Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1972-12-12; Planning Commission; Minutesf ., ~ MEETING OF: DATE : TTME: PLACE: - . ". CITY OF , "V. CMLSBAD ' PLANNING COMMISSION DECEMBER 12, 1972 7:30 P.M. CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS ROLL CALL: City Staff members prespnt: D.A. Aqaten, V. Riondo, T.C. Flanagan, David Meyer, Michael Zander APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The minutes of the reqular meeting of Yovember 28, 197 were approved as corrected. The minutes of the ad- journed meetino of December 7, 1972 were anproved as read. WRITTEY COMMUNICATION: None ORAL COMMUNICATI.0N: None PUBLIC HEARINGS: (a) Continued - PRE-ANNEXAT1QNAL.ZONE CHANGE & SPECTf from County A-1-8 to 'City of Carlsbad P-M (Planne In.dustria1) and AdoDtion of ASpeciffc Plan on property located south of Palomar Atrport Road and west of El Camino Real. Applicant: Systems Capital Corp. : """"""""""""""""""""""""-~"" ..GI The Chairman read a letter from Hughes Aircraft (Systems Capital Corp.) requesting a delay in tfi hearing of this matter to January 23, 1973. Ther was a short discussion regarding the application and it was explained by Staff that all City requirements would be, met before- recommendation of approval would be made. A motion was then made to grant the request for continuance. (b) Continued - VARIANCE - Request to allow tandem parking on the existing drive beh-ind cars that will be parking in new carport on the corner of Garfield Street and Normandy Lane. Applicant: Chandler B. Edwards ........................... Mr. Agatep presented the staff.report setting forth th reasons and conditions for approval. Mr. Chandler B. Edwards, 5471,Los Robles, Carlsbad, the applicantj was present and requested consideration for three units instead of two as recomm.ended by staff. He further requested that the matter be<Festbdduled to a later meeting in order to reach agreement with staff on num- ber of units. The City Attorney recommended that the Commission return the application to Staff for their presentation at a later date. A motion was made to continue this item to the meeting of January 30, 1973. (c) Continued - TENTATIVE MAP & SPECIFIC PLAN - Request for approval of a 269-lot residential de- velopment on 290 acres located north of Rancho Santa Fe Rd. and the proposed La Costa Avenue extension to be known as La Costa Vale, Units 2-4 Carlsbad Tract 72-20. Applicant; La Costa Land Company ........................... COMMISSIONERS PRESEYT MOT I ON AYES NOES ARSTAIN - MOTION AYES NOES MOTION AYES NOES I - CITY OF CARLSBAD Chairman Jose read a letter from Ricks Engineerinq re- questing continuanceeof this matter to the meeting of January 9, 1973. Staff recommended continuance to the meeting of January 23, 1973 and the applicant, Mr. Robert Ladwig, 509 Elm Avenue, Carlshad, concurred. It was then moved tha.t the request be approved. (d) Continued - ZONE CHANGE & ADOPTION OF A MASTER PLAN - Request for Change of Zone from R-1-10,OO ' to. P-C (Planned Community) Zone and Adoption of a Master Plan on 36 acres located on the-east s8de of 1-5, south of Palomar Air.port Road. Appl i cant: Fred C. Sproul, Inc. """"""""""""""""""""""""""" Staff requested continuance of this item to the meetin of January 23, 1973 as environmental impact staCement requirements bad not been completed. Andrew McReynold 2316 Calle Chiquita, La Jolla, the applicant, asked fo consideration of an earlier date. He later agreed to the recommendation of Staff. The motion to approve th continuance carried. (e) Continued - TENTATIVE MAP & SPECIFIC PLAN - Reque for approval of a 321-unit condominium developmen located on 35 acres at the northeast corner of .Alga Road and El' Fuerte Street to be known as La Costa Meadowbrook, Carlsbad Tract 72-26. Appl icant: La Costa Land Company ........................... The'Staff report was made by Mr. Agatep. Their recom- nendation was that the proposed Tentative Map & Specif Plan be approved subject to the reasons and conditions outlined in the report. There was a short discussion by the Commission regarding agreements made between th developer and the City (per Conditions) and the keepin Df records on these agreements. The Commission sugges that the Engineering Department make a report to them on this situation. Mr. Flanagan of the Engineering Department advised that this study was being made. Chairman Jose then moved that Condition No. 6 in the Staff Report be reworded as corrected. Yr. Robert Ladwig, Ricks Engineering, 509 Elm Avenue, Carlsbad, applicants representative, agreed to the - change in Condition No. 6 regarding the traffic signal He also stated that he would meet with the City Engi- neer re:. future agreement for lighting in La Costa and advised that C.M.W.D. and Sern Marcos County Water Dis- trict will serve the Meadowbrook development. He then requested Commcission approval of the application. There was notooe to speak in favor of the project,or in opposition, and the public hearing was closed at 3:40. A motion was then made for approval and the notion carried. COMMISSIONERS MOTION AYES NOES I MOT I ON AYES NOES ?d MOTION AYES , NOES MOT 1 ON AY ESI! , NOES. 14 1' I CITY OF CARLSBAD (f) Ameddment to Carlbbad Municipal Code - Request fo an amendment to Section 17.16.040. Tit1.e 17. ~~~ Carlsbad Municipal Code, regardinq requirements Fire Zone 3. . Initiated by Staff (Fire Dept.) ........................... I Mr. Agatep advised the Commission that a Staff report. had been prepared and submitted for their consideratio but that a last minute discussion with the Building an Fire Departments necessitated the withdrawal of this request for further study. An overlap in required further discussion. A motion was take this item off calendar and submit to a later date. NOE (9) Amendment to Carlsbad Municipal Code - Request for an Amendmen$ to Section 21.42.010; Ti&le 21, Section 21.42.010 of the Carlsbad MuniciDal Code pegapdinl ~~~~u~el~"~n~ncaenq~B~~~~~!~ n~ Initiate by Staff (Planning Dept.) ........................... Mr. Agatep presented the Staff report explaining that the Amendment was an attempt by the City €0 alleviate the need for C.U.P.s for uses that are for charitabqe purposes and clarified that this referred only to thos requesting permits for two da.ys or less, and that this change would make the Ordinance inclusive of service groups also. There was-no:onecpceseRd to.hpehk ~scC~~V of ;:.or- in oppofjtfoando'this~~ceqaes~Gt The1 Coiumrissioh concumed with the recommendation of Staff and the motion made to this effect carried. (h) Amendment to Carlsbad Municipal Code - Request for an amendment to Title 5, Section 5.24.145 and I Title 21, Section 21.42.010-of the Carlsbad Muni- cipal Cade by adding provisions for a watchman's trailer. Initiated by Staff (Planning Dept.) ........................... The Staff report was made by Mr. Agatep outlining the changes requested to be made in the Code. The Commiss approved the recommendations of Staff.? There wafiao publ~~~co~meaEea6d~th~~~mo~i~n.~~~re4er the request to' City Council was approved. NEW BUSINESS: (a) Continued - TENTATIVE MAP - Request for approval of a Tentative Map for a 380-unit Condominium project located norhh of Agua Hedionda Lagoon between 1-5 and Santa Fe Railroad right-ofkway, known as "Papagayo". ACDI iApplicant: Hunts Parhnership COMMISSIONERS rMOT AYE NOE on MOT AYE NOE I .. -t CITY OF CARLSBAD The Staff report, including EnvironmehBal Impact Re- port (final) was presented by Mr. Agatep. Th'ere followed a lengthy discussion on points of concern to both Staff and Commission as to the effect this proposed project would have on the Lagoon and whether or not problems in this regard had been settled betwee the applicant and S.D.G. & E. Revisions made on the Tentative Map which reflected some differences between T.M. and the approved Specific Plan were discussed, as well as the number of units and sewer system for the proposed project. Staff recommended approval of the application based on the conditions outlined in the report presented to the Commission,'in addition to the several other conditions set out by the Commission Mr. Larry Hunts, 3024 Fifth Ave'nue, San Diego, the applicant, was present. He advised that several meet- ings had been held bitkcGnD..G & E., that agreement has been reached re: the Lagoon, but the written versi had not been completed yet. It was agreed' that this agreement should be made a part of the documents. He also expressed agreement to the additional conditions made by the Commission. There was no one else present to speak in favor of the proposed project. Mr. Harry Truax, 2141 Harbor Drive, Carlsbad, was present to speak in opposition. A source of concern was the traffic circulation problem that could occur. Mr. Donald Panska, 4265 Skyline Drive, Carlsbad, was concerned only with the density proposed by the de- vel oper. There being-no further public comment, the public hearing was closed. .Further discussion of the traffic signal and circu- lation problems ensued and it was agreed that further study would be required. The motion adcgptiggthhe Final Environmental Report was approved. The motion adopting Resolution No. 834 for Tentative Map was approved. I I 1 ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ (b) Review of Environmental Impact Statement for Encina Water PolSution Control Facility. """"""""""""""""""""""""""" This report was re-scheduled for a future heari.ng whel all information would be received. T e C herBiiwdS-ti'discussion, at this time, regarding the stablishing by resolution the conduct of the Plannin ommission with regard to procedure. This included a standard way of adopting resolutions and the manner of conducting Public Hearings. A flow-chart was pre- sented to the Commissioners for their information. COMMl SSIONERS City"Attorney commented on A.B. 889 which was concern el d .- - - '. -1 - CITY OF CAFLSBAD with the filing of new guidelines on Environmental Impact. He also adofsed that with regard to the 120- day moritorium, the City Council unanimously decided to continue with the same procedure already establishe by ordinance. OLD BUSINESS: The Tri-C regard be was made, plans for Del Norte ity Auto Plaza was discussed with particular ing given to landscape buffer zones. A motio and carried, that ~he;eo~~issioajapppe~e any the five remaining dealerships in. the Plaza . r: 7;c ,?, : r:q '4 be & 9- . It was moved that the meeting of December 26, 1972 be cancelled and that all matters to be considered at that meeting should be set .forward to the f.irst meetin in January. The meeting was adjourned at 10:30. Respectfully submitted, " _""" Liz Estel, Recording Secretary COMMISSIONERS (Pnch;kczra-L, MOTION AYES NOES MOT I ON AYES NOES.