Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-08-02; Traffic and Mobility Commission; ; Kelly Drive and Park Drive Complete Street Improvements, Capital Improvement Program Project No. 6075Item 3 Meeting Date: Aug. 2, 2021 To: Traffic and Mobility Commission Staff Contact: Brandon Miles, Associate Engineer Brandon.Miles@carlsbadca.gov, 760-602-2745 Subject: Kelly Drive and Park Drive Complete Street Improvements, Capital Improvement Program Project No. 6075 Recommended Action 1. Receive a presentation regarding the Kelly Drive and Park Drive Complete Street Improvements, Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Project No. 6075 (Project); 2. Receive input from the community; and 3. Provide input on the following project aspects: a. Alternatives for Kelly Drive including either Class II buffered bike lanes or a Class- IV two-way protected bikeway b. Intersection control alternatives at the intersection of Kelly Drive and Hillside Drive including either a roundabout or stop-controlled intersection with traffic calming features Background This Project proposes improvements to Kelly Drive and Park Drive including complete streets design features and to provide a connection from El Camino Real to the Agua Hedionda Lagoon for active transportation users as originally identified in the Carlsbad Comprehensive Active Transportation Strategy, or CATS, which was developed in coordination with the Trails Master Plan. The Project is aligned with the Carlsbad Community Vision Core Value 5: "Walking, Biking, Public Transportation and Connectivity" and the City Council goal to become a leader in multimodal transportation systems and creative approaches to moving people and goods through and within Carlsbad. As described in the CATS, the Project scope of work includes: • Reduced vehicle lane widths • Enhanced mobility for all modes of travel • Traffic calming • New and enhanced sidewalks and crosswalks • Reverse angle parking at Laguna Riviera Park • Consideration of traffic control alternatives at the intersections of Kelly Drive and Park Drive and Kelly Drive and Hillside Drive including modern roundabouts or side street stop control with traffic calming As part of the prior Project public outreach efforts, staff has received public input through online surveys, post card mailers and public meetings to guide the project development. Staff has also coordinated with the Carlsbad Police Department, Parent Teacher Association, Carlsbad Unified School District staff and local residents. Staff is seeking additional input from the Traffic and Mobility Commission and public on the proposed project improvements and alternatives as shown in the concept plans provided in Exhibit 2. Staff is evaluating two alternatives for traffic control at the intersection of Kelly Drive and Hillside Drive including either a calmed intersection with bulb-outs and side street stop control or a modern day roundabout with raised central island, splitter islands and channelization. Earlier project direction was supportive of an intersection with curb extensions and no additional intersection control at Kelly Drive and Hillside Drive. With the adoption of the Sustainable Mobility Plan, which includes guidelines to consider roundabouts when evaluating intersection controls in Chapter 5, page 106, the city will now complete an Intersection Control Evaluation study to determine if a roundabout is a feasible option for the intersection. In addition to the new city guidelines a roundabout at this location would also provide a more efficient transition for bicyclists traveling southbound on Kelly Drive through the intersection at Hillside Drive to the Class I pathway south of Park Drive and would improve the consistency of intersection controls and user operations through the Project area. The benefits of roundabouts are explained in the information provided in Exhibit 3. Staff is also considering two alternatives for bike facilities on Kelly Drive including buffered bike lanes (Class II) or a separated two-way bikeway (Class IV) along the east side of Kelly Drive between El Camino Real and Hillside Drive. The two-way separated bikeway alternative presents concerns due to the number of driveways (17) which intersect the bikeway and the two-way operation of bicycles in these locations as people walking and driving may not anticipate bicyclists traveling in the counterflow direction. Motorists entering or crossing the roadway may not notice bicyclists approach from their right, and motorists turning into driveways across the bicycle facility may likewise fail to notice bicyclists traveling in the opposite direction. Due to the concerns with the number of conflict points and visibility at the driveways, staff is recommending Class II buffered bike lanes for this segment. On Park Drive a Class-IV separated bikeway with adjacent walking path is proposed along the south side of the roadway between Kelly Drive and Neblina Drive. This will provide a protected bicycle and pedestrian connection from Kelly Drive to the lagoon trail at the southside of the intersection at Neblina Drive. Necessary Council Action Staff will finalize the Project environmental documents and permitting process, construction plans, specifications and cost estimates, and present them to the City Council for approval and authorization to advertise the Project for construction bids in spring-2022. Next Steps Following the Traffic and Mobility Commission’s (T&MC’s) review and comments, staff will perform additional public outreach seeking the community feedback on the proposed roadway intersection and bikeway improvements. Staff will then return to the T&MC to report the feedback received by the public and recommend direction for the completing the design. Once the T&MC recommends final direction on intersection control at Hillside Drive and Kelly Drive, staff would complete the design and present the 90% design to the T&MC with a recommended action to recommend to the City Council to accept the plans as complete and bid the project. Exhibits 1. Location Map of Kelly Drive and Park Drive Complete Street Improvements Project 2. Proposed conceptual improvement plans 3. Information on Modern Roundabouts NOT TO SCALE LOCATION AGUA HEDIONDA LAGOON MAP PROJECT NAME KELL y DRIVE AND PARK DRIVE COMPLETE STREET IMPROVEMENTS PLOTTfD BY: SCOTT EVANS PLOT DATE:2/21/17 PA7H:D: \1RANSPORTA710N DEPAR1MENT\LOCA710N MAPS\AUrocAD\6075.DKG PROJECT EXHIBIT NUMBER 1 6075 Key MapSection Locations SCALE: 1"=150' AT 30"X42"NORTH0 75 150 300003916 Normal StreetSan Diego, CA 92103619.294.4477www.ktua.comKEYMAP PLANDATE: 8/31/18Segment5Segment4Segment3Segment2Segment1Valencia DriveEl Camino RealHillside DriveNeblina DriveAlondra DriveSection1Section3Section4Section5Section2Exhibit 2 ~ 'lo· ir.c / ' . . ' ,. iJ; i' c;~: uli}/ 1 I / i '. ______________ /_ \ I I i'--------------, I I I I (,,' I I ' I I I I I I ---/ ________ , /~ :O ii 7 ~ -j ~ '•,,, ~":,[!/ ·;],/ ------' / ' I I , , I I I I I ' ' ' ' I I ,~ I ---~~[ I I ( ----L __ r; ~- ~:u- -)G" ------,--- Kelly Drive between El Camino Real and Hillside Drive Proposed: Cycle Track Option Existing Parking Parking (8’) (7’-6”)(6’) Parking Parking SidewalkSidewalk Walkway (8’) (8’) (8’) Sidewalk (6’) (6’) Bicycle Lane Travel Lane (11’) (10’) (14’) Travel Lane Travel Lane Travel Lane (11’) Median Median (10’) (14’) Bicycle Lane Cycle Track (2’) (2’) (6’) Planting (6’) (6’) (7’-6”) Segment 1 Buffer Buffer Exhibit 2 Kelly Drive between El Camino Real and Hillside Drive Proposed: Buffered Bicycle Lanes Option Existing Parking Parking (8’) (7’-6”)(6’) Parking Parking SidewalkSidewalk Walkway (8’) (9’) (9’) (8’) Sidewalk (6’) (6’) Bicycle Lane Travel Lane (11’) (10’) (14’) Travel Lane Travel Lane Travel Lane (11’) Median (14’) Bicycle Lane Buffered Bicycle Lane Buffered Bicycle Lane (6’) Planting (3’) (6’) (7’-6”) Segment 1 Exhibit 2 Kelly Drive between Hillside Drive and Park Drive Proposed Existing Section 2 Parking Parking (8’) (8’)(8”’)(6’-6”) (4’) Parking Parking (8’) Walkway (8’) Sidewalk Sidewalk Bicycle LaneBicycle Lane (5’) (5’)(6’)(6’) Travel Lane Travel Lane Travel Lane Travel Lane (11’) (13’) (11’) (13’) Median Median (4’) (11’) Cycle Track Sidewalk (8’) (2’) (2’) Planting Planting (5’) Buffer Buffer Exhibit 2 Park Drive between Kelly Drive and Alondra Drive Proposed Existing Section 3 Parking Parking/Travel Lane (7’-6”) (23’) Parking (7’-6”) (12’) Trail Trail (8’) (Varies) Sidewalk Sidewalk (5’-6”) (6’-6”) Travel Lane Travel Lane (11’) Travel Lane (11’) Cycle Track (8’) (2’) (2’) (3’) Planting Buffer Buffer Exhibit 2 Park Drive between Alondra Drive and Valencia Drive Proposed Existing Section 4 Trail (8’) (8’) Sidewalk Parking (6’) Travel Lane (11’) Travel Lane (11’)(8’) Cycle Track (3’) (2’) (2’) (2’) Planting PlantingBufferBuffer Parking/Travel Lane (23’) Trail (Varies) (12’) Sidewalk (6’) Travel Lane Exhibit 2 Existing Parking/Travel Lane (19’)(12’-6”) Trail (Varies) Sidewalk (6’) Travel Lane Park Drive between Valencia Drive and Neblina Drive Section 5 Proposed Trail (8’) (8’) Sidewalk (6’) Travel Lane (11’) Travel Lane (11’) Cycle Track (4’) (2’) (2’) (2’) Planting Planting Buffer Buffer Exhibit 2 SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH0 20 40 80003916 Normal StreetSan Diego, CA 92103619.294.4477www.ktua.comPLANDATE: 8/31/18Kelly Drive between El Camino Real and Hillside DriveSection1SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH0 20 40 80003916 Normal StreetSan Diego, CA 92103619.294.4477www.ktua.comPLANDATE: 8/31/18Segment1SCALE: 1"=150' AT 30"X42"NORTH0 75 150 300003916 Normal StreetSan Diego, CA 92103619.294.4477www.ktua.comKEYMAP PLANDATE: 8/31/18Section 1 Key MapEl Camino RealExhibit 2 I , / / f \ , , , , \ , ,, / / ! ! I / / , / /C/ I ! .L , , .. / / I ! ,-------, / I I \ ! , , / ; = _J:;1 ~ ~-:,. -$ ~ ~~ ~ --, • • • • • • , , / / , / / / / --, • • • • -• • • • • • • )\ , , ' ' ____ , \,---\ I 1 -i c_ _,,_J_ -, \ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH0 20 40 80003916 Normal StreetSan Diego, CA 92103619.294.4477www.ktua.comPLANDATE: 8/31/18Kelly Drive between Hillside Drive and Park DriveSection2SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH0 20 40 80003916 Normal StreetSan Diego, CA 92103619.294.4477www.ktua.comPLANDATE: 8/31/18SCALE: 1"=150' AT 30"X42"NORTH0 75 150 300003916 Normal StreetSan Diego, CA 92103619.294.4477www.ktua.comKEYMAP PLANDATE: 8/31/18Section 2 Key MapHillside DrivePark DriveSegment2Exhibit 2 • • • • • • • • • • ' ' ' ' ' ' • ' ' ' • • • • • • • • • ., e/ .j .'' ' ' ~I '/-• ' ' ' ' I I I ' ' ' ' ' ' ' I I I I I I I I ' ---r---------, I I I I I I " 7 .J 1 / ' ~- I X I I 11 X I I l >< l I c... I I I I I ',// /, ' ' I ·"· / _.,l I I I I -t-\--- 1 I r· ._x ' ' ' I \ ' ' J.---'{. I .' ·\._ 'is. .. , ' ' ' a ' ! ! ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' J_ ___ .!.--- .. :~/•\:z··:7 ¥? ' ·, .. 1/ ,._ ··'- ' ' -----, , - \ _/ ___ ::{:-::-:=-- /.k :::::: . ~----:.__ ·::.,,;:: .. ··r~ --~~:-~~-=--=------;[.=~~:.=·-- " ,, ' ,, ' ,, ' ' \', \ ,, ' ' \1 -, \1 ', -· \\. --- ' \ ' ' ', ,;~c":c::,-•'i 1. ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' i ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' C ' ' ' ' \ \ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ·, ' ' ' ' /. ' C '· ., ' \ -'.-- ' I I I I I •,, I I I I I I I • I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I \ ' ' ' ' ' \ ' ' ' ' ' I I I I I I I \ \ \ \· '' \ ' ' ' \' ' '' \' \ '' '' ---\ \ ., ' ' ' ' r ' ',....__Y.. -/ ' / ' ·•· ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' .•. ••••• •• /,, ... ! ••• ••• •••• ••• ~ ' / \ '' ,, ' \ '', " '' '' '' '' '' '' '' '' '' '' '' '' '' " '' '' '\ '' '\ '' '' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' \ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '' '' '' '' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' •• Park Drive between Kelly Drive and Alondra Drive SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH 0 20 40 8000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Section 3 SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH 0 20 40 8000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Segment 3 SCALE: 1"=150' AT 30"X42"NORTH 0 75 150 30000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com KEYMAP PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Section 3 Key Map Alondra Drive Exhibit 2 I I I I I I I I I I ' I I I I I I I I I I I -, _/ •••••••••• I I I I I I I " I I / / I ' , I I / ! , '· ,' /•. I ' I j i/ , , __ // 'I /' I I ,':> / I I I ,111 / I I I I I I 'I I I 1' I , /I // / ' ' ' ' ' ' / , ' , , / , / •••••••••••• ' ------:~-----~~~c-:;~:c \ \ \ \ . ', .• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ktu ' ' ),.--- _/ ' ' , ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' , ' , ' ' ' , ' ..., ' -i i ' ' -I ! ' ' ' ' ' ' ', ' ·,. __ \ ·--, ·----\ __ / ' ' ··-\] ' ~ l\ '' , I,' ' ' ' ' __ J , ' ' ' SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH 0 20 40 8000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Section 4 SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH 0 20 40 8000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Segment 4 Park Drive between Alondra Drive and Valencia Drive SCALE: 1"=150' AT 30"X42"NORTH 0 75 150 30000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com KEYMAP PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Section 4 Key Map Exhibit 2 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' I ' \ / \i ' ~. 7; I ' ' ' ' . " 'i ' \ __ _ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' -' ' ''-' ' /~ / ,/---·-_, ' ,_ ' ' ,. ' --/L1'.jc3/~::,. ' !!f;§J/8 ' ··, ··: y'.:$ ~(i-_/ I •. . ·c.". ·. ' I "·<ij'S{' ' ' ' ,~.-.'< ,'·,, -~~,,,.-' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' =·--, ' ' ' ' I") '. ' . ' I~, I-Cr _j '-r tc, I '·t_ \ I {-'-~-o--.../ ,) ,-J _,' ,' ~-;=,,,__, ,' .l1.~1 '-.,.,' ! I I {'_l_,c;;:: __ _J 1 ,\\ -~ , I '•.,, .. ·, , -., ,.;,., /." I ,,';-',;:<< I '1. ' I .. ,, ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' C ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' n1)( /'·-----------' ....._______ , 1 \ I I -;,,--_ --, ---I ---/ -~-=------; C ,,.--c---..--.. j )~~ ~t ·-;_;:::_-_-,_----~-~ l /' ":<' ;J~l_J/1 _1~ c,f--;-f; -__ = _ I / _-~ r-1'-i/ --'1,_.J/'_ '1 H ~j /\'"=--,7--T-c"",_-~ " )J _-},,-, /1_t""j---r--.l.-,-.-4._ lf:-V(01/ IC-"-)1.._ 1,J 0 o~-=-,-;,;:.---, ~"" -._ . __ _ / :c j'" I> c_L ___ /_ ._ .!...._/-,-::__-J--,0-.c---=;-Jh,_cJ'r•, s 't-r,~;~ f , , .-. •• f ' ___ ,---______ ' .j_ ,_ ""-' ' ( I/ /--~::-~_-1-\---; 1'---~' --------~·-··u,29;."--~~=----~~~:: I -~1.-:,-f1, \ I i--_/ ·--/ 17,)·• ,,---= I 1. ~ 1. t\ .,.-, 1 I"'"-•"· ··•---,-11 .,J -~ •C~f-·r·T ll_i;,--1 I I ,_. I I I~ ,,, ~J 1 ~----/ ,--;._"i =----\_ --\ ,1 / I '/2:'--::J-I I 'cl~f::/_ 1 I I I I ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' •••••••••••• / // -• • • • ' ;;,/ ,;;);;::: ;,:;, / ,<; / / )<:"' ./~-·;::; /. ':' . ;,✓ ,A ".. --~,' ,/.~_';:; i-----------------,~1 j-------r:: '·~ ',:r-----f/?--• • I ■ I ■ : . : . •;;·cc•.c-,, < •~ C ~ c,•, '-'-;;·•~-C ''<c ;; CJ! • /;/ ,p '/,' ./ ',( i/ . / /;'~,· / ,( ,' .,. ///~ ,,/ ' ; [ ,, ,, ,:, i,/ :/ ,,// ' ,'~ ,,:/ ' -~, ' ,,,, V ,, ' ' I -~--' ' / ' ' ,i,\,1--,L_ I--I / I 11 I ,, ' ,, ' ,, " ' ,, ' 11-~_ ,, ' ,, ,, -;:<;-~---/ ; / / / I' .. ''c( ' ·c I / '' \ ,/ :--... ' -... ;-,,\/ .... .. ,, . ·--........\ '-· ------,>'( ·---.y -,-_____ "-c...-,_ V I 1I ' LJ-1--~_.. I I I -,-"--"'"' __ )7/-r 7-1, / / 1/ / /-7·1···1 / // I 1 " / // // /// I I I r1,-1-I I ' I I I/ I I I/ I L' ------I" L--------1/· I ' I I \,,,, ', 1-1-----\ I I r I I I I I I -1 / ; 1/ I ,I ---" _J ~--x-~--/I -"'-~ _,., / ' -.~"--, ' '•-.,, ----, I I I / I I __ ,_._ _.c-___,·_ _J ----------1---~ l ---_r ___ :,.:: ----171' 11.---~~--;-) V ·1-1---.J , / // / / ./ \ I \ / // / // // /-7 I I // // / // / / / I I I // / // // / / --N-,.---' / , / / L I I I=---= =---"=-----L 1/ I I -----=" ,,j /I / /1 / / / / 1 I I ~/ I I I I ' I / / / / JI .../-,-. I I _L~---1 I t - - --- - - - - ---I=------- - -C71 I • ~ ~ ~/ 1 V'T_~ __ _/' /// '~\ \_L_ / 1\1 ///// I I I I / / ' ,,, N-r· -/ / ' l-1 -...., / / / .. ·· .·· I ·.. I . / / . 1 ••••••••••••••••••••• _, ~-' --------,,, I-~--I I -__ \I->:__ ______ ;,:.-~1 -~ \\_ I / I -., '· ✓-, ' , , I I \ \ r--' ~ / I \ \ / \ , __ , -,--':.!. ' '-' \I ' ' -,,,--7?·----,,----, __ _ ---:,Jr-V:.-----.,.:~L :.-----~,,..,,..~z. I I \ / / .· I \ \ I --j ' r---' ,, ,, ' / ' ' ----I 1----·-1 \I I -~·;:_/···•' __ :: .. / _;. \ ::.., -,.,,..✓-✓--./ ' ,,-7 ' ·; ----7 I ----/--r ,--7-1 /II I / / / \ \ ./ ,..;', ' ' /. / ,•, \ ' //, .·· L-/ 1 ,//./' ·.·'/)1 '(/' ///./\ / .·· ' .·· .. · \ \ . / / I I / .. / I ------,, / / \ ,-', I .·· / . /'I 'i( ' / // / .· .· ~:_~, I / / _c::-:.>i:,__--I lc,c'-->--____ , \ ', I \ --i \ I ~--1 .J ' \' \.\ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ~ / .-·\", ) / ' ' I I I I I~ ! I I I 1·~ !/ ' ' ( / ·,, I_/:-I I I r/--,-v / I I I ' I 7-..,._ l1 ,-:,---/ 1 /• I --i/ )--.J -I ' I I ' ' ' i 17 ! ' ' ' ' : ./ I l~-1/'' "~ ;k ~--"~-' /I 1_ __/ .· ./ .·· 1--__ ,,. · / 1 ---:...._ · I I / I 1 -.J ( / I I I ' ' / I I ✓-I ' ' ' I I -* ,/-~_-:-----JI -._/ ' ' ( ·-... / I V I I / '/ ' I I I I ' I I / ' ' ' ' ' ' ' / ,, ' i'.' ,, ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' j ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ,-\ ' r/;,-----'-,---;,-_______ _ l ________ "1,,,., \/ -----r---' ' ' I ' --___ l1 ------,tF----,11[--e=======-d,1-----~-------111 ---..'.:.__ __l,!-1-I I r-,--,r--__ l ( ' V /---;--,.... ,/---:c--I / i / / // / / i ' i/ / / / I I r-1 ./ / / ) 11 , 7 I ~ / / / I I, 11, I I / .··II ,/ / ///11 I / / / /1 11 I I I/ / / / .. J -1' I I /. // I I ( / __ / / / , ,I ii/ 1--"--./·i/l // I ---::...1 ii I I I I / ----Ii' I .1 / /, ~(/ __ ; J_(--I ,-1I ' ' ' ' r--'-v 11 ' ' ' ,, ' ,, ' ,, ' ,, ,, ,, ,, -I .11 r--:-.· --1 / ') ' ' ,~ / . / 11 f /I' I //. /I I / " / .. · I ,I / .. · I / / / / / ' 1/ /. / I 1, .· 'I / ./ I ! / / -Ji i' _/ / / I -~-1 I -v----\ ,-----------, r::..J __ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' Jj --. r--1 ,_ ' ' ' ' ' • • • ' I j I /I //i - -__,( __/2 ' I I I! I< ' / p-• i-r -A ' 1111 i .. ·· ,.,. I // / ■ I ' / / r-j : / /. " ' ' ' ' I , ' / ' : ~--_I 1 / / //. I V / / .·· I'/ ,■ / ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' I ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' I/ / .·· . ,r_~ //i'-. I --_J \ __ / ... • • • - Park Drive between Valencia Drive and Neblina Drive SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH 0 20 40 8000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Section 5 SCALE: 1"=40' AT 36"X48"NORTH 0 20 40 8000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Segment 5 SCALE: 1"=150' AT 30"X42"NORTH 0 75 150 30000 3916 Normal Street San Diego, CA 92103 619.294.4477 www.ktua.com KEYMAP PLAN DATE: 8/31/18 Section 5 Key Map Valencia DriveNeblina DriveExhibit 2 I I ' / ' ' / I / / ' ' ' ' I ' I I I I I /--ft I / ;' _~ I I 11 I ,, \ I' / / I '-<_-- --,y --x - -----( '. . ;~f -.. ·•·:·•· :-~ c;. ;'· •• \ ' .. . . . -. ,-.. • •·-..... ·• -------------___ ~_-_--___ cc ------____ ~-~ ~ ____ ~ -~ ~ ~-~ ~ ~ ~l -" --- 1" ' l ---: \ ,- X- / ------ I I I ------1 I I I I I I I I 1-----_/_1 I I I " ,-/ I I I ' ! I I I I / ,J I I \ I I I I I I • ':·. ""· .. ',"""" "'• •. • --···:•:: •-•···::•::: •---,--,cc,-, cc• •· •-,-,._.,., • ,, ..... , .... ,, c,,c-·cc, ---- I ktu • • • • • • • • • • • • EXHIBIT 3 Information on Modern Roundabouts Videos: 1. Federal Highway Administration Modern Roundabouts - A safer choice a. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhHzly_6lWM 2. Tips on Using Carlsbad’s Roundabout – a. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XGc5aHbMfb4 Websites: 1. Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) – Intersection Safety – Roundabouts a. https://safety.fhwa.dot.gov/intersection/roundabouts/ Publications: 1. Understanding Modern Roundabouts a. https://www.carlsbadca.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/1458/6374314320559300 00 2. County of San Diego Air Pollution Control District – Modern Roundabouts REDUCE CONGESTION AND IMPROVE SAFETY ON MAIN ROADS a. https://www.sandiegocounty.gov/content/dam/sdc/apcd/PDF/Air%20Quality%20Planni ng/Modern-Roundabouts-Traffic-Circles.pdf