Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-11-09; Planning Commission; MinutesCITY OF 'ARLSBAD - PLANNING COMMISS NOVEMBER 9, 1977 , CITY OF CARLSBAD PAGE 1 ION MEET COUNC I L I NG CHAMBERS . CALL TO ORDER - The meeting was called to order at 7:05 P.M. KOLL CALL .L , PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE APPROVAL OF MINUTES - A motion was made to approve the Minutes of October 26, 1977 with the addition of Commissione Jose's name being included with the Kelly's as opposing. the numbers and types of anima in Case No. ZCA-86. -APPROVAL OF RESOLUTIONS (1) Resolution No. 1417, CUP- s in connection with grazing 42, Dennis Dassof. A motion was made to approve Resolution NO. 1417. (2) -Resolution No. 1418, CUP-143, Charles Monson. A motion was made to approve Resolufion No. 1418. (3) Resolution No. 1419, ZCA-86, 'City of Carlsbad Commissioner L'Heureux was absent at the meeting when. ..ZCA-86 was discussed but he wished to go on record as . saying that he thinks the Commission is doing dis'service to the city bymaking the changes to the Ordinance Amendment as he feels the Planning Commission disturbed the intent of the zone that was proposed by staff. A motion was made to trai 1 this item to the end of the agenda for further discussion. A motion was made at the time the item was reviewed at the end of the agenda to approve Resolution No. 1419. .:? (4) Resolution No. 1420, PCD-5, Don Sharp - Porsche A motion was made to approve Resolution No.. 1420. (5) Resolution. No. 1407,' ZC-186 (A),. Ross Winton, e,t 31 , Commissioners Rombotis and Jose did not feel that the. information presented by staff sufficiently supported 'Finding No. 5 in the resolution. _. x" A motion was made to approve Resolution No. ,1407 .r: with the deletion of Finding No. 5. .. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS - None - ORAL COMMUNICATIONS Commissioner Jose r'equested that the City Engineer check the southwest corner of Elm and Monroe. The oleander bushes are blocking the view-of t.he traffic and causing a dangerous traffic 'situaJion. , -.. I aP 8 !' PRESENT +lOT I ON !YES lBSTA I N 40T 1 ON 4Y ES JOES \BSTA I N 10T I ON (YES 4BSTA IN IOT I ON \YES LBSTA I N 10T I ON \YES \BSTA I N 10T I ON \YES \BSTA I N 40T I ON 4YES 4BSTA I N I X X X X X x. X X - - X X X X X I( K K X X T - - X X X X X X X t- " .- X X X X K K X K X - - X X X X i X X X I CITY OF 3ARLSBAD Page 2 PLANNING COMMISSION MEET NOVEMBER 9,1977 ./ ' . I NG PUBL I C HEAR I NGS (New) (1) Case No. CUP-144, City. of Car1sbad"t.-Request for approv to erect a building with broadcast tower for public use on property generally located on the east side of El Camino Real between Palomar Airport Road and Tamarack extended - 300 feet north of Squires Dam. Y Mr. Bud Plender, Assistant Planning Director, gave the staff presentation. He stated the staff report is correct .in.that the City of Carlsbad is the applicant. The agenda ind.icating the Carlsbad Municipal Water District as applican i s incorrect. The Public Hearing was closed at 7:30 P.M. A motion was made to approve CUP-144 based on the findings and subject to the conditions presented in the staff report. Resolution NO. 1422. Commission Rombot.is asked if there was any examination of comp?iance of the conditional use permit. Mr.,Plender sa'id it.was not considered necessary but if there were any complaints it could be reopened for review. 1 of (2) 'Case No. CUP-145, Bruce -Smith - Request for approva a greenhouse in the PC zone on property generally , located on the west side of El Camino Real north of , Batiquitos Lagoon and south of Arena1 Road. jj+ Mr. Bud Plender gave the staff ~reoort. Commissioner L'Heureux suggested that the word ''terminate" would be a better herin. for the word "void" - last . ' word of Condition No. 3. Commissioner Larson was concerned that Condition No. 3 , does not clearly state the intent of staff. ,. ,iq There was a general discussion by the Commi ss ioners regardir pesticides, 'fertilizers and runoff of the ground water.. Mr. Bruce Smith, '1318 Beljeview, Cardiff," appl icant, stated that he planned ,to raise some flowers but would have ' mostly.trees. He explained that there would be a poly- thylene covering of the greenhouse as well as the green covering stipulated in the conditions. - The pubi ic hearing .. closed at 7:45#..M. .cA motion was made to approve CUP-145 based on the findings ..and subject to the conditions as stated in the staff report.with the following correctionsi Condition No: 3 - . Corrected to read:that at the end of the first five year period the applicant may submit a letter to t'he Planning Commission requesting extension for an additional five year period; that the Commission will reyiew the CUP and the conditions and may extend it for additional five year . - periods based on such terms and conditions that they may desire. The la,st word of the condition "void" is to be ,' changed to "terminate." Changes in Condition No. 5: Adapesticide and that the ground water run off will be to the Satisfaction of the Cit) Engi neer. Resolution No. 1423. I HOT I ON YES . * *: 1 MOT I ON AYES X Y X !I , -CITY OF ':ARLSBAD PAGE 3 NOVEMBER 9, 1977 'PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING NEW BUSINESS r (3) Case No. CUP-140, H. W. Butts. ' . __I A motion was made to receive the report as filed and staff was instructed to proceed with further inspections as outlined. (4) .Noise Complaint - Carlsbad Skateboard Park Mr. Bud Plender gave the staff presentation. Mr.- Ed Siege1 , 2805 Ocean .St., Carl sbad, Ma,nager:;of the Skateboard Park stated that they would not admit to making loud, bothersome noises but will do all that is possible to alleviate the problem if there is indeed a problem. Mr. Hans Ledri, currently living in Vista, owns the 20 acres adjacent- to the park stated he would soon be moving to the property in Carlsbad. He said he did not feel that the Skateboard Park Gas an asset to.the City of Carlsbad. When he purchased the property he was under the impresslon that the conditional use permit would-be valid for a .seven year period only. Mr. Ledti said the skateboar park did not bother him, but the noise must be toned down. Staff was instructed to send.Mr. Ledri a copy of the conditional use permit for the Raceway - Resolution No. ,749. A motion was made to di rect staff to work with the operator- to reduce noise created by the loud speakers and report back to the.Planning Commission in three months. ' y 15) Resolution of Intention 160, ZCA-91,City of Carlsbad Mr. Bud Plender said he would like to hear from the Commissioners on any questions or suggestions they had regar the zone code amendment which would be a public hearing item at the hovember 16, 1977 meeting. ,$ . The Commissioners discussed generally the following . topics: Setbacks and landscaping, uses,'positioning of' buildings on ajZ1 .appl icat-ions so as to.take advantage of solar energy conservati.on, objections to the small +parcel to the west which seemed to. be bringing "Car Country" to the wrong side of the freeway and the height of the . fence at six feet does not seem adequately to screen from pub1 ic view. The Commissioners requested a copy of the Car Country CCER's be sent to thelw'in the packet on November . 10, 1977. ., .r; . A motion was made to accept the Resolution of Intention and set the item before Public Hearing on November 16, 1977. At 8:40 P.M. the meeting was adjourned ro November 16, 1977. 4 -.__ I MOT I ON AYES MOT I ON AYES ABSTA I N ng 10T I ON IY ES * .. * " l- "-