HomeMy WebLinkAbout1975-09-24; Encina Joint Advisory Committee Ad Hoc; Minutesa
JOINT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
September 24, 1975
Chairman, Ed Stiles
Present:Buena:
Carlsbad:
Encinitas:
Leucadia:
San Diego County;
San Marcos:
Vista:
Brown & Caldwell:
Blade-Tribune:
Carlsbad:
CPO:
LOWV:
San Diego County:
.Vice-chairman/ Stanley__Mahr_
Bill Dominguez, Ed Stiles
Tim Flanagan, Lew Chase, Diane Hubbard
Mark Schneider, Jack Kubota, Dave
Bricks
Dick Hanson, Stan VanSickle
Chuck Oldsen, George Long, Sr.,
G.M. Bowman, Gary Decker
Gene Madison
Bob Foo, Joe Zapotocky, Paul Pressman,
Wayne Elliott
Eric Mische
Liz Harris
Joseph Eggleston, Roger Greer
Steve Sachs
Ruth Honnold, Jane Skotnicki
Jane Ullman
Minutes__o_f August 20__Meeting
The minutes of the August 20 meeting were approved as submitted, with
the minor correction of the spelling of Mayor Meyer's name.
Operations and Maintenance Reports
It was requested by Joe Zapotocky that staff reports be included in
the agenda that is sent to member agencies prior to the meeting so
that reports could be reviewed prior to the meeting.
The plant 'is now in conforrnance with the Water Quality Control Board
regulations and is having no more trouble with grease and oil dis-
charge into the ocean. Odor problems are still occurring; digester
#3 is pretty much taking the full plant sludge load at this time,
but there was another problem relating to odor, that being a tomato
field east of the plant and north of Palomar Airport Road. The owner
was piling tomatoes on the ground and the smell was co-mingling with
the plant's odor problems. Solamar Mobile-home Park had complained
during the month, but the smell that they had was partially due to
the tomatoes. Digester #1 will not be back into operation for at
least a month; it is in the process of being seeded and brought, back
to full operation after the cleaning process.
The Dixon Ford industrial waste problem needs to be reported to the
Regional Water Quality Control Board; Carlsbad is studying the problem
and will be handling it. Burroughs is unable to complete their waste-
water reclamation facilities as soon, as anticipated. A meeting will
be set up in the near future to move it along to a satisfactory con-
clusion.
Joint Advisory Committee
September 24, 1975
Page Two
2. Operations and Maintenance jReports, cont'd.
The total flow is up slightly, with no significant changes in any of
the agencies. Cost accounting is well below pro-rated costs.
3. Existing and Projected Flows
Not all of the agencies are calling in or writing in their reports
monthly for this report; cooperation was requested from all.
Connections projected for the coming months will be close to 200
per month.
4. New Work Program, Increasing Operating Staff
These two agenda items were combined into one item and reported on
by George Long. The current staff totals 7 people, with three more
positions to be filled. These people will be hired during the month
of October. A breakdown of preventative maintenance and priority
work scheduled was included in the agenda packet.
5. Report on Septage Haulers
Although only a cursory review has been made, no major violations
have been noted by the septage haulers. Several haulers have been
negligent in logging in their dumps. Staff has tried to devise a
means to keep down odors generated in dumping and have constructed
a cover for a manhole with an opening smaller than usual, big enough
for a hose to fit into.
6. Alternative Methods for Disposal of Sludge
A report was made on the several alternate methods of disposing of
the digested sludge at the plant, including selling it to the public,
giving it to the public andselling it to fertilizer companies. The
estimated costs for charging the public for sludge would end up
costing the member agencies. Contact with fertilizer companies has
not resulted in anything substantial, because of the low nitrogen
content in the sludge. A motion passed (Zapotocky-Chase) to adopt
the County's recommendation of using the honor system in charging
the public, as long as there were no legal entanglements, using this
system for a period of six months to test it. Chuck Oldsen advised
that it would take two or three months to get this program into
effect, after the preventative maintenance program was started and
they had sufficient personnel on hand. Ed Stiles suggested that we
first check to see how much product liability insurance would cost.
Mr. Zapotocky withdrew his first motion and another passed (Zapotocky-
Chase) that the Chairman be instructed to pursue the products liability
aspect of the plan and report back next meeting. A further motion
passed (Dominguez-Chase) that staff investigate with San Diego Fert-
ilizer Co. further to see whether it would be feasible to contract
for the hauling and purchasing of available sludge, and report back
at the next meeting.
Joint Advisory Committee
September 24, 1975
Page Three
7. Progress Report on Phase I I and I I A
Little or nothing has happened on the construction of Phase II and IIA
during the last month, because there have been no deliveries. The
contractor is waiting for all the equipment to be at the plant and
ready to install before he returns to finish the contract.
8. Progress Report on Phase III
The grant eligible flow is now 13.55. Water Quality Control people
have rejected the bar screen, influent structures and some piping as
being grant eligible. Staff will talk to them again about these
items and others. The WQC also does not feel it is necessary to
cover the bio filters. On concept approval review, items 1 through
3 were newly accepted (as listed on letter in agenda packet) .
Chuck Oldsen invited all members to attend a meeting on Monday,
September 29 at 10:30 a.m. at the plant with the project evaluator
and his supervisor, the Air Quality Control Board coordinator, EPA,
and CPO.
Ongoing negotiations with Brown and Caldwell have not yet resulted
in new design contract.
9. Report on "Independent Management Study Subcommittee"
Carlsbad, through the recording secretary, reported that only Enciriitas
and Carlsbad have responded to the instructions given at the July
meeting where member agencies were to go back to their respective
boards to receive direction on their attitudes to the management
study. As soon as everyone advises this has been done, a Subcommittee
meeting will be convened.
10. Report on Phase IIA Project Administration
A staff report regarding engineering inspection services for the Phase
IIA project was included in the agenda packet. It was briefly reviewed
by Chuck Oldsen.
11. Proposal by LCWD to Reclaim Wastewater
Chuck Oldsen reported that we should work this process through and
make it feasible, as this type of request will become more frequent
in the coming years. His concerns focused on: sludge that may cause
some concerns at the plant as far as flotation .is concerned; more
sludge will need to be treated and a surcharge should be imposed on
LCWD until the completion of Phase III; waste discharge requirements
will have to be set by the Regional Water Quality Control Board.
Motion passed (Zapotocky-Dominguez) to accept staff recommendations
whex*eby further discussions would continue between staff, agency
engineers and Leucadia to develop solutions to the various problems
and considerations inherent with the proposal.
Joint Advisory Committee
September 24, 1975
Page Four
11. Proposal by LCWD to Reclaim Was it e wa to r
Dick Hanson advised that LCWD is continuing to use their treatment
plant at about 100,000 to 150,000 gallons per day and discharging
this amount to La Costa. They do not plan on putting the newly-
cleaned digester back into operation and are currently taking their
raw sludge from that which they are sending to La Costa and processing
it through Encina. No objections were voiced to permitting them to
continue doing this, unless it becomes a problem to the plant.
Motion passed (Schneider-DOi\.rnguez) that Leucadia be allowed to
continue with their current operation until such time that it creates
a problem for the other agencies, and instructing staff to come back
with a report on the possible problems at the next meeting. That
is, Chuck will report on how this is affecting the plant, the odor
problems, capacity and the plant's ability to treat influent.
12. Proposed JAC Resolution
In light of requests imposed by A-95 review, motion passed (Zapotocky-
Hanson) to adopt the resolution of the Joint Advisory Committee
requesting local planning efforts in the Encina service area.
13. Other Business
Insurance details have been taken care of; the new additions from
Phase II and IIA are covered and are awaiting the inspector to give
a cost for policy purposes.
The meeting date for next month was changed to October 15, 1975.
Respectfully submitted,