-19 HAINES JANET L 3450 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 312 168-050-41-20 KRISTINE BROWN & SMERDU PATRICE 3499 DON PORFIRIO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 313 168-050-41-21 BOHEN ROBERTA 3454 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 314 168-050-41-22 DIANE F COOPER 3456 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 315 168-050-41-23 VOLGAMORE FAMILY TRUST 3458 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 316 168-050-41-24 PODRUP TRUST 3460 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 317 168-050-41-25 SUSAN K AFENTUL 3462 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 318 168-050-41-26 MARKEY FAMILY TRUST 3464 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 319 168-050-41-27 WHEELER CAROL N 36240 PECAN CT FREMONT CA 94536 320 168-050-41-28 MACE BRYAN A 3468 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 321 168-050-41-29 FRANCES JEAN 3470 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 322 168-050-41-30 TOBY S SLOVER 3472 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 323 168-050-41-31 CULBERT FAMILY TRUST 3476 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 324 168-050-41-32 WEISS GARY F & REBECCA J 3478 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-41-33 SAME AS #72 325 168-050-41-34 MARTHA L OXLEY 3484 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 326 168-050-41-35 BERRY FAMILY TRUST 3488 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-41-36 SAME AS #202 327 168-050-41-37 PAMELA C DESMOND 3481 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 328 168-050-41-38 JAMES A & BARBARA J KORNOFF 3479 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 329 168-050-41-39 STRINGER VIOLET B 130 AVENIDA BARCELONA SAN CLEMENTE CA 92672 330 168-050-41-40 MELISSA W COOK 647 ALAMEDA BLVD CORONADO CA 92118 331 168-050-41-41 LAYNE BONNIE L 3469 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 332 168-050-41-42 CROWE FAMILY TRUST 3467 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 333 168-050-41-43 SALVATORE R & SUSAN M GAGLIANO 3465 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 334 168-050-41-44 CHU IRIS J GOODRIDGE 3461 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 335 168-050-41-45 AWERMAN BONITA 3459 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 336 168-050-41-46 EVANSON FAMILY TRUST 3457 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 337 168-050-41-47 TERSOLO REMO J & MARGARET C 7101 MANZANITA ST CARLSBAD CA 92011 338 168-050-41-48 MITCHELL GEORGE S & PHYLLIS J 3449 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 339 168-050-41-49 MARGUERITE L HUNT 3447 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 340 168-050-41-50 LOMBARDI FAMILY TRUST 3445 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 341 168-050-41-51 KATHLEEN Y MACKZ 3443 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 342 168-050-41-52 JAMES V STORELLI 3439 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 343 168-050-41-53 MATA MARGO 3437 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 344 168-050-41-54 RUNNER FAMILY TRUST 3433 DON LORENZO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 345 168-050-41-55 BAUMEISTER GENEVIEVE M 203 ACACIA AVE HUNTINGTN BCH CA 92648 346 168-050-41-56 CRISPEN FAMILY TRUST 2378 TERRAZA RIBERA CARLSBAD CA 92009 347 168-050-41-57 ARNOLD FAMILY TRUST 3432 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 348 168-050-41-58 BLANCO FAMILY TRUST 1341 CORVIDAE ST CARLSBAD CA 92011 349 168-050-41-59 MORRIS E & PATRICIA A TILDEN 3438 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 350 168-050-41-60 KAMPMANN FRANK & RUTH 3440 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 351 168-050-41-61 ROCHELLE GERLICH 3442 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 352 168-050-41-62 TURIACE FAMILY TRUST 3444 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 353 168-050-41-63 RICHMOND H & VERONICA K WARREN 3446 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 354 168-050-41-64 SONNENBERG RICHARD H 3450 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 355 168-050-41-65 WILLYARD FAMILY TRUST 3454 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 356 168-050-41-66 EDWARD W BUTTS & DIETRICH NYDALEE B 3456 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 357 168-050-41-67 VANSLYKE ALASKA 300 HERMIT ST #8 JUNEAU AK 99801 358 168-050-41-68 KLINKO FAMILY TRUST 3462 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 359 168-050-41-69 BORISON PATRICIA L 3466 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 360 168-050-41-70 JABEZ FAMILY TRUST 3468 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 361 168-050-41-71 ANNABLE LOUISE K 3470 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 362 168-050-41-72 DENOOY HERMAN R 5105 DON MIGUEL DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 363 168-050-41-73 NAUTA FAMILY TRUST 3478 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 364 168-050-41-74 ANTHONY N KURLOVICH & SAYLES NANCY J 3534 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 365 168-050-42-01 HEADINGS FAMILY TRUST 3479 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 366 168-050-42-02 SWEARINGEN FAMILY TRUST 3475 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 367 168-050-42-03 DAWSON FAMILY TRUST 3473 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 368 168-050-42-04 ELIZABETH R LEBARON 3471 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 369 168-050-42-05 KASTENHOLZ LINDA 3467 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-42-06 SAME AS #189 168-050-42-07 SAME AS #107 370 168-050-42-08 DAPELLO/KEYES FAMILY TRUST 3451 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 371 168-050-42-09 KATHLEEN A SPRAGUE 3445 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 372 168-050-42-10 HALEY FAMILY TRUST 3019 AZAHAR CT CARLSBAD CA 92009 168-050-42-11 SAME AS #217 373 168-050-42-12 SCHUMACHER FAMILY TRUST 3439 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 374 168-050-42-13 DINGLE BARRY L & KATHERINE J 3435 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 375 168-050-42-14 MCCULLAH RONALD & MARIANNE 3433 DON ORTEGA DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 376 168-050-42-15 GRESHAM FAMILY TRUST 3446 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 377 168-050-42-16 ODELL SUSAN M 3450 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 378 168-050-42-17 RAYMOND D & SHARON L LARSON 3454 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 379 168-050-42-18 LEONARD B & CAROLYN A FOLEY 3458 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 380 168-050-42-19 CORREIA LEWIS A & JENNIFER L 3462 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 381 168-050-42-20 STONE FAMILY TRUST 3464 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 382 168-050-42-21 JEFFREY E LANDES 916 PIOVANA CT CARLSBAD CA 92011 383 168-050-42-22 WILLIAM H & SUSAN P WILSON 3472 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 384 168-050-42-23 CLEMENT LON F 3474 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 385 168-050-42-24 RENTERIA TERESA 3478 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 386 168-050-42-25 JAMES H & JANICE B NEWLOVE 2749 ABERDEEN LN EL DORADO HILLS CA 95762 387 168-050-42-26 BROOKS LEONA M 3505 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 388 168-050-42-27 HESTER DAYL 3515 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 389 168-050-42-28 HANDELMAN FAMILY TRUST 3523 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 390 168-050-42-29 ABBAMONTE CRAIG D 14011 VENTURA BLVD #301 SHERMAN OAKS CA 91423 391 168-050-42-30 AMOS ALBERTA 3539 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-42-31 SAME AS #80 392 168-050-42-32 GARRY L FOSTER & LAKE JOCELYN L 3553 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 393 168-050-42-33 JOHNSTON PAUL M & MARJORIE E 3561 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 394 168-050-42-34 DELANGE PHYLLIS E 3569 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 395 168-050-42-35 PRICE FAMILY TRUST 3506 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 396 168-050-42-36 WHITING BROEDER FAMILY TRUST 3514 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 397 168-050-42-37 GULIZIA SHARON J 3522 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 398 168-050-42-38 MITCHELL FAMILY TRUST 3530 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 399 168-050-42-39 HORNA LOUISE M 3538 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 400 168-050-42-40 WILLIAM L & ANNIE M SIMONTON 3546 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 401 168-050-42-41 WOODROW POORE & BRIGGS-POORE PAULA 3554 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 402 168-050-42-42 JENKS FAMILY TRUST 3562 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 403 168-050-42-43 PATRICIA A PALUMBO 3570 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 404 168-050-42-44 CINKO FAMILY TRUST 3571 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 405 168-050-42-45 BLANCO FAMILY TRUST 1341 CORVIDAE ST CARLSBAD CA 92011 406 168-050-42-46 LEWIS FAMILY TRUST 4784 BEACHWOOD CT CARLSBAD CA 92008 407 168-050-42-47 PETRACH FAMILY TRUST 3547 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 408 168-050-42-48 KOSCIELSKI FAMILY TRUST 3539 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 409 168-050-43-01 FANT DOYLE & BONNIE 3497 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 410 168-050-43-02 SIMES RONALD V 3491 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 411 168-050-43-03 MELLER DIANA L 3485 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 412 168-050-43-04 REED FAMILY TRUST 3479 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 413 168-050-43-05 DORIS F HERMES 3471 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 414 168-050-43-06 RAYMUNDO & REBECCA C MURILLO 3463 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 415 168-050-43-07 SCOTT & CHERYL L SUTCLIFFE 3455 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 416 168-050-43-08 BLAZAK FAMILY TRUST 1254 WINCHESTER CT VISTA CA 92083 417 168-050-43-09 THOMAS T & KATHLEEN A MYRON 3443 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 418 168-050-43-10 PERCY N & MARGARET J CRIDDLE NORTH SAANICH BC CANADA V8L5T4 419 168-050-43-11 FINN KATHLEEN M 3431 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 420 168-050-43-12 SCOTELLA FAMILY TRUST 28913 BESTE ST ST CLR SHORES MI 48081 421 168-050-43-13 RONALD D MARBEN 3424 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 422 168-050-43-14 BETTY KENNEDY 2729 LA GRAN VIA CARLSBAD CA 92009 423 168-050-43-15 ROXANNE K REGINATO 554 HARVEY LN CORVALLIS MT 59828 424 168-050-43-16 KENT & MARILYN M ALLEN 3446 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 425 168-050-43-17 DONNA GOOLEY 3454 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 426 168-050-43-18 ESTUESTA RICHARD L & VICKY L 3462 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 427 168-050-43-19 OLEARY FAMILY TRUST 3468 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 428 168-050-43-20 GUNNY FAMILY TRUST 3476 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 429 168-050-43-21 NORMA R PAYNE 3484 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 430 168-050-43-22 BURMEISTER FAMILY TRUST 3490 DON ALBERTO DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 431 168-050-43-23 GOLDSMITH CHRISTINE 3496 DON ALBERTO DR #442 CARLSBAD CA 92010 432 168-050-43-24 ROLLER FAMILY TRUST 3461 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 433 168-050-43-25 RICCI DOROTHY L 3457 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 434 168-050-43-26 JOHN G & FRANCES J ELLENA 3453 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-43-27 SAME AS #62 435 168-050-43-28 WYNNE HELEN P F 537 MARIPOSA AVE #9 MOUNTAIN VIEW CA 94041 436 168-050-43-29 BOSWORTH L C 3441 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 437 168-050-43-30 ALBERTS LILIANE G 3437 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 438 168-050-43-31 THEODORE F SPRIGGS 3433 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 439 168-050-43-32 CUSTODERO FAMILY TRUST 3429 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 440 168-050-43-33 FITZGERALD CARYL L 3425 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 441 168-050-43-34 PAUL R & CHERYL L BLANKENSHIP 3410 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 442 168-050-43-35 KOHL MOTT TRUST 3414 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 443 168-050-43-36 LAJOYE FAMILY TRUST 3418 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 444 168-050-43-37 PHEGLEY FAMILY TRUST 3422 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 445 168-050-43-38 ANSELONA FLORENCE V 3426 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 446 168-050-43-39 SCHENK JAMES M & EVANS JUDY A 1670 MAKALOA ST #204-4 HONOLULU HI 96814 447 168-050-43-40 LEMOI DONNA 3434 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 448 168-050-43-41 STRONG ALAN G & DOROTHY E 3438 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 449 168-050-43-42 SCIALDONE FRANK JR 5580 AZTEC DR #610 LA MESA CA 91942 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 450 168-050-43-43 BROWN RUTH S 3446 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 451 168-050-43-44 PEDROTTA FAMILY TRUST 3450 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 452 168-050-43-45 CLUTTER FAMILY TRUST 3454 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 453 168-050-43-46 GLADDEN ELLEN J 3458 DON CARLOS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 454 168-050-43-47 STEPHEN RUBIN & BRADY-RUBIN PAULA 3479 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 455 168-050-43-48 SHARI L RANSFORD 31016 SADDLEBACK RD VALLEY CENTER CA 92082 456 168-050-43-49 BONNIE B SAWYER 3467 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 457 168-050-43-50 A R A FAMILY TRUST 3461 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 458 168-050-43-51 EILEEN M TILTON 3455 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 459 168-050-43-52 HOBSON DENIS & DOROTHY 3449 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 460 168-050-43-53 RODDENBERRY ROD 15260 VENTURA BLVD #1040 SHERMAN OAKS CA 91403 461 168-050-43-54 FLORENCE H RHEBERG 3439 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 462 168-050-43-55 FROKE FAMILY TRUST 5410 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 463 168-050-43-56 JANET L WEIGEL 5418 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 464 168-050-43-57 WOOD DOROTHY B 5426 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 465 168-050-43-58 MAYER FAMILY TRUST 5434 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 466 168-050-43-59 UNDERHILL JAYNE E 2870 WINTERWARM WAY FALLBROOK CA 92028 467 168-050-43-60 DAVID H BAKER 5205 NE 32ND AVE PORTLAND OR 97211 468 168-050-43-61 BALANCIO BILL & PAMELA 5460 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 469 168-050-43-62 VIRGIL L & MARY MINKS 5459 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 470 168-050-43-63 VICTORIA J JACOBSON 5451 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 471 168-050-43-64 KNIGHT FAMILY TRUST 5443 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 472 168-050-43-65 PACE FRANK & SHEILA M 5435 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 473 168-050-43-66 THOMAS M & SUSAN M BLACKWELL 5427 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 474 168-050-43-67 ARTHUR H & MURIEL M WAHL 5419 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 475 168-050-43-68 PAULA C MANHEIM 5411 DON FELIPE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 476 168-050-43-69 MEACHAM ROMY C 3130 ARLOTTE AVE LONG BEACH CA 90808 477 168-050-43-70 HURTADO RALPH F 245 MARGUERITA LN PASADENA CA 91106 478 168-050-43-71 ANDERSON FAMILY TRUST 5446 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-050-43-72 SAME AS #422 479 168-050-43-73 OVERLAND JOANNE 5430 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 480 168-050-43-74 PRATT FAMILY TRUST 5422 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 481 168-050-43-75 SELTSER TRUST 5414 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 482 168-050-43-76 RUSSELL SAMUEL & NORMA 5406 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 483 168-050-43-77 ERNST JOANNE C 5455 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 484 168-050-43-78 RONALD A MILLER 5447 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 485 168-050-43-79 VAUGHAN-CHALDY CAROLYN 5439 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 486 168-050-43-80 MENNING FAMILY TRUST 5431 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 487 168-050-43-81 BRADFORD ROBERTA J 5423 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 488 168-050-43-82 SAAR CHARLES E 5415 DON LUIS DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 489 168-050-43-83 MUCKEY ROY W & BARBARA L 7929 LOS PINOS CIR CARLSBAD CA 92009 490 168-050-43-84 MYERS FAMILY TRUST 3428 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 491 168-050-43-85 PEDROTTA FAMILY TRUST 3442 DON JUAN DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 492 168-360-01-00 C I C GLEN RIDGE L P 3990 RUFFIN RD #100 SAN DIEGO CA 92123 493 168-360-06, 07-00 FOOTHILLS AT CARLSBAD HOMEOWNERS ASSN 5950 LA PLACE CT #200 CARLSBAD CA 92008 494 168-360-11-01 SABRINA CARLI 3595 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 495 168-360-11-02 LEE FAMILY TRUST 3599 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 496 168-360-11-03 LAWRENCE & LEE DIGNEY P O BOX 124 PRINCETON MA 1541 497 168-360-11-04 SHIH FAMILY TRUST 3527 ROCK RIDGE RD CARLSBAD CA 92010 498 168-360-11-05 DU KONG TRUST 111 CANDLEGLOW IRVINE CA 92602 499 168-360-11-06 RAJENDRA N SALVI & MOHITE VAISHALI 3591 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 500 168-360-11-07 AHMED E ABURAHMAH 3571 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 501 168-360-11-08 ANDREW & YUAN WONG 8108 AURORA LN WHITTIER CA 90605 502 168-360-11-09 NATACHUK LLC 3905 SKYLINE RD CARLSBAD CA 92008 503 168-360-11-10 SHELLKOPF FAMILY TRUST 3503 FOUR PEAKS ST CARLSBAD CA 92010 504 168-360-11-11 BARBARA BRANT 3563 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 505 168-360-11-12 LONG KY & ANNIE CHANG TRAN 3559 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 506 168-360-11-13 DOUGLAS J & KATHERINE A BOBECK 3550 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 507 168-360-11-14 DEQI & FU RAO CHEN 3554 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 508 168-360-11-15 NICOLE T VASIL 3562 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 509 168-360-11-16 DYLAN MALAYTER 3558 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 510 168-360-11-17 A & M FAMILY TRUST 2750 ARGONAUTA ST CARLSBAD CA 92009 511 168-360-11-18 MCNAMARA CASO FAMILY TRUST 3566 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 512 168-360-11-19 DIANA RADESTOCK 3578 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 513 168-360-11-20 MEAD FAMILY TRUST 3574 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 514 168-360-11-21 JENNIFER SELLERS 3586 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 515 168-360-11-22 KASEM & CEYDA S MARIFET 48 GOLDENBUSH IRVINE CA 92604 516 168-360-11-23 GEORGE H & SANDRA GROZA 3594 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 517 168-360-11-24 ARENSTORF ROSANNA J 3590 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 518 168-360-11-25 CHARLES J A & KRISTIN M HARTMANN 3602 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 519 168-360-11-26 JOEL & HEIDI MONSON 3598 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 520 168-360-11-27 BERRY FAMILY TRUST 4833 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 521 168-360-11-28 LISA M SETTLECOWSKI 4837 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 522 168-360-11-29 KENNETH F FINNIGAN 3643 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 523 168-360-11-30 ROBERT A & PATRICIA A PASCOE 4825 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 524 168-360-11-31 DANIEL A CAMPBELL & ODONNELL ANNE M 4829 MESA TRAIL PL CARLSBAD CA 92010 525 168-360-11-32 BRENT E & CHRISTINE R LABOUNTY 3631 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 526 168-360-11-33 JEFFREY & SUSAN WERNER 3635 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 527 168-360-11-34 ANCONG SHEN 3639 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 528 168-360-11-35 DREUSIKE GUY & ELLEN 3619 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 529 168-360-11-36 JAGADEESWAR R BUTTI & KAMATHAM KAVITHA 3623 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 530 168-360-11-37 HAN CHIEN-PAI & MARIA LEE-FAN 5020 BRIDGEWATER DR ARLINGTON TX 76017 531 168-360-11-38 DOUGLAS A & DEBRA J EATROS 3607 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 532 168-360-11-39 JENIFER F DUBERCHIN 7849 CERRO DEL SUR SAN DIEGO CA 92127 533 168-360-11-40 KENT A & WARE KERRI BRICKNER 3615 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 534 168-360-11-41 STUART & KIMBERLY OVERLIN 3605 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 535 168-360-11-42 RYAN & MARAHI RITA WILSON 3609 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 536 168-360-11-43 ROBINSON COLLEEN M 3597 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 537 168-360-11-44 OLIVA SHEN 3601 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 538 168-360-11-45 CHAUHAN FAMILY TRUST 3589 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 539 168-360-11-46 WILLIAM R & LAUREN K MATHIAS 3593 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 540 168-360-11-47 CHRISTOPHER M & PAMELA G F CASAS 3581 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 541 168-360-11-48 JEAN C CLENET 3585 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 542 168-360-11-49 SAN FAMILY TRUST 3573 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 543 168-360-11-50 SANJIV & MONICA MEHTA 3577 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 544 168-360-11-51 NICOLE J DEGRAAN 3565 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 545 168-360-11-52 EVAN & MARIKA DIXON 3569 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 546 168-360-11-53 PAUL & NICOLE WYSOCKI 3557 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 547 168-360-11-54 JASON & DIANA E EVANGELISTA 3561 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 548 168-360-11-55 PHILLIPA A ORIMOLOYE 3553 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 549 168-360-11-56 SIDJONN M & KRISTINE TRAN REGALA 3549 SUMMIT TRAIL CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 550 168-360-17 TO 19-00 CASA ALDEA CARLSBAD LP 6102 GULLSTRAND ST SAN DIEGO CA 92122 168-361-03-00 SAME AS #493 551 168-370-84-00 FOOTHILLS AT CARLSBAD HOMEOWNERS ASSN 5966 LA PLACE CT #170 CARLSBAD CA 92008 552 168-372-01-00 MICHAEL K & LAURA M CHAN 3502 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 553 168-372-02-00 HERBERT D & DEBORAH S BUTLER 3506 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 554 168-372-03-00 JOSEPH C & MICHELLE C MARTELL 3510 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 555 168-372-04-00 SHIJIANG & ZHAO BIN LIANG 3514 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 556 168-372-05-00 DMITRY & ELENA PUSTOVALOVA 3518 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 557 168-372-06-00 OSCAR M & SYLVIA R CUEVAS 3522 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 558 168-372-07-00 YUNGHANS FAMILY TRUST 3526 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 559 168-372-08-00 PATRICK HOWELL & WAGARI HANNA 3530 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 560 168-372-09-00 SEAN P SILLSTROP 3534 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 561 168-372-33-00 FU-DONG & WU LIN-WEI SHI 5258 COLERIDGE CT CARLSBAD CA 92008 562 168-372-34-00 SAHU DAS FAMILY TRUST 3521 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 563 168-372-35-00 ADRIAN ELLIOTT & MENDES DEBRA 3517 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 564 168-372-36-00 RUSSELL W & MARCIA R TASSINARI 3513 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 565 168-372-37-00 TRINH HUY CHAN 3509 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 566 168-372-38-00 SWYNEY FAMILY TRUST 3505 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 567 168-372-39-00 HERRINGTON FAMILY TRUST 3501 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 568 168-372-40-00 HOWE FAMILY TRUST 3782 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 569 168-372-41-00 HADDEN FAMILY TRUST 3486 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 570 168-372-42-00 STEVE & SHERRIE BARRETT 3490 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 571 168-372-43-00 WILLIAM C & LINNEA S MARTIN 3504 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 572 168-372-44-00 PAUL G & DIANA R HAGERTY 3508 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 573 168-372-45-00 SALVATORE A & KATHLEEN H DANNA 4482 PALM AVE YORBA LINDA CA 92886 574 168-372-76-00 MARQUISS FAMILY TRUST 3410 FOUR PEAKS ST CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-372-83, 84, 87-00 SAME AS #551 575 168-380-01-00 ANTHONY P & NICOLE DEROSE 3461 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 576 168-380-02-00 BRANDON S SOUTHWORTH & NERI CATHERINE C 3465 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 577 168-380-03-00 PATEL BIPIN & SHOBHANA 3469 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 578 168-380-04-00 ERIK Y ZHANG & GUO XIAOMENG 3473 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 579 168-380-05-00 BRIAN RAUCH 3477 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 580 168-380-06-00 FRENCH LEONARD & SANDRA 3481 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 581 168-380-07-00 RADD EASON FAMILY TRUST 3485 ALANDER CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 582 168-380-08-00 CLARK FAMILY TRUST 3442 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 583 168-380-09-00 SUN ZUOMING & ZHOU HAIYING 1927 HIGHLAND OAKS DR ARCADIA CA 91006 584 168-380-10-00 MIKIE J & SOMMER N KETRON 3450 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 PRAMIRA-JAMIE SANDOVAL 3465 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD-600' OWN LIST APN OWNER MAIL NO.MAIL DIR MAIL STREET MAIL SFX MAIL UNIT MAIL CITY MAIL STATE MAIL ZIP 585 168-380-11-00 NORMAN A & MAMIE I LEE 3454 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 586 168-380-12-00 HALL FAMILY TRUST 3458 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 587 168-380-13-00 THAI C CHEN & MORIMOTO JEANETTE F 3462 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 588 168-380-14-00 JEFFREY S & HEIDI ORR 3466 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 589 168-380-15-00 KHALILI FRED & AZAM 3470 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 590 168-380-16-00 MONTHER J ABUSHABAN & ALAFRANJI LEENA S 3474 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 168-380-17, 20-00 SAME AS #551 591 168-380-22-00 STEPHEN J & KRISTIN M BLAKE 3481 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 592 168-380-23-00 MARK RIPPERGER 3477 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 593 168-380-24-00 DENISE M WILSON 3473 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 594 168-380-25-00 STANLEY & TRACY S FELDSOTT 3469 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 595 168-380-26-00 SATISH R & APARNA JAYANTHI 3465 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 596 168-380-27-00 WILLS ANN M 3461 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 597 168-380-28-00 JAMES E BRUSH & COLWELL MARTI J 3457 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 598 168-380-29-00 REBECCA A CORNILLE 3453 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 599 168-380-30-00 PATRICK R & RUTHJOY R BITNER 3449 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 600 168-380-31-00 JUSTIN & MICHELLE LEVY 3445 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 601 168-380-32-00 SAMMY FAMILY TRUST 3441 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 602 168-380-33-00 JORDAN & PHANY S RACEY 3442 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 603 168-380-34-00 TY & CHERI ONDATJE 3438 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 604 168-380-35-00 CHARLES & CAROLYN LUNA 3433 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 605 168-380-36-00 ERIC & TANYA A WATANABE 3437 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 606 168-380-37-00 ANNETTE L PEER 3441 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 607 168-380-38-00 RYAN W & MELISSA L TEDDER 3445 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 608 168-380-39-00 BERT & JULIE A ORTIZ 3449 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 609 168-380-40-00 SUSAN M STOREY 3453 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 610 168-380-41-00 SCOTT & MARTZ KRISTINA PACE 3457 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 611 168-380-42-00 ELIZABETH LORBER 3461 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 612 168-380-43-00 BRIERY FAMILY TRUST 3454 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 613 168-380-44-00 JODI & RODNEY SQUIRES 3460 TRAILBLAZER WAY CARLSBAD CA 92010 614 168-380-45-00 ROBERTSON RANCH WEST VILLAGE OWNERS ASSN 501 W BROADWAY SAN DIEGO CA 92101 615 168-380-46-00 CITY OF CARLSBAD 1200 CARLSBAD VILLAGE DR CARLSBAD CA 92008 208-010-38, 39, 42-00 SAME AS #615 616 208-020-39-00 STATE OF CALIFORNIA 100 S MAIN ST LOS ANGELES CA 90012 617 208-040-15, 17-00 PAUL & STACEY FREDERIKSEN 5010 EUCALYPTUS LN CARLSBAD CA 92008 618 208-162-34-00 CARLSBAD CANTERBURY ASSN 10721 TREENA ST #200 SAN DIEGO CA 92131 619 208-170-37, 38-00 HIDDEN RIDGE AT CARLSBAD HOMEOWNERS ASSN 15375 BARRANCA PKWY #B212 IRVINE CA 92618 620 208-195-01-00 SHAPELL ROBERTSON LLC 1990 S BUNDY DR #500 LOS ANGELES CA 90025 621 208-195-09-00 RANCHO COSTERA LLC 725 W TOWN AND COUNTRY RD #200 ORANGE CA 92868 622 212-152-01-00 EVANS POINT HOMEOWNERS ASSN 10721 TREENA ST #200 SAN DIEGO CA 92131 ANDREA TSCHINKEL 3718 MASTODON CT CARLSBAD CA 92010 GREG MEGOWAN 3529 BUCK RIDGE AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 TOM YUNGHANS 3526 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 TIM VAN KLAVEREN 3782 GLEN AVE CARLSBAD CA 92010 CITY OF CARLSBAD 1635 FARADAY AVE CARLSBAD CA 92008 ATTN: MICHAEL HANNA OR VERONICA ARVIZU 29504 MASTERS DR MURRIETA CA 92563 EXHIBIT D 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:35 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Proposed Cell Tower @ Trailblazer Park -----Original Message----- From: Nick G. Foster <nfoster00@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, October 13, 2019 2:40 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Proposed Cell Tower @ Trailblazer Park Shannon, Crown Castle has applied for a permit for what they are calling a temporary 95” tall monopole cell tower, however, temporary sites are typically cellular on wheels, not 95” monopoles, those are typically permanent. How is Carlsbad preventing this from becoming a permanent installation? Overall the proposed plan would not fit in at all with the character of this residential area, similar stealth cell tower installations found in Carlsbad, and without question would decrease adjacent property values who now have to look at an eye sore of a cell tower out their bedroom windows. The three sites they are proposing to relocate I believe are the three monopalm sites on top of the hill at Marja Acres is this correct? Why can’t each wireless carrier just put up their temp sites on top of that hill? Has Crown Castle and the City of Carlsbad exhausted all alternate locations and designs? How can the public voice opposition to this project, in addition to this e-mail? Nick G. Foster 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:32 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Proposed cell tower on Cannon -----Original Message----- From: Andrea Tschinkel <atschinkel@me.com> Sent: Friday, November 1, 2019 3:29 PM To: Cliff Jones <Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov>; Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Proposed cell tower on Cannon I live in The Foothills community off of Cannon and am writing to let you know that I am strongly opposed to the location for the proposed cell tower. When we purchased our home here, we were told that the field would become a park. We have just been notified about the proposed cell tower and are very upset at the prospect. Who wants an eyesore that will effect property values installed up against property lines? Not to mention potential health issues all of that radiation might have not only on us, but our children. In addition, what about the effect on wildlife in the area? There are walking trails there and lots of birds, animals etc. It is a huge pro to living here to escape to nature right out our backyard. Now they want a 7 story cell tower there? No thank you. Surely, these cell companies aren’t dictating to us where they will be putting there towers in our city right?! These people don’t live in Carlsbad. They state that it will be ”temporary”... we don’t believe that whatsoever. As tax paying citizens of this city, we should have a say in this matter. Why can’t the tower be proposed in areas where people don't live. What about the open space near Faraday? There has got to be a better solution to this. Andrea Tschinkel 3718 Mastodon Ct 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Thursday, November 7, 2019 3:01 PM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Proposed Cell Tower in The Foothills FYI- email from Foothills resident. -Shannon Shannon Harker Associate Planner Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 www.carlsbadca.gov 760-602-4621 | Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL YOUR REQUEST FOR SUBMITTAL APPOINTMENT Phone: 760-602-2723 Email: devappt@carlsbadca.gov From: Stephanie Griffin <sbritt2896@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, November 7, 2019 11:47 AM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Cc: Chris Griffin <cgriffinatlanta@hotmail.com> Subject: Proposed Cell Tower in The Foothills Shannon: Good morning! Thank you for your work in Carlsbad making our community a healthy and safe place. After attending the recent Crown Castle meeting, I had a few questions on the proposed cell tower on Cannon: Will elected officials be discussing this with input from residents? In other words, where do I as a constituent and home owner go to have my voice/concerns heard? Has the ‘deal’ for the tower already been passed? Or is it truly up for discussion/voting? What other areas are being investigated for this tower relocation? From their presentation - this seemed to be the only one and this doesn’t seem wise. 2 From a homeowner in Carlsbad who purchased just this year and moved cross country from Atlanta this summer - I had a lot of options to choose from when deciding on real estate. The same million + dollar investment could have been made in several of the surrounding cities - but we chose Carlsbad and specifically the foothills because of the aesthetics, the amenities and the community. This location would have been immediately removed from my list of had I know a tower would be going up. Your community realtors talk of the Foothills as a mixed development community offering park and retail opportunities. My understanding was that those features were coming - in the NEAR future - not a giant eyesore with potential long-term consequences instead. This conversation simply can’t end with a vote in silence. Wholeheartedly against this proposal, Stephanie Griffin 404-693-2777 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Tuesday, December 3, 2019 7:46 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Stop Crown Castles cell tower FYI -----Original Message----- From: Rebecca Mauricio <beccak2@yahoo.com> Sent: Sunday, December 1, 2019 12:04 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Stop Crown Castles cell tower Dear Shannon, I’m writing to you regarding the stop of Crown Castle cell tower. I do not want the cell tower put up. I do not want it to cause any health risk for my family. I also do not want to depreciate the value of my home. The information in the mail also states it’ll be used for Verizon wireless. I’ve had Verizon Wireless thewhole nine years I’ve lived here. And I have never had a problem with service. Therefore, is unnecessary to have a tower put up. It would be dangerous because of health risk depreciation of property value and a complete waste of money. Thank you, Rebecca Keifer Sent from my iPhone 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:33 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: proposed cell phone tower monstrosity near the Foothills From: Tom and Lois Yunghans <tlyunghans@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 29, 2019 9:06 PM To: Cliff Jones <Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov>; Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Cc: Felicia Baker <fbaker@prescottmgt.com> Subject: proposed cell phone tower monstrosity near the Foothills Hello Cliff, Shannon, Please don't let them build that ugly cell phone tower near our homes. If there is no other place which can be found, they should do what they need to do to make it more aesthetically pleasing, even if it is just temporary. If temporary was only a few months, that's one thing, but they are talking 2-3 years. That is not acceptable. I have attached a photo of what they expect it to look like. They superimposed the antenna on a photo taken from the corner of El Camino and Cannon. The tower is 75 feet tall! It dwarfs the fire station which you can see at the right of the photo. Tom Yunghans 3526 Glen Ave Carlsbad, CA 92010 (714) 336-9503 2 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Tuesday, December 3, 2019 7:44 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: T-Mobile Tower FYI From: lynn <lynnrealtor@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, December 2, 2019 1:24 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: T-Mobile Tower We have received information about the Crown Castle Cell Tower proposal to be located in the Foothills community. We are not in favor of this proposal !! A few questions: Has not this tower been located on El Camino Real near the Nursery and Bobby's Hideaway for many years? Now that there are homes planning to be built there, does the developer wish to relocate the tower to avoid possible negative feedback and a drop in property value to his new homes? The idea of a "temporary location" is unreasonable, as it rarely doesn't work short term--no one wants to pay the additional expense to relocate a tower again---no doubt it would be a permanent fixture. It's just dubbed and promoted as "temp". What guarantee do the homeowners have of it being "temporary"? Here is a valid reason why we are against this proposal: In another community where I lived previously, there were power towers near the homes. The media informed the public of the increased electromagnetic field radiation concerns. Because of this, not only did it take over a year to sell our property, but at a reduced value. We do not want to experience this again. It does affect property values! It seems that there are other alternatives to the relocation of this tower rather than in the Foothills Community where it would lower our property values and create a negative effect. 1) There is vacant land near the NW corner of El Camino Real & Cannon Rd...where there is wild brush and trees only and the tower could be located there,as it seems it would be far enough away from homes. Or nearer the Discovery Center on Cannon Rd? It's an open area with no homes nearby. 2) There are already tall light towers at the Sage Creek High School...locate the new tower atop or near those towers. The High School land elevation is even higher than the Foothills Community allowing for a better reception. There is plenty of land around the High School, and at the parking area and also at the end of College Rd- away from any homes. 3) Keep the tower in the same location-and have the new developer deal with it. Have these locations been considered by either the City of Carlsbad or the Cell phone companies? It seems there are other "city owned" land in which Carlsbad could receive revenue from the tower, rather than in the Foothills Community. Please respond to each of the numbered alternatives. 2 Thank you for your attention regarding this issue, Lynn Shellkopf, GRI,Realtor Foothills Resident P.S. Would you like this tower in "your" backyard?? 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Tuesday, December 3, 2019 7:46 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Planning project cell towe FYI -----Original Message----- From: Laura Chan <laura.chan315@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, December 1, 2019 7:27 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Planning project cell towe I object to the cell tower on corner of El Camino and Cannon. It is ugly, an EMF danger and certainly not a park or future park. Even if it is temporary or short term. Three or four yrs is not short term and could easily is extended. It says or until another suitable location can be found. That makes it a permanent location. How often do suitable locations pop up in the future if they do not exit today? What a few months and find a real perm location. I work in the industry an recognized the “until a suitable location can be found” ploy. I also know the dangers it poses to me and my family so near my home. Not to mention resale value issues should I have to sell. I live at 3502 Glen and this would certainly impact my homes value. I would not have bought so close to a tower or would I recommend such a think to anyone. Sent from my iPad 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Tuesday, December 3, 2019 7:45 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: OPPOSITION TO CROWN CASTLE CELL TOWER FYI From: Ross Sylvia <ross.sylvia8@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, December 2, 2019 12:13 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: OPPOSITION TO CROWN CASTLE CELL TOWER Hi Shannon, My name is Ross Sylvia and I live at 3611 N Fork Ave. in the Foothills in Carlsbad. I am vehemently opposed to the "temporary" cell tower at the corner of El Camino Real and Cannon Rd. I do not see any reason whatsoever why the tower would be placed at this location when there are many other locations that are not as densely populated by residential homes. I am the President of the Foothills HOA and represent not only myself, but also a community of over 400 homes, with a total value in excess of a half billion dollars. This eyesore poses an immediate risk to our home values, our quality of life and possibly our long term health. This area near the fire station was sold to us by the builders as an area that would be built out as a community park. I have come to learn that this park is delayed (would like to know how long) because of cost overruns of Alga Norte. I would love an update on when this area will in fact be turned into a community park. What was not sold to us when we bought our home was a 75 foot eyesore of a cell tower. In addition, temporary suggests 3 months - NOT 3-4 years, or until another suitable location is found. I have heard this messaging before and temporary and 3-4 becomes 5-7 years. If this project proceeds past planning stages, I would be part of whatever legal action is necessary to restrict this placement. I can appreciate the need for the tower, however, THERE IS NO NEED FOR THIS TOWER TO BE PLACED AT THIS LOCATION WHEN THERE ARE FAR MORE SUITABLE LOCATIONS that are not in a residential neighborhood. Sincerely, Ross Sylvia 858-284-9415 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:32 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: No 5G Tower From: Jodi Squires <j4squires@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, November 1, 2019 1:47 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: No 5G Tower Hi Shannon, I have left you two messages about this 5 G Tower and have not heard back. Can you please let me know who to speak with regarding this 5 G Tower they want to put up in my Backyard! We do not want a 5G Tower anywhere near our home or street. Please let us know when the hearing for this will be or a petition to sign. Jodi Squires 949-290-1990 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Tuesday, December 3, 2019 7:44 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Crown Castle Cell Tower on Cannon road Tom, I will be sending a number of emails your way that I received while I was out. Here’s the first…. Shannon Shannon Harker Associate Planner Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 www.carlsbadca.gov 760-602-4621 | Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL YOUR REQUEST FOR SUBMITTAL APPOINTMENT Phone: 760-602-2723 Email: devappt@carlsbadca.gov From: Sara Rj <sarasg8928@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, December 2, 2019 4:03 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Crown Castle Cell Tower on Cannon road Dear Ms. Harker, My husband and I are residents at the FootHills area, very close to the Fire Station, where a " temporary" cell tower is proposed for installation. We as residents FIRMLY OPPOSE this, as this cell tower is hazardous to the residents with Increased Electro Magnetic Field Radiation with significant health risks to humans. Other open areas where there is no immediate residential properties are located should be considered. Sincerely, Mr and Mrs. Rajagopalan 2 FootHills Windtrailway and Alander Ct 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:34 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Crown Castle - Trailblazer Park (resident concerns) From: Raluca State <raluca@ralucastate.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 29, 2019 9:37 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Crown Castle - Trailblazer Park (resident concerns) Hello Ms Harker, I am a second generation Carlsbad resident and live in The Foothills neighborhood adjacent to the park where you and Crown Castle are proposing to relocate two cell phone towers serving the area. Ignoring the dismay that this neighborhood already has over an empty field that was promised as an active city park when we all purchased homes here, this new (and very quiet) plan to add these towers is absolutely unconscionable to me. This is a neighborhood filled with young families, baby boomers, pets and life. The fact that our city is overlooking all of that in order to appease the developer of the Marja Acres project and the Crown Castle team is so disappointing and such a blatant disregard for Carlsbad’s residents and tax payers (which, frankly, seems to be the trend in this city now – sadly). I took the time to attend Crown Castle’s meeting tonight. How sad to see that no one from the city could find the time to be there – to properly and adequately answer residents’ concerns. To stand beside us and listen to the canned replies from the CC team and the representatives they had on-site, none of which were San Diegans. To think that putting a letter in a select number of mailboxes but not doing anything at all to effectively communicate this plan that would have a HUGE impact on hundreds of Carlsbad residents is ok. What’s the expression they use online nowadays? SMH. Shaking my head. This neighborhood vehemently opposes your plan. We do not want cell phone towers in our back yard. We do not want them moved closer to our kids. There is a lot of land in Carlsbad and in this area, in particular, and we would like to know how the city’s planners deemed that empty space not adequately “zoned” for this but decided a space adjacent to our homes and children is? You and your team owe this community answers and an opportunity to have a proper discussion before you vote anything into plan. You are our representatives and neighbors, not the Crown Castle team. You are the ones we are looking to for a sound future for our families. Please advise as to next steps and how residents can be involved so we can communicate it to our community where your team has failed to. This cannot be a quiet discussion that is limited in scope and magnitude. Your residents’ health and well-being surely warrants more than that. I look forward to your reply, Raluca State 310/382-4144 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:33 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Cell tower -----Original Message----- From: Nathan <nathanst2121@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 29, 2019 8:08 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Cell tower Ms. Harker With regards to a temporary cell tower next to the fire station on Cannon, my family and neighbors are extremely opposed to it. The City of Carlsbad should be focusing on the development of a community soccer field that was planned and promised. Robertson Ranch and Foothills communities are full of kids that need fields to play in and not surrounded by a 75ft cell tower. Would you want this monstrosity in your back yard so a private company can make millions in profits? Homeowners bought in this area not only because it’s safe but healthy. Why is the City of Carlsbad even considering placing a private corporations equipment on taxpayers land in the heart of a new community? It’s unhealthy and ruins the charm community around it. Thank you for your consideration, Nathan and Amanda Stringer 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:33 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Cell Tower to be located in Foothill Tract -----Original Message----- From: Dale Bodman <dalebodman@icloud.com> Sent: Wednesday, October 30, 2019 3:33 PM To: Cliff Jones <Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov>; Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Cell Tower to be located in Foothill Tract Cliff and Shannon- I have read the information on the relocation of the cell tower from behind Bobby’s Cafe. I am opposed to the relocation of this tower from its location behind Bobby’s to our development. I have been against the development of the area at Bobby’s Cafe, but to then move a tower into our area while development is going on is crazy. The tower should remain in its present location during development or be positioned in another area under development such as the senior housing complex on the other side of Wind Trail Way. Thanks, Dale Bodman, PE 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Tuesday, November 12, 2019 9:46 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Cell Tower Relocation FYI From: Tim <chevelle496ci@aol.com> Sent: Monday, November 11, 2019 11:16 AM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Cell Tower Relocation Shannon, It has come to my attention that there is a proposal to build a new cell site within the Foothills community. Although my home is not directly next to the site and therefore I'm not concerned with the health implications, the proposed tower is unsightly and extremely large. This tower does not fit our community, the proposed park or the architecture of the new fire station. I'm honestly not sure a worse spot for could be found. I am requesting that this application be denied and another more appropriate site found. Thanks for your time, Tim Van Klaveren 3782 Glen Ave 714-913-0321 Get BlueMail for Android 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:32 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Cell Phone Tower at Cannon and El Camino From: Greg Megowan <gmegowan@halozyme.com> Sent: Friday, November 1, 2019 11:43 AM To: Cliff Jones <Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov>; Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Cell Phone Tower at Cannon and El Camino Good afternoon Mr. Jones and Ms. Harker, I just wanted to voice a concern that I have over the proposed placement of the cell phone tower on the corner of Cannon and El Camino. While I certainly understand the need for the cell phone tower, and the importance thereof, I do feel that the proposed placement at the corner of Cannon and El Camino is a very poor choice. Particularly, with its proximity to both the Robertson Ranch and Foothills developments (where my home is), and also on a site that is designated for future soccer fields for kids and a playground. While I know that most residents in most neighborhoods are not happy to have a large cell tower erected in their neighborhood, it is important that we all balance those concerns with the need for infrastructure like cell phone towers. My feeling on this particular tower is that it should remain where it is now behind Bobbi’s restaurant, as that location has already been in existence for many years, it is not as central to highly dense neighborhoods as the proposed site, and the new developer there should just be required to incorporate the existing tower, since they bought the land with the tower on it. Thank you very much for your consideration of my request. All the best, Greg Megowan 3529 Buck Ridge Ave. Carlsbad, CA 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Wednesday, November 27, 2019 11:48 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: Cannon/El Camino Cell Tower FYI- email from resident in Robertson Ranch. -Shannon Shannon Harker Associate Planner Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 www.carlsbadca.gov 760-602-4621 | Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL YOUR REQUEST FOR SUBMITTAL APPOINTMENT Phone: 760-602-2723 Email: devappt@carlsbadca.gov From: Ken campion <kgcampion@hotmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, November 27, 2019 11:43 AM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Cannon/El Camino Cell Tower I have received a flyer objecting to the installation of the so-called "temporary" cell tower near my home in the Foothills development. I understand the necessity of transmitting phone calls over the air. However, this is not a good use of this particular property for the city. This is so, despite whatever financial incentives Crown Castle is offering Carlsbad. It will be, in fact, a blight on the landscape and I expect that it will not be "temporary". When both Foothills and Robertson Ranch houses were sold by the respective developers, there were promises of soccer and/or other park-like public spaces for this area. Those promises, along with those made of a retail convenience shopping area off of Cannon have gone, as they say, unrealized, at least to date. If I were involved in City government and planning, as you are, I would be more committed to enforcing those promises than being unduly influenced by a private concern that wants to use this property to erect a 75 foot ugly tower for their own interests. That monstrosity will clearly cause a depreciation in value among the 2 community members that become insulted by its presence. It will be, in effect, a public nuisance, condoned by the very entity that should be preventing them. My suggestion to the Crowns and/or Castles is that they begin their search for an alternate site forthwith, and withdraw their application for this one, since I am sure their AZ proprietors truly care about the public interest of CA residents. Ken Campion 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Monday, November 4, 2019 10:31 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: 5G Tower Tom, I'm going to forward you all of the emails I've received thus far- there are many. -Shannon Shannon Harker Associate Planner Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 www.carlsbadca.gov 760-602-4621 | Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL YOUR REQUEST FOR SUBMITTAL APPOINTMENT Phone: 760-602-2723 Email: devappt@carlsbadca.gov -----Original Message----- From: Lucy Hargett <lucyhargett@icloud.com> Sent: Thursday, October 31, 2019 11:34 PM To: Cliff Jones <Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov> Cc: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: 5G Tower You’ve already destroyed what made Carlsbad so special with all the home building and high rises going in near the beach. Now a tower. When does the greed end?? Get that tower away from our homes and away from our high school! I’ll be fine with slow internet. It's better to live your own destiny imperfectly than to live an imitation of somebody's else's life with perfection. The Bhagavad Gita 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Wednesday, November 6, 2019 2:06 PM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: 5G tower Tom, Please see email below. Shannon Shannon Harker Associate Planner Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 www.carlsbadca.gov 760-602-4621 | Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL YOUR REQUEST FOR SUBMITTAL APPOINTMENT Phone: 760-602-2723 Email: devappt@carlsbadca.gov From: Jen Belnap <jenwrite@hotmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, November 6, 2019 1:32 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: 5G tower Hello Shannon, I'm writing to express my utter disappointment with the city of Carlsbad for even considering placing a 5G- capable cell tower right in my neighborhood, the Foothills. Wether it's behind the fire station directly or on the opposite end of the currently-barren land, it is an undesirable and negligent choice. I cannot believe the city of Carlsbad would even consider placing a 5G-capable cell tower right in a neighborhood. With all of the claims of poor health, physical and mental, due to proximity to these towers, why would the city think that residents of any neighborhood would be fine with having such a tower in their backyard? The reason for tower relocation given at the first meeting on this subject was that the old, or current, tower needs to be moved due to construction. Firstly, since this is a temporary tower, why not keep moving it around on the land it's currently at to accommodate construction? Secondly, why did the city not tell the 2 developer of that land that they would need to prepare in their planning to accommodate the current tower as well as space for its upgrade? Carlsbad has areas where the new temporary tower can go that are not directly tied to where children live and play. Go back to the drawing board and get this right! Jennifer Belnap Foothills resident 1 Jonathan Restivo From:Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Sent:Tuesday, November 12, 2019 10:46 AM To:Tom Hanna Subject:FW: FYI From: Bruce Ruberti <bar3801@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, November 10, 2019 9:43 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: I am vehemently opposed to proposed cell tower at Cannon &El Camino. I own a home in the Ravinia subdivision right above fire station. This would affect my property value dramatically. Vote No! Bruce Ruberti 407 430 8080 2 Shannon Harker Associate Planner Planning Division 1635 Faraday Avenue Carlsbad, CA 92008 www.carlsbadca.gov 760-602-4621 | Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL YOUR REQUEST FOR SUBMITTAL APPOINTMENT Phone: 760-602-2723 Email: devappt@carlsbadca.gov -----Original Message----- From: Scott <scottpace07@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, December 3, 2019 10:17 PM To: Shannon Harker <Shannon.Harker@carlsbadca.gov> Cc: Kristina Martz <kristina.martz@nmmf.org> Subject: Crown and Castle Cell Tower Adjacent to Carlsbad Fire Station # 3 Shannon, I write you to express my family’s extreme opposition to this potential cell tower. Our home is within 200 yards of this site and we’re very concerned about exposing our 3 young children to the possible harmful health/developmental effects of tower. Also, the dream house that we worked so hard for would immediately depreciate greatly in value. If we had known that the city of Carlsbad could allow this, we never would’ve chosen this neighborhood in the first place. Please let me know of anything we can do to prevent this from happening. Respectfully, Scott Pace and Kristina Martz (concerned parents of 3 children; ages 2 and under) Sent from my iPhone EXHIBIT E TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP COMMUNITY MEETING AND FEEDBACK Community Meeting and Feedback 831227 Trailblazer Park Temporary Facility On December 20, 2020, Crown Castle Towers 06-2 LLC (“Crown Castle”) submitted to the Planning Division of the City of Carlsbad a revision to our application for a temporary Wireless Cellular Facility at the corner of Cannon Road and El Camino Real. On January 15, 2020, Crown Castle and our four carrier partners held a community outreach meeting at Sage Creek High School on this revised proposal. Below are the questions and comments we were able to record at that meeting. Crown Castle has not received and is not aware of any community feedback since the revision to the project outside of the inquiries and commentary received on January 15th. Attached separately is a document of Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) that incorporate answers both to questions/comments from before the December 20th revision and feedback at the community meeting discussing the proposal updates. Community questions and feedback received at the 1/15/20 meeting along with Crown Castle responses: • Why won’t the original landlord renew the lease for the existing sites? o See item 2 and 4 on the attached FAQ. • Why won’t other landlords want a lease with Crown Castle? o Crown Castle cannot speak for those landlords but is continuing to work towards a location for a permanent cellular facility that will meet the needs of the community while maintaining its character. See item 3 on the attached FAQ for more details. • I am worried about a loss of coverage. o This project is needed to prevent that loss. See items 1 and 14 on the attached FAQ. • What are the health concerns for this proposal? o See item 10 on the attached FAQ. • I’d like to better understand the search area. o Crown Castle did not have our search area maps at the community meeting and described the search area using maps that we did have. The search area maps were provided to planning and full-size boards of the maps can be brought to any future hearings and meetings. • Will our property values be impacted? o See item 13 on the attached FAQ. • When will the lease at this new proposal expire? o See item 6 on the attached FAQ. TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP COMMUNITY MEETING AND FEEDBACK • What is the status of the development at the existing location? o See items 2 and 4 on the attached FAQ. • What is the length of this temporary lease with Carlsbad? o See item 6 on the attached FAQ. • What do I do if I want this temp site to happen? o See item 9 in the attached FAQ. • What happens in three years if we haven’t found a new site for this? o The City of Carlsbad is agreeing to a temporary term for the proposed facility. If no new location can be found in that time then the community and carriers will face the same issues faced today. See items 6, 7, and 14 in the attached FAQ. • I wish a representative with the city was here today. o City representatives can be contacted directly and will be in attendance at any hearings. See item 9 in the attached FAQ for more details. • Will this temporary site just become a permanent site? o This temporary facility will not become permanent. A new permanent facility will need to be proposed in the future. • I am concerned with coverage and what happens if the site goes away. o This project is needed to prevent that loss. See items 1 and 14 on the attached FAQ. • Why is this site not closer to the fire station? o The prior proposal was closer to the fire station. After the first community meeting and subsequent discussions with planning, it was determined that the lowest impact location for this temporary facility would be the currently proposed location. • I am interested in having good coverage, will this site have greater power? o This site is designed to maintain the existing cellular network and is not designed with enhancements. • I am not concerned with losing coverage and I don’t want this site here. o See item 14 in the attached FAQ including notes on E911, an important community service. TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP COMMUNITY MEETING AND FEEDBACK Photos from the Community Meeting on January 15, 2020 TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP COMMUNITY MEETING AND FEEDBACK TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP COMMUNITY MEETING AND FEEDBACK TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS FAQ - Frequently Asked Questions 831227 Trailblazer Park Temporary Facility 1. Why is this project necessary? a. There are three existing cellular facilities along the ridge above Bobby’s Hideaway Café on the south side of El Camino Real. That ridge is being developed into a new mixed-use community, Marja Acres, that will displace the existing facilities. A temporary location is required for T-Mobile, AT&T, Verizon, and Sprint to maintain current network coverage and ensure continuity of emergency services. 2. Can the temporary or permanent facility remain at the existing property? a. Unfortunately, it cannot. The ground elevation at the existing facility is being reduced by grading which will eliminate the ridge line. Crown Castle and our carrier partners worked for over three years to find an alternative location on the existing property. However, none of the locations at the new lower elevation were suitable to meet coverage needs. Due to the expiring lease and the inability to find a location on the existing property, the four major cellular carriers seek approval for a temporary facility. 3. What locations are available for deployment of temporary facilities? a. While Crown Castle has made some progress on alternate locations, the only suitable location that could be licensed in time is the land set aside for a future park off Trailblazer Way. The proposed location in the southeast corner of the future park is the only one that meets the five criteria necessary for a cellular facility: i. Real Estate: The City is the only property owner within the search area currently willing to license ground space for a cellular facility. ii. Cellular Coverage: The future park is within the search area (i.e., land within ½ to ¾ of a mile of the existing facilities). A temporary facility in the SE corner will provide coverage to a sizeable portion of the coverage gap produced by the loss of the three cellular facilities. The maximum workable distance varies due to trees, buildings, and terrain that can block signals. iii. Zoning: City Council Policy No. 64 lists City-owned land as the most preferred location for a cellular facility. While commercial properties are on the list of preferred locations, the owners within the applicable search area have not been willing to discuss allowing a cellular facility on the property. iv. Environmental: Numerous conservation easements in the search area preclude development of cell towers. The City’s future park is not subject to conservation easements. TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS v. Constructability: The proposed facility has sufficient room for the construction, operation, and maintenance of the temporary facilities. 4. Is there any opportunity to keep the current cellular facilities at the existing location? a. The facilities cannot stay where they are because our lease with the owner of Marja Acres is expiring and they will not agree to extend the lease. The existing facilities are located on privately owned property, and we cannot compel the owner or the Marja Acres developer to enter into an agreement with us. We are legally required to vacate the property upon lease expiration. 5. What efforts have been undertaken to minimize impacts to the neighborhood? a. The initial design placed the temporary facility near the fire station to be closer to utilities and other buildings. After community feedback, the proposal was updated to move to the farthest viable location away from houses but that would still allow for any initial development work at the park. 6. How long will this temporary facility be in place? a. The initial license term is for 3 years and bridges the gap until a new location can be secured and a permanent cellular facility developed. The process of design, community input, zoning, permitting, and construction typically takes two years or more for cellular facilities. The short-term license allows four carriers to remain on air until a permanent facility can be developed. 7. Will the temporary facilities impact planned park development? a. The license, as structured, will provide the City with flexibility and discretion for future park development. It is our understanding that the City will begin the design phase of the future park in 2020 and that park development will follow in approximately 3 years. The initial license term mirrors the design timeline for the park. Upon expiration of the initial term, the City retains the right to approve or disapprove each of the three additional 1-year terms. If the City approves any additional terms, the City has the right to terminate the license at any time upon 180 days’ notice. 8. What is the process for approving this temporary facility? a. Once a zoning permit application is submitted to the City, a notice of proposed project is mailed to those living within a certain distance of the proposed project. The notice includes an invitation to attend an informational meeting. The first meeting was on October 29th. Meanwhile, city staff reviews the application to determine if it meets code and composes a staff report. Once all of this is done, a zoning hearing is scheduled with the Planning Commission to hear any community concerns and determine whether the project will be approved. The decision at this hearing can be appealed to the City Council, although sometimes the two steps are combined to get a final decision faster. TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS 9. How can the community provide input into this project? a. The City of Carlsbad Community members can provide feedback by contacting the planner and by attending the zoning hearing to be scheduled after city review. Community feedback has already been incorporated after two community meetings including one on January 15th after the proposal was updated. If you have any further questions or input, please feel free to also reach out to Crown Castle’s contact: Name: Jonathan Restivo Title: Applicant Zoning Manager Phone: 860-334-9509 Email: jonathan.restivo@pramira.com 10. Are the same safety standards applicable to temporary facilities? a. Community safety is of the utmost importance to Crown Castle. Crown Castle follows FCC emissions regulations, and this facility will operate well under those applicable limits. The safety of RF emissions has been studied for more than 60 years, and the research is under constant review by governments, health agencies, and standard-setting organizations in the U.S. and around the world. These organizations have all reached the same general scientific conclusion: there are no established health hazards from exposure to RF emissions that are below the FCC limits. For independent studies on RF, visit the websites of the American Cancer Society, the Federal Communications Commission, the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection, Public Health England, Health Canada, the Australian RPNS Agency, and the World Health Organization. 11. What is being done to ensure that the temporary facility fits with the character of the community? a. After the first Open House on October 29th, the project was revised in several key ways. i. The temporary facility was moved as far away from existing houses as possible. ii. The height was reduced as much as possible by switching to two shorter structures. iii. The two structures were camouflaged using a faux-Eucalyptus tree design. iv. The layout and fencing were updated so that ground equipment would not be visible. 12. What features of this facility make it temporary? a. The proposed cellular facility uses above-ground foundations for all equipment. This design allows the entire facility to be removed at the end of the project. 13. Will this project affect my property value? a. This topic has been a concern over the years that cellular and other infrastructure have served our communities. Crown Castle is not aware of any definitive link between telecommunications to lower TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS property resale values. Today over half of American households are wireless-only, meaning they have no “land-line.” Wireless networks will power autonomous vehicles, in-home healthcare applications, public safety solutions, etc. Being in a cellular “dead zone” may even have a negative impact to the resale value of a home. 14.My cellular service is fine. Why is this new tower needed? a.Essential coverage and capacity are being provided to the area from the cellular facilities that have been in service for some time. To maintain that service and avoid a dead zone for all four carriers, this temporary facility will provide coverage and capacity to the area while a permanent facility is designed and constructed. The temporary facility will also be critical to maintaining the current E911 system which works through the cellular network. The displacement of facilities for all four carriers in the same location is a significant problem at this location for the E911 network supporting our emergency services. ATTACHMENT 8 IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM3T-13COUNTY:TOWER HEIGHT:SITE TYPE:(2) 55'-0"TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP SITESAN DIEGO COUNTYTITLE SHEETT-1A-1SITE PLANLOCATION MAPNO SCALEAPPLICABLE CODESALL WORK SHALL BE PERFORMED AND MATERIALS INSTALLED INACCORDANCE WITH THE CURRENT EDITIONS OF THE FOLLOWINGCODES AS ADOPTED BY THE LOCAL GOVERNING AUTHORITIES.NOTHING IN THESE PLANS IS TO BE CONSTRUED TO PERMIT WORKNOT CONFORMING TO THESE CODES:CODE TYPECODEBUILDING2019 IBCMECHANICAL2019 IMCELECTRICAL2019 NECNOTE:PRIOR TO ACCESSING/ENTERING THE SITE YOU MUST CONTACTTHE CROWN NOC AT (800) 788-7011 & CROWN CONSTRUCTIONMANAGERPROJECT DESCRIPTIONPROJECT TEAMA&E FIRM:CROWN CASTLETOWERS 06-2 LLCCONTACTS:JOEL TAUBMAN - PROJECT MANAGER(480) 734-2414PRAMIRA2552 WALNUT AVE., SUITE 200TUSTIN, CA 92780ZONING CONTACT:SITE INFORMATIONCARRIER/APPLICANT:SHEET #DRAWING INDEXSHEET DESCRIPTIONALL DRAWINGS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE FORMATTED FOR ----.CONTRACTOR SHALL VERIFY ALL PLANS AND EXISTING DIMENSIONSAND CONDITIONS ON THE JOB SITE AND SHALL IMMEDIATELY NOTIFYTHE ENGINEER IN WRITING OF ANY DISCREPANCIES BEFOREPROCEEDING WITH THE WORK OR BE RESPONSIBLE FOR SAME.----ELECTRIC PROVIDER:----TELCO PROVIDER:----CROWN CASTLE TOWERS06-2 LLCAPPLICATION ID:GROUND ELEVATION:LATITUDE TOWER-A:LONGITUDE TOWER-A:UFACILITY IS UNMANNED AND NOT FORHUMAN HABITATIONOCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATION:A.D.A. COMPLIANCE:MAP/PARCEL #:CITY OF CARLSBADJURISDICTION:SITE ADDRESS:COUNTY:AREA OF CONSTRUCTION: TEMPORARY FACILITYNAD83LAT/LONG TYPE:PROPERTY OWNER:CROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM, SUITE 1700IRVINE, CA 92618TOWER OWNER:VTYPE OF CONSTRUCTION:MATTHEW LEVESQUE - ZONING MANAGER(800) 678-1169200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 1700IRVINE, CA 92618THIS PROJECT PROPOSES A TEMPORARY TELECOM FACILITY TOTEMPORARILY REPLACE TWO EXISTING FACILITIES SERVINGT-MOBILE, AT&T, VERIZON AND SPRINT.THESE (2) 55'-0" TEMPORARY FAUX MONO-EUCALYPTUS TOWERSWITH ABOVE GROUND FOUNDATION WILL CONSIST OF...AT ANTENNA LEVEL:·INSTALL (9) AT&T PANEL ANTENNAS·INSTALL (9) T-MOBILE PANEL ANTENNAS·INSTALL (9) VERIZON PANEL ANTENNAS·INSTALL (9) SPRINT PANEL ANTENNASAT EQUIPMENT LEVEL:·INSTALL 8'-6" TALL ALUMINUM ECLIPSE PRIVACY FENCINGBY ULTRA FENCING AND RAILING OR APPROVED EQUAL·INSTALL 1'-2" TALL EQUIPMENT PLATFORM·INSTALL (3) 6'-0" TALL AT&T EQUIPMENT CABINETS·INSTALL (3) 6'-0" TALL T-MOBILE EQUIPMENT CABINETS·INSTALL (3) 6'-0" TALL VERIZON EQUIPMENT CABINETS·INSTALL (3) 6'-0" TALL SPRINT EQUIPMENT CABINETS----CROWN CASTLE TOWERS06-2 LLCSITE NAME:A-2ENLARGED SITE PLANA-3PROPOSED EQUIPMENT & ANTENNA LAYOUTSA-4A-5PROPOSED ANTENNA LAYOUTSELEVATION-208-010-038SAN DIEGO COUNTY----DESIGN PACKAGE BASED ON THE RFDSREVISION: 1.0DATE: 7/2/2019DESIGN PACKAGE BASED ON THE APPLICATIONID: 3246625REVISION: 1.0TRAILBLAZER PARK TEMP SITESITEMONO-EUCALYPTUSNEAREST ADDRESS3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010CITY OF CARLSBAD1200 CARLSBAD VILLAGE DR.CARLSBAD, CA 92008NEAREST ADDRESS3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010CALL CALIFORNIA ONE CALL(800) 227-2600CALL 3 WORKING DAYSBEFORE YOU DIG!(E) SITES TO BE REMOVED ANDRELOCATED, TYP. OF 2A-6ELEVATIONA-7ELEVATIONA-8ELEVATIONLATITUDE TOWER-B:LONGITUDE TOWER-B:33.151018°-117.296972°33.151095°-117.296910°SITE NAME:SITE ADDRESS:CROWN SITE #: 831227T-MOBILE SITE #: SD06203AAT&T SITE #: CAL00750VERIZON SITE #: 506523SPRINT SITE #: SD25XC836PROPOSED ANTENNA LAYOUTA-9ZONING:P - CLOT SIZE:242,041 SQ. FT.SURVEY SHEETSLS-1 -- LS-6ATTACHMENT 9 WVWV WVWVHYD WV HYD IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM3125'0"50'50'24"x36" SCALE: 1" = 50'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1" = 100'-0"SITE PLANNESW1A-2A-1TRAILBLAZER WAYCANNON ROADWIND TRAIL WAY SECTOR AAZIMUTH30°SECTOR BAZIMUTH150°SECTOR CAZIMUTH270°LOT SIZE:242,041 SQ. FT. IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM314'0" 4'24"x36" SCALE: 3/16" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 3/32" = 1'-0"2'ENLARGED SITE PLANA-21&2A-3SECTOR BAZIMUTH150°SECTOR CAZIMUTH270°NESWA-81A-71A-61A-91SECTOR AAZIMUTH30° IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM312' 1' 0"2'24"x36" SCALE: 1/2" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"PROPOSED T-MOBILE ANTENNA LAYOUT24'0" 4'24"x36" SCALE: 3/16" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 3/32" = 1'-0"2'PROPOSED EQUIPMENT LAYOUTNESWA-3(P) ANTENNA SCHEDULEALPHA SECTORBETA SECTORGAMMA SECTORANTENNAPOSITIONSTATUSRADCENTERANTENNA DIMENSIONS( L x W x D )AZIMUTHANTENNACOUNTREMOTE RADIOUNIT COUNTA1(P)47'-0"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"30°12A2B1B2C1C2(P)1-(P)150° 1(P)1(P)270° 1(P)1TOTALNESW30°150°270°----129SECTOR AAZIMUTH30°SECTOR BAZIMUTH150°SECTOR CAZIMUTH270°A1A2C1B1C2B2A3C3B322-A3(P)130°B3(P)1150°C3(P)1270°47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"222 IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM312' 1' 0"2'24"x36" SCALE: 1/2" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"PROPOSED AT&T ANTENNA LAYOUT22'0" 2'24"x36" SCALE: 3/8" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 3/16" = 1'-0"1'PROPOSED VERIZON ANTENNA LAYOUTA-4NESWNESWSECTOR AAZIMUTH30°SECTOR BAZIMUTH150°SECTOR CAZIMUTH270°SECTOR AAZIMUTH30°SECTOR BAZIMUTH150°SECTOR CAZIMUTH270°A1A2C1B1C2B2A3C3B3A1A2C1B1C2B2A3C3B3(P) ANTENNA SCHEDULEALPHA SECTORBETA SECTORGAMMA SECTORANTENNAPOSITIONSTATUSRADCENTERANTENNA DIMENSIONS( L x W x D )AZIMUTHANTENNACOUNTREMOTE RADIOUNIT COUNTA1(P)37'-0"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"30° 12A2B1B2C1C2(P)1-(P)150°1(P)1(P)270° 1(P)1TOTAL30°150°270°----12922-A3(P)130°B3(P)1150°C3(P)1270°72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"222(P) ANTENNA SCHEDULEALPHA SECTORBETA SECTORGAMMA SECTORANTENNAPOSITIONSTATUSRADCENTERANTENNA DIMENSIONS( L x W x D )AZIMUTHANTENNACOUNTREMOTE RADIOUNIT COUNTA1(P)47'-0"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"30° 12A2B1B2C1C2(P)1-(P)150°1(P)1(P)270° 1(P)1TOTAL30°150°270°----12922-A3(P)130°B3(P)1150°C3(P)1270°47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"47'-0"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"59" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"22237'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0" IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM312' 1' 0"2'24"x36" SCALE: 1/2" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"PROPOSED SPRINT ANTENNA LAYOUT2NOT USEDNESWA-5SECTOR AAZIMUTH30°SECTOR BAZIMUTH150°SECTOR CAZIMUTH270°A1A2C1B1C2B2A3C3B3(P) ANTENNA SCHEDULEALPHA SECTORBETA SECTORGAMMA SECTORANTENNAPOSITIONSTATUSRADCENTERANTENNA DIMENSIONS( L x W x D )AZIMUTHANTENNACOUNTREMOTE RADIOUNIT COUNTA1(P)37'-0"72" x 12.8" x 8.6"30° 12A2B1B2C1C2(P)1-(P)150°1(P)1(P)270° 1(P)1TOTAL30°150°270°----12922-A3(P)130°B3(P)1150°C3(P)1270°72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 12.8" x 8.6"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"72" x 19.7" x 8.5"22237'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0"37'-0" IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM3PROPOSED SOUTHEAST ELEVATION14'3' 2'1' 0"4'24"x36" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0"A-6 IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM3PROPOSED SOUTHWEST ELEVATION - TOWER "A"14'3' 2'1' 0"4'24"x36" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0"A-7 IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM3PROPOSED NORTHWEST ELEVATION14'3' 2'1' 0"4'24"x36" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0"A-8 IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON,UNLESS THEY ARE ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTIONOF A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER,TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT.REVISION:SHEET NUMBER:ISSUED FOR:DRWNREVDESCRIPTIONDES./QADATE1PRELIMINARYCROWN CASTLE TOWERS 06-2 LLC200 SPECTRUM CENTER DR., SUITE 200,IRVINE, CA 9261806/14/19MQ.GAMMSITE BUN #: 831227SITE NAME: TRAILBLAZERPARK TEMP SITE3465 TRAIL BLAZER WAYCARLSBAD, CA 92010ramiraPARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING SERVICES2PRELIMINARY REV08/16/19P. JTSMMverizonCUP 2019-00323ZD REV02/04/20P. JTSMM3PROPOSED NORTHEAST ELEVATION - TOWER "B"14'3' 2'1' 0"4'24"x36" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"11"x17" SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0"A-9 From:Stephen Clark To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Opposition To Proposed Wireless Communication Facility Date:Saturday, May 23, 2020 12:39:49 PM Dear Planning Commission, This e-mail is to express my strong opposition to the proposed installation, operation and maintenance of “temporary” Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way. (Case Name: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Park WCF). . My family and I have been homeowners in The Foothills Community in Robertson Ranch for over 8 years. We are deeply concerned that the installation and operation of this facility, in close proximity to our home, will cause increased Electromagnetic Field Radiation (EMF) which will present potential serious health risks to our family. This has been the findings of many studies and research conducted by leading scientists, including those at UC Berkeley. I am outraged that the City of Carlsbad would seriously consider allowing the installation and operation of two highly dangerous cell phone towers in extremely close proximity to Carlsbad residents! In addition, the location of these cell phone towers is on the boundary of a proposed City Park where many children will be playing in the future. These same studies have also shown that children are the most vulnerable to the significant health risks from EMF. I would like to believe that our Carlsbad City Planners can find a much better location for this Wireless Communication Facility which will not endanger the health and safety of Carlsbad residents and their children! I am also deeply concerned about the impact of the installation and operation of this facility on the value of my property. I have been made aware of a recent survey by the National Institute for Science, Law and Public Policy which found that 94 percent of homebuyers would pay as much as 20 percent less for properties located near a cell phone tower! In addition to the health risks associated with this Wireless Communication Facility, I can also expect that this facility will lower the value of my property. This is not acceptable! In addition, it is my understanding that this proposed Wireless Communication Facility is “temporary” for 3-4 years or until “another suitable location” is found. If the application for the Conditional Use Permit does not guarantee that the this facility will be dismantled and taken out of service within 4 years, then it is my belief that this facility will be “permanent”. It would be very easy for Crown Castle to claim that it could not find “another suitable location” and, therefore, must keep this facility operational for many years to come! ATTACHMENT 11 Please do not approve a Conditional Use Permit for the installation and operation of a highly dangerous Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way! Stephen A. Clark 3442 Glen Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92010 CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Planning To:Cliff Jones; Don Neu; Melissa Flores Subject:FW: June 3, 2020 5G meeting Date:Tuesday, May 26, 2020 12:13:39 PM From: Jodi Squires <j4squires@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 26, 2020 12:00 PM To: Planning <Planning@CarlsbadCA.gov> Subject: June 3, 2020 5G meeting We are property owners at 3460 Trailblazer Way, Carlsbad, CA 92010 We are against the 5G being installed so close to our homes. We do not wish to be exposed to 5G Radiation. This can cause headaches,anxiety, teary eyes, low levels of energy, lack of mental clarity and who knows what other symptoms we will experience with high levels of 5G. Your letter from the City keeps explaining what it will look like and how it will be disguised however, it states nothing about the harmful health factors associated with 5G. Please provide more information about the health impact and the close proximity to so many homes with children and animals. We disagree with the 5G tower. Thank you! Jodi Squires 949-290-1990 CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Keith Shellkopf To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) Trailblazer Park WCF Date:Tuesday, May 26, 2020 4:31:38 PM Dear Planning Commission Members, I have 2 questions that should be addressed. 1. This is project is described as a “temporary Wireless Communications Facility”. What time period is defined as “temporary”? 2. Has there been any evaluation or consideration given to the possible adverse human health effects from the operation of this WCF near residences? If so, what are the are the possible effects on people living nearby? I am sure that many others in our neighborhood have the same questions and will appreciate your consideration of these in the upcoming public hearing. Thank-you for your attention to these matters. Keith Shellkopf Foothills Resident Sent from Mail for Windows 10 CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Stephen Clark To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Opposition To Proposed Wireless Communication Facility Date:Sunday, May 31, 2020 5:37:59 PM This e-mail is to request that the comments below be read into the record at the Planning Commission Meeting to be held on Wednesday, June 3, 2020 at 3:00pm regarding the proposed Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way (Case Name: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Park WCF). The comments below were previously transmitted to you by e-mail on May 23, 2020. Please read the following into the record: Dear Planning Commission, This e-mail is to express my strong opposition to the proposed installation, operation and maintenance of “temporary” Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way. (Case Name: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Park WCF). . My family and I have been homeowners in The Foothills Community in Robertson Ranch for over 8 years. We are deeply concerned that the installation and operation of this facility, in close proximity to our home, will cause increased Electromagnetic Field Radiation (EMF) which will present potential serious health risks to our family. This has been the findings of many studies and research conducted by leading scientists, including those at UC Berkeley. I am outraged that the City of Carlsbad would seriously consider allowing the installation and operation of two highly dangerous cell phone towers in extremely close proximity to Carlsbad residents! In addition, the location of these cell phone towers is on the boundary of a proposed City Park where many children will be playing in the future. These same studies have also shown that children are the most vulnerable to the significant health risks from EMF. I would like to believe that our Carlsbad City Planners can find a much better location for this Wireless Communication Facility which will not endanger the health and safety of Carlsbad residents and their children! I am also deeply concerned about the impact of the installation and operation of this facility on the value of my property. I have been made aware of a recent survey by the National Institute for Science, Law and Public Policy which found that 94 percent of homebuyers would pay as much as 20 percent less for properties located near a cell phone tower! In addition to the health risks associated with this Wireless Communication Facility, I can also expect that this facility will lower the value of my property. This is not acceptable! In addition, it is my understanding that this proposed Wireless Communication Facility is “temporary” for 3-4 years or until “another suitable location” is found. If the application for the Conditional Use Permit does not guarantee that the this facility will be dismantled and taken out of service within 4 years, then it is my belief that this facility will be “permanent”. It would be very easy for Crown Castle to claim that it could not find “another suitable location” and, therefore, must keep this facility operational for many years to come! Please do not approve a Conditional Use Permit for the installation and operation of a highly dangerous Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way! Stephen A. Clark Carlsbad, CA 92010 CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Annette"s Peer To:Planning Subject:Statement on cell phone tower.gov Date:Sunday, May 31, 2020 9:55:07 PM To whom it may concern, Please read my statement at the hearing of CUP 2019-0032(DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Way Due to the executive order from the governor on remote hearings during Covid 19, this virtual hearing is not an adequate forum for the communities of Robertson Ranch, the Foothills, and the Rancho Carlsbad Homes residents that will be affected from the placement of the cell phone towers to voice their concern or be involved in these plans. In your staff report all calls and voice mails left in opposition that were made to the office are not documented. As well as both public forums that were held were put on by Crown Castle and not the City of Carlsbad for us to discuss these plans. First off, an open space is not identified as a preferred locationper City Council Policy No.64 as stated in your report, park sitesare preferred locations. This is a discouraged location. Thereare no plans on developing this area within 5 years, this wouldnot be in the so-called “temporary” time frame for these cellphone towers. This “temporary” seems sneaky as this can beapproved through 6 years with no public involvement, thatseems like a long temporary. If this gets approved, please letafter the 3 years for the public to be involved at a public hearingso we can state if we are seeing any problems with this.Because all meetings were put on by Crown we could not giveinput on current plans (ect moving further away from homes,more trees per tower, as well as specifics of other locationsconsidered). Second according to the environmental protection agency, they are concerns about potential health effects of RF energy, especially on the developing brains and bodies of children. Both Robertson Ranch as well as The Foothills is filled with young children whose parents have worked very hard to live in these communities to provide a safe environment for our children. Obviously in 3 minutes I am not able to state all the facts. But why would this even be considered placing near a community of children? According to this report, the current location is being moved due to affordable housing being built, are they not wanting themnear their homes/development? Most cell phone towers arenear highways and industrial areas, not near homes. These areover a million-dollar homes were placing these towers here willgreatly depreciate the value of our homes. These towers are aneye soar and way too close to the homes. We have all workedvery hard to live in these communities and this is heartbreakingthat this is even being considered. Other industrial sites shouldbe looked at further (Including the water plant, i.e. higher towersthere). Time should be spent finding these towers a permanent location not near homes and children and near an area that is more suitable for these towers. If this happens to be approved our communities will appeal this to the city council delaying this even further in court. Concerned Carlsbad resident, Annette Peer CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Raluca State To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Crown Castle - Trailblazer Park (resident concerns) Date:Monday, June 01, 2020 9:41:23 AM Mr Jones et al., I would like this email shared aloud at the June 3 virtual hearing regarding the development of the Trailblazer Park cell phone tower proposal: I am a second generation Carlsbad resident and live in The Foothills neighborhood adjacent to the park where you and Crown Castle are proposing to relocate two cell phone towers serving the area. Ignoring the dismay that this neighborhood already has over an empty field that was promised as an active city park when we all purchased homes here, this new (and very quiet) plan to add these towers is absolutely unconscionable to me. This is a neighborhood filled with young families, baby boomers, pets and life. The fact that our city is overlooking all of that in order to appease the developer of the Marja Acres project and the Crown Castle team is so disappointing and such a blatant disregard for Carlsbad’s residents and tax payers (which, frankly, seems to be the trend in this city now – sadly). I took the time to attend Crown Castle’s meeting several months ago. And stand opposed. This neighborhood vehemently opposes your plan. We do not want cell phone towers in our back yard. We do not want them moved closer to our kids. There is a lot of land in Carlsbad and in this area, in particular, and we would like to know how the city’s planners deemed that empty space not adequately “zoned” for this but decided a space adjacent to our homes and children is? You are our representatives and neighbors. You are the ones we are looking to for a sound future for our families in the communities where we’ve invested our money and our hearts. Your residents’ health and well-being should surely come first and foremost, especially in times like these. We look forward to you making the right choice for our community and for our families. Raluca State CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Jenny Sellers To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Statement for Hearing (CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Park WCF) Date:Monday, June 01, 2020 10:02:16 AM To Whom It May Concern, This e-mail is to request that the comments below be read IN THEIR ENTIRETY intothe record at the Planning Commission Meeting to be held on Wednesday, June 3, 2020 at 3:00pm regarding the proposed Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 TrailblazerWay (Case Name: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Park WCF). To begin, the residents of this community are irate that, as per your report, our previous phone calls and emails are not being considered in this public hearing. We understand the need tohold the public hearing virtually, but we were told that previous phone calls and emails were being documented and would be passed over at the public hearing. Why the sudden change?As residents of the community where this cell tower is being placed, we don't feel that this live streamed hearing provides us the opportunity to fully be heard, especially when our previousefforts are now being dismissed for reasons unbeknownst to us. As a homeowner in The Foothills community, I stand in firm opposition to the proposed location of the "temporary" cell tower in Trailblazer Park. My home falls within the 600'radius of where the tower will be positioned, and I am concerned about the installation for the following reasons: 1. Safety and health of residents and their children as a result of the proximity of the tower to neighborhood homes2. Affect of cell towers on property values 3. The proximity of the tower to neighborhood homes/residents based solely on the City'sdesire for it to "blend in" with trees so as not to be an "eye sore" for the City 4. "Temporary" nature of the placement of the tower5. The removal of the tower from its previous location which is now being turned into a residential neighborhood Since the City and the Contractor rely solely on the FCC's outdated and dangerous regulations which deem EMF radiation as "safe" because they don't produce adequate radiation to affectour bodies thermally, I'll start with home value. A study by the National Institute of Science, Law, and Public Policy stated that, "94 percent of homebuyers are “less interested and would pay less” for a property located near a cell tower orantenna...Of the 1,000 people who responded to the survey, 79 percent said that under no circumstances would they ever purchase or rent a property within a few blocks of a cell toweror antennas." It further goes on to sate that, "...buyers would pay as much as 20 percent less, as determined at that time by an opinion survey in addition to a sales price analysis." According to this article from the Environmental Health Trust, "the US Department ofHousing and Urban Development (HUD) considers cell towers as “Hazards and Nuisances.” Further, right here in CA, "The California Association of Realtors’ Property SellersQuestionnaire specifically states that 'cell towers' be listed on the disclosure form for sellers of real estate. The seller must note 'neighborhood noise, nuisance or other problems from..' and includes cell towers and high voltage transmission lines on the long list problems." My own buying behavior would have changed, had I known that a cell tower was beingplanned for the community. I know this to be true for many of my neighbors as well (and specifically my community members who live on Trailblazer Way), as many would neverhave purchased their "forever" homes, had they known that a cell tower was to be installed in the park behind their homes. Since many of us would not have purchased homes in such closeproximity to a cell tower, we can be sure that there are potential buyers in the future who will consider the same. This isn't a residents-only issue - it has the potential to also affect the City who won't be ableto collect as much on property tax as a result of decreased home values. It's a lose-lose for both community members and the City, and we urge you to take this into consideration whenmaking your decision. Another location must be found. The inevitable decrease of property values is a direct result of our main concern - the safety and health of community members and their children who will be living in such closeproximity to a cell tower. We are highly concerned about this, and rightly so. The Foothills and Robertson Ranch communities are home to hundreds of families with young children (andkids are often the most affected by the bioaccumulation that can occur from prolonged exposure to EMF radiation). Take a look at this group of letters, written by medical professionals from across the nationwho banded together to fight the proximity of cell phone towers near homes and schools. There are more than 18 letters written from doctors at Harvard, UCSD, the University atAlbany, the Environmental Working Group, and others who cite studies completed by the National Institutes of Health, the National Toxicology Program, and other highly respectedpeer-reviewed journals. On page 3 of this compilation of letters, Dr. Martha Herbert from the University at Albany in NY states that, "...the aggregate exposure over time coming from being close to a celltower can be very significant... In fact, there are thousands of papers that have accumulated over decades that document adverse health and neurological impacts of EMF/RFR. Childrenare more vulnerable than adults. Current technologies were designed and promulgatedwithout taking account of biological impacts other than thermal impacts. We now knowthat there are a large array of impacts that have nothing to do with the heating of tissue.The claim from WiFi proponents that the only concern is thermal impacts is nowdefinitively outdated scientifically. Radiofrequency electromagnetic radiation from WiFiand cell towers can exert a disorganizing effect on the ability to learn and remember, andcan also be destabilizing to immune and metabolic function. This will make it harder forsome children to learn, particularly those who are already having learning or medicalproblems in the first place. Powerful industrial entities have a vested interest in leadingthe public to believe that EMF/RFR, which we cannot see, taste or touch, is harmless, butthis is not true. Please do the right and precautionary thing for our children." On page 51 of this compilation, Dr. Beatrice Alexandra Golomb, a Medical Professor at our very own UCSD wrote a 5-page document imploring the State to reconsider where it placescell towers in relation to people's homes and schools. The 5-page document is followed byanother 21 pages consisting of 360 sources and citations that back up her concernsregarding the proximity of cell towers to homes and schools. Worthy of note in her letter, she states, 'The legislature granted an exemption from SB 649 to the firefighters who requested it for health reasons. Throughout California firefighters havelong complained of often disabling symptoms from cell towers on their stations. Cities frequently rent out space on fire stations to add to city revenue. …Symptoms experienced bythe firefighters have included neurological impairment including severe headache,confusion, inability to focus, lethargy, inability to sleep, and inability to wake up for 911emergency calls. Firefighters have reported getting lost on 911 calls in the same community they grew up in, and one veteran medic forgot where he was in the midst of basicCPR on a cardiac victim and couldn’t recall how to start the procedure over again…Prior to the installation of the tower on his station, this medic had not made a single mistake in 20years. A pilot study (2004) of California firefighters showed brain abnormalities,cognitive impairment, delayed reaction time, and lack of impulse control in all 6firefighters tested (https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/7022117660.pdf). This study led to theoverwhelming passage of Resolution 15 by the International Association of Firefightersin Boston in August 2004. Res. 15 called for further study and was amended to impose amoratorium on the placement of cell towers on fire stations throughout the US andCanada.'15 28Clearly, others who experience similar problems also deserve protections." With the proximity of the proposed cell tower to Carlsbad Fire Station #3, not onlywould the tower have potential negative health impacts on the community and childrenwho reside closest to it, but we could be putting the greater Carlsbad area residents atrisk due to the proximity of the tower to the Firehouse. I am also highly concerned that the sole reason cited to me by the City (during a phone callwith Shannon) for the placement of the tower being in such close proximity to the homesis so that it be nestled in with the trees to keep it from being a stand-alone structurewhich would "stick out like an eye-sore." The City apparently has no concern for the safety and health of its residents who would nothave bought our homes in this location, had this tower been here (or been in the plan for the park) when we purchased our homes. Please don't put our health, the health of ourchildren, and our property values at stake because you want the tower to "blend in" withthe flora and fauna of the proposed location. Not only is it unacceptable to the residents ofthis community to place this tower closer to the homes for cosmetic reasons, it's downright irresponsible (and frankly disgusting). We expect better from you, Carlsbad. My final concerns are the "temporary" nature of the 3-year lease, and the fact that it's beingmoved from its current location as a result of the building of additional housing. As residents in this neighborhood, we know that if the tower finds a comfortable home in our backyards for3 years, there's little to no chance the City will find another place for when the lease is up. Further, if the developer of the new residential space doesn't want it in his development, itfeels rather backhanded for the City to move it to ours. Again, many of us would not have bought homes in this neighborhood if the tower were here, and once it gets placed it will affectus financially as we try to leave. We request first that another location be considered for the placement of this tower thatis away from homes, schools, and residences. Carlsbad touts its success in keeping 40%of the City as open space...that should leave more than enough alternative options forthis tower than being placed right in our backyard. Second, if the City cannot protect the residents of this neighborhood by finding a location other than Trailblazer park, werequest that it be placed as far away from our residences as possible (perhaps at thecorner of Cannon and El Camino Real) without concern over the "eye-sore" it would befor the City. Keep this tower as far away from our homes as possible, please. Signed, Jenny SellersSummit Trail Ct. CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Melissa Vasconcellos To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Statement for hearing of CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Way held on June 3, 2020 at 3:00pm. Date:Monday, June 01, 2020 1:38:47 PM Dear Planning Commission, Please read my statement at the hearing of CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Way heldon June 3, 2020 at 3:00pm. My Family on Trailblazer way is in strong opposition of the proposed “temporary” Wireless facility. Due to the executive order from the governor on remote hearings during Covid 19, this virtual hearing is not an adequate forum for the communities of Robertson Ranch, the Foothills, and the Rancho Carlsbad Homes residents that will be affected from the placement of the cell phone towers to voice their concern or be involved in these plans. In your staff report all calls and voice mails left in opposition that were made to the office are not documented or being heard/recorded at this hearing. Both public forums that were held were put on by Crown Castle and not the City of Carlsbad for us to discuss these plans or get answers. Please postpone this hearing until the public can participate. First off, an open space is not identified as a preferred location per City Council Policy No.64 as stated in your report, park sites are preferred locations. This is a discouraged location. There are no plans on developing this area within 5 years or more, this would not be in the so-called “temporary” time frame for these cell phone towers. This “temporary” seems mis-leading as this can be approved through 6 years with no public involvement, that seems like a long temporary. There is also no way for the public to participate after the “temporary” 3 years, making this seem impossible to be “temporary”. Since all meetings were put on by Crown Castle we could not give input on current plans (ex. moving further away from homes, more trees per tower, as well as specifics of other locations considered). As a community we have unanswered questions and concerns. Second and Most importantly according to the environmental protection agency, they are concerns about potential health effects of RF energy, especially on the developing brains and bodies of children. Both Robertson Ranch as well as The Foothills is filled with young children whose parents have worked very hard to live in these communities to provide a safe environment for our children. I have two young children myself and this is very disturbing. Obviously in 3 minutes I am not able to state all the facts. But why would this even be considered placing near a community of children? According to this report, the current location is being moved due to housing being built, are they not wanting them near their homes/development? Most cell phone towers are near highways and industrial areas, not near homes. Not to mention these towers here will greatly depreciate the value of our homes. Other industrial sites should be looked at further (Including the water plant, i.e. higher towers there). Time should be spent finding these towers a permanent location not near homes and children and near an area that is more suitable for these towers. Or keep them were they are at. If this happens to be approved our communities will appeal this to the city council delaying this even further in court. Please do not approve a Conditional Use Permit for the installation of these towers! Melissa Tedder (Robertson Ranch home owner) CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Meenal Chauhan To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Cell Towers Date:Monday, June 01, 2020 8:42:40 PM Hello, My name is Meenal Chauhan and I currently live on Summit Trail Court in Carlsbad. I moved to this areabecause of the schooling, location, and a safe community to raise my kids. One of the deciding factors ofmoving to the Foothills was there were no direct power lines above our home, as there are in many areasof Carlsbad. My concern is that if the cell towers are constructed this can cause harm to our communityvery much like power lines. I have researched the harmful effects from cell tower radiation and I do notwish to impact my family to this twenty four hour environmental exposure. I would appreciateconsideration of not building these towers solely due to health concerns. If you have any questions,please contact me at the below number. Thank you, Meenal Chauhan ( CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Meenal Chauhan To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Re: Cell Towers Date:Monday, June 01, 2020 8:45:18 PM Also, please have this email read during the hearing. Hello, My name is Meenal Chauhan and I currently live on Summit Trail Court in Carlsbad. I moved to this areabecause of the schooling, location, and a safe community to raise my kids. One of the deciding factors ofmoving to the Foothills was there were no direct power lines above our home, as there are in many areasof Carlsbad. My concern is that if the cell towers are constructed this can cause harm to our communityvery much like power lines. I have researched the harmful effects from cell tower radiation and I do notwish to impact my family to this twenty four hour environmental exposure. I would appreciateconsideration of not building these towers solely due to health concerns. If you have any questions,please contact me at the below number. Thank you, Meenal Chauhan On Monday, June 1, 2020, 08:42:34 PM PDT, Meenal Chauhan <meenalc@sbcglobal.net> wrote: Hello, My name is Meenal Chauhan and I currently live on Summit Trail Court in Carlsbad. I moved to this areabecause of the schooling, location, and a safe community to raise my kids. One of the deciding factors ofmoving to the Foothills was there were no direct power lines above our home, as there are in many areasof Carlsbad. My concern is that if the cell towers are constructed this can cause harm to our communityvery much like power lines. I have researched the harmful effects from cell tower radiation and I do notwish to impact my family to this twenty four hour environmental exposure. I would appreciateconsideration of not building these towers solely due to health concerns. If you have any questions,please contact me at the below number. Thank you, Meenal Chauhan CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Sarah Dessert To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones Subject:Cell Tower Date:Tuesday, June 02, 2020 7:21:21 AM Please take this email into consideration for the hearing of the cell tower proposed to be installedbehind the fire station in the Foothills neighborhood. Please read at the hearing. I’ll keep this short. Myself and my family have lived in this community for three years now. A cell tower placed in Thiscommunity will expose everyone in the community with a CONSTANT emission of cell radiation that can have severe health effects. I am AGAINST the cell tower near our lovely community. Please note the letter below.CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know thecontent is safe. Sincerely, Sarah Dessert Sent from my iPhone From:E & P Broeder To:Planning Subject:Fw: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) - Trailblazer Park WCF Date:Wednesday, June 03, 2020 2:16:59 PM ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: E & P Broeder <vegesoul@sbcglobal.net> To: Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov <cliff.jones@carlsbadca.gov> Sent: Tuesday, May 26, 2020, 11:13:42 AM PDT Subject: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) - Trailblazer Park WCF Dear Cliff I'm contacting you to find out if this project is "5G"?? There's no mention of it in the Notice. I live close by and 5G is getting a lot of NEGATIVE publicity health wise. Doesn't seem like a good idea especially now considering 5G destroys immune systems. Please let me know if this project is in fact a "5G" installation. Thank you, Pam Broeder CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Jodi Squires To:Planning Subject:Opposition To Proposed Wireless Communication Facility Date:Tuesday, June 02, 2020 1:59:32 PM I would like this read at the June 3, 2020 public hearing Please read the following into the record: Dear Planning Commission, This e-mail is to express my strong opposition to the proposed installation, operation andmaintenance of “temporary” Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way. (CaseName: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – Trailblazer Park WCF). My family and I reside on Trailblazer Way. We have lived here for almost 4 years inRobertson Ranch. We are very concerned that the installation and operation of this 5 G towerbecause of the close proximity to our home, will cause great health risks to our family andneighbors. It has shown that children are at greater health risks from EMF (Electromagnetic FieldRadiation) which can cause anxiety, headaches, cancer. I am asking that the Carlsbad City Planners find a much better location for this WirelessCommunication Facility which will not put health risks on us or our neighborhood. Pleaseprotect the health and safety of Carlsbad residents and their children. I am also I licensed real estate appraiser and I am greatly concerned about the CommunicationFacility being so close to our home and lowering the value of our property. This is notacceptable! I know Carlsbad can find another location that is suitable for this 5G tower. Please do not approve a Conditional Use Permit for the installation and operation of ahighly dangerous Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way! Jodi & Rodney Squires Carlsbad, CA 92010 Jodi SquiresCertified Real Estate Appraiser www.lci-network.com CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Stephanie Griffin To:Planning Subject:RE: PLEASE READ AT THE 6/3 HEARING Date:Tuesday, June 02, 2020 4:22:31 PM Dear Planning Commission: This email serves to communicate my STRONG opposition to the proposed installation of, operation of, and maintenance of the “temporary” wireless communication tower facility at3465 Trailblazer Way. (Case Name: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) - Trailblazer Park WCF). I simply do NOT consent to having this type of installation. As a homeowner, mother of twoboys (one with compromised health) and a practitioner in health care, it is not appropriate to have this tower in a neighborhood full of children. I’m OUTRAGED the town of Carlsbadwould place money and lobbying before the health and welfare of residents. Informed consent is required prior to installing/utilizing interventions that impacthealth. This is an essential and fundamental human right. Without accurate information - we the homeowners will not provide consent. Currently, there is no actual data to indicate the safety of such equipment utilizing EMF(Electromagnetic Field Radiation) with regard to impact on human health. There is propaganda and marketing material - but no current published data regarding safety. In fact, alot of studies prove the contrary - a huge and detrimental impact to human health. Without published, independent research into the long-term health risks from being exposed to thesetowers 24/7 (to 2G, 3G, 4G and 5G) - there is no place for this type of equipment in our neighborhood. I am especially concerned with the more vulnerable populations of TheFoothills such as children, fetus in the womb, and the immune compromised. These are YOUR constituents, your voting base, your neighbors, too. Even the private ensurers (yes, private!) of cell towers (ex. Swiss Re) state that 5G towers arethe highest risk category. These insurers are the ultimate arbiters of risk - and yet they, too - have evaluated that the risk is such that standard insurance companies won’t take on theliability. (Much like the nuclear industry). This should be a data point worth noting. In addition to health risks, the impact to property value is huge. Our Foothills Neighborhood is a gem of community offering housing options at a variety of price points. Lowering the valueof ANY of our homes is unacceptable. We purchased our home last year at over $1M and am gobsmacked that a project like this would even be considered in a residential neighborhood.Any realtor will tell you that cell tower proximity reduces home value by up to 20%. Most cell towers are near highways, industrial areas or protected space - and not near homes. Why in theworld the council even consider this spot for installation? Please do not approve a Conditional Use Permit for the installation and operation of the irresponsibly risky Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way! Warm regards,Stephanie Griffin CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Stacey Baker To:Planning Subject:EMF Wireless Tower on Trailblazer Way Date:Tuesday, June 02, 2020 5:19:09 PM Dear Planning Commission: This email serves to communicate my EXTREME opposition to the proposed installation of the “temporary” wireless communication tower facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way. (Case Name:CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) - Trailblazer Park WCF). I CLEARLY do NOT consent to having this type of installation. As a homeowner, 43 year Carlsbad resident and a mother of four children having this tower in a neighborhood full ofchildren it is not appropriate. I am disgusted and ashamed at the city of Carlsbad for even considering this location as an option. OUTRAGED the town of Carlsbad would place money and lobbying before the health and welfare of residents. Informed consent is required prior to installing/utilizing interventions that impact health. Thisis an essential and fundamental human right. It is a right to the residents of this neighborhood and surrounding community. We the HOMEOWNERS do not provide consent. There is no actual data to indicate the safety of equipment utilizing EMF with regard to how itimpacts human health. There is fake studies, propaganda and marketing material - but no actual current published data regarding safety. Studies actually show a huge and detrimentalimpact to human health. Without published, independent research into the long-term health risks from being exposed to these towers 24/7 and especially with the unknown risk to healthfrom the newly upgraded 5g, there is just NO place for this type of equipment in OUR neighborhood. We are YOUR constituents, your voting base, your neighbors, too. In addition to health risks, the impact to property value is huge. Our Foothills Neighborhood isa family community with housing options at a variety of price points. Lowering the value of ANY of our homes is NOT acceptable. We are appalled that this would even be considered ina residential neighborhood. Any realtor will tell you that cell tower proximity reduces home value by up to 20%. Where will the compensation for our loss of equity be coming from? Most cell towers are near highways, industrial areas or protected space - NOT smack dab right near homes. There is so much open space in Carlsbad so why in the world is this the ONLYspot for installation? In addition, it is my understanding that this proposed Wireless Communication Facility is “temporary” for 3-4 years or until “another suitable location” is found. If the application forthe Conditional Use Permit does not guarantee that the this facility will be dismantled and taken out of service within 4 years, then wouldn’t that automatically make it “permanent”. Isthe use of the word “temporary” just being used as a way for the City of Carlsbad to sneak it past us all? It would be very easy for Crown Castle to claim that it could not find “anothersuitable location” and then keep this facility operational indefinitely. If an alternate location cannot be located at this time, there is no way one will be located at a later date. This tower isnot “temporary” and the residents of this area know that. Please do not approve a Conditional Use Permit for the installation and operation of the irresponsibly risky Wireless Communication Facility at 3465 Trailblazer Way! Warm regards,Stacey Baker . CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Lee Lorber To:Planning Subject:Case Name: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) - Trailblazer Park Date:Tuesday, June 02, 2020 9:22:40 PM My name is Elizabeth Lorber and I live at , Carlsbad California. I purchased my home in July, 2019. It was very important to me how the land behind my homewould be developed before I put an offer on the home. I was assured by the selling real estate agent that there was a park that was going to be built in that space. I had mentioned to myrealtor after he showed me one property with a tower nearby, that that was definitely a deal breaker. I am concerned that even though you addressed no significant risk, even a minimalrisk to our health and the environment, is a cause for great concern. I, therefore, am adamantly object to the construction of a WCF in the land behind my home. Thank you foryour sensitivity and consideration to myself and my community. Elizabeth Lorber CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Cliff Jones To:Don Neu; Melissa Flores Subject:FW: Trailblazer Park WCF Date:Wednesday, June 03, 2020 10:48:25 AM Sincerely, Cliff Jones Senior Planner Community Development Department City of Carlsbad 1635 Faraday Ave. Carlsbad, CA 92008 www.carlsbadca.gov 760-602-4613 | Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov DURING THE CURRENT PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY: FOR ONGOING PROJECTS, PLEASE CONTACT YOUR PROJECT PLANNER TO SCHEDULE A RESUBMITTAL DROP-OFF APPOINTMENT. FOR NEW PROJECT SUBMITTALS AND LANDSCAPE SUBMITTALS/RESUBMITTALS/ASBUILTS, PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL YOUR REQUEST FOR A SUBMITTAL DROP-OFF APPOINTMENT: Phone: 760-602-4610 Email: planning@carlsbadca.gov Facebook | Twitter | You Tube | Flickr | Pinterest |Enews From: Jordan Racey <jordanracey1@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, June 3, 2020 8:57 AM To: Cliff Jones <Cliff.Jones@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Trailblazer Park WCF Hi Cliff, My name is Jordan Racey and I live at . I had some communication with Shannon Harker back in November where she stated the project site was to potentially be moved closer to the intersection of Cannon and El Camino. From the rendering I received on Friday in the mail, it looks as though the site will now be directly behind the homes on our street? We would like to request the site be moved as far away from our street/homes as possible. Can this be brought to the planning board today, I may not be able to log in to the virtual meeting. Thank you! Best regards Jordan CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:Adrian Elliott To:Planning Cc:Cliff Jones; Debbie Subject:4. CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) – TRAILBLAZER PARK WCF: MUST READ AT Date:Wednesday, June 03, 2020 10:47:41 AM I respectfully request that this letter to the Planning Commission be read aloud at the hearing. Ladies and Gentlemen, I'd like to express my firm opposition to item #4 on today's agenda, the installation of aWireless Communications Facility in the Open Space (O-S) zone within Planning Area 12 of Robertson Ranch. The City Planner has noted that, "...the project belongs to a class of projects that the StateSecretary of Resources has found not to have a significant impact on the environment." This may well be true, but the impact of these large towers are not insignificant on aesthetics of ourneighborhood (The Foothills) and thus our home values. To wit, a 2018 article in the "Scientists for Wired Technology" magazine relates the story of a house that fell out of escrowdue and subsequently sold at $150,000 below asking price some 6 months later. The proposed location of the WCF is at the very front of The Foothills and would be the first thing prospective homebuyers see as they approach our neighborhood. Given the potential forsignificant impacts to the aesthetics of our community and the values of our homes, I recommend that the Planning Commission explore other potential locations. In the area ofRobertson Ranch there is an abundance of apparently unused space, particularly by Sage Creek High School, that would serve your purposes well. Again, as a homeowner, I want to emphasize my strong opposition to this endeavor. Respectfully,Adrian Elliott MD CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:OSBORNE, JOHN R To:Melissa Flores Subject:Document for today"s Planning Commission item on the Crown Castle cell sites relocation Date:Wednesday, June 03, 2020 1:27:46 PM Attachments:Cell_Site_Safety_022019.pdf Melissa, I would like to submit the attached document into the record for today’s Planning Commission item on the Crown Castle cell sites relocation. Please confirm receipt and or advise if there is something else I need to do to submit the document. John Osborne AT&T Director – External affairs Mobile (preferred): 619-200-3024 Office: 619-574-3046 Email: jo2783@att.com or john.osborne@att.com CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From:OSBORNE, JOHN R To:Melissa Flores Subject:RE: Document for today"s Planning Commission item on the Crown Castle cell sites relocation Date:Wednesday, June 03, 2020 2:01:50 PM Melissa, Yes, please. Thank you John Osborne AT&T Director – External affairs Mobile (preferred): 619-200-3024 Office: 619-574-3046 Email: jo2783@att.com or john.osborne@att.com From: Melissa Flores <Melissa.Flores@carlsbadca.gov> Sent: Wednesday, June 3, 2020 1:59 PM To: OSBORNE, JOHN R <jo2783@att.com> Subject: RE: Document for today's Planning Commission item on the Crown Castle cell sites relocation Hello John, The document has been received and forwarded to the Planning Commission for today’s hearing. Did you want this read during the hearing? Thank you. From: OSBORNE, JOHN R <jo2783@att.com> Sent: Wednesday, June 03, 2020 1:28 PM To: Melissa Flores <Melissa.Flores@carlsbadca.gov> Subject: Document for today's Planning Commission item on the Crown Castle cell sites relocation Melissa, I would like to submit the attached document into the record for today’s Planning Commission item on the Crown Castle cell sites relocation. Please confirm receipt and or advise if there is something else I need to do to submit the document. John Osborne AT&T Director – External affairs Mobile (preferred): 619-200-3024 Office: 619-574-3046 Email: jo2783@att.com or john.osborne@att.com CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. There are no known adverse health effects from cell sites and no health risks to the general public have been shown. The FCC has pointed out that the possibilities are remote that a person could be exposed to RF levels that exceed the FCC guidelines. You can find the full FCC guidelines for Cellular and PCS Sites at: http://www.fcc.gov/cgb/consumerfacts/rfexposure.html In addition, the American Cancer Society (ACS) affirms the FCC’s conclusion stating “at ground level near typical cellular base stations, the amount of RF energy is thousands of times less than the limits for safe exposure set by the FCC and other regulatory authorities.” The ACS also states that it is “very unlikely” for an individual to be exposed to excess RF levels just by being close to a cell site. According to a report on cell sites, the ACS confirms that most scientists believe that cell sites and antennas are unlikely to cause cancer or result in health problems. You can find the full ACS report at: http://www.cancer.org/Cancer/CancerCauses/OtherCarcinogens/AtHome/cellular-phone-towers Furthermore, the World Health Organization (WHO) confirms that RF emissions diminish rapidly with distance. Likewise, the WHO states that studies have not shown a correlation between exposure to RF emissions from base stations and an increased risk of cancer or any adverse long or short-term health effects. You can find the full WHO report at: https://www.who.int/peh-emf/publications/facts/fs304/en/ AT&T builds and maintains all cell sites and antennas in accordance with FCC guidelines for human exposure to radiofrequency (RF) fields. The energy from the antennas on cell sites decreases with distance. As a result, ground-level exposure is much lower than if a person were very close to the antenna and the main beam. The FCC’s RF exposure guidelines recommend a maximum permissible exposure level to the general public of approximately 580 microwatts per square centimeter. This limit is many times greater than RF levels typically found near the base of cell sites or in the vicinity of other, lower-powered cell site transmitters. © 2017 AT&T Intellectual Property. All rights reserved. AT&T Places the Safety of Its Customers First From:E & P Broeder To:Planning Subject:Today"s Planning Commission Meeting 3/6 at 3pm Date:Wednesday, June 03, 2020 2:13:53 PM RE: CUP 2019-0032 (DEV2019-0179) - Trailblazer Park WCF I am a Carlsbad resident and have been trying to ascertain if this PROJECT IS 5G??? I emailed previously with this question on 5/26. I have yet to receive an answer. The "Notice of Public Hearing" the city mailed to me makes no mention of 5G. Also made a second attempt to find this out by calling in a second time to the City Works dept, I was told to speak with Construction Management and was unable to complete a call to that number. I am against the idea of a 5G installation at this time, just a stone's throw from my house especially during a PANDEMIC whereby immune systems are and will be compromised. BTW, 5G was installed in Wuhan just prior to the outbreak. It certainly didn't help anyone. Could someone please note "my objection" please. Thank you, Pamela Broeder CAUTION: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.