HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-05-10; Historic Preservation Commission; ; Properties of ConcernITEM #6
Meeting Date: May 10, 2021
To: Historic Preservation Commission
From: Suzanne Smithson, Library & Cultural Arts Director
Staff Contact: Suzanne Smithson, suzanne.smithson@carlsbadca.gov
Sheila Crosby, sheila.crosby@carlsbadca.gov
Subject: Properties of Concern
District: All
Recommended Action
Informational.
Executive Summary/Discussion
Commissioners may share and receive information about properties of concern in Carlsbad.
Properties which have been discussed recently include the Culver-Myers-Capp home, the
Marron Adobe, and the Magee House.
As this is the first meeting for two new commissioners, it is worthwhile to discuss the context of
the various lists of properties with the new commissioners
Next Steps
Based on discussion.
Fiscal Analysis
No fiscal impact.
Public Notification
Public notice of this item was posted in keeping with the Ralph M. Brown Act and was available
for public viewing and review at least 72 hours before the scheduled meeting date.
Exhibits
1. Historic Properties in Carlsbad
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
February 23, 2021
Property Name Address CC Action Plaque Tour 1980 List 1984 List 1986 List 1990 HRI 2004 List 2010 List
Alt Karlsbad/Frazier's Well 2802 Carlsbad Blvd.X X X X X X X X
Army Navy Academy/Red Apple Inn 2605 Carlsbad Blvd. X X X X X X X X
Barrio "Heart of the Barrio"Walnut Ave. & Roosevelt St.X X
Barrio Museum 3304 Roosevelt St.X X X X
Beller House/Deckleman House 1448 Forest Ave.X X X X X X
Calavera Lake & Dam Lake Calavera X X X
Calavera School Site Calavera Hills Community Park X X X X
Carlsbad Springs Mineral Springs Hotel 2855 Carlsbad Blvd.X X X X X X
Carlsbad School District Office/Pine Street School Pine Ave. & Harding St.X X
Carlsbad Theater 2822 State St.X X X X X
Carlsbad Union Church 800 Pine Ave.X X X X
Carrillo Ranch 6200 Flying Leo Carrillo Ln.X X X X X
Cohn House 3003 Carlsbad Blvd.X X X X X X X
Culver-Myers-Capp House 3140 Highland Dr.X X X X X X X X
El Camino Real Bell State St. & Grand Ave.X
Gage House 3080 Lincoln St.X X X X X X X X X
Gaus House 3442 Roosevelt St.X X X X X X X X
Highland Bungalows 3264 Highland Dr.X X X
Highway 101 Highway 101 X X
Hosp Grove 2240 Jefferson St.X
Kelly Barn El Camino Real X X X X
Killian Building 2900 block of State St.X X X X X X X
Kreutzkamp House 624 Laguna Dr.X X X X X X
Ledgerwood House 3862 Carlsbad Blvd. X X X
Los Diego Hotel 2907 State St.X X X X X
Magee House 258 Beech St.X X X X X X X X
Mission Santiago 3329 Roosevelt St.X X X X
Ramirez Bungalow 3309 Roosevelt St.X X X X
Ramsay House 1330 Chuparosa Way X X X X X X X
Rancho Agua Hedionda Adobe/Marron Adobe 2770 Sunny Creek Rd.X X X X X X
Santa Fe Depot 400 Carlsbad Village Dr.X X X X X X X X
Shaw House 3081 Highland Dr.X X X X X X
Shipley Ward House 2747 Carlsbad Blvd.X X X X
Shirley House (Rancho de la Motte-Kirmse-Shirley)1542 Oak St.X X X X X X
South Coast Land Company 2958 State St.X X X X X X X
Stagecoach Stop El Camino Real X X
St. Michael's Episcopal Church 2775 Carlsbad Blvd.X X X X X X X X
St. Patrick's Church/Heritage Hall 2650 Garfield St.X X X X X X
Twin Inns/Schutte House 2978 Carlsbad Blvd.X X X X X X X
Twin Inns Gazebo Magee Park X
Twin Inns Granary Magee Park X
"Historic" Properties in Carlsbad
Properties designated historic by City Council, marked with a plaque and/or appear in Historic Carlsbad: A Self-Guided Tour
ITEM #6
Also known as 1980 List
Royal Palms Motel Beach and Tennis Club
(Alfred Cohen [Cohn] House) (1927)3001 [3003] Carlsbad Blvd.
Myer[s] House
(Culver House) [Capp House]3140 Highland Anderson Cottages (c.1940)3044 State St.
Santa Fe Depot (1887)
(Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway Depot)1200 Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]
Magee House (1887)
(Samuel Church Smith House)258 Beech Apex Hotel (c.1920)3200-3206 Carlsbad Blvd.
Carlsbad Mineral Springs Hotel
(Carlsbad-by-the-Sea) (1929)2855 Carlsbad Blvd.
Rancho de la Motte Kirmse (1886)
(Shirley House)1542 Oak
Army and Navy Academy (1936)
San Diego Army and Navy Academy
(Red Apple Inn)
Luther Gage House (1930)3080 Lincoln
St. Michael's by-the-Sea Chapel (1894)
St. Michael's Episcopal Church 2775 Carlsbad Blvd.Carlsbad Civic Center (1967)1200 Elm [Carlsbad Village Dr.]Rancho Agua Hedionda Adobe (1842)
(Juan Marron Adobe)2770 Sunny Creek Rd.Six Twenty Four Laguna (Kreutzkamp House)626 [624] Laguna Killian Block Commercial Buildings (c.1920's)2900 Block-State St.Twin Inns (1886)
(Schutte House)2978 Carlsbad Blvd.Deckleman Residence (1894)1448 Forest Ave.
John A. Frazier Well (1883) and
Alt Karlsbad (1965)2802 Carlsbad Blvd.
Gaus House (1922)3162 Jefferson
Greenwood House (1935-40)1166 Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]
Hess House (1889)3048 Jefferson
Hill Cottage (possibly c. 1910)3112 Lincoln
Vermilyea House (c.1925)
Killian House 645 Grand
Frank Knowles House (c.1899)380 CedarOcean Vista Cabins
(Ocean Vista Motel) (c.1920)2005 North Highway 101
Pebble House 3839 Garfield
St. Patrick's Catholic Church (1926)3075 Harding
Ramsay House (c.1890)1330 ChuparosaSchindler House (1927)
(Clark Shaw House)3081 HighlandCarlsbad Union Church
(Old Carlsbad Union church) (1925)800 PineMagee Gardens (1887)
(Colonel Ward House)
(Alexander Shipley House)2747 Carlsbad Blvd.
Young House (c. 1900)352 Cedar
Wright House (c.1888)1088 Laguna
The resource containing this list is available in the Carlsbad History Collection at Georgina Cole Library, call number: 979.498 COM V.1
http://www.carlsbadhistoricalsociety.com/Carlsbad%20Historical%20Society_files/historical/Regionl%20Historic%20Preservation%20Study%20Carlsbad%201980.pdf
Note: Library staff added any text in square brackets [ ].
It is also available online on the Carlsbad Historical Society's website at:
"…a site which may have the potential to meet criteria for inclusion in the National
Register of Historic Places."
"…a site which has historic significance of local importance.""…a site which meets the established criteria for inclusion in the Pilot Area Survey but
which is not considered a prime candidate for preservation."
Regional Historic Resources Inventory: Pilot Area Survey, Carlsbad, California
WESTEC Services, Inc. April, 1980
Site Ranking 1 Site Ranking 2 Site Ranking 3
Also known as 1984 List
1 Alt Karlsbad and John A. Frazier Well 2802 Carlsbad Blvd.
2 Anderson Cottages 3044 State St.
3 Army Navy Academy 2585 Carlsbad Blvd.
4 Carlsbad-by-the-Sea (Carlsbad Mineral Springs Hotel)2855 Carlsbad Blvd.
5 Carlsbad Civic Center 1200 Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]
6 Carlsbad Union Church 800 Pine Ave.
7 Deckleman Residence (Beller House)1448 Forest
8 Luther Gage House 3080 Lincoln
9 Gaus House 3162 Jefferson St.
10 Greenwood House 1166 Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]
11 Hess House 3048 Jefferson St.
12 Hill Cottage 3112 Lincoln
13 Killian Commercial District 2900 block State St.
14 Frank Knowles House 380 Cedar [Christiansen]
15 Magee Gardens (Ward/Shipley House)2747 Carlsbad Blvd.
16 Magee House (Samuel Church Smith House)258 Cedar [Beech]
17 Myer[s] House (Culver House) [Capp House]3140 Highland Dr.
18 "Pebble House"3839 Garfield St.
19 Ramsay House 1330 Chaparosa [sic] Way
20 Rancho Agua Hedionda (Juan Marron Adobe)2770 Sunny Creek Rd.
21 Rancho de la Motte Kirmse (Shirley House)1542 Oak Ave.
22 Alfred Cohen [Cohn] House 3001 Carlsbad Blvd.
23 St. Michael's by the Sea Chapel 2775 Carlsbad Blvd.
24 St. Patrick's Catholic Church 3075 Harding St.
25 Santa Fe Depot Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]
26 Schindler Residence (Clark Shaw House)3081 Highland Dr.
27 Six Twenty Four Laguna (Kreutzkamp House)624 Laguna Dr.
28 Twin Inns (Schutte House)2978 Carlsbad Blvd.
29 Vermilyea House (Killian House)2906 Roosevelt St.
30 Young House 352 Cedar [Christiansen]
Inventory of Structures
"Exhibit A"
Included in memo from Martin Orenyak, Director of Building and Planning
September 5, 1984
"Permits for alteration, demolition, repair, or removal of structure on this property need prior approval of the City's
Historical Preservation Committee."
This memo is available online in the City of Carlsbad e-records database at:
https://records.carlsbadca.gov/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=4658880&dbid=0&repo=CityofCarlsbad&searchid=4d3b6a71-
c1db-469c-b7f6-6ed0c287a814
Also known as 1986 List
1 Rancho Agua Hedionda Hacienda 2270 Sunny Creek Rd.1 Knowles-Craig House 380 Christiansen Way 1 Hill House-Sea Witch 3132 Lincoln St.
2 Carrillo Ranch 2 Shipley-Ward House 2747 Carlsbad Blvd.2 Clauson House-Landry Office 2921 Roosevelt St.
3 Smith-Shipley-Magee House 258 Beech Ave.3 Kreutzkamp House 624 Laguna Dr.3 Beller-Deckleman House 1448 Forest Ave.
4 St. Michael's Episcopal Church 2775 Carlsbad Blvd. 4 Hess House 3048 Jefferson St.4 Cottage 1101 Knowles Ave.
5 Frazier's Well-Alt Karlsbad 2802 Carlsbad Blvd.5 Shirley-de la Motte-Kirmse House 1542 Oak Ave.5 Carlsbad Bank-Music Store 505 Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]
6 Schutte House-Twin Inns 2878 Carlsbad Blvd.6 William S. Kelly Home east of El Camino Real 6 Ramsay Building 2998 State St.
7 Santa Fe Depot-Chamber of Commerce 400 Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]7 Young House 352 Christiansen Way 7 Killian Conkey Building 2971 State St.
8 Culver-Myers-Caps House 3140 Highland Dr.8 Red Apple Inn-Army/Navy Academy 2585 Carlsbad Blvd.8 Los Diego Hotel 2901 State St.
9 Calavera School Site east end of Tamarack (Calavera Park)9 St. Patrick's Catholic Church-Heritage Hall 2650 Garfield 9 Casa Blanca Boarding House 2685 State St.
10 Ramsay House 1330 Chuparosa Way 10 Carlsbad Hotel 2855 Carlsbad Blvd.10 Bungalows-Shops 2633-39 State St.
11 Bungalow 3309 Roosevelt St. 11 Carlsbad Theater 2822 State St.11 Cohn Houses-Fidel's Restaurant 3001 Carlsbad Blvd.
12 James Kelly Home Sunny Creek Rd.12 Mission-Style House 1138 Knowles Ave.12 Moorish Style Bungalow 138 Chestnut Ave.
13 Kelly Barn El Camino Real 13 Bungalow 3379 Roosevelt St.13 Recent Spanish style renovations 1274 Chestnut Ave.
14 Hart Real Estate Office [South Coast Land Company]2950 [sic] State St.14 Ledgerwood House and Seed Store 3862 Carlsbad Blvd.14 Greenwood House 1166 Elm Ave. [Carlsbad Village Dr.]
15 Carlsbad School 201 Pine Ave.15 Spanish-style Bungalow 1098 Magnolia Ave.15 Pebble House 3839 Garfield St.
16 Carlsbad Union Church 800 Pine Ave.16 Ingram-Swab House 3640 Adams St.16 Tootsie K Ranch Sunny Creek Rd.
17 Gage House 3080 Lincoln St.17 Recent Spanish-style Renovations 3384 Highland Dr.
18 Bungalow 3265 Highland Dr.18 Vermilyea House 2906 Roosevelt St.
19 Shaw-Shindler House 3801 Highland Dr.19 Severino House Between Magnolia and Park
20 Anderson Cottages 3044 State St.
21 Gaus House 3162 Jefferson St.
22 Cerro de La Calavera (Skull Hill)1930s street paving rock
23 Calavera Lake and Dam
24 Little Encinas Oak Grove (water source)east of El Camino Real
25 Water sources Sunny Creek Rd. (Archeological)
Note: At the September 14, 1987 Meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission, the Stagecoach Stop was added to the A list and El Camino Real was added to the C list. Library staff added any text in square brackets [ ].
This list is available online in the City of Carlsbad e-records database at:
City of Carlsbad
Historic SitesRevised July 1986LIST A LIST B LIST C
https://records.carlsbadca.gov/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=5159592&dbid=0&repo=CityofCarlsbad&searchid=9c5bfb6a-d54e-4097-94f9-21b8e637b61f
Also known as 1990 List
1990
All five volumes are available online in the Carlsbad City Library catalog at:
City Council Resolution 93-151 is available online in the City of Carlsbad e-records database at:
https://cbcl.sdp.sirsi.net/client/en_US/historyroom/search/detailnonmodal/ent:$002f$002fSD_ASSET$002f0$002f1381/ada?qu=historic+resources+inventory
Historic Resources Inventory: supplement to City of Carlsbad cultural resources survey
In 1990, Roth and Associates were hired to complete a survey of sites with potential historic significance in Carlsbad. The resulting 5-volume report is now housed
in the Genealogy & Carlsbad History section at the Georgina Cole Library. This survey was adopted by City Council as the Historic Resources Inventory in 1991. In
1993, City Council “deleted” the Inventory and stipulated inclusion on any historic listing be voluntary (City Council Resolution 93-151). The Historic Resources
Inventory has been retained in the Library’s Carlsbad History Collection as a valuable reference source for historic information about the properties included in the
survey.
Vol. 1 covers Adams through Date
Vol. 2 covers El Camino Real through Highland
Vol. 3 covers Jefferson through Madison
Vol. 4 covers Magnolia through Spruce
Vol. 5 covers State through Wilson and Other Resources
https://records.carlsbadca.gov/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=4814601&dbid=0&repo=CityofCarlsbad
Also known as 2004 List
HPC Plaque installed?
1 Red Apple Inn/Army Navy Academy 2585 Carlsbad Blvd.circa 5/2009
2 Cohn House/Fidel's Norte 3003 Carlsbad Blvd.
3 Gage House/Monterey Condominiums 3080 Lincoln has plaque from 1966, not from HPC
4 South Coast Land Company/Garcia's Barbershop 2956 State St.circa 5/2009
5 Los Diego Hotel/Caldo Pomodoro Restaurant 2907 State St.
6 Barrio Museum 3304 Roosevelt St. circa summer 2009 at Heart of the Barrio (Lola's Market)
7 Mission Santiago 3329 Roosevelt St.
8 Killian Building 2900 State St.
9 Fire Station/CA Forestry Station Carlsbad Blvd.
Historic Preservation Commission
Recommendations for Future Plaques
12/28/2004
This list is available online in the City of Carlsbad e-records database at:
Note: Library staff added any text in square brackets [ ] and, where applicable, the dates plaques were installed.
https://records.carlsbadca.gov/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=4881152&dbid=0&repo=CityofCarlsbad&searchid=c91c532f-fc74-4910-92d8-6b90931af48c
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Also known as 2010 List
Descriptor used in Envision Carlsbad Address [Also Known As]
2978 Carlsbad Blvd.[Twin Inns/Schutte House]
400 Elm Ave. (Carlsbad Village Drive)[Old Santa Fe Train Depot/Santa Fe Depot]
3309 Roosevelt St.[Ramirez House]
3329 Roosevelt St.[Mission Santiago]
2770 Sunny Creek Rd.[Juan Maria Marron Adobe/Rancho Agua Hedionda Adobe]
El Camino Real
Kelly Barn [2770 Sunny Creek Rd.]
Haymar Road Adobe [Haymar Dr.][Sylvester Marron Adobe]
3080 Lincoln Street [Gage House/Monterey Condominiums]
2956 State Street [South Coast Land Company]
Rancho De Los Kiotes [6200 Flying Leo Carrillo Ln.][Leo Carrillo Ranch Historic Park]
Stage Coach Park [3420 Camino De Los Coches][Ybarra Adobe Ruins]
Magee House Magee Park, 258 Beech St.
Frazier's Well/Alt Karlsbad 2802 Carlsbad Blvd.
Carlsbad Village along Carlsbad Village Dr.
Old Carlsbad south of Buena Vista Lagoon, west of El Camino Real, north of Cannon Rd.
Barrio Neighborhood
St. Michael's Episcopal Church 2775 Carlsbad Blvd.
St. Patrick's Church (Heritage Hall)Magee Park, 2650 Garfield St.
Red Apple Inn/Army Navy Academy 2585 Carlsbad Blvd.
Carlsbad Mineral Springs Hotel/Carlsbad-by-the-Sea 2855 Carlsbad Blvd.
Cohn House/Norte 3003 Carlsbad Blvd.
Killian Building 2900 State St.
Los Diego Hotel/Caldo Pomodoro Restaurant 2907 State St.
Carlsbad Theatre 2822 State St.
Barrio Museum 3304 Roosevelt St.
Gaus House 3442 Roosevelt St.
Shaw House 3081 Highland Ave.[Schindler House]
Shirley House 1542 Oak St.[Rancho de la Motte-Kirmse-Shirley House]
Culver House 3140 Highland Dr.[Culver-Myers-Capp House]
Kreutzkamp House 624 Laguna Dr.
Beller House 1448 Forest Ave.[Deckleman House]
Ramsay House 1330 Chuparosa Way
https://www.carlsbadca.gov/civicax/filebank/blobdload.aspx?BlobID=23349
City of Carlsbad
Envision Carlsbad
Working Paper No. 4
Historic and Cultural Resources
published 2010
This list is available online in the City of Carlsbad website at:
Note: Library staff added any text in square brackets [ ] and any "also known as" information in the last column of the list.