HomeMy WebLinkAbout1984-05-09; Planning Commission; MinutesMINUTES
MeetirY;J of:
Date of MeetirY;J:
~n«; CXMHSSICN
May 9, 1984
T iae of MeetirY;J: 7:00 p.m.
Pl&~ of Meeting: City O:>uncil l"hantlers
CALL'OO CRlER:
The MeetirY;J was called to ccdet" by Chairman Rontx>t is
at 7:01 p.m.
R>LL CALL:
Present: Cllairman Raltx>tis, Camlissioners
Rawl ins, Schlehuber, Sl!li th, Marcus,
and Farrow.
Absent: None.
PLmJGE CF AL,[B;;!NCE was led by Chairman Ramotis.
Staff Ment>ers Prese,1t:
Bill Bofman, Principal Planner
Mike Howes, Assistant Planner
Ex-officio Melrbers Present:
Mike HolZllliller, Land Use PlannirY;J Manager
Dan Hentschke, Assistant City Attorney
DaYe Hauser, Deputy City Engineer
Walter Brown, Developnent Engineer
Mike HolZllliller, Land Use PlannirY;J Manager, stated ZC
309, Aqua Hediooda Lagoon, had been withdrawn.
A Notiae of Intent ioo to re-zaie in that area that
had been paued by the PlanniBJ Caimissicn. The City
Council took actioo last weeJc that cancelled that
Notioe of Intentioo. Notices had been sent out for a
public hearirY;J tooight , however, and oow the item is
~irY;J withdrawn.
The Planning Caaissioo withdrew ZC-309 fran the
Agerm.
Nllf Alll.IC lmARDCS:
3. Cl' 8~275 -L.\ CDII'A RIVIERIA -Request to 00nlltruct:art8-wrlt cxini£ainl1.a1 project en a 1.31 acre
lot located m the north side of Navarra Drive between
Viejo C.tilla WIiy and the La Qleta Golf O:>urse.
Th.I Plavung Caaiaia'I <Dnt inued this item to May 23,
1914.
t . a,,-243 --BUD ~ -Rleqlle8t fer lll)l'UVal ol • ciiniUUc:inal uae perait to a! 1111
ditional pole llign 1n car Count ry at 5500 Paaec> del
llalte.
'1'be Plannlng Oollliuion withdrew this i tm fra11 the
A9lllda at tba ~t of the ,n>licant.
loltx>tis
Rawlins
Schlehuber
Smith
Marcus
Farrow
lalb>til!I
Ralina
Schlehuber
Slllith
Marcus
Farrow
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
I
X
X I
X
I
I
MINUTES
PINfiIN:; O'.llflUSSIOO Miy 9, 1984
OID BlEINFSS:
1. er 84-2/CP--270 -IA <Xln'A POINl'E -Approval of
doc:.unents.
The Planning Camrlssioo approved the following
Reeolutien, with the Mdition of Section (c) to
finding 1 as oontained in we nerorandum dated May 9,
1984, rran the Land use Planning Office to the Planning
Ccwrissien:
~IOl tO. 2265, DENYIN; A 48-uNIT TENI'ffl'IVE TRACT
MAP lH> ClHXNINitPI PERMIT 00 PRJPERI'Y c»IBRALLY I.£XM'ED
Ol 'mE t«)RI'BWESl' ~ OF AU::,/\ ION) AND EL FUERl'E
Sl'REEI'.
2. ZCA-169/ZC-293 -CITY OF CARI.SBAD -An amendment to
the zoning ordinance to inmrporate scenic rorrioor
studies into the scenic preservation overlay zone, to
place this zone en properties with frontage along El
CSllino Real, and to adopt •EI Cl"mino Real Developnent
staooaros•.
Bill Hofman, Principal Planner, gave the presentation as
contained in the staff report, Mding a sentence to page
10 at the end of Section 5 to indicate the action of the
Planning Ccmni.ssien lllly be appealed to the Ci ty Council;
l!d!ing a ~ion d to Section 7 on page 8, and
t..:>rrecting a typographical error.
Chairman Ra!tx>tis q:>ened tl.~ public hearing at 7:09 p.m.
and issued the invitatien to speak. Since oo coe wished
tc speak en this item, the p..iblic testim:x,y portion was
concluded.
The Planning Cannissien approved the Negative Declaratio.1
i ssued by the Land Use Planning Manager and adopted the
follcwing Resolutioos:
~IOl tO. 2232, RECDlmi:>INi APPRJVM, CF A~ O'.DE
:JMlilllir, »ia>OO TITLE 21 , CHAPl'ER 21 • 40 OF 'mE
CARLSMD ~CIPAL O'.DE, BY 'mE AIDITIOO OF SECI'ICNS
21 .40.010(5), 21.40.045, 32.40.115, ~ 21.40.117, TO
INCDRPaWrE OCffiIC CDRRIDOR sruorrn :rnro THE ocmrc
PRBSERVM'IOl C1JER1AY ~.
RBSCUJrIQI NO. 2233, ll«DlffN>INi APPRJ\TAL CF PLACDli THE
SCINIC ~MIOl ( S-P) OVERIAY ZCNE Ol AIL PRJPERl'Y
Wl'1'R PR:Rl'ltG! AUK; EL °'"1NO REAL.
Rl!SCUJ!'IQI ti>. 2234, ~:or; AOOPTIOl CF -rliE EL
CMDI) A!AL ~ IEVEURBNl' sr~• twl'ED
PB8IIJMY 8, 1984.
Staff wa <Xllplilnerlted for their work and presentation en
theeeatani:iards.
__ Pllll.IC IIEMil«:;61
3. Thia it• v• oontinued to May 23, 1984, earlier in
thia aetinJ.
PI.AllfDE CXJIUSSIQI PRX:JDJRE:
At thia point, Cllainan Rollbotie aued fer the Planning
ow-1uton l>rooa&Jre to be ahown m the overhead
pa,jectcr, ad he Mlted the ax!ience to apend a few
aimtM lffding the Prooe&Jre.
~tis X
Rawlins X
Schlehuber X X
smith X
Marcus X
Farrow X
ladx>tis X
Rawlins X
Schlehuber X
Smith X
Marcus X X
Farrow X
MINUTES
May 9 1984
4. er 83-9(A) -MA?O\NA -Request for an amendment to a
previously !R'roved 138-lot tentative tract map oo 194.3
acres located !R'roximately ate mile east of El Camino
Real at the eai1tern terminus of Sunny Creek !bad in the R-
E 2ICll1e.
Mike Bo,,"'('8, Assistant Planner, gave the presentatioo oo
this iten as rontained in the staff report, using a
transparency to sholo• the site and a wall map showing the
tentative map.
In answer to CCll'lftiss ioo query, staff stated the lots, as
they were previously divided, were in ronflict with the
SOOlE easement. With the new alignnents, the lots,
including the panhandle lots, were not d:>jectionable.
Chainnan Rattiotis q,ened the piblic hearing at
7: 14 p.m., and issued the invitatioo to speak.
Mr. Akbar Ghahremani, 18552 MacArthur Blvd., Irvine,
spcite as the !R'licant, stating all oonditioos were
acceptable, and urging the Planning cannissioo to
approve the !R'licatioo.
Sin<.• no ate else wished to speak oo this item, the
public testinony was roncluded at 7: 15 p. m.
The Planning Ccmni.ssioo adq:>ted the following
Resolutioo:
RJ!SOCtJl'ICW 00. 2291, ~DC APPR)IIAL FOR AN
MaU4EH1' TO A PRE.VIOOSLY APPRJVID TENl'M'IVE TRACT Mi\P
~ PRlPERl'Y <»mRA!LY I.Oan'ID }1(1' THE E'ASl'ERN TERMnuS
OF &Jtlff CREEi{ R:W) IN THE R-E 1.CWE.
5. ClJP-241 -CALI~IA FI:Rn' BANI( -Request for
approval of a cxiiHtiooal use permit for a drive-thru
bank facility at the southeast corner of Faraday Avenue
an5 El Cainino Real in the M-Q zooe.
Chainan Raltx>tis stated he would abstain frcrn discussioo
on this ite111. Vioe-<:hnirman Rawlins took over the
Chair fer Item ts.
Mike Bowes, Assistant Planner, gave the presentatioo oo
this item 11111 cu1tained in the staff report, using a
tranaparenc.y ehowing the site and a wall mp shc:Ming the
project.
Vioe-OMlinllill, Rawlins q>en; . .<l the plblic hearing at 7: 20
p.a., and iaaued the invitatioo to speak. Since ro me
wiahed to &peak at this item, the plblic testimony
partioo _. cloeed.
The PlainiB} ca.issioo an>t:Oll'f!d the Negative Declaratioo
i uued by the LaYJ ON Planning Manager and adopted the
followiB} Rnolutioor
Rl90Wl'l0f tD. 2288, APPR:1ID«; A CXH>rI'I~ USE P!a(l'l' ffl iu2ii A !IUVl-'l'RRJ MNlt P'ACILITY ~ 1. 3 M::HtS CF
W i CllilMILY UlCld'l!D ~ 'DIE s:xJfflBASl' ~ CF EL
CMill) 11W. NI> PMN»J AVIHJE.
Foltx>tis X
Rawlins X
Schlehuber X
smith X
Marcus X
Farrow X X
lalh>tis X
Rawlins X
Schlehuber X
Sllith X X
Mar'Cu8 X
Farrow X
MINUTES
P~ CXMUSSICN May 9, 1984 Page 4 1! ~l\ o~~~~
COMMISSIONERS ~ ~"" \
Chainnan Ra'l'botis resumed the Chair for the remainder of
the ireeting.
6. ZC-299 -SOIINJro~Il,l'.; -Request for a pre-
annexaticnal za,e ~t"an A-70 (County) to R-1-
7 ,500 for two parcels with a CDll'bined area of 19.97
acres located to the south of the southerly end of
Pontiac Drive.
MiJce Howes, Assistant Planner, gave the presentation en
this item as rontained in the staff report, using a
transparency to show the site.
Chairman Ralix>tis q:,ened the public hearing at 7:25 p.m.
and issued the invitatioo to speak. Since oo cne wished
to speak oo this item, the public testim::lny portioo was
closed.
The PlAMing Cawnissioo approved the Negative Declaratioo
issued by the Land Use Planning Manager arn MOpted the
following Resolutioo:
REOOWl'ICN N:>. 2287, ~:m:; APPFOVAL CF A
~~I<:NAL ZOIB OtW;E F10I A-70 (COONI'Y) TO R--1-
7 , 500 CN PIOPERl'Y <alERALLY u:x::M'ED s:XJl"H OF 'lliE s:XJl"HERLY
TEJllml.JS OF PCNI'I.AC DRIVE.
7. SP-19 (A) -CAR <XUn'RY -Request tc amend the
existing epe<-i fic plan en property located in the C-2
zme between Cannon Road and Palanar Airport Road.
Bill Hofman, Principal Planner, gave the presentatioo oo
this item as rontained in the staff report.
Chairmn Raltlotis q>ened the public hearing at 7:27 p.m.
and issued the invitatioo to speak.
Mr. Tall CAIVlOfl, Cannon , Associates, P. o. Box 3417,
Miasioo Viejo, addressed the camlissioo, inquiring about
tlle basic requirements in a C-2 zooe, Staff explained
theee reguin!altl\ta are rontained in the proposed specific
plan ae11d11ent. Mr. Cannon s tated he vas in bgr'eefflent
with the aaendllent.
Since no one else wished to speer. oo thia item, the
public t:eeti.Jlary wag roncluded at 7: 29 p. m.
The Planning ec..dssioo adopted the following Resolutioo:
RSSCUJl'I<Jt N:>. 2274, BDIU!H>Dl'.; APPIUJAL CF SPB::IFIC
PLMI 19 (A) , kii AN MlltDIBNr ro 'lliE EXlSl' IK; SPB::IFIC
PIM m R!DJLlll'B SIGNDl'.i CN PRPBRl'r camRALLY I.OCM'ED
llll'IIIIN <:Wi. ION> Ml> PAI£M\R AIRPCm' RW>.
8. CUP-245 -MB~E/MDI -Request &r ~ ol • an'I~ tto 110Ye an existing
pole aign and acid an actditicnal pole sign in Car Country
at 55-U Paeo del Norte.
Bill Bof.aln, Principal Planner , gave the preaentatioo oo
thia it.ea • oontained in the staff report, LBing a
tnnapanncy to llhow the propc:>eed sign locations,
pointing aut the exiating free-etanding sign.
IOrhotis X
Pawlins X X
Schlehuber X
Smith X
Marcus X
Farrow X
Jultx>tis X
Rawlins X
Schlehuber X X
Slldth X
Marcus X
Farrow X
@
MINUTES
~ 9, 1984 Page 5
Mr. Hofman stated cne additional rondition should be added
to the Resolution; that of !!ppt'O\Tal of the CUP subject to
approval of the specific plan a111endment 1:7f the City
Council.
Chait111an Raltx>tis opened the ?,lblic hearing at 7:33 p.m.
and issued the invitation to speak.
Mr. Tan Cannon, Cannon Associates, stated he was in
agreement with the specific plan dlange, and these signs
were in <Dll'lianoe ",i th the reoonmended dlange.
Since no cne else wished to speak en this item, the
public testi.Jn::lny was <Dncluded at 7:34 p.m.
The Planning Camiissioo adopted the following Resolution:
RESOWl'IOl 00 2272, APPRJIJll,I; A aH>rrrauu.. lEE PERMIT ro
~ AN HDrl'IOIAL PREESI'AN:>IN'.i POLE SIGN 01 PR:>PERl'Y
Gml!:RAILY I:OCJa'ID CN 'fflE &\Sr SIDE OF PASro DEL N:Rl.'E,
~., ~ (F C'A?H:N ~-
9. This item was withdrawn earlier in the meeting.
10. EIR 83-9 ZC-290 Cl' 83-25 -CAMIOO HILL.5 -Request
for ( Cert ,oat oo of an Env ronmental Inpact Rieport,
(2) a u:ne change to RMIP zooc, and (3) a tentativa tract
IMP and IEbile hane park permit for 112 lots oo 29 acres
located oo the west side of El Camino Real, iJl'lnediately
north of. CArlsbad Research Center.
Mr. Bill Hofman, Principal Planner, gave the presentation
as oontained in the staff report, using a transparency
showing the site.
In miawer to Cannissioo query, staff stated the airport
isaue had been fully addressed, with no significant
hpact to the project.
Mr. BofJllan used a wall mp to point oot the major
feeturee of the p:q,oeed project and stated there would
be separate ownership of the lots in the IIObilehaae park.
The ..-,,ea road, SliA)ery Hill Lane, was discussed, with
the eventual change into a wl~ being roted.
lfal.ter Brown, Develq:aent EB,Jineer, explained the three
~ of. a00N9 develqaent, with initial E.'i!rving of. the
project. froa Bl Calno Real, with a left tum to SliA)ery
Rill Lane. At a future date, either the Jl:oll property er
the f.elly Randi prq>erty developaent will provide access.
,._.. the eeoond acoeu, either fran Jl:oll Ot' l(elly, is
prwided, and tbe aedian is installed oo El Candn:l, there
will be a right tum in and out island installed. Mr.
BffM\ UNd a tranapu:ency to show the island to be
irwtalled. A right t!......tl'Tl in and out would be allowed,
.. in; the mngeetia, that NOUld occur at College. The
intanectim IIOUld be cloeer than allOlfed for priaary
uuriw, float t:he tiae the aeoond acoesa is
cnwuuot:.ed, a a.u-de-eac would be oonstructed oo
Slippery Bill Lane.
Ramotis X
Rawlins X
Schlehuber X
Sllith X X
Marcus X
Farrow X
@
MINUTES
PLMIUK; CDIUSSICN May 9, 1984 Page 6
1:.1ill Hofman called the Cannission's attention to the
lllelll>randurn fn,n Land Use Planning Office dated May 9,
1984, giving the revisions to the conditions for this
item. These conditions should be included in the
Reeolut ion.
In answer to CCIIIIUssion query, staff stated the condition
regarding foundations ooly applies to ruildings that
would have foundations, euch ae a recreation roan. In
reply to a (JleStioo regarding the land slide area, staff
indicated to the Camrl.ssion, as conditioned, there would
be a soil engineer oo the job.
Chairman Rartx>tis opened the public hearing at 7:52 p.m.
and issued the invitatioo to speak.
Mr. Don Agatep, 2956 Roosevelt, addressed the Comnission
on behalf of the applicant, stating all ronditions were
acceptable with the exception of t:wo issues. Mr. Agatep
stated the airport owners suggested the prospective
owners be informed of the close proximity to the airport
and this be included in the CC&R's. Mr. Agatep felt the
conditioo regarding the oo parking signs in the private
driveways al page 9, Q:ndition 48, was vague and
suggested adding three words at the front: '"l'he
entrances to-•.
Mr. i-lofman stated this condition referred to private
•streets• and that parlting would be allowed oo cne side
of the street ooly.
Mr. Agatep questioned Condition 41, as to whether this
remainder (lllroel would not be a legal parcel until such
time as there is public access, and the Assistant City
Attorney stated this parcel was specifically designated
under the Subdivisioo Act.
Chait11111n Ralt>otis stated his ooncern about informing the
residents dboot the closing of Sliwery Rill Lane at a
future date. The Assistant City Attorney stated
Cmditioo 34 did not provide for this adequately and he
would provide staff with the appropriate language to
OOll'er this.
Mr. Art Anderson, 4961 Cindy Avenue, addressed the
ca.iuioo oo this ita, stating this pad: will be for
the City's benefit, with m rent squabbles. Be stated
there are m purchasers already than there ai-e lots
available. Mr. Anderaon asked for the c.amdssioo 's
-wtoval.
Since m one else wished to speak al this item, the
public tect::.ia:lny wu ooncluded at 8:05 p.m.
O':W!iu\oner Schlehuber stated he felt there l«lllld be a
aiailar miae il!pllC't a, College with the high ellhlnlanent
then. Mr. Bofaan stated there ia a bena that separates
the ad>J.lehcat pan fr:ca College, but this oould be an
adlted aonditioo.
MINUTES
May 9, 1984 Page 7
In an.'Nll!r to cannissioo query, the applicant stated
there ..ould be limits oo the types and age of
nobilehc,rnes, and they ..ould have to be approved.
The Planning Cannission adcpted the following
Reecl.utioos:
RESOWl'ICN NJ. 2294, RECOtmm:rt«; CERI'IFICM'ICN CF AN
milIRHl!Nl'AL IMP~ llEPCE', EIR 83-9, FOR A~
Gl!HERAILY n«:uJDTI«;: (1) A ZOlE CHA.N'.iE moil R-1-10,000 ro
RMtP (IID3ILE IDilE PARR ZOIB), and 2) A TENl'M'IVE TRACI'
MP NI) KEILE IDilE PA.RI{ PERMIT CN 29. 8 ACRES l.OCM'ID CN
THE lP.81' SIDE CF EL CAMIN'.> ~ IMMEDIM'ELY tURl'fl CF
CARLSIW) ~"F.A.ROf c»n'ER.
RES>UJI'ICN NJ. 2295, ~It«; A.PPRJlJA.L CF A ZOlE
CHMCB ~ R-1-10, 000 ro IMiP CN 29 ACRES CF PK>PERl'Y
Gl!NERA.LLY l.OCM'ID CN 'fflE WESI' SIDE OF EL CAMIN'.> ~
IfllElIJn'ELY N:E'FI OF CARLSBAD RESEA.Rrn c»n'ER.
RESOWl'ICN NJ. 2296, ~It«; A.PPRJlJA.L CF A TENl'ATIVE
TRACI' 19.P NI) l'03ILE !:DIE PA.RI{ PERMIT CN 29 ACRES
Gl!NERA.LLY l.OCM'ID CN 'fflE WESI' SIDE OF EL CA.MIN'.> ~
IfllElllft'ELY tDU'B CF CARLSBAD RESEA.Rrn CENl'ER.
Subject to additimal ronditions as suani tted by staff,
and a:nUtioos added tonight, regarding closing of
Slii:pery Rill Lane and rnise mitigation oo College
Boulevard.
AOO.fi'ICK\L BUSINESS:
Chairmn Raltlotis announced Cannissioner Lyttletoo had
resigned and asked the oonsensus of the Collnissioo for a
suitable date for a luncheon. Friday, May 18, 1984, was
selected as the tentative date.
By iroper mtioo, the meeting of May 9, 1984, was
adjourned at 8: 16 p.m.
Reepectfully a.ibnitted,
MI<EML J. lll!ll.DIJLYIR
Land ON Planning Manager
Harriett Babbitt
Miootee Clute
ial'DIJS Ml Ala:> 1'APl!D All> KEPI' CN FILE CM'IL 'fflE
MIIIJl'BB Ml APPIOll!D.
ID!tx>tis X
Rawlins X X
Schlehuber X
Smith X
Marcus X
Farrow X
lodx>tis X
Rawlins X X
Schlehuber i(
Smith X
Marcus X
Farrow X
6)