HomeMy WebLinkAbout1982-08-25; Planning Commission; MinutesMINUTES
MDTING OF: PUDIK co•IS■IO■
August 25, 1982 DU'I or MEETING:
TINI or MEETING: 7:00 P.H.
PLACI OF MEETING: City Council Chambers
CALL TO ORDER
The •eting was called to order by Michael Holzmiller,
Secretary to the Planning co-ission, at 7:00 P.H.
IOLL CALL
Preaent -Harcua, Roabotia, Jose, and Rawlins.
Frieatedt arrived at 7:23 P.H.
Absent -Farrow, and Schlehuber.
Staff Members present were:
Bill Hofman, Principal Planner
Charles Gri-, Principal Planner
Richard Allen, City Engineer
Ex-Officio Members present were:
Michael Holzmiller, Land Use Planning Manager
Daniel Hentschke, Assistant City Attorney
Election of Chair-n pro tem
In the absence of Chairman Farrow and Vice-Chairman
Schlehuber, the co-ission elected co-iaaioner Harcus
to chair the meeting.
AG!IO)A ITEM COMMUNICATIONS
Michael Holzmiller indicated Staff received a letter from
Ji■ Haga-n, Research and Analysis, requesting that one of
the Co■■issioners repreaent the City at the Coastal
Coa■ission Hearing, to be held Friday, August 27, 1982 at
9:00 P.H., in Marina Del Rey, to present a position in
support of the Agua Hedionda Specific Plan.
The Co-iaaion agreed that Chairman Farrow ahould
repreaent the City at the Hearing. eo■.iaaioner Roabotis
was selected aa the alternate, in the event Chairman
Farrow was unable to attend.
ITDI our OF ORDER
11W PUBLIC H!AI.INGS
2. CT 82-6/PUD-40 AND CT 82-7/CP-2091 IAMAll -l) 115-
unit Tentative Tract Nap and Planned Unit
Developeent, located on the north aide of Park Drive;
and, 2) 46-unit Tentative Tract Hap and Condo■ini~•
Per■it on the aouth aide of Park Drive i-diately
aero•• fro■ the eztenaion of Neblina Drive.
Co■aiasioner Ro■botis indicated he would abatain on the
ite■, due to a conflict of interest.
The abstention of co-iaaioner Ro■botis created lack of a
quoru■•
eo■■iasioner Marcus inquired if anyone in the audience
was preaent to addre11 the ite■•
Harcua
Ro■botis
Joae
Rawlina
X
X X
X
X
I l
j
MINUTES
Aqu1t 25, 1982 Page 2
The Coi.iaaion recognized Mr. Joe Sandy, 2956 Roo1evelt,
Carl1bad, representing the applicant. Mr. Sandy requested
a continuance to the next regular meeting, due to the lack
of a quorum.
The Coi.iaaion continued the -tter to the meeting of
Septeaber 8, 1982.
COlffIRUED PUBLIC HEAllING
1. er 82-4/PUD-38. BIRTCHER BUSINESS CENTER -Request
for approval of a Tentative Subdivision Map and
Planned Unit Development to create 7 industrial lots
on the south aide of Palo-r Airport Road to the
ve1t of Palo-r Oaks Way in the P-M Zone.
With the aid of a tran1parency shoving the location of the
property, Bill Hof-n gave a staff report on the -tter.
Be referenced Condition No. 29 of the Resolution, and
indicated Staff ia reco-nding same be revised to read:
''Weat Oaks Way shall be modified by revising the 200
foot radius curve shown adjacent to lot 6 to a 300
foot radius miniaim, to the satisfaction of the City
Engineer."
Mr. Hofman indicated that a workable solution had been
reached regarding the alignment of the private street
through this property, the Aladray property, and the
Ukegava property.
co-i1aioner Marcus opened the public hearing at 7:15
P.H., and extended the invitation to speak.
The Comission recognized Mr. Bob Campbell, representing
the applicant. Be expressed agreement with the condition,
of approval, and indicated that they have arrived at a
workable 1olution for all property owner, involved.
Since no one el1e vi1hed to addre11 the -tter, the public
hearing va1 cloaed at 7:17 P.H.
The co-iaaion approved the Negative Declaration i11ued
by the Planning Director, and adopted the following
Re1olution approving er 82-4/PUD-38, baaed on the
finding• and 1ubject to the condition, contained therein;
with the reviaion to Condition No. 29 •• outlined by
Staff:
3.
USOLUTION NO. 1995, APPROVING A TENTATIVE
SUBDIVISION MAP ARD PLAMNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT TO
CHAT! 7 INDUSTRIAL LOTS AND 1 OPEN SPACE LOT ON
PllOP!RTY G!NIRALLY LOCATED ON TB! SOUTH SIDE OF
PALOMAR AIRPORT ROAD TO THE WEST OF PALOKAR OAKS
WAY.
er 82-20/PUD-17(C). GRANT -Requeat for• Tentative
Tract Nap and an ••nd•nt of• Planned Unit
Developaent for Lot 16 of• previoualy approved
indu1trial Planned Unit Development located on the
-•t aide of Avenida !ncina1, approxi-tely 600 feet
1outh of Cannon Road in the P-M Zone.
Bill Hof•n gave the 1taff report, with the aid of•
tran1parency 1hoving the location of the property.
Marcu1
Ro.bot ii
Joie
Ravlin1
Marcu1
Roabotil
Joie
Ravlin1
X
I X
X
X
X X
X
X
•
X
.
r l
MINUTES
Aqu1t 25, 1982 Page 3
Coaai11ioner Harcus opened the public hearing at 7:19
P.H., and extended the invitation to 1peak.
r 'I
The Co.aiaaion recognized Mr. Mylo Hau, representing the
applicant, who expre11ed villingne1a to respond to any
queation1.
Since no one else vi1hed to speak on the -tter,
Co.ai11ioner Marcua closed the public hearing at 7:20
P.H.
The Co-isaion adopted the f~llowing Resolution,
approving CT 82-20/PUD-17(C), baaed on the finding, and
aubject to the condition• contained therein:
4.
USOLUTION NO. 2004, APPROVING A TWO LOT TENTATIVE
TRACT MAP AND AN AMENDMENT OF A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED
PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT ON PROPERTY GENERALLY
LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF AVENIDA ENCINAS
APPROXIMATELY 600 FEET SOUTH OF CANHON ROAD.
ZC-262/CT 82-15/CP-212, ALICANTE HILLS -1) A Zone
Change from R-1-10,000 to RD~ and; 2) A 40-lot/493-
unit Tentative Tract Hap and Condominium Permit,
located on the aouth aide of Corte De La Viata
(Alfil Way), eaat of Alicante Road in La Costa.
With the a~d of a tranaparency 1howing the location of
the project, Bill Hof-n gave the staff report.
COMMISSIONER FRIESTEDT ARRIVED AT 7:23 P.H.
C~1aioner Harcus opened the public hearing at 7:24
P.H., and extended the invitation to 1peak.
The Coaa.~1aion recognized Hr. Ji■ Goff, repre1enting the
Daon Corporation and che applicant, 1241 Elm Avenue,
Carlabad. Mr. Goff outlined the -jor feature• of the
project, and reaponded to co-iaaion queationa regarding
aeparation of the hillaide unite and parking.
Co.aiaaioner Rollbotia expreaaed diaaatiafaction regarding
the iaaue of aeparation of the hillaide unite, and their
vilual iapact.
In re1ponae to co-iaaion query regarding the condition•
of approval, Hr. Goff indicated that they received a
letter fro■ the Coata Real Municipal Water Di1trict
(CINWD), and the current condition ia aatiafactory a1 far
aa the applicant ia concerned. Be concluded by indicating
that the applicant ia in aaree-nt vith all other
condition,, and requeated approval of the project.
f'be C~iaaion recognised a reaident of Alti•-Way. She
co-■-nted that ahe ia happy that the project will have
recreational facilitiea in exceaa of what ia required, and
ezpreaaed concern regarding the a_,unt of traffic that
will be aenarated by the project. She further expreaaed
concern with reaard to circulation, and 1tated her opinion
that the project 1hould not be approved until further
atudy ia done on the circulation iaaue. She c~nted
that with the li■ited acce1• in and out of the project,
fire reaponae i• down to a nil, and requeated the -tter
be tabled to allow conaideration of •a-.
Harcua
Ro■botis
Joie
Ravlina
I
I
X X
I
·-... ·
MINUTES
Augu1t 25, 1982 Page 4
Richard Allen reaponded that a condition baa been placed
on the final -P that require■ the developer to bond and
1ubtdt improvement pl1na for the widening of Alga Road
where it ia nov tvo lanea, to be conatructed to four
lane11 prior to the occupancy of unit 101.
Mr, Allen continued that the City baa bonda and
iaprove-nt plane, and the extenaion of Alga Road to the
ea1t. and Melroae from Alga to Rancho Santa Fe Road ia
currently half under conatruction. He added that the Daon
Corporation will be proceeding within the next aix month ■
to a year to put Alga through ao there will be another
acce11 out to the eaat. He indicated that a condition
could be added to thia project, requiring that the road be
coapleted before thia project could have any occupancy.
Since no one elae viahed to ■peak on the matter, the
public hearing vaa closed at 7:58 P.M.
Ccn.i.aaion diacuaaion related to the capacity of Alga
Road vith regard to traffic and circulation.
Coaaiaaioner Ravlina expreaaed concern with regard to the
height of the project. He believed the building■
exceeded the 35' height limit.
Staff indicated that the project could not be built if it
did not meet the height limit.
The Comiaaion approved the Conditional Negative
Decl•ration iaaued by the Land Uae Planning Manager, and
adopted the following Reaolutiona, reco-nding approval
of ZC-262/CT 82-15/CP-212 to the City Council, baaed on
the finding■ and aubject to the condition■ contained in
the ataff report :
s.
RESOLITJ'ION NO. 2013, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF A 40
I.OJ' TENTATIVE TRACT MAP AND A 490 UNIT CONDOMINIUM
PERMIT ON PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE SOITJ'H
SIDE OF CORTE DE LA VISTA, EAST OF ALICANTE ROAD.
USOLITJ'ION NO. 2014, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF A ZONE
CRAiiGE FROM R-1-10,000 TO RD-MON PROPERTY GENERALLY
LOCATED ON THE SOITJ'H SIDE OF CORTE DE LA VISTA, EAST
OF ALICANTE ROAD.
CT 82-16/CP-213 TREETOPS UNLIMITED (VILLAGE J) -
leque1t for a l~-lot/222-unit Tentative Tract Map
and Condoainiua Perait in Village J of the Calavera
Hilla Maater Plan, located approxiaately 1000 feet
northveat of the eaaterly terainua of Taaarack
Avenue in the P-C Zone.
With the aid of a tranaparency ahoving the location of
tbe property, Bill Hofaan gave the ataff report.
Co_i,1ioner Marcua opened the public hearing at 8:03
P.N., and extended the invi tation to ■peak.
Tbe co-i11ion recognized Mr. Gary Watta, Project Manager
repreaentina Pacific Scene, 3900 Harney Street, San Diego.
Nr, Watt• expreaaed villingneaa to reapond to any
que1tion1.
Since no one elae vi ahed to apeak on the aatter, the
public hearina vaa cloaed at 8:04 P.H.
Marcua X
Rombotia I
Joae X X
R-lina I
Frieatedt I
MINUTES
Aquet 25, 1982 Page 5
The C~ission approved the Negative Declaration ieeued
by the Land Use Planning Manager and adopted the
following Resolution, reco-nding approval of CT 82-
16/CP-213 to the City Council, baeed on the finding• and
eubject to the condition• contained therein:
USOLUTION NO. 2008, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF A 15
Uff/222 UNIT TENTATIVE TRACT MAP AND CONDOMINIUM
PIRMIT ON PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED TO THE
IORTHWEST OF THE EASTERLY TERMINUS OF TAMARACK
AVENUE.
6. ZCA-147, CITY OF CARLSBAD (DRUG PARAPHERNALIA
ORDINANCE).
Co-ieeioner Marcus inquired if anyone in the audience was
preeent to address Item No. 6, and received no response.
THI COMMISSION TRAILED ITEM 6 TO THE END OF THE MEET ING.
GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENTS
7. GPA-62(B)/MP-149(J), DAON CORPORATION -Request to
aaend the Land Use Element of the General Plan and
the La Costa Master Plan from Travel Service (TS) to
Community Co-rcial (C) on property located on the
eouthvest corner of Rancho Santa Fe Road and Mision
Eetancia.
With the aid of a traneparency shoving the location of
the property, Charles Gri-gave the staff report,
indicating that Staff is proposing to add a condition to
the Maeter Plan text to require a Site Development Plan.
co-ieeioner Harcu• opened the public hearing at 8:10
P.M., and extended the invitation to speak.
The co-iesion recognized Mr. Jim Goff, representing the
Daon Corporation, 1241 Elm Avenue, Carlsbad. Re indicated
that Staff ha• adequately addressed the applicant's
concerns, and urged approval of t~e amendaent.
Since no one el•e viehed to addrees the matter, the public
bearing va• cloeed at 8:11 P.M.
The co-ieeion approved the Negative Declaration iesued
by the Land Uee Planning Manager, and adopted the
following Reeolutione, reco-nding approval of GPA-62(B),
and NP-149(J) to the City Council, baeed on the finding•
contained in the etaff report:
USOLUTION NO. 2010, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL or AN
liiiibiiilff TO TRI UND OSI ELEKINT or THE GENERAL
PLAN PROM TRAVIL SERVICE (TS) TO COMMUNITY
cottmRCIAL FOR PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED AT THE
INTIRSICTION or FUTUU MISION ESTANCIA AND RANCHO
SANTA n ROAD.
USOLUTION NO. 2011, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF AN Dtiibiiiif TO TBI U COSTA MASTER PLAN TO REVISE THE
LAND OSI PLAN or LA COSTA SOUTHEAST (TRAVEL SERVICE
TO COIMUIITY COMMERCIAL Sl-17) AND TO MAU MINOR
ADHUtlSTRATIVE CHANGES TO THI MASTER PLAN nrr AND
MAPS ON PIOPDTY GINIRALLY LOCATED AT THE
IlfflRSICTION or RANCHO SANTA Fl ROAD AND FUTURE
MISION ESTANCIA.
Marcue
Ra.both
Joee
Rav line
Frieet ?dt
Marcue
ROllbotie
Joee
Ravlin"
Frieetedt
I
X X
X
X
X
X
I
I I
I
I
MINUTES
Augu1t 25, 1982 Page 6
8. IIR 81-9/GPA-62(A), HUNTINGTON BEACH COMPANY -
Requeat to amend the Land U1e Element of the General
Plan from Non-Reaidential Reaerve to Planned
Induatrial.
With the aid of a tran1parency ahowing the location of
the property, Charle• Gri11111 gave a ataff report on the
.. tter.
Coa.i11ioner Harcua opened the public hearing at 8:16
P.H., and extended the invitation to apeak.
The Coaaiasion recognized Hr. Bob Ladwig, Rick
Engineering, 3088 Pio Pico, Carlabad. Hr. Ladwig urged
approval of the project, and expre11ed willingness to
re1pond to any question,.
The Co-iasion recognized Hr. Don Agatep, 2956 Rooaevelt,
Carl1bad, repreaenting the Ultegawa and Kelly properties to
the 1outh of the Huntington project. He indicated that
their concerns were with ceapect to circulation, and that
ju1t review be given to two -jor de,,1.:.-ttiona that have
occurred; Hacario to the we1t and Laurel Tree Lane to the
eaat. He added that any connection to College and Palomar
Airport Road should take into conaideration the existence
of tho1e two roads.
Hr. Ladwig expre18ed agreement with Mr. Agat~p, and
indicated that the owner was not co11111ittal ; however, same
could be addressed during the design phase.
Since no one else wiahed to apeak on the matter,
co-i11ioner Harcua cloaed the public hearing at 8:20
P.H.
The Co11111i11ion adopted the following Resolution:
RESOLUTION NO. 2003, RECO..mNDING CERTIFICATION OF
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT (EIR 81-9) FOR A PROJECT
INCLUDING ANNEXATION AND A GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT
FOR 110 ACRES GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF
PALOMAR AIRPORT ROAD APPROXIMATELY l HILE EAST OF
INTERSTATE 5.
The Co-i11ion adopted the following Reaolution:
RESOLUTION NO. 2002, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF AN
lMiiibHENT TO TR! LAND USE EL!HEMT OF THE GENERAL
PI.AR FROM NON-USID!NTIAL RESERVE (NRR) TO PLANNED
INDUSTRIAL (PI) ON PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE
NORTH SID! OP PALOHAlt AIRPORT ROAD APPROXIMATELY ONE
MIL! EAST OP INTERSTATE 5.
UCISS
Co.ai.11ioner Marcu1 called a rece11 at 8:29 P.H., and the
Co.ai11ion reconvened at 8:38 P.H., with five aeaibera
prHent.
Marcua X
Rombotia X X
Jose X
Rawlin1 X
Frieatedt X
Marcua l[
Roabotia X l[
Joae X
R-lin1 X
Frieatedt X
MINUTES
Auguat 25, 1982 Page 7
9. GPA-62(E). WERSCHING -Requeat to aaend the Land Uae
Element of the General Plan froa Re1idential Lov-
Mediu■ Density (RLH) to C~nity-<:~rcial (C).
Qiarle1 Griami gave a brief report on the matter.
At the requeat of the applicant, the C01aiaaion continued
the -tter to the Novellber, 1982 General Plan Amendaent
Rearing.
10. GPA-62(C), CITY OF CAllLSBAD (RLH TO RH) -Request to
aaend the Land U1e Eleaent of the General Plan from
Reaidential Low-Medium Denaity (RLH) to Residential
Hediu■ Denaity (RH).
With the aid of a tran1parency shoving the location of
t',e project, Charles Gri-gave the staff report. He
ceferenced page 2 of the Resolution, Finding No. 3(b),
regarding the public facilities fee, and indicated that
Staff is reco-ending deletion of same.
Ca-iaaion diacuasion related to consistency in grading
of projects.
Ca-iasioner Harcus opened the public hearing at 8:47
P.H., and extended the invitation to speak.
The co-isaion recognized Hr. Ed Waile, who expressed
agreeaent with the Staff report and conditions of
approval. He added that the grading issue is being
addreased, and they are working with Staff to resolve any
questions.
Since no one else wished to speak on the matter, the
public hearing was closed at 8:49 P.H.
The Coaai1aion approved the Negative Declaration issued
by the Land Use Planning Manager, and adopted the
following Reaolution, reco-nding approval of GPA-62(C),
baaed on the findings contained in the staff report:
6.
RESOLtrrION NO. 2009, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF AN
AMENDMElff TO THE I.OD USE ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL
PLAN FROM RESIDENTIAL LOW-MEDIUM (RLM) DENSITY TO
RESIDENTIAL MEDIUM DINSITY (RH) ON PROPERTY
GENERALLY LOCATED 500 FEET WEST OF EL CAMINO REAL
NORTH OF ALGA ROAD.
ZCA-1471 CITY OF CARLSBAD (DRUG PARAPHERNALIA
oibIICANC!) -An a-ndaent to the Zoning Ordinance
requiring a Conditional Use Per■it for drug
paraphernalia atorea.
Michael Hols■iller, Land Use Planning Manager, gave a
brief ataff report on the -tter.
Co.aiaaioner Marcua opened the public hearing at 8:52
P,N,, and eatended the invitation to speak. Since no one
viahed to apeak on the -tter, the public hearing vaa
cloHd,
-.
Marcua I
Ro■botia X I
Joae I
Ravlina I
Frieatedt I
Marcua X
Ro■botia X
Joae X X
Ravlina X
Frieatedt X
.
MINUTES
Auguat 25, 1982 Page 8
The Comniasion apprJved the Negative Declaration is1ued
by the Land Use Planning Manager, and adopted the
following Re1olution, recoDDending approval of ZCA-147 to
the City Council, based on the findings contained in the
staff report; with the amendment of the Findings, as
outlined by Staff:
R!SOLtn'ION K~. 2005, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF A ZONE
CODE AMENDMElff, AMENDING TITLE 21 OF THE CARLSBAD
MUNICIPAL CODE BY THE A~OITION OF SECTION
21.42.010(5)(BB) TO REGULATE THE LOCATION OF DRUG
PARAPHERNALIA STORES.
RESOLtrr IONS FOR ADOPT ION
11. Rf'r~Ltn'ION NO. 1996 -CT 82-11/PUD-44.
The Co11111ission adopted the following Resolution:
RESOLtn'ION NO. 1996, APPROVING AN 8-UNIT TElffATIVE
TRACT MAP AND PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMElff ON PROPERTY
GENERALLY LOCATED AT THE END OF LUCIERNAGA COURT
BETWEEN LUCIERNAGA STREET AND ARGONAtn'A STREET.
12. RESOLtn'ION NO. 2001 -CT 82-9/CP-ZlO.
The Conmission adopted the following Resolution:
RESOLtn'ION NO. 2001, APPROVING A 12-UNIT TENTATIVE
TRACT MAP AND CONDOMINIUM PERMIT ON PROPERTY
GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF LUCIERNAGA
STREET WEST OF URUBU STREET.
ADJOURNMElff
By proper motion, the meeting was adjourned at 9:00 P.H.
Respectfully Submitted:
MICHAEL J. HOLZMILL , Secretary
CARLSBAD PLANNING COMMISSION
Ann R. Alleman, Minutes Clerk
Marcus X
Romboti1 X
Jose X X
Rawlins X
Friestedt X
Marcus X
Rombotis X
Jose X X
Rawlins X
Friestedt X
Marcus X
Rombotis X X
Jose X
Rawlins X
Friestedt X